<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[ClimateWire exposes the on-the-ground reality of developing countries challenged by a world that will require every nation to cut carbon emissions. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:33:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/greater-expectations" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Major oil-producing nations have not revealed their plans to reduce CO2 emissions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/major-oil-producing-nations-have-not-revealed-their-plans-to-reduce-co2-emissions-1b19dc05e8fe?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b19dc05e8fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cop21]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Oct 2015 15:20:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-22T15:20:27.828Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/618/1*xVvZGP5_Kzz3nNvfSt4isA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/snapr/540280595/">Flickr</a></figcaption></figure><p>by Lisa Friedman, <a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw">ClimateWire</a> — a publication of <a href="http://www.eenews.net/">E&amp;E Publishing</a></p><p>BONN, Germany — Kuwait, Malaysia and the United Arab Emirates are preparing to submit their climate change targets to the United Nations, negotiators from those countries told <em>ClimateWire</em>. They are among 41 nations that, for various reasons, have not offered plans for curbing greenhouse gas emissions as part of a new global agreement set for Paris in December.</p><p>Atif Al Harbi, who leads Kuwait’s delegation to the U.N. climate negotiations, said his country did not recognize an Oct. 1 submission deadline that, while informal, over 150 other countries adhered to. He noted that the precise language diplomats created two years ago merely “invites” countries to put forward their plans “well in advance” of the Paris conference.</p><p>“They didn’t say a date certain to submit,” Al Harbi said, adding he is “sticking to the wording” of U.N. texts. Nevertheless, he said of Kuwait’s target, “We are in the process to submit it.”</p><p>Malaysian negotiator Gurdial Singh Nijar said his country’s plan is “on the way” and “almost submitted.” A representative from the UAE said its target is “in its final approval stage.”</p><p>The great majority of countries have submitted “intended nationally determined contributions,” or INDCs, include the United States, Europe, China and India, as well a number of small and impoverished developing countries. In all, their plans cover 87 percent of global emissions.</p><p>Observers say some absent countries like Fiji or Syria may lack the capacity or government stability to put together a plan. But major oil producers and their allies — which also include Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Qatar, Iran and Angola — have been holdouts for more strategic reasons.</p><p>“They aren’t yet fully on board,” said Wael Hmaidan, who leads Climate Action Network International and has worked closely on climate policies in Arab Gulf countries. Nations in the region have all prepared their INDCs, he said, they just haven’t pulled the trigger on submitting.</p><p>“They’re trying to make a decision if they embrace a transformation or not. They understand the world is changing. They feel the pressure that they need to change as well. The final thing is that they need to embrace the change,” he said.</p><p>Countries had called for INDCs to be sent in by Oct. 1 so the United Nations could conduct a review of how far they collectively get toward keeping global temperatures at safe levels.</p><h3>Grumbling along the sidelines</h3><p>That report will be unveiled at the end of the month. Scientists, though, have already concluded the current plans won’t keep temperatures from rising above the 2-degrees-Celsius threshold. That will still hold true even if all of the 41 outstanding INDCs roll in, said Bill Hare, founder of Climate Analytics.</p><p>“It’s not fundamentally important. It won’t change the adequacy of the whole amount,” he said.</p><p>But Hare and others argued that having as many countries as possible — especially from among major oil producers — is politically and symbolically important.</p><p>“We need to have global participation,” said Alden Meyer, director of strategy and policy for the Union of Concerned Scientists.</p><p>“To have a number of countries sitting on the sidelines, particularly major Gulf countries … I think it’s a problem that some of the largest per-capita emitters, some of the wealthiest countries, have yet to put their targets on the table,” he said.</p><p>Negotiators said there has been some talk of only allowing countries that submit INDCs to become a party to a deal in Paris or of requiring an INDC before a country could access money from the Green Climate Fund. Such a restriction would not apply to least developed nations.</p><p>Still, several sources said, those discussions have not gone far. It may also be moot because widespread pressure has helped prod some recalcitrant countries to move.</p><h3>Playing games with numbers?</h3><p>Still, what those missing INDCs from Gulf nations will look like is also a key concern. Al Harbi said Kuwait will not have a quantitative emissions target and as a developing country should not be expected to. Instead Kuwait will detail projects it is launching “that have co-benefits” of curbing emissions and helping to diversify the economy.</p><p>Under the current rules of the U.N. climate regime, a handful of fully industrialized countries are expected to bear the largest weight of cutting emissions and helping developing countries.</p><p>Al Harbi said developed countries have not yet done enough. “Show us some leadership and we will follow,” he said. “They are playing games with numbers.”</p><p>He also pushed back on the widespread perception that the major oil producers have been obstructing climate negotiations. Kuwait, Al Harbi argued, is being hit from both sides. Its economy will suffer if countries truly make good on pledges to decarbonize, and the country also is vulnerable to desertification, rising sea levels and other consequences of climate change.</p><p>“We care about the climate change. Why do people think we are against it?” he asked. “By the way, for your information we are doing so many things that are nice for the environment, but we don’t make a big deal about it like you do in America.”</p><p>Malaysia’s Nijar also noted that his country’s pledge will be dependent upon “the means of support and enablement.” That is, money. “The more ambitious developed countries are, the more ambitious we can be,” he asserted.</p><p>A spokeswoman for the UAE declined to discuss the specifics of the country’s plan but said it will be filed early next week. She said the delay was only due to internal process approval delays.</p><p>Other countries that have not produced an INDC include Brunei, Egypt, Iraq, Libya, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Pakistan and Venezuela.</p><p>Hmaidan noted that when Qatar hosted U.N. climate talks in 2012, it along with Saudi Arabia, UAE and Bahrain made a major announcement that they would develop climate pledges. So far, none has materialized.</p><p>“This is the their last chance,” he said.</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060026744">NEGOTIATIONS: Major oil-producing nations have not revealed their plans to reduce CO2 emissions</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b19dc05e8fe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/major-oil-producing-nations-have-not-revealed-their-plans-to-reduce-co2-emissions-1b19dc05e8fe">Major oil-producing nations have not revealed their plans to reduce CO2 emissions</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Activists say solar can power India, but politics and economics of coal win out]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/activists-say-solar-can-power-india-but-politics-and-economics-of-coal-win-out-526c2ef6489f?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/526c2ef6489f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2015 15:05:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-19T15:06:24.801Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xSr_DZV1xxEuD2BKD-CRJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan</figcaption></figure><p><em>by </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/staff/Gayathri_Vaidyanathan"><em>Gayathri Vaidyanathan</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw"><em>ClimateWire</em></a><em> — a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations/stories/1060026477"><em>Part 2</em></a><em> of 2 stories on India. See Part 1 </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/climatewire/stories/1060026415"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>DHARNAI, India — One year ago, environmentalists hailed this tiny village as the future of clean energy in rural India. Today, it is powered by coal.</p><p>Dharnai, a community of about 3,200 people in eastern India’s Bihar state, had been without electricity for three decades. So when activists with Greenpeace set up a solar-powered microgrid in July of 2014, the excitement was palpable. But, residents said, the problems started almost immediately.</p><blockquote>When the former chief minister of Bihar state visited to inaugurate the grid, villagers lined up to protest, chanting, “We want real electricity, not fake electricity!”</blockquote><p>By “real,” they meant power from the central grid, generated mostly using coal. By “fake,” they meant solar.</p><p>Analysts say the story of Dharnai illustrates how difficult it can be to provide reliable, high-quality electricity to the world’s poor without using the central grid. The challenge is coming into focus as Prime Minister Narendra Modi moves forward on an ambitious pledge to generate 175 gigawatts from utility-scale solar and wind energy by 2022 and increase coal-powered generation. Much of that power would go into the central grid, rather than being disseminated through small, decentralized energy systems.</p><p>Vijay Kumar Das, a line engineer with Dharnai’s electricity committee, compared the village’s solar microgrid experiment to polluted groundwater.</p><p>“If you don’t find bottled water to drink, you have to settle for water from the hand pump,” he said. “Similarly, when we did not have real electricity, we had to make do with solar power.”</p><h3>Trying to prove a solar point</h3><p>Dharnai is in the heartland of a guerilla communist movement called Naxalism. Perhaps because of this political alliance, the community never regained the electrical supply it lost in 1981. Over the years, the community adapted.</p><p>The rich set up rooftop solar panels that supplied a single light bulb or ceiling fan. Poorer people used kerosene lamps. In 2010, the villagers pooled 45,000 rupees ($680) and asked the local electricity board for a connection, but they never got it.</p><p>A chance encounter last year between the village chief and a Greenpeace activist on a train brought the group to Dharnai. Greenpeace wanted to set up a solar village to show the government that it is possible to power rural communities with renewable energy.</p><p>The project was important to Greenpeace’s ambition. The group wants India to stop all new coal mining and coal-fired power plants because the resulting carbon emissions would contribute to climate change. The hitch is that about 400 million Indians, mostly in rural Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, remain without power. This is mainly because power lines have not reached every village and home.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*9sb969ABkgbyk2Tm.jpg" /><figcaption>Greenpeace installed a solar microgrid system in Dharnai, but villagers soon learned that it couldn’t handle the load for basic household chores like cooking and ironing. Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan.</figcaption></figure><p>Greenpeace, like many environmental groups, argues that these people could be supplied through decentralized solar and other renewable energies. They envision a future where 1.3 billion people globally could skip fossil-fuel-fired power plants and enter a prosperous, low-emissions world.</p><p>The fallacy in this position, others argue, is that solar microgrids do not address climate change. The microgrids do not displace coal use because the target villages were never hooked to the central grid in the first place. In fact, in parts of India, microgrids have become a stopgap solution for the energy-poor while they wait for the central grid.</p><blockquote>“I’d agree 100 percent this is primarily a development solution, not a climate solution,” said Justin Guay, climate program officer at the David and Lucile Packard Foundation who was previously with the Sierra Club.