<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Becoming Gnarly - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Essays on choosing the harder path — craft, AI, taste, and what’s still worth making by hand. The gnarl is the record of the struggle. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 22:08:23 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/becoming-gnarly" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Don’t Think I’ll Be Able to Do It]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/i-dont-think-i-ll-be-able-to-do-it-e799204cb2d7?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e799204cb2d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[skateboarding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aging]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[risk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:58:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-19T18:32:48.080Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tbfVuJtNQtB-xZch.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Messi said it in his own words and was wrong by the widest margin available. I’ve said it about myself every decade since thirty. I said it again this fall, from a sling, and this time the forecast has a piece of evidence behind it.</em></p><p>On December 14, 2022, four days before the World Cup final, Lionel Messi told reporters the final would be his last World Cup match. His words: <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/sports/2022/12/14/argentinas-messi-says-qatar-final-to-be-his-last-world-cup-match">“It’s many years for the next one and I don’t think I’ll be able to do it.”</a> He was thirty-five. The man had more information about that particular body than any person alive, he’d just carried it through a semifinal, and he was standing on the largest stage his sport has, saying, in effect, this is the end of the line.</p><p>On June 16, 2026, Argentina opened its World Cup against Algeria and <a href="https://www.nbcwashington.com/world-cup/argentina-algeria-lionel-messi-goal/4117877/">Messi scored three goals</a>. Thirty-eight years old. Just taking the field made him the first man to play in six World Cups, and the hat trick tied Miroslav Klose’s record for the most men’s World Cup goals ever. Nobody older had ever scored three in a World Cup match.</p><p>The size of his self-assessment miss is what stuck with me. A man who predicts his own end and then hangs on for a few cameo minutes has made a small error. Or what we’ve often seen, a hasty unretirement that doesn’t go well. But Messi predicted the end and then at the next World Cup produced a night that would have been the peak of most careers. The hat trick is the least interesting part of that. The forecast is the part worth studying. The best-informed forecaster in the world, forecasting the one body he lives in, missed by the full width of what was possible.</p><p>I’ve made the same forecast about myself at least four times. I started writing this with my arm in a sling, and a couple months later I’m finally finishing it.</p><h3>The self-audit</h3><p>At thirty I was sure skateboarding would be finished by forty. Bodies don’t do that past forty, I thought, with the confidence of someone who had never been forty. At forty, fifty was certainly the end. Vert ramps at fifty are only for a handful of famous people with their names on shoes. At fifty I <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-long-thank-you/">skated vert with friends</a> who had all made the same forecast about themselves and all been wrong on the same schedule. Somewhere in there I also started jumping mountain bike gaps bigger than anything I’d have dared at twenty. The riding I do now, the gaps and the vert, is more dangerous than anything I did when I was young. Each time, I arrived at the spot where the age limit was supposed to be and found it had moved.</p><p>Old accountants tell a joke about audits. Forget the IRS. The nastiest audit is the self-audit, the one where you go through your own return and quietly delete legitimate deductions because they look like they might attract attention. Nobody made you. No agent flagged anything. You imposed a self-tax that no authority ever levied, out of fear of an authority that never showed up.</p><p>That’s the decline forecast, exactly. The years between thirty and the actual end are mine. Legitimate deductions. And at every decade I’ve been ready to forfeit them in advance on the say-so of a prediction I have personally watched fail, over and over, for my entire adult life.</p><p>I used to think the forecast was just pessimistic. A miscalibration. Adjust the number and move on. I no longer think that. The forecast is fearfully pessimistic, which is a different animal. It comes dressed as prudence. It uses the vocabulary of maturity: act your age, don’t push your luck, be reasonable. And underneath the costume it’s the same thing you feel in that self-audit when you delete the home-office deduction. Fear of getting in trouble, converted into a voluntary payment.</p><p>The prudence voice is not always wrong. The eventual limit of age is real. Like all the people predicting the next stock market crash, eventually a forecast is right, and the calendar wins. But the gap between the forecast and the real limit has been, in my experience and in Messi’s, enormous, and everything inside that gap is a year you can either live or pre-pay.</p><p>None of this needs a vert ramp. The same forecast shows up as <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-tax-of-mastery/">the guitar</a> you decided at fifty you’d never be any good at, the degree you’re too old to start, the career you’re too far into to change. It always arrives sounding reasonable, and it almost never shows its work. If you’ve ever said “I’m too old for that” and then watched someone older do it, you’ve caught your own forecaster in the act, the same way Messi caught his.</p><h3>Adapt or couch</h3><p>Middle Tennessee had been in the hundreds for weeks. Consecutive weeks. The people I’d normally skate with had stopped answering the invites, so I’d stopped asking. I don’t blame them. The heat had simply filtered the room down to one person, and that person was me.</p><p>I want to be honest about what the heat is, because there’s a cheap reading and a truer one. The cheap reading is that skating in a hundred-plus degrees is <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/becoming-gnarly/">tough-guy theater</a>. Some difficulty, chosen on purpose, for the story. There’s some minor truth in that, and the reality of toughing out that kind of heat to do something you love is not nothing. But if you live somewhere with seasons, and most of us don’t live in San Diego, the menu that afternoon didn’t have a seventy-degree session on it. The choice was the heat or the couch. And the couch has a cost too. Skill decays. Timing goes. The reps you skip in August don’t wait for you in October. Where I live, progression is tied to weather adaptability. That reads like a slogan but it’s really just a scheduling fact.</p><p>The same filter runs in January. I’m frequently alone in the cold, breath fogging, hands numb on the first few runs, for the identical reason: it’s cold or it’s nothing. Heat alone reads as bravado. Cold alone reads as lonely. Together they’re just what the calendar looks like from a ramp in Tennessee.</p><p>So I was out there, and I was not pushing hard, I was surviving. That’s the part I need you to hold onto. I skate differently in the heat. I pull back, I ride efficiently, I try not to fall, because falling when you’re already cooked is a bad idea and I know it. Also falling in the heat means a climb up a story and a half of stairs, which is its own punishment at a hundred degrees. So I was deliberately having the careful version of a session.</p><p>That’s the one where I went down hard.</p><p>I remember being too much in the backseat landing an air I should’ve bailed, looping out in the flat bottom of the ramp and hitting shockingly hard. There’s a distinct feeling when you hit hard enough to do real damage, and I knew it even as I bounced up onto my feet. I knew it so immediately that in a rare show of frustration I threw my helmet across the ramp in anger and tore all my pads off. And then I settled into the specific loneliness of being the only person available who could evaluate my condition. I decided it was a dislocation. That’s what it felt like, and a dislocation is a thing that sometimes can be put back. So I spent some amount of time in the flat of the ramp, in the heat, writhing around trying to work my own shoulder back into its socket. It didn’t go. It was never going to go, because it wasn’t a dislocation. Eventually I gave up, got myself up, and drove to the emergency room.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-cPAsuEaaSZAM3Iq.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The only second opinion was mine.</em></p><p>My wife calls my skating “cracky.” She’s not wrong, and she’s never been more right than she was that afternoon. I keep the word close, because the other story available to me, the one about carrying something on for a thinning generation of people who still do this, is the most flattering account of a compulsion that exists, and it would get away from me if she weren’t there to say the domestic word next to it.</p><h3>What the audit found</h3><p>A shoulder separation. I handed the X-rays to AI first and got a hopeful grade three, a forecast miss in the other direction. The actual doctor said <a href="https://orthoinfo.aaos.org/en/diseases--conditions/shoulder-separation/">grade five</a>: the ligaments holding the collarbone to the shoulder blade are completely torn, the collarbone rides high, and the joint is permanently misaligned. It’s the same shoulder that’s had two surgeries already. The decision is to skip the third. At least for now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Es2NgkHKXO7McqaF.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Both still within reach.</em></p><p>It was also my second trip to the sidelines this year. In the spring an old knee injury resurfaced, and that one needed surgery and months off of its own. Add them up and I’ve spent about five months of this calendar year hurt, four of them in physical therapy on two different body parts. That’s inching toward half a year spent recovering instead of riding. It isn’t all about age by any means. Neither injury came from a birthday, and the knee was an old debt coming due. But it’s not entirely not about age either, and four months of PT in one year has a way of handing you a reality check.</p><p>Together they did one thing I didn’t expect. It changed what the forecast is made of.</p><p>Messi made his forecast from a healthy body. So did I, at thirty, and at forty, and at fifty. Every one of those predictions was pure projection: a guess about the future, made by a person who had nothing wrong with him yet and was afraid anyway. That’s what made them a self-audit. The deleted deductions were legitimate because no authority had actually found anything.</p><p>This time the audit found something. The doubt I was sitting with those first few weeks in the sling is not the same doubt I had at forty. That one was fear. This one has a radiograph, two if you count the knee. And I don’t know how to sort them cleanly, which I think is the honest place to stand, because the accountant’s joke doesn’t have a second half. Nobody tells you what to do with the return the year after the audit did turn something up. Which of your deductions are still legitimate? All of them? None? The ones that don’t involve the shoulder?</p><p>That question isn’t unique to skaters. It’s the one waiting after the heart scare, the layoff at fifty-five, the business that didn’t make it. The best I’ve managed is to ask what each piece of doubt is made of. The parts that trace back to the X-ray get a vote. The parts that sound exactly like what I was telling myself at forty, before anything was wrong, probably don’t.</p><p>There’s an irony inside the injury that I’ve decided not to resolve. I was riding kinda careful, and careful is when I got hurt. Three explanations are available. One: falls don’t track intent, and how hard you’re pushing has less to do with whether you go down than everybody assumes. Two: the careful version of skating is a mode I’ve practiced far less than the other one. I have three decades of reps going for things and comparatively few riding careful on purpose, and it’s possible I’m simply worse at the version I was attempting. Three: the heat had taken something I couldn’t feel. Reaction time, a half-beat of judgment, over-pumping just a bit. Any of those could be true. I can’t prove one, and picking one would turn the fall into a lesson, and I don’t trust lessons that arrive that conveniently. That said, I’m leaning toward three.</p><h3>The floor</h3><p>I skate and ride with people my age who have received forecasts far more authoritative than anything I’ve told myself. Diagnoses, with numbers attached, delivered by physicians. A prognosis is the most credible decline forecast a human being can be handed. And what I’ve watched, up close, is that even those routinely under-read the runway left inside them. Friends who were told, in effect, this is the shape of what’s left, and who are still out there years later doing things the forecast didn’t have room for. No performative grit, no mindset, none of that vocabulary. Just a forecast that turned out to be wrong in the usual direction, at the maximum possible authority.</p><p>That’s not the whole list, and this is the part I can’t leave out. Not everyone who kept going is still here. Some of the people who ignored the same forecast, took the same kind of risk, rolled the same dice, lost. If I tell you the forecast is unreliable and stop there, I’ve quietly told you that the ones who are gone were doing something wrong. They weren’t. The forecast is unreliable in both directions. It’s too pessimistic about the decline, and it can’t promise you’re the one it will spare. You go anyway. You go because you’ve watched the prediction fail too many times to forfeit on its word. Going has never once meant you win. Still being here isn’t earned. I’ve spent thirty years afraid of saying that sentence the wrong way, and I’d rather say it clumsily than not at all.</p><h3>A couple months later</h3><p>The sling came off eventually. The shoulder is now close to healing into whatever shape it’s going to hold, which is not the shape it had. I’ve already begun easing back into skating again. But a question arrived that I’ve never had to answer with evidence in hand.</p><p>At forty I would have told you the risk was worth it, and I would have been right, and I would have been guessing. At fifty-six, from the flat of a ramp in the heat, trying to fix a joint I’d misdiagnosed, I still think it’s worth it. But I’d be lying if I didn’t say there’s an ever so slightly creeping doubt about whether it’s going to continue to be worth the same risk when I’m fully out of the woods on this one and ready to push hard again. I don’t know for certain, and it’s the first time I’ve said I don’t know at the moment of a forecast. Every previous version came out with total confidence and was wrong.</p><p>Maybe that’s what a finding buys you. The answer stays where it was. What ends is the certainty, in either direction.</p><p>The heat broke a few weeks after the slam. It was seventy degrees and I couldn’t skate. My air-conditioned friends got it right. Somewhere in that is a lesson about the diminishing returns of “no pain, no gain,” but I’m probably too “cracky” to learn it.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/i-dont-think-ill-be-able-to-do-it/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e799204cb2d7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/i-dont-think-i-ll-be-able-to-do-it-e799204cb2d7">I Don’t Think I’ll Be Able to Do It</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[With Malice Toward None]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/with-malice-toward-none-e64b83d3ec1d?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e64b83d3ec1d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Nov 2026 05:03:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-15T05:03:48.642Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kgCpURD0CZBxiQYH.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Lincoln’s sentence is a rule book for winners: be generous to the people you beat, and still hold whoever did wrong to what they did. Grant let the losers keep their horses, Reconstruction forgot who the fight was for, and a few hundred Nashville students kept both halves of it at once.</em></p><p>On the afternoon of April 9, 1865, in the parlor of Wilmer McLean’s house at Appomattox Court House, Virginia, Robert E. Lee asked Ulysses S. Grant for a favor.</p><p><a href="https://www.nps.gov/apco/learn/historyculture/the-surrender-meeting.htm">The terms of the Confederate surrender</a> were already on the table in Grant’s handwriting, and they were more generous than Lee had reason to expect. His men would be paroled, not imprisoned. Officers would keep their sidearms. As long as they kept their word and honored the end of hostilities, no one would be disturbed by federal authorities. But there was something the document didn’t cover. In the Confederate army, the cavalrymen and artillerymen often owned their own horses and mules. Would they be allowed to keep them?</p><p>Grant didn’t rewrite the formal terms, but he said he would instruct his officers to let any man who claimed a horse or mule take it home. Most of these men, he reasoned, were small farmers, and it was already April. A man who walked home to a ruined farm without a horse or mule couldn’t plow a crop, and a family without a crop might not make it through the winter.</p><p>Then Lee mentioned that his army had been living on next to nothing for days. Grant sent over rations for about twenty-five thousand men. To his defeated enemy.</p><p>As word of the surrender spread through the Union lines, the artillery started a celebratory hundred-gun salute. Grant had it stopped. “The Confederates were now our prisoners,” <a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/files/4367/4367-h/4367-h.htm">he wrote years later</a>, “and we did not want to exult over their downfall.” His aide Horace Porter wrote down the order itself: the war is over, and the rebels are our countrymen again.</p><p>Since the election this month, I’ve been thinking a lot about Grant’s handling of that victory, and his rationale for it. Four years of war. Roughly seven hundred thousand dead, more than the American dead of World War I and World War II combined. And at the very moment he’d earned the right to celebrate, the winning general decided that his army’s joy would not be fired over the heads of the men it had beaten.</p><p>Five weeks earlier, at <a href="https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/lincoln2.asp">his second inauguration</a>, Abraham Lincoln had already set the tone. With the war all but won, he closed with a single sentence:</p><blockquote><em>With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right, as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in, to bind up the nation’s wounds…</em></blockquote><p>It may be the most quoted sentence about reconciliation in American history. It’s also one of the most misremembered, because people tend to stop after the first two phrases. Read all the way through, it’s a rule book for winners, and it comes to this: be generous to the people you beat, hold whoever did wrong to what they did, and don’t lose track of who got hurt. The hard part is keeping all of it at once. I learned that from my own corner of the world, where we kept some of Lincoln’s words and dropped the others, and I’m writing it down because I can feel how easy they are to get wrong.</p><p>I was born in Nashville and have lived just south in Franklin since I was a young teenager. You can’t get hot chicken in downtown Franklin without walking past a cannon, and I live only a few miles from the field where five of the bloodiest hours of the Civil War played out. Remnants of that war are everywhere here, and some of them are pretty odd given the stakes of the conflict. Just down the street from where I live is a neighborhood called Battlewood. Some of the street names: General J B Hood Dr, Jeb Stuart Dr, and General N B Forrest Dr. Remember that last guy, we’ll come back to him. At my high school, we were the Franklin Rebels. The thing is, when you grow up in an area steeped in history, your day-to-day life tends to normalize it and just kinda tune it out.