<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by zenny RD on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by zenny RD on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 21:44:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Baiq Nuril and The Multi-sided Law that Gone Too Far]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/baiq-nuril-and-the-multi-sided-law-that-gone-too-far-b6ff449e1df7?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6ff449e1df7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[injustice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[womens-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-harrassment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jul 2019 02:30:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-24T02:30:52.357Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*_YOqUurFi5NaKlfLg06V1A@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>On July 15, 2019 news and media reported that President Joko Widodo granted Amnesty for Baiq Nuril. This was hopefully the last chapter of a long controversial case of Baiq Nuril.</p><p>Baiq Nuril, a wife, a mother and a high school administrative staff in Mataram, West Nusa Tenggara, was a victim of sexual harassment back in around 2017. The sexual harassment was conducted verbally by the Principal of the high school through a sexually engaged conversation he initiated. This conduct had put Baiq Nuril into psychological pressure that she decided to record the conversation. Without any intention to report the evidence to law enforcers, she handed the recordings to her colleague, who delivered the evidence to Mataram Office of Youth and Sport (Dinas Pemuda dan Olah Raga Mataram). From here the story went far.</p><p>Instead of being protected as a victim, Baiq Nuril was prosecuted under the Law of Electronic Transaction Number 1/2016 Article 27 Section 1 regarding distribution and accessibility of electronic documents containing any decency-breaking contents. This accusation had been wrong since the beginning. (1) Baiq Nuril was not the one who made the evidence accessible for public. (2) The circumstances where her action was under, strongly showed the situation of sexual harassment towards her, in which naturally it supposed to be taken as evidence to drag the school Principal to jeopardy. (3) No advantages in any form that she would gain by her action but to make evidence of a crime where she was a victim. Therefore, the accusation should had not been made whatsoever.</p><p>But the hard part of the law was, article 27 section 1 ITE Law was a formal delict which emphasize on the action and not the unlawful effect. The law was too elastic it opened opportunity to multi interpretations. The law was also opened huge gate towards criminalization. Everyone knew Ariel ‘Peterpan’, few years before, was arrested under same law where he was more the victim than the doer of the distribution of porn videos starring him. Same went to Baiq Nuril who was criminalized as a victim.</p><p>The District Court of Mataram stated that she was proven not guilty (vrijspraak). This was a good news until the prosecutor appealed for cassation. Talking about permission to go on cassation towards vrijspraak rooted to the Constitutional Court decision number 114/PUU-X/2012 that amending article 244 of Indonesia Criminal Procedural Code, stating that cassation was prohibited towards vrijspraak. The decision amended the provision into allowing cassation for vrijspraak.</p><p>Given this legal basis, the cassation against Baiq Nuril was accepted by the Supreme Court and she was sentenced for 6 months behind bars and 500 millions rupiah subsidiary to a confinement. (1) The idea to permit cassation for a vrijspraak decision was not in accordance to fundamental rights protection for individuals. Vrijspraak means the prosecutor, representing the State, had failed to prove their accusation. Such failure then should not be given second attempt when it came to the protection of statesperson’s right of freedom. (2) The Supreme Court power was in the scope of judex juris in which it was only examining the accuracy of the law implemented. This did not include reexamination of the case (judex factie) itself.</p><p>The ITE Law on one hand, it provided legal basis towards certain unlawful behavior conducted online and/or electronically. On the other hand, it was a right tool to freely criminalize a person(s). It was a double-edge sword that was used to criminalize a should-be-protected victim and to set free a-should-be-investigated person. Numbers of cases had arised, e.g., Prita Mulyasari, Ariel Peterpan, and Baiq Nuril. Each person was severing loss due to unfortunate circumstances arose yet they were being the suspect.</p><p>The society reacted for Baiq Nuril. The tag ‘Justice for Baiq Nuril’ was all over media. She appealed for Peninjauan Kembali (Review) as the last resort she might use to fight for her justice. But this attempt was rejected by the Supreme Court. President Joko Widodo, reached out and used his prerogative rights as a President and granted Amnesty. It was still a set of procedure until the Amnesty would effectively set Baiq Nuril free. But it was a positive approach to restore the injustice caused by the implementation of the law.</p><p>Indonesian law was a rigid-positivistic set of regulation. A pursue towards legal certainty had drawn away fairness. That was also applied vice-versa, that pursuing fairness had drawn away legal certainty. Especially in the context of criminal law, Indonesian criminal law was very positivistic in which it relied upon the principle of legalistic. Baiq Nuril action, objectively, fulfilling the provision of article 27 section 1 ITE Law, but that was not absolute that she was culpable. Ideally, the consideration must include: the evaluation of the quality of ITE Law; the whole context of the circumstances she was caught up; the consequences of any action in examining her situation; and the basic rights of a woman who suffered sexual harassment. But Indonesian criminal law enforcement was far from the education of those points. Instead, the emphasis was still as narrow as systematically threading provisions in the regulations possible to put someone undeserving behind bars. Interpretation methods was very limited that gave consequence when someone, who, as long as, fulfilling the provision accused, he or she was very likely to be punished. Baiq Nuril case was showing the face of the Indonesian criminal injustice system, where someone seek for protection and be beaten up instead. All behind justification of the law. It showed a systematic trouble started from the law making, the education of law enforcers, and the capability of settlement.</p><p>It was a great challenge for the Indonesia criminal justice system to change perspective from legalistic to fairness minded and restorative instead of punitive. Spotlight was on all law faculties and any legal education institutions to teach law in a non-legalistic way. Baiq Nuril’s case had gone too far and it deserved happy ending.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6ff449e1df7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chemical Castration in Indonesian Penal System: from Technical Issues to Children’s Rights.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/chemical-castration-in-indonesian-penal-system-from-technical-issues-to-childrens-rights-34e17aa2efdb?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/34e17aa2efdb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chemical-castration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crime-sexual]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[punishment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Nov 2018 02:36:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-03T02:37:34.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>President Joko Widodo established Peraturan Pemerintah Pengganti Undang-Undang (Perppu) in 2016 to become a legal basis to add chemical castration as a criminal punishment for sexual predators. Perppu Number 1 Year 2016 entitled Perubahan Kedua atas Undang-Undang Nomor 23 Tahun 2002 tentang Perlindungan Anak gave addendums about chemical carstration as alternative punishment as stated in Article 81 (7) and Article 81A (1)(2)(3)(4). This Perppu has been transformed as Undang-Undang through Undang-Undang Number 17 Year 2016.</p><p>This concept of chemical castration as an alternative punishment for sexual predators is not without controversy. The main issue that has risen is related to the nature of chemical carstration as a mode of punishment is seen as cruel and torturing. In relation to that, it is violating human rights as set in ICCPR and CAT. On the opposite opinion, chemical carstration is seen as an adequate reaction from The President towards an exploding number of sexual harrassment cases against children in Indonesia. This new method is hopefully will help eradicate cases of sexual harrassment against children</p><p>Chemical castration is a type of hormone therapy that takes away the offender’s sexual desire. The very purpose of chemical castration is to exert control over the mind of the offender by drastically reducing the brain’s exposure to testosterone. (Stinneford, 2006). In Indonesia, the procedure is done by an injection, which is a clinical process performed only by medical workers and doctors. This has a consequence; doctors are spotted to be the executor. Ikatan Dokter Indonesia (IDI) made a statement that they refuse to be the executor for chemical castration punishment. IDI respected the decision of chemical castration as punishment method, but declined the possibility that doctors were going to be the executor.</p><p>dr. Wimpie Pangkahila, an andrologist, gave a statement in a seminar held by law faculty of one of private universities in Jakarta (08/2018) discussing about chemical castration from constitutional perspective. His statement was that IDI generally declined to implement chemical castration, with logical reasons. First, doctors are supposed to cure people, not making people sick or have lower life quality, not excluding criminals. Second, that is mainly against doctor’s ethical code. Third, simply that any medical actions should be conducted under the patient’s or their family’s consent.</p><p>But, dr. Wimpie also emphasize that doctors are in a difficult situation between their obligation to follow ethical code and their obligation as a good citizen that must obey law’s command. The government is currently working on the government regulation to follow up the chemical castration law. If it is decided so, the appointed doctor shall obliged with the court decision and shall do the chemical castration injection if stated in the verdict. Other option is to appoint the medical worker that is trained to do the injection and doctor acts as supervisor. Regarding this aspect, the government should do studies on lethal injection as a death execution method in other countries, as a comparison.</p><p>The government should also brainstorm on the budget issue related to the implementation. The law also regulates chip implant as detector, together with chemical castration. This needs budget. Although, dr. Wimpie stated that it is not too expensive, but it still need budget.</p><p>The effectiveness of the implementation of chemical castration is also another issue. The injection needed for an effective castration is 3 (three) times injections once a month, should already show effects. More than 3 (three) times, likely the effects begin to be more permanent. This condition can be restored just by having a testosterone injection treatment. This has meaning that the criminal shall receive the punishment for several months but he can always be cured again sometimes after. There also needs other studies to correlate chemical castration with the decreasing number of child sexual abuse cases. Very few child molesters admitted that they have incapability to control their high libido so they willingly proposed to have chemical castration. But the significance of the number of this type of child molester and other majority type as seen in many cases should be highly considered before adding chemical castration as punishment method within the legal system.