<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Common Lodge - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Common Lodge is a place for written debates on cultural and political topics between opposing academics, practitioners, and public intellectuals. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/commonlodge?source=rss----ae59961ba793---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 10:08:40 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/commonlodge" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Zoos can’t be ethically justified.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/commonlodge/zoos-cant-be-ethically-justified-a8ceb29bb5e2?source=rss----ae59961ba793---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8ceb29bb5e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zoo]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Common Lodge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Jun 2019 23:26:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-29T15:21:27.457Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vb8Yj__52KnLlLJ3YS9dNA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Proposition</h3><p>Zoos are no longer ethically justified.</p><h3>For: Opening</h3><p>F.O.01 Entertainment used to be the only justification we needed to cage animals. But once investigations showed that animals suffered and died from living and working conditions, public opinion changed and with it the animal entertainment industry. In response, zoos adjusted and re-framed their mission to one that focused on education, scientific research, and conservation.</p><p>F.O.02 Change may be on the horizon, however, because new evidence shows that animals are sentient beings, many of whom have complex inner and emotional lives.</p><p>F.O.03 In 2012, it was declared, “humans are not unique in possessing the neurological substrates that generate consciousness.” All mammals, birds, and other animals like octopuses, possess consciousness (“<a href="http://fcmconference.org/img/CambridgeDeclarationOnConsciousness.pdf">Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness” 2012</a>). The great apes, dolphins, and elephants aren’t the only ones who mourn, celebrate, and plan for the future. These traits have even been observed in fish (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/What-Fish-Knows-Underwater-Cousins/dp/0374537097">Balcombe 2016</a>).</p><p>F.O.04 Today, few people believe that zoos are justified in keeping animals in captivity solely for entertainment. But what about for education, science, or conservation? Whether zoos successfully serve those purposes is uncertain and controversial. Because animals are sentient beings, the benefits of captivity don’t outweigh the costs.</p><h4>Educational Charades</h4><p>F.O.05 Proponents often defend zoo exhibits and amusements because of their role in educating people, especially children, about animals. The Association for Zoos and Aquariums (AZA) asserts that zoos are effective tools for education that positively change people’s attitudes toward wildlife (<a href="http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.574.3479&amp;rep=rep1&amp;type=pdf">Falk et al. 2007</a>).</p><p>F.O.06 Various researchers disagree. Some criticized the AZA study’s limitations, conflicts of interest, and assumptions (<a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10645578.2011.608001">Dawson and Jensen 2011</a>; <a href="https://animalstudiesrepository.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.com/&amp;httpsredir=1&amp;article=1007&amp;context=acwp_zoae">Marino et al. 2010</a>); none found support for the claim that zoos promote long-lasting education or changes in visitors’ attitudes (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22674295">Moss and Esson 2013</a>; <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10645578.2011.608001">Dawson and Jensen 2011</a>; <a href="https://animalstudiesrepository.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.com/&amp;httpsredir=1&amp;article=1007&amp;context=acwp_zoae">Marino et al. 2010</a>; <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13504620701430604">Ballantyne et al. 2007</a>; <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Zoos-21st-Century-Catalysts-Conservation/dp/0521618584">Reading and Miller 2007</a>).</p><p>F.O.07 Do people go to zoos for educational purposes? Zoos present manufactured, self-directed learning environments: if motivated by education, people must come to zoos with the intent to learn (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22674295">Moss and Esson 2013</a>). Most don’t — they visit to be entertained. If you’ve ever visited a zoo, you know from experience that most people spend little time reading signs, especially those with a lot of text or those next to unpopular animals.</p><p>F.O.08 Educational effectiveness can also be affected by several factors. Preexisting knowledge and attitudes (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22674295">Moss and Esson 2013</a>), how closely enclosures mimic natural environments (<a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13504620701430604">Ballantyne et al. 2007</a>), and an animal’s rarity, size, and endangered status (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Gianna_Moscardo/publication/266370151_Understanding_Visitor_Perspectives_on_Wildlife_Tourism/links/54d935970cf25013d04132a6.pdf">Moscardo et al. 2000</a>) all influence emotional appeal and thus, whether you’re likely to acquire new knowledge.</p><p>F.O.09 Since the evidence in support of education doesn’t stack up in favor of zoos, simply pursuing knowledge for its own sake isn’t ethical grounds for confining sentient beings in cages.</p><p>F.O.10 Zoos aren’t our only option for learning about wildlife, science, and conservation. Lectures, books, videos, assignments, and discussions from formal educational institutions can suffice. Plus, we can have immersive experiences through ecotourism and travel, spending time in the outdoors, and visiting national, state, or local parks, and museums.</p><h4>An Issue of Significance</h4><p>F.O.11 Zoos claim to support and conduct vital scientific research. Some provide funding or research support to unaffiliated scientists. The Lincoln Park Zoo in Chicago supports 19 field projects where multiple independent organizations work together <a href="https://www.lpzoo.org/conservation-science">(“Conservation and Science” n.d.</a>). Zoos are most likely to contribute to science as part of a collaborative network that focuses on ecosystem and species health. Nevertheless, those studies rarely benefit zoo animals and most of this research could be supported by other agencies.</p><p>F.O.12 Research conducted at zoos tends to focus on animal behavior, anatomy, and pathology to improve zoo conditions and clarify animal preferences and stressors. That research isn’t valuable in its own right because if zoos didn’t exist, there wouldn’t be a need for research on how to improve them!</p><p>F.O.13 Since most zoo research is conducted on captive animals, it’s generally limited in scope, experimental design, and relevance. The behavior of captive animals and experimental constraints are highly variable. Therefore, experiments are unlikely to be replicated — a tenet of scientific research — and results won’t be consistent between zoos or captive and wild animals.</p><p>F.O.14 Statistically, credible scientific research requires robust sample sizes. The small number of animals of a species at zoos precludes generalization of results, especially to field settings. Such research would be useless for understanding wildlife threats and conserving species in the wild.</p><p>F.O.15 In reality, very few zoos do significant research. Although 173 of the 236 AZA-accredited zoos reported participating in research projects, only 11 had full-time research staff. Of the 1,280 reported studies in 2017, 170 papers, reports, or book chapters were published (<a href="https://www.aza.org/research-and-science">“Research and Science” n.d.</a>). Only 13% of studies have become available to the scientific community, while the majority of the research hasn’t been published.</p><p>F.O.16 The best research uncovers a universal truth so significant that it sheds light on an issue as a whole and thus outweighs any costs. Because it’s clear that most zoo research doesn’t do this, keeping animals in captivity for research purposes is not justified.</p><h4>A Dying Breed of Conservation</h4><p>F.O.17 Do zoos conserve species that would otherwise go extinct? Most attempt to do so through Species Survival Plan (SSP) breeding programs. The aim is to “oversee the population management of select species” across AZA-accredited institutions and “enhance conservation of [that] species in the wild” (<a href="https://www.aza.org/species-survival-plan-programs">“Species Survival Plan Programs” n.d.</a>). Note that SPP programs don’t require a species to be endangered.</p><p>F.O.18 The SSP strives to maximize genetic diversity and population sustainability. Ironically, one of the largest concerns with breeding programs is genetic diversity loss (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1389760/">Jiang et al. 2005</a>), often resulting in high infant mortality rates (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Defense-Animals-Second-Wave/dp/1405119411">Jamieson 2006</a>). Animals bred in captive isolation within small sub-populations can also diverge behaviorally and genetically, so that eventually, they differ from the source population in the wild (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Defense-Animals-Second-Wave/dp/1405119411">Jamieson 2006</a>) raising concerns about reintroductions.</p><p>F.O.19 Despite the ubiquitous use of contraception (an ethical issue in its own right), many breeding programs produce a surplus of animals. Zoos may engage in what Marc Bekoff, a professor emeritus of ecology and evolutionary biology, calls “zoothanasia”: the intentional killing of healthy animals who don’t fit into a zoo’s breeding program (<a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/animal-emotions/201208/zoothanasia-is-not-euthanasia-words-matter">Bekoff 2012</a>). Animals can also end up in circuses, roadside shows, or be sold on the black market, which fuels the exotic animal and parts trade and illegal breeding programs (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Defense-Animals-Second-Wave/dp/1405119411">Jamieson 2006</a>).</p><p>F.O.20 Ideally, zoo breeding programs release captive-born animals into the wild to supplement endangered wild populations, but it is an elusive goal. Habituation to humans, a lack of survival and hunting behaviors and skills, and the complicated nature of reintroducing new individuals into cohesive groups, mean that most reintroduced animals die (<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0006320707004417">Jule et al. 2008</a>; <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0006320700000483">Fischer and Lindenmayer 2000</a>).</p><p>F.O.21If a species isn’t protected in the wild — the reason many are endangered — the reintroduction of new animals will cause suffering and fail. Out of 500 AZA SSP programs (<a href="https://www.aza.org/species-survival-plan-programs">“Species Survival Plan Programs” n.d.</a>), ten species have been “saved from the brink” (<a href="https://medium.com/taronga-conservation-society-australia/10-endangered-species-saved-from-extinction-by-zoos-682c454d0125">“10 endangered species” 2017</a>). But the lack of protection they receive in the wild continues to threaten their existence. Dr. Paul Dolman, a lead researcher from the University of East Anglia states, “without conservation in the wild there is no point in captive breeding” (<a href="http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/06/150604203450.htm">University of East Anglia 2015</a>). In some cases it can do more harm than good (<a href="https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1365-2664.12449">Dolman et al. 2015</a>).</p><p>F.O.22 We should ask ourselves this final, poignant question: Should we strive to conserve species that may only exist in zoos one day?</p><h4>No Justification</h4><p>F.O.23 Zoos claim to be important institutions for education, research, and conservation despite the lack of scientific evidence for these outcomes. They deny animals a basic right to freedom, elicit unnatural behaviors leading to stress, and can cause suffering or death. Zoos also perpetuate the false belief that humans are superior and have the right to use and abuse other species for selfish gain.</p><p>F.O.24 Without proof that zoos promote education or support significant research and conservation, we are left with anecdotes and knowledge for its own sake, which doesn’t justify keeping sentient beings captive. Once we understand that many animals are capable of complex thought and emotion, acknowledging that zoos are unethical institutions comes on its heels.</p><h3>Against: Opening</h3><p>A.O.01 It is difficult to think of a more wholesome family activity than a visit to the local zoo. Seeing the awe and inspiration displayed on a child’s face when they see an elephant or zebra for the first (and perhaps only) time in person is powerful. At the same time, zoos have come under fire for their treatment of animals. To be sure, the concern of animal maltreatment is valid and serious. Many people feel that humans do not have a right to contain wild animals in any capacity to begin with, let alone in spaces that are arguably inhumane. Furthermore, many would agree that animals are intelligent, important, and exist for purposes well beyond that of human education and pleasure.</p><p>A.O.02 In an ideal world, no animals would be endangered or threatened as a result of human impacts on their natural environment. However, we live in a world struggling with climate change, habitat loss, and other increasing threats to wildlife. In this context, zoos are ethically justifiable for three reasons. First, they are a haven from the struggles of habitat loss, starvation, and other challenges in the wild. Second, zoos offer natural spaces in otherwise urban areas, thus providing unique spaces that enhance communities and contribute to human flourishing. And third, zoos provide enriching educational opportunities for people of all ages who otherwise may not have access to such opportunities. The exposure can help form children and adults into socially- and environmentally-conscious individuals who can help fight for the fair treatment of animals in zoos and beyond. In other words, zoos can help address the very injustices that their opponents highlight.</p><h4>Zoos help vulnerable species</h4><p>A.O.03 Zoos save animals from poachers, starvation, habitat loss, and predators. Because of the threat of climate change, animals are more vulnerable than ever to environmental threats from human actions. Of course, the reality of climate change demands long-term sustainable action. Yet, at the very least, zoos can provide a short-term <a href="https://www.aza.org/aza-and-animal-program-conservation-initiatives">refuge</a> for animals who are vulnerable or endangered. Not only do zoos offer refuge for vulnerable and endangered species, but they actively work to reverse this vulnerability by breeding animals that would otherwise be vulnerable to extinction. This breeding often leads to <a href="https://www.aza.org/reintroduction-programs">reintroduction programs</a> that release animals back into the wild. This process further works to reverse the damaging effects of habitat loss, poachers, and other human-induced environmental challenges.</p><p>A.O.04 For example, according to <a href="http://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/22706052">Bird Life International</a>, the Hawaiian Crow is extinct in the wild, but has found refuge in captivity. A reintroduction plan is being developed so that it can safely return to the wild. Additionally, the <a href="http://www.aza.org/">Association of Zoos and Aquariums</a> (AZA) has developed <a href="https://www.aza.org/species-survival-plan-programs">Species Survival Plan Programs</a> that work to “oversee the population management of select species…and to enhance conservation of this species in the wild.”</p><p>A.O.05 Zoos allow for better research on animals. In fact, all AZA-accredited zoos are expected to participate in <a href="https://www.aza.org/research-and-science">research </a>in order to “advance scientific knowledge of the animals in [their] care, enhance the conservation of wild populations, and engage and inspire the visiting public.” By engaging in humane research in zoos, we can better understand vulnerable animals and work harder to protect them than we could in the wild.</p><p>A.O.06 Accredited zoos can be trusted in that they are regulated by entities such as the AZA. Those that are not AZA-accredited are still regulated by the federal <a href="https://www.thoughtco.com/overview-of-the-animal-welfare-act-127546">Animal Welfare Act</a> (AWA), which helps ensure that animals in zoos have “adequate housing, handling, sanitation, nutrition, water, veterinary care and protection from extreme weather and temperatures.” This legislation allows for unannounced checks of zoos and works to make sure the animals are well cared for at all times. To be sure, there is broad criticism that AWA regulations are insufficient. However, given the significant advantages of zoos presented here, this criticism does not mean that zoos are hopelessly harmful and cruel. Rather, this legislative shortcoming calls for better regulation, not for the eradication of zoos altogether.</p><p>A.O.07 Finally, we must not conflate freedom with goodness. <a href="https://www.nwf.org/Educational-Resources/Wildlife-Guide/Threats-to-Wildlife">The National Wildlife Federation</a> rightly points out that animals in the wild must deal with the threat and stress of predators, untreated illness and injury, invasive species, poor diet, and exposure to the elements. In well-run zoos, however, animals do not have to deal with these challenges, at least not to the same extent. This does not mean that all animals in the wild should be brought into captivity. It merely demonstrates that those who are vulnerable and brought into captivity can experience relief from stressors in the wild.</p><h4>Zoos provide spaces for human flourishing and health</h4><p>A.O.08 More than 135 million people visit the more than one hundred zoos in the United States every year (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Why-Wild-Things-Are-Children/dp/0674017528">Melson 75</a>). Many of these people live in urban areas with high population density and very little green space. Los Angeles and New York City, for instance, are the two most densely populated cities in the country, making it arduous for residents to get around each day, let alone find time for nature (<a href="https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/the-most-crowded-city-in-the-united-states.html">Dillinger 2017</a>). Fortunately, cities like these usually have zoos available for their residents. The presence of these zoos helps ensure that folks in urban environments have exposure to more than urban critters like dogs and pigeons. This matters because, as one study found, “feeling connected to animals at the zoo is significantly associated with cognitive and emotional responses to climate change, as well as with other social groupings and social responses” (<a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/13504622.2013.816267">Clayton et al. 2014</a>). Another study discusses how visits to natural spaces can have positive effects on our health. That is, there are “comprehensive health benefits of exposure to nature and green environments on human systems” (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5580555/">Hansen et al. 2017</a>). Zoos offer these green spaces and can provide some health benefits by bringing wild nature to the cities. Their presence can offer mental and emotional relief for humans while also educating them about the environmental issues that affect them and non-human animals so pervasively and deeply.