<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[criticalnarratives.publicaccommodation - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[The authors, building on a seminar on Critical Narratives of Civil Rights at @ NYU Law, explore discrimination in public accommodations and the need for a fundamental right to public accommodations. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation?source=rss----8522888061bd---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:41:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bathrooms, an Old Frontier of Public Accommodation Rights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/bathrooms-an-old-frontier-of-public-accommodation-rights-c2e6d194bbf2?source=rss----8522888061bd---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2e6d194bbf2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Critical Narratives]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Dec 2018 02:48:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-11T03:10:48.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/what-its-like-to-use-a-public-bathroom-while-trans-65793/"><em>“They stomped on me and they beat me so bad they tore my dress off, they tore my panties off [and] they ripped my brand new wig.… they kicked me so many times in the ribs. I tried to cover my face to protect my face. As I’m laying there, pretty much lifeless, a guy whips out his penis about to urinate on me….the police officer says, as I’m sitting in the gurney, ‘This never would have happened to you if you weren’t wearing a dress and trying to fool men.’”</em></a></p><p>By Stephanie Sebastian</p><p>This article will describe the background of the “Bathroom Bills”, explore the history of denial of access to bathrooms on the basis of womanhood and gender, and attempt to identify constitutional grounds upon which the Bathroom Bills can be struck down and a new fundamental right can be forged.</p><p>Part I provides background on the Transgender experience in America. Part II reviews the prominent “Bathroom Bill” legislation and provides a historical overview over bathroom access. Part III articulates two potential Constitutional challenges to this legislation. Part IV concludes.</p><h3><strong>Part I: Who are “Transgender” People?</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VA4ifmhgzKCLPrAM_FK_Zw.jpeg" /><figcaption>“As long as we are living in a culture where one has to prove their womanhood or manhood, we are not living in a free culture.” Laverne Cox, actress, transgender activist, and a phenomenal woman.</figcaption></figure><p>“Transgender” is a term used to describe people whose gender identity is different from the sex they were assigned at birth<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn1">[1]</a>. Gender identity is a person’s self-perception of having a particular gender, whether it be male, female, a blend of both, or neither<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn2">[2]</a>. While most transgender people have a gender identity that is either male or female<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn3">[3]</a>, some describe themselves as being “non-binary” if their gender identities do not fit neatly into “male” or “female”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn4">[4]</a>. Some non-binary people have an identity that is a blend of male and female identities, while others have an entirely unique gender identity<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn5">[5]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/513/1*b-nK7QvXY9Xt1jsGp_WK0g.jpeg" /><figcaption>“I wasn’t born in the wrong body. I was born in the wrong world.” Alok Vaid-Menon, a LGBTQ rights activist and poet. Vaid-Menon identifies as gender non-conforming and transfeminine, and uses they pronouns.</figcaption></figure><p>Many transgender people remember their awareness of gender in their earliest memories, while it may take more time for others<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn6">[6]</a>. Transitioning is the time period during which a person begins to live in accordance with their gender identity. Transition looks different for every person. Some trans people choose to change their name, pronoun, and/or state identification documents. Some decide to change their clothes or appearance. Some also choose to undergo hormone therapy or gender-affirming surgeries to change their physical characteristics. While some trans people simply do not want to physically change their bodies, many consider it vital<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn7">[7]</a>. Still, transgender people face a number of obstacles, such as the prohibitively high costs of medical treatments and the rampant discrimination often faced in a medical environment, in receiving the medical care they need<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn8">[8]</a>.</p><p>In addition, transgender people often struggle to gain recognition from their friends, family, community and government. The requirements for changing the gender marker on a birth certificate or a state ID are often cumbersome, discriminatory, and constantly changing. A number of states require proof of a gender-affirming surgery to change the gender marker on an ID or birth certificate<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn9">[9]</a>. Such a requirement is incredibly restrictive, as the surgery is expensive and hard to obtain. Furthermore, the requirement is illogical, because a surgery does not determine gender identity. Some states refuse all-together to amend a gender marker<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn10">[10]</a>. Failing to gain full recognition from the government on what is often a primary proof of citizenship has a number of negative consequences. Any interaction with a cop, potential employer, landlord, or even a bouncer can “out” a transgender person, leaving them susceptible to “awkwardness, humiliation or, in some cases, discrimination”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn11">[11]</a>. A 2011 survey indicates that only 21% of transgender people have updated their documents, and nearly 60% experienced discrimination through the process<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn12">[12]</a>.</p><p>Transgender people cannot change their gender identity any more than cis-gender people can. Attempts to do so, such as through conversion therapy, are extremely harmful and can lead to depression, substance abuse, and even suicide<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn13">[13]</a>. Some transgender people may experience gender dysphoria, a medical diagnosis for serious emotional distress at the difference between the gender assigned at birth and the gender a person consider themselves to be<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn14">[14]</a>. Medical authorities recognize that living according to one’s gender identity is an “effective, safe and medically necessary treatment for many people who have gender dysphoria.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn15">[15]</a>In addition, due to widespread discrimination, many transgender people experience physical and mental health problems, such as depression and anxiety. Such problems are not caused by being transgender, but by the intolerance and hatred that transgender people face in the world everyday<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn16">[16]</a>.</p><p>Transgender people are one of the most vulnerable communities in the country. According to the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey (“USTS Survey”), 29% of respondents were living in poverty (more than double the general population of 12%) and nearly 30% have experienced homelessness. The unemployment rate of trans people is three times the amount of the national employment rate (15% and 5% respectively)<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn17">[17]</a>. Even more startling, 39% of respondents experienced psychological distress in the month prior (compared to 5% of the national population) and a staggering 40% have attempted suicide in their life (compared to 4.6% of the national population)<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn18">[18]</a>. In addition, the USTS survey looked at the compounding impact of other forms of discrimination, and found that transgender people of color were more likely to live in poverty, experience greater health disparities, and face more violence than their white counterparts<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn19">[19]</a>. In 2018 alone, at least 23 trans people have been murdered, the majority of whom were women of color<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn20">[20]</a>,<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn21">[21]</a>. Of those killed, 16 were Black, including an 18-year old girl named Vontashia Bell<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn22">[22]</a>. One died in an ICE detention center, as a result of untreated, severe dehydration. Her name was Roxsana Hernandez Rodriguez. The autopsy revealed Ms. Rodriquez suffered physical abuse, with deep bruising from blunt-force trauma “indicative of blows or kicks, and possible strikes with blunt object” and hemorrhaging on her wrists “typical of handcuff injuries.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn23">[23]</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*hXw26Pe8p4IowcDleFkmxQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Roxsana Hernandez Rodriguez. Please see footnote 20 for a full list of the transgender people whose lives were taken this past year.</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Part II: A Historical and Modern Overview of Bathroom Access</strong></h3><h4>A. Anti-Transgender Modern Legislation</h4><p><strong><em>“I don’t want to be scared to go to the restroom or anywhere in public. And I never want to use the boy’s restroom. It would be so weird,” </em></strong><em>said 7-year-old Libby Gonzales to Texas state senators committee considering “bathroom bill” legislation. </em><strong><em>“Please keep me safe.”</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*LTTngrY4oVhUQJxl7gR_NA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Libby Gonzales, held by her father as he testifies against Texas HB 2899.</figcaption></figure><p>In 2018, 10 states have introduced 21 anti-transgender bills<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn24">[24]</a>. These bills take different forms — health care bills that restrict transgender people’s access to health care, ID bills that prevent trans people from changing their gender market and name, preemption and discrimination carve-out bills that make transgender discrimination permissible, youth bills that curtail the rights of transgender students and children, and of course, bathroom bills, the re-occurring ghost of anti-transgender legislation<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn25">[25]</a>. Bathroom bills first gained popularity in 2016, and since then, they have re-appeared in every legislative cycle.</p><p>The “Bathroom Bills” gained popularity in 2016 as a state-level response to a number of federal and municipal protections gained for and by transgender people<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn26">[26]</a>. “Bathroom Bills” refer collectively to the legislation across various states aimed at restricting transgender people’s access to traditionally gendered spaces. Generally, such legislation requires all persons within the state to use the restrooms or locker rooms associated with the sex they were assigned at birth, rather than the gender they identify as. The most notorious of them is North Carolina’s HB 2, also known as the Public Facilities Privacy &amp; Security Act.</p><p>Under HB 2, which was passed by legislature and signed by Governor Pat McCrory, all persons in the state are required to use the bathroom or locker rooms in public buildings that corresponds to “their biological sex” as “stated on a person’s birth certificate.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn27">[27]</a>” Governor McCrory stated the bill was a response to “activist overreach” and that he had “no interest in the subject” until the city council in Charlotte passed an anti-discrimination bill that included protected bathroom access for transgender people<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn28">[28]</a>. There was an enormous public backlash to HB 2 and the controversy played a major role in the subsequent gubernatorial election, which the Democratic candidate won. A compromise between the newly-elected Democratic Governor Cooper and the Republican-majority General Assembly, HB 142 repealed much of HB 2. However, it restricts local governments, like Charlotte, from passing ordinances governing private employment or public accommodations<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn29">[29]</a>. And while the language of HB 2 dictating who can use what bathroom was removed, HB 142 prohibits all state entities other than the state legislature from regulating bathrooms or other multi-occupancy facilities<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn30">[30]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*g1_NTJw626u4KGeFX_bchw.png" /><figcaption>Governor Cooper asking for a repeal of HB 2.</figcaption></figure><p>Similar bills across the country proscribed harsh criminal and civil penalties for those who refused to follow the state guidelines. In Texas<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn31">[31]</a>, HB 1747 would have made it a crime of “disorderly conduct” for transgender people to enter the public bathrooms associated with their gender identity, unless they have changed the gender marker on their driver’s license<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn32">[32]</a>. Even harsher, HB 1748 would have made it a Class A misdemeanor for any person above the age of 13 to use the restroom not matching the “gender established at the individual’s birth or by the individual’s chromosomes” and would have made it a state felony for business owners to allow any person above the age of 7 to use a restroom that does not accord with their gender assigned at birth or indicated by their chromosomes.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn33">[33]</a>Similarly in Florida, HB 583 proscribed criminal penalties and private causes of actions against any violators who did not use the facility designed for their assigned sex.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn34">[34]</a></p><p>Bathroom bills have a number of negative consequences for transgender and otherwise gender nonconforming people. The bills define sex and gender in ways that “rely on either phenotypic appearance or chromosomal genotype.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn35">[35]</a>Some of the legislation, like the proposed HB 1748 in Texas, places responsibility of enforcement on the people maintaining the facility and penalizes non-compliance as a felony<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn36">[36]</a>. Requiring genetic proof or basing entry off of physical appearance forcibly and publicly “outs” and humiliates transgender people. In addition, transgender people who have visibly transitioned are at risk of serious violence and harm if they are forced to use the bathroom of their assigned gender. This state-sanctioning of discrimination in public accommodations has a tremendous number of physical and mental health outcomes for transgender people, including various physical symptoms of stress, asthma, and depression.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn37">[37]</a></p><h4>B. Denying womanhood and recycling reasons, from the 1800s to the 2010s</h4><p><em>“My cook, Zephyr Wright, who has been working for me for many years — she’s a college graduate — and her husband drove my official car from Washington down to Texas… they got hungry, they stopped at grocery stores on the edge of town in colored areas and bought Vienna sausages and beans and ate them with a plastic spoon…</em><strong><em>And when they had to go to the bathroom, they would stop, pull off on a side road, and Zephyr Wright, the cook of the Vice President of the United States, would squat in the road to pee.”[1]</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*foiKxFMj0O1ojGU704jhcA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Zephyr Wright, who cooked for Vice-President Lyndon B. Johnson.</figcaption></figure><p>Proponents of the bathroom bills often emphasize that the purpose of these acts of legislation is to protect women from sexual harassment by predators, ostensibly either non-transgender men who could “dress up” to enter the women’s bathroom <a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn38">[38]</a>or transgender women themselves. A subtle theme underlying this legislation is the notion that transgender people are somehow “deviant and deceptive and are themselves fraudulent simply by existing.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn39">[39]</a>By perpetuating the notion that <em>some </em>women need to be protected and some are not even women, the government is effectively denying transgender women their womanhood. This is a familiar practice in this country.</p><p>In 1887, Massachusetts passed a bill establishing gender-segregated restrooms for men and women, the first regulation of its kind in America<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn40">[40]</a>. Over the last century and a half, the practice of segregation in bathrooms persisted and tightened. Then and now, the rationales offered were promulgated under the guise of protecting <em>some </em>women and perpetuated the notion that some women were not even women at all. These rationales relied on untruths, suggested negative stereotypes of women as needing protection, and stroked irrational fears of vulnerable groups.</p><p>The creation of gender-segregated bathrooms in the late 1800s were not prompted by the physical differences between men and women. Rather, these policies were the result of widespread social anxiety of the women’s role in the modern world.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn41">[41]</a>At the turn of the century, a time where women were entering the workplace, policymakers argued that women were “inherently weaker and still in need of protection from the harsh realities of the public sphere<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn42">[42]</a>.” Laws that limited women’s work hours were upheld by the Court, even as they struck the same policy for men, under the guise of protecting women.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn43">[43]</a>Other policies included requiring a rest period for women during the work day and prohibiting certain dangerous jobs for women.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn44">[44]</a>Bathrooms were a special target, since they had the potential to compromise the strong Victorian values of the time — namely privacy and modesty<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn45">[45]</a>. Gender-segregated restrooms and other facilities, like separate waiting rooms, train cars, and even reading rooms in public libraries, were introduced to society. The lush furnishings of the women’s only spaces, including “thick curtains and chaise lounges,” mimicked the traditional domain of women, the home<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn46">[46]</a>. These gender-segregated spaces were designed to be an extension of the home, a “protected haven in this dangerous public space,” for women <a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn47">[47]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/899/1*DtAY6opj-IQX741pmiAppw.png" /></figure><p>Notions of gender inferiority continued but in the aftermath of the Civil War and the Reconstruction period, mass hysteria of the intermixing of the races began to center bathroom segregation around protecting <em>white </em>women. As such, bathrooms were at the center of Jim Crow laws. Segregation was not immediately imposed at the end of the Civil War. There was a brief moment of fluidity, between the end of slavery and the start of the 20thcentury, when white and Black people lived near each other in a “salt-and-pepper” pattern<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn48">[48]</a>. During this time, Black people and poor white people were aligned politically. But at risk of losing their political power, elite white Southerners launched “campaigns of white supremacy” to “unite the white people against the negroes.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn49">[49]</a>They did this, in part, by portraying Black men as rapists who would come after white women<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn50">[50]</a>. Segregation “had to be invented”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn51">[51]</a>to protect the “enclave of white women.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn52">[52]</a>Violence against Black people, such as in the form of lynching, were justified under sexuality and safety concerns of white women<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn53">[53]</a>. In addition to a lynching culture, “white men asserted and white women agreed” that excluding and segregating Black people in public life was necessary to protect white womanhood<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn54">[54]</a>.</p><p>Black women were not seen as worthy of the state-sponsored paternalistic protection that white women were afforded. Allowing Black women into gender-segregated spaces traditionally reserved for white women would threaten the superior, almost sacred status of white womanhood. Lola Huock, a Black pregnant woman traveling alone, was refused entry to the ladies’ car and was thus denied the “right to be recognized as a woman.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn55">[55]</a>” Black women’s only option for train service was the smokers’ room, where they would be at risk for violence and sexual harassment. Mary Jane Chilton, who was told by the conductor that the ladies’ car was not for Black people, refused to enter the smokers’ room<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn56">[56]</a>. After the conductor forcibly removed her from the platform, to the cheers of bystanders, Ms. Chilton and her children walked all the way to Carondelet, Missouri. Sometimes the humiliation of the denial of public accommodation escalated to violence, such as in the case of Catherine Brown<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn57">[57]</a>. Ms. Brown was dragged from the railroad car and was brutally beaten and left disabled by a railroad employee<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn58">[58]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1021/1*-hfTX2W2fT2NLTeT-CX9Cg.png" /><figcaption>Segregated public restrooms, 1965, rural South Carolina</figcaption></figure><p>Gatekeepers of gender-segregated public spaces kept Black women out, first by rationalizing it under general safety concerns and second by denying Black women their womanhood. These gatekeepers, as the ones today, understood that womanhood has nothing to do with sex or genitalia — and it has everything to do with power. Women, now and then, are often a symbol of their community or group. Denying a Black woman entrance to a women’s only space was “an insult as well to their husband’s status and to men of color in general.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn59">[59]</a>By protecting white women, white men were protecting their own power and status. These laws have shifted. Now, the rationales promulgated for the necessity of Bathrooms Bills is the security and privacy interests of <em>cis </em>women.</p><p>Proponents of the bathroom bills often emphasize that the purpose of these acts of legislation is to protect women from sexual harassment by predators, ostensibly either non-transgender men who could “dress up” to enter the women’s bathroom <a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn38">[38]</a>or transgender women themselves. A subtle theme underlying this legislation is the notion that transgender people are somehow “deviant and deceptive and are themselves fraudulent simply by existing.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn39">[39]</a>. But there is no evidence that indicates that allowing transgender people to use the bathroom of their choice compromises the safety of cis women<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn60">[60]</a>. Local leaders from states that have passed laws prohibiting anti-transgender discrimination in public accommodations echo that there has been no increase of sexual harassment or abuse in facilities, with Minneapolis police spokesperson John Elder saying that it has not been “even remotely” a problem<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn61">[61]</a>. This past September, UCLA School of Law’s Williams Institute released a Massachusetts-based study indicating there is no statistically significant evidence that transgender bathroom access and bathroom-related crimes are connected.</p><p>Second, the privacy concerns are also ill-founded. All bathrooms are designed to maintain some personal privacy<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn62">[62]</a>. Separate stalls are the norm in women’s restrooms, and even men’s restrooms include some stalls for those who wish to bypass the urinals<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn63">[63]</a>. Adding privacy curtains to locker rooms could achieve the same goal easily and with little cost<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn64">[64]</a>.</p><p>Given the lack of evidence supporting the safety and privacy rationales of the Bathroom Bills, supporters of such legislation are not protecting cis women — rather, they are trying to maintain the status quo of a traditional gender-binary world. The patriarchy, the male-dominated social structure that survives on the oppression of women, reinforces sexism <a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn65">[65]</a>when it perpetuates the belief that gender is “biologically determined and therefore unalterable.” Framing gender as inherent, rather than as a social construct, de-politicizes the patriarchy and justifies the subordination of women as the natural state of affairs<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn66">[66]</a>. And as bell hooks once said, “patriarchy has no gender.” Women can and do perpetuate the patriarchy, both unintentionally and intentionally<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn67">[67]</a>.</p><p>While the security and privacy benefits are minimal, if not entirely nonexistent, trans women and men suffer greatly under such legislation. By forcing them to pick between going to the bathroom of the gender they were assigned to at birth, putting them at extreme risk for violence if they have visibly transitioned, and not using the bathroom at all is no choice at all. 12% of transgender people report that they have been attacked or sexually assaulted in a bathroom last year<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn68">[68]</a>. Like Mary Jane Chilton, who walked all the way to Carondelet, Missouri, rather than sit in the smokers’ car where her bodily integrity was at risk, many trans people go out of their way to avoid going to the bathroom. A staggering 59% of trans people have avoided bathrooms last year because they feared confrontation<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn69">[69]</a>. As a result, almost 8% report having a kidney or urinary tract infection from avoiding restrooms<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn70">[70]</a>.</p><h3><strong>Part III: Constitutional Challenges to the “Bathroom Bills”</strong></h3><p>In this section, I identify two Constitutional arguments to dismantle the Bathroom Bills. First, I argue that the right to access the bathroom of your choice is a fundamental right through the fundamental right of privacy. Second, which would either exist on its own or in the background of this identified fundamental right, I argue that these Bathroom Bills impermissibly rely on gender stereotypes to exclude access to gendered spaces and as such, are violations of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.</p><h4>A. Establishing a fundamental right</h4><p>In the seminal case <em>Griswold v. Connecticut</em>, Justice Douglas held that the right of privacy, albeit unenumerated, was nonetheless fundamental<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn71">[71]</a>. The right of privacy, he argued, falls under the “penumbra” of the other rights in the Constitution, particularly the First, Third, Fourth, Fifth, and Ninth Amendments. If any of those rights have any meaning, they rely on the right of privacy being guaranteed. In holding that the right of privacy allows married couples to purchase and use contraceptives, Justice Douglas linked privacy spatially to the home and the marital bedroom, which the State should be kept out of. In <em>Eisenstadt v. Baird</em>, Justice Brennan untethers the right of privacy from marriage, extending it to all individuals<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn72">[72]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*EFD8pNjCSf3bzd7Htr2F_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Estelle Griswald.