</p><p>Deterrent effect is other aspect to evaluate. The implementation of chemical castration has never taken place since its establishment in 2016. The government regulation as the follow up of the law is also still under construction. Some articles showed that chemical castration is cruel and barbaric, that the purpose of this method of punishment is as retaliation only. That is, perhaps, the background of the Perppu Number 1 Year 2016. Around that time, several child sexual abuses came up on the news. Most of the cases ended with the death of a victim. Yuyun case, Angeline case, JIS case, are few of highly reported children sexual abuses. Yuyun, a teenager from Bengkulu, Indonesia, was brutally raped by 14 men. Not only being raped, she was also tortured and killed. Yuyun’s body was dumped into a chasm. In some other cases, boys were sodomized by school staffs, and teachers.</p><p>This has become an emergency for Indonesia. It is understood that the government should take action to maintain the social situation, for that the society itself, generally, was devastated. The President, using his constitutional rights, established a harsher type of punishment for child molester through Perppu. This Perppu was then being debated, but some of Jokowi’s other Perppu were also debated, but that is the whole different discussion. The Perppu of chemical castration was debated as violating constitutional law. The requirement of Perpuu establishment is an emergency situation. Indonesian Constitutional Court interpreted the element of emergency as:</p><ul><li>An urgent event,</li><li>- and there is an absence of law, or inadequate law regarding the urgent event,</li><li>- and the normal legislative process takes longer time.</li></ul><p>In the end, The President has a full authority to determine what is urgent and this is on his own subjectivity. The high rates of child sexual crime number, perhaps, pass the criteria of what emergency situation is. Maruarar Siahaan, a former Constitutional Court Judge, at the same seminar stated that, at least, despite the controversy, the establishment of chemical castration has shown the concern of the government towards children sexual assault crisis in Indonesia. It is now the homework of how to make it implementable and effective.</p><p>Related to chemical castration, it is the rights of the criminals. Chemical castration, as stated above, can be seen as cruel and torturous method of punishment. The effect of chemical castration will degrade the quality of life of the person. Testosterone is an important hormone for body vitality, not only for men but also for women. Low testosterone level will affect the health. Decaying skin, teeth and bones, hair, and bad metabolism are only a few of the consequences.</p><p>The definition of torture according to Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CAT) is,</p><ul><li>(1) the term “torture” means any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession, punishing him for an act he or a third person has committed or is suspected of having committed, or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind, when such pain or suffering is inflicted by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official capacity. It does not include pain or suffering arising only from, inherent in or incidental to lawful sanctions.</li><li>(2) This article is without prejudice to any international instrument or national legislation which does or may contain provisions of wider application.</li></ul><p>Referring to the definition of torture in CAT, chemical castration as in Children Protection Law is not fit perfectly to the CAT’s shape of torture. Part (2) of article 1 CAT emphasizes that the term torture here is without prejudice to national legislation that has wider application. The concept of chemical castration as a punishment in Indonesian penal system is as supplement sanction, to be dropped together with the main sanction. The method is written in a law that makes it a lawful sanction. The decision to put chemical castrations as provided penal method is also according to many background and purpose based on the social circumstances (wider application).</p><p>International Convention of Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) stated that,</p><p>Article 7</p><p>No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. In particular, no one shall be subjected without his free consent to medical or scientific experimentation.</p><p>This article, however, systematically interpreted to article 1 (1)(2) of CAT, resulting to the similar concept of torture. Compared with death penalty, Indonesia ratified ICCPR that prohibits death penalty. However, if the national legislation still allows death penalty, then it is a lawful sanction. Chemical castration is a lawful sanction too.</p><p>Arist Merdeka Sirait, chief of Indonesian Child Protection Commission, at the previous mentioned seminar, stated that chemical castration is not violating human rights. The existence of this method of punishment is in the corridor of children rights protection. The evidences of child sexual abuse cases were cruel and brutal. It has triggered the concern on how children, the more vulnerable form of human being, need a better rights protection. Children sexual abuse has now mentioned as extraordinary crime in national sense.</p><p>The problem with chemical castration is in its affectivity. First, this sanction is supplementary and optional. Second, the law has no government regulation (PP) yet to make it implementable. Third, uncertainty on the process related to the uncertainty appointment of executors. Forth, chemical castration does not guarantee the man not to repeat the crime. Fifth, chemical castration has extended regulation, it is a rehabilitation mechanism. These factors cause chemical castration to be weak in implementation.</p><p>Chemical castration was provided as an optional punishment method through Children Protection Law to enhance the protection of children’s rights. This breakthrough needs to be more studied and carefully formulated to ensure the affectivity and effectiveness in social realm. Chemical castration is not a new concept. Other countries such as The USA (in some States, e.g., Florida, Louisiana, and California), Australia, Argentina, Denmark, Estonia, Israel, Moldova already legalized castration forcibly or offered to reduce the jail time. In Indonesia, cthe formulation of chemical castration feels like a soft option. The government must put teeth on it. Otherwise it is going to be cold words inside law book.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=34e17aa2efdb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Effect of Elon Musk’s Neuralink to The Life of Human Beings]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/the-effect-of-elon-musks-neuralink-to-the-life-of-human-beings-420b87d4323f?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/420b87d4323f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elon-musk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 May 2018 07:15:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-09T07:15:08.055Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*_qM7uOssUmn6ZVbRt6DwFg.jpeg" /><figcaption>cnn.com</figcaption></figure><p>Turns out, my one fine marking-day was an inspiring one. I was strucked to, not one, but two writings (that was a requirement as a final assignment in Philosophy of Law class). If you have not read the previous writing entitled “Reincarnation”, then you should. In this page, I’d like to share another one of two writings which I feel it deserve better audience than my dull, boring, email inbox. Here is one brief opinion about the real life Iron Man and his interesting startup, written by Suherlin, a brilliant Law School President University Student who’s now living her life as an intern in one of leading law firm in Indonesia.</p><p><em>Currently, there is an issue about implanting computer chip to human brain. This issue cause a huge shock wave to everyone all around the world especially for the people who is interested in the development of world technology. Tesla CEO, Elon Musk who is also well-known as Iron Man in real life, has reportedly been working on a brain-computer interface, using a telephathy start up called Neuralink.</em></p><p><em>The operation of Neuralink will develop computer chips that able to be implanted in human brain. The implanted chip aimed to increase the capacity of brain to memorized as well as installing or downloading “thoughts”. Further, the chip is supposed to help human brain accessing certain softwares or applications. Elon Musk has given some clue about Neuralink that it will work on the unification of human biological ratio and digital ratio.</em></p><p><em>It has been a year after the news about this issue is posted. However, the Neuralink has not been operated. There is also no appearance of the physical form of Neuralink. However, the development of this new invented-technology is inevitable. Especially, if such technology is applied and if it become marketed in the society, that is to say, people must be very well-prepared to encounter with the Neuralink which is presently worked by Elon Musk.</em></p><p><em>Knowing that there will be such amazing new-invented technology, Neuralink, we need to also be aware of the consequences and the effects of the presence of such chip.</em></p><p><em>a. Effect to the World Education</em></p><p><em>The might-be-invented chip will work on increasing and upgrading the capacity of human brain to have a wonderful skill in memorizing even to installing, downloading as well as accessing a certain softwares. Consequently, it would also change the way people learn.</em></p><p><em>Imagine when all the people in the world have already implanted the Neuralink chip in their brain. Since they have a very strong memorizing skill, it would lead them to read books faster. They would be able to read many books in a short time. Not only be able to read fast, but also be able to memorized all the material in the books. When there is new material that is given by the teacher in the class, they would be able to understand and remember all the materials.</em></p><p><em>The next skill, people would learn everything through downloading the needed material and ‘save’ it in their brain’s storage. So, if there is online books that is given to the people as their source to learn, they will not need to have it in hard copy, not even need to read it through laptop or smartphone, but they themselves even able to download the books and ‘save’ it in their brain storage.</em></p><p><em>It seems so great to have such implanted chip in our brain. However, among all the advantages we would have, there are also some disadvatangaes that would occur if the implanted chip is truly applied to people in the world. There are several disadvantages also that we have to highlight so that we can prepare everything to encounter with the disadvantages of the occurance of implanted chip.</em></p><p><em>The first disadvantage is that of course it will be hard for the teacher to give close-book examination. According to my point of view, I believe that there will be no more close-book examination. Since the students can easily take a look to the book which has been installed in their brain, and they can open it during the close-book examination without being caught by the teacher. Therefore, such close-book examination will be not effective anymore to be conducted.