<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[A Continued Mapping Project - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:44:37 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/continued-mapping-project" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Interview 3 — On Learning How to Interview a Tree]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/interview-3-on-learning-how-to-interview-a-tree-27f4c1fd0fe1?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/27f4c1fd0fe1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 May 2015 07:25:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-02T07:25:19.093Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Interview 3 — On Learning How to Interview a Tree</h3><p>The open path before me drew me onward, as paths have a funny way of doing. I felt called forward, the unexplored trail beckoning with promise of at least new questions, and hopefully answers as well. The Western Red Cedars I had tried to converse with faded into the background, and new potential interview subjects came into view.</p><p>The trail led me to the edge of a forest. I wondered aloud about how these trees might differ from the ones I had just interviewed. Being on the fringe between dense woods and open field, these border trees had a unique perspective on the world that their kin on either side of that divide only knew half of. Those living in the field grew up surrounded by the clarity of open air. They were free to stretch out in all directions, but perhaps knew some loneliness, towering islands in an open sea of tall grasses.</p><p>The trees which grow in the forest, on the other hand, were accustomed to the dark enclosure lent by their brothers and sisters. Competitive siblings twisted and turned over, around, through each other to reach for the sunlight, resulting in intricate curves and intertwined trunks. I was struck by the different lives trees even of the same species might live based on their environment, as well as by the fortune of those trees who grow along the border, who get to experience life on both sides of the tracks.</p><p>I sat for a while with one such tree. It stood maybe 15 feet tall. From its narrow trunk, spindly branches (so numerous and criss-crossed that they seemed countless) sprung out in all directions, making the entire form of the tree about as wide as it was tall. Within those branches hard, bright red berries nestled among grey bark and comingling mosses and lichens. Down below, a dank matting of leaves in varying states of brown and red, of dead and alive, coated the cold ground. I knelt down to investigate rotting leaves. As I looked closer, I could see some opportunistic mushrooms springing up from the soil amid the detritus.</p><p>Suddenly the scene took on a whole new identity for me, the tree’s narrative playing out before my eyes. I could see a young tree emerging from fertile soil in the warm sun of spring in Bellingham. Years of cycles of vibrancy and dormancy, as inch by inch, the tree grows. A tree soon old enough to produce hundreds of leaves, dropping its suncatchers one by one as they are torn free from their branches by biting autumn breezes. Leaves lying wet on the ground become a delicious meal for the decomposers of the deciduous — mushrooms move in and gorge themselves. The nutrients held within the leaves get broken down and returned to the soil, infusing the Earth with richness and the potential for new life. Eventually, the tree dies, and the ground once shaded by its gnarled branches is struck by new rays. A young tree emerges from fertile soil.</p><p>I pondered over how amazing it was that this little ecosystem was able to comprise a self-reciprocating network until my thoughts were shaken by a rustling from above. A squirrel was jumping from branch to branch, collecting berries from only the highest section of the tree. Why would he be doing this? There were plenty of berries much lower to the ground. Wasn’t it riskier to forage so high up? I figured there must be some squirrel logic within his tiny brain that was behind this behavior, but it was lost on me.</p><p>As I was watching the squirrel, I began to become more attuned to other sounds in the forest as well. I could make out several distinct bird calls, but theirs was a conversation in a language completely lost on me. I longed to know who these birds were, what they were talking about. I decided to move onward, deeper into the forest. As I did, I noticed that the trees here seemed to grow in cliques, like adolescents in a lunchroom, clinging to the comfort of their own kind. Again, I was filled with a sense of wonderment — why did they grow like this? Were the birches too cool to be seen growing alongside the firs? I knew of the concept of succession, that forests come about in a very certain way, but these details too were beyond my knowledge. Again, I longed to know — to know about the narrative of the forest, its story (and stories) from birth to death.</p><p>Walking through the forest in search of answers as a hopeful interviewer, I found myself presented with more questions instead. This in itself was an answer for me in a way though. I began to understand that the types of conversations I was trying to have were, by their nature, very different from what I had anticipated. Not only would they have to be with entire landscapes at once rather than just a lone tree, but they would also take place on a different time scale from the conversations I was used to. The narratives of landscapes tell their secrets in as much as one is equipped and willing to listen.</p><p>There is no such thing as an isolated moment of dialogue with a tree. On the contrary, there is a constant conversation going on all around us at all times — narratives unfolding, stories being shared, morals there to be gleaned. Taking part in the conversation is all a matter of attunement. Of opening our ears to the songs of the forest; of breathing in the fresh mists of a gray morning. The songs of birds, the scratchings of deer antlers on tree bark, the presence of old growth versus young trees, all tell countless stories which unfold within each moment and across days, seasons, decades.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=27f4c1fd0fe1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/interview-3-on-learning-how-to-interview-a-tree-27f4c1fd0fe1">Interview 3 — On Learning How to Interview a Tree</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Interview 2 — My First Interview with the Trees]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/interview-2-my-first-interview-with-the-trees-4d3ecafbfe6f?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4d3ecafbfe6f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 May 2015 07:24:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-02T07:22:24.968Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-ZFk6Gg53bqxXj2-qxlbcw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Interview 2 — My First Interview with the Trees</h3><p>In my first entry in this ongoing project, I began exploring the notion of arguing with a copse of madrona trees. I wanted to explore this type of dialogue further, and so under the influence of Robert Weiss’s interview method in <em>Learning from Strangers</em>, I sought out qualitative interviews with the trees. As I approached my first interview subject, a copse of Western Red Cedars growing near the edge of a field in the Happy Valley neighborhood, I had no idea what to expect. My environment once again demonstrated that it has countless stories to tell though, and new insights in terms of metaphor and my process of attenuation arose like eager spring shoots from fertile soil.