<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Yusuf Basurian on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Yusuf Basurian on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@yusufbasuria?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 20:40:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@yusufbasuria/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Basurian (Sichuanese) as a Tibeto-Burman nation: the case of Crab and white turban]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/basurian-sichuanese-as-a-tibeto-burman-nation-the-case-of-crab-and-white-turban-faf8c39a90ef?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/faf8c39a90ef</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Mar 2026 17:11:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-02T16:35:08.818Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Basurian call crab <em>pangkhai 旁凯</em>. There are some variants of this term such as “pankhai盘海” “pakhai爬开” but the general pronunciation rule persists. The retention of archaic features in Sichuanese is well-documented, particularly in the Minjiang dialect, which preserves checked tones and is especially difficult for other Mandarin speakers to understand. This is a case reflecting proto-Sino-Tibetan languages.</p><p>The term for crab reconstructed Old Chinese: Old Chinese: 蟹 (*ɡreːʔ) /*m-kˤreʔ/ (B-S)</p><p><em>**Beijing: 蟹 (xiè) /ɕi̯ɛ⁵¹/ (“crab”)</em></p><p><em>**Guangzhou-Hong Kong: 蟹 (haai5) /hɑːi̯¹³/ (“crab”)</em></p><p>On the other hand, in Tibeto-Burman: Proto-Tibeto-Burman: *d-k(y)aːy ⪤ *d-k(y)aːn (Matisoff, STEDT); *d-kaːy (Benedict, 1972); *d-kɑːy (Chou, 1972)</p><p><em>**Tani: *ke ~ kjo</em></p><p><em>**Tangkhul Naga: khaireu</em></p><p><em>**Jingpho: chahkan, chahkan</em></p><p><em>**Garo: ang·ke</em></p><p>In fact, the Basurian word for crab is much closer to Tibetan-Burmese words than to other Sinitic branches, despite Basurian having become Sinitic by itself. What has evolved from proto-Sino-Tibetan in other sinitic languages is the dropping of velar <em>k- </em>sound entirely and became <em>h </em>or <em>x. </em>But Busurian <em>pang</em><strong><em>khai </em></strong>has retained the velar sound just like other Tibeto-Burman languages.</p><p>This resembles the case of “蜀人呼筆爲不律也” in the《尔雅》commentary. What are the variants of proto-Tibeto-Burman term for writing utensil? Here summarized from wikitionary: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Sino-Tibetan_language">Proto-Sino-Tibetan</a> <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Reconstruction:Proto-Sino-Tibetan/b-ris&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1"><em>*b-ris</em></a> (“to draw; picture”) or <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Reconstruction:Proto-Sino-Tibetan/rit&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1"><em>*rit</em></a> (“to draw; boundary”) (STEDT). Related to <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E8%81%BF#Chinese">聿</a> (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Chinese">OC</a><em> </em>*b·lud); more distant cognates from the <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/allofam">allofamic</a> root <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Reconstruction:Proto-Sino-Tibetan/b-r%C9%99y&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1"><em>*b-rəy</em></a> (“to draw, mark; boundary”) include <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E7%90%86#Chinese">理</a> (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Chinese">OC</a><em> </em>*rɯʔ, “to cut jade, put in order”), <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lhasa_Tibetan">Tibetan</a> <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E0%BD%A0%E0%BD%96%E0%BE%B2%E0%BD%B2#Tibetan">འབྲི</a> (<em>‘bri</em>, “to write”), <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burmese_language">Burmese</a> <a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E1%80%9B%E1%80%B1%E1%80%B8#Burmese">ရေး</a> (<em>re:</em>, “to write”).</p><p>Based on several years of research, I increasingly suspect that Sichuanese is a branch of Tibetan-Burmese populace that has been thoroughly sinicized through political domination and cultural assimilation but retains genetic and linguistic linkages to Tibetan-Burman groups, particularly Tujia, Nuosu (Yi), Qiangic, and rGyarongic. Due the later political domination and cultural assimilation into the imperial Sinicization project, official narratives and myth-making works have to invent a Chinese origin for Basurian. As a result, 湖广填四川 has been promoted and working as an orthodoxic <a href="https://medium.com/@yusufbasuria/%E6%B9%96%E5%B9%BF%E5%A1%AB%E5%9B%9B%E5%B7%9D-%E7%9A%84%E8%B0%8E%E8%A8%80-d3708524a7ac">creation myth</a> imposed on the Tibeto-Burmese Basurian.</p><p>Also, Sichuanese Han people wear white turbans. The custom of Sichuan Han people wrapping white cloth (<em>bai pazi</em>) around their heads has persisted for centuries. This is not coincidental, as Qiang, Tujia, and Nuosu wear turbans too. The Qiang ethnic group demonstrates this clearly: “Both men and women wear head scarves and cotton or brocade gowns” (Su Yan-fei, “<em>A Study on the Cultural Meanings of Qiang’s Traditional Costumes</em>”). Moreover, this custom is practiced by both men and women among Sichuan Han, much like their Qiang brethren. This is particularly interesting as most Han Chinese, whose very established identity means internalizing the Confucian sense of patriarchal order, clearly distinguish female and male dressing in all aspects. Yet, the practice of wearing <em>pa </em>by both men and women appears across southwestern minorities who maintain Tibeto-Burman linguistic and cultural connections. Worth noting is that I do not deny significant Chinese as well as Daic and Hmong-mien infusion and admixture in the Basurian genetics and culture, but that will be a different story for another time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*73LoBBs75IrgjaPy.jpg" /><figcaption><a href="https://museum.sinica.edu.tw/collection/4/item/633/">Qiang white turban in Wenchuan</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*NLjsEitSTSIt5kgnTaaFPA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.sohu.com/a/351063215_454884">Han white turban in Dujiangyan</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*llDaZEDopMLLa7DqN6cArw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tujia white turban</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=faf8c39a90ef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[「湖广填四川」的谎言]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/%E6%B9%96%E5%B9%BF%E5%A1%AB%E5%9B%9B%E5%B7%9D-%E7%9A%84%E8%B0%8E%E8%A8%80-d3708524a7ac?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3708524a7ac</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Feb 2026 08:36:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-28T08:47:46.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>本文思路、证明材料由人工完成</p><p><strong>「湖广填四川」是中国历史上流传最广的移民叙事之一。</strong>传统观点认为，明末清初的战乱导致四川人口几乎灭绝，随后由湖北、湖南移民大规模填充，形成今天的四川汉族人口。然而，杨成昆等人2024年发表于《Nature Human Behavior》的<a href="https://ideas.repec.org/a/nat/nathum/v8y2024i6d10.1038_s41562-024-01886-9.html">遗传学研究</a>发现西南地区的汉族属于「文化扩散」而非「人群扩散」类型。这意味着四川汉人采用官话主要是通过原住民的语言转换，而非大规模人口替换。结合明显不可靠的人口普查记录、地理屏障的物流限制，以及系统性伪造的族谱，种种证据表明：「湖广填四川」是一种歪曲现实的儒教神话。它服务于大一统帝国的政治目的，强化了汉族有一个统一来源的虚假意识，严重夸大了人口替换的规模。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*b9IP_d95gOTZcz9D.jpeg" /><figcaption>楚蜀鸿沟：蜀国中国，一边一国</figcaption></figure><h3>遗传学否证了湖广填四川的可能</h3><p>前面提到的Yang et al (2024) 分析了926个方言点的1,018个词汇特征，并整合了来自26个省份30,408名汉族个体的遗传数据。他们的核心发现识别出一种混合模式：人群扩散（人口迁移）主导了华中地区（也就是明朝的湖广道），而文化扩散（观念传播而非人口替换）主导了西南巴蜀地区。</p><p>这一发现的意义至关重要。如果大规模的湖北至四川移民确实重新填充了该省，那么遗传学和语言学应该呈现一致性 — — 正如在华中地区所观察到的那样。然而，四川呈现的是不一致：语言高度「北方化」，但遗传组成却保持着本地特征。这种错位揭示了四川采用西南官话主要是一种文化现象，叠加在原住民的遗传基底之上。杨成坤等人2024年的研究修正了文波「人群扩散」的笼统结论：该模式适用于华中，但不适用于西南，在那里甚至部分的男性介导迁移模式也高估了实际的人口替换程度。</p><p>另一项基因研究（<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327369845_A_Comprehensive_Map_of_Genetic_Variation_in_the_World&#39;s_Largest_Ethnic_Group-Han_Chinese">Chiang et al, 2018</a>）分析了10,640个汉族基因组，也支持这一结论。四川和重庆人口显示出的混血信号并非来自湖北或湖南，而是来自地理上位于西南地区的少数民族 — — 包括傣族（壮侗语系）和苗人。这种非汉族的遗传基底恰恰是原住民被文化同化而非被替换时预期出现的模式。</p><p>遗传证据中的性别不对称性尤其值得关注。一般认为汉族向南扩张主要由男性主导：北方父系血统与原住民母系血统结合。但由于O-M134这个单倍体本身最早是起源于南方(<a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution/articles/10.3389/fevo.2022.853391/full">Huang et al 2022</a>)，一部分父系基因在分化之前就已经先于北方汉族存在于巴蜀。2024年，<a href="https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-97-4848-8_5">一项综述</a>总结发现，O-M134及其突变型O-M117的地理分布在西藏-缅甸语群体中高度富集（塔芒人达86%，印度东北部多个藏缅语民族超过85%），而在现代汉族中仅占9.6%至15%。单倍群多样性分析显示，羌族群体的O-M117多样性为目前研究的中国人群中最高，表明川西/藏东高原是汉藏语系人群的父系遗传起源地。这也是为什么一些明显带有labeling错误倾向的基因公司，如23魔方，会误导性的生成一些湖南、广东的姓氏和单倍体出现在巴蜀，因此得出巴蜀移民来自华中、华南的错误结论。这是因为，巴蜀所谓汉族大量混入了侗台、苗瑶民族的单倍体，尤其是母系mtDNA。而这些民族也极强地对华中、华南“汉族”贡献了基因构成，造成一种表面的因果，而实际上是被遮蔽的相关关系。</p><p>从这一视角看，「湖广填四川」叙事不仅在逻辑上是颠倒的 — — 实际的史前人口流动方向是从川滇向外扩散，而非相反 — — 而且低估了四川原住民对东亚人口形成的奠基性贡献。这意味着巴蜀人口 携带的原住民遗传遗产远超父系族谱所暗示的比例。</p><h3>伪造族谱与麻城起源神话</h3><p>支持「湖广填四川」的主要证据来自族谱 — — 而这些族谱显然是不可靠的。四川移民研究领域的权威学者、四川省社会科学院的陈世松直接指出，大多数声称祖籍麻城孝感乡的家族都是在进行「冒籍」 — — 即故意虚假地声称来源地。当现代四川后裔前往麻城寻找族谱联系时，只有大约10%的人能够找到微妙的关联。</p><p>仔细审视之下，这些不可能之处层层叠加。孝感乡只是麻城县内的一个小乡镇，作为行政单位早在1472年就已被撤销。然而，绝大多数族谱声称的迁移时间都在清初（1660年代至1700年代） — — 距离这个地方正式不复存在已超过200年。人口史学家曹树基发现，郧阳县地方志中记载为麻城移民的向氏，实际上是「鄂西湘西典型的蛮族大姓」，根本不可能从麻城迁来。更令人震惊的是，人类学家芮逸夫在1940年代发现，甚至四川的苗族土司和普通苗族家庭都声称祖先来自麻城孝感乡 ，王明珂也在《寻羌》中提到，北川的羌族声称祖先来自湖北麻城。对于非汉族群体而言，这一声称在民族和语言上都是荒谬的。</p><p>麻城现象与中国南方其他地区发现的伪造模式如出一辙。在广东，超过150个姓氏和797个宗族支系声称从珠玑巷迁来 — — 但珠玑巷原本只是一条约200米长、4米宽的小巷，根本无法容纳声称从那里迁出的人口规模。学者曾祥炜认为，珠玑巷故事是「少数民族为获得合法文化身份而编造的」。在福建，族谱压倒性地将祖籍追溯到河南光州固始。</p><p>中央研究院的历史人类学家王明珂为解释这一现象提供了理论框架，他提出了「华夏边缘」的概念：处于中华文明边疆的人群采用中原族谱，以跨越从「蛮夷」到「文明」的边界，从而获得税收优惠、科举资格和社会声望。王明珂记录了四川北部的人群如何在数个世纪中根据哪种身份更有利而在汉族与少数民族身份之间切换。族谱产业本身就是腐败的。在明清时期，职业「谱匠」准备好姓氏空白的通用模板，配有署名朱熹、欧阳修等著名学者的相同序言，然后只需填入客户的姓氏即可。香港中文大学的科大卫证明，华南的宗族是明代的「祖先发明学」，服务于社会和财政目的，而非记录实际的血统。</p><h3>统计税丁而非实际人口的人口普查数字</h3><p>据称激发移民的人口崩溃依赖于方法论上站不住脚的明清人口统计。明代人口登记是一种财政核算制度 — — 里甲制度 — — 统计的是「丁」（应税人口），而非实际居民。正如历史学家卜正民所记录的，「财政义务促使许多家庭少报户内人数」。明代官方数字在200多年间一直冻结在5,100万至6,200万之间，而实际人口可能达到1.5亿至2亿。1572年的《会稽县志》记载官方人口为62,004，同时注明实际数字「是其四倍有余」。</p><p>被引用作为四川人口锐减证据的戏剧性数字 — — 1661年登记在册成年男丁16,096人 — — 并非人口统计。它代表的是在一个仍处于争夺中的战区、行政控制支离破碎的情况下，在勉强运转的清朝税务机构登记的男性人数。山区（羌、彝、藏、苗等民族的聚居地）的大量人口完全处于登记制度之外。为逃避数十年战乱而逃往偏远地区的人口未被统计在内。《明史》记载张献忠活动导致6亿人死亡 — — 在中国总人口不足1.5亿的情况下，这一数字显然是荒谬的。</p><p>随后清代的「人口爆炸」在很大程度上是人口普查改革的产物。康熙帝1712年「滋生人丁永不加赋」的谕令以及雍正帝将丁税并入地税的措施，消除了躲避登记员的动机。此前隐形的人口在记录中「重新出现」。与此同时，「改土归流」政策 — — 用任命的流官取代世袭土司 — — 首次将以前自治的少数民族人口纳入直接管理和人口普查。土家族提供了一个民族身份流动性的戏剧性例证：他们的人口普查数字从1982年的283万到1990年的573万翻了一倍多，几乎完全是通过重新分类实现的。</p><h3>结论</h3><p>「湖广填四川」叙事属于一系列起源神话 — — 与洪洞大槐树（华北）、珠玑巷（广东）、瓦屑坝（湖广）并列。历史学家赵世瑜将这些分析为「建构的归属叙事」，服务于政治和身份认同功能，而非记录真实的人口统计历史。</p><p>如今，遗传学证据明确支持西南地区的文化扩散而非人群替换。地理屏障使大规模移民的物流极为困难。支撑人口锐减叙事的人口普查数字测量的是税收义务而非实际人口。