<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Writing and Conversations - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Essays, Stories, and Interviews - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:07:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/de-tour-texts" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Processes of Formalization in Pasolini’s Saló]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/processes-of-formalization-in-pasolini-s-sal%C3%B3-3cc5e6f46122?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3cc5e6f46122</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Apr 2015 17:26:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-26T19:46:19.801Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Processes of Formalization<br>in Pasolini’s Saló</h3><h4>Alex Villar, Lecture Notes, Art &amp; Law Visit, 2015</h4><p>Two scenes that happen early into Saló, Pier Paolo Pasolini’s film on the Marquis de Sade’s book 120 Days of Sodom, encapsulate a systematic process of formalization at work throughout the film.</p><p>The first of these scenes shows what appears to be the headmaster at an orphanage yelling at pupils that are loosely placed in a room. The resulting reaction by the group takes the form of a couple of lined rows stoically arranged in the space of the room. The empty space surrounding the tightly rearranged group then dominates the scene, conveying a sense of supreme obedience.</p><p>The next scene readily follows the first, and also involves a similar situation. Having arrived at their destination, the pupils hang out haphazardly in a large room. They have likely joined others who were arrested elsewhere. Once more, the group is subjected to yelling by someone who looks to be, judging by clothes and demeanor, from the security forces. Again, the group is reorganized into a row formation. This time there are three rows instead of two, confirming the perception that it comprises a larger group. The circular architecture of this second building reinforces, by contrast, the contrived compliancy of the young bodies occupying this large room of their prison-palace.</p><p>The formal device of contrasting positions is often repeated throughout the film. For instance, in one scene the kneeling in desperation of a young woman is met with standing arousal by the four men. In another scene, two standing groups are presented at contrasting vertical points: powerful men on the top balcony where politicians typically stand, while prisoners stay at the ground level, looking up in unavoidable acquiescence.</p><p>The violence that succeeds these scenes, and that continues until the very last ones, is so vigorous in arresting the viewer’s attention that one could easily lose sight of the role that formalizing procedures play in performing the systemic orientation of Sade’s work. As Simone de Beauvoir states in summary form what merits our attention in the Marquis de Sade’s work is not his literary abilities nor the originality of his perversions, but rather the fact that he turned the latter into a comprehensive system.</p><p>This system is comprised of a body of rules laid down in much the same way as in other domains where conduct requires a formal code of behavior. It essentially forms an ethical code of conduct. Never mind that the solipsistic morality that authorizes this code into law in Saló is of an aberrant type, because in its form it is still a law like any other. It is the protean characteristic of the law that Sade adopts as language and subverts in purpose.</p><p>Sade’s work by itself provides only a partial attempt to turn the law’s conservative imperatives against itself. That is why Deleuze studies Masoch: to also think the upheaval of the law from the side of the weak. While Sade appropriates and lays bare the language of power while relying on the assertion of property to convey authority, Masoch makes use of the form of the contract to exercise control over his submissive experiences. Both strategies seek to formalize behavior into a code of ethics. Both authors mimic while displacing established instruments of power. And in both cases, although they remain within the form of the law, what allows them to change the established registers of power are not given by law, but rather by language. That language can accomplish a performative displacement in the operative forms of the law which are so firmly established by usage is indicative of its transformative force.</p><p>The Nazi concentration camp actualizes what in Saló is represented as an exceptional state that coincides with the rule. That is to say that the extreme processes of formalization that were carried out in the camp were conducted under the guise of the law. To be included in the camp, its subjects needed to be dispossessed of citizenship. That much was accomplished by decree. But in order to be exterminated, one needed first to be disqualified as a human being. That task was accomplished by language.</p><p>The subhuman status can perhaps be best understood by contemplating an extreme example. In the camp, there was a provisional form of existence that situated life at the threshold point between the living and the dead. Those who embodied this abject condition were called Muselmann. This being for whom existence was reduced to a quasi-vegetative state, for whom notions of dignity no longer applied, was considered by Germans and Jews alike to be no longer human. The Muselmann was someone whose death was deemed meaningless because he was no longer a human being. And in ceasing to be human, or to qualify as human, one’s life could be discarded as if it were without value. The Muselmann is of course merely the most extreme example of a negative operation of language that is already at play in the figure of the Jew. Under the Nazi regime, the Jew was to the German what the Muselmann was to other Jews in the concentration camp, someone whose humanity was vacant.</p><p>If language can operate such powerful shifts in how we perceive what qualifies as human, a perception that can then be used to institute lawful, if perverse, regimes of governmentality, then what becomes clear is that we cannot merely rely on the same tools of formalization to do the undoing work. In other words, we cannot simply work through the law to move us beyond a constrictive horizon. We must probe the more fundamental ground in which ideas are first formulated, ideas that will shape the understanding of our world and the lives of the beings who inhabit it.</p><p><em>Seminar presentation by Alex Villar at Art Law Program, Fordham Law School, on April 21, 2015, from 6 to 9 pm.</em></p><p><strong><em>Bibliography</em></strong></p><p>Agamben, Giorgio. “The Muselmann.” In<em> Remnants of Auschwitz: The Witness and the Archive</em>, 41–86. New York: Zone Books, 2000.</p><p>Beauvoir, Simone. “Must We Burn Sade?” In <em>The Marquis De Sade: The 120 Days of Sodom, and Other Writings</em>. New York: Grove Press, 1966.</p><p>Deleuze, Gilles. “Humor, Irony and the Law” and “The Language of Sade and Masoch.” In <em>Masochism: Coldness and Cruelty &amp; Venus in Furs</em>.</p><p>Pasolini, Pier Paolo. <em>Saló, Or, The 120 Days of Sodom</em>. Directed by Pier Paolo Pasolini. 1975. Film.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3cc5e6f46122" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/processes-of-formalization-in-pasolini-s-sal%C3%B3-3cc5e6f46122">Processes of Formalization in Pasolini’s Saló</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts">Writing and Conversations</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Omnibus]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/omnibus-e012e4070145?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e012e4070145</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Oct 2014 20:01:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-10-08T16:48:46.787Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1021/1*9Kev6F2Qi02YdiSpvC95FA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Alex Villar</em></p><p><strong><em>HOT DOGS.</em></strong> In the early seventies, during my first years in high school in Rio de Janeiro, I was faced with the same free meal options as the other kids in my public school. My clear choice was hot dog pasta. I know it sounds strange. The cafeteria cooks used the same cheap sausage used in street corner hot dog carts. They didn’t include the bread, and that was the difference. But the sausage was authentic. They cut it into rough chunks and mixed them in with the pasta. I could count the pieces of sausage, eight in a good day. It was still well worth it. My first class was at seven-thirty. I had to be in school by seven-fifteen and so I dragged my feet there with my eyes still closed. Bumping into people on the way to school was my way to become more alert. Realistically, I wouldn’t be fully awake until an hour later, which it was just about the time I began to daydream about food. At nine-thirty the alarm would go off and everybody would run to the cafeteria. A handful of kids with fat pockets would skip to a luncheonette nearby to buy soda and sweets. Years later, I would find myself there too, drinking Grapette soda between mouth full amounts of cheese crackers; I guess I liked to stuff my mouth with food. In the meantime, my main gig was the free food at the cafeteria. I would get in line twice when possible. Whenever they wouldn’t recognize me. Except for a rich kid, whom to everyone’s envy had a motorcycle and a girlfriend, everybody else seemed to be in a similar situation, meaning that the bulk of us had flat pockets and definitely no girls to call ‘friend.’ My love affair was with food. I remember eating bread while looking at the chicken they used to cook in rotisseries everywhere. If you closed your eyes, the smell would help do the trick of fooling your belly into believing that you were having chicken wings, instead or a piece of plain bread that was made even plainer because it didn’t have any butter in it. Having no money was a real leveler when it came to the range of everyday pleasures available to us flat pocket kids growing up in the city.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>SPHERE, RHOMBUS, RECTANGLE.</em></strong> All of us used the same stupid white and blue uniform. White and blue like the colors of the Brazilian flag. You know, blue like the sphere that is at the center of a rhombus, which is itself in the middle of a rectangle; a true geometric mélange. The sphere has a white ribbon with the phrase order and progress written on it. By the way, that was not a subtle message by any standards. It was the rule of the day, blatantly shoved on our faces, as if it were an ancient Greek maxim that one should follow with pride. Every kid was supposed to know it by heart, even before we could read. All of us, poor kids or middle class kids, kids who walked to school or those few who were driven to it, kids who descended from the hills or those who took the bus to school, all were supposed to follow that rule. It was as if we were supposed to know what it meant. As if at the end of our ordered path to progress we would find a big pot of food, because that’s what was in my mind back then. I pictured a huge pot of hot dog pasta; again, no bread. Also because I hated the bread they used on hot dogs. They called it bald bread. This soft bread would get soggy the moment you added sauce to it. I would much rather have French bread any time of the day, that is any time it came hot out of the bakery, three times a day. And believe me, just because we called it French bread, it doesn’t mean we were getting expensive bread, imported from France. French bread is the name of a cheap type of bread sold almost at every corner where one can still find a bakery these days. There were a lot more at that time, as I remember.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>MILITARY CANTEEN</em></strong>. I was one of the kids who walked to school. The bus was expensive. Plus, whatever coins I could get my hands on, I would put to good use in one of the peanuts machines that began to appear everywhere. I didn’t come across many coins. And I used to be hungry all the time. By no means I was starved or even remotely approaching malnutrition. I was lucky that way. Surely, I was later diagnosed with a low count of white blood cells. That discovery translated into a much-reviled inclusion of vegetables in my diet. The irony is that I mostly eat vegetables these days; I probably now have a low count of red blood cells. Don’t really know why I was often thinking about food. I was neither fat nor really famished, just, let’s say, concerned about food. I was also concerned about water. Or perhaps I was concerned about being thirsty while in a situation where water wasn’t readily available. One of my first possessions was a used military canteen. It was big but light, possibly made out of aluminum. Together with all the mercury rich fish I’ve eaten, and that bit in a bottle that my dentist gave me as a toy, I probably have enough in my system to be slowing down my once-upon-a-time mental clarity. It would explain my short-term memory. The rest of my thoughts come back to me in bursts, like the out-of-the-blue memories in this text. I would take that canteen with me on long bus trips, mostly interstate trips during which time I thought water would be nowhere to be found. Last time I saw that canteen I was already a late teenager and liquor had long replaced water as the liquid my friends and I couldn’t do without. The canteen probably disappeared during one of those trips. I am not surprised because we would start drinking already before we boarded the bus. Once we took a bus to a city where we didn’t have a place to stay or knew anybody for that matter, much like I used to enjoy starting sentences I didn’t yet know how to conclude. Ah, the liberties one can take in their own language. But all this happened much later.