<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Fresh Wit - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Ideas that haven’t been written 100 times already. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/fresh-thoughts?source=rss----beab6830ca81---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:17:30 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/fresh-thoughts" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Boundaries” are Harmful]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fresh-thoughts/boundaries-are-harmful-e452b6aa10d8?source=rss----beab6830ca81---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e452b6aa10d8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[linguistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boundaries]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autistic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ayn-rand]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Doe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Feb 2026 15:27:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-07T15:33:21.241Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Boundaries didn’t come from therapy, they came from capitalist self-help.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/0*DxmAJ5ERQ9HJV5a2" /><figcaption>A man with “healthy boundaries”.</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Note: This Medium post is free to read outside of Medium <a href="https://medium.com/fresh-thoughts/boundaries-are-harmful-e452b6aa10d8?source=friends_link&amp;sk=cebc61df68be44d69b8812374f7263f7">using this link</a></blockquote><p><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/jul/14/what-are-relationship-boundaries-jonah-hill">This article in The Guardian</a> explains that “boundaries” didn’t come from therapy or sociology: they came from 1990’s capitalist self-help books!</p><p>To explain what a boundary is the early books resorted to analogies of property rights, and the image of suburban houses with fences.<br>You know, like houses in American suburbs where we are all alone with our material possessions.</p><p>(It also mentions some some older work from the 1960’s about “ego development” but my post is about the 1990’s style of “picket fence” boundaries.)</p><blockquote><strong><em>Note: underlined text is how </em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/blog/an-update-on-profile-colors-and-themes-2cb471e61e40"><strong><em>Medium styles links</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></blockquote><h3>“Healthy boundaries” are still bad, just linguistically.</h3><p>Before I get to painful, harmful, or deadly boundaries, I’d like to start with healthy behaviors we have now decided are “boundaries”.</p><p><em>I’m not against these healthy behaviors!</em></p><p>But:</p><p>What do <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/conquering-codependency/202010/how-to-conquer-codependency">co-dependent people learning to stop being doormats</a> have to do with <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/joepublic/2010/mar/23/write-to-freedom-caspar-walsh">prison inmates being forced to do a writing exercise to earn freedom</a>?</p><p>And what do either<em> </em>of these things have to do with <a href="https://www.attachmentproject.com/psychology/parentification/">telling parents not to give their children age-inappropriate caregiving responsibilities</a> their brains can’t handle?</p><p>And what does not treating your nine-year-old like a twenty-nine-year-old have to do with … <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-ethical-professor/202005/boundaries-its-about-time">being on time for therapy</a>?</p><p>And what does <em>punctuality</em> have to do with <a href="https://medium.com/@constantinpatrascu/gentle-parenting-is-making-kids-worse-heres-what-the-research-actually-shows-fa258b7ee6ba">not letting kids have junk food for dinner</a>?</p><p>When it comes to feelings, therapy teaches us <a href="https://feelingswheel.app/">to use specific words</a>. No one would take a therapist seriously if they generalized every feeling as “getting emotional”, and rightfully so!<br>Also, while school teaches us to make inferences and generalizations, therapy gives us a generalization about generalizations: <em>generalizations are always bad</em>, because they are a “cognitive distortion” and a sign of mental illness: <a href="https://cogbtherapy.com/cbt-blog/cognitive-distortions-overgeneralizing">“When someone overgeneralizes, they accept patterns to be true despite having no actual proof that these patterns exist.”</a></p><p>So why is it, when it comes to behavior, then 1) punctuality, 2) refusing to let another person take advantage of you, 3) and making prisoners write essays are all <em>generalized </em>as “boundaries”?</p><h3>I can’t proceed without attempting to define a “boundary”.</h3><h4>Gottman actually says that a boundary is an ultimatum spoken in a nice tone of voice:</h4><p>I remember a few years back reading that a boundary <em>without enforcement</em> is not a boundary, but a “request”. And further, that making requests is, rather than what polite and civilized people do, instead <em>proof that you don’t respect yourself</em>.