<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Fluff, Fumble, Splat - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Perspectives on storytelling, worldbuilding, and the craft of writing. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 09:53:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/fluff-fumble-splat" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Solarpunk in 2023: An Introduction to Solarpunk]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/solarpunk-in-2023-an-introduction-to-solarpunk-b86877408f31?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b86877408f31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[speculative-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ecology-and-environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solarpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daeres]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 Feb 2023 00:12:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-18T00:22:18.591Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A painting of a rounded, organic looking house set in a quiet marshy landscape, with a forest visible in the background. There is a slight mist on the landscape, the kind that makes you think fondly of the early morning rather than anything sinister. The house looks as though seven cherry trees have been grown together to form its core structure, with a glass-like substance set between the branches, creating a house with a bulbous, mushroom like upper storey." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/930/0*vasuXDAsW_cm_n53.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Maison des Cerisiers</strong> by Luc Schuiten. His work predates the solarpunk movement, yet anticipated many of its philosophies.</figcaption></figure><p>In 2016, I wrote <a href="https://medium.com/p/e996aebfd610">this article</a>. In it, I talked about an emerging speculative genre and community called solarpunk, one firmly rooted in the idea of humanity responding to the consequences of its ecological misdeeds not with denial, or fear, but with sleeves rolled up. It was a vision of sustainability and optimism that was already poignant in that moment, offering a concrete alternative to the paralysing fear that many already felt about climate disaster. I was firmly convinced that solarpunk was breaking through, that its cloud of ideas was imminently about to solidify into creations for people to engage with.</p><p>Almost seven years have passed since then. I could say, with some justification, that the passage of time alone would justify a sequel article, talking about solarpunk’s journey in the intervening years and its current state. But my desire to reconnect with this topic is also firmly rooted in cumulative grief. Both my own, and the grief we have experienced as societies and communities over the past seven years. Solarpunk is, at its core, a speculative conversation about healing, rebirth, and restoration, one that doesn’t involve retreat into nostalgia or imply that you must become a better <em>type</em> of being to experience a better type of existence. Amid such grief as we have already experienced, as we grapple with the problems of yesterday, today, and tomorrow, I think exploring solarpunk is more important than ever.</p><p>To look at solarpunk in the kind of detail I think is necessary, a single sequel article isn’t enough. The genre and movement are large enough at this stage a seven minute read isn’t going to cut it for what I have in mind. Instead this is the first of a series of articles looking at different aspects of solarpunk in 2023.</p><p>At times I will raise comparisons with other genres where it seems relevant and appropriate, but I am not going to constantly measure or define solarpunk by a more widely known genre. My focus is instead on presenting as much of the solarpunk movement’s own perspective and context as I can manage, whilst still providing my own commentary and analysis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0s3WVbyLg2eIIZ0r.jpg" /><figcaption>Solarpunk concept art created as a collaborative piece by Rojom and gazolyn (on Reddit), aka Archeives (their joint account on Instagram)</figcaption></figure><h3>What is Solarpunk?</h3><p>Solarpunk is a political movement and creative genre that imagines sustainable human existence through an optimistic lens. Most deliberately created solarpunk stories are set in the near future, and examine versions of human living in which we as a species act far closer to being the environment’s gardeners and caretakers rather than its masters. These modes of living differ by author and interpretation, but are unified by their shared focus on environmentalism and sustainability, and by their rejection of mass-consumerist solutions and ideologies.</p><p>The full documentation of solarpunk’s origins is complex, and the subject of a separate article in this series. To summarise, whilst tentative explorations of similar concepts can be documented online since 2008, what is now recognised as solarpunk was first explored by a Brazilian anthology called <em>Solarpunk</em>: <em>Histórias Ecológicas e Fantásticas em Um Mundo Sustentável </em>published in 2012. Various small scale movements began to coalesce almost immediately. This nascent genre then attracted much wider notice in 2014, after <a href="https://missolivialouise.tumblr.com/post/94374063675/heres-a-thing-ive-had-around-in-my-head-for-a">a tumblr post about the concept</a> went viral, to the point where some incorrectly attribute the origin of the solarpunk genre in its entirety to that post. The genre has continued to grow ever since.</p><p>Many core ideas of solarpunk are collected by <a href="https://www.re-des.org/a-solarpunk-manifesto/">this document, helpfully titled ‘A Solarpunk Manifesto’</a>. This is not the only plausible interpretation of solarpunk, nor does this manifesto itself as the sole source of solarpunk’s core ideals. Instead, the document is a kind of distillation of multiple perspectives on solarpunk, and even in so doing freely acknowledges at the very beginning that the genre ‘is not yet clearly defined’. That this manifesto acknowledges its limitations, cites its source material, and does not presume to own the concept of solarpunk or means of defining it is, hopefully, representative of the genre in its own right. Inclusivity, adaptability, and at times decentralisation are all crucial aspects of the solarpunk movement as articulated by its most active proponents. This likewise means that solarpunk refuses to impose a unitary aesthetic or ‘correct’ set of solutions on either the genre itself or the societies that are imagined by its authors.</p><p>However, on the whole solarpunk tends to specifically reject retrofuturism. Retrofuturism, in this context, is speculative work that creates <em>alternate</em> presents and futures by borrowing the materials (and aesthetics) of how past societies imagined the future would look, and at times the most outlandish-seeming elements of that past society. Steampunk is a clear example of a retrofuturist aesthetic and genre, for instance. Solarpunk is instead focused on <em>possible</em> futures. It does not imagine our present as something to be rejected in totality, in the way that other speculative genres often prefer to wipe the slate clean of contemporary communities and people. Its proponents are concerned with imagining how to make things better for <em>us</em>, the people of today and tomorrow. There have been individual solarpunks who have delved into past aesthetic movements for inspiration, and in my 2016 article I had imagined solarpunk attached to an art nouveau revival. However, this is not the same as retrofuturism’s forward-projection of yesterday’s futures.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VY0P4V9ltHpUKqmO" /><figcaption>A take on a solarpunk Cape Town, created by pickledtezcat</figcaption></figure><p>Solarpunk has evolved to aim for more than simply thematic inclusivity, and began to actively seeking to carve out spaces for, to quote Jay Springett;</p><blockquote>indigenous sovereignties, reproductive justice, and radical queer politics</blockquote><p>This is fundamentally a statement about what we can and should be doing <em>in this present</em> <em>moment</em>. This is also, to my mind, what separates solarpunk as a movement and as literature most strongly from what I’d call ‘traditional’ cyberpunk and steampunk, the earliest of the self declared -punk genres.</p><p>Many formative cyberpunk works placed a scaremongering fear about western society being insidiously transformed, ‘invaded’ economically and culturally, by Japanese culture at their heart, whilst also fixating on the notion of bionics, prosthetics, and other body modifications as fundamentally dehumanising. Likewise, steampunk very quickly grew to elide the immense human cost of Victorian-inspired industrial societies, eliding the impact on working class members of those societies, eliding the immense colonial extraction networks required to gather many of those industrial resources, eliding the genocidal reach of European imperialism. At its worst certain steampunk communities essentially became British Empire cosplayers with a few extra cogs and gears thrown in, pith helmets and all.</p><p>Solarpunk, by contrast, is a movement that actively seeks multiple perpectives, that aims to connect ecological catastrophe with the wider injustices of society rather than treating ecocide as the sole arbiter of humanity’s fate, and that (theoretically) isn’t using exploration of the future to avoid confronting the injustices of the present. In solarpunk struggles for racial equality, reproductive rights, and many other causes that impact people right now are not secondary to the goal of sustainable life, they are placed at the heart of imagining what a possible future should look like. Solarpunk has, I feel, sought to grow by actively inspiring people, by providing something meaningful, rather than appealing to pure curiosity. It has sought to provide a community, but also a framework to provide grounded optimism. I do often have a sense, however, of a pressure within the community to prove worthy of these ideas, to meet expectations, that sometimes overcorrects into abstention from contributing to the growing body of solarpunk creative work.</p><h3>The Solarpunk Community: Who are Solarpunks?</h3><p>Solarpunk is, at its heart, a decentralised movement. Nobody with any credibility claims ownership over solarpunk, or to be its leader. The elder generation of solarpunks, those who became attached to the movement in its earliest days, will at most refer to themselves as stewards, usually in the context of explaining the movement’s history to outsiders and newcomers. They do not, to my awareness, ask for special status or credibility within the modern movement as a result of their relative longevity. Neither is there a single formal space or organisation to which solarpunks are expected to belong, or in which they are expected to make an appearance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/0*kNiQcjykkp4fLv2E.jpeg" /><figcaption>Concept art by Teikoku Shounen, aka Imperial Boy. His artwork was among the first to be used to explore an explicitly solarpunk aesthetic, and I used it in my 2016 article as its main image.