<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Zack Stein on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Zack Stein on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@zackstein?source=rss-a24e086cc57f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 22:48:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@zackstein/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Bug in the Code]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zackstein/a-bug-in-the-code-9267c4cb369f?source=rss-a24e086cc57f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9267c4cb369f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[twitter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tripwire-interactive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-gibson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zack Stein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Sep 2021 15:19:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-07T15:46:25.890Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Politics have not made video gaming better.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MDjnh04LKhJIx6vhYBcU-A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Former Tripwire Interactive CEO John Gibson, from his Twitter feed.</figcaption></figure><p>John Gibson, CEO of Tripwire Interactive, <a href="https://twitter.com/RammJaeger/status/1434245886670901250">tweeted</a> something that many people in the video game community found abhorrent:</p><h3>John Gibson on Twitter: &quot;Proud of #USSupremeCourt affirming the Texas law banning abortion for babies with a heartbeat. As an entertainer I don&#39;t get political often. Yet with so many vocal peers on the other side of this issue, I felt it was important to go on the record as a pro-life game developer. / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>Proud of #USSupremeCourt affirming the Texas law banning abortion for babies with a heartbeat. As an entertainer I don&#39;t get political often. Yet with so many vocal peers on the other side of this issue, I felt it was important to go on the record as a pro-life game developer.</p><p>People lost their minds, and then Gibson stepped down. Tripwire issued a statement, as reported by <a href="https://kotaku.com/tripwire-ceo-steps-down-after-supporting-texas-anti-abo-1847626560">Kotaku</a>:</p><p><em>The comments given by John Gibson are of his own opinion, and do not reflect those of Tripwire Interactive as a company. His comments disregarded the values of our whole team, our partners and much of our broader community. Our leadership team at Tripwire are deeply sorry and are unified in our commitment to take swift action and to foster a more positive environment.</em></p><p>So is this a victory? Was Gibson not fostering a positive environment before he tweeted that sentiment? Was he a tyrant who committed an unforced error and now it’s “Ding dong, the witch is dead”?</p><p>I don’t know. Honestly, I hadn’t ever heard of Gibson until a few days ago. Chances are, most of you hadn’t heard of him either, or if you had, you knew him as the guy from Tripwire. Did you have a value judgement of who he was as a person? I’m guessing probably not until he made that tweet.</p><p>First, let me say I don’t agree with Gibson. And I don’t understand how he thought this would play out beyond the predictable pearl-clutching and need for fainting couches. As I said, it’s an unforced error.</p><p>A scroll through his Twitter timeline shows a man who tweeted mostly about his adventures in the world of video gaming. He was in Seattle at PAX. He’s looking for devs who might need a publisher. Fairly standard stuff. Clearly, though, something was bubbling beneath the surface. It’s right there in his tweet: “…with so many vocal peers on the other side of this issue…”</p><p>But the thing is, why did he have to say anything? And why <em>are </em>there so many vocal peers on the other side?</p><p>Why are there <em>sides </em>in video gaming?</p><p>Pull back to 30,000 feet so we can clear up something: Your politics are not who you are. If that were true, my brother’s wonderful in-laws wouldn’t be so wonderful.</p><p>They welcomed my family into their large family every year at Thanksgiving, because they knew my wife’s family were thousands of miles away. I spent four of the warmest, most loving Thanksgivings at their large home outside of Fresno, with about 20 of the nicest people you could want to spend Thanksgiving with.</p><p>Also, they’re all staunch Republicans who were Trump voters. So I guess they’re cancelled.</p><p>But I don’t want to cancel them because, you see, their politics are not who they are.</p><p>SNL tried to tell us this in their delightful Black Jeopardy sketch with Tom Hanks from a few years ago:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FO7VaXlMvAvk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DO7VaXlMvAvk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FO7VaXlMvAvk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7028816353d21d1068e8309909cd4df0/href">https://medium.com/media/7028816353d21d1068e8309909cd4df0/href</a></iframe><p>Unfortunately most of us missed the point.</p><p>Mark Twain has been attributed with the sentiment that politics and religion should not be discussed in polite company. It used to be this way, even back when I was a teenager in the 1980s. I cannot remember a time from my childhood when politics were the part of any family gathering we had, whether a Christmas party, Memorial Day picnic, birthday celebration, whatever. Ronald Reagan won two elections, including a landslide in 1984. Mathematically speaking, I must have crossed paths with a Reagan voter during the 80s. It’s not like you could have picked them out in a crowd. The Reagan voters weren’t the ones pissing in the punch bowl or kicking the dog.</p><p>I cannot think of one facet of life that has been made better by our heightened awareness of politics. I bet you can’t either.</p><p>Here’s the thing: Your politics aren’t anyone’s business. It shouldn’t make up so much of who you think you are. If your basic goals are just trying to be the best person you can be every day, your political leanings have absolutely nothing to do with that. You can be pro-life or pro-choice and still be a good person. You could have voted for Trump or Biden and still be a kind and considerate person. And we really, really need to reckon with that.</p><p>So why in the world have we brought this kind of mess into video gaming? It’s a hobby. It’s supposed to be common ground, where people from all walks of life can meet in the middle and share their love of this wonderful form of entertainment. But now some folks are eliminating some games because this person or that person has expressed a political view that they do not agree with. Is this a desired outcome?