<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Giving On The Edge - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[A series of articles on model thinking and effective altruism that might become a book - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 11:04:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/giving-on-the-edge" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What would be the ideal social innovation?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/what-would-be-the-ideal-social-innovation-131de67eff3f?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/131de67eff3f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[existential-risk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[effective-altruism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-rivalrous-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exponential-technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Jan 2019 10:37:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:15:16.964Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qXyFJ8IQGf2X_lS-71KAcQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>While people currently have strong pride in their cars, almost no-one would fight over a shopping card. The economy built on anti-rivalrous foundations would prefer access to services rather than owning products. (Photo: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shopping_cart">W</a>ikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>A friend asked me recently how would I conceptualize an ideal social innovation. If I dare to be completely free to brainstorm the ideal social innovation:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2Fwhat-would-be-the-ideal-social-innovation-131de67eff3f&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2F131de67eff3f&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/da1d1c9f5ae00f729e7ccb3f15a9caf7/href">https://medium.com/media/da1d1c9f5ae00f729e7ccb3f15a9caf7/href</a></iframe><p>I will start from the point of <strong>Effective Altruism</strong> (combining rationality and heart — economics and philosophy/morality/values) and will go two levels deeper, through a <em>systemic change</em> into a <em>change of mindset</em>/mental models.</p><p>An ideal social innovation would bring a solution to a major problem, that would require a change of mindsets and mental models, or creating “mental debugs”, that will help to transform the current economy from <strong>rivalrous</strong> foundations to <strong>anti-rivalrous</strong> foundations. And these would at the same time need to survive in the current competitive world. (by being anti-fragile to the current rivalrous economy, and being built on solid game-theoretical foundations). This hasn’t been tried before. For example, communism or socialism was still based on rivalrous foundations (people and countries competing in zero-sum games).</p><h4><strong>How to measure social impact</strong></h4><p>Imagine a cube (or a rectangular cuboid) with three dimensions. These dimensions are <strong>Importance</strong>, <strong>Solvability</strong> and <strong>Neglectedness</strong> of a <strong>problem</strong>. This problem should be ideally global in scope. You could add another dimension of a “<strong>personal fit</strong>”, or organizational fit, or country fit — something that is relevant for you personally, or for your country, or for your organization. This could be a color of the cube.</p><p><strong>Now you want to find cube(s) with the biggest volume</strong> = the most solvable, important and neglected problem(s), and at the same time ideally a problem that is the closest to your heart. Imagine that there are more than 500,000 people killed by violence each year, and more than 1 million people killed in traffic accidents each year globally. Imagine your solution (e.g. a self-driven car) would reduce the number of fatal road accidents by 90%. It would represent 900,000 lives saved each year. So a very big problem would be solved by 90%. For example <em>particle pollution</em> is even a 3x bigger problem.</p><p>(There are other considerations regarding counterfactuals, like who else is working on developing autonomous cars, if not just you. And this is the dimension of Neglectedness.)</p><p>In terms of size, these big problems (and opportunities) are very <strong>unequally distributed</strong> in the problem-space. It means there are very few very big problems, and very many small problems. Imagine a very rare earthquake of magnitude 9 that happens once in a hundred years compared to magnitude 1 earthquakes that happen thousand times a year. The same distribution applies for so called 500-year floods. In the same way, imagine a place where there is a lot of gold underground, compared to the total amount of soil, where there is no gold. To look for social impact is similar to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67oL0ANDh5Y">prospecting</a> for gold. Most places (problems or solutions clusters) will yield very little to no gold, and a very few places will hold the most gold in the world.</p><p>The biggest and most solvable and neglected problems represent the biggest golden nuggets to discover in a very unequally distributed problem-space.</p><h4><strong>The biggest problems</strong></h4><p>There is a class of risks that are called <strong>existential risks</strong>, and another class or intensity of risks, that is called <em>global catastrophic risks</em>. Existential risks mean that the whole human population wouldn’t survive. The global catastrophic risks mean a major global catastrophe, e.g. meteorite crushing to earth, or global nuclear winter, or catastrophic climate change, but not killing everyone.</p><p>There is a class of information-enabled technologies, or digital technologies, that we call <strong>exponential technologies</strong>, because their performance compared to the cost seems to grow exponentially in time — e.g. doubles every two years, before stagnating and creating an “S” shaped curve.</p><p>These exponential technologies <strong>represent a lever on our choice-making</strong> with ever increasing power. So the results of these exponential technologies can be increasingly and exponentially super good or super bad for the humanity as a whole. It depends on our choice-making ability. Imagine an AI used with misinformation, biotechnology, nanotechnology and digital fabrication. So insufficient or bad <strong>choice-making</strong> (based on inadequate <strong>sense-making</strong>) combined with exponential technologies equals the global civilization will self-terminate at some point in the near future, probably by 22nd century.</p><blockquote><strong>The choice-making capacity also needs to grow exponentially in order to catch up with exponential technologies. Otherwise the humanity as a whole will self-terminate at some point in the future.</strong></blockquote><h4><strong>The systemic change should solve all existential risks</strong></h4><p>Existential technologies produce these S curves of ever faster and stronger performance. Solving for one existential risk (reduction of nuclear warheads to zero) will reduce the overall global existential risk by a little — because there still will remain other existential and catastrophic risks, for example from a powerful general AI that is not human-aligned. Or from the current but militarized AI and autonomous weapons.</p><p>So to solve for all existential risks would mean to solve the <strong>generator function</strong> of all existential risks. Imagine a process that creates this ever bigger cubes — growing problems and existential risks of humanity’s self-termination. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xhrr-fJCTWY">David Schmachtenberger</a>, thinker influenced by complexity science, says the <em>generator function</em> of these existential risks seems to be <strong>rivalrous behavior</strong> and rivalrous economy itself, meaning zero-sum games.</p><p>The rivalrous behavior was very effective in making us the apex predators and winning in the evolution game, and getting people into space, and building the current global civilization and all the previous ones. But it cannot survive exponential technologies in the long term. After the nuclear bomb the situation changed for the humanity. And after the innovation in AI, digital fabrication, biotech and nanotechnology, the dimensions of existential risk proliferated further.</p><p>Evolution and zero-sum games helped us to get into the current state of economic and technological development. But evolution and rivalrous dynamics are not useful in the age of exponential technology and existential risks. Because all win-lose games will turn into lose-lose games in the face of a nuclear winter.</p><blockquote>All win-lose games will turn into lose-lose games in the face of a nuclear winter.</blockquote><h4><strong>What could be the foundation for an anti-rivalrous economy?</strong></h4><p>A good example is caterpillar-to-butterfly metaphor. Caterpillar eats all the vegetation in the process of getting ever bigger and destroys the environment. You wouldn’t predict a butterfly by observing a caterpillar. But then something happens and the caterpillar is transformed via a cocoon into a butterfly. The ideal social innovation for me would represent such <strong>cocoons</strong> — places that can nurture and protect innovation of the anti-rivalrous economy. Some hacker places, maker places, Fab Labs, think-tanks, communities, or places such as Santa Fe Institute can serve as a precursor to such collaborative and anti-rivalrous environments.</p><h4><strong>What does it mean to aim for an anti-rivalrous economy?</strong></h4><p>While home ownership in the big rich cities is an example of very <strong>rivalrous goods</strong>, the example of <strong>anti-rivalrous goods</strong>, like the use language or some other platform influenced by the network effect is the <strong>exact opposite</strong>: anti-rivalrous = you want as many people to use the language or the platform as possible, and you are willing to share it for free. Or even pay people to learn the language or the calculus. Because the more people use the language, the more valuable it is.</p><p>Or imagine the difference between car ownership and the use of shopping carts in the supermarket. Almost no-one feels they want to fight with others over an access to a shopping cart — you can just put a euro there and use it and then put it back. These dynamics can be made true also for shared cars, or autonomous vehicles. It happened previously in the area of digital photography — you can make as many copies of digital photos as you want — it is not perceived as scarce anymore. The world of atoms is more difficult to disrupt than the world of bits, but it can be done — e.g. 3D printing, or 4D printing, AI, smart materials, bio-mimicry… can make even house-building much cheaper than it is today.</p><p>But the systemic change needs to start by changing the mindset and instilling new mental models and by expanding the space to imagine the impossible — the idea of an economy build on anti-rivalrous foundations. This type of innovations that will give rise to anti-rivalrous economy need to have solid game-theoretical foundations (that don’t create externalities and have closed loops and don’t create zero-sum win-lose games). And they need to be anti-fragile to the existing rivalrous economy environment.</p><p>Not an easy task, but to create such a space of a cocoon for the future would be my example of the ideal social innovation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=131de67eff3f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/what-would-be-the-ideal-social-innovation-131de67eff3f">What would be the ideal social innovation?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sokal Cubed]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/sokal-cubed-e99d64f9340c?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e99d64f9340c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[signaling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existential-risk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-b]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metamodernism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Jan 2019 09:10:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:16:30.023Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r5IZdOWDzLaB0Pf6YgSrtw.jpeg" /><figcaption>You shouldn’t imagine you can lecture black swans how to fly. (picture: <a href="http://nzbirdsonline.org.nz/species/black-swan">http://nzbirdsonline.org.nz/species/black-swan</a>)</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>What if you could create university that was mostly about learning?</em></strong></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2Fsokal-cubed-e99d64f9340c&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2Fe99d64f9340c&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/02a435e0259bc3c5140fbb08020b3149/href">https://medium.com/media/02a435e0259bc3c5140fbb08020b3149/href</a></iframe><p>The Sokal Squared hoax was one of the most important events in the culture wars of 2018. Its name is derived from the original Sokal <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair">hoax</a>, done by Alan Sokal who hoaxed an academic journal called Social Text devoted to postmodern cultural studies. In his paper he claimed that quantum gravity is a social and linguistic construct. In 2018 a much more massive “Sokal Squared” <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grievance_Studies_affair">hoax</a> of 7 accepted papers and 4 published papers was perpetrated by the trio of activists for science: James A. Lindsay, Peter Boghossian, and Helen Pluckrose.</p><p>They wrote together 20 papers and wanted to attack, what they call, “Grievance Studies”, in their opinion a set of disciplines that tries to redeem societal grievances. For example, Fat Studies that want to change the norms of bodily beauty to be more inclusive to overweight people. The trio of activists hoped to give a fatal blow to this type of disciplines, because in their opinion, these “grievance studies” prepare activists and not scientists and thus they interfere with hard sciences and corrupt the academy.</p><p>But nothing much changed. One can ask why? Maybe the activist trio would claim that it is due to a strong ideological power that these disciplines and narratives have over the minds of academics. But just maybe we can go a level deeper and contemplate the possibility of Sokal Cubed.</p><p>The problem is their naïve belief that education and university is <strong>mostly</strong> about learning and truth. But university is mostly <strong>not</strong> about learning and truth (collective sense-making). So the Sokal Cubed would be an inverse hoax — actually creating a place that would be <strong>mostly</strong> about learning. Maybe the real world precursor could be Santa Fe Institute where complexity science was born through a true collaboration by scientists from different disciplines. Or for example <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centro_Intercultural_de_Documentaci%C3%B3n">CIDOC</a>, the radical think tank and free university in Mexico, founded by Ivan Illich in the 1960s (who is famous for the concepts of deschooling and counterproductivity).</p><h4><strong>As many other areas, Education is mostly about signaling</strong></h4><p>In the last two years there were at least two books that claimed education is mostly about signaling of intelligence and diligent work (e.g. that you can do math and have a will power to graduate at that). Signaling itself is a concept from biology and you can complicate it by the concept of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersignaling">counter-signaling</a>.</p><p>Bryan Caplan’s The Case Against Education <a href="https://press.princeton.edu/titles/11225.html">documents</a> how around <strong>80%</strong> of the value of a university degree comes from the diploma and graduation itself. What economists call the “sheepskin effect”. Now, everyone knew that graduating Harvard has benefits beyond learning stuff. Like getting to know people from rich and powerful families. But not everybody knew that the effect can be so large — the vast majority of the value. If we internalize that than we can understand why some universities with bad reputation can actually create negative value. Everybody understands that driving a Jaguar is not only about getting from place A to place B. But appearing in a destroyed looking car might be worse than arriving on foot. Another book that tries to apply this thinking of hidden motives (A is mostly not about B) is a <a href="http://elephantinthebrain.com/">book</a> Elephant in the Brain by Robin Hanson and Kevin Simler.</p><p>(I think both books might be interesting to understand the concept, but I would not overindex on such thinking and especially their libertarian prescriptions. It is enough to internalize that education is <strong>mostly</strong> not about learning.)