</p><p>To interview a tree requires a specially designed process. Obviously I wasn’t going to be able to just turn on my digital recorder and wait for responses to questions as I might in a traditional interview. However, as I said in <em>Arguing with the Madronas</em>, narratives can rise out of anything, and so I knew that if I were to ask the right kinds of questions and listen in a variety of ways, the answers would come. Weiss’s method involves determining an aim of an interview and then tailoring a substantive frame which guides the types of questions to be asked. In this interview though, the aim was less about the answers that I received and more about exploring how a conversation of this kind can unfold.</p><p>This interview was also influenced by insights yielded in my previous interview with John on ways of gaining nature awareness. To go about the interview, I combined conventional question-asking with methods of attunement based on John’s practices. I made a ‘sit spot’ — a sense meditation exercise — and tried attenuating with different senses as well. I also tried to incorporate other aspects of nature awareness such as wildlife tracking, although I am still an amateur at best with such skills.</p><p>When I first arrived at the site, I began to take note of the surroundings. I asked the trees, “What do you see? What is this place that you call home?” I could see a path running tangent to the cluster of trees, leading from the road through an open field and into the forest. From the trees’ vantage point, a breathtaking view of the Chuckanuts lay between expanses of brown grasses and blue sky. Someone seemed to have a gardening project going next to the trees, and there were remnants of an attempted treehouse as well: bolts were screwed into the tree trunks, and lumber in various states of disrepair was strewn about at their bases. Whether construction of the treehouse was abandoned for good or only put on hold during the cold, wet Bellingham winter will only become clear with time and subsequent visits.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ly3A7TOCy1_7FJG9eoDxlA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The cedars’ scenic view</figcaption></figure><p>I could clearly see that an anthropomorphic community had formed around this dendropomorphic community, and I asked the trees how they felt about this. Might it bring them joy to see people cultivating new life in the shade of their boughs? Might they have felt pained as bolts were driven into their flesh, as they became exploited as supports for a structure composed of their fallen kin? Or could they be happy to take place in this interspecific partnership? My questions were met with stolid silence, and I was left to ponder.</p><p>After allowing myself to be drenched in the wordless ambience of this non-answer for a few moments, I decided to delve deeper into attunement with my various senses. I reached up into the outstretched branches of one of the cedars and closed my eyes, letting my mind focus on the tactile sensations of our human-tree handshake. The individual leaves were rough to the touch. If I took a handful of leaves at once though, the perceived roughness of the individual leaves was replaced with a distinct sensation of softness. Influenced by John’s constant mindfulness towards survival skills and natural resources, I found myself instantly thinking that a collection of these would make comfortable bedding were I to need to build a shelter.</p><p>Being reminded of John, I thought to look for any animal markings that might contribute to these trees’ narratives. I was unable to find markings, per se, that I could interpret, but I did become more aware of the wildlife intertwined with the trees. Spiders had spun webs spanning fissures in the bark and birds flitted about and sang from the tree tops. I was beginning to see the various communities overlain and interwoven in this small stand of trees, which started to shift my metaphors. Would it be a stretch to think of these cedars as community organizers?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/472/1*2qMdz8AbRK4Drik8XEEbcw.jpeg" /></figure><p>As I continued to move about through the trees, breathing in their freshness, feeling the softness of their wood, and observing them up close, I came to notice a peculiar quality in the coloration of their bark. On certain sides of the tree tinges of green could be found all along their trunks, most likely some species of lichen. This had the effect of causing the trees to appear from afar greyish-green on some sides but greyish-brown on other sides. Suddenly I saw this simple dichotomy of perspectives as a microcosm of the very ideas that I am working with in terms of metaphor and attenuation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/919/1*QwuE9xDLSjPHS5PmiD5Qwg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Two sides of the same tree</figcaption></figure><p>I imagined that someone might spend their whole life walking along a path to the west of these trees every day. They pass the cedars by and orient themselves within the space as being next to a group of greyish-brown trees. Now, another person may walk along a slightly different path every day which takes them on the eastern side of the trees; this person would orient themselves in regard to the greyish-green trees. Both people’s mental maps would be correct, and yet if they were to confer with each other about the trees in the middle, they would call the other person wrong. That is until someone comes along who walks along multiple paths, weaving varied perspectives together to form a more highly-aware understanding.</p><p>This seemingly simple anecdote can be analogized to a number of situations with much greater implications — morality; religion; environmental practices — being open to other perspectives and ways of orienting can circumvent conflict and bring us to greater levels of awareness. It was as if in that moment the trees were trying to tell me something, embodying and demonstrating the power of perception from multiple perspectives. This felt like an affirmation of the work I’ve been doing with attenuation and metaphor.