</p><p>Today, I can’t find that assertion on <a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/boundaries-vs-ultimatums.html">Gottman’s site</a> or even by using Google. Instead, I now read that requests are<em> the first step</em> to setting a boundary, which is a sort of <em>enforcement </em>of a dis-regarded request.</p><p>However, I did find here this surprising confession:<br> <br>“Truthfully, the area between boundaries and ultimatums can be quite gray. The distinction lies in our tone, intention, and mindset when we say it⁠ — which is hard to quantify in a meaningful way.”</p><p>I screen shot it so it can’t get away:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QRzbKky4kyyYTDvoTswoBQ.png" /></figure><p>After years of reading that a boundary is <em>not </em>an ultimatum, something more like (but not quite) <a href="https://www.facebook.com/drlaurenfogelmersy/photos/a.393241897811792/1130959247373383/?id=336917900110859">this</a> post, and that ultimatums are almost always bad, while boundaries being good is treated as obvious, I find this confession surprising.</p><p>I was looking for that meme of two stick figures, one drawing a circle around themselves labelled “boundaries”, the other drawing a circle around the other person, labeled “ultimatum”. All I could find was this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/0*71TRWnwAPry2f50w" /></figure><p>I wanted to debunk it with the simple statement that an estrangement, even for the best reasons, for the worst abuse,<em> </em><a href="https://www.apa.org/monitor/2012/04/rejection"><em>still affects the other person</em>.</a> There are very few cases where a boundary that is made in response to another person also <em>doesn’t</em> affect that other person.</p><p>Instead, I find something better: the official <em>confession </em>that the difference between a boundary and an ultimatum can’t be “quantified” in a “meaningful way”.</p><p><em>If something can’t be quantified in a meaningful way, it means that “something” can’t be used in a scientific experiment.<br>It means it cant be </em><strong><em>scientifically </em></strong><em>said to exist.</em> <br>More on that later. For now, I will use this definition.</p><p>Therefore, from the <em>outside</em>, and <em>without a mind-reading machine</em>, a boundary <em>is </em>an ultimatum, but spoken in <em>a nicer tone of voice</em>.</p><h4>A “Nice tone of voice” with an ultimatum terrifies me, because I know not what horrors lurk beneath.</h4><p>Lots of normal men, besides autistic women like me, struggle with subjective “tone of voice”. <br>This is something that in certain places I <em>could be given accommodations for</em>. <br>But if we have problem with “boundaries” — which are different on the receiving end from ultimatums <em>only through a tone of voice</em> — then “no accommodations for you!” — the problems are <em>on us</em>. <br>For instance: “<a href="https://www.rootsrelationaltherapy.com/blogs-for-better-relationships/how-to-set-boundaries-a-better-approach-in-10-steps">There is no shame in that if you are aware of it and committed to getting better.</a>” implies that there <em>is</em> shame if you are aware of it, <em>and disagree that “Boundaries are better”</em>.</p><p>All I want, as an autistic software engineer, is clarity and precision. So when hearing <a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/boundaries-vs-ultimatums.html">these examples</a> with my autism:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CBCG4cvq5R2qMymOBK1WlA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>I prefer to hear the top one.</em></strong><em> (And yes, that’s how I ended up marrying an abuser, the preference for the top statement over the bottom one. Not saying my preference is correct, just explaining it)</em></p><p>Firstly, the top statement is <em>shorter</em>.<br>If you can say the same thing in two different ways,<em> the shorter one is usually the better one</em>!</p><p>Secondly, while <em>both </em>of these statements are deeply nasty, the top one lets you know <strong>exactly</strong> where you stand. <br>The person wants help with the kids! <br>How <em>badly </em>do they want it? <br>They want it <em>more than they want their marriage</em>. There is no <strong>chance </strong>this will be misunderstood.</p><p>Also, the only “nasty” part about the <em>top </em>statement is the “quit your job” part. <br>But if I hear it, <em>I am comfortable picking it out and addressing it:</em> “Wait a minute, quit my job? How about I use the income from my job to hire a babysitter or a cleaner?”<br>The top part is <em>mean</em>, but its flaws are <em>glaringly obvious. </em>And so I can <em>address </em>them.</p><p>The bottom example, “If we can’t find a solution, I worry about the long-term sustainability of our relationship.” sounds like something a very skinny bleached-blonde woman in Human Resources says when things have <em>already </em>gone wrong and they are <em>already </em>starting the termination process.<br>What will this person consider “working for both of them” and <em>how many guesses do you have before she decides your response is incorrect</em>, or not nicely phrased <em>enough</em>, or <em>what</em>?</p><p>But lets say instead of perceiving this clear threat <em>as</em> a threat, I take it literally, without any threat, as I’m sure it’s <em>intended </em>I take it.