</p><h4><strong>Universities mostly don’t create knowledge, they collect it and study it</strong></h4><p>This is one of the main takeaways from Nassim Taleb’s Antifragile. You can read the chapter <a href="http://fooledbyrandomness.com/birds.pdf?fbclid=IwAR0b4Kva3WUm2GrVePuF-sIaTeO7LS7SqIU3c9HV8qmktox1Be2FL7fvOHQ">here</a>. The idea is simple: People shouldn’t <em>lecture birds how to fly</em>. And much of the academy needs to be much humbler about their role. Which is mainly about “studying how birds fly” and not “lecturing how they should fly”. The main idea is that it took thousands of years for someone to apply the invention of a wheel to a suitcase. And maybe another 30 years for someone to put it finally on a school bag (well school is mostly not about learning and comfort, otherwise we would let kids sleep longer and maybe invent a schoolbag with wheels sooner). Practice beats theory big time. There are exceptions like the invention of a nuclear bomb, etc. But for example, Bayesian statistics, that underlies causation theory behind science itself, was discovered by a priest with a hobby.</p><h4><strong>Universities are mostly about creating middle management workers for imperfect and very rivalrous meritocracies</strong></h4><p>Peter Thiel talks over and over how universities are something akin to an exclusive night club, a pure zero sum game, where everybody shows off, parties hard and then is quite poorer when it is over. It doesn’t make sense to him why would Harvard limit their pool of graduates to a few thousands a year, if they are the best school in a country of 325 million people.</p><p>So for Peter Thiel the alternative explanation is that universities are an insurance policy for when times get bad and suddenly there will be a big competition for jobs. Or that their business model is similar to exclusive night clubs, that serve to protect, show-off and enhance prestige. Or that they are the successors of churches that sell indulgences (certificates, diplomas, the sheepskin effect).</p><p>Don’t get me wrong. This insurance policy is working and there is a new aristocracy of the 9.9% highly educated experts, bureaucrats and middle managers who grease the wheels of the current globalized economy. And the divide between highly educated with a degree from prestigious institutions and the rest is growing as documented by this great <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/06/the-birth-of-a-new-american-aristocracy/559130/">article</a> from the Atlantic. But they are mostly middle managers or highly paid consultants for others.</p><p>There is also The Gervais Principle, an interesting book-long <a href="https://www.ribbonfarm.com/the-gervais-principle/">argument</a> based on The Office series, that tries to explain how there are three distinct groups in the corporate hierarchies and how they map on the saying that “some people talk about other people, others talk about events, and yet others talk about ideas”. And this middle management group, that the author Venkatesh Rao calls Clueless, talks mostly about other people, and is mostly inspired by other (great) people and wants to emulate other (great) people. Nassim Taleb calls the very elite of them <em>name-droppers</em> at Davos.</p><p>And (I would add) therefore they follow current top trends and go to top universities. But this creates zero-sum dynamics and intense competition and jealousy. Peter Thiel described this well in his book Zero to One. It is interesting to note here that despite Peter Thiel being a libertarian, he is connected via Stanford to his mentor Rene Girard and thus to his friend Jean Pierre Dupuy who was close to Ivan Illich (famous for concepts of deschooling and counterproductivity).</p><h4><strong>Exponential technologies plus collective stupidity equals civilization will self-terminate</strong></h4><p>This argument is deep and is well explained by Daniel Schmachenberger for example <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xhrr-fJCTWY">here</a>. Basically if you combine ever more powerful technologies like CRISPR/Cas9 and AI and neuroscience you expand the possibilities for both <strong>good and bad </strong>tremendously. But we need collective <strong>sense-making</strong> and collective <strong>choice-making</strong> to be also on an <strong>exponential improvement trajectory</strong>, otherwise the civilization will self-terminate (existential risks will become reality). We need to embrace the <strong>Game B</strong>, or an economy based on anti-rivalrous foundations. That hasn’t been tried much yet (no it’s not communism, it was still rivalrous). But again places like Santa Fe Institute and The Centro Intercultural de Documentación (CIDOC), and your local hacker space or maker space can be precursors to it. To make this the norm would be Sokal Cubed. Displaying how not only grievance studies, but whole university <strong>wasn’t</strong> until now mostly about learning but about prestige and hierarchy. Well because until now, almost everything was about those things. But civilization needs to undergo a <strong>phase shift</strong> — where most of the economy will be about <strong>anti-rivalry</strong>. The great metaphor for that is a <strong>caterpillar to butterfly</strong> (via a liminal stage of a cocoon). You wouldn’t predict a butterfly from the behavior of a caterpillar that eats and destroys the environment in the quest to get ever bigger. But the butterfly pollinates plants and has very different behavior and look.</p><p><strong>We need new cocoons</strong> — makerspaces and hubs and organizations like Santa Fe Institutes, CIDOCS and FabLabs… that will help to create a new <strong>anti-rivalrous economies</strong> and inventions while being <strong>anti-fragile</strong> to the current rivalrous economy and use good game theory foundations.</p><p>And we need new <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metamodernism"><strong>meta-modern</strong></a> values that combine what we have learnt via modernity and postmodernism into something more productive with the future generations and survival of the planet in mind.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e99d64f9340c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/sokal-cubed-e99d64f9340c">Sokal Cubed</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Four modes of thinking about cause prioritization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/four-modes-of-thinking-about-cause-prioritization-8b9f81abd6b0?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b9f81abd6b0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[effective-altruism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cause-prioritization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sdgs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainable-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theory-of-constraints]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Aug 2018 15:53:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-28T19:25:28.793Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*JGH5W5QW5tQclwC3" /><figcaption>Image that illustrates Theory of Constrains (ToC) and the need for Synthetic/Systemic Thinking. From <a href="https://praxis.fortelabs.co/theory-of-constraints-106-the-five-focusing-steps-741f1b770bf1/">https://praxis.fortelabs.co/theory-of-constraints-106-the-five-focusing-steps-741f1b770bf1/</a></figcaption></figure><p>If you want to improve the world in big way, where shall you invest first? The process of coming up with areas and projects for improvement and ranking them is called by effective altruists “<a href="http://effective-altruism.com/ea/1lu/current_thinking_on_prioritization_2018/">cause prioritization</a>”. Cause is an area like <em>farm animal suffering</em>. And we can use various ways how to compare the need of investment among various causes. And these can be matched with four ways of thinking — on the horizontal axis 1. <a href="https://blog.givewell.org/2014/06/10/sequence-thinking-vs-cluster-thinking/"><strong>Sequence Thinking</strong></a> (a sequence of arguments and assumptions that can run wild and get us to concepts like “whole brain emulations”) versus 2. <strong>Cluster Thinking</strong> (kind of mental parliament negotiating between various theories and approaches in order to limit the tendency to go into extremes based upon one theory like in Sequence Thinking).</p><p>And on the vertical axis 3. <strong>Analytic Thinking</strong> (animal suffering analyzed further as farm animal suffering and wild animal suffering, etc.) versus 4. <strong>Synthetic Thinking</strong> (Finding common patterns or systemic bottlenecks — see a related approach of <a href="http://systemicthinking.com/origins/theory-of-constraints.html"><strong>Systemic Thinking</strong></a>).</p><p>These are four tools for cause prioritization that I so far stumbled upon:</p><p><strong>1. </strong><a href="https://80000hours.org/articles/problem-framework/"><strong>Importance-Tractability-Neglectedness Framework</strong></a> — if a certain cause is more <strong>important</strong> (e.g. kills 100x more people annually) we shall prioritize it among other candidate causes that kill much less people. Or if the cause is more <strong>neglected</strong> (gets 100x less attention and funding) and/or if the cause is more <strong>solvable</strong> (e.g. half of the problem can go away if we double the investment in the cause). You can rate and rank various causes on these three criteria, using something akin to a Richter earthquake scale and then sum up the points.</p><p><strong>2. Cost — Benefit Analyses</strong> represent a single criterion — value for money in terms of dollars invested versus benefits. For example, <a href="https://www.copenhagenconsensus.com/post-2015-consensus">Copenhagen Consensus</a> assembles economists to calculate cost-benefit estimates of various interventions, like salt iodization versus expansion of vocational training in poorer countries.</p><p><strong>3. Theory of Constraints</strong> — where is the biggest bottleneck in the system?</p><p>Theory of constraints originates from manufacturing and can be applied to knowledge work. The conclusion of ToC is quite counterintuitive — only the action on the bottleneck matters and people should reduce efforts in other places, otherwise they will make the situation worse(!). Take a café owner who wants to increase revenue. No matter what interior design changes he comes up with, nothing will change if the bottleneck is the slow cash register. Because this sets a daily limit of customers that can be served and changes in interior design won’t make the revenue grow, because there is a limit on them posed by the cash register speed. If you want to read more about Theory of Constrains — this is a good <a href="https://medium.com/praxis-blog/theory-of-constraints-101-2d4d9cf1916a">place</a> to start.</p><p><strong>4. Network theory</strong> — what are the most connected nodes in the network of causes?</p><p>This is a recent World Bank <a href="http://sdg.iisd.org/news/world-bank-paper-tests-methodology-for-prioritizing-sdgs-indicators/">paper</a> with some interesting application of network theory in prioritization of Sustainable Development Goals with counter-intuitive conclusions for people used to reasoning along the lines of cost-benefit estimates, like the ones by Copenhagen Consensus. In short, goals like <em>affordable clean energy </em>and <em>sanitation</em> are <em>central</em> to many of the Sustainable Development Goals and can thus increase probabilities of their achievement.</p><p>ToC and Network Theory approaches seem intuitively similar and they also seem to apply synthetic/systemic thinking. The ITN Framework seems similar to (horizontal) cluster thinking (because it combines various criteria). Cost-benefit analysis seem to attract analytic thinking that chases after “low-hanging fruits”.</p><p>Network theory of prioritization makes the trade-off explicit — a country can pursue “low-hanging fruits first” strategy, but it might as a result reduce probability of achieving more goals (like Sustainable Development Goals) in the more long-term future. As if the country pursued (also) goals that are more interconnected (seems similar idea to bottleneck). So there is a trade-off and countries should balance both approaches.</p><p>There is a use for each of the four types of thinking shortly outlined in a rather limited and speculative manner. But it would be wise to combine them and don’t rely too much on only one way of thinking — as it might be counterproductive after one loses a good sense of measure.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b9f81abd6b0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/four-modes-of-thinking-about-cause-prioritization-8b9f81abd6b0">Four modes of thinking about cause prioritization</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Intellectual Dark Web should help expand the moral circle and shrink the extremism circle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/the-intellectual-dark-web-should-help-expand-the-moral-circle-and-shrink-the-extremism-circle-560fc7389e4a?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/560fc7389e4a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[moral-circle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maajid-nawaz]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sam-harris]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jordan-peterson]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Jul 2018 16:51:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-08T16:51:39.648Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*T4XOgbBhJcZvPmPJkR_l8Q.png" /><figcaption>While Jordan Peterson talks about lobsters and hierarchies, he is still in the Gauss science paradigm. But extreme events in many domains, including wealth distribution, are better captured by Pareto science paradigm, that includes fractals and scale-free theories.</figcaption></figure><p>Civilization progresses by expanding the moral circle over history. We care not only about our immediate family and village, but also about people in our nation, or group of nations like Europe, and even people in other richer or poorer countries.</p><p>In the Western democratic and industrialized countries, we managed to expand rights for women, ethnic and religious minorities, and more recently also for sexual minorities. Couple of countries also progressed in the animal rights issues, for example ending the classification of some animals as things. Other countries abolished some old laws against blasphemy and thus expanded freedom of speech and expression.</p><p>If we imagine what will our grandchildren in the future perceive as moral failing of our times, one can probably mention farm animal suffering, homelessness, mental health, drug war and massive incarceration, extreme poverty, and the suffering of war refugees (as distinguished from economic migrants in relative poverty, more on that later).</p><p>There might be even more important issues under the umbrella of preserving future generations and thus fighting existential and extreme risks, also called XRisks. These might be preventing extreme climate change; or biotechnology, AI and nanotechnology gone wrong; along with the more traditional threats of nuclear wars or accidents, and genocides.</p><h4><strong>Tribalism prevents us from expanding the moral circle, but we need Goldilocks conditions of moderate but not extreme ideologies — left, right, conservative and liberal</strong></h4><p>In my previous <a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek/to-expand-the-moral-circle-we-need-to-shrink-the-extremism-circle-4dc3af6c9ad2">article</a> I wrote about shrinking of what I called “the extremism circle”. It draws on the idea of <a href="https://www.timesofisrael.com/the-british-activist-who-went-from-radical-islam-to-staunch-israel-ally/">Triple Threat</a> by Maajid Nawaz. He means extremists from <strong>1.</strong> <strong>the far right</strong> (neo-Nazis, alt-right advocates of ethno-states and ethnic superiority, etc.), <strong>2.</strong> <strong>from above</strong> (extremist theologians inciting hatred and violence), and from <strong>3.</strong> <strong>the far left</strong> (extremists advocating violence and espousing the bigotry of low expectations and <em>overplaying</em> the identity politics). I added the fourth element — extremists <strong>4. from the underground</strong>, organized crime and gangs (that seem to be quite connected also to terrorism, often pursue power over politicians and use violence and threats).</p><p><strong>But in my previous article I was wrong to think that one shall aim to reduce the extremism circle to zero</strong>, to something that some people call Radical Centre politics, or the rationality of technocratic experts. No, <strong>shrinking it too much</strong> would be a mistake as in the very center there is basically <strong>nihilism</strong>. But <strong>expanding the circle too much</strong>, into the extreme gives us totalitarianism of mafia states.