</p><p>Initially my plan for this endeavor had been to get an interview or narrative out of several individual trees that day, but I quickly realized that this was a highly reductionist way of thinking about the process. As I was trying to enter into a dialogue with the trees, other elements of the environment began to seep into the conversation as well, and I saw that I was not interviewing just a tree, but rather engaging in a dialogue with all of the cohabitants in my environment that I was able to attune myself to. It also soon became clear that this would not be a one-time event for an hour or two like my interview with John; these conversations would be a long-term process that will require multiple visits to be able to glean answers from the trees and other cohabitants of that space. I carried these realizations forward with me as I moved on to new dialogues with new trees. As I headed down the path toward the forest, a sense that interviews there would continue to inform and reshape my processes of attenuation began to grow within me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4d3ecafbfe6f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/interview-2-my-first-interview-with-the-trees-4d3ecafbfe6f">Interview 2 — My First Interview with the Trees</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Interview 1 — Interview with the Naturalist]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/interview-1-interview-with-the-naturalist-cc12afe897e3?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc12afe897e3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 May 2015 07:24:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-02T07:24:19.533Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Interview 1 — Interview with the Naturalist</h3><p>So far in my explorations of attunement and metaphor in the estuary, my process has been almost completely of my own design. I have been influenced by reading environmental literature, but this is at best a mimesis of an author’s end-product rather than of their process itself. To branch out from this, I sought someone more trained in ways of sensing and being in the wilderness. I had recently learned of a program called Wilderness Awareness School (WAS), an organization that operates out of Duvall, Washington. At the school, students learn a mix of various naturalist practices, largely centered around survival skills. Through mutual friends I was able to connect with someone who had gone through the program and I set up an interview. My interview with John allowed me a glimpse into the process of a trained naturalist. Insights gained from this conversation will undoubtedly influence my own explorations of my environment.</p><p>John, currently a student in the Fairhaven College of Interdisciplinary Study at Western Washington University, told me about his history with this type of study. He had been involved with multiple teen survival skills programs growing up and had also completed an intensive wildlife tracking course in addition to his time at the WAS. In these programs he learned about animal tracking, bird language, and building shelters, among many other things.</p><p>When I pressed him a little more to explain what he learned at the WAS, he told me a “mix of survival skills and nature awareness”. John explained the concept of ‘nature awareness’ as maintaining awareness of what’s going on in the landscape around you while going about whatever you are doing, whether it be walking through a park or building a shelter in the mountains. This level of cognizance is partly achieved through exercises to expand sensory awareness, much like the experimentations with different modes of attenuation that I have been conducting.</p><p>John is also currently in the process of completing the Kamana Naturalist Training Program. Aimed towards “learning the language of nature”, the program recommends first establishing a ‘sit spot’ when exploring an environment — a place reserved for focused sensing — and then going through a series of mappings. These mappings progress in the order of a trails map, a vegetation map, a topography map, a hydrology map, and then a soil and rocks map; they are geared towards identifying the various resources available from a survival standpoint. Although it isn’t necessarily included in the Kamana model, John’s personal interest lies especially in animal tracking.</p><p>I learned from John that there is a distinction between animal tracking and trailing: tracking is only concerned with the identification of animal markings, whereas as trailing involves actually following the animal’s tracks to find the animal. John had interesting metaphors tied to the idea of animal tracking; he thinks of it like a treasure hunt, seeing marks like a deer’s antler scrapings on the bark of a tree as clues. This was encouraging for my own project to be able to see a clear example of someone else developing new metaphors for their cohabitants based on new modes of attunement.</p><p>Animal tracking is just one mode of developing nature awareness. There are many ways to “read the landscape” as John put it, a concept which I’ve come into contact with in ecocritical literature as well. Development of nature awareness leads to what John called ‘orienting’, a term coined by Peter Levine in his Somatic Experiencing approach to psychotherapy. Orienting is a means of situating the self within the external world, like creating a mental map of one’s surroundings. This is a crucial concept in the development of my personal model of sensing and being in natural environments. Orienting is achieved through attunement and the construction of metaphors to bring the cohabitants of a space into our own realm of understanding.</p><p>John and I both found ourselves in the middle of a developing practice of pursuing nature awareness and got to talking about how that evolution was unfolding. He told me that as he has practiced new modes of attenuating himself to the environment and orienting, his interactions with his environment have evolved. Specifically, he said that reading field guides and other materials have made it easier for him to recognize a personal narrative rising out of a space, which was something that I completely identified with.</p><p>John also said something which I found especially interesting — that he had become more tactical in his movements. When I asked him to unpack this further, he explained that he tries to maintain awareness of the circles of perception maintained by all of the other living things in his space. He said that this way of moving through his environments was both conscious and unconscious; it usually takes a concentrated effort to accomplish this but it has become more habitual and natural for him the more he practices. He even referred to this as being “culturally transformative” for him, because he sees a stark difference between his interactions with the environment and those typical of what he referred to as “mainstream American culture”. We agreed that American culture is geared towards being laser focused, which is beneficial from a capitalist perspective, but that nature awareness stems from an opposite approach — one that embraces a widening of one’s field of attenuation.</p><p>One other important way in which I identified with John’s experiences is with a tending towards the scientific in the narratives that arise from the landscape. I increasingly find myself using scientific knowledge to inform my experiences in nature; when I see a tree I think of its ties into ecological systems, when I feel the breeze against my skin I think of the atmospheric conditions that move around the air. In discussing this we began talking about the environmental narratives employed by native peoples of this region, in that they vary greatly from a ‘scientific’ narrative. Native Americans, like older cultures all around the world, used metaphor and mythology to create maps and orient themselves within the wilderness. They would identify trees and mountains through imaginative stories rather than empirically gathered data. John and I agreed that both ways of forming narratives have their benefits.