<br>This statement, “I worry about the long-term sustainability of our relationship,” uses therapeutic “I words and feeling words” which on it’s own <em>tells me that this person is looking for emotional validation</em>. <br>If I don’t <em>correctly </em>perceive the <em>veiled and vague threat</em> in this “nice” statement, I am just as likely to try to validate feelings with something like “Nah! Don’t worry about it! Our relationship is fine!” <br>This would be perceived, under the circumstances, as <em>gaslighting rather than validation</em>, and I would be <em>divorced</em>.</p><p>All you need to do to <em>un-</em>nasty the bottom statement, is remove the <em>threat </em>from it. It’s not <em>nice </em>to threaten your co-parenting partner! <br>I am a problem-solving over-thinking pro! Hearing the bottom section <strong>without </strong>the boundary/mini-ultimatum/threat at the end, <strong>I would jump right to it</strong>! Solve problems! Logistics! I’m in!!!<br>But, without the threat, this is a “<em>request</em>” and not a “<em>boundary</em>”.</p><h4>A boundary is not used to control another another person …<br>… unless it is!</h4><p>While <a href="https://www.simplypsychology.org/boundaries-vs-ultimatums.html">we can’t “control someone else”</a> with boundaries, suddenly this definition changes when we are discussing <a href="https://medium.com/@constantinpatrascu/gentle-parenting-is-making-kids-worse-heres-what-the-research-actually-shows-fa258b7ee6ba">children </a>or <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/joepublic/2010/mar/23/write-to-freedom-caspar-walsh">prisoners</a>.</p><p>Consider this absurdity:<br>When Tom sets consequences for his children to make them go to bed, he is “setting boundaries”.<br>When Tom sets <em>the same</em> consequences for his <em>wife </em>to make her go to bed, he is abusive and controlling.</p><p>Before “boundaries” were invented, we still had “consequences” and “authority”. <br>“Authority” sounds too violent or tyrannical to therapists (who hypocritically are themselves often offended if you verbally question the morality of benefit of their suggestions, or the un-explained unilateral decisions they started making now and calling “boundaries”). <br>It seems we use the neutral word “boundary” deliberately to obscure what’s going on when a legitimate authority, such as a parent, prison guard, or medical professional, sets consequences for someone else to control another person’s behavior.</p><h4>So combined these sections lead to this definition of a boundary:</h4><p>A “boundary” is small ultimatum, aimed at another person, but <em>only </em>when you <em>in good faith feel their actions affect yourself</em>, delivered in <em>a nice tone of voice.</em> <br>Preferably, <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/DecidingToBeBetter/comments/1qmv4yz/deciding_to_stop_overexplaining_my_boundaries/">delivered without any explanation,</a> but <em>always </em>enforced by your own actions.</p><p>Does the following sentence pass the common sense “sniff test”: “Delivering small ultimatums, without explanation, in a nice tone of voice, will make your relationships better”?</p><h3>Where is the science?</h3><p><em>If something can’t be quantified in a meaningful way, it means that “something” can’t be used in a scientific experiment, or </em><strong><em>scientifically</em></strong><em> be said to exist.</em></p><p>This means that the concept of “boundaries” needs to live in the same mental realm of astrology and theology, maybe philosophy or even <em>morality</em>, but not <em>science</em> or <em>medicine</em>.<br> “Boundaries” should live in the same house as your local Reiki practitioner, who, ironically, <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/04/reiki-cant-possibly-work-so-why-does-it/606808/">has more science to back up his practice</a>, than do “boundaries”.</p><p>So, therapists like to tell people to <em>notice</em> things. “Notice when you have anxiety”. “Notice your judgements” (I have, and I <em>still </em>don’t like the president). “Notice good things about your spouse”. (This is very powerful! I will now forever see the man who almost killed me but for a “hairs breadth” of self control, as the inventor of a fantastic three-bean-chili, <em>because a therapist told me to notice</em>!)</p><p>I have a modest proposition: Start <em>noticing</em> when the topic of boundaries comes up, <em>if there is any mention of science</em> at all with it.</p><p>I <em>notice </em>that articles about CBT and DBT usually mention <em>studies</em>. <br>I notice that articles about SSRI’s usually <em>also </em>mention studies about <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4592645/">placebos </a>or <a href="https://www.npr.org/2026/01/12/nx-s1-5667599/exercise-is-as-effective-as-medication-in-treating-depression-study-finds">exercise</a>.<br>I even have a vague recollection of reading a few studies regarding the powerful and <em>measurable </em>effects of <em>noticing things! (</em>I can’t find one right now but <a href="https://minahil14.medium.com/the-science-of-gratitude-journaling-how-writing-about-positives-reshapes-the-brain-2ba2e6f0337e">this one about noticing positives in your life is close</a>. I notice the title that I just linked <em>starts </em>with the words “the Science”.)