</p><p>Can you imagine a chess club being divided because some of the members are Republican and others are Democrats? So then <em>these</em> members won’t play with <em>those</em> members even though <em>they all love chess? </em>Sounds awesome.</p><p>Let’s bring it back down to street level and ask the question again: Why are we insisting on politicizing video gaming? Why is there no room for conflicting opinions? Why is the discourse so hyperbolic and vitriolic? Why can’t we just be a group of people, together, enjoying games, and discussing that enjoyment?</p><p>Politics have replaced identity on all sides. As much as we are reluctant to examine the nature of our politics, and why some had such a negative reaction to his tweet, is the same reason Gibson is pushing back with his reaction to the discourse he’s endured over however long. We shut our ears, close our minds, stomp our feet and yell, “Shame! Shame! Shame!”</p><p>This isn’t discourse. It’s the end of discourse. It’s throwing our hands up and giving up.</p><p>We’re awfully righteous and callous behind our keyboards. The technology has removed our empathy. John Gibson isn’t a monster. He’s supporting the Texas law because he’s pro-life. It’s what he knows. Chances are he was brought up with different values than you. He’s different.</p><p>How is this not prejudice — pre-judging. How is it not bigotry? He’s being judged based on his politics, and not the content of his character. Politics are not character. They are <em>not </em>identity. If they were, I wouldn’t have spent so many wonderful Thanksgivings with my brother’s in-laws. Would you be so quick to vilify Gibson if you had spent a delightful afternoon with him?</p><p>Video game Twitter has an ouroboros nature to it — you know, the snake eating its tail? There is little consistency and faulty logic, and it tends to consume itself. There is so much judgment, so much piousness, so much grandstanding, as if no one on Twitter has ever made a mistake or committed a sin. There is a mob mentality that is vicious and relentless, with little mercy for infractions.</p><p>Video game culture is fighting for inclusivity, but has no use for someone if their politics don’t align with the left-leaning majority. Do we really know anything about Gibson other than he supports an extreme pro-life law in Texas?</p><p>Yes, actually we do. He also supports Black Lives Matter:</p><h3>John Gibson on Twitter: &quot;I&#39;m proud to lead a group of people willing to stand up and take action for justice. https://t.co/DNflR1asMV / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>I&#39;m proud to lead a group of people willing to stand up and take action for justice. https://t.co/DNflR1asMV</p><p>Which holds more weight? Pro-life or anti-racism? John Gibson resigned as CEO of Tripwire, which then released a statement saying that they’re working to foster a more positive environment.</p><p>Was his support of Black Lives Matter not fostering a more positive environment?</p><p>What are we doing, injecting politics into video gaming? What are we improving? What good came out of this outrage?</p><p>I don’t know John Gibson. Chances are neither do you. Based on two tweets we know he’s pro-life and pro Black Lives Matter.</p><p>Conclusion: People are complicated and your politics do not define you.</p><p>Let video games be video games. Leave the politics to the politicians.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9267c4cb369f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Filip Miucin: There but for the Grace of God]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zackstein/filip-miucin-there-but-for-the-grace-of-god-go-i-42dd25a93f3b?source=rss-a24e086cc57f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/42dd25a93f3b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[filip-miucin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zack Stein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Sep 2021 13:07:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-07T13:24:04.851Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*oOeOQZpekoiK6KfnofVHJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken from Filip Miucin’s Twitter account.</figcaption></figure><p>He committed the worst sin that a journalist could commit: He plagiarized. He was not only fired, but ostracized as well. He was hunted by the lynch mobs of the internet. He was the butt of jokes and a focus of ridicule; a name which launched a thousand YouTube videos. He was left to rot on an island, alone and forever tainted.</p><p>What Filip Miucin did wasn’t great. In an industry already under constant scrutiny for its history of being a bit too close with the subject of its coverage, IGN didn’t need this kind of publicity. The world’s largest video game and nerd culture outlet already endures daily the slings and arrows from the malcontent. They are the definition of low-hanging fruit. IGN is an easy target, and often it just isn’t fair. But it goes with the territory, and they (mostly) take it in stride, with good humor, knowing that much of their criticism is unwarranted (or born out of jealousy). The conspiracy theories are unfounded. And they work hard to keep their ship tidy.</p><p>So when Filip Miucin, a rising YouTube star hired by IGN to cover Nintendo and its still-young Switch console, was outed for having plagiarized a healthy swath of his production for IGN, including his review for Dead Cells, it wasn’t just that he had instantly ruined his own credibility, he also took IGN with him.</p><p>Much has been written and discussed about the aftermath. I am not here to litigate that. Feel free to pause here and Google “Filip Miucin” if you are not familiar. What this is about is forgiveness.</p><p>Recently, Filip appeared on Colin Moriarty’s Sacred Symbols Plus podcast. It is, to my knowledge, the first time he has told his entire side of the story in interview form. As Filip explained at the end of the podcast, upon his exit, he signed an agreement which forbade him from discussing his time at IGN for three years. Those three years are now up, and Filip is free to talk. And so, he talked.</p><p>I, like so many others, had thoughts about what Filip did. Of course it was wrong, yet it was such an odd case of plagiarism. He plagiarized a review. I got stuck on that. <em>Why would anyone plagiarize an opinion? </em>And I felt that IGN owned a sliver of the responsibility. They hired a YouTube content creator, not a journalist. YouTube is the wild west. Anything goes. IGN holds itself to a higher standard, a journalistic standard. If you don’t believe that, then you don’t understand what journalism is. I know this to be true because I worked at IGN for a year. I, too, got fired, but not because I plagiarized. I got fired for reasons that are gossipy and sad. The man who fired me was fired several years later for his own bucket of sins. But I’m not here for any of that.