</p><p>The core concept that I was missing is the sense of a good measure, what we call <strong>Goldilocks conditions</strong> (not too cold and not too warm) or “being in the zone”, or having “a flow state of mind” while working on sufficiently challenging, but not too threatening challenge. This is what Buddhism might call the middle way.</p><p>More technically this is the zone of <strong>not too much chaos and not too much order</strong>, <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/figure/The-Ashby-Space_fig3_287423440">called</a> the Ashby Space in complexity science. The similar idea is of a good measure in relationships and network science is the idea of weak ties (one finds e.g. life partners more easily through weak ties — acquaintances, friends of friends). Similar idea was more recently presented in regards to social change and social networks by a mathematician Benjamin Allen who <a href="https://aeon.co/ideas/global-cooperation-depends-on-the-strength-of-local-connections">says</a> that the interactions on social networks are not enough, and the structure of networks matters for propagation of cooperation, and that local ties and physical meetings are necessary to propagate positive global behavior (Campaigning on social media is not enough and might even weaken the efforts for change).</p><p>Complexity researcher Bill McKelvey <a href="http://www.billmckelvey.org/documents/-0-Pubs%20to%20be%20added%20as%20Hot-Links--TEMP%20FILE/2012%20Lichtenstein,%20McKelvey(12)-Four%20Types%20of%20Emergence.pdf">writes</a> how (too) strong ties where everyone is connected with everyone else can create “a complexity catastrophe” (technical term) of a groupthink, but the optimal level of complexity creates “the rugged landscapes, which lead to the highest system-wide fitness levels”.</p><p>I didn’t know what a complexity catastrophe means some days ago, so don’t worry if you got lost on some of the examples — basically it is the same principle of having <em>a sense of balance</em>, or <em>a sense of a good measure</em>, or the <em>Goldilocks principle</em> of not too cold and not too warm, or what recently got a mainstream attention in the person of Jordan Peterson and his insistence on the balance between <em>order and chaos</em> (as we need both).</p><h4><strong>But what does it exactly mean keeping the ideology in the Goldilocks zone?</strong></h4><p>The most controversial would be the Goldilocks zone for the fourth “underground” dimension of crime — here my attempt of an answer would be e.g. not jailing kids for one joint, or ending the drug war or having slight exceptions to traffic rules for some occasions and some groups. Maybe being a slight libertarian at times — meaning e.g. not calling police on street vendors that you might suspect of not having a license.</p><p>On the Left a good example is a political ideology called social democracy or democratic socialism (e.g. SPD in Germany). Because it consists of two words that indicate a certain trade-off: achieving the goals of universalism and demonetization of certain services that are considered rights (e.g. 2 different healthcare systems in Britain and Continental Europe) but doing it through democratic means (as opposed to totalitarian ones). To help people distinguish the phenomena of 1. online call out culture, 2. extreme identity politics and e.g. 3. various forms of Left politics democratic socialism, here is an <a href="https://www.socialeurope.eu/bo-interview">interview</a> with a Swedish social democrat Bo Rothstein criticizing too much identity politics. Here is an author of Kill or Normies book, Angela Nagle on Zero Books podcast, a critical theory publisher with Marxist influences, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IA02FVFxdYQ">answering</a> her critics that <em>called her out online</em> on Twitter and <em>misrepresented</em> her views or blamed her for being sympathetic to the so called alt-right.</p><p>The broader point is that e.g. Sam Harris or Jordan Peterson are not the only people getting hate online, even Marxists get the same, and therefore we as humans are more united and more similar than we tend to think. So blaming Marxism or postmodernism alone is not enough and probably wrong (they are often contradictory terms as explained by <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LqZdkkBDas">ContraPoints</a>, a trans-sexual youtuber, who also gets hate online from some far left elements for e.g. opposing the notion of cultural appropriation). The problem might be a lack of attention due to social media addiction, shrinking media market, weak economy with a whole generation that might not own homes, and some resulting virtue signaling, tribalism and game theory that might resemble <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexican_standoff">a Mexican standoff</a>. Podcasts and youtube seems to be the technology that disrupts this suboptimal media landscape and allows people to engage in deeper learning and discussions that results in good faith attempts to steelman the opponent viewpoints.</p><p>One might ask but what about Marxism? Doesn’t it lead always to a totalitarian big state and Orwellian society. One might view Marxism just as one ideology and influence on social democracy that needs to be kept in balance and within the boundaries of liberal democracy and the rule of law. But to steelman Marxism would mean just acknowledge its main point — <strong>economic reality matters</strong> — for example generational poverty means kids hear much less words from their parents when they grow up, and it later shows in their learning ability.</p><p>So if people like Jordan Peterson want to draw a red line around the notion of equity — one needs to understand that this too is a question of a good measure and balance. I think the red line shall be drawn around extreme identity politics where you start to judge people, or order people, and even prosecute people according to their origin and class — for example business people, owners of big farms, some other minorities or ethnicities, including what some people call white privilege.</p><p>But one needs to again be sensible and understand that there are historic dynamics that are also technically called “rich get richer dynamics” and this creates the famous 80/20 Pareto distribution and power laws. The Atlantic illustrates this point perfectly in the <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/06/the-birth-of-a-new-american-aristocracy/559130/">article</a> “The 9.9 Percent Is the New American Aristocracy”:</p><blockquote>“If you are starting at the median for people of color, you’ll want to practice your financial pole-vaulting. <a href="https://ips-dc.org/report-the-road-to-zero-wealth/">The Institute for Policy Studies calculated</a> that, setting aside money invested in “durable goods” such as furniture and a family car, the median black family had net wealth of $1,700 in 2013, and the median Latino family had $2,000, compared with $116,800 for the median white family. A 2015 study in Boston found that the wealth of the median white family there was $247,500, while the wealth of the median African American family was $8. That is not a typo. That’s two grande cappuccinos. That and another 300,000 cups of coffee will get you into the 9.9 percent.”</blockquote><p>So if the Intellectual Dark Web wants to steelman the arguments of their ideological opponents they don’t need to discard science — just understand that in many areas the most value comes from signaling, as opposed to intrinsic value (e.g. driving Tesla vs. driving from A to B), and virtue signaling is important. This means a need for a greater epistemic humility — acknowledging the fact that we have much to learn scientifically (Pareto science versus Gauss science) but also emotionally (trying to feel through the lived experiences of others).</p><h4><strong>Goldilocks conditions is one useful idea, and Pareto science is the second one</strong></h4><p>At the beginning I asked how to expand the moral circle and make people more sensitive towards the suffering of farm animals, or towards global catastrophic risks that might wipe out not only us but also our future generations, or towards global extreme poverty and local generational poverty.</p><p>And I proposed an argument, that in order to expand the moral circle, we need to reduce tribalism, and shrink the extremism circle with four sides — far right, far left, above (theocracy and totalitarianism) and underground (gangs, organized crime, mafia states).</p><p>But I stressed the need for moderation, for staying in the middle way, in the zone, in Goldilocks conditions of not too cold or warm, and keeping a sense of a good measure or balance (all examples of the same concept). Too much ideology might lead to extremism and totalitarianism and too little ideology might lead to nihilism, economism or a technocratic stalemate with no clear, optimistic and definite future (plans and visions).</p><p>Then I explained that the red line shall be attacks on liberal democracy as a playing field and space by groups from the left, right, above and underground, that want to overthrow the system through extreme identity politics (as opposed to moderate identity politics). Moderate identity politics is what Zizek calls “tolerating your Neighbour” and practically one can see it when standup comedians make fun about their identities or tell stories about their friends who made fun of their identities. Acceptable identity politics is when groups try to pursue collective action to expand their rights. And it is when people observe “<strong>the</strong> <strong>platinum rule</strong>” (treat others as they want to be treated by you) as opposed to <strong>the golden rule</strong> (treat others as you want to be treated). Then it gets quite simple — if girls call each other “bitches” and they are ok with it, it doesn’t mean that e.g. men can call them that and they are ok with it. Yes, the Overton window keeps shifting in time, and what is politically correct changes. But if it is sensible, charitable, in good faith and moderate, that we can get along.</p><p>As the last point I want to address the second concept of Pareto versus Gauss science. Liberals complain often that they observe a certain apocalyptic sect-like behavior on the Left — e.g. the belief that everything is going into ruin, the world will end in climate change catastrophe and the late capitalism will collapse because of rising inequalities. They try to counter that narrative with optimistic visions about science and enlightenment. The recent example is the latest book of Steven Pinker “Enlightenment Now: The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress”.</p><p>But I want to stress that the both sides are wrong, because they underestimate the positive opportunities of exponential technologies and but also the negative existential risks that go along with them. The problem is in the current paradigm of Gauss science and the absence of thinking in terms of earthquake science, or Pareto science and complexity science with extreme statistics.</p><p>In short the far Left sometimes slides towards the unacceptable behavior of “punching Nazis” or “calling everyone who disagrees with their ideas a gateway to alt-right”. It is understandable at some level, because they want to prevent another Holocaust or another second world war. But similar to tsunamis and earthquakes, they are underestimating the threat and fighting the last war. Of course, anyone sensible wants to prevent the next war where 50 million people would die. But the extreme statistics that observe the rare events in earthquake science tells us that we shall be worried even more about the first war that might kill 500 million people, or 5 billion people or even much more than 50 billion people (human extinction event that would destroy the future generations as well). So this is the same thinking that goes with observing earthquakes, there are hundreds of thousands of small earthquakes every year that we hardly observe, but scientists care about several magnitudes larger earthquakes that are rare (e.g. 8’s once in 300 years) but very consequential. Now you see the problem with Pinker’s narrative of ever improving world, and the need for including the Taleb’s concept of (anti)fragility. I write more about the magnitudes of positive and negative events that might occur in short e.g. <a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek/how-to-improve-negative-thinking-in-13-easy-steps-19c91cac5737">here</a>.</p><p>Exponential technologies might help humanity achieve sustainable prosperity, peace and even help us expand our moral circles. The current tribalism might be a result of new technologies and economic uncertainty that goes in hand with the lack of imagination for a positive and definite future. We need to use concepts of moderation (Goldilocks conditions) and Pareto science to keep liberal democracy safe from its enemies and even expand it and start to dream up positive and definite futures again — as in the moonshot era of the 1960s.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=560fc7389e4a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/the-intellectual-dark-web-should-help-expand-the-moral-circle-and-shrink-the-extremism-circle-560fc7389e4a">The Intellectual Dark Web should help expand the moral circle and shrink the extremism circle</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to increase our social impact exponentially?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/how-to-increase-our-social-impact-exponentially-eb5a9ad21354?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb5a9ad21354</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[socisdg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sote-hub]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-impact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[effective-altruism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sdgs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Jun 2018 11:34:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-12T11:34:16.708Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/1*ps3WrRTcLULRNoYEFoL-nw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Students from Sote ICT Club at Kajire Girls secondary school present their training company Marvelous Arts at Innovation Fair 2017, in Voi, Kenya.</figcaption></figure><p>Everyone wants to leave a legacy and contribute to something meaningful. Many companies, non-profit organizations, donors or whole countries are asking how to measure social impact and increase it considerably?</p><p>The problem is that this question seems to confuse most of people, and it seems to require considerable time investment to get into the details of practicing social impact measurement. Therefore, we need to invest into producing understandable and short explanations, but without the oversimplification. This article claims that it is useful to take an <em>outside view</em> and start with prioritizing the most important problems.</p><h4><strong>Inside view versus Outside view</strong></h4><p>Many organizations want to get a stamp of approval that their activities are efficient and have an impact in real life. This need is understandable, but one can start with taking the “outside view” first — and start asking what is the most pressing need in my region, country or globally?</p><p>The famous author of Thinking Fast and Slow, a Nobel Prize laureate <strong>Daniel Kahneman</strong> describes how he failed to estimate how long will it take him and his co-authors to write a curriculum and a text book on the topic of decision making and critical thinking. Their estimates where somewhere between one and three years. But when he prompted a curriculum development expert to think of how long does it <em>usually</em> take to write a text book (and example of an <em>outside view</em>) he paused for a long time and said something shocking: maybe 40% of the teams failed to ever finish the book and the rest took somewhere between 7–10 years. But the same expert gave an estimate in the 1–3 year range, when he took the optimistic <em>inside view</em>.</p><h4><strong>Exploitation versus Exploration</strong></h4><p>Many of us are spending most of our days at improving our current activities, projects and daily routines. In other words, we ask how to be more efficient at what we do and how to <em>exploit</em> the skills and opportunities that our current situation and assets allow to make the most of what we have. But we should spend 10–20% of our time in <em>exploration</em> activities — this means learning or unlearning new skills, and “learning to learn” more effectively, or brainstorming brand new projects.</p><p>The famous Pareto distribution or Pareto Rule describes how 80% of results come from 20% of effort. The economist, Vilfredo Pareto observed that 80% of land in his home country Italy is owned by 20% of population. Many events and aspects of our world follow similarly uneven distribution.