</p><p>Where is the science of the effects of setting boundaries, vs <strong>not </strong>setting them? <br>Where is the science comparing the anti-depressant or anti-anxiety effects of boundaries to exercise or placebo? <br>Even this question reads like an absurdity! But why should it, if boundaries make us happier? <br>We can compare <a href="https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/diet-vs-exercise">nutrition vs exercise</a>. Why not boundaries?</p><p>(If someone were to do a study like that, because “boundaries” equate to “saying no” for co-dependents, I wouldn’t be surprised to read one day that boundaries increase wellbeing for co-dependents <em>but no one else</em>.<br>I’m sure when this occurs, that study will also <em>not </em>study the effect of <em>punctuality </em>on co-dependents, even though that is <em>also </em>“boundaries”.)</p><p>So when a psychological article is written, notice firstly, <em>if</em> it mentions boundaries, and secondly, if it mentions or refers to any science regarding the boundaries themselves.</p><p>I’m not making judgements here. I’m just asking you to take a minute and start … noticing.</p><h3>A practical example: the same boundary that leads to life also leads to death.</h3><blockquote><strong><em>Trigger warning:</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>From here on, I create a hypothetical thought experiment that uses abstract descriptions of two fictional anorexics to make a point about the uselessness or harmfulness of the same boundary. <br>If this triggers your eating disorder, stop reading. <br>If my use of an illness I don’t suffer from to illustrate an un-related hypothetical point about boundaries triggers you, also stop.</blockquote><p>A typical self-protective boundary example I often see online is an old person commenting on a young person’s weight.</p><p>To show why this boundary is wrong, I need to take it to <strong>both extremes</strong>. So I will invent two fictional anorexics for this purpose.</p><h4>Imaginary character Susan is a successfully recovered anorexic.</h4><p>Susan only sees her grandma, Karen Boomering, on holidays that center around food such as Christmas and Thanksgiving. <br>Predictably, Karen Boomering won’t stop making comments about Susan’s weight and how much she is eating, especially in the context of being thin enough to find a man to marry.<br>Susan wants to be single, but these conversations still cause Susan’s illness to flare up, and she always loses some weight afterward, as measured by a scale. (I’m adding this to the story to state there is demonstrable harm to her imaginary body, and a risk to her actual life.)</p><p>So Susan “sets a boundary” saying “if you mention my weight, I will leave the house”.</p><p>This is a reasonable and self-protective action.</p><p>Now, as an aside, if we want to “go no contact” with Karen Boomering, “boundaries” <em>again </em>make things <em>worse </em>rather than better.<br>We are not estranging Karen because she isn’t conforming to a vague, modern, pseudo-therapeutic unspecified moral value. We are estranging her <em>because she tried to manipulate an ill young person to die</em>.</p><p>This is actually one case where “boundaries”<em> as a word </em>is useful, but only in the sense that vague corporate-speak like “our goals are no longer aligned” is useful: <em>to obscure the truth</em>. <br>In this case, I would argue that a more honest “I’d like to keep private as it concerns other people” is still better than falsely blaming crossing “boundaries” when the problem at hand is attempted murder.</p><h4>Now consider the opposite example.</h4><p>Nasu S. thinks he is fat, but he’s <em>an under-weight active anorexic</em>. <br>His grandma, Caring Busybody, sees Nasu look increasingly ill every time she visits. I’m not going to describe anything dire here, as that’s not needed to make this example. <br>Caring grew up like me, being told “if you see something wrong, and do nothing about it, your are guilty of making it happen.” If you are powerless to stop something, it’s your duty to <em>at least speak out</em>. I learned this in High School during lessons about WW2, as well as, from my parents who were dissidents in Soviet Russia.<br>Caring Busybody <em>also </em>believes, as I do due to my immigrant culture, that a parent’s job is to raise a child, alive and self-sufficient, <em>by any means necessary</em>. Caring can’t force-feed Nasu, because she only visits on holidays, but she also can’t allow herself to <em>stop</em> speaking out, or in other words, “making comments”.</p><p>Nasu’s mental illness tells him he is too fat to ever get married or even have friends. Thanks to his illness, he wrongly believes Caring Busybody is manipulating him <em>because she doesn’t want him to be attractive</em>.<br>So Nasu <em>sets a boundary</em>.</p><p>It is the <em>same boundary</em> as Susan’s: “if you mention my weight, I will leave the house”.</p><p>While Susan <em>is </em>protecting herself, Nasu <em>truly believes </em>he is protecting himself.</p><p>According to the un-scientific Idol of “Boundaries”, “we can’t control other people” and therefore we “can’t” do anything to help Nasu. We need to “respect his boundaries” <em>even if he died from them</em>.