</p><p>What I am here to do is to make a case for why it’s time to stop villainizing Filip. I felt he had a right to tell his story and I applaud Colin for giving him a platform. During the 90-minute conversation, Filip is contrite, lucid, finally self-aware, and brutally honest. It’s heartbreaking to listen to, and also revealing.</p><p>I don’t, for one minute, condone what Filip did. He stole someone else’s hard work and passed it off as his own. However, I understand why he did what he did, because I remember how intimidating it can be to be tossed into the machine that is IGN.</p><p>I was hired at IGN to run their news division. My job right before IGN was as news director for KFBK in Sacramento. I had never worked at a website. I was a video game enthusiast with a particular set of skills who also dreamed of working at IGN.</p><p>When I first started at IGN, in May of 2014, I had very little training. I had someone who reluctantly taught me how to work their CMS (content management system). I was shocked at how loose everything was there. They basically hired self-starters, people who could be relied on to churn out their own content without much direction. From where I stood, the two managing editors were quite hands off.</p><p>While there were a few people who were kind to me, the overwhelming sentiment, which I was told about on more than one occasion, was that people thought my hiring was a mistake.</p><p>One longtime editor had applied for my job, and instead was saddled with having to show me the ropes. Saying he was bitter about it is an understatement. Another well-known host, who is still there, made his feelings known by interacting with me as little as possible, though he did eventually tell me I should have never been hired. “It’s not your fault they put you in this position.”</p><p>How easy it would have been for some of these people to instead give me a chance and share some of their wisdom. Alas, when I was at IGN, that just wasn’t in the cards.</p><p>Let me pause here to say Filip’s story is, sadly, similar to my own. He was hired from outside the industry. He was told that someone else was in line for his job, but instead Filip was hired because he was willing to accept the low pay. Many people there felt his hire was a mistake, and he also found several of them to be dismissive.</p><p>We were also both hired by that managing editor who has since been fired, as I stated earlier. And we were both tossed into the deep end of the pool with two choices: sink or swim.</p><p>Here’s the thing, though: I was a journalist with a newspaper and radio background. And while I didn’t have an insider’s knowledge of the video game industry, I knew the rules for telling a story. In radio, I often moved from city to city. Each time you start at square one, learning the lay of the land, the players, and the stories. Each time I found my bearings quickly and make a go of it. I was successful enough to continue to climb the ladder of my industry so that I eventually became a news director. I had also worked at the network level in Washington DC. So while I was new to video game news coverage, I wasn’t <em>new</em>.</p><p>Filip, on the other hand, went from studying mass communications at college, to running his own YouTube channel, to IGN.</p><p>I think, at some point, before he was hired, someone should have found out if the guy could write a story. Yes, he had reviews on his YouTube channel, but as we now know, some of those were cribbed from other channels, too. IGN had no evidence that the guy could write, just a few videos and a desirable view count.</p><p>What’s clear now is that the person whose idea it was to hire Filip was looking for a shortcut. YouTube content creators have been cutting into the traditional side of games journalism for several years. I’m sure IGN, as well as other big sites like GameSpot, have seen numbers telling them that these YouTube (and Twitch) folks are a serious threat to their industry. So why not invite one of them to the dark side?</p><p>When Filip joined IGN in 2017, I remember thinking it was a cynical move. I wondered how it would work out, because what IGN does versus what many YouTubers do is not always the same thing. This isn’t to say there aren’t true game journalists on YouTube, because there absolutely are. There are also people who think they’re journalists, but they’re really not. They like to gossip and stoke the rage embers, but it isn’t journalism. There are also some wonderful game reviewers on YouTube, like ACG, that compete with the best IGN has to offer.</p><p>Filip told Colin that his job interview at IGN wasn’t as scrutinizing as he anticipated. They asked him some questions, like, “Can you do this job?” and he said, “Yep!” because what else was he going to say. He idolized IGN. He was Charlie with the golden ticket, about to be given access to the chocolate factory. To paraphrase a line from Ghostbusters, “<em>If someone asks you if you can do the job at IGN, you say, ‘Yes!’”</em></p><p>My interview process for IGN was a bit more thorough. I had one long phone interview with one managing editor (the one who got fired) and then another phone interview with his immediate supervisor (and childhood best friend who was also fired). I also submitted samples of my writing, links to news stories from various radio station websites, and some audio clips.</p><p>I was then brought in for an extensive interview with a gaggle of senior editors. They asked tough questions about journalism, my background, and my favorite video games. Whatever I said was enough to get the job, but not enough to instill confidence in half that room. At the very least, they knew I could write, that I could speak coherently, and that I had serious journalism chops.</p><p>Filip didn’t have half of what I had, but he made some nice-looking videos that thousands of people seemed to enjoy.</p><p>While I am in no way saying that IGN is to blame for Filip’s plagiarism, what I am saying is that they brought in a stray from the wild that shit on the rug, knocked over the trash, and eventually bit them. And while that isn’t always the case with strays, when it happens, you say, “Well, I mean, he <em>is </em>a stray…”</p><p>YouTube isn’t IGN. And IGN isn’t YouTube. Neither of them should <em>want </em>to be the other. When I see someone reporting on a rumor on YouTube, the first thing I do is Google it. Why? Because I’m hoping IGN, or Kotaku, or even Bloomberg (Jason Schreier!) will have actual reporting on it, with sourcing.