</blockquote><h3>When a light bulb isn’t enough</h3><p>The Indian government plans to expand the central grid and has promised that every citizen will have reliable electricity by 2022. By June, the energy ministry estimated it had already brought about 60 percent of India’s 714,204 unwired villages online.</p><p>To meet the needs of 1.2 billion citizens, the government plans to double coal extraction to 1.5 billion metric tons by the end of the decade and quadruple its renewable energy capacity. At the same time, officials have promised that with international assistance India will increase the share of non-fossil-based capacity in its energy mix to 40 percent by 2030, up from 30 percent today. But analysts say that boosting those clean energy levels will not be easy.</p><p>Rupesh Kumar, an 11th-grader in Dharnai, grew up studying by the light of kerosene lanterns. He was hopeful when Greenpeace representatives came to his family’s two-room house, walking past two buffaloes tied at the front porch.</p><p>They promised him a light bulb he could study by. He hopes to be the first in his family to go to college and get a job other than farming.</p><p>Over three months, engineers set up 70 kilowatts of photovoltaic cells on the rooftop of public buildings scattered throughout the village. They installed 224 batteries to store the energy. Artists painted a cheerful mural of rainbows and birds on the wall of the village chief’s office, branding the village “Dharnai Live.” The village also has a website. All told, the installation cost 2.7 crore rupees ($407,050).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*f7t-jn4h4IDLZieb.jpg" /><figcaption>Solar power failed Rupesh Kumar, an 11th-grader in Dharnai, when he wanted to study before his farming chores at dawn. Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan.</figcaption></figure><p>Kumar’s family received one compact fluorescent light bulb and a wall outlet to charge their mobile phone. The power would be free for six months and then cost 70 rupees per month. That comes to about $1, but a steep price tag in a place where poor people earn, on average, the equivalent of about 30 cents per day. Most of Kumar’s neighbors could not afford it.</p><p>In the more prosperous part of the village, well-to-do families already had rooftop solar panels. But Greenpeace’s microgrid promised to be more reliable, and many of them signed up, as well.</p><p>The day the power came was one of celebration. Villagers, rich and poor alike, ate sweets. Then, the wealthy families plugged in energy-inefficient televisions and refrigerators. With the power suddenly facing heavy demand, the batteries drained within hours. When Kumar woke up at 4 a.m. before his farming duties to study, the light bulb did not work.</p><p>“I think it’s wrong that when I studied, the power would get cut,” he said.</p><h3>Bringing coal-fired power to town</h3><p>The microgrid operators scrambled to fix the mess. The village electrification committee decided to restrict electricity supply to five hours at nighttime. Greenpeace put up posters telling people not to use energy-hungry appliances such as rice cookers, electric water heaters, irons, space heaters and air coolers.</p><p>One month after the rollout, Greenpeace invited Bihar’s former chief minister, Nitish Kumar, to inaugurate the solar village. A head of state visiting a small village under the glare of television cameras is a huge deal, and the citizens knew it was their best chance to get a permanent solution.</p><p>Children held placards and the adults chanted their mantra asking for “real” electricity.</p><p>One week later, trucks rolled in and set up a 100-kW transformer in town, connecting Dharnai to the grid.</p><p>Power is now free for Kumar and his neighbors who are below the poverty line. Others pay 3 rupees per kilowatt-hour of electricity. As of July, villagers were getting electricity day and night, albeit with power cuts. At such times, they’d use the microgrid as a backup.</p><p>Meanwhile, enrollment in the solar program has fallen to 120 households, down from 380 at the start, according to Ramapati Kumar of the Centre for Environment and Energy Development, which operates the system now. He previously headed Greenpeace India’s renewable energy program.</p><p>Dharnai is a work in progress, and the microgrid is operating as it was designed, he said. He hopes that the generated power will get fed into the central grid in the future. India, at present, does not have a policy to handle such inputs.</p><p>At present, solar power in Dharnai costs at least three times as much as grid power. It can support only expensive energy-efficient appliances, such as CFL bulbs. A CFL bulb in India costs 700 rupees ($10), while an incandescent bulb costs 10 rupees (15 cents).</p><h3>Using the poor as a pro-coal argument</h3><p>M.V. Ramana, a physicist at Princeton University who has studied energy access in India, questioned the ethics of foisting an expensive solution on the poor, who’ve historically contributed so little to global warming.</p><p>“I strongly encourage [microgrids] for urban, upper classes of people who can afford it,” he said. “But [I would] not do it on the backs of people who are poor and who can’t afford these experiments.”</p><p>Grid power, which in India’s case is mostly coal-based, generates enough electricity to power factories, agricultural processing, hospitals, schools and malls, all of which drive human development and create jobs, said Alex Trembath, a senior analyst at the California-based Breakthrough Institute.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*EncFm01zfVdCPJqY.jpg" /><figcaption>Months after the rollout of dozens of solar rooftop panels in Dharnai, the chief minister ordered the village connected to the central grid. Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan.</figcaption></figure><p>Groups that claim that microgrids can fuel similar levels of development are “conducting clean energy and climate policy on the backs of the global poor,” he also argued.</p><p>Guay of the Packard Foundation strongly disagreed and said that even a single light bulb powered by a microgrid is valuable to someone without power. Decentralized grids are solutions of the future while the central grid is like “whale oil,” he said.</p><p>“It has everything to do with progress,” Guay said. “I don’t think you will see a single person say that the poor should continue to use whale oil in the 21st century and call that ethical and progressive.”</p><p>Only a small number of villages are too remote to be hooked to the central grid and would be good candidates for microgrid-only solutions, Ramana said. The government has identified 12,771 such villages. There are also thousands of hamlets where fewer than 100 families live that could benefit, other experts said.</p><h3>A village’s gratitude for coal</h3><p>As the sun set in Dharnai on a recent summer evening, Greenpeace’s solar-powered street lamps switched on and pooled white light along the thoroughfare. Villagers chatted on streets that would have once been pitch-dark. Life has improved after Greenpeace came, they said.</p><p>Not because the group brought solar. Rather, they said, they appreciate that the group brought the chief minister, who brought in the grid.</p><p>Yet a canopy of wires and plastic bottles overhanging Dharnai’s streets is also evidence of India’s problematic central grid. Though the villagers prefer it to solar, they acknowledge the government’s supply is unreliable.</p><p>The cuts are a reminder that India’s electricity demand far outstrips supply. Bihar’s power plants this year are generating 21 percent less electricity than needed during peak demand. The government has never mulled whether it should keep coal in the ground for the sake of the climate because it can use all of the power it can get, Ramana explained.</p><p>Toward that end, India has announced an ambitious plan to install 100 GW of solar by 2022, up from 3 GW today. The target would be difficult to achieve in the next few decades, analysts say. Solar photovoltaics are not cost-competitive with coal. And India’s aging grid cannot handle the fluctuations in capacity that occur when the wind dies or the sun hides behind clouds.</p><p>Christopher Field, director of the Carnegie Institution for Science’s Department of Global Ecology and an active participant in the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, said that rich nations have a moral responsibility to make renewables more affordable in the developing world.</p><p>Until that happens, coal plants will continue being built in India in the near future, Field said in an interview in August.</p><p>“Right now, if I were Prime Minister Modi, I’d be saying, ‘Gee, I can deliver coal-based electricity way cheaper than I can deliver renewables,” he said.</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing LLC</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=526c2ef6489f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/activists-say-solar-can-power-india-but-politics-and-economics-of-coal-win-out-526c2ef6489f">Activists say solar can power India, but politics and economics of coal win out</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In India, climate change takes a back seat to coal-powered development]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/in-india-climate-change-takes-a-back-seat-to-coal-powered-development-d94bbe9fbe1f?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d94bbe9fbe1f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Oct 2015 18:33:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-16T18:32:57.053Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YiNT86XTDQdKWYSy1dL-Eg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan</figcaption></figure><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/staff/Gayathri_Vaidyanathan">by Gayathri Vaidyanathan</a>, <a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw">ClimateWire</a> — a publication of <a href="http://www.eenews.net/">E&amp;E Publishing</a></p><p><em>(Part one of a two-part report on India)</em></p><p>SINGRAULI, India — Here at the foot of a mountain of coal mining debris live 150 people in one of the most polluted places on Earth.</p><p>The air is dense with coal dust and other particulates. The drinking water source is a spring that emerges from the coal dump. When the rains come, landslides from the rock pile threaten to crush the small mud homes at its foot.</p><p>Kunti Baiga, who is 25 or 30 years old by her best reckoning, lives there with her kids — two boys and a girl. The coal mining company, Northern Coalfields Ltd., has offered her family a spot in a resettlement camp nearby. But she refuses to move because she has seen the miserable conditions there.</p><blockquote>“We would rather be crushed by the debris here rather than under the roof of those houses,” she said. “I would rather die here.”</blockquote><p>The coal boom is meant to power India’s economic growth and supply the 400 million people like Baiga who do not have electricity. Indeed, India sees its energy mix as inextricably linked to coal. Electricity demand is estimated to double by 2022 nationwide, and coal production is expected to double to 1 billion metric tons by then. Much of it would be burned in carbon-spewing power plants to generate an additional 103 gigawatts of capacity.</p><p>India is already the world’s fourth-largest emitter of carbon dioxide after China, the United States and the European Union, releasing more than 2 billion metric tons in 2013. By 2030, emissions are projected to rise to between 4 billion and 5.6 billion metric tons, according to modeling <a href="http://cprindia.org/sites/default/files/Informing%20India%27s%20Energy%20and%20Climate%20Debate_CPR-IIASA.pdf">studies</a>.</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations/stories/1060026415">Government leaders are unapologetic about India’s right to pollute, just as other nations have done in the quest for prosperity.</a></p><p>“We need carbon space, please vacate the carbon space which countries have occupied,” Prakash Javadekar, India’s environment minister, said in a recent interview. “We want free carbon space where our development can be parked. We want to bring them [poor people] out of poverty. … And to that end, we’ll produce more energy.”</p><p>And yet, in India’s race to develop, people like Baiga get left out.</p><h3>Attacking those who attack coal</h3><p>Priya Pillai, 37, a senior campaigner with Greenpeace India, has come as close as anyone to challenging the government’s position that coal-powered development helps the poor. She believes that is why, on Jan. 11, as she was boarding a flight to London to talk to British ministers about coal extraction in India, she was stopped.</p><p>In the coming months, Greenpeace would be targeted as an enemy of the state, its bank accounts would be frozen, and it would be forced to fight in the courts for its survival. But that January morning, Pillai was alone.