</p><h3>The Human alternative:</h3><p>Instead of “We <em>can’t control </em>Nasu”, it is instead <em>our human duty and obligation</em> to help Nasu, <em>especially </em>if he is our family. <br>(It’s already too long, or I would address the counter-example of “helping” people incorrectly, such an Evangelical trying to “cure” gayness. In this case, “boundaries” <em>are</em> a better option. But a shared commitment to <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01916599.2016.1203590">Enlightenment “tolerance”</a> is an <em>even better </em>option still.)</p><p>So how do we help Nasu? By v<em>iolating his boundaries</em>, brining him to a hospital against his will, where medical professional will <em>further</em> violate his boundaries with a feeding tube.</p><p>This article is about boundaries, not anorexia. Possibly due to my autism, I feel that using a specific example is best. I am hoping the reader will generalize from this example. <br>For instance, if you believe that “doves are white”, all you need to learn this is false it to see a single brown Carolina pigeon. You can throw away your generalization about doves based on one example. Likewise if you believe boundaries are needed or beneficial, each example to the contrary here should start the questioning process.<br>I believe anyone can, if they tried, think of other examples.</p><p>So, science says that in the case of an anorexic, <a href="https://keck.usc.edu/news/groundbreaking-study-shows-substantial-differences-in-brain-structure-in-people-with-anorexia/">their brain actually shrinks by some amount</a>. <br>I can’t find this now, but I remember reading that talk therapy doesn’t work for active anorexics because of their brain shrinkage <a href="https://www.gaudianiclinic.com/gaudiani-clinic-blog/2015/11/2/how-anorexia-causes-a-starved-brain-understanding-cerebral-atrophy">which is dire</a>. So I will just say, there exist some professionals, I don’t know how many, who have scientific reasons to believe that you must <em>violate an anorexic’s boundaries around food first,</em> in order to restore their brain to its normal size, before there is any hope of them making better choices.<br>I’m using the word “boundaries” here myself because I feel it’s the best way to make a pro-boundaries person understand this point. A better phrase would be “learn to eat enough” but that won’t make my point about “boundaries”.</p><p>We have correctly decided that parents shouldn’t decide when to force-feed kids. Medical professionals exist, and know how to do it better and <em>safer</em>.<br>But we <em>all </em>would take people like Nasu to the hospital, usually against their will, where medical professionals will “violate his boundaries”.<br>Therefore <em>it’s not a question of boundaries</em>, but a question of <em>who has the legitimate authority to use “controlling behavior”</em>, such as force-feeding, on other people and under what circumstances.</p><p>This dire situation, as it relates to boundaries, is the <em>same situation</em> as the more common (and pleasant) situation of parents “setting boundaries” around their child’s bedtime.</p><p>It’s a good boundary for an “authoritative parent” to set a bedtime for his children, and we call this “a boundary”.<br>But it’s an abusive and controlling behavior for the same father to set the same boundary for his <em>wife</em>.<br>The word “boundary” is obscuring the simpler and clearer concept of legitimate authority used for another person’s own good.</p><p>Likewise, it’s a good idea for Susan to escape from Karen Boomering who is literally killing her (notice I wrote ‘escape’ not ‘set boundaries’). <br>And while its a bad idea for Susan Caring to try and force Nasu to eat, she should execute her legitimate authority as family to deliver Nasu to a hospital, where medical staff will discharge their own legitimate authority and obligations by re-feeding Nasu with a tube. <br>See how much shorter this concept reads without “setting boundaries” everywhere? I think it’s clearer and more precise, too.</p><h3>Boundaries are painful</h3><p>I could show examples from estranged boomers, or<a href="https://annhotezontrustloveandattachmentintherapy.quora.com/Has-your-therapist-changed-her-boundaries-Maybe-she-allowed-emailing-in-between-sessions-though-now-she-does-not-or-4?ch=15&amp;oid=1477743893417599&amp;share=73470bd6&amp;srid=uUUdyt&amp;target_type=answer"> from Quora of therapists suddenly, without explanation, “setting boundaries”</a> that make some patients want to die, self harm, or in once case end up in an institution. <br>But I would like to present instead my own mild and simple experiment with boundaries, because I think its <em>simplicity </em>should be more convincing than any dire example.</p><p>One day, when my youngest daughter was around age four, plus or minus a few months, I wondered if boundaries were just something neurotypical people liked that I didn’t. <br>For instance, because I’m autistic, I don’t like lies. Not even about Santa Clause, <a href="https://medium.com/@kylejohnson_40581/in-defense-of-parents-who-dont-lie-about-santa-de281d6925e8">which is common for autistic people</a>. But neurotypical people won’t hire me if I answer “what’s your biggest weakness?” or even “how are you?” with honesty. Neurotypical people prefer lies, because lies show that I know what to say in a social situation.