</figcaption></figure><p>Subsequent holdings bolster the position that there are spaces too intimate for the State to penetrate. The right of privacy has been extended over the marital and quasi-marital home, including issues on procreation, sex, and reproductive autonomy. In <em>Lawrence v. Texas</em>, for instance, Justice Kennedy paints the plaintiffs — two unmarried men engaging in no-strings-attached-sex — with a brush of domesticity and frames their arrests as a gross intrusion of the State into a quasi-marital bedroom. The Court also roots reproductive rights in the right of privacy. In <em>Roe v. Wade</em>, the Court held that the “zone of privacy” under the Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments encompasses a woman’s decision to terminate her pregnancy<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn73">[73]</a>. A further ruling in <em>Planned Parenthood v. Casey </em>held that family planning decisions are central to the right of privacy and that restrictive abortion laws “deprive her [a woman] of basic control of her life.”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn74">[74]</a>These cases are critiques of the use of criminalization, the most potent expression of state power, in intimate spaces and circumstances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*1EZ8bYkhrdwpAIv6rBWM8g.png" /><figcaption>Plaintiffs in Lawrence v. Texas</figcaption></figure><p>There are few spaces more intimate than a bathroom, and few actions worthier of an expectation of privacy than what one does in a bathroom. “Toilet activities are highly personal and ordinarily occur backstage of life,” says NYU Sociology Professor Harvey Molotch<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn75">[75]</a>. Physical boundaries within restrooms, such as stalls or other partitions, are supplemented by behavioral patterns that suggest “civil inattention,”<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn76">[76]</a> such as the polite disregard of noises and the cessation of conversation. As discussed earlier, the creation of gender-segregated bathrooms arose as a need for an extension of the home, a haven, in the public world. Today, they operate similarly, in that they function as a refuge of privacy and intimacy in a public landscape. Trans women and men have the right to engage in private intimate conduct in the bathroom they choose, without having to “out” themselves and lose their dignity as free people in the eyes of the State through criminal proceedings. Further, any notion of privacy should ensure that trans women and men do not have to divulge the details of their genitalia or their chromosomes to the public every time they use the bathroom. By forcing a trans women who has transitioned, medically or not, to use the men’s bathroom is asking her to divulge intimate, personal details of her genitalia, genetic information, and medical history. In addition, it is asking her to put her life at risk.</p><p>As in with bedrooms and homes, the state should extend the constitutional right of privacy over bathrooms. The right of privacy would necessarily have to entail the right of public accommodation, at least in the bathroom setting. As such, any regulation over bathroom access must the requirements of strict scrutiny, in that the regulation must further a compelling interest and is narrowly tailored to achieve that goal. As articulated in previous sections, while privacy and security may be compelling state interests, Bathroom Bill legislations do not serve those goals<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn77">[77]</a>.</p><h4>B. Equal Protection Clause Argument</h4><p>Although the Fourteenth Amendment does not explicitly mention gender, Courts have understood gender to be a protected class under the Equal Protection Clause. Early cases struggled with the perceived biological and natural differences of women, such as in <em>Muller v. Oregon</em>, where the Court upheld maximum work hours for women but not for men. Similarly, in <em>Bradley v. Illinois</em>, Justice Bradley’s concurrence focused on the “natural order” of women needing the protection of men. But in later decades, the Court began to narrow in on impermissible and permissible gender classifications.</p><p>In <em>Reed v. Reed</em><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn78"><strong><em>[78]</em></strong></a>, the Court held that gender classifications must be “reasonable, not arbitrary, and must rest upon some ground of having a fair and substantial relation to the object of the legislation, so that all persons similarly circumstanced shall be treated alike,” suggesting gender classifciations are subject to intermediate scrutiny. In <em>Craig v. Boren</em>, Justice Brennan disavowed the strict scrutiny standard from <em>Frontiero v. Richardson </em>and re-affirmed intermediate scrutiny standard as the appropriate standard of review for gender classifications.<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn79">[79]</a> Over the follow years, the standard of intermediate scrutiny became clearer. In <em>United States v. Virginia</em>, Justice Ginsburg held that that the reasons for differentiating on the basis of sex cannot be rooted in stereotypes that rest on perpetuating women’s supposed inferiority<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn80">[80]</a>. The Supreme Court has also held that the stereotypes need not be based on negative stereotypes. In <em>Mississippi University for Women v. Hogan</em>, Justice O’Connor held that the exclusion of men from a nursing program perpetuated the stereotype that nursing is a women’s only job<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn81">[81]</a>. And presumptions, or stereotypes, based on gender cannot be justified by administrative convenience or statistical likelihood<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn82">[82]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*qMWm3wS1vdGyeGLWlFtcDQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Justice Ginsburg, who wrote the Majority opinion in United States v. Virginia.</figcaption></figure><p>Transgender discrimination naturally relies on gender discrimination. In practice, Bathroom Bills, even the ones that rely on the gender marker on birth certificates, rely on stereotypes of what women should look like and exclude those who do not fit the typical feminine gendered model from women’s only restrooms, including many trans women who do not “pass” and also some masculine-appearing cis women. Generally, people do not carry their birth certificates with them. In practice, this means that gate-keepers will be using outward appearance and behaviors to inform their judgement of who gets go to the bathroom. While current gender identity is often visible, using outward appearances is not accurate measure of a person’s gender assigned at birth<a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn83">[83]</a>. Presumptions based on outward appearances may often accurately align with someone’s assigned gender at birth but are still impermissible to use out of mere administrative convenience. For all these reasons, the Bathroom Bills likely violate the Equal Protection Clause on gender discriminatory grounds and should be struck down.</p><h4><strong>Part IV: Looking Forward</strong></h4><p><em>“That night, I remember singing “We Shall Overcome,” many a times, on different demonstrations, on the steps of Albany, when we had our first march, where I spoke to the crowds in Albany. I remember singing but I haven’t over-come a damn thing,” said the legendary transgender activist Sylvia Rivera, reflecting on the Stonewall Riots.</em><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftn84"><strong><em>[84]</em></strong></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*TVPkFJNwhohwF2bqBo_jJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sylvia Rivera</figcaption></figure><p>Bathrooms have long been battlegrounds for civil rights.</p><p>First, the necessity of having gender-segregated “havens” in public life rested on the perceived inferiority of women. Second, Jim Crow laws segregating access to bathrooms were designed around protecting the enclave of white womanhood. Jim Crow laws operated by denying Black women their womanhood and status, and in doing so, insulted both the woman herself, the men in her life, and her greater community. Today, we see the same recycled arguments. Some women have to be protected, and some women are not women at all. By denying the status of womanhood to some women, particularly trans or masculine-appearing women, the purpose is not to protect <em>cis </em>women but to uphold the gender binary and the gender norms that come along with it. Ultimately, the big winner is the patriarchy and those who seek to uphold it, whether they be the men who enjoy their elevated status in society or the women who enjoy their protection under it, even if such protection rests upon their own inferiority. It is the patriarchy that wins when we confirm the rigidity of the gender binary, as assigned at birth, and when we sanction stereotypes of how women and men should act and look. In such a world, we are left with fragile women and the strong men who protect them from invisible bogeymen and monsters that do not exist. The denial of womanhood never depended on genitalia, but has instead rested on maintaining and accumulating power.</p><p>While gendered violence can happen in public facilities, studies shows that it does not happen as a result of letting trans people use the bathroom of their choice. But studies do show that trans people are incredibly vulnerable in bathrooms, and trans women forced to use the men’s room face extreme violence and sexual harassment. Proponents of the Bathroom Bills suggest they are necessary for the safety of women, but all they do is place the most vulnerable of women in extreme danger. Constitutionally, trans people are afforded the right of privacy, both in intimate spaces and in terms of bodily security. Bathroom Bills, also sometimes called “Genital Check” Bills, rob trans people of their privacy in intimate spaces and force them to “out” themselves, placing them in extreme danger. Any meaningful right to privacy under the Constitution also dictates the right of public accommodation, to use the bathroom of your choice. Further, on Equal Protection Grounds, legislation that rests on gendered stereotypes should be struck down, if they do not rise to meet intermediate scrutiny. Here, Bathroom Bills impermissibly rest on notions of what women, in particular, should act and look like. While the rationales of privacy and security are legitimate goals of the State, they are not served by this legislation.</p><p>These bills will not be going away. Many of these bills have been defeated — by vocal and massive public resistance. But should any more pass through the political process, it is unlikely that the current make-up of the Supreme Court of the United States will accept the arguments outlined here. Given this reality, while much of this paper focused on deepening the federal right of public accommodation, I encourage future thinkers, writers, and scholars to look towards State constitutions and State courts as potential avenues of progress towards establishing a right to public accomodation.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref1">[1]</a><em>Transgender FAQ</em>, GLAAD, <a href="https://www.glaad.org/transgender/transfaq">https://www.glaad.org/transgender/transfaq</a>(last visited Dec. 1, 2018)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref2">[2]</a><em>Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Definitions</em>, Human Rights Campaign, <a href="https://www.hrc.org/resources/sexual-orientation-and-gender-identity-terminology-and-definitions">https://www.hrc.org/resources/sexual-orientation-and-gender-identity-terminology-and-definitions</a>(last visited Dec. 1, 2018)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref3">[3]</a><em>Understanding Non-Binary People: How to Be Respectful and Supportive</em>, National Center for Transgender Equality (Oct. 5, 2018), <a href="https://transequality.org/issues/resources/understanding-non-binary-people-how-to-be-respectful-and-supportive">https://transequality.org/issues/resources/understanding-non-binary-people-how-to-be-respectful-and-supportive</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref4">[4]</a><em>Transgender FAQ</em>, <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref5">[5]</a><em>Understanding Non-Binary People</em>, <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref6">[6]</a><em>Frequently Asked Questions about Transgender People</em>, National Center for Transgender Equality (July 9, 2016), <a href="https://transequality.org/issues/resources/frequently-asked-questions-about-transgender-people">https://transequality.org/issues/resources/frequently-asked-questions-about-transgender-people</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref7">[7]</a>German Lopez, <em>Myth #5: All trans people medically transition</em>, Vox (updated Nov. 14, 2018) <a href="https://www.vox.com/identities/2016/5/13/17938114/transgender-people-transitioning-surgery-medical">https://www.vox.com/identities/2016/5/13/17938114/transgender-people-transitioning-surgery-medical</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref8">[8]</a>Neda Ulaby,<em>Health Care System Fails Many Transgender Americans</em>, NPR (updated Nov. 21, 2017) <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/11/21/564817975/health-care-system-fails-many-transgender-americans">https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/11/21/564817975/health-care-system-fails-many-transgender-americans</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref9">[9]</a>Bethy Squires,<em>For Trans People, Changing Your ID to Match Your Gender is a Nightmare</em>, NPR (updated Aug. 21, 2017) <a href="https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare">https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref10">[10]</a><a href="https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare"><em>Id</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref11">[11]</a><a href="https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare"><em>Id</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref12">[12]</a><a href="https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare"><em>Id</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref13">[13]</a><em>Frequently Asked Questions about Transgender People</em>, National Center for Transgender Equality (July 9, 2016), <a href="https://transequality.org/issues/resources/frequently-asked-questions-about-transgender-people">https://transequality.org/issues/resources/frequently-asked-questions-about-transgender-people</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref14">[14]</a><a href="https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare"><em>Id</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref15">[15]</a><a href="https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/yww3yj/for-trans-people-changing-your-id-to-match-your-gender-is-a-nightmare"><em>Id</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref16">[16]</a><a href="https://transequality.org/issues/resources/frequently-asked-questions-about-transgender-people"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref17">[17]</a><em>2015 U.S. Transgender Survey: Executive Summary</em>, National Center for Transgender Equality (December 2016) <a href="https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/usts/USTS-Executive-Summary-Dec17.pdf">https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/usts/USTS-Executive-Summary-Dec17.pdf</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref18">[18]</a><a href="https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/usts/USTS-Executive-Summary-Dec17.pdf"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref19">[19]</a><a href="https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/usts/USTS-Executive-Summary-Dec17.pdf"><em>Id</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref20">[20]</a><em>GLAAD calls for increased and accurate media coverage of transgender murders</em>, GLAAD (Oct. 20, 2018) <a href="https://www.glaad.org/blog/glaad-calls-increased-and-accurate-media-coverage-transgender-murders-0">https://www.glaad.org/blog/glaad-calls-increased-and-accurate-media-coverage-transgender-murders-0</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref21">[21]</a>We remember <strong>Christa Lee Steele-Knudslien, Viccky Gutierrez, Zakaria Fry, Celine Walker, Tonya Harvey, Phylicia Mitchell, Amia Tyrae, Sasha Wall, Nino Fortson, Karla Patricia Flores-Pavon, Gigi Pierce, Antash’a English, Roxsana Hernandez, Diamond Stephens, Cathalina Christina James, Keisha Wells, Sasha Garden, Vontashia Bell, Dejanay Stanton, Shantee Tucker, Londonn Moore Kinard, Ciara Minaj Carter, Nicole Hall, Nikki Janelle Enriquez. </strong>We also recognize the lives taken whose names we do not know.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref22">[22]</a>Anna Swartz, <em>Two black transgender women — Vontashia Bell and Dejanay Stanton — were killed the same day</em>, Mic (Sept. 4, 2018) <a href="https://mic.com/articles/191080/black-transgender-women-vontashia-bell-and-dejanay-stanton-killed-the-same-day#.16DvbYHJb">https://mic.com/articles/191080/black-transgender-women-vontashia-bell-and-dejanay-stanton-killed-the-same-day#.16DvbYHJb</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref23">[23]</a>Scott Bixby &amp; Betsy Woodruff, <em>Trans Woman Was Beaten in ICE Custody Before Death, Autopsy Finds</em>, Daily Beast (Nov. 26, 2018) <a href="https://www.thedailybeast.com/trans-woman-roxsana-hernandez-rodriguez-beaten-in-ice-custody-before-death-pathologist-finds">https://www.thedailybeast.com/trans-woman-roxsana-hernandez-rodriguez-beaten-in-ice-custody-before-death-pathologist-finds</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref24">[24]</a><em>Take Action Against Anti-Trans Legislation Now!, </em>National Center for Transgender Equality <a href="https://transequality.org/action-center">https://transequality.org/action-center</a>(last visited Dec. 5, 2018)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref25">[25]</a><em>Id</em>. Note that the majority of these bills have either failed or inactive.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref26">[26]</a>Vincent J. Samar, The Right to Privacy and the Right to Use the Bathroom Consistent with One’s Gender Identity, 24 <em>Duke Journal of Gender Law &amp; Policy</em> 33–59 (2016)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref27">[27]</a>Public Facilities Privacy &amp; Security Act of 2016, § G.S. 115C-47, see also Samar, <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref28">[28]</a><em>Id</em>, see also Gregory Krieg, <em>North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory blames Democrats for ‘bathroom bill’</em>, CNN (May 11, 2016) <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2016/05/11/politics/north-carolina-pat-mccrory-bathroom-bill-the-lead/index.html">https://www.cnn.com/2016/05/11/politics/north-carolina-pat-mccrory-bathroom-bill-the-lead/index.html</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref29">[29]</a>Elise Hofer McKelvey, <em>North Carolina Enacts Law Repealing “Bathroom Bill” But Limiting Local Anti-Discrimination Laws</em>, Littler (April 5, 2017). <a href="https://www.littler.com/publication-press/publication/north-carolina-enacts-law-repealing-bathroom-bill-limiting-local-anti">https://www.littler.com/publication-press/publication/north-carolina-enacts-law-repealing-bathroom-bill-limiting-local-anti</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref30">[30]</a><em>Id</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref31">[31]</a>Despite Libby’s testimony, SB 3 and SB 9 made it out of committee. SB 91 was eventually set aside, but SB 3 enjoyed a full round of debates before ultimately failing during the Special Session.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref32">[32]</a>As indicated earlier, changing the gender marker on a state ID is intentionally very difficult. See <em>supra</em>, Part I.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref33">[33]</a>Vincent J. Samar, The Right to Privacy and the Right to Use the Bathroom Consistent with One’s Gender Identity, 24 <em>Duke Journal of Gender Law &amp; Policy</em> 33–59 (2016)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref34">[34]</a>HB 583 failed in Judiciary Committee on April 28, 2015, after a lengthy petition drive against it. See Samar, <em>Id</em>.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref35">[35]</a><em>2015 U.S. Transgender Survey (Full Report)</em>, National Center for Transgender Equality (2015)<a href="https://www.transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/USTS-Full-Report-FINAL.PDF">https://www.transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/USTS-Full-Report-FINAL.PDF</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref36">[36]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref37">[37]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref38">[38]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref39">[39]</a>Quoting Chase B. Strangio, an ACLU attorney. See Maria L La Ganga, <em>From Jim Crow to transgender ban: the bathroom as battleground for civil rights</em>, The Guardian (Mar. 30, 2016) <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/30/transgender-ban-bathrooms-north-carolina-civil-rights">https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/30/transgender-ban-bathrooms-north-carolina-civil-rights</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref40">[40]</a>Maya Rhodan, <em>Why Do we Have Men’s and Women’s Bathrooms Anyway?, </em>Time (May 16, 2016) <a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/">http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref41">[41]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref42">[42]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref43">[43]</a><em>Bradwell v. State of Illinois</em>, 83 U.S. (16 Wall.) 130 (1873).</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref44">[44]</a>Terry S. Kogan, <em>How did public bathrooms get to be separated by sex in the first place?, The Conversation (May 26, 2016) </em><a href="http://theconversation.com/how-did-public-bathrooms-get-to-be-separated-by-sex-in-the-first-place-59575">http://theconversation.com/how-did-public-bathrooms-get-to-be-separated-by-sex-in-the-first-place-59575</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref45">[45]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref46">[46]</a>Rhodan, <a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref47">[47]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref48">[48]</a>Alana Semuels, ‘Segregation Had to Be Invented’, The Atlantic (Feb. 17, 2017) <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/02/segregation-invented/517158/">https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/02/segregation-invented/517158/</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref49">[49]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref50">[50]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref51">[51]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref52">[52]</a>Barbara Welke, <em>When All the Women Were White, and All the Blacks Were Men: Gender, Class, Race, and the Road to Plessy</em>, Law and History Review, Vol. 13 №2 (Autumn 1995).</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref53">[53]</a><em>History of Lynchings</em>, NAACP <a href="https://www.naacp.org/history-of-lynchings/">https://www.naacp.org/history-of-lynchings/</a>(last visited Dec. 8, 2018)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref54">[54]</a>Jennifer Ritterhouse, <em>Daily Life in the Jim Crow South, 1900–1945</em>, Oxford Research Encyclopedia of American History (May 2018) <a href="http://oxfordre.com/americanhistory/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199329175.001.0001/acrefore-9780199329175-e-329?print=pdf">http://oxfordre.com/americanhistory/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199329175.001.0001/acrefore-9780199329175-e-329?print=pdf</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref55">[55]</a>Welke, <a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref56">[56]</a>She was told this in more insulting language. See <em>Id</em>. at 261.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref57">[57]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref58">[58]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref59">[59]</a>Welke, <a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref60">[60]</a><em>2015 U.S. Transgender Survey (Full Report)</em>, National Center for Transgender Equality (2015)<a href="https://www.transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/USTS-Full-Report-FINAL.PDF">https://www.transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/USTS-Full-Report-FINAL.PDF</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref61">[61]</a><a href="http://time.com/4337761/history-sex-segregated-bathrooms/"><em>Id.</em></a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref62">[62]</a>Scott Skinner-Thompson, <em>Bathroom Bills and the Battle Over Privacy, </em>Slate (May 10, 1016) <a href="https://slate.com/human-interest/2016/05/in-the-battle-over-bathroom-privacy-transgender-peoples-needs-matter-more.html">https://slate.com/human-interest/2016/05/in-the-battle-over-bathroom-privacy-transgender-peoples-needs-matter-more.html</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref63">[63]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref64">[64]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref65">[65]</a>Linda L. Lindsey, Gender roles: a sociological perspective, Chapter 1: The Sociology of Gender (2005) at 3–5.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref66">[66]</a>Claire, Binary or Spectrum, Gender is a Hierarchy, Sister Outrider (Sept. 5 2017) <a href="https://sisteroutrider.wordpress.com/2017/09/05/binary-or-spectrum-gender-is-a-hierarchy/">https://sisteroutrider.wordpress.com/2017/09/05/binary-or-spectrum-gender-is-a-hierarchy/</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref67">[67]</a>bell hooks, <em>Understanding Patriarchy.</em><a href="https://imaginenoborders.org/pdf/zines/UnderstandingPatriarchy.pdf">https://imaginenoborders.org/pdf/zines/UnderstandingPatriarchy.pdf</a>(last visited Dec. 9, 2018).</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref68">[68]</a>German Lopez, <em>The largest survey of transgender people yet shows the dangers of bathroom hysteria</em>, Vox (Jul. 12, 2016) <a href="https://www.vox.com/2016/7/12/12161210/transgender-bathroom-survey">https://www.vox.com/2016/7/12/12161210/transgender-bathroom-survey</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref69">[69]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref70">[70]</a><em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref71">[71]</a><em>Griswold v. Connecticut, </em>381 U.S. 479 (1965).</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref72">[72]</a><em>Eisenstadt v. Baird, </em>405 U.S. 438 (1972).</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref73">[73]</a>See<em>Craig v. Boren</em>, 429 U.S. 190 (1976).</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref74">[74]</a><em>Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992).</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref75">[75]</a>Julie Beck, <em>The Private Lives of Public Bathrooms, </em>The Atlantic (Apr. 16, 2014) <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/04/the-private-lives-of-public-bathrooms/360497/">https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/04/the-private-lives-of-public-bathrooms/360497/</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref76">[76]</a>Civil inattention is a term that describes a “brief pattern of visual interaction,” where “individuals both acknowledge one another’s presence and, immediately thereafter, one another’s right to be let alone.” Id.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref77">[77]</a>See <em>Supra</em>, Part II.