</em></p><p><em>The second disadvantage is still related to the first disadvantage, since close-book examination will not be conducted anymore, it means, the teacher cannot make test to measure the capability of the student in memorizing too. It is true that chip is said able to increase the capability of human to memorized, but how to prove it? Since, at the time, human will be able to just read anything, googling anything by its brain to get the answer needed when they face a test/examination.</em></p><p><em>The third disadvantage is that such chip has the potential to decrease the work of the biological version of brain. What I am saying here is like this, when human can easily just having the world knowledge in their mind by installing, downloading as well as saving it in their brain storage, human would get lazy to learn about all those thing, they will be lazy to do thing called memorizing. The worst case would be happened is that there will come a day when human just live by depending on the implanted chip, forget and even stop using their biological brain, which it would lead to the decrease of brain’s system.</em></p><p><em>As we know, all part of our body, if we do not really use it or move it, it would become very slow and even has the possibiliyy to not being able to work anymore. For example, when we do not exercise, we would get so many disease related to our bone. The same thing will also happen to our brain, when our brain do not get its exercise such as used to learn, to memorized and to think, I believe that our brain’s work system can be ruined. What I am trying to say is, this might-be-invented chip has the ability to damage our brain.</em></p><p><em>b. Effect to the World Medicine</em></p><p><em>This new invention is actually will also be very helpful for the Medicine field. As we know, the-said Neuralink chip, when it is implanted in the human brain, it would have the ability to increase human’s ability to memorized, it means it will also increase human’s capacity to remember. By which, this new chip will also able to capture every momment stronger than human’s brain could do.</em></p><p><em>Further, it is very clear that this new-invented chip will be very helpful to help the people who suffer from Alzheimer’s disease. In which, Alzheimer’s disease is a progressive disease that destroys memory and other important mental functions.This Alzheimer’s disease make the people with the disease become easily forget about anything.</em></p><p><em>However, the time when this implanted-chip is marketed to the society, there is a possibility to help the people with Alzheimer’s disease. The chip is able to help the Alzheimer’s patient to increase their capacity to memorized and help them to capture momment, and also to remember it for a longer time.</em></p><p><em>c. Effect to the Human Social Life</em></p><p><em>Nowadays, human beings are being very individualistic. There is a cause that leads people become more and more individualistic, which is smartphone. People nowadays own their world in their hand. They can scroll the whole world with only using one of their finger. They can see every inch of the world with their eyes looking at a rectangle screen. That is why people nowadays forget the real form of world that they have to pay more attention at.</em></p><p><em>By having such smartphone, by which human can bring to everywhere they go, it has leads them to forget their real world. Which also cause people become less sympathic and less empathic. But still, there is also time where people do not hold their smartphone. Therefore, maybe in a day, someone would only spend 15 hours with their smartphone. But even, by only spending such time, they have forget their real world, their family, their friend, and everything around them.</em></p><p><em>Imagine, when all people on Earth have such implanted chip which make them able to installed, download as well as saving any softwares, application and documents, honestly saying, the chip is actually will have the same function as smartphone. In other words, this implanted chip will subtitute the role of smartphone. Which also means, human beings will not only spend 15 hours in a day with their smartphone, but after having such implanted-chip in their brain, human will spend 24/7 with their brainphone!</em></p><p><em>Which means, in the future, people will not only will got to see the whole world with their eyes anymore, but, people would even have the whole world in their brain. Then, ironicly, it would also mean that the real world would become more forgotten by people. People will keep playing and spending time with every installation they have in their brain. People will become so busy with the world in their brain and leaving the real form of world.</em></p><p><em>What I am trying to say here, this new chip will actually lead people become more individualistic, and even will make people not even knowing anyone in their real life for being so busy with their brainphone and their internet life. And even, it would lead people to have no social life anymore.</em></p><p><em>d. Effect to the Religious Matter</em></p><p><em>Actually, this new-might-be-invented chip would also actually affect the religious matter in human life. As we know, there are a lot of atheist or the people who do not believe in God nowadays. Why do there are a lot of atheist? Because they believe in their ratio.</em></p><p><em>Atheists believe that whatever cannot be proven by their ratio, will be considered as not existing. In other words, atheists believe in science more than God. The more people adore the science which comes from human ratio, the more actually people have the possibility to become an atheist.</em></p><p><em>However, this Neuralink chip will increase the capacity of human brain to elaborate, think, and memorized better. It means, people in the future, with such implanted chip in their brain would even be smarter and even can become a genius. However, it means, there would be more people who adore their own ratio. In which, it would makes them believe in science. And it would also mean, the atheists in the world will also be increased.</em></p><p><em>Another possibility that would happen in the future also is that, people will be questioning, “Is there really a God? I do not think so. People keep on talking that there is God who has higher position than our ratio because He is the one who gives us the ratio. But now, can you just see it? That even human also can give ratio to human by such implanted chip. Which means, at the very beginning, the ratio is given by human to human.”</em></p><p><em>When such situation happens, we know what will happen right? That, there will be even more people who do not believe in God. Even, I am scared that there will be a day where the number of the atheists is higher than the one who believes in God.</em></p><p><em>e. Effect to the Legal Positivism</em></p><p><em>As we know, nowadays, everyone’s life is ruled by the law which is made by the sovereignty or by the people who really have such authority to make the law. What I am trying to say is that, there is law which is made by a group of people to rule people and the people can choose whether they want to obey or not. However, whether they want to obey or not, these people are forced indirectly to obey the law, by which, we can see from the punishment provided for those who do not obey the law. In other word, whenever we are, we are now really ruled by the law which is made by the sovereignty, and we have no other choice other than obey and do the command of the rule.</em></p><p><em>We have such will to obey the law, because we know that the people who made the law really have the integrity, capability and ability to make the most suitable and justiciable law. We know that the sovereignty is smarter than us in making law, that is why we believe in the law that is made by them. That is also the reason why we obey.</em></p><p><em>However, nowadays we find out so many people out there who keep on critisizing the sovereignty-made-law. These people keep on questioning the validity and the fairness of the law. Even there are some people who intentionally do not obey the law because they think such law is not deserved to be obeyed. Why this situation occur? Because these people think that they know what is better for the society. Some of them also even think that they are the ones who have the capability to make the best law. Then such thoughts occur? Because people are growing smarter and being more active in giving their opinion. People nowadays does not want to be just obeying the law without firstly analayze the law. Which is, we can conclude that actually people who critisize the law is the result of the people in the world who are growing smarter.</em></p><p><em>Yes, of course people growing smarter and smarter. That is why the technology, science, infrastructure and everything keeps on developing without any stop period.</em></p><p><em>Now, let us think the situation in the future when the implanted chip is applied. It will have the possibility that there will be a day, where everyone feel smart. They will be more critical in the way they think. And, maybe all people in the world will complain on everything which they think it is not right.</em></p><p><em>It seems like a simple situation. But actually, what I am scared of is that, the world law will be chaos. There will be so much of critics. There will be so much input from all world smart people. Which, it might even lead the world change their system of government. Which is like the very old one, where people live on their own law. Where people made their own family law and live just the way they want. The sovereignty’s era might be crashed.</em></p><p><em>to conclude:</em></p><p><em>The technology will keeps on developing. No one can stop such development of technology. Because, if people want to stop the development of technology, it can be only done by stopping human to learn anything. Which is, stopping human to learn is something impossible to do.</em></p><p><em>Therefore, we have to just let the technology develops. But we have to know, no matter what will happen in the future, we have to firstly strengthens our life vision so that we ourselves will not be able to be shaken by the development of technology’s wave.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=420b87d4323f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reincarnation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/reincarnation-131a24809996?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/131a24809996</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion-and-spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reincarnation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 May 2018 06:57:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-09T06:57:58.250Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*WXWR_ldDlS7rYlTR37mpbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>One day I was examining all paper submission, when, I finally strucked to one paper with this interesting topic, “Reincarnation”. In my humble opinion, the writing worth better audience than my cold-silent email inbox. So, here is a brief story about reincarnation, written by the talented Ni Luh Larasathy Pinkan, a pretty Balinesse girl, law student in Law School President University Cikarang, who’s now in pursue of her legal career through internship in one of leading technology company.