</p><p>We could think of e.g. 90/10 split — if we invest constantly 10% of our time in learning and exploration of new opportunities it might bring us 90% of new business and increased results in the future.</p><p>It might be difficult to take the <em>outside view</em> on our cherished and long-term “business as usual” project or a cash-cows. But we could start at “the edges of our organization” and invite new thinking and models to explore the possibilities for a greater social impact when planning <em>new</em> and <em>future</em> projects.</p><p>This article aims to help with fresh thinking about social impact, but at the same time it aims keep it simple and accessible to any practitioner. We want to explain some tools used by people in the Effective Altruism community that can help us to prioritize our interventions and connect them to Sustainable Development Goals framework.</p><h4><strong>How much good can you do with an additional euro or person?</strong></h4><p>Imagine some extreme and hypothetical example: There are only two scientists in the whole world who work on reversing aging — the cause of death for 66% of global population. And they operate on an annual budget of 100,000 euros.</p><p>We can suspect that they might be underfunded and would need additional funding to buy more equipment or hire more people. We can also find it strange that there are only two people doing this in the whole world. Maybe all the other scientists already concluded that to reverse aging is impossible, or that it requires tremendous amounts of time and money.</p><p>If we take an <em>outside view</em> — a view that an impartial donor or an investor might take, we can ask: How much good would I create if I 1) doubled the budget of those two scientists, 2) found another skilled scientist for them, 3) promoted their work in public, 4) helped them to create a company or NGO, or 5) joined them and worked directly on their research or assist them with operations?</p><p>In other words, you can make a positive impact directly with your work and career, indirectly with influencing and promoting the cause, and by donating or investing for the cause. You can also combine these approaches.</p><p>The most important realization is that very impactful projects and organizations will be <em>rare</em> and thus Pareto-distributed. It means they don’t follow a normal, Gauss Curve and bell-shaped distributions but a very “long-tailed” distribution (with a few very large outliers — e.g. a project that is 1000x more effective than the median one).</p><p>Finding projects with extraordinary impact is like meeting a person who is 200 meters or 20,000 meters tall. Well that is absurd in terms of height, but not in the cases of wealth distribution or social impact or popularity of musicians. Our brains cannot comprehend these differences — but they are nevertheless striking: For example, Oxfam <a href="https://www.oxfam.org/en/pressroom/pressreleases/2017-01-16/just-8-men-own-same-wealth-half-world">reported</a> in 2017 that the richest 8 people own as much as half of the planet combined. In a “Pareto World” averages of e.g. wealth size are much less meaningful than medians.</p><p>One can find a similar situation in development cooperation and poverty eradication programs. Some economists, such as William Easterly or Ester Duflo, are famous for criticizing development projects e.g. in Africa, where some big farm or a big dam, or any so called “white elephant” flagship projects, is built by foreign donors in cooperation with local authorities. But often the project fails to deliver because of mismanagement or corruption, and sometimes money are siphoned off to Swiss bank accounts. However, these economists criticize maybe the <em>average</em> development project, but discount the fact that some projects might be 1000x more effective than others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*-GF0irNYJ-15m4dWs3r9hA.jpeg" /><figcaption>WHO smallpox eradication program that saved estimated 60 million people, or 5x what would “a world peace” save since 1980.</figcaption></figure><p>For example, Viktor Zhdanov, a Deputy Minister of Health for the Soviet Union, once proposed a novel idea to World Health Organization — a project to eradicate smallpox from the planet. Despite the Cold War this idea was implemented by an international team of doctors and experts from all around the world and managed by an American, Donald Henderson. The project lasted for 10 years, and the last case of small pox was eradicated in Somalia in 1977.</p><p>It was the first disease that the humanity eradicated from earth. And some estimates say that since then the eradication saved around 60 million lives on planet, or 5x more than a hypothetical world peace would save. The program was so cost-effective that if development cooperation didn’t produce any other benefit, only this program, it would be still very cost-effective according to Western standards for costs to save lives e.g. by improving road infrastructure.</p><h4><strong>Look for the most neglected, solvable and important problems</strong></h4><p>As we mentioned earlier — there are huge differences between a typical project and an extraordinary project. We can say the same about comparing various problems, some might be much more important than others. For example, over a million people in the world die each year from traffic related accidents, and 4.6 million people die from small particles pollution — this is almost 10x more than people who die from violence globally. And people who die from aging are then again in another magnitude — some 36 million people each year.</p><p>I picked up these extreme examples just to make a broader point — in any sector or cause area we can find specific causes or problems that are orders of magnitude more neglected, or more important than others.</p><p>Take the cause of animal rights. Around 3400 farm animals are killed in the US for every dog that is euthanized in the animal shelter. But the biggest 90 animal shelters receive together 1.2 billion dollars every year. Compared to that, the biggest farm animal advocacy organizations <a href="https://animalcharityevaluators.org/donation-advice/why-farmed-animals/">receive</a> together only 19 million dollars of donations each year. So there is a three orders of magnitude difference between various types of animals who might suffer (dogs and cats vs farm animals) and there is two orders of magnitude difference in funding. If we add importance of the problem (number of animals killed) and neglectedness (annual budgets for these two types of charities), together these would make five orders of magnitude. This is exactly what the ITN Framework does.</p><p>ITN Frameworks stands for Importance-Tractability-Neglectedness <a href="https://80000hours.org/articles/problem-framework/">Framework</a>, and works in a similar way as a Richter earthquake magnitude scale — where the difference between two points is 10x — or one magnitude.</p><p>So if you are a donor or a company that wants to conduct a brainstorming session about new future projects and cause areas that would radically increase your impact a good way to start is to rate various problems on these four criteria: Importance, Tractability (Solvability), Neglectedness and Personal Fit (how close it is to your mission, interest or skillset).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/979/1*wgflc2k2uOFPpt11X9JgnQ.png" /><figcaption>How to think about importance, tractability and neglectedness (room for funding) in a broader picture. Source: <a href="http://effective-altruism.com/ea/yp/evaluation_frameworks_or_when_importance/">http://effective-altruism.com/ea/yp/evaluation_frameworks_or_when_importance/</a></figcaption></figure><p>In our example above, if you are a person who just wants to decrease animal suffering and you have no preference of dogs or cats above other animals, if you donate towards farm animal advocacy groups your euro or dollar will travel further than if you donate towards animal shelters. Actually much further, like 100,000x further — this difference of five orders of magnitude is so huge that our brains are not accustomed to work with these numbers and we experience something called <em>scope insensitivity</em> — a cognitive bias also described by Kahneman and his friend Tversky.</p><p>But what about Solvability? We can ask a simple question and make a very crude estimate — How much of the problem would we solve if we doubled the current funding that goes to those organizations? For example, if we estimate with the 10% probability that doubling the funding for organization that advocate for farm animal welfare, would reduce the number of killed animals by 10% the total <em>expected value</em> is 10% x 10% = 1% reduction in killed animals. But since there are 9.2 billions of farm animals slaughtered in the US alone, it would mean saving 92 million animal lives for another 19 million dollars (doubling the total current budget of organizations that deal with this cause in the US). Or almost 5 farm animal lives saved per dollar.</p><p>It needs to be stressed here, that this is only statistical approximation and many people would object to these “cold hearted” calculations. But they are important to help us to combat our cognitive biases like scope insensitivity and allow us to be actually more emphatic to others.</p><p>But it is important to understand that our resources in terms of time, attention, career capital and social capital are limited. And there are many opportunities that might produce results that are orders of magnitude more beneficial and socially impactful. An illustration of this thinking is the <a href="http://www.copenhagenconsensus.com/sites/default/files/post2015brochure_m.pdf">ranking</a> of Sustainable Development Goals and its targets by Copenhaagen Consensus Center — their economists estimated that e.g. tripling preschool education in Africa would bring 33 dollars of benefit for every dollar invested. Compared to that increasing secondary school enrollment would bring “only” 4 dollars of benefit for every dollar invested.</p><p>The pattern in similar rankings is straightforward — it is cheaper to invest early than later — in preschools and primary schools then universities. One can suspect that it is due to decreasing marginal returns — early interventions might produce much more value than if one “comes relatively late to the party” — or to the process of learning.</p><p>Again this doesn’t mean that we shall abandon for example the ambitious goal of universal secondary education enrollment — but that preschool is much cheaper and it shall have a larger weight in our portfolio of interventions.</p><h4><strong>How to scale our solutions exponentially?</strong></h4><p>If we increase the number of our beneficiaries, people who use our solution or are enrolled in our program, we talk about the <em>breadth of impact</em>. If we talk about improving the quality of their lives, we talk about <em>the depth of our impact</em>.</p><p>Increasing the number of beneficiaries is not the same as scaling our impact. Scaling means <em>doing more with less</em> — it implies reduction of costs per every new marginal customer or beneficiary.</p><p>For example, in our <a href="https://www.facebook.com/SoteHub/">Sote ICT Clubs</a> in Kenya we had in 2017 around 1000 students at 12 schools and our annual budget for this activity was around 50,000 euros. So the cost per student was very roughly 50 euros. At our <a href="http://www.sotehub.com/">Sote Hub</a> in Voi town we had a community of around 50 members who came repeatedly to our events and were interested in developing their own startups and pitched at our competitions. And running Sote Hub also cost around 50,000 euros a year. So the cost per each active member was very roughly 1000 euros.</p><p>We have around 500 members who signed up for Sote Hub membership, we also had around 500 visitors who took part at our events in 2017. But still in this case, the cost per member or visitor is around 100 euros.</p><p>But how could we provide our services and acquire new beneficiaries 10x cheaper? These questions are crucial if we want to grow exponentially. To scale Sote ICT Clubs or to scale Sote Hubs would mean to find ways to reduce the marginal cost of acquiring new members, opening IT clubs at new schools, or creating a community of entrepreneurs in new towns <em>more cheaply</em>.</p><p>One clear answer is <em>to digitize our services</em> more. For example, every lecture we put on youtube can be viewed by many more people than just the event at a particular school or day in Sote Hub.</p><p>Another way is to use the <em>pull</em> approach instead of <em>push </em>approach — instead of going to new schools and proposing new Sote ICT Clubs and then equipping them — we can organize more Startup Idea <em>competitions</em> and open them to schools outside our current program. This way we will gain contact to a broader pool of new motivated teachers. And we will pull the teachers and students who are already motivated but lacked means to join our competitions or to create communities that are similar to ours.</p><p>The third option is to build <em>a movement</em> of teachers that would self-organize some regular peer learning groups in their towns or villages and start their own new Sote ICT Clubs.</p><p>The fourth option is to empower these teachers further by certification to start their own franchise and somehow formalize the informal communities.</p><p>The fifth option is to nurture <em>online communities</em> and platforms where e.g. students and teachers compete in innovative content creation or problem-based learning.</p><p>The sixth option is to create <em>open source</em> material that can be used by other actors and thus spread our indirect reach.</p><p>Out of these options we feel that a greater digitalization, community-building and organizing competitions are the three main elements. We are also particularly interested in a certain time of competitions like X Prize modeled after DARPA tournaments — that aims to produce very concrete solutions that are radically cheaper due to exponential technologies.</p><p>If we were to take an outside view — we could spread our program to primary schools where the costs of nurturing digital and business skills might be cheaper and benefits greater. We might also focus more heavily on coding and STEM to bridge the numeracy gaps between rural and elite schools.</p><p>But all these options are good candidates when we think how to scale our impact — spread our program to additional beneficiaries but reduce the costs 10x at the same time. This is a challenge that needs radically different ways of thinking and doing.</p><p>I will write about why competitions are important for scaling innovation in a follow up article. For now, I wanted to outline ways how organizations could aim to improve their impact by at least an order of magnitude. One way is to focus on new projects that try to solve an order of magnitude more important, neglected or solvable problem. Another one is to look for solutions that scale — and reduce the costs of acquiring new clients, or beneficiaries by an order of magnitude or more.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb5a9ad21354" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/how-to-increase-our-social-impact-exponentially-eb5a9ad21354">How to increase our social impact exponentially?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Decades Long Quest for A Digital Aristotle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/the-decades-long-quest-for-a-digital-aristotle-3546464eccc?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3546464eccc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-based-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aristotle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[effective-altruism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-assistant]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 May 2018 15:16:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:15:39.147Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*4RZETfRzNHIfAOMxk7VqvA.png" /><figcaption>Picture from a video Digital Aristotle: Thoughts on the Future of Education: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=98&amp;v=7vsCAM17O-M">https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=98&amp;v=7vsCAM17O-M</a></figcaption></figure><p>Aristotle was probably the best tutor in the world and the most knowledgeable person of his times. But still his student, Alexander the Great, went on to conquer half of the world. Being smart it seems, doesn’t automatically translate into being peaceful. The same fears echo today with the rising power of artificial intelligence.