</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref78">[78]</a><em>Reed v. Reed</em>,404 US 71 (1971)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref79">[79]</a><em>Craig v. Boren</em>, 429 U.S. 190 (1976), <em>Frontiero v. Richardson,</em>411 U.S. 677 (1973)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref80">[80]</a><em>United States v. Virginia, 518 U.S. 515 (1996)</em></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref81">[81]</a><em>Mississippi University for Women v. Hogan, </em>458 U.S. 718(1982)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref82">[82]</a><em>Orr v. Orr</em>, 440 U.S. 268 (1979)</p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref83">[83]</a>Sophie Searcy. <em>Dear People Who Aren’t Trans: Bathrooms Hurt You, Too</em>. Huffington Post (Feb. 23, 2017). <a href="https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/dear-people-who-arent-trans-bathroom-bills-hurt-you_us_58af548fe4b0e5fdf6196fbc">https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/dear-people-who-arent-trans-bathroom-bills-hurt-you_us_58af548fe4b0e5fdf6196fbc</a></p><p><a href="/service/applewebdata://88F7E221-A6EF-4E04-AF45-20506EFC0021#_ftnref84">[84]</a>Sylvia Rivera, <em>June 2001 Talk at the Lesbian and Gay Community Services Center in New York City</em>(transcribed), History is A Weapon <a href="https://www.historyisaweapon.com/defcon1/riverarisingandstronger.html">https://www.historyisaweapon.com/defcon1/riverarisingandstronger.html</a>(last visited Dec. 5, 2018)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2e6d194bbf2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/bathrooms-an-old-frontier-of-public-accommodation-rights-c2e6d194bbf2">Bathrooms, an Old Frontier of Public Accommodation Rights</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation">criticalnarratives.publicaccommodation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Antidiscrimination and Public Accommodation: Legal reforms towards equality in Latin America]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/antidiscrimination-and-public-accommodation-legal-reforms-towards-equality-in-latin-america-d07c10a6c7f?source=rss----8522888061bd---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d07c10a6c7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Critical Narratives]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Dec 2018 00:12:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-11T00:12:47.578Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>I. Introduction:</strong></p><p>Is there a right to public accommodation in countries different than the United States? Specifically, how is the discussion about egalitarian access to public spaces and services in Latin America? Do black people, the LGBTIQ community and indigenous peoples suffer discrimination in access to bars, restaurants or public squares?</p><p>This paper presents some answers to the latest questions. The main objective is to show how the fundamental right to public accommodation is built in Latin America. To achieve the goal, the text is divided in four main sections. In the first one, I present recent cases in Colombia, Chile and Peru that highlight the debate and open the question for comparison. The second section faces the debate about the effectiveness of Law as a useful tool to combat discrimination. On the third part, I will show how different States created legal reforms to guarantee the fundamental right to public accommodation. Finally, on the fourth section, I will conclude and develop some questions for future comparative research on the issue of public accommodation.</p><p><strong>II.</strong> <strong>Public accommodation in South America:</strong></p><p>April, 2008. Bogotá, Colombia. Marvín Carabalí, Jordan Viveros, Paola Ortíz, Edna Martínez, Fatimah William and Aiden Salgado, a group of six Afro-descendant young people, went out to party in an exclusive neighborhood of the city. All of them, as was stated by one of the petitioners of the case, were well dress, following the “social norms” for this type of places. However, in every of the three bars they tried to get in, the bouncers told them: “This is a private party” or “Did you have the ID to prove that you are partners of this establishment?”<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. Time and again, their access to private places were denied when, in front of them, other mestizo or white people were getting in the bars without any constraints. After a long juridical dispute in front of the District Court and the Colombian Supreme Court, the plaintiffs won the case<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>. The Court<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> argued that their access was denied because of their skin color and ordered the bars to stop denying access to people based on race, and to offer public apologies to the six plaintiffs. The Court also ordered the national and local governments to create programs against discrimination of black people in the country. This decision set a point in the juridical battle of Afro-descendant people in Colombia to have plenty access to public spaces.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*sIQfL2uZE2vRppMX3cJ_RQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Source: TeleSur (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.telesurtv.net/news/CIDH-Colombia-debe-eliminar-el-racismo-en-la-protesta-social-20170614-0054.html">https://www.telesurtv.net/news/CIDH-Colombia-debe-eliminar-el-racismo-en-la-protesta-social-20170614-0054.html</a>)</p><p>March, 2012. Santiago de Chile, Chile. As one of the most Catholic cities in the continent, Santiago de Chile has a long history of public discrimination against the LGBTIQ community. Daniel Zamudio was a twenty-four years old gay Chilean man when he was murdered by a group of Neo-nazis. Daniel was walking in Santiago’s downtown when four other young men beat him in public because he was gay<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>. The attack was so violent that he died after three weeks in a public hospital.</p><p>Zamudio’s case opens a legal discussion to guarantee the LGBTIQ community rights to live safely in the country. Given how shocking the case was, Congress passed a law, the Zamudio Act<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a>, condemning the attack of this young man and looking for the protection of all the communities that suffer daily attacks in a highly homophobic context. Among the measures, Congress changed the criminal code to include an aggravating clause in the cases were the attack was founded in discriminatory intends like homophobia.</p><p>January, 2018. Lima, Peru. “What can I do to find the keys for success?”<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a> That is the phrase that opens one of the shows of Paisana Jacinta, a popular two-decade Peruvian T.V. show that has as the main character a man dressed up as an indigenous woman. In the show the person makes fun of indigenous peoples by embracing the social stereotypes that make them look like weak, silly and ignorant. Although the show has been criticized, Jacinta passed from television to the cinema.</p><p>When Jacinta’s movie was released at the beginning of 2018, the social discussion about it grows in the media. For example, Tania Pariona, an indigenous leader and congresswoman, expressed that the movie and the main character were “a form of discrimination towards the 55 native populations that live in our country”<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>. In a context where issues related to free speech and access to entertainment have been addressed by conservative social sectors, Jacinta received more than 500,000 views in the national cinemas. How can this happen in a country with more than four million indigenous persons according to the 2007 data?<a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a></p><p>The denial of access to public accommodation –having access to private spaces, public spaces or media — is an ongoing difficult question that a lot of Latin-American countries are facing. Due to the constant critiques presented by social movements against this reality, the legal field has been changing in the last few years. Using the frame of anti-discrimination agenda, some countries have been doing legal reforms to prohibit attacks and guarantee rights of discriminated populations.</p><p><strong>2.1. How to frame the question in South America?</strong></p><p>Why has it been so difficult to do legal reforms in Latin America? Academic literature has found at least two answers to the question. First, some countries –like Brazil and Colombia — are politically and socially founded under the myth of racial democracy (Múnera, 2005). According to this myth, due to the colonialism process, the entire population is racially mixed between indigenous peoples, African-descents and Europeans. This myth creates a legal and political denial to attack discrimination because it supposedly dissolves the racial tension in the general society. There could not be discrimination because everyone recognizes each other as equal and thus they would not act against themselves. State responsibility, from this framework, ends with the constitutional recognition of the equality between persons but cannot go beyond because people are mixed in a racially happy democratic system (Rodríguez, Alfonso and Cavelier, 2006). In other countries, like Argentina and Chile, the myth acts as a denial. According to this idea, there is no racial discrimination because there are not black people in those countries. They found their historical narrative on the idea that they do not have black people, and so it is impossible to discriminate them. A similar and more contemporary discourse of this myth can be seen in the social conversation against the LGBTIQ community. According to this logic, States cannot act because there is no social exclusion to solve. Both of the myths are false, create barriers to State action, and are politically used by some social groups to inhibit interventions. That is why States, to do any political intervention, need to recognize they are myths. After doing this political recognition of the discriminated groups, States can start doing legal reforms to protect them.</p><p><strong>2.2.</strong> <strong>Why talking about comparison matters?</strong></p><p>If this is the scenario, it can look very much like a domestic discussion of Latin American countries without any relationship to countries outside of the region. Nevertheless, one of the main<strong> </strong>aims of this text is to present the Latin-American experience as a way to enrich the global discussion of how to substantially guarantee people’s right to public accommodation. For this objective are, at least, three main reasons.</p><p>First, there is a political reason related with the creation of data about discrimination in different countries. Many practitioners, advocates and social leaders have difficulties arguing cases related with discrimination because they do not have the <em>hard</em> data to prove that a specific action is not an isolated violation but part of a systematic and structural system. Having this data for different countries is useful to have the conversation in comparative terms so advocates can know what is going in other countries and advance on a shared agenda against discrimination. Second, legal imagination expands with the comparative process. The legal and political reforms that countries are doing can be useful in different contexts. Sharing experiences and knowing what others States are doing might be helpful to see if a solution can be implemented in other circumstances.</p><p>Finally, a better comparison between different countries enables a global conversation that is useful to break ideas of legal and political exceptionalism that are rooted in some countries. The global conversation is particularly relevant for the United States because the idea of exceptionalism creates two impacts on the legal field. On the one hand, exceptionalism creates a distance between US social leaders and communities with their counterparts in other parts of the world. Making them part of the same conversation is useful to build a strong fort for the fundamental right to public accommodation. On the other hand, the distance created by the United States is a way to maintain a colonial relationship with the rest of the world. When the local context breaks relationships with other countries, it is sacralizing their experience and denying the exchange with other actors. At the end, this position does not change the situation of political subordination that the legal the US system tries to impose all over the world. For these reasons this paper creates a global conversation and brings some ideas to the US context about how to advance in the recognition of public accommodation as a fundamental right.</p><p><strong>III. Solutions from social movements and political actors:</strong></p><p>In Latin America, as an archetypical discussion<a href="#_ftn9">[9]</a>, there is a previous conversation of whether the Law is a significant tool to end social and political discrimination suffered by groups like indigenous peoples or African-descendants. Even tough it is a long debate between the social movements and the State I will summarize it following the two main poles of this conversation. Social and political actors move in a spectrum that goes from believing that law is effective to change reality to the other pole that focuses their attention on non-legal tools.</p><p><strong>3.1. The problem and the solution are a juridical debate:</strong></p><p>Some social movements — like indigenous peoples and women organizations — explained that discrimination occurs because the State has not been diligent in the sanction of these behaviors. From this shore, the State’s responsibility and possibility to transform the situation is enormous because it can change behavior with its intervention. For example, discrimination occurs because there are not sufficient legal consequences that sanction it.</p><p>One of the paradigmatic examples of this perspective is the Colombian Act against discrimination. This Act was presented by a right wing Christian party called Mira<a href="#_ftn10">[10]</a> to create criminal sanctions for racial discrimination and other causes of discrimination like religion. The legislative procedure counts with social support from some historical organizations like Movimiento Cimarrón and the Centro de Reconocimiento Afrocolombiano<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a>. At the same time, the political party launched a campaign called <em>I am Afro-friendly, and you?</em><a href="#_ftn12">[12]</a><em>,</em> to channel black peoples’ support. Beyond the political tensions created on the legislative route, some organizations believed that Law could be useful to combat social discrimination. Their objective, overall, was to change the criminal law to create severe norms that prohibit discriminatory acts.</p><p><strong>3.2. The problem and the solutions are a cultural debate:</strong></p><p>Some other social organizations understood that Law ands its reform is not a useful tool to combat social discrimination. From this bench, what the political actors and even the State need to do, is to focus their efforts on more structural social interventions that eliminate discriminatory practices. For example, some of the organizations in this group argue for a better protection of public education<a href="#_ftn13">[13]</a>.</p><p>Social organizations and movements — like black peoples’ organizations — argue that discrimination occurs because people are being educated in a way that does not recognize others as equals. For this to change, society must transform other social areas like education or job markets.</p><p>Their critique goes further because it moves the discussion into the effectiveness of criminal law as a tool that recognizes and empowers the people that it is trying to protect. From this perspective, Law is not a useful tool and, contrarily, it will impose discrimination against the ones that suffer it the most. Criminal reform is only a valuable State tool to legitimate violence in cases related with public accommodation.</p><p><strong>IV. Solutions from the State: Changing Legal regimes</strong></p><p><strong>4.1. Constitutional reforms</strong></p><p>The legal debate about the reforms to guarantee the right to public accommodation, in Latin America, was preceded by one of the most spectacular legal changes in the continent: the multicultural constitutionalism of the end of the 20th century (Bonilla, 2015). With some fundamental differences within the region, the constitutions suffered transformations that diversified who are recognized as a citizen and their relationships with the State.</p><p>According to the literature<a href="#_ftn14">[14]</a>, the multicultural constitutionalism has –for the objective of this paper — five main elements that changed the legal panorama in the region. These changes show that the states are willing to respond to more diverse constituencies that go beyond the white-owner-male that found the Constitutions in the 19th century (Lemaitre, 2012).</p><p>First, the new Constitutions changed the understating of the national unity, recognizing more institutional subjects. As a consequence, many of the Constitutions recognize the state as multiethnic or multicultural. Second, these Constitutions also included the diversity and religious equality. As a way to enhance the social and political recognition of other ways of being, these Constitutions break their Catholic dependence to Rome and allow cultural diversity of populations. Third, the Constitutions also have specific provisions to protect historically discriminated communities like indigenous peoples, women, and Afro-descendants communities. As historical reparation, this legal recognition opens a space for the construction of legal regimes that bring better life conditions to these groups. Fourth, Constitutions also break the one-dimensional existence of the State and recognized other authorities and jurisdictions over the same territory. For example, constitutions in Bolivia, Colombia and Ecuador recognize that indigenous peoples authorities can judge actions. Fifth, “(…) many Constitutions express a strong commitment to equality, not only prohibiting discrimination on [the] grounds of race, gender, and other factors, but also ordering special affirmative action policies to make equality real and effective””<a href="#_ftn15">[15]</a>. This last element opens space for the creation of legal regimes against discrimination.</p><p>In the coming section I will focus on the public policies and legal reforms that were created to implement equality and non-discrimination. Most of them, like in the discussion of the Enforcement Acts in the United States, aim to guarantee real equality in access to public places and services by creating criminal reforms.</p><p><strong>4.2. Promulgation of Acts and other types of norms to solve discrimination:</strong></p><p>Latin American states have solved the question about equality to access and the prohibition discrimination using two legal interventions, following the camp that thinks that law has a transformative power. On the one hand, some States have created criminal law that aims to guarantee equality between persons. For example, similarly to the Third Enforcement Act in the United States, some of these articles protected historically discriminated groups creating criminal norms that include higher sanctions for persons that discriminate based on race, gender, sexual orientation or ethnicity. On the other hand, other states have created norms to guarantee equality by the implementation of administrative norms that aim to protect the same groups implementing systems like affirmative action programs<a href="#_ftn16">[16]</a>. One of the elements that literature<a href="#_ftn17">[17]</a> has shown is that the criminal repertoire has been used more often by the States than the use of remedies like the affirmative actions because they are cheaper in political and social terms compared to programs that combat structural discriminatory systems.</p><p>Except for Paraguay, all Latin American countries<a href="#_ftn18">[18]</a> have done national reforms to include criminal laws that prohibit racial discrimination<a href="#_ftn19">[19]</a>. These reforms are done because of political pressure made by social movements and political parties to materialize constitutional reforms.</p><p>Until now, Latin-American countries have adopted two systems based on criminal resolution against discrimination. On the one hand<a href="#_ftn20">[20]</a>, countries created criminal norms that specifically condemn racial discrimination. Cuba, El Salvador and Venezuela are in this group. For example, the Cuban case highlights the legal procedures that prohibit discrimination in public accommodation. In constitutional terms, article 4 of the National Constitution established equality in terms of rights and duties. The same article prohibits any type of discrimination based on race, skin color, sex, national origin or religious beliefs.</p><p>In Cuba, any act of discrimination based on sex, race, color or origin that ends up hindering or preventing the enjoyment of the rights of a person is sanctioned. As a penalty, a person can be punished with deprivation of liberty or economic fines<a href="#_ftn21">[21]</a>. In February 2011, the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination of United Nations asked the Cuban State for information about the implementation of the criminal norms that sanction discrimination. In its own words:</p><p>“The Committee regrets that it has not received information on proceedings initiated or sentences handed down during the reporting period for the commission of acts that run counter to the Convention, as provided for by article 295 of the Criminal Code. While the Committee takes note of the delegation’s explanations about the mandate and functions of the Office of the Attorney General of the Republic, it remains concerned by the lack of reported cases, prosecutions and convictions relating to acts of racial discrimination during the reporting period”<a href="#_ftn22">[22]</a>.</p><p>The Cuban case shows how the creation of the criminal norms is just a step in the path of protecting discriminated groups. The promulgation of the criminal act is not enough; it is important to examine their implementation. With a better understanding of how those norms are acting so that States can prove the effectiveness of criminal law in guaranteeing equality for all.</p><p>On the other hand, other countries introduce a complex understanding of the struggle against discrimination and in favor of public accommodation. These norms have a longer<a href="#_ftn23">[23]</a> list of discrimination forms that are prohibited. This is the example of countries like Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Peru, and Uruguay.</p><p>The Mexican case exemplifies this type of legal regimes. Article 149-ter of the Criminal Code sanctions people that discriminate based on origin, ethnicity, race, skin color, tongue, gender, sex or sexual option, age, civil status, national origin, social or economic condition, health, pregnancy, political opinion. The sanctions also include discrimination based on any other issue that harms the human condition, or anyone who eliminates or reduces any right or liberty. Within the scope of the norm, actions that end on the violation of the right to public accommodation are include. Specifically, the article establishes that the crime could be done when someone denies a service, restricts labor rights or the right to education. The sanction will be stronger if a public official commits the crime. In that case, the person will be punished with an administrative process that will end their contract.</p><p>The Mexican case also includes the creation of the Act to Prevent and Eliminate Discrimination (Ley para Prevenir y Eliminar la Discriminación, in Spanish). The Act was approved under the Fox administration and even though it protects Mexicans from being discriminated on the bases of gender, sexual orientation and ethnicity, article 4 does not include the prohibition of racial discrimination ignoring the Criminal code. This Act excludes actions that the State can do to eliminate the discrimination suffered by the Afro-Mexican population. Article 9 of this Act presents some examples to understand how discrimination is created in cases like pay gap, limited access to a specific program or bullying.</p><p>The Act also creates a specific office that is in charge of its enforcement. The National Council to Prevent Discrimination (Consejo Nacional para Prevenir la Discriminación –CONAPRED-, in Spanish) is an independent organism that follows the implementation of the Act and enforces the protection of the groups included in the legal reform. For example, the Council is in charge of creating public policies that will protect discriminated groups, investigate discriminatory actors and solve cases. What is interesting about this institution is that it is in charge of investigating discrimination cases and sanctioning conducts. Among the sanctions that the Council can do, there are: courses about non-discrimination, the creation of signs in public spaces prohibiting discrimination, sending Council officers to teach courses, and the publication of the resolution and decision of the Council. If at the end of the investigation, the Council finds that there was no discrimination, it will publish an agreement of non-discrimination.</p><p>After years of the promulgation of the norm, there are cases and denouncements of all types of discrimination against persons protected by the Act. According to Burcio Mújica, former president of the Conapred, discrimination suffered by the LGBTIQ community persists as an ongoing struggle<a href="#_ftn24">[24]</a>.</p><p>Finally, and contrary to all of this reforms, the Paraguay case shows the opposite side of the regional move towards criminal reforms against discrimination. In Paraguay there are two specific reasons why the State has not created a norm for these cases. The first reason is related with the political difficulties. An Act against discrimination has to pass over Congress but there is a lack of political interest to promote a law that prohibits and sanctions discriminatory actions<a href="#_ftn25">[25]</a>. The second reason is that there is social discrimination against groups like indigenous peoples, women and the LGBTIQ community. Because of this social bias, society is not ready to respond to the political pressures and their constitutional and international duties to protect all citizens<a href="#_ftn26">[26]</a>.</p><p><strong>V. Conclusion</strong></p><p>In this paper I show the different responses that states in Latin America have implemented to respond to social, political and legal pressures to guarantee the right to public accommodation. Every country responded to specific pressures and States solutions vary from the inclusion of a constitutional reform to the creation of criminal acts.</p><p>Latin American countries understand the existence of a fundamental right to public accommodation. However, the protection of this right is developed under the right to not be discriminated. The latter opens a space to do constitutional reforms in favor of diversity and criminal changes prohibiting discrimination. For the creation of strategic litigation programs, advocates must have in mind that public accommodation is developed under the umbrella of non-discrimination. Apart from this first conclusion, Latin American cases demonstrated that there is a huge possibility to create litigation activities in favor of the right to public accommodation. What is most important, from this perspective, is to build narratives of the rights that allow judges to bring integral solutions that combat discrimination in a structural way.</p><p>For the comparative debate there are two main questions that have to be solved. On the one hand, there is a question about how to frame mobilizations and juridical changes towards the guarantee of a more egalitarian system. In Latin America, as has been shown in the paper, the frame is the open scheme of antidiscrimination. With the use of this type of legal repertoire, the state aims to include different legal remedies. However, because Law is a field of constant construction of narratives from different actors, this is not the only chance that political actors have to request legal reforms. For example, the field of fundamental rights is being tangentially used in this context. Thinking about narratives and frames for having these debates in every country became a central question to actors arguing for political transformation. The second question is the idea<a href="#_ftn27">[27]</a> of the uses of criminal law as an effective tool to guarantee the right to public accommodation. As has been shown<a href="#_ftn28">[28]</a> the criminal law the creation of these norms can be criticized for two specific reasons. First, the implementation of criminal law affects the same groups that it is trying to protect. The unequal impact of criminal law raises a question about the effectiveness of these tools as a way to solve the problem or as a way to bring more exclusion against those groups. For this reason, the criminal reform can be also another jail for persons that want to be set free with legal transformation.</p><p>The second critique comes from criminal studies. Criminal reforms are populist transformations of the Law that will not be implemented or will create a sense of more protection without doing real transformations on social fields. These critiques explain how changes on criminal law are part of the repertoire of actions used by the State to create a sense of protection and security but never reflect about the implementation of the norms or the creation of sanctions. These can be the research questions that have to be done in places like Cuba.</p><p>If norms are on papers but are not changing the political field, they will create a curtain of distraction to appease political actions against the State. People critique the procedural elements of criminal cases about discrimination. The law requires a transformation of the burden of proof and the way that juridical actors think about basic criminal elements like responsibility or intention. The majority of these cases involve the construction of criminal norms so people will need to rethink criminal law elements to truly open the space for state action. All these critiques must be taken into consideration when other States evaluate the evidence presented in this paper to create legal transformations.