</p><h4>Zoos contribute to education and environmental efforts</h4><p>A.O.09 Interactions with animals can help children engage in critical thinking about their connection to non-human animals and their own place in the wider ecosystem (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Why-Wild-Things-Are-Children/dp/0674017528">Melson 2001</a>). In <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Geography-Childhood-Children-Concord-Library/dp/0807085251">The Geography of Childhood: Why Children Need Wild Places</a>, Nabhan and Trimble emphasize the importance of children’s interactions with wild animals in order to prevent what they call “the extinction of experience” (p. 92). Zoos can help facilitate and strengthen environmental literacy by giving children unique interactions with animals from not only their own region, but also regions all over the world (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Why-Wild-Things-Are-Children/dp/0674017528">Melson 2001</a>). Experiences like these help shape children at a malleable age. That is, zoos help them see early on that animals hold a valuable place in the ecosystem and deserve our protection and respect. Accredited zoos also offer training programs to teachers who will reach out to children. Within a recent ten-year span, more than 400,000 teachers were trained with sophisticated science curricula that they then passed onto young minds. In other words, zoos reach well beyond their borders to inspire and teach young people (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Why-Wild-Things-Are-Children/dp/0674017528">Melson 2001</a>).</p><p>A.O.10 Finally, a conservation biologist theorizes that “a physical separation from nature . . . leads to a psychological separation from nature” (<a href="https://www.thenatureofcities.com/2014/01/22/what-is-the-point-of-zoos/">Mader 2014</a>). That is, those who do not have easy access to natural spaces may be less likely to think about nature and its importance. This dynamic can potentially lead to less awareness, understanding, and action regarding issues like climate change. In fact, one study of more than 5,000 people found that zoo visits did, in fact, “prompt individuals to reconsider their role in environmental problems and conservation action, and to see themselves as part of the solution” (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/253004933_Why_Zoos_Aquariums_Matter_Assessing_the_Impact_of_a_Visit_to_a_Zoo_or_Aquarium">Falk et al. 2007</a>). Those surveyed also identified a stronger connection to nature because of their visits to local zoos. Overall, zoos help individuals of all ages think critically about the animals they are seeing, the wider ecosystems, and their own roles within them.</p><p><a href="https://commonlodge.substack.com/subscribe?utm_medium=web&amp;utm_source=subscribe-widget&amp;utm_content=79052">Subscribe now</a></p><h3>For: Rebuttal</h3><p>F.R.01 My opponent provides a compelling defense for zoos. However, her arguments are deficient or they perpetuate a human-centered worldview and therefore, provide a false basis for justification.</p><p>F.R.02 First, I need to address an overarching concern. Misconceptions about zoo accreditation and licensing are common, and the argument in A.O.05 is overly simplistic. About 2,800 animal exhibitors are licensed in the United States, but fewer than 10% are AZA-accredited (<a href="https://www.aza.org/what-is-accreditation">“About AZA Accreditation” n.d.</a>). Although the remaining 2,520 exhibitors are licensed by the USDA’s Animal &amp; Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS), the Animal Welfare Act only requires a minimum basic care and doesn’t cover birds, rats, mice, livestock, reptiles, amphibians, fish, or invertebrates (<a href="https://www.thoughtco.com/overview-of-the-animal-welfare-act-127546">Lin 2007</a>).</p><h4>Zoos Aren’t Safe Havens</h4><p>F.R.03 The claim that zoos are a “haven” from environmental threats (A.O.02) and that we shouldn’t “conflate freedom with goodness” in this context (A.O.06) is fanciful. Sheltering animals from experiencing harsh realities of a life in the wild — which they’d be exposed to if they were reintroduced — doesn’t mean captivity is virtuous or preferable to freedom. A life lacking intellectual stimulation and the freedom to exercise natural instincts and proclivities is hardly desirable.</p><p>F.R.04 My opponent continues, saying zoos provide “short-term refuge for vulnerable and endangered species,” and they “reverse this vulnerability by breeding animals that would otherwise be vulnerable to extinction” through reintroduction programs (A.O.03). This is misleading. In fact, the majority of captive-born animals aren’t endangered or reintroduced to the wild. Only 16% of species in AZA-accredited zoos are threatened or endangered and only 34% of all SSP breeding programs focus on endangered species (<a href="https://www.aza.org/zoo-and-aquarium-statistics">“Zoo and Aquarium Statistics” n.d.</a>).</p><p>F.R.05 Breeding programs are also highly unethical (see F.O.19). A horrifying example was when Marius the giraffe in Copenhagen was killed, butchered, and fed to lions in full view of zoo visitors because his genetic makeup was overrepresented in the zoo’s gene pool (<a href="https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/02/140210-giraffe-copenhagen-science/">Smith 2014</a>).</p><p>F.R.06 Lastly, the argument for research isn’t as strong as suggested in A.O.05. I mention in F.O.12 through F.O.14 that most zoo research is conducted on captive animals to understand their preferences within the confines of a zoo or is very limited in terms of scope and relevance. That research is not only unimportant, but it also doesn’t help us “understand vulnerable species” or “protect them” in the wild (A.O.05).</p><h4>An Egocentric Flourishing</h4><p>F.R.07 Next, my opponent argues, “zoos offer natural spaces in otherwise urban areas, thus providing unique spaces that enhance communities and contribute to human flourishing” (A.O.02). She cites psychological and social benefits for humans living in overcrowded cities removed from nature (A.O.08). Clearly, this is a valid point in favor of zoos, but only if you consider the benefits to humans and ignore the impacts on other animals. Of course, for zoos to be beneficial in this way, people must actually visit them.</p><p>F.R.08 The idea that zoos emotionally connect people to animals and nature and encourage us to think about climate change is compelling (A.O.08). However, the researchers are careful to point out that although zoo visitors expressed a sense of connection, which was related to attitudes about climate change, “The data cannot distinguish whether the sense of connection is preexisting or is a more transient state induced by the zoo visit.” In other words, the study found a correlation between them, not causality (<a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13504622.2013.816267">Clayton et al. 2014</a>).</p><p>F.R.09 These arguments can’t <em>ethically</em> justify zoos because they’re human-centered and fail to account for the lives of animals.</p><h4>The Fallacy of Education</h4><p>F.R.10 The last justification offered is that “zoos provide enriching educational opportunities for people of all ages” (A.O.02). I agree that feeling connected to nature and environmental literacy is important (A.O.09). However, I explain in F.O.05 through F.O.08 that the evidence isn’t conclusive.</p><p>F.R.11 The most widely cited reference for the educational benefits of zoos (included in A.O.10) has been subjected to scrutiny and criticism (<a href="http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.574.3479&amp;rep=rep1&amp;type=pdf">Falk et al. 2007</a>) (See F.O.05 and F.O.06). The researchers were accused of making several methodological errors and strong causal claims that weren’t supported by their data (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22674295">Moss and Esson 2013</a>; <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10645578.2011.608001">Dawson and Jensen 2011</a>; <a href="https://animalstudiesrepository.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.com/&amp;httpsredir=1&amp;article=1007&amp;context=acwp_zoae">Marino et al. 2010</a>). For instance, they measured what people <em>said</em> they believed, not their actual knowledge, and failed to account for response bias — that is, whether people were providing answers they thought the researchers wanted to hear.</p><p>F.R.12 Unfortunately, there also aren’t data to support the statement that people who visit zoos will “help fight for the fair treatment of animals” (A.O.02) since “zoos help [children] see early on that animals hold a valuable place in the ecosystem and deserve our protection and respect” (A.O.09). Realistically, it may do exactly the opposite. By taking children to zoos, we teach them it’s morally OK to confine animals and perpetuate the false belief that we are superior.</p><p>F.R.13 It makes sense that people “who do not have easy access to natural spaces may be less likely to think about nature and its importance,” which could “lead to less awareness, understanding, and action regarding issues like climate change” (A.O.09). However, I disagree that zoos are the best way to bridge that gap.</p><p>F.R.14 Caging animals isn’t a solution for “a world struggling with climate change, habitat loss, and other increasing threats to wildlife” (A.O.02). It only creates another problem. If zoos’ main objective were to protect vulnerable species in the wild, then they would house only endangered species; all captive-bred animals would be both endangered and reintroduced to the wild; and animals wouldn’t be killed for not fitting into a zoo’s breeding program.</p><h3>Against: Rebuttal</h3><h4>Education Is Often a Subtle and Prolonged Process</h4><p>A.R.01 I want to add some nuance to the evolution of zoos that my opponent outlines in F.O.01. Although part of the narrative may have been zoos responding to criticism, there also was a backdrop of “a great interest in the ethology and social biology of animals” (<a href="https://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/rearvision/the-ethical-history-of-zoos/6869776">Phillips 2015</a>). In other words, there were more altruistic motives behind the evolution of zoos. Many folks wanted to understand more about the animals and provide good care for them, not merely avoid criticism (although this may have been part of the shift for some).</p><p>A.R.02 In F.O.07, my opponent assumes that many people — perhaps most people — visit zoos without explicitly learning anything. However, just because people may not spend their time explicitly learning at zoos does not mean they are not affected and inspired in positive ways. Learning can be implicit, subtle, and impactful over the long-term.</p><p>A.R.03 In F.O.09, my opponent states, “simply pursing knowledge for its own sake, isn’t ethical grounds for confining sentient beings in cages.” I agree with her that this reason alone is insufficient. However, my opponent leaves out the many other reasons that she and I have both discussed for why zoos exist. With these combined reasons (conservation, inspiration, etc.), I argue that zoos are ethically justified.</p><p>A.R.04 As I stated in paragraph A.O.10, “a physical separation from nature…leads to a psychological separation from nature” (<a href="https://www.thenatureofcities.com/2014/01/22/what-is-the-point-of-zoos/">Mader 2014</a>). This disconnect can lead to weakened engagement with issues pertaining to environmentalism and animal welfare. Although books, videos, and discussions can be highly valuable, they do not compare to being in physical proximity to animals and the wonder they inspire (F.O.10). As far as the “ecotourism and travel” that my opponent recommends in F.O.10, these activities can be difficult for low-income families. Given the ubiquity of zoos, they offer everyone the opportunity to be immersed in unique natural spaces with animals they may never otherwise encounter.</p><h4>Research Is Justified Given the Complexity at Hand</h4><p>A.R.05 In F.O.12, my opponent writes that research on animals in captivity would not be necessary if zoos did not exist. On its own, this statement is true. However, it ignores the fact that animals are in zoos for complex and valid reasons, such as preservation and safety. Her argument dismisses this reality by assuming that zoos exist simply for our entertainment.</p><p>A.R.06 In F.O.15, my opponent sets a high bar for research. To expect studies to “[uncover] a universal truth” is unfair and ignores the countless studies whose conclusions fall short of this, but still manage to shed some light on the issue at hand. Many studies end with humble results, often emphasizing their limits and the need for additional research. This does not mean that their research was done in vain. I agree that the products of research should outweigh any costs. However, my opponent speaks of research as if it is the only thing keeping animals in captivity. As she and I have both pointed out, there are other reasons.</p><p>A.R.07 In F.O.16, my opponent notes that the AZA does not require a species to be endangered in order to be a part of a Species Survival Plan program. While not a strict requirement, the AZA does specify that these programs aim to “manage and conserve a select and <em>typically threatened or endangered</em>” species population (<a href="https://www.aza.org/animal-programs">Animal Programs</a>, n.d.; emphasis added). While perhaps not all their efforts pertain to vulnerable species, they explicitly prioritize these groups and make a concerted effort to engage in conservation.</p><p>A.R.08 The issues raised in F.O.18 are undoubtedly serious. No animals should have to suffer or die unnecessarily, whether that is from “zoothanasia” or being sold on the black market. These challenges do not necessitate the elimination of zoos altogether, but require better regulation. Zoos come with many benefits, as I have argued. Let not the perfect be the enemy of the good.</p><h4>Zoos Embody a Helpful Way Forward</h4><p>A.R.09 In F.O.23, my opponent writes, “zoos also perpetuate the false belief that humans are superior and have the right to use and abuse other species for selfish gain.” Of course, we should never advocate for or excuse the abuse of animals. I want to argue that, regardless of whether we see ourselves as superior beings, we as human beings have a responsibility to combat the human-induced threats of climate change, habitat loss, etc. Zoos help us do that by offering regulated spaces for vulnerable species, combatting the forces that make them vulnerable in the first place, and inspiring the public to do the same. These goals do not exist merely for selfish gain.</p><h3>For: Closing</h3><p>F.C.01 In the beginning I stated, “Entertainment used to be the only justification we needed to cage animals” (F.O.01). But it was eventually regarded as unethical. It’s time to reexamine the ethical role of zoos and their support of education, scientific research, and conservation in the justification of animal captivity.</p><p>F.C.02 By definition, education requires knowledge gain. Yet, there’s no conclusive evidence that zoos promote education or beneficial attitude changes towards wildlife. Knowledge for its own sake isn’t grounds for keeping animals captive, and neither inspiration (A.R.02 and A.R.04) nor the virtue of encountering unfamiliar animals (A.R.04) can act as education. On the whole, zoos aren’t justified by inspiring a few visitors.</p><p>F.C.03 Zoos support little scientific research. Most studies are under constraining limitations, which prevents a wider application because they are conducted on captive animals. Research ideally “uncover[s] a universal truth so significant that it sheds light on an issue as a whole and thus, outweighs any costs” (F.O.16). It’s never been truer than when applied to living, sentient animals. We should be demanding the highest standards for research in terms of ethics, significance, and credibility — that would be fair (A.R.06).</p><p>F.C.04 Instances where zoos have prevented species extinctions or contributed to conservation efforts in the wild are rare. SSP programs are unethical and unlikely to conserve wild populations because they don’t focus exclusively on endangered species and most captive-born animals aren’t reintroduced to the wild (F.R.04).</p><p>F.C.05 My opponent suggests these inadequacies can be addressed through regulation (A.O.06 and A.R.08). But better regulations aren’t going to address animal captivity — the ethical issue being discussed.</p><p>F.C.06 Based on the evidence, zoos don’t successfully serve their goals. Coupled with the knowledge that animals (especially those in zoos) are capable of suffering and complex thoughts and emotions, the benefits of zoos do not outweigh the costs of captivity. Just as circuses lost public favor, so too will zoos.</p><h3>Against: Closing</h3><p>A.C.01 I want to reiterate my stance that the poor regulation of zoos does not automatically necessitate their removal from society altogether. It is more realistic and appropriate to insist on improved regulation of zoos. This action would allow zoos to continue carrying out the benefits I have outlined while also holding them to a higher standard that ensures the flourishing of all creatures. Put another way, zoos are not inherently bad when one considers what they are responding to (environmental destruction) and working toward (a better world for all animals). Rather, zoos become harmful when they are poorly regulated.</p><p>A.C.02 This argument extends into the discussion on breeding and reintroduction. If only a minority of endangered species are a part of Species Survival Plan breeding programs (F.R.04), we must fight to change that, not erase zoos entirely. We must push for the preservation of animals like the Hawaiian Crow (A.O.04) that is extinct in the wild, but will soon be reintroduced to the wild, thanks to the hard work of zoo officials.</p><p>A.C.03 Zoos also offer wholesome, accessible natural environments where people of all ages and abilities can come together to experience a small, yet powerful snapshot of nature. This refuge from more urban settings not only offers physical and psychological health benefits, but it engages people with issues of environmentalism, climate change, and their own individual impact in the world (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5580555/">Hansen et al. 2017</a>).</p><p>A.C.04 As I have stated, many zoos train educators in their communities, thus teaching people — children especially — not just through direct experience with animals, but indirectly in children’s own daily learning environments (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Why-Wild-Things-Are-Children/dp/0674017528">Melson 2001</a>). This knowledge and these experiences provided by zoos help form young people to think more critically about the natural world and their place in it (<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Why-Wild-Things-Are-Children/dp/0674017528">Melson 2001</a>).</p><p><a href="https://commonlodge.substack.com/subscribe?utm_medium=web&amp;utm_source=subscribe-widget&amp;utm_content=79052">Subscribe now</a></p><h3>Debaters</h3><h4>For: Haley R. Pope</h4><p>Haley R. Pope has a Master of Science in Zoology from Stellenbosch University in South Africa where she studied marine ecology and climate change (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Haley_Pope2">Research</a>). As the President of TerraLens Photography LLC, Haley provides conservation photography, photo archiving, and writing services and has written for organizations like the North American Nature Photography Association and Save Our Seas Foundation. This work can be viewed on her <a href="https://www.terralensphotography.com/">website</a>. Haley provided the image for this debate.</p><h4>Against: Tara Corbett</h4><p>Tara Corbett has a Master’s in Social Work from the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, as well as a Master’s in Theological Studies from Duke University. Tara is fascinated by the intersections of ethics, theology, and culture. As a recent Duke graduate, she hopes to land a job that empowers marginalized women. Longer-term, Tara plans to pursue a PhD in Christian social ethics.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8ceb29bb5e2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge/zoos-cant-be-ethically-justified-a8ceb29bb5e2">Zoos can’t be ethically justified.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge">Common Lodge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Identity politics is a net positive force.