</figcaption></figure><p>The end result is that the solarpunk community is maybe best understood as a network rather than a definable entity, a network that at times nests smaller, more ‘definable’ sub-communities within. This network bridges diverse pre-existing communities and movements. The solarpunk community has strong overlaps with environmentalism, futurism, sci fi fandom, and ecological science, which you would correctly call fairly ‘obvious’ connections to an ecologically focused genre of speculative fiction. However, it also has equally strong overlaps with queer communities, anarchism, and hacker subculture, as well as afrofuturism, indigenous activism, and other communities of colour outside of these specific movements.</p><p>Through the community’s quite deliberate decentralisation the solarpunk movement has very soft edges, to the point where there are people who would call themselves solarpunks who are not necessarily greatly familiar with any of the genre’s recent fiction or its specific history. Likewise, several significant contributors to the genre and the community are not ‘full time’ participants, with established roots in other genres and whose most prominent work is often not within solarpunk as a whole. For example, Jaymee Goh, Daniel José Older and Cory Doctorow are all important contributors to solarpunk that are not necessarily known primarily for those contributions. Even the editor of the very first solarpunk anthology, the prolific Gerson Lodi-Ribeiro, is best described this way, having many more famous works within Portuguese-language sci fi than the <em>Solarpunk</em> anthology. That 2012 anthology is one of <em>seven</em> such genre-focused anthologies that he has edited to date, and to my knowledge <em>Solarpunk</em> remains his only direct contribution to, well, solarpunk.</p><p>This is not an accusation directed at either the genre or at those authors. If anything it’s very important to the health of solarpunk that these kinds of intersections have taken place and continue to take place. If they hadn’t, the very first published literature terming itself solarpunk wouldn’t have appeared in 2012, and numerous of the published solarpunk anthologies to date would either not have come into existence or been left poorer for the absence of numerous poems and stories produced by authors with that kind of relationship with the genre. Solarpunk’s soft edges are crucial. For a genre that is still at a formative stage, where there are still far more people talking about the solarpunk they’d like to see written than writing it, the more contributors become involved the merrier, even if they don’t necessarily dedicate their creative lives purely to this one genre and movement.</p><p>My hope, both for the current state of solarpunk communities and for its success in the future, is that its soft edges are not maintained at the expense of any of the sub-communities it shelters. One of the single most destructive forces that can be applied to any movement dedicated towards a vision of social justice, decentralised or otherwise, is the harbouring of those who loudly claim that they follow its vision but who, in reality, are harming others through toxic behaviour or even bigotry. This is already a lesson that has been drilled into me through lengthy personal experience, but which has been further emphasised by, well, <em>gestures at the 2020s to date</em>,<em> </em>we’re experiencing a period in which the language of social justice is frequently co-opted to feign innocence by bad faith actors, or clung to by those incapable of perceiving that they are acting against their stated beliefs. Likewise, every community brought together by enthusiasm and a general belief in goodwill will have its moment of innocence lost, where some dispute or moment of personal behaviour will shatter prior harmony that was previously taken for granted. In these moments stewards, to borrow Jay Springett’s term of choice, are vital. Care, after all, is not just passively being nice to people, it also involves defending them from those who are doing them harm.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/375/0*9bEM1guClF6elHHz.jpg" /><figcaption>Sunvault, the earliest solarpunk anthology that I bought a physical copy of</figcaption></figure><p>In the next article in this series I’ll be looking at the literature and creative works the solarpunk community has produced to date, along with its reception.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b86877408f31" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/solarpunk-in-2023-an-introduction-to-solarpunk-b86877408f31">Solarpunk in 2023: An Introduction to Solarpunk</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat">Fluff, Fumble, Splat</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Power of Map Creation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/the-power-of-map-creation-62d5df0163a?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62d5df0163a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cartography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[worldbuilding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-process]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maps]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daeres]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Apr 2020 02:03:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-04T02:01:50.204Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VKtyFjQus3r7-ERN7fDDMw.png" /><figcaption>An infographic of the planet Asterion, by the author</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve been trying to write about the relationship between mapmaking and the worldbuilding process for a while. It’s been a repeated game of putting finger to keyboard and failing miserably. The main reason for that is that the subject is much broader than it seems. Even for someone who has made maps for years, and is comfortable rambling about subjects at a moment’s notice, it’s intimidating in scope. But we’re all a little trapped in our own homes and heads at the moment. It’s a fine time to be talking about the act of creation, and imagining worlds other than this. So here we are.</p><p>Let’s talk about Maps.</p><p>The Map is a big deal in the creation of fictional worlds. With the proliferation of graphics editors, and the platforms on which to share our creations, they are arguably even more of a big deal than ever before. It’s not just that published fantasy works will have An Official Map attached, it’s that people with works-in-progress will have made a decent attempt at An Official Map before they’ve even seemingly finished their first draft. Oh look, here’s a hobbyist with no intention of using their fictional setting for any published works who has personally put together a jaw-droppingly beautiful, professional quality map. The minute you venture into any worldbuilding-related community these things will be everywhere.</p><p>It will soon feel like any worldbuilder or author worth following has A Map. Does this mean <em>you</em> have to have A Map?</p><p>When you see the level of attention and engagement these pieces of work can get, it can definitely begin to seem obligatory. The current internet is dominated by a relatively small number of highly used sites and apps, most of which involve sharing content and visible metrics of engagement. One soon begins to notice that worldbuilding content that comes with high quality maps gets, on the whole, more engagement than that which does not. For those without pre-existing skills in digital graphics or traditional art this, at best, smacks of gatekeeping. The numberless corpses of maps judged to be poor quality, ignored by everybody, is testament to that fact.</p><p>Let’s say it out loud. Feeling you have to make a map because you’ll get more upvotes, retweets, likes, shares, reblogs, or views is not a healthy mindset.<br>No, you <em>don’t</em> have to have A Map.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S2FPBNlhgY4ZH-2DfKPaqw.png" /><figcaption>Though they are very handy for breaking up large bodies of text. An abstractified map of Bactria, once again by the author.</figcaption></figure><p>There are plenty of reasons why making, or commissioning, a map for your ongoing project might make sense. Maps can be working documents just as much as they are pieces of visual art. If your work involves a lot of Proper Nouns in the form of locations and regions then it can prove a handy resource for readers, and yourself, to keep track of these things. Alternatively you might want a visual component to your work and lack the experience or confidence to post things like character art, but possess enough experience with digital graphics to produce a map you feel good about sharing. Or you might want to invoke a particular atmosphere for the work, even heavily stylising the map in question to best fit the intended mood.</p><p>And then there are those of us for whom mapmaking is itself part of the creative process.</p><p>This is when things get more complicated.</p><p>If making maps is intrinsic to your creative process we’re no longer dealing with simple questions of peer pressure. Instead we’re getting into the specific qualities of cartography, above and beyond its relationship to creating fictional worlds. This is a creative field that has <em>history</em>, and it’s this part that makes our topic so cavernous. Maps, and mapmaking, hold specific power beyond being attractive graphics in an era of tiny screens and endless scrolling. Because they hold power, maps are not neutral. Let’s get into why.</p><p>Maps proclaim certainty over what they depict. This city is here, that other city is there. This river flows from here and ends there. This area is divided administratively and politically like so. This street is named thus. These people live here, those people live there. This is reality. Anything that the map does not depict within its bounds is less important, unofficial, or wrong. That certainty then allows claims of ownership, both by its decisions over what is official and by the demonstration of knowledge that it implies. This is a form of what we call reification: a material representation of an immaterial thing, and the process of making something seem more ‘real’. This is a power that has been used to give reality to epidemics, the plight of the downtrodden, the existence of the overlooked, but also to homogenise the complex, marginalise the unwanted, and to deny the inconvenient.</p><p>When it comes to creating a map for a fictional world this is heady stuff. We are giving an unreal place a kind of official existence and exactitude by the sense of certainty that maps impart, whilst also asserting our creative ownership over it. We are bringing our created world into reality, differently than through prose. We are also potentially visiting the misuse of maps on our creations, if we’re not careful. Let’s take societies that are labelled as barbarian, uncivilized or nomadic, fictional and otherwise. These tend to be presented on Official Maps two ways. The lucky ones get to be homogenised blobs with coloured-in borders similar to a ‘settled’ nation or kingdom of some kind, with totally arbitrary depicted borders and an unfounded depiction of unitary statehood. Most of them, however, are demoted to being a floating text label, often in italics, showing that this society was located in *gestures with wavey hands at general area*.