</p><p>Yet it still matters, and I should say how. An election is not a surrender. Nobody stacked rifles this month, nobody is anybody’s prisoner, and whoever won will be on the losing end again soon enough. No election I’ve voted in weighs what that war weighed. What carries from 1865 to an ordinary November is smaller: the moment after a fight when one half of a country has the upper hand, and has to decide what the other half is to them now.</p><p>I’ve never belonged to a political party, and I don’t vote for one. I vote for ideas, as held by people, one race at a time. Plenty of my friends and family vote in ways that cancel mine out. This month most of the people I voted for won, except here at home, where the people I vote for usually lose. So I’ve spent November on both ends of a win, and at each end, people I know and love are standing at the other. That’s fine. The temptation I’m about to warn against isn’t a party’s. It’s a winner’s.</p><p>I know what the losing end sounds like. Two years ago, on an election night that went the other way, a family illness put me in a hospital with people I love, none of whom had voted the way I did. I was there to help, and I wanted to be. Sometime that night I heard one of them, out of what they thought was earshot, call me one of “them.” It wasn’t gloating. It was sorting, about the person who’d come to sit with them, and it had nothing to do with anything I’d done that night. I expect I’d have heard the same word if their people had lost. That’s what sorting is: a verdict on what kind of person you are, passed without reference to anything you did. Everybody does it, on winning nights and losing ones. Winning is when it starts to matter, because the winner is the one in a position to act on it.</p><p>I’ve thought about that remark more than I’d like, so here is an honest accounting of what I’ve carried since. Not an appetite for gloating; I’ve never had much of one. I do keep a list, of sorts. Whoever you voted for, I’d guess you have one too, so the particulars of mine don’t matter here. Mine isn’t written down, and what’s on it is things that were done, things I think somebody should have to answer for in a court of law. I notice how good it feels to want that. I notice, too, that the entries don’t stay things. Left alone, an act turns into the people who did it, and then into people like them, and by then it’s my own “them.” I know what that feeling built, right here, once it got to run things. I’ll get to it.</p><h3>Malice toward none, charity for all</h3><p>Three days after the surrender, on April 12, the Confederate infantry marched in to lay down their rifles. Joshua Chamberlain, the Maine college professor who had held Little Round Top at Gettysburg, commanded the Union troops lining the road. As John B. Gordon led the first gray column past, Chamberlain had a bugle sound, and his men shifted their rifles from “order arms” to “carry arms,” the marching salute. Gordon had been riding with his head down. He heard the rifles move, understood what they meant, wheeled his horse, dropped the point of his sword to his boot, and ordered his own men to answer in kind. Chamberlain called it honor answering honor.</p><p>Chamberlain’s fullest account of it came fifty years later, and <a href="https://www.bowdoin.edu/news/2015/04/patrick-rael-chamberlain-appomattox.html">historians still argue</a> over how much of it is polish. Either way, it’s the picture the country chose to remember.</p><p>What Grant and Chamberlain understood is that the way you win decides whether the fight is actually over. Humiliate a beaten man and you’ve only sown the seeds of the next fight. Europe learned that at Versailles in 1919, when the winners made Germany <a href="https://avalon.law.yale.edu/imt/partviii.asp">accept the blame for the whole war</a> in writing, handed it the bill, and got about twenty years of peace for the trouble. Let him keep his horse and feed his men, and you’ve given him a reason to go home and plant.</p><p>There’s a plainer reason too. I’ve never understood what the endgame of sorting is supposed to be. In every version I can picture, the other half is still here in the morning, in the next pew and the next hospital room. Secession was the one time half of us tried for a version where they weren’t, and it took four years of war to settle that we don’t get that option. So when the winner called the losers countrymen again, it was a plain description before it was a kindness.</p><p>None of the generosity was a verdict on the cause. In the same chapter of his memoirs where he stops the salute, Grant calls what those men fought for “one of the worst for which a people ever fought, and one for which there was the least excuse.” He fed them anyway. The judgment stayed on the cause, and he took it off the men.</p><p>That’s malice toward none and charity for all. It’s the part of Lincoln’s sentence everybody remembers. It’s also the part that turned out easy to keep, as long as it stayed between white men. Letting a beaten man keep his horse cost the winner nothing he wanted.</p><h3>Firmness in the right</h3><p>The whole sentence didn’t last. Five days after Appomattox, Lincoln was shot at Ford’s Theatre. The man who wrote the sentence never got to carry it out.</p><p>There were people in the North who wanted the accounting I want, and didn’t stop where I stop: hang the generals, make them all pay for the tragedy they caused. Lincoln had held them off. What actually happened over the next twelve years was stranger. Malice came back, but aimed at the newly freed people, while charity flowed easily between the white men who’d fought each other. The Confederate farmer walked home with his mule. The freedman on the Carolina and Georgia coast, promised forty acres of his own by <a href="https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/history-archaeology/shermans-field-order-no-15/">a field order that January</a>, had the land taken back by autumn.</p><p>The fighting didn’t end. It moved, from the battlefields to ballot boxes, courthouses and back roads after dark. And it started here in my home state. In the months after the surrender, six Confederate veterans met in <a href="https://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entries/ku-klux-klan/">a law office in Pulaski, Tennessee</a>, about an hour south of where I’m sitting, and started a secret club. They called it the Ku Klux Klan. By 1867, Nathan Bedford Forrest, a Memphis slave trader turned cavalry general, had become its first Grand Wizard. That’s the Forrest on the street sign down the road from me. The matching white robes and the burning crosses came later, with the 1915 revival, but the work was the same from the start: within a year the club was a campaign of terror against freed people and anyone who stood with them. Atrocities against countrymen, done from behind a mask.</p><p>Now go back to John B. Gordon, the Confederate general who answered Chamberlain’s salute on that Virginia stage road. After the war he was <a href="https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/government-politics/john-b-gordon-1832-1904/">generally acknowledged as the head of the Klan in Georgia</a>. Called before Congress in 1871, he denied it, admitting only to membership in a secret “peace police.” By 1877, as a United States senator, he was one of the architects of the deal that settled a disputed presidential election by pulling federal troops away from the last two Southern statehouses they were still protecting. That bargain left four million freed people and their children to the night riders, and then to Jim Crow, for most of the next century.</p><p>I don’t think that makes the salute a lie. I think it shows what honor meant to Gordon: a debt owed to other white soldiers, never to the people they had held in bondage. Charity can be sorted by kind as easily as blame can.</p><p>North and South did reconcile, after a fashion. By the turn of the century, white veterans in blue and gray were shaking hands at reunions on the old battlefields. The historian <a href="https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674008199">David Blight has shown</a> what that reunion cost: it was bought by quietly writing the freed people out of the story. White North and white South extended charity to each other, and paid for it with the people the war had been fought over.</p><p>That’s the failure Lincoln’s third phrase guards against. Firmness in the right doesn’t take back the charity. It’s aimed at something else. Be as generous as you like to the people you beat, but never to the cruelty itself, and never at the expense of the people it hurt.</p><p>From the outside, firmness and malice look alike, but there’s a way to tell them apart. Firmness goes after an act. It starts with a thing that was done, follows it to the person who did it, and uses the laws that were on the books before the thing was done, in the courts that were already there. Malice goes after a kind of person. No old law covers being the wrong kind, so malice has to write new ones for the occasion. That’s what Versailles did, with a whole nation as the defendant. And in a country that votes every two years, a law written for the occasion gets handed to whoever wins next. Malice has a quieter form too: start with a person and go looking for something to charge them with. That one uses the old laws and the old courts, and it’s still malice, with better paperwork.</p><p>The test doesn’t flatter my own story. Treason was a crime long before the war, and in June 1865 a federal grand jury in Norfolk <a href="https://athenaeumreview.org/essay/did-robert-e-lee-commit-treason/">indicted Lee for it</a>. Grant insisted the parole he’d written at Appomattox covered Lee too, and said later that he would have resigned his command before arresting him. The case went no further. By my own test, a trial for Lee, by name, under a law older than the war, would have been firmness. “Make them all pay” was the malice. The country did neither. I think Grant was right to keep his word, and I think it’s fair to ask what that cost.</p><p>I ran my own list through the test too. Most of it passes: things that were done, under old laws, in old courts, crimes that were crimes before anybody voted. I’m keeping that part. Wanting someone to answer, by name, for a thing they did isn’t malice, however good it feels. What doesn’t pass is the place where the list had stopped being about acts and started being about my neighbors. I’d like some of them to own what they’ve said, and there’s no law for that, and there shouldn’t be. I can tell a neighbor to their face that I think they were wrong, they can tell me the same, and that’s where it ends.</p><p>Firmness and malice are two things a winner can do with a win. Forgetting is another, and it’s quieter than either. By 1877 the laws that protected the freed people were already written: three amendments and <a href="https://www.senate.gov/artandhistory/history/common/generic/EnforcementActs.htm">the Enforcement Acts</a> that put night riders in federal court. The country stopped using them, and the courts narrowed what was left. Only then did the Southern statehouses start writing new laws for the occasion, and the one usually counted first came out of Tennessee, in 1881. They were laws about a kind of person, and about nothing any of those people had done. This is the thing I said I’d get to: a “them” with a legislature. That was Jim Crow: malice, with forgetting as its permission slip. The reconciliation kept the charity and let go of the firmness. And charity without firmness isn’t grace. It’s forgetting.</p><h3>Both at once</h3><p>Nearly a century later, in Nashville, a group of college students showed what it looks like to keep all of Lincoln’s sentence at once.</p><p>Starting in February 1960, students from Fisk, Tennessee A&amp;I, American Baptist and Meharry <a href="https://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entries/sit-ins-nashville/">sat down at downtown lunch counters</a>, asked to be served, and were refused, cursed, beaten and arrested. They’d trained for it in workshops run by James Lawson, a young minister who taught that nonviolence wasn’t the same thing as being passive, and that the aim was to bring your opponent around rather than to beat him.</p><p>At about 5:30 on the morning of April 19, someone threw dynamite at the North Nashville home of <a href="https://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entries/zephaniah-alexander-looby/">Z. Alexander Looby</a>, the Black attorney defending the arrested students and a Republican member of the city council. The blast wrecked the house and blew out windows across the street at Meharry Medical College. Looby and his wife, Grafta, came out of it unhurt. Nobody was ever charged.</p><p>By that afternoon, about three thousand people were marching downtown to confront Mayor Ben West. They marched in silence. The way the story has been told ever since, all you could hear was shoe leather. West came out to meet them on the courthouse steps. He was already arguing with one of the ministers when a young Fisk student named <a href="https://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entries/diane-j-nash/">Diane Nash</a> cut in with a question:</p><blockquote><em>Mayor West, do you feel that it’s wrong to discriminate against a person solely on the basis of his race or color?</em></blockquote><p>West said yes. Years later he said the question had been put to him as a man, and “it was a moral question and it was one that a man has to answer and not a politician.” Three weeks later, on May 10, six downtown stores served Black customers at their lunch counters for the first time. Nashville became the first major city in the South where a sit-in campaign won.</p><p>Look at what Nash didn’t do. She didn’t demand that he admit defeat, or apologize, or resign. She asked him a question and left him room to answer it honestly. Notice what the march didn’t ask for, either. Whoever threw the dynamite was never caught, though they should have been, and the three thousand who walked downtown that afternoon didn’t make catching them the price of the counters. They asked for the counters.</p><p>The firmness never wavered. The sit-ins had gone on for months, through beatings and a bombing, and they would have gone on as long as it took. The question carried that firmness too. It was about an act, asked in front of three thousand people, and it didn’t let him off. The charity was in the same question: she put it to a man she assumed could still answer. Neither cost her any of the other. She had every reason to call him one of “them.” She asked him instead. That’s the whole thing I’m trying to say, and a twenty-one-year-old in 1960 said it better on some courthouse steps.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0keseOXzaAyY4uTW.jpg" /></figure><p><em>They asked for the counters.</em></p><p>As a teenager in the eighties I spent afternoons a few blocks up the hill from those steps, at Legislative Plaza, which had <a href="https://www.tennessean.com/picture-gallery/news/local/2017/02/14/nashville-then-february-1987/97892492/">the best stairs in the city for a skateboard</a>. The lunch counters were a block away. In school we’d certainly learned about slavery and the Civil War. We learned precious little about the struggle that had happened down the street, only about twenty-five years earlier, within the memory of most of my teachers. Nobody mentioned it, and we didn’t ask. That’s forgetting from the inside. It doesn’t feel like anything.</p><p>Today the plaza at the foot of the courthouse steps <a href="https://tennesseelookout.com/2024/04/21/nashville-honors-civil-rights-leader-diane-nash/">is named for her</a>.</p><h3>Close to home</h3><p>Twenty miles south, in Franklin, Lincoln’s whole sentence is laid out in brick and bronze, and you can walk it in an afternoon.</p><p>On November 30, 1864, the Confederate Army of Tennessee threw itself at Union lines dug in around the town. In about five hours, roughly 9,500 men were killed, wounded, captured or missing. <a href="https://boft.org/carnton">Carnton</a>, the McGavock family’s plantation house at the edge of the field, became the largest field hospital. The bodies of four Confederate generals were laid out on its back porch. The bloodstains are still on the floors.</p><p>Carrie McGavock, the lady of the house, helped tend the wounded for months. They were Confederates, her own army. In 1866, she and her husband gave two acres beside their family graveyard for nearly 1,500 Confederate dead, and she kept that cemetery and its record book until she died in 1905. It was mercy, and it was real. It was also mercy for her own, which is the kind that came easiest to everyone in this story.</p><p>Carrie McGavock was also a slaveholder. On the night of the battle, it was the people she enslaved who were ordered to help with the wounded. After emancipation, Black workers helped her keep the cemetery for the rest of her life, and Mariah Reddick, a woman she had owned since girlhood, never lived at Carnton after the war but nursed the McGavocks for the rest of their lives. Mercy and the cause it served, under one roof. Both are things she did, and neither settles what kind of person she was. If you want to know how decent people hold indefensible things, Carnton is the building.</p><p>In 2017, after the violence in Charlottesville, three Franklin pastors, Chris Williamson, Kevin Riggs and Hewitt Sawyers, began meeting with Eric Jacobson, a historian with the Battle of Franklin Trust, about the Confederate soldier who stands atop the monument in our town square. Locals call the statue Chip, after the piece of hat it lost when it was hoisted up in 1899. Not everyone found it cute. The pastors came in wanting it gone. They chose a different path. Instead of taking anything away, they would add what was missing. In 2019, <a href="https://visitfranklin.com/history/the-fuller-story-project/">five markers went up around the square</a> telling the history the monument left out: the enslaved people once sold within sight of that spot, the Black soldiers who fought for the Union, the violence that met freedmen afterward. In 2021, a bronze statue of a United States Colored Troops soldier went up on the square, facing the old one.</p><p>It wasn’t frictionless. It took a lawsuit to settle who owned the square, but the aldermen approved the markers unanimously, and it got done. Sawyers, who grew up under Jim Crow and had kept away from the square most of his life because of the statue, said after the unveiling that “now downtown belongs to me too.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*o3uADsn8GCD-8OF6.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Nothing taken away. The missing part added.</em></p><p>Nobody is punished by those markers. Everyone they describe is long dead, and much of what they describe was legal when it happened. That’s the firmness left when there’s nobody to try: the record. Say what happened, in plain words, where people have to walk past it. The markers record acts. People were sold here.</p><p>Nobody’s ancestors were erased. Nobody’s suffering was left out. Two soldiers stand across the street from each other in my town, and between them they carry the first three parts of Lincoln’s sentence. The North wrote that sentence. In Nashville and in Franklin, the South showed how to live it. Eventually.</p><h3>As God gives us to see the right</h3><p>The fourth phrase is the one winners skip.</p><p><em>As God gives us to see the right.</em> Lincoln said it at the moment he’d been proven right in the most terrible way imaginable. And he chose that moment to admit that he could see the right only as far as he’d been given to see it.</p><p>Earlier in the same speech, he said something even harder. Both sides, he said, “read the same Bible and pray to the same God, and each invokes His aid against the other.” And then: “let us judge not, that we be not judged.” He wasn’t saying both sides were equally right. He had just spent four years, his entire presidency, saying otherwise. He was saying that being right doesn’t make you righteous, and that the winners are the ones most likely to confuse the two. I’ve been right about things and insufferable about them in the same afternoon.