<br>In the same way, I greatly prefer problem-solving over “empathy” or “validating feelings” without action. But I know normal people can end a decade-long friendship over a single suggestion. One woman lost a friend because after a decade, she suggested to her friend that her stance against shaving may be the reason she can’t find a partner. <br>So I find it inexplicable that micro-threats delivered in a “Nice tone of voice” are the preferred method of communicating, but maybe it’s just me!</p><p>So I decided to make an experiment on my youngest child. Now: I can already hear some outrage about “making experiments on my children”. <br>Good! Be outraged! <br>But if you <em>are </em>outraged, please be honest to yourself about <em>what </em>exactly you are outraged about: <strong>you are outraged that I am following parenting advice that I disagree with, and that you <em>do </em>agree with.</strong></p><p>If you think this parenting advice should not be followed? <br>Good! <br><em>That’s exactly my point!</em></p><p>So as I understand the rule of boundaries, they work like this: you set the boundary, and then <em>you don’t explain the reasons for the boundary.</em> <br>When the boundary is crossed, you <em>validate feelings</em>, and then and <em>re-enforce the boundary</em>.</p><p>So the next time my youngest wanted candy, I didn’t <em>explain </em>why it was the wrong <em>time </em>to eat candy, I <em>validated feelings</em>, and then “set a boundary”.</p><p>“I understand you really really really want a candy.” (Validation) “But you’re not having one!” (Boundary)</p><p><strong>I have never seen my daughter cry over not having candy as hard as she did that day.</strong></p><p>Well, I knew what to do! The advice columns say you let them “own their feelings” while you <em>keep validating</em> feelings <em>while re-enforcing the boundary:</em></p><p>“I know you feel very sad right now and I can see you are crying very hard. But you’re <em>still </em>not having candy!”</p><p>I did a few rounds of this, and she melted down more and more. <br>Honestly I knew exactly how she felt: validation doesn’t feel good when it’s a manipulation designed to <em>hide total disregard </em>for the factual substance of what is being said.</p><p>At this point, I felt like I was emotionally bullying her. <br>I could have persisted until my daughter wore herself out, like with “cry it out sleep training” (<em>that we didn’t do</em>!) but I saw no reason to continue this experiment because I had my answer: at least <em>this one</em> normal young person <em>without autism</em> hated boundaries as much as I did!<br> <br>Usually I <em>explain </em>why I make any rule, but having already put myself in <em>this </em>situation with my daughter, I didn’t see any way out except by pivoting to “Because I said so.”</p><p>I said: “you’re not having candy because I said you are not having candy.”</p><p>She was still upset, <em>but she instantly calmed down</em>.<br>The tears went away like a tap has been turned off. A slightly disappointed look was on her face.</p><p>Logically, the idea that “x because I said x” is more of a tautology than <em>a reason</em>. <br>It makes just as much rational sense as a “boundary” does. <br>But <em>this </em>way of communicating, <em>also </em>communicates that “I’m in charge”.</p><p>Just like with the other examples, “boundaries” muddy the situation where underneath it all, we are born with an innate understanding that some people to have legitimate authority over others. Hence, the science behind “authoritative parenting”!</p><h3>Boundaries are Selfish (with a capital S)</h3><p>I find it very strange that people who love therapy usually hate Ayn Rand, and vice versa. <br>Because Ayn Rand’s doctrine of Selfishness seems to me to fully encompass the doctrine of Boundaries.<br>It seems that Selfishness is a <em>larger </em>concept than just Boundaries, because it also includes the rest of capitalism. But if there is a difference between Boundaries and the subset of Selfishness they reside in, I would love for someone to explain it!</p><p>I’d like to relate a scene from the Fountainhead to illustrate this, but I feel dishonest unless I explain <em>first </em>what I believe Ayn Rand herself meant by it, even though that has nothing to do with my main point.</p><p>Before Ayn Rand, characters that martyred themselves to help others, such as Beth March in Little Women or the main character in Les Misérables who doesn’t stop giving charity, are seen as <em>blessed</em>.<br>Ayn Rand believed that helping other people and charity are actually <em>evil</em>. As I understand her views, because no one knows another person as well as they know themselves, helping other people violates their Self and hurts them. At best, helping is a total waste: the poor stay poor, the stupid stay stupid.<br>Meanwhile, while you “help” other people, according to Rand as I understand it, you are betraying your Self, which you <em>could </em>actually reasonably help if you directed your efforts there, instead.<br>I think it is these concepts she was illustrating in the scene Katie and Peter having lunch. When I tell it, I will use boundary language, as that’s how I actually <em>remember </em>it.</p><p>Correct me if I tell this scene wrong, I lost my book (probably on purpose, as I hated Selfishness too) and don’t remember the scene very well.