</p><p>Since my interview with John, I have already started to incorporate some of his metaphors and methods into my own practice. I have tried to keep more of an eye open toward animal tracking and looking for resources in a landscape, even though I still always try to think of the trees and such as more than just a resource to be used. This winter I plan to take the entry-level Kamana course to start becoming better versed in naturalist practices. I will also continue pursuing more scientific knowledge through field guides and other reading, but won’t abandon more traditional modes of employing metaphor as well, hybridizing the modern naturalist method with the more imaginative, metaphorical processes used hundreds of years ago. That John considered his development of new modes of sensing and being in his environments “culturally transformative” was the most profound moment in our conversation. It gives me hope that this work of exploring new metaphors and modes of attenuation can possibly lead to the kind of cultural shift necessary to remedy our current relationships with the environment.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc12afe897e3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/interview-1-interview-with-the-naturalist-cc12afe897e3">Interview 1 — Interview with the Naturalist</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Ode to Om]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/an-ode-to-om-7c7bb7fb9799?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c7bb7fb9799</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Nov 2014 23:59:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-12-19T22:12:19.220Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/199/1*GjSLeulg4zct2kRTv0M67w.gif" /></figure><p>An Ecological Revision of Grace</p><p>When I was growing up, I was lucky enough to be in a family where we ate dinner together around the dinner table most nights of the week. At some point, my dad started leading us in saying grace before each meal.</p><blockquote>God is great, God is good</blockquote><blockquote>And we thank him for our food</blockquote><blockquote>By His hands we must be fed</blockquote><blockquote>Give us all our daily bread</blockquote><blockquote>In Jesus’ name we pray,</blockquote><blockquote>Amen</blockquote><p>We weren’t necessarily a religious family – we stopped even the somewhat token act of attending services on Christmas and Easter early in my childhood – but my dad saw some values that he wanted to pass on in the act of saying grace. It was something he had done as a child, and he carried on the tradition by using the same words he had been taught.</p><p>There came a point in my existential angst as a youth where I questioned why we were saying this so-called grace, droning together in a slew of sounds from rote memorization. I didn’t even think about the words as I said them; I was aware of very little meaning in them. And so I resigned myself to politely bowing out of the chorus, silently drooping my head and folding my hands. I still do this when I get to join my family around the dinner table back in Colorado.</p><p>I didn’t give much thought to saying grace for a few years after moving out of my parents’ house for college. But one day, perhaps purely out of sentimentality, I thought back to those words that I used to recite with my family almost every night. I thought about the values held in the metaphors, proclaiming humbleness before the God so great that He gives us life as food. In spite of my contempt for organized religion, this practice suddenly struck a chord within me.</p><p>I had recently become flush with thoughts along the same lines of those metaphors, but in praise of the Earth rather than a Christian idea of God. The idea began to formulate within me to write a new sort of grace that I could say, acknowledging my deep gratitude and humility before the Earth. I chose to take a systems thinking approach as I felt that it best applied to the awe-inspiring menagerie of systems that comprise the Earth.</p><p>It started with the simple act of saying</p><blockquote>Thank You</blockquote><p>I began to think about everything that was involved in the systems of getting my food ‘from seed-to-table’. I thought of the animals that give their life when I choose to eat meat… of the animals who make my dairy, my eggs, my honey… of the plants who bear the fruits of their labors for my nourishment, and who give their lives for me as well… of the farm workers who meticulously nurture and raise livestock and crops… of the workers who transport and process foods… of the people who prepare and cook my food…</p><p>And these all stood out to me as things that were worth being thankful for, every time I’m fortunate enough to have a meal available to me. So I started saying thank you to all of those things before my meals, bowing my head as if in prayer. This is never a recitation of a prescribed text though; it is always a dynamic and engaging process. I began taking time before a meal to have a silent conversation with my food, taking note of as many different contributors to the dish that I could think of: “Thank you green peppers! Thank you chickens! Thank you farmers!” And I have to admit it is hard to say thank you to a green pepper without a smile on my face.</p><p>As this became more of a regular practice for me, I started to reflect back on the grace I said as a child in comparison to this new ritual. I think I began to see why we said grace as a child, even though we weren’t a religious family, per se. Grace was like a package of metaphors, carrying values that my dad wanted to carry forth. I saw how my own practice could become the same thing. Perhaps my children will one day engage in the same thanksgiving at our family dinners.</p><p>In thinking about my parents’ version of grace, I found that I liked the sense of closure given by “In Jesus’ name we pray, Amen”. I wanted to emulate this; I sought out some form of mimesis. Eventually I started ending my conversation with my meal by saying “And thank you to the Earth, for all Its good graces,” (both in reference to the abundances afforded to us by the Earth and also as a nod to those other ‘graces’, versions of this same concept, that people around the world practice) but some metaphorical implications of this particular phrase didn’t quite sit well with me. I knew I could chose my metaphors more deliberately.</p><p>The problem for me lay in the pronoun: ‘It’. In current usage, this connotes an objectification, and I felt that this didn’t accurately portray the Earth’s fullness of life. My thoughts turned to feminine metaphors of Earth – of Mother Earth and Gaia. I was hesitant to confine my model of the Earth to all the associations that come along with bestowing gender, though. Each pronoun embodied metaphors which are appropriate for certain purposes, but didn’t quite capture the sentiment I was looking for in this usage. It dawned on me that we don’t really have a pronoun equivalent of ‘he/she/it’ that would do justice to what I was trying to say. So I decided to invent a new one.