声称记录移民来源的族谱被系统性伪造以获取社会利益，这一点已被该领域权威学者所承认。这些都不否认曾有移民发生 ，但其规模已被神话化到面目全非的程度，将一个渐进的文化同化过程和适度的人口补充转变为全面人口替换的建国叙事。</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3708524a7ac" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evidence that Shanxi was part of Eurasia Steppe Culture]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/evidence-that-shanxi-was-part-of-eurasia-steppe-culture-b1050593376d?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1050593376d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Feb 2025 08:27:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-24T08:27:14.135Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A recent archaeological excavation in Yuncheng, Shanxi Province, has unearthed a pottery shard featuring a geometric symbol closely resembling a tamga — a distinctive mark historically associated with nomadic cultures of the Eurasian Steppe.</p><p><a href="https://m.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_30223470">Chinese state media</a> has reported that this symbol likely represents a clan emblem linked to the “Yasheng”亚生 clan, based on its superficial resemblance to characters in the oracle bone character. However, this interpretation is a horrible dumbfounded anachronic error: there was no written record of oracle bone characters until Shang period in 1500 BC, definitely not in the Mesolithic era. Even assuming they are some proto form of oracle bone symbols, two oracle bone symbols were never carved inside each other.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ae8FCv1HgmlaSsu_.jpg" /></figure><p>In fact, the symbol’s form bears a striking resemblance to Tamga symbol, which had deep historical roots among steppe nomads. The earliest known tamga-like symbols trace back to the Andronovo culture (ca. 2000–1000 BCE), a Bronze Age society spanning parts of Central Asia and southern Siberia. Tamgas were originally used as tribal, familial, or personal emblems, serving both practical purposes (such as marking livestock and property) and representing social identity and political authority.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/273/0*wvUcNLgQxPn6EkgX.jpg" /></figure><p>The symbol found on pottery in Yuncheng could as well be the Tamga sign for items associated with the pastoralist lifestyle, such as cattle. Cattle was imported from Andronovo-related cultures along the Eurasia steppe. Old Chinese word for cattle ([ŋ]ʷə) was a borrowed term from proto-Indo-European *gwou.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*pqGC_h7h373Cso9maWcOdA.png" /></figure><p>Importantly, the Xiongnu, considered one of the earliest proto-Hunnic confederations, are known to have adopted tamga symbols. The Xiongnu had extensive interactions with Han China and left behind numerous tamga-marked artifacts. Historical and archaeological evidence suggests that the Xiongnu occupied regions corresponding to present-day Shanxi during the late Zhou period. In this period, the Zhongshan and Dai state were of Hunnic origin (鲜虞). The new evidence from Yuncheng implies that Xiongnu presence in Shanxi may predate these historically recorded settlements, extending into prehistoric times.</p><p>It suggests a continuous cultural thread linking Bronze Age steppe societies (e.g., Andronovo) to later nomadic empires (e.g., Xiongnu), long before imperial Chinese records document such encounters.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1050593376d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The strange case of “sexually transmitted diseases” in Ch]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/the-strange-case-of-sexually-transmitted-diseases-in-ch-10e540bdcaab?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10e540bdcaab</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jan 2025 07:01:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-13T07:03:38.769Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The strange case of “sexually transmitted diseases” in China</h3><p>Ideally, as one would typically assume, if a disease (or infection, if you prefer a less stigmatized description) is transmitted through sexual intercourse, we would call it a sexually transmitted disease (STD). However, no virus or bacteria recognizes its host vector from the onset. They simply evolve to adapt to a more favorable vector condition relative to others. All STDs can be transmitted through non-sexual means for this simple reason. Labeling it an STD is just a combination of: 1) the majority of infections are found to be transmitted through sexual contact, usually recorded in clinical settings by self-report or from a subpopulation that officials and doctors believe to be very sexually active; 2) the popular conviction that sexual vices are to blame for the epidemic of the said disease, so labeling it would help warn others and reduce transmission to a certain level.</p><p>But you simply don’t have any virus that only selects human sexual organs and secretions to survive in. Most pathogens find human blood and secretions a favorable environment, and they live in their host’s blood and body fluids, waiting to be transported to another host’s blood and fluids. Such an opportunity occurs when blood or fluid, or both, change hands with another human. Sexual activity would be one occasion for such an opportunity to happen, but so do many other things that happen independently of sex or during sex. If anal intercourse without proper lubrication causes tearing damage to the cell wall of one’s rectum, blood will mix with sperm, which is a body fluid that contains a certain virus, and transmission of a disease happens through the blood and fluid between two persons. In this case, to what extent shall we call it “sexual” rather than a blood infusion transmission?</p><p>Now look further. Some sexual activities during BDSM “rituals” involve minor tearing, bruising, and even cutting of one’s skin and other body parts. Just for the sake of supposition: if one’s favorite S&amp;M foreplay ritual causes some bleeding in both partners, and they only engage in sexual intercourse after a prolonged period of foreplay and teasing, then a virus has been transmitted purely through the blood during the foreplay phase, and one partner ends up getting an infection after the episode from the other partner, shall we call this sexually transmitted or blood transmitted? If an even stranger ritual of intimacy requires cutting and exchanging blood, not very different from ancient people drinking from a cup with another person’s blood for an oath of alliance or brotherhood, and insertive sexual intercourse doesn’t even happen beyond this ritual, do you still call the transmission caused by exchanging blood during this ritual sexually transmitted?</p><p>Physicians usually do not know exactly what happened during an episode where an infection supposedly transpired. Patients are asked about their sexual orientation, injection drug use history, sexual history, partner relationships, and so on. Their partners and families are tested too. If an HIV patient is a homosexual male, doesn’t use injection drugs, and didn’t get a blood transfusion before the episode, then the recorded patient interview and medical history will be passed to administrators or directly determined by the physician for the cause of HIV: here it would most probably be classified as homosexual sexual activity. Administrators at CDCs would certainly not know what exactly happened when an infection transpired if the physicians didn’t know. But causes are published and released to the public, relevant directives for funding allocation will consult the cause data, and public health campaigns are made to target populations based on the cause data.</p><p>When two homosexual partners fought on the battlefield and one got infected with HIV by helping with his partner’s bullet wound, do we ridiculously call that a sexually transmitted infection? Yes, it was a medical accident, but it wasn’t in a clinic; yes, it was blood transfusion, but one wasn’t receiving blood. Where does our administrator fill in the sorry blank that only has four categories: mother-child, blood transfusion or medical accident, drug injection, sexual intercourse? After scrutinizing all the risk factors, it seems only sexual intercourse is left, and voilà, a new case of homosexually transmitted HIV.</p><p>In terms of probability at the population level, when various risk factors such as sexual orientation and medical history are considered altogether, we, of course, have some confidence level to determine which risk factor was most likely the cause of an infection. I am not arguing with low-probability exceptions to overturn the regular pattern that at the population level, male homosexuals with HIV but without blood transfusion and drug use history had likely acquired HIV through sexual intercourse. I am, however, arguing with realistic daily examples to show that at the microbe level, a pathogen can transmit through many possible non-sexual vectors regardless of whether sexual intercourse took place.</p><p>I find it strange when people in China often attribute the higher prevalence of HIV in southwestern China to the local liberal sex culture (e.g. Chengdu being the gay capital, Busurian girls being permissive, prostitution not too stigmatized, etc). This is an example of ecological fallacy and attribution fallacy. When you see a map of HIV distribution at the provincial level and then claim that places with higher prevalence of HIV are also sexually promiscuous or, in a more politically correct sense, sexually progressive, you are making an incorrect assumption.</p><p>The map I created from 2020 province-level health statistics of China shows that all STDs do not have a similar distribution pattern at all. While HIV is concentrated in the southwest, the more prevalent STD gonorrhea is common in the southern coastal zone where the economy is doing better. Syphilis is more widespread but has higher prevalence in the southern coastline and the northwest. I included Hepatitis B here even though it’s not commonly labeled an STD because I want to show how we don’t classify Hep B as an STD even though it can be sexually transmitted too. Interestingly enough, Hep B has a very similar pattern to syphilis. Then why is it not a STD when about 38% of Hep B were found sexually acquired in the US (Roberts et al, 2021) and <a href="https://www.hepb.org/blog/sexual-transmission-hepatitis-b-among-adults-china/">35% in China</a>?