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2Fthe-decades-long-quest-for-a-digital-aristotle-3546464eccc&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2F3546464eccc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/64ba9e31da84e1707ee739b1f3502bb8/href">https://medium.com/media/64ba9e31da84e1707ee739b1f3502bb8/href</a></iframe><p>Aristotle is also the name of the <a href="https://www.edge.org/conversation/w_daniel_hillis-aristotle-the-knowledge-web">essay</a> that a technologist Daniel Hillis published on Edge.org in 2000. The essay received many reactions from top scholars, like Seymour Papert, the founder of constructivism in education who co-authored Logo programming language and inspired e.g. Lego Mindstorms robots and Scratch programming language.</p><p>In his essay, Daniel Hillis, imagines a digital assistant that would know people intimately, and was able to teach them effectively — based on their interests and styles of learning. The essay was viewed as very creative and ambitious, but the response from experts was somewhat skeptical. People asked — how can computers know us, and understand us?</p><p>Around the same time, at the dawn of a new millennium, a new set of Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) was adopted by the global community. And by the end of that decade, countries like Kenya made their primary and secondary education tuition-free. Also during those years, Wikipedia and Google changed the way how we search for information and create knowledge.</p><p>In our decade, since 2010, we saw a tremendous progress in some areas of artificial intelligence, like machine learning and deep learning, based on the exponential growth of processing power of Graphics Processing Units. With even more fascinating progress in neuroscience, based on fMRI technology and combined with machine learning, scientists are getting closer to literally “reading minds and visualizing memories and dreams”.</p><h4><strong>Could digital assistants help children learn more effectively and escape poverty?</strong></h4><p>From 2016 there is a new set of global goals — 17 so called Sustainable Development Goals, and a broader Agenda 2030 that was adopted by the UN, and aims to be universal. Meaning, it is not just rich countries helping poorer countries to develop faster — which was the paradigm of MDGs. Sustainable Development Goals imply that all countries are somewhat “developing countries” in their own ways and with their own challenges.</p><p>The goal SDG4 is to improve the quality of education and associated targets, are relevant for rich and poor countries alike. There are pockets of generational poverty also in the richest developed world. And education is broadly seen as a means for upward social mobility. But often children from marginalized backgrounds fall behind. Mostly because they lack the creative and motivated environment, and skilled tutors and mentors, that kids from the richer backgrounds have.</p><p>One way how to help students learn and teachers teach better, could be the use of smart digital assistants powered by artificial intelligence in the classrooms and homes. But the path towards digital assistants like Aristotle seems littered by failed startups and grand ambitions, that so far didn’t materialize. Still today we can see some encouraging signs — there is a strong trend in EdTech startups and some innovative approaches like Global Learning XPrize competition.</p><p>We also saw a success of companies like Duolingo, that bring free language courses on finger tips via mobile apps. And there is a solid research of what is effective in “learning to learn” — for example summarized in the most popular <a href="https://www.coursera.org/learn/learning-how-to-learn">course</a> on Coursera by Barbara Oakley and called Learning How To Learn.</p><h4><strong>Aristotle today is called Jill Watson or Wolfram|Alpha</strong></h4><p>Personal attention to each individual student by skilled teachers is crucial and AI might never truly replace real teachers. But digital and exponential technologies might rapidly reduce the cost of personalized teaching and replying questions that students might have.</p><p>For example, Ashok Goel, professor at Georgia Institute of Technology, have created an automated AI teacher assistant <a href="http://www.news.gatech.edu/2017/01/09/jill-watson-round-three">Jill Watson</a> (on IBM Watson platform) for students taking his courses online.</p><p>Google, Amazon and Apple have their AI based digital assistants. Amazon’s Alexa and Apple’s Siri both use calculations in their answers that are provided by Wolfram|Alpha. A computational search engine, named after Stephen Wolfram, creator of the Mathematica software and Wolfram Language.</p><p>Similar tools help children to calculate and visualize math problems and reply questions given in plain language.</p><p>Currently, there is no easy way for students to go back to concepts they learned over the years, and to see where the gaps in their knowledge and skills are. For example, biology connects to math. “Are there paths that unravel blockages over the time?” This is what Aditi Avasthi, CEO of an Indian company <a href="https://www.embibe.com/landing">Embibe.com</a> asked.</p><p>And her company created a knowledge graph to map the whole education concepts in Indian curriculum. She found out that the key to remove the blockages is so called grit — the ability of students to persevere among difficulties and continue with learning. (Another important and related concept is “a growth mindset versus fixed mindset” researched by a psychologist Carol Dweck.)</p><p>Embibe found out that AI can help parameterize human behavior and help students in learning according to their individual needs and style. For example, their software tracked parameters like “first-look accuracy” and “careless mistakes”, and gave students feedback what to improve.</p><p>At the end of her TEDx talk, the Emibe CEO, Aditi Avasthi, said: “No child shall be left behind, and no child shall be labeled.”</p><p>This is a worthy goal and AI for sure can help to reduce costs of individualized learning. Maybe it can even help to motivate children and keep them on track of their personal journey in effective learning. But AI is built by humans, and it mirrors biases of its creators. Digital technologies are just tools and no complete replacements to dysfunctional institutions or politics and outdated concepts like teacher-centered frontal instruction with “talk and chalk”.</p><p>But surely one can imagine also innovative peer-learning groups that use digital assistants in their collaboration and solve real-life problems. Therefore, a cautious optimism is warranted. What can be automated, probably will be automated by AI. But people all around the world shall have a say in how exactly this will be done and to what extent — keeping a good measure and balance between performance, privacy, freedom and sustainability. Sustainable Development Goals are also an attempt to strike such balance between prosperity and sustainability, between current generations and future ones. Between globalization and protection of unique cultural heritage.</p><p>Aristotle said that “Every virtue carried to the extreme, is a vice”. In our age, when researchers are pursuing the creation of “Safe AI”, this quote seems relevant as ever.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3546464eccc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/the-decades-long-quest-for-a-digital-aristotle-3546464eccc">The Decades Long Quest for A Digital Aristotle</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Universal Scholarship as an alternative to UBI]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/universal-scholarship-as-an-alternative-to-ubi-eee59d3773bc?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eee59d3773bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universal-basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universal-scholarship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Mar 2018 14:54:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:16:12.286Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*NOUwhEhgPZO2ewdznY_hew.jpeg" /><figcaption>Technology reverses globalization and threatens jobs in poor and rich countries alike. Screenshot of an article title, source: <a href="http://fortune.com/2016/05/25/adidas-robot-speedfactories/">http://fortune.com/2016/05/25/adidas-robot-speedfactories/</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>Epistemic status: Speculation on alternative to Universal Basic Income</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2Funiversal-scholarship-as-an-alternative-to-ubi-eee59d3773bc&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2Feee59d3773bc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f1594d3ed57e9392241fb7d1b5843384/href">https://medium.com/media/f1594d3ed57e9392241fb7d1b5843384/href</a></iframe><p>Universal Basic Income is increasingly accepted as a viable cure to challenges posed by automation. I am excited about various experiments with UBI on municipal levels. I also support testing of UBI in Kenya by GiveDirectly by small monthly donations that can elevate one family out of extreme poverty.</p><p>But at the same time I see the political and societal limits of UBI as it is seen as a zero-sum endeavor — effectively redistributing income from rich people or corporations towards citizens in order to provide them with a buffer against long-term unemployment or way to decouple work from income to unleash broader creativity. The latter part — allowing people to learn, to pursue entrepreneurship, crafts and other projects is particularly exciting to me as it seems very non-zero-sum.</p><p>Interestingly UBI is popular among libertarians and the Left alike — but they have very different views how to implement it. Libertarians like the simplicity of UBI, and want all the social programs to be replaced with one single UBI payment. People on the political left want UBI to be complementary with existing social security net.</p><p>Another problem is with the bottleneck of urbanization and ever rising costs of housing in cities where all the ambitious people flock for opportunities. Again this could be eased up if people realize they don’t need to live in big successful cities. But if the change of minds doesn’t occur, UBI could be translated straight to inflation of housing prices. In the same way as most of the investment in startup money in Silicon Valley ends up with local landlords due to enormous costs of living.</p><p>And the third problem is the universality of UBI — will it be provided only to inhabitants of certain cities, only to citizens, or all residents of certain countries, or globally to all?</p><h4><strong>Alternatives to UBI</strong></h4><p>One alternative <a href="https://futurism.com/ubi-universal-basic-income-alternative/">proposed</a> by the economist Zoltán Pogátsa suggests we could pressure corporations to pay us for data we provide them:</p><blockquote>“We could hold Google and Facebook and all those big multinationals accountable; we could make sure that people, like those who are currently ‘voluntarily’ contributing their data to pump up companies’ profits, are given something that is adequate to support their livelihoods in exchange.”</blockquote><p>He proposes that this funds could be collected by a public trust and invested in education. This is, I think a move in a right direction towards a paradigm shift.</p><p>More money leads to more free time and that leads to more learning and culture and that leads into historical legacy that small countries like Denmark could amass in terms of thinkers like Kierkegaard.</p><p>(Because most philosophers were rich enough to allow long periods for thinking, without constant worry for bread and butter issues. So the idea is that if much more people don’t need to worry about living expenses we could see more intellectual outliers, artists, philosophers, entrepreneurs or craftsmen.)</p><p>Another alternative is something in the vein of “housing-first” projects for the homeless that operate under straightforward assumptions that providing housing to homeless is cheaper as prevention than expensive medical treatments and the cost of emergency care once people are freezing on the streets. In combination with some futuristic views about technological abundance and food alternatives (like powder food, Soylent…) one can imagine a house with one tap for running water and one for food. Again this view is still in the paradigm of redistribution. And also in-kind provision of material benefits is usually more expensive.</p><h4><strong>Universal Scholarship</strong></h4><p>An alternative to UBI we can call Universal Scholarship would be an opt-in scheme that would incentivize people to learn and share openly their progress — both successes and failures, troubles and small victories and how it impacted their skills. In a way it is similar to the idea of requiring companies to pay for the data people provide. But it is also different — because those data would be open source, related to their learning and skills progress and a result of collaboration between teams, and teams of teams.</p><p>These learning outcomes would also serve as alternative CVs and open learning resources — in the same way as people blog or create podcasts — we could see and verify that the person is making some progress according to her own criteria, ambitions and pace.</p><p>This would be a way to create and redistribute <em>intellectual capital</em> and support cultural development. And also a way how to incentivize people to stay in second-tier towns and villages — to ease the bottleneck of overcrowded cities where too much competition occurs and creates both hedonistic treadmills (keeping up with Joneses) and burnout through overworking.</p><p>The idea is similar to social scholarships for highschool and university students but would facilitate life-long learning and make the learning visible and automatically certifiable (e.g. on a blockchain). The Universal Scholarship would also promote cooperation of teams and pursuit of common projects and participation in competitions.</p><h4><strong>Universal Scholarship and equity crowdfunding</strong></h4><p>The above mentioned idea of Universal Scholarship would decrease the waste of grant-writing and reporting for scientists and would turn students on all levels and adults outside universities or academia into popular scientists, engineers, hobbyists, craftsmen and peer-to-peer teachers. So the amount of Universal Scholarship could received monthly could depend on some transparent milestones and accomplishments.</p><p>Current university systems are mostly about signaling that one belongs to current elite, and offer net-positive opportunities only to a very limited number of people who attend elite universities each year. This is very inefficient way of selecting the future elites and becomes even less relevant in the looming future of algorithmic governance, where bots might become lawyers and bosses for an increasing number of people.</p><p>The second aspect of Universal Scholarship might be an opportunity to later turn a large number of learning projects into commercial spinoffs and raise equity through crowdfunding. This would provide additional income to founders but also return funds to the providers of Universal Scholarship.</p><p>Equity financing has a positive asymmetry for the entrepreneurs vis-à-vis financiers who bear higher risk. But again in the paradigm of learning and win-win mindset (collective exploration of the possibility space), both financing entities and entrepreneurs might prosper if there is a shift towards equity financing (because it is antifragile if distributed to as many entrepreneurs as reasonable) and away from debt financing (because it is more fragile — upside is limited but downside can be substantial in cases of default).</p><p>This is just a speculative discussion about Universal Scholarship as a preliminary idea about alternative to UBI that would shift paradigm from redistribution and zero-sum thinking towards collaboration based on mutual learning assisted by AI, providing incentives and coordination around desired future goals (e.g. via something like XPrize competitions).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eee59d3773bc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/universal-scholarship-as-an-alternative-to-ubi-eee59d3773bc">Universal Scholarship as an alternative to UBI</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[10x Core Concepts: 4. Garden versus Machine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-4-garden-versus-machine-c743da0ea5ec?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c743da0ea5ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[seymour-papert]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reza-negarestani]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eric-liu]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Mar 2018 18:03:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:17:00.392Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/485/1*Tkbe56t0y1gX-1XOZ2bfAw.png" /><figcaption>A computational universe — the patterns on a shell seem to resemble a cellular automaton like Rule 30</figcaption></figure><p><em>Society is more like a garden and less like a machine.