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/commonlodge/identity-politics-is-a-net-positive-force-a35756ab7640?source=rss----ae59961ba793---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a35756ab7640</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[identity-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Common Lodge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Apr 2019 14:26:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-08T21:51:40.654Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A-HfHhz3NTPAi9VFAruGqw.png" /></figure><p><em>For by Dan Melo. Against by Matt Johnson. Please see end of debate for bios.</em></p><h3><strong>Opening: For</strong></h3><p>F.O.1 Despite being a persistent object of scorn, identity politics is not an all-powerful trump card. It has served and continues to serve a vital role in helping us shape our understanding of, and the solutions to, the problems faced by marginalized people. What’s more, it’s part of the inexorable trek toward advancing universal human rights. When stripped of the rhetoric, it’s a necessary, pragmatic first step. Identity politics, like any other human construct, is imperfect and subject to pitfalls, but ultimately provides both strength and a voice for marginalized groups to better advance their rights as people, thereby exerting a net positive force in society.</p><h4><strong>What Do We Mean by Identity?</strong></h4><p>F.O.2 A definition of identity politics seems to derive from any identity group positioning itself as unique regarding an issue or past grievance, e.g., LGBTQ+ and marriage equality, people of color and segregation, etc. We have had to make distinctions regarding identity for legal purposes — an immutable characteristic. But from an epistemological standpoint, identity could be categorized rather broadly, with anyone capable of being sorted into any number of identities based on a trait or set of traits. A group of people of color could also be cis-gendered, male, Marxists, Buddhists, etc. The key in any attempt at a concise definition (and thus, in part, the merits of the identity politics approach) is recognizing there is a level of universality to categorization, whether external or self-imposed, making some form of identity inescapable.</p><p>F.O.3 <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/identity-politics/#HistScop">The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy</a>’s definition of identity politics, while broad, serves as a useful standpoint from which to analyze the subject –“the term signifies a loose collection of political projects, each undertaken by representatives of a collective with a distinctively different social location that has hitherto been neglected, erased, or suppressed.” The alternative fine line-drawing that often happens at this stage of defining identity politics requires too much focus on a particular approach (e.g., the problems of <a href="https://areomagazine.com/2018/09/25/identity-politics-does-not-continue-the-work-of-the-civil-rights-movements/">social constructivist theory</a>) and comes with a series of epistemological problems; versus having to defend the concept writ large. The more universal the definition, the better the explanation (and justification for it) needs to be.</p><p>F.O.4 Identity plays a significant role in shaping our knowledge and is necessary for identity-based empowerment (closing the gap between marginalized people and the rest of society). A momentary detour into the world of physics is illustrative. Carlos Rovelli argued in The Order of Time that our understanding of time is based exclusively on how we choose to organize information. He illustrates this using a deck of playing cards: if we shuffle the cards and then array them, how do we decide which one is first? Is it the first card in the deck? The smallest number? The first red card? Or maybe the first spade? Rovelli’s point is that “order,” (and therefore time) as we perceive it, is a relative thing; deciding what comes first requires one to set a second (or third) parameter to judge “first” by — in this instance numbers, colors, or whether a card is on top or bottom. It’s only in this relational aspect between two things that we arrive at any sense (albeit an illusory one) of order.</p><p>F.O.5 So too with identity. It is precisely by setting ourselves apart from one another based on certain categories that we can recognize where we stand in relation to things like equal access to certain rights. Based on how the slave-holding writers of the U.S. Constitution sorted human beings relative to rights, they did not appear to believe that the parameters set by words “all men are created equal” applied to their human property. Categorization determined treatment.</p><p>F.O.6 The relative nature of human interaction makes a focus on identity not just an important, but a required first step toward advancing universal liberalism; in part because the oppression is grounded on that same identity. The Civil Rights Movement was able to promote the cause of people of color because it identified where they stood relative to whites. Gay Pride advanced sexual freedom through the contrast of its identity to heterosexuals. They were not advocating for universal rights in a vacuum, free from the existence and promotion of a particular identity. Their success is as much about how each identity group related to another (white to black, gay to straight) as it was about how each group related to the rights at stake. There was and is no way to accomplish this end without some version of identity politics, because there’s no way to perceive and remedy problems without identifying them through comparison.</p><p>F.O.7 Attempting to cement universal human rights free from identity creates the problem of foundationalism. David Deutsch, physicist and author of The Beginning of Infinity, debunks this approach — there are no absolute foundations to anything because foundations only exist in response to a problem. In other words, no theory of physics exists independent of the universe it is trying to explain. Similarly, universal rights do not emerge separate and distinct from the problem of particular identities not having them. The Civil Rights Movement, Gay Pride, and New Wave Feminism could not pursue rights separate from their identities. It’s illogical for the remedies to focus on a group’s identity but claim that the problem cannot be defined by that identity.</p><p>F.O.8 We conceptualize the idea of universal human rights because of identity. People on a planet where no humans have experienced a deprivation of life, liberty, or property because of their skin color have no reason to identify themselves as black or white or anything else as it relates to those issues. Which is not to say they wouldn’t identify themselves at all, merely that skin color, etc., are of no consequence to their understanding of their rights. One cannot break with identity to address the problems that stem from it. Regardless of what drives the social theory and justifications for it, the core of identity politics (identity) serves the necessary function of expanding our understanding of the problems marginalized people face, and is in part what makes identity politics a positive force for change.</p><h4><strong>The Practical Reality of Experience</strong></h4><p>F.O.9 The other positive aspect of identity politics is its practical significance as it relates to experience and closing the rights gap. Identity groups have specific, rather intimate understanding of the issues they confront. There is nothing fanciful or overbearing about this conclusion. Tomorrow, if we discovered a population of Caucasians that had been enslaved for hundreds of years, then treated as a racially inferior people and incarcerated by the state in disproportionate numbers, they would have a lot to talk about with many other oppressed people around the globe, including people of color in the U.S. And they should be able to do so on equal footing, even under the most rigid social constructivist view (experience = authority). But I (and hopefully most others) have no interest in recreating institutionalized slavery for the sake of gaining experience.</p><p>F.O.10 The question (and the origins of some of the criticisms of identity politics) then becomes: where does an outsider to that experience fit? Can an outsider arrive at the same conclusions and remedies that any insider to an identity group can? The short, but practical, answer is: probably not. When it comes to unfolding and attempting to remedy the subjective aspects of human suffering, we are necessarily reliant on the experience of others when we have not experienced something ourselves. It’s the problem, as author, philosopher, and mathematician Nassim Taleb has described, of “<a href="http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/Triana-fwd.pdf">lecturing birds how to fly.</a>” Despite having developed intricate theories and math to explain birds’ flight, birds require none of it to actually fly; nor is theory a substitute for their own intimate understanding of flight. Taleb argues at length in Antifragile that knowledge does not travel equally between practical experience and theory and the latter is no substitute for the former. That’s not to say we are incapable of discovering flight ourselves, but that doesn’t do much for birds.</p><p>F.O.11 In the case of identity politics, amidst the constant ideological assault, we have conflated the practical reality of identity politics with the theoretical debate about it. Identity politics, unadorned, is an expression of experience and crucial to understanding the challenges faced by oppressed and historically marginalized people. <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/08/01/488250700/taiwanese-president-issues-countrys-first-apology-to-indigenous-people">The struggles of aboriginal Taiwanese</a> to improve their lot does not require them to engage (or even contemplate) the whirling academic discussion of identity politics in order to pursue identity-based goals of equality. Theoretical understandings, standing alone, do not resolve problems; they must be tied with practical experience. Identity politics is the many voices of marginalized people demanding engagement with them rather than just about them.</p><h4><strong>The Limits of Identity</strong></h4><p>F.O.12 Of course, there are legitimate concerns about identity taken too far. To the extent that an identity group advocates for a set of moral rules different from other groups, there will be contradictions to contend with and bad ideas to cast out. No person, irrespective of their identity, is infallible, nor free from criticism. Despite these concerns, reality has yet to bear out such dire epistemological problems. Under former President Obama, <a href="https://www.vox.com/2018/6/21/17488458/obama-immigration-policy-family-separation-border">immigrant families were being detained</a>, and at the time of this writing, his administration <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/obamas-deportation-policy-numbers/story?id=41715661">deported more people</a> than any other President’s. I have yet to see anyone even attempt to defend those policies across identity lines. Ta-Nehisi Coates <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2014/11/the-cosby-show/382891/">wrote</a>, long before Bill Cosby’s conviction, that he believed Cosby to be a rapist; even as he acknowledges Cosby as one the loudest black voices of our time. He remains <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/05/im-not-black-im-kanye/559763/">highly critical</a> of Kanye West and West’s support of Trump.</p><p>F.O.13 The monolithic view of identity politics lacks the nuance of the views actually expressed. One can advocate for a position such as “The system is rarely fair to a person of color” without holding that same person of color blameless. If there are indeed people who believe in different moral rules for different identities, the inherent contradiction in their view will run into trouble very quickly, and likely with another identity group. In order to vindicate Bill Cosby across identity lines, one would also have to marginalize women and their voice (something that, if recent history is any indication, women, even women of color, are not interested in).</p><p>F.O.14 Critics are also right to be concerned about the possibility of a growing empathy gap if identity serves as a separator. Research demonstrates <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2013/06/racial_empathy_gap_people_don_t_perceive_pain_in_other_races.html">we care less</a> when observing pain in other races. A lack of empathy helped deliver prejudicial behavior over the centuries toward people of color, the LGBTQ+ community, and immigrants, among others–and still does. But the solution does not lie in demanding that we no longer congregate within identity groups. The research <a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/04/100426182002.htm">also demonstrates</a> that people of color show greater empathy for other people of color than Caucasians do for other Caucasians. It shows the empathy we experience toward our ingroup vs. the rest of humankind is <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1053811910003125?via%3Dihub">neurologically different</a>.</p><p>F.O.15 Bridging the empathy gap is not as simple as seeking out shared humanity without regard for identity. Although identity politics has the potential to widen the divide between groups, it also can provide the beginnings of a solution. The problem (as <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3108582/">this</a> and the aforementioned studies show) is not the existence of the us/them dichotomy we tend to think of, but rather the implicit biases associated with each. Breaking down those biases doesn’t begin with pleas of shared humanity, but rather, with correcting the underlying misperceptions. Identity politics can serve as a spotlight, bringing those disparities into vivid contrast. Empathy is not born of a reductionist approach, stripping away identities to try to arrive at a common humanity, but of learning to acknowledge that those differences do not make us less human. The solution lies in expanding our understanding of what “human” means, in all of its many identities. Identity politics can help get us there.</p><h3><strong>Opening: Against</strong></h3><h4><strong>Defining Identity Politics</strong></h4><p>A.O.1 When you think of the term identity politics, what comes to mind? Protesters in Baltimore or Ferguson, Missouri demanding answers about a police shooting? Women sharing their stories of sexual harassment and assault? LGBTQ+ activists fighting for basic rights and equality? These images are ubiquitous in our culture, and they have convinced many people that identity is the axis around which social and political change must revolve.</p><p>A.O.2 Tactically speaking, they may have a point. Identity is among the most powerful engines of political mobilization, as movements like Black Lives Matter and #MeToo have demonstrated over the past several years. Francis Fukuyama explains why identity is such a potent political force in<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Identity-Demand-Dignity-Politics-Resentment/dp/0374129290"> Identity: The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment</a>: “Because human beings naturally crave recognition, the modern sense of identity evolves quickly into identity politics, in which individuals demand public recognition of their worth.”</p><p>A.O.3 This demand is understandable, and it’s clear that many identity-based grievances are legitimate. But we can’t simply redefine identity politics as an attempt to address various forms of prejudice, discrimination, and inequality — if the definition were that vague and anodyne, there would be nothing to argue about. Nor should we accept Ezra Klein’s <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/11/5/18052390/trump-2018-2016-identity-politics-democrats-immigration-race">assertion</a> that “virtually all politics is identity politics” — a statement that robs the term of any meaning whatsoever.</p><p>A.O.4 Even if we grant the claim that all politics is ultimately based on identity, we’d still have to acknowledge that some political movements and ideologies are more identitarian than others. Consider the difference between, say, fascism and humanism — one is explicitly nationalistic and xenophobic while the other is cosmopolitan and inclusive. Fascists are obsessed with identity — when neo-Nazis shout “blood and soil” at their rallies, they’re broadcasting their contempt for supposedly inferior races and calling for the establishment of a hyper-chauvinistic ethno-state. Humanists, on the other hand, seek to improve the well-being of every person regardless of race, religion, or any other marker of identity. The difference between attending a humanist conference and screaming “Jews will not replace us!” on a street corner isn’t just a matter of degree.</p><p>A.O.5 Claims like “virtually all politics is identity politics” only add to the confusion about the term. They’re intended to obscure a real phenomenon in the West — the balkanization of our civic life as people organize themselves into narrower and narrower identity-based political factions. The term identity politics shouldn’t be diluted. We need a way to describe political movements that are inordinately concerned with identity — movements that use identity as an infinitely replenishable source of out-group hostility and that blindly castigate and stereotype people on the basis of gender, race, sexual orientation, or some other (often immutable) characteristic.</p><h4><strong>Restoring the Primacy of the Individual</strong></h4><p>A.O.6 Even in its most outwardly benign and justifiable form, identity politics undermines one of the most fundamental principles of liberal democracy: the protection and promotion of individual rights. In June 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson delivered the <a href="https://www.c-span.org/video/?326895-1/president-lyndon-b-johnson-commencement-address-howard-university">commencement address</a> at Howard University in Washington, D.C., in which he argued that injustices against some groups (such as black Americans) are so deep and enduring that these groups deserve special rights and protections: “You do not take a person who, for years, has been hobbled by chains and liberate him, bring him up to the starting line of a race and then say, ‘you are free to compete with all the others,’ and still justly believe that you have been completely fair.”</p><p>A.O.7 While it’s easy to appreciate the force of this argument — especially coming as it did at the end of the Jim Crow era — Johnson’s attempt to envision a “completely fair” society was far less compelling: “We seek not just legal equity but human ability, not just equality as a right and a theory but equality as a fact and equality as a result.”</p><p>A.O.8 The government can protect “equality as a right,” but given the wide variation among people — in aptitude, personality, and practically everything else we care about — the pursuit of “equality as a result” is a fantasy. What’s worse, any attempt to realize it would inevitably infringe upon the rights of others. Even the most legitimate effort to secure “equality as a result” (affirmative action) is, by necessity, discriminatory — if certain groups’ interests are consistently being promoted in a zero-sum contest like getting into college, other groups will suffer. Just ask Asian applicants to Harvard University.</p><p>A.O.9 Individual rights are universal rights. They’re granted to every citizen without reference to any characteristic other than his or her citizenship itself. While it’s true that history is replete with negations of these rights — negations that have disproportionately harmed certain groups of people — the remedy to these injustices has always been the refusal to wedge diverse individuals into fixed categories that determine their social and political status.</p><p>A.O.10 Identity politics ranks people according to rigid hierarchies of privilege and victimhood. But considering the vast, incalculable differences in individual circumstances among people, it’s extremely difficult to determine who has been more victimized or disadvantaged than whom.