</p><p>A YouTuber doesn’t have to play by the same rules. They can say whatever they want. They are beholden to no one. Gossip is fun, but journalism is satisfying.</p><p>When Filip was brought in, on his first day he was asked to provide a review for the Switch port of Doom 2016. He was asked if he could turn it around in two days. What he said was, “Yes.” But inside, he was a ball of panic. He had no idea where to begin.</p><p>If you’re a writer, or a journalist, you know where to begin. It’s obvious. You write out your thoughts and organize them into a coherent opinion.</p><p>Filip, on the other hand, was lost because he isn’t a writer. He doesn’t have a journalism background; doesn’t have the basic analytical tools needed for the job. He’s a badass when it comes to video editing and talking about video games enthusiastically. But writing a review requires a different muscle.</p><p>Still, to his credit, he turned in a draft to the reviews editor — but not before watching other videos to get some idea of where to begin. And this is exactly when the first red flag should have been raised — not that anyone knew to look for them. Not even Filip knew he was doing something he shouldn’t have. Would Roger Ebert have read Gene Siskel’s review of a film before writing his own? Absolutely not. Good reviewers do not want to know what other reviewers are thinking. They don’t want their opinions tainted. They want to offer a pure, fresh take.</p><p>Filip wanted guidance. He needed a map. In retrospect, I feel quite sorry for him. He didn’t want to let anybody down. Yet already, on day one, he was in over his head.</p><p>The second red flag was when the reviews editor returned Filip’s first draft with lots of notes. The notes aren’t the red flag; it’s the downward spiral that Filip entered when he got those notes. You see, Filip had never been copyedited before. He didn’t know this is part of the process. What he thought was, “Oh shit, I really screwed the pooch on this one. Look at all these errors and corrections. They’re going to know I’m a fraud!”</p><p>I wrote only one video game review during my time at IGN. As the news editor, reviews weren’t really part of what I was supposed to do. After my first draft, the reviews editor sent back my copy with a ton of requested changes. I didn’t blink, because I had written professionally before and I knew this was part of the process.</p><p>I also edited all of my freelancers, many of whom thanked me for my guidance. You should always have someone look over you work. Always.</p><p>But Filip didn’t know any of this. That first copyediting experience was so traumatic that it reinforced all his worst instincts. Filip saw it as a value judgement. So rather than working to improve his own skills, he instead borrowed someone else’s. And then he did it again and again and again.</p><p>In hindsight, Filip realizes what he did was very, very wrong. It was nice to hear how clear he is about all of this now. He offers sincere apologies without any qualifications. He is not making excuses. Being ignorant of the law is not a defense from the law, and the same is true for journalism. Not understanding why plagiarism is a big deal is not a defense of it.</p><p>I worry that we are not learning the correct lessons from Filip’s cautionary tale, however.</p><p>Yes, rage is addicting and, for many people, quite fun. Twitter seems like its entire <em>raison d’etre</em> is to cause outrage. And boy, do we love having a villain. Filip fit that bill for many people, not just on the internet, but at IGN as well.</p><p>I get why his IGN coworkers were pissed. He dragged them all into the mud with him. That sucks. But for the rest of the internet, other than the people from whom he stole, why are they still holding a grudge?</p><p>We are losing our ability to empathize at an alarming rate. We are so quick to judge, yet rarely do we ever try to empathize or understand. There seems to be no appetite for it. There is a ruthlessness and callousness that underlines nearly all of our virtual interactions.</p><p>To be fair, shortly after his firing from IGN, Filip came across as a sociopath. His first public apologies were so thin, so cynical, so disingenuous. It was hard to feel sorry for him. But now, three years later, after listening to Filip tell his whole story to Colin, I only wish him peace.</p><p>Filip did something really stupid, and he paid a hefty price. But since then he’s put in the work. He sought therapy and untangled some knots. He discovered a delicate, scared person who had a difficult childhood. He has battled addiction to alcohol. He learned that he suffered from impostor syndrome. By the time he got to IGN, he wasn’t at all ready for the big time. He was fragile and naïve. He didn’t have the tools to be out in the real world.</p><p>Filip isn’t blaming IGN. And I hope that maybe, someday, some of the people there will find a way to forgive Filip for what he did. It would be healing for all sides.</p><p>One last thought:</p><p>Think about the worst thing you have ever done — the time in your life when you were in a lot of trouble, whether at work or in your personal life. Remember the panic. Remember the sense of impending doom. Remember that sinking feeling in your stomach; that thought that your world was going to end.</p><p>Now imagine if that situation played out in front of the internet and all of social media. Imagine that you going through this personal hell, but instead everyone knows about it. There are Reddit threads dedicated to your fuck-up. YouTubers are getting tens of thousands of views discussing your faux pas.</p><p>You’re trending.</p><p>You’re a hashtag.</p><p>You’re a joke.</p><p>I don’t know how anyone could survive that exposure, the rawness and the humiliation. Filip certainly didn’t help his cause by making righteous half-assed excuse videos. But how well would you function under the weight of all that pressure? Do you always say and do the right thing when the chips are down?</p><p>I’m talking about perspective. I’m talking about true reflection.</p><p>I’m talking about empathy.</p><p>Filip Miucin made a mistake. He should have known better, but he didn’t. During his conversation with Colin, Filip answered very tough questions with honesty and candor. He never once shifted the blame. He owned it. He’s looking to move on, with full knowledge that his misdeeds will follow him for the rest of his life.</p><p>Shouldn’t that be enough? Isn’t it time to let this one go?