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TOg9E19pvtYqu1NQithFaQ.png" /><figcaption>distribution of STDs by province in China, 2020 data</figcaption></figure><p>I don’t think you can say all four STDs are caused by more frequent, permissive, or commercial sexual behaviors. I even doubt their distributions are caused by province-level sexual activities in any shape, form, or manner. According to the sexual liberal hypothesis, if HIV is caused by promiscuous sexual activities among certain populations, then what explains gonorrhea and syphilis, whose per-act infection probability by sex is much higher than HIV, not occurring as frequently in the areas where HIV is concentrated? Conversely, since gonorrhea infection rates are very high on the southeast coast of China and we assume gonorrhea is mostly sexually transmitted, why haven’t the responsible sexual activities converted into a high HIV infection rate?</p><p>I compared the distributions in China with a cursorily made map of STD distribution in the US. You would see at a glance that the regional pattern of STD distribution in the US is more consistent. Where HIV prevalence is higher, the same places have higher syphilis and gonorrhea prevalence. The South, California, Nevada, and New York tend to have high STD rates of all types. Even Hepatitis B is more common in the South and Nevada. While you can’t generalize what was behind the infection rate, it’s safer to assume the underlying causes of region-level STD infection are similar for different types of STDs here in the States. Still, you can’t say for sure that sexual activity was the primary cause. Poverty, injection drug use, health care resources, etc., these variables are highly correlated and tend to vary at a similar pace across states.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*veweLub9yfjiOu9JzCWVKg.png" /></figure><p>But not so much can be concluded about the STD prevalence in China. One thing I’m suspecting is that the primary cause of one STD is NOT the primary cause of another STD in China. But sex is not one of the primary causes here — at least for HIV, and the liberal sexual hypothesis is very likely not true. While it’s true that, for STD with very low prevalence like HIV, a small group of a particular community could be responsible for most of the cases and vastly elevate the relative infection prevalence of their entire region, the inconsistent distributive patterns of the more prevalent STDs — syphilis and gonorrhea — still make me curious what could be causing the irregularities at province-level. Blood transfusion infection and medical accidents are not rare in China and remain unreported. Could that be? One can only speculate. Or, take the Durkheimian anti-reductionist approach and simply avoid explaining region-level phenomena with the imagination of what could happen between affected individuals.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10e540bdcaab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reconstructed proto-Sinitic sentences that prove the original Chinese were Tibeto-Burman]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/three-reconstructed-proto-sinitic-sentences-that-prove-the-original-chinese-were-tibeto-burman-32ad6123dc1c?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32ad6123dc1c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 May 2024 08:04:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-30T10:14:47.985Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>ŋa nai ken se ŋi na swaŋ nan kweint ŋan khyim la?<br>吾 尔 见 斯 日 汝 使往 侬 犬子 俺 坅 欤？<br>En: I saw you today you dispatch your dogs-son to my home, ain’t?</p><p>Kluu-Thlaŋ gro Klaŋ kdje rwe<br>姬昌 后 姜/羌 氏/氐 惟<br>Ch: 姬昌是氐羌部落的王</p><p>gro ŋis(Gro ŋis) smiet ku ŋi<br>后 彝(后 羿) 使灭 九 日<br>Ch: 尼苏/彝人的王，后羿，熄灭九个太阳</p><p>Klaŋt-ŋa Gawkraŋ-kha gliep dmak <br>羌子 吾 镐京/岗 于 列 武 <br>Ch: 我羌哥(姜子牙)在高原(镐京)上驻扎士兵</p><p>dban-pa, Pe-tiwt le Tiw-ŋuwan ajo miŋia rwe<br>亶父/蕃部 不喾 与 周嫄 祖 民吾 惟<br>Ch:藏人亶父、不喾(夫周）和周嫄（女周）是我民族/弥药的祖先。</p><p>Gro Mranma sken Han sries Dok tiak Khyon ba la ke<br>后 马武 使现 汉 使 蜀 织 邛 竹 予 矣<br>Ch: 缅甸(骑马武士)王把蜀锦邛竹给汉朝使节看了</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32ad6123dc1c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Loan as payment]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/loan-as-payment-5cc9578ef642?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5cc9578ef642</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Apr 2024 17:11:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-02T17:11:57.802Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The idea that quickly came to mind was inspired by the fact that many, including myself, subscribe to certain channels on YouTube for a nominal fee of $0.99. This subscription allows us to comment with personalized tokens and share memes. A portion of this $0.99 goes to the channel host, while another portion is retained by YouTube for service maintenance and other purposes, what not.</p><p>If one continues subscribing to a channel for a year, the total payment amounts to $0.99 * 12 = $11.88. Let’s round it up to $12. After a year, $12 is transferred for consumption. However, this consumption is virtual, and it doesn’t result in any tangible or concrete benefits beyond symbolic value. Over time, I started questioning whether my payment was truly worth it, even though it’s a minuscule amount of money that doesn’t significantly impact my life in any way, shape, or form.</p><p>The question then arises: what does $12 a year mean in financial terms? Considering the current base interest rate of approximately 5.3%, the transfer of $12 from me to another person represents a labor-free and risk-free means of production temporarily borrowed from me. This allows the recipient to appropriate $12 from the central bank, relying on their creditworthiness. The principal amount that forms the basis of this risk-free loan is calculated as $12 / 0.053 = $226. Money essentially represents credit supported by the paying party. In this case, the individual seller I’m subscribing to has credit guaranteed by one of the largest tech companies in the world.</p><p>This leads to another question: since the interest income from $226 over the same one-year period equals the total monthly payment of $0.99, why do I choose to subscribe with monthly payments that potentially continue indefinitely if the content is worth the money? Instead, why not temporarily loan the merchant $226 for the limited period of one year?</p><p>There are two main advantages to this loaning business model. The second model is equally profitable for the merchant, just like the first. As long as the total income for the seller remains $12, the method of profit generation, whether through fixed income or as a recipient of payment transfer, is irrelevant. Based on my understanding of global tax laws, fixed income from interest is generally taxed less heavily compared to capital gains. The other advantage lies in the interest of the consumers. By temporarily loaning a fixed amount of money to the seller, with the promised repayment of the principal, the consumer can enjoy the content without losing any monetary value of their original principal unless the principal was alternatively invested elsewhere. For a significant portion of the population who are risk-averse, this payment is essentially zero. The key here is that the payer understands that the temporary loan is guaranteed with repayment after a specific time period, and this certainty requires the credit and trust of the payee, which is usually reinforced by banks and corporations.</p><p>People already engage in similar practices by loaning money or deferring income to the state because they believe the state has the ultimate creditworthiness for repayment, often incorrectly but still commonly prevalent. When the state issues bonds using its credit or levies taxes while deferring payment to its employees, we comply because credit-fiat money allows us to rely on the existing relational interconnection between the public and the state. Anyone with comparable creditworthiness will be able to extract interest payments through the same method as the state.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5cc9578ef642" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Genetic footprint of Sino-Tibetans along the Southwest Silkroad]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/genetic-footprint-of-sino-tibetans-along-the-southwest-silkroad-db4300d7ae93?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db4300d7ae93</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 2024 08:04:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-01T08:04:26.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Chinese civilization developed as an amalgamation of various strings of technologically advanced neolithic, and early bronze age cultures transmitted through two main routes: the northern route and the southern route. The northern route connects west Eurasia and Central Asia to China proper in the Yellow River basin through the upper Yellow River corridor (the Hexi corridor), which traverses across modern Gansu and Xinjiang. The northern route may also encompass the Mongolian plateau where the sites of Afanasevo bronze culture were found, and whose far eastern extension manifested as early bronze age Qijia culture in Ganzu. The less discussed southern route, on the other hand, consists of a land branch and a maritime branch. The maritime route connects southeast Asia with coastal eastern China and populated the latter region by the proto-Austrasiatic, Kra-Daic, and Hmong-Mien people. The land route connects southwestern China (Yunnan and Sichuan) and the Tibetan Plateau to Burma, northeastern India and modern Bangladesh, and ultimately taps with the Semitic and Indo-European cultures in western Eurasia. The southern route later became known as the Southwest Silkroad, and the northern route was developed into the Northwest Silkroad. Most subsistence products (animals and plants), metallurgy and pottery techniques, linguistic origins, transportation and weaponry, which used to be thought as indigenously developed, are now found to have been imported or directed implanted from civilizations along these two main routes.</p><p>The northern route was relatively well studied by archaeologists and historians dated back to the early 20th century. For example, the hallmark of neolithic culture within the scope of China proper — Yangshao culture — was the agricultural domestication of millet (both foxtail and broomcorn millet species) around 6000 BP (before present). Yet, millet was first cultivated by people outside the traditional sphere of China proper in Bohai and West Liao River regions further back in 9000-8000 BP, who is attributed to be the ancestors of a series of Trans-Eurasian languages, including Koreanic, Japonic, Tungustic, Mongolic, and Altaic languages and whose paternal Y-haplogroup had a concentration of C and C-subclades. Millet cultivation was only discontinuously spreading to Yellow River (YR) basins in the next two millenniums, being slowly adopted by the local inhabitants of YR and brought to YR basins by Trans-Eurasian people from the West Liao River. Another considerably powerful evidence undermining the demic hypothesis of a Sino-Tibetan (ST) language is the lack of etymological cognates for the staple agricultural products, millet and pig, across Sino-Tibetan languages. These different types of evidence now suggest that millet cultivation that marked the neolithic Yangshao culture, the “dawn light” of Chinese civilization with the first settled agriculture, was likely an import from West Liao River Trans-Eurasian cultures that transmitted to YR regions after the split off of Old Chinese from the Proto-ST language.