</p><p>I dug into the etymologies of our current personal pronouns by combing through the Oxford English Dictionary as a means of informing the formation of this new pronoun. All of them arose mainly out of what could be called laziness – the roots of these words, which trace back to Old English and have relatives in many Old Dutch and Old Germanic languages, are some of the easiest vowel sounds to produce. They were some of the first babblings to be produced by humans, and were probably some of our first utterances as a linguistic species. Pronunciations shifted somewhat over time and space, and cultural influences took hold as well. For example, the differentiation between masculine and feminine came about by adding an additional sound to their then neutral personal pronoun to make a second word. ‘It’ eventually came into use as a gender-neutral pronoun, but over time shifted to be used as an object-identifier.</p><p>Drawing inspiration from these examples, I tried to find a similar, easily produced and simple sound for the word. My mind quickly turned to the widely-recognized incantation ‘Om’. Following the same patterns of linguistic production of other members of its set of words, ‘Om’ also has strong spiritual connotations from its use in Hinduism. In the Hindu tradition, ‘Om’ symbolizes a source of life and creation, the manifestation of God in form. So, I drew from the libraries of linguistic and religious tradition and adopted “Om” as my new pronoun to use when referring to the Earth. Now I am able to signify a transition into the meal with, “And thank you to the Earth, for all Om’s good graces,” and I call my practice my <em>Ode to Om.</em></p><p>Rituals such as these, foundational elements of our own personal cultures and narratives, can have resounding impacts on our outlook on life. I now engage in my relationship with the Earth in new ways, attuning myself to new aspects of our dialogue. I am more constantly aware of my position within the many systems at work in the biosphere, creating a binding sense of interconnectivity. Not only do I feel a greater sense of connection and appreciation to Om, but I also enjoy my food more. I can chew slowly and delight in the flavors and textures as I contemplate the great gift I am given in my food. This is one key difference between my <em>Ode to Om </em>and most other forms of grace – I always take a bite of food first. I find that I’m able to more fully appreciate and explore the food when I think about it this way.</p><p>My process and my metaphors aren’t necessarily ideal for everyone. But just the act of giving a nod of appreciation to Om, or of restructuring your metaphors in other ways as well, are opportunities to take an active role in shaping your own reality. If we think critically about our cultural practices and metaphors, we can position ourselves to promote a brighter future.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c7bb7fb9799" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/an-ode-to-om-7c7bb7fb9799">An Ode to Om</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ecocriticism in the Digital Age]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/ecocriticism-in-the-digital-age-bb3409c97a97?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb3409c97a97</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Nov 2014 23:38:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-11-15T01:04:49.304Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rizMLG-ZzrbOqGaD6IS_Ow.jpeg" /></figure><p>Remapping Our Place in a Modern World</p><p>In this world of endless status updates, tweets, emails, Netflix binges, and the general deluge of data that commands our attention, ‘Nature’ can often be seen as a respite from the chivvies of modernity. While this idea has merit, the influence of the digital still makes our experiences in Nature fundamentally different from those in a past era. Gone are the stacks of reference guides and thick bundles of field notes. To write, I speak into a digital recorder. I take time-stamped and geotagged pictures and videos with my smartphone. I can ask my phone if a berry is safe to eat, or when low tide will be. Digital technologies, which have become so engrained in our being to the point of becoming extensions of ourselves, reshape the ways in which we can interface with the world around us.</p><p>The digital age casts us awash with new networks, from cell phone networks, to social networks, to the internet. In his essay <a href="https://medium.com/message/seeing-like-a-network-114c5a13fe0d"><em>Seeing Like a Network</em></a>, Quinn Norton illuminates the ways in which we are integrated with networks. “In this phase of human civilization the interaction of the vast networks we’ve built is just about where everything happens. Understanding how networks function isn’t esoteric specialist knowledge anymore than being able to read is.” Being so entrenched in these digital networks, we are conditioned into thinking in systems.</p><p>Thanks to our networks, the flow of information in our society has also shifted towards a rhizomatic distribution of knowledge. In our participatory culture, everyone has a voice through comments, live tweeting, and self-publication. This model of communication has shaped the way that I communicate with the cohabitants of my environments as well.</p><p>I see the trees, rocks, and everything else as equal participants in my dialogue. I take them in with all of my senses, and this leads to new relationships with them. The objects in my environment come alive in new ways as they become imbued with metaphors. Trees dance and the water stands guard, and they begin to have their own voice within my writing. Just as in our participatory culture, the cohabitants of my environment all have something to teach and contribute to the conversation.</p><p>At a time when the consequences of our environmental abuse are coming to a head, this revisioning of our metaphors has never been more crucial. This different way of being in our environments, of cohabitating these spaces, holds implications for our relationships with each other; for our view of humanity’s place within greater systems; and for the environmental impacts of our actions. Engaging in a new Ecocriticism entrenched in the digital age may be a key factor in forming more sustainable relationships with our planet.</p><p>Mine is not a new path. Winding through the woods and mountain trails, I walk in the footsteps of writers who have explored humanity’s relationship with the earth, embarking in what has come to be called Ecocriticism. Thoreau went to Walden to ‘live deliberately’; I am spending my days among the trees to construct my metaphors more deliberately. However, I am entrenched in a new existential paradigm, one deeply intertwined with modern technologies. The digital has become a quintessential part of ourselves and our realities, and therefore seeps into the construction of our metaphors in powerful ways. My entry into the literary discussion of our relationships with the environment rides along the wave of the current moment, carrying Ecocriticism into the digital age.