</p><p>I’ve had some very difficult situations in my own personal life. At the time they were hell, but I came out the other side a better person. I just thank God that I didn’t have the rest of the world piling on while I went through them.</p><p>I look at Filip and I think, “There but for the grace of God go I…”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=42dd25a93f3b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Defense of Dunkey: Why His Critique of Game Critics Is Valid]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zackstein/in-defense-of-dunkey-why-his-critique-of-game-critics-is-valid-833aa0ad1af4?source=rss-a24e086cc57f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/833aa0ad1af4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[opinion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zack Stein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Jul 2017 18:55:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-07T12:59:27.088Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*UR7wzrisL_iuxC_wvttRZA.png" /><figcaption>From Dunkey’s Twitter profile.</figcaption></figure><p>Roger Ebert is sorely missed. Widely considered to be one of the best and most popular movie reviewers in cinema history, Ebert cultivated a large and loyal following due to his populist approach to critiquing. Ebert was the every-man who could equally enjoy a summer blockbuster and a French New Wave film. He understood the art of film, but also embraced its commercial side. All he cared about was whether he enjoyed the movie he was watching.</p><p>One grew to understand Ebert during his four-decade career. He exposed much of himself through his writing, whether it be a column in a newspaper or one of the many books he published. It was clear that this was simply his opinion, and so when he didn’t like Die Hard as much as you did, you had an entire body of work to look back on and see the many other times your tastes did align with his.</p><p>Video games don’t have a Roger Ebert. Not yet, anyway. We have plenty of websites and YouTube personalities reviewing our games. To be fair, game critiquing is relatively young compared to movies. The entire gaming industry continues to grow and evolve, from publishing games to the press, taking major leaps every few years. There’s still a war of ideas and best practices; the horrific GamerGate debacle a few years back exposed how far it still has to go.</p><p>However, there is an palpable tension and a lack of respect between the gaming press and its audience. Neither side is truly trying to understand what the other is saying when it comes to reviews; instead it plays out in a flurry of tweets and sucker punches in the comment sections. Mixed in with legitimate takes on inconsistency and lack of clear vision are misogynistic comments and harassment of nuclear proportions. And so there’s little hope or opportunity for advancing the conversation.</p><p>And this is where Dunkey enters the fray, producing a video about game critics that cuts through the noise like a hot knife through butter. It’s eight minutes and fifty-three seconds of pure vitriol. And while I don’t agree with some of his phrasing (I don’t think all critics “fucking suck”), the underlying message is completely valid.</p><p>The game press is having none of it.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FlG2dXobAXLI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DlG2dXobAXLI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FlG2dXobAXLI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b880ad974ac41b2d6943f552121c7e26/href">https://medium.com/media/b880ad974ac41b2d6943f552121c7e26/href</a></iframe><p>They reacted, predictably, by circling the wagons with subtweets and hot takes, dismissing Dunkey as misguided and comparing this video to hot garbage. The overwhelming response from the game press industry: <em>We’re right and he just doesn’t get it. Anyone who agrees with him is wrong.</em></p><p>(Interesting how several of this video’s detractors admitted that they “liked Dunkey…until now.”)</p><p>Dunkey’s ultimate point is that large outlets like IGN and GameSpot have far too many writers reviewing games, so much so that it’s nearly impossible for an audience to grasp the site’s identity when it comes to reviews. There’s no consistency, nothing for an audience to invest in, no clear voice to identify with.</p><p>The New York Times has Janet Maslin. Rolling Stone has Peter Travers — large publications that devote one voice, sometimes <em>maybe </em>two or three at the most, to review films. Most daily and weekly newspapers, and magazines have one critic with which its readership develops a relationship over time. Roger Ebert was with the Chicago Sun Times. Gene Siskel, his partner on At the Movies, was with the Chicago Tribune. Big publications, one voice.</p><p>Large video game sites don’t have this. And, yes, I understand why. During the holiday season, publishers release a dozen or more games within a very short time-frame. Over the past few years, the spring has become nearly as crowded as the fall. It would be impossible for one person to review all those games. However, movies are released year round as well, with busy seasons in the summer and fall. Of course, a movie is two hours on average, where games can vary from five to 50 hours or more. It’s simply not realistic to think one critic can cover a year’s worth of video game releases. But that shouldn’t be the end of the discussion.</p><p>Let’s put a pin in that and take a moment to remember that the point of a review is to inform, to provide the audience with something of value. The audience wants to know whether they should see that movie, play that game, buy that phone — whatever. A review should provide a service. And a review only holds value when the voice is one of authority. A reviewer should be some kind of expert in his or her field. A reviewer should earn our trust and cultivate a relationship with their audience. Over time, a reader learns the personality and quirks of that reviewer so context can be applied to their opinion. There absolutely needs to be consistency in order for the review to have weight and hold value.</p><p>Which brings us back to Dunkey’s point. When IGN uses more than 30 writers for reviews so far in 2017, in whom are we investing? Thirty writers are bound to have widely varying tastes and experiences. It makes for a slippery relationship with its audience and it weakens IGN’s authority.</p><p>When one reviewer lauds praise for a game, and a day later on a podcast a bunch of folks trash it — or vice versa — it leaves an audience reeling. We read reviews so we can be better informed about our purchases.