</p><p>In the northern route, the earliest bronze age site ever excavated is seated in the eastern end of the route connecting upper-middle YR to Central Asia. This bronze age culture became known as Qijia culture, which is a non-indigenous bronze culture extending the Afanasevo culture found in Inner Asia and southern Siberia. Studies by Hosner et al showed a decline of archaeological sites based on millet and pig agriculture in YR region during the 2nd millennium BCE was accompanied by the introduction and growth of products and technologies originated from West Eurasia, including sheep, goat, cattle, horse, chariots, wheels, wheat, and barley. The first archaeologically confirmed state of China — Shang dynasty —was long suspected to have originated from Manchuria in the northeast by historian Fu Sinian. The overwhelming military advantage enjoyed by Shang people is documented as their horse-driven chariots unseen by the contemporaneous foot soldiers in the YR basin. This exact chariot technology and horse domestication, along with sheep and cattle, was transmitted via the northern route by agro-pastoralists from Central Asia and the western Eurasian steppe, by a branch of the Indo-European people whose expansion took place in the 3rd–2nd Millenium BCE and reached YR China proper by the end of 2nd Millenium BCE ().</p><p>The southern route of the grand cultural connection between China and western Eurasia, namely the Southwest Silkroad, consisted of a maritime and an inland trail. The connection occurred between China and northeastern India and modern Bangladesh took place along the land route, which will be the focal discussion of the current chapter. The maritime route spread the population belonging to Y-haplogroups O-M95 and O-M119 along southeast Asia and coastal China, from modern-day Guangzhou to as far north as Shandong. Haplogroup O-M95 overlapped and concentrated among the speakers of Austrasiatic languages, incluidng Munda, Khmer, and Vietnamese, as well as southern Han Chinese; whereas O-M119 is often found among Austronesian and Kra-Daic speakers in addition to southern and eastern Han Chinese. These demographic groups correspond closely to Hundred Yue/Viet (百越) and Hundred Pu/Pyu (百濮) barbarians recorded in Chinese historical writings including <em>Shiji </em>and <em>Han Book</em>. Even today, the endonyms of southeastern Han Chinese cultures still retain the vestige of this ancient connection to Austroasiatic and Austronesian civilizations by having the word “Yue/Viet” in titular appellations, such as Wu Yue (Ngoyue), Min Yue (Menve), and Nan Yue (Namyuet). The festival activity of dragon canoe racing and flower boat tour, unseen in China proper, reflects the intimate cultural relevance of southeastern China to that of southeastern Asia.</p><p>Our focal interest here — the inland route of Southwest Silkroad — is of paramount importance to the peopling of East Asia because this is where major eastern Eurasia Y-haplogroups had evolved and split into modern genetic and linguistic groups since the out-of-Africa movement of <em>homo sapiens</em>. Ancient haplogroup D hailed from the Horn of Africa into the Arabian Peninsula, where it diverged from haplogroup M and took the maritime coastal route to Andamese Island and, northward, to Bangladesh. Around 60 kya, bearers of descendant haplogroup D1 and D3 traveled further north to Yunnan and across the Himalayas to Tibetan Plateau. Today, approximately 20–40% of Tibetans, 20–30% of Yi, and 10–20% of Qiangic people, belong to haplogroup D (). This haplogroup is also found in some Han Chinese at a lower frequency. The relative heavier concentration of haplogroup D in these Tibetan-Burman groups suggests that, first, the Tibetan-Burman branch of the Sino-Tibetan language family received a distinct genetic foundation different from Han Chinese; second, as an earlier human migrated into modern China, haplogroup-D predates haplogroup-O, which is the foundational haplogroup in most Chinese ethnic groups including Han Chinese. Travelling further north, haplogroup-D is found among modern-day Mongolians, Koreans, and various Turkic groups in Xinjiang. The migratory map of haplogroup-D depicted that northeastern India and Bangladesh were the main watersheds that formed the initial peopling of China.</p><p>Twenty thousand years later, around 40 kya, ancient haplogroup-NO followed the steps of haplogroup-D to arrive in the vicinity of northeastern India and Bangladesh. Haplogroup-O is the major genetic lineage found in East Asia and is particularly prevalent in populations from China, Korea, and Japan. After diverging from its antecedent NO group and splitting from haplogroup-N around 20–10 kya, haplogroup O began to expand and diversify within East Asia around 25,000 to 20,000 years ago. This coincided with the retreat of the glaciers and the subsequent reoccupation of the region. The migration routes and patterns of this expansion are still being studied, but it is believed that Haplogroup O mainly spread across East Asia by 1) traversing eastward to southeast Asia and then into southern China, where O-M95, O-M119 and O-M7 groups were developed, and 2) northward route into modern Sichuan and Yunnan, before it finally reached upper and middle Yellow River and evolved into one major ancestral lineage of modern Han Chinese — O-M134*117 as well as other Sino-Tibetan groups. Another study (Shi H et al 2005) showed that most of the major STR haplotypes occurred in southern populations living in modern-day Burma, Yunnan, Thailand, and northeastern India, which is likely the origin place of haplogroup-O.</p><p>The intriguing evolution history of haplogroup-O reveals that this ancestral group probably stayed longer in the vicinity north to Bangladesh and in southeast Asia before it diverged into different mutation groups. Analysis of haplotypes based on short tandem repeat (STR) indicates that O-M7 (mainly Hmong-Mien people) and O-M95 (mainly Austro-Asiatic people) were closer to undifferentiated O* before the evolution bottlenecks imposed by climate and topography were broken off by proto-Sino-Tibetan ancestors who were marked by O-M122 (Cai, X et al 2011). This means that the ancestors of Sino-Tibetan people stayed in the warmer woodlands of Asia in 20–25 kya and departed at this point to venture northward into the semi-arid scrubs of modern-day Yunnan en mass. The northward migration of O-M122 initiated around northeastern India and Burma around 20 kya, they traveled up to the Salween River or Mekong River into Yunnan. Through the Zomia highlands and forests, they moved into Sichuan and eastern Tibetan Plateau, a region that then became the homeland of the proto-Sino-Tibetan language (van Driem, 1999). The estimated time of the arrival of the ancestral Sino-Tibetan people into China varies by studies, but a general consensus is 25 kya, about 18–20 thousand years ahead of the Yangshao neolithic culture, which ushered in ancient Chinese civilizations (Cai, X et al 2011; Shi H et al 2005). Before their long march to China, both O-M122 and O-M95 had left genetic footprints in Bangladesh and northeastern India. Today, a large number of Austro-Asiatic people live in Bangladesh (Munda and Khasi), and several Tibetan-Burman nationalities claim northeastern India and Bangladesh as their traditional homeland (e.g. Meithei, Mizo, Garo), although the Tibetan-Burman groups in South Asia are likely later migrants from Tibet and Yunnan.</p><p>Many Chinese people today also carry haplogroup-C, which is found concentrated among Mongolic and Tungustic people in northern Tran-eurasian forests and steppes from Korea to Altai Mountain. Haplogroup-C is believed to have taken the maritime route of coastal southeast Asia and eastern China before reaching the West Liao River and spreading to Trans-Eurasia, thus it has left genetic footprint all over eastern China, Korea, Manchuria, and the Mongolian Plateau. Both Ghengis Khan and Confucius prove to share the paternal lineage of haplogroup-C2b (Wu, Q et al, 2020), confirming Fu Sinian’s hypothesis of the Manchurian origin of Shang Dynasty. However, the maritime transmission route of haplogroup-C had less to do with northeastern India and Bangladesh, we will leave it out of the scope of this chapter. Nevertheless, Bangladesh and northeastern India are of crucial importance in the evolutionary history of human genetics because this region is the only gate for out-of-Africa <em>homo sapiens </em>to go into East Asia during the Last Glacial Maximum around 20 kya. The northwestern Silkroad was closed off by extreme coldness, and the Himalayas were naturally inhibiting. Human migration into East Asia had to traverse through modern-day Bangladesh into Southeast Asia, where they flourished and developed new haplogroups including O, C, D, N, F (Hallast et al, 2020).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*oLTTtfmYEZXyzrTPAavADw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The genetic evolution map of haplogroups clearly carved northeast India and the Southwest Silkroad to be the most critical route for the development of any subsequent Sino-Tibetan populations, including the earliest known Chinese state that spoke an archaic Sinitic language — the Zhou dynasty (Shang, on the other hand, originated from Manchuria or Bohai-Liao River area). The prehistoric human deployment of the resources, terrains, structures of Southwest Silkroad was very antiquated and far predated the earliest written record of this route by Chinese historians. The later Sinocentric historical narrative promoted by the “tianxia” worldview, however, sees the world from a centrifugal perspective that historical importance and cultural relevance were equated with the Central Plain of China, while other regions further from the Central Plain were dismissed as barbaric. The barbarians of all four directions (the Eastern Yi, Northern Di, Western Rong, and Southern Man), in the eyes of heavily ideologized Chinese literati bureaucrats, lived in ignorance waiting for salvation by memorizing Chinese characters and kowtowing to the condescending Confucianist patriarch.