</p><p>She was directed to a holding area. Pillai does not have a criminal record, but she said she felt the grip of paranoia. Her suitcase had already been checked in, and she felt convinced that the authorities would put drugs in her bags and arrest her on a false charge.</p><p>Her fear was the culmination of five years she had spent organizing villagers in Singrauli to protest against coal mining. The region, in central India’s Madhya Pradesh state, is so remote that it takes a day’s travel from Delhi to reach it. Residents there do not know what is owed them by the government, as it takes away land and awards it to India’s biggest energy companies to generate coal-fired electricity and power distant megacities, advocates say.</p><p>That was the case when Pillai got there in 2011. One morning, she hired a sedan and drove to a village near the Mahan forest, which was slated for destruction. On both sides of the road were houses and farms dotted with cows. To the southeast loomed a 1,200-megawatt power plant built by the Essar Group, an Indian multinational conglomerate. The plant had cost the company 3,600 crore rupees ($550 million).</p><p>Four villages had already been displaced. Essar and its partner company, Hindalco Industries Ltd., wanted to move two other villages to mine coal to supply the power plant. The mine would destroy 967 hectares of the Mahan forest.</p><p>Mahan was strategically ideal for Greenpeace, which was looking for a cause to spark a nationwide anti-coal movement. The fight would pit villagers against the might of the government and a mega-energy company, Essar, which was then listed on the London Stock Exchange.</p><h3>‘My people have the right to grow’</h3><p>Greenpeace set up its India office in 2002, and since then, it has grown to have the largest on-the-ground presence of all international environmental groups that focus on climate change issues. Greenpeace’s goal in India is to stop all new coal-fired power plants because the resulting carbon emissions would contribute to global warming, even though scientists caution that renewable energy has not yet matured enough to supplant future coal-fired generation.</p><p>“For us, as an environmental organization, it is important that coal remains below the Earth, it is not dug up and it is not burnt,” Pillai said.</p><p>Activists urging fossil fuel divestment have a list of the top 200 companies to target, and Coal India Ltd., the state-owned producer, heads it with a potential 57 gigatons of carbon dioxide emissions in its reserves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/338/0*Va3HzX6FmVTjPwvL.jpg" /><figcaption>Priya Pillai, a campaigner with Greenpeace India, has been under attack for fighting coal development, which the government considers key to the country’s growth. Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan.</figcaption></figure><p>That’s one reason why the Indian government sees the meddling presence of international green groups in the work of Greenpeace India. Greenpeace International, which is involved in divestment campaigns, and U.S.-based ClimateWorks partly fund and train activists with Greenpeace India. Last year, the Intelligence Bureau wrote to then-Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and called the group a threat to “national economic security.”</p><p>“Greenpeace aims to fundamentally change the dynamics of India’s energy mix,” the report, which was leaked to the media, states.</p><p>Though India ambitiously plans to generate 175 GW of renewable energy by 2022, modeling studies show that coal would occupy more than half of its energy mix in 2030. Curbing carbon emissions in the next few decades, officials say, is not a reality that the nation can commit to. Indeed, as India’s contribution to a new global climate change agreement in Paris in December makes clear, “coal will continue to dominate power generation in [the] future.”</p><p>The Paris targets call for curbing emissions 33 to 35 percent per unit of economic output from 2005 levels by 2030. But there will be no peak year beyond which the country’s carbon emissions will start to decline. No country could ask such a thing of India, where the average person uses just 6 percent of electricity as the average American, Javadekar said.</p><p>The emerging deal in Paris stands in stark contrast to the current Kyoto Protocol, which demands only a handful of wealthy countries curb emissions. India, aligning itself in recent years with major oil producers like Saudi Arabia, has been the staunchest opponent of any effort to force developing countries to undertake mandatory carbon cuts, arguing that wealthy countries have not yet done enough. Many of its Paris targets are conditional on receiving aid.</p><blockquote>“My people have the right to grow. First is the access to the energy, second is the quality of power,” Javadekar said.</blockquote><h3>High-level lobbying meets forest activism</h3><p>Virendra Singh, 36, a farmer, was taking his cattle for grazing in 2011 when Pillai’s sedan pulled up. She asked him the way to the village chief’s house, and then about the coal mine proposed for the region.</p><p>Did he think the Mahan forest and their village should be saved from Essar? “Our forests must remain if they can,” he recalled saying, echoing a widespread sentiment that villagers did not have a say in such matters.</p><p>Mahan is a 20,000-hectare forest that overlies some of the highest-quality coal in India. It is part of the central coal belt, which stretches across four states and coincidentally contains 36 percent of India’s remaining forestland.</p><p>Activists say a fight against coal in India is a fight to save its forests.</p><p>To convert its anti-coal movement into a forests campaign, Greenpeace used the Forest Rights Act, a landmark law enacted in 2006 that allows mining only if a majority of villagers in the area agree to the development. Greenpeace wanted the Mahan villagers to oppose Essar’s coal mine, which was in the process of securing permits.</p><p>Pillai and her colleagues began visiting nearby Budher, a forest hamlet of 165 people where the air is punctuated by the music of cowbells. Essar representatives had told residents their village belonged to the company.</p><p>Their certainty stemmed from the fait accompli nature of environmental clearances for industrial projects in India, activists said.</p><p>But Essar had not wagered on Greenpeace and Pillai.</p><h3>‘Suffering’ for a shopping mall</h3><p>At international climate negotiations, Indian leaders point to their rural poor as the raison d’etre for the nation’s economic development agenda.</p><p>“We don’t want to keep tribal people always poor,” Javadekar told <em>ClimateWire</em>. “We don’t want to exhibit them as the poverty of India, we want to bring them on par with our average citizens.”</p><p>Energy production would eventually benefit those communities, “because any economic activity creates more employment, and it benefits the poor more,” he said.</p><p>Yet, it is unclear that they are benefiting. About 75 percent of India’s most impoverished citizens live in the countryside, yet electricity flows are lopsided toward urban centers. In rural India, about 134 million families earn less than $2.50 a day, and only half have access to electricity.</p><p>Rural homes regularly experience rolling blackouts during times of peak demand as utilities move available power to commercial operations and energy-hungry cities. That means the average rural consumer ends up subsidizing power for urban residents by 240 to 510 rupees ($4 to $8) per year, according to a study in Karnataka state done by Rahul Tongia, a fellow at Brookings India. It may not seem high by U.S. standards, but experts note it places an unfair burden on villagers who already live hand to mouth.</p><p>In Amlohri, Ram Shah Baiga, 22, owns a single incandescent light and gets an electricity bill that is half his monthly earning of 1,000 rupees ($150). The bill is particularly incongruous given that a city resident who owns a refrigerator, ceiling fans and multiple light bulbs would be charged similarly.</p><blockquote>“Now tell me if this is fair. I only have one bulb in my house,” he said.</blockquote><p>M.V. Ramana, a physicist at Princeton University who has studied energy access in India, said new coal plants might create employment for city dwellers, at the expense of poor people elsewhere. “Is that suffering justified to set up a mall, to air condition a mall?” he asked.</p><h3>Intel bureau slams Greenpeace for renewable energy push</h3><p>Back in Singrauli, Pillai had to show the villagers what was at stake if they did not fight to save the forest.</p><p>She took them to resettlement colonies for people displaced by coal mining. One such is Amlohri, 20 minutes away, a desolate settlement without roads and electricity. Few people there are regularly employed, said resident Gopi Baiga. He could feed his young daughter only one meal the previous day, he said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/338/0*35BGyrZYK2E78tmL.jpg" /><figcaption>India’s coal boom is aimed at helping people like Kunti Baiga, a villager in Singrauli, rise out of poverty. But activists say coal is only making rural conditions worse. Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan.</figcaption></figure><p>“Since we moved here, we don’t want to continue living,” he said. “If a man is starving, there is no peace left for him.”</p><p>Months later, a dozen villagers sat with Pillai and told her they would fight Essar and demand their forest rights.</p><p>Over the next months, Greenpeace helped organize the resistance. They borrowed heavily from the nonviolence playbook of Mahatma Gandhi and one evening brought a projector to the village to play the Academy Award-winning movie about the Indian independence leader’s life. Soon, the villagers who attended the meetings were greeting each other by pumping a fist in the air and shouting, “Zindabad!” or “Victory,” a rallying cry of the movement against the British.</p><p>With Greenpeace’s help, the locals prepared an official resolution under the Forest Rights Act to be voted on during a village committee meeting. If it passed and got recognized by the government, the villagers could block the mine.</p><p>The government watched in alarm. State-level intelligence officials pretended to be villagers and appeared at Greenpeace meetings in Budher to learn their tactics.</p><p>“Greenpeace has been growing exponentially in terms of reach, impact, volunteers, movements it supports and media influence,” the Intelligence Bureau wrote to Singh. “Activists have focused on ways to create obstacles in India’s coal-based energy plans and methods to pressure India to use only renewable energy.”</p><p>In January 2014, Pillai and her colleagues gathered 27 villagers and took them to Essar’s headquarters in Mumbai, the nation’s financial center. The villagers, some whom had never left Singrauli, gaped as six men in tiger costumes jumped off a 23-story glass building and unfurled a banner that read, “We kill forests: Essar.”</p><p>The villagers and 40 Greenpeace activists were arrested, but Mahan made headlines. About 1 million people signed up online in support of the anti-coal movement, according to the group.</p><p>Two weeks later, the government gave Essar and Hindalco all required clearances to mine coal from Mahan.</p><h3>Mines blocked, but at a price</h3><p>The public, by then, was deeply angry with the government following a series of corruption scandals.</p><p>The nation’s auditor general had found large irregularities in the awarding of coal blocks — including Mahan — to companies in the past decade. The nation had lost 1,860 billion rupees ($31 billion) in revenue, the auditors said. The scandal implicated Essar, Hindalco and other companies.</p><p>In national elections that April, Indians decisively voted out the ruling government. Prime Minister Narendra Modi won with an absolute majority, which gave him free rein to govern aggressively.</p><p>Almost immediately, his administration leaked to the media the Intelligence Bureau report, which revealed Greenpeace’s foreign funders and made the group unpopular in a nation that was riding a nationalistic wave.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*uEqXYzfJGbhLXc28.jpg" /><figcaption>India’s proposed targets for a new global climate change agreement make clear that coal is here to stay, saying the fossil fuel source will “continue to dominate power generation in [the] future.” Photo by Gayathri Vaidyanathan.</figcaption></figure><p>In September, the nation’s Supreme Court canceled most of the mines allocated since 2006, including Mahan, citing the auditor general report. Greenpeace and the villagers in Singrauli declared victory.