</p><p>Individual maps also don’t leave a lot of room for competing claims over reality or diversity on too small a scale to demonstrate. This process can actively encourage a worldbuilder to create big homogenous blobs on the map, as this speeds up the creation process and makes large scale maps easier to produce. By doing so we’re often unconsciously erasing subcultures, non-sovereign nations, and cultural variations before they’ve even had a chance to come into existence in this created world. We lose our chance to present a world where borders and ownership don’t neatly align, among other missed opportunities. And where there <em>are</em> more complex realities in our prose, or in our heads, we often do them a disservice by presenting the kind of neat cartographic reality that would have appealed to a 19th century imperial power.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*c2aL5riebH2w6GgWvmcP7g.png" /><figcaption>This was an earnest attempt to map the worldview of a culture from an alternate history I was writing. The overall form is meant to resemble <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liver_of_Piacenza">Etruscan haruspicy models</a>. Also by the author.</figcaption></figure><p>None of this means that Maps Are Bad, or even that Maps That Show Borders Are Bad. It means that the information we put in our maps, and how that’s presented, is something that should be carefully, and conscientiously, considered. It means that the creativity and invention of maps can be pushed further than presently. It means that we don’t have to replicate what has gone before, even when it’s aesthetically pleasing or popular. All acts of creation benefit from deliberation, and thinking outside the box. In the case of worldbuilding, our maps improve from making this extra effort just as much as any other aspect of the craft.</p><p>When’s the last time you saw anybody make a map from the perspective of a nomadic horse-riding culture? A map that focuses on their needs and behaviours, that shows the migration routes of different subcultures and important landmarks along the way? When’s the last time you saw a map that revels in disagreement and ambiguity about what things are called, who they belong to, that champions the street and the vernacular? Have you ever seen a pair of contrasting maps that show starkly, maybe irreconcilably, different visions of the subject matter? None of these ideas rely on gatekeeping via digital graphics skill either, this is ambition of concept which doesn’t rely on the perfection of its execution.</p><p>There’s nothing wrong with wanting to get better at making maps. There’s nothing wrong with wanting to get your work more attention by sharing maps. But what I’m claiming about the power of mapmaking still gives no ground to the notion that you have to have a high quality map for your worldbuilding to count, or for your world to be worth paying attention to. In an online environment that prizes numbers getting higher, and displays many of those numbers publicly, that is still not a measure of the quality of your interactions or its impact. Nor is it a measure of how ‘good’ your world is.</p><p>What your world will benefit from is imagination, forethought, and pushing out of the easy paths that popular online content has already trampled into the long grass. Whether mapmaking is part of your worldbuilding process, or a necessary moment for a singular purpose, it can never function as an easy ticket to worthiness, or as a stamp of recognition. But we are presented with a far greater opportunity than that. By choosing heartfelt expression we are given the chance not just to reify the world which we have created, but to amplify everything that is exciting, considerate, and innovative about it. If you treat it as an opportunity to be radical, mapmaking can be a radical act. So why not take the hand that is offered?</p><p>If you do take this path, there is a decent chance your work might not fit in with the hot property of today’s internet. My honest belief: <em>so be it</em>. When you push confidently and consistently towards conscientious innovation you <em>will</em> draw just as much attention, perhaps more, than those going down the well trodden path. And when they do, you will know that it’s your world and your vision that drew their notice, not how closely you managed to imitate a world atlas from 1958 because that’s what everyone else is doing. Make a map that you want to make, when you want to make it, because you want to make it. And if you don’t want or need to make a map then don’t. Any suggestion of obligation to produce a map for a created world, professional quality or otherwise, should be treated with the contempt it deserves. Go make awesome things.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62d5df0163a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/the-power-of-map-creation-62d5df0163a">The Power of Map Creation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat">Fluff, Fumble, Splat</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Solarpunk- Welcome to the club]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/solarpunk-welcome-to-the-club-e996aebfd610?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e996aebfd610</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solarpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daeres]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 May 2016 15:59:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-05-23T15:58:46.415Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0enx2a3P0pTxVC97.jpg" /><figcaption>Cityscape, by Imperial Boy</figcaption></figure><p>The -punk family of genres is an extremely fertile one. Though most people have only really heard of cyberpunk or steampunk, the -punks have never really stopped multiplying since steampunk first appeared in the late 1980s. The majority of them are only really known by small communities, genre-fiction enthusiasts, or TV Tropes addicts, but they’re out there. Biopunk, clockpunk, dieselpunk, dungeonpunk, oceanpunk, and yes, there’s also punkpunk in the form of <a href="http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PunkPunk">a trope name</a>. But whilst I feel many of these -punks are destined to remain low key, or only a ‘thing’ to people who like naming genres, there’s a new -punk on the block that I think has the mileage and strength of community to break into the mainstream over the next few years. Its name is solarpunk, and I’d like to talk about it a little.</p><p>Despite the enthusiasm and passion of its adherents, I don’t think a great many people beginning this article will be familiar with the nascent genre of solarpunk; imagine an <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_Nouveau">Art Nouveau</a> aesthetic combined with eco friendly, green technologies. That’s the genre’s visuals in a nutshell. Its tone is generally optimistic, and like cyberpunk it is primarily geared around imagining a new, future society, as opposed to steampunk which is all about re-using bits of an older, Victorian society. That’s solarpunk.</p><p>It was something I first encountered not long after the original tumblr post suggesting a new -punk genre was created, specifically in <a href="http://missolivialouise.tumblr.com/post/94374063675/heres-a-thing-ive-had-around-in-my-head-for-a">this post</a>. I ran into it because someone else had linked to it on their tumblr blog, which showed me that it had definitely caught attention, but at the time I had no idea whether it would actually result in anything wider or not. Fast forward a year and nine months and I can say for sure that it’s definitely caught on.</p><p>Yet I began the article assuming no one reader would already be aware of the genre, and right now no published work calling itself solarpunk has reached any kind of mass awareness. So when I’m talking about the genre catching on, I’m not talking about solarpunk being a name on everyone’s lips, and solarpunk books flying off the shelves. What I’m talking about is the stage before that, the stage where a bunch of highly talented people all get enthusiastic about an idea, talk about it with one another, and spread the idea to yet more highly talented people. There are groups and boards relating to solarpunk that have sprung up all over the internet, and even a couple of publications. This kind of movement is, in my opinion, guaranteed to start producing results, and all it takes is a breakout piece of solarpunk media or two for this creative infrastructure to be unleashed into wider awareness, where it’ll no doubt thrive.</p><p>That being said, I’ve already treated both cyberpunk and steampunk with a critical eye on Medium and, if solarpunk wants to be the new big thing, it should be subject to the same level of criticism, accounting of course for the fact that it’s a toddler compared to Grandpa Cyberpunk and Uncle Steampunk. And there are a few things about solarpunk as currently envisaged which have me concerned.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jlFoOtBk6O1v3ge5.jpg" /><figcaption>The world needs more science fiction based on this aesthetic, that’s for sure!</figcaption></figure><p>It seems to me that the genre is actually a new iteration of utopian sci fi without calling itself that. This is what separates it from most of its other -punk relatives, many of them are imagining possible or cool-looking societies, not envisaging a society the author thinks is great and wants to actually see happen. I’m not in any way objecting to idealistic sci fi settings, not only do I have a fondness for them but I think the pendulum in popular culture is firmly swinging back towards positive, or optimistic speculative fiction. That’s actually part of why I think solarpunk is going to be in the right place at the right time.</p><p>My problem is actually to do with setting derived tension, aka the Roddenberry Problem. Once you establish a future society that seems to have fundamentally better than our own, which from our point of view seems closer to utopian than not, what aspects of that setting can be played for drama? This was a thorny issue during a particular phase of Star Trek’s existence because not only was the Federation a pretty excellent place in which to live, Gene Roddenberry, the series’ original creator, kept trying to have humans behave and react in ways which prevented any kind of on-screen drama. In the case of the franchise’s later series the desire to burst free of these writing constraints led to writers blasting sacred cows of the franchise with phasers, not always successfully.</p><p>This is not an intractable problem. High quality slice-of-life media does exist which lacks any antagonists of any kind, for example, and a good writer could still create interpersonal drama in a setting where many material and political concerns are lacking. Likewise, some writers who used their personal philosophy to create speculative societies still managed to talk about flaws and failings of those systems they otherwise agreed with. Ursula K. Le Guin in particular has always been good at this. But this requires discipline that genre fiction has not always successfully maintained, and if the problem becomes endemic then it will definitely limit the size and scope of solarpunk, as well as exposing it to the same kind of pendulum swing that will push people towards it.