</p><p>With this worldview in mind, the official narrative continuously attempts to establish how Soutwest Silkroad was a trade and civilizational project largely developed by the central government of Chinese dynasties. However, commonsense in history and economics defies such assertation. A trade route requires free flow of capital, liquidity of assets, and participating customers with diversified demands. None of these can be activated by a monopolizing agent. Quite contrarily, buzzling and booming transactional activities must already have been present among the different nationalities along the Southwest Silkroad, who each brought with their unique products and demands, before any central government can set up any profitable trade post to also benefit from trading with all other equal parties in this market.</p><p>Chinese states repeatedly tried to use the Southwest Silkroad to establish relationships with the states and tribes that resided in modern Bangladesh and ultimately with western Eurasia. The nationalist and Sinocentric ideology that dominated Han Chinese historian narratives had simply concealed the independently important roles of the Southwest Silkroad and the history of the indigenous population along this route in the making of East Asian historical trajectory. The Sinocentric narrative upholds how the central government from China proper singlehandedly created the Southwest Silkroad and enriched inland China by setting trade posts in Sichuan (Basu Commandery or Basuria) that connects to barbarian states in modern northeastern India, Bangladesh, and Burma. However, in fact, these official trade posts were short-lived and quickly abandoned due to insufficient maintenance and funding. Daily commerce had been conducting since the 2nd millennium BCE between Sichuan and western Eurasian via the Southwest Silkroad, whereas centralized Chinese attempt to establish an official trade post only first occurred in the 1st century BCE.</p><p>For example, <em>The Record of the Grand Historian </em>documented: when Xiongnu cut off and monopolized the Northwest Silkroad, Chinese Han dynasty’s emissary Zhang Qian found Sichuan Silk(蜀锦) and Sichuan-Tibetan Bamboo (邛竹杖) in Bactria and was surprised that indigenous people of Sichuan had been doing business with Central Asia and India via the “Sichuan-Hindu route (<em>shu-shendu dao</em> 蜀身毒道)” for millennia. The same book also documented that in the attempt to acquire a legendary sauce “qijiang (枸醬)” traded in Sichuan (the most southwestern territory by then), Chinese General Tang Meng tried in vain to conquer southwestern states and could not monopolize the Southwest Silkroad. The failed conquest was replaced by a peaceful mutual-cooperation strategy initiated by a Sichuan indigenous Sima Xiangru who convinced the Chinese emperor in the north that trading with them “southwestern barbarians” was not worthy of military intervention. More of a gesture to save face, the Chinese emperor Wu knew that his conquest would be defeated and the Southwest Silkroad had been firmly controlled by indigenous states long before him. <em>The Record of the Grand Historian </em>also recorded that Sima Xiangshu used to wear a shorts known as “bullock nose pant”(犊鼻裈) in public, a deviant and vulgar act in the eyes of Confucianists. This shorts is associated with people who “wash horse”. With archaeological evidence showing short pants were originally wore by horse herders in western Eurasia (), it is not unlikely that Sima Xiangru and other Sichuan natives had learned about wearing short pants by interacting with western Eurasian merchants via the Southwest Silkroad.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db4300d7ae93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Problems in phylogenetic studies on Sino-Tibetan origin: why Sichuan is still its homeland]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/problems-in-phylogenetic-studies-on-sino-tibetan-origin-why-sichuan-is-still-its-homeland-d9bf18547740?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9bf18547740</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Dec 2023 14:13:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-18T14:13:26.402Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the debate of where lies the homeland of proto-Sino-Tibetan (ST) language, three hypotheses exist: middle Yellow River basin of China’s Central Plain, western Sichuan/eastern Tibetan Plateau, northeastern India. I have been a staunch advocate for the western Sichuan hypothesis for various reasons which I do not see any compelling evidence waged against. The most well known scholar advocating for the Sichuan hypothesis is van Driem. Myself wrote a few posts on this site through the lens of historical comparative methods that trace the cognates for <a href="https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/bear-bamboo-fog-the-homeland-of-sino-tibetan-languages-a586bf5a2a11">flora and fauna</a> in the proto-ST environment, especially different species of <a href="https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/bear-panda-and-sino-tibetan-homeland-7e2087d60bd3">bears</a>, in addition to an ambitious <a href="https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/memorandum-of-research-on-basuria-as-the-origin-of-far-east-civilizations-d3fb9f1a0497">general introduction</a> of why genetic and historian studies pointed to Sichuan/Basuria as the cradle of early East Asian civilizations.</p><p>Chinese scholars have generally espoused the Yellow River origin hypothesis, which I<a href="https://medium.com/@yusufbasuria/sino-tibetan-urheimat-and-the-chinese-nationalist-propaganda-7b0abbd02b88"> have c</a>autioned, at least among some of these scholars, were a nationalist propaganda implicitly encouraged by the P.R. China government. This strategic propaganda effort is now being forcefully pushed on university-level archaeology and historical education and research, after Xi Jinping released his speech of “forging the communal sense of the Chinese nation” and “sticking to four confidences”. The new directorial spirit of the Chinese government now explicitly requires historical researchers to stick to the narrative that promote the core of Chinese civilization as independently developed out of the Central Plain along Yellow River while <em>absorbing </em>parts and parcels of surrounding cultures in China. Naturally, whether fit or not, linguists based in Chinese institutions need to forge their findings to match with the Yellow River origin hypothesis for basically any culture-level phenomenon. Millet farming needs to originate in Yellow River, ST language needs to develop first in Yellow River, Bronze metallurgy needs to independently develop in there, even Homo Sapiens cannot come out of Africa before China.</p><p>I will not suggest all studies concluding with the Yellow River hypothesis being propaganda, some are clearly not. The suspicious tendency only appears when the findings of a study do not fully support the hypothesis, yet the authors proceeded to the conclusion without hesitation, nonetheless. I am going to show the difference between two studies on the homeland of proto-ST with the same conclusion affirming the Yellow River hypothesis but different tones of narrative and rigor. One was published in <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-77404-4"><em>Scientific Reports</em></a> in 2020 and another in <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1153-z"><em>Nature-Letters</em></a><em> in </em>2019.<em> </em>Both studies have a lead author named Zhang, but the first (Zhang et al 2020) had authors based in the UK and the latter (Zhang et al 2019) was based in China.</p><p>To begin with, phylogenetic method, whether using Bayesian statistical inference or the classical frequentist model-testing, is simply a testing tool against priors or hypotheses. Scholars would first propose a family tree for many members of a supposed genus. Then, based on the number of the presence and absence of common traits (e.g. morphology, cognate, etc), similar members will be grouped together and claimed to have a common ancestor which is a node preceding them. The most distant member from all the rest is supposed to be remotely related or have split the earliest from the rest. In ST languages, this most distant member is often Chinese, which has the fewest number of common traits with other ST languages. Thus, the immediate preceding ancestor for Old Chinese is just proto-ST.</p><p>But phylogenetic method was developed to apply the logic of biological evolution to empirical data. When birds shared the fewest traits with a group of mammals, phylogenetic tree means birds diverged from mammals before these mammals evolved and they shared a common ancestor. It by no means implies birds predates the ancestor of mammals other than the fact birds is genealogically, not in real time, closer to the bird-mammal common ancestor. More importantly, biological species and their fossils are the actual embodiment of anatomical traits that are used to group commonalities and divergence. This is not the case for linguistic evolution. Birds cannot suddenly lose their wings without prolonged evolution and adaptation, but a language can. A labelled language may undergo fundamental internal changes that nearly fully altered the original morphological, topological, and semantic features. Old Chinese and Middle Chinese have very significant differences that cannot be explained by natural evolution and contact, such significant Schuessler and Benedict both suggested that Old Chinese was only spoken by a minority of Zhou conquerors and imposed <em>in nomine</em> on the Kra-Dai, Trans-Eurasian, and Austronesian people who resided in Central Plain during the 1st Millenium. Middle Chinese was a creolization product that resembles more of Hmong-Mien, Kra-Dai features rather than other ST languages. Therefore, while a biological species that share the fewest traits with other species can be justified as a distant split-off in a phylogenetic tree, a distant language may not be so. The distinction of Old Chinese from Tibetan-Burman language may suggest it is the first split-off (even so, it still does not imply which is older), but it may also mean Old Chinese is the strangest ST language due to creolization arising from the contact with the possibly Tungustic-speaking Shang people and myriad of Kra-Dai and Hmong-Mien speakers residing in the Central Plain.