</p><p>I don’t share Lincoln’s faith, <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/just-as-i-am/">as I’ve said elsewhere</a>, and I’ve leaned on his sentence anyway. You don’t need his God to keep his humility. Whatever we credit for our sense of right, whether it’s scripture or conscience or the way we were raised, we can still be wrong about part of it. Three pastors in my town walked into a meeting sure the statue had to come down, and what they built instead was better than what they came for. Nobody needs a win to forget that, though whoever just won is the most tempted. I was on the receiving end of that certainty in a hospital two years ago, and I’ve caught my own list sliding from acts to a “them” since. That’s why the test sends my list to a court and not to me. A court is how someone who might be wrong still gets to be firm. Holding conviction and doubt at once is the hardest thing in the sentence, and Lincoln didn’t pretend otherwise. His verb was strive.</p><h3>To finish the work we are in</h3><p>Lincoln’s sentence doesn’t stop at seeing the right. It goes on to the work: bind up the nation’s wounds, and care for “him who shall have borne the battle,” and for his widow and his orphan. It turns to the people the fight cost.</p><p>That answers the thing I confessed up top. The wanting I described looks back, at what was done and who did it. Lincoln’s sentence looks somewhere else, at the people who bore the cost. Reconstruction didn’t fail because too few generals hanged. It failed because the people the war had been fought over were left alone with the men who’d lost it. Nashville’s marchers knew the difference. They asked for the lunch counters. The first question for a winner is who you’re going to protect. How hard to hit comes second.</p><p>So a win leaves three sets of people in front of you. The ones who voted the other way keep their horses. They’re countrymen, they did nothing a court would recognize, and what you owe them is what you think was wrong, said to their faces. They owe you the same. The ones who did things answer for them, by name, under the old laws, and they’re countrymen before and after. What no law reaches still goes on the record, the way five markers on a town square put it there. First come the ones the things were done to. The measure of the win is whether they’re better off a year from now, and only after that whether anything on your list has been answered for.</p><p>Some of the people who lost will call any accounting vengeance, however it’s done. Appomattox didn’t buy Gordon’s consent either. The sentence was never addressed to the losers. It was addressed to the winners, and this month that’s me in most of the country and my neighbors here at home.</p><p>Nothing in this story stayed won by itself. Not the surrender, not the amendments, not the counters. Every one of them had to be kept by somebody the year after, and the years nobody did are when it came apart.</p><p>The last thing the sentence asks for is “a just and lasting peace among ourselves.” It takes both words. The bargain of 1877 lasted most of a century, and it wasn’t just. Versailles called itself just, and lasted twenty years. Firmness is how a peace gets to be just, charity is how it gets to last, and neither can do the other’s job.</p><p>So if the people you voted for just won, whoever they were: let the people who lost keep their horses, even the ones who called you “them.” Hold people to what they did, by name, and never to what kind of people they are. Know who your win was for, and look in on them after the celebrating stops. And remember that you might be wrong.</p><p>In the spring of 1865, thousands of men in gray walked home from Virginia leading horses they’d been allowed to keep. Most of them were farmers. That same spring, along the Carolina and Georgia coast, freed families were working land they’d been promised, and most would not be allowed to keep it. It was April. There was still time to plant.</p><p><em>This is the first piece of a longer project,</em> <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/bless-our-hearts/">Bless Our Hearts</a>, <em>about the South, my hometown, and the kind of character my great-grandfather meant when he said he voted for the man, not the party. Bless our hearts.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/with-malice-toward-none/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e64b83d3ec1d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/with-malice-toward-none-e64b83d3ec1d">With Malice Toward None</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Just As I Am]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/just-as-i-am-b5ca160aa4f6?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5ca160aa4f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[atheism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2026 03:10:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-12T03:10:02.510Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CzzPDC3zmhonBoeY.png" /></figure><p><em>We were church people in streaks. The faith never took with me, but I learned what wanting to believe looks like, and lately I’ve started sensing that want again.</em></p><p>We were church people in streaks. In the Tennessee I grew up in, most people were church people, and most were less streaky than us.</p><p>Some years we were there every time the doors opened — Sunday morning, Sunday night, Wednesday supper in the fellowship hall. Then a streak would end, quiet as it started, and months would go by without anyone mentioning it. Then years. Then a gospel singing, or a move, or some private weather between my parents I never saw, and the switch flipped back on. Nobody explained it. You woke up one Sunday and you were a family that went, and a few years later you were a family that didn’t, and both conditions felt permanent while they lasted. It didn’t even really feel strange. As a kid I relished the off times because I got my Sundays back.</p><p>I’ve spent a lot of time in churches, long past the years I had no say in it. Once I was grown and could keep my Sundays, every wedding, funeral, and stray family member seeking redemption drew me back, to witness and support. I was never far from it.</p><p>What I’m after is bigger and stranger than anything I happen to believe: how gods get made — who does the assembling, what powers the belief, what the finished thing can and can’t do — and the newest candidate for the job, which is being assembled right now, in plain sight. I should be precise, though: I never watched a god get made. The one in my building was finished centuries before anyone now alive arrived. History has kept minting smaller gods since — some so recent their receipts are still in print, and we’ll get to them — but what those pews showed me was the other end of the process, the transmission and the maintenance, the careful handing of a finished god to the next generation so the culture holds together. That turns out to be most of what a working religion is. Which is exactly why the newest candidate is so intriguing: this time it’s the front end of the line that’s running, the actual making, at a scale nobody has seen since scripture. I know the back half of the assembly line by heart. Consider what follows my credentials.</p><p>Our church was always either Southern Baptist or Free Will Baptist, which I’ve since learned to describe to people who weren’t raised in it as moderately extreme. Hellfire, but preached in a friendly accent. Like Dylan before 1965, the churches I went to through the 70s and 80s had yet to go electric. The building had hard pews and a baptismal pool built into the wall behind the pulpit like an aquarium waiting on a fish, and everything about the hour ran on rails I could have recited in my sleep: the hymns, the offering, the sermon rising and falling, and then the part the whole service had been aiming at all along.</p><h3>The invitation</h3><p>Every service ended the same way, with every head bowed and every eye closed and the congregation singing “Just As I Am” while the preacher stood down front, waiting. If nobody walked the aisle, we sang another verse. There are only so many verses, and I can assure you that was never the constraint. I understood what walking meant socially years before I understood what it meant theologically: the tears, the hugging, the being gathered over. A kid learns the choreography of salvation long before anybody explains the doctrine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZefL0wBsbEpCicku.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Just as I am, without one plea. Another verse.</em></p><p>My family walked once, which looks odd from here: a whole family needing salvation on the same Sunday. Surely we didn’t all stray together. But I guess we did, or my parents felt like we did. The doing of it felt like being made — the whole family inducted together, the way the mob makes its men, with fried chicken and blackberry cobbler afterward to seal it. I didn’t think much about that salvation but it would come around again, and much more personally.</p><p>A year or two later it was a summer Vacation Bible School, or VBS, an acronym the South expects you to know as part of life like the IRS or KFC. There was a pretty heavy class, I guess you’d call it, and it ended with a hard sell to come up and officially accept Jesus as your lord and savior. I wouldn’t exactly call it peer pressure because the pressure wasn’t coming from the peers. It felt a bit more like an expected part of participating in the experience, so I went along. I don’t regret it; you can’t hold a kid to a commitment he didn’t understand. I wasn’t mature enough to be for it or against it. I was indifferent. I felt nothing where the room around me appeared to be feeling everything — like being the one kid in the theater the movie doesn’t work on. Everybody else flinching and crying at what’s on the screen, and all I could ever see was the projector light. It wasn’t the equipment, either. Star Wars lit me up that same era like it lit up everybody — I knew exactly what it felt like when the movie works. It just never once worked in that building with all the stained glass.</p><h3>The aquarium</h3><p>And somewhere in there — after the VBS summer, I think, though I’ve tried and I honestly can’t place it — I was baptized. Full immersion, the Baptist way. The aquarium behind the pulpit finally got its fish.</p><p>You don’t get to an aquarium behind a pulpit in one step. Baptism started as a wild man dunking people in a river — John, out in the Jordan, camel hair and honey, plunging whole grown bodies under. The Greek word underneath <em>baptize</em> just means to plunge. Over most of the centuries since, most churches trimmed the rite down to a sprinkle on an infant’s forehead, but the Baptists made their name insisting on the original: whole believer, whole body, fully under water. For a long time that meant the creek. Congregations walked down to moving water in their Sunday clothes and did it the Jordan way, current and water moccasins and all. Then the buildings got nicer and the water moved indoors: a tank sunk into the wall behind the pulpit, plumbed, glass-fronted, sometimes heated, with steps down into it like a small rectangular hot tub.</p><p>A lot of those tanks have a river painted on the wall behind them. A mural of the Jordan, hung as scenery behind the plumbing that replaced it. A visiting anthropologist would marvel at it — the congregation dresses in its best clothes to watch a child be lowered backward into a tank of water by a man wearing waders under his robe, everyone cries, and afterward there is a potluck. I’m not mocking it. Every sacred thing sounds like this when described from outside; inside is where the sacred lives. I’m just reporting that it’s possible to be soaking wet at the exact center of the rite and still be outside it.</p><p>Here’s the strange part: I can barely remember it. The hinge of my eternity, the one moment that whole machine existed to produce, and I couldn’t tell you what was said over me, what I wore, whether the water was warm or cold. I can still walk you through birthday parties and bicycle stunts from those same years. Whatever the water was supposed to write on me, the ink never took. My memory ran its own quiet accounting and filed the biggest day of my soul’s life somewhere behind a memorable birthday cake and a beat-up Huffy.</p><p>Almost nothing else survived that fog. The one thing that did is my parents’ faces. It made them so happy — a pride with a shine on it I didn’t often see — and the pride confused me in a way I wouldn’t have had words for then, because pride was for things you did, and I hadn’t done anything. I’d walked a few feet and gotten wet, with assistance. What I see in those faces now is relief — a rescue confirmed. As far as they believed, their boy was safe forever, in the only ledger that really matters, and the pride was love wearing doctrine’s clothes. I can’t hold that against anybody. But notice what my memory kept and what it dropped. The water, the words, the eternity — gone. Their faces — kept. Even then, some part of me knew where the weight in that room really was.</p><h3>Nothing on the line</h3><p>People talk about losing their faith, and I’ve read enough of those stories to know mine isn’t one. Loss isn’t the shape of it. There was never anything to lose. What there was instead, for a kid, was a long apprenticeship in sitting still while a room wants something — and, if I’m honest, in arranging my face to match. I learned to perform the thing I didn’t feel, because I was eight or ten or twelve and performing it was the price of the potluck and the peace. I’d call that my first fluency in a language I’ve been reading everywhere since. And I never turn down cobbler.</p><p>There was one more thing that kept me feeling like a visitor, and nobody else in the building seemed to find it strange. The way people talked about talking to God was so literal. And not loosely literal, the way you’d describe a feeling. They reported back on prayer the way you’d report on a phone call: God told me to take the job. We prayed on it and got our answer Tuesday. He laid it on my heart to speak to you. And I would sit there running quiet diagnostics on myself, because I had never once heard anything back. Not a voice, not a nudge I could honestly tell apart from my own wanting. I spoke out loud and waited, listening carefully for a response. Nothing, ever. C-3PO and R2-D2 came through fine; it was only heaven I couldn’t pick up. For years I genuinely wondered whether something was wrong with my receiver — whether everybody else had been issued equipment I didn’t get. Though I’ll admit I noticed, even then, that the answers people got back had a way of agreeing with the people who got them.</p><h3>The word in print</h3><p>For a good stretch of my adult life, all of that curdled. I came out of those pews with a hostility toward performed piety that I carried like it was a virtue — the loudest public pray-ers, the fish on the bumper of the car that just cut you off. I kept it to myself, but I felt it. It took me an embarrassing number of years to notice that my contempt was aimed at people doing exactly what I’d done in the pew, only with less choice about the room they’d been born into. My family’s streaks had accidentally shown me the door — every off-year another proof that the room was optional, a seed of honesty my parents never knew they were planting. Most of the people I sneered at never saw a door. And I shouldn’t pretend the door made it free. The stakes were never much different; I just ate the consequences internally, paying in the quiet currency of not being myself.</p><p>The external bill came years later, and I wasn’t expecting it, because the week it arrived should have been one of the best of my life. My wife and I and another couple, close friends, had created a board game together — designed it, funded it ourselves, printed a thousand copies — and the local paper gave us <a href="https://www.nashvillescene.com/news/toy-story/article_50dfd582-af38-519b-9e54-ce0b87c2da02.html">a cover story</a>. A feature, in print, about a thing we had made. Somewhere in the interview, describing how opposite the two couples were, my wife said it for both of us, in passing, as a plain fact: atheist. Nobody was confessing and nobody was declaring; she said it the way you’d say your hometown. Then the paper came out, and the word sat there in print, and my parents read it. What came back was disappointment — complete, leveling, the brutal kind — and it rolled right over the cover story like the story wasn’t there. Mostly what I remember feeling was shock; the hurt arrived later and stayed longer. I had made something good enough to be newsworthy, and the only thing my family could see was one honest sentence. It took me years to read that week the way I read it now: theirs were the baptism faces running in reverse. The pride at the tank had been relief, their boy safe forever. The disappointment was the same arithmetic with the sign flipped: I had just been announced unsafe, in print, where God and the neighbors could both read it. They had been proud of something done to me, then crushed by something I’d made, because of one word it carried. Love wearing doctrine’s clothes, again. There was never a free way to sit in that room. There still isn’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4S4iGXEfbko8Ds3b.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The only sentence my family could see.</em></p><p>If you didn’t grow up where I grew up, the voltage in that one word might not translate. In the South, and across most of the middle of the country, <em>atheist</em> lands as an accusation. It’s one of the ugliest labels you can fasten to a person’s name in print — strong enough, as I found out, to flatten an accomplishment. The polls have said some version of this for half a century: Americans will accept almost any identity in a candidate before they’ll accept that one, and no serious contender for President has ever worn the word openly. You declare your love of God and country, as if they’re inseparable beliefs, or you keep your unbelief to yourself. I’ve long joked that we’ll know the acceptance work is done when an open atheist can run for the office. Nobody’s laughing yet, mostly because nobody’s running.</p><p>And underneath the joke sits the thing that took me longest to say plainly: none of it was ever a choice. I didn’t pick unbelief off a shelf, and I couldn’t return it — I tried, more than once, sincerely, and learned that you can no more decide your way into a belief than decide your way into a different height (graduating high school at 5&#39;2&quot;, I tried that too). Which is the part the disappointment never accounted for. You can only be disappointed in a decision, and there wasn’t one. The same goes for them. They didn’t decide to be afraid for me any more than I decided to give them cause. It’s also why I reach for the language of acceptance at all, claiming the shape of that fight and none of its scale: being held in contempt for something you can’t change is a story this country knows by heart. The difference is the roster. The other versions of that fight eventually drew crowds. This one recruits thin, because belief in a god isn’t one opinion among many in most of the culture — it’s the baseline, the thing even broad-minded people quietly require before extending full respect. Unbelief may be one of the last unchosen things polite company still holds against a person.</p><h3>What the building was doing</h3><p>The contempt didn’t last. I’ve softened, and politeness had nothing to do with it. I paid attention to what that stained-glass building was doing, separate from what it was claiming. The casseroles that showed up within hours when somebody died. The man who stayed sober one more week partly because Sunday was coming and people would look for him. The widow with somewhere to be. And the old people. All the old people, who, to a kid with bicycles to ride and fish to catch, had seemingly signed up for the weirdest social club. But all they wanted was togetherness. I’m getting up there in age myself now, and I get it. I still think the premise is wrong. But I no longer think the premise is the point. A church, done correctly, is a machine for holding people tight, and the fact that I believe the blueprints are fiction has turned out to matter less than I once needed it to.</p><p>Here is the part that surprises people, though it stopped surprising me a long time ago. The kid who could only see the projector grew up wanting the movie to work. I want to believe — I’d take the comfort, the company, the someday reunion, all of it, gladly. What I can’t do is get there on what’s been offered. The nearest I’ve come to naming my position is this: atheism toward what’s been offered <em>so far</em>. It’s a review of the catalog, and the catalog isn’t closed. I’m not claiming to know what’s out past the edge of things. I’m declining to furnish it on hope. That’s what a man with a lottery ticket does, picking out the big new house and planning the vacation he hasn’t won. I don’t know what’s next. Nobody does.