</p><p>A.O.11 For example, is a white, middle-aged, working class man from the Midwest — who has no high school diploma and finds himself at <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/casetextsp17bpea.pdf">greater risk</a> for “deaths of despair” like opioid overdoses and suicides than an average Hispanic or black American — more privileged than a well-educated, middle class black man? You could point out that the former has never experienced racial discrimination. But what if he has experienced poverty? Or unemployment? Or a mental illness? This complexity is why it makes more sense to treat people as individuals first and members of broad, diverse demographic groups second.</p><p>A.O.12 But that’s not what many identitarian academics, politicians, and social justice activists are doing. Instead, they’re making demographic categories more politically salient and downplaying the significance of individual circumstances. What is intersectionality, if not a sort of identity-based victimization shorthand? (While a black person is oppressed, a black woman is more oppressed, and a black gay woman is even more oppressed.) This way of thinking isn’t confined to the political fringe, either, as Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand demonstrated when she <a href="https://twitter.com/SenGillibrand/status/1070106980298186753">reminded</a> her Twitter followers that “our future” is “female” and “intersectional.”</p><p>A.O.13 You could argue that, although a white man from the Midwest may have certain disadvantages, his ancestors weren’t subjected to centuries of slavery, oppression, and theft. Our society has a moral obligation to rectify these injustices because it inflicted them. Conversely, nobody is responsible for the man’s mental illness, and the moral responsibility for poverty and unemployment is more diffuse than the responsibility for racist subjugation.</p><p>A.O.14 But this would be a strange objection. When it comes to the formulation of public policy, the most important variable should be how much assistance each individual or group needs. It doesn’t matter if our society is less culpable for economic distress in the Midwest — the most relevant question is: “How much are people suffering and what can be done to help?”</p><p>A.O.15 Of course, black Americans must contend with disproportionate levels of poverty, incarceration rates, disenfranchisement, and a lot of other problems. But shouldn’t we focus on addressing the problems themselves instead of the identities of the people afflicted by them? Why do we place so much emphasis on demographic characteristics like race and gender when there are so many people — including white males — who fall outside this paradigm of victimhood and still suffer from poverty, substance abuse, mental illness, suicide, and many other social and economic disadvantages?</p><p>A.O.16 Identity politics even makes these problems difficult to discuss, as it elevates personal experience and subjective feelings over arguments that can be universally understood. While it’s true that I have no idea what it’s like to be a black woman or a gay man or a Muslim, nobody has any idea what it’s like to be anybody else. This is the reason why we need to embrace common national values and norms of discourse that allow us to solve problems that affect everyone.</p><h4><strong>How Identity Politics is Fracturing our Civil Society</strong></h4><p>A.O.17 While identity can be a catalyst for positive social change, it can also lead to tribalism and civic disintegration. Therefore, any definition of identity politics that encompasses historic campaigns for civil rights and equality but excludes the rise of nationalism and populism is far too narrow. For example, Trump promises to restore an idyllic, homogeneous, and largely fictional American past, and he cynically articulates conservative cultural grievances to provoke and activate his base. Trump’s brand of identity politics may be opportunistic, but it has been the impetus for many of his most toxic policies, such as his travel and immigration restrictions.</p><p>A.O.18 Trump knows he can manipulate our national conversation with a single tweet about NFL players kneeling during the national anthem or immigrants invading our southern border. During the election, he exploited tragedies like the terror attack in San Bernardino by announcing his intention to <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/politics/first-draft/2015/12/07/donald-trump-calls-for-banning-muslims-from-entering-u-s/">ban Muslims</a> from the United States, <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/donald-trump-implement-registry-muslims/story?id=35321441">create a registry</a> to track them, and <a href="https://www.politico.com/story/2015/11/trump-close-mosques-216008">shut down mosques</a>. Before he ran for president, he spent his time peddling an inane and paranoid conspiracy theory about President Obama’s identity, insisting that he was born outside the United States.</p><p>A.O.19 Identity politics fuels identity politics. When Trump’s white male supporters are constantly lambasted for their cultural and economic hegemony — when they’re told their beliefs and anxieties are somehow invalidated by the color of their skin or their gender — they become embittered and insular. This dynamic allows a demagogue like Trump to speak to these feelings and channel them into political action. Meanwhile, when Trump says there are “some very fine people on both sides” after a violent white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, the identitarian left takes the opportunity to remind its followers that the United States is the land of institutional racism and the home of crypto-fascism.</p><p>A.O.20 Should we really allow these voices, who profit from generating as much hatred and division as possible, to hijack our civic discourse? By prioritizing our membership in certain tribes over our identities as citizens and human beings, we have made ourselves vulnerable to manipulation by unscrupulous politicians, preachers, activists, and anyone else who wants to engender social and political conflict. Just look at the digital campaign to subvert the American electoral process in 2016 — Russian hackers and trolls created fake social media groups like <a href="https://money.cnn.com/2017/09/28/media/blacktivist-russia-facebook-twitter/index.html">“Blacktivist”</a> (which had hundreds of thousands of followers) to inflame racial animosity among black Americans. Meanwhile, they exploited white identity politics by amplifying Trump’s attacks on immigrants, Muslims, and other minority groups.</p><p>A.O.21 There are also many ways in which identity politics intersects with and exacerbates other social and political tensions. As Fukuyama points out: “Economic grievances become much more acute when they are attached to feelings of indignity and disrespect.” From the election of Trump to Brexit, the interplay between economic grievances and feelings of indignity and disrespect may be the political story of our time — and it’s not a charming tale.</p><p>A.O.22 At a time when the United States is more fragmented by partisan conflict than it has been in decades, identity politics is a needlessly divisive force multiplier. It encourages people to view civic life as an arena of endless zero-sum competition in which their interests are perpetually at odds with the interests of other groups. It offers a bleak and ahistorical view of the remarkable social and political progress that has been made by marginalized groups over the past century. And it emphasizes superficial characteristics like race and gender instead of ideas and principles.</p><p>A.O.23 Take a look at this recent <a href="https://twitter.com/Amy_Siskind/status/1074668068448677890">tweet</a> from the writer and activist Amy Siskind: “I will not support white male candidates in the Dem primary … White male is not where our party is at, and is our LEAST safe option in 2020.” No mention of policy or character — just melanin and genitalia. This is identity politics in the second decade of the twenty-first century, and it’s as prejudiced, ugly, and counterproductive as ever.</p><h3><strong>Rebuttal: For</strong></h3><h4><strong>Definitions Shape Criticisms</strong></h4><p>F.R.1 Mr. Johnson acknowledges that identity is a “powerful [engine] of political mobilization” (A.O.2) but rejects a definition of “an attempt to address various forms of prejudice, discrimination, and inequality (A.O.3)” as “vague and anodyne” leaving “nothing to argue about” <em>(id.)</em>. He also rejects Ezra Klein’s “all politics is identity politics” as robbing the term of meaning entirely. <em>(id.)</em>. He instead posits that the term should refer only to “political movements that are inordinately concerned with identity” (A.O.5). However, Mr. Johnson does not offer up a justification or a factual basis for this approach.</p><p>F.R.2 Taking this definition on its face would almost certainly render identity politics an unnecessary evil; as would re-defining humanism as being “inordinately concerned with the advancement of the human race to the exclusion of all other species.” The fact that there is a particular behavior we seek to target, and address does not give us license to commandeer terminology for that purpose. Moreover, we do have terms to describe behaviors that “blindly castigate and stereotype people on the basis of gender, race, sexual orientation . . .” (A.O.5); see e.g., sexism, racism, homophobia, etc. If we should use identity politics as an exclusively pejorative term, Mr. Johnson has not provided a compelling reason, factual or epistemological, to do so. Rather, defining identity politics as representative of a collective, addressing a grievance specific to them (see F.O.2), still leaves open the ability to criticize movements (even nationalist ones) without erasing the meaning of the term and the good work it has done.</p><h4><strong>Individual Rights Don’t Exist in a Vacuum</strong></h4><p>F.R.3 Mr. Johnson posits that identity politics undermines the fundamental principle of liberal democracy, i.e. individual rights. (A.O.6). The notion that individual rights exist independently of the people seeking them falls into the same trap of foundationalism (see F.O.7). We cannot pursue rights on an individualized basis free from identity when the oppression targeted the individual because of identity. The Civil Rights Movement would have had no way of addressing the wrongs perpetrated on people of color’s identity free from that same identity.</p><p>F.R.4 Mr. Johnson also creates a straw man — that identity politics requires us to address the suffering of different groups in some hierarchical fashion — but provides no proof that such a view even exists. (see A.O.13 &amp; 14). Of course, we should work to alleviate all forms of human suffering. Identity politics does not deny this reality; it simply is not the appropriate method of addressing suffering in all instances.</p><p>F.R.5 He also rejects Lyndon Johnson’s vision of a “completely fair” society that seeks “not just legal equity but human ability, not just equality as a right and a theory but equality as a fact and equality as a result” as “a fantasy.” (A.O.8). The equality in theory/in-fact dichotomy is far from fantasy and is not a zero-sum game. “Separate but equal,” as upheld in the Supreme Court decision of <a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/163/537">Plessy v. Ferguson</a>, embodies the problem of equality in theory but not in fact. <a href="https://www.britannica.com/event/Plessy-v-Ferguson-1896">The majority reasoned</a> one could theoretically segregate people while still giving them equal protection of the law, because separation did not imply legal inferiority.</p><p>F.R.6 In overturning Plessy, the Court in <a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/347/483">Brown v. Board</a> (sensibly) decided that separate facilities are “inherently unequal” (emphasis mine). By their nature, they foster inferiority. True, whites lost priority seating on buses, at lunch counters, and exclusive admission to colleges, but the fact that there was some form of deprivation does not render equality-in-fact unreasonable. As <a href="https://www.vox.com/first-person/2018/10/18/17995270/asian-americans-affirmative-action-harvard-admissions-lawsuit">this article</a> points out, the problem with Harvard and Asian applicants (see A.O.8) is not that one identity is constantly given preference; it’s the potential that the reviewers still harbor unfair stereotypes about a group of people. The fact that an identity-based pursuit of equality does not move smoothly between theory and practice does not render it fantastical. Theory and practice are not two-way streets. (See F.O.11).</p><h4><strong>The Fractionalization of Society</strong></h4><p>F.R.7 Here, Mr. Johnson and I agree, in part. As I acknowledged, to the extent that identity politics has been used to create different moral rules for different identities, we should be ruthlessly skeptical (I have yet to see consistent concrete evidence). (See F.O.12). The same goes for misusing identity politics to widen the empathy gap. (See F.O.14). But the fact that a demagogue like Trump can abuse identity for political gain (see A.O.17 through 19) does not upend the positive legacy of identity politics in advancing universal human rights in the form of Civil Rights, LGBTQ+, and New Wave Feminism movements. We will not close the empathy gap by becoming color- or gender-blind (see F.O.9). Human rights are propelled forward by embracing our differences rather than pretending they don’t exist.</p><h3>Rebuttal: Against</h3><p>A.R.1 In his opening statement, Dan Melo points out that people can be classified according to a virtually unlimited range of identities, arguing that this is the “key in any attempt at a concise definition” (F.O.2) of identity politics.</p><p>A.R.2 Of course, we all have identities, but this observation gets us no closer to a concise definition of identity politics. It does the opposite. Not only are some identities far more politically salient than others, but there’s also a huge amount of variation within identity groups. For example, a citizen of the United States could be an ultra-nationalistic America-Firster or someone who regards national identity as morally and politically irrelevant. A woman could vote for a female candidate solely on the basis of her gender or she could assess the candidate’s experience, temperament, and policies without reference to the number of X chromosomes she has.</p><p>A.R.3 Although Melo begins by emphasizing the broadness of the concept of identity, he then accepts a definition from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy as a “a useful standpoint from which to analyze the subject.” (F.O.3) It reads: “The term signifies a loose collection of political projects, each undertaken by representatives of a collective with a distinctively different social location that has hitherto been neglected, erased, or suppressed.”</p><p>A.R.4 With its emphasis on marginalized and persecuted groups, this definition conveniently ignores the most harmful forms of identity politics that have existed throughout history. Didn’t the slaveholders who argued against the abolition of slavery believe their identity as whites gave them the right to oppress other human beings? Didn’t the Nazis condemn millions of people to death and wage the most destructive war in human history on the basis of their national identity and perceived status as members of a master race? Stanford’s definition would also leave out most of the populist and nationalist movements in the world today, which often appeal to members of traditionally dominant majorities.</p><p>A.R.5 If we’re unable to establish a more precise definition of identity politics, the debate can’t even begin. Melo can’t seem to decide if he agrees with Ezra Klein (who <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/11/5/18052390/trump-2018-2016-identity-politics-democrats-immigration-race">says</a> “All politics is identity politics,” rendering the term meaningless) or if he wants his definition to exclude many of the clearest examples of identity politics. Neither view is helpful.</p><p>A.R.6 The importance of subjective experience is at the center of Melo’s argument. He asks, “Can an outsider arrive at the same conclusions and remedies that any insider to an identity group can? The short, but practical, answer is: probably not. When it comes to unfolding and attempting to remedy the subjective aspects of human suffering, we are necessarily reliant on the experience of others when we have not experienced something ourselves.” (F.O.10)</p><p>A.R.7 Although subjective testimonies and perspectives can give us powerful social and political insights, the claim that outsiders can’t “arrive at the same conclusions and remedies” as members of certain groups is deeply antithetical to the values, institutions, and conventions that underpin Western liberal democracies. As I observed in my opening statement, nobody understands what it’s like to be anybody else — every human being is a vast constellation of identities, accumulated experiences, and subjective frames of reference. But our ability to communicate and reason with one another allows us to overcome these differences and work toward public policies and social norms that prioritize the well-being of as many people as possible, regardless of their identities.</p><p>A.R.8 History contradicts Melo’s claim at every turn — there have been countless white abolitionists, men who fought for the Nineteenth Amendment, Christians who denounced the persecution of non-Christians, straight activists who campaigned for gay rights, and non-Jews who resisted the scourge of anti-Semitism. None of these people had to be part of a specific identity group to recognize that members of that group deserve the same rights and freedoms as everyone else.</p><p>A.R.9 We’re not “reliant on the experience of others” (F.O.10) to alleviate human suffering. In fact, subjective feelings and personal anecdotes are often terrible guides to the development of good public policy, as they’re liable to all sorts of bias and error. This is why elected representatives, writers, and others responsible for formulating or analyzing public policy use data and arguments that are accessible to everyone.</p><p>A.R.10 Melo believes identity politics is necessary to advance universal human rights, but he has it exactly backwards. The most successful campaigns to secure universal rights have appealed to shared values, such as equality under the law, the protection of the individual, and common citizenship. And in many cases, these campaigns have had to overcome the mindless tribalism of identity politics, which is so often a vehicle for racism, misogyny, homophobia, and other forms of out-group prejudice. Instead of continuing to obsess over what divides us — the source of intensifying identitarian conflict across the United States and Europe today — it’s time to abandon identity politics once and for all.</p><h3><strong>Closing: For</strong></h3><p>F.C.1 Mr. Johnson and I fundamentally disagree on what identity politics means and thereby what goods (or evils) it represents. We agree that identity groups are “powerful engines of political mobilization” (A.O.2). We may need a less fraught term to describe identity groups addressing social inequality. Throughout his rebuttal, Mr. Johnson relies on a foundationalist approach (contrast with F.O.7) where universal human rights exist somewhere independent of oppressed people and their oppressors, even as he acknowledges that “many identity-based grievances are legitimate.” (A.O.3). We can readily distinguish between identity movements, like indigenous rights, that self-advocate for equality, and those, like fascism, that self-promote at the expense of it. He has not addressed how one remediates wrongs done to an identity free of that identity. We cannot erase our human past, free from oppressors targeting race, sex, or religion. But we can use identity as a stepping stone toward a better understanding of universal rights (see F.O.4, 05). Call it by any term, but identity will play a role whenever identity is the target of oppression.