</p><p>Let’s say a reviewer gives a game an 8.5. A reader sees that and decides to place an order on Amazon (or purchase it through an online store and download it), then the next day they hear four other editors trash it on a podcast — that’s really confusing. IGN just told them it’s a good game, but now these editors say it isn’t. The reader is back at zero with their relationship with IGN. They have no idea what an IGN score means anymore.</p><p>That is Dunkey’s point.</p><p>Of course not everyone at a publication will agree on everything, but there needs to be a general consensus if that publication’s name is on that score. There needs to be some sort of through-line for the audience to follow. Tossing in random freelancers with associate editors and executive editors into some sort of critical bouillabaisse is a recipe for distrust and animosity.</p><p>To see the blowback on Twitter and hear the vitriol on programs like Waypoint Radio only makes one more suspicious. It’s as if the game press is willfully misunderstanding Dunkey’s point. In fact, it’s telling in a way. The harder the audience pushes for clarity, the harder the publications’ editors push back with a message of “you’re wrong!” How is that a winning strategy?</p><p>This is exactly the reason why social media personalities on Twitch and YouTube are raking in the subscribers (and cash) while the established website-based game press is scrambling to adapt. With someone like Dunkey or another YouTube reviewer like ACG, you know where they stand. You learn what they like and what they don’t. A relationship is established and a bond is formed; trust is earned. If you don’t agree with their review, you know why.</p><p>Pauline Kael, the legendary film critic, had an incredibly devout following long before the internet was a twinkle in Al Gore’s eye. She put it all out there for her readers to see for decades. She liked some off-the-wall shit, and trashed some very popular stuff. But either way, it was Kael being Kael. The same went for Roger Ebert, as it now goes for someone like Wesley Morris.</p><p>If video game coverage is to mature editorially, it will need strong voices to survive. Running out dozens of critics for one publication only dilutes its authority and weakens its voice. Whether or not the game score goes away has nothing to do with it. Are too many games being reviewed? Can we limit the amount of editors reviewing so that there is one main reviewer, with only a few select editors chipping in? Just because someone <em>can </em>review a game doesn’t mean that they should. We all have opinions, but some opinions <em>should</em> matter more than others. To reiterate: A review is a transaction of trust. I’m trusting you to tell me whether I should buy this game.</p><p>I know reviewers go crazy when they see someone in the comments or on Twitter say “They gave X game a 9.2 and then gave Y game a 7.9! WTF?” Often this is an apples to oranges comparison. You can’t compare the latest Call of Duty to a game like Inside, the same way you can’t compare a film like Guardians of the Galaxy to Lion (another 2014 movie, if you’re wondering). But the underlying message (sometimes, and sometimes not) those folks are trying to make is they’re not seeing consistency. They can’t get a handle on that site’s voice.</p><p>Dunkey has a point. Whether you agree with it doesn’t matter. The audience will continue to search for stability and consistency, the voice who speaks to them. The numbers already reflect this. Laughing off and subtweeting away a valid critique of critics might make you feel better in the moment, but it looks crass to your audience. And it doesn’t earn their trust.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=833aa0ad1af4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Dark Tower Series Review: The Road to Nowhere]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zackstein/the-dark-tower-series-the-road-to-nowhere-7137cf5fa2cc?source=rss-a24e086cc57f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7137cf5fa2cc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stephen-king]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-dark-tower]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zack Stein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Oct 2016 06:48:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-04T17:02:08.498Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lku4QrzHndV4awmpJMqv4A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>Spoilers lie ahead; you have been warned.</em></strong></p><p>Stephen King and I have had a long, tumultuous relationship, going back nearly four decades. I’ve loved him, loathed him, evangelized his brilliance and cursed his name in vain. And still, there is no other author who has sung so completely to my soul, vibrated within my being and resonated so perfectly with my imagination as sai King. All of this is why I feel so utterly abused by his Dark Tower series.</p><p>The first Stephen King book I read from cover-to-cover was The Shining. I was far too young, merely 10-years-old, to be reading such material. Much of it went over my head, while other parts kept me up at night — if only because part of me somehow recognized the dark spaces he was writing about, even if my human mind could not yet grasp all of its horrific concepts. I was hooked. By the time I was 16 I had read everything up through IT, which I eventually wrote about for my senior English thesis two years later. I got an “A”.</p><p>The Gunslinger was purchased for me by my mother for a teen-age birthday, which one in particular I do not recall. It was a lovely edition, a tall paperback with luscious illustrations. I tried to read it, but instead tossed it aside with a shudder after 30-or-some odd pages. Like The Eye of the Dragon, I dismissed it as one of King’s fever dreams. It might as well have been written in cyrillic; I couldn’t penetrate its narrative. We all have bad days; King is allowed to have a bad book. I would not revisit this novel for another 30 years.</p><p>Throughout the years I kept up with King’s work. I read all of it, skipping The Dark Tower novels as they were released at odd and sputtering intervals. I saw the high praise they received from its smaller but fervent fanbase. Yet some door in my mind was closed to its possibility. I do not like reading fantasy. I never have.</p><p>I enjoy my fiction grounded in reality. Not in a Dean Koontz Scooby Doo “It was Old Man Withers all along!” sort of way. I never cared for Koontz. He always felt like a cheat. He would tempt you with metaphysics and magic, only to make a sharp 90-degree turn at the end and explain it away with some sort of pseudo-science — like the worst kind of magician, the one where you can see the wires.