</p><p><em>Reincarnation is the philosophical or religious concept that an aspect of a living being, starts a new life in a different physical body or form after each biological death. The theory of reincarnation or “life after death” is believed by certain community such as Buddhism and Hinduism. Although, there are also several philosophers who also believe in such theory, such as Curt John Ducasse, Pythagoras, Socrates, etc.</em></p><p><em>Ducasse, a French philosopher, stated that reincarnation is a form of life after bodily death in which the soul becomes incarnate again through reentry in a new human or possibly animal body. From the aforementioned definition, it can be noted that the individual soul lives in a body on earth not once but several times. While Pythagoras, a Greek philosopher, apparently was famous as an expert on the fate of the soul after death, in which he thought that the soul was immortal and underwent a series of reincarnations. Such statement was disclosed by Cuffman, a leading scholar on Pythagoras theories. As for Socrates explanation on reincarnation, he said that if the soul existed before birth then the soul exists after death.</em></p><p><em>Reincarnation, as what has been stated before, is also believed by several religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism, and usually being attributed to the idea of Karma. In Christianity, they do believe in Karma in a different term. In Galatians 6:8, it says “Whoever sows to please their flesh, from the flesh will reap destruction; whoever sows to please the Spirit, from the Spirit will reap eternal life”. Or in Bahasa Indonesia, it is commonly known as rule of “tabur tuai”. Karma itself shall mean a result of what we have done in our whole life. If we did something good, then our Karma will be good, and vice versa.</em></p><p><em>According to Hinduism, reincarnation is one of 5 beliefs in which all Hindus shall have faith in them, as the main destination of a living being is not heaven, but rather Moksha. Moksha is a term which refers to freedom of the soul to become one with the God. When our soul reaches Moksha, there will not be life anymore. We will be released from all the good and bad. There will only be silence and peace. In order to reach that, Hinduism believes that human needs to go through several lives in this world in order to purify, and release their soul from all the bad karma they have done in life. That is why in Hinduism we are required to stay in line with Dharma, and do all the good thing to all the living beings in this whole entire world. Whether it is our fellow human, or, animals and even plants.</em></p><p><em>The idea of reincarnation also related to the existence of heaven and hell. We will be reborn after the death, and whether or not we will be reborn as a human in a good and perfect condition, it depends on our past lives. If we conducted more good things instead of the bad ones, we will go to hell before our soul stay in heaven while waiting for our turn to be returned to the world as the most perfect living being, possessed with integrity and common sense, called human. And if otherwise, we will go to heaven first to get a reward for the good things we have done in life, and after that our soul will go straight to hell, while waiting our turn to be returned back to the world whether as a disabled human, or even worse animals or viruses or plants</em></p><p><em>An American scientist, Dr. Ian Stevenson has conducted several scientific research about reincarnation and he was convinced that it is real. His research began in 1960 when he learned of a case in Sri Lanka where a child reported to remember a past life. And he continued his research and wrote 14 books and around 300 papers related to reincarnation. During his original research into various cases involving children’s memories of past lives, Dr. Stevenson did note the fact that the lasting birthmarks on someone’s body could possibly be related to their murder or the death they suffered in a previous life.</em></p><p><em>As a case that happened in Brazil where a man, in his deathbed, told his niece that he would reborn as her son because he knew that she would look after him and would be a great mom for him, considering that he claimed her current daughter to be his deceased sister. And before he passed away, he told her that her future son will have an exact same scar as he had on his back and nose. 18 months later, she gave birth to her son and when she looked at his back, he had the exact same scar as Victor, her uncle, told her before he passed away</em></p><p><em>Another thing that he found during his investigation was that 35% of cases he investigated, children who died an unnatural death, developed phobias. For example, if they had drowned in a past life then they frequently developed a phobia about going out of their depth in water. If they had been shot they were often afraid of guns and sometimes loud bangs in general. If they died in a road accident they would sometimes develop a phobia of traveling in cars, buses, or lorries.</em></p><p><em>As a case that happened in England, on 5 May 1957. There was an incident of a car hitting an eleven-year-old Joanna, and her six-year-old sister Jacqueline Pollock, while they were playing on the pavement. They were found dead on the street right after the incident happened. A year later, Mrs. Pollock was pregnant and her husband got a vision that she would give birth to twin girls and these two girls would be their lost daughters reborn. Mrs. Pollock, as a strict Catholic of course refused to believe in reincarnation and denied his husband’s statement. And finally Mr. Pollock was found to be right. She gave birth to identical girl twins. And as they grew older, the twins started to amaze their parents by pointing out places that they had never been before. One of the girls said “the school is just around the corner”. The other one pointed to a hill and said “our playground was behind there. It had a slide and a swing.” Further, their recognized their old toys they had in their previous life. They even knew the exact name of their dolls. Jennifer said, “Oh! That’s Mary.” And she went for the second doll and said “that’s my Suzanne! I haven’t seen them for ages.” She used the same names which the deceased Jacqueline had previously given her two dolls. Jennifer turned to Gillian (her twin), pointing to another toy and said “that’s your washing machine.” Both of them also developed over-cautious responses when crossing roads and feared speeding cars (considering that they were run down by a car which caused their death).</em></p><p><em>However, this reincarnation concept is not widely accepted within the society. There are a lot of communities that stand against this concept of reincarnation. Because, according to them, there is no such life after death. They believe that hell and heaven last forever and that our soul will be placed in either hell or heaven. It will be determined based on what we have done when we are still alive. There are several other religions that do not believe in reincarnation, inter alia, Islamic, Christianity, and Catholic.</em></p><p><em>According to the Moslems, they believe that God created Adam and Eve and that was the beginning of the creation of human in this world; they regenerate. In Islamic, human does not possess control over their soul after death. The soul/spirit will stay in the “other side” until the end of the world, after Allah awaken all the deceases. As in Hinduism, they believe in Karma from the elders, Moslems believe otherwise. In Al-Muddatsir 74:38 it stated that every being will be liable to what they have done. Islamic does not recognize reincarnation, but they believe in resurrection instead. In the essence, there is no such a past life in Islam. Further, a Ma’mun once said to Imam Reza: “what’s your opinion about those who believe in reincarnation?” The Imam replied: “one who believes in reincarnation has denied God Almighty and has claimed heaven and hell to be unreal”. Similarly, Imam Sadiq also says: “they suppose that both heaven and hell do not exist, nor will resurrectiob happen and in their view resurrection is nothing but transferring from one body and structure to another. If the soul was a righteous one while in the former body it will return a better and superior structure at the highest level imaginable in this worls, but if it was corrupt and ignorant, it will return in the form of four legged animals that are used for hauling things which live in pain and hardship or in the form of a small ugly looking bird that flies at night and likes the graveyard and finds peace there.”</em></p><p><em>The famous philosopher, Sadrul Mutaahhilin (Mullah Sadra) says: “…the nafs, in its first level of being brought to existence, stands at the level of nature. Then in proportion to its materialistic motion towards perfection, the nafs evolves all the way through being a plant and an animal to being a human. And if the nafs, at any level fulfills its potential (quwwah), even in the most subtle amount, it is impossible for this actuality (fi’liyyah) to regress back into pure potentiality once more. In addition to this, as was said before, the matter (maddah) and form(surah) are a united entity that bears the two aspects of actuality and potential, that take on the path of evolution together, advancing and developing at any point and chance possible, therefore, it is impossible for a soul that has passed the vegetative or animate level to attach to a form of sperm or fetus (be reincarnated in these forms).”</em></p><p><em>As deprived from another source, which is Catechism of the Catholic Church, it stated that “when the single course of our earthly life is completed, we shall not return to other earthly lives”. They also believe that immortality of an individual soul is a truth and is the faith of Christian. As also stated in the bible, that Hebrews 9:27 confirms that we only die once, our individual immortal souls cannot reincarnate. They also believe that by maintaining an indefinite series of chances for human souls, reincarnation reduces the seriousness of God’s grace. The whole thrust of the bible opposes reincarnation. The bible teaches that at death, while man’s body is mortal, decays, and returns to dust, their soul and spirit continue on either place of torments, or in paradise. Both categories of people will be resurrected, one to eternal judgment and the other to eternal life with a glorified body. Such statement is stated in a bible verse, particularly John 5:25–29. One exact bible verse that blatantly stating that Christianity does not believe in reincarnation exists in Hebrew 9:27, which stated that and just as people are appointed to die once, and then to face judgment.</em></p><p><em>Further, according to Christian authors, Henry M. Morris and Martin E. Clark, in their book, they stated that “classical ideas of reincarnation know nothing of a personal God who enters holy relationships with His creatures. In fact, ultimate reality is usually conceived as a cognitive process within man himself, rather than as a personal God. Further, reincarnation schemes make men’s spiritual advancement contingent upon his mortal efforts, attempting to make merit outweigh demerit. Christianity shows, however, that salvation cannot be earned by sinful man, but rather, it is merited by Jesus Christ’s substitutionary death and resurrection for all who believe. Also, many theories of reincarnation hold that man’s spiritual, physical, and moral conditions are determined by a former life and therefore not under his control. Physically, this has led to a passive, pessimistic acceptance of untold misery that was actually unnecessary. Spiritually, it is even more devastating. The Bible reveals that no one is bound in his sins against his will, and though born under Adam’s curse, “if we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous to forgive us of our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1 John 1:9). Through God’s forgiving grace, “though your sins be as scarlet, they will be as white as snow; though they are red like crimson, they will be like wool” (Isaiah 1:18). Consequently, the Christian does not worry about his merit outweighing his demerit, for his sins have been forgiven, God having promised, “I will remember their sins no more” (Hebrews 8:12).”