</p><p>F.C.2 Contrary to Mr. Johnson’s assertion (A.R.8), I make no claim that people outside of identity groups cannot work to protect the rights of those groups. I am not advocating for a self-defeating, postmodern relativistic approach (another discussion entirely). Rather, I assert that in order to fully and better remediate the oppression experienced by an identity, we must involve the special perspective that the identity has on the issues it faces. (see F.O.10). That perspective is not the final word but an essential one. No human construct is infallible, but identity politics has performed a necessary function of expanding our understanding of universal rights. History evidences many liberal movements relying on identity politics to ensure equality, both theoretical and factual.</p><h3><strong>Closing: Against</strong></h3><p>A.C.1 Melo’s definition of identity politics encompasses every social and political movement in which “representatives of a collective” attempt to address “a grievance specific to them.” (F.O.3) It doesn’t matter if these representatives articulate their grievances with appeals to universal rights and values or tribal loyalties — as long as members of an identity group are engaged in political activity, they’re practicing identity politics.</p><p>A.C.2 To Melo, it was identity politics that led Martin Luther King Jr. to call upon his nation to “live out the true meaning of its creed: ‘We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.’” Just as it was identity politics that led Stokely Carmichael to chant “We want black power!” at a march in Greenwood, Mississippi three years later. Any definition that can’t distinguish between these political tactics and principles is far too vague.</p><p>A.C.3 Melo’s criticism of my point about the impossibility of securing “equality as a result” (F.R.5) conflates two completely different issues — equality under the law and equality of outcome. He cites the Brown v. Board Supreme Court decision to overturn the separate but equal ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson (F.R.5). But I explicitly pointed out that the “government can protect ‘equality as a right’” in my opening statement (A.O.8), which is exactly what the Brown v. Board decision did.</p><p>A.C.4 Our core disagreement is this: Melo believes identity politics is necessary. As he puts it, “The Civil Rights Movement would have had no way of addressing the wrongs perpetrated on people of color’s identity free from that same identity.” (F.R.3)</p><p>A.C.5 But the treatment of black Americans was a horrific injustice that anyone can recognize and work to rectify. As King <a href="https://www.archives.gov/files/press/exhibits/dream-speech.pdf">observed</a> during the March on Washington in 1963: “Many of our white brothers, as evidenced by their presence here today, have come to realize that their destiny is tied up with our destiny.” Our destinies are all intertwined, and even though identity is “inescapable” (as Melo puts it, F.O.2), one identity supersedes all the others: We’re human beings.</p><h3><strong>Debaters</strong></h3><h4><strong>For</strong></h4><p>Dan Melo is a recovering lawyer, propelled by a fascination of social constructs and how they govern our interactions. He is currently working on a book about the current struggle of the progressive movement when reaching across the aisle. Dan writes on <a href="https://medium.com/@themelodan">Medium</a> and has a number of articles published in <a href="https://areomagazine.com/author/saxrunner/">Areo Magazine</a>.</p><h4><strong>Against</strong></h4><p>Matt Johnson has written for <a href="https://ssir.org/articles/entry/how_the_united_states_can_help_educate_the_world"><em>Stanford Social Innovation Review</em></a>, <a href="https://thebulwark.com/author/matt_johnson/"><em>The Bulwark</em></a>, <a href="https://quillette.com/author/matt-johnson/"><em>Quillette</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.splicetoday.com/authors/Matt%20Johnson"><em>Splice Today</em></a>, <a href="https://areomagazine.com/author/mattjj89/"><em>Areo Magazine</em></a>, <a href="https://arcdigital.media/my-brother-is-a-trump-supporter-b454b321f0b0"><em>Arc Digital</em></a>, and many other outlets. He was formerly the opinion page editor at the <em>Topeka Capital-Journal</em>. In 2015, he received a Master’s in Journalism from the University of Kansas. Matt writes on <a href="https://medium.com/@mattjj89">Medium</a> and can be found on <a href="https://twitter.com/mattjj89">Twitter</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a35756ab7640" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge/identity-politics-is-a-net-positive-force-a35756ab7640">Identity politics is a net positive force.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge">Common Lodge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Climate change on a massive scale is a done deal. Society should focus on adapting to it.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/commonlodge/climate-change-on-a-massive-scale-is-a-done-deal-society-should-focus-on-adapting-to-it-383d263e8caf?source=rss----ae59961ba793---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/383d263e8caf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[global-warming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Common Lodge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Apr 2019 14:48:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T00:08:25.947Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MpGKUvkQHDGd9kk0IZ6JHw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Opening: For</h3><p>F.O.1 In a major milestone for the collective acknowledgement of impending disaster, nations around the world gathered at COP21 in Paris and agreed that “climate change represents an urgent and potentially irreversible threat to human societies and the planet and thus requires the widest possible cooperation by all countries.” Two primary goals were identified at the conference: 1. limit the increase in the global average temperature to “well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels” (which is approximately 3.6°F) and 2. increase the capacity of the world at large to “adapt to the adverse impacts of climate change.” <a href="http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-18-6592_en.htm">The agreement</a> called for “ambitious and early action, including major reductions in the cost of future mitigation and adaptation efforts.”</p><p>F.O. 2 The prevailing mood in 2015 was one of hope that, if all nations committed to carrying out their pledges, we would be able to take on the climate crisis. But the later decision of President Donald Trump to pull the US out of the Paris Agreement dealt major blows to the global effort. The current US administration, with its petroleum-friendly policies and science-skeptical messaging, has done irreparable damage to the hard-won consensus of COP21.</p><p>F.O. 3 Still, the world must move forward. Challenges for the future, as recognized at <a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">COP24 in Katowice, Poland</a>, will revolve around “a detailed set of rules and guidelines” for addressing global warming. The question on the minds of world leaders, and for all of us, will be: how exactly should nations proceed over the next several decades, in order to avoid the worst effects of climate change?</p><p>F.O. 4 Strategies to combat climate change generally follow one of two approaches: mitigation, to try to limit the rise in global average temperature by reducing the amount of greenhouse gas in the air, and adaptation, to improve the ability of society to adjust to a changing climate. Both of these approaches are critically important and necessary to see us through the coming crisis. I argue that the main thrust of government policy should be on adaptation to climate change, with mitigation strategies taking second priority.</p><h4>The response to climate change is too slow to meet COP21 targets</h4><p>F.O.5 One of the central points made during COP21 was that, while the target 2°C increase in global average temperature was a valuable starting point, limiting the rise to 1.5°C <a href="https://www.bna.com/26-environmental-rules-n73014477330/">would ultimately be necessary</a> to avoid the worst consequences. (Currently, the planet is about 1°C warmer on average than it was during pre-industrial times, prior to the Industrial Revolution in the 1800s.) This is important because, according to the IPCC Special Report released in October 2018, the rise in average temperature is highly likely to “reach 1.5°C between 2030 and 2052 if it continues to increase at the current rate.” While greenhouse gases already in the air today will continue to cause gradual warming for centuries to come, the IPCC report concluded that “these emissions alone are unlikely to cause global warming of 1.5°C.” That means nations around the world have a timeframe of 12 to 34 years to make monumental changes in their governance and infrastructure.</p><p>F.O.6 This emergency has not sprung upon the world suddenly — it has, of course, been a growing concern for many years. Although suspicions were brewing in the scientific community for at least half a century, the 2006 documentary “An Inconvenient Truth” featuring Al Gore may be considered the watershed that raised the issue to the forefront of public consciousness. Fast forward 12 years, and the current administration is rolling back <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/315207a0">regulations that limit greenhouse gas emissions</a> from vehicles and power plants.</p><p>F.O.7 Contrast this situation with the response of the US and the rest of the world to discovery of the Antarctic ozone hole in 1985. The international <a href="https://www.state.gov/e/oes/eqt/chemicalpollution/83007.htm">Montreal Protocol</a> in 1987, followed by amendments and additional protocols throughout the 1990s, brought nations together to ban emissions of ozone-depleting chlorofluorocarbons. , This remarkable accomplishment proved that it is possible for countries to collaborate with the common goal of averting environmental catastrophe. Yet it also demonstrates that climate change is a very different beast — and it will be a matter of generations, not decades, before the world gets a handle on it.</p><h4>Mitigation strategies take a long time to be developed and adopted</h4><p>F.O.8 Enormous scientific strides are being made to develop carbon-neutral energy alternatives as well as cost-effective technologies for carbon capture. These advances are the key to solving the climate crisis in the long term. However, spectators outside the field tend to grossly underestimate the time and investment needed to adopt these innovations on a global scale. Each of the hundreds-to-thousands of technologies that have been demonstrated at lab or pilot scale must be scaled up to meet the demands on at least a regional scale, with each region around the world requiring a unique approach. It will require extensive collaboration between local communities, private companies, utilities, and the government.</p><p>F.O.9 We are unlikely to <a href="https://www.nap.edu/catalog/4767/technological-trajectories-and-the-human-environment">see this task</a> <a href="https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-and-changing-energy-sources">come close</a> <a href="https://valadao.house.gov/uploadedfiles/western_water_and_american_food_security_act_of_2015.pdf">to fruition</a> within the next 34 years, even if we discover a scientific “miracle cure” that drastically alters the way we produce power — typical estimates are more in the range of a hundred years or more. Even the Internet, a revolutionary yet singular technology, took about 3 decades after its initial invention to become fully integrated in global society.</p><h4>Adaptation strategies are practical, achievable, and politically uncontroversial</h4><p>F.O.10 While climate change is a polarizing subject in the political sphere, effective adaptation to it can be framed in a manner that appeals to both sides. Most everyone agrees that managing water shortages, relocating refugees due to natural disasters, and improving buildings and infrastructure to better withstand the elements are issues that should be addressed by government policy. In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in 2005, there was a massive, largely nonpartisan public outcry about the <a href="https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/reports/katrina-lessons-learned/">failure of the Bush administration</a> <a href="https://www.npr.org/documents/2006/feb/katrina/house_report/katrina_report_full.pdf">to provide sufficient aid to the victims and to repair destroyed buildings and roads in New Orleans</a>.</p><p>F.O.11 Goals associated with climate change adaptation are usually concrete and tangible, with clear positive outcomes. The upgrading of structural materials in climate-sensitive areas can be streamlined into construction projects with relative ease. A complementary approach would be to implement more sophisticated evacuation protocols and disaster-relief policies in these areas. Precedents already exist in many countries that have historically been more vulnerable to natural disasters. Such tasks are far more feasible in the immediate term than the gargantuan feat of reducing greenhouse gases, <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0959378006000410">the sources of which</a> <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13549839.2016.1216954">remain poorly understood</a> <a href="https://www.rand.org/pubs/working_papers/WR514.html">and immensely difficult to control</a>.</p><p>F.O.12 The fact that these efforts should be achievable on regional to local scales and on a time scale of years to decades means that we can also adapt our adaptation efforts in response to gradual climate shifts. In this way societies around the world can endure, and even thrive, through the time it will take to develop and integrate carbon-neutral technologies.</p><h3>Opening: Against</h3><p>A.O.1 Climate change is happening, accelerating, and causing widespread harm to societies, economies, and the environment. More severe effects are <a href="https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/downloads/NCA4_Report-in-Brief.pdf">predicted for the future</a>. The present debate, therefore, addresses unanswered questions about climate change: 1. To what extent can the human enterprise adapt to a radically warmer planet and all the attendant hazards? 2. Can the worst effects be mitigated, within reasonable bounds of timing, feasibility, and cost, and if so, how? This essay is an attempt to answer the second question, and therefore to present the case that mitigation is not only an option, but by far the best choice for the planet’s future: “Reaching and sustaining net zero global anthropogenic CO2 emissions . . . <a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">would halt anthropogenic global warming . . .</a>”</p><p>A.O.2 The current climate change phenomenon is caused by increasing concentrations of greenhouse gasses (GHG) in the Earth’s atmosphere. The GHG (principally carbon dioxide, but also methane, nitrous oxide, and other trace gasses), trap infrared radiation (heat) in the lower atmosphere. The increased heat not only raises temperatures, but also causes a cascade of direct and indirect effects, including stronger storms, longer and more intensive droughts, and more frequent and intensive flooding in others.2 Sea levels are rising because the oceans expand as the water warms, and because the rising temperatures cause melting of glaciers and ice sheets. As ice cover decreases in the Arctic and Antarctic, the reflectivity (albedo) of the Earth’s surface decreases, <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-08467-z">meaning the land and water absorb more heat</a>. It is also likely that warming of vast regions of tundra in boreal and arctic zones <a href="https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2010.0341">will release significantly large amounts of GHG</a> that have long been sequestered in tundra soils and permafrost. The oceans are becoming more acidic as they absorb excess amounts of carbon dioxide. Climate change disrupts ecosystems as species adapt in various ways to rising temperatures and changes in other habitat conditions. Some individuals and species, failing to adapt, will perish.</p><p>A.O.3 Mitigation <a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">does not mean a total reversal of warming</a>, about 1.5°C of which has already been locked in as the result of past emissions. Rather, mitigation, as defined here, would be the result of a suite of actions that would prevent the most catastrophic effects of climate change, by limiting the increase in global average temperature to 2°C or less over the pre-industrial baseline, the policy commitment of the <a href="http://www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1710465114">2016 Paris Climate Agreement</a>. The <a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">most recent estimate indicate</a> that net zero GHG emissions will need to be attained by 2050 to avoid going beyond a 1.5°C increase in global average temperature.</p><p>A.O.4 There are three main avenues for mitigation: 1. reducing emissions of GHG; 2. carbon capture and sequestration (CCS); and 3. solar radiation management (SRM). Other classifications are possible, e.g., CCS and SRM are sometimes lumped together as climate geoengineering, and CCS can be subdivided into biological and technological (or green and gray) approaches. Feasibility, cost, effectiveness, and risks of unintended consequences need to be considered. The literature is vast; <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Drawdown-Comprehensive-Proposed-Reverse-Warming/dp/0143130447">Hawken</a> outlines 98 separate mitigation methods, so the following treatment is a greatly abbreviated summary.</p><h4>Reducing GHG emissions</h4><p>A.O.5 The primary sources of anthropogenic GHG emissions are, <a href="http://&/#39;https://ourworldindata.org/co2-and-other-greenhouse-gas-emissions">in order of magnitude</a>: fossil-fuel based energy production and transportation; land use, agriculture and forestry; and industrial, commercial, and residential sources. Switching energy production and transportation systems to non-carbon sources (such as solar, wind, nuclear, renewable electric, and hydrogen power), would reduce global carbon dioxide emissions by 50–60% (<a href="https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-and-changing-energy-sources">estimated from Hannah and Roser</a>). Although this shift has begun, it is not sufficient either in magnitude or speed to achieve the needed reductions. Even in the unlikely case that all anthropogenic GHG sources were to reach zero emissions within the next decade or two, warming would be slowed only enough to prevent more than 2°C warming, but not enough to <a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">attain the 1.5°C threshold</a>. Mitigation cannot succeed solely by emission controls.</p><h4>Carbon capture and sequestration</h4><p>A.O.6 Carbon dioxide is taken up and stored by photosynthetic organisms (green plants and algae). The more plant and algal biomass that is produced, the more carbon is sequestered. Although this storage is not permanent, it provides the opportunity to reach a more optimal global equilibrium between green biomass and the atmosphere, with the effect of reducing net carbon emissions. Reforestation, afforestation, and protection of existing forests could make major contributions to GHG reductions, but must be balanced against other land use needs, especially agriculture. Marshes, seagrasses, and coral reefs sequester large amounts of carbon dioxide, but currently are threatened by sea level rise, coastal development, and in the case of coral reefs, warming and acidification of the oceans. Protection and enhancement of these green resources is less costly than most other mitigation methods, making a substantial contribution to CCS, while contributing to a healthy environment. Crops grown in large quantities for energy production (e.g., second-generation biofuels), for other commercial uses (e.g., hemp), or specifically for CCS can also contribute, <a href="https://www.nap.edu/booksearch.php?record_id=4767&amp;term=land+use">but may compete with food production and other essential land uses</a>.</p><p>A.O.7 A variety of methods can be used to capture carbon dioxide from emission sources, or directly from the atmosphere. Once captured, the carbon dioxide may be pumped into deep underground reservoirs for long-term sequestration or sold for other uses. Although there has been some r<a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">esearch into and limited demonstrations</a> of these technologies, little has been published about them.