</p><p>The other issue with settings that the author wants to come about in reality, which they are politically and personally invested in, comes to the matter of antagonists. Assuming solarpunk doesn’t become dominated by slice-of-life stories, or adaptations of Samuel Beckett plays, authors are going to want to include bad guys and enemies of various kinds. But reading, for example, the <a href="http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SolarPunk">TV Tropes page for solarpunk</a>, one gets the impression that the intended bad guys in solarpunk are roughly the same caliber of those on Captain Planet. When the supporters/characters enmeshed in an eco-friendly, politically stable, pretty looking world are faced with villains who are evil because they support less environmentally friendly industry, or simply because the evil organisation is corporate (and thus amoral), I am going to look askance at the credentials of calling that work speculative fiction.</p><p>The foundation of cyberpunk was creating protagonists who refused to partake in the alienating and inhumane system they found themselves in, who tried to exist on its margins or to damage that future in some way. The setting itself is an enemy in cyberpunk. Steampunk has at times regurgitated 19th century imperialism with a smattering of nostalgia, but you would still be able to find plenty of steampunk antagonists who are not evil because they want to bring the era of Victoriana to an end, and plenty where the protagonists are themselves opposed to problematic aspects of their own steampunky world. The strength of -punk fiction is often linked to how willing the authors are to poke credible holes in it. But when you are terribly invested in the notions and ideals of an eco-technology setting, how trustworthy are you to create actual complex villains that might not be entirely wrong, or opponents of the setting’s philosophy who are not actually villains or portrayed as evil at all? This is not a blanket statement claiming solarpunk authors are incapable of such things, but a call for self reflection, and a warning that creating too many two-dimensional villains limits the lifespan of a genre; those that lean too heavily on morally upstanding, happy protagonists versus entirely obviously evil people (who never have a good point), suffer exactly the same as those that rely on unpleasant protagonists and gritty settings full of murderdeath. Given its semi-utopian, optimistic nature, solarpunk is particularly vulnerable to this.</p><p>The hard part will not be creating solarpunk artwork, games, novels, comics, even from a cursory examination of the community it’s absolutely raring to go with ideas and projects and support. The trick is in creating a popular and sustainable genre, one as sustainable as the technologies that it speculates over. The unifying theme of all of the genre’s potential pitfalls is that solarpunk authors have to resist the temptation to outright preach. Given the wish to share optimism that lies at the heart of the genre, and the clear desire to tell people that their visions of the future need not be desolate, this is going to be really, really difficult. But we have been shown again and again what happens when a genre has that kind of atmosphere- as soon as there’s a significant shift in society, or enough people become tired of being talked at, it loses ground. Whether in academic history, or space opera settings, telling people ‘this is what progress looks like, isn’t it marvellous, aren’t things great, aren’t those who aren’t part of this or who oppose it evil’, again and again, will lead people to find alternatives with more complexity.</p><p>Solarpunk needs to exist outside political diatribe and polemic in order to be more than a counterreaction to cyberpunk. Given that I really, really like Art Nouveau, and also care about tonal diversity in fiction, this is something I’d rather avoid. I want more optimistic, visionary fiction in the spotlight, and weight is building up behind having more optimistic fiction across all forms of media. But if you’re publishing something just telling me how great X people are, in their great society of greatness, opposed by the ruthless, amoral, and unsympathetic Y people, that’s not genre-fiction, that’s moonlighting as an opposite-land Ayn Rand with a strong belief in how cool wind farms are. Please don’t be opposite-land Ayn Rand.</p><p>Whatever happens, in my opinion solarpunk is definitely going to ‘happen’. The part that’s still up for grabs is whether it’ll become a new stalwart genre, still vibrant and active in thirty years time, or whether in thirty years’ time it’ll be thought of like we think of 80s hair and neon-coloured clothing. But solarpunk is nothing if not founded on optimism, and I’m an optimistic person. Let’s dare to hope that all I’m doing is worrying about maybes, and what-ifs, and that any problems I’m seeing can and will be solved. We have room for a new genre, let’s make room for one that envisions hope for the future rather than fears it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e996aebfd610" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/solarpunk-welcome-to-the-club-e996aebfd610">Solarpunk- Welcome to the club</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat">Fluff, Fumble, Splat</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Telling Readers a Thing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/telling-readers-a-thing-326de72d85af?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/326de72d85af</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daeres]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Feb 2016 15:06:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-04T15:08:35.546Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Picture the scene. A writer has embarked on their quest to transform the world with their latest piece of fiction. They sit at their desk, or in a coffee shop, or in a library with very uncomfortable seats. Their neck is craned awkwardly as they lean forward into their typing, and by the end of this writing session will have become incredibly sore. Pillows will be needed. Soft pillows. They are typing prose at lightning speed, leaving multitudes of spelling errors for tomorrow’s author to deal with. They do so because there is a Thing that they have come to realise, and they <em>must</em> get it onto the page.</p><p>Their work may not be about the Thing but, right now, getting that Thing out of their head and into the text is the most important task in the world. Attempts at conversation or socialisation are met with silence, automatic responses, or hostility, for these are only distractions from the task at hand. Any food, no matter how delicious, will be half eaten at best until the end of the writing session, at which point it will be devoured in seconds. But amidst this frantic composition there will be pauses, some great, some small, and many of them will be about the exact method by which the Thing should be imparted to the reader.</p><p><em>Telling Readers a Thing</em> is the result of our hypothetical writer deciding that pacing, description, characterisation, and at times punctuation are all unacceptably slowing the Thing down. The integrity of the Thing must be preserved, and all other prose will be warped by its presence and <em>like</em> it, damn it.</p><p>The end result is a form of aside glance, or a wink at the camera, but without the self awareness that these imply, or any intention of comedy. It is the abandonment of artifice because the excitement of imparting the Thing is simply too great to delay any longer. The kind of things that exemplify Telling Readers a Thing are classics like <a href="http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/40cakes_4996.jpg"><em>And That’s Terrible</em></a> and Ayn Rand’s seventy page monologue in <em>Atlas Shrugged, </em>which may serve as an early indication as to why this is not a recommended practice.</p><p>Telling Readers a Thing generally takes three forms. In each case I will point out a work that, by all accounts, is guilty of doing this but in my opinion remains eminently enjoyable.</p><p>The first is an uncontrollable urge to explain every cool aspect of the setting, to the point where it seems like the work is nothing but a travel brochure. I dub this <em>Giving Readers the Lonely Planet Guide</em>. This frequently overlaps with settings that are not of this Earth, where the author has clearly been developing many ideas that they want to use and they want to make sure the reader understands every last one of them. Every. Last. One. It also usually comes from genuine confusion as to how to impart expository detail that the reader actually does need to understand for the benefit of the story. The arch-example of a work that is does this and is still well regarded is JRR Tolkien’s <em>Lord of the Rings</em>. The reason that Tolkien got away with it was because he genuinely understood the medieval epic genre that he was imitating, and because he did it with such genuine conviction. However, heed well that even people who enjoy Lord of the Rings often struggle with beginning which is almost entirely Telling Readers a Thing about Hobbits, and that there is a reason the book trilogy is not to everyone’s taste.</p><p>The second comes from a different place; it is the compulsion to demonstrate the hundreds of hours of research the author has done on a particular subject, and is not always done because the author thinks this information is cool. The author might really enjoy guns, planes, the complexities of medieval Breton economics, but in many cases it’s that they are not going through that amount of research without making everyone else suffer through it too. This is <em>Telling Readers How to Correctly Assemble a Nuclear Warhead</em>. The end result is a sudden genre switch from novel to technical manual. A futher potential embarrassment in this case is showing off all this research only for it to turn out to be incredibly inaccurate. Larry Niven manages to mostly pull this off in his fiction, because his works are generally highly character driven and there is a far greater ratio of plot to technical manual, but this also makes those few uncorrected mistakes he does make extremely obvious for the experts in those fields.</p><p>The third is perhaps the most difficult of all to deal with, because it comes from the heart. This is when there is a piece of ethics, morality, or philosophy that the author simply has to share with their readership in its complete, unabridged form. This is <em>Telling Readers What is Wrong/Right with the World</em>. If characters spouting moral opinions are doing so in character, or are argued against by non-strawmen characters, or if any number of other subtleties are in place then this is not Telling Readers a Thing. This is when you are reading a public speech from the author and you know that’s what it is, and you just can’t do anything about it. It’s time for a Public Service Announcement and you won’t get any cookies or cartoons until you’ve listened to it. Dickens gets away with it because he was writing in the mid 19th century, where such things were not only expected but encouraged. In essence this is a Grandfather Clause, because Dickens genuinely had an impact with his open criticisms of the workhouse and treatments of poverty in Victorian Britain, and because he became so foundational to storytelling in the English language. The only way you can hope to replicate Dickens is by historical sleight of hand.