</p><p>After all, even if recorded writing and pronunciation of Old Chinese faithfully reflects how Zhou people spoke, phylogeny still does nothing to confirm the direction of language evolution. The only resort by both phylogenetic studies to affirm the Yellow River hypothesis is by referring to a potential match between their estimated time of divergence in proto-ST and the time of millet farming, both of which are highly variable with wide confidence intervals. However, as many scholars have explained and I have also made a post earlier, the adoption of technology does not equal replacement of population (this point is also admitted in Zhang et al 2020 paper). The assumption of demic diffusion has undergone critical evaluation recently. Given that millet cultivation was discontinuously transmitted from modern Manchuria (West Liao River) to Yellow River, and only then spread to Sichuan and Tibetan Plateau over a period of two to three thousand years (Hosner et al 2016), being an earlier culture to cultivate millet says nothing about whether the population of this culture migrated to and replaced other later adopters. The lack of etyma for millet in ST languages refutes the assumption that millet was very important for all ST people. Similarly, another hallmark species used to prove Yellow River agriculturists initiated demic diffusion of proto-ST is pig. Unfortunately, just like millet, Sagart (1999) found in <em>the Roots of Old Chinese</em> that “No outside comparisons have been found for a root *hlaj? ‘pig’. It is possible that we are dealing with a Chinese innovation”.</p><p>Finally, Jade Guiede’s (2018) review of archaeological fieldworks in eastern Tibetan Plateau and western Sichuan showed that millet farmers did not fully expand into this region but gave way millet and pottery technology to the local foragers and hunters. The rapid penetration of millet farmers into Himalayas was also questioned as implausible for the short period by Liu Chi-chun et al (2022). Then, the more realistic scenario is that the local foragers traded, conflicted, inter-married with millet farmers, forcing the latter to hold steads in low-elevation river valleys of the Plateau. Local foragers maintained a versatile economic advantage over the millet farmers by adopting multitudes of subsistence strategy including hunting, subsistence farming and herding. Thus, neolithic sites in eastern Plateau such Karuo received Yangshao pottery and millet infusion only to a limited extent during a limited time. Millet farmers intermingled with local advantageous foragers, instead of replacing them in the manner of what the Indo-Europeans did to prehistoric Europeans and Indus River civilization. This peaceful coexistence scenario likely reflects the fact that the indigenous inhabitants of eastern Tibetan Plateau were already cultural and genetic relatives of Yangshao millet farmers before the arrival of the latter, and this possibility is attested by genetic studies on Y-haplogroup O-M134.</p><p>In short, the recent obsession over Bayesian phylogenetic modeling overlooks the fundamental issue of applying phylogenetic models to linguistic data. Now we turn to the two studies mentioned above, some oddity will emerge to baffle us regarding how Yellow River hypothesis can be affirmed in face of weak evidence.</p><p>Zhang et al (2020) study reserved a more careful tone in linking phylogenetic tree to the homeland of proto-ST. Their main conclusion is that proto-Chinese split off from proto-ST in 8000 BP, a time much earlier than any other studies. This period overlaps that of millet cultivation in northern China but actually predates Yangshao culture tremendously by two to three millennia, contradicting their own claim that millet farming marked the bifurcated divergence within proto-ST. On contrary, the Bayesian phylogenetic result of Chinese being the earliest divergence would attest my hypothesis that Old Chinese is the earliest wanderer off from western Sichuan and intermingled with other non-ST population in eastern China, including proto-Tungustic millet gatherers distributed from West Liao River to Shandong (Robbeets et al 2021). Millet was then slowly and gradually borrowed back to proto-ST groups remained in western Sichuan and eastern Tibetan Plateau without population replacement.</p><p>Bayesian models can give posterior likelihoods and their distribution. Like any statistics, these likelihoods per se have a confidence interval and a range allowing randomness. An estimation of 8000 BP with a 95% CI ranging from 4079 to 11112 BP is just too wild to meaningfully match and triangulate with any historical and archaeological evidence. If this estimation is taken as true, any sloppy archaeological evidence of millet farming within the wild scope of 4 to 11 millennia BP would substantiate their assumption that millet farming coincided with the split of Chinese from proto-ST.</p><p>Another problem being the phylogeny in this study, as elsewhere, was built only on cognates, and no morphological traits were considered. The problem of only using cognates to establish the Stammbaum in ST language has been warned by Randy LaPolla in edited book <em>Areal Diffusion and Genetic Inheritance</em>, where he cautioned that ST is notorious for word contagion and borrowing with the neighboring Hmong-Mien, Austroasiatic, Kra-Dai, and Indo-Aryan languages. Similar opinion was expressed in Laurent Sagart (1999) that many perceived congates were loanwords between Chinese and Tibetan-Burman, or other languages, due to areal proximity. Therefore, without also consulting the divergence of morphological traits in the ST languages, phylogenetic studies based on cognates are likely inherently biased by areality. This leads to the fundamental issue with phylogenetic study on language: phylogene cannot account for areal proximity. Old Chinese were the earliest divergence from proto-ST not because its own evolutionary path and mutation, but simply because Old Chinese was the farthest branch that tapped deep into areas of non-ST languages!</p><p>Due to the above reasons, the authors themselves were hesitant: “This calls for a more cautious interpretation of the inferred root age, and a more nuanced understanding of the first Sino-Tibetan speakers than ‘out-migrating farmers. Farming in East Asia may have spread gradually through the mixing of farmers and hunter-gatherers”. This nuanced interpretation actually aligns with Guedes (2018). We have reasons to doubt, if millet farmers arrived extremely slowly over a long period time, how can proto-ST originate from millet farmers without replacing the large number of ST languages spread across the entire southwestern China, Himalayas, and Burma? The more realistic scenario is again that proto-ST speakers already existed in eastern Himalaya/western Sichuan before the arrival of Yangshao millet farmers in the 6th millennium BP.</p><p>In the other study — Zhang et al (2019), the same problem inherent in phylogenetic study still exists. They made a phylogenetic tree with Chinese as the outlier first split off from proto-ST and estimated the time of the onset of proto-ST to be 6000 BP, with 95% CI being 4100–7800 BP. Because this time of onset coincided with the time of millet cultivation, the authors claimed Yellow River origin to be the correct hypothesis. Not to mention that millet cultivation now prove to be much earlier than 6000 BP in West Liao River, the logical link connecting food production with the formation of a language is very arbitrary. As we have discussed above, the expansion of millet and pig based agriculture is very gradual and discontinous than previously believed.</p><p>The authors also made a probiblity density map for the possible homeland of ST language, and the result is surprisingly western Sichuan/eastern Himalayas. They claimed two conditions were not met so their own map couldn’t be taken seriously. But their explanation of the violation of the two conditions were very ad hoc: first, the language extinction occurred in eastern China did not primarily happen to ST language but ancient Hmong-Mien and Austroasiatic languages. Second, all ST groups undergoing migration in the same direction is by itself an assumption under the hypothesis of Yellow River origin. In fact, under Sichuan origin hypothesis, some ST groups migrated north and east-ward to become Chinese and Tangut; some migrated southward via valleys into Burma and northeastern Indian; while others migrated west-ward to form Bodic group and then further south across the Himalaya to form various ST groups in Nepal and northeastern India. The map by these authors espousing the Yellow River hypothesis ironically pointed out western Sichuan as the homeland of proto-ST.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kWZEwOZiNM2Xqyy8C4TzAw.png" /><figcaption>supplementary map by Zhang et al (2020) showing western Sichuan as the homeland of proto-ST</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9bf18547740" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bear, Panda, and Sino-Tibetan Homeland]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/bear-panda-and-sino-tibetan-homeland-7e2087d60bd3?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e2087d60bd3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Dec 2023 15:18:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-01T17:40:56.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In a <a href="https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/bear-bamboo-fog-the-homeland-of-sino-tibetan-languages-a586bf5a2a11">previous post</a>, I have listed and discussed several etyma found across Sino-Tibetan (ST) languages that all pointed to a common natural environment that likely was the homeland of proto-ST. Among them, the animal bear (<em>ursus) </em>is of the utmost interesting story that further helps us pinpoint the homeland of ST to western Basuria and eastern Himalaya ranges.</p><p>The etymon for bear in proto ST is <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=bear#">dɣwjəm</a>. In Tibetan-Burmo, it evolved to be d-wam, and later d-wom due to a vowel shift. In Old Sinitic Chinese, the word root evolved to be gwjəm, with a g-d replacement of the consonant, which is common in Tibetan-Burmo languages like Kanauri. Zhang Shuheng’s 2019 article in <em>Sino-Platonic Papers</em> “Three Ancient Words for Bear” proposed that a <em>d-wam — g-wom </em>shift is possible due to the above patterns of evolution.</p><p>Cognates based on <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=bear#">dɣwjəm</a> are overwhelmingly common across ST languages, evident in basically every single ST language and this fact can be checked in <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=bear">STEDT database</a>. On the ground, <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=bear#">dɣwjəm</a> most likely refers to Asian Black Bear (<em>ursus tibetanus</em>) and this species is the most widely distributed in East Asia. Therefore, the fact d-wam as an etymon for bear is seen in most ST languages reveals that the Asian Black Bear had a very wide scope of geographical distribution across East Asia, from Tibetan Plateau to Korea, but coastal East China has not seen fossils or existence of Asian Black Bear. Today, d-wam as Asian Black Bear in Continental East Asia is present in southern China, Yunnan, western Basuria/eastern Himalaya, Korea, and outer Manchuria. Since d-wam is a validly confirmed ST etymon, all of these above regions could have been a homeland for ST.