</p><h4>Solar radiation management</h4><p>A.O.8 Global warming could be mitigated through blocking solar radiation before it reaches the Earth’s surface, collectively known as SRM. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032113008460">An article by Ming et al.</a> is a comprehensive review of the possibilities for SRM, and compares SRM to “Earth radiation management,” a suite of technological methods to increase radiation from the Earth to space.</p><p>A.O.9 The most widely discussed method of SRM is global-scale deployment of sulfate aerosols, or other absorbing substances, in the atmosphere. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-006-9101-y">This technique</a> mimics the effects of large volcanic eruptions; known to cool the climate over short periods (~1 year). Thus, deployment would have to be continuous until GHG emissions are sufficiently reduced. Although modeling has shown this method is cost-effective, there is concern, as with all SRM, over side effects, including stratospheric ozone depletion, acid rain, changes in regional precipitation, and human health risks.</p><h4>Mitigation can be an effective approach to climate change</h4><p>A.O.10 The <a href="https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/summary-for-policy-makers/">recent IPCC report</a> makes it clear that mitigation measures, if fully employed within the next decade or two, will limit global warming to 2°C or less, thereby avoiding the most catastrophic effects of unchecked climate change. Net carbon emissions will have to drop to zero or below. This level can be attained by massive reductions in fossil fuel combustion coupled with aggressive investments in broad-based CCS. With a strong emphasis on green CCS, it will be unnecessary to invest heavily in questionable technologies such as CCS at fossil-fueled energy production facilities, or SRM. The movement toward a carbon-neutral society is already underway and gathering momentum. Commitments by public and private entities have been made, from international to local, to effect changes. This momentum must increase exponentially over the next decade.</p><p>A.O.11 To accept warming of 5°C or more over the next century will have catastrophic consequences for the world’s people, economies, and the environment, regardless of what adaptation measures are taken.</p><h4>Rebuttal: For</h4><p>F.R.1 The main thrust of the opponent’s opening statement is that the goal of limiting the global average temperature increase to 2°C or less by 2050 can be achieved by mitigation strategies focusing on carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) (A.O.3 and 04), specifically the production of additional biomass and the protection of forests, marshlands, and reefs which draw down carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.</p><h4>Growing new crops for carbon dioxide sequestration</h4><p>F.R.2 A key difficulty in repurposing land for CCS lies in the competition with land used for agriculture. Half of all habitable land is used for food production, and although agricultural technology and genetic engineering have improved agricultural efficiency over the last fifty years, <a href="https://ourworldindata.org/yields-and-land-use-in-agriculture">land area still plays a major</a> role in determining yield in most developing countries. Any CCS program involving substantial use of land for new crops cannot compete with land used for agriculture in those countries, unless technological advancements are made which will likely take a number of years to implement, more time than we have left for combating climate change.</p><p>F.R.3 In North America and Europe, higher agricultural yields for food production mean that more land can be spared, but that land is being used increasingly to produce biofuels. According to <a href="https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/legacy/assets/documents/clean_vehicles/Indirect-Land-Use-Factsheet.pdf">some</a> <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10584-016-1764-4">assessments</a>, the processing and combustion of biofuels generates nearly 3 times more carbon dioxide than is sequestered from the atmosphere, so these crops cannot be considered truly carbon neutral. <a href="http://science.sciencemag.org/content/326/5958/1397/tab-article-info">Unexpected effects</a> of land use changes for biofuels or other crops can also cause more greenhouse gas emissions, such as the increase in nitrous oxide from fertilizers.</p><p>F.R.4 On a political note, the U.S. EPA Renewable Fuel Standard <a href="https://www.epa.gov/renewable-fuel-standard-program/renewable-fuel-annual-standards">requires a percentage of biofuel</a> to be blended into petroleum-based transportation fuels. Growing new crops for CCS purposes will compete with either food or energy production, leading to opposition from both farm coalitions and oil companies, arguably the two most powerful forces in government, at least in the United States.</p><h4>Protection and enhancement of natural carbon dioxide sinks</h4><p>F.R.5 Preserving existing land for CCS faces challenges in developing countries where the demand for agricultural land and natural resources is growing. For example, the deforestation of the Amazon rainforest has been a major problem for decades. The large landmass of the forest is an important sink for greenhouse gases, and its encroachment by agricultural and logging interests is a significant cause of global warming.</p><p>F.R.6 In 2008, delegates to the Convention for Biological Diversity <a href="https://www.wwf.or.id/en/news_facts/?1192">pledged to eliminate deforestation by 2020</a>. While the rate of deforestation has decreased since the 1990s, <a href="http://www.mma.gov.br/informma/item/15259-governo-federal-divulga-taxa-de-desmatamento-na-amaz%C3%B4nia.html">illegal rainforest destruction remains a serious issue</a> with nearly 8,000 square kilometers destroyed in 2018. When the natural environment is jeopardized by economic expansion, even a united political will may not be sufficient to prevent its devastation.</p><p>F.R.7 The opponent argues that protecting carbon dioxide sinks in the natural environment such as marshlands and coral reefs will mitigate global warming (A.O.6). It is definitely important to conserve these vulnerable ecosystems, but it is unlikely to contribute significantly to CCS.</p><p>F.R.8 The effort required to maintain these resources is considerable given the many factors that threaten their survival. Not only do human activities upset the delicate balance of life in these ecosystems, but the climate shifts induced by global warming cause damage that they may not be able to recover from. The hurricanes Maria and Irma that ravaged the Caribbean in 2017 <a href="http://reefresilience.org/coral-reefs/stressors/climate-and-ocean-change/changes-in-storm-patterns/">disrupted many coral</a> <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06014-y">reef colonies</a>, and scientists predict that the increasing frequency of such natural disasters will deteriorate their health.</p><p>F.R.9 Since the details of climate change are not well understood, it is not clear how coral reefs and other resources can be shielded from its consequences. Even if it is possible to protect these regions, utilizing them for CCS is a complex task. In the case of coral reefs, <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/092181819190117F">carbon dioxide is converted into calcium carbonate</a>, which has the side effect of worsening ocean acidification. Land-based ecosystems such as forests have no known negative feedback effects, but would need to rapidly increase their land area before 2050. It takes <a href="https://pubag.nal.usda.gov/catalog/731321">a hundred years or more</a> for destroyed rainforest to grow back. This is not fast enough to attain the level of CCS needed to limit the global average temperature and avoid climate change on a massive scale.</p><h3>Rebuttal: Against</h3><h4>Policies and trends</h4><p>A.R.1 The “for” statement begins by citing the goals and conclusions of the <a href="http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-18-6592_en.htm">Paris Climate Agreement</a>, which outline a balanced, combined strategy of mitigation and adaptation. It is then argued that “. . . the later decision of President Donald Trump to pull the US out of the Paris Agreement dealt major blows to the global effort.” (F.O.2). Given that there is a growing consensus among governmental, commercial, and non-governmental sectors that massive mitigation efforts are essential, the Trump declaration, although certainly not a positive development, seems more symbolic than potent. It is not at all clear that it “. . .has done irreparable damage to the hard-won consensus of COP21.” (F.O.2)</p><p>A.R.2 The principal argument given for prioritizing adaptation over mitigation is that the necessary degree of mitigation cannot be achieved within the “timeframe of 12 to 34 years.” (F.O.5). Although the challenge is indeed “monumental” (F.O.5), no solid evidence is presented that it will be impossible. Yes, the current US government has engaged in a spate of anti-mitigation policy changes, but changes in policy do not necessarily mean changes in practice. Will the US really invest in more coal-fired power plants? The trend is toward disinvestment in fossil fuel power and investment in renewable energy, regardless of national policies. Globally, nationally, and regionally, economic and social forces will continue to accelerate this trend. There is, in fact, evidence that net zero carbon emissions can be achieved within the next 2–3 decades.</p><p>A.R.3 The “for” statement does not provide support for the claim that “. . . climate change is a very different beast” from the chlorofluorocarbon (CFC) case (F.O.7). If they are so different, why make the analogy? It is true that the GHG problem is larger in scope and more diffuse than the CFC problem, but is this not a matter of degree rather than taxonomy?</p><h4>Timely mitigation is possible</h4><p>A.R.4 No evidence is supplied to support the statements in F.O.8: “Mitigation strategies take a long time to be developed and adopted.” In fact, the technologies required to mitigate climate change over the next few decades are well- or fully-developed, including renewable power generation, electrification of transportation systems, and green CCS (we know very well how to grow trees, for example). The challenge will be deployment of already proven systems at the necessary scales. The “. . . technologies that have been demonstrated at lab or pilot scale . . .” (F.O.8) are the gray CCS technologies, which would capture GHG from emission sources or directly from the atmosphere. In A.O.10, it is shown that these methods will not be essential to mitigation: “. . . mitigation measures, if fully employed within the next decade or two, will limit global warming to 2°C or less.” No “miracle cure” (F.O.9) will be required.</p><p>A.R.5 Indeed, climate change has been a “. . . polarizing subject in the political sphere.” (F.O.10), but how much longer will it remain so? The real manifestations of climate change in recent years have been making it apparent — to all but the most intransigent deniers — that it cannot be wished away or quashed by unbelief.</p><h4>Adaptation is not enough</h4><p>A.R.6 The main defense of adaptation in the “for” statement is introduced by the phrase “Most everyone agrees . . .” (F.O.10), which is a very weak assertion at best. Although it may be true that there is strong support for some adaptation measures, how do we know that “most everyone agrees?” To take one example, relocating refugees, whether from natural disasters or other effects of climate change, will be a huge challenge logistically, economically, and politically. The Katrina example given in F.O.10 (“In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in 2005, there was a massive, largely nonpartisan public outcry about the failure of the Bush administration to provide sufficient aid to the victims and to repair destroyed buildings and roads in New Orleans”) involved a few thousand refugees; climate change refugees will number in the tens of millions. Where will they go? Who will want them? Consider the current refugee conflicts in Africa, Europe, and North America. As another example, there is no feasible scale of infrastructure development that can protect all the residents of coastal areas and low islands around the world from sea level rise.</p><p>A.R.7 Strategic and orderly development of adaptation policies and their implementation will be essential, but not sufficient, responses to climate change in the near term. The scenarios outlined in the “for” statement, however, cannot be accomplished at the scale or in the time frame to prevent catastrophic consequences, unless combined with massive mitigation efforts. It is not even clear what the following statement means: “The upgrading of structural materials in climate-sensitive areas can be streamlined into construction projects with relative ease.” (F.O.11). If the statement is a reference to infrastructure improvements such as seawalls, only a tiny fraction of climate-sensitive areas could be protected, logistically or economically. Finally, improving evacuation protocols and disaster relief efforts are important, but hardly strategic approaches to the climate change problem: “A complementary approach would be to implement more sophisticated evacuation protocols and disaster-relief policies in these areas” (F.O.11).</p><h3>Closing: For</h3><p>F.C.1 The opponent provides no supporting evidence for a number of key claims in the rebuttal. While renewable energy investment has increased in recent years, as noted by the opponent in A.R.2, no examples are raised to suggest that these investments are of a sufficient magnitude to meet the mitigation targets of COP21. The assertion that “there is, in fact, evidence that net zero carbon emissions can be achieved within the next 2–3 decades” (A.R.2) is also unsubstantiated.</p><p>F.C.2 To the contrary, <a href="http://science.sciencemag.org/content/299/5615/2052/tab-article-info">a combined climate and energy analysis</a> concluded in 2003 that at least 900 megawatts of carbon-free energy must be added to the global energy system daily for 50 years in order to limit warming to 2°C. Over fifteen years later, only one-sixth of that amount is being added (about 150 megawatts daily), such that <a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/s/610457/at-this-rate-its-going-to-take-nearly-400-years-to-transform-the-energy-system/">400 years will be required</a> to achieve a similar transformation. No amount of rapid acceleration in investment is going to change that reality before 2050.</p><p>F.C.3 Adaptation, on the other hand, encompasses a variety of approaches that can be taken now on a grand scale without relying on future projections of technology development. As the opponent states in A.R.6, climate change refugees will grow in numbers as natural disasters become more frequent and severe. Yet adaptation can also come in the form of aid delivered to climate-sensitive regions including coastal areas, which can alleviate the worst effects and avoid or delay the need for relocation.</p><p>F.C.4 If nations around the world take measures to prepare for and respond to catastrophic events, the inevitability of global warming can be endured. Climate change will be experienced most acutely by those living in the poorest countries, who are least able to protect themselves. The position of developed nations, which will remain relatively unscathed, should be to accept that carbon neutrality is a long-term solution, and fight to defend the vulnerable from climate devastation.</p><h3>Closing: Against</h3><p>A.C.1 The chief argument for rapid and comprehensive efforts to mitigate climate change is that society and the environment will not be able to adapt without massive disruptions and harm. Human health, nutrition and well-being, the global economy, and aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems are all at risk. Some damage has already happened, and more is unavoidable, but through mitigation society can avert the worst consequences of rising temperatures, rising seas, and the attendant failures of infrastructure, agriculture, and ecosystems.</p><p>A.C.2 Effective mitigation will not require huge investments in risky or unproven technologies such as SRM, or huge CCS infrastructure projects. A combination of greatly reduced GHG emissions plus intensive employment of green CCS can achieve the &lt;2°C goal within the next two decades. The technical and economic barriers can be overcome, but only with a global consensus coupled with political commitment and prompt action.</p><p>A.C.3 The principal means of adaptation are infrastructure improvements and relocation of human populations. Of the multiple climate-related causes for human migration, consider sea level rise. In some areas, mainly large coastal cities, massive infrastructure projects will be appropriate adaptation measures. Nevertheless, sea levels that are likely within this century will inundate large areas regardless of what barriers can be constructed. On its face, the retreat-relocate adaptation strategy is conceptually simple. Without mitigation, however, the disruption will be immense, both for those relocating and for the recipient communities. <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/surrendering-to-rising-seas/">It has been shown</a> that depopulation of coastal areas is not quick, cheap, or politically popular. With tens of millions of potential climate refugees, the outcome of failing to prioritize mitigation could be a global dystopia.</p><p>A.C.4 Both mitigation and adaptation are essential responses to climate change. This debate is about when, where, and how rather than whether we should employ these tools. For mitigation, the answers are now, everywhere, and using proven methods.</p><h3>Debaters</h3><h4>For</h4><p>Dr. Mica C. Smith is a postdoctoral research associate in chemical engineering at MIT. She earned her PhD from University of California, Berkeley. Her research has included analyzing basic properties of greenhouse gases and developing materials and methods to reduce harmful emissions from fuels. She can be found on <a href="https://twitter.com/micacsmith">Twitter</a>. Dr. Smith’s academic page can be found <a href="http://greengroup.mit.edu/mica-smith">here</a> and research can be found <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mica_Smith">here</a>.</p><h4>Against</h4><p>Dr. Stephen J. Jordan is an environmental scientist who retired from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) at the end of 2015. Before retirement, he was Assistant Director of the National Health and Environmental Effects Laboratory in EPA’s Office of Research and Development. Previous employment included the Maryland Department of Natural Resources, The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and Johns Hopkins University.</p><p>Dr. Jordan’s prior research, relevant to this written debate include: <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/5/11/4688/htm">Governance and the Gulf of Mexico Coast: How Are Current Policies Contributing to Sustainability?</a> and <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0787/2/2/119">Sustainability — What Are the Odds? Envisioning the Future of Our Environment, Economy and Society</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=383d263e8caf" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge/climate-change-on-a-massive-scale-is-a-done-deal-society-should-focus-on-adapting-to-it-383d263e8caf">Climate change on a massive scale is a done deal. Society should focus on adapting to it.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge">Common Lodge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introductions of new species should be viewed as natural within a large geologic timescale.