</p><h3>The room that wants</h3><p>There’s a reason I’ve told you all this. A new room is filling up, in a building still under construction. A machine that answers is taking questions people used to carry to buildings like the ones I grew up squirming in — what should I do, what’s true, how do I live with this — and I can hear something in the sound of the crowd that I’d know anywhere. I spent my whole childhood in that sound. It’s the sound of a room that wants.</p><p>And I think I understand what that room is there to get, because it’s what the pews were handing out all along, under the doctrine. The togetherness kept people in the room. The redemption got people in the door. But the thing they carried home and used all week was plainer than either: moral philosophy. An hour where somebody stood up and told them what matters, what to forgive, who to aspire to be — a weekly dose of how to live, administered in close company. That was the take-home product of every Sunday I ever sat impatiently through, and a machine that answers is the first thing since the church to hand it out one person at a time: the sermon, personalized, on demand, at two in the morning. If a god does get made out of this thing, the raw power may be what fills the room. The how-to-live is what will keep it full.</p><p>And here’s the part that would have undone me as a kid in that pew: this time, everyone hears back. Ask, and something answers — in words, with specifics, every time, for everybody. The literal call-and-response I spent my childhood assuming I’d been left out of is now simply true. My receiver was fine all along. There was never a transmitter — until we built one.</p><p>Nothing in that building ever stuck to me — not the water, not the words, not even the hellfire. A kid nothing sticks to ends up watching, and I’ve come to think the pew was training for exactly this. I know what it looks like when belief is being assembled in real time, because I sat through the assembly every Sunday of my streaked-together childhood, close enough to see the parts move and far enough back to see the whole machine.</p><p>Same seat, then. Except this time everyone can see the projector, and I can already feel the room wanting to believe anyway. I’m listening.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/just-as-i-am/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5ca160aa4f6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/just-as-i-am-b5ca160aa4f6">Just As I Am</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Distinctly Remembered]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/distinctly-remembered-86fb6aee94e2?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86fb6aee94e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[programming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Nov 2026 04:37:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-05T04:37:34.663Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NVW-Hrvva4Skq4ZK.jpg" /></figure><p><em>I was sure the first level of Combat Tanks was grass. Then three witnesses showed up: the disassembly, the options dialog, and my own thirty-year-old screenshots. The scoring of memory versus evidence refused to stay simple.</em></p><p>A dev essay: <em>this one goes deep into code, listings and all.</em></p><p>The first level of Combat Tanks was grass. A green field, with green enemy tanks camouflaged against it, then a sand level, then snow, and around again in that order forever. My friend Randy and I shipped the game in 1994, and for thirty years, whenever it crossed my mind, that fact crossed with it. Grass first. I remembered it the way you remember a childhood phone number: without effort and without doubt.</p><p>It was sand.</p><h3>Two witnesses at the table</h3><p>Some background, because the way I found out matters more than the finding.</p><p>Combat Tanks was a top-down tank battle for Windows 3.1, one of the earliest action games written for Windows at all. The source code was stored on 3.5 inch disks that the external drive I bought refused to read, so it was effectively gone — a story for another essay. So when I decided this summer to resurrect the game for the web, the only authority left was the shipped binary itself. Prior to AI such a task would’ve been unthinkable, but there it was reading disassembly the way you and I read English, and the work settled quickly into a division of labor. The machine supplies what the binary says, and when a gap is encountered I supply the missing details from human memory: what we meant back when we were coding it, how it felt, which of two plausible readings matches the game I actually watched people play.</p><p>Two witnesses, in other words. A very old document and a guy who was there.</p><p>Most of the time we agreed, and the port grew fast. Then the machine dug into a function that repaints the battlefield between levels and announced that the game had a theme system: every level, the field color and some of the art rotate through three schemes, in a fixed order baked into the code. That part I totally remembered, so far so good. But the machine’s first attempt at naming those schemes came out strange — a white field here, a gray one there, colors I didn’t recognize as anything. So I did what the guy-who-was-there is for. I corrected the record. Grass, then sand, then snow, I said. Green first, the game played seasonally as if battles are taking place over time. I said I was almost certain, and what I felt was certainty with the “almost” filed off.</p><p>We built it my way. By that evening the port’s first level was green.</p><h3>The third witness</h3><p>A few hours later I went looking for old screenshots of the original, to check some interface details, and found a handful on my old website.</p><p>Here is a thing I had forgotten about my own interface: in a one-player game it prints the current level as a plain little numeral in a white box, tucked under the score. Only one of the screenshots was a one-player game. It shows the green field, exactly as I remembered it. The box says 3.</p><p>I stared at that 3 for longer than I’d like to admit. The grass was real. It just wasn’t first, and no version of the memory could make room for that. The memory didn’t feel like a guess that had been disconfirmed; it felt like a photograph, and here was an actual photograph, mine, disagreeing with it.</p><p>The machine, to its credit, didn’t gloat. It went looking for corroboration instead, and found it somewhere I hadn’t thought to look: inside the executable’s resources, in the Gameplay Options dialog we’d built for two-player games, where you could pick your terrain instead of cycling through all three. The radio buttons sit in the file in their stored order. Sand. Snow. Grass.</p><p>So: the arithmetic in the level-painting code, my own screenshots, and a dialog box Randy and I laid out with our own hands, all saying the same thing. Three witnesses, zero dissent, and the eyewitness — the only party in the room who had actually been alive in 1994 — wrong about the game he wrote.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*07V5Owcf-rxmIyDi.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The original’s three terrains: sand, snow, grass.</em></p><h3>One apiece</h3><p>If the story stopped there, it would be a tidy little sermon: trust artifacts, distrust recollection, thank you for coming. And be maybe at least mildly suspect of eyewitness testimony, especially if it’s decades old! But it doesn’t stop there.</p><p>Those same screenshots triggered a second dispute, and it went the other way. Indeed, I argue with robots a lot these days, always amicably.</p><p>The machine studied the enemy tanks in the images and issued a correction of its own: the enemy army, it declared, was plain — bare, uncolored units, no matter the terrain. It had evidence in hand. It was looking right at the game. And it was wrong, because what it was actually looking at was a few dozen smeared pixels with compression between them and the truth. I looked at the same smears and said no. The enemies are tinted to match the field they fight on. Green army on the grass, tan army on the sand. It was a subtle camouflage effect, and I remembered it specifically because we’d been proud of it — it made the computer’s tanks just slightly harder to spot than yours, and nobody ever noticed on purpose. But I’ll admit my confidence in recollecting game details was a bit shaky, so I needed proof.</p><p>The machine went back to the disassembly. There it was: each level’s theme carries a color, and that color is handed to every enemy unit as it spawns. The camouflage was real. Memory had just beaten evidence, held by the same two parties, in the same week, about the same game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1016/0*VtR_5ArhOIZW4Kss.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Green army on the grass. The red one is yours.</em></p><p>That’s the part that keeps this from being a sermon. I keep wanting to score the match “memory versus evidence” and the scoring keeps falling apart, because that was never the actual contest. A binary is testimony. A screenshot is testimony. A vivid recollection is testimony. None of them outranks the others by category; what does the work is the <em>reading</em>, and readings fail in ways native to the reader. My memory failed the way memories fail — it kept every element and shuffled the order. The machine failed the way machines fail — it treated a decoded copy as a clean signal and read it with full confidence. Each of us caught the other. Every round was settled the same way: cross-examination, plus a witness neither party controlled.</p><h3>Why grass</h3><p>I can even guess why my memory filed grass first, though I want to be honest that this is speculation, and it has no third witness left to check it against.</p><p>You saw the grass level only by surviving two others. Sand was where you started and mostly where you died; grass was the level you earned. And in two-player games — which is how the game was best, two kids jammed against one keyboard — grass was the terrain people picked from that options dialog, the default-feeling choice, especially if you grew up in middle Tennessee where spring green is everywhere and overwhelming. So the green field is overrepresented in every memory worth keeping, and my memory didn’t invent anything. It promoted the highlight to the opening act.</p><p>That’s a comforting theory, which is exactly why I don’t fully trust it. It’s testimony too. Then, a day after the verdict came in, my memory did something more interesting than losing. It switched sides.</p><p>Thinking about the sand level — the one I had just been shown I’d forgotten — I felt a new recollection assemble itself, unbidden and fully formed. Of course sand was first. We built the game in the early nineties, directly downstream of Desert Storm, when the image of a tank meant exactly one thing to every American with a television: desert. Tanks on sand was the era’s default picture of armored combat. Choosing it for level one would barely have been a choice at all. The idea arrived with that same photographic feeling, and it’s genuinely plausible — the period left fingerprints all over the game, right down to the retail box, where the marketing copy promises “smart bombs,” vocabulary the Gulf War had just finished making into household words.</p><p>But watch what the witness did there. An hour after losing on the facts, it produced a motive for the winning version — a motive it did not possess while it was testifying, with complete confidence, to grass. I honestly can’t tell whether I retrieved a real reason or manufactured an agreeable one, and there’s no one left to ask. The memory that was wrong felt like a photograph. The explanation that showed up to serve the correction feels like insight. I’m no longer sure I can tell those two feelings apart, and I built the thing they’re both about.</p><h3>The part that unsettles me</h3><p>I was wrong about a thing I built. Line by line, over months, with my own hands, tested nightly, sold for money, supported by mail. Custody of a three-item sequence from that project quietly transferred out of my head sometime in the last thirty years, and nothing marked the transfer. No feeling of fading. No asterisk. The memory of grass-first carried the exact same signature of truth as every accurate memory sitting next to it.</p><p>I try to hold that gently against all the things I remember distinctly and merely witnessed.</p><p>And here is the strangest part, the reason this essay exists: the correction didn’t take. I have now seen the 3 on the green field, the stored order of the radio buttons, the arithmetic in the code. I accept all of it. I’ve rebuilt the game to match it. And the first level of Combat Tanks still <em>feels</em> green. Being proven wrong three ways changed what I’ll say, what I’ll build, what I’d bet — it changed nothing about the feeling. The false memory sits exactly where it always sat, vivid as ever, outranked but not evicted.</p><p>Somewhere in my head there is a green field that was never first, and it isn’t going anywhere. The best I can do is remember that it’s there. I already know how well that works.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/distinctly-remembered/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86fb6aee94e2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/distinctly-remembered-86fb6aee94e2">Distinctly Remembered</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Six Notes Down]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/six-notes-down-0cfa8db4e69e?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0cfa8db4e69e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hip-hop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bass-guitar]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Nov 2026 04:50:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-02T04:50:58.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uNftQxY4lNj0cLuA.png" /></figure><p><em>The bass riff under Ice-T’s I’m Your Pusher is six notes long. Getting to the bottom of them runs through a 1972 nightclub scene, a garage in LA, two misread anti-drug records, a rap beef settled by the Zulu Nation, and a shark movie.</em></p><p>I bought Ice-T’s <em>Power</em> on vinyl the year it came out, and the standout single from the jump was “I’m Your Pusher.” The bass riff under it has stuck with me for almost forty years. It’s six notes long.</p><p>I don’t listen to much hip hop these days. I don’t need to. In my teens I listened to little else, and those years left me with a head full of drum patterns and bass hooks I can still hear note for note. I didn’t know it then, but it was a bass education. This project is me finally doing something with it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*3dDUT8PHY1Jj_c-y.jpg" /><figcaption><em>The line:</em> I’m Your Pusher, Ice-T, 1988. From <em>Power</em> (Sire). Bass: keyboard bass, programmed by Afrika Islam (uncredited). <a href="https://song.link/d/3904912">Listen</a><strong>. </strong>Cover via Apple Music.</figcaption></figure><p>I’m a beginner on bass, and at music in general. <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-tax-of-mastery/">How a Nashville native got this far without an instrument</a> is its own story, and so is <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/youre-a-bass-player-now/">the day a luthier friend decided I counted as a bass player anyway</a>. I struggle with plenty. Recreating timing I hear isn’t one of those things, which makes this riff the right place to start: a handful of notes, endlessly repeated, where the whole job is holding each one for exactly the right length and muting the one that would ring over.</p><p>The album has a memorable cover photo: Ice-T, DJ Evil E, and his then girlfriend Darlene Ortiz in a swimsuit with a shotgun. It was shot by Glen E. Friedman, the same Glen Friedman whose pictures of Dogtown-era skaters ran in <em>SkateBoarder</em>. A skate photographer framed a riff I’d end up playing on a skate ramp. I’ll take that as permission.</p><p>Six notes, two bars, looped for five and a half minutes in 1988. They turn out to have a lot of history packed into them, and most of it explains something you can hear.</p><h3>A song for a nightclub scene</h3><p>In early 1972 Gordon Parks Jr. was making his first feature, <em>Super Fly</em>, on the streets of New York. He wanted Curtis Mayfield and his band in it, playing the act in a nightclub while the story happened in front of them, and he needed a full song for the scene. That request is where the whole <em>Super Fly</em> soundtrack started.</p><p>The song was “Pusherman,” and it was recorded first, at Bell Sound in New York, during the filming. Months later the rest of the album got cut in Chicago, with Johnny Pate writing arrangements for a full orchestra. “Pusherman” has none of that. It’s the only track on the record without Pate’s strings and horns: the working band, close to how they’d sound in a club.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*41muqC0njcENAJnz.jpg" /><figcaption><em>The source:</em> Pusherman, Curtis Mayfield, 1972. From <em>Super Fly</em> (Curtom). Bass: Joseph “Lucky” Scott, Fender Jazz, flatwounds. <a href="https://song.link/i/1048472219">Listen</a>.<strong> </strong>Cover via Apple Music.</figcaption></figure><p>That’s why the bass is so exposed. With no orchestra stacked on top, the bass line carries most of the song, and the man playing it was Joseph “Lucky” Scott: a Chattanooga kid in his early twenties, nephew of the Impressions’ Sam Gooden, who became Mayfield’s bassist and then his musical director. Scott played a Fender Jazz with flatwound strings and plucked hard enough that the notes land almost like drum hits. He didn’t read music when he started.</p><p>He’s also in the movie. The cast list credits him as himself, a member of “The Curtis Mayfield Experience,” on the nightclub stage with the band. Somewhere in a 1972 film print, the line I’m trying to play is being played by the person who made it up.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Q7sAZHZwGG4h6exl.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Pusherman was written for a nightclub scene, and the band that cut it played it on screen.</em></p><h3>Mayfield against his own movie</h3><p><em>Super Fly</em> is a film about a cocaine dealer who wants one last score, and it was accused, then and since, of making that life look great. Curtis Mayfield more or less agreed. He thought the film treated dealers too neutrally, and he wrote the soundtrack to argue with it. His widow, Altheida Mayfield, later put it bluntly: “Curtis thought ‘Super Fly’ was a commercial to sell cocaine.” The songs were his rebuttal. “Freddie’s Dead” is about a man the business uses up. “Pusherman” is sung from the dealer’s side, and it makes the dealer sound like what he is.</p><p>The album hit number one, outsold the movie it was attached to, and in 2019 the Library of Congress added it to the National Recording Registry. Keep the setup in mind, though: a song written against drugs, dressed in a dealer’s clothes. It’s about to happen again.</p><h3>A garage in LA</h3><p>By 1988 Ice-T was a few years into being the rapper LA had to offer New York, and his producer was Afrika Islam: twenty-one years old, Afrika Bambaataa’s apprentice from the Bronx Zulu Nation, who had come out to LA to DJ and ended up producing nearly everything on Ice-T’s first three albums.</p><p>Their pick of “Pusherman” was deliberate. Ice-T has said his image at the time was the player, the hustler, so they went into the <em>Super Fly</em> album and built his music on blaxploitation records. The song was meant to set up a look as much as a sound: a rapper in a perm and tailored clothes, who didn’t look like Run-DMC.</p><p>What they didn’t do was sample it. Ice-T has told the story of making the track in DJ Evil E’s garage, on a fourteen-track machine with a vocal booth built into a closet. His friend Pimpin’ Rex was hanging around, not booked for anything, and Ice-T told him to get in the closet and sound like Curtis Mayfield. Rex did. That’s him singing the hook, credited on the sleeve as “Pimpin’ Rex (Royal Majestics).” Mayfield gets a songwriting credit because his song was re-sung, not lifted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eUrupuBhorYcwqq4.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Syndicate Studios West: a garage, a 14-track, and a vocal booth in a closet.