</p><p>The Modi administration said it would not offer Mahan up for mining again — the Greenpeace campaign had made it toxic. But the government also recognized that a repetition of Mahan could be dangerous for India’s energy security.</p><p>The Ministry of Home Affairs, which deals with internal security, acted decisively. It froze Greenpeace India’s bank accounts, making it difficult for the group to pay its employees for some months. The group can no longer receive money from foreign donors, including Greenpeace International. The government has alleged that the group did not declare its foreign funding properly. The government has also challenged Greenpeace’s status as a nonprofit and canceled its registration in India. It no longer recognizes Greenpeace India as an environmental nongovernmental organization. The group rebuts all charges and is fighting seven cases in court for its survival.</p><p>The most personal cost of the crackdown was borne by Pillai.</p><h3>Javadekar: Greenpeace broke the law</h3><p>Together with other activists, she was placed on a watch list that prevented her from traveling to London to address British parliamentarians in January. Immigration officers stopped her at the airport and stamped her passport with a red “offload” sign. In indignation, she appeared on national television and challenged the legality of the Modi government’s actions.</p><p>Her parents had not known that Pillai was a grass-roots organizer taking on the powerful coal mining interests and the government. They became frantic for her safety. She recalled her father saying, “These people are very powerful; they are a government. They can do anything to you.”</p><p>She brushed off their concerns. Days later, her father, who was an epileptic, suffered a hard fall due to stress. His hip broke in multiple places, and he passed away a month later.</p><blockquote>“I guess everything has a price,” Pillai said.</blockquote><p>The actions suggest the government is not interested in setting right the environmental and social injustices of coal extraction, which Greenpeace’s activists highlighted in Singrauli, said Ramana of Princeton University.</p><p>There is a large transfer of natural resources — land, water and forests — from the poor to corporations in these cases, he said. Other analysts note India must address that reality with its insistence that the country be allowed to emit unchecked carbon in order to benefit the most needy.</p><p>Javadekar said Greenpeace is in trouble simply because it broke the nation’s laws.</p><p>“We have not gone against anybody. Those who violate the law will have to face the law,” he said. “There is a legal process, and they [Greenpeace] have every right to plead their case.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d94bbe9fbe1f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/in-india-climate-change-takes-a-back-seat-to-coal-powered-development-d94bbe9fbe1f">In India, climate change takes a back seat to coal-powered development</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why wealthy Singapore resists tough domestic climate action]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/why-wealthy-singapore-resists-tough-domestic-climate-action-ce0764e2ab85?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce0764e2ab85</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[singapore]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2015 15:25:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-15T15:31:33.417Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Wnwzk5ED2x3V1l6Scd5Fw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>by Coco Liu, E&amp;E correspondent, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw"><em>ClimateWire</em></a><em> — a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p>SINGAPORE — This is a rich island nation, and despite pressures to help combat climate change, it fully intends to stay that way.</p><p>Standing on the peak of Jurong Hill, looking out across a man-made isle off the mainland bearing the same name, it’s easy to see why. Manufacturing facilities crowd the artificial land mass. Silver-colored storage tanks and giant chimneys painted in red and white indicate its status as one of the top three oil refining centers in the world.</p><p>Home to oil giants like BP PLC, Royal Dutch Shell PLC and Exxon Mobil Corp., Jurong Island’s refineries contribute heavily to Singapore’s greenhouse gas emissions profile. But they also make this tiny nation one of the richest per capita in the world, and its leaders have signaled no plans to restrict the country’s economic engine.</p><p>“The energy and chemicals industry is a major carbon emitter worldwide. It is the nature of the industry,” Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong explained in a speech at the opening of Exxon Mobil’s new facility last year.</p><p>“We must reduce our emissions, both of greenhouse gases as well as other more local pollutants,” Lee said. “But at the same time, I want to assure all the energy and petrochemicals companies here that the Singapore government stands fully behind them and will continue to help them to succeed.”</p><p>Under the United Nations’ 20-year-old climate change agreement, Singapore is considered a developing country exempt from the emissions cuts that are mandatory for a handful of industrialized nations. <a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations/stories/1060026342">But as governments prepare to sign a new accord in Paris in December, those old divisions are fading away.</a></p><p>Countries like Singapore — where the economy has more than tripled and whose emissions have jumped by 61 percent since the dividing lines between “rich” and “poor” nations were drawn — face new demands for climate action. But observers say the domestic pressure to resist measures that could threaten the country’s prosperity is equally strong.</p><blockquote>“Like every country, Singapore is interested in protecting its national interests while advancing the global efforts. So they have … favored approaches that can achieve that,” said Elliot Diringer, executive vice president of the Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit Center for Climate and Energy Solutions (C2ES).</blockquote><p>Singapore has long straddled the line between developed and developing nations in the U.N. talks. That’s why, Diringer said, the government was an early supporter of a flexible Paris deal that might avoid those strict divisions. That appears to be how the agreement is taking shape, with countries defining their own plans for carbon cuts based on “national capabilities” instead of old categories.</p><p>“I think that its position is shaped by resource constraints, as well as its economic position regionally. It is a very vibrant economy but has many rising competitors in the region,” Diringer said. “Competitiveness is an issue for all the countries. I think Singapore would like to maintain a level playing ground so that it is not put at a competitive disadvantage.”</p><h3>Climate targets rated ‘inadequate’</h3><p>Experts outside and in Singapore say concerns over economic development, allied with resource constraints, have prevented it from pursuing ambitious climate change mitigation.</p><p>In 2009, ahead of key U.N. talks in Copenhagen, Denmark, the government vowed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 7 to 11 percent below business-as-usual levels by 2020. That is expected to generate a reduction of emissions up to 8.5 million tons over a decade, a result that critics say is far too small for such a wealthy country.</p><p>Singapore, with a land size smaller than New York City and a population of more than 5 million people, has the third-highest per capita economic output in the world.</p><p>Recently, the government has pledged to push further. But the target submitted as part of a pending U.N. deal in Paris in December — to reduce emissions 36 percent per unit of economic output by 2030 compared with 2005 levels as well as peak emissions around 2030 — has not stemmed the criticism.</p><p>Climate Action Tracker, an independent scientific analysis produced by four European research organizations to assess countries’ pledges, described Singapore’s as insufficient and warned they aren’t even plausible under the country’s current policies.</p><p>“We rate this target ‘Inadequate,’ meaning it is not in line with any interpretations of a ‘fair’ approach to hold warming below 2ºC,” the research group explained in a statement. “If most other countries followed Singapore’s approach, global warming would exceed 3–4ºC.”</p><p>Yet others say Singapore is probably not in the best position to be a climate change fighter. The country’s flat landscape makes it difficult to produce hydroelectricity. Sheltered by Malaysia and Indonesia, there is little potential for Singapore to tap into wind power. Nuclear energy is not an option, either, due to its limited spaces.</p><p>As an official jokingly put it: “If we have to evacuate, the whole Singapore probably will have to go to somewhere else.”</p><h3>Consumption skyrockets even as efficiency improves</h3><p>To clean up its power sector, Singapore has switched from burning oil for electricity to burning natural gas, the cleanest form of fossil fuels. Currently, natural gas makes up more than 90 percent of the country’s power generation. Beyond that, Singapore has been taking preliminary steps to improve energy efficiency.</p><p>The government here has established a multimillion-dollar fund to help factories replace outdated equipment with energy-efficient ones. Subsidized training course on energy management and grants for technology innovation have also been made available.</p><p>Other energy-saving efforts include introducing minimum energy performance standards to major household appliances such as refrigerators and clothes dryers. By 2030, according to the government’s plan, four out of five buildings in Singapore will have a BCA Green Mark, a local green building certification in which a building’s energy efficiency is taken into account.</p><p>Orchids, ferns and other types of vegetation grow along the road of Singapore and expand their territories to include walls. Visitors are reminded of rainforests while wandering around Southeast Asia’s banking capital. At the same time, the green walls serve as natural “air conditioners” to keep the city-state cool.</p><p>Officials say these measures have helped Singapore scale down its energy footprint. Yet government statistics also show the country’s total electricity consumption more than tripled between 1990 and 2012.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*C4A5y-Enhl-tn4Ba.jpg" /><figcaption>Singapore’s Jurong Island, home to some of the world’s largest oil refineries and the top source of the country’s greenhouse gas emissions. Photo courtesy of Wikipedia.</figcaption></figure><p>The similar trend also appears in Singapore’s emissions profile. Although the country ranks among the top 20 percent most efficient in the world in terms of emissions intensity by the intergovernmental organization International Energy Agency, its total greenhouse gas emissions jumped by 74 percent from 1990 to 2012, according to the estimates of D.C.-based think tank World Resources Institute.</p><p>A growing desire for modern comforts has also contributed to the increase. Like people around the globe, Singaporeans, who have worked hard for decades to lift the country out of poverty, now want to enjoy their fortune. The country’s narrow streets are crowded with stalls selling the spiky, smelly durian fruit, as well as deluxe shopping malls. The real estate construction seems never-ending. It’s not unusual to see a Lamborghini or Rolls-Royce drive by.</p><p>On top of that, the country’s dependence on the oil refining sector has worsened the problem.</p><h3>Wealth built on oil refineries</h3><p>Oil refining has been the cornerstone of Singapore’s success since its very early days. According to Ng Weng Hoong, a local reporter and author of “Singapore, the Energy Economy,” the country’s gross domestic product per capita was $1,360 in 1960 in Singaporean dollar terms. That level more than quadrupled in 1974, thanks to the operation of three oil refineries as well as skyrocketing oil prices in the 1970s.</p><p>Ng noted that Singapore’s maritime trade and port traffic also grew under the influence of the oil refineries. Meanwhile, the refining industry helped attract substantial investments for key supporting sectors such as banking, trading and engineering services.</p><p>“In contrast, Singapore’s electronics industry started off in the 1960s as a small TV assembly operation, while shipbuilding began as an experimental venture between Japanese and Singaporean interests. Neither these nor other industries could match oil refining in terms of investment size, value-add, export earnings or value of manufacturing output,” Ng said.