</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2F10x-core-concepts-4-garden-versus-machine-c743da0ea5ec&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2Fc743da0ea5ec&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/45a82cd5a770ca6d4ec57a2c7e8e475e/href">https://medium.com/media/45a82cd5a770ca6d4ec57a2c7e8e475e/href</a></iframe><p><em>If you are lost on a desert and dying of thirst the first glass of water will save your life. But the fifth glass of water gives you less pleasure, and the tenth glass of water might make you sick.</em></p><p>[<a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-3-fragility-robustness-antifragility-81dc1468a30">Previous article: 10x Core Concepts: 3. Fragility — Robustness — Antifragility</a>]</p><p>Machine “doesn’t care” if you pour into it one liter, ten liters or 100 liters of fuel at once. But garden flowers do care if you pour too little or too much water at once. Or if you don’t water them regularly. You cannot water a garden by pouring their monthly water need at once and then leave for a month. You cannot make the trees to grow faster. Nine pregnant women don’t reduce the time for a baby to be born into just one month.</p><p>Society needs more people who “know a good measure” like gardeners, and less people who over-rely on mechanical and linear thinking. The quantity is not the only thing that matters. Focus on finding a good measure and good balance.</p><p>The idea of complex garden versus linear machine comes from the book by Eric Liu and Nick Hanauer called The Gardens of Democracy.</p><h4><strong>Biology, humans and human societies are complex systems</strong></h4><p>As we said in the beginning a garden is very different from a machine. If you pour 6 or 60 liters of fuel into a machine it doesn’t matter. But if you pour 6 or 60 liters of water in your garden it might have very different effects. Too little water and your plants might die. Too much water and your plants might die as well. The balance, good measure and right timing is crucial. This is how complex systems behave.</p><p>If you have only one type of plants in your garden you might be more fragile than if you have 10 types of plants in your garden. A disease might attack one type but leave others intact. This is the main point of the previous article about antifragility.</p><p>The same applies to the number of transferable skills, personal traits and the number of your connections or customers. A good measure is important. You grow too quickly and you might fail because you underestimate the importance of the development and quality management. You grow too slow and you might fall behind the competition.</p><p>Many things in life and in the society are more like a garden, and less like a machine. If you are too extreme or too specialized in one area, you might not see the bigger picture or might miss a chance to positively influence the world. It is like pouring too much water on your plants at once.</p><p>If you bother people with your ideas or products too much they might switch off and disregard what you are saying. Moderation and good timing are the key.</p><h4><strong>Learning and unlearning</strong></h4><p>We discussed previously how to balance growth and development — the quantity and quality or depth. And we saw an example of cauliflower that looks like composed of ever smaller cauliflower — this self-similar objects are called fractals. In the same way we need “to water our plants constantly” — don’t get stuck in one narrow skill or subject of study, but regularly relearn and unlearn many transferable skills — these are the skills that can be used in many areas and practical life. As I write these pages I feel that my typing skills — how to touch-type without looking at the keyboard are deteriorating. I might need to invest a couple of painful hours to learn again, to correct my mistakes and to get, metaphorically, from a current sub-peak on a learning terrain (an adaptive landscape idea from biology) — or local optimum where I feel comfortable writing — into a higher peak — a more optimal, quicker way of touch-typing with a fewer mistakes.</p><p>The idea of relearning is very strong and it is called spaced repetition — our learnt knowledge has a half-life of one sleep. So if you learn something the next day you remember only half of what you knew, and the next day only half of that half. So of course if you have a good short-term memory you can cram before the exams and pass them — but you will forget most of what you learnt quickly. So we discussed the need for a growth mindset — that means focusing on the process and not the result — being motivated to learn new things not because of grades and external pressures — but because we have passion to learn new things — because they help us to become better people, and better citizens and more productive at meaningful things we plan to do in our lives.</p><p>Besides the need spaced repetition — relearning the topic or skill after a few days — we also need to feel a bit of a pain and stress when we learn. We discussed this while describing antifragility — lifting weights is a bit painful — but if we are careful not to damage our muscles and overdo the exercise — the pain and stressors make our muscles grow and become stronger. The same counts for “brain muscles” — we need to exercise them regularly and effectively by a technique that is called active recall. It means that instead of rereading the topic over and over — just don’t look at the text and try to recall it from your memory. If you fail to do it — practice again and again. This is more painful and costs us more energy — but ultimately it is more effective.</p><h4><strong>Living on the edge</strong></h4><p>Imagine you happen to be lost in the desert and wandering around under a violent sun with your lips being dry and the wind blows the sand to your eyes and hurts them. The sweat hurt them too. You are completely thirsty and you feel that you started to hallucinate — you seem to see a blurry contours of an oasis.</p><p>As you come closer and closer you are ever more joyful — this is not a mirage — this is real! And it has a well with flowing water. You take your palm and get some water and start to drink it hastily — the first minute of drinking feels like heaven. But then the pleasure decreases. And after five minutes you even feel a bit too full and start getting sick.</p><p>This is the same principle we saw with flowers in the garden — the first cup might feel amazing, the second less so and the fifth might give you a stomachache. Economists call this decreasing marginal utility. Decreasing means that with every other cup you feel less and less pleasure. Marginal means additional — the next cup, or the additional cup is marginal cup. Imagine you have a small pool of water and you pour another cup into it and the pool gets bigger — its margins expand. Utility is what economists and philosophers call usefulness — something that gives us pleasure or helps us to achieve our goals and the things that we care about.</p><p>So the additional cup we drink has a decreasing marginal utility. And after maybe a 5th cup one can start to get sick — it means that now the utility is negative — it starts to hurt us instead of giving us pleasure.</p><p>Let’s get back to our garden example. Maybe you forgot to water plants in some area for a few days and they were neglected and seem to be a bit weak, even dying. You need to take care of them as a priority — but not overdo it with water — as the shock of too much water can kill them. I once did it with my cactus that colleague gave me. It was a small green cactus siting on my desk. I neglected it for long and forgot to water it. Once I realized it and rushed to pour water on it. But I poured too much water. I only realized it after a while — when the cactus broke into two!</p><p>So this is an important realization — prioritize those plans that are <em>neglected</em>! But don’t go into extremes and overdo it with watering — they are not machines — they cannot process the additional water with ever faster speed!</p><p>We can speculate that something similar happens to poor people when they win a lottery and get the big pile of money all at once — they don’t know what to do with it and take care of it properly — and it might turn to be a curse. Then we read stories how someone who won a million is broke and bankrupt after two years again. But this doesn’t happen as often when people get those people get their winning money over a long time — in monthly installments.</p><p>We could also say that prioritize not just the plants and flowers that are <em>important</em> but also those that are more important — that give you higher utility. Maybe those that fetch a higher price on the market or those that have higher chance of withstanding the dry periods. Also remember the idea of antifragility — having a variety, a quantity of many different plants, skills, contacts and projects.</p><p>Also grow plants that match your current ability. I wrote above, that I failed at taking care of cactus properly — maybe I am <em>not yet</em> (remember growth mindset and the power of Not Yet) qualified to take care of some very delicate flowers that require much more experience. So I need to progress in steps and learn actively how to take on more and more challenges. This means, focus on things that seem to be solvable and you can prove somehow that they are solvable by doing experiments. Again keeping a growth mindset — you can do it if you try — try again, fail again, fail better! Or as they say, fake it until you make it!</p><p>But it is important to go first after the things that are more <em>solvable</em> first! This is what we call go after the margins — and living on the edge! Taking new challenges — going through sometimes painful exercise to grow your mental muscles — but don’t overdo it, don’t start with too difficult things and don’t do everything at once — without repetition. Also don’t do something that feels comfortable — like rereading — instead do something that is more painful — like learning through active recall of what you read.</p><p>………………………………………………………………………………………</p><h4><strong>Notes on the Garden versus Machine</strong></h4><p>Nassim Taleb has also a similar metaphor of the difference between cat and a washing machine. But the metaphor of garden by authors Eric Liu and Nick Hanauer — and their description of the difference between “machinebrain and gardenbrain” mindset I find more appropriate.</p><p>I wrote a separate article called Living on the edge that explains the concept of marginal utility and connects it to the effective altruism that I will explain as the 8th concept. But we can use the metaphor of a small pool of water and four directions instead of North, East, South and West. So imagine these directions or four criteria are Importance, Tractability (another word for solvability), Neglectedness and Personal Fit. The idea is to balance all four and let our plants (our projects) grow in all four of these dimensions. So how to select the plants to grow — or the projects to engage in? Consider all of these four criteria — what problems are most important, solvable, neglected and they represent the biggest fit? Rate them from e.g. 1 to 10, when one is small like a dust speck and the ten is big as a meteorite. Or if these are too big — think of a mouse and an elephant. In the article about effective altruism I came up with every animal in-between a mouse and an elephant.</p><p>Think about the difference between 3 and 4 as in orders of magnitude, like the Richer scale does for measuring the earthquakes. So 3 is e.g. like 100 and 4 is like 1000.</p><p>Also a side note — a mouse is much less effective than an elephant but much more antifragile than an elephant! A mouse needs to sleep long hours, an elephant sleeps four hours and can consume tons, but its legs are very fragile. If an elephants leg gets broken, it will die. There are also not that many elephants left on the planet. But the same cannot at all be said about mice.</p><p>I read Antifragile by Taleb and he gives a lot of often funny examples about the difference between humans and machines — and how an average temperature doesn’t give us much information if we don’t know the variation — if we stay in “an average 25 degree Celsius temperature” for four hours, but the first 2 hours it was 100 degrees and the next two hours it was minus 50 degrees Celsius we will be for sure dead.</p><p>But I would need a lots of technical complexity science literature to get deeper to the topic. Recently a philosopher Reza Negarestani wrote what seems to be a good <a href="https://toyphilosophy.com/2018/02/09/complexity-collection/">overview</a> on complexity science literature that he uses in his project of <a href="https://toyphilosophy.com/">Toy Philosophy</a> — to build a toy universe from bottom up using models like Lego bricks in a mindset of an engineer rather than a philosopher. I have to note that I am nowhere near the sophistication and understanding of majority of these models that Reza Nagarestani uses — but my goal is to simplify 100+ models and select ten most useful models for high school kids to learn how to learn quicker and get more and more models like a snowball rolling down and getting bigger. So my challenge is to introduce readers from a bird-eye point of view to 10x Core Concepts, while at the same time not being too simplistic, but use practical and easy examples.</p><h4><strong>Reconciling Gardens with Machines</strong></h4><p>Of course if we over speed and don’t shift gears we can break a car. Machines are also sensitive. But they seem to be built for a single purpose. Hardware seems to be quite different from wetware (our brains). But then there are ideas like Society of Mind by Minsky and Papert that focus on many different agents that seem to occupy our minds. Like hundreds of little machines that do their work and coordinate each other.</p><p>Cognitive science and also physics increasingly use the paradigm of computation in their fields along with many concepts from computer science. Then they arrive at the metaphor of computational brain or computational universe.</p><p>It is important to say that also earlier and ancient discoveries of e.g. hydraulics lead to similar metaphors used to explain processes in our bodies.</p><p>Nevertheless, books like The New Kind of Science by Stephen Wolfram show how very complex behaviors can arise from very simple rules and cellular automata.</p><p>Also fractals seem to be present everywhere in nature, including human biology.</p><p>Seymour Papert who co-authored the book Society of Mind with Marvin Minsky is also a pioneer of constructivism in education — of learning by doing and discovering big ideas of how the world works. Papert wrote a book called Mindstorms where he explains his constructivists ideas and e.g. the importance of debugging — of learning through mistakes and being able to correct them. The Lego company called their Lego robots set, Lego Mindstorms in tribute to Seymour Papert.</p><p>My cursory understanding of what Reza Negarestani is doing now with his Toy Philosophy for philosophy is something similar to what Papert tried to do in education — building it brick by brick. Now Negarestani uses legos instead of logos — mental models to construct toy universes.</p><p>My cursory understanding of books like Society of Mind is that they show how conscience comes into being by a work of hundreds of separate agents that are themselves without conscience — like some machines doing their jobs — and in the process they create conscience through emergence.</p><p>Eliezer Yudkowsky in his tome Rationality from AI to Zombies warned against overusing the concept of emergence as a vehicle to describe a process or a phenomenon, we don’t currently understand.</p><p>But we can look at emergence as a certain tipping point — once a certain threshold is reached, there is a change in quality, patterns emerge suddenly and they seem to make sense to us.</p><p>Think of Conway’s Game of Life — a cellular automaton and “a zero player game” that shows interesting patterns between order and chaos and is similar to Stephen’s Wolfram Rule 110. Both are Turing complete and A Game of Life foreshadowed the later computer exploration of fractals. In both cases very interesting patterns emerge from very simple set of rules.</p><p>In this Notes section I wanted to outline the sources of my thinking and also gaps in my understanding and things that need further exploration.</p><p>Gardens are a metaphor from agricultural revolution and machines are a metaphor from industrial revolution. In the post-industrial era we need to prioritize again the metaphor of gardens — to understand and simplify complexity and understand that taking good measure and good timing are important when dealing with biology, humans and our society. Again fractals, or self-similar objects are a good candidate for such simplification. Also the concept of antifragility shows us that, as Taleb says: Living creatures crave volatility (change) but can break if volatility and stress is too high.