</p><p>Finally, the question of how to deal with private and social stereotypical norms overflows the capacity of the law. Thus, more interdisciplinary approaches to the right to public accommodation are urgent to understand social norms. Stereotypes that create fear, rage or disgust need to be tracked to formulate political changes. The transformation of legal regimes is useful if States want to satisfy the right to public accommodation in private or public spaces that are embedded on the public sphere. But these changes have a fainter power on the transformation of private in-house- relationship. On the private and more personal relationships, historically discriminated groups suffer discrimination and for those, there is a debt of research and public scrutiny to fulfill the feminist dream of “democracy in the square and in the bed”<a href="#_ftn29">[29]</a>.</p><p><strong>Footnotes</strong></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> See <em>El bar que no acepta negros, Retrieve from: </em><a href="https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/investigacion/el-bar-no-acepta-negros-articulo-637237">https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/investigacion/el-bar-no-acepta-negros-articulo-637237</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> To know more about the case, see the press release Retrieve from: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/454.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/454.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Decision Retrieve from: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/452.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/452.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> <em>See La muerte de un joven gay reabre el debate sobre la homophobia en Chile, Retrieve from: </em><a href="https://elpais.com/sociedad/2012/03/27/actualidad/1332875522_330643.html">https://elpais.com/sociedad/2012/03/27/actualidad/1332875522_330643.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> To know more about the Act, see <a href="https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=1042092&amp;r=2">https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=1042092&amp;r=2</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> See <em>Lo major de la paisa Jacinta, Retrieve from: </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpIp1YKQgFQ">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpIp1YKQgFQ</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> See <em>The Paisana Jacinta Controversy continues to divide Peruvians</em>, Retrieve from: <a href="https://perureports.com/paisana-jacinta-controversy-continues-divide-peruvians/6553/">https://perureports.com/paisana-jacinta-controversy-continues-divide-peruvians/6553/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> See <em>¿Sabemos cuánta población indígena hay en el Perú?</em>, Retrieve from: https://revistaideele.com/ideele/content/¿sabemos-cuánta-población-indígena-hay-en-el-perú</p><p><a href="#_ftnref9">[9]</a> To know more, see Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref10">[10]</a> To see more about the Mira’s proposition, see <a href="http://carlosalbertobaena.com/ley-antidiscriminacion/">http://carlosalbertobaena.com/ley-antidiscriminacion/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref11">[11]</a> To see more about the legislative procedure, see: <a href="https://www.congresovisible.org/agora/post/no-discrimino-pongamos-en-marcha-la-ley-anti-discriminacion/3800/">https://www.congresovisible.org/agora/post/no-discrimino-pongamos-en-marcha-la-ley-anti-discriminacion/3800/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref12">[12]</a> To see more about the campaign, see: <a href="http://congresovisible.org/agora/post/postura-del-movimiento-soy-afro-amigo-y-tu-en-relacion-al-objecion-presidencial-al-proyecto-de-ley-16510-camara-0810-senado-penalizacion-de-la-discriminacion/2673/">http://congresovisible.org/agora/post/postura-del-movimiento-soy-afro-amigo-y-tu-en-relacion-al-objecion-presidencial-al-proyecto-de-ley-16510-camara-0810-senado-penalizacion-de-la-discriminacion/2673/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref13">[13]</a> See for example, education programs: <a href="https://akubadaura.org/lineas-de-trabajo/">https://akubadaura.org/lineas-de-trabajo/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref14">[14]</a> Even thought there is a huge group of literature that explains the Latin-American constitutionalism changes, Uprimny’s perspective brings the best example of the regional trends of these reforms.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref15">[15]</a> Uprimny, 2011, 1592.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref16">[16]</a> Because of the scope of this paper, brining the comparison between the US case and the Latin American case, I do not present the other type of actions that have been created to respond to these issues. Nevertheless, for information about them can check: Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref17">[17]</a> To see more about this debate, see Ikawa, D (2009). <em>The right to affirmative actions for blacks in Brazilian universities</em>. The Equal Rights Review. 3 and Fraser, N and Honneth, A (2004). Redistribution or recognition: A political-philosophical exchange. Verso.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref18">[18]</a> See the following norms: Argentina: Art. 3; Act. 23.925; Art. 2; Act 23.925.Art. 80, Criminal Code and Art. 3, Act. 23.925. Bolivia: Art. 23, 24; Act 045 de 2010, Art. 32 Criminal Code, Art. 21, 22, 23, 24, 26 — Act. 045 de 2010, Art. 23, 24; Act 045/2010; Art. 281 septieser — Criminal Code. Brazil Art. 20, Act 7716/89, Art. 3, num. III y IV Criminal Code, Art. 4, num. VIII, Art. 5, num. XLI, Art.1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 18 — Act. 7716/89, Art. 3 — Act. 7716/89, Art. 20 — Act 7716/89. Chile: Art. 1, 19 Political Constitution, Art. 2, 17. Act. 20609/12 . Colombia: Art. 58 Criminal Code; Art. 4, 5, 6, 7 — Act 1482/011, Art. 58 Criminal Code, Art. 3, 5, 6 — Act 1482/011, Art. 58 Criminal Code, Art. 4, 5, 6 — Act. 1482/011. Costa Rica: Art. 123 bis, 375 Criminal Code, Art. 6. Act 7711/1997, Art. 2 — D. 4230/68, Art. 375 Criminal Code. Cuba: Art. 295,num. 1 and 2., Criminal Code, Art. 295 — Criminal Code, Art. 295, num. 1. Criminal Code. Dominican Republic: Art. 336 y 336–1 — Criminal Code. Ecuador: Art. 212ª, num.. 1, 212c, 212d — Criminal Code, Art. 3, num. 1 Political Constitution, Art. 212ª, 212b, 212e — Criminal Code, Art. 212ª, num. 3, 212d — Criminal Code. El Salvador: Art. 246, 292 Criminal Code. Guatemala: Art. 376, Criminal Code. Art. 202 bis Criminal Code, Art. 377, Criminal Code. Honduras: Art. 60, PC. Art. 321, Criminal Code, Art. 3 Executive Order PCM 09–2007. Mexico: Art. 149 Per, Criminal Code, Art. 149 Per, Criminal Code, Art. 2, CP. Nicaragua: Art. 549 y 550 Criminal Code, Art. 16, 549 Criminal Code, Art. 549 y 550 Criminal Code. Panama Art. 131, num. 3. Criminal Code, Art. 441, num, 8. Criminal Code. Peru Art. 323 — Criminal Code, Art. 3 — Act 27270/00. Uruguay: Art. 149 bis — Criminal Code changed by Act 17.817, Art. 149 ter. — del Criminal Code changed by Act. 17.817, Art. 149 bis — Changed by Act. 17.817. Venezuela: Art. 8, Organic Act against Racial Discrimination, Art. 37, 38 — Criminal Code.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref19">[19]</a> Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref20">[20]</a> Ibid.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref21">[21]</a> Article 295, Criminal Code.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref22">[22]</a> Consideration of reports submitted by States parties under article 9 of the Convention. Concluding observations of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination. Cuba</p><p><a href="#_ftnref23">[23]</a> Idem.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref24">[24]</a> To know more, see: <a href="https://www.conapred.org.mx/index.php?contenido=boletin&amp;id=783&amp;id_opcion=&amp;op=213">https://www.conapred.org.mx/index.php?contenido=boletin&amp;id=783&amp;id_opcion=&amp;op=213</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref25">[25]</a> To know more about the political situation, see: <a href="https://nodiscriminesparaguay.org/que-es-el-proyecto-de-ley-contra-toda-forma-de-discriminacion/">https://nodiscriminesparaguay.org/que-es-el-proyecto-de-ley-contra-toda-forma-de-discriminacion/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref26">[26]</a> <a href="http://www.abc.com.py/edicion-impresa/locales/paraguay-es-el-unico-pais-sin-ley-contra-discriminacion-en-el-mercosur-1129676.html">http://www.abc.com.py/edicion-impresa/locales/paraguay-es-el-unico-pais-sin-ley-contra-discriminacion-en-el-mercosur-1129676.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref27">[27]</a> See for example: Roundfield, L (2008). Defining, Finding and Remedying Discrimination: Dominant Legal Perspective. Philadelphia, Temple University Press.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref29">[29]</a> “Democracia en la plaza y en la casa” was one of the main slogans of the feminist movement in Latin America when they start presenting the right to abortion as a human right that must be protected to guarantee equality between women and men.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d07c10a6c7f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/antidiscrimination-and-public-accommodation-legal-reforms-towards-equality-in-latin-america-d07c10a6c7f">Antidiscrimination and Public Accommodation: Legal reforms towards equality in Latin America</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation">criticalnarratives.publicaccommodation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Modern Denials of Public Accommodation, the Creation of Invisible Castes, and the Need for a…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/modern-denials-of-public-accommodation-the-creation-of-invisible-castes-and-the-need-for-a-9203e30127b9?source=rss----8522888061bd---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9203e30127b9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Critical Narratives]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Dec 2018 23:28:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-10T23:21:24.538Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Modern Denials of Public Accommodation, the Creation of Invisible Castes, and the Need for a Fundamental Right to Public Accommodation</strong></h3><p><strong>By Emily Harris</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*Zu0OtHOZmH48LApO6VIhoA.jpeg" /></figure><p>“This is a White Man’s Neighborhood.”</p><p>“For Colored Only.”</p><p>“Only Whites Served Here.”</p><p>“We Wash For White People Only.”</p><p>“No Spanish or Mexicans.”</p><p>“Colored Seating in Rear.”</p><p>Signs bearing these overtly racist and discriminatory directives hung throughout America during the Jim Crow era. Establishments holding themselves open to the general public — be they local stores, laundromats, restaurants, other commercial and public spaces, or even just neighborhood streets — loudly proclaimed who would and would not be accepted as part of the “public”<a href="#_edn1">[i]</a> they served. Beyond just their segregated shops, though, the private actors running places of segregated public accommodation also worked to recreate the “public” sphere. There was the “public” that was welcome to accommodations — generally white people with the means to afford whatever accommodation was on offer — and everyone else who was excluded and forced to find alternative accommodations.</p><p>In excluding particular groups of people from places held out as serving everyone, public accommodation denials marginalize whole sectors of the “public.” Unable to enter, utilize, exist within, or take advantage of these public goods, the marginalized groups are forced to seek these accommodations elsewhere. When the sentiment of enough of those in control of access to accommodations aligns to exclude a particular type, class, or group of people, the marginalized group is forced to exist outside of the mainstream “public,” often impacting the ability to access the types of political, social, and cultural capital that are perpetuated and exchanged within public spaces.</p><p>During Jim Crow, and indeed throughout the bulk of American history, excluding people of color from public spaces and creating “whites only” places of public accommodation allowed white people with means to exist in a “public” sphere that did not reflect the actual public. Rather than engaging with the actual public — the fellow members of their community — segregated accommodations allowed white people to ignore the realities and existence of others in their communities and society that they did not see or interact with. For white people operating in segregated spheres of society, the “public” reflected a constructed narrative– a white society without people of color or any interaction between different races unless they sought it out. Through segregation of “public” accommodations, the “public” that was reflected was monochromatic. In white “public” spheres, people of color were invisible — literally unseen in segregated places of accommodation — and their narratives thus easily avoided, ignored, or erased.</p><p>While the explicitly racist, overtly and obviously discriminatory signage prevalent during Jim Crow has mostly<a href="#_edn2">[ii]</a> disappeared, denials of public accommodations have not. Segregated “public” accommodations and spheres of public life continue to be created and maintained by proprietors of accommodations. In many ways, though, the overt signage has been replaced by more subtle messages of exclusion. Rather than loudly proclaiming their biases and preferences for discrimination, public spaces and places of public accommodation can appear to be non-discriminatory, non-racist, and places of supposed equality for all members of the public while still operating as places of segregation and exclusion. These more subtle forms of discrimination create ever more spaces where those who are not excluded do not have to acknowledge that the “public” around them is not the true public at all. A very brief list of these modern forms of discrimination in public accommodations includes: explicit denials to gay couples seeking cakes,<a href="#_edn3">[iii]</a> flowers,<a href="#_edn4">[iv]</a> and photography<a href="#_edn5">[v]</a> from wedding vendors for their same-sex marriage ceremonies; refusing access to bathrooms consistent with the gender identity of trans individuals;<a href="#_edn6">[vi]</a> removing people from flights for speaking Arabic;<a href="#_edn7">[vii]</a> and euphemistic “dress codes” that allow bar and club owners to exclude certain races and ethnicities.<a href="#_edn8">[viii]</a> While many of these instances of discrimination have been met with litigation, there are of course myriad other instances of discrimination by public and private actors, as well as explicit and implicit<a href="#_edn9">[ix]</a> denials of access to public accommodations. Additionally, various states and local communities<a href="#_edn10">[x]</a> have enacted or attempted to enact laws that protect or entrench forms of segregation and exclusion.</p><p>Discrimination, exclusion, and “public” accommodations that serve only a segment of a segregated public are clearly not new. But the form and function of these exclusions have evolved, continuing to exist — albeit often in more subtle or ignorable ways — into the modern era. Notably, though, the Supreme Court has been reluctant to acknowledge a fundamental right to public accommodation which would provide teeth to existing anti-discrimination laws and avenues for challenging with strict scrutiny the continued exclusion from public accommodations faced by a many.<a href="#_edn11">[xi]</a></p><p><strong>Legislation-Supported Exclusions from Public Spaces</strong></p><p>While other pieces in this series delve in greater detail into some of these historical and modern public accommodation denials, both in the United States and abroad, this piece focuses on denials of public accommodations that come with the weight of legislative backing. In particular, this piece looks through the lens of laws designed to exclude from public spaces and places of public accommodation people experiencing homelessness and people with criminal convictions for sexual offenses. Through this lens, this piece explores not only a realm of discrimination and denials of public accommodation that is enforced through legislation and not purely through (societally permitted) actions of private actors, but also forms of exclusion and discrimination that are less often called out as explicitly discriminatory and often come with public support. In examining this realm of denials of access to public accommodations, this piece also seeks to advance further support for arguments in favor of access to public accommodations as a fundamental right routed in the post-Reconstruction Constitution.<a href="#_edn12">[xii]</a></p><p><em>Intentional Exclusion of People Experiencing Homelessness</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*uATquXWywh8cW5Q6jn4GGA.jpeg" /></figure><p>One form of legislative exclusion prevalent in American communities of all kinds are ordinances designed to keep people experiencing homelessness<a href="#_edn13">[xiii]</a> from entering, staying in, or utilizing public spaces. The National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty and the National Coalition for the Homeless identified a variety of laws that impact the ability of homeless people to engage in public spaces, or that criminalize their conduct within public spaces, including:</p><blockquote> <em>“L</em>aws that make it illegal to sleep, sit, or store personal belongings in public spaces.</blockquote><blockquote> Selective enforcement of ostensibly neutral laws, such as loitering, jaywalking, or open container laws, against homeless persons.</blockquote><blockquote> Sweeps of city areas in which homeless persons are living to drive them out of those areas, frequently resulting in the destruction of individuals’ personal property such as important personal documents and medication.</blockquote><blockquote> Enactment and enforcement of laws that punish people for begging or panhandling in order to move poor or homeless persons out of a city or downtown area.</blockquote><blockquote> Laws that prohibit groups sharing food with homeless persons in public spaces.</blockquote><blockquote> So-called ‘quality of life’ ordinances regulating public activities and hygiene (i.e., public urination) when no public facilities are available to people without housing.”<a href="#_edn14">[xiv]</a></blockquote><p>Though less explicit than a “No Homeless People Allowed” sign, these types of laws transform public spaces into areas where people experiencing homelessness are explicitly unwelcome and at risk of criminal sanctions — including potential incarceration and fines — for attempting to utilize and exist within them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*ae0EYJ51PwZhT2rV4eX3iw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In addition to laws designed to exclude people experiencing homelessness from public spaces, or to exclude homeless peoples’ ability to exist and utilize spaces as they wish, many communities also have laws and police policies designed to “move along” homeless persons.<a href="#_edn15">[xv]</a> These ordinances seek to physically remove and displace homeless persons from specific areas like business districts and downtown areas. These policies range from police directing people to vacate an area ad hoc to policies that bus homeless people out of a particular area to different cities or even states.<a href="#_edn16">[xvi]</a> In many communities, Business Improvement Districts work with local elected officials and police departments to create and enact anti-homeless policies.<a href="#_edn17">[xvii]</a> For example, the Downtown Denver Partnership proposed a ban on sleeping in public to the City Council 2012. That measure ultimately passed, and businesses that are part of the partnership now regularly call the police to exclude homeless people from their downtown area.<a href="#_edn18">[xviii]</a></p><p>Despite some legal challenges to and advocacy against ordinances that impact homeless persons existing in public spaces, these types of laws continue to grow and spread. <a href="#_edn19">[xix]</a> The National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty, which has been tracking anti-homeless laws in the same 187 cities since 2006, found that anti-homeless laws have increased in every city they track, in some cases exponentially. For example, bans on city-wide camping have increased by 69 percent, bans on camping in particular public places have increased by 48 percent, city-wide bans on sleeping in public have increased by 31 percent, and bans on sitting and lying down in public have increased by 52 percent.<a href="#_edn20">[xx]</a> To put this in a different perspective, a 2016 report from UC Berkeley School of Law found 592 laws restricting and excluding homeless people from public spaces in the 58 most populous cities in California.<a href="#_edn21">[xxi]</a> The same study found an additional 781 restrictions on homeless people in non-public spaces. <a href="#_edn22">[xxii]</a></p><p>Notably, though perhaps not surprisingly, these types of anti-homeless laws do little to actually reduce the rates of people experiencing homelessness. But despite their counterproductive impact the laws, policies, and ordinances designed to remove homeless people from public spaces receive widespread support. One recent study found that 52 percent of people surveyed supported exclusionary polices banning panhandling in their community and 46 percent supported a ban on sleeping in public.<a href="#_edn23">[xxiii]</a> Even among respondents who said they supported providing subsidized housing to homeless people the rates of approval for these exclusionary policies were 47 percent (banning panhandling) and 44 percent (banning sleeping in public).<a href="#_edn24">[xxiv]</a> This is in line with surveys from the early 2000s, including a TIME/CNN/Harris poll in which 47 percent of respondents said it should be illegal for homeless people to sleep in public places.<a href="#_edn25">[xxv]</a> As these polls are conducted via the internet or phone calls, it is also likely that they reflect the opinion of the “public” which does not include homeless individuals who many not have a home phone number or steady internet access.</p><p>Given “public” support for these laws, and the idea that public laws and ordinances are the result of democratic activity and express the will of the public, anti-homeless laws can seem difficult to challenge. But “public” and business community support of these laws underscores the impact of excluding the voices and presence of people experiencing homelessness from public areas. Not only are homeless people physically excluded, but their narratives are also excluded, eliminated, and erased from public spheres. Unable to engage in public spaces and interact with the rest of the community, the voices of people experiencing homelessness are diluted if not completely drowned out by those who have the privilege of ignoring the negative impact on their fellow community members (and lack of efficacy) of these policies and ordinances.</p><p>Much like the examples of Jim Crow-era segregation and exclusions from public accommodation, these modern local ordinances reshape the public sphere. Though “public accommodations” is a term generally used to refer to the types of businesses and service providers that hold themselves open to the public, these laws and policies impact more purely public spaces. Anti-homeless ordinances impact places that are inherently public, which should be open to all but for limited circumstances. Exclusionary laws and policies turn these public spaces into places serving the “public” — a public that does not include homeless persons. The “public” that does utilize the space is left with the intentionally false impression that people in their community are not experiencing homelessness and that homeless persons are not a part of their community or their public space. In this way, homeless people are rendered invisible in their communities, kept from being seen and engaging with their fellow citizens in these traditionally public forums. This constructed version of the “public” perpetuates inaccurate ideas of who the “public” is and what community members want and need, which, as discussed further below, prevents the ideals of democracy and republican representation from operating as envisioned by the framers of the reconstructed Constitution.</p><p><em>Exclusions and Restrictions on People with Convictions for Sexual Offenses</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*pLi1Qu3bwWWEZJJJBf95cQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Another population that faces similar restrictions on inhabiting or existing within public spaces are people with particular criminal convictions, most prevalently people with convictions for sexual offenses. Despite being in the community and not incarcerated, in many cities people convicted of sexual offenses are forced to register as a convicted sexual offenders and abide by particular regulations and restrictions. Registration and regulations can be in addition to an incarceral sentence, and extend beyond any period of probation or parole. For some categories of people with sexual offense convictions these restrictions include blanket exclusions from living, entering, or working in specific parts of their community. While homelessness can be a temporary or periodic status for many people and families restrictions on people with convictions for sexual offenses can be a lifetime brand. Additionally, restrictive policies and registration requirements or community disclosure laws lead to increased housing instability and homelessness among people with convictions for sexual offenses.<a href="#_edn26">[xxvi]</a></p><p>In 1994 Congress passed House Resolution 324, the “Jacob Wetterling Crimes Against Children Registration Act”<a href="#_edn27">[xxvii]</a> which required every state in the nation to create registries “requiring persons convicted of [specific] criminal offense[s] against a minor to register a current address with a designated State law enforcement agency (LEA) for ten years after being released from prison or being placed on parole, supervised release, or probation.”<a href="#_edn28">[xxviii]</a> This requirement was amended in 1996 with the passage of House Resolution 2137, better known as “Megan’s Law,” which allowed law enforcement agencies to publicize information from the registry that was deemed necessary to protect public safety.<a href="#_edn29">[xxix]</a> All states now also maintain publicly accessible online registries.<a href="#_edn30">[xxx]</a> In 2006 the passage of the “Adam Walsh Child and Protection Safety Act” further expanded the restrictions on and requirements of people convicted of sexual offenses. The 2006 Act created a national database of people registered as sex offenders and created post-release civil commitment procedures whereby people deemed to be “dangerous” can continue to be incarcerated through civil commitments after serving the sentence for their criminal conviction.<a href="#_edn31">[xxxi]</a> These registries, even without associated laws requiring self-disclosure or public disclosure, allow members of the “public” to easily identify and ostracize any member of their community who is on an registry.</p><p>Beyond the registries, though, most restrictions on people convicted of sexual offenses are determined and enacted at the state and local level. As such, there is variety amongst the regulations in each state. A 2009 50-state survey found that twenty states have legal restrictions on where people with registered convictions for sexual offenses can live, work,<a href="#_edn32">[xxxii]</a> or physically be present.<a href="#_edn33">[xxxiii]</a> In addition to state-wide laws, cities and towns have also passed laws and ordinances restricting residence, employment, or physical presence of people with sexual offense convictions. These state-by-state and city-by-city differences create what is at times a complicated tapestry of laws, including laws such as: excluding people on sex offender registries from living or working within a certain distance of places like schools, child care facilities, and parks; <a href="#_edn34">[xxxiv]</a> restrictions on being physically present in areas like school campuses and parks;<a href="#_edn35">[xxxv]</a> and limits on who they live in a person on the registry’s own home.<a href="#_edn36">[xxxvi]</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/507/1*-u2-xaq0BGhR7Vg-QrOLYA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Much like anti-homeless regulations, registries and restrictions on people on sex offender registries have both not been proven to reduce recidivism or decrease instances of sexual offenses, and yet they still receive public support.