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>GERSON’S LAW</em></strong>. I was still too young to go on interstate trips. But not too young to take a city bus by myself. I would take a bus from the south zone to the north zone of the city and back. It was far, hours away, so far that I had to take a train between buses. Some of these buses were crowded but the trains were worse, they were inundated with people. At the end of the day during the week, the main train station was completely filled with people waiting for their trains to go back home from their working day. People were so close to each other in the station that it was hard for me to reach for my canteen. As the train arrived, some of them empty because coming from a service station, the multitude at the station would not wait for a sign to board. You could feel that collective body vibrating as if getting ready to erupt. And sure enough, the more agile ones would jump from the platform into the train through its window. Some people would reach for the top of the train. No image was further removed from the notion of order and progress than this experience. The situation was more akin to a kind of progress that would skip order altogether. They used to show this old commercial on TV, <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6brObB-3Ow">a cigarette ad campaign that showed Gérson</a>, a soccer player from the winning Brazilian selection of the 70s, promoting the idea that one should attempt to gain competitive advantage over everything in life. This infamous campaign became known as Gérson’s Law, much like one would refer to Murphy’s Law. That guy who jumped through the window to get a seat in the train before children or their mothers, before older people or the sick, was undoubtedly following the Gérson law. Come to think of it, order was never a notion that seemed very natural in Brazil. I used to think that it would be more normal in Switzerland, until I found out that they have a penchant to host upper crust criminals, those who fly above the radar of the regular order.[1] Progress too didn’t feel like a very Brazilian notion. It always made me think of something that moved slowly.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>HAIRCUT</em></strong>. Order was very much like those line formations we needed to get into before we progressed to the classroom. I never understood why we had to boil under the sun, in those stupid uniforms, before we were sent to our classrooms. It always made me thirsty. And I never have my canteen on me that early in the day. The whole situation felt like a scene in a movie about the army. That’s what we were being turned into, an army of little people dressed in matching colors, forced to group in lines, required to sing the national anthem and march to our classrooms, where we were to be indoctrinated in the virtues of obedience. Once I punched a kid twice my height and ran to my classroom for shade. Only to be formally exited from the room for an interview with the school’s director who didn’t like my long hair. Many visits later resulted on a haircut. By the time I had my hair short, I was already taking the bus to school. It was even more expensive then and I still had no money to spare. But I had learned a trick or two about how to ride the bus without relinquishing the money I didn’t have. I just needed to hang for a while with the crowd in the back of the bus before the turnstile, where an employee of the bus company would seat to collect the fare. Once my stop came, I would run out of the back door, before anyone got in. It was never as smooth as it sounds but lots of kids did that, or enough did to become noticeable. Our lawless career didn’t last long because the greedy bus owners instructed their workers to run after us ‘criminals’. When they caught us, they would force us to pay or else face the law. We all knew what that meant: someone with a stick and a gun, who was always ready to enforce the order, as long as ordered by someone in a position of authority, someone with a bigger gun. We didn’t know anything about auto-reduction tactics. Roughly around the same time Autonomists in Italy had already taken the problem of arbitrary increases in public services in their own hands.[2] They only paid what was fair, what their meek salaries could realistically afford. People like us shouldn’t be paying full fare. I meant students like us, but then again, neither should anybody else who was taking those buses. That’s what taxes were for, although we didn’t really know who was in charge of the buses, if the city or some local mob,[3] it just seemed logical that if we were going to public school we should also be taking a free bus to get to it. It still seems logical to me that if someone is taking a bus to go to a miserable job that barely pays to put food on the table, the very least the government must do is to foot the bill. That would have been the moment to present our struggle as part of a continuum, before they split in the quantitative and qualitative ends of the spectrum.[4] But I am getting ahead of myself; I had no idea about such things back then. The scope of the universe seemed so much smaller. Plus, collective problems were taken to be personal ones. It was my problem or your problem. The way I saw it, I would rather walk than pay. Those were my choices and I chose walking as the way to resolve the situation. The bus got more expensive. I continued to walk. After all, my destination wasn’t that far and I still had young feet. Other kids weren’t so lucky.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>PORTUGUESE STONES</em></strong>. Surely, we weren’t so different then, we wore the same uniforms, sang the same anthem, marched together, and attended the same classes. But of course the differences were already there and would only grow more pronounced as time went on. At that time, we were enveloped in a rhetorical fog of equality. The most I noticed in the way of difference back then was this rich kid who was in my class. We had the same first name. He didn’t wash his teeth in the morning, even though he had an electric brush. And nobody else I knew had an electric brush. Other than that, we were the same bunch of kids getting by, without thinking too hard, entertained by mundane distractions. Once I was walking home while talking to my friends and not paying much attention to my path. I ended up kicking a huge pile of horse shit, so big that even my white shirt became brown. I had finally managed to change the school enforced color scheme. I’d never seen a happier bunch of kids around me; it almost made me enjoy being covered in shit. I had good fun with my friends. We were not a particularly intellectual group. But we thought we were, you know, special. Once I remembered loosing an argument to one of my big friends that only lasted for a few minutes. I wanted to convince him that he was way too fat for his own good, so much so that he was growing breasts. He cursed at me and that would have been the end of it, if it wasn’t for my adoption of a facetious counter-argument: I dressed my mouth with a sly grin and proceeded to let my hand to gracefully reach through under his flexed arm and, how should I put it, squeeze his supple breast. As a result, well, let’s just say that his closing argument was decisive. He was several times my weight and chose to simply seat on my knocked down body while my face became imprinted with the outline of the Portuguese stones that famously pave the Copacabana beach’s sidewalk. Water flew out of my eyes but I didn’t cry, like a baby. Other intellectual conversations involved some running nose, not always my own. I was much smarter at a younger age, or at least wittier, which I know it is not necessarily the same thing. I remember a few episodes when my running mouth, not my nose, progressed ahead of my diminished size, getting me into trouble with less imaginative kids, who happened to be much bigger than I was. To one such kid, a bully whose uncle, who won his living as a docile dentist, if you can forgive the <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aErDEFpoD_0&amp;list=PLF3CC5CDFF92C41FA&amp;index=10">oxymoron</a>, I once declared that intelligence was worth more than strength. He was not convinced and set himself on the loose to prove me wrong. I was saved by the graces of my dentist who, for some reason, was amused by my precocious mouth. Such luck was not to follow me further in life and I eventually learned to keep my mouth shut, most of the time.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>SAMBA, SOCCER, AND RELIGION</em></strong>. One time it was ok to run one’s mouth was at the soccer stadium. There you could scream obscenities out of your lungs and not get into trouble. As cathartic as this experience was, I only went once, or twice. The truth is that although I like samba, I’ve never been into soccer. I know that this is supposed to be practically a sacrilege for a Brazilian person, same as not being catholic or an atheist or worse, not being into sports at all. It all boils down to the same thing: not being real Brazilian. Well, what’s the most eloquent way to put this? Bullshit. It is our flag all over again. I mean the specter of those two nasty words back to haunt us: order and progress – the self-imposed order of a religious morality and the calculated progress of a competitive code. But I digress. So, back to the matter at hand: who the hell came up with that idea, who came up with the thought that the Brazilian flag should have the words order and progress written on it? According to Wikipedia, because I don’t remember learning that in school, it was a philosopher, Raimundo Teixeira Mendes, who had this idea, sometime at the end of the eighteenth hundreds. In fact, he borrowed the idea from Comte –- Yes, Auguste Comte, the positivist. Sure, he had some progressive ideas back then, but after positivism became disregarded as a credible way to make sense of the world, more or less at the turn of the nineteenth-century, we got stuck with the thought as it became frozen in time in our flag. The military intelligentsia (sic), who took over the government from ‘64 to ‘85, infused this old republican idea with a twisted, essentially fascist, signification. But once more I get ahead of myself. Where was I? Oh yes, fuck soccer! I didn’t give two shits about it then, I couldn’t care less about it now. Especially now that FIFA is threatening to suspend the country’s juridical order to superimpose its very own courts for the duration of the world cup in Brazil.[5] Once more, people will be subjected to a legal order of things whose conditions of possibility originated in a delusional appeal to progress. We will end up pledging allegiance to the flag of the Fédération Internationale de Football Association.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>TRANSAMAZONICA</em></strong>. We were already fed those ideas in those classrooms I had to march into. In a typically autocratic manner, which was how the generals spoke, we were informed that Brazil was the country of the future. The subtext was that we should ignore the present then, along with the immediate past and focus on grand gestures toward the future. They were building the Transamazônica, a four thousand kilometers long highway. The same megalomania behind today’s stadiums for the upcoming world cup was already at work at the time. We were told that we were the children of the future. But I couldn’t see that far in the future, my eyes would only go as far as the food in the cafeteria, half hour away from my class. There was not much history being thought as I recall. Not that my memory is that reliable. But I would have remembered some contemporary history. Without a doubt, there was not much talk about what was going on in the country right then. I don’t mean Brazil’s celebrated participation in the world cup of nineteen seventy. I mean the crazy persecution of anyone who didn’t follow to the letter the implicit prescription of the dictatorial order, which was imposed by the ostensive forces of order in the name of an irrefutable, if improbable, progress. Now, that’s a long sentence; I confess that I used to hate English. Sometimes it shows that I still think in Portuguese. Soccer and torture were twins in a parallel reality, kind of like it is possible in the Twilight zone, or popular quantum mechanics. Nobody talked about politics then, and certainly nobody talked to us kids about it in those long lasting classes. I had to wait for the movies to learn the truth about our recent history. It made me feel a bit like that kid in the film ‘The Year our Parents Went on Vacation.’ Shit happening all around me and the only shit I could see was the shit that was literally on me, the horse shit I kicked in my way home from fictional history class.