</p><p>Terry Pratchett is an example of coming close to Telling Readers What is Wrong with the World but averting it. Each <em>Discworld</em> novel is, in its own way, a strong expression of humanist philosophy, and with a few exceptions you always finish one of his books with a strong impression of a moral stance. However, his work frequently involved parody and satire, where aside glances were already constantly flying out at you, in that environment a moral or ethical aside glance functioned happily. It was also because he possessed enough writing talent to both have characters give voice to his opinions whilst having them remain <em>that character</em>. If you wish to gain insight on expressing moral opinions without turning into Telling Readers a Thing then you could do far worse than reading the Discworld novels in sequence from<em> Mort</em> to <em>Thud!</em>.</p><p>This not a mockery of having a Thing you need to get on the page, or that you wish to explain to people. The art of essay writing is entirely based around finding compelling ways to Tell Readers a Thing whilst showing how you came to that conclusion. This is myself offering advice that Things should be inserted into literature, particularly novels, with great care, and that heavy-handed is not a literary synonym for weighty. If I had wanted to write a purely mocking article it would have turned into 10,000 words about how laughable I find Atlas Shrugged. Instead, I’m hoping that a few more authors will keep their counsel just that little bit longer, and work their Things into their stories in a way that both does the idea justice and is supported by the rest of the work. Things are valuable, the trick is to help the reader understand how, and you will never do it by slamming the story to a halt.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=326de72d85af" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/telling-readers-a-thing-326de72d85af">Telling Readers a Thing</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat">Fluff, Fumble, Splat</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Creating more interesting Steampunk]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/creating-more-interesting-steampunk-3e92d87a9625?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3e92d87a9625</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[steampunk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daeres]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Feb 2016 18:26:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-03T14:12:49.753Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/714/0*92e5cHOyIiLL3CX7.jpg" /><figcaption>Truth, a steampunk themed coffee shop in Cape Town, photographed by Shanna Jones.</figcaption></figure><p>You might have read my first article on Medium, on issues in <a href="https://medium.com/@RMcGowanSmith/on-steampunk-and-cyberpunk-7b7b3ed8d0ca#.mryjkr56z">steampunk and cyberpunk</a>, and thought ‘well, I live in a western-type country, want to write steampunk, and I want to come up with more original stuff, and I want to improve the subgenre, how do I do that Ruairi?’. Or you might have stumbled upon this post in the vast seas of the internet. With any luck you’ve come to the right place. Be warned that this is a <em>long</em> article, because this is not a small subject.</p><h4>Settings</h4><p>Steampunk’s inspiration nursery was, and remains, the Victorian era British Empire, combined with the science fiction of Jules Verne and his contemporaries: William Gibson and Bruce Sterling’s <em>The Difference Engine, </em>though not the originator of such things, firmly established<em> </em>fantastical what-if scenarios involving the British Empire as one of steampunk’s major avenues; China Miéville’s steampunkier works, even those set in fantasy worlds, often contain a huge shout out to the great smoggy metropolis that was Victorian-era London; the free online game <em>Fallen London</em>, sharing it setting with the recent <em>Sunless Seas</em>, takes place in a Victorian London that has essentially relocated to hell (insert snarky comment about the state of London in the 2010s). The way I see Victorian London and the Victorian-era British Empire in steampunk is now much the way I see roast chicken- usually overdone. In the hands of talented creators and artists Victoriana can still form the core of intricate, imaginative, and sensitive works. But I, personally, want to be taken out of my comfort zone by fiction that I read, and most British-Empire inspired steampunk can no longer manage that, and I am not alone. Not only that, there are huge audiences who rightly crave work that speaks to their world more directly. I don’t just mean audiences in other countries, I mean audiences within our own. The active steampunk scenes in countries like Brazil are hugely encouraging, but that is not a reason for steampunkers within the western world to become complacent. I keep seeing articles on steampunk by authors who deny that the genre is inherently about the European/western industrial experience, yet all of the fiction they recommend is exactly that kind of steampunk.</p><p>Let’s talk about some undertapped potential inspirations for steampunk then, and fair warning; there will be a lot of wikipedia links in this section in the belief that anyone interested in what they find will do more comprehensive research afterwards.</p><p>There’s China, both alternate versions of the real 19th century China and imaginary places heavily inspired by the idea of a steampunk China. <em>Jadepunk</em> is a recent example of entirely rewriting the notion of steampunk to create something that is very different, particular to Chinese inspiration for the setting, and paying no heed to the Victorian world. China is the world’s largest country by population and its third largest country by geographical span, with well attested history in the area stretching back thousands of years, and a rich archaeology that goes back even further. Though often seen as homogeneous in the west China is, in fact, home to many different ethnic groups and cultures, some of whom continue to preserve their traditional lifestyles in the face of the great changes that have swept China across the 20th and 21st centuries. Imagine a fantasy world with a main setting based on a steampunk version of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kam_people">Kam people and their culture</a>, or an alternate 19th century in which the main setting is a cog, airship, and machine filled version of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yunnan#Geography">Yunnan province</a>, or even a steampunk world based heavily on the visual style of the ancient site of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanxingdui">Sanxingdui</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ASBII1MAamEZPmAE.JPG" /><figcaption>A bronze head discovered at Sanxingdui, made sometime in the 13th/12th centuries BCE.</figcaption></figure><p>We can extend this to the rest of East Asia, as well- a steampunk version of Korea under the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseon">Joseon dynasty</a>, airships carrying batteries of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hwacha">hwachas</a>, Uighurs with railways, a journey across a fantasy world inspired by the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamchatka_Peninsula">Kamchatka peninsula</a>, the life of a blacksmith living in a world living by Taoist principles who struggles to accomodate the new industrial technology becoming prevalent. Japan is unusually well served with both externally and domestically produced steampunk, but even it could do with more diverse steampunk settings, where are the steampunk <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ainu_people">Ainu</a>? Where are the steampunk works criticising Japanese <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korea_under_Japanese_rule">colonisation</a> of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiwan_under_Japanese_rule">East Asia</a> in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwantung_Leased_Territory">19th century</a>? South East Asia recently had <em>The Sea is Ours </em>cover a defiantly colonialism absent steampunk version of the region with its collection of stories, and I’d love some more works that had versions of South East Asia’s diverse cultures, a steampunk take on the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majapahit">Majapahit</a> say, or <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayutthaya_Kingdom">Ayutthaya</a>, or a fantasy version of Indonesia. Then let’s talk about the Pacific; who would honestly say no to steampunk <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polynesians">Polynesian-inspired</a> settings? How is a setting similar to the Pacific, with its huge expanses, abundant and diverse flora and fauna, and beautiful archipelagos not fertile ground for steampunk works?</p><p>Africa is the world’s second largest continent, and accounts for 20% of all land surface on the face of the planet. 1.1 billion people live on the African continent, and that’s projected to rise to 2.4 billion by 2050. There is absolutely nothing homogeneous about Africa, from the types of societies people live in, to the languages they speak, to the climate they live in, to the cultural world they engage in, to the colours of people’s skin. There are creators and thinkers who create pan-African movements, and steampunk authors who take inspiration from those movements are entirely free to do so. However, there is a world of difference between those celebratory movements and someone incapable of viewing Africa as anything other than a single lump of ‘deepest, darkest Africa’. Ethiopia-inspired steampunk work is a conspicuous absence, in my opinion, and I’d be pretty enthused about steampunk cultures inspired by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Songhai_Empire">Songhai</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mali_Empire">Mali</a>, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghana_Empire">Ghana</a>. Dare to dream, imagine an entirely different world in which West Africa is the centre of industrialisation, or the equivalent of <em>Avatar the Last Airbender</em> where, rather than fantasy versions of East Asian cultures, it’s fantasy versions of different major peoples in South or North Africa.</p><p>There are even many places in Europe traditionally ignored in western fiction, such as the Baltic nations, Romania (bar an association with Dracula), Malta, Sardinia, and much of Eastern Europe, or cultures in the ancient past of Europe that weren’t, funnily enough, Greek or Roman, who would certainly be interesting candidates for steampunkification. Nor can I forget the peoples of North and South America such as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chim%C3%BA_culture">Chimu</a>, or the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chachapoya_culture">Chachapoyas</a>, or the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ta%C3%ADno">Taino</a>, or the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haudenosaunee">Haudenosaunee</a> (perhaps better known as the Iroquois Confederacy) among countless others. Neither are the mentions of these peoples intended as an afterthought, listing the multitude of native peoples in the Americas, from the frozen north to the tip of Patagonia, would be an article in itself (and that might be an article I end up writing), and I want to encourage readers to find other under-recognised cultures under their own steam.