</p><p>Katie is “enmeshed” with her communist dad, and loses her “Self” by serving other people <em>co-dependently</em> at her dad’s request. (The words “enmeshed” and “co-dependent” don’t appear in a book of this age, of course.)<br>Katie has lunch with Peter, the conformist architect. Katie is concerned for Peter’s health (which suffers from the stress of putting other people’s opinions above his own) and makes him eat a salad instead of a manly steak his body actually needed. Peter conforms (because he’s a conformist, or in modern terms, “lacks boundaries”) and walks away un-satisfied on the poor salad. <br>This is used to illustrate how caring about other people (like Katie) is evil, and how submitting to other people (like Peter) has no up-side. <br>But isn’t this scene <strong>also </strong>an example of boundaries?</p><p>If Katie had been Selfish and not tried to help Peter … she would have had “healthy boundaries” instead of “enmeshment”.<br>If Peter had refused Katie’s suggestion to have a salad, he would have been uncharacteristically Selfish but also … he would have “had boundaries”.</p><p>Now I could be mis-understanding both concepts of Selfishness and Boundaries here. If I am, please correct me.</p><p>But what is Howard Roark but an embodiment of Boundaries?</p><h3>Boundaries are selfish (small s)</h3><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/meaningfull/202508/the-dark-side-of-boundaries-no-one-talks-about">This article from Psychology Today</a> shows how the concept of boundaries breaks the concept of <strong>reciprocity</strong>, and therefore human relationships.</p><p>The writer of this article also uses the word “selfish”. But instead of questioning the Sacred Idol of “Boundaries”, she asserts that as we can’t control other people (from the Boundary Doctrine of Gottman) to make other people reciprocate, she instead calls for people with “high reciprocity” to find each other. <br>Rather than reciprocity being the foundation of civilization, or any healthy society, it’s become merely a question of match-making!</p><p>The flaw in this individualistic thinking is that while we are discouraged from lecturing people to <em>be more reciprocal</em>, we are enthusiastically supporting lectures telling people <em>to have better boundaries</em>. <br>(And I suspect there is more science about the benefits of reciprocity than there is about the benefits of boundaries!) <br>There is a distinct imbalance in what views we are encouraged to spread here, and so it’s not looking good for the concept of <em>reciprocity</em>.</p><h3>Alternatives to boundaries: Ubuntu, Indra’s Net and other healthy un-American enmeshments</h3><h4>Indra’s Net :</h4><p><a href="https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/466054/boundaries-psychology-self-care-burnout">This Vox article</a> understands that “boundaries” <em>prevent us from helping others</em>. While I just mentioned how boundaries discourage reciprocity, this article shows how the doctrine of boundaries encourages selecting self-care every time, and indefinitely postponing charity. (Very, Randian!)</p><p>I see it is a “members only” so I will quote some random parts:</p><blockquote>But I think the popular language of “boundaries” isn’t quite passing the sniff test for you — and for good reason. We’re taught that “a boundary is a limit or edge that defines you as separate from others” — it’s “where I end and where you begin,” to quote a couple of popular therapists. Yet if you believe, as I do, that we’re all actually profoundly interconnected and interdependent, that we’re constantly influencing and shaping reality for one another, then that idea of boundaries may feel like it muddies more than it clarifies. Is it really possible to draw a sharp line between ourselves and other people.</blockquote><p>and:</p><blockquote>So allow me to present Indra’s net, a classic Buddhist metaphor that originated in ancient India.<br>Picture an infinite net stretching out across the universe (a bit like a spiderweb). At each node where the threads intersect, there’s a jewel (a bit like a dewdrop that sits on the spiderweb). And each jewel is so shiny and reflective that it contains the image of every other jewel in the entire net. Which means each jewel also contains the reflections of the reflections, and the reflections of those reflections, on and on forever.<br>This is reality, the Buddhists say. No jewel exists as a separate, boundaried entity: Change one jewel, and every jewel in the net transforms too, because they’re all reflecting each other. Change one person, and every person changes too.</blockquote><p>and:</p><blockquote>If you see yourself as one of the jewels in the net, you immediately realize a couple things. First, there is no sharp distinction marking off “where I end and where you begin.” And you don’t take care of yourself today so that you can better take care of me tomorrow. You take care of yourself because you are one of the jewels in the net — you are inherently precious! And if you mess up your own well-being, you are smudging up one of the jewels, or worse, creating a rip in the net!</blockquote><p>The interesting thing about this image, is that another word for “net” is “mesh”.</p><p><em>This is </em><strong><em>a mesh!</em></strong></p><p>A better alternative to boundaries <em>is enmeshment</em>.