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>ENTREPRENEURIAL SPIRIT</em></strong>. My friends were clueless too. I guess there were more pressing matters at hand. One of my buddies’ urges was to come up with schemes to raise funds for his own causes. His audience was made out of old ladies and other credulous passersby. His most effective narrative involved posing as an innocent kid who was collecting donations for an inexistent soccer team. He carried a soccer t-shirt in his hand to make it more believable. This much of the plan was calculated because he chose the team that was most popular at the time. Occasionally the same person would stop by to ask him if he had managed to buy all the shirts for his team. The S.O.B. would go on to say that there was only one missing. This guy didn’t know the first thing about soccer, nor politics for that matter. He was an entrepreneur; the rest was just academic detail. Like I said, we were not intellectuals. But we had smarts, which means that we were good with words. We were also incredibly short sighted in our goals, not to say fundamentally compromised in our ethics. But that’s is a bit harsh. We were still kids. Stupid kids to be sure. Not so different from Beavis and Butthead after all. Ok, a little better. <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1tpWFm7Jbo">We never tripped a cow</a>. Our stunts were thin, but the rewards were immediate. None of that bull of waiting around for Godot. To hell with waiting! The moment was now. It was now then. It was so now that the next day we would have already forgotten all about it. Again, we were short sighted or, as I like to call it, nearsighted. We could only see well what was so near as to already belong to our limited field of vision. Out of sight, out of mind, they say, and that’s how it was. Should we have been farsighted, we would have become real entrepreneurs. My friend, the one who collected contributions for a fake soccer team, could have graduated with a degree in speculation. He could have become that guy who had the foresight of funding the ‘pacifying’ police in Rio in order to rip large returns in his real estate dealings in a predictable future.[6] But of course in reality that would never happen. The nearsighted and the farsighted were separated at birth by an intrinsic gap in worldview. No optometrist could correct such kind of optical difference. While the nearsighted followed the Gérson Law, the farsighted had the Capital Law at their disposal. For instance, while the Gérson Law may enable someone to gain immediate advantage over another who is essentially equally positioned, the Capital Law can operate at a much wider net to disenfranchise entirely distinct segments of the population in order to benefit a very small group. The Gérson Law follower works alone to benefit himself and himself only. He is only thinking about how much candy he will buy that afternoon. His is indeed an individualist vision. The Capital Law follower, on the contrary, possesses a corporatist vision. He seeks to substantively increase the profits of his small group. This guy is thinking about how to gain control of the entire candy production and he knows he can’t do that without his cohorts. These two guys may have even lived in the same neighborhood but their life experiences were worlds apart. Incidentally, I knew both of them. The former lived in a tiny apartment with a nuclear family much like my own, but with some closet space, while the latter lived in a humongous apartment shared by three generations of the same family. It may seem promiscuous at first glance but in retrospect I realized that his family was trying to emulate nobility, or the mob. This latter guy also read the Financial Times when he was seven. I kid you not; <a href="http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/261729/7-Up/overview">there are people like that</a>.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>LUMPEN</em></strong>. My friends and I had a mind of our own. It just didn’t have much in it. But that didn’t keep us from pontificating on every single thing on the face of earth. Anything that could be made into a subject of debate was game. We definitely enjoyed an argument. Winning wasn’t the goal since it would put an end to the debate. It was more exciting to keep it going. All those things we were not supposed to argue about, like religion, politics or the sex of angels, were favorite subjects. Not that we knew much about any of it. But we surely had an opinion, a strong, unabashed, certainly unsubstantiated, opinion about everything. I, for one, had a personal distaste for the petit bourgeois worldview. I hated the middle class mentality with a passion. And I was supposed to be a part of it, or at least a part of me was supposed to be included in some sort of middle class census because by comparison there were people who were doing a hell of a lot worse. But what I really was, along with my core group of friends, was a kind of sub-middle class. We did live in a middle class area. But our living standards were below standards. Like the lumpen proletariat we were also lumpen. Let’s say we comprised the substrata of a class I would like to call the lumpen middle class. That could explain our flirtation with the underside of legality that is, in a way, part of the charm of growing up in Rio. Think <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2eOpqjyjX6I&amp;list=RD02ZbTkbh2uOC4">Moreira da Silva</a>, Cartola and other samba composers who were famous at a time it didn’t bring fortune. But I should speak only for myself since I only knew my friends’ first name. Who knew what kind of goods their families kept hidden in their small apartments. To be sure, I noticed is that at some point, my friends began to get used cars by school’s graduation time and I still didn’t have jack. I can’t even remember graduating but I must have because I eventually ended up in college. I eventually came to grips with the notion that I didn’t have much to fall back on. But it was not like I wanted much either. I was an altruist kid in some sense of the word I was unaware of. I hated all that bullshit of piano classes or English lessons. Argh! British English was the currency in middle class parlance. And so, I also came to hate English with a passion.</p><blockquote>§</blockquote><p><strong><em>LE MONDE OF MY OWN</em></strong>. I wanted to learn French. French, that pathetic and affected little language that was pretty much good for nothing when I was growing up, was the foreign language I really loved. Loved but didn’t manage to learn; at least not enough to list it among my most proud possessions. To this day I stumble through the pages of Le Monde Diplomatique trying to guess my way out of sentences that I only sometimes understand because of a certain familiarity in construction with my native Portuguese. Come to think of it, throughout my life I have sustained an interest in things that don’t produce much in the way of tangible results: education, art, and philosophy. I eventually learned English. I had to. I moved to New York in nineteen eighty-nine. After some time, language has it own insidious ways to get under your skin. It happened in my sleep. I began to swear in English in my dreams. That was it. I had become a fucking New Yorker. So much for my émigré status! As much as I would like to hold on to my memories, like my hair, they too began to fade. Or, perhaps, what faded was my attachment to them. Before that happened, I was getting haunted found myself haunted by my worst memories. One of them, the disgusting smell of a mix of extreme pollution and some kind of crude oil, typical of São Cristóvāo, an old industrial neighborhood of Rio, became a favorite recollection. I would dream of it almost every week for a while. After that, I began to remember much older things, things I had already forgotten. It was kind of like when you forget the plaque of your last car while perfectly remembering the numbers from the beaten down plaque from your first vehicle. I was already overcompensating and I didn’t know. I should have recognized the signs of the beginning of the end of my attachment to my prior life. Perhaps it was the flight here that cut me off from the land. I should have taken the bus. But at these prices, who can afford it? I should have protested then.</p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><ol><li>For a prototypical example of how the rules may be suspended at the top of the social pyramid, see Jennifer Rankin. Marc Rich: controversial commodities trader and former fugitive dies aged 78. The Guardian, Wednesday 26 June 2013. <a href="http://bit.ly/1aghegn">http://bit.ly/1aghegn</a></li><li>A detailed account of this strategy is given in Autoreduction Movements in Turin by Eddy Cherki and Michel Wieviorka, in Autonomia: Post-Political Politics, Semiotext(e)/Foreign Agents (Los Angeles: Semiotext(E), 2007), 73.</li><li>For background about the private interests in control of city buses and substantially more on the Brazilian context for recent protests in the country, see Tomas Rotta. Brazil 2013: Mass Demonstrations, the World Cup, and 500 Years of Oppression. Counterpunch, June 2013. <a href="http://bit.ly/17VgDAt">http://bit.ly/17VgDAt</a></li><li>A very lucid analysis of the contemporary situation of protests in Brazil is provided by Rodrigo Nunes. Brazil’s perfect storm of discontent. <a href="http://aje.me/14fuluw">http://aje.me/14fuluw</a></li><li>For a description of the law FIFA superimposes on a country’s own law, see Michel Caillat and Marc Perelman. Brazil: less sporting opium, more politics, published in L’Encontre, reprinted on the Verso blog. <a href="http://bit.ly/1frtz5l">http://bit.ly/1frtz5l</a></li><li>For a discussion of the overlapping commercial interests, particularly in relation to real estate speculation and policial initiatives, see Jacques Denis. Rio de Janeiro endosse sa tenue olympique, Le Monde Diplomatique, January, 2013. <a href="http://bit.ly/1b5w5if">http://bit.ly/1b5w5if</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e012e4070145" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/omnibus-e012e4070145">Omnibus</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts">Writing and Conversations</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Normalizing Mechanisms Lecture]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@villar/normalizing-mechanisms-lecture-b63ff4fce278?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b63ff4fce278</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Jul 2013 18:37:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-10-08T20:20:58.128Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*duhFkEcQjpPbqKKozUCTEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Elevation, section and plan of Jeremy Bentham’s Panopticon penitentiary, drawn by Willey Reveley, 1791</figcaption></figure><h4>Reading Foucault’s Truth and Juridical Forms</h4><h4>Introduction</h4><p>The text we are reading, <em>Truth and Juridical Forms</em>, by Michel Foucault, combines five lectures delivered in Brazil in 1974, a year before the publication in France of his book <em>Discipline and Punish</em>, of which it constitutes an earlier draft. Constructed in this text is a genealogy of the concept of normalization and its strategic place in Foucault’s theorization of power-knowledge.</p><p>Before we start our reading, let me go over as few aspects of Foucault’s thought that might be helpful to know as we perform the reading; some are peripheral to the text, while others are in it but only manifest themselves gradually, as the text unfolds.</p><p>First off, you should keep in mind that the real point of his study is not the past itself, despite his digging up of remote events in time. The vantage point is the present and the goal is to improve our understanding of current conditions. Foucault is less concerned in this text with determining the origin of things and more in tracing how the present came to be shaped as a result of contingent events in the past.</p><p>One of the consequences of this genealogical approach is that the present loses its apparent solidity, its appearance of immutable eternity. The contemporary condition presents itself as what it is: a recent point in history. In other words, this is not how things have always been but rather how they have become in a relatively short period of time.</p><p>What he does is not the official history of law in the sense of a sequence of the proper names that have authored it. Instead, he links up fragments that have constituted the practice of law at different points in time and sketches out the developments of the body of knowledge that was formulated as a result.</p><p>He also does more than simply look at the practice of law, he looks at its very conditions of possibility in the mechanisms society devised to extract truth from conflicting situations; i.e., power relations. Additionally, Foucault also investigates how these mechanisms have come to constitute distinctive new systems of power, a power that operates through processes of subjectivation.</p><h3>Nietzchean insight</h3><p>In order to delve deeper into this notion of subjectivization as a form of control, we should start with what Foucault has to say about a type of knowledge of man that took shape in the 19th century. He contends that a knowledge about individuality was invented then and that it was informed by the newly conceived notion of the normal as opposed to abnormal individual. He also says that this knowledge has its foundation in the social practices, more particularly, those practices involved in the control and supervision of individuals.