</p><p>Fast-forwarding into the 21st century, oil refining and its downstream business still play a crucial role in Singapore’s economy. In 2013, oil refineries — together with petrochemical producers — seized annual investment commitments of $1.8 billion, the second highest in the nation. The refining and chemical industries also contributed to around a third of Singapore’s manufacturing output by value.</p><p>Although there is no official breakdown available in greenhouse gas emissions of each industrial sector in Singapore, the oil refining industry has long earned the reputation of being carbon-intensive. Fossil fuel combustion for powering heaters and boilers releases large amounts of carbon dioxide emissions into the atmosphere, as does the production process of oil refining. Methane emissions from a typical petroleum refinery arise from process equipment leaks and crude oil storage tanks. Flaring off waste gas also contributes to the overall greenhouse gas emissions at the refinery.</p><p>In the eyes of climate activists, that has become a major obstacle in the country’s journey to cut emissions.</p><blockquote>“To get the country to totally go out of it [oil refining], the first question every government should address is whether the country has any other alternative. Which Singapore doesn’t,” said Wilson Ang, president of the Environmental Challenge Organization in Singapore.</blockquote><p>“Nonetheless, since Copenhagen [climate change summit], Singapore has available funds in to encourage clean-tech startups and attract such companies to come to Singapore. However, it has not grown massively enough yet,” he added.</p><h3>‘What is their national interest?’</h3><p>There is also an issue of fairness. Because most of Singapore’s petroleum products are not consumed domestically, greenhouse gas emissions generated by the oil refining industry should not be simply counted as Singapore’s responsibilities, said Edwin Khew, chairman of the Sustainable Energy Association of Singapore.</p><p>Khew and others say Singapore’s highly efficient oil refining industry could help the world meet its demand for petroleum at a lower environmental cost than elsewhere. Government officials also argue that even if Singapore stops building oil refineries, it would not make a big difference in combating global warming because the country accounts for only 0.11 percent of global emissions.</p><p>But not everyone agrees.</p><p>“The point is that if you aggregate every country’s contribution, it spells a difference,” said Zelda Soriano, political adviser at Greenpeace Southeast Asia in the Philippines.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/178/0*ON3nIfyG6TGjz3V3.jpg" /><figcaption>Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has promised new efficiency measures for refineries but said the government “stands fully behind” the high-emitting sector. Photo courtesy of Wikipedia.</figcaption></figure><p>“If you just take the possible contribution of Singapore, as a small island state, you will realize that it is such a small contribution to reduce emissions in general,” Soriano said. “But every possible effort, every feasible level form of contribution from whatever source — small, medium, big countries — we would need all of them because what really matters is to aggregate all these efforts.”</p><p>Moreover, as Singapore has long been viewed as a development model by many Asian nations, its policy has a strong influence in the region, and climate policy is not an exception, said Bernise Ang, a co-founder of nonprofit organization Syinc in Singapore.</p><p>“If we are progressive, others will be encouraged,” Ang said. “But the stakes are actually higher in the negative. If Singapore adopts less progressive policies at further cost to our environment, it becomes complicit to forming the kind of norms that give permissions to other countries in the region to do the same.”</p><p>While no country in history has achieved its economic growth without causing environmental damage, expectations for Singapore’s mitigation ambition are particularly high because it is a leading figure in facilitating a global climate change treaty.</p><p>With its unique position as a developing country under the United Nations and as one of the more advanced economies in the world, climate activists say, Singapore in recent years has become a bridge between the developing and developed world in the international negotiations.</p><p>“I assume they have a much bigger say than they would claim,” said a former negotiator who attended the U.N. climate change conference last year in Lima, Peru, and who spoke on the condition of anonymity in order to talk freely without seeking higher approval.</p><p>“I think they have the greatest capability of any diplomats in small island states. They have the capability to try to play a role that is at the best to their national interest. The question is, what is their national interest?” the negotiator said.</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing LLC</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce0764e2ab85" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/why-wealthy-singapore-resists-tough-domestic-climate-action-ce0764e2ab85">Why wealthy Singapore resists tough domestic climate action</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mexico tries to bridge U.N. climate talks roadblocks]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/mexico-tries-to-bridge-u-n-climate-talks-roadblocks-1216ec55dd34?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1216ec55dd34</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mexico]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2015 14:49:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-14T16:33:07.622Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rDDLOFh4RFDq2gLk7Ix39g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo courtesy of<a href="https://flic.kr/p/e4iM5P"> Flickr.</a></figcaption></figure><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/staff/Umair_Irfan"><em>By Umair Irfan</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw"><em>ClimateWire</em></a><em> a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p>Where some are planning walls, others are planning windows. Or rather, pipelines.</p><p>Across the dusty 1,954-mile border between Mexico and the United States, international companies are gearing up to spend more than $10 billion on thousands of miles of steel tubes carrying cheap natural gas from Texas to hungry markets on the other side of the Rio Grande.</p><p>The recent surge in natural gas investment is just one element of the colossal changes underway in Mexico’s energy portrait. Fracturing monopolies, surging demand, falling oil prices and ambitious climate change mitigation goals are intersecting in Mexico, creating unprecedented challenges and opportunities for curbing greenhouse gases.</p><p>The United States’ southern neighbor is the world’s 10th-largest oil producer, and by 2050 is expected to become the world’s fifth-largest economy. Though it contributes less than 2 percent of the planet’s carbon emissions, the country made an aggressive climate pledge toward a new global accord: to peak national emissions by 2026 and drive them down 22 percent by 2030. That makes Mexico one of the largest developing countries to issue such a proposal.</p><p>The world is watching. Emerging economies have often argued that they should be compensated before they take action against climate change. Mitigation opponents in wealthy nations, on the other hand, justify inaction because cutting carbon pollution from developing countries is sine qua non for curbing global warming.</p><blockquote>Mexico pokes a hole in both arguments.</blockquote><p>As a large developing resource economy in the Western Hemisphere — and a major oil producer, as well — it has embraced unconditional emissions targets. Moreover, Mexico doesn’t fit well into any existing power bloc in U.N. climate negotiations. Instead, it borrows elements from all of them, hurdling over the old rich-poor divide.</p><p>Its role as a bridge builder was highlighted when Mexico hosted U.N. talks in Cancún in 2010 and argued that climate change is a global problem that required everyone, not just wealthy countries, to fix. Two years later, the country approved the first comprehensive climate law in the developing world.</p><p>Now, in the runup to Paris, where leaders hope to sign a new international agreement in December, Mexico is on the front lines in challenging all nations to step up to take bolder climate action.</p><p>“Given that Mexico was the key place where this concept was developed and formalized, Mexico wanted to be an important player going into the meetings in Paris,” said Carlos Pascual, who served as the U.S. ambassador to Mexico from 2009 until 2011 and later the State Department’s special envoy and coordinator for international energy affairs.</p><h3>Will market liberalization help or hurt climate action?</h3><p>The new climate law set targets for curbing greenhouse gas emissions and ramping up clean energy production. By 2050, Mexico expects to curb greenhouse gas emissions 50 percent relative to 2000 levels. The government has also pledged to generate 35 percent of its electricity from clean sources by 2024 (up from the current 25 percent) and 60 percent by midcentury.</p><p>Now that Mexico has shown that it is willing, the question is whether it is able.</p><p>There are many confounding factors, but the largest may be the Mexican energy revolution. For the first time in more than 75 years, the electricity and oil sectors are opening up to private investors, introducing competition to its energy-producing stalwarts, putting billions of dollars of profits and tax revenue into play.</p><blockquote>“It’s rare to have a market that large open itself in this day and age,” said Carlos Solé, co-chair of the Latin America practice at Baker Botts LLP, a law firm that represents many energy companies.</blockquote><p>The state oil monopoly, Pemex, and the state electricity monopoly, CFE, ruled Mexico’s energy systems since they were nationalized in 1938. The companies are a point of national pride for Mexicans, and their federal government relies on Pemex for more than a third of its revenue.</p><p>“People in Mexico grew up with and were taught in school that the nationalization of oil and gas was for the benefit of the Mexican people,” said Pascual. “The day that oil and gas was nationalized was a national holiday.”</p><p>The monopolies powered Mexico for decades as the world grew addicted to oil. But blocking outside competition let these energy firms languish and grow complacent. Oil production began declining in 2005, and the recent drops in oil prices have left the Mexican government scrambling to fill a budget shortfall.</p><p>“Pemex got too big and became inefficient,” said Matthew Bey, an energy analyst at Stratfor, a think tank. “Their biggest source of revenue is exporting oil, and a lot of that goes into the United States.”</p><p>But last year, the United States produced more petroleum than any other country, driving down demand for Mexican energy.</p><p>Meanwhile, electricity prices in Mexico rose, making the country less attractive for international companies wanting to set up factories. “That kind of gave it its drive to bring in foreign investment,” Bey said.</p><p>Pemex and CFE did not respond to requests for comment.</p><h3>Transforming oil use</h3><p>In 2012, the government planted the seeds of market liberalization, amending the constitution so that private and foreign investors could buy into Mexico’s energy systems and wean the government off oil taxes. The idea was that private companies could more efficiently exploit and market Mexico’s fossil fuels, expanding the overall tax revenue pool for the government.</p><p>However, the idea of selling a public commodity to private interests sparked outrage. During a 2013 debate in the Mexican Congress, Deputy Antonio García Conejo stripped down to his underwear at the lectern, protesting that privatizing energy would rob the nation and that those in favor of the reforms were committing treason.</p><p>“Pemex is not just an oil company. It’s an institution,” Bey explained.</p><p>And Mexico’s first foray into the free market didn’t go well. In an auction this summer, the government only managed to sell two of 14 offshore drilling plots. Many bidders thought the asking price was too high, the leases too short and the fields weren’t that lucrative given the low oil prices in the Americas.</p><p>This was a rude awakening for the government, showing just how out of touch it was with international energy markets.</p><p>It also signaled how much Mexico still depends on carbon-spewing resources to power its economy, for export and domestic use.</p><p>Mexico gets a huge chunk of its energy from burning its own oil, which was the culprit behind its explosive growth in greenhouse gas emissions in the 20th century. Between 1891 and 1982, carbon pollution rose 6.5 percent each year, growing more slowly thereafter.