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c743da0ea5ec" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-4-garden-versus-machine-c743da0ea5ec">10x Core Concepts: 4. Garden versus Machine</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[10x Core Concepts: 3. Fragility — Robustness — Antifragility]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-3-fragility-robustness-antifragility-81dc1468a30?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81dc1468a30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[antifragility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nassim-taleb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fractals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peter-thiel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zero-to-one]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Mar 2018 10:01:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:17:34.943Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2F10x-core-concepts-3-fragility-robustness-antifragility-81dc1468a30&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2F81dc1468a30&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f22e4632a1f8155b01f2d564d4abfa57/href">https://medium.com/media/f22e4632a1f8155b01f2d564d4abfa57/href</a></iframe><p><em>Avoid the messy middle. Separate work from fun. Embrace the volatility by having many many skills, friends, hobbies, customers, projects. Avoid the boring routine. Eat vegetarian for a day, skip lunch, introduce new positive habits and reduce the bad habits.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/956/1*6SMaoolEB9aj7Dn0V5KxOw.png" /><figcaption>Antifragility or optionality strategy is to avoid the messy middle and split investments like two barbells of very unequal size: 90–99% of investment into very safe instruments, like cash equivalents, and 1–10% very risky investments, but with a big potential upside. (Photo source: <a href="http://complementarytraining.net/talent-id-is-bullshit/">complementarytraining.net</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>[Previous article: 10x Core Concepts: Growth mindset versus fixed mindset]</p><p>A growth mindset empowers us to be less fragile by taking on challenges and learning new things. If we have growth mindset we understand “the power of not yet” and know that the pain and frustration, we experience when we learn new things will gradually wear off, and we will become much faster and stronger in these new skills we painfully develop. But we need to understand the distinction between fragility, robustness and antifragility.</p><p>Probably you saw packages with label “Fragile! Handle with care!”. Imagine if you saw a package with a label “Antifragile, please mishandle.” Antifragility is a concept developed by Nassim Taleb and can be best illustrated with physical exercise such as weight lifting. If you apply reasonable stress to your muscles by exercising they become gradually stronger and bigger. If you don’t exercise or don’t move your muscles they become weaker and more fragile. So the stressors help us become stronger.</p><p>Antifragility is different from a mere robustness and is the real opposite of fragility. Robustness is merely in the middle of a scale from fragility to antifragility. Antifragility can prosper during volatile periods, robustness can merely withstand misfortune or volatility.</p><p>Imagine a writer who gets bad reviews, but people discuss his work and thus becomes more famous. He is under the stress of criticism and needs to endure it. But this negativity if it is not too strong and fatal, actually helps to spread the word about her book and makes her famous.</p><h4><strong>Taxi driver and a bank clerk</strong></h4><p><em>To repeat the main points: Nassim Taleb introduced the spectrum of fragility-robustness-antifragility. Antifragility is like weightlifting — your muscles grow under reasonable stress. If you avoid exercise and exposure to stressors, you become weak and fragile. But if you put too much stress you can damage your muscles. Moderation is the key. But don’t avoid the pressure, difficulty and stressful situations. Embrace the volatility in life.</em></p><p>We have already illustrated the point with a writer that gets under the stress for bad reviews but emerges stronger and more famous, because more people learn about his book as a result of the criticism.</p><p>But let’s take two quite different professions — taxi driver and a bank clerk. If you are employed as a bank clerk your monthly income is stable. You might get an annual bonus and your boss might review your income and raise it a bit every year. But if you work as a taxi driver, your income is much more volatile. The word volatile means there are much bigger differences in what you earn each day. One day you can earn twice or even four times as much as the previous day. But it also means that the day after you might earn again half of what you have earned today. This almost never happens to the bank clerk — he earns every month more or less the same. Maybe if he falls ill for a longer period his income might decrease a bit if the medical insurance doesn’t cover the whole salary.</p><p>But interestingly — a taxi driver is more antifragile, because he has many sources of income and not just one single employer. This is very important to understand because it is a general point — if a company has many customers and many projects it is less fragile than a company that has only one main customer. Imagine two design studious — one works for local small businesses and often the income is volatile — some months are hard, some people are late with payments, some month the company sees the number of jobs drop by half. The second design studio has a stable income and a much higher income than the first studio — but the big studio has one main customer a local bank. And this bank contributes a staggering 90% share to the monthly income of the company. The rest is made up by some small adhoc works for two other regular clients. Now you can see that if the big bank for some reason stops to cooperate with the design studio, they might collapse — because 90% of their income will be gone from one month to another.</p><p><strong>So the moral of the story from the viewpoint of antifragility is:</strong></p><ul><li>Limit the potential losses by not over-relying on a few big customers, and expand your possibilities by having the foot in the door of many projects.</li><li>Don’t be a turkey that doesn’t realize the possibility of the Thanksgiving day.</li><li>Always keep thinking about the unthinkable — what extreme event could happen and how you can protect yourself or use it as opportunity.</li></ul><h4>Antifragility in investing</h4><p>Nassim Taleb gives examples of what he call the optionality strategy or the barbell strategy:</p><p>Invest 90% of your assets in an extra safe instruments and 10% in extra risky enterprises. This is the barbell strategy — as those investments are separated into two barbells of very unequal size.</p><p>When investing into risky enterprises (the much smaller barbell) separate the risk <strong>by investing into as many experienced teams as possible and still reasonable</strong>.</p><p>So use what he calls the “1/N strategy”, also called optionality strategy. Limit your losses by spreading investment into as many high-potential projects as possible and still reasonable. But don’t limit your payoff option. Leave the option of a big payoff — by e.g. investing into equity and not debt. This is what Teleb calls positive asymmetry.</p><p>This is optionality and antifragility. Some instruments introduce positive asymmetry, like equity investments. Some introduce negative asymmetry like debt.</p><p>This is the optionality strategy or barbell strategy proposed by Nassim Taleb, the author of the books Antifragile, Black Swan and A Skin in the Game — like a barbell with one big weight representing investment in extra safe things and one small weight representing the investment into many and diversified small things.</p><p>……………………………………………………………………………….</p><h4><strong>Notes: Antifragility in innovation and revolutionizing systems</strong></h4><p>Use the strategy of <em>“picking the low-hanging fruits first”</em> for optimizing and reforming the current system.</p><p>But if you want to invest into “systems change” and revolutionizing the system, use the “1/N” or “hit-based” strategy of funding as many lean, local and small projects as possible.</p><p>This way you limit the risk of failure and increase the chance of success. Extreme events are rare. Maybe one in 100 projects will have an extremely positive outcome and an extreme payoff. Extreme events are impactful, but very rare. So you need to explore the possibility space well enough.</p><h4><strong>Reconciling technocrats with revolutionaries</strong></h4><p>For the best results you can use these two strategies at once, but keep them separate to avoid the messy middle of complexity. Like a barbell mentioned above. Invest 90% in optimizing the system and 10% in revolutionizing the system. But do it far away and on a separate location to avoid the refusal of the innovation by the immunity system of the establishment in your team, organization or country.</p><p>Imagine a landscape with two peaks — the metaphor from the first article — Growth versus Development. One is lower and one is higher. The <em>low-hanging-fruit- first</em> strategy will allow you to only reach to the local peak, that represents the local optimum.</p><p>But this is sub-optimal from global perspective of the whole landscape — because there is a higher peek — but you would need to go down the “valley of tears” first to reach it.</p><p>But if you combine <em>low-hanging-fruit-first</em> strategy with the <em>hit-based</em> strategy that — Taleb calls <em>optionality</em> or <em>antifragility</em> strategy — you let only small teams of creative freaks experience failures and a valley of tears in a separate location, while you optimize the rest of the organization and its cash cow.</p><p>Again we can see a certain parallel of two components that might look like they are in the conflict but resemble similar conflicts from previous articles — Growth versus Development and Growth Mindset versus Fixed Mindset.</p><p>At the end of this article we use the concept of antifragility and its practical application in hit-based strategy of investing into projects (what e.g. venture capital does) to show that it can be recombined with a conservative and a more technocratic approach of optimizing the current system by pursuing the <em>low-hanging-fruit-first</em> strategy.</p><p>There is a long standing debate and conflict between the reformers and the revolutionaries — the reformers are optimizing and <em>picking the low hanging fruit first</em> and the revolutionaries want <em>a systems change</em> — a complete overhaul of the old ways of doing things.</p><p>So the main question I am trying to answer here — is there a real conflict between reformers (those who optimize towards the current local optimum) and people who desire a more profound “systemic change”?</p><p>If we use the concept of antifragility and the practical application of the optionality strategy — we see that we can resolve this conflict with simple heuristics —the metaphor of a barbell with very unequal weights— invest 90% into something very safe (low hanging fruit picking — small reforms and nudges) and 10% into something very risky (but do it in a small region, remote location, and on periphery away from the center of the organization).</p><p>Because, for example Leery Keeley in his book 10 Types of Innovations or Salim Ismail in his book Exponential Organizations say that you might want to have innovative teams on the periphery — outside of the big organization not to cause the autoimmune reaction that might destroy the radical innovation in its beginnings.</p><h4><strong>Reconciling Zero to One with Antifragility</strong></h4><p>If you read the Zero to One book by Peter Thiel you can spot that he is very contrarian and counterintuitive — for example he says that competition is for losers and praises the monopolistic power. He says the monopolistic power can be achieved only through radically better technology. And technology is opposed to globalization. Because this technology represents a vertical improvement — zero to one — but globalization is optimizing around the current technology and breeds unhealthy race to the bottom competition and resentments — in zero to many (copycats, outsourcing where labor is cheaper).</p><p>Peter Thiel also gives practically the opposing advice to Nassim Taleb on investing not into as many projects — but focusing on only the one crazy idea that seems to be off and under-performing but thanks to exponential growth it will conquer the world. (Think small digital fabrication factories versus big just in time factories. This Local Motors versus General Motors).</p><p>But if we are familiar with the concept of fractals (self-similar objects on ever smaller level — parts of cauliflower that looks like the whole cauliflower) we can again resolve this problem easily: Use the fractal barbell strategy — if you are a super rich investor invest 100 millions like this: 90 millions into some cash-like equivalents (e.g. US Treasuries) and 10 million into venture capital. From that 10 million into VC, use again 9 million into your very crazy idea <strong>that you are so sure and convinced about</strong> — and that is currently being tried by e.g. only 3 startups in the world. So give those 3 startups 3 millions each, and the rest — one million go for the 1/N strategy — as many startups as possible to get the optionality — limiting the downside and maximizing the upside.</p><p>You can see that the fractality can go on still a few levels — e.g. investing 900,000 like 30x 30,000 seed funding money into 30 projects and keeping the last 100k for a student competition and supporting 1000 best projects with 100 euro each.</p><p>Well you can again see that I am in a speculative stage and try to connect these seemingly opposing strategies of Thiel and Taleb — and I am using a notion of fractality to achieve that.</p><p>We can see that something similar we can do also in the debate between the <em>low-hanging fruit-first</em> nudging technocrats versus the more revolutionary “we need systems change” types.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81dc1468a30" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-3-fragility-robustness-antifragility-81dc1468a30">10x Core Concepts: 3. Fragility — Robustness — Antifragility</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[10x Core Concepts: 2. Growth Mindset versus Fixed Mindset]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-2-growth-mindset-versus-fixed-mindset-a23e3b2536fb?source=rss----febce667623d---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a23e3b2536fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[exponential-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jean-pierre-dupuy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[globalization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth-mindset]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Feb 2018 10:08:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-24T14:17:55.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*0PtfaYmxPkVbwwybuA2fQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Students in Sote ICT Club at Kajire Girls secondary school. (Author: Jakub Simek, 2014)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Reward the process, not the outcome. Praise hard work, not talent.<br>You can do anything if you keep working hard enough through small steps.<br>Immerse into the new topic, practice active recall and spaced repetition.</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Fembed%2F%3Farticle_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fmedium.com%2F_p%2F10x-core-concepts-2-growth-mindset-versus-fixed-mindset-a23e3b2536fb&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fplay.ht%2Farticles%2Fa23e3b2536fb&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2F0%2ALIIx-_lV_6rbJPU4.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=play" width="700" height="185" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3df6155508ce45ee2e9ca8f97e2b50c5/href">https://medium.com/media/3df6155508ce45ee2e9ca8f97e2b50c5/href</a></iframe><p>[Previous<a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-1-growth-versus-development-e56f0ec6457f"> article</a>: 10x Core Concepts: 1. Growth versus Development]</p><p>A growth mindset is probably the most important ingredient in the ability “to learn how to learn” and thus propel personal development and withstand failure. This probably means it is key to decreasing current social inequalities.</p><p>Our biggest obstacle is the lack of imagination. Growth mindset is the power of “not yet” against the “tyranny of now”. Developed by the psychologist Carol Dweck, growth mindset creates a “victorious circle”- and a positive feedback loop of curiosity, hard work and growing confidence in personal abilities.