</p><p>However, all of these suggestions come with a proviso. If you want to use these times and places as settings do them the service of proper research, and avoid turning them simply into a barrel of stereotypes. Familiarise yourself with the way these cultures were portrayed by imperial powers, modern or ancient, so that you might avoid replicating these attitudes, and if there are living cultures involved make sure that you understand their history and how to treat their culture respectfully. Remove the sentiment of deeming something ‘exotic’. If you accidentally repeat some racist caricature that you honestly had no awareness of, and find that this has been pointed out by those who are aware, have the good grace to accept this and rewrite. Likewise, with any setting you intend to be nonwhite in character, do not have their people be nothing more than set dressing for white characters to interact with. If that sounds difficult, simply having multiple nonwhite characters with agency, individual personalities, and conversations with one another that are not about a white character would be a vast improvement on a lot of fiction across <em>all</em> genres and media, not just steampunk. Even better is putting a halt to defaulting white characters as main characters, especially if the work is primarily centered around a culture where it would make no sense. I do not want to begin immersing myself in a rich, Sri Lankan inspired steampunk setting with cool robots only to suddenly be confronted by a white protagonist who commands all of the narrative’s attention.</p><h4>Characters</h4><p>You also create a more interesting steampunk world is improving the quality and diversity of the characters who inhabit it. In my experience, people are more willing to forgive an unoriginal setting that has several intriguing, well differentiated characters than something with a fantastic setting and monotonous drones rather than characters. You could give me the most wonderful steampunk world dripping with intrigue and detail, but if the characters I am experiencing this setting through are boring, or slavish copies of a character I’ve read thirty versions of already, I’m going to give up eventually. Everything that follows is obviously my own opinion rather than diktat, but I gently assume that those who have come this far do so because they are interested to see what it is.</p><p>Roleplaying sourcebooks are a law unto themselves in this area, but for everything else listen up; the more differences you have from safe, comfortable Victorian London the greater the temptation becomes to have multiple characters turn into walking exposition factories, belching out entire short stories’ worth of prose purely in the interest of Telling Readers a Thing. Barring a humorously literal interpretation of this notion this is <em>beyond</em> unwise. It’s a pit that many works have fallen into, and it’s especially prevalent in fiction which has to establish the heck out of setting it takes place in. Rather than swamping your work with paragraphs of direct exposition carefully deploy it. Find ways to integrate it into conversations characters would actually have, or have details come out incidentally, without the prose screaming at the reader that This Will Be Important Later. Casually deploy weird things in what people are doing as well as saying; ‘Jan woke up, stretched, put on his glasses, then flew his house to the west bank of the river’. Disciplined and skilled worldbuilding of this kind builds up enough goodwill to allow an expository paragraph or two later if it becomes necessary.</p><p>Do not let characters end up becoming mouthpieces for thinly veiled opinions you hold, and if you still end up having that happen do <em>not</em> let the relevant characters be your pet that nothing bad ever happens to, or forever arguing only with strawmen. Cliched characters are not automatically bad characters but keep control over them; a character that seems to be automatically generated is barely a character at all, particularly if they are an important one to the story. Even better is understanding and manipulating the cliches in question, picking key moments to alter reader expectations. Sometimes these will go so far as to be called a twist. You can either hint at a big character twist liberally, treating it like a detective story that a reader has a chance to figure out before the conclusion, or make it unexpected and shocking. When pulled off successfully an unexpected character twist definitely works, but to make it successful <em>pick your moment carefully</em>, and it’s still a good idea to leave a few crumbs hinting towards what’s to come that a re-read will spot.</p><p>Steampunk isn’t just in need of a base standard of writing, though, but also increased diversity of who and what is portrayed. It seems that all of the steampunk fiction with the most visible marketing has one of two trends. The most common is repurposing white, Victorian-era character archetypes for a modern sensibility, which skilled authors can use successfully but also encourages many of lesser skill to create legions of unoriginal characters, and reinforces the issues with steampunk and skin colour mentioned in my <a href="https://t.co/c0V4y76DGw">previous article</a>. Nearly as prevalent is the steampunk romance, the beast with a billion identical front covers, which almost always features a white female protagonist with a mostly undressed male love interest, and the love interest in the book almost always turns out to be a sensitive but strong and manly man, or to have some kind of magical/steampunky ability. That ability either manifests like the curse of Beauty and the Beast, threatening to destroy the man’s humanity, or is some sort of prosthetic for some terrible combat injury. This article is not about attacking female authors for wanting to write steampunk romance, or for what kind of characters they want to write, or god forbid complaining about writing handicapped characters, but I would like there to be a lot more sharing of space, particularly when it comes to marketing, for <em>all</em> the authors who want to write steampunk, and I wouldn’t mind a lot of the genre’s authors expanding beyond ‘write what you know’. Western steampunk in particular is lacking protagonists who are either lower class or persons of colour, never mind both.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qf2sutX9KsGz0TcB.jpg" /><figcaption>Jules Verne didn’t automatically do everything better, but can’t say I’d complain about more intricate looking covers in this sort of style. The ‘regencypunk’ <em>Newt’s Emerald</em> has a great cover, let’s import these back into steampunk!</figcaption></figure><p>The diversity of characters within a fictional world has a relationship to how interesting it’s going to be, be it in personality, upbringing, cultural identity, racial identity, sexual identity, or gender identity, or physical ability. You are not obligated to have your steampunk world have the exact same conflicts as our own, but even in a setting absent of homophobia, or racism, or classism, the skill required to create compelling characters across such a broad spectrum does indicate a minimum standard of authorial ability and an ambitious vision, not to mention the ability to avoid tokenism. Think of it as adding human geography to go with the maps. Not every creative piece with a highly diverse cast ends up being especially good, but I would struggle to think of a piece that handles such matters with dignity and respect that is anywhere near the garbage pile. <em>Perdido Street Station</em>, released by China Miéville in 2000, is one of the most highly regarded works of steampunk I’m aware of, and how many people remember that the main protagonist, Isaac, is explicitly brown-skinned, or that the final of his novels in the Bas-Lag setting, <em>Iron Council</em>, has a gay main character in Cutter? Miéville’s Bas-Lag works feature one of the most expansive collections of nonhuman species you will ever find, but critically and crucially it also contains a highly differentiated <em>human</em> cast as well, and that is reflective of the author’s abilities.</p><p>There is a tendency to call attitudes like this ‘pandering’. The tone of accusations like that leaves you somehow feeling that this is something to get angry about. In actual fact, pandering is exactly what is going on, because <em>that’s what every creator who aims to capture an audience is doing.</em> Why shouldn’t everyone be entitled to expect that there will be a wide selection of quality work that specifically attempts to entice them, to gain their particular interest? There are always going to be some authors who create with no audience in mind, and who don’t even care if their game, book, tabletop RPG sells. I think I can safely say that this covers a vanishingly small minority of creative people. The difficulty for most is producing an original vision that is also one people will be attracted to, or that agents want to hawk. Publishing remains a very homogeneous industry in many parts of the western world, but so long as there are publishers who embrace steampunk works like Balogun Ojetade’s <em>Moses: The Chronicles of Harriet Tubman</em> there is hope for the future of the genre. I’m not part of the publishing industry but it is not just a matter of waiting for them to change. We reduce the homogeneity of publishing by flooding them with high quality works which cannot be ignored, supporting the other works that snap at its heels and push its boundaries, and by supporting one another.</p><h4>Supporting other authors</h4><p>In other words, you help create more interesting steampunk by helping others gain attention. After all there is only so much a single author can produce, and as a genre becomes thriving it begins to create even more space to be explored by new and existing authors. Someone will read your work and go ‘that’s a great idea, I want to do something with this too!’, or you will read someone else’s work and go ‘damn, I wish I thought of that, but it’s also made me think of <em>this</em>’. This is the basis of healthy competition, but I also want to talk about that collaborative aspect of creation, and I don’t mean two people writing a book, or bringing together a team to make a steampunk game.</p><p>The chances are that everyone reading this article does so in an environment in which capitalism is, if not the entire basis of social relations, a huge part of the creative industry at the very least. This emphasises competition, and creativity in the modern world is often treated as an exercise in one person standing alone against the world, imposing their vision. Notice how film advertising emphasises either the director or writer, if a member of the crew of a movie is emphasised at all. Anyone who has worked on a film, video game, or a comic knows that internally this is simply not the norm. Solitary film, gamemaking, and comic work does exist, but for all that solo auteurs have enormous control over their work it is difficult to beat a high quality collaborative enterprise, one that brings together many talents in different areas into harmony, and most work in those media involves at <em>least</em> two people, often legions more. A novel is expected to only have one author, and it is true that the laying down of prose will probably be in the hands of a single person. But if you take most successful books, even excluding those that are volumes of multiple authors or that have two distinct authors, the author is not the only one who has had an impact on the final product. Any author with a great editor will swear that they are part of the creative process in their own way, and many authors will have selectively shown their work to others in the hope of feedback and responses.