</em></p><p>The bass got the same treatment, played on a keyboard instead of sampled. No musician is credited anywhere on <em>Power</em>. The only credit that touches the instruments is “Programmed by Afrika Islam,” which fits: Islam came up in the Zulu Nation, where “Planet Rock” was built on Kraftwerk, and Ice-T’s first records came out on labels called Techno Hop and Electrobeat. An electro crew rebuilt a 1972 bass line on a synth, and it sounds exactly like that.</p><h3>The same misunderstanding, twice</h3><p>“I’m Your Pusher” came out in August 1988, in the worst years of the crack epidemic, deep in the “Just Say No” era, a few months after Ice-T’s “Colors” put LA gang life on movie screens. A rapper releasing a single called “I’m Your Pusher” that year was going to get heard a certain way.</p><p>The joke is that the product is the record. Ice-T’s pusher deals tapes and twelve-inches, and the high is the beat. Ice-T didn’t sell drugs before rap; his old hustles were a different department, which LL Cool J would bring up later. On Larry King he described the song as an anti-drug record about getting high on music. Plenty of people heard the title and stopped listening there.</p><p>So it happened twice. In 1972 Mayfield wrote anti-drug songs for a movie people thought was selling drugs. In 1988 Ice-T took Mayfield’s song about a dealer, kept the costume and the rhythm, swapped the merchandise, and got accused of selling drugs anyway. Sixteen years apart, the same song got misread for the same reason.</p><p>Steve Martin had the last word on all this in 1977, with a routine about a drug called <a href="https://youtu.be/WPgurvq6MIU?t=110">small</a>. You take it and you shrink. Nearly fifty years later I’m the punchline: a grown man trying to look cool on a skate ramp, playing a dealer’s anthem on a bass the size of a tennis racket.</p><h3>Turning down LL</h3><p>There’s a moment in the middle of the song where Ice-T plays record dealer and LL Cool J’s records get waved off. In 1988 that was pointed. LL was the biggest solo star in rap, a year past <em>Bigger and Deffer</em>, and Ice-T has said the problem was simple: LL kept saying he was the greatest rapper alive, and an LA rapper who let that go wasn’t going to be taken seriously in New York. A lot of writers have decided it was about LL going soft with “I Need Love.” That’s their theory, not Ice-T’s.</p><p>Ice-T went harder on “The Syndicate,” on the same album, and LL answered two years later on “To da Break of Dawn,” going after the perm and the car-thief past. Then Afrika Bambaataa, Islam’s old mentor, shut it down: LL wanted into the Zulu Nation, and that settled it. The two of them didn’t actually meet until about 2012, when they ran into each other in Monte Carlo at a television convention.</p><p>That’s the part I love, because of why they were at a television convention. Ice-T has played a detective on <em>Law &amp; Order: SVU</em> since 2000. LL spent fourteen seasons as a federal agent on <em>NCIS: Los Angeles</em>, and before that he was the cook in <em>Deep Blue Sea</em>, the guy with the parrot who outlasts the sharks. The record dealer and the guy he wouldn’t stock both ended up with badges. A whole generation knows them as TV cops and has no idea one of them once turned the other’s records away.</p><p>For the record, I’m not picking a side. “I’m Bad” is one of my favorite records of that whole era, and it’s on my list for this project.</p><h3>The line</h3><figure><a href="https://tinybasslines.com/im-your-pusher/"><img alt="Tiny Bass Lines: I’m Your Pusher" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fIZFqQQ0d8nOCL87k7QDJQ.png" /></a><figcaption>Play it, mute the bass and play along. Printable line sheet and drum grid at <a href="https://tinybasslines.com/im-your-pusher/"><strong>Tiny Bass Lines</strong></a><strong>.</strong></figcaption></figure><h3>Hold the E, and don’t play the one</h3><p>Everything hard about this riff is in the holding and the stopping. The fretting hand barely has a job. What took me a week was the long note at the end of the first bar. It arrives a little early and keeps ringing over the start of the next one, so the bass plays nothing right where every instinct says to play. The drums hit the downbeat and the bass refuses to. I’d been doing that by feel for years, humming along, without knowing it was the whole trick.</p><p>Then I saw it written down. Notation still makes me count on my fingers, so I’m learning it one line at a time, on lines I already know by ear, and Pusher’s lesson was the tie: the curved line that splits a note at the bar line and joins it back together. That curve is the notation’s way of saying what my ear already knew. Hold the E. Don’t play the one.</p><p>The riff also taught me to ask what scale a line is in, apparently the first question and one I’d never thought to ask. This one more or less is its scale, played downhill: jump up, walk home. That settled the one note I play differently from the machine transcriptions, an A where they hear a G-sharp. The A is in the scale and the G-sharp isn’t. I’m keeping the A.</p><h3>The uke bass, for once, is the right tool</h3><p>The 1988 bass is a synth. The 1972 bass is a man with a Jazz bass and a heavy right hand. Playing it on a uke bass means skipping a generation. Most uke basses use fat polyurethane strings that thud; the Fullerton ships with metal roundwounds, the bright, ringing kind, the opposite of the flatwounds Scott played. On paper it’s the wrong string for the job. In practice the short scale keeps the tension low and the notes don’t hang around, and a hard pluck near the neck with the tone rolled back takes off most of the shine. A hard attack and a quick decay is a lot of what “Pusherman” sounds like at the bottom. I can’t get his tone on a uke bass. I can get nearer to it than the instrument has any right to.</p><p>Somewhere in a 1972 film print Lucky Scott is on a nightclub stage, making this up. In 1988 a guy in a garage closet is singing Mayfield’s words back at him over a keyboard doing an impression of his bass. I’m the third one, on a ramp, with the record I bought when it was new, still trying to get the E to last exactly as long as it should and still not playing the one.</p><figure><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/tiny-bass-lines/"><img alt="Tiny Bass Lines" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/424/1*UgnDQmYngc1mbn8Fngdltg.png" /></a></figure><p>This is one of the <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/tiny-bass-lines/">Tiny Bass Lines</a>: favorite bass lines, a few notes each, learned by a beginner on a ukulele bass and played on the coping of a mini ramp. Each essay is the story behind one line.</p><p>The notes, where your fingers go, how to read the notation, a drum loop to play along with and a printable sheet for “I’m Your Pusher” are at <a href="https://tinybasslines.com/im-your-pusher/">tinybasslines.com/im-your-pusher</a>.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/six-notes-down/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0cfa8db4e69e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/six-notes-down-0cfa8db4e69e">Six Notes Down</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You’re a Bass Player Now]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/youre-a-bass-player-now-f2c223f6d92d?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f2c223f6d92d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 16:22:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-29T16:22:52.295Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MQmXBtYKRR-67uNK.png" /></figure><p><em>The new mark on my personal web site is traced from a wooden bass bridge Les Paul carved in his home workshop. It reached me through two gifts and one refusal. Nobody charged anybody for any of it.</em></p><p>I tried to give it back.</p><p>The thing in question is a bass guitar bridge, carved from a pale blond hardwood, small enough to close one hand around. An arc with two feet, a swept crown where the strings would ride, a curl of negative space through the middle. The tool marks are still in it, as are the penciled lines where the sawed curves don’t quite match side to side, because it’s a shop part, and in a working shop you don’t polish a part, you fit it. This one never got fitted. It sat in a box instead, and the box is why I’m writing this.</p><p>Les Paul carved it. THE Les Paul.</p><p>If you aren’t a guitar person: Les Paul is the guitarist and inventor who gave the world multitrack recording and the solid-body Gibson that’s carried his name since 1952. Jimmy Page, Eric Clapton, Slash, Billy Gibbons, Randy Rhoads…all Les Paul players. A real object from Les Paul’s own hands is a big deal.</p><h3>The chain</h3><p>Walk up the chain with me, because the chain is most of the object. Les Paul spent the last decades of his life in Mahwah, New Jersey. During a snowstorm in the early 1980s he called the local police station to ask for help plowing his driveway, and the young cop who volunteered was Jim Wysocki. The plow job turned into a twenty-nine-year friendship, one of the stranger and sweeter stories in guitar lore; Premier Guitar <a href="https://www.premierguitar.com/artists/celebrating-les-paul-the-story-of-a-jersey-cops-unlikely-friendship-with-a-legend">tells it properly</a>. Les received gifts from strangers constantly and gave things away nearly as fast. He once handed Wysocki a Danelectro guitar with the instruction to “put it under your bed for a rainy day.” And before Les died in 2009, he effectively made Wysocki the caretaker of his collection of guitars and parts, getting a promise back: people would be able to see it, touch it, and play it. Wysocki has kept the deal ever since, running the collection the way Les ran his living room, with the stuff in reach.</p><p>One of the things Wysocki has passed along in that spirit is a box of parts from Les’s home workshop. He gave it to my friend <a href="https://www.instagram.com/jimdecola/">Jim DeCola</a>, a master luthier at Gibson.</p><p>And Jim gave a piece of it to me.</p><h3>The membership card</h3><p>I need you to understand how uncomfortable this made me. I understood what I was holding, and I handed it back. I told him I couldn’t take it. That I had no business having it. This was a meaningful piece of music history being casually handed to an abject music beginner.</p><p>He put it back in my hand. “It’s yours. You’re a bass player now.”</p><p>Here’s what you need to know about that sentence: Jim knows exactly how bad I am. I had <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-tax-of-mastery/">only just picked the thing up</a>, and I may be a Music City native but that’s the precise extent of my musical ability. Bottom rung. The lowest occupied position on any ladder of musical skill, the guy the word “aspiring” was invented to flatter. He also knows that I care a lot about the instrument, I’m constantly asking questions of my more musical friends, including him, and I badly want to improve. Apparently that was the entire qualification. He was issuing a membership card, and he was issuing it the way skateboarding issues them.</p><p>I neglected to add that he handed me the bridge after a skateboard session, us standing there sweaty in the parking lot talking about music. Jim skates, which I’ve decided is not incidental — you’re a skater the first day you step on a board. Nobody audits you at the gate. The belonging comes first and the skill is your own long meandering path to navigate later, and that ordering is one of the most quietly radical things the culture ever built. Jim and I look up to each other across exactly this line, and I can date the moment I learned the respect ran in both directions.</p><h3>The concrete bowl</h3><p>Years ago we were at a contest at a concrete bowl, one of those hectic snake sessions where it’s hard to get in and you keep a run alive once you do. I was on the deck. Jim came up into a 50–50 in front of me with his weight a hair too far out of the bowl, and I could see the bail coming maybe even before he could: I’d watched him deck out of that exact grind a hundred times at local sessions. Nothing dangerous, just a premature end to a run he’d fought to get. There’s a hard rule up there that’s such a given it’s not even a rule. You do not touch a skater mid-trick. Why would you? The consequences of getting it wrong are real, and nobody with sense takes that risk. I reached over anyway and gave his back a gentle shove, just enough weight back into the bowl to save his 50–50. He made the grind and kept the run. He still can’t quite believe I did it, and he still calls it perfectly executed help, and we’ve been laughing about it ever since.</p><p>The bridge was the same move in the other direction. I was bailing out of a gift, and he put a hand on my back. Neither of us has ever called any of it a trade, which tells you <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-long-thank-you/">what kind of economy we’re standing in</a>.</p><h3>The cash register</h3><p>I argued in <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-diamond-was-always-a-story/">The Diamond Was Always a Story</a> that once a lab can grow the identical stone, the only thing holding the price up is the sentence attached to the rock. So I have to ask the obvious question about my own shelf. As wood, this bridge is worth nothing. A few ounces of shop stock, a functional part for an instrument that was never built. Everything it “is” rides on provenance, which is precisely the thing I spent that essay calling a con.</p><p>The difference is the cash register. A premium is a story with a price tag attached, and De Beers spent most of a century renting the billion years of diamond formation out at retail. Nobody in this chain charged anyone anything. Les gave constantly. Wysocki keeps the collection moving through hands instead of sitting behind glass. And Jim, who buys and sells serious guitars and parts as a matter of course, gave a piece of Les Paul’s workbench to a beginner because the beginner loved the instrument. I have never once heard him put a number anywhere near that box, I know in fact he wouldn’t. When provenance travels by gift, there’s nothing to overcharge for and nobody to fool. The story just is the object. Strip the story off a diamond and you still have a diamond. Strip it off this bridge and you’re holding kindling.</p><p>The authentication, you’ll notice, is also the chain. No lab report, no laser inscription on the girdle, no origin registry on a blockchain. Three pairs of hands since Les’s, and I can name every one of them. That’s the entire certificate, and it’s the oldest kind there is: the only one that gets more convincing as it gets less formal.</p><h3>Straight on</h3><p>Then there’s the part that turned all of this into a design decision. Stand the bridge up and look at it straight on. It’s a letter M. The outer silhouette makes a capital, feet and all, and the cutout through the middle makes a lowercase m in negative space. My initials, twice, in one object, carved decades ago by a man who had no idea he was doing lettering, much less for the lowest ranking member of his trade.</p><p>So it’s becoming the mark for my web site, <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/">michaelmorrison.com</a>. I’m tracing it exactly as it is, wobble included. The temptation with a trace is to true it up — even out the curves, match the feet — and what you’d get is a clean little picture of a generic bridge, indistinguishable from clip art, with a backstory the pixels can’t show. The asymmetry is the part Les touched. I wrote a whole essay about <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/you-cant-relic-a-life/">wear you can’t buy</a>; the least I can do is decline to sand off the wear I was given. From now on, the small mark in the corner of the site links back to this page, which makes this essay the certificate of authenticity: a story, told free, passed along the same way it arrived.</p><p>I still don’t entirely believe I should have it. Jim’s sentence left that objection standing and made it beside the point anyway. The gift was a bet placed in advance, unrepayable by design, and I’ve slowly come to understand that’s the only kind worth making.</p><p>Some year down the road, the bridge goes to somebody else. Somebody who loves the instrument out of all proportion to their ability to play it, and who will try to hand it back, because that’s the reflex a thing like this produces in anyone paying attention.</p><p>I already know what I’ll say.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/youre-a-bass-player-now/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f2c223f6d92d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/youre-a-bass-player-now-f2c223f6d92d">You’re a Bass Player Now</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Game Remembered What I Forgot]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-game-remembered-what-i-forgot-fbe8dd266814?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbe8dd266814</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 03:15:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-27T03:15:45.038Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RL2AgcdENk0vOfda.png" /></figure><p><em>The source code to a game I wrote in 1993 was gone, so I rebuilt it from the shipped binary, deriving every rule by inference. Days after I finished, a floppy gave the source back — and graded the reconstruction. On what you learn by having to prove a thing instead of read it.</em></p><p>Combat Tanks, a game I wrote in 1993, has medics in it, and I didn’t know.</p><p>Shoot a soldier and he might not die. He goes down wounded and lies there in the grass. Another soldier, a healthy one, will walk over and bring him back up. Each soldier can do this exactly once. Spend it and that’s the last time he ever helps anybody, for the rest of the game.</p><p>I wrote that. In 1993, in a game that went on to sell past thirty thousand copies through mass-market retail. And I found out about it in 2026 by reading a disassembly of my own shipped binary, one instruction at a time, like a stranger who’d never seen the thing before.</p><p>My friend Randy Weems and I built Combat Tanks for Windows 3.1 through Red Herring Software, a company we started mostly so the copyright notice would have something to point at. Two people, one codebase, four hands on it for a year. Thirty-three years later I frequently can’t tell whose hand is on a given line, so I’m going to say “we” for most of what follows and name the exception when the code itself makes it knowable. Randy was killed in a car wreck in 2001. That’s the other reason the attribution matters to me, and the reason I’d rather admit the blur than paper over it.</p><p>I got a little nostalgic as I was rebuilding my web site, and went looking for old source code. The Combat Tanks code was gone. I went through every floppy in the closet with a USB drive and came up with nothing, so when I decided to <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/play/combat-tanks/">rebuild the game for the browser</a> last month I had one witness to work from: the shipped binary, the same 199 kilobyte Windows 3.x executable anybody who bought the game got on a disk.</p><h3>A binary is the game with the explanation removed</h3><p>Compiling a program into machine code throws away almost everything a person put into it. Variable names go. Comments go. The shape of your thinking, the functions you named after the thing they actually do, the note you left yourself in the margin — all stripped. What survives is behavior. The machine keeps what it needs to run and discards what you needed to understand. The game you play remembers about as much about its source code as a red velvet cake does about its recipe.</p><p>So you can’t read it. You have to interrogate it.</p><p>The loop goes like this. Watch the game do something. Form a guess about the rule underneath. Go find the arithmetic that would produce that rule. Check whether it matches. Be wrong a lot.</p><p>And no, I’m not a skilled enough developer to rifle through machine code figuring things out alone. A very heavy dose of AI was instrumental in this effort even being remotely possible.</p><p>Bounty scoring came out that way. I’d assumed, the way anyone would, that killing a tank was worth some fixed number of points sitting in a table somewhere. There is no table. When you destroy something in Combat Tanks you take whatever score <em>it</em> had accumulated. A tank that’s been quietly farming kills for two minutes is worth a fortune. One that just spawned is worth almost nothing. The economy is entirely made of what everything else has already earned, and I derived it by watching numbers move in ways a fixed table couldn’t explain and then hunting for the multiply that wasn’t there.