</p><p>King? He <em>goes </em>there. And he goes all the way, baby. He plays in the arena of gods <em>and </em>monsters. He bends reality to his will, shuffling dimensions like a deck of cards. David Blaine might have a trick quarter he’s folding before your eyes. King <em>actually</em> bends the quarter, melts it in his palm and licks his hands clean, the silver metal shining on his teeth and tongue.</p><p>I’ve always admired King for going to the ends of sanity and back, and I’ve thanked him for taking me with him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*lUQqEANbHWQOTLdoU-TQvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Why do so many people love Stephen King so passionately? It’s because of his characters, not just his monsters. He paints pictures of a world which we recognize, and then he slices it wide open and lets loose the Cthulhu. He finds the most minute details and sprinkles them on his reality salad, like parmesan cheese. He listens to our music, watches our sports, reads our newspapers and magazines. He loves our television and movies. He is one of us — only, with a titanic-sized imagination and a 700-horsepower writing motor. It only makes sense that he would write himself into The Dark Tower series. Who else would have the cajones and the dexterity to do so? And to whom else would we give such license.</p><p>But I’m getting ahead of myself.</p><p>Why did I finally submit and read The Dark Tower series? I’m glad you asked. The simplest answer is “boredom”.</p><p>I spent 13 months unemployed; I had some free time. After reading the last few King books which eluded me during my professional career, I decided to consult a ranked list of “the best books by Stephen King.” I saw some interesting things written about The Dark Tower series, and. . .well, I was bored; I was caught up on my King. So back to The Gunslinger I went.</p><p>It was an easy read, finished within a day. I enjoyed it. It piqued my curiosity. It wasn’t the fantasy dreck I had dismissed it as decades earlier, but I couldn’t see how six more volumes could be milked out of this dry, dusty cow.</p><p>I next picked up The Drawing of the Three. It took its time at first — and then it had me, like one of the lobstrosities on the beach. Wow that book gets going and never lets up. I was dizzy and breathless. I felt like I just found a $20 bill in my pants pocket on laundry day — a fortunate discovery. <em>And there were five more of these suckers?</em> Why had I been so stubborn, so turned off to the thought of being one of <em>those </em>King fans? I couldn’t even remember anymore.</p><p>And then I discovered that the series got even better. I read The Waste Lands. Holy shit, that is an amazing book all on its own, one of the finest novels to ever come forth from King’s imagination, regardless of it being a Dark Tower volume. It’s fascinating, terrifying, heartbreaking, salty, with a hint of sweet. It ends breathlessly on a cliffhanger. I couldn’t imagine how the readers felt in 1993, when it was first released. I would have lost my mind waiting for the next one. But this was 2015 and Wizard and Glass was sitting right beside me. I shed a tear of joy. I had this amazing, richly woven tapestry of worlds and adventure unfolding before my feeble brain. I was rediscovering my favorite author. There was another level to my worship I never knew possible. King was truly the gift that kept on giving.</p><p>After Wizard and Glass I was a bit burned out. I needed a palate-cleanser. I started reading Jack Reacher novels because King said I should (this is true, he’s a huge fan). I enjoyed the diversion and change of pace. They’re a fun read, and highly recommended. They’re disposable, light and airy. They’ll never be confused for great literature, but not all books need to be. There’s a place for fun. Jack Reacher books are fun.</p><p>Anyway, after some time away from The Dark Tower’s multiverse, the glamour wore off. It’s not that I had changed my opinion. I hadn’t; but there was mounting trepidation all the same.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/545/1*Wn4qYQKqKxW1Z6JvSd6_SQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I had read some reviews of the last three books, all written after King suffered a nightmarish accident in 1999. They weren’t of the same quality as the initial four, according to many fans and reviewers alike. The general consensus was that King must have felt some sort of obligation to finish his magnum opus. Fans were mortified by the thought that King might have gone to his grave without finishing The Dark Tower saga. Who cares that King could have died? Like Annie Wilkes in Misery, fans were demanding a resolution to Roland’s quest for the Dark Tower!</p><p>I know now that King felt such a pressure; he’s admitted as much in several interviews as well as in his own writing. And so, after recovering from a near-fatal accident in which he was laid-up for nearly a year, he went back to Mid-World and quickly knocked out volumes five, six and seven.</p><p>Unfortunately, the desperation is there on the page for all the world to see.</p><p>I do believe that King had an idea of how his tale would end, which stories were left to tell, but the roadmap was fuzzy and vague. It’s a writer at work who is known for his long-winded prose and tendency to ramble indulging in his weaknesses. He’s needed a good editor for decades, but his success somehow injured the eye which allows one to see their writing through a neutral filter. King’s literary vomit can occasionally be endearing, but it often exhausts one’s patience.</p><p>And so, with an urgency born from facing his own mortality, King wrote Wolves of the Calla, Song of Susannah, and The Dark Tower. Nothing good ever comes from fear. These books reek of it. They feel like someone begrudgingly paying a debt. “Here’s your goddamn Dark Tower! Now leave me alone!”</p><p>Which is a shame, really, because the world King created is so exotically lovely, like the rose that grows in an empty lot in New York City, singing its heartsong that cures acne and calms the insane.</p><p>I was patent with Wolves of the Calla because I knew it was part of the journey, and I was enjoying my companions’ company. Yes, it largely feels like King paying homage to The Magnificent Seven, but there are important developments as well. We meet Pere Callahan, and learn what happened post Salems’ Lot. And it’s when King first writes himself into his own masterpiece — the volume of work for which he’ll be remembered beyond all others. And he handles the reveal beautifully.</p><p>I tried to ignore the lightsabers and golden snitches. They seemed at odds with all that came before, but I dismissed them as a quirk, a flight of fancy from a writer whose only rule now was, “There are no rules.” Little did I suspect that, later, the homage would become a crutch.