</em></p><p><em>In conclusion, there are still pros and cons regarding the reincarnation concept. Ones believe that reincarnation is real according to their scientific research, and the others denied because it does not comply with the teaching of God, that there will only be a resurrection day. There is no such certain decision in this matter. People will believe in what they believe and will continue to do that until they prove themselves wrong. There is no such wrong or right concept, considering the deceases cannot talk to us and tell us what happen in the “other side”. It is all about belief, about what we have been taught since we were kids. I personally believe in reincarnation because that is what my parents taught me. If you think otherwise, that is probably you learned something different. The only thing I know for sure is that we have to do the good and avoid the bad in order to get a proper and glorious life, whether it is in heaven, or when we reborn as a human in this world (before we reach Moksha, for me).</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=131a24809996" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Causation in Indonesian Criminal Justice System]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/causation-in-indonesian-criminal-justice-system-907624b6a23?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/907624b6a23</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[causation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Apr 2018 04:53:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-23T04:53:13.813Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Law students maybe (or maybe not) have learned theories about causation. In Indonesian Law School, principles regarding causation are learned in the pursue of understanding delicts. But, this one important aspect of delicts (or crime) has never been written specifically in any research. That was what I know from a book discussion I attended in Yayasan Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Indonesia (Indonesia Legal Aid Foundation) in Jalan Diponegoro №74, Jakarta, on April 12th, 2018. The book that we discussed entitled “Ajaran Kausalitas Hukum Pidana (Causation in Criminal Law)” is written by Dr. Ahmad Sofian, S.H., M.A. A lecturer in Bina Nusantara (Binus) University. This book is derived from his dissertation in Universitas Indonesia.</p><p>Causation holds an important role in criminal law enforcement. In general, principles of causation seek for the exact cause for specific effect. The principle of causation itself, although it is used in law system, it is not originally from law science. In the beginning, it was developed in Theology. If we look at the metaphysics as a branch of philosophy, then the discussion of “what”, “being”, and “cause” are the core of all discourse.</p><p>The epistemology in the form of analyzing premises, to conclude exactly the cause of a determined result, was then borrowed by natural sciences. Scientists use this method in an experiment to prove their hypothesis into thesis.</p><p>Later after that, groups of science that put human (and society) as the object, also implement the similar epistemology. Once we started to use premises in creating hypothesis regarding social sciences, we already moved far from the pursue to understand human and society in its humanity.</p><p>The point is, causation has recognized as principles that is studied in criminal law studies and is implemented in Criminal Justice System. But, either it is understood and implemented accordingly is a whole other story. The problem started to occur when experts admit that the epistemology of cause and effect in natural science is not adequate to be used in social sciences. First, in natural sciences, experts may generalized the thesis they produce based on many experiments. Second, this generalization cannot be used towards cases in social science. If we insist in using the same epistemology, means, we must (and we will) objectifying the elements. These elements, meanwhile, many times are subjective because it relates much with the human factors that make the case is always dynamic. The results is every case is always different (casuistic) and we can never generalized them. So, in 5 cases, for instance, that have exact same major premise, it is possible to have different consequences.</p><p>In criminal law enforcement sense, causation determines culpability. Before I discuss about culpability, better to get to know crime in Indonesian Criminal Justice System first. There are varieties in delict, according to the penal code and doctrines. One of those varieties is a classification of delicts into formal delict (formeel delicten) and material delict (materiil delicten). In material delict, we emphasize on the result of crime. In formal delict, the crime is considered as done by the fullfillment of elements of action (not awaiting or considering on results). The Common Law System recognizes material delicts as result crimes, as for the formal delicts are known as crimes. Since Indonesia was colonialized by The Dutch, the legal system it adopted is Civil-Law System. No wonder elements and legal terms are derived from Dutch’s.</p><p>Causation is relevant in material delicts. In determining cause, law enforcers should observe and analyze the result of an action (or series of actions). E.g., I shot my enemy, with a revolver, the bullet went straight to the head, deadly to the brain, and then she’s dead instantly. The result of my action pulling the trigger of my revolver, was the death of my enemy. This is the situation when A shot B’s head then B was dead. In this situation we can obviously determine that the cause of B’s death is a gun shot wound, done by A. My enemy’s death was caused by revolver shot by me. Later, we can determine that A (and I) hold culpability.</p><p>Things will get more indetermined when the situation is far more complex than that. E.g., A stabbed B with small knive and has caused a severe bleeding. C, then, accidentaly thrusted a fork to the wound that has worsen the bleeding. Later B was rescued and taken to the E.R. At the E.R., the doctor was wrongly diagnozing B’s condition, which led to a worse bleeding than before. To fix the condition, B was asked to receive a blood transfusion, but B refused. In the end, B was dead.</p><p>In the second illustration, it is harder to determine which factor that has caused B’s death. The difficulty to determine the cause will consequent to the difficulty to determine who’s responsible.</p><p>From the two illustration, it can be analyzed that causation is most relevant in material delict or result crime. The logical reason is because in material delict the division of cause and result is strong. Compared to formal delict, formal delict requires all elements of action that has been formulated in criminal regulation, without depending on the result. That is because the action itself doesn’t require a result, as long as the actions are done, that is already unlawful. E.g, stealing, rape, assault.</p><p>The importance of determining a cause for a result is to determine liability. The subject that is liable must be those who holds a guilt factor. Guilt factor (mens rea) is a factor of fault. In deciding someone’s liability, it is determined by two important element, unlawful acts (actus reus) and guilt (mens rea). But, not to forget that there must be a causation between if and then, between the acts, the guilt, that together they’ve resulted to certain facts. Investigator must seek the link between the case they investigating with the most potential suspect. This doesn’t mean that the suspect must be proven to hold mens rea, but at least there must be minimum 2 (two) sufficient preliminary evidences that lead to the suspect. All the elements of delict are subjected to be proven in a trial stage.</p><p>But, looking at the first paragraph of this article, determining causation is not as easy as it sounds in theories. Many delicts are invlolving too many complications it is hard to only determine one cause-factor. The difficulties then, worsen by the fact that subject of crime is not only human, but also a corporation.</p><p>A corporation that does crimes needs to be analyzed differently. In corporate crime, it is an organizational action, where one employee acts based on command of the authority. As an example, one of the speaker in the Book Discussion event, Mr. Grahat Nagara (Auriga Foundation, lecturer at Jentera Law School) mention the case of Adelin Lis, a suspect of illegal logging that was commited by his company, PT. Keang Nam Development Indonesia (PT. KNDI). PT. KNDI committed an illegal logging, by not doing the reboization as mandated by law. Adelin Lis as a Finance Director was convicted based on an “indirect” fault. He did not directly doing the unlawful act, it was some employees who maintained the blocks. But he was considered guilty because of the reason that his action of not budgeting for reforestation had caused his underlings not to perform reforestation.</p><p>If we refer to the Von Buri’s conditio sine qua non, where every single cause has similar values and should not be excluded as a cause-factor, then it is assumed that the consideration in Adelin Lis case used such reasoning. This is not in accordance with the meaning and purpose of mens rea, where the guilt factor must be determined in someone’s consciousness and this someone should be he who has conducted and has caused the result crime.</p><p>But, it is understood that in corporate crime or any syndication crime, the distribution of guilt may be a thing. Investigators should use unconventional methods and reasoning to process the case. The understanding of causation in this type of crime should be seen from different perspectives.</p><p>To conclude, causation is an important aspect of crime to determine liability. Generally, the burden of liability lies on subjects who hold guilt. Guilt is a subjective element that the subject bears, which later should be objectify by actions and situational evidences. The process is more complicated than any theories may say. This difficulty is followed with the progressing characteristic of crimes. Nowadays, we recognize corporate crime and any syndication crime where distribution of authority is involved. Causation, then, should be dynamic following the type of crime that investigators working on.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=907624b6a23" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Actus Reus dan Mens Rea dalam Penyelidikan Perkara Korupsi di Indonesia]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/actus-reus-dan-mens-rea-dalam-penyelidikan-perkara-korupsi-di-indonesia-55cff993e698?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/55cff993e698</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[actus-reus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[penahanan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[acara-pidana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mens-rea]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[korupsi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Mar 2018 10:19:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-19T10:20:06.060Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Mens Rea dalam Perkara Korupsi</p><p>Dalam teori pidana, sebuah tindak pidana dibangun atas dua unsur penting yaitu unsur objektif/physical yaitu actus reus (perbuatan yang melanggar undang-undang pidana) dan unsur subjektif/mental yaitu mens rea (sikap batin pelaku ketika melakukan tindak pidana).