[1]</p><p>To reach that insight, that is, in order for him to reach an understanding of the mechanisms at play in shaping the human subject, it was necessary for Foucault to move away from the notion of the subject as simply given–a subject that is simply assumed to exist and on the basis of which knowledge is conceived. He needed to move towards a conception of the subject that is constituted within history and which results from the processes that traverse its being.[2]</p><p>That’s why he needs Nietzsche, because Nietzsche is the thinker who conceived of knowledge as resulting from a struggle between instincts,<a href="https://medium.com/p/b63ff4fce278/edit#_ftn3">[3]</a> as opposed to something that simply occurs to the subject, unencumbered by other forces. Nietzsche’s <em>Will to Knowledge </em>implies the presence of a driving force. From Nietzsche, Foucault understood that in order to fully grasp how knowledge is formed, he needed to look at its generative stage within relations of power.<a href="https://medium.com/p/b63ff4fce278/edit#_ftn4">[4]</a> This task required the thinker to descend from the abstract realm in which subject and knowledge have customarily been thought, and go down to the more mundane level where battles of force are held and organized into practice.</p><p>One can then understand why Foucault seizes the juridical practices. As he put it, they are “among the social practices whose historical analysis enables one to locate the emergence of new forms of subjectivity.”[5]</p><p>Foucault sums it up, while still referring to Nietzsche: “One can understand what knowledge consists of only by examining these relations of struggle and power, the manner in which things and men hate one another, fight one another, and try to dominate one another, to exercise power relations over one another.”[6] We are here far removed from the language of abstraction and down to the mundane, at times even base, struggles for power.</p><p>You will note that it was the practical form these struggles took that constituted the institutional knowledge about them; not the other way around.</p><h4>Detour to the ancients</h4><p>But before we reach that point in the logical sequence of the text, Foucault takes a detour in the narrative toward the time of the ancient Greeks, a remote point in relation to the time frame of the rest of the text which broadly goes from the Medieval period to the 19th century .</p><p>He situates our attention in <em>Oedipus</em>, a play by Sophocles, whom he sees as orchestrating a theatrical ritualization of law in a series of plays that includes <em>Antigone </em>and <em>Electra.</em>[7]</p><p>At stake for Foucault in the <em>Oedipus </em>play is the discursive shift that is effected at the level of what he calls the enunciation of truth. What is introduced in this piece, and what drastically transforms the manner in which the truth was sought until then, is the search for evidence. This new concept occasions a practical reversal in the established forms of prophetic discourse at work then.[8]</p><h4>War by other means</h4><p>Having established with the Greek example that the historical sequence is not so linear as one would hope for while trying to understand its developments–in fact the history of knowledge is replete with discontinuous instances–Foucault can then return to his main narrative; he takes us next to the Medieval period.</p><p>In order to contrast the developments he is about to cover, he paints an unflattering, while realistic, portrait of the law during medieval times. In plain words, law was simply a means of regulating acts of revenge; i.e., a “regulated way of making war.”[9]</p><p>Furthermore, feudal law mediated disputes through a rather bizarre system: the test. The test, or series of tests, was something both parties would agree to take part in, regardless of the irrationality involved in these procedures.[10]</p><p>Discovering what had really occurred, what led to the dispute, had no place or meaning in such a context. Resolution had nothing to do with discovering the truth of the situation. It was instead a matter of establishing the “strength, the weight, the importance of the one who spoke.”[11] Victory or defeat were the only significant elements in feudal law. Force, not justice was at stake.[12]</p><p>The role authority played was solely the one of a witness to disputes, as to ascertain the properness, indeed the regularity, of the procedure.[13]</p><p>All was about to change, and this occurred through the introduction of a new form of knowledge that entered the practice of law: the inquiry.[14] The inquiry is a way of establishing the authenticity of what it discovers through its procedure. The form of the inquiry will allow for the gathering of clues that will comprise the truth of a situation. It is in that sense that it will become a form of knowledge-power.[15]</p><p>Something else is introduced along with the invention of the inquiry, and that is the notion of the infraction. That’s when what was before a struggle between two parties, only witnessed by authority, became an offense against the state. We then acquired this notion of a wrong that is committed against society.[16]</p><h4>A Social Orthopedics</h4><p>When crime ceases to be a transgression, in the religious sense of being a sin, and becomes a wrong committed against society as a whole, we then arrive at the definition of the criminal as the enemy of society.[17] Revenge and redemption, the established ways for the reparation of crimes under a religiously inflected law, are no longer appropriate forms of redress for this newly conceived crime. If the crime harms society, one needs to find a way to repair this social injury.[18]</p><p>An obvious way of protecting society is by diminishing the number of crime occurrences. The manner in which the 19th century chose to do this was by assessing and controlling the level of dangerousness of individuals. To accomplish this enormous task, an entire institutional system was created. Starting with institutions that one would expect to be involved in the segregation of dangerous individuals like the police and the psychiatric asylum, but then extending to hospitals and schools, therefore making clear that what was at stake was not simply the punishment of individuals but shaping and correcting them at the level of their potential actions.[19]</p><p>Foucault will call this social project an orthopedics and synthesize its principles by invoking the ominous and pervasive architectural project of the Panopticon. What this circular building, with a central point of observation, permits is an optimum and economical type of surveillance that is equally suitable for the control of prisons, asylums, hospitals, schools, factories and so on.[20]</p><p>With the Panopticon we traded the probing, while still relatively superficial, notion of the inquiry for something much more invasive, and therefore more suitable for the job of controlling and shaping the individuals under its gaze: the examination.[21]</p><p>The notions of inquiry and examination may seem conceptually close but their procedures could not be more distinct. While the inquiry seeks to uncover if something has happened and if someone is culpable, the examination operates at a different point in the temporal sequence. It seeks to prevent criminal action from occurring by correcting individual behavior at its formative stage. For that, it needs a model to follow. This model is provided by the norm, or the notion of what is understood as the normal state of being, which itself is defined by contrast with that which it is not; i.e., the abnormal.[22]</p><p>With this notion of normality, we have completed the trajectory that led from a knowledge of law formed around the need to regulate something that had already happened, all the way to the prospective operation designed to prevent and shape, that which was yet to occur.</p><p>In that slippage we also traded the object of knowledge, which before was given by the event and is now offered by the subject. In other words, we traded a focus on actions to one based on the individuals who may or may not commit such actions.</p><h4>Productive Power</h4><p>We have arrived at a concise understanding of this type of power that Foucault is, in a shorthand manner, calling Panopticism: it is a type of power characterized by its continuous application to individuals, it is also a power that seeks to correct or mold individuals according to accepted norms. In sum, this power is comprised of three constitutive aspects: supervision, control and correction.[23]</p><p>Something that clearly distinguishes Foucault’s conception of power from purely negative or repressive formulations is his notion that power is exercised through productive mechanisms. He states as much directly when he says in relation to the factory that it attaches, rather than excludes, individuals to its production apparatus. This is true even about the prison, in spite of the fact that it excludes individuals from the rest of society. His point is that it does so by attaching them to the normalizing apparatus of the prison, which is itself part of society’s overall system of production.[24]</p><p>This more sophisticated type of inclusion, what Foucault calls sequestration, is best understood by comparison with the practice of confinement, widespread in the 18th century. While the latter reinforced marginality, the former aimed to inscribe the individual through a process of normalization.[25]</p><p>Economically speaking, as the practice of sequestration turned out to be too inflexible to accommodate the fluctuations of the market, more subtle mechanisms of control were developed. Savings banks and relief funds provided the means to assure control throughout an entire lifespan, as opposed to simply the period of work.[26]</p><p>But, in spite of this stress on economic matters, this power is not solely economical, neither it is just political. It is also a judicial power in the sense that, despite its emphasis on training, it really has the ability to apply punishment to those who do not conform to the positive prescriptions of the normalizing apparatus.[27]</p><p>Foucault will conclude by saying that power and knowledge are not simply a layer added to the production apparatus. They are rather deeply rooted in it. They are a substantive component of what constitutes relations of production.[28]</p><h3>Concluding Remarks</h3><p>It should now be clear why in the title of this text the word truth is juxtaposed to the words juridical forms. Truth provides a stand in for knowledge as in a type of knowledge procedure that seeks to attain the truth of a situation. Juridical forms is a collection of practices that effect a deployment of power by means of a normative regulation of individual behavior. What Foucault attains by this juxtaposition in ‘power-knowledge’ is a synthesized formulation of a continuum between these two realms.</p><p>Power-knowledge is the complex space within which a multiplicity of subjectivizing mechanisms like class, gender, ethnicity, and so on, traverses the individual while seeking to maintain control over its normalizing outcome.</p><p>The reliance of this power on the norm, on the conception of what constitutes normality in existing situations is also what opens itself up to dispute. The norm, insofar as it informs the application of the law, represents a prime terrain of struggle. Since it provides a privileged framework that creates the conditions of possibility for the practice of law, the norm, or the assumptions that inform it, need to be continually reevaluated for its applicability to our own time.</p><p><em>Seminar by Alex Villar at Art Law Program, Fordham Law School, on February 5, 2013, from 6 to 8 pm.</em></p><p><strong>Notes</strong></p><ol><li><em>Truth and Juridical Forms, </em>in Th<em>e Essential Works of Foucault 1954-1984, </em>Volume 3: Power. (New York: The New Press, 2000) p..2.</li><li>Ibid., p.3.</li><li>Ibid., p.8.</li><li>Ibid., p.12.</li><li>Ibid,, p.4.</li><li>Ibid., p12.</li><li>Ibid., p.33.</li><li>Ibid., p.23.</li><li>Ibid., p.35.</li><li>Ibid., p.37.</li><li>Ibid., p.37.</li><li>Ibid., p.39.</li><li>Ibid., p.39.</li><li>Ibid., p.40.</li><li>Ibid., p.52.</li><li>Ibid., p.43.</li><li>Ibid., pp.53–54.</li><li>Ibid., p.54.</li><li>Ibid., p.57.</li><li>Ibid., p.58.</li><li>Ibid., p.58.</li><li>Ibid., p.59.</li><li>Ibid., p.70.</li><li>Ibid., p.78.</li><li>Ibid., pp.78–79.</li><li>Ibid., p.81.</li><li>Ibid., p.83.</li><li>Ibid., p.87.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b63ff4fce278" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Like a Fish out of Water, in the Water]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/like-a-fish-out-of-water-in-the-water-6975fa86c0ac?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6975fa86c0ac</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jul 2013 23:40:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-08-26T21:17:27.254Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*xea3-SUwsOx4SQ8p.jpeg" /></figure><h4>By Alex Villar</h4><p>From the coast of Mexico comes the Axolotl, an amphibian that did not progress to the next phase of its metamorphosis to become a terrestrial animal. Instead, it took a detour in its migratory journey to live its entire life cycle in water, much like the fish that comprises its infant state.