</p><p>According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, Mexico gets 53 percent of its energy from petroleum, 36 percent from natural gas, 5 percent from coal and 4 percent from hydroelectric power. The remainder comes from wind, solar and nuclear power.</p><p>Petroleum, meanwhile, accounts for well over half of the country’s fossil fuel emissions, while natural gas accounts for 23.6 percent. The World Bank reports that Mexico’s per capita emissions are 3.9 metric tons of carbon dioxide, just a hair below the global average of 4 metric tons. In 2011, Mexico produced 466 megatons of greenhouse gases, up 4.7 percent from the previous year.</p><p>As such, fossil fuel dependence is a potent threat to Mexico’s climate ambitions but remains a pillar for Mexico’s economy, which is still struggling to elevate the impoverished.</p><h3>Banking on the shale boom</h3><p>Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto campaigned on a promise of lifting 15 million people out of poverty, but the poverty rate grew to 46.2 percent between 2012 and 2014 for Mexico’s 122 million citizens.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*Eo2-aPq_zH2z5uQq.jpg" /><figcaption>Former Mexican President Felipe Calderon at U.N. climate talks in Cancun in 2010. Photo courtesy of the International Institute for Sustainable Development.</figcaption></figure><p>For some officials, keeping energy prices down and employment up is a higher priority than averting rising sea levels and more intense droughts. That means pipelines may be lifelines when it comes to meeting Mexico’s climate goals.</p><p>Mexico is lining up to take advantage of the shale boom in the United States, having announced 1,000 miles of new pipelines — including a 500-mile underwater gas pipeline from Texas — in a country with only 9,000 miles deployed so far.</p><p>Though Mexico does produce some natural gas, demand far outpaces supply. The shortfall may grow critical as electricity producers close down old oil and coal plants in favor of cleaner natural gas.</p><p>The U.S. Department of Energy reported that U.S. gas exports to Mexico totaled 70.9 billion cubic feet in April, a 25 percent increase from the prior year. By 2020, monthly exports are on track to double.</p><p>In 2014, Mexico levied a tax of $3.50 per ton of carbon dioxide equivalent, carving out a special exclusion for natural gas. Insofar as it replaces carbon-intensive coal and oil power, natural gas is a huge gain in cutting the country’s carbon footprint, all while creating new jobs and bringing power to isolated parts of the country.</p><p>The market liberalization means that Mexican power producers could more easily buy cleaner, cheaper natural gas from abroad instead of burning domestic oil. But that oil may simply go abroad, and low fuel prices may undercut the case for zero-carbon renewables.</p><p>Nonetheless, renewable energy is also blooming under the energy reforms, and international developers are champing at the bit to get a share of the market.</p><p>Mexico is a vast country with scattered load centers, and renewable energy could help deliver power to far-flung regions from Baja to Yucatán. In some regions, solar panels and wind turbines are already competitive with fossil fuels without subsidies.</p><h3>Opening up to solar and wind</h3><p>The energy reforms also created financial instruments to fund renewable projects and allowed private projects to inject electrons onto the national grid.</p><p>“You put all these things together, that makes a good environment for us to invest,” said Michael Harrington, director of Actis, a private equity fund that invests in emerging markets. “Mexico is by far the one country where I have my team working the hardest.”</p><p>Renewable energy also offers Mexico an opportunity to regain lost ground in manufacturing. This summer, SunEdison Inc. announced that its photovoltaic factory in Juárez reached its peak production capacity of 1.3 million solar panels per year, making it the largest solar manufacturing facility in Latin America.</p><blockquote>These factors add up to strong momentum for deploying clean energy and cutting greenhouse gas emissions in Mexico.</blockquote><blockquote>“It’s happening more or less on the time scale [the government] said, which is a lot faster than the private sector expected,” Harrington said.</blockquote><p>However, energy transmission is still going to be a challenge across wide swaths of the country, and the inefficiencies and corruption that plague emerging economies still lurk throughout the country.</p><p>Across the border in the United States, with the 2016 presidential campaign underway, Mexico occasionally enters the discussion, but rarely in the context of energy and climate collaboration.</p><p>“The focus on border issues related to immigration has eclipsed a broader view of economic interests and a mutual energy and environmental interest,” said California Sen. Bill Monning (D), who joined a delegation to Mexico in August.</p><p>“While our targets and objectives are not identical, they lend themselves to sharing academic research, technology exchange and business investment information.”</p><h3>Perestroika, meet Paris</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*krR2K91rWdjbUlCZ.jpg" /><figcaption>Wind and solar power currently make up less than 2 percent of Mexico’s energy mix. Exactly how Mexico plans to boost its renewable energy generation remains unclear despite ambitious plans to peak greenhouse gas emissions. Photo by Mark Stevenson, courtesy of AP Images.</figcaption></figure><p>With so many tools at its disposal, many think that Mexico can meet its environmental and economic obligations.</p><p>“I’m very optimistic,” said Rogelio López Velarde, a partner at the López Velarde, Heftye and Soria SC consulting firm, who likened the energy reforms to the Glasnost and Perestroika policies during the twilight of the Soviet Union.</p><p>The Mexican public also seems on board with the transition to private markets and cleaner energy now. “Actually, people are very happy with the energy reform,” he said. “Threats of unrest didn’t materialize.”</p><p>Still, a major resource economy like Mexico is beholden to the whims of international market forces, which have drastically shifted before and could do it again, throwing a wrench into all of these reforms. And the freer market means that fossil fuel consumption could resurge if prices drop again.</p><p>The country is now preparing another round of auctions for oil, and observers are keen to see whether the government has learned from its past experience. The auctions may be a microcosm of Mexico’s approach to energy and climate as adapts and copes with a free market.</p><p>“A lot of the private sector is taking a wait-and-see approach,” said Pablo Zárate, a senior consultant at FTI Consulting in Mexico City. “They want to see how the wholesale market will pan out.”</p><p>Mexico’s success will likely depend on how it holds itself accountable in curbing emissions and growing its clean energy sector. “Right now, you have the 2018 and the 2025 goals, but you don’t know what the goals for each year are,” Zárate said. “The details and specifics of how this market will work are not there yet.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing LLC</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1216ec55dd34" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/mexico-tries-to-bridge-u-n-climate-talks-roadblocks-1216ec55dd34">Mexico tries to bridge U.N. climate talks roadblocks</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[30 years after famine and strife, Ethiopia sees a future that is bright green]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/30-years-after-famine-and-strife-ethiopia-sees-a-future-that-is-bright-green-136c60cb0b72?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/136c60cb0b72</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cop21]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Oct 2015 16:42:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-13T16:41:45.968Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EP54fMNsxl_Q926qObsarA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Daniel Cusick</figcaption></figure><p><em>By </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/staff/Daniel_Cusick"><em>Daniel Cusick</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw"><em>ClimateWire</em></a><em> — a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p><strong>ADDIS ABABA, Ethiopia</strong> — From atop Mount Entoto, which rises 10,500 feet above sea level and draws thousands of pilgrims annually as one of this country’s most revered spiritual sites, it is impossible to look upon the sprawling capital below without sensing both the burden of Ethiopia’s history and the promise of its future.</p><p>Addis Ababa, meaning “new flower” in Amharic, has been shaped by forces both internal and external since its founding in 1887. They include a devastating 16-year civil war and communist tyranny, multiple foreign invasions, and chronic cycles of drought, flood and famine that contributed to more than a million deaths since 1970.</p><p>Today, 24 years since its last government overthrow and 30 years since its last crippling famine, the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia is enjoying relative peace and prosperity. Those conditions have helped Addis Ababa emerge as one of Africa’s political and economic superhubs alongside Johannesburg, Nairobi and Accra.</p><p>Unlike many of its sub-Saharan neighbors, however, which have embraced economic growth at the expense of environmental protections, Ethiopia has embarked on one of the world’s most ambitious green growth and climate mitigation programs.</p><p>Nothing like it has been tried before, much less in one of the world’s largest and poorest nations.</p><blockquote>“No other African country has even begun to make the level of commitment that Ethiopia has in reducing emissions,” Robert Mukiza, Ethiopia country director for the Global Green Growth Institute, said in a recent telephone interview from Addis.</blockquote><p>His organization is working with the government to help implement sustainability programs, including elements of Ethiopia’s Growth and Transformation Plan.</p><p>The blueprint for Ethiopia’s climate agenda, drafted by the government in 2011 and now being implemented across all levels of society — from the herding villages of the central highlands to the transit corridors of Addis — is embodied in a 15-page document called the “Climate-Resilient Green Economy strategy,” or CRGE.</p><p>Much more than an emissions plan, the CRGE is a multipronged development program that promises to hold Ethiopia’s greenhouse gases at 145 metric tons of CO2 equivalent per year over the next 15 years, while also lifting the country from among world’s poorest nations to achieve middle-income status by 2025.</p><p>The challenge is immense, the cost astronomical, and failure is a distinct possibility.</p><h3>A path to a low-carbon Africa?</h3><p>Consider that Ethiopia currently ranks 186th out of 198 countries in per-capita gross domestic product, and roughly a third of its estimated 94 million people live on less than $1.25 per day, according to recent World Bank estimates.</p><p>But no one, least of all Ethiopia’s prime minister, Hailemariam Desalegn, is bowing to the conventional wisdom that Ethiopia’s only path to climate security is through foreign aid agencies and nongovernmental organizations.</p><p>In fact, officials here argue the opposite, often invoking the words of the late Prime Minister Meles Zenawi. In 2009, he told U.N. climate delegates gathered in Copenhagen, Denmark, that Ethiopia would not stand by as Western nations develop and implement strategies to address the world’s most pressing environmental problem.</p><blockquote>“Africa is a continent of the future; it is destined to be a growth pole of the 21st century,” Zenawi declared.</blockquote><p>“We are therefore here not as victims of the past,” he added, “but as stakeholders of the future reaching out across the continents, so that together we can build a better and fairer future for all of us. … Africa is a green field that can and wants to chart a different course of development, one that is not carbon-intensive.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Now Ethiopia faces an early critical test of its climate commitments as it prepares to impose binding caps on greenhouse gas emissions for 2020 and beyond.</a></p><p>Those measures, spelled out in the country’s proposed emissions targets submitted to the United Nations in June, will be a focal point of the next round of U.N. climate negotiations happening in Paris in December.