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/318/1*hIR4zi73y8nXjqho6zrraA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Asian Black Bear/d-wam/熊</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/1*suRDekSJGBe7Vi6idYhOTA.png" /></figure><p>However, we cannot rule out other regions that historically had seen <em>d-wam </em>could have also been the ST homeland. The only problem is when did Asian Black Bear go extinct from where its fossils were uncovered. If it had gone extinct a long time (say, Pleistocene) before human settlement in East Asia in the Holocene, then those regions that only historically featured Asian Black Bear, e.g. middle Yellow River, cannot possibly be the homeland of ST because the first ST speakers could not have seen Asian Black Bear there. However, supporting literature documenting the fossils and their carbon-dated ages of Asian Black Bear found in China is extremely obscure and lacking. The historical limit of Asian Black Bear’s existence in China is largely based on literary tradition such as 山海经、尚书、楚辞, whose mythological depiction of animals was ambiguous at best. Thus, on the more conservative side and to be safer, we should restrict our identification of the ST homeland to where the fossils, not the story documentation, of Asian Black Bear are found and recorded, such as western Basuria, Shaanxi, and Yunnan. This region is where ST ancestors of different tribes all witnessed Asian Black Bear and called it <em>d-wam</em>.</p><p>Other than the Sinitic descendant of proto-ST d-wam that is <em>gwjəm</em> (熊), Old Chinese had another term for a different kind of bear and written as 羆. This character often appeared together with 熊 as 熊羆 in the Book of Odes. Zhang Shuheng (2019) had meticulously documented the historical mentioning and evolution of these two characters in Chinese literature. The consensus is that 羆 is a bear with stripes or spots, and most likely associated with Eurasian Brown Bear (<em>ursus arctos arctos).</em></p><p>The Old Chinese sound for 羆 is <em>pray</em>, it is reconstructed to have the same root with <em>pran</em> “spots/stripes” (斑), and both can be traced back to proto-Tibetan-Burmo *<em>pral</em>. Since both black bear and brown bear in East Asia have a white ring/stripe on their chest (up until maturity for brown bear), it is likely Old Chinese use <em>gwjam</em> <em>pray </em>熊羆 together to either 1) denote both species as a common class, or, as suggested by Zhang Shuheng, 2) to use <em>pray </em>as an adjective to denote stripe-shaped bear.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/1*zaOiDraknKrIC9kA7J3_ug.jpeg" /><figcaption>Eurasian Brown Bear with white stripe on the chest</figcaption></figure><p>In fact, the proto-TB root for stripes has a deeper origin as p(w)ay ⪤ b(w)ay, which means “encircled, ringed, striped”. This etymon evolves to be <em>pai</em> in Mikhir to mean ring, <em>pài</em> in Jingpho to mean spotted,<em> </em><a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/etymon/597#"><em>lo⁵⁵</em></a><em> pi³³</em> in Nuosu to mean ring the jewlry. In rGyalrong languages, <em>pri</em> or <em>pre</em> specifically means yellow (brown) bear, contrasting it with black bear (<em>tawom</em>) and carrying the same meaning as the Old Chinese <em>pray</em>. The <em>rjɨj </em>in Tangut is a close relative of the rGyalrongic <em>pri.</em></p><p>Since several ST languages possess a common root for the meanings of stripe and brown bear, ancestors of the ST language probably lived close to the natural habitat of brown bear (<em>ursus arctos</em>). Whereas the Asian Black Bear has a widespread distribution in China, brown bear’s habitat is quite restricted to the Tibetan Plateau and the Himalaya ranges. This, for the second time, strongly suggest the homeland of ST is located in western Basuria/eastern Himalaya.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lqNpuGLxZCLe5XST2c5iKQ.png" /><figcaption>distribution of bear species (Kumar et al 2017)</figcaption></figure><p>Now, Eurasian bears of both the black and brown kinds are relatively well studied by comparative linguists. There is little controversy regarding what Old Chinese word each species corresponds to and what proto-ST root can be reconstructed for each, as seen above. One bear species that surprisingly went unnoticed by comparative linguists is Giant Panda (<em>Ailuropoda melanoleuca), </em>whose habitat today is strictly western Basuria. Giant Panda may have had a larger habitat limit in the past, but when was it and where is their habitat limit during the Holocene only? Do ST ancestors have a common etymon for Giant Panda too?</p><p>Giant Panda is sporadically called 貔(pi) or 白豹(bai bao, lit. white leopard) in 尚书, but the depiction of 貔 is very ambiguous and figurative. However, from the previous section, we know that <em>pway </em>is the proto-ST root for spot/stripe. If 貔(pi) in ancient Chinese literature really signified Giant Panda, then it will match well with the intended meaning of “striped animal” embedded on the etymon <em>pway. </em>As supporting evidence, I found that ɣɔ⁴⁴ be³³ in Lisu is the name for Panda. <em>ɣɔ</em> is a common Loloish cognate for bear, deriving from <em>ɣɔm</em>, and <em>be</em> is an adjective cognate deriving from proto-Tibetan-Burmo p(w)ay ⪤ b(w)ay.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*_7ZLhmNwxSkJ-dYGiDZaKQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Where was Giant Panda possibly distributed then? Although dental fossils of Giant Panda are said to be found as far north as Zhoukoudian, new <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-13402-y#Sec6">studies</a> excluded this northmost site because the size of the dental fossil was too large to be from Giant Panda. Additionally, the Zhoukoudian fossil was dated the Pleistocene era, far too early for human interaction with the animal. With regard to the claimed Giant Panda teeth fossil found at Lingjing, Henan, the only source identifiable came from a few Chinese website without further citation of any original publication. The only academic paleoarchaeology study on this fossil record was a study by 李占扬 &amp; 董为 (2007). This study explicitly stated that the fossil tooth belonged to unspecified <em>ursidae</em> bear, likely brown bear, but further class cannot be established. Similar with the Zhoukoudian fossil, Lingjing fossil was then probably taken by nationalist propaganda to exaggerate the historical limit of Giant Panda habitat. Correcting the exaggeration, the real distribution of all known fossils of Giant Panda is exclusively in southern China and Southeast Asia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*15VJ59Q3o2dqHgaZTPWFiw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In this map, a few fossil sites are located in the traditional area of Yangshao culture, but the main cultural center of Yangshao (i.e. Shanxi, northern Shaanxi, Hebei) does not contain any site of panda fossils. Furthermore, the descendant of Yangshao — Majiayao culture, does not contain any such site either. If proto-ST ancestors originated from Yangshao culture, they would not have any knowledge of the Giant Panda, let alone naming it with a word related to the common ST etyma <em>pway.</em></p><p>On top of the overall distribution of all known fossils, <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4425/9/4/198">a study</a> published in <em>MDPI</em>-<em>Genes </em>found that panda diversity was rapidly lost during the Holocene, as a part of the Holocene extinction. This means many of the mid-Pleistocene sites of panda habitat should have already disappeared by the time humans appeared in East Asia, leaving the panda-active areas during the Neolithic era to be closer to where they are mostly active today, which is western and northern Basuria.</p><p>Now we have established that Asian Black Bear, Eurasian Brown Bear, and Giant Panda, each has their own common word root in the proto-ST language and such word roots have been preserved in many modern ST languages. Thus, by the principle of comparative linguistics, the speakers of the proto-ST language, who first appeared in East Asia in 7000–8000 bp, should have been living in an environment where all three species were found. We have already seen in the maps above: the only overlapping area in which Eurasian Brown Bear and Asian Black Bear intersect is western Basuria/eastern Himalaya; Giant Panda’s active sphere since the Holocene is mostly restricted to Basuria and Shaanxi. Based on the evidence of fossil excavation, climate, and flora habitat, the safe bet for the location of such an environment can only be western Basuria/eastern Himalaya.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e2087d60bd3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bear, Bamboo, Fog — the Homeland of Sino-Tibetan languages]]></title>