<a href="#_edn37">[xxxvii]</a> With little research into potentially effective policies<a href="#_edn38">[xxxviii]</a> and great public animosity towards and fear of people who commit or are convicted for sexual offenses, many local laws passed to restrict movement and interaction between the public and people on sex offender registries are based not on evidence-based, scientifically-driven policy, but purely on popular “public” opinion.<a href="#_edn39">[xxxix]</a> Perhaps more troubling: a 2015 study found that “the public’s perceptions about these offenders and the laws used to control or rehabilitate them are built upon faulty perceptions” but that “public opinion has been a driving impetus in policy creation and additional sex offender restrictions.”<a href="#_edn40">[xl]</a></p><p>The number of people impacted by these laws and regulations has also continued to grow. While in 2005 there were an estimated 550,000 people on sex offender registries nationwide, by 2013 that number had grown by 35 percent to 750,000.<a href="#_edn41">[xli]</a> Notably, this increase in the number of people on sex offender registries occurred at a time when the number of people in America under correctional supervision actually declined 2.1 percent.<a href="#_edn42">[xlii]</a></p><p>As discussed above, the registries, regulations, and laws that the “public” supports push people with convictions for sexual offenses out of public spaces. Coupled with laws that require disclosure of registry status or even public announcements of registry status before moving into or existing within certain spaces, these laws have been likened by many to a modern day form of banishment.<a href="#_edn43">[xliii]</a> Excluded from living in, existing, and in some cases even entering a community, people with convictions for sexual offenses are denied the ability to engage socially or politically to oppose the laws that are designed to exclude them. Much as with laws excluding people experiencing homelessness, laws excluding people with convictions for sexual offenses erase their narratives and existence from a community, and they do so with community support. People with convictions for sexual offenses are not only rendered invisible in their communities, they are banished, and the voices they would have contributed silenced.</p><p><em>A Continuation of Jim Crow</em></p><p>The parallels to Jim Crow extend beyond just the denial of access to public accommodations for particular populations. The exclusions of people experiencing homelessness and people with convictions for sexual offenses also disproportionately impact racial minority groups.</p><p>More than 40 percent of people who are experiencing homelessness are African-American, despite making up only 13 percent of the general population.<a href="#_edn44">[xliv]</a> Additionally, per each 10,000 African-Americans in the general population approximately 52.1 are experiencing homelessness. Similarly, the share of people who identify as Native American/Alaskan Natives, Native Hawaiians and Pacific Islanders, or having two or more races who are experiencing homelessness is more than double their share of the general population. Per each 10,000 Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islanders in the general population approximately 93.8 are experiencing homelessness, compared to 20.2 per 10,000 Whites. While Hispanic people are represented in the homeless population at rates approximately equal to their share of the general population, Whites and Asians are significantly underrepresented compared to their share of the general population.<a href="#_edn45">[xlv]</a></p><p>Such disparities are similarly present in the population impacted by sex offender registries and restrictions. While close to two-thirds of the 750,000 people on sex offender registries in America are white men, black men are disproportionately represented on registries compared to the actual population. Black people are twice as likely to be on a sex offender registry than white people.<a href="#_edn46">[xlvi]</a> One recent study found that “[r]oughly one out of every 119 black men living in the forty-nine states analyzed were registered sex offenders — <em>nearly 1 percent of all black men.</em>”<a href="#_edn47">[xlvii]</a> Additionally, some recent studies have found that people of color who are convicted of sexual offenses are treated more harshly than white people convicted of sexual offenses.<a href="#_edn48">[xlviii]</a></p><p>While exclusions based on homelessness and prior criminal convictions (for sexual offenses or otherwise) are not explicitly based in race like the exclusions of Jim Crow, people of color are disproportionately represented in the homeless population and on sexual offender registries and disproportionately feel the impacts of these exclusions and restrictions.</p><p><strong>Creating Invisibility and “Public” Accommodations</strong></p><p>By excluding people experiencing homelessness and people with convictions for sexual offenses from public spaces and denying access (or even proximity) to places of public accommodation, these laws, policies, regulations, and restrictions reshape the make-up of the “public” and work to render these groups’ narratives invisible. Without a presence or a voice in public spaces, members of these excluded groups are less able to combat the narratives the majority “public” places upon them. Predominantly, these are narratives of disgust, fear, and othering. This is a particularly important issue as laws designed to excluded people experiencing homelessness and people with sexual offense convictions have popular support.</p><p>As discussed briefly, above, when groups are excluded from public spaces their narratives, voices, and political power are diluted and potentially destroyed. Already vulnerable due to a lack of community support — and even community disgust<a href="#_edn49">[xlix]</a> — a loss of ability to engage with and interact as equals with other members of the public in public spaces and places of accommodation further hurts excluded group’s ability to advocate against laws that exclude them or dispel the myths that characterize their existence. Further, when non-excluded members of the majority “public” do not come into contact with members of the excluded groups in the standard public spaces of accommodation, they are able to assume that the types of groups that have been excluded simply do not exist naturally in their community or that their exclusionary policies were in some way effective in reducing instances of homelessness or sexual offenses. Elected officials are similarly free to either ignore or remain willfully ignorant about the existence of constituents in their districts who are impacted by these exclusions.</p><p>Through these exclusionary policies, the majority “public” is able to create and enforce a constructed version of “public” that renders the excluded groups invisible. Particularly when homelessness and convictions for sexual offenses come with voting disenfranchisement, the excluded members must rely on other members of the public to protect their interests — a potentially Sisyphean task when the “public” does not interact with those excluded in standard public forums and does not see their existence in places of public accommodation. For the rest of the “public,” members of the excluded groups are invisible. Unseen. Unheard. Unnoticed. Unnecessary to pursue or support their interests.</p><p>Inherent in the concept of exclusion and invisibility is the centering of the majority narrative and the majority voices. The group that has the power to exclude and chooses to exercise that power makes others invisible <em>to them</em>. Of course people excluded from “public” spaces do not actually become invisible. They continue to exist in places and to utilize alternative — and more welcoming — forms of accommodations. But this conception of invisibility — of one group having the power to exclude another group and to render them unseen by the majority, to silence their voices to others — highlights the damage these exclusionary laws do to the whole of the public. In allowing a majority group to silence, to render another invisible, these exclusionary laws and regulations undercut the proper functioning of a truly representative republican government.</p><p><strong>Towards a Fundamental Right of Public Accommodation</strong></p><p>Understanding the pains of public accommodation denials as undermining a republican form of government and acting as a mark of Cain, we can then see potential routes for arguing a fundamental right to public accommodations routed in the reconstructed Constitution. In particular, arguments utilizing Article 4 of the Constitution’s promise of a republic form of government,<a href="#_edn50">[l]</a> as expanded by the Reconstruction Amendments.</p><p>Despite being technically democratically enacted — the will of a majority of voters, or the work of people elected by a majority of voters — laws that deny access to public spaces and places of public accommodation cut against the idea of a truly representative government. While it may seem difficult to imagine such an argument succeeding in the modern age, there is some compelling precedent. Furthermore, understanding the Constitution as one that was reconstructed through the passage of the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments into a fundamentally human rights focused Constitution adds even greater traction to the argument.</p><p>This argument also draws on two other closely related arguments from the arena of education. First, arguments made during the legal battle to integrate public schools and the fight to protect affirmative action, which underscore the need for interaction and engagement amongst a diverse body of students. Second, arguments being advanced now for the currently unenumerated, and not yet officially recognized, fundamental right to education.</p><p>In the first <em>Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka</em><a href="#_edn51"><strong><em>[li]</em></strong></a><em> </em>case, the Supreme Court declared that separating children in public schools based on their race had “a detrimental effect” on students of color who were excluded from the white “public” schools.<a href="#_edn52">[lii]</a> Excluding children of color from white majority schools, the court argued, marked them with a badge of “inferiority” that was detrimental to their education and development. Carrying forward to the modern day, though a spotty record on education, the Court has held in the 2016 <em>Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin</em> decision — somewhat tenuously — that promoting “cross-racial understanding” through the composition of diverse public higher education student bodies is a compelling interest.<a href="#_edn53">[liii]</a> Of course, utilizing these arguments about integrated schooling and education as a fundamental right requires some analogizing, but the central arguments are similar — both those who are excluded and those who exist in a segregated space are harmed by exclusionary policies; and engagement with heterogeneous populations is important for the well-being of American citizens and future voters. One can further analogize and expand a penumbra from the importance of education in an integrated space to an argument that existing in integrated — non-exclusionary — public spaces is also important to a well-functioning republic and body politic.</p><p>New arguments are also being advanced that education is a fundamental right which can be informative, and potentially extended, to developing a fundamental right to public accommodations. Asserting that public education was important to the framers of the 14th Amendment’s conception of what citizenship within the republic entailed, new arguments rely on a conception of what it means and requires to be a citizen to advance arguments about education.<a href="#_edn54">[liv]</a> There is similarly ample evidence that equal rights to public accommodations were crucial to the reconstruction-rea Congressmen’s understanding of the rights and privileges of citizenship, and imbedded in the reconstructed Constitution conceived of by these 14th Amendment framers. Speeches given in support of the Civil Rights Bill of 1875 highlighted the importance of public accommodations to the congressmen’s conception of what it meant to be a “man” within America, and a citizen of the republic. Speaking in support of the Civil Rights Bill of 1875, Representative Joseph H. Rainey even underscored the importance of being allowed to “remain in [the white majority’s] midst [as] an integral part of the body-politic.” Other Representatives, also speaking in support of the 1875 Civil Rights Bill, and with their passage of the Reconstruction Amendments in their recent memory, spoke of the humiliation of being denied access to public accommodations like train cars, restaurants, and hotels as they travelled to Washington D.C. for Congressional business. For these congressmen — particularly black congressmen who were just recently part of the excluded class — access to public accommodations and public spaces on an equal footing to white men was central to being respected as a citizen of the post-Civil War nation. Access to public accommodations were seen as an integral part of being a newly acknowledged citizen of America. Additionally, as Representative Rainey noted, the ability to remain within the public sphere was important to remaining “an integral part of the body-politic,” and of being a citizen who was respected, acknowledged, and politically engaged within the republic.</p><p>Much as new arguments for the fundamental right to education call upon the understanding of reconstruction-era framers and politicians, novel arguments for the fundamental right to public accommodations can do the same. In addition to the words of the framers themselves, central to this conception is understanding and reframing the narrative that is told about the Constitution and the 14th Amendment. Despite how it has been interpreted, and constrained, there is a strong argument to be made that the 14th Amendment, along with the 13th and 15th amendments and the legislation advanced during reconstruction, radically reshaped the Constitution in ways that have not been acknowledged by the Supreme Court. A more honest and human rights focused narrative should accept that the Reconstruction Amendments were intended to help America re-found itself after the Civil War as a nation atoning for and attempting to rectify a history of slavery and human rights atrocities. Through this new narrative lens, the Constitution is more easily seen as one designed to be the hero that responds to, defeats, rectifies, and protects against the “Trouble” of a segregated America where whole groups of Americans are denied a host of fundamental rights. Understanding the Constitution as a document designed to protect against the nation approaching anything even close to the atrocities and utter dehumanization of slavery, it is easy to find within its promises a fundamental right to public accommodations. Seeing the Reconstruction as reshaping not only who is a citizen but what is required of citizenship and must be provided to protect the proper functioning of the nation, the arguments for education as well as unfettered access to the public square, public forums, and public accommodations becomes clear.</p><p>While it is difficult to feel optimism about this argument in light of the current court and the current political climate, fighting for fundamental rights is a long-term process. Though the holding in <em>Fisher</em> may be overturned in an upcoming session, and there may not be a majority on the Supreme Court who believes in the Constitution as a fundamentally human rights focused document for some time, the act of making arguments and pushing against assumptions is an important part of the fight for fundamental rights.<a href="#_edn55">[lv]</a></p><p>As lawyers and legal scholars we must be prepared to “[speak] the language of the law” while remaining always “ready to try to change it.”<a href="#_edn56">[lvi]</a> This argument for a fundamental right of public accommodations is one attempt at trying to change the status quo and the narratives that allow for the creation of excluded and invisible Americans. Key to this long-term fight is illuminating the myriad methods utilized to deny access to public accommodations and the various groups who are impacted. Acknowledging, articulating, and understanding the various ways laws and regulations are used to exclude people like those experiencing homelessness and those with convictions for sexual offenses is an important early step. From there, both history and the contemporary work being done by others can be used to keep pushing for legal recognition for new fundamental rights. Exploring potentially novel arguments, in the interest of a stronger republic and a more just understanding of fundamental rights, is essential even if these arguments may be years away from having the desired impact.</p><p><a href="#_ednref1">[i]</a> Throughout this piece places that claim to be for the public, or open to the public, yet explicitly exclude some members of the community are referred to as “public” or “public” accommodations to recognize that the true, complete public is not permitted entry. This is discussed further in the text below.</p><p><a href="#_ednref2">[ii]</a> Though, indeed, plenty of examples of modern day hate speech, racist vandalism, and overtly discriminatory public rhetoric abound. For a brief overview of the rise in hate crimes in America, <em>see, e.g.</em> Ctr. for the Study of Hate &amp; Extremism, Cal. State Univ., San Bernadino, Report to the Nation: Hate Crimes Rise in U.S. Cities and Counties in Time of Division &amp; Foreign Interference (May 2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref3">[iii]</a> <em>See </em>Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, 584 U.S. ___ (2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref4">[iv]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>State v. Arlene’s Flowers, 187 Wash.2d 804 (2017) (Judgement later vacated and case remanded for further consideration in light of <em>Masterpiece Cakeshop</em>).</p><p><a href="#_ednref5">[v]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>Elane Photography v. Willock, 309 P.3d 53, (N.M 2013).</p><p><a href="#_ednref6">[vi]</a> <em>See, e.g.</em> Gloucester Co. School Bd. v. G. G. ex rel. Grimm, 137 S.Ct. 1239 (2017).</p><p><a href="#_ednref7">[vii]</a><em> See, e.g.</em> Makhzoomi v. Southwest Airlines Co., 2018 WL 3861771 (N.D. California 2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref8">[viii]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>Reuben A. Buford May and Pat Rubio Goldsmith, <em>Dress Codes and Racial Discrimination in Urban Nightclubs</em>, 4:4 Sociology of Race and Ethnicity 555 (2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref9">[ix]</a> While this essay and the series in general does not directly address the role of violence in denying access to public accommodations it must be noted that violence, violent communications, and threats of violence can and have all been weaponized to create implied understandings that certain groups of people are not welcome. Similarly — particularly with the modern rise of hate speech, hate crimes, and white supremacy in America — inclusion of symbols of hate and symbols aligned with particular groups known for violence, racist views, or specific animosity toward various groups can serve as a modern update to the Jim Crow signage discussed above. <em>See</em>, <em>supra</em> note ii.</p><p><a href="#_ednref10">[x]</a> Not to mention national-level discriminatory legislation, which is outside the scope of this piece.</p><p><a href="#_ednref11">[xi]</a> <em>See</em> Kenji Yoshino, <em>The New Equal Protection</em>, 124 Harv. L. Rev. 747, 752, 758–59 (2011) (discussing the Court’s reluctance to give heightened scrutiny to new classifications of rights in an increasingly diverse society).</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">[xii]</a> For a different, but related, argument about public accommodations for people experiencing homelessness,<em> see </em>David Rudin, <em>“You Can’t Be Here”: The Homeless and The Right to Remain in Public Space, </em>42 N.Y.U. Rev. of L. &amp; Social Change 309 (2018). (Arguing for extending the substantive due process reasoning in <em>Obergefell </em>to protect access to public accommodations and spaces for homeless people).</p><p><a href="#_ednref13">[xiii]</a> This piece utilizes the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services definition of homelessness, which defines a person experiencing homelessness as: “an individual who lacks housing (without regard to whether the individual is a member of a family), including an individual whose primary residence during the night is a supervised public or private facility (e.g., shelters) that provides temporary living accommodations and an individual who is a resident in transitional housing.” Public Health Service Act, 42 U.S.C. § 245(b). This paper also utilizes “person-first” language, acknowledging that people should not be defined solely by external conditions such as homelessness or a conviction for a sex offense.</p><p><a href="#_ednref14">[xiv]</a> National Law Center on Homelessness &amp; Poverty and National Coalition for the Homeless, Homes Not Handcuffs: The Criminalization of Homelessness in U.S. Cities, 9 (2009) <em>available at: </em><a href="http://nationalhomeless.org/wp-content/">http://nationalhomeless.org/wp-content/</a> uploads/2013/11/CrimzReport_2009.pdf.</p><p><a href="#_ednref15">[xv]</a> <em>See</em>, <em>e.g .</em>Rudin,<em> supra</em> note xii, at 327.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">[xvi]</a> Katie Pierce, <em>Lab Report: Where, Why and How Cities are Busing Homeless People Out, </em>City Lab, Dec. 22, 2017, <a href="https://www.citylab.com/life/2017/12/lab-report-where-why-and-how-cities-are-bussing-homeless-people-out/549086/">https://www.citylab.com/life/2017/12/lab-report-where-why-and-how-cities-are-bussing-homeless-people-out/549086/</a> (last accessed December 10, 2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref17">[xvii]</a> It is worth noting, though not the focus of this piece, the similarities between the Jim Crow business proprietors who argued for a business “need” for racial segregation, particularly in the South. Proprietors claimed that despite their own personal opinions about racial integration, their business interests required segregation — either at the behest of their customers, or the community at large. <em>See, e.g.</em> Garner v. Louisiana, 368 U.S. 157 (1961) and Bell v. Maryland, 378 US. 226 (1963).</p><p><a href="#_ednref18">[xviii]</a> Joe Palazzolo and Alejandro Lazo, <em>Business Interests Hold Sway on Cities’ Homeless Policies, </em>The Wall Street Journal, Oct. 15, 2016, <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/cities-adopt-homeless-policies-pushed-by-downtown-business-interests-1476544016.">https://www.wsj.com/articles/cities-adopt-homeless-policies-pushed-by-downtown-business-interests-1476544016.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref19">[xix]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>National Law Center on Homelessness &amp; Poverty, Housing not Handcuffs: A Litigation Manual, <em>available at</em>: <a href="https://www.nlchp.org/documents/Housing-Not-Handcuffs-Litigation-Manual.">https://www.nlchp.org/documents/Housing-Not-Handcuffs-Litigation-Manual.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref20">[xx]</a> Housing Not Handcuffs, <em>supra </em>note xiv at 10–11.</p><p><a href="#_ednref21">[xxi]</a> Berkeley Law Policy Advocacy Clinic, University of California, California’s New Vagrancy Laws: The Growing Enactment and Enforcement of Anti-Homeless Laws in the Golden State, 3 (June 2016) <em>available at: </em><a href="https://www.law.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Californias-New-Vagrancy-Laws.pdf.">https://www.law.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Californias-New-Vagrancy-Laws.pdf.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref22">[xxii]</a> While outside our scope here, it is also important to consider other forms of anti-homeless exclusion including anti-homeless “hostile” architecture and design intended to prevent laying, sitting, or staying in public spaces too long and other anti-homeless design like playing music to deter congregating in front of storefronts and employing security guards who lack any authority but patrol areas to deter loitering and camping.</p><p><a href="#_ednref23">[xxiii]</a> Scott Clifford and Spencer Piston, <em>Explaining Public Support for Counterproductive Homelessness Policy: The Role of Disgust,</em> 39 Polit. Behav. 503, 511 (2017)</p><p><a href="#_ednref24">[xxiv]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref25">[xxv]</a> <em>Id.</em> at 504. 2</p><p><a href="#_ednref26">[xxvi]</a> American Bar Association, <em>Restricting Sex Offender Residences: Policy Implications</em>, Human Rights, Vol. 36 (2009) <em>available at: </em><a href="https://www.americanbar.org/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/human_rights_vol36_2009/spring2009/restriciting_sex_offender_residences_policy_implications/">https://www.americanbar.org/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/human_rights_vol36_2009/spring2009/restriciting_sex_offender_residences_policy_implications/.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref27">[xxvii]</a> Named for Jacob Wetterling, whose abduction, the mismanaged search for his abductor, and the rise of Sex Offender Registrations and restrictive policies it spawned was chronicled in Season One of the APM Reports podcast <em>In The Dark,</em> hosted by Madeline Baran. More information about the podcast (as well as the second season which follows the miscarriage of justice that is the Curtis Flowers case) is available at: <a href="https://www.apmreports.org/in-the-dark">https://www.apmreports.org/in-the-dark</a>. Notably, Jacob Wetterling’s mother discusses in this podcast her move away from supporting sex offender registries.</p><p><a href="#_ednref28">[xxviii]</a> H.R. Res. 324 , 103rd Cong. (1993) (enacted as 42 U.S.C. 14071(d)).</p><p><a href="#_ednref29">[xxix]</a> H.R. Res. 2147, 104th Cong. (1996).</p><p><a href="#_ednref30">[xxx]</a><em>Restricting Sex Offender Residences: Policy Implications, supra</em> note xxviii.</p><p><a href="#_ednref31">[xxxi]</a> H.R. Res. 3132, 109th Cong. (2006); S. Res 1086, 109th Cong. (2006).</p><p><a href="#_ednref32">[xxxii]</a> New York does not have state-wide residency restrictions on people on the Sex Offender Registry who are no longer on probation or Parole, but the state does ban any person on the Registry from operating an ice cream truck. NY CORRECT §168-v (WEST 2018)</p><p><a href="#_ednref33">[xxxiii]</a> NIC/WCL Project on Addressing Prison Rape, American University, Washington College of Law, Fifty State Survey of Adult Sex Offender Registration Requirements (Aug. 2009) <em>available at</em>: <a href="http://ssrn.com/abstract=1517369.">http://ssrn.com/abstract=1517369.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref34">[xxxiv]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>MISS. CODE ANN. § 45–33–25(4) (West 2008); TENN. CODE ANN. § 40–39–211 (West 2008).</p><p><a href="#_ednref35">[xxxv]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>LSA-R.S. § 14:91.2 (West 2008); CAL. PENAL § 3003.5(b) (West 2008).</p><p><a href="#_ednref36">[xxxvi]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>ALA. CODE § 15–20–26 (West 2008); O.R.S. § 144.642 (West 2008).</p><p><a href="#_ednref37">[xxxvii]</a> Poco D. Kernsmith , Sarah W. Craun &amp; Jonathan Foster, <em>Public Attitudes Toward Sexual Offenders and Sex Offender Registration</em>, 18:3 J. of Child Sexual Abuse 290, 291 (2009).</p><p><a href="#_ednref38">[xxxviii]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref39">[xxxix]</a> Amy L. Anderson, Lisa L. Sample, and Calli M. Cain, <em>Residency Restrictions for Sex offenders: Public Opinion on Appropriate Distances</em>, 26(3) Crim. Justice Pol. Rev. 262, 263(2015); <em>Public Attitudes Toward Sexual Offenders and Sex Offender Registration</em>, <em>supra </em>note xxxvii at 291.</p><p><a href="#_ednref40">[xl]</a> Christina Mancini and Kristen M. Budd, <em>Is the Public Convinced that “Nothing Works?”: Predictors of Treatment Support for Sex Offenders Among Americans</em>, 62(6) Crime &amp; Delinquency 777, 778, 794 (2016).</p><p><a href="#_ednref41">[xli]</a> Trevor Hoppe, <em>Punishing Sex: Sex Offenders and the Missing Punitive Turn in Sexuality Studies</em>, 41:3 Law &amp; Social Inquiry 573, 580 (2016).</p><p><a href="#_ednref42">[xlii]</a> <em>Id.</em> at 582.</p><p><a href="#_ednref43">[xliii]</a> <em>See, e.g.</em> Kari White, <em>Where Will They Go — Sex Offender Residency Restrictions as Modern-Day Banishment</em>, 59 Case Western Reserve L. Rev. 161 (2008).</p><p><a href="#_ednref44">[xliv]</a> National Alliance to End Homelessness, Racial Inequalities In Homelessness, By The Numbers, (June 2018)<em> available at: </em><a href="https://endhomelessness.org/resource/racial-inequalities-homelessness-numbers/">https://endhomelessness.org/resource/racial-inequalities-homelessness-numbers/.