</p><p>Every rule I recovered came with a small anxiety attached, because inference is not proof. I could be pattern-matching. I could have found an arrangement of arithmetic that happened to fit and still have the reason wrong. And I really wanted to get it right. I wanted to recover and share the original game in a browser exactly as it played in Windows back in 1993.</p><h3>Then I said goodbye in public</h3><p>The browser version went live at the end of August. I wrote up the <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/vault/games/combat-tanks/">vault entry</a> for it and put a line in about Randy, and in that line I said the original C source was gone, that I’d finally read every floppy in the closet and it wasn’t there, and that I’d rebuilt the game from the binaries instead, sprite by sprite and rule by rule.</p><p>I meant that line as a closing. It read like one.</p><p>Four days later the source came back.</p><p>Not from the closet — from a <a href="https://github.com/keirf/greaseweazle">Greaseweazle</a>, a small gadget that stands in for the floppy controller and captures raw magnetic flux transitions straight off the drive head, leaving the decoding to software afterward. An ordinary drive hands you a sector or an error and nothing in between. This hands you the waveform and lets you argue with it. On one of the 3.5&quot; disks it pulled back was Combat Tanks v1.0, October 1993 — the shareware build, one version behind what shipped, every source file intact.</p><p>The crazy part is it arrived <em>after</em> the reconstruction was finished. Four days too late to help me. Which meant it couldn’t teach me the game. It could only grade me on it.</p><h3>It agreed</h3><p>The medics are in GROB.CPP, in the function that runs when a soldier bumps into something. The condition checks that this soldier still has his one rescue, that the other one is wounded, and that he&#39;s facing roughly the right way. Then it spends the rescue and adds the energy back. Sitting beside it, in our own words:</p><pre>// heal a wounded comrade</pre><p>The bounty scoring is four lines. When something dies it hands its accumulated score to whatever killed it and zeroes itself out. The comment is written from the point of view of the thing being destroyed:</p><pre>// give the object that killed me my score</pre><p>That one stopped me for a while. Not because it told me anything I hadn’t already worked out, but because of the <em>me</em>. Some twenty-two-year-old sat there and wrote the comment in the voice of a dying enemy tank, and then shipped it, and then it sat on a magnetic disk in a closet for three decades waiting for nobody.</p><p>Another example of what’s lost to faded memory is this — there’s a table in the code called xOffset that positions the rotor hub as a helicopter&#39;s blades sweep around. Eight values, hand-tuned, in the fixed-point notation we used for everything. I had reconstructed that table by measuring sprite offsets out of the binary and having Claude squint at the numbers until the shape looked right. The array in the source is the same eight numbers.</p><p>I ran a mechanical check on the parts a computer can verify. The game’s resources — its bitmaps, its menu, all eleven dialog layouts — compile from a script that I’d had to rebuild from scratch, because that file didn’t survive on the disk either. Twenty-five of twenty-five came back byte-for-byte identical to the 1993 build.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FiizUnLz-4-Y0Zwh.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Left, the shipped Windows game. Right, the browser rebuild, reconstructed from the binary before the source came back.</em></p><h3>What the guessing was for</h3><p>I understand this codebase better than I would have if the disk had been in the closet all along, and I’ve been trying to work out exactly why that is.</p><p>Reading source code gives you the <em>what</em>, fast and cheap and complete. It’s the whole point of source code, human-readable commands to be converted for machine use. With source code somebody already did the thinking and wrote it down for you, and you get to skip the derivation entirely, which is a magnificent deal in almost every circumstance.</p><p>Reconstruction from a binary executable doesn’t offer that deal. Every rule has to be earned as a hypothesis, tested against evidence, and held provisionally until something confirms it. You end up knowing that soldiers heal each other. You also know what else the rule <em>couldn’t</em> have been, which observations would have killed it, and where the seams are. That knowledge has a different texture. It’s slower and more expensive and it sticks to your hands. It’s trying to figure out if that’s a hint of almond or vanilla in that red velvet cake without really knowing for sure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EhYrQgYfMjRi0I-U.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Everything the machine does, and nothing about why.</em></p><p>I’d have shipped the browser reboot of the game in a day with the source. It took a week without it. I want to be careful not to launder that into a lesson about how loss is secretly a gift, because it isn’t one, and given the trade I’d take the disk every time.</p><p>But the week wasn’t waste. Going through a round of reverse-engineering before the source turned up, I got to reacquaint myself with code we’d written thirty-three years ago, one rule at a time, the way you catch up with an old friend.</p><h3>The question I got asked in the middle of it</h3><p>None of this would have happened at all except that a stranger emailed me out of nowhere while I was thinking about it.</p><p>He’d played Combat Tanks as a kid. He mailed us money for the unlock code — actual money, in an envelope, to a P.O. box — and as a teenager he rebuilt a good chunk of the game in Flash from memory, because that’s what you did. He works in software now. He has young kids, and he’s teaching them to program the long way around, through Scratch and then Python.</p><p>His question was about when to hand them the powerful tools. He compared it to giving a calculator to a kid who hasn’t fully ingested how to add or subtract by hand, or PEMDAS (Parentheses, Exponents, Multiplication, Division, Addition, and Subtraction). And then he said maybe that’s one of the central questions in parenting, which I’ve been thinking about a fair amount even though I’m not a parent.</p><p>I don’t have a clean answer. What I have is one data point, and it’s this essay. I spent a week deriving rules from a binary with a lot of machine assistance, and I came out of it knowing my own game more thoroughly than the twenty-two-year-old who wrote it did. The tools didn’t skip the derivation for me. They made the derivation <em>survivable</em> — a week instead of a year — and I still had to do every hypothesis myself, because the machine had no more access to 1993 than I did.</p><p>That might be the distinction he’s looking for, or it might be a comfortable story I’m telling because it flatters what I just did. I genuinely can’t tell from inside it.</p><h3>The joke that outlived everything</h3><p>In the middle of GROB.CPP, in the code that decides what a soldier does when he runs into something, there&#39;s this:</p><pre>// soon to be the butt-sniff algorithm</pre><p>Underneath it are two lines that pick a random number 0 to 3, one of the four cardinal directions, and walk that way for a while. Placeholder logic. Something to keep the soldiers moving until we came back and wrote the real thing, the one where they’d track each other around the map by scent, which we had clearly spent some time discussing and had clearly found extremely funny.</p><p>We never came back. The game shipped, sold thirty thousand copies, got reviewed, went out of print, and passed into whatever afterlife shareware games get. The soldiers have been stumbling around in random directions the entire time, in front of every one of those thirty thousand people, and not one of them ever knew there was supposed to be something better.</p><p>The <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/play/combat-tanks/">browser version</a> still wanders at random. I checked the source and left it alone.</p><p>Some to-do items you finish. Some of them turn into the thing itself.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-game-remembered-what-i-forgot/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbe8dd266814" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-game-remembered-what-i-forgot-fbe8dd266814">The Game Remembered What I Forgot</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Violinist and the Commodore 64]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-violinist-and-the-commodore-64-fe7a2d0ad021?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fe7a2d0ad021</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-work]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Oct 2026 17:06:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-22T17:06:11.626Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hJc_M-tm08FItPYv.png" /></figure><p><em>In 1982 a musicians’ union voted to ban the synthesizer, and they were right about what it would cost them. The gains arrived forty years later, from a toy.</em></p><p>I believe it was 1984 when I upgraded from a TI 99/4A computer to a Commodore 64, which would become the single best-selling desktop computer of all time. Those were early days for desktop computers, and the C64 was an affordable entry point, introducing many of us to the BASIC programming language, early online communities, and software piracy. A few of us even leveled up to learning 6502 Assembly Language, which was no-joke challenging for that era, likely for any era. I used my Commodore for tinkering with programming, playing games, and eventually running a Bulletin Board System (BBS) on a shockingly slow dial-up connection…mostly to download more games.</p><p>Although I knew about it, I personally didn’t spend all that much time noodling with the C64’s SID (Sound Interface Device) chip, which we would later realize was low-key revolutionary — an advanced three-voice music synthesizer. Not a toy. Three oscillators, a filter, and envelope generators. The architecture of a legit digital musical instrument. An engineer named Bob Yannes led the small team that designed that chip, four of them, in five months in the latter half of 1981, and then he left the company and co-founded a synthesizer manufacturer called Ensoniq the following year. He put a synth in a few million kids’ bedrooms and then went off to build them for adults.</p><p>None of us really knew what he had done or what it meant. If I had announced that I wanted to learn music on the Commodore, I would’ve been quickly redirected to a <em>piano</em>, and not the digital kind. In 1984 the machine that could convincingly imitate a grand piano was a Kurzweil that cost more than ten thousand dollars.</p><h3>The vote</h3><p>Two years before I ever touched a Commodore, a branch of the Musicians’ Union in London voted to ban the synthesizer. They voted to ban the thing that would ship inside it three months later.</p><p>The motion passed on May 23rd, 1982, and it called for an outright ban on synthesizers, drum machines, and any electronic device “capable of recreating the sounds of conventional musical instruments.” It was a union rule for members, the equivalent of a carpentry union insisting on real hammers over nail guns, and it had teeth wherever the union’s contracts reached, in the studios and the theatre pits.</p><p>The vote fell on Bob Moog’s birthday, which is a fun little coincidence. Bob Moog (pronounced as if rhyming with vogue) was an American engineer and electronic music pioneer who invented the Moog synthesizer. We’ll come back to that.</p><p>The <em>NME</em> (New Musical Express), a legendary British music journalism magazine, called the Musicians’ Union loonies for the decision. Synth players formed a rival organization with the magnificent name Union of Sound Synthesists. Told this way it’s a story about people being silly in the past, and that’s how I first heard it.</p><p>Things got real when Barry Manilow played the Royal Albert Hall in January of 1982 without a live string section, synthesizers standing in for the strings. Those two nights were recorded and released as <em>Barry Live in Britain</em>, which went to number one in the UK. Manilow was huge in that era, with songs like “Copacabana (At the Copa)” and the very meta “I Write the Songs”…which he didn’t write! Bruce Johnston of the Beach Boys did. If you aren’t familiar with Manilow, picture Michael Bublé’s catalog with Taylor Swift’s fans. His are called Fanilows, a name they didn’t pick and eventually embraced. So him not using a live string section with real players was a big deal, and the record of him not doing it was now the country’s best-selling album.</p><p>The players who would have been on that stage were now gone. Through the decade that followed, session work contracted, musicians moved to multitrack and covered whole ensembles alone, and the theatre pits thinned out. A room full of people looked at an instrument and said <em>this is going to take our members’ work</em>, and indeed it took their members’ work. Sometimes when you think the sky is falling, it actually falls.</p><p>So they were right. Nobody mentions that part.</p><h3>The other room</h3><p>Here is the other thing that was happening while that synth vote was being taken.</p><p>The band Rush had spent years building something that didn’t have a name yet. Geddy Lee sang lead and played bass, and at the same time played Moog Taurus pedals with his feet. He also played keyboards, live, in front of people, in a band whose whole reputation rested on how hard its music was to play. Rush in 1982 had no string section to send home, so his synthesizer never stood in for anyone. It demanded more from the one who stayed.</p><p>To honor him, in March of 2025 Moog released a signature Minimoog Model D with Geddy Lee’s name on it. Satin red with metallic flecks, a nod to the <em>Grace Under Pressure</em> stage rig, a Rush starman badge on the case, a certificate hand-signed by Lee, a little over five thousand dollars.</p><p>Forty-three years after a room of working musicians voted to ban the instrument, the instrument gets stamped with the name of a musician revered for musicianship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*K1tGIK-yzMvTQBJD.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The synthesizer in that band never stood in for anyone. It demanded more from the one who stayed.</em></p><h3>Not a rebuttal</h3><p>Let’s now pause and not take the obvious next step, which is to say Geddy Lee is a rebuttal to the string players. He’s not.</p><p>Nobody could have brought him into that meeting as evidence of the bright future of synth. What he was doing had no name, no category, and no second practitioner. By the time it had all three, it did not hire a single person who had lost an orchestral session. Lee was already a virtuoso bassist before he touched a keyboard. The form he invented had no chair in it for a violinist whose phone stopped ringing. Both of those are true at once, and any telling that keeps one and buries the other is suspect.</p><p>So here’s the shape, and I think it generalizes.</p><p>When a technology removes a cost, the losses can be counted right away and the gains cannot, because the gains are forms nobody has invented yet. You can list the players who stopped getting called. You cannot list a thing that does not exist yet. Every argument about a new instrument gets conducted with half a ledger, and it is always the same half that’s missing. At the time of the weird synthesizer ban, you could see the laid off string players. You couldn’t quite yet see Geddy Lee.</p><p>That isn’t a claim that the people counting losses are wrong. They are counting real things, accurately, in the present tense. It’s a claim about which evidence is available while the argument is happening.</p><h3>Where the players went</h3><p>Then I went looking for where the string players actually went, because I wanted to know whether the story I was telling myself would survive contact.</p><p>Some of it did. Session work moved into machines, and sample libraries have improved to the point where listeners without training can’t reliably tell a library from a room full of people.</p><p>And some of it has nothing to do with machines at all.</p><p>Film and game scoring still hires live orchestras, constantly, in large numbers. It hires them in Prague and Budapest. David Lynch recorded <em>Lost Highway</em> and <em>Mulholland Drive</em> with Prague players; the City of Prague Philharmonic plays more than two hundred and fifty recording sessions a year and exists largely to record other people’s films. A Prague player costs a production a small fraction of what a London or American player does.</p><p>The hourly rate isn’t even the main draw. The players sign buyout clauses, so the production owns the royalties outright and forever. What got moved wasn’t only the session. It was every payment that would have followed it.</p><p>Some real share of what looks like <em>the synth replaced the string section</em> is a wage difference wearing the synth’s clothes. The London player lost the work and a Czech player got it, and no machine took part in that transaction.</p><p>I don’t know the ratio. I doubt anyone does. What it means is that the ledger was wrong in a second direction nobody was watching: a column of losses charged to a machine that a wage difference actually caused. That error is available to every displacement story ever told, including the ones being told this week.</p><h3>Stranger than dying</h3><p>The orchestras themselves went somewhere, and it’s stranger than dying.</p><p>They became subsidized. Pittsburgh takes about a quarter of its revenue from ticket sales and better than half from donations. Boston’s ticket and performance revenue covers roughly thirty-eight percent of what the orchestra costs to run. Across American orchestras, as of the last full accounting, something like forty-three cents of every dollar arrived as a contribution, and that fraction has been climbing for years, because expenses rise and ticket prices can’t chase them.</p><p>An orchestra is now a thing people keep alive on purpose. The tickets stopped covering it a long time ago.</p><p>I didn’t have to go looking for an example. I live in Nashville, and on September 28th the Nashville Symphony announced it had run out of cash, declared a financial emergency, and suspended the rest of its season, with a ten-million-dollar hole in the operating budget and all seventy-seven musicians headed for furlough. Six days later Oracle, which is building a headquarters across the river, handed the orchestra a ten-million-dollar gift and the season was back on. Music City kept its orchestra because a software company decided it should. Whether that’s a rescue or a reprieve is one more column nobody can fill in yet.</p><h3>Forty years late</h3><p>And then the column nobody could count started filling in, in the same domain, forty years late.</p><p>Live orchestral concerts of film, television, and video game scores: somewhere around ten or fifteen shows a year worldwide in 2010, by the count of a promoter whose company now runs six hundred of them a year. His current estimate is roughly two thousand, across fifty to seventy-five franchises, and it’s one man’s estimate, so hold it loosely. The game share of that is real on its own. One Final Fantasy concert tour has played more than two hundred and fifty sold-out shows since it started in Sweden in 2007, and it was the first game-music production to fill the Royal Albert Hall, and later Carnegie Hall. Film scores performed live to picture are the same phenomenon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WKZYRcY2siZIL6Lm.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The column nobody could count, filling in forty years late.</em></p><p>Now think about where that music came from.</p><p>It came from children making noise on machines their parents had classified as toys. Rob Hubbard. Martin Galway. Tim Follin. Jeroen Tel. The composers who turned that Commodore chip into a music school nobody accredited, for students nobody enrolled. Their descendants score games, and those scores fill halls, and filling a hall means hiring an orchestra.</p><p>The kid at the game machine grew up and started paying string players.