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb3409c97a97" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/ecocriticism-in-the-digital-age-bb3409c97a97">Ecocriticism in the Digital Age</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Revisiting Metaphor: A Walk in the Woods]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/revisiting-metaphor-a-walk-in-the-woods-87cc0bb3c179?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/87cc0bb3c179</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Nov 2014 23:38:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-11-28T23:29:51.595Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0V-o1QMuB82jdoeeYM7eGA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Can closing your eyes help you see the forest for the trees?</p><p>The shifting tides had swallowed the beach by the time I reached the estuary. The water, acting as a gatekeeper, barred my path along the muddy flats that had held my footprints so many times before. Undeterred, I worked my way up to higher ground. I bushwhacked through the tall grasses and shrubs growing along the embankment that braced the land against the oncoming seawater. The going was slow and winding, with blades of grass tickling and scraping at my legs.</p><p>As I pondered along this new approach into the estuary, I thought about how the high tide had changed my experience in the environment. On previous visits, the entrance to the estuary had always opened up to an expanse of mud and multi-colored shells. The water had now completely engulfed the beach, warding off any land-dwelling visitors. I came to see the high water level as a sentinel of the shore. This unconscious body of water had influenced my conscious actions, and consequently I began to experience and understand the environment differently.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ub1WTXY7_8ZoeZqaBfIRtg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A dialogic relationship between our means of interacting with the objects we encounter and our metaphors causes each to inform the other. As the nature of our interactions with our environment shifts, the metaphorical connections we make can change in nature as well, which can envoke further changes in the ways we treat our surroundings — a positive feedback loop can ensue. Metaphor is more than a poetic device; it is intrinsic to our process of finding and making meaning in the world around us. Restructuring our metaphors can enable a renewed understanding of our environments, and therefore new relationships with our surroundings as well.</p><p>The spaces we move through are richly populated with ‘objects’, whether they be trees, the weather, or anything else that we give a name. These cohabitants of our environments endlessly reform and rearrange themselves, creating new points of contact between objects. The tide rolls in and out. Leaves blush with the warm colors of autumn and fall to the ground. The objects which cohabitate our spaces are constantly in states of movement and change, leading to ever-changing connections.</p><blockquote>The tree is not a dancer and the dancer is not a tree, and yet each is the metaphor running through me</blockquote><p>Through metaphor, we identify these points of contact. The wind may blow through the leaves grouped at the top of a tall, slender alder, bending the tree’s body to and fro – a dancer gracefully swaying to a steady rhythm. Metaphor allows us to bring something outside of ourselves into the realm of human experience. By equating one object with another, we are also implicitly stating our position in relation to both, and proclaiming that connection formed through us as the identity of the object. The tree is not a dancer and the dancer is not a tree, and yet each is the metaphor running through me. Drawing such connections is something we do <em>constantly. </em>Ours is a world steeped in metaphor.</p><p>When I began writing about restructuring metaphor out in the woods at my estuary, I started to wonder why I had come out there to write at all. I could have gone through the sterilized, prescribed writing process from the comfort of my desk at home, rather than trekking through blackberry thickets and heavy, black mud. However, I recognized the cohabitants of the space as participants in my ecology of writing. The trees and other objects whispered countless narratives, informing my own experience within the space. The text organically arises out of coming into contact with them, or for those hip with the compositional rhetoric, their ‘rhetorical triangles’. Such immersion leads to a very different product than what I could have produced elsewhere.</p><p>To explore different avenues of communion with my environment and of creating metaphor, I tried experimenting with ways of sensing. I came up to a fallen birch, closed my eyes, and leaned into an embrace with the tree. In my mind, associations with the visual rendering of the tree fell away and I became more attuned to the feeling of its cool, papery skin against mine. As I continued this I realized that, without the use of my eyes, so much more of the surrounding environment seeped into my experience of the tree. The sounds of the wind in the trees and leaves falling on the ground, the sensation of the wind on my face — all were part of the birch. The birch was no longer one tree; it encompassed everything happening in that moment, spawning new metaphors of interconnectedness. The tree was a shield against the chilling wind, a steady companion to lean on. Upon opening my eyes this effect was completely lost and couldn’t be recaptured, no matter how I tried.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fSr1QBOMFHhLCTmGkyywbA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I also played around with proximity and its effect on metaphor. I tried generating as many metaphorical associations as possible about a mossy tree stump from a distance of about 10 feet away and, to compare, from less than an arms-length away. At the further distance, the moss elicited notions of an infection or plague, crawling up the tree and taking hold of it. The moss was a thick carpet with patches of bright and dark greens, and I could see it spreading up and outward. The tree stump itself had craggily, bumpy bark that reminded me of dragon skin, and for a moment I imagined the stump as the foot of a forest-dwelling dragon.</p><p>When I came up close, my perceptions and metaphors drastically shifted. Immediately more complex textures jumped out visually. I could see thousands of little green feathers, hairs, and spirals comprising the moss. It was no longer one big mass on the stump, but rather an assemblage of these individuals. My brain also started counting automatically when I saw the moss in this way, seeing small numbers and clusters of data: How many feathers in this bright patch? One, two, three, four… How many hairs on this feather? Five, six, seven, eight… What had appeared to me from a distance as only randomly dispersed patches of varying greens, now took on a different air as well. I recognized that the darker patches were dying and the more vibrant patches were still towards the middle of their life cycle. The moss became a patchwork quilt of co-mingling growth and decay.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sy4mhsyfodECF0TkweHeXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>And this is where the magic of it all lies. The moss <em>became </em>something else. Our inherent use of metaphor shapes the cohabitants of our individual realities.