</p><p>Dalam prosedur penegakkan hukum pidana (acara pidana), terdapat dua pendapat mengenai mana yang harus terlihat lebih dahulu, actus reus atau mens rea? Secara umum, dalam penyelidikan, otomatis penyelidik akan melihat dari actus reus, karena ini pasti lebih dahulu terlihat dan dijadikan dasar untuk pemeriksaan lanjutan, ketimbang mens rea (sikap batin) yang –karena bukan hal yang bersifat fisik- tidak selalu terlihat di tahap penyelidikan. Dalam hal tertangkap tangan pun, mens rea masih penting untuk dibuktikan di tahap berikutnya.</p><p>Hal yang perlu diingat adalah, mens rea ini menjadi unsur penting untuk menentukan pertanggungjawaban dari si pelaku. Sebuah tindak pidana bisa jadi menitikberatkan pada actus reus, ketimbang mens rea, misalnya dalam pembunuhan yang dilakukan dengan niat menghilangkan nyawa, maka jelas mens rea nya adalah guilty (bersalah). Namun, dalam pembunuhan akibat dari kelalaian (misalnya, saat pengemudi ugal-ugalan menabrak orang hingga mati), maka pelaku tetap dapat didakwa menghilangkan nyawa orang lain, hanya saja pasalnya akan berbeda (karena mens rea nya berbeda).</p><p>Sehingga, berapapun ratio perbandingan mens rea dan actus reus, terlepas dari mana yang harus timbul duluan, keduanya adalah unsur yang harus ada dalam pertanggungjawaban pidana.</p><p>Dalam perkara korupsi, akhir-akhir ini muncul perdebatan. Di mana KPK kesulitan melanjutkan perkara korupsi RS Sumber Waras akibat sulitnya menemukan mens rea, walaupun, menurut pemberitaan, pemeriksaan diawali karena adanya hasil audit BPK yang mengindikasikan terdapat kerugian Negara yang timbul dalam peristiwa RS Sumber Waras.</p><p>Terlepas dari polemik RS Sumber Waras, dalam perkara korupsi, actus reus dan mens rea penting. Tapi, ketidakhadiran mens rea seberapa pentingkah, untuk menentukan tersangka korupsi ditahan atau tidak?</p><p>Korupsi adalah tindak pidana yang tidak mungkin tidak sengaja. Apapun niatannya, jika perbuatannya menimbulkan akibat, seperti, merugikan keuangan Negara dan/atau memperkaya diri sendiri secara melawan hukum, maka itu dinamakan korupsi. Perlu diingat bahwa setelah ada putusan MK 25/PUU-XIV/2016 korupsi adalah delik materil. Sehingga unsur memperkaya diri sendiri dan merugikan keuangan Negara tersebut perlu dibuktikan terjadi.</p><p>Jadi dalam delik korupsi, titik beratnya lain, jika dibandingkan dengan ilustrasi delik pembunuhan di atas maupun tindak pidana biasa lainnya. Pertanggungjawabannya adalah strict liability. Apapun mens rea nya, jika terbukti actus reus nya mengakibatkan akibat yang dimaksud dalam UU Tipikor, maka pelaku dapat dipidana. Di sini, unsur actus reus : unsur mens rea adalah 100 : 0. Perkara korupsi, tidak ditentukan oleh mens rea, melainkan actus reus yang memenuhi UU Tipikor secara formil, dan alat bukti yang cukup untuk membuktikan akibat yang dilarang oleh UU (delik materil) memang terjadi.</p><p>Mens Rea dan Penahanan</p><p>Apakah kemudian mens rea harus terlihat dari awal proses penyidikan untuk menentukkan dapat ditahan/tidaknya tersangka? Kembali ke konsep awal unsur tindak pidana, actus reus dan mens rea harus ada dalam tindak pidana, tapi tidak ada ketentuan mens rea harus terlihat di tahap awal, apalagi menjadikannya dasar utama untuk penahanan.</p><p>Dasar penahanan menurut Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Acara Pidana (KUHAP) adalah kewenangan penyidik untuk menahan tersangka jika terdapat kekhawatiran bahwa tersangka akan:</p><p>1. Menyembunyikan alat bukti.</p><p>2. Melarikan diri.</p><p>3. Mengulangi tindak pidana.</p><p>Asumsi yang dapat ditarik dari ketentuan KUHAP tersebut adalah, merupakan hak penyidik untuk menentukan apakah mens rea terlihat di proses penyidikan atau tidak. Jika ya, maka penyidik punya kekhawatiran tersangka akan melakukan ketiga hal tersebut di atas dan kemudian menetapkan tersangka perlu ditahan. Jika tidak, maka penyidik tidak akan menahan tersangka. Tapi, hal itu tidak limitatif, dalam arti, walau mens rea terlihat di proses penyidikan, penyidik masih berhak untuk tidak menahan, jika tidak khawatir akan ketiga dasar penahanan yang disebut sebelumnya.</p><p>Kesimpulan dari penulis dalam hal ini, penempatan mens rea adalah fleksibel dan kasuistis di mana mens rea akan menemui tempat akhirnya, yaitu di ruang pengadilan di mana ia (mens rea) akan dibuktikan. Sebagaimana actus reus pun akan diperiksa apakah benar melawan undang-undang pidana atau tidak, di pengadilan.</p><p>Untuk perkara korupsi, penulis berpendapat strict liability adalah tepat sebagai bentuk pertanggungjawaban, sehingga, unsur mens rea menjadi tidak relevan dalam prosedur pemeriksaannya, apalagi jika kemudian dijadikan dasar untuk tidak melanjutkan pemeriksaan tindak pidana korupsi.</p><p>Untuk penahanan, dasar penahanan adalah untuk menahan tersangka jika terdapat kekhawatiran bahwa tersangka akan menyembunyikan alat bukti, melarikan diri, mengulangi tindak pidana sebagaimana ditentukan oleh KUHAP.</p><p>Ketiga hal tersebut seluruhnya adalah tergantung penyidik perkara yang bersangkutan. Sehingga akan menahan atau tidak menahan, alasannya dapat ditemukan dalam pertimbangan penyidik.</p><p>Dalam hal tindak pidana korupsi, terlepas dari akan ditahan atau tidak, jika dalam penyelidikan diketahui bahwa perbuatan yang diduga adalah tindak pidana (e.g., korupsi) maka perkara akan dibawa ke tahap berikutnya, penuntutan dan pemeriksaan pengadilan. Dalam hal ini, tidak ditemukan mens rea dalam sebuah perkara korupsi tidak mengakibatkan dihentikannya penuntutan. Penuntutan akan gagal jika tidak ditemukan 2 alat bukti atau lebih pada saat penyidikan.</p><p>Dalam hal ini penulis berpendapat bahwa,</p><p>1. mens rea tidak pernah disyaratkan untuk muncul terlihat dari awal pemeriksaan perkara pidana (e.g. korupsi), sehingga menjadikan tidak adanya mens rea sebagai alas an untuk tidak melanjutkan pemeriksaan perkara adalah tidak tepat. Masih sangat mungkin mens rea baru muncul di pemeriksaan pengadilan.</p><p>2. Alasan untuk tidak melanjutkan perkara adalah jika tidak ditemukan 2 alat bukti minimal, tidak adanya 2 saksi minimal, sehingga/dan perkaranya bukan tindak pidana. Ini menitikberatkan pada actus reus yang harus berupa tindak pidana. Mens rea, sekali lagi, dapat dibuktikan di acara pemeriksaan pengadilan.</p><p>3. Perihal penahanan, dasar penahanan bukanlah ada/tidaknya mens rea, melainkan ada kekhawatiran penyidik bahwa tersangka akan menyembunyikan alat bukti, melarikan diri, mengulangi tindak pidana. Akan menahan atau tidak itu terserah penyidik, selama tidak mengganggu jalannya pemeriksaan perkara dan alasannya dapat diterima. Penting bagi penyidik menyatakan secara jelas alasan menahan/tidak menahan tersangka agar tidak dipertanyakan di kemudian waktu.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=55cff993e698" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reconceptualizing Sanction in Indonesian Criminal Justice System: Restorative Justice or Repressive…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/reconceptualizing-sanction-in-indonesian-criminal-justice-system-restorative-justice-or-repressive-c23e6d20c706?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c23e6d20c706</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal-justice-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criminal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Feb 2018 11:56:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-08T11:56:26.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Reconceptualizing Sanction in Indonesian Criminal Justice System: Restorative Justice or Repressive Justice?</h3><p>Sanction is an inseparable part of criminal law. Together with several other aspects of criminal law, namely, harmful and unlawful behavior; guilt; culpability; society; and law enforcer, they embody criminal law.</p><p>The general understanding of sanction is as a payback. A retaliation for criminals after crimes that they commited. By having a sanction it is believed that it will keep the balance between criminals and victims.</p><p>Several theories then occurred in a pursue of understanding sanction. The purpose of sanction and punishment is one of aspects that commonly being debated. The classic idea of a sanction is that it serves as a punishment, a retaliation of a perpetrator, to create an equality for the victim. The wide consequence is a sanction (punishment) may create a deterrent effect for the society. Hopefully this will prevent the society from a crime to happen (preventive purpose).</p><p>The next idea of a sanction is that the purpose is not to fully as a retaliation, but also to create a restorative purpose. A perpetrator needs to be punished, but the punishment must also consider development aspects, for both perpetrator and the victim (also society in general). For instance, the first version of punishment: if James murdered Alex, James deserves a death penalty. Only by that the fairness for the victim is served.</p><p>For the same illustration, the 2nd version of punishment should say: James deserves a death penalty. But, he is a husband and a father of a newborn. A reason he murdered Alex is to avoid paying his debt to Alex. James had financial reason that has driven him into the crime he committed. In this version, sentencing James with death sentence have lesser advantage than other way to punish him. We will consider his wife and his baby, and also his motives in murdering Alex. Then we can calculate on what sanction has better purpose.We have come to an era that criminal sanction is not only has punishing purpose, but also has consideration of the perpetrator and the related society.</p><p>In short, sanction may take these purposes:</p><ol><li>Repressive</li><li>Restorative</li></ol><p>In Indonesia, the main source of criminal law is The Penal Code, in Bahasa known as Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana (KUHP). This law was originally from the Dutch. Indonesian had criminal system from the Dutch during colonialism. After the independence, Indonesia re-enact the Dutch’s criminal law system (named Wetboek van Straafrechts, translated into Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana c. 1960s). Logically, methods and types of sanction in KUHP use the Dutch’s.</p><p>After being independent from colonialism for 73 years, Indonesian justice system has been developed rapidly. Not only modifying the old Dutch laws, Indonesia also created many its own national laws. One thing that hasn’t been fully determined is, what kind of justice that Indonesian justice system is pursuing?</p><p>In criminal law sense, particularly, it’s seemed that the law wants to serve restorative purpose, seeking substantial justice and its kind (although, speaking of substantial justice, the concept can be philosophically questioned). The bottom line is, law is no longer seen as always-fair always-certain always-ideal anymore. This is proven by the establishment and implementation of methods in dispute settlement that is not using litigation, or known as alternative dispute resolution. Even there is a new method called diversion, used in juvenile criminal justice system. It tries to settle juvenile criminality without litigation and a harsh imprisonment.</p><p>BUT, in the very same time, Indonesia incriminating sanction for some crimes considered as extra-ordinary, such as, corruption and narcotics. Note that incriminating here is still limited because the law system is determining that maximum sanction for imprisonment is 20 years or life-sentence. More harsh than that is death sentence. Still we can say that for some crimes, the enforcement is escalated. It seems that Indonesia wants to imprisoned as many as it can, or even harsher, execute as many drug dealer, for instance, as it can.