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref45">[xlv]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref46">[xlvi]</a> <em>Punishing Sex: Sex Offenders and the Missing Punitive Turn in Sexuality Studies</em>, <em>supra </em>note xli at 584</p><p><a href="#_ednref47">[xlvii]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref48">[xlviii]</a> <em>Id. </em>at 575</p><p><a href="#_ednref49">[xlix]</a> <em>See, e.g.</em> <em>Explaining Public Support for Counterproductive Homelessness Policy: The Role of Disgust</em>, <em>supra</em> note xxiii.</p><p><a href="#_ednref50">[l]</a> U.S. Const. art. 4, § 4.</p><p><a href="#_ednref51">[li]</a> Brow v. Board of Education of Topeka, 347 U.S. 483, 493 (1954).</p><p><a href="#_ednref52">[lii]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref53">[liii]</a> Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, 138 S.Ct. 2198, 2203 (2016).</p><p><a href="#_ednref54">[liv]</a> <em>See, e.g. </em>Derek W. Black, <em>The Constitutional Compromise to Guarantee Education</em>, 70 Stanford L. Rev. 734 (2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref55">[lv]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref56">[lvi]</a> James Bond White, Heracles’ Bow: Essays on the Rhetoric and Poetics of the Law, 34 (1985)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9203e30127b9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/modern-denials-of-public-accommodation-the-creation-of-invisible-castes-and-the-need-for-a-9203e30127b9">Modern Denials of Public Accommodation, the Creation of Invisible Castes, and the Need for a…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation">criticalnarratives.publicaccommodation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[911 is a Joke: The Systematic Denial of Public Accommodation Through the Use of Strategic 911 Calls]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/911-is-a-joke-the-systematic-denial-of-public-accommodation-through-the-use-of-strategic-911-calls-470163265433?source=rss----8522888061bd---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/470163265433</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Critical Narratives]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Dec 2018 18:02:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-16T05:55:15.941Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/611/1*R0iFFZ7I6mTozVnHzlAVtA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Four North Carolina A&amp;T Students Sitting at a “Whites Only” Counter at Woolworth’s in Greensboro, North Carolina on February 1, 1960 (JACK MOEBES / CORBIS)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>Public Enemy released the song from which this piece borrows its title in 1990. In somewhat comical flavor, Flavor Flav discusses how first responders are slow to respond to crime in poor communities of color, neglecting them during their times of need. Nearly thirty years later, the song’s central complaint still rings true.<a href="#_edn1">[1]</a> The slow response of first respondents wreaks of irony when pitted against law enforcement’s heavy reliance on racial profiling and the over-policing of black communities. The irony becomes more striking when one considers how quickly and earnestly law enforcement responds to calls from white people, especially calls placed regarding black people who are doing nothing–except existing. Those who pay any attention to race relations in this country know that racism is not a relic of the past. Today, overt and covert incidents of racism occur daily; however, covert forms of racism reign supreme, and arguably are the most dangerous. 911 calls on black people in public spaces, referred to in this piece as “strategic 911 calls”, represent an insidious hybrid form of racism–one that is just subtle enough to allow the perpetrator to escape liability and social condemnation, but still obvious enough to emphasize the notion of the black person as other. Strategic 911 calls are rooted in stereotypes of black criminality that believe that a black person in a space frequented by whites must be up to no good. Those who place these calls deem black people suspicious at all times, whether a black person is trying to get home after a long day of work<a href="#_edn2">[2]</a>, selling water outside of their home<a href="#_edn3">[3]</a>, or knocking on doors for a political campaign<a href="#_edn4">[4]</a>.</p><p>Strategic 911 calls reach their peak within the realm of public accommodations. This year, citizen-collected footage bombarded our newsfeeds, documenting white people calling police on black people for partaking in the most mundane activities– enjoying a barbecue in a park<a href="#_edn5">[5]</a>, waiting for friends at a Starbucks<a href="#_edn6">[6]</a>, shopping at a store<a href="#_edn7">[7]</a>, and swimming at a pool<a href="#_edn8">[8]</a>. These anecdotes do not begin to cover the incidents that are not captured on tape or the incidents not involving the police.<a href="#_edn9">[9]</a> Since the Civil Rights Movement, the federal government and 45 states enacted laws prohibiting racial discrimination in places of public accommodation.<a href="#_edn10">[10]</a> Still, strategic 911 calls demonstrate that black people continue to face pervasive discrimination in these spaces fueled by the implicit and explicit biases of white people. Given the statistics on police brutality and data about its effect on the black mental health<a href="#_edn11">[11]</a>, it is clear that for black people in places of public accommodation, 911 continues to be a (potentially deadly) joke.</p><p>This piece conceives of the right to public accommodation as an extension of the already constitutionally recognized right to travel and free movement and argues that strategic 911 calls on black people in places of public accommodation unduly restricts and denies the exercise of this right. In addition to trammeling this already recognized right, these unwarranted 911 calls reinforce badges and incidents of slavery in violation of the Thirteenth Amendment.</p><p><strong>Public Accommodation as a Fundamental Right</strong></p><p><em>Already Recognized Rights to Travel and Free Movement</em></p><p>The right to public accommodation can be conceived of as an extension of the explicitly recognized right to interstate travel and the implicitly recognized right to intrastate travel and freedom of movement.</p><p>The Supreme Court has explicitly recognized the right to interstate travel as implicit under the United States Constitution, justifying it under the Commerce Clause as well as the Privileges and Immunities Clause.<a href="#_edn12">[12]</a> There are also instances where the Court recognized the right but declined to explicitly state its basis. Based on the existence of this right, the Supreme Court affirmed Congress’ power under the Commerce Clause to pass legislation protecting individuals from violations of civil rights that impinge on their free movement in interstate commerce.<a href="#_edn13">[13]</a> In <em>Saenz v. Roe</em>, the Court maintained that the right to travel encompassed the following components: “the right of a citizen of one state to enter and to leave another state, the right to be treated as a welcome visitor rather than an unfriendly alien when temporarily present in a second state, and for those travelers who elect to become permanent residents, the right to be treated like other citizens of that state.”<a href="#_edn14">[14]</a> The Court concluded that the last two components of the right to travel we supported by the Privileges and Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment while leaving the question regarding the constitutional support for the first component open.<a href="#_edn15">[15]</a></p><p>Despite the Supreme Court’s recognition of the fundamental right of interstate travel, it has declined to rule explicitly on the matters of intrastate travel and the freedom of movement, which this piece treats as interchangeable.<a href="#_edn16">[16]</a> Still, many of the Court’s decisions address freedom of movement and point to a history and tradition of recognizing this right.<a href="#_edn17">[17]</a> At least three circuits have explicitly recognized the right to intrastate travel or movement to be fundamental, using the Supreme Court’s decisions that address interstate travel to imply an attendant right of intrastate travel as a matter of practical logic and tradition.<a href="#_edn18">[18]</a> Other lower courts also acknowledged that their precedents supported the existence of the right.<a href="#_edn19">[19]</a> In its recognition of a right to intrastate travel, the Second Circuit tied it directly to the explicitly recognized right of interstate travel, maintaining, “it would be meaningless to describe the right to travel between states as a fundamental precept of personal liberty and not to acknowledge a correlative constitutional right to travel within a state.”<a href="#_edn20">[20]</a> Years later, the Third Circuit, conceiving of the right to intrastate travel as “the right to travel locally through public spaces and roadways”, applied the history and traditions test and concluded that “the right to move freely about one’s neighborhood or town…is implicit in the concept of ‘ordered liberty’ and ‘deeply rooted in the Nation’s history.’”<a href="#_edn21">[21]</a> In 2002, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals applied the history and traditions test and held that the Constitution protected a fundamental right to intrastate travel, which it characterized as, “the right to travel locally through public spaces and roadways.”<a href="#_edn22">[22]</a> The court began its analysis <em>United States v. Wheeler, </em>which citing the Articles of Confederation, recognized the rights of citizens “peacefully to dwell within the limits of their respective states, to move at will from place to place therein.”<a href="#_edn23">[23]</a> From the Articles of Confederation, the <em>Johnson </em>court jumps to the mid-nineteenth century, where the right to intrastate travel was implied in a Supreme Court decision. Dissenting in <em>Smith v. Turner</em>, Chief Justice Taney stated, “we are all citizens of the United States, and as members of the same community, must have the right to pass and repass through every part of it without interruption, as freely as in our own states.”<a href="#_edn24">[24]</a> Citing other, more modern Supreme Court decisions, the <em>Johnson</em> court concluded that “the right to travel locally through public spaces and roadways enjoys a unique and protected place in our national heritage.”<a href="#_edn25">[25]</a></p><p><em>Extending the Right to Travel and Movement to Public Accommodation</em></p><p>Many of the cases addressing the right to intrastate travel or movement deal with loitering ordinances, government-imposed curfews, or residency requirements.<a href="#_edn26">[26]</a> However, these precedents support the extension of these principles to the area of public accommodation. In his partial concurrence in <em>Bell v. Maryland</em>, Justice Douglas asked, “Does not a right to travel in modern times shrink in value materially when there is no accompanying right to eat in public places?”<a href="#_edn27">[27]</a> Articulating an argument similar to the one later used by the Second Circuit in <em>King v. New Rochelle Municipal Housing Authority</em>, Douglas maintained that if the right to discrimination-free interstate travel was protected by the Constitution, then “certainly [the] right to travel intrastate is as basic. Certainly his right to eat at public restaurants is as important in the modern setting as the right of mobility. In these times that right is, indeed, practically indispensable to travel either interstate or intrastate.”<a href="#_edn28">[28]</a></p><p>Some courts have rejected the argument that the right to intrastate travel guarantees a right to public accommodation.<a href="#_edn29">[29]</a><em> </em>When discussing the right to intrastate travel, the Second Circuit maintained “while the parameters of that right have not been sharply defined by our Court, it is clear that the right protects <em>movement between places </em>and has no bearing on <em>access </em>to a particular place.”<a href="#_edn30">[30]</a> Such an understanding mischaracterizes the right of movement. The <em>Johnson</em> court itself maintained that “the right to travel locally through public spaces and roadways is fundamentally one of access.”<a href="#_edn31">[31]</a> If the right to public accommodation is unduly restricted, the right to intrastate travel is necessarily infringed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/1*opHxk2f_MU7T3-bEq_D3fA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cover of “The Negro Motorist Green Book”</figcaption></figure><p>Embracing Justice Douglas’ judgment, it becomes clear that the right of access to a place of public accommodation necessarily implicates the rights of travel guaranteed by the Constitution. The implications for interstate travel are clear. In upholding the application of Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to a discriminatory hotel in <em>Heart of Atlanta v. United States</em>, the Supreme Court acknowledged the impact of racial discrimination on interstate commerce and travel.<a href="#_edn32">[32]</a> Before the enactment of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, black travelers were forced to carefully strategize travel, looking for places willing to accommodate them. “The Negro Motorist Green Book” constituted one response to restricted public accommodations access. The “Green Book” places of public accommodation that black travelers could frequent without fear of racial discrimination.<a href="#_edn33">[33]</a> Although the book aided interstate travelers, limiting one’s understanding of the “Green Book” to interstate travel misunderstands its broad purpose. Black residents of cities such as Jackson, Mississippi and New York, New York needed to know where they could receive service without fear of discrimination just as much as black visitors of those places. People planned where they ate, stopped for gas, and listened to music based on whether or not the establishment welcomed black people­–regardless of whether they were traveling across the country or across town. At bottom, the “Green Book” represented an attempt to facilitate mobility of black people and provides one poignant example of the ways in which access to public accommodation is inextricably connected to the right of intrastate travel. Following the constitutional and statutory victories of the Civil Rights Movement, the “Green Book” ceased publication, implying that its publishers believed that these new legal mandates guaranteed black people the full benefits of citizenship–a promise not yet fulfilled.</p><p><em>Thirteenth Amendment</em></p><p>“<em>Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction. Section 2. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.”</em></p><p>The right to free movement in places of public accommodation is also one protected by both sections of the Thirteenth Amendment. The Supreme Court has held that the Thirteenth Amendment also seeks to eradicate the “badges and incidents of slavery.”<a href="#_edn34">[34]</a> The common contemporary understanding is that Section 1 prohibits slavery and involuntary servitude in the strictest sense, while Section 2 enables Congress to legislate in order to eliminate slavery’s “badges and incidents.”<a href="#_edn35">[35]</a> Despite this common reading of the amendment, there is academic and historical support for a conception of Section 1 that includes the “badges and incidents” in addition to prohibiting slavery in the strict sense.<a href="#_edn36">[36]</a> One such conception views “badges and incidents” as components of the slavery addressed in Section 1.<a href="#_edn37">[37]</a></p><p>Conversations during the drafting of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 support a broad understanding of “slavery” as defined by the Amendment. Representative Martin Russell Thayer maintained that the Thirteenth Amendment declared “not only that feature of slavery shall be abolished which permitted the purchase and sale of men, women, and little children as slaves, but that all features of slavery which are oppressive in their character, which extinguish the rights of free citizens, and which unlawfully control their liberty, shall be abolished and destroyed forever.”<a href="#_edn38">[38]</a> Another statement of support for the power of Section 1 to prohibit the badges and incidents of slavery came from Senator William M. Stewart, who contended that the Thirteenth Amendment conferred “freedom [on the negro], and that implies that he shall have all the civil rights necessary to the enjoyment of that freedom.” Representative Donelly put it plainly, saying “he who is not entirely free is necessarily a slave”, supporting the notion that freedom from physical bondage also mandated freedom from political and social bondage.<a href="#_edn39">[39]</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/1*eP3PykWm1CQqrKS7-v2mdA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Certificate of Freedom of Harriet Bolling, Petersburg, Virginia, 1851. Carter G. Woodson Collection, <a href="https://www.loc.gov/rr/mss/">Manuscript Division</a>, Library of Congress</figcaption></figure><p>If one accepts this more expansive reading of Section 1, it becomes clear that restrictions of movement and denial of public accommodation were clearly components of slavery and therefore, are part of the badges and incidents that the Thirteenth Amendment prohibits. Restriction of movement was a necessary component of slavery. Enslaved persons traveling needed to present “passes” in order to demonstrate that they, in fact, had permission to travel.<a href="#_edn40">[40]</a> This restriction of movement was not limited to slaves. Free black people were forced to carry their “free papers” with them at all times in order to demonstrate that they were, in fact, free.<a href="#_edn41">[41]</a> All sectors of society participated in this restriction of movement. Anyone, law enforcement, or otherwise could stop a black person and demand to see his or her papers or pass. Fugitive Slave Laws mandated the return of people deemed runaways­–put simply, these laws demanded the return of anyone who could not present a paper demonstrating they had permission to be moving freely. At its ugliest, the societal custom of restricting the movement of black people allowed those who were free to be sold in slavery–simply for exercising their right to freedom of movement.<a href="#_edn42">[42]</a></p><p>By restricting movement, slavery also restricted access to places of public accommodation. Subsequent denials of public accommodation on the basis of race during Reconstruction and onward consistently reinforced the badges and incidents of past slavery by restricting the means of movement afforded to black people.<a href="#_edn43">[43]</a> These incidents demonstrate how the denial of public accommodation restricts the movement of black people, relegating them to second-class status and exacerbating community-wide wounds left by slavery.</p><p><strong>Violation of the Right: Strategic 911 Calls</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*wOpdc5XbTXZL3dyMKoYHXw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jennifer Schulte, the Woman Dubbed “BBQ Becky” (MICHELLE DIONE/YOUTUBE)</figcaption></figure><p>Having explored the constitutional bases protecting the right to public accommodation, we now focus on the impact of strategic 911 calls on that right. First, the use of strategic 911 calls necessarily restrict the right of movement. Judge Rogers’ opinion in <em>Hutchins v. District of Columbia </em>acknowledged a fundamental right to move in public spaces “without subjecting oneself to police custody.” Implicit in Rogers’ statement is the understanding that if people cannot move in public spaces without fear of police interaction, their movement becomes severely restricted. This is compounded when one considers the impact of police brutality on the black psyche.<a href="#_edn44">[44]</a> Black people make up a disproportionate number of victims of police violence and police interaction. Just as fear of racial discrimination prompted people to look to “Green Books” for guidance, fear of police violence forces black people to make a frustrating calculus before they decide whether to frequent certain establishments–a calculus that white people do not need to make. In the modern era, the absence of <em>de jure </em>segregation complicates this calculus. Unlike a lunch counter in the Jim Crow South, there is not a “Colored” entrance outside of Starbucks. Often, people are not aware that they will face unprompted discrimination until they arrive at an establishment and by then, it may be too late. Routine interactions with law enforcement can become deadly for black people in a matter of seconds.<a href="#_edn45">[45]</a> When white people call the police on black people in places of public accommodation, they are playing with our lives.</p><p><em>Badges and Incidents of Slavery</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/571/1*dLLSg9APl0kNwLCpzjzKVg.png" /><figcaption>“Slave pass”, issued to a slave named Alfred circa 1845, was proof of license to travel in and around Washington DC. , “I Will Be Heard”: Abolitionism in America, Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library</figcaption></figure><p>“That citizens can walk the streets, without explanations or formal papers, is surely among the cherished liberties that distinguish this nation from so many others.”</p><p><em>-</em> <em>Gomez v. Turner</em>, 672 F.2d 134, 143–44 n.18 (D.C. Cir. 1982)</p><p>The above-cited quote gets to the heart of why the denial of the right of public accommodation reinforces the badges and incidents of slavery. While the right to movement without interference is firmly engrained in the traditions of this nation, this right was noticeably absent for black people. 911 calls in places of public accommodation reinforce the badges and incidents of slavery for two reasons. First, the violation of free movement and the stripping of dignity attached to it are reminiscent of slavery. Second, the involvement of law enforcement is comparable to slave patrols and the enforcement of fugitive slave laws. Strategic 911 calls and the subsequent law enforcement interaction harken back to the antebellum south, where law enforcement stopped black people at will. In addition to law enforcement, white citizens could also self-deputize themselves and ask for one’s “pass” or “free papers.” Today, strategic 911 calls allow white civilians to self-deputize by beginning the searching inquiry to figure out whether or not a black person “belongs”. Similar to the use of passes and free papers, 911 calls contain the implicit assumption that black people moving throughout white spaces need permission. This inquiry culminates with the arrival of law enforcement who arrive ready to inquire into a black person’s purpose, often taking the white caller’s claim at face value. A quick aside–when strategic 911 calls take place in <em>black </em>spaces that white<em> </em>people take it upon themselves to gentrify (for example, Flatbush in Brooklyn and Oakland), this assumption drips of irony.<a href="#_edn46">[46]</a> Strategic 911 calls center the comfort of white people over the freedom and dignity of black people, reminding us that despite America’s progress, many vestiges of slavery remain.</p><p><strong>Enforcement</strong></p><p>Even when accepting the above construction of the freedom of movement and the right to public accommodation, one is still faced with the question of enforcement. The contemporary understanding of the Fourteenth Amendment only protects people from violations committed by the state or its agents, rather than by private actors. The Thirteenth Amendment is not subject to this barrier as it reaches private action. However, the above conception of badges and incidents of slavery being encompassed within Section 1 of the Amendment is less common. The common understanding of badges and incidents of slavery does not preclude enforcement of the right to public accommodation; rather, this understanding conceives of badges and incidents as things that Congress can legislate against, as prohibited by Section 1. Given current political gridlock and the fact that Congress has already passed public accommodation legislation under its Commerce power, it is unlikely that it would seek to pass any meaningful legislation that fully embraces the Thirteenth Amendment and the Radical Reconstruction.</p><p>There is potential that a reframing of the state action doctrine that conceives of state inaction­–i.e. the state’s failure to prevent or penalize private actors who deny others of their right to public accommodation–as state action under the Fourteenth Amendment could allow for judicial enforcement of the right. We do not explore that concept here. However, given the makeup of the Supreme Court, the state action doctrine would not be the end of the hurdles facing those who seek to enforce the right to public accommodation.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Strategic 911 calls are a poignant example of how the denial of the right to public accommodation persists. The systematic denial of access to places of public accommodation demonstrates the need to elevate the constitutional status of the right. The right of travel and the Thirteenth Amendment provide valuable frameworks and constitutional bases for the right. Future efforts may also want to consider what constitutional bases exist for articulating access to public accommodation as a stand-alone right. Given the current makeup of the federal government and the federal courts, enforcement of the right under any of the posited constitutional bases will be of special importance. While this piece does not represent an exhaustive exploration of ways to assert the right, I hope it will serve as a useful tool for those seeking to help members of marginalized communities attain the promise of full citizenship.</p><p><a href="#_ednref1">[1]</a> David A. Love, <em>Is 911 Still a Joke for African-Americans?</em>, The Grio (Apr. 23, 2014), <a href="https://thegrio.com/2014/04/23/is-911-still-a-joke-for-african-americans/">https://thegrio.com/2014/04/23/is-911-still-a-joke-for-african-americans/.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref2">[2]</a> Mina Kaji, <em>Woman Defends Herself After Video Shows Her Refusing to Let Black Man into His Own Apartment Building</em>, ABC News (Oct. 17, 2018, 11:03 AM), <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/US/woman-defends-video-shows-refusing-black-man-apartment/story?id=58555536.">https://abcnews.go.com/US/woman-defends-video-shows-refusing-black-man-apartment/story?id=58555536.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref3">[3]</a> <em>Listen: 911 Call Confirms ‘Permit Patty’ Called Police on Girl Selling Water</em>, ABC 7 (June 30, 2018), <a href="https://abc7.com/society/listen-911-call-confirms-permit-patty-called-police-on-girl-selling-water/3681028/">https://abc7.com/society/listen-911-call-confirms-permit-patty-called-police-on-girl-selling-water/3681028/.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref4">[4]</a> P.R. Lockhart, <em>A Black Political Candidate was Canvassing in Her District. Then Someone Called the Police</em>, Vox (Sept. 20, 2018, 3:20 PM), <a href="https://www.vox.com/identities/2018/9/20/17883018/shelia-stubbs-canvassing-911-police-racial-profiling-wisconsin.">https://www.vox.com/identities/2018/9/20/17883018/shelia-stubbs-canvassing-911-police-racial-profiling-wisconsin.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref5">[5]</a> Gianluca Mezzofiore, <em>A White Woman Called Police on Black People Barbecuing. This is How the Community Responded</em>, CNN (May 22, 2018), <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/22/us/white-woman-black-people-oakland-bbq-trnd/index.html.">https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/22/us/white-woman-black-people-oakland-bbq-trnd/index.html.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref6">[6]</a> Matt Stevens, <em>Starbucks C.E.O. Apologizes After Arrest of 2 Black Men, </em>N.Y. Times, Apr. 15, 2018, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/15/us/starbucks-philadelphia-black-men-arrest.html?module=inline.">https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/15/us/starbucks-philadelphia-black-men-arrest.html?module=inline.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref7">[7]</a> Gina Martinez, <em>Woman Dubbed ‘Cornerstore Caroline’ </em>Faces Backlash After Falsely Accusing 9-Year-Old Boy of Sexual Assault (Oct. 16, 2018), <a href="http://time.com/5426067/cornerstore-caroline-backlash-sexual-assault-boy/;">http://time.com/5426067/cornerstore-caroline-backlash-sexual-assault-boy/;</a> <em>See also</em> <em>Shop and Frisk: NYPD and Barneys Accused of Racial Profiling</em>, WNYC News (Oct. 24, 2013), <a href="https://www.wnyc.org/story/shop-and-frisk-nypd-and-barneys-accused-racial-profiling/">https://www.wnyc.org/story/shop-and-frisk-nypd-and-barneys-accused-racial-profiling/.