</p><p>Coming to know my environment in different ways generated a variety of metaphors, shaping the ecology that arose out of our interactions. I realized, too, that no particular metaphor is universally correct or best. Different metaphorical models and ways of exploring are best suited to different needs. To what extent do you find yourself looking at the world around you in the same way, using the same metaphors day after day? Applying the same models and ways of thinking that are considered ‘normal’? If we can adjust our interactions with the spaces around us and restructure our metaphors, we can come to a greater sense of communion and harmony with our environments.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=87cc0bb3c179" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/revisiting-metaphor-a-walk-in-the-woods-87cc0bb3c179">Revisiting Metaphor: A Walk in the Woods</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Arguing With the Madronas]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/arguing-with-the-madronas-a676a00acd2d?source=rss----9c74b4af923---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a676a00acd2d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ferris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Nov 2014 23:37:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-11-28T23:14:24.900Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O8B6mugX3soDs5AquO-xcQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Can one really argue with a plant?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bEhlPDsK8WOtY2HBZq11zQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The birds were out in droves on this bright fall morning. A murder of crows scavenged along the muddy beach and ducks dipped their faces into the cool, shimmering water. A solitary heron stood watch in the shallows, lithe and stolid amid the gently ebbing tide. As I approached the estuary, shells crunched underfoot and salt lingered in the air, flavoring the atmosphere that swirled around me.</p><p>I quickly came to realize the water, about halfway between high and low tides, had already moved far enough up the shore to prevent a leisurely stroll along the beach to my destination. My objective, a copse of madrona trees emerging from a time-carved sanctuary of sandstone, lay on the other side of a stretch of bitingly cold water and narrow, crumbling rock ledges. It was precarious to traverse, but there was mapping to be done, and so traverse I did. This brought me into an exploration of argument with the noble madrona tree, as I attempted to navigate the waters of such a dialogue at varying depths.</p><blockquote>Can one really argue with a plant?</blockquote><p>Questions came to mind as I was considering argument with a tree, something that might seem a little out of the ordinary to most. Why would I want to argue with a tree, and is it even possible? A narrative can arguably be constructed for anything the moment we give it a name, and that narrative takes on complexities and nuances as we interact with that object. Take a rock, for example. As soon as I call it a rock, I define some of its qualities (solid, rigid, etc), and just as importantly, I say all the things it’s not (water, a duck, etc). If I investigate the rock further, I may be able to add complexity to the name — say an igneous rock — which lends greater detail into the rock’s history, stating that the rock was once magma. I might throw the rock from the top of a hill. Now the rock’s name for me is “rock that I just threw”, and it’s name to someone at the bottom of the hill is “rock that came from the top of the hill”; a web of names and narratives begins to take shape, all from a seemingly innocuous rock.</p><p>Argument is a topic within the field of rhetoric which has garnered a high amount of attention, with varying views across the field. Jim Corder, one notable entrant into the discussion on argument, <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/465760">promotes a view of argument as emergence, rather than conflict</a>. Argument from a Corderian perspective, and that is to say the interfacing with a “narrative in another world” (Corder, 18), with the madrona, then, is a completely feasible and promising endeavor. I decided to strike up an argument with the madronas as a part of enmeshing myself in my local environment’s narrative.</p><p>‘A plant can’t talk back, how could they argue,’ one might ask, but there are many ways in which a plant and I could impact each other’s narratives. I could carve a special someone’s initials along with mine into the smooth, soft trunk, embroiling the trees into a passionate love affair; the madronas certainly shaped my narrative by teaching me about themselves and the nature of argument.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/549/1*0uJa9sAmVE4yGtfiBhc5cw.jpeg" /><figcaption>This tree would now speak volumes about my own story — an intertwining of narratives</figcaption></figure><p>For this mapping, I embraced two methodologies to approach this dialogue. To explore an artistic method, I visited the madronas’ home and tried to recreate them on my page with pencil. Open to other avenues of thinking as well, I employed a more quantitative, albeit distanced, approach, investigating information published in research on the organism. Each enabled very different interactions with the madronas’ narratives, lending multifaceted insights to both the madrona and the concept of argument itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2XiRn0fnegT0EigVg5OG7w.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>We felt a shift in the taste of the air. Smells of smoke and smog clung to a body; they came from a place very different from this, our home. The effluvium felt heavy and dirty on our leaves, weightless but carrying the weight of countless engines, cities, factories. This was not a new sensation for us. We have come to expect such visitors. This one seemed somehow different from most though. More like the birds which we hold in our branches than its fellow man which heavily plod along the beach, this one sat with us for hours. It pressed its warm hands against our cool bodies. It sat on the rocks, watching us. We grew accustomed to its presence, the way it would breathe in and out, slowly and deeply, developing a dialogue of breaths with us, the same one breath moving out of it and into us, out of us and into it.</em></strong></p><p>To map the madronas’ small nook within the estuary and argue intimately with them, I perched myself on a cliff overlooking the sandstone cove that they called home. The sun shone as a brilliant backlight from the east, draping the green and red branches of the trees in bright warmth – a perfectly posed model lay before me. As I was recreating the trees on the pages of my sketchbook, it began to dawn on me that drawing them was a part of my way of entering into a dialogue with their narratives. To truly do their form justice, I had to step out of my reality and give myself to their essence for a brief period; my eyes were transfixed to the madronas’ elegant lines, tracing the years passed from root to tip. Any lingering remnants of my typical mental milieu fell away as I became engrossed in this discourse with the madronas, devoting all of my attention to the trees’ contours and character.