</p><p>Since it’s clear that I think authorship is already a collaborative enterprise let’s get talking about steampunk authors supporting one another. Authors do not suffer from someone else in the same genre becoming more successful, especially when that genre needs to be expanded and diversified. Anyone who reads a piece of genre fiction and likes it is going to seek out more high quality works that are similar to it, and a lot of the -punks are notoriously addictive for those who become enamoured. There are those who become <em>that</em> type of fan, who become attached to something and bitterly attack anything else they see as becoming popular in a similar area, but you can’t ever plan for that type of person and most are far more generous than that. In other words, suffer the success of other steampunk authors gladly, because it raises the profile of everything else associated with it, and if your work is high quality it will doubtless see the benefits in due course. The balance of public perception of the genre, and what it can produce, will alter for the better. There’s also absolutely no benefit towards resenting authors in the same genre for existing, let alone expressing that in any form. There’s also no call for being a snob about steampunk either, if you want to criticise work do so constructively, and based on that work’s own merits. Then you can expect to receive the same, instead of snobbery, when other authors find things to criticise about <em>your</em> work, and there will be things that deserve a critical response. By this process a genre grows rather than metastasising into an impossibly divided, bitter shouting match that never ends, and avoids the even worse possibility; fossilising entirely, reduced to desperately hoping the cultural pendulum will swing again within a person’s lifetime.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*s87MMxjIxkS0B4Oe.jpg" /><figcaption>Don’t let the genre turn into one of these.</figcaption></figure><p>The task of widening and improving the quality of a self identifying genre is equal parts personal and communal. It is up to individuals, you, me, the person twenty miles away doodling airships on a napkin, to develop attention grabbing settings and diverse casts of characters. We cannot, should not rely on others to make the choice for us. But when that choice is made we are not alone. Not only is it vital to morale to have friends who are also steampunk authors but you will also produce better work from their influence, and vice versa. This whole process, going into a genre to remake it one novel, short story, or even drabble at a time, is a little daunting; this is a conscious attempt to produce work to influence a wider culture. Personally that’s exactly how I think it should be, but there is also nothing wrong in wanting confederates at your side. Groups of authors build associated networks of dedicated supporters, and they in turn build audiences, and audiences are the essence of public creativity.</p><p><em>All pictures used in this article are in the public domain.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3e92d87a9625" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/creating-more-interesting-steampunk-3e92d87a9625">Creating more interesting Steampunk</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat">Fluff, Fumble, Splat</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Steampunk and Cyberpunk]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/on-steampunk-and-cyberpunk-7b7b3ed8d0ca?source=rss----d4b1319e5471---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b7b3ed8d0ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[steampunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberpunk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Daeres]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Feb 2016 18:26:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-31T15:00:07.591Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*934b3lwJ2T8sxWCt.jpg" /><figcaption>Shibuya, Tokyo- Wikipedia’s chosen image to illustrate William Gibson’s quote ‘<em>Modern Japan simply was cyberpunk</em>’.</figcaption></figure><p>‘-punk’, the rapscallion, has been leading a double life as a suffix applied to stuff. There’s the ‘-punk’ that is all about themes, and societies, and a, well, <em>punk</em> attitude; if we can’t beat the system then we’ll at <em>least</em> insult it. Then there’s the ‘-punk’ that’s about aesthetics, atmosphere, and feel, who doesn’t care much for attitude or insulting any sort of system if it comes at the expense of immersion or enjoyment. ‘Steampunk’, the bringer of cogs, goggles, and airships, and ‘Cyberpunk’, bringer of cybernetics, immersive virtual realities, and neon absolutely everywhere, are two dovetailing examples which perfectly illustrate how this is double life creating parallel movements that begin to talk past one another.</p><p>Cyberpunk was first created as a term in 1980, by Bruce Bethke in his eponymous story <em>Cyberpunk</em>. The inclusion of ‘punk’ in the title was very deliberate. Steampunk was named in imitation of cyberpunk, by Kevin Wayne Jeter in 1987. He used ‘steam-punks’ to describe those authors writing what he called ‘Victorian fantasy’, which he expected to become the next big thing. I’m not sure he quite expected to name the entire genre practically overnight, but he did. In terms of fiction cyberpunk describes a sub-genre of science fiction which focuses on the virtual, the artificial, and alienation. Steampunk first created the idea of -punk referring to an aesthetic. These days steampunk tends to refer to a subgenre of fantasy that heavily relies upon 19th century visuals, ideas, and technology, especially steam powered technology. It’s generally included in fantasy because it usually involves creative applications of these technologies, incorporates explicitly magical elements, or places these 19th century things in unusual settings. In terms of stereotypical visuals cyberpunk’s jam is virtual reality, ASCII interfaces, and maudlin rain-soaked skyscrapers. Steampunk’s is cogs, the British Empire what the sun never sets on, and wearing corsets outside your clothes.</p><p>These are both simplifications of the two oldest -punks, which are now accompanied by numerous descendants such as ‘dieselpunk’ and ‘biopunk’ to name but a couple. Cyberpunk has mutated considerably, as all science fiction does, with changes to culture and technology. Originally you would expect cyberpunk to go something like this; first, take the plot of William Gibson’s <em>Neuromancer</em>, published in 1984 ,with its main character described as a ‘console cowboy’. Now combine this plot with the visual look of Ridley Scott’s <em>Blade Runner</em> from 1982, which pictures a 2019 Los Angeles of near constant rain, mass-consumption of Japanese culture, corroded older buildings amid the towering skyscrapers of the future, and a tortured sky reflecting pollution gone rampant. Hey presto! These days the genre is filled with arguments about what is cyberpunk, what works count as cyberpunk, and what is its place in a world with our current technology. There’s also quite a lot more cyborgs, not to mention religious themes going around these days thanks to 1999’s <em>The Matrix</em>, along with a general notion that we might just have actually stepped into a cyberpunk society.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WQ9-PGOWQbJyYjmW.jpg" /><figcaption>The outer edge of Kowloon Walled City, which had a population density of 3.3 million per square mile.</figcaption></figure><p>Steampunk is a little different. Rather than a vision of the near-future it is rooted in a real era that has already come and gone. Cyberpunk did use real things for visual inspiration, Blade Runner’s look was heavily influenced by the now-demolished Kowloon Walled City in Hong Kong for example, but not to the same degree, nor was it a restoration of a prior era’s sensibilities. However, steampunk is not solely Victorian fashion and technology with different colours, nobody wandered around Carnaby Street in 1870 with about 5 lbs of gears and cogs trailing out of their pockets. To get the stereotypical steampunk setting you take a Victorian era society, preferably the British Empire. Then, depending on what flavour of steampunk you like, you inject it with the shadowy style of a Mike Mignola comic, or you design hugely complicated and oversized steam contraptions which replicate something not possible with Victorian era technology, or you put in fully fantastical elements from absolutely any era you choose. However, it’s also become recursive- now many adaptations of Victorian era stories include nods to steampunk, like Guy Ritchie’s pair of Sherlock Holmes movies. As with cyberpunk this causes many arguments over what exactly counts as a steampunk piece of work.</p><p>In both genres, however, the double life of -punk also continues apace. There are many works that are called cyberpunk which have all the visual tropes but it’s just there to be visually interesting, and ditto with steampunk. For what it’s worth I don’t get bothered by the fact that -punk after a word now primarily means an aesthetic. There’s a clear reason why this has happened, there’s nothing automatically wrong with having an aesthetic just because you enjoy its look, and neither do I take umbrage at pulp. The problem comes with the kind of bitter fights that ensue over whether something ‘counts’ as cyberpunk/steampunk or not, and with some of the specific consequences from choosing a particular aesthetic outside of its context.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/575/0*1IvhloGMAMlR12rK.jpg" /><figcaption>The original cover of William Gibson’s Neuromancer, released in 1984, considered one of the honoured founder texts of the cyberpunk genre (and for good reason).</figcaption></figure><p>Let’s take cyberpunk first. Depending on who you ask, it’s anything set in the near future that heavily involves virtual reality, and/or the internet, and/or cybernetics. Others would call it science fiction meets film noir. Others insist that to be cyberpunk, not only must there be a take on technologies that introduce the artificial into basic elements of human life, but there also must be a punk sensibility, or at least a pessimism about the impact of these near future technologies. Anything which can’t fit into another subgenre but isn’t sufficiently pessimistic is ‘postcyberpunk’. This has as much to do with the people who use cyberpunk as a visual aesthetic as the Magna Carta has to do with medieval re-enactors. Those who create works inspired by the most distinctive visuals associated with cyberpunk, or who write cyberpunk that isn’t particularly frightened of the future, or who create subcultures generated from the genre, are not <em>wrong</em>. It is fair to value a brace of themes associated with a form of speculative fiction, but you have to be prepared for a genre to thematically alter over time, particularly one so heavily based around the near future and technology. It isn’t enough to recognise that 12 gigabytes of data is not as impressive in the real 2016 as it was in the 1980s imagining the 2010s, you also have to recognise that different perspectives will be brought to near-future imaginings of human society’s continuing relationship with technology, and that cyberpunk should be big enough to fit those in. This is especially inevitable given that cyberpunk is not the sole province of North American and Japanese creators anymore, to our great fortune.