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref8">[8]</a> Jeff Wiltse, <em>“Get Out, Little Punks”: Recent Racist Incidents at Swimming Pools Have a Long History</em>, Vox (July 11, 11, 2018, 8:20 AM), <a href="https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2018/7/11/17556342/adam-bloom-pool-patrol-paula-video-racist.">https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2018/7/11/17556342/adam-bloom-pool-patrol-paula-video-racist.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref9">[9]</a> Tamar Lapin, <em>‘Target Teresa’ Caught on Video Harassing Black Customers</em>, N.Y. Post, Dec. 4, 2018, <a href="https://nypost.com/2018/12/04/target-teresa-caught-on-video-harassing-black-customers/">https://nypost.com/2018/12/04/target-teresa-caught-on-video-harassing-black-customers/.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref10">[10]</a> <em>State Public Accommodation Laws</em>, National Conference of State Legislatures (July 13, 2016), <a href="http://www.ncsl.org/research/civil-and-criminal-justice/state-public-accommodation-laws.aspx."><em>http</em>://www.ncsl.org/research/civil-and-criminal-justice/state-public-accommodation-laws.aspx.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref11">[11]</a> Mark Moran, <em>Study Exposes Mental Health Effects of Police Shootings on Black Communities</em>, Psychiatric News (July 31, 2018), <a href="https://psychnews.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/appi.pn.2018.7b3">https://psychnews.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/appi.pn.2018.7b3</a> (noting that study’s estimates “imply that the police killings of unarmed black Americans could contribute 1.7 additional poor mental health days per year among black American adults in the [United States]”).</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">[12]</a> <em>United States v. Guest</em>, 383 U.S. 745, 757–58 (1966); <em>See also</em> <em>Shapiro v. Thompson</em>, 349 U.S. 618 (1969).</p><p><a href="#_ednref13">[13]</a> <em>Guest</em>, 383 U.S. at 759.</p><p><a href="#_ednref14">[14]</a> <em>Saenz v. Roe</em>, 526 U.S. 489, 500 (1999).</p><p><a href="#_ednref15">[15]</a> <em>Saenz</em>, 526 U.S. at 501, 504.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">[16]</a> <em>See Memorial Hospital v. Maricopa County, </em>415 U.S. 250, 255–56 (1974).</p><p><a href="#_ednref17">[17]</a> <em>See Guest</em>, 383 U.S. at 757 (“The constitutional right to travel from one state to another . . . occupies a position fundamental to the concept of our Federal Union. It is a right that has been firmly established and repeatedly recognized.”); <em>Saenz</em>, 526 U.S. at 498<em> </em>(describing the constitutional right to travel as “firmly embedded” in the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence); <em>Shapiro</em>, 394 U.S. at 649 (Stewart, J. concurring) (The right to travel is<em> “</em>assertable against private interference as well as government action . . . . a virtually unconditional personal right, guaranteed by the Constitution to us all.”);<em> Papachirstou v. City of Jacksonville</em>, 405 U.S. 156, 164 (1972)(characterizing freedom of movement as “historically part of the amenities of life as we have known them.”); <em>City of Chicago v. Morales</em>, 527 U.S. 41, 54 (1999) (“Indeed it is apparent that an individual’s decision to remain in a public place of his choice is as much a part of his liberty as the freedom of movement in frontiers is part of our heritage, or the right to move to whatsoever place one’s own inclination may direct’ identified in Blackstone’s Commentaries.”).</p><p><a href="#_ednref18">[18]</a> <em>See King v. New Rochelle Municipal Housing Authority</em>, 442 F.2d 646, 648 (2d Cir. 1971); <em>Lutz v. York</em>, 899 F.2d 255,268 (3d Cir. 1990);<em> Johnson v. City of Cincinnati</em>, 310 F.3d 484, 498 (6th Cir. 2002).</p><p><a href="#_ednref19">[19]</a> <em>Spencer v. Casavilla</em>, 903 F.2d 171,174 (2d Cir. 1990)(“Our Court has held that the Constitution also protects the right to travel freely within a single state.”); <em>Hutchins v. District of Columbia</em>, 188 F.3d 531, 561–62 (D.C. Cir. 1999)(Rogers, J. dissenting in part, concurring in part, joined by Tatel and Wald, JJ.)(“Precedents recognize a fundamental right to walk through public streets without thereby subjecting oneself to police custody.”).</p><p><a href="#_ednref20">[20]</a>[20] <em>King v. New Rochelle Municipal Housing Authority</em>, 442 F.2d 646, 648 (2d Cir. 1971).</p><p><a href="#_ednref21">[21]</a> <em>Lutz v. York</em>, 899 F.2d 255,268 (3d Cir. 1990).</p><p><a href="#_ednref22">[22]</a> <em>Johnson</em>, 310 F.3d at 495.</p><p><a href="#_ednref23">[23]</a> <em>United States v. Wheeler</em>, 254 U.S. 281, 293 (1920).</p><p><a href="#_ednref24">[24]</a> <em>Smith v. Turner</em>, 48 U.S. 283, 492 (1849) (Taney, C.J. dissenting).</p><p><a href="#_ednref25">[25]</a> <em>Johnson v. City of Cincinnati</em>, 310 F.3d 484, 498 (6th Cir. 2002).</p><p><a href="#_ednref26">[26]</a> <em>See King</em>, 442 F.2d 646 (addressing validity of a durational residency requirement); <em>Lutz</em>, 899 F.2d 255 (addressing an ordinance restricting cruising around certain major public roads in the city); <em>Johnson</em>, 310 F.3d 484 (addressing an ordinance that excluded persons convicted of certain drug offenses from certain zones of the city).</p><p><a href="#_ednref27">[27]</a> <em>Bell v. Maryland</em>, 378 U.S. 226, 255 (1964).</p><p><a href="#_ednref28">[28]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref29">[29]</a> <em>Bryant v. City of Cayce</em>, 2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 136212 at *9 (D.S.C. 2010) (“No circuit has extended that right to intrastate travel to include a ‘right of access to public accommodation.’”).</p><p><a href="#_ednref30">[30]</a> <em>Williams v. Town of Greenburgh</em>, 535 F.3d 71, 75 (2d Cir. 2008).</p><p><a href="#_ednref31">[31]</a> <em>Johnson</em>, 310 F.3d at 495.</p><p><a href="#_ednref32">[32]</a> <em>Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States</em>, 379 U.S. 241, 253 (1964) (“we shall not burden this opinion with further details since the voluminous testimony presents overwhelming evidence that discrimination by hotels and motels impedes interstate travel.”).</p><p><a href="#_ednref33">[33]</a> Meredith Mendelsohn, <em>How an Artist Learned About Freedom From ‘The Negro Motorist Green Book’</em>, N.Y. Times, Jan. 19, 2018, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/19/arts/design/how-an-artist-learned-about-freedom-from-the-negro-motorist-green-book.html.">https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/19/arts/design/how-an-artist-learned-about-freedom-from-the-negro-motorist-green-book.html.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref34">[34]</a> <em>Civil Rights Cases</em>, 109 U.S. 3, 20 (1883).</p><p><a href="#_ednref35">[35]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref36">[36]</a> James Gray Pope, <em>Section 1 of the Thirteenth Amendment and the Badges and Incidents of Slavery</em>, 65 UCLA L. Rev. 426, 428 (2018).</p><p><a href="#_ednref37">[37]</a> <em>Id.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref38">[38]</a> <em>Id. </em>at 440.</p><p><a href="#_ednref39">[39]</a> <em>Id. </em>at 442.</p><p><a href="#_ednref40">[40]</a> <em>Life in Bondage</em>, “I Will be Heard”: Abolitionism in America, <a href="http://rmc.library.cornell.edu/abolitionism/slave_life/Life_in_Bondage.htm.">http://rmc.library.cornell.edu/abolitionism/slave_life/Life_in_Bondage.htm.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref41">[41]</a> <em>Free Blacks in the Antebellum Period</em>, Library of Congress, <a href="https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/african-american-odyssey/free-blacks-in-the-antebellum-period.html.">https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/african-american-odyssey/free-blacks-in-the-antebellum-period.html.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref42">[42]</a> <em>See Solomon Northup</em>, Encyclopedia Britannica, <a href="https://www.britannica.com/biography/Solomon-Northup.">https://www.britannica.com/biography/Solomon-Northup.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref43">[43]</a> <em>See Civil Rights Cases</em>, 109 U.S. 3 (1883); <em>Decuir v. Benson</em>, 27 La. Ann. 1 (1875).</p><p><a href="#_ednref44">[44]</a> <em>See supra </em>note 11.</p><p><a href="#_ednref45">[45]</a> <em>See e.g. </em>David A. Graham, <em>The Second Amendment’s Second Class Citizens</em>, The Atlantic, July 7, 2016, <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/07/alton-sterling-philando-castile-2nd-amendment-guns/490301/;">https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/07/alton-sterling-philando-castile-2nd-amendment-guns/490301/;</a> Frances Robles, Alan Blinder &amp; Jason Grant, <em>After 8 Shots in North Charleston, Michael Slager Becomes and Officer Scorned</em>, N.Y. Times, Apr. 12, 2015, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/13/us/after-8-shots-a-quiet-officer-now-scorned.html?module=inline.">https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/13/us/after-8-shots-a-quiet-officer-now-scorned.html?module=inline.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref46">[46]</a> <em>See </em>Gina Martinez, <em>Woman Dubbed ‘Cornerstore Caroline’ </em>Faces Backlash After Falsely Accusing 9-Year-Old Boy of Sexual Assault (Oct. 16, 2018), <a href="http://time.com/5426067/cornerstore-caroline-backlash-sexual-assault-boy/;">http://time.com/5426067/cornerstore-caroline-backlash-sexual-assault-boy/;</a> Gianluca Mezzofiore, <em>A White Woman Called Police on Black People Barbecuing. This is How the Community Responded</em>, CNN (May 22, 2018), <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/22/us/white-woman-black-people-oakland-bbq-trnd/index.html.">https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/22/us/white-woman-black-people-oakland-bbq-trnd/index.html.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=470163265433" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/911-is-a-joke-the-systematic-denial-of-public-accommodation-through-the-use-of-strategic-911-calls-470163265433">911 is a Joke: The Systematic Denial of Public Accommodation Through the Use of Strategic 911 Calls</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation">criticalnarratives.publicaccommodation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Antidiscrimination and Public Accommodation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/antidiscrimination-and-public-accommodation-89ddabcf599f?source=rss----8522888061bd---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89ddabcf599f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[latin-america]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carlos Andres Baquero diaz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Dec 2018 05:28:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-10T15:53:28.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Antidiscrimination and Public Accommodation: Legal reforms towards equality in Latin America</strong></h3><p><strong>I. Introduction:</strong></p><p>Is there a right to public accommodation in countries different than the United States? Specifically, how is the discussion about egalitarian access to public spaces and services in Latin America? Do black people, the LGBTIQ community and indigenous peoples suffer discrimination in access to bars, restaurants or public squares?</p><p>This paper presents some answers to the latest questions. The main objective is to show how the fundamental right to public accommodation is built in Latin America. To achieve the goal, the text is divided in four main sections. In the first one, I present recent cases in Colombia, Chile and Peru that highlight the debate and open the question for comparison. The second section faces the debate about the effectiveness of Law as a useful tool to combat discrimination. On the third part, I will show how different States created legal reforms to guarantee the fundamental right to public accommodation. Finally, on the fourth section, I will conclude and develop some questions for future comparative research on the issue of public accommodation.</p><p><strong>II.</strong> <strong>Public accommodation in South America:</strong></p><p>April, 2008. Bogotá, Colombia. Marvín Carabalí, Jordan Viveros, Paola Ortíz, Edna Martínez, Fatimah William and Aiden Salgado, a group of six Afro-descendant young people, went out to party in an exclusive neighborhood of the city. All of them, as was stated by one of the petitioners of the case, were well dress, following the “social norms” for this type of places. However, in every of the three bars they tried to get in, the bouncers told them: “This is a private party” or “Did you have the ID to prove that you are partners of this establishment?”<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. Time and again, their access to private places were denied when, in front of them, other mestizo or white people were getting in the bars without any constraints.</p><p>After a long juridical dispute in front of the District Court and the Colombian Supreme Court, the plaintiffs won the case<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>. The Court<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> argued that their access was denied because of their skin color and ordered the bars to stop denying access to people based on race, and to offer public apologies to the six plaintiffs. The Court also ordered the national and local governments to create programs against discrimination of black people in the country. This decision set a point in the juridical battle of Afro-descendant people in Colombia to have plenty access to public spaces.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*sIQfL2uZE2vRppMX3cJ_RQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: TeleSur (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.telesurtv.net/news/CIDH-Colombia-debe-eliminar-el-racismo-en-la-protesta-social-20170614-0054.html">https://www.telesurtv.net/news/CIDH-Colombia-debe-eliminar-el-racismo-en-la-protesta-social-20170614-0054.html</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>March, 2012. Santiago de Chile, Chile. As one of the most Catholic cities in the continent, Santiago de Chile has a long history of public discrimination against the LGBTIQ community. Daniel Zamudio was a twenty-four years old gay Chilean man when he was murdered by a group of Neo-nazis. Daniel was walking in Santiago’s downtown when four other young men beat him in public because he was gay<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>. The attack was so violent that he died after three weeks in a public hospital.</p><p>Zamudio’s case opens a legal discussion to guarantee the LGBTIQ community rights to live safely in the country. Given how shocking the case was, Congress passed a law, the Zamudio Act<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a>, condemning the attack of this young man and looking for the protection of all the communities that suffer daily attacks in a highly homophobic context. Among the measures, Congress changed the criminal code to include an aggravating clause in the cases were the attack was founded in discriminatory intends like homophobia.</p><p>January, 2018. Lima, Peru. “What can I do to find the keys for success?”<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a> That is the phrase that opens one of the shows of Paisana Jacinta, a popular two-decade Peruvian T.V. show that has as the main character a man dressed up as an indigenous woman. In the show the person makes fun of indigenous peoples by embracing the social stereotypes that make them look like weak, silly and ignorant. Although the show has been criticized, Jacinta passed from television to the cinema.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/501/1*bvtNViPJCmt-w8mE__4GDw.png" /><figcaption>Source: El Popular (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.elpopular.pe/actualidad-policiales/2018-11-28-jueza-ordena-suspender-programa-paisana-jacinta)">https://www.elpopular.pe/actualidad-policiales/2018-11-28-jueza-ordena-suspender-programa-paisana-jacinta)</a></figcaption></figure><p>When Jacinta’s movie was released at the beginning of 2018, the social discussion about it grows in the media. For example, Tania Pariona, an indigenous leader and congresswoman, expressed that the movie and the main character were “a form of discrimination towards the 55 native populations that live in our country”<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>. In a context where issues related to free speech and access to entertainment have been addressed by conservative social sectors, Jacinta received more than 500,000 views in the national cinemas. How can this happen in a country with more than four million indigenous persons according to the 2007 data?<a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a></p><p>The denial of access to public accommodation –having access to private spaces, public spaces or media — is an ongoing difficult question that a lot of Latin-American countries are facing. Due to the constant critiques presented by social movements against this reality, the legal field has been changing in the last few years. Using the frame of anti-discrimination agenda, some countries have been doing legal reforms to prohibit attacks and guarantee rights of discriminated populations.</p><p><strong>2.1. How to frame the question in South America?</strong></p><p>Why has it been so difficult to do legal reforms in Latin America? Academic literature has found at least two answers to the question. First, some countries –like Brazil and Colombia — are politically and socially founded under the myth of racial democracy (Múnera, 2005). According to this myth, due to the colonialism process, the entire population is racially mixed between indigenous peoples, African-descents and Europeans. This myth creates a legal and political denial to attack discrimination because it supposedly dissolves the racial tension in the general society. There could not be discrimination because everyone recognizes each other as equal and thus they would not act against themselves. State responsibility, from this framework, ends with the constitutional recognition of the equality between persons but cannot go beyond because people are mixed in a racially happy democratic system (Rodríguez, Alfonso and Cavelier, 2006).</p><p>In other countries, like Argentina and Chile, the myth acts as a denial. According to this idea, there is no racial discrimination because there are not black people in those countries. They found their historical narrative on the idea that they do not have black people, and so it is impossible to discriminate them. A similar and more contemporary discourse of this myth can be seen in the social conversation against the LGBTIQ community. According to this logic, States cannot act because there is no social exclusion to solve.</p><p>Both of the myths are false, create barriers to State action, and are politically used by some social groups to inhibit interventions. That is why States, to do any political intervention, need to recognize they are myths. After doing this political recognition of the discriminated groups, States can start doing legal reforms to protect them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/493/1*ha25Yaufwjiq2PbL8-zisw.png" /><figcaption>Source: lgbtqnation.com (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2013/10/four-chilean-men-found-guilty-in-brutal-murder-of-gay-man/">https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2013/10/four-chilean-men-found-guilty-in-brutal-murder-of-gay-man/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2.2.</strong> <strong>Why talking about comparison matters?</strong></p><p>If this is the scenario, it can look very much like a domestic discussion of Latin American countries without any relationship to countries outside of the region. Nevertheless, one of the main<strong> </strong>aims of this text is to present the Latin-American experience as a way to enrich the global discussion of how to substantially guarantee people’s right to public accommodation. For this objective are, at least, three main reasons.</p><p>First, there is a political reason related with the creation of data about discrimination in different countries. Many practitioners, advocates and social leaders have difficulties arguing cases related with discrimination because they do not have the <em>hard</em> data to prove that a specific action is not an isolated violation but part of a systematic and structural system. Having this data for different countries is useful to have the conversation in comparative terms so advocates can know what is going in other countries and advance on a shared agenda against discrimination.</p><p>Second, legal imagination expands with the comparative process. The legal and political reforms that countries are doing can be useful in different contexts. Sharing experiences and knowing what others States are doing might be helpful to see if a solution can be implemented in other circumstances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*82vSygAPT1_EnP_v_3fdjQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: The New York Times (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/es/2016/10/21/la-marcha-de-las-mujeres-en-argentina-formacion-de-una-tribu/">https://www.nytimes.com/es/2016/10/21/la-marcha-de-las-mujeres-en-argentina-formacion-de-una-tribu/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Finally, a better comparison between different countries enables a global conversation that is useful to break ideas of legal and political exceptionalism that are rooted in some countries. The global conversation is particularly relevant for the United States because the idea of exceptionalism creates two impacts on the legal field. On the one hand, exceptionalism creates a distance between US social leaders and communities with their counterparts in other parts of the world. Making them part of the same conversation is useful to build a strong fort for the fundamental right to public accommodation. On the other hand, the distance created by the United States is a way to maintain a colonial relationship with the rest of the world. When the local context breaks relationships with other countries, it is sacralizing their experience and denying the exchange with other actors. At the end, this position does not change the situation of political subordination that the legal the US system tries to impose all over the world. For these reasons this paper creates a global conversation and brings some ideas to the US context about how to advance in the recognition of public accommodation as a fundamental right.</p><p><strong>III. Solutions from social movements and political actors:</strong></p><p>In Latin America, as an archetypical discussion<a href="#_ftn9">[9]</a>, there is a previous conversation of whether the Law is a significant tool to end social and political discrimination suffered by groups like indigenous peoples or African-descendants. Even tough it is a long debate between the social movements and the State I will summarize it following the two main poles of this conversation. Social and political actors move in a spectrum that goes from believing that law is effective to change reality to the other pole that focuses their attention on non-legal tools.</p><p><strong>3.1. The problem and the solution are a juridical debate:</strong></p><p>Some social movements — like indigenous peoples and women organizations — explained that discrimination occurs because the State has not been diligent in the sanction of these behaviors. From this shore, the State’s responsibility and possibility to transform the situation is enormous because it can change behavior with its intervention. For example, discrimination occurs because there are not sufficient legal consequences that sanction it.</p><p>One of the paradigmatic examples of this perspective is the Colombian Act against discrimination. This Act was presented by a right wing Christian party called Mira<a href="#_ftn10">[10]</a> to create criminal sanctions for racial discrimination and other causes of discrimination like religion. The legislative procedure counts with social support from some historical organizations like Movimiento Cimarrón and the Centro de Reconocimiento Afrocolombiano<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a>. At the same time, the political party launched a campaign called <em>I am Afro-friendly, and you?</em><a href="#_ftn12">[12]</a><em>,</em> to channel black peoples’ support. Beyond the political tensions created on the legislative route, some organizations believed that Law could be useful to combat social discrimination. Their objective, overall, was to change the criminal law to create severe norms that prohibit discriminatory acts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*fRWEzi-v0WKBGP05kBISZw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Fundación AfroAmigos (Retrieve from: <a href="https://twitter.com/soyafroamigo">https://twitter.com/soyafroamigo</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>3.2. The problem and the solutions are a cultural debate:</strong></p><p>Some other social organizations understood that Law ands its reform is not a useful tool to combat social discrimination. From this bench, what the political actors and even the State need to do, is to focus their efforts on more structural social interventions that eliminate discriminatory practices. For example, some of the organizations in this group argue for a better protection of public education<a href="#_ftn13">[13]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*1kACWRqGiGunp5_BZK1Uvg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Blanco Porcelana Exposition (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.radionacional.co/noticia/exposici-n-blanco-porcelana-de-la-artista-margarita-aguilar-llega-cali">https://www.radionacional.co/noticia/exposici-n-blanco-porcelana-de-la-artista-margarita-aguilar-llega-cali</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Social organizations and movements — like black peoples’ organizations — argue that discrimination occurs because people are being educated in a way that does not recognize others as equals. For this to change, society must transform other social areas like education or job markets.</p><p>Their critique goes further because it moves the discussion into the effectiveness of criminal law as a tool that recognizes and empowers the people that it is trying to protect. From this perspective, Law is not a useful tool and, contrarily, it will impose discrimination against the ones that suffer it the most. Criminal reform is only a valuable State tool to legitimate violence in cases related with public accommodation.</p><p><strong>IV. Solutions from the State: Changing Legal regimes</strong></p><p><strong>4.1. Constitutional reforms</strong></p><p>The legal debate about the reforms to guarantee the right to public accommodation, in Latin America, was preceded by one of the most spectacular legal changes in the continent: the multicultural constitutionalism of the end of the 20th century (Bonilla, 2015). With some fundamental differences within the region, the constitutions suffered transformations that diversified who are recognized as a citizen and their relationships with the State.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*6mwdLVcvHZINgiGcfKDuig.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Outrapolitica.com (Retrieve from: <a href="https://outrapolitica.wordpress.com/2010/04/06/ecuador-movimiento-indigena-y-la-revolucion-ciudadana/">https://outrapolitica.wordpress.com/2010/04/06/ecuador-movimiento-indigena-y-la-revolucion-ciudadana/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>According to the literature<a href="#_ftn14">[14]</a>, the multicultural constitutionalism has –for the objective of this paper — five main elements that changed the legal panorama in the region. These changes show that the states are willing to respond to more diverse constituencies that go beyond the white-owner-male that found the Constitutions in the 19th century (Lemaitre, 2012).</p><p>First, the new Constitutions changed the understating of the national unity, recognizing more institutional subjects. As a consequence, many of the Constitutions recognize the state as multiethnic or multicultural. Second, these Constitutions also included the diversity and religious equality. As a way to enhance the social and political recognition of other ways of being, these Constitutions break their Catholic dependence to Rome and allow cultural diversity of populations. Third, the Constitutions also have specific provisions to protect historically discriminated communities like indigenous peoples, women, and Afro-descendants communities. As historical reparation, this legal recognition opens a space for the construction of legal regimes that bring better life conditions to these groups. Fourth, Constitutions also break the one-dimensional existence of the State and recognized other authorities and jurisdictions over the same territory. For example, constitutions in Bolivia, Colombia and Ecuador recognize that indigenous peoples authorities can judge actions. Fifth, “(…) many Constitutions express a strong commitment to equality, not only prohibiting discrimination on [the] grounds of race, gender, and other factors, but also ordering special affirmative action policies to make equality real and effective””<a href="#_ftn15">[15]</a>. This last element opens space for the creation of legal regimes against discrimination.