</p><p>The Paris meeting will differ from previous U.N. conclaves, most notably because developing countries like Ethiopia will for the first time have to take a measure of responsibility for addressing climate change and participate in multilateral strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.</p><p>Gone is the notion that poor nations, especially in Africa, cannot help solve the world’s environmental problems. In its place is an expectation that a country like Ethiopia, endowed with some of the continent’s greatest renewable energy resources, can and will develop a program to secure its own climate security while providing a model for its neighbors to follow.</p><h3>A city booms, but so does its emissions</h3><p>The stakes are high for Ethiopia and particularly Addis, where the city’s booming industrial, transportation and building sectors are potential sources of rising greenhouse gas emissions.</p><p>Today, those three sectors account for just 20 metric tons, or roughly 13.4 percent, of all of Ethiopia’s greenhouse gases, according to government estimates. That compares to 130 metric tons produced by the country’s agriculture and forestry sectors, the top two greenhouse gas emitters by volume.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*YYKm0KSt_1FieDM4.jpg" /><figcaption>Nearly 250,000 new housing units are coming online in Addis, which the government hopes will ease daily commutes for city-dwellers. Photo by Daniel Cusick.</figcaption></figure><p>But as is the case across much of Africa, rapid urbanization is tipping Ethiopia’s emissions profile.</p><p>“Urban growth is major issue, and even in the past with a smaller population and before the construction boom, there were challenges in the city of Addis with meeting sustainable development goals,” said Robi Redda, an adviser with the Climate and Development Knowledge Network who has worked with Ethiopian officials to craft a national emissions reduction strategy.</p><p>That’s because in terms of real growth, Addis Ababa is the engine that now drives Ethiopia. Recent projections call for more than a doubling of the region’s population — from 3.4 million to 8 million people — by 2020, while annual economic growth has reached double digits for a good part of the last decade, converting broad sections of Addis from hovels to high-rises.</p><p>It was inside one of those new developments, a five-star Radisson Blu, that Dessalegne Mesfin explained how Ethiopia intends to keep its economic engine revved while holding its carbon emissions to no more than 145 metric tons, or roughly 64 percent lower than what the country would emit under a business-as-usual growth scenario.</p><h3>Harnessing hydroelectric, wind and recycling power</h3><p>Mesfin is the former deputy director of Ethiopia’s Environmental Protection Authority, where he helped develop the CRGE. He is now a consultant on applying ecological principles to development, or “eco-economy.”</p><p>For Addis, Mesfin said, a key component of green growth will be converting the city’s underdeveloped manufacturing and service sectors into 21st-century hubs of technology, energy efficiency and supply-chain innovation.</p><p>The strategy includes new firms vying to serve Africa’s burgeoning computer, IT and medical fields, while also adopting ecosystem-based industrial zoning whereby one firm’s waste becomes another firm’s raw material. Pollution associated with solid waste disposal currently accounts for 13 percent of all emissions generated in the city.</p><p>For example, a leather tannery’s wastewater could be treated and converted into process water for a nearby manufacturer, or waste heat generated by a cement kiln could be recovered and used in a co-generation power plant.</p><blockquote>“In this way, it could be possible to leapfrog the historical Western model of development and address what your country in previous days couldn’t solve,” Mesfin explained.</blockquote><p>Firms that move into Ethiopia’s new eco-industrial parks will also receive 100 percent carbon-free energy, much of it coming from plants like the 6,000-megawatt Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam being built on the Blue Nile River near the Sudan border. The $5 billion hydropower project, expected to be operational by 2017, will deliver baseload power to Addis and other regions where the government has put development on a fast track and where incomes are expected to rise fastest.</p><p>A second massive hydropower project, the 1,870 MW Gilgel Gibe III Dam on the Omo River in southwestern Ethiopia, began delivering its first power last month.</p><p>Excess power from the two hydrodams, along with hundreds of megawatts of renewable energy coming from Ethiopia’s new wind farms and geothermal plants, will be sold both domestically and to neighboring countries, further enhancing Ethiopia’s green growth agenda, officials say.</p><h3>A ‘least-developed country’ tries to set a high bar</h3><p>Indeed, some here frame Ethiopia’s climate strategy as only partly stemming from a desire to protect the country from harm caused by climate change. An equally important part of the strategy is for Ethiopia to raise millions of dollars in revenue by tapping regional and international carbon markets.</p><p>“Ethiopia doesn’t say, ‘I will act only if developed countries are acting,’” Mesfin said. “Under the [CRGE] strategy, Ethiopia says, ‘I will act because the opportunity is here, now.’ That’s why it sets the bar high, even as a least-developed country.</p><p>“We don’t believe in a green economy that is separate from the rest of the economy,” he said. “Ethiopia believes in one mutually supportive and inseparably linked strategy. One cannot divide the country so that this section is for climate mitigation and this section is for economic development. Both must exist simultaneously.”</p><p>In key ways, Ethiopia’s development program borrows heavily from China’s model of growth, including an adherence to strong central planning and massive investments in infrastructure projects — like the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam — designed to meet social, environmental and economic priorities.</p><p>In Addis, the largest expression of that approach is an elevated ribbon of concrete and steel rail snaking through the city and converging at Meskel Square, Addis’ largest open-air market and gathering place for festivals, public events and occasional demonstrations.</p><p>The superstructure is sub-Saharan Africa’s first modern light rail transit (LRT) system, built at a cost of $475 million by the China Railway Engineering Corp., in partnership with the Ethiopian Railways Corp. The electric-powered rail line, 85 percent financed by the China Export-Import Bank, began carrying passengers last month along 10.5 linear miles of track linking the city’s northern and southern suburbs to the central city. An east-west line, nearly 11 miles in length, is expected to begin operating this month.</p><h3>Light rail transforming dirty transport</h3><p>Experts project that the light rail will help displace thousands of older motor vehicles, including gasoline- and diesel-powered cars, trucks, taxis and buses that pump roughly 1.4 million tons of carbon dioxide into the city’s air annually. Those vehicles account for 29 percent of Addis Ababa’s carbon footprint, according to a recently completed greenhouse gas inventory competed by the Addis Ababa City Government Environmental Protection Agency with support from the World Resources Institute and EchnoServe Consulting PLC.</p><p>Gifti Nadi, an Ethiopia-based consultant with C40, a collective of global cities that have committed to leadership on climate change, said Addis’ public transportation system has long relied on state-owned buses and more than 4,000 Toyota taxi vans, called “mini-buses,” that ply well-established routes and are cheap enough for average city dwellers to use.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*P6F7qcQT22ukWbNs.jpg" /><figcaption>Passengers wait to board the Addis Ababa Light Rail Transit, which Ethiopia hopes will displace 1.4 million tons of annual vehicle emissions. Photo by Marthe van der Wolf, courtesy of AP Images.</figcaption></figure><p>Now officials are looking for new strategies to reduce tailpipe emissions while helping to increase mobility. “For Addis, vehicles, especially old vehicles, are a real source of both congestion and pollution,” Nadi said.</p><p>The LRT will also allow aid in the pursuit of transit-oriented development in neighborhoods along the rail line and other designated corridors. Ethiopia’s Ministry of Urban Development, Housing and Construction, working alongside city officials, has initiated the completion of nearly 250,000 new housing units in the city, mostly in condominium blocks that are sprouting up across the central city and surrounding hillside neighborhoods. The new housing is expected to ease daily commutes for thousands of city dwellers while also raising new tax revenues to pay for the LRT.</p><p>On a July afternoon, in the shade of one of the LRT’s concrete flyovers near Meskel Square, a 26-year-old Ethiopian who identified himself only as Isaac offered his view on the as-yet-unfinished transit line.</p><p>“I am very happy for this [rail] to be built here,” said Isaac, who said he emigrated to Addis from northern Ethiopia’s Tigray Region, roughly 500 miles away, to complete graduate studies in chemistry at Addis Ababa University. “When I get on, it will be the first train [ride] in my life.”</p><p>For now, he is mostly walking and busing between home and school while trying to make extra cash as a disc jockey and selling recordings of his music. Asked if the LRT will help him move more easily around the city, he said, “If it goes where I need to go, I will use it.”</p><p>It remains an open question, though, whether large numbers of Addis Ababans will abandon traditional forms of transport for a modern LRT.</p><p>While the line’s construction has been highly visible and a source of pride and daily conversation among Ethiopians, reaching its projected capacity of 60,000 passengers per hour will require converting thousands of drivers and walkers into riders.</p><p>Concerns have also been raised about existing residents, many of whom are seeing their neighborhoods reconfigured with the advance of new residential and commercial development.</p><p>But experts like Nadi remain optimistic. She said Ethiopia’s shift to a new way of urban living has been happening for about a decade, and residents are adjusting to the conditions.</p><p>“Addis Ababa has been a melting pot for hundreds of thousands of people, coming from all corners of the country in search of better employment opportunities and services,” she said. “With major infrastructure projects designed to reduce the negative impacts of climate change, the co-benefit is an improved quality of life for all.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p><em>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing, LLC</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=136c60cb0b72" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/30-years-after-famine-and-strife-ethiopia-sees-a-future-that-is-bright-green-136c60cb0b72">30 years after famine and strife, Ethiopia sees a future that is bright green</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can a country planning 80 coal-fired power plants get serious about climate change?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/can-a-country-planning-80-coal-fired-power-plants-get-serious-about-climate-change-dcada046af5f?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dcada046af5f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cop21]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Oct 2015 15:45:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-09T15:43:23.540Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xkLWiBib7NGPQHQV0qF8Rw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Atilla Suzer</figcaption></figure><p><em>by </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/staff/Lisa_Friedman"><em>Lisa Friedman</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw"><em>ClimateWire</em></a><em> — a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p>ISTANBUL — Driving along the E5 highway, this ancient city’s jumble of concrete block high-rises and Ottoman-domed mosques recedes into the distance. The future gleams.</p><p>Sleek luxury condominiums and shopping malls tower over modern new suburbs. Orange construction cranes have taken up residence along the side of the roads, feeding the teeming city’s seemingly endless building boom.</p><p>Fueling Istanbul’s growth — and, as the country’s economic center, Turkey’s development, as well — is coal. With the second-highest energy consumption growth after China, Turkey is highly dependent on Russian and Iranian oil and gas. Even as the country works to take advantage of its location between Europe and Asia to become a regional energy corridor, the government is also banking heavily on coal to power the future.