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/commonlodge/introductions-of-new-species-should-be-viewed-as-natural-within-a-large-geologic-timescale-a4643efed433?source=rss----ae59961ba793---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a4643efed433</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[invasive-species]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[global-warming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Common Lodge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Apr 2019 17:48:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-04T02:31:00.666Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DSvPd5kJFiIAC4W6E7ELyw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Opening: For</h3><h4>Insight from History</h4><p>F.O.1 We are in Utah. It’s the late Tertiary period, two million years ago. Looking across the landscape, we see rolling mountains and valleys. Volcanic eruptions spew debris in the distance. Streams snake through the valleys joining a giant lake that stretches through current day Nevada, Idaho, and Utah. After the extinction of the dinosaurs, mammals diversified. Now camels, mastodons, horses, and ground sloths graze, while saber tooth cats and giant wolves stalk nearby.</p><p>F.O.2 Fast-forward 400,000 years. It’s the Pleistocene epoch. The Ice Age is in full swing. Mammoths invade North America from Asia and encounter Utah’s native flora and fauna. Over the next 1.5 million years, species compete and adapt as cycles of glaciation and deglaciation change landscapes and, with that, the requirements for survival.</p><p>F.O.3 Then, about 10,000 years ago, after <em>Homo sapiens</em> had arrived, the game changed ( <a href="https://geology.utah.gov/popular/general-geology/geologic-history/utah-a-geologic-history/">Utah Geological Survey</a>). As the Ice Age came to a close, humans proliferated and dominated. By the end of the Pleistocene, there was a net loss of biodiversity as extinction claimed all the species mentioned above (Utah Geologic Survey). The invasion of humans and subsequent loss of species has occurred throughout the world (<a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/113/23/6388">Boivin et al. 2016</a>).</p><h4>The Concept of Invasive Species is Erroneous</h4><p>F.O.4 Invasive species often cause biodiversity loss within a habitat. This statement introduces the topic in countless scientific papers, which often end with a call for management or eradication of said species. This is the prevailing view and bias: human activity has introduced countless invasive species that can threaten the integrity of ecosystems by eliciting changes within native communities. Therefore, we need to mitigate their impacts by focusing on prevention, management, and eradication.</p><p>F.O.5 The problem with this assessment is twofold. First, the definition of ‘invasive’ hinges on <em>human involvement</em>. An invasive species is not only non-native with the potential to cause harm, but also humanity must have played a role in its introduction (<a href="https://www.invasivespeciesinfo.gov/what-are-invasive-species">U.S. Department of Agriculture</a>). Conversely, native species haven’t been introduced by humanity and don’t cause harm.</p><p>F.O.6 However, no landscape, seascape, or species has escaped the influence of humankind. Through agriculture, animal and plant domestication, and the destruction and creation of ecosystems, we have affected Earth’s climates and species distributions and extinctions (<a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/113/23/6388">Boivin et al. 2016</a>). According to those definitions either no species is native, and all are invasive — an absurd idea — or we need to rethink the invasive species concept. The definitions also assume humans are separate from the natural world and therefore, our interference with species’ distributions is unnatural.</p><p>F.O.7 Second, this view employs a <em>short time span</em>, creating the illusion that landscapes are, and should be, static. Any change to a habitat would then be obvious and considered detrimental, since we are looking at a single snapshot in history instead of watching the entire movie. But our planet is in a constant state of physical and evolutionary flux. It’s naive to view the world as if frozen in time. The movement of species into new geographic areas is not only an expected consequence of changing climates and ecosystems within a broad evolutionary timescale, but those species are not inherently detrimental to native communities. Ultimately, it’s not realistic to control species’ movements. We need to reassess our view of invasive species.</p><h4>Environments Change, Species Adapt</h4><p>F.O.8 The planet is an enormous living, breathing organism that has changed and evolved for the past 4.5 billion years. No two snapshots are the same. Scrolling through time, tropical landscapes become deserts; forests rise out of freshwater lakes; gargantuan glaciers melt to reveal waving prairies; continents move; species split, morph, and evolve, including humans; others disappear.</p><p>F.O.9 With such constant motion, how does one determine which species are native, if that is even an important question? In Utah, were dinosaurs native and mammoths invasive? What about humans? They certainly changed native communities. I’d argue that geographic shifts are part of the normal ebb and flow of species responding to changing environments.</p><p>F.O.10 As habitats change, the requirements needed to live there change and interspecies competition for resources like food and space is affected. In such a scenario, each species must adapt to survive — natural selection demands this. Those who can’t adapt don’t survive. Adaptations come in many forms: as random genetic mutations that are passed on, or as new behaviors which turn out to be beneficial for survival. But adapting also includes physically moving to an environment that better suits one’s current biology. This is the case especially if the rate of environmental change or intensity of competition pressure doesn’t allow a species time to evolve.</p><p>F.O.11 This is the scenario today: For many species the only option is to physically move and encounter species they haven’t competed with. If successful, they will carve out a niche in the landscape maybe at the expense of other species, but maybe to the benefit of local biodiversity if their immigration encourages the presence of other species (<a href="https://www.cell.com/trends/ecology-evolution/fulltext/S0169-5347(03)00224-6">Sax &amp; Gaines 2003</a>). If they aren’t successful, they may be forced to move or perish.</p><p>F.O.12 While change is almost certain, new species aren’t inherently worse than resident species and it’s not a given the newcomers will damage the landscape. Nevertheless, scientists try to identify how an invasive species is having a negative impact on the native community. There isn’t a shortage of studies concluding that they do. The Invasive Species Specialist Group outlined the world’s top 100 worst invasive species, claiming each brings nothing short of calamity (<a href="http://www.iucngisd.org/gisd/100_worst.php">Global Invasive Species Database</a>).</p><p>F.O.13 Purple Loosestrife is a wetland plant notoriously invasive to the northern USA where it displaces native species and alters habitats. Researchers concluded that its presence signified an ecological disaster (<a href="https://catalogue.nla.gov.au/Record/4001984">Thompson et al. 1987</a>). But what if invaded habitats were assessed over longer time spans? While local biodiversity may fluctuate after the emergence of new species, it’s unlikely to remain in decline. In fact, a meta-analysis found no evidence of local plant biodiversity loss over time (<a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/110/48/19456">Vellend et al. 2013</a>). Habitats are instead undergoing species diversity change, not net loss (<a href="https://www.cell.com/trends/ecology-evolution/fulltext/S0169-5347(03)00224-6">Sax &amp; Gaines 2003</a>; <a href="https://www.uvm.edu/~ngotelli/manuscriptpdfs/DornelasScience.pdf">Dornelas et al. 2014</a>).</p><p>F.O.14 Surely not all invasive species are harmful. Where would we be without wheat, rice, corn, or soy? What about chickens or cows? Humans domesticated and introduced them and they have significantly altered native communities, yet we don’t consider them invasive even though by definition we should. Here the prevailing bias comes into full view. Studies exploring the <em>benefits</em> of invasive species are practically non-existent. But, the absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence. Ken Thompson, in the book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Where-Do-Camels-Belong-invasive/dp/1781251746"><em>Where Do Camels Belong</em></a>, presents a strong case for exactly that. He points instead to a lack of interest and funding for studying species that don’t appear to be a threat, while simultaneously downplaying the potential benefits of new species.</p><p>F.O.15 Landscapes change and species move in response to environmental conditions, which are affected by humanity. Not only are we making the unreasonable assumption that invasive species are bad and represent a threat (they only represent a threat to our idea of a static environment), but also the findings of studies are dependent on their spatial and temporal scope. Time and scale are limiting factors in understanding how species in a landscape affect one another and an ecosystem. Such complex interactions can only be understood from the point of view of evolutionary time.</p><h4>The Way Forward</h4><p>F.O.16 Once science identifies a harmful invasive species, efforts get underway to control it. Trying to manage the infamous Purple Loosestrife has cost $45 million per year (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259640053_Environmental_and_Economic_Costs_of_Nonindigenous_Species_in_the_United_States">Pimentel et al. 2000</a>). In the United States, $100 million is spent annually on invasive species prevention, detection, management, research, and restoration (<a href="https://www.fws.gov/verobeach/pythonpdf/costofinvasivesfactsheet.pdf">U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service</a>).</p><p>F.O.17 As long as we view the natural world as static and immigrating species as harmful, we will continue to spend billions to control them. This simply doesn’t make sense. Once we discard these incorrect notions, we see the futility of controlling the inevitable movement of species. Frankly, it’s not possible and it’s the wrong approach. Boivin and her colleagues declared in a 2016 paper: “The impact of human agency on ecosystems is neither completely avoidable nor entirely undesirable. . . Rather than an impossible return to pristine conditions, what is needed is the historically informed management of emerging novel ecosystems to ensure the maintenance of ecological goods and services.”</p><p>F.O.18 We should spend our money, time, and resources to address encompassing and imminent threats like climate change, pollution, and human population growth. If we address those top-tier issues, we will mitigate a host of additional problems that affect biodiversity, ecosystem functioning, species extinctions, and human health and safety. Let’s focus on the underlying sickness rather than the benign symptom of species on the move.</p><h3>Opening: Against</h3><h4>What is an alien species?</h4><p>A.O.1 Species that have been moved by humans to a region where they have not previously existed are known as alien or non-indigenous. This movement can be intentional, such as taking a plant from its native region and moving it to a new region for ornamental purposes. It can also be unintentional, such as species that grow on submerged areas (e.g., hull, keel or water inlets) of boats or ships travelling among ports (<a href="https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1365-2664.2007.01442.x">Hulme et al. 2008</a>). This unnatural movement of species is yet another direct result of human activity that causes unprecedented and often negative changes in the natural world. Introductions of new species through human means, particularly intentional introductions, are not the natural way species migrate and adapt to new climates. As such, these species are typically not dispersing as a survival strategy, but rather, are being taken from their native environments by humans, and being moved to new regions, where in some cases they are unable to survive and in others, they are able to thrive and often do significant harm.</p><h4>How do introduced species become successful invaders?</h4><p>A.O.2 Once a species is introduced, it has overcome the barrier of geography (which usually prevents dispersal unless humans intervene) and there remain several other barriers before being able to establish itself in the new environment (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/51154938_A_proposed_unified_framework_for_biological_invasions">Blackburn et al. 2011</a>). First, it needs to be able to withstand the new environmental conditions. If environmental conditions in the recipient region are substantially different from that of the species’ native region, it could either die off, or adapt to the new environment.</p><p>A.O.3 The next barrier is reproduction, which often depends on how many individuals are introduced, their sex ratios, and reproductive strategies. For example, if enough males and females are introduced, there is a greater chance for them to successfully reproduce. In some instances, pregnant females are introduced (e.g., a crab carrying eggs) and in this case there is no need for a male. Consequently, if a species reproduces asexually (e.g., a plant that can reproduce via budding) then the likelihood of that species spreading successfully is high, as it takes only a single individual to reproduce.</p><p>A.O.4 Once a species has survived and is able to reproduce successfully, it is known as an established alien species. After establishing a population in the new environment, if the species is able to disperse from the point of introduction, then it is classified as an invasive species. Invasive species are, therefore, those alien species that produce self-sustaining populations, spread from their point of introduction, and create impacts that threaten ecosystems and species in recipient regions.</p><h4>What impacts do they have?</h4><p>A.O.5 Environmental impacts imposed by invasive species include changes in native community composition, competition for resources, hybridizing with native species, population loss, and changes in ecosystem processes. Often, environmental impacts can threaten the economy, social structure and health of humans. While the majority of impacts observed have been negative, impacts can also be positive, as is the case with the African Black Oystercatcher in South Africa (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/223830274_Can_we_predict_the_effects_of_alien_species_A_case-history_of_the_invasion_of_South_Africa_by_Mytilus_galloprovincialis_Lamarck">Branch and Steffani 2004</a>): an invasive mussel, <em>Mytilus galloprovincialis</em> has acted as a food source for these birds, allowing them to increase their reproductive output and re-establish their declining population numbers. Invasive species are, therefore, not always bad. Why, then, should we prevent, manage or eradicate them? For fear of the unknown? Or do we have evidence that invasive species can cause real and dramatic impacts on our environment, our economy, and our society?</p><p>A.O.6 This evidence certainly exists. The positive impacts, which are far less documented than the negative, can often be considered transient, whereas negative impacts can be permanent (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ddi.12150">Richardson and Ricciardi 2013</a>). Negative consequences of invasions manifest in a variety of ecosystems including terrestrial, marine, and freshwater environments. The increase in human population, trade, and developments in technology has changed the ways in which species are transferred, causing a rise in species introductions (<a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms14435">Seebens et al. 2017</a>). Initial introductions were land-based and generally intentional, for consumptive, medicinal, or ornamental purposes. With the development of ships and commercial trade, species were able to cross oceans. Advances in development allowed for several pathways to emerge, including railways, roads, shipping, aircraft, aquariums, and even the pet trade. As a result, most native ecosystems are exposed to introductions.</p><h4>Examples of invasive species in a terrestrial, marine, and freshwater ecosystem</h4><p><strong><em>Terrestrial<br></em></strong>A.O.7 A group of terrestrial invasive species that is receiving increasing attention, due to the conflict it has created, is the <em>Prosopis </em>tree genus (Mesquite and related plants). Known as one of the world’s most damaging woody invasive taxa, it was introduced to many regions for its various uses such as fuelwood, fencing poles and fodder. <em>Prosopis</em>, therefore,<em> </em>starts off being quite beneficial but if left unmanaged, its negative impacts outweigh the benefits (<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0140196312001012?via%3Dihub">Wise et al. 2012</a>). These impacts result from the formation of dense, thorny thickets, and include reducing the water supply to humans, plants and animals, reducing native forest cover, adversely affecting livestock health, and restricting access to water sources, roads, and other areas in villages.</p><p>A.O.8 Studies have reported that more than 90% of livestock farmers find <em>Prosopis</em> to be problematic and the invasion has resulted in serious and violent conflict among communities in Ethiopia and Kenya. This phenomenon is related to the scarcity of natural resources as a result of the <em>Prosopis</em> invasion, which dramatically affects the farmers’ livelihoods (<a href="http://scholar.sun.ac.za/handle/10019.1/98686">Shackleton 2016</a>). This invasion, therefore, displays clear negative impacts on biodiversity and socio-economic stability.</p><p><strong><em>Marine<br></em></strong>A.O.9 The marine environment is not devoid of invasive species that cause detrimental impacts. Along the coasts of Tasmania and mainland Australia, the invasion of the northern Pacific Sea Star, <em>Asterias amurensis</em>, has caused noticeable changes in marine communities, significantly reducing densities of native mollusk species. Since some of the native fish species are dependent on mollusks for food, competition for resources with the Sea Star resulted in declines of fish populations (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/285747356_Decadal_decline_in_demersal_fish_biomass_coincident_with_a_prolonged_drought_and_the_introduction_of_an_exotic_starfish">Parry and Hirst, 2016</a>).</p><p>A.O.10 Furthermore, native mollusks were unable to recognize the invasive Sea Star as a threat (<a href="https://digital.library.adelaide.edu.au/dspace/handle/2440/16492">Hutson et al., 2005</a>), supporting the theory that escape responses of marine invertebrates have evolved in relation to predation risk. This type of prey naivety puts native marine species particularly at risk from invasive predators. The Sea Star is also able to shift its diet to feed on other species when the main component of its diet occurs at low densities, putting other species at risk of depletion and further affecting prey availability for native predators. In addition to the environmental impacts, the Sea Star also affects commercial bivalve farms, since many of the mollusk species that it feeds on are used in the bivalve farming industry (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/250217673_Impact_of_introduced_seastars_Asterias_amurensis_on_survivorship_of_juvenile_commercial_bivalves_Fulvia_tenuicostata">Ross et al. 2002</a>).</p><p><strong><em>Freshwater<br></em></strong>A.O.11 Similarly, freshwater invasions have displayed serious consequences to native species and the economy. One example is that of the parasitic Sea Lamprey, <em>Petromyzon marinus</em>, one of the oldest living vertebrate lineages alive today. This invasion goes back to the early 1920s, when modifications to a canal that links lakes in the United States resulted in the movement of Sea Lampreys into the Great Lakes. They parasitized large predatory fish species, such as Lake Trout, by attaching their sucker-like mouths directly onto the fish, feeding on their blood and bodily fluids, ultimately resulting in the hosts’ death. The invasion resulted in the collapse of commercial and recreational fisheries of the Great Lakes, causing devastating economic impacts with cascading effects on food webs within the ecosystem (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/238422945_Sea_Lamprey_Petromyzon_marinus_in_Lakes_Huron_Michigan_and_Superior_History_of_Invasion_and_Control_1936-78">Smith and Tibbles 1980</a>; <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232859899_Extinctions_of_North_American_Fishes_During_the_past_Century">Miller et al. 1989</a>).