</p><p>Not only that, the current trending topic in Indonesia, there is The Draft of Indonesian Penal Code / Rancangan Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana Indonesia (RKUHP). The draft was first initiated in 1983, yet it hasn’t been legalized until this year (2018).</p><p>What’s hot topic about this draft is that the draft criminalized many social aspects than the old law. For example, mutual sex was not against the old law, but it is regulated so in the draft.(this needs to be discussed in other writing on how actually the new draft still possess the similar context about mutual sex as regulated in the old law. But it is true that the new formulation about it, in the new draft, opened wider interpretation than the old law. Considering the law enforcement in Indonesia is still relatively troubled, this kind of situation will bring more problem). Other example is criminalization for adat crime. Adat crime is supposed to be settled in its own adat community system. But the new draft mentions that it is possible to be settled in state court. This opens many criminalization. Not to forget, that death penalty is still available in the legal system. Death penalty is, of course, not in line with restorative justice.</p><p>It is concluded that Indonesia, tries to pursue restorative justice for its criminal justice system as seen in some laws and dispute settlement methods. At the same time, the other laws wants to incriminate the sanction and also criminalized many social aspects. Increasing the number punishment to put teeth in the law enforcer is typically a repressive justice.</p><p>It is needed to re-concept the purpose of sanction (and also law enforcement) to also seek its utility and not only emphasizing on the legal certainty.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c23e6d20c706" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Badan Usaha Tidak Berbadan Hukum sebagai Subjek Hukum Pidana Korporasi]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/badan-usaha-tidak-berbadan-hukum-sebagai-subjek-hukum-pidana-korporasi-8d9dae381df4?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d9dae381df4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tindak-pidana-korporasi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jan 2018 12:47:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-11T12:47:11.425Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Pada saat saya membaca kembali definisi tentang badan usaha, yang saya dapat pada intinya bahwa badan usaha itu adalah sekumpulan orang maupun modal yang melakukan kegiatan usaha secara terus menerus dengan tujuan mendapat keuntungan.</p><p>Definisi tersebut serupa dengan definisi dari korporasi. Peraturan Mahkamah Agung Nomor 13/2016 tentang Tata Cara Penanganan Tindak Pidana oleh Korporasi memberikan definisi korporasi sebagaimana definisi badan usaha, dengan penjelasan bahwa yang termasuk korporasi adalah badan usaha berbadan hukum dan juga yang tidak berbadan hukum. Berbadan hukum contohnya Perseroan Terbatas (PT), yayasan dan koperasi. Non-badan hukum contohnya persekutuan perdata, firma (Fa) dan CV.</p><p>Kemudian, dikaitkan dengan tindak pidana korporasi, tindak pidana korporasi pada intinya adalah perbuatan melawan hukum pidana yang dilakukan oleh korporasi. Jika digabung dengan definisi korporasi, berarti yang termasuk ke dalam subjek tindak pidana ini tidak hanya PT dan badan hukum lainnya, tapi juga termasuk firma, cv dan persekutuan perdata.</p><p>Dalam hal ini terdapat perbedaan antara konsep subjek hukum tindak pidana korporasi sebagaimana diuraikan di atas, dengan konsep subjek hukum menurut doktrin.</p><p>Dalam ilmu hukum (khususnya hukum perdata) subjek hukum dikenal ada dua yaitu orang perseorangan (<em>naturlijk persoon</em>) dan badan hukum (<em>rechtpersoon</em>)</p><p>Sesungguhnya jika merujuk pada definisi <em>rechtpersoon</em> menurut ahli, <em>rechtpersoon</em> adalah badan hukum. Yaitu subjek hukum yang bukan manusia dan mampu mengemban hak dan kewajiban hukum serta dapat menuntut dan dituntut.</p><p>Sedangkan <em>rechtpersoon</em> padanan kata dalam bahasa inggrisnya adalah <em>legal entity</em>. <em>Legal entity</em> jika diartikan adalah badan hukum.</p><p>Dari sini, definisi <em>rechtpersoon</em> hanya merujuk pada badan hukum. Secara <em>a contrario</em>, artinya non-badan hukum bukan subjek hukum? Lalu bagaimana jika sebuah perikatan perdata dilakukan dengan firma misalnya? Sementara firma bukanlah badan hukum.</p><p>Dalam hukum pidana, subjek hukum pidana adalah orang (individual). Sifat sanksi pidana pokok yang merupakan pidana badan membuat konsep awal subjek hukum pidana adalah orang saja. Lalu dengan adanya Perma 13/2016 ditegaskan bahwa korporasi pun dapat dimintakan pertanggungjawaban pidana. Walau tentunya bukan pidana badan.</p><p>Dalam uraian tersebut, saya melihat terdapat perbedaan-perbedaan konsep subjek hukum. Dalam perdata, subjek hukum adalah orang perseorangan dan badan hukum (berarti non-badan hukum bukan subjek hukum?). Dalam pidana, subjek hukum adalah orang perseorangan. Dalam tindak pidana korporasi, secara khusus diatur bahwa subjek hukumnya adalah tidak hanya orang, tapi juga korporasi (artinya mencakup badan hukum DAN tidak berbadan hukum).</p><p>Lalu bagaimana nantinya dalam penerapan? Kembali kepada prinsip dan asas. Hukum memiliki asas <em>lex speciali derogate legi generali </em>yaitu aturan yang khusus mengesampingkan aturan yang umum. Konsekwensinya, untuk tindak pidana korporasi, badan usaha tidak berbadan hukum juga merupakan subjek hukum dan dapat dimintakan pertanggungjawaban pidana.</p><p>Hal ini memerlukan analisis lebih lanjut tentang konsekwensi-konsekwensi lainnya. Misalnya tentang kaitan konsep subjek hukum dalam tindak pidana korporasi dibandingkan dengan subjek hukum dalam perikatan perdata, kaitannya dengan pemisahan harta pada badan usaha berbadan hukum dan tidak berbadan hukum. Karena sengketa perdata terkait badan usaha, juga pertanggungjawaban pidana sebuah korporasi dalam tindak pidana korporasi, akan bermuara pada kewajiban pembayaran ganti rugi/denda.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d9dae381df4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kriminalisasi LGBT dan Kumpul Kebo, dari Kacamata Ilmu Pidana]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@zennyrezania/kriminalisasi-lgbt-dan-kumpul-kebo-dari-kacamata-ilmu-pidana-df7d72fa058?source=rss-d34c4b5b3216------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df7d72fa058</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kriminalisasi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mahkamah-konstitusi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kejahatan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hukum-pidana-indonesia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[zenny RD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jan 2018 09:13:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-08T09:13:12.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Baru-baru ini Indonesia diramaikan dengan topik Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi yang menolak untuk mengkriminalisasi zina dan hubungan sejenis. Reaksi yang timbul dapat diduga datang dari dua kubu, pro dan kontra. Ada yang menyayangkan dan bahkan mengecam keras putusan MK tersebut, ada pula yang setuju dan menganggap putusan MK tersebut amat logis.</p><p>Putusan MK nomor 46/PUU-XIV-2016 menyatakan bahwa petisi yang dimintakan oleh Guru Besar IPB, Euis Sunarti dan beberapa orang lainnya, ditolak dengan beberapa alasan. Secara garis besar, alasan tersebut adalah, hal-hal yang dimintakan oleh pemohon sudah merupakan pembentukan hukum baru yang merupakan ranah dari pembentuk undang-undang. Pemohon dalam gugatannya meminta agar perbuatan zina, pemerkosaan, dan hubungan sesama jenis sebagaimana diatur dalam Pasal 284 ayat (1) sampai dengan ayat (4) KUHP tentang zina, Pasal 285 KUHP tentang pemerkosaan dan Pasal 292 KUHP tentang pemerkosaan dengan sesama jenis atau di bawah umur adalah bertentangan dengan Pancasila dan UUD 1945 sehingga perlu untuk diperbaharui sifat kriminalnya. Dengan kata lain, untuk perbuatan zina diminta agar diperluas unsur pidananya sehingga dapat mengkriminalkan kumpul kebo, juga agar LGBT dapat dikriminalisasi.</p><p>Mahkamah Konstitusi memutus menolak permohonan tersebut dengan dissenting opinion 4 (empat) hakim dari total 9 (sembilan) hakim. Putusan penolakan tersebut serta merta menimbulkan persepsi beragam dari masyarakat, di mana penolakan tersebut kemudian dianggap sebagai Mahkamah Konstitusi melegalkan LGBT.</p><p>Beberapa opini yang menyayangkan putusan MK tersebut datang dari beberapa pihak, selain dari pihak pemohon sendiri. Beberapa barisan konservatif Islam menyayangkan putusan tersebut. Ketua fraksi PKS, Jazuli Juwaini sebelumnya menuturkan penolakan itu semakin mengancam masa depan generasi bangsa dan tidak sesuai dengan karakter kebangsaan Indonesia yang beradab, bermartabat dan relijius.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><p>Wakil Sekretaris Jenderal MUI Muhammad Zaitun Rasmin mengatakan, putusan itu harus ditinjau ulang oleh MK. Menurutnya, urusan zina dan LGBT merupakan permasalahan besar yang mestinya dijatuhi hukuman pidana.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> Secara umum pihak ini menyatakan bahwa zina dan LGBT melanggar Pancasila khususnya Sila Pertama, Kedua dan Ketiga, serta UUD 1945.</p><p>Salah satu pemohon uji materi, ketua Aila (Aliansi Cinta Keluarga), Rita Soebagio, ada 93 persen masyarakat Indonesia yang tidak setuju homoseksual dan perzinahan. Akhirnya, Rita mengemukakan, para pemohon sepakat untuk mengajukan uji materi ke Mahkamah Konsitusi. Sebab jika menunggu pembahasan KUHP di DPR terlalu lama dan tarikan politiknya sangat besar. Menurut dia, para pemohon yakin Mahkamah Konstitusi akan membahas semua sisi secara komprehensif dan minim tarikan politiknya.<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a></p><p>Sementara, komentar Menteri Agama dan plt Ketua DPR cenderung netral dan hanya meminta masyarakat agar menilai secara obyektif.</p><p>Di sisi lain, dalam peristiwa ini, penting disimak uraian dari komnas wanita sebagaimana dikutip dari aruspelangi.org dalam menanggapi permintaan kriminalisasi zina dan LGBT.</p><p>Pertama, Pemohon tidak memiliki legal standing untuk melakukan uji materiil terhadap Pasal 284, 285, dan 292 KUHP karena Pemohon tidak bisa membuktikan kerugian konstitusional yang bersifat spesifik ataupun khusus dan aktual, serta memiliki hubungan sebab-akibat antara kerugian hak dan/atau kewenangan konstitusional dengan undang-undang yang dimohonkan.</p><p>Kedua, Sebagaimana dinyatakan oleh Para Pemohon bahwa tujuan pengujian ini untuk meminta agar MK melakukan penghapusan dan penambahan kata dan/atau frasa dalam hal ini perluasan makna perzinahan, perkosaan, dan juga perbuatan cabul. Jika merujuk ke Pasal 57 ayat (2A) huruf c Undang-Undang Nomor 8 Tahun 2011 tentang Perubahan Atas Undang-Undang Nomor 24 Tahun 2003 tentang Mahkamah Konstitusi yang menegaskan bahwa putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi tidak memuat rumusan norma sebagai pengganti norma dari undang-undang yang dinyatakan bertentangan dengan Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945. Maka dalam pandangan kami, MK tidak memiliki kewenangan untuk memeriksa perkara ini. Kepentingan Pemohon seharusnya disampaikan kepada lembaga legislatif dalam hal ini DPR dan Pemerintah yang saat ini sedang pada proses revisi Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana.</p><p>Terkait substansi yang disampaikan pemohon, Azriana mengungkapkan bahwa selama ini Komnas Perempuan merasa cukup terbantu dengan keberadaan Pasal 284 ayat (1), ayat (2), ayat (3), ayat (4), dan ayat (5), sebagaimana yang saat ini ada di dalam KUHP dan juga Pasal 292 Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana.</p><p>Ruang lingkup zina sebagaimana yang ada di dalam Pasal 284 ayat (1), ayat (2), ayat (3), dan ayat (4) telah melindungi hak konstitusional warga negara termasuk dalam hal ini perempuan atas perlindungan diri pribadi, keluarga, dan kehormatannya. Hak setiap orang untuk mempertahankan perkawinan dan keutuhan rumah tangganya dalam pandangan kami melalui pasal ini dilindungi secara utuh oleh negara.</p><p>Selain itu, keberadaan Pasal 292 KUHP dengan rumusan yang sekarang telah membantu perempuan korban perkosaan seksual untuk mendapatkan keadilan. Dalam beberapa kasus, penyidik menggunakan Pasal 292 tentang perbuatan cabul ini untuk menjerat pelaku dalam kasus-kasus perkosaan yang sulit dibuktikan karena definisi perkosaan yang masih sangat terbatas dalam KUHP, akhirnya pelaku dijerat dengan Pasal 292. Jadi kami membayangkan kalau pasal ini kemudian dicabut atau diubah, satu-satunya yang bisa melindungi perempuan dari perkosaan itu menjadi tidak ada lagi, sementara kita juga belum memperbaiki KUHP kita.</p><p>Perubahan Pasal 285 KUHP menurut kami perlu dilakukan menyeluruh, bukan sekedar mencabut frasa wanita yang bukan istrinya. Pencabutan frasa ini justru menyebabkan relasi kuasa berbasis gender yang khas mewarnai perkosaan menjadi tidak tampak.</p><p>Kekhawatiran Pemohon tentang tidak adanya perlindungan hukum bagi putera-puterinya adalah tidak berkaitan dengan perluasan definisi Pasal 285 KUHP. Karena sudah ada undang-undang perlindungan anak, khususnya Pasal 281 dan 282 yang menjamin perlindungan anak dari tindak hubungan seksual apalagi pemaksaan hubungan seksual dalam bentuk apapun. Jadi meskipun Pasal 285 itu tidak diperluas, anak-anak kita tetap akan terlindungi karena ada Undang-Undang Perlindungan Anak untuk melindungi mereka.</p><p>Kami ingin menginformasikan benar ada laporan tentang perkosaan terhadap laki-laki dewasa sesuai dengan definisi yang disampaikan Pemohon, tapi kejadian ini hampir selalu berkaitan dengan kondisi korban sebagai laki-laki dengan ekspresi gender yang tidak sesuai dengan harapan masyarakat. Maupun dalam hal ini transeksual, transgender, waria, maupun terhadap laki-laki dengan orientasi seksual sejenis. Jadi, kondisi ini yang membuat mereka rentan menjadi korban perkosaan.</p><p>Hal ini menunjukan bahwa tindakan perkosaan tersebut ditujukan sebagai hukuman yang didasarkan pada diskriminasi berbasis ekspresi gender dan orientasi seksual. Jika kita mengacu kepada Undang-Undang Nomor 5 Tahun 1998 tindakan ini merupakan bagian dari kejahatan penyiksaan. Karenanya perluasan cakupan perkosaan dalam 285 perlu memastikan pengalaman laki-laki Indonesia sebagai korban pemaksaan hubungan seksual tidak direduksi sekedar tindak perkosaan, tetapi juga pengalaman mereka sebagai korban penyiksaan sesual.</p><p>Pemantauan Komnas Perempuan menunjukan kebutuhan untuk membuat norma baru bukan saja terbatas pada pemidanaan, melainkan juga menanganan dan pencegahan, termasuk dalam ini mengubah kebiasaan yang menyalahkan korban, mengawinkan korban dengan pelaku, dan lain-lain. Mengingat kompleksitasnya persoalan kekerasan seksual ini Komnas Perempuan dan jaringannya lebih berorientasi pada proses legislasi di DPR bersama Pemerintah dari pada menyoal satu persatu lewat mekanisme judicial review karena dia butuh perubahan yang menyeluruh. Kebutuhan perluasan definisi perkosaan dan memberikan payung hukum pada penyiksaan seksual telah diakomodasi dalam Rancangan Undang-Undang Penghapusan Kekerasan Seksual yang saat ini sudah masuk dalam Proleknas prioritas tahun 2016.</p><p>Uraian jawaban di atas, menurut hemat penulis, pada beberapa bagian, baik dalam menanggapi permohonan uji materi untuk mengkriminalisasi zina dan homoseksual.</p><p>Bahwa, perluasan makna pasal 284 KUHP, dengan menghilangkan unsur “salah satu atau keduanya yang berzina berada dalam ikatan perkawinan” berakibat hubungan seksual yang dilakukan suka sama suka juga merupakan tindak pidana. Jika dilihat dari perspektif agama, khususnya agama Islam, perbuatan seks yang demikian sudah dikategorikan sebagai zina. Dalam perspektif KUHP nyatanya tidak demikian.</p><p>Mengenai perspektif KUHP tersebut memang perlu diingat bahwa KUHP yang berlaku sekarang ini masih KUHP warisan penjajahan Belanda, sehingga isinya tidak 100% mencerminkan budaya Indonesia. Salah satu contohnya, mengenai definisi zina tersebut.</p><p>Kejahatan sendiri, kriterianya di Indonesia, adalah segala perbuatan yang diatur dalam KUHP dan UU Pidana lainnya. Jadi jika tidak diatur dalam per-UU-an pidana, perbuatan itu bukan kejahatan. Jika kita lihat dari perspektif ilmu pidana, kriminalisasi artinya menjadikan suatu perbuatan yang tadinya bukan kejahatan, menjadi kejahatan (=tindak pidana, dapat dipidana). Dapat kita tentukan perbuatan macam apa yang biasanya diatur sebagai pidana. Ada beberapa unsur,</p><p>- pertama, ada orang yang patut diduga bersalah melakukan perbuatan jahat;</p><p>- kedua, ada perbuatan yang patut diduga memenuhi rumusan pasal kejahatan di UU</p><p>- ketiga, ada hubungan sebab akibat langsung antara kesalahan pelaku+perbuatan yang melawan hokum dan diatur dalam UU, dengan kerugian yang dialami oleh korban.</p><p>Secara garis besar, perbuatan merupakan perbuatan jahat saat perbuatan itu menimbulkan korban. Artinya, korban tidak menghendaki perbuatan tersebut terjadi padanya.</p><p>Dalam hal hubungan seks suka sama suka, kumpul kebo, dan sejenisnya, dapat disimpulkan bahwa perbuatan tersebut tidak memenuhi unsur-unsur kejahatan di atas. Artinya, secara natuur, perbuatan itu tidak dapat memenuhi syarat untuk dinyatakan sebagai tindak pidana.</p><p>Kemudian, menghilangkan unsur delik aduan dalam pasal 284 sesungguhnya membatasi hak setiap keluarga dalam mempertahankan keutuhan rumah tangganya. Bahwa, hal-hal yang terjadi dalam rumah tangga seseorang merupakan hak mutlak keluarga tersebut tentang bagaimana akan ditindaklanjuti. Intervensi hukum yang terlalu besar dalam urusan rumah tangga dapat mendatangkan konsekwensi yang lebih berat, misalnya, kehilangan sosok pencari mata pencaharian (=keadaan ekonomi terganggu), kehilangan sosok ibu (=tumbuh kembang anak terganggu) akibat ayah atau ibunya mau tidak mau harus dipenjara (karena perzinahan menjadi delik biasa atas dasar laporan siapa saja).</p><p>Berikutnya, mengenai pasal 285 KUHP, mengenai perkosaan terhadap wanita. Jika persoalan pasal 285 ini adalah untuk diperluas maknanya agar tidak hanya perkosaan terhadap wanita, tetapi juga terhadap lelaki, maka penjelasan dalam kutipan artikel di atas dapat dijadikan dasar. Bahwa, pemerkosaan terhadap lelaki dapat dikategorikan ke dalam pasal penganiayaan, mengenai penyiksaan seksual. Memang betul, pasal-pasal mengenai kejahatan seksual perlu untuk dirumuskan secara lebih komprehensif dan sistematis. Pemerkosaan terhadap lelaki pun sah saja jika ingin diatur dalam pasal tersendiri. Hanya saja, untuk hal ini, prosedurnya adalah melalui prosedur pembentukan UU yang merupakan kewenangan legislatif, dan bukan kewenangan MK. Pemohon mengatakan bahwa, prosedur normal melalui DPR akan banyak tarikan politik dan tidak akan objektif, maka “jalan pintas” melalui MK ini juga bukan prosedur yang benar. Ini artinya menolak sebuah penyimpangan melalui penyimpangan baru.</p><p>Berikutnya mengenai pasal 292 KUHP tentang perbuatan cabul dengan sesama jenis dan di bawah umur. Pemohon meminta agar frasa “belum dewasa” dihapus sehingga perbuatan cabul antar sesama jenis mencakup segala usia. Untuk masalah ini sekali lagi dapat digunakan pasal penganiayaan, untuk sementara, sampai dengan adanya perubahan KUHP, tanpa menyimpangi kewenangan MK.</p><p>Jika tujuannya adalah untuk mengkriminalisasi hubungan sesama jenis, transgender dan biseksual, maka dapat dibaca kembali unsur-unsur kejahatan yang telah diuraikan pada paragraf sebelumnya. Bahwa pada dasarnya perbuatan dapat dikategorikan sebagai kejahatan jika dapat menimbulkan korban, baik korban individual maupun korban kolektif. Sebagai perbandingan, dapat dianalisis bahwa terhadap pengguna narkoba, melalui SEMA №4/2010, dikenakan rehabilitasi dan bukan dihukum penjara. Pemidanaan adalah bagi yang terlibat dalam perdagangan narkoba. Bagi pelaku prostitusi, terhadap orang yang melakukan hubungan seksualnya tidak ada pidana, melainkan pidana bagi mucikarinya, atau bahkan pelaku perdagangan orangnya.</p><p>Kemudian, mengenai topik kriminalisasi sendiri, Indonesia saat ini sudah over-kriminalisasi. Periode 1998–2014, terdapat 154 UU yang mengandung ketentuan pidana, dari 563 UU yang disahkan. Dalam periode yang sama, terdapat 885 tindak pidana yang telah ada, dan ada tambahan 716 tindak pidana baru.<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> Hal ini memiliki efek domino di mana, penegak hukum kewalahan dengan semakin banyaknya perbuatan yang menjadi masuk kategori pidana dan perlu ditindak melalui hukum acara pidana. Selanjutnya, lembaga pemasyarakatan yang over-capacity, tidak sebanding antara jumlah lapas dengan jumlah penghuni dan calon penghuninya.</p><p>Kenyataan bahwa mayoritas masyarakat Indonesia tidak setuju dengan zina dan LGBT dan meningkatnya fenomena kumpul kebo dan LGBT memang memprihatinkan. Hal tersebut, bagaimana pun, tidak berarti serta merta dapat disimpulkan bahwa dapat diatasi dengan mengubah undang-undang. Seolah-olah dengan mengubah KUHP maka keprihatinan itu akan teratasi.</p><p>KUHP Indonesia yang berlaku saat ini merupakan warisan dari pemerintah kolonial dan perlu diakui beberapa pasalnya sudah tidak efektif lagi untuk Indonesia masa sekarang. Dalam menjembatani masalah gap tersebut, hukum memiliki prinsip-prinsip seperti lex speciali derogate legi generali, yang memungkinkan negara untuk membuat perundang-undangan di luar KUHP untuk mengatur sebuah peristiwa secara lebih spesifik, maupun untuk mengubah pasal-pasal yang dirasa tidak efektif dalam KUHP.</p><p>Mengenai pasal pemerkosaan terhadap anak di bawah umur misalnya, Indonesia melalui Undang-Undang Perlindungan Anak telah memberikan lex speciali-nya mengenai kejahatan anak.</p><p>Dalam permasalahan-permasalahan sosial yang dimohonkan oleh pemohon, penulis setuju bahwa hal-hal tersebut merupakan penyimpangan. Hanya saja, permasalahan sosial demikian terlalu bias moral. Zina dan LGBT terlalu kuat unsur norma agama dan sosialnya, sehingga solusi melalui norma hukum tidak akan tepat. Katakanlah MK mengabulkan permohonan, atau bahkan KUHP diperbaharui sesuai permohonan, maka zina dan LGBT akan tetap ada. Masalah-masalah penyimpangan sosial bukan untuk diselesaikan melalui pasal-pasal dalam undang-undang. Sesungguhnya, undang-undang itu sendiri menjadi bagian dari masalah sosial. Masalah sosial perlu pendekatan sosial. Saat hukum juga merupakan masalah sosial, maka anggapan bahwa undang-undang merupakan solusi dalam mengatasinya adalah sebuah kekeliruan.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Lihat <a href="https://www.cnnindonesia.com/teknologi/20171218173724-192-263316/cuitan-mk-soal-bantah-melegalkan-lgbt">https://www.cnnindonesia.com/teknologi/20171218173724-192-263316/cuitan-mk-soal-bantah-melegalkan-lgbt</a> diakses 22 Desember 2017 jam 14.10.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Ibid.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Lihat <a href="https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/989225-uji-materi-zina-dan-lgbt-ketua-aila-kami-tidak-ujuk-ujuk">https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/989225-uji-materi-zina-dan-lgbt-ketua-aila-kami-tidak-ujuk-ujuk</a> diakses 22 Desember 2017 jam 14.15</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Anugerah Rizki Akbari, Potret Kriminalisasi Pasca Reformasi &amp; Urgensi Reklasifikasi Tindak Pidana di Indonesia, Jakarta Institute of Criminal Justice Reform, 2015.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df7d72fa058" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>