</p><p>It feels like this is a common problem to any work or genre that was intended to be cutting edge but has existed for long enough to gain a history. Steampunk has ended up embracing this; the early steampunk influences are primarily works of Victorian science fiction, or its close equivalents, intending to genuinely speculate about the future with known science at the time, especially those works by Jules Verne. Instead they are now easily incorporated as somewhat pulpy, fantastical elements in a piece of fiction because science, technology, and science fiction have all changed so radically since then. Cyberpunk has been around a while, culturally speaking; if we purely went by its coinage as a term then the genre has been around for at least 36 years. If we included works prior to the genre getting solidified and named then we might be talking a full 50 years, going back to the earliest of Phillip K Dick’s work that resembles what became cyberpunk and his similar contemporaries in the 1960s. Even if we went with 36 as the minimum age then that is long enough that Usenet was only just established the very same year, 1980. Usenet is old enough that its decline is traditionally dated from 1993, and that AOL discontinued access to it in 2005 (many other ISPs having blocked access to it after a run of investigations into child pornography hosted on Usenet in the 90s). We are now in a world in which, as of 2015, you can expect an average internet speed of 2.8 mb/s in the Philippines, which is still below the global average of 5.1 mb/s, and in 2016 it’s estimated that there will be 2 billion users of internet-capable smartphones. The face of technology, the shape of history, and our interactions with simulations and the virtual have all gone along a very different path to that foreseen in the 1980s, to the point where all of the earliest cyberpunk seems like serious literature attached to an unbelievably pulpy setting, not to mention cliched. It is a complement to cyberpunk that, despite how dated much of the genre classics have ended up with extremely dated predictions, its aesthetics and some of its notions have ended up absorbed by populations at large, and celebrated. This is also why, to retain the serious credentials its authors seek, cyberpunk authors and critics need to stop trying to prevent substantial changes that preserve the genre’s spirit from counting as ‘cyberpunk’.</p><p>Steampunk, on the other hand, does have a problem with aesthetics trumping other concerns. There is a very good reason that I don’t believe that this is hypocrisy, given my earlier stance on aesthetic genres, and that is because of its incorporation of historical elements, and replication of something close to historical societies. Steampunk’s very underpinnings are taking Victorian era idealistic visions of the future and running with them, that’s where it comes from, and there’s not necessarily anything wrong with that. The problem comes when work labelled steampunk forgets what the Victorian era actually was, not to mention the British Empire that is so heavily mined for inspiration. These are not neutral subjects, these are not societies that are safely past and which have no resonance in very modern issues. It’s fine that -punk does not primarily mean a punk sensibility anymore, but I would hope that it was an accidental reminder to be careful with the real elements that your aesthetic incorporates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gJv1HYAiNz8HSrHs.jpg" /><figcaption>Edward VII alone ruled over 393 million subjects in 1907, six years after Queen Victoria’s death, at a time when the world’s population was only estimated at around 1.7 billion. The British Empire’s territory and population only stopped growing as a result of the Second World War.</figcaption></figure><p>The Victorian era did see the industrial revolution begin to come into its own, with grand architecture, magnificent machines, eccentric fashions, and a great amount of literature that we continue to enjoy. The thing is that the British Empire, the actual Victorian society used as the basis for Victorian fantasy, was in such a position in large part because of its, well, Empire. It runs off a fundamental concept that other peoples need to be dominated and controlled by their betters, and people seem to miss that founding and maintaining the Empire required a willingness to kill and manipulate for the sake of expansion. This isn’t me throwing out ‘give peace a chance’, it’s me complaining that what’s seen as quirky British upper class culture -silly accents, bowler hats, cricket, afternoon tea- masks the reality. It’s also the society that started the process of codifying eugenics, social darwinism, and racism, and this is not from the mouths of kooks; all of these either became mainstream in Victorian era British society, were codifying existing widely held views, or would become mainstream within a decade or so of Queen Victoria’s death. Neither are these the only dangers of the period. The Victorian world was one in which epidemics were frequent, even in the world’s most powerful and richest nations. In the UK it was normal for whooping cough alone to cause 10,000 deaths a year, across this entire period of history. Abject poverty was rife in Victorian Britain. Homelessness among children and destitution among adults was a simple fact of life, as was child labour. Not only did children work for a living, by necessity, many of them worked in factories and helped to maintain extremely dangerous machinery.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/0*vJi_K9bch0mW3Ofm.jpg" /><figcaption>It took over 250,000 cows alone just to make one WW1 era Zeppelin, what would you need in order to make an airship like this?</figcaption></figure><p>Steampunk fashion, these days, relies upon artisans as much as it does any kind of mass-manufacturing, perhaps more. But the goods and periods that are being replicated are those where mass production factories were dominant in working life for the first time. Take an airship that a begoggled character is flying in. Where did the materials come from make it? Are they the result of mass industry in the home nation or are they extracted from colonial subjects? What are the conditions of those workers like? Do they have any ability to organise to get better conditions? Do their children have any likelihood of becoming something other than their parents? And what about the people who made the airship, who put together its complex components and final form? What are conditions like in the factory? Are there children working there, and are there dangerous machines they are likely tasked to maintain? How much are these factory workers paid? Do they have any choice about working in a factory? Are there hazardous materials that they are being exposed to? In other words, the price of these cool steampunk toys is usually being paid by ignored multitudes. Works labelled as Steampunk that care, or at least <em>think</em> about this in some way are works that I respect, the ones that don’t are the reason that I am writing this article.</p><p>All of the steampunk fiction that I regard highly does not suffer the problem of perpetuating a white, upper class, western perspective on an industrial society. These works either draw attention to the inequities of the period, make an active attempt to demonstrate that things are different in particular ways, or introduce complexity in other ways. China Mieville, Neal Stephenson, Beth Cato and their kind are not the kind of authors I have a problem with. This is not an inevitable problem with steampunk, neither with fictional steampunk settings nor with purely aesthetic steampunkers. In both cases awareness, and accompanying forethought, goes a long way. However, as of right now, do pay close attention to who currently gets involved in steampunk fashion and subcultures- there’s a reason you might not find many dark skinned faces, because the history of race relations and the treatment of those considered nonwhite in this period does not lend itself to enthusiasm for the era, or a -punk derived from the Victorian era. Queen Victoria came to the throne in 1837, and not all slaves in the British Empire were actually free yet- it was only in 1838 that their period as forced apprentices ended. The most deadly conflict in US history was fought in the 1860s predominantly over the issue of slavery’s continuing existence in the USA. Though the 19th century saw the destruction of the Transatlantic slave trade via an increasingly potent alliance of abolitionist countries the actual treatment and attitudes towards the freed slaves, their descendants, and the free black people already living in the relevant countries did not improve. In fact it became even worse in some places. The Jim Crow laws in the United States was instituted from 1877 onwards, and in many cases reduced the legal rights and abilities of black Americans even compared to those they possessed before the abolition of slavery. In 1885 King Leopold II of Belgium acquired control over what was called the Congo Free State, and instituted a regime so brutal in the privately owned colony that it was scandalous even in the world of the early 20th century once knowledge became widespread of what was going on. It is recent enough in history that photos survive of Congolese men and women who had their hands cut off for incredibly minor offenses, and it’s estimated that up to 20% of the population of the Free State died from 1885 to 1908. Those of colour who do partake in steampunk fashion, in my experience, try to celebrate what might have been, and what could have been. Treating the British Empire, and the elite of the 19th century imperial powers, purely as a wardrobe for quirky dressup is a good way to show off disregard for quite a lot of people, past and present, and earns anything labelled steampunk nasty looks at times. And as for anyone who actively wishes to celebrate the British Empire as it really existed, well it’s pretty clear me and thee won’t see eye to eye.</p><p>Cyberpunk’s problem can be the inability to acknowledge the diversity that already exists in the literary genre, and to acknowledge that it’s become as much of a look and design choice as a deep and meaningful examination of the effects of technology on mankind. Conversely I think that many steampunk authors and aficionados lack an awareness of what they are playing with and its historical significance, and also an awareness that the movement <em>lacks</em> in diversity. <em>Jadepunk </em>and<em> The Sea is Ours </em>are welcome changes of pace, of an ilk with <em>Avatar the Last Airbender</em> in being entirely non-European inspired steampunk, and there needs to be far more steampunk of a similar mindset to both that still remains respectful towards people of colour. I really don’t want steampunk to gain the same reputation as high fantasy, which is (not always fairly) reputed to have become nothing but clones of the genre’s ur-texts. This doesn’t just require inspired writers to put their fingers to keyboard, it also requires support from those who love the genre and, when necessary, getting out of those writers’ way.</p><p><em>All pictures used in this article are in the public domain.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b7b3ed8d0ca" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat/on-steampunk-and-cyberpunk-7b7b3ed8d0ca">On Steampunk and Cyberpunk</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fluff-fumble-splat">Fluff, Fumble, Splat</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>