</p><h4>Ubuntu (no, not the Operating System)</h4><p>Another concept of “we are all in this together” and “if my brother isn’t happy, I&#39;m not happy” is the<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubuntu_philosophy"> African concept of Ubuntu</a>.</p><p>Ubuntu literally means:<strong> “</strong><a href="https://www.dandelionphilosophy.com/blog/whats-in-a-word-the-meaning-of-ubuntu">a person is a person through other people</a><strong>”.</strong></p><p>Isn’t that also just a great definition of “enmeshment”?</p><p>(But… I actually couldn’t prove that statement, because <em>dictionary.com doesn’t have a definition for it </em>and forwards you to the thesaurus.)</p><h4>Housing without picket fences!</h4><p>I started this article with a Guardian article that placed Boundary Ideology as having originated from glorifying the property rights of suburban homes with picket fences.</p><p><a href="https://www.treehugger.com/vindmollebakken-coliving-project-helen-and-hard-architects-5187303">This Nordic project</a> is eliminating boundaries with architecture!</p><p>Can you imagine all these people eating together worrying about “setting boundaries” with each other:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iuhvzTF78AIr-G9Z.jpg" /><figcaption>Nordic common room</figcaption></figure><p>I suspect they worry more about <em>getting along</em>. Or maybe even about <em>each other</em>.</p><p>But somehow, while Ayn Rand would definitely hate this, I doubt even Howard Roark would dislike the architecture itself:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5zUDTJoNCV4LMYHu.jpg" /><figcaption>Nordic common room</figcaption></figure><p>I know I would not be a fit for a place like that today.<br>But I <em>also </em>know if I had grown up in one, playing with neighborhood children, having tea with neighbors as an adult, and then growing old in the same place, <em>I would have grown into it</em>. I would be happier and healthier. I wouldn’t be writing <em>this</em>.</p><p>Now who needs more therapy: people who believe in Ubuntu, Indra’s net, or live in Nordic communes? <br>Or people who “set boundaries”?</p><h3>Realistic Alternatives to boundaries: clear language</h3><p>I hear “<a href="https://www.creators.com/read/my-so-called-millennial-life/03/25/everyone-wants-a-village-but-no-one-wants-to-be-a-villager">everyone wants to have a village, but no one wants to be a villager</a>”. <br>Now, sadly, when you live in a suburban house, with a fence, you can’t just suddenly decide to “be a villager” all by yourself.<br>If they don’t call the police when you knock on their door, they will at least “set boundaries”.<br>Most likely, your attempts to “be a villager” will attract a small-n narcissist (with or without clinical NPD) to take advantage of you.</p><p>You can’t weave Indra’s Net from a single node, and a Nordic Village built by — and for — a single person is just another American McMansion.</p><p>But one thing we can do, right now, is stop <em>glorifying</em> “boundaries”.</p><p>Firstly, we can use clear language:</p><p>We use authoritative parenting because authoritative parenting is scientifically proven to be the best, not because “boundaries” are proven to be the best.<br>We don’t let people take advantage of our good will because letting selfish parasites take from givers helps neither party. Not because of “boundaries” (or because we are Selfish).<br>We don’t eat candy for dinner because it’s full of sugar and no vitamins or fiber, but <em>will make us lose our appetite for food that does</em>. And we teach this to our kids, for their own good. Not because of “boundaries” (And where we make parenting mistakes, they are free to judge them as mistakes, and do something different for a different reason with their own kids, as they will.)<br>We don’t vent our marital problems to children because that damages <em>children</em>, not because it damages <em>boundaries</em>.<br>Likewise, we don’t tell recovering anorexics to lose weight because we are decent human beings, not because they “set boundaries”. <br>Yet we should still force actively delusional people, such as paranoid people or anorexics, into treatment to save their lives, regardless of their “boundaries”.</p><p>Clear language lets us tell the good from the bad and the reasons for it, instead of yielding to a culture that conflates diverse concepts and tells us to live emotionally like we live physically: within fences and alone.</p><p>Lastly, we can take some hints from non-<a href="https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/09/joseph-henrich-explores-weird-societies/">W.E.I.R.D. people</a> and start talking about, maybe, more reciprocity, or even <em>healthy enmeshments</em> instead of just “healthy boundaries”. <br>Indra’s Net and Ubuntu are both <em>healthy enmeshments</em>.</p><p>But at the very least, if you <strong>still </strong>insist on loving Boundaries, at least be honest about it, <strong><em>and give Ayn Rand credit for coming up with the idea </em></strong>if not the <em>terminology.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e452b6aa10d8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fresh-thoughts/boundaries-are-harmful-e452b6aa10d8">“Boundaries” are Harmful</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fresh-thoughts">Fresh Wit</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>