[1] One could say that the Axolotl chooses never to grow up, except that it goes on to attain full reproductive capabilities. That is to say that in the process it contrives a new form of existence. For all intents and purposes it is still a fish in water, even if by default it shouldn’t have remained there. It is, in a way, out of place in that habitat, while at the same time insisting in affirming its life in that environment. It is possible to ‘correct’ for this ‘defect’ in laboratory by subjecting the Axolotl to Iodine injections to induce its thyroid to produce Thyroxine and force it to advance into its expected final stage as a Salamander. But the operation is known to shorten its lifespan from an average of 15 years down to about 5 years. It is clear that the life form of this organism is not completely determined by its environment; neither is its potential existence foreclosed by its morphological shortcomings. In this dual sense, the Axolotl is not so different from humans. In spite of a significant dependence on the environment, human life is never completely predicated by it. And, as a parade of prosthetic invention can attest, never have physiological limitations prevented humans from advancing into unknown territories.</p><p>A good example of this incursion into unlikely terrain is the human insistence in exploring situations in which our dependency on oxygen is put to test. Although the terrestrial environment provides optimum conditions for what human organs need to do to process consumed oxygen, humans persist in adventuring toward more challenging breathing situations. The aquatic environment provides an attractive contender due to its immediate proximity and inviting vastness when compared to the relatively small terrestrial surfaces that cover our planet. Although water contains oxygen, it does so in considerably less quantity than air. And humans, like other mammals, require large quantities of oxygen to sustain their bodies. There is substantial work involved in processing oxygen and much more work is required when the oxygen is extracted from water. This processing work, combined with the small amounts of oxygen available in water, result into a particularly challenging environment for mammals. What other warm-bodied species that live in the ocean do to retain their oxygen is to rely on a mechanism known as the Mammalian Diving Reflex. This reflex optimizes respiration to permit extended periods under water. It works first by slowing down the heart rate upon contact with cold water; this lessens the need for bloodstream oxygen. Next, it constricts the capillaries in the extremities of the animal’s body so as to require less blood in those areas, reserving the available blood to help with the functioning of more vital organs. Last, there is a blood shift that occurs in deep dives during which time plasma and water are allowed to pass freely throughout the thoracic cavity at a constant pressure rate so that the organs are not crushed. That’s what whales and dolphins do during their long diving periods. Other aquatic species have gills, which is a more suitable apparatus to process the dissolved oxygen found in water. Fish are doubly prepared for the aquatic environment. Their organism requires less oxygen, which compiles with the fact that they have an ideal equipment to efficiently process the bits of oxygen dispersed in water.</p><p>Unlike Axolotls, humans left behind the aquatic environment of their prenatal period in the Amniotic sac – the composition of the Amniotic fluid is considered to be similar to seawater. Newborn babies still retain, while not the ability to breathe underwater, at least the reflex to immediately hold their breath for a few seconds when immersed in water. Adults have long forgotten those reflexes. If not properly trained, they readily succumb to despair at the slightest obstruction of their breathing channels. An extreme example of this sensitivity, exploited to perverse ends, is to be found in the interrogation technique known as Waterboarding. During this procedure, a piece of absorbent cloth is wrapped around the victim’s face to block sight and inhibit other faculties, most pointedly to disrupt normal breathing. Next, water is poured over the subject’s wrapped face in a continuing fashion. Once the cloth is fully saturated with water, airflow is restricted anywhere between 20 and 40 seconds. The victim is then allowed to catch 3 or 4 breaths and the procedure is repeated. The practice dates as far back as the Spanish inquisition but has been perfected by many parties, including the Japanese during the Second World War and, most infamously, by the CIA on Al-Qaeda suspects, following from the polemical authorization of the practice by the Department of Justice during the Bush administration. The experience during this torture session is described as the exact sensation of drowning. The subject becomes convinced of impending death and succumbs to a state of desperation.</p><p>On the flipside of this technique of abject subjection is another practice that pivots the objective to exert control by inducing drowning into its obverse. That is to say that it seeks to enhance, rather than subject, the subject’s inherent, while underdeveloped, ability to endure longer periods without breathing under water. This diving technique has two basic modalities; one is called Static and the other Dynamic Apnea. While during the static modality the subject is expected to float underwater usually in a pool for as long as possible, on the dynamic modality the goal is to descend as much as possible toward the bottom of the sea. In both cases the goal is to extend the body’s ability to stop breathing underwater for extended periods of time. The practice of diving on a single breath has been around for a real long time; some accounts date it back to the 5th century. It still persists today and its practitioners continue to cross previously unimaginable limits; athletes have been able to descend to depths greater than 250 meters and hold their breath for over 10 minutes. In the end of the 1940s, it was accepted as fact the idea that humans could not dive deeper than 50 meters. It was thought that at lower depths, the water would impose an unbearable pressure over the body’s respiratory organs that would crush as a result. After individual divers broke through many thresholds established by the doctors of the time, the phenomenon known as Blood Shift was then discovered to happen in humans. Similarly to what happens for other animals, the process reduces the lungs’ residual volume resulting on the widening of the lungs’ capillaries. It turned out that humans also have their own diving reflex, indeed a variation of the Mammalian Diving Reflex.</p><p>After the fact, both the Apnea practitioner and the victim of waterboarding seem to undergo a period of adjustment. Beside the immediate risks of death during waterboarding – heart attack, lung damage, actual drowning – there are post-traumatic effects that are typical in cases of abuse. Apnea also poses immediate risks ranging from actual drowning to Shallow Water Blackouts, i.e. a loss of consciousness caused by cerebral Hypoxia. Apnea practitioners may also experience problems long after their immersion in water–anything from Hypothermia to a variation of Decompression Disease. The post-traumatic situation of the tortured victim and the sickened diver resemble the fate of the Axolotl when it is subjected to the aforementioned lab-enforced procedure used to extract the truth about its condition by forcing it to complete its transformation, therefore resulting in the reduction of its lifespan. Both the truth extraction technique deployed during the torture session and the idealized truth about the human potential sought by the crossing of limits exhibited in the diver competition result in potential damage to the subjects of the experience. While the ethical circumstances of these situations are completely distinct and perhaps precisely because they are so polar, the commonality that exist in the procedural steps of both practices becomes all the more striking. The meticulousness in which divers train and perform their breathing deferral techniques is very much on pair with the degree of methodical attention devoted to sessions of torture. Compared in such a manner, by the symmetry of their procedure and results as opposed to by their intent, these two drastically different human activities begin to recede into a zone of indistinction.[2] That is not to say that they can ever be confused with one another, only to suggest that the tools of a procedure can be employed to radically distinct purposes.</p><p>Human praxis engenders a vocabulary through its actions that operates within an elaborate system of codifications. Although this system provides its conditions of possibility, they can also be articulated in a multiplicity of inflexions.[3] There is a pivotal moment that occurs during limit-experiences as reported by human subjects that undergo such experiences that could be described, by borrowing once more from our observation of the Axolotl, as a short-circuit that interrupts an otherwise continuous process. At that turning point, the subject’s hold on material reality is replaced by a perceived sense of displaced spatiality that may be what sets in motion a change of course in the subject’s purview. Perhaps when the experiential shift is radical enough to effect a modification in the structural ordering of the subject’s way of perceiving the world, a new horizon of possibilities opens up. What happens next could instantiate an entirely new form of life.</p><p><em>Text by Alex Villar. Published in the book The Unknown as We Know it, Marek Wasilewski, ed., University of Arts in Poznan and Mediations Biennale Foundation, 2012.</em></p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><ol><li><em>For a discussion of the Axolotl in relation to Neoteny – a condition known as the retention of juvenile features in adult animals as being a significant characteristic of human potentiality, see Agamben, Giorgio. “The Idea of Infancy,” inIdea of Prose (Albany: State University of New York, 1995), 95–98.</em></li><li><em>Agamben derives the notion of a ‘Zone of Indistinction’ from Deleuze’s discussion of indiscernibility instantiated by Melville’s Bartebly’s assertion of his preference ‘not to be (or to do)’ something that was requested of him. Agamben, Giorgio, and Daniel Heller-Roazen. “Bartleby, or On Contingency,” in Potentialities: Collected Essays in Philosophy (Stanford, CA: Stanford UP, 1999), 243–74.</em></li><li><em>For a discussion of multiplicity in relation to the application of a rule and the possibilities it presents for innovative action, see Virno, Paolo. Multitude: between Innovation and Negation(Los Angeles, CA: Semiotext(e), 2008).</em></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6975fa86c0ac" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/like-a-fish-out-of-water-in-the-water-6975fa86c0ac">Like a Fish out of Water, in the Water</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts">Writing and Conversations</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Connecting Nodal Points]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/connecting-nodal-points-9aa79757c790?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9aa79757c790</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jul 2013 22:21:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-07-19T22:21:19.351Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/631/0*ByD5qXnDG4vVjrwH.jpeg" /></figure><p>A few years ago, while researching a project, I came across a curious book[1] whose subject matter I could describe today, not without a touch of irreverence, as a manual on alternative techniques of circulation. I had been observing how a number of consumer products continue to circulate beyond their purchase moment, via their public display on the body of the consumer. Such is the case of clothes, jewelry and personal electronic devices, but also of products that are consumed socially like beverages, books, among others. My interest was in finding ways to disrupt the fluid continuity of this process, particularly in finding disrupting tactics already at play in the social sphere. I found in the book I just mentioned, a perhaps extreme, but no less pointed, example of engaging commodity circulation while, at the same time, momentarily but assertively interrupting its image projection through bodily display. Eventually, the lifted merchandise eventually finds its way back into the traditional channels of circulation, but for the brief instance during which time the stolen product is worn in disguise, a different relation to the body is founded, one that reverses the practice of enhancing one’s identity via identification with the image conveyed by the wearable product. I am calling this situation a reversal simply because instead of the product covering the body, it is the body that covers the product. Say we uphold this reversal, however provisional and isolated it may be, and enhance its potential through aesthetic recombination, similarly to how Critical Art Ensemble, following Guy Debord, defined it as making use of already existing representations and recombining them in disruptive ways.