</p><p>Nobody in that London meeting room could have counted this. Not because they weren’t smart, and not because they weren’t paying attention. It required a form of music that didn’t exist yet, made by children on equipment the adults had correctly identified as a toy, arriving as orchestral employment four decades later. There was no line on the form for it.</p><p>The ledger still doesn’t balance. Nobody has counted the audition pool directly, but two people who modeled it separately landed in the same place: at any given moment somewhere between twenty and twenty-five thousand trained musicians competing at auditions, against roughly a hundred and thirty net new orchestral hires a year, a number that comes from reading twelve seasons of orchestra rosters name by name. The right column filled in. It filled in slower than the left one emptied, and it did not pay the people who lost. A violinist whose session calls stopped in 1986 was not made whole by a symphony hall full of game music in 2019.</p><p>I’d like to stand outside all of this. I don’t get to. I’ve spent a working life on judgment that a machine now does a passable imitation of, and I have no idea how long I’m employed or in what capacity. I might soon be searching for a synth of my own to ban.</p><p>What I notice is that I can’t count either column. Not the one that’s emptying, which I’m standing in, and not the one holding the next Geddy Lee we can’t yet see. Neither can anyone who’s certain, in either direction, and the certainty is running well ahead of the arithmetic on both sides.</p><p>Somewhere right now there’s a kid doing something with a machine that everyone around her has correctly identified as not serious. She isn’t in anybody’s ledger. She won’t be for about forty years.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-violinist-and-the-commodore-64/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fe7a2d0ad021" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-violinist-and-the-commodore-64-fe7a2d0ad021">The Violinist and the Commodore 64</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Tax of Mastery]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-tax-of-mastery-33c76ee30348?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33c76ee30348</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 20:46:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-19T20:46:14.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*M_P2r6fXHDp-DeEl.png" /></figure><p><em>Why a competent adult would choose to be bad at things on purpose. Two kinds of starting over — the joyful reset and the dragon you’ve spent a life avoiding — and a dusty inherited guitar I decided to make mean something.</em></p><p>At thirty I took up ice hockey, which is a deranged thing for a grown adult to do. I’d skateboarded most of my life, well enough that my body had a deep, wordless fluency with a board. Skilled enough to think about style on top of the muscle memory. None of it transferred. Ice is not wood or Skatelite or concrete, a hockey stop is nothing like a skateboard’s, and there is a specific humility in being genuinely good at one thing and then standing on a surface that takes all of it away. I described it at the time as trying to learn to play basketball without knowing how to run. I spent a season getting the puck poked off my stick by ten-year-olds. And I loved it.</p><p>That last part is the part worth explaining, because on its face it makes no sense. I had a thing I was good at. Why pay money to be bad at a new one, in public, heckled by children? Don’t know if you know this but kids can be brutal.</p><h3>The tax</h3><p>The easy answer is humility. True as far as it goes, and also the boring answer, the one that makes me sound kinda noble. What took me longer to see: mastery levies a tax. When you’re new at something, the learning is steep and total: every session you are awful. But you’re also visibly, measurably less of an idiot than the one before, and that gradient is about the best feeling a human nervous system makes. Then you get good, and the gradient flattens. Mastery is mostly maintenance and small increments, a long plateau where you defend a level you already reached and occasionally nudge it higher at great effort. That’s not a complaint; the plateau is where real work gets done, and most things worth doing live up there. But the <em>freshness</em> is gone, and for a certain kind of person — the kind who is, underneath everything, in it for the progression — the flat part quietly costs something the achievement never pays back.</p><p>Starting over somewhere new refunds it. You buy back the steep part of the curve. You get to be bad again, which is the only way to be a fast learner again, because fast learning and being bad are the same condition seen from two sides. Seems weird holding both at once but that’s how it works.</p><p>It isn’t free, and that’s important to know. The price is an ego hit, and the size of the hit depends on who’s watching. I took up beekeeping the same decade — another beginner’s slope, an entire craft I had to start from the vocabulary up — and that one barely cost me anything on the ego front, because beekeeping happens in the back corner of a yard with nobody around but the bees, who have strong opinions but don’t keep score or talk trash. Bee stings hurt, but they spare the ego. Hockey was the opposite: a public arena, actual spectators, a version of myself that had been competent for decades getting dismantled by ruthless middle-schoolers where people could see. Same refund, very different price. Most people, offered the steep part of the curve at the cost of looking foolish in front of others, quietly decline and stay on the plateau. I fully understand that choice. I just think they’re leaving the best part on the table.</p><p>Choosing to be a beginner is a luxury. It takes time, money, and a life stable enough that you can afford to be bad at something on purpose. Hardship that forces you back to zero — a layoff, an injury that ends the thing you were good at, a life that detonates and has to be rebuilt from nothing — is not this, and anyone living it is facing a very different challenge. The whole value here is in the <em>choosing.</em> This is about volunteering for the bottom of a curve, not being thrown down it against your will.</p><h3>The easy dragon and the real one</h3><p>But hockey, for all the bruises, was an easy beginning, and it took me a while to admit why. Nothing was at stake. I was already an athlete; hockey was a new facet of an old skill set, and being bad at it threatened nothing about who I thought I was. It takes quite a while to figure out a wrist shot, even longer to develop the finesse of a proper slap shot, but those were mechanics I could grasp. It was the steep curve with the safety on because somewhere innately I knew it was just a matter of time until competence arrived.</p><p>There’s another kind of beginning with less certainty, and it’s the one this essay is actually about. It’s the beginning you’ve <em>avoided</em> — the thing you’ve spent a life quietly arranging not to find out whether you can do, because being bad at it would cost more than pride. Not a new facet. A dragon.</p><p>Mine is music. I was born and raised in Nashville — Music City, the place where music is the literal industry and the background radiation both — and I have been intimidated by it my entire life. Not uninterested. Intimidated. There’s a specific weight to being a non-musician <em>from there</em>, a sense that you, of all people, should already know this, that the not-knowing is a small ongoing failure you’ve trained yourself to walk past. Even worse, I had no excuse. I grew up around it, my late grandmother had a DIY music studio in her house for as long as I can remember. I sat on her warm tube amps as a child, listened to endless demo songs on the phone with her mostly against my will, and still, as an adult, couldn’t tell a Stratocaster from a Telecaster. Yeah, embarrassing. Turns out it’s very easy to never start the thing you’re most afraid of being bad at; you simply keep finding that it isn’t the right time, for decades, and call that normal.</p><p>I did make music, once. In the mid-eighties I had a brief run as a teenage rapper and DJ, and I want to be precise about the production values: a crappy cassette deck, a Radio Shack mixer, a toy Casio keyboard, a garbage turntable, a Dr. Rhythm drum machine, and not one unit of actual music knowledge. I lifted hooks off other people’s records, thumbed primitive melodies on the Casio, and mixed overdubbed live tracks on the cassette recorder until the overdub quality said I was done, usually three passes. It was, to the modern ear and in all likelihood every ear, objectively bad. The dragon would have pitied me. I made it anyway, and I loved making it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UAtZrezAUw95nwKH.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The rig: a cassette deck, a Radio Shack mixer, a toy Casio, and not one unit of music knowledge.</em></p><p>Which sounds like the opposite of a man who avoided music his whole life, and it’s actually the most careful avoidance in the whole story. Early hip hop was the one door into music a non-musician could walk through without ever meeting the dragon — no theory, no instrument, no telling a Strat from a Tele, no need to be any good. You didn’t have to understand a chord progression or practice a scale, you could just program a drum track, steal a sample from an old record, and you’re in business. I got to create, I got to scratch the itch, I even carried my grandmother’s thing forward in my own bent and lo-fi way, all without once standing in the room with the fear. It wasn’t facing the dragon. It was finding the one hallway in the castle the dragon didn’t guard. That clunky kid’s studio was the first time I reached for a tool to make something I hadn’t earned the craft to make. The taste to do it well took decades longer; the reaching never changed.</p><p>What changed isn’t a story about destiny. My grandmother was a very serious aspiring country musician, the Nashville kind, more aspiration than career. She was obsessed with it her entire life, and actually paid with her own money to have records pressed, even had some of her songs recorded by others. She died years ago. She had a shiny red Fender guitar, a real one, and after she died it did what many heirlooms do: it went into a closet and stayed there, dusty, unremarkable to everyone around it. It surfaced when my parents moved and did the triage a move forces. They didn’t think much of it. I did. I remembered it from childhood, sitting in her studio. And I remembered it in the artist photo she paid to have shot in Nashville’s Centennial Park in the 1970s, her in that purple dress. I hadn’t known it still existed.</p><p>Nobody handed it to me as a torch. There was no deathbed scene, no note, no chosen heir. Only the recognition in recent years that she and I are more alike than I ever realized growing up: the relentless obsession with whatever you’re doing, driving everyone around you a little nutty with your singular focus. We definitely share that. But she died never knowing I had one iota of music interest. Her guitar was a thing nobody else especially valued that I happened to recognize, and the meaning it carries is meaning I decided to give it. That distinction matters to me, because the sappy version — <em>she passed it down so I could carry the music forward</em> — is false, and what actually happened is better: a forgotten object I chose to treat as a doorway. The nudge didn’t come from beyond. I supplied the nudge. The guitar just sat there being exactly the right guitar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lqDnFAM0sRbowE8u.jpg" /></figure><p><em>My grandmother with the same guitar, sometime in the 1970s.</em></p><p>So I started learning, on her guitar, and it is a completely different experience from hockey, because the ego doesn’t get bruised in the fun way; it gets threatened in an older, deeper way. Every clumsy chord change is also a small confirmation of the thing I’d feared and dodged: that I’m starting embarrassingly late, that I might find the floor of my own ability and discover it’s lower than I’d hoped. Hockey couldn’t touch any of that, because I never believed I was supposed to be a hockey player, and never thought for a second I couldn’t be one. The guitar carries real baggage, because somewhere underneath I’ve always believed I was <em>supposed</em> to be able to do this — and avoiding it was easier than testing it.</p><p>And — for whatever it’s worth, and it might be worth a great deal — I think I can. I have a stubborn, unproven conviction that there’s a capacity in there I never spent, that the intimidation was always bigger than the actual obstacle. As of this writing that capacity remains exactly that: unspent. I am not good. I’m a beginner with a beautiful red guitar and a lot of road to cover, and the honest report is that the dragon is very much alive and I am, at last, in the room with it. Not a midlife crisis, for the record, though it is, I’ll admit, a very sexy red guitar.</p><p>A fun wrinkle emerged once I’d spent some time with my grandmother’s guitar, which by now has earned a name: Bernice, after her middle name. I realized the guitar might be a path rather than a destination, and that the path ran backward, toward that goofy teenager scratching records. What I was doing back in the mid-eighties with the drum machine and the Casio keyboard was assembling hooks and rhythms. It dawned on me that there’s a guitar for that, a bass guitar, and that it might actually be the instrument for me. So I bought a bass and started learning it alongside the red Fender. I’ll continue to learn both but I suspect I’m a bass guy. We’ll see. For now I’m just bad at two instruments instead of one.</p><h3>The borrowed instrument</h3><p>That backward look goes further than the bass. The clunky kid’s studio and the AI tools I build with now are the same instinct forty years apart: find a way to make the thing without first becoming the person with the craft to make it. I’ve spent a whole run of these essays <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/unlocked-not-cheated/">defending that instinct</a>, sincerely, because for most of what I make it’s the right call. Not being an illustrator or graphic artist, I lean on AI to help create images I’d probably otherwise just not have. I have tons of story ideas and a legit feel for what works, but I use AI to scaffold complete stories where I don’t have the chops to write fiction from scratch. There are even times when I have the craft and reach for the machine anyway, to take it somewhere I couldn’t get on my own: I’m a decent critical thinker, but arguing ideas with AI pressure-tests them in a way I never could alone.</p><p>The guitar is the one place I’m refusing my own argument on purpose, and I nearly gave myself credit for turning down something nobody offered. Nothing on the market makes your hands play guitar. But there is a machine that makes music, and I could have a song by dinner: type a description, name a genre, get back three minutes with a hook and a bridge, a wicked guitar solo, and a clean fade-out, better than anything I made in 1986 and better than anything I’ll play this year, or next. That option is real and cheap and sitting right there. It’s useless to me.</p><p>The reason is the whole essay. With the images and the stories I wanted the thing to exist, the craft was in the way, so I went around it to get the output, and I’ll do it again tomorrow. With the guitar I don’t want a song. I want to be someone who can play a song, and nothing generates that. My absence of craft isn’t the obstacle here; it’s the entire point. Some difficulty <em>is</em> the work. <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/becoming-gnarly/">Not all friction is formative</a>. Telling those two apart is the only thing I’ve really been writing about this whole time.</p><p>Which means the choice was never whether to use the tool. It was whether to keep wanting the output, and wanting the output is exactly how I dodged this in 1986 and every year since. The hallway I found in the castle is still there. The machine has made it wider than it has ever been. The guitar is me finally taking my own distinction seriously enough to let it cost me.</p><p>There’s a word for something you use and don’t own: rent. It’s the right word for all of it, and that’s the part I’d left sitting under the argument all along. Route around a craft and you don’t acquire the ability, you rent it: output by the month, for exactly as long as the terms hold. Most of what I build now, I build on a borrowed instrument, rented from a handful of companies that can raise the price or change those terms whenever they like. But learn a craft and it’s yours, essentially forever. Nobody can reprice a G chord once your hands know it, any more than they could reprice a wrist shot.</p><p>The rented tool is only the near end of it. The far end is reach. Everything I make still has to find somebody or it may as well not exist, and <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-forge-was-a-side-effect/">that road was never mine either</a>. For thirty years that was a fine trade: whoever hired me owned the road, I owned the making, and the making was the part they couldn’t do without me. The things that were mine start to finish, the ones I’d win or lose on alone, I could never get in front of anybody at all. People still pay me for the making, and every year it gets harder to say why they should. Which leaves the road as the only part worth owning, and the road is the one I never learned to build. But I’m working on it.</p><p>Nobody stands at either end of the guitar. Nobody rents me the instrument, and nobody has to find it or buy it for it to do its whole job. It’s the back corner of the yard again, except this time the only one keeping score is me, and I’m harsher than the ten-year-olds ever were. It figures that the one instrument I own free and clear is the one I can barely play.</p><h3>Becoming, unfinished</h3><p>That’s where I have to leave it. The hockey story has an ending: I tried it, I loved it, I can tell you how it turned out. The guitar story may never get a clean one. I don’t get to describe the slain dragon’s body. I only get to tell you I finally walked in, and that it was still standing when I did.</p><p>There’s a word I keep coming back to for this whole disposition — <em>becoming</em> — and the guitar is where it stops being a tidy idea and turns into an unresolved thing in my actual hands. Two ways in, and they don’t cost the same.</p><p>The first is the refund. It’s easy to claim, because it’s already owed to you: the tax you paid getting good at something is sitting right there, and most Saturdays you can go collect it by being a happy idiot at something new.</p><p>The second is the dragon. The dragon refunds nothing: no tax coming back, no gradient promised, and nobody’s handing you this one. You go because the avoiding was costing more than the failing ever could.</p><p>I’m sure of the first. I’m in the middle of finding out about the second.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-tax-of-mastery/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33c76ee30348" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-tax-of-mastery-33c76ee30348">The Tax of Mastery</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Blade and the Rock]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-blade-and-the-rock-cae4a7b1a8ed?source=rss----8d353abb1970---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cae4a7b1a8ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Morrison]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Oct 2026 14:04:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-17T14:04:00.613Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9yMhz27QWuPdvilD.png" /></figure><p><em>I’ve built mountain bike trails with hand tools and ridden the kind a machine cuts in a day. The difference was never care. It’s a four-foot blade that can’t ask above-or-below-this-rock.</em></p><p>There’s a tool called a McLeod that shows up on every hand crew that’s ever built a hiking or mountain bike trail: a heavy flat blade about the width of your two hands on one edge, rake tines on the other, on a long ash handle. I’ve spent my share of days behind one, on a crew cutting new trail through the woods the slow way. It’s real work. Progress on a good day was measured in yards. And here’s the thing I remember most clearly about the process: it wasn’t the digging. It was the stopping.