</p><p>In the coming section I will focus on the public policies and legal reforms that were created to implement equality and non-discrimination. Most of them, like in the discussion of the Enforcement Acts in the United States, aim to guarantee real equality in access to public places and services by creating criminal reforms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Jm3Pul8Dc0qfNxlJ0eHFCA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: El Furgon (Retrieve from: <a href="http://elfurgon.com.ar/2016/12/19/buen-vivir-segun-las-mujeres-de-pueblos-originarios/">http://elfurgon.com.ar/2016/12/19/buen-vivir-segun-las-mujeres-de-pueblos-originarios/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>4.2. Promulgation of Acts and other types of norms to solve discrimination:</strong></p><p>Latin American states have solved the question about equality to access and the prohibition discrimination using two legal interventions, following the camp that thinks that law has a transformative power. On the one hand, some States have created criminal law that aims to guarantee equality between persons. For example, similarly to the Third Enforcement Act in the United States, some of these articles protected historically discriminated groups creating criminal norms that include higher sanctions for persons that discriminate based on race, gender, sexual orientation or ethnicity. On the other hand, other states have created norms to guarantee equality by the implementation of administrative norms that aim to protect the same groups implementing systems like affirmative action programs<a href="#_ftn16">[16]</a>. One of the elements that literature<a href="#_ftn17">[17]</a> has shown is that the criminal repertoire has been used more often by the States than the use of remedies like the affirmative actions because they are cheaper in political and social terms compared to programs that combat structural discriminatory systems.</p><p>Except for Paraguay, all Latin American countries<a href="#_ftn18">[18]</a> have done national reforms to include criminal laws that prohibit racial discrimination<a href="#_ftn19">[19]</a>. These reforms are done because of political pressure made by social movements and political parties to materialize constitutional reforms.</p><p>Until now, Latin-American countries have adopted two systems based on criminal resolution against discrimination. On the one hand<a href="#_ftn20">[20]</a>, countries created criminal norms that specifically condemn racial discrimination. Cuba, El Salvador and Venezuela are in this group. For example, the Cuban case highlights the legal procedures that prohibit discrimination in public accommodation. In constitutional terms, article 4 of the National Constitution established equality in terms of rights and duties. The same article prohibits any type of discrimination based on race, skin color, sex, national origin or religious beliefs.</p><p>In Cuba, any act of discrimination based on sex, race, color or origin that ends up hindering or preventing the enjoyment of the rights of a person is sanctioned. As a penalty, a person can be punished with deprivation of liberty or economic fines<a href="#_ftn21">[21]</a>. In February 2011, the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination of United Nations asked the Cuban State for information about the implementation of the criminal norms that sanction discrimination. In its own words:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_ZTX3hZ24ArwKudlpTzxBw.png" /><figcaption>Source: Observatorio de Discriminación Racial (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.dejusticia.org/abierta-convocatoria-concurso-de-fotografia-altocontraste/">https://www.dejusticia.org/abierta-convocatoria-concurso-de-fotografia-altocontraste/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>“The Committee regrets that it has not received information on proceedings initiated or sentences handed down during the reporting period for the commission of acts that run counter to the Convention, as provided for by article 295 of the Criminal Code. While the Committee takes note of the delegation’s explanations about the mandate and functions of the Office of the Attorney General of the Republic, it remains concerned by the lack of reported cases, prosecutions and convictions relating to acts of racial discrimination during the reporting period”<a href="#_ftn22">[22]</a>.</p><p>The Cuban case shows how the creation of the criminal norms is just a step in the path of protecting discriminated groups. The promulgation of the criminal act is not enough; it is important to examine their implementation. With a better understanding of how those norms are acting so that States can prove the effectiveness of criminal law in guaranteeing equality for all.</p><p>On the other hand, other countries introduce a complex understanding of the struggle against discrimination and in favor of public accommodation. These norms have a longer<a href="#_ftn23">[23]</a> list of discrimination forms that are prohibited. This is the example of countries like Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Peru, and Uruguay.</p><p>The Mexican case exemplifies this type of legal regimes. Article 149-ter of the Criminal Code sanctions people that discriminate based on origin, ethnicity, race, skin color, tongue, gender, sex or sexual option, age, civil status, national origin, social or economic condition, health, pregnancy, political opinion. The sanctions also include discrimination based on any other issue that harms the human condition, or anyone who eliminates or reduces any right or liberty. Within the scope of the norm, actions that end on the violation of the right to public accommodation are include. Specifically, the article establishes that the crime could be done when someone denies a service, restricts labor rights or the right to education. The sanction will be stronger if a public official commits the crime. In that case, the person will be punished with an administrative process that will end their contract.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/592/1*LybmDgYVlDOH7LyuNwRaDA.png" /><figcaption>Source: Copred CDMX (Retrieve from: <a href="http://data.copred.cdmx.gob.mx/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Placa-No-Discriminaci%C3%B3n-para-Establecimientos-P%C3%BAblicos.pdf">http://data.copred.cdmx.gob.mx/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Placa-No-Discriminaci%C3%B3n-para-Establecimientos-P%C3%BAblicos.pdf</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>The Mexican case also includes the creation of the Act to Prevent and Eliminate Discrimination (Ley para Prevenir y Eliminar la Discriminación, in Spanish). The Act was approved under the Fox administration and even though it protects Mexicans from being discriminated on the bases of gender, sexual orientation and ethnicity, article 4 does not include the prohibition of racial discrimination ignoring the Criminal code. This Act excludes actions that the State can do to eliminate the discrimination suffered by the Afro-Mexican population. Article 9 of this Act presents some examples to understand how discrimination is created in cases like pay gap, limited access to a specific program or bullying.</p><p>The Act also creates a specific office that is in charge of its enforcement. The National Council to Prevent Discrimination (Consejo Nacional para Prevenir la Discriminación –CONAPRED-, in Spanish) is an independent organism that follows the implementation of the Act and enforces the protection of the groups included in the legal reform. For example, the Council is in charge of creating public policies that will protect discriminated groups, investigate discriminatory actors and solve cases. What is interesting about this institution is that it is in charge of investigating discrimination cases and sanctioning conducts. Among the sanctions that the Council can do, there are: courses about non-discrimination, the creation of signs in public spaces prohibiting discrimination, sending Council officers to teach courses, and the publication of the resolution and decision of the Council. If at the end of the investigation, the Council finds that there was no discrimination, it will publish an agreement of non-discrimination.</p><p>After years of the promulgation of the norm, there are cases and denouncements of all types of discrimination against persons protected by the Act. According to Burcio Mújica, former president of the Conapred, discrimination suffered by the LGBTIQ community persists as an ongoing struggle<a href="#_ftn24">[24]</a>.</p><p>Finally, and contrary to all of this reforms, the Paraguay case shows the opposite side of the regional move towards criminal reforms against discrimination. In Paraguay there are two specific reasons why the State has not created a norm for these cases. The first reason is related with the political difficulties. An Act against discrimination has to pass over Congress but there is a lack of political interest to promote a law that prohibits and sanctions discriminatory actions<a href="#_ftn25">[25]</a>. The second reason is that there is social discrimination against groups like indigenous peoples, women and the LGBTIQ community. Because of this social bias, society is not ready to respond to the political pressures and their constitutional and international duties to protect all citizens<a href="#_ftn26">[26]</a>.</p><p><strong>V. Conclusion</strong></p><p>In this paper I show the different responses that states in Latin America have implemented to respond to social, political and legal pressures to guarantee the right to public accommodation. Every country responded to specific pressures and States solutions vary from the inclusion of a constitutional reform to the creation of criminal acts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A_9iqGVtCeuRNVkSqQIYKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Vox (Retrieve from: <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/3/7/14834454/exoneration-innocence-prison-racism">https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/3/7/14834454/exoneration-innocence-prison-racism</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Latin American countries understand the existence of a fundamental right to public accommodation. However, the protection of this right is developed under the right to not be discriminated. The latter opens a space to do constitutional reforms in favor of diversity and criminal changes prohibiting discrimination. For the creation of strategic litigation programs, advocates must have in mind that public accommodation is developed under the umbrella of non-discrimination. Apart from this first conclusion, Latin American cases demonstrated that there is a huge possibility to create litigation activities in favor of the right to public accommodation. What is most important, from this perspective, is to build narratives of the rights that allow judges to bring integral solutions that combat discrimination in a structural way.</p><p>For the comparative debate there are two main questions that have to be solved. On the one hand, there is a question about how to frame mobilizations and juridical changes towards the guarantee of a more egalitarian system. In Latin America, as has been shown in the paper, the frame is the open scheme of antidiscrimination. With the use of this type of legal repertoire, the state aims to include different legal remedies. However, because Law is a field of constant construction of narratives from different actors, this is not the only chance that political actors have to request legal reforms. For example, the field of fundamental rights is being tangentially used in this context. Thinking about narratives and frames for having these debates in every country became a central question to actors arguing for political transformation. The second question is the idea<a href="#_ftn27">[27]</a> of the uses of criminal law as an effective tool to guarantee the right to public accommodation. As has been shown<a href="#_ftn28">[28]</a> the criminal law the creation of these norms can be criticized for two specific reasons. First, the implementation of criminal law affects the same groups that it is trying to protect. The unequal impact of criminal law raises a question about the effectiveness of these tools as a way to solve the problem or as a way to bring more exclusion against those groups. For this reason, the criminal reform can be also another jail for persons that want to be set free with legal transformation.</p><p>The second critique comes from criminal studies. Criminal reforms are populist transformations of the Law that will not be implemented or will create a sense of more protection without doing real transformations on social fields. These critiques explain how changes on criminal law are part of the repertoire of actions used by the State to create a sense of protection and security but never reflect about the implementation of the norms or the creation of sanctions. These can be the research questions that have to be done in places like Cuba.</p><p>If norms are on papers but are not changing the political field, they will create a curtain of distraction to appease political actions against the State. People critique the procedural elements of criminal cases about discrimination. The law requires a transformation of the burden of proof and the way that juridical actors think about basic criminal elements like responsibility or intention. The majority of these cases involve the construction of criminal norms so people will need to rethink criminal law elements to truly open the space for state action. All these critiques must be taken into consideration when other States evaluate the evidence presented in this paper to create legal transformations.</p><p>Finally, the question of how to deal with private and social stereotypical norms overflows the capacity of the law. Thus, more interdisciplinary approaches to the right to public accommodation are urgent to understand social norms. Stereotypes that create fear, rage or disgust need to be tracked to formulate political changes. The transformation of legal regimes is useful if States want to satisfy the right to public accommodation in private or public spaces that are embedded on the public sphere. But these changes have a fainter power on the transformation of private in-house- relationship. On the private and more personal relationships, historically discriminated groups suffer discrimination and for those, there is a debt of research and public scrutiny to fulfill the feminist dream of “democracy in the square and in the bed”<a href="#_ftn29">[29]</a>.</p><p>__________________________________________________________________</p><p><strong>Footnotes</strong></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> See <em>El bar que no acepta negros, Retrieve from: </em><a href="https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/investigacion/el-bar-no-acepta-negros-articulo-637237">https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/investigacion/el-bar-no-acepta-negros-articulo-637237</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> To know more about the case, see the press release Retrieve from: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/454.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/454.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Decision Retrieve from: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/452.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/452.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> <em>See La muerte de un joven gay reabre el debate sobre la homophobia en Chile, Retrieve from: </em><a href="https://elpais.com/sociedad/2012/03/27/actualidad/1332875522_330643.html">https://elpais.com/sociedad/2012/03/27/actualidad/1332875522_330643.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> To know more about the Act, see <a href="https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=1042092&amp;r=2">https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=1042092&amp;r=2</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> See <em>Lo major de la paisa Jacinta, Retrieve from: </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpIp1YKQgFQ">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpIp1YKQgFQ</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> See <em>The Paisana Jacinta Controversy continues to divide Peruvians</em>, Retrieve from: <a href="https://perureports.com/paisana-jacinta-controversy-continues-divide-peruvians/6553/">https://perureports.com/paisana-jacinta-controversy-continues-divide-peruvians/6553/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> See <em>¿Sabemos cuánta población indígena hay en el Perú?</em>, Retrieve from: https://revistaideele.com/ideele/content/¿sabemos-cuánta-población-indígena-hay-en-el-perú</p><p><a href="#_ftnref9">[9]</a> To know more, see Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref10">[10]</a> To see more about the Mira’s proposition, see <a href="http://carlosalbertobaena.com/ley-antidiscriminacion/">http://carlosalbertobaena.com/ley-antidiscriminacion/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref11">[11]</a> To see more about the legislative procedure, see: <a href="https://www.congresovisible.org/agora/post/no-discrimino-pongamos-en-marcha-la-ley-anti-discriminacion/3800/">https://www.congresovisible.org/agora/post/no-discrimino-pongamos-en-marcha-la-ley-anti-discriminacion/3800/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref12">[12]</a> To see more about the campaign, see: <a href="http://congresovisible.org/agora/post/postura-del-movimiento-soy-afro-amigo-y-tu-en-relacion-al-objecion-presidencial-al-proyecto-de-ley-16510-camara-0810-senado-penalizacion-de-la-discriminacion/2673/">http://congresovisible.org/agora/post/postura-del-movimiento-soy-afro-amigo-y-tu-en-relacion-al-objecion-presidencial-al-proyecto-de-ley-16510-camara-0810-senado-penalizacion-de-la-discriminacion/2673/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref13">[13]</a> See for example, education programs: <a href="https://akubadaura.org/lineas-de-trabajo/">https://akubadaura.org/lineas-de-trabajo/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref14">[14]</a> Even thought there is a huge group of literature that explains the Latin-American constitutionalism changes, Uprimny’s perspective brings the best example of the regional trends of these reforms.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref15">[15]</a> Uprimny, 2011, 1592.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref16">[16]</a> Because of the scope of this paper, brining the comparison between the US case and the Latin American case, I do not present the other type of actions that have been created to respond to these issues. Nevertheless, for information about them can check: Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref17">[17]</a> To see more about this debate, see Ikawa, D (2009). <em>The right to affirmative actions for blacks in Brazilian universities</em>. The Equal Rights Review. 3 and Fraser, N and Honneth, A (2004). Redistribution or recognition: A political-philosophical exchange. Verso.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref18">[18]</a> See the following norms: Argentina: Art. 3; Act. 23.925; Art. 2; Act 23.925.Art. 80, Criminal Code and Art. 3, Act. 23.925. Bolivia: Art. 23, 24; Act 045 de 2010, Art. 32 Criminal Code, Art. 21, 22, 23, 24, 26 — Act. 045 de 2010, Art. 23, 24; Act 045/2010; Art. 281 septieser — Criminal Code. Brazil Art. 20, Act 7716/89, Art. 3, num. III y IV Criminal Code, Art. 4, num. VIII, Art. 5, num. XLI, Art.1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 18 — Act. 7716/89, Art. 3 — Act. 7716/89, Art. 20 — Act 7716/89. Chile: Art. 1, 19 Political Constitution, Art. 2, 17. Act. 20609/12 . Colombia: Art. 58 Criminal Code; Art. 4, 5, 6, 7 — Act 1482/011, Art. 58 Criminal Code, Art. 3, 5, 6 — Act 1482/011, Art. 58 Criminal Code, Art. 4, 5, 6 — Act. 1482/011. Costa Rica: Art. 123 bis, 375 Criminal Code, Art. 6. Act 7711/1997, Art. 2 — D. 4230/68, Art. 375 Criminal Code. Cuba: Art. 295,num. 1 and 2., Criminal Code, Art. 295 — Criminal Code, Art. 295, num. 1. Criminal Code. Dominican Republic: Art. 336 y 336–1 — Criminal Code. Ecuador: Art. 212ª, num.. 1, 212c, 212d — Criminal Code, Art. 3, num. 1 Political Constitution, Art. 212ª, 212b, 212e — Criminal Code, Art. 212ª, num. 3, 212d — Criminal Code. El Salvador: Art. 246, 292 Criminal Code. Guatemala: Art. 376, Criminal Code. Art. 202 bis Criminal Code, Art. 377, Criminal Code. Honduras: Art. 60, PC. Art. 321, Criminal Code, Art. 3 Executive Order PCM 09–2007. Mexico: Art. 149 Per, Criminal Code, Art. 149 Per, Criminal Code, Art. 2, CP. Nicaragua: Art. 549 y 550 Criminal Code, Art. 16, 549 Criminal Code, Art. 549 y 550 Criminal Code. Panama Art. 131, num. 3. Criminal Code, Art. 441, num, 8. Criminal Code. Peru Art. 323 — Criminal Code, Art. 3 — Act 27270/00. Uruguay: Art. 149 bis — Criminal Code changed by Act 17.817, Art. 149 ter. — del Criminal Code changed by Act. 17.817, Art. 149 bis — Changed by Act. 17.817. Venezuela: Art. 8, Organic Act against Racial Discrimination, Art. 37, 38 — Criminal Code.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref19">[19]</a> Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref20">[20]</a> Ibid.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref21">[21]</a> Article 295, Criminal Code.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref22">[22]</a> Consideration of reports submitted by States parties under article 9 of the Convention. Concluding observations of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination. Cuba</p><p><a href="#_ftnref23">[23]</a> Idem.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref24">[24]</a> To know more, see: <a href="https://www.conapred.org.mx/index.php?contenido=boletin&amp;id=783&amp;id_opcion=&amp;op=213">https://www.conapred.org.mx/index.php?contenido=boletin&amp;id=783&amp;id_opcion=&amp;op=213</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref25">[25]</a> To know more about the political situation, see: <a href="https://nodiscriminesparaguay.org/que-es-el-proyecto-de-ley-contra-toda-forma-de-discriminacion/">https://nodiscriminesparaguay.org/que-es-el-proyecto-de-ley-contra-toda-forma-de-discriminacion/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref26">[26]</a> <a href="http://www.abc.com.py/edicion-impresa/locales/paraguay-es-el-unico-pais-sin-ley-contra-discriminacion-en-el-mercosur-1129676.html">http://www.abc.com.py/edicion-impresa/locales/paraguay-es-el-unico-pais-sin-ley-contra-discriminacion-en-el-mercosur-1129676.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref27">[27]</a> See for example: Roundfield, L (2008). Defining, Finding and Remedying Discrimination: Dominant Legal Perspective. Philadelphia, Temple University Press.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref29">[29]</a> “Democracia en la plaza y en la casa” was one of the main slogans of the feminist movement in Latin America when they start presenting the right to abortion as a human right that must be protected to guarantee equality between women and men.</p><p>___________________________________________________________________</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>ABC Color (2008). <em>Paraguay es el único país sin ley contra discriminación en el Mercosur</em>. Available in: <a href="http://www.abc.com.py/edicion-impresa/locales/paraguay-es-el-unico-pais-sin-ley-contra-discriminacion-en-el-mercosur-1129676.html">http://www.abc.com.py/edicion-impresa/locales/paraguay-es-el-unico-pais-sin-ley-contra-discriminacion-en-el-mercosur-1129676.html</a></p><p>Bonilla D. (2015) (Ed.) Constitucionalismo del Sur Global. Bogotá: Siglo del Hombre Editores.</p><p>Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (2011). Consideration of reports submitted by States parties under article 9 of the Convention. Concluding Concluding observations of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination. Cuba.</p><p>Congreso Nacional de Chile (2012) <em>Ley Zamudio. </em>Available in: <a href="https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=1042092&amp;r=2">https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=1042092&amp;r=2</a></p><p>Congreso Visible (2012). <em>No Discrimino: Pongamos en Marcha la Ley Anti-Discriminación.</em> Available in: <a href="https://www.congresovisible.org/agora/post/no-discrimino-pongamos-en-marcha-la-ley-anti-discriminacion/3800/">https://www.congresovisible.org/agora/post/no-discrimino-pongamos-en-marcha-la-ley-anti-discriminacion/3800/</a></p><p>Congreso Visible (2012). Postura del movimiento Soy Afro Amigo ¿ y tú? en relación a la objeción presidencial al proyecto de ley 165/10 Cámara 08/10 Senado “penalización de la discriminación”. Available in: <a href="http://congresovisible.org/agora/post/postura-del-movimiento-soy-afro-amigo-y-tu-en-relacion-al-objecion-presidencial-al-proyecto-de-ley-16510-camara-0810-senado-penalizacion-de-la-discriminacion/2673/">http://congresovisible.org/agora/post/postura-del-movimiento-soy-afro-amigo-y-tu-en-relacion-al-objecion-presidencial-al-proyecto-de-ley-16510-camara-0810-senado-penalizacion-de-la-discriminacion/2673/</a></p><p>El Espectador (2016). <em>El bar que no acepta negros, available in: </em><a href="https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/investigacion/el-bar-no-acepta-negros-articulo-637237">https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/investigacion/el-bar-no-acepta-negros-articulo-637237</a></p><p>El País (2012). <em>La muerte de un joven gay reabre el debate sobre la homophobia en Chile. </em>Available in<em>: </em><a href="https://elpais.com/sociedad/2012/03/27/actualidad/1332875522_330643.html">https://elpais.com/sociedad/2012/03/27/actualidad/1332875522_330643.html</a></p><p>Fraser, N and Honneth, A (2004). Redistribution or recognition: A political-philosophical exchange. Verso.</p><p>Ikawa, D (2009). <em>The right to affirmative actions for blacks in Brazilian universities</em>. The Equal Rights Review.</p><p>Lemaitre Ripoll, J (2009). <em>El Derecho como Conjuro. Fetichismo legal, violencia y movimientos sociales. </em>Bogotá: Siglo del Hombre Editores; Universidad de los Andes -Colección Derecho y Sociedad.</p><p>Múnera, Alfonso (2005). <em>Fronteras imaginadas. La construcción de la raza y de la geografía en el siglo XIX colombiano</em>. Bogotá: Editorial Planeta.</p><p>Observatorio de Discriminación Racial (2008). <em>El Observatorio de Discriminación Racial de la Universidad de los Andes, el Proceso de Comunidades Negras y Dejusticia interponen una acción de tutela para detener la discriminación racial en bares y discotecas</em>. Available in: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/454.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/454.pdf</a></p><p>Partido Político Mira (2013). <em>Ley Antidiscriminación</em>. Available in: <a href="http://carlosalbertobaena.com/ley-antidiscriminacion/">http://carlosalbertobaena.com/ley-antidiscriminacion/</a></p><p>Peru Reports (2018).<em> The Paisana Jacinta Controversy continues to divide Peruvians</em>, available in: <a href="https://perureports.com/paisana-jacinta-controversy-continues-divide-peruvians/6553/">https://perureports.com/paisana-jacinta-controversy-continues-divide-peruvians/6553/</a></p><p>Rodríguez Garavito, C. and Baquero Díaz, C (2015). Reconocimiento con redistribucción. El derecho y la justicia étnico-racial en América Latina. Bogotá: Colección Dejusticia.</p><p>Rodríguez, C.; Alfonso, T. and Cavelier, I (2008). <em>El derecho a no ser discriminado: Primer informe sobre discriminación racial y derechos de la población afrocolombiana</em>. Available in: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/269.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/269.pdf</a></p><p>Roundfield, L (2008). Defining, Finding and Remedying Discrimination: Dominant Legal Perspective. In: <em>Theorizing discrimination in an era of contested prejudice : discrimination in the United States</em>. Philadelphia, Temple University Press.</p><p>Sánchez Velásquez (2015) <em>¿Sabemos cuánta población indígena hay en el Perú?</em>. <em>Revista Ideele, 256. </em>Available in: https://revistaideele.com/ideele/content/¿sabemos-cuánta-población-indígena-hay-en-el-perú</p><p>Tribunal Supremo del Distrito de Bogotá (2008). <em>Judicial Decision. Case 20080173</em>. Available in: <a href="http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/452.pdf">http://www.odracial.org/files/r2_actividades_recursos/452.pdf</a></p><p>Uprimny, R (2011). The Recent Transformation of Constitutional Law in Latin America: Trends and Challenges. <em>Texas Law Review, </em>89 (7) 1587–1609.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89ddabcf599f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation/antidiscrimination-and-public-accommodation-89ddabcf599f">Antidiscrimination and Public Accommodation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/criticalnarratives-publicaccommodation">criticalnarratives.publicaccommodation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>