</p><p>No, when Wolves of the Calla ended, I wasn’t disappointed. Sure, it wasn’t on par with the previous four books, but I saw it as a bridge, its own sort of palate-cleanser for this oddessy. Wolves gives way to Song of Susannah, which is really one long chase scene. Again, I wasn’t hard on this work. It kept me interested and I knew we were building up to the grand finale. After all, The Dark Tower — the final volume — is more than 800 pages long. We would finally reach our destination, air our grievances, and get the tasty dessert we worked so hard for after eating all those greens and meats. We earned it.</p><p>And so, like Roland standing before the Dark Tower, I had finally arrived. I savored the moment before cracking open the final volume. When it was all over, I wept — not tears of joy, but of sorrow.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/1*BKEnR1UKPzhWQtrHJcZAAw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I wondered at what point did this master author, master craftsman, far and away the greatest of his generation — a man who wrote such tomes as the 1138-paged IT, the equally as long The Stand, Insomnia and 11/22/63 — this author who has never shied away from the epic novel, begin to buckle and crumble under the weight of The Dark Tower? Did the accident do far more damage than he would have us believe?</p><p>The final novel is so oddly paced, spending far too much time in its first half with characters who play small roles and then disappear. Hundreds of pages are spent on parts that could have easily been digested into much smaller, yet still substantial episodes. The back half is a confused, boggling concoction of interludes that feel as lost and wandering as Roland and his ka tet. The author who is famous for long, rambling passages describing the most trivial of details is suddenly painting in broad strokes, dismissing key antagonists and fascinating creatures within mere paragraphs.</p><p>And when we get to the Dark Tower itself, it’s all resolved within a few short chapters. The grand villain who has haunted us for thousands of pages is defeated in a most trivial manner, after tossing golden snitches at Roland.</p><p>Really? In the climactic battle of a seven-volume epic story you bite off a piece of JK Rowling and spit it into your stew? Could you think of nothing else, sai King? No other way for your main protagonist and main antagonist to play out their final conflict? In the end, Harry Potter was all you had?</p><p>And then the story ends. That’s it. Thanks for coming. Make sure to turn out the lights when you leave.</p><p>Who was The Crimson King? We never really find out beyond the vague passages and throw-away teasers that promise more to come, but fail to deliver. We learned so much more about some of King’s most infamous creatures, like Pennywise in the novel IT, or even Randall Flagg in The Stand and The Dark Tower, than we ever do about The Crimson King. We had a more satisfying encounter with this demon in Insomnia than we did in all of The Dark Tower series.</p><p>Roland’s only true interaction with The Crimson King is a shouting match near the end, and then it’s over. Who was he? Where did he come from? Why do so many fear him? What was his motivation? How did Randall Flagg come to be in his employ?</p><p>We’ll never know.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*Pn01RxZXdgEo2nIrccBKLg.jpeg" /></figure><p>And it’s with this empty feeling that I closed The Dark Tower and stared off into space, feeling cheated and sad. I wasn’t disappointed in Roland’s grand revelation, that his journey is one he had made before and will make again. That, actually, is quite brilliant, and at one point in King’s life he might have handled it far more gracefully. Here, it was juggled, fumbled, and fell to the floor like a stray egg, cracking and spilling its goo on the linoleum.</p><p><em>Here’s your ending. Thank you. Goodbye.</em></p><p>And to add insult to injury, in the afterward, King acknowledges that we, the constant reader, might not be happy with the ending. But none of it was about the ending; it was about the journey, he writes glibly. To me, that feels like a cop-out. He knows it isn’t the resolution that this saga deserved, but he didn’t quite know how to untangle the knot — so he simply cut the ball of string into shreds and tossed the odds and ends back at us.</p><p>I could have lived with Wolves of the Calla and Song of Susannah had The Dark Tower concluded in some sort satisfactory manner. But in the light that the final novel sheds on its previous two installments, I have to say they look worse for wear. It’s with this hindsight that I see them for what they truly are — a means to an end. The glamour has worn off. They are not brilliant bodies of work, they are baskets of snakes and rotted meat, much like what Roland and Susannah find on the bridge at The Crimson King’s castle.</p><p>I love Stephen King. I always have. I always will. He’s written far too much and influenced me and generations of readers and writers. He’s given us so much joy and fulfillment over the years. He’s a brilliant man, kind and generous. He has style to spare and an imagination as warm and bright as our own sun.</p><p>And yet, his Dark Tower series, to me, will always be a stain on that legacy. Someone once told me that potential is a cruel word. The Dark Tower is the definition of that word. Its foundation is flawless, drawn from lovable, memorable characters, with, literally, its own language and physics. There is potential there for a classic epic high-fantasy that could sit confidently upon a shelf alongside other literary classics. But the master fumbled the ball as he neared the end zone. The last three books are the work of a tired, older man who tried to take on a younger man’s load and found it too heavy.</p><p>Many will disagree with me vehemently. I’m sure I’m in the minority with my opinion. After all, the sales and fan-base speak for itself. There are movies and television series on the horizon. There are comic books, graphic novels — an entire cottage industry based upon The Dark Tower series.</p><p>But I suspect we’re all celebrating the former glory, the first four volumes which came from a pre-near-fatal accident mind, not a post, fearful one. We’re not being honest with King by calling The Dark Tower series King’s lasting legacy. But maybe he’s earned that blindspot from us. And to that I have two things to say, and then I shall say no more.</p><p>You say true. I say thankya.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7137cf5fa2cc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>