</p><p>A.O.12 Often, when a native predator is removed from a food web, prey species can dramatically increase in numbers because the absent predator can no longer naturally regulate their population size. This effect results in overconsumption of resources further down the food chain, which can include other prey species, as well as primary producers such as plants or algae. There results an imbalance in the ecosystem, and since so many ecosystems are interconnected, the effects can further influence the ability of the system to recover.</p><h4>Management can reduce or prevent the impacts of invasions</h4><p>A.O.13 Not all introduced species cause negative impacts from an environmental, social, or economic standpoint. However, those that do, have demonstrated clear and sizable negative consequences, with real-world challenges. Attempts to address the problem of invasive species, therefore, focus largely on the prevention of their introduction in the first place (<a href="https://www.cell.com/trends/ecology-evolution/fulltext/S0169-5347(12)00174-7?switch=standard">Simberloff et al. 2013</a>). While eradication is initiated in regions where it is affordable and where negative impacts have outweighed the costs that would be required to counteract those impacts, more and more regions are aiming to prevent introductions. When invasive species are left to thrive, the impacts can become overwhelming, costly, and often harmful to ecosystems. Do we stand aside and allow ecosystems to degrade and livelihoods to crash? Or should we do something about it? We can and should, by implementing management programs that are able to reduce or prevent negative impacts, before they reach catastrophic levels.</p><h3>Rebuttal: For</h3><h4>Humanity’s Involvement: A Red Herring</h4><p>F.R.1 In paragraph F.O.5, I introduced two problems underlying the traditional view toward invasive species. First is the assumption that human interference of species’ distributions is unnatural. But it isn’t. We’re just a species that’s wildly successful at colonizing and altering habitats (that makes us an invasive species). In her opening paragraphs (A.O.1 through A.O.4), my opponent makes this assumption while failing to explain what quantifies native environments, or natural species movement.</p><p>F.R.2 One can extrapolate that a species’ native environment is one where they weren’t introduced “through human means” via pathways mentioned in A.O.6, and that natural movement means species are “dispersing as a survival strategy” on their own (A.O.1). However, to find species whose distributions were <em>not</em> influenced by humans, we need to travel back over 200,000 years in Africa — before our species evolved — and 60,000 to 2,000 years ago in other continents. Humans have been affecting species’ abundances and ranges since the dawn of our evolution (<a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/113/23/6388">Boivina et al. 2016</a>). How can we possibly define ‘native’ and ‘invasive’ based on humanity’s involvement?</p><p>F.R.3 The author also mentions that it’s challenging for species to overcome geographical barriers without human help (A.O.2). But it’s not impossible or unlikely. We only need to account for genetic and environmental variability, species interactions, and <em>time</em> (<a href="http://labs.bio.unc.edu/Buckley/WGdocs/Case2005.pdf">Case et al. 2005</a>). A species with high genetic variability could invade a habitat exhibiting gradual environmental differences given enough time.</p><p>F.R.4 Even lacking some of those conditions, colonization is possible. Hawaii and the Galapagos are volcanic islands that haven’t been connected to other landmasses. To reach them, species overcame seemingly insurmountable barriers by sea and air. It is presumptuous to assume that species considered invasive never would have reached those locations without us. If they had, they wouldn’t be considered invasive even if they dramatically changed recipient communities.</p><h4>The Impact of Time</h4><p>F.R.5 The second problem introduced in F.O.7 is the opposition’s adoption of a short timeframe. This perpetuates the illusion of static environments in which change is often seen as negative, especially when attributed to invasive species. The author’s arguments in A.O.5 and A.O.6 operate from this snapshot perspective.</p><p>F.R.6 While the author admits that not all invasive species are bad (A.O.3), she also says invasive species “display impacts that <em>threaten</em> ecosystems and species in recipient regions” (A.O.4). She creates her case by saying “the majority of impacts observed have been negative” (A.O.5) and that “positive impacts. . . can often be considered transient, whereas negative impacts can be permanent” (A.O.6).</p><p>F.R.7 She doesn’t mention that most observed impacts are negative because it’s easier to secure funding for species that seem to have negative impacts (F.O.12 and F.O.14, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Where-Do-Camels-Belong-invasive/dp/1781251746">Thompson 2014</a>). Yet, her worst oversight is not acknowledging that any impacts can be transient. It’s complicated to determine the direction of change since it depends on perspective and time. What may seem bad now may end up being good in ways we can’t yet comprehend.</p><p>F.R.8 I am not arguing that action shouldn’t be taken to address immediate health and safety concerns caused by invasive species (in reference to A.O.7). I’m arguing for a measured approach to understanding their impacts seated within the context of broad timescales. If the impacts mentioned in A.O.9 through A.O.12 were placed within a broader timescale (e.g., centuries or millennia), we would see an accurate picture of what’s occurring and may find habitats and biological communities are not worse off after invasions despite how it may appear from time-limited studies.</p><h4>Management is Unrealistic and Unpredictable</h4><p>F.R.9 In A.O.13, the author poses a final question: “[should] we stand aside and allow ecosystems to degrade and livelihoods to crash?” She answers saying no, we should manage invasive species via prevention and eradication “before [impacts] reach catastrophic levels.” First, change doesn’t equal degradation, as mentioned above.</p><p>F.R.10 Second, prevention and eradication is shortsighted and unlikely to be successful. There are no data on the efficacy of prevention since we don’t know how many species we’ve prevented from invading or how many we could have prevented if actions had been different. Eradication takes precise planning and execution. Efforts should be underway within the first four years of a species’ introduction. But even then, only 50.9% of eradication attempts are successful (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3482215/">Pluess et al. 2012</a>) and 79% of case studies reported continued spread or increasing densities despite management efforts (<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326564905_The_role_of_invasive_alien_species_in_shaping_local_livelihoods_and_human_well-being_A_review">Shackleton et al. 2019</a>). These are not great odds.</p><p>F.R.11 One possible explanation is that invaders and communities adapt to one another’s presence and changes in a landscape; they are immediately and intimately interwoven by the time an invasion has occurred. <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4893336/">Ballari and colleagues (2016)</a> even found that the eradication of a single invader can negatively affect native species because of complex food-web hierarchies and interactions.</p><p>F.R.12 The opposition’s argument operates on a narrow timeframe, perpetuating the false idea that landscapes are static. It’s based on a host of assumptions including that invasive species threaten recipient environments and our role in species’ distributions is unnatural. This view isn’t accurate or informed.</p><h3>Rebuttal: Against</h3><p>The key arguments in the authors opening statement has been identified and addressed below.</p><h4>1. Humans are part of the natural world and our role in species movement should be left as is.</h4><p>A.R.1 While I appreciate the opponent’s view regarding the definition of invasive species in F.O.5, current invasions cannot be equated to those in the fossil record. The present scale of invasions, their subsequent impacts and evolutionary importance is unique. We have created pathways for species to spread faster, further away, and at much higher densities than ever before (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ddi.12150">Richardson and Ricciardi, 2013</a>). Human-created pathways are also profoundly distinct from species’ natural dispersal mechanisms as mentioned in A.O.1.</p><p>A.R.2 Yes, we are a part of the natural world but simply ignoring the fact that we are causing species movements that can damage ecosystems and livelihoods, would be to say that we may as well continue burning fossil fuels. By considering ourselves equivalent to any other species, then surely our actions should not be controlled either?</p><p>A.R.3 Following the view of the author in F.O.10, the result of our resource extraction should be left as is because we are a part of the system and this is our way of competing for resources, our way of adapting and surviving, as natural selection demands. However, the very fact that we are cognizant of our actions and that we’re able to mitigate and prevent harmful consequences is what sets us apart and influences our duty to act. The author states in F.O.7 that “it’s not realistic to control species movements” but that’s exactly what we are doing, we are moving species around, causing ecosystem impacts and we can address it, as much as we do for every other threat we created.</p><h4>2. Invasion scientists view the natural world as a static environment and aim to preserve a world that does not change by focusing on a short time-span.</h4><p>A.R.4 The author suggests in F.O.7 and F.O.15 that all forms of species movements, including human-mediated introductions change ecosystems and by managing introductions and looking at a single snapshot, we advocate for a pristine and unchanged environment. I disagree. We acknowledge natural dispersal mechanisms and natural geographic range shifts of species that ultimately result in constantly changing ecosystems. We further acknowledge naturalized species, which are introduced species that have self-replacing populations outside of captivity or culture but have not spread from their point of introduction. As such, invasion scientists are not aiming to create a static environment but rather trying to prevent the evidence-based impacts that can occur as a result of human-mediated introductions. Furthermore, invasion ecologists are assessing new concepts such as novel ecosystems (Richardson and Gaertner, 2013), mentioned in F.O.17, among others, in order to gain a better understanding of global change effects.</p><h4>3. Scientists only seek out the negative impacts of introduced species, with the assumption that native species do not cause harm.</h4><p>A.R.5 In F.O.12, the author states that not all “newcomers will damage the landscape”, a point that has already been addressed in A.O.5. The author then continues, declaring that “scientists try to identify how an invasive species is having a negative impact.” However, scientists try to determine whether there is an impact at all, in order to inform management decisions and whether action is indeed warranted.</p><p>A.R.6 Furthermore, previous studies have shown that non-native species are more likely to cause negative ecological and socio-economic impacts than native species (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ddi.12150">Richardson and Ricciardi, 2013</a>). This point is further supported by cases when invaders have demonstrated stronger impacts in their introduced ranges compared to those in their native ranges. In F.O.14, the author makes reference to the lack of studies that explore the benefits of invasive species. There are studies that address both positive and negative consequences of invasions, and for now, it appears that some invasions are initially beneficial, but if left to thrive, species can become problematic (see A.O.7). I would welcome studies that assess benefits of invasive species and their long-term effects.</p><h4>4. Spending money on controlling invasive species is ill-placed and should rather be directed towards other, imminent threats.</h4><p>A.R.7 While I agree that money could often be better spent on more pressing issues (see F.O.18), I don’t agree that we should neglect oversight of our own movements of species that could cause and have caused harm. By suggesting that we let introduced species run their course and harm human livelihoods, and doing nothing about it when we have the ability to do so, debunks the opponent’s portrayal of species (including humans) adapting to change. Implementing management programs is one of our ways of responding to a changing ecosystem as a result of our own actions. This is exactly why prevention is important, so that we are not forced to eradicate species that we introduced in the first place.</p><p>A.R.8 We should certainly not be excluding ourselves from the natural world, but to simply ignore our active and accelerated role in spreading species beyond their natural biogeographic ranges would be imprudent.</p><h3>Closing: For</h3><h4>Species on the Move, Naturally</h4><p>F.C.1 The global movement of species into new environments has been a phenomenon throughout time. Species move in response to changing climates and ecosystems within broad evolutionary timescales. Static, or pristine, environments in which certain species have always been present don’t exist. Impermanence rules.</p><p>F.C.2 Nor are human-induced species migrations a new phenomenon. By creating novel ecosystems and destroying others, humans have always affected species’ geographic distributions as they adapt to us. That’s how natural selection and evolution work. Thus, categorizing species as native or invasive based on humanity’s involvement is futile (F.O.6).</p><p>F.C.3 It’s also a prejudiced view to expect invasive species will “threaten ecosystems and species in recipient regions” (A.O.2) and that negative impacts are more permanent than positive ones (A.O.6 and A.R.5). Ken Thompson states that this view is “justified by a focus on a relatively few species that cause undoubted economic or environmental harm . . . But it ignores the vast majority that do no harm at all, or are positively useful . . .” Scientists should correct their tendency to view invaders as guilty until proven innocent.</p><h4>Misguided and Distracted</h4><p>F.C.4 If the opposition’s desire is to prevent species introductions (A.O.13 and A.R.7), the solution is clear: We must cease altering environments in ways that encourage species’ movement. Practically, that’s not possible. Our species will grow alongside novel environments, technology will advance, and global trade and travel will increase. In response, species will adapt to their changing surroundings and move to new environments (F.O.10).</p><p>F.C.5 Therefore, it’s unrealistic to control species’ movements through prevention or eradication (F.O.7 and F.O.17). That doesn’t mean I’m “[ignoring] our active and accelerated role in spreading species beyond their natural biogeographic ranges” (A.R.8). There isn’t sufficient long-term evidence that spreading species is inherently dangerous or that changes caused by alien species damage ecosystems.</p><p>F.C.6 Focusing on invasive species distracts us from addressing more serious, yet complicated problems like climate change, pollution, overfishing, and habitat loss. We should address top-tier issues. That will mitigate impacts on biodiversity, ecosystem functioning, and human livelihoods, health, and safety more so than any attempt to control so-called non-native species.</p><h3>Closing: Against</h3><h4>Human activities are the ultimate cause of invasive species threats</h4><p>A.C.1 Humans are a part of the natural world, but our conscious, increasing and accelerated movement of species cannot be viewed as a natural way for species to disperse. The core arguments to support this are as follows:</p><ol><li>A.C.1.1 Human-mediated, species range shifts are profoundly distinct from natural species dispersal mechanisms. They occur over short time periods, at increasing frequencies and move species beyond their natural dispersal abilities where other species have not evolved to survive with the newcomers (see A.R.1).</li><li>A.C.1.2 Negative impacts of invasive species currently outweigh positive impacts (A.O.6). This is prevalent in numerous ecosystems and is supported by evidence-based research (for examples, see A.O.7 to A.O.12). “This is further supported by cases when invaders have demonstrated stronger impacts in their introduced ranges compared to those in their native ranges” (A.R.6).</li><li>A.C.1.3 Humans are cognizant of the ecological and socio-economic impacts and have the ability to address them, as with every other human-induced threat. Therefore, implementing management programs is our duty, and the best approach currently is to prevent or reduce harmful introductions (see A.O.11 and A.R.3).</li></ol><p>A.C.2 While my opponent introduces some interesting concepts, she fails to adequately address the arguments and fails to understand that rapid human-mediated introductions cannot be equated to the long-term range shifts and subsequent distributions she refers to (F.R.3 an F.R.4). Consequently, the author’s campaign for a broader timescale approach may not be wise, as it is neither an accurate view, nor supported by any solid evidence. By waiting to “see an accurate picture” (F.R.8) it may be a case of too little too late.</p><p>A.C.3 Our direct movement of species is yet another human-induced, environmental and socio-economic threat. This idea may be hard to grasp compared to other threats because addressing the issue involves controlling and removing species. The opposition states, “management is unrealistic” and “unlikely to be successful” and stating that “ultimately, it’s not realistic to control species,” but managing any human-induced threat is challenging, and we created the problem by being responsible for their movements in the first place. Furthermore, biosecurity measures in Australia and New Zealand prove that preventive measures can be successful.</p><p>A.C.4 As a result of these shortcomings and the lack of empirical evidence to support the opposition’s claims, I retain my position.</p><h3>Debaters</h3><h4>For</h4><p>Haley R. Pope has a Master of Science in Zoology from Stellenbosch University in South Africa where she studied the spread, life-history strategies, and impacts of an invasive marine barnacle under the context of climate change. Her research, related to the topic of this debate, can be found <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/scientific-contributions/2068112113_Haley_R_Pope">here</a>. Haley is the President of <a href="https://www.terralensphotography.com/">TerraLens Photograph</a>, providing conservation photography, archiving, and writing services.</p><h4>Against</h4><p>Koebraa Peters has a PhD in Zoology from Stellenbosch University in South Africa. For the past 8 years, she has worked extensively on invasive species. Her work on marine invasive species has included developing prioritization tools for monitoring alien species in regions where resources are lacking. Koebraa is published in the Journal of Environmental Management, BioInvasions Records, Management of Biological Invasions and African Journal of Marine Science. Her research, related to the topic of this debate, can be found <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Koebraa_Peters">here</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a4643efed433" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge/introductions-of-new-species-should-be-viewed-as-natural-within-a-large-geologic-timescale-a4643efed433">Introductions of new species should be viewed as natural within a large geologic timescale.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/commonlodge">Common Lodge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>