[2]</p><p>Following these thoughts, I produced a video called Blind Spots in which I use the instructions from the book as point of departure. While shoplifting was the tactical point of departure for Blind Spots, the video used techniques from a visual vocabulary that references television commercial spots. In the video, from scene to scene, a series of products is revealed out of their temporarily occluded spots in the body and presented against their stated retail prices, similarly to what is used in commercials but here converted from expense to income. The objective was to attain a disjointed encounter between opposing strategies as to short-circuit the subjectivizing mechanisms present in persuasive communication. Such an outcome is not directly transitive from the piece to actual life but they could function as a discursive rearrangement of established norms, a disjunctive conjunction, to use the terms Jacques Ranciere elaborated as a play in the ambiguity of resemblances and on the instability of dissemblances.[3]</p><p>Blind Spots explores a particular facet of shoplifting, the instance of disguise of the stolen commodity. This fact situates the shoplifting gesture at a nodal point that operates a shift in the subjectivizing mechanism ruling the relations between body and commodity. But there are other questions worth exploring in related subject areas, and the occasion of this essay presents the opportunity to expand the initial investigation. A case in point are those situations that involve technology-enabled means to control the movement of products, particularly those devices used in retail to prevent the so-called unauthorized removal of articles.[4] In the recent past, EAS (Electronic Article Surveillance) was prevalent in retail stores as a means of countering shoplifting; in fact they are still in use. These days the security industry is heavily pushing for the indiscriminate use of a more evolved technology. Radio Frequency Identification tags, or simply RFID, are comprised of two related parts: on one end there is an integrated circuit for storing and processing information; on the other, there is an antenna for receiving and transmitting the signal. This tag can be used not only to track the article’s unauthorized movement but also to control inventory. Walmart notoriously implemented RFID tags in its stock control system and integrated with its suppliers via extranet to minimize the occurrence of out-of-stock items, reduce overstock and automate supply orders.[5] But the most controversial use of RFIDs is to be found in the Human Microchip Implant version of these tags. Initially targeted at serious medical cases that require immediate attention facilitated by the embedding of the patient’s critical information in the chip, it has since been used by companies and government to controls access to restricted areas.[6] Counter activity already exists in the form of hacking into the chip via scanning of its signal to either clone or disrupt it, bringing a situation once limited to science fiction literature into the mundane level of commodity logistics management.[7]</p><p>What remains consistent, regardless of technological advances, is the managerial need to control the physical location of bodies as they flow through space. This body is ever more enhanced by prosthetic devices and voluntary inscription in locatable grids, typically via GPS enabled phones, but it is still the actual body, not solely its virtual double that is the focus of control. Like other technical advancements, the defensive rhetoric appears to amount to a residual, not to say negligible, profit percentage, especially when compared to the enormous gains afforded by new opportunities for profit extraction. For example, GPS-enabled triangulation of the potential buyer at the moment of intersection with a store that matches the consumer’s interests as per their stated profile of interests maximizes the chance of impulse buying. Such logic is not a novelty; a cursory look at the developments in retail display systems reveals a direct correlation between logistical rearrangement and exponential growth. The product accessibility introduced by the department store in the retail economy translated into increased impulse driven consumption. On the other hand, shoplifting also progressed as a result but typically at a fraction of the rate of increase in profit. We could say that its very conditions of possibility share the same source with a capitalist invention designed to maximize profits. Not unlike residual unemployment under neo-liberal regimes, shoplifting subsists alongside the retail machine as a necessary remainder. In spite of the disproportion between shoplifting costs and the size of the security industry, shoplifting is portrayed as the villainous debaser, out to destroy the virtues of commercial exchange. But contrary to this vigorous rhetoric laid against it in the manner of a moral battle, shoplifting is not really meant to be extinguished. It is more useful, for the sake of justifying disproportional counter-attacking measures, that this irritant factor be simply sustained at a tolerable level.</p><p>This disguised sustainability allows the system to continuously re-invent its mechanisms of self-defense and in the process recycle itself toward previously unexplored territories. A good example is the recorded music industry. For years now this industry has been leveling an inquisition-like battle against individuals who engage in free downloading of music from the Internet. It has gone to unimaginable measures to sue teenagers, single mothers and the elderly.[8] At the same time, advantageous deals were being arranged, notably with My Space and Google in China to allow people to do precisely what they have forbade in the U.S. and Europe: listen to music without paying.[9] The difference is that when this activity is performed in the terrain of tightly defined agreements, which is to say paved by profitable partnership contracts, the once unproductive listening activity has again become lucrative. Once a new business model is conceived, the moral ban is lifted and the same activity is proclaimed ethical.</p><p>Now that we have established the lack of moral grounds in such pleads by ascertaining their sole profit logic, it remains necessary to unhinge the fundamental polarity between good and evil that frames the circulation of commodities. To accomplish this task we need to tackle the situation from a tangential perspective. Instead of operating within the available terms as set in place by the given discursive framework, we should dispute the very framework and broaden the scope of the situation. Rather than ask if we have the means to afford this or that product or service, we should inquire on the conditions that determine such affordability. Then we can proceed to adjust reality to need, instead of simply conforming to the reality of need. An extraordinary case in point was the Autoreduction initiative that took place in Turin in the Fall of ‘74.[10] Following from the increase in bus fares by the order of 20 to 50% by two private local companies, the workers whose salaries were not increased to accommodate this excessive burden, refused to comply. After their vain attempts to obtain results via protests, they decided to auto-reduce the fares back to the original amount, prior to the arbitrary price increase. Faced with the monetary disadvantageous alternative of stopping service altogether, the bus companies were returned to their profit logic and chose to take the money, which they initially refused. In this example, the tactic consisted in assuring the continuity of the bus service. What was renewed, or in this case retrofitted, were the terms of engagement. Once the framework was rejected, what were initially incongruent positions became liberated for creative rearrangement. Without a doubt, this is not a model that can be easily generalized. The event was largely dependent on the political and historical conditions of Italy and the innovations introduced by the Autonomia movement. But the lessons from this specific post-Fordist tactic, outlive its timely occurrence and remain available to us in the terms of a theoretical proposition that prescribes the displacement of given frameworks combined with the factual rearrangement of established plateaus of experience.</p><p>I’ve began this essay with a cursory description of the ideas for Blind Spots and then expanded the scope to include other aspects of its object. While in the first part, I described the re-arrangement of the relation between body and commodity, in the second part, I exemplified the reconfiguration of the terms of a social experience. There is a marked homology between these two sequences that, in spite of their vast difference in scale, suggest a conceptual transitivity between a singular and isolated gesture on one end and a multiple and interconnected action on the other. The possibility of such transitivity, that is to say of this unobstructed passing between disparate domains of experience foregrounds the art practice from which Blind Spots comes out. Substantiating my focus on micro-experiences is the idea that a mere dislodging of isolated instances can be connected to much larger events.</p><p><em>Text by Alex Villar, Published on the “Circulation” issue of Printed Project, 2009.</em></p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><ol><li><em>Caime, Gabriel, and Gabriel Ghone. S(h)elf Help Guide: The Smart Lifter’s Handbook (Hagerstown: Trix Publishing, 1996).</em></li><li><em>Ensemble, Critical Art. The Electronic Disturbance (New York: Autonomedia, 1994).</em></li><li><em>Ranciere, Jacques. The Future of the Image (New York: Verso, 2007).</em></li><li><em>“Electronic article surveillance (EAS) system,” in Electronics manufacturers, </em><a href="http://bit.ly/JflTY"><em>http://bit.ly/JflTY</em></a><em>.</em></li><li><em>Williams, David H. “The Strategic Implications of Wal-Mart’s RFID Mandate,” in Directions Magazine, </em><a href="http://bit.ly/ahlmP"><em>http://bit.ly/ahlmP</em></a><em>.</em></li><li><em>Bahney, Anna. “High Tech, Under the Skin,” The New York Times,</em><a href="http://bit.ly/1HT09y"><em>http://bit.ly/1HT09y</em></a><em>.</em></li><li><em>Newitz, Annalee. “The RFID Hacking Underground,” Wired News,</em><a href="http://bit.ly/kN3wh"><em>http://bit.ly/kN3wh</em></a><em>.</em></li><li><em>See Beckerman, Ray. “Recording Industry vs.The People,” Recording Industry vs. The People, </em><a href="http://bit.ly/iUvaf"><em>http://bit.ly/iUvaf</em></a><em> and Borland, John. “RIAA settles with 12-year-old girl,” CNET News, </em><a href="http://bit.ly/Prn4R"><em>http://bit.ly/Prn4R</em></a><em> as well as Itzkoff, Dave. “Woman fined $1.92M in music piracy case,” The New York Times, June 19, 2009, </em><a href="http://bit.ly/14xcUR"><em>http://bit.ly/14xcUR</em></a><em>.</em></li><li><em>Arrington, Michael. “Stealing Music: Is It Wrong Or Isn’t It?,” Techcrunch, </em><a href="http://bit.ly/Luen8"><em>http://bit.ly/Luen8</em></a><em>.</em></li><li><em>Autonomia: Post-Political Politics, Semiotext(e)/Foreign Agents (Los Angeles: Semiotext(E), 2007), 73.</em></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9aa79757c790" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/connecting-nodal-points-9aa79757c790">Connecting Nodal Points</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts">Writing and Conversations</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[9/12 ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/9-12-dd5c0ea41b05?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd5c0ea41b05</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Mar 2013 19:14:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-03-26T19:16:32.543Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I saw the sign at the entrance of the White Box gallery stating that the space had been closed by the <em>Cultural Bureau of the Office for Homeland Security</em>, my eyes blinked in very slow motion as if attempting a second chance at grasping the meaning of the statement. In between my two glimpses, precisely during the brief moment when my eyes remained closed, an image made itself perceptible to my brain. This image occupied the precise gap between my two glances, not as an effect of the movement created by the dislocation of my eyes, more like an image formed in the irrational interval between my attempts at intelligibility. As if undergoing a subliminal experiment, I was not aware that I had registered that instant. It is only now, upon attempting to reconstruct that moment, that is, upon actively remembering it, that I have in fact become fully aware of it. The image produced in my mind was the one of a traffic sign. On this sign, we see an octagonal red shape accompanied by a black arrow. Both are contained by a black line and are painted over a yellow plate. This sign is like any other traffic-sign, except that its referent is yet another traffic-sign. In spite of its cryptic appearance, the message is simple and clear: the arrow indicates that a stop sign, which is represented by the red shape, lies ahead. Most traffic signs are introduced along the way prior to the circumstance they are to call attention for. This one is not different in that regard, except that this sign is situated further away in the signification chain from the situation it refers to. Its function is like that of an eye-opener, it alerts about the coming presence of another sign which, if noticed, will then provide a direct description of the matter at hand. While my body was still there, outside the gallery, temporarily frozen in front of a sign that stopped my flow into the space, my mind went elsewhere.