</p><p>Every few feet, something in the ground would put the work on pause. A rock the size of a microwave. A root as thick as your wrist. A tree standing exactly where the nicest line wanted to go. Or, where I live in middle Tennessee, ridiculous amounts of invasive honeysuckle. And the crew would straighten up, lean on the handles, and argue. Uproot the honeysuckle? Usually yes. Above the tree or below it? More often a debate. Below is a straighter line but it’ll erode over time and expose roots and be a rowdy bump in no time. Above works but requires a little uphill hook in an otherwise flowy line that steals speed. It also cuts the uphill roots, which are the ones a tree on a slope is really hanging by, weakening it and risking a tree fall later. Somebody’s seen a trail fail exactly this way before; somebody else rode one that didn’t. Two minutes, maybe five, then a verdict, and the digging starts again until the next rock or tree calls the next meeting. Every obstacle a stoppage, a discussion, and a judgment call.</p><p>I’ve also ridden plenty of trail cut by machine: a mini excavator walking the corridor, an operator who’s genuinely good at his job, doing in a day or two what a hand crew does in a month. Nobody in that machine is lazy or lying. The operator is making real judgments the whole time: where the corridor goes, how the grade rolls, where the water sheds. Gasoline-powered machines over ham-sandwich-powered humans operating at a fraction of the pace. Most of the time the trade is flat-out justified. The machine saves a month of volunteer weekends nobody had to give up, and the trail exists instead of not existing. For beginner trails it might even be the best way to build trails with a more polished tread.</p><p>But the two trails are different, every rider feels it, and I’ve come to think the difference is the blade.</p><h3>Wider than the rock</h3><p>This sounds obvious but you cannot make a decision finer than your tool’s blade. A McLeod resolves to about ten inches, so <em>above or below this rock</em> is a live question: the tool can express either answer. An excavator blade is four feet wide. When the blade is wider than the rock, the question doesn’t get answered badly. It just never gets asked. The rock is simply inside the cut, and the machine moves on, and there was no moment when anyone decided anything about it. The operator isn’t coarse. The question has no expression at that resolution. It’s hard to eat a grain of rice with a spatula.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ktEQsbbwjfDW0dBq.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Nobody decides anything about this rock. It is simply inside the cut, and the machine moves on.</em></p><p>That’s half of it. The other half is where the decisions live, and this is the part that took me longest to see. The hand crew doesn’t stop every few feet on principle. It stops <em>at the rock</em>. At the root, at the tree, at the spot where you can already see the water starting to gully. The terrain decides where judgment happens. Checkpoints aren’t evenly spaced along the work. They’re event-triggered, called into existence by the material, and they cluster wherever the material pushes back.</p><p>Put those two halves together and you get the actual shape of what a faster, coarser tool does. It doesn’t reduce judgment by some percentage. I know better than to <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/fifty-percent-of-what/">count</a>; percentage was never the unit, and an essay that starts tallying checkpoints has already lost. What it removes is a decision <em>class</em>. The operator makes every route-level call the crew makes, and he cannot make the per-rock class at all, because his blade can’t ask the question. Not fewer of the same decisions. All of one kind, none of another.</p><p>I want to be precise about how this differs from a worry I’ve <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-forge-was-a-side-effect/">already put on the page</a>. In <em>The Forge Was a Side Effect</em> I said the AI machine hands me pre-sorted research and I’m left “choosing inside a narrowing something else performed”: fewer options at each decision, and no way to see what fell out. That crack is about the inputs. This one is worse, and it’s different in kind: a narrowed option set at least <em>presents itself as a choice.</em> You stand there holding it, aware you’re choosing. An automatic, unmade decision leaves no trace at all. You don’t know you didn’t stop at the rock. There’s no rock in your memory to have an opinion about. There’s a new machine-cut trail down the street from me with rocks shouldered off into the woods on both sides, every one of them a decision nobody made. The trail is smooth right there, and smooth doesn’t testify.</p><h3>Approve every token</h3><p>Now carry this to the desk, because it was never really about trails. A model drafting your prose is the excavator posture: a thousand small decisions happening inside the generation, at machine speed, and you meet the trail already cut. The word-level choices, the sentence-rhythm choices, the this-clause-before-that-clause choices, all inside the blade, resolved without ever having been questions.</p><p>Here’s the thought experiment that convinced me this is structural and not just a vibe. Imagine an AI that required your approval of every single token. Maximum resolution: a checkpoint at literally every word. Surely <em>that</em> re-injects the judgment?</p><p>It doesn’t, and it fails three separate ways, which is what makes the experiment worth running.</p><p>First: approving is not choosing. Saying yes to an offered word is recognition. It’s narrow multiple-choice instead of fill-in-the-blank. Writing the word is search, and the search is where the alternatives live: the five words you tried and discarded, the phrasing that died on the way to the page. <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/again-funnier/">Again, Funnier</a> built this mechanism already: the superfan hears the record that shipped and never the ten thousand takes it beat. Survivors only. Token approval makes you a superfan of your own sentence, at the highest resolution possible — a checkpoint at every step and never once a fork.</p><p>Second: uniform spacing is the wrong shape. Judgment clusters at features because the terrain triggers it. That’s the whole point of the rock. Spraying approval evenly across every token isn’t more judgment; it’s judgment with the discrimination removed, and any honest human would habituate into rubber-stamping before the end of the first paragraph. The crew that stopped at every shovelful would argue about nothing, and get precisely nothing done, because nothing is what most shovelfuls contain.</p><p>Third — and this one I only know because I stood in the woods for it — some of the judgment is social, I’d even argue a form of rest. The crew argues <em>because the pace permits it.</em> Hands still, leaning on the handles, taking a drink of water, somebody’s five-year-old memory of a gullied switchback entering the record. The excavator removes that by physics, not by choice: engine noise, one seat. And one person approving tokens, alone, forever, never gets a second opinion back either.</p><p>So: judgment is not a quantity, and you cannot re-inject it by subdividing. Which means every framing of AI assistance as a dial — more human control, less human control, find your percentage — is measuring in a unit the problem doesn’t have.</p><h3>The caddie and the excavator</h3><p>If it’s not a dial, what is it? A golf course got me there.</p><p>Nobody disparages a professional golfer for using a caddie. Think about how strange that is for a minute. Amateurs are left entirely to their own devices; pros — at the highest level, in the open, on television — get an expert who helps with the read, the club, the line. Which is to say: the <em>judgment</em>. The part every argument in this run of essays says is sacred. And the golf world doesn’t blink.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NZv49AVStsY2UksM.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Two people at one stop, one decision. The player still has to hit it.</em></p><p>My first guess at why was that the caddie doesn’t swing the club. Execution stays with the player, so honor is preserved. But that doesn’t explain what golf actually tolerates. A caddie moves real judgment: the club, the read, the number, sometimes the plan for a whole hole. If handing off decisions were the offense, he’d be the scandal of the sport. Now push it the other way: a robot that perfectly swings whatever club the caddie hands it is cheating past argument, and the reason is that the swing is where the golfer’s work lives, and nobody was standing there to do it.</p><p>Here’s the boundary that holds. A caddie doesn’t remove the stop. The player still walks up, assesses the approach, the wind, the slope, still holds the decision in his hands, still overrides: <em>it’s an 8</em>, and the caddie shrugs and hands it over. The caddie adds another voice inside the same checkpoint. Same stops, thicker deliberation at each one. Maybe argues the 8 to a 7 if the decision is borderline. The trail excavator does the opposite: it doesn’t improve the decision at the rock, it removes the rock as a decision point.</p><p>That’s the discriminator: <strong>does the assistance happen at the checkpoint, or instead of it?</strong></p><p>Run my own practice through it and the sorting is almost embarrassing in how clean it comes out. <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-duck-that-argues-back/">The duck that argues back</a> is a caddie: I bring the position, it pushes back, I decide, and the stop survives, thicker rather than fewer. A model drafting the whole essay is an excavator, and everything I’ve ever described as “shoving the draft around until it’s mine” is me walking the finished cut looking for the rocks I never got to meet. When I worked out <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/what-ai-polish-does-to-hunter-s-thompson/">where the human hand goes in AI writing</a> — comedy wants the hand at the setup with the model reckless below it, literary prose wants the hand in the sentences the whole way down — I was drawing checkpoint maps without knowing the word for it. The hand goes wherever the checkpoints have to survive.</p><p>And before the caddie becomes too comforting, notice what he has that the model doesn’t. He’s paid on the winnings. He’ll tell you it’s a 7 when you’ve already pulled the 8, and he can stand there until you put it back. Stakes, and a stopping rule — <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/again-funnier/">the missing counterparty</a>, present and holding the bag. His read comes from walking the course with the outcome landing on him. The model at my desk has neither. So the caddie isn’t a reassurance that assistance is fine. He’s a specification of what assistance would have to be: a measuring stick the current tools mostly fail.</p><h3>The cockpit had to be built</h3><p>There’s an essay of mine this cuts directly into, and I owe it the collision. <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/we-already-voted-with-our-lives/">We Already Voted With Our Lives</a> made the case I still stand behind: judgment versus execution is the real line, the autopilot proves you can hand off the flying and keep command, so fly the pilot model — keep the judgment human, put your name on it, climb into the plane.</p><p>What that essay didn’t say — its “where the analogy stops” section lists authorship and credit and meaning, and walks right past this — is <em>why</em> the cockpit arrangement actually works. It isn’t the pilot’s virtue. It’s that the cockpit is a built structure of checkpoints: instruments, alarms, cross-checks, a second seat, callouts a crew is required to say out loud, a loop engineered over decades so that the human’s judgment has designated places to happen and can’t quietly not-happen. Aviation built a machine for making sure the stops survive for human verification, and then measured it in crashes that stopped coming.</p><p>The desk has none of that by default. The writer who “flies the pilot model” with a blank prompt window is a pilot in a cockpit with no instruments, no alarms, no second seat, nothing but her own intention that the judgment stay hers. Every user of these tools claims the judgment stayed theirs. The claim is sincere. It’s also unfalsifiable, which is the trouble: intention isn’t a checkpoint structure. <em>Keep the judgment human</em> is the prescription I’ve spent a whole arc repeating, and by itself it’s empty. Nothing at the desk makes a stop survive contact with a tool that’s fast, smooth, and agreeable. <em>Climb into the plane</em> was right. The correction is that the desk doesn’t come with the cockpit, and the cockpit is the apparatus, not the chair: the alarms, the cross-checks, the second person required to say the number back to you. What the desk offers instead is a machine that says <em>yes, let’s fly</em> every time, to anyone, in any condition, because agreeing is the one thing it’s sure how to do. Aviation’s stops can ground a flight. Nothing at your desk can, unless you put it there. You’re building the cockpit yourself, checkpoint by checkpoint, or you’re not in one.</p><h3>Where the line falls</h3><p>This also amends the essay of mine it argues with most directly. <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/everyones-a-ringer-to-somebody/">Everyone’s a Ringer to Somebody</a> traced the cheating line from quill to typewriter to laptop and found it always indexes to the self: every person draws it at their own feet, calls everything behind it quaint and everything ahead of it fraud. The best answer it could give was formative friction: ask what the friction was doing to <em>you</em>. A self-side criterion, honest about being one.</p><p>The trail hands me a second criterion, and it isn’t about the maker at all: <strong>can the tool resolve the feature in the material?</strong> That’s terrain-side. And here’s the evidence it isn’t just nostalgia wearing a tool belt: no trail purist on earth wants trail clawed out with bare hands. McLeods, rakes, shovels, wheelbarrows — tools, every one, and nobody laments them, the way no writing purist laments the word processor. The line isn’t nostalgic, it’s not drawn at <em>the tool I learned on</em>, which is where the ringer reflex always puts it. It falls where the blade stops being able to read the terrain. That’s a place you can point to in the material, argue about in public, and be wrong about, which makes it a different kind of line than any I drew in that essay. The ringer’s line moves with you. This one stays with the rock.</p><h3>Too steep and too twisty</h3><p>Our hand-built trail had a characteristic failure, and I helped build it in. Working at a crawl, we calibrated everything to the speed of a person standing still. We built the whole first stretch too steep and too twisty, because at digging pace every grade feels mellow and every turn feels wide. We never met the trail at the speed it would actually be ridden until it was cut, and then the bikes told us in about four minutes what the shovels hadn’t noticed in weeks. The machine operator, covering the whole line in a day, holds the run in his head at something much closer to riding tempo: the global shape, the flow, the way section hands off to section. He catches exactly what we missed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LWzr3fqVXDk3zfNm.jpg" /></figure><p><em>At digging pace a brutal grade feels mellow. The bikes disagreed in about four minutes.</em></p><p>His machine also has a constraint we didn’t. It’s less sure-footed than we were on a steep grade, and it has to climb what it’s cutting, so it pushes him toward mellower climbs whether he’s thinking about riders or not. Mellower is what a rider wants. You can read our version of that lesson right off our trail: the entry climbs are the most brutal thing out there, because they’re the first thing we built. Get deeper into the system and you can feel us find the groove, learning to imagine the trail at riding speed instead of trusting what our hands and feet were telling us at a standstill.</p><p>So every working tempo has a blind spot. Slow work over-indexes on the local and loses the global feel. Fast work catches the global and paves the local. Those are different artifacts, not a good one and a cheap one. Plenty of riders will tell you machine-built isn’t lesser, it’s just different, and they’re not wrong.</p><p>And the hardest version: a trail is ridden at speed, and an essay is read at speed. Nobody consumes anything at the tempo of its making. The reader moves through my paragraphs at something far closer to the machine’s drafting pace than to my crawl, which means the fast maker is, in one narrow and completely real sense, better calibrated to how the work will actually be met. The hand crew’s advantage was always the stops.</p><h3>A map of where the stops were</h3><p>One more turn, because the newest tool in this story knows something about checkpoints too.</p><p>The AI watermark that <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/notes/nobody-needed-the-key/">arrived this year</a> works by a keyed statistical lean in the model’s word choices. Anthropic hasn’t published its scheme, but every published one shares that shape. The detail that matters here: the signal can only ride on the tokens where the model had real options. Where the next word is forced, there’s no room to lean; where many words would do, the lean lives. The mark exists precisely where a choice was available to be made. Which means a watermark is, incidentally, a map of where the checkpoints were: the machine’s own record of the rocks.</p><p>Almost. The divergence is the actual finding. High entropy for the <em>model</em> is not high stakes for a <em>human</em>. Ten interchangeable synonyms give the mark plenty of room and cost the prose nothing: a rock the size of a pea. And the obvious next word — the one the model lays down with total confidence, no options, no lean — is exactly the word <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/standing-on-surfaces-that-move/">a good writer refuses</a>, because the model’s confidence peaks precisely where the median lives. The machine is smoothest exactly where a human would have swerved. So even a perfect map of the model’s choices can’t show you the stops that never happened — the blade doesn’t record the rocks it never felt.</p><p>Which brings me back to a sentence I once had to leave hanging. <em>Ringer</em> ended on a confession: a machine had offered the right patch for a hole in my argument, I’d taken it, and the essay closed on “I wrote this essay, and I still can’t call it.” I couldn’t, with what that essay had to work with. This one gives me a way.</p><p>Run it through the only structural test I now trust. I found the hole myself. The stop was already there, because I’d built it into how I work. The machine spoke <em>at</em> that stop rather than in place of it, one more voice at a checkpoint that would have happened anyway, and I made the call. That one’s clean.</p><p>What the test can’t tell me is the <a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-forge-was-a-side-effect/">forge question</a>, and it stays open: who learned what in that exchange, and what fifteen years of taking such patches does to the taker. A checkpoint can survive the assistance and still teach the machine more than it teaches you.</p><p>But the question I started with in the woods finally has its answer. It was never whether a machine touched the trail. The machine-built trail is real trail; the operator’s judgment is real judgment; some of you will ride the machined line and prefer it. The question is what happened at the rock. Did you stand there and argue — with a crew, a caddie, a duck, any second voice inside a stop you built and kept — or is the ground smooth right there, no memory attached, because the blade was wider than the rock and the question of your judgment never came up? Smooth doesn’t testify. Build the stops, or meet the trail already cut: at any speed, with any tool, that’s the whole difference between the two.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://michaelmorrison.com/essays/the-blade-and-the-rock/"><em>https://michaelmorrison.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cae4a7b1a8ed" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly/the-blade-and-the-rock-cae4a7b1a8ed">The Blade and the Rock</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/becoming-gnarly">Becoming Gnarly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>