            <link>https://yusufbasuria.medium.com/bear-bamboo-fog-the-homeland-of-sino-tibetan-languages-a586bf5a2a11?source=rss-6cb62302963a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a586bf5a2a11</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yusuf Basurian]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Nov 2023 20:58:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-01T12:49:06.757Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Bear, Bamboo, Fog — the Homeland of Sino-Tibetan languages</h3><p>In comparative linguistics, word roots from related languages in a family may reveal the common knowledge shared by the proto speakers of the language about their familiar natural environment. The lack of true cognates to signify a basic object from the nature across different languages within the same linguistic family leads to the suspicion that the earliest forebears of the proto-language may not have been familiarized with the said natural object before the split of the proto language into the extant languages. For example, Abram has been seeing automobiles and call them “car” by the time he had three kids, all his three kids would learn the word “car” and use it as a basic root to describe human-transporting machines even when they change the term with certain morphological adaptations. However, if Abram has never seen and called a “car” and all his kids learned about this machine on their own after they moved out, they may call the machine with their own convenient word root, e.g. auto-mobile, big wheel, transporter, vehi-cle, etc.</p><p>In earlier posts, I have talked about the competing hypothesis of the homeland of Sino-Tibetan language (ST): the northern China hypothesis vs. Sichuan-Himalaya hypothesis. The northern China hypothesis is really a catch-all umbrella term to put both central China Yangshao culture along the middle Yellow River (YR) and the upper YR Qinghai-Gansu area in the same designation. However, upper YR and middle YR are very distinct culturally and geographically, as well as in terms of their access to other contemporaneous cultures that bore the peopling of the Y haplogroups of C2, Q, and N. Linjia site of Majiayao culture at upper YR in Gansu is the earliest site for bronze metallurgy, suggesting an Inner Asia route of technological spread from the west. On the other hand, Yangshao culture as a millet farming population has acquired millet from the much earlier Transeurasian cultures in today’s Amur and Liao river areas (Robeets et al 2021), who had cultivated millet as hunter-gatherers and only needed to partly domesticate millet because its harvest cycle is a <a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/12/151214084754.htm">short period of 45 days.</a> The spread of technological advances such as millet cultivation or bronze metallurgy does not mean a parallel spread of genetic and linguistic bearers. Archaeological findings that formed Majiayao culture may have appeared later than Yangshao and its people acquired millet farming from Yangshao, but they only imply the route of technological transmission, not a genetic and linguistic one. An archaeologist from the future may dig out sites in Guangdong with much advanced mastery and earlier adoption of semi-conductor technology, compared to Gansu, owing to Guangdong’s convenient maritime commerce route with the United States, then s/he may wrongly conclude that Guangdong precedes and leads the peopling of Gansu in a form of demic diffusion.</p><p>Back to my point, the spread of technology and artifacts is a separate phenomenon from the spread of language and cannot be used as a piece of foundational evidence for locating the homeland (urheimat) of a language family. Lauren Sagart, Zhang Menghan, He Guanglin, and many more have been forging a link between different operational levels without carefully differentiating their unique mechanisms.</p><p>Then back to my point in the first paragraph, we may locate the homeland of ST by tracing it to a natural environment, in which most languages in the ST family would have common etyma (root words) to describe the typical products of this natural environment. A large part of the etymological information in this post comes from Jacques Guillaume’s forthcoming article “Origins of Sino-Tibetan, bringing in evidence from history, biology and archaeology” and Matisoff (2009) “Stable Roots in Sino-Tibetan/Tibeto-Burman”, as well as from the <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/">STEDT</a> database.</p><p>Many have suggested northern China as the Urheimat of ST and the demic diffusion of millet farming spread proto-ST from northern China to Tibet and Basuria. However, there is simply no common cognate for millet (both broomcorn and foxtail species) across ST. The Old Chinese 稷 <em>tsik</em> can only find a correspondence with Nungish <em>cek. </em>This oddity again suggests that Yangshao people, or whoever grew millet, did not speak a proto-ST language, and likely had learned millet cultivation from Trans-Eurasians in Manchuria, instead of inventing and later spreading it to other ST speakers. If the middle YR area in north China was the homeland of ST, then other ST clades would have known how to say “millet”.</p><p>What are some stable and reconstructible ST etymon then? They are:</p><p>#Bear.</p><p>In Old Chinese 熊 *<em>gwem </em>had reliable correspondences in Bodish <em>dom</em>, Burmo-Gyarongic <em>təwam</em>, Tani <em>tum, </em>etc. Another Old Chinese term 羆pje←*praj has correspondence with Gyarongic <em>pri</em>. The distribution of bears in East Asia (ursus tibetanus) precludes eastern China as the homeland of ST and points instead to Eastern Himalaya (including west Basuria, southern Gansu, Qinghai, and upper YR). The existence of another bear species, the Giant Panda, in western Basuria further corroborates the possibiltiy that Eastern Himalaya is the Urheimat of ST. Although earlier bear distribution before human devastation of the environment may extend further east in East Asia, bears’ preference for mountainous habitat and hibernation tendency makes Eastern Himalaya a more favored ecological niche. Because Giant Panda as a subspecies of bear has lost most of its habitat <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324279940_Ancient_DNA_from_Giant_Panda_Ailuropoda_melanoleuca_of_South-Western_China_Reveals_Genetic_Diversity_Loss_during_the_Holocene">since entering the Holocene</a>, other bears faced similar issue and were increasingly confined to the Tibetan Plateau, upper YR, and western Basuria.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1yv0sYZyiMChnK6yuqvtPA.png" /></figure><p>#Monkey.</p><p>STEDT has a proto-form as m(y/r)uk, corresponding to Old Chinese mə-gˤ(r)o, which then survive as Mandarin 猕猴 (mihou) and Cantonese 马骝 (marou). This root word is widely found in other ST languages, such as Lolo-Burmese <em>myuk</em>, Jirel Tibetan <em>moro</em>, and <em>yok</em> in various Himalaya languages.</p><p>An interesting evolutionary biology study (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ajp.23142">Li Baoguo et al 2020</a>) showed that Asian macaques entered East Asia from Yunnan and southeastern Himalaya (also pointing to western Basuria) before reaching into China proper. The early humanoids should have started to see monkeys first in Basuria and Eastern Himalaya. Having a common cognate shared across so many ST languages for monkey strongly suggests that the urheimat of ST is also within the same areal range. In addition, the lack of non-human primate fossils in northern China cautions against locating ST urheimat in northern China at all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/312/1*g9U05seTsLY0MhIQcLnB-g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Snub nose monkey in Basuria</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/501/1*4z3Evub_AA0U50Pym2lmnw.gif" /></figure><p>#Birch and Pine.</p><p>Old Chinese 桦 *ɢʷˁra corresponded to Tibetan <em>gro.ga. </em>For pine, Tibetan <em>tʰaŋ</em>, Gyarongic <em>tutho, </em>Tangkhulic <em>mə.tɐŋ </em>are related to Sinitic 蒸tɕiŋ←*təŋ.</p><p>Both birch and pine trees grow and thrive in cold climate. Its temperature tolerance is an upper limit of 30 Celsius. Today, its famous habitats in East Asia are Manchuria, Mongolia, Loess Plateau and southwestern China. Central Plain is simply not where it grows. In addition, the temperature in the Neolithic era is 3–5 Celsius higher than today, leaving the loconym 豫 to the Central Plain of China due to its elephant produce. The summer temperature of modern Central Plain often reaches 38 Celsius, making its neolithic upper temperature, which would have ranged from 40 to 45, a killer of any healthy birch growth. Alternatively, Eastern Himalaya and its slope ranges extending from Qinghai to Basuria would be the ideal habitat for birch forests. <a href="https://www.earth.com/news/heat-makes-pine-trees-more-susceptible-to-disease/">Heat</a> also makes pine tree extremely susceptible to diseases, delisting lower YR and Central Plain from the ideal place for pine forests and making them unlikely a homeland to languages that share the etyma of birch and pine. The ecological needs of birch and pine do not, however, exclude Loess Plateau in northern China as a urheimat candidate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NE00TvqqTv7v8s_RVYUsgQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>#Bamboo.</p><p>Proto-ST (<a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=bamboo#">g-)pwɑ</a> is constructed, from which Old Chinese 匪 pəjʔ derives. Bamboo is also a ST cognate according to Matisoff, only that he does not see it as pervasive enough.</p><p>While temperate flora like birch and pine do not prefer areas with high summer temperatures, subtropical flora such as bamboo also preclude further north in East Asia from the best Urheimat candidates. Thus, certain Yangshao sites such as Shimao, and Liao River Hongshan cultures would neither be the homeland of ST. This still does not exclude the southern Loess Plateau from the competition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/1*nR6wBZbJxmEZjduAf-ILKw.jpeg" /></figure><p>#Fog.</p><p><em>mway</em> is both fog and cloud in Tibet-Burmese. For proto-ST, the cognate for fog is <em>mruk, </em>which is the Old Chinese <em>kə.mok </em>and<em> mi̯ug (</em>雾, or 霾<em>). </em>Corresponding pervasively with Baic <em>mɯ²¹ko</em>, Nuosu <em>mu³³ hɔ⁵⁵</em>, Gyalrong <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=fog#"><em>zdo</em></a><em> mə</em>, Tani <a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=fog#"><em>doŋ</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://stedt.berkeley.edu/~stedt-cgi/rootcanal.pl/gnis?t=fog#"><em>muk</em></a>, Tibetan <em>rmuk.</em></p><p>Ding and Dong (2023) have found an interesting phenomenon that ST people living on higher altitudes tend to not distinguish cloud from fog in their language, due to the topologically identical position of both meteorological phenomena. The proto <em>mway </em>refers to both cloud and fog interchangeably. The existence of a co-lexified word cloud/fog in ST suggests locating its urheimat at somewhere with higher altitude. Again, the Eastern Himalaya appears to be a more likely place over northern China because the latter either lacked the high altitude (Central Plain) or high humidity (Loess Plateau) required to develop cloud/fog.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*mIaKFOBjxXEJRm3kqOODtw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Although tracing the initial natural environment of stable cognate is not definitive in locating the homeland of the ST language, the evidence, when combined, points toward a more plausible area and helps us exclude those unlikely. When all ST languages share the common words of bear, bamboo, birch, pine, monkey, fog/cloud, and the early speakers have lived with or through these natural beings, isn’t it more likely than any other hypothesis that the homeland of ST is just Eastern Himalaya/Western Basuria, whose staple produce include bear, panda, monkey, bamboo, and birch and pines on mountain slopes, and is also cloudy and foggy all year around?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a586bf5a2a11" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>