</p><p>A couple of years ago I was asked what I thought had been the most formative events in my life, meaning what public events had shaped my perception of the world. I recalled two interrelated events that left a lasting impression on me because of the way in which they worked retroactively, reordering what up to the point of their occurrence had been deemed to be the accepted truth. The first was the military dictatorship in Brazil, the second the Freedom of Information Act in the United States. The former attempted a self-serving reconfiguration of the historical facts that had preceded the military coup’s coming into power by suppressing information from freely circulating in the media and in the educational system, i.e., by direct censorship. The latter facilitated the correction of a misperception of the United States’ role in international affairs, by allowing access to documents that show how interventions in foreign territory were designed to favor U.S.’s national interests at the cost of enormous repression of civil liberties in those foreign countries. Both of these events had the ability to change the nature of my relationship to prior events. To that I would add a third event, the morning of September 12. I spent that morning experiencing this most uneventful of all events: television watching. As news after news, commentator after commentator, passed in front of my eyes, I saw the meaning of what had occurred the day before change. Like the famous flashback of the moments of a person’s life often reported as occurring when someone is between life and death, I saw footage of various events throughout the world flashing by my eyes. It was as if the tv programming were in rewind mode, as if were looking for something in particular, something that could be not the cause but the easy target with which to conflate the anger and distress caused by the events from the day before. During this editing process, without my full awareness, without my granting it my consent, I was robbed of my certainty about the meaning of a prior event and was offered another, more simplified, even mechanistic, version of the same story. In this new version, only one movement took place, the one that went from the part who committed the aggression to the part that suffered its impact. No cause and effect is allowed in this rationale, except of course, the action that follows from it, that is vengeance. The narrative is ungrounded from any foundation. What is complex is the way in which this narrative replaces our prior links between words and things and their contextualization in the actual historical terrain.</p><p>Still at the door, I inventoried my two thoughts. On the one hand I had a sign that referred to another sign. On the other, I had an event that changed my relationship to prior events. But how are these thoughts related to the sign in front of me? It didn’t quite synced. One of the things that puzzles me about today’s event, and makes me not accept the notice on the door at face value, is the discrepancy between the activities of the <em>Bureau</em> and those of the gallery. While the <em>Bureau</em>’s stated goal is to care for national security, the art space’s declared goal is to exhibit its artist’s work for public viewing. The incongruity between their assumed interests was beating me over the head to the point of obfuscating the almost obvious connection between the violent action of closing the space and the subtle work on representation deployed by the artists in the gallery in re-articulating received notions of security. It would be very tempting, if it weren’t short sighted, to qualify the violence deployed in the abrupt closing of the space, an action in sync with the current generalization of the police apparatus onto various spheres of public life, as a retrograde maneuver, a leftover of a faded McCarthyism. The risk in thinking this way is that we would discard this tendency as a fad, an annoying but nevertheless passing nostalgic moment that is ultimately understandable given the traumatic events of our recent past. But what if instead of a simple recurrence of things past we were confronting a new arrangement of power, or at least a new stage for a configuration already on the make for a very long time?</p><p>In order to look at this matter more fittingly, we need to frame things in slightly more general terms and ask: what is the nature of the relationship between blunt violence and the more sophisticated mechanisms of subjectivization at work in the contemporary world? Taken out of context, Foucault’s statement that “in itself the exercise of power is not violence” immediately sets up an opposition between the two terms. Of course he meant, as his work thoroughly demonstrates, that although violence might be, and indeed often is, an instrument of power, power itself is exercised over a free subject who have choices as opposed to the violence imposed upon a captive subject who has absolutely no choice. In other words, power is not the work of repression, i.e., it is not solely a negative force; it also works productively through the shaping of our ways of being in the world.[1] In spite of Foucault’s positing of the relationship between power and violence not as mutually exclusive terms but as correlative elements, we insist in seeing them as each identified with a distinct historical moment. Certainly, in comparison to the very sophisticated operations of power through our bodies and minds, the crass police apparatus appears to be a relic of a remote past. But to sustain this thought is to subscribe to a very ingenuous notion: the evolutionist understanding of society which neatly organizes our development from barbarian times to today’s advanced form of organization. Clearly, violence as a practice of control has never disappeared. Although except for isolated demonstrations of its most dramatic face in the first world, it has been pretty much insulated in the third world. Now that blunt violence has made its way more nakedly into the first world, we can say without a doubt that the relationship between power and violence cannot be simply presented as a ‘new versus old’ type of problem. Power and violence are definitely contemporaneous to each other. But, are they mutually exclusive? In other words: is the use of violence only deployed by lower, unethical, forms of organization? If only our recent history could negate that bloodbaths and democratic states were not in fact sharing the same dining table we could at least fantasize about this old western logic of ‘good guys versus bad guys.’ The examples are too many to count in our hands. Chomsky’s inventory, based on research in large part allowed by the Freedom of Information Act, along numerous other sources, provides a meticulous account of our recent past, a history replete with examples of the relationship between democratic societies and the brutal violence they committed mostly elsewhere. We might have to look for the logic of the liaison between power and violence in a place not so distant from our own.</p><p>Agamben’s input to this debate, comes in the form of a study that outlines the relations between law and violence. He locates the formative nexus between law and violence at the beginning of western civilization, already present in Ancient Rome’s inseparable figures of the consul endowed with imperium and the lictor closest to him, who carried the sacrificial ax used to perform capital punishment.[2] From this contiguous relationship, Agamben traces the consistent path of its development all the way to its most radical outcome, the concentration camp, the place where control over the naked life of human beings is exerted in absolute fashion. If he is right when he says that the camp is not an isolated exception but only the most obviated sight of power and the very condition toward which we have moved, then we can begin to reformulate the question of why a hegemonic power ever more involved in the production and regulation of subjectivities[3] would still deploy the brute force of the police. The question should not any longer be ‘why’ but ‘how.’ Understanding how power simultaneously deploys subtle technologies of subjection in conjunction with blunt demonstrations of violence can prevent us from the mistake of fighting the wrong enemy. The sign might be in front of our eyes, but if we don’t know how to read it, we will fail to see that it is merely pointing to another sign. And the actual function of its message might be indeed to focus our attention in the wrong direction. Perhaps we can start by doubting the sign. Rather than asking: can the gallery be closed? Along with the related set of question that would naturally follow, like: Who authorizes it? Is it legal? These are types of questions that operate within the provided framework after all. Instead, we could ask, in a Foucauldian manner, how has this come to be possible? What conditions were fulfilled that allowed this state of things to come into being? In other words, what are the conditions of possibility for this event? Perhaps, if we can spot the fragile lines that connect the various pieces that sustain this hegemonic puzzle, we will be able to reassemble its parts in more favorable ways for most people. We might still be far from a solution but at least we can start by asking more pertinent questions.</p><p>Text by Alex Villar. Published in Radioactive (New York: White Box, 2002).</p><p><strong>Notes</strong></p><ol><li><em>Foucault, Michel “The Subject and Power,” in Art after Modernism: Rethinking Representation (New York: The New Museum, 1984), 421.</em></li><li><em>Agamben, Giorgio. Means without End: Notes on Politics(Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2000), 104.</em></li><li><em>Hardt, Michael and Toni Negri. Empire (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2000), 321.</em></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd5c0ea41b05" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/9-12-dd5c0ea41b05">9/12 </a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts">Writing and Conversations</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Freirean Detours]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/freirean-detours-9baa554a44db?source=rss----e74457179e7e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9baa554a44db</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Villar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Mar 2013 20:25:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2013-07-07T16:10:48.668Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The first thing to be said about the Paulo Freire method is that there is not such a thing. Freire himself said as much on many occasions. Despite his admonition, the Paulo Freire ‘method’ has been used widely, primarily but not exclusively in the teaching of the illiterate. There are reasons for this fixation on the method, one of them is of the set of procedures Freire designed and employed in Brazil in the 1960s. It took only 45 days to teach someone how to read. The new procedure would have completely eradicated illiteracy in Brazil were it not for the direct intervention of the military coup of 1964. The reasons for the suppression of the implementation of his pedagogy and Freire’s consequent exile first in Chile, then in the U.S. might have had something to do with his personal commitment to progressive causes. They have had certainly a lot to do with the political implications of his pedagogy. Freire’s most well known book is called nothing less than ‘Pedagogy of the Oppressed.’[1] Obviously, the notion of a single category of oppressed people under which complex subjectivities would be lumped together would be seem as essentializing today. So, his book needs to be read with the awareness of its conception during the polarizing sixties. Nevertheless, what is articulated there is rather valuable.</p><p>Freire developed his pedagogical principles against what he termed ‘banking’ education; i.e. teaching that functions as deposits of information into an empty container–the empty space being the head of the student. According with the goal promoted by the banking educators, the student would, at the end of his or her education be filled with all the information necessary to be fully functional in society. Freire scrutinized this approach and described all its inherent problems and the consequences of its use. First of all, the mind of the student is not a blank slab on which knowledge can be written. The students already come to school with a baggage of life experiences. They already bring with them values they have absorbed from their particular backgrounds. The banking approach ignores the specificities of these different backgrounds. Or rather, it validates some values in detriment of others. Freire correlates the high number of drop out rates among impoverished and ethnic communities with the alienation they undergo when faced with a curriculum that does not validate their life experiences. In place of the most complete negligence for the student’s prior to school knowledge, Freire proposed the most complete, in fact minute, attention to the specificities of the student’s experience as a social being. The curriculum itself was going to be assembled from the collection of ‘codifications,’ i.e. images and/or words that could represent the universe of experience of the student. This collected vocabulary constitutes the student’s contribution to the educational experience. In contrast to the ‘banking’ approach, which perceives the student as the mere receiver of a message entirely formulated by the teacher–its passive target, Freire’s approach conceives of the whole process as starting with the student and remaining dialogical throughout.