</p><p>The metaphors that we employ implicitly shape our narratives, and as such should be chosen thoughtfully and deliberately. Regarding argument, language that evokes images of war is most often used in our culture – ideas get ‘shot down’, some people tend to get ‘defensive’ – a dialogue grounded in debate results. In the spirit of rhetoricians like Corder, one can look to a model of argument that embraces collaboration over conflict. One possible option is based in dance instead of war. When approaching another’s narrative as a dance partner, the rhetorical steps and modes of thinking drastically shift from when another’s narrative is viewed as the opposition. Arguers carry, guide, and follow each other, skirting opposite edges of the same point as they twirl through the space of their dialogue.</p><blockquote>The trees were leading, and I was following…</blockquote><p>Contemplating the shades and tones of the madrona, I came to realize that this particular embodiment of argument was much more akin to dance than war. More so, I realized that in this dance the trees were leading and I was following. While the madronas confidently curved and drew me in with their grace, I navigated the finest subtleties of their movements to be able to dance in stride. Such attention to detail opened me up to a higher awareness and understanding of the madrona at a fundamental level. I became attuned to new attributes of the madrona that had been sitting before me all along: for example, it seems that branches sprout off of the main trunk at noticeable kinks, protruding from the reflexively angled side of such bends.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/428/1*HNgtkJS9AwTAJzoYnuV3wg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The composition of the trees was a beautiful balance between straight lines and curves. At times, as my eyes would follow along their contours, I would reach a point in the trees’ history in which they seemed to have experienced a sudden burst of growth, surging up and outward towards the sun. When I would widen my focus to the trees figures overall, however, the seemingly straight lines gave way into great sweeping curves. My mind was drawn away briefly as I was reminded of old calculus classes and the approximation of a curve as a series of straight line segments. Attuning myself to such nuances implored a slowing down of my perception and my hand, and this deceleration sparked a further awareness of the role of time in argument.</p><p>The presence of time within the dialogue became acutely apparent as the tide continued to roll in. There came a point where the water level was just high enough to hit the rocks in such a way that the water lapping up onto them sounded uncannily like footsteps, creating the illusion that there was a person coming up towards me, broaching the intimate space in which I was arguing and dancing with the madronas. Even though I realized soon enough that there was no person approaching, this gave me the pressure of feeling rushed, at least as a reminder that I still had to wade back through now higher waters to return homeward.</p><p>The sense of dwindling time starkly changed the tone of my dialogue with the trees and my ability to draw. I immediately noticed a lack of precision and attention to detail as compared to when I felt locked in a timeless tango of narratives. I tried to let go of the sense of time pressing in on me, but it was difficult at this point as I had already been pulled out of my state of immersion. Noticing both how the lack of time and, more specifically, my awareness of that lacking affected my dialogue with the trees, I gained further understanding of the essentiality of holding time in our arguments.</p><p>In coming into contact with the trees’ narratives, I also took an approach one might find more typical for trying to learn about the life of madrona trees – sifting through biological research on the internet. This turned up a mountain of data on <a href="http://www.fs.fed.us/database/feis/plants/tree/arbmen/all.html"><em>Arbutus Menziesii</em></a>, and I was able to learn things about the madrona that were beyond the scope of my own observations. For instance, the madrona, referred to as ‘madrone’ in southern Oregon and northern California, is native to the west coast of North America from British Colombia to the western slopes of the Sierra Nevada range (Sonja, 2007). While these facts were interesting and shaped my understanding of the madrona, they felt detached from the experience of the organism.</p><p>This mode of inquiry and interfacing yielded inert insights into the madrona that I could not have obtained on my own. However, the facts lacked vivacity and subtlety when compared to the depth and intimacy of information I gleaned from my dance-like argument with the trees. Even still, I now had access to parts of the trees’ narratives which had previously been unknowable; this modified my own perceived narrative I had begun constructing by drawing the madronas. Connections between quantitative and qualitative nodes of information began to take shape.</p><p>The artistic and the scientific provided two avenues along which I could converse with the madronas. These two ways of embracing the madronas’ narratives may seem to be opposing, but they are in actuality complementary. Each contributes to the appreciation of the other, demonstrating the value in approaching an argument from multiple viewpoints. Entering into a dance with the trees more profoundly brought their narrative into my own, but a detached and disinterested perspective revealed new sides to my dance partner as well.</p><p>Reflecting upon my dialogue with the madronas, there are new insights to be found into the concept of argument itself. The manner of approach, including the language and metaphors at play, strongly affects the discourse and resulting impact on participatory narratives. Adopting various modes of interfacing with narratives enables a cross-pollination of ideas from different worlds, producing a gestalt argument from the synergies of the combined inquiries. Time plays a crucial role in argument as well, whether in the meticulous care it took to observe and draw the trees or in the hours of research done to compile the data I was able to find on the internet. Allowing oneself to become immersed in the argument at hand and lose a sense of time and the rest of the world also produces a much more fruitful discourse.</p><p>Although it provided me with some answers, this argument left me with many more questions about the madronas and about how I can further interface with the narratives of my environment as well. This argument with the madronas won’t have been my last.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bEhlPDsK8WOtY2HBZq11zQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a676a00acd2d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project/arguing-with-the-madronas-a676a00acd2d">Arguing With the Madronas</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/continued-mapping-project">Attunement and Metaphor in the Estuary</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>