</p><p>The opposite to it is a fixed mindset when children and adults don’t even try to solve challenges that lie in from of them. Maybe they believe they will never understand math. So they cheat at exams instead of working hard. This creates a “vicious circle” of envy, corruption of standards and a feelings of failure.</p><p>A person with a growth mindset understands that they are not there yet, but if they try and invest for example 2 hours to understand the problem and 20 hours to solve the problem they can do it.</p><p>People who want to encourage growth mindset should praise the <em>process</em> and not the <em>results</em>. They should not praise children that they are super talented in something, rather they should praise their current level of effort, or tell them they need to work harder next time.</p><h4><strong>Overcome the pain and fear of learning new things with a growth mindset</strong></h4><p>Change your mindset from the fearful and fixed mindset that never tries because things seem hard, into a growth mindset that is fine with not knowing things yet, but is willing to invest a minute, 12 minutes and then 25 minutes, 2 hours and 20 hours in effective and focused learning and slowly gaining a new skill.</p><p>It might be painful and frustrating. But also exercising is painful and frustrating. But we feel good afterwards and are proud of ourselves. And we gain strength and speed — something that used to take us 2 hours or even two days at first, we can suddenly do in 20 minutes.</p><p>The author of the concept and researcher in motivation, a psychologist Carol Dweck says embrace the “Power of Yet” and escape the “Tyranny of Now”.</p><p>The growth mindset is crucial in “learning to learn skills” and in fighting the corruption in public sphere, or in private and professional life.</p><p>And specifically it can reduce cheating in schools. Because process (how one gets there) becomes more important than goal itself (what results one achieves). And we can learn from failure, if we fail quickly, if we fail often, and not too drastically.</p><p>Because people with growth mindset are comfortable with “not yet”, there are fine with admitting failure and don’t focus only on signaling their competence. They are not interested in knowledge and people only for instrumental reasons (as means to achieve goals), but also for their intrinsic (internal) value. They want to learn or play according to the rules with a fair play as a goal in itself.</p><p>Sometimes it is painful to learn new skills because we underestimate the initial difficulty and slowness of picking up a new skill. But then we also underestimate the increasing pace of progress we make. Something that took us week, we can now do in one day and then in two hours. This is called exponential growth and we will discuss it in a separate chapter — Exponential Growth versus Linear growth.</p><h4><strong>Reconciling Growth Mindset with Fixed Mindset</strong></h4><p>But are a growth mindset and a fixed mindset totally opposed to each other? Can they be complementary in some ways?</p><p>It is important to note that fixed mindset is connected to our identity, to who we are and how we do things. We don’t want to constantly change and reinvent ourselves and we don’t want to lose the core substance of who we are. As children we maybe liked to hang out with people who seemed cool and at the same time hated math or science.</p><p>Maybe we are adults now and like social sciences, philosophy and literature and consider people who preach natural sciences as shallow and narrow-minded. We might think they approach on our turf and see the world only through their models and data.</p><p>Or we might protest learning English as it is so different from our mother tongue and people who speak it seem to think and act a bit differently when they think in English.</p><p>We might feel that the world is losing its diversity when globalization makes all people speak the same and buy the same products. And maybe we find diversity, not only beautiful, but also important for progress and innovation.</p><p>People from the cities might look down at people in rural areas as stuck in their old ways and with a culture hostile to change. People in rural areas might look down at city folks as the ones who are selling their soul and culture for profit and have only shallow relationships in an ever faster era.</p><p>But we might see a similarity with the previous chapter on Growth versus Development. We tried to reconcile the seemingly irresolvable conflict between growth and development by finding the right moment when to switch from quantity into quality.</p><p>There the answer was to take a good measure and a balanced approach, we might call it a <em>fractal approach</em> — stop growing in one area and switch to another area. Stop growing in quantity and start growing in quality. Maybe, if you are a company owner and feel that your customer service is getting worse, stop hiring new employees for a time, and invest into the proper and thorough training of your current employees. But we saw that again we need a quantity of a focused time to achieve that quality of customer service.</p><p>Here growth mindset helps us to brace the richness of opportunities in the indefinite future. But we need to have a fixed plan and a fixed block of uninterrupted time to actually develop into a specific and definite future direction. We need a fixed future point that we are moving into. We need to set a vivid picture of our future self and what do we want to achieve with some specific deadline.</p><p>So you actually have to block off a certain time and have a<em> fixed</em> period where you do only this one task with full focus. You have to block off other distractions and interests to just focus on learning that one particular skill.</p><p>You can use for example the Pomodoro technique — google for an online pomodoro app and set up a timer for 25 minutes of uninterrupted focus on just one task. Then take a 5-minute break and continue another with another pomodoro, another 25 minutes. After four pomodoros, or 2 hours take a longer break, 14 minutes. This is much more productive and effective than multitasking and constant switching between emails, phone, social media and discussions.</p><h4><strong>Moving with a growth mindset towards a fixed and definite future</strong></h4><p>Previously we discussed that if we grow too much or too quickly in one area we might become fragile and fail. We need a balanced growth and development in many areas.</p><p>The same can be said about the relationship between a growth mindset, that sees endless new possibilities and things to learn everywhere, and a fixed mindset that keeps our core identity and who we are fixed.</p><p>Maybe as a child you set a goal to become a famous writer. Now this is your very fixed and definite future. You want to become a famous writer. But over the years you can use a growth mindset and constantly adjust your strategy to get to your desired goal.</p><p>Maybe at first you thought that you need to be a full-time writer and earn a living by writing books. But then you learn that many famous writers had a rather dull day jobs, some of them were accountants and bank clerks. For example Franz Kafka was an insurance officer.</p><p>So maybe this job security eased their stress and pressure to succeed in writing and allowed them to be more creative. Maybe your growth mindset guides you to completely new territories — instead of poetry you end up writing non-fiction about some breakthroughs in computer science.</p><p>But if you don’t have a fixed future point — a fixed and definite future goal you will hardly make a radically better or different product and an innovation that can make a positive difference in the world. You might end up going with the flow, constantly experimenting, competing and randomly soaking in new information.</p><p>So again we see a similar pattern — the need for a balance between a growth mindset and a fixed mindset. And that both seem to have again something like fractal properties — like the cauliflower that seems to consist of yet smaller cauliflowers and they seem to consist of yet smaller cauliflavers…</p><p>You have to nurture a growth mindset to creatively solve challenges that come into your way and learn new skills, but you also have to have a fixed mindset —especially about creating a definite future vision where you build and bootstrap your future fixed identity — the person you want to become.</p><p>……………………………………………………………………………….</p><h4><strong>Notes on Growth Mindset versus Fixed Mindset</strong></h4><p>I need to stress that I have only a cursory understanding and knowledge about the research by Carol Dweck who coined this metaphor. But I have a strong intuition that this metaphor can be very useful and is connected to the concept of growth versus development that I described in the previous chapter.</p><p>I think that this is the same problem, but now more focused on the process and on timeline, and various future possibilities that constantly arise.</p><p>If we want to produce a radically better solution, maybe at least 10x improvement in speed, quality and price, we cannot rely on incremental progress. We need to fix our mind on something that might sound foolish and expensive and unrealistic at first. But thanks to exponential growth the originally exotic solution might totally crush the existing competition or consensus.</p><h4>Memetic competition, second order effects and reflexivity</h4><p>At least this is the insight of Peter Thiel that he described in his book Zero To One. He praises the monopolistic power of radically better technology and puts technology into opposition with globalization. Technology helps us to go “from zero to one”, globalization is a memetic competition “from zero to n” (many).</p><p>Memetic competition means people competing and catching up with their neighbors and childhood friends by e.g. also buying SUVs or bitcoins — because they see their friends or foes doing it.</p><p>Memetic competition, or FOMO (fear of missing out) is similar to the concept of reflexivity (there seems to be bipolar periods in the markets — cheerful rallies are followed by sad selloffs). But there is again a certain fractal property to this move — like a 3D printer head doing the same moves, but printing an ever larger object.</p><p>So the memetic competition creates second order effects that Ricardo didn’t understand when he thought about comparative economic advantages. What do second order effects mean? The first order effect is that by offshoring production to China, US companies can increase profits and decrease labor force and American consumers get to buy cheaper products. But the second order effects are that Chinese workers get richer and start also buying SUVs and thus make competition for resources bigger and increase global price of commodities like petrol fuel, also for the US drivers.</p><p>Growth mindset helps people to be positive about the future and try out learning more things and learn how to learn, how to fail, how to fail again and fail better. This positive attitude and partial successes motivate others and create a race to the top — people competing and focusing on process of self-improvement and a fair play- not just on achieving results. This partial successes and new skills compound and can lead to exponential growth. The rub or the flipside is that also failures and disappointments can compound and create an increasingly depressing results. This bipolar power laws — people wining or failing exponentially seem to be a deep root of inequality. Growth mindset can refocus people from envy and jealousy and resentment and act as a negative feedback loop — stopping people from ever falling and failing deeper.</p><h4>Growth mindset as a metaphor for bootstrapping the desired future</h4><p>Growth mindset seems to me like a very useful metaphor to describe the concept of <em>bootstrapping</em> that is paradoxical — as it creates something from nothing through self-transference. The French philosopher Jean-Pierre Dupuy writes extensively about bootstrapping the desired future (e.g. landing on Mars in 2040) or avoiding the undesired future (e.g. reducing climate change and avoiding the flooding of major cities by 2100).</p><p>The future in this case is fixed by a definite timeline and vision — for example by a moonshot — some brave goal like a woman landing on Mars in 2040. The time from 2040 until 2018 then becomes a projected time — time projected from the future and this fixed moonshot helps in coordintation of actions of masses of people that compete and cooperate the selected goal. We again see that growth mindset is the paradoxical belief that we can reach the unreachable star and the fixed mindset see our future identity as fixed and definite —for example a picture of a woman astronaut, originally coming from Kajire village in Kenya, and now setting her foot on a red dust of Mars on 1 May 2040.</p><p><strong>Growth mindset as means of “growing the pie” and fighting populism and extremism</strong></p><p>As I wrote in the beginning our biggest obstacle is the lack of imagination. We are historically used to linear growth and are not good enough at predicting exponential growth or exponential decline.</p><p>Populists and extremists focus in my opinion too much on unfair “division of the current existing pie” and underestimate both the possibility of rapid progress if things go well, and a rapid decline if things deteriorate.</p><p>The physical pie has some clear limits of growth. But the virtual pie in our shared imagination can grow indefinitely. This is both curse and a blessing. The saying goes that our needs are finite, but our desires infinite. It would help to channel those desires into creating innovative and radically better and sustainable technologies. And not into memetic competition and resentment.</p><p>So again we need a good balance between focusing on the fixed identities and grievances of today and a growth mindset that can see people living up to their potential and that can see the importance of fair play and the importance of focusing on process and not a result.</p><p>We can see that growth mindset is paradoxical — for example a village girl student from a school in Kenya believing that she is a future astronaut. Now, this paradox of <em>focusing on the process of future becoming</em> and not focusing on a current <em>result</em> of being someone or rather being-not-yet someone, is very similar to the Weberian paradox of Puritan ethics. J-P Dupuy sees this paradox as a key ingredient of capitalism — people coordinate their activities around anticipated future, and thus bootstrap this future through a projected time — time that is being projected from a fixed and definite future goal point.</p><p>Dupuy explains that Puritan paradox is the belief that one might be predestined to become chosen, but needs to deliberately work hard as if one is chosen.</p><p>He further explains that technically the Puritan paradox is equivalent to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox">Newcomb’s Paradox</a>:</p><blockquote>There is a predictor, a player, and two boxes designated A and B. The player is given a choice between taking only box B, or taking both boxes A and B. The player knows the following:<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox#cite_note-Wolpert-4">[4]</a></blockquote><blockquote>Box A is clear, and always contains a visible $1,000.</blockquote><blockquote>Box B is opaque, and its content has already been set by the predictor:</blockquote><blockquote>If the predictor has predicted the player will take both boxes A and B, then box B contains nothing.</blockquote><blockquote>If the predictor has predicted that the player will take only box B, then box B contains $1,000,000.</blockquote><p>So the question is if one shall choose only box B or both boxes. Most lay people when interviewed say that one shall take only the box B. Experts in economics say mostly that the dominant rational choice is to take both boxes — at least one ends up with the 1000 dollars and in case the predictor e.g. wasn’t 100% accurate one might end with also the opaque box full of money.</p><p>Now the metaphor of Growth mindset and Fixed mindset developed by Carol Dweck is clearly useful in solving this paradox — <em>focus on process and not on result</em>. Act as if you belonged to the group of “chosen people” who practice a strategy of being constant and focused on winning in the long-run.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-3-fragility-robustness-antifragility-81dc1468a30">Next article: 10x Core Concepts: 3. Fragility — Robustness — Antifragility</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a23e3b2536fb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/10x-core-concepts-2-growth-mindset-versus-fixed-mindset-a23e3b2536fb">10x Core Concepts: 2. Growth Mindset versus Fixed Mindset</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge">Giving On The Edge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>