</p><p>Freire also contested the purported neutrality of education, its self proclaimed universality, which in actuality conceals the discussion of the social grounding of knowledge. Neutrality operates as a filter that blocks out discourses that appear to ‘take sides,’ leaving one of the sides free to appear as if it were the natural way of being. Freire attacks this equation and does so simply by taking a position. His position is indeed a radical one. He notes that education is used as a tool to assure the perpetuation of a hegemonic power. His practice here takes two paths. On one hand he worked with post-colonial governments in Africa to build their new educational programs. On the other hand, he worked under capitalist governments to develop an essentially subversive project. The content of his education was not in itself always used to promote revolution. But insofar as his pedagogy fostered the discussion of the conditions of living and labor of the subjects involved in the learning, it could be seen as playing a role in a broader program of social reform. This second way, the one that operates from within an antagonist system to generate a subversive practice is precisely where the interest lies while coming to Freire’s pedagogy from a contemporary vantage point. When we consider the argument that there is no longer an outside to power, the immediate quest arises about the need to think of critical ways of operating from within. This thought is of course not new. The line from Foucault to Negri via Deleuze is just one of the most clear examples of it. Freire can provide a way of thinking in similar terms in the educational context. Granted we don’t treat his thinking as that which it is not, i.e. a method. The reasons for Freire’s reluctance in accepting the reduction of his ideas to a fixed methodology have to do with a sharp understanding that the crystallization into a method of a dialogical pedagogy would render a contradiction. More importantly, the literal application of his method would lay a grid upon a variety of situations, contributing to their homogenization and possible consolidation. Instead of the Paulo Freire method that can teach someone how to read in less than two months, what is more important is his conception of an entirely different approach to education, a process which allows the subject to contribute to the educational process, to learn words while discussing the world as well as reflecting upon their role in it.</p><p>In order to fully depart from the method it might be instructive to look at it a bit more closely. The process starts with the research of the student’s universe, in search of its codifications. A group comprised of educators and students take charge of the field research. Collected examples might include photos or drawings of people engaged in a variety of every day situations like work, craft, play, etc. The action in the classroom takes the form of conversations about such codifications. Freire calls this phase ‘decodification,’ which means the unfolding of the coded or symbolic meaning represented in the visual props. For example, a work situation would be discussed not abstractly as if it existed in the natural world, but rather as a socially constructed activity that has cultural, economic and political determinants. One reason for starting with the discussion of codified situations is so that the more abstract concepts to come can be foregrounded by the affirmation of the student’s experience. Codifications pave the way to their synthesizing into a selection of generative words, i.e. a core group of words from which other words can be generated. These words come from the pool of words that represent the universe of the students, i.e. words found during the discussion of the codifications. The selected words should also possess a good potential for recombination. The Portuguese word ‘tijolo,’ which means brick, is an example used during the teaching of urban illiterates in the late 50’s in Brazil who worked primarily in construction jobs. The word was segmented in its three syllables: ti-jo-lo. This syllables function as modular blocks that can form other words. A different vowel is added to each syllable to form other morphemes: ta, te, ti, to, tu; ja, je, ji, jo, ju; la, le, li, lo, lu. The word ‘lote,’ which refers to a basic unit of land can be formed with the syllables ‘lo’ and ‘te,’ and so on, leading to the discussion of their meaning and relationship to one another. It is not a matter of finding a fixed structure for language, if anything it becomes clear throughout this process that the signifier-signified relationship is contingent upon each particular context. The decomposition of words into smaller units does not tie them up to meaning; Freire is not talking about prefixes or any such basic units of meaning. The syllabic segmentation provides a game-like procedure that sets in motion creative juxtapositions. It is the subject her/himself that does the semantic work. These procedures were specifically designed to teach someone how to read and write, more particularly while learning the Portuguese language.[2]</p><p>Let us attempt to translate Frere’s thinking to a different set of circumstances, say for example to art education, without simply adapting his methodology. It becomes clear from looking at the details of the ‘method’ that its importation into a radically different situation would not produce equivalent results. Say for example that in order to teach students about contemporary artistic practices one would simply segment the field’s various strategies into modular groups that when combined would provide the subject with the ability to read and engage with art and culture. The seductive trap set up by this procedure resides in its promise to encapsulate a moving target within a fixed vocabulary. In spite of the apparent similarity of this approach with Freire’s, what would be implemented is simply a more flexible banking approach. We could call this approach ‘interactive,’ which in popular computer usage is little more than the possibility of user input within a limited range of possibilities. We should look instead toward the translation of Freire’s general pedagogical principles.</p><p>Perhaps the single most important notion in his pedagogy is the concentration on concrete situations. Instead of abstract concepts that would eventually materialize in reality, the group should start from the situation itself and only then investigate the concepts that sustain it. Also, there is not a single situation that is paradigmatic of a whole variety of problems. So, one should start from very particular events that arise during the dialogue with the students and relate them to broader phenomena. Examples of current situations could be extracted from a variety of sources: the student’s own everyday social and educational experiences, news reportage on TV and newspapers, arguments in theoretical journals, among other sources. Obviously the subject matter needs to be narrowed down to prevent complete disintegration of content. For example, in a class designed to teach critical spatial practices in contemporary art the theme ‘space’ would provide a relatively well defined, while still flexible, frame to aid the selection process. Instead of words, one can imagine questions that would trigger both the collecting of ‘codifications’ and the selection of possible artistic strategies conceived to tackle particular problems. While a final list of questions can only come from the actual discussion, one can imagine a few possibilities coming directly from the immediate surroundings of the students: How are the public and private areas physically represented in campus? Who is allowed to go where? Is there a gender qualifier attached to such locations? How are these spaces represented visually and verbally, are there signs or other means of spelling out the rules? Are there ways of circumventing the rules? Following these questions, the geographical spectrum could be enlarged to include the city itself: How does the university stand in relation to the city? How does it represent itself to the public through the usage of fliers, maps, bulletins, advertising? Who goes there? Where do they come from? What about those that don’t go there, why don’t they? At this point one could move on to the whole city and its relationship to the country: How does this city come across to the rest of the country? What is its self-image like? Do cities promote themselves? How do they do it, by what means? Who does it? Are artists used for that purpose? Can art engage critically in this process? Who has done so? Although it is not necessary to follow such a linear sequence from the particular context of the university to the general and multiple context of the country, its pursuit can be helpful to broaden and complexify the discussion gradually. A similar set of questions could be asked about the relationship between countries: How is one represented to the other? How one comes to appear as a center while others are classified as periphery? Who has the power to articulate such representations? How can such hegemonic representations be rearticulated? The point of the questions is to allow the presentation and discussion of various artistic approaches to tackle each particular problem while departing from the problems themselves.[3]</p><p>The other significant element of Freire’s pedagogy lies in fostering the students’ ability to grow beyond the provided knowledge, which he accomplishes by employing generative words. Such words are more than simple building blocks since the possibilities they allow cannot be traced back to the words themselves but only to their common particles. In our example of translation to art education, we have proposed to trigger the research of codifications by asking a series of questions pertinent to the subject matter of the chosen course. In continuing with our speculative example, we can imagine a selection of generative ‘clusters of problems/tactics’ to come out of the discussion about the codifications. Our final selection would contain a fixed, although not limited, number of space related problems accompanied by examples of artistic approaches employed in relation to similar problems. It is important to present a variety of approaches to avoid a mechanical linkage between problem and solution. What is to be emphasized is the problem/criticality nexus, not the subscription to any dogmatic paradigm. These clusters could be introduced against a background of the theoretical discourses that have informed current artistic practices, particularly ideas and debates in architecture, media and film studies. Simply put, the goal is to allow the student to understand the larger historical context and to learn to think from within, that is to think from within the problem s/he confronts and to develop creative responses, initially by ‘playing’ with the examples given and finally by developing their own responses. The goal is after all not just the learning of a few bags of tricks, but to engage the subjects who participate in the educational experience in a more integral act of cognition.</p><p>No approach to education informed by Freire’s thinking would be worth its claim without a practical intervention. Any validity these remarks might have will not be confirmed without their being put to test, which would essentially transform them. This is not to say that speculative thinking is a futile exercise, only that these ideas should be used as a sketch, an initial outline to be subjected to further critical scrutiny. Also, the brief introduction of Freire’s thinking in this essay is not intended as a summing up of his ideas. More than 30 years have passed since the publication of Freire’s first works. There is now a large secondary literature on him added to Freire’s own prolific output; there is much to be read in terms of current revisions and critical views of his approach, especially by those who were involved with his pedagogy. A real dialogue with his thinking would also not be complete without a critical engagement with his ideas. Let us end this brief introduction with the suggestion that we begin a dialogue with and, when necessary, beyond Freire.</p><p>Text by Alex Villar. Published in Homework (New York: Artwurl, 2007) and in Valdez: An Anthology of Revolutions: (New York: Valdez, 2002).</p><p><strong>Notes</strong></p><ol><li><em>Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Mira Bergman Ramos, trans. (New York: Continuum, 1992).</em></li><li><em>Thanks to Marta Fronc for her comments and suggestion to substantiate this essay with more examples, which derive from: Ana Maria Araujo Freire and Donaldo Macedo, eds., The Paulo Freire Reader (New york: Continuum, 1998).</em></li><li><em>These thoughts about class design are informed by frequent discussions with François Bucher, Katya Sander and Valerie Tevere.</em></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9baa554a44db" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts/freirean-detours-9baa554a44db">Freirean Detours</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/de-tour-texts">Writing and Conversations</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>