</p><p>The Turkish government is planning to double its coal power capacity over the next four years, making it the country with the world’s third-largest investment in the fossil fuel, according to a Turkish energy consulting group. Plans for 80 new plants will quadruple the number of coal-fired power plants from the 22 currently online.</p><p>“That is the only natural resource that we have in this country,” said Volkan Ediger, a professor at Kadir Has University in Istanbul and a former energy adviser to three Turkish presidents. He noted that Turkey produces just a quarter of the energy it consumes, spending $60 billion per year on imports, a massive chunk of gross domestic product.</p><p>“This is not sustainable for the next century. The No. 1 priority for the Turkish energy system is independent energy sources,” he said.</p><p>“It’s a very important issue for Turkey. It’s much more important than any other thing. It’s more important than the climate change, than the environment, than anything else.”</p><h3>‘We don’t hear climate change’</h3><p>Government leaders appear to feel the same. State figures show that Turkey’s emissions grew a shocking 110 percent between 1990 and 2013, the bulk of it from the energy sector — particularly cement production. Meanwhile, according to researchers at the Climate Action Tracker, Turkey’s carbon pollution is expected to increase by 134 percent by 2030.</p><p>That’s hardly consistent with a new global change agreement that will be signed in Paris in December, or calls from wealthy countries to decarbonize the world’s energy systems by the century’s end. Under the new accord, all countries — particularly major emerging economies like Turkey — are expected to announce new curbs on greenhouse gas emissions.</p><p>With the Group of 20 (G-20) meeting slated for the city of Antalya just ahead of the Paris talks, Turkey will be under pressure to show that it takes its climate responsibilities seriously. But environmental activists say they are not optimistic.</p><p>“Turkey’s government never, ever puts climate change on the agenda. They see climate change as a threat to their political standing and not a threat to the country,” said Özgür Gürbüz, the World Wide Fund for Nature’s communication chief in Turkey.</p><p>“They want to build lots of motorways, bridges, mega-projects. Their election campaign promises are all based on fossil fuels. We don’t hear climate change, we don’t hear public transportation,” he said.</p><p>“Twenty years from now, people will look at Turkey and say, ‘What are you going to do now, close all the coal plants you just opened?’”</p><p>Many activists said that far from figuring out its responsibility in a decarbonizing world, Turkey appears more concerned with pumping out as much coal as it can before regulations are imposed on the country.</p><blockquote>“This is the Turkish mentality. When we see a yellow light, we speed up instead of slowing down,” one Turkish energy researcher joked.</blockquote><h3>Airports, bridges and a ‘slaughtered’ forest</h3><p>Perhaps no place exposes the tension over Turkey’s rampant development more than the site of a planned third airport on the outskirts of Istanbul’s European side.</p><p>Slated to become the world’s third biggest, the 29 square miles of land has already been cleared of trees.</p><p>Onur Akgül, an activist with the Northern Forest Defense, which has been fighting the airport, a third bridge over the Bosporus and a motorway that will cut through Istanbul’s forested north, describes the barren land as an “open wound” where forests once stood.</p><blockquote>“They slaughtered the whole forest,” he said.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*xwASTsCynb6Uah1r.jpg" /><figcaption>A villager outside Yeniköy points to open-pit coal mines that are being filled in as part of the construction of a third airport outside Istanbul that environmentalists say is exacerbating Turkey’s climate contribution. <em>Photo by Lisa Friedman.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Some villagers agree. Hayri Koyuncu, 53, points to a vast expanse of grassland around the town of Yeniköy that will soon be airport. His family has been in the Black Sea region since 1924, for decades working in animal husbandry and farming.</p><p>“In these days, the beans and vegetables that were flooding the market for Istanbul were produced here. We had cows, animals, we were very happy. This village took care of itself,” Koyuncu said. “My opinion is, if the airport is constructed, the freedom of the village people will be ended. Because for someone to be free, he has to survive with the natural resources.”</p><p>On the other hand, Handi Akyuz, an Istanbul taxi driver, said he wants to see even more mega-projects.</p><p>“It’s not enough. Even a third bridge is not enough. We need four bridges, five,” Akyuz said, navigating Istanbul’s notorious congestion.</p><p>Ozcan Omural, head of business development for the Mapa Construction and Trade Company Inc., one of the five companies involved in building the airport, said Turkey deserves the same prosperity Western countries have achieved by cutting forests and building coal plants. Like many Turks, he found the global environmental criticism facing Turkey just as its economy is taking off suspicious.</p><p>“Turkey is a developing country, and of course it needs infrastructure. The city has to grow somewhere, and you have to build new places,” he said. “In my opinion, I believe they bring those rules to control the developing countries’ industrialization.”</p><h3>A country hiding behind ‘a special circumstance’</h3><p>In the international climate negotiations, Turkey plays a unique and sometimes isolated role.</p><p>When the Kyoto Protocol was established in 1997, creating two categories of countries — industrialized or “Annex A” nations expected to take mandatory emissions cuts and developing “non-Annex A” countries off the hook entirely — Turkey somehow found itself in both groups.</p><p>Turkish officials maintain it was simply a clerical error. Others say it happened because the country’s negotiators were poorly prepared and assumed it was in Turkey’s best interest to be linked to wealthy nations. As soon as leaders realized the implications of the decision, they tried to back out.</p><p>For the next several years, Turkey had a single-minded focus: getting out of Annex A. It succeeded in 2001 and was granted a “special circumstance.” In the years since, analysts say, the country has laid low.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*5TT8gOmlDIbLo3E9.jpg" /><figcaption>New housing, shopping malls and office towers are a common sight around Istanbul, where the construction craze has helped boost Turkey’s gross domestic product 230 percent since 1990. Photo by Atilla Suzer.</figcaption></figure><p>The government rarely offers ideas for tackling difficult issues in the talks — its most recent submission was in 2013 — and its delegation is usually among the first to fly home from negotiating sessions. At the most recent talks in Lima, Peru, last year, the only notable intervention Turkey made was when its chief negotiator threatened a veto if talks went past 5 p.m.</p><p>“Let’s keep our heads down, and maybe no one will notice us. That’s been our position, I feel,” said Mahir Ilgaz of 350.org, an environmental group. Several efforts to interview members of Turkey’s negotiating team were unsuccessful.</p><p>Liz Gallagher, who leads the climate diplomacy project at E3G, a U.K.-based advocacy group, said Turkey doesn’t align itself with the hard-liners in the U.N. talks or the progressive nations or even regional neighbors.</p><blockquote>“In the climate negotiations, it’s quite difficult to box them in. They’re sort of on their own,” she said. “In some ways, it’s turning into Russia, becoming more obstinate. On a geopolitical level, it doesn’t much care what the rest of the world thinks about it.”</blockquote><p>But, Gallagher said, “they are going to be forced into the spotlight at the G-20, and they are going to be forced to talk about climate change, and they don’t have anything to say, frankly.”</p><h3>There is a way, but is there a will?</h3><p>Yet it’s not as if Turkey has done zilch on the clean energy front. In 2010, the government implemented a renewable energy law aimed at increasing the share of clean energy to 30 percent by 2023, incentivized by feed-in tariff rates. A separate energy strategy blueprint set out goals to reduce primary energy intensity by 20 percent in 2023 compared with 2008.</p><p>Environmentalists grouse that renewables already represent 29 percent of the mix, making the target negligible. They also maintain the government limited licenses for solar and wind while giving legal and financial incentives to coal.</p><p>But Adonai Herrera-Martinez, working with the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development in Turkey, said the government has been eager to work with a sustainable energy initiative that develops credit lines to support small energy companies and energy efficiency projects. And Tanay Sidki Uyar, president of Eurosolar Turkey, says he is certain the country can go to 100 percent renewables by 2023.</p><p>“Turkey can go to 100 percent renewable energy a little bit earlier than California. This is possible. Renewable technologies have grown and are competing when compared with fossil fuels,” Uyar said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*YkkbcHJVrpvU5_zq.jpg" /><figcaption>Construction of a third bridge across the Bosporus has sparked controversy in Turkey. Photo courtesy of Wikipedia.</figcaption></figure><p>Construction of a third bridge across the Bosporus has sparked controversy in Turkey. “Even a third bridge is not enough. We need four bridges, five,” said one taxi driver. Environmentalists disagree and argue that such mega-projects fuel more pollution.</p><p>But getting there is going to depend on what policies the government implements in the coming years, as well as its target for Paris. Environmentalists, for their part, wanted to see Turkey set a year by which its emissions will peak, but those hopes were flatly dashed when the government released a Paris target of only cutting emissions “up to” 21 percent from business-as-usual levels by 2030.</p><p>Activists quickly calculated that this will lead to Turkey’s emissions reaching 11 tons — rising as much as 116 percent — by 2030. Gürbüz tweeted that the contribution “offers nothing.”</p><p>Gürkan Kumbaroglu, incoming president of the International Association for Energy Economics who has been leading the modeling for the Turkish government’s Paris pledge, said he still hopes Turkey can be part of a global solution to climate change. But, he said, it must change its embrace of coal and remove hurdles for clean power for that to happen.</p><p>“Turkey’s renewable energy potential is much larger than European countries. From energy efficiency to wind to solar, there’s much potential to exploit in Turkey,” he said. “But right now, if you want to put solar panels on your roof, it’s a huge bureaucratic hassle. You have to get a license like you’re making a second floor of your house.</p><p>“By 2025, I would like energy intensity growth to change radically, to come down to levels comparable with European countries. And by 2025, a large portion of renewables should be specified by a carbon price,” he said. “If Turkey goes the sustainable development path, this could set an example to other Middle Eastern countries.”</p><p>WWF’s Gürbüz said activists need to fight the narrative popular in Turkey that it is being asked to take on an unfair burden.</p><p>“I think it’s a deliberate misunderstanding, actually,” he said. “We don’t want Turkey to save the world. We want every single country to do whatever they can do. If you want to clean the street, you must sweep the floor of your own house.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p><em>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing, LLC</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dcada046af5f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/can-a-country-planning-80-coal-fired-power-plants-get-serious-about-climate-change-dcada046af5f">Can a country planning 80 coal-fired power plants get serious about climate change?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Chile, solar power lights the way to a cleaner, more competitive economy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/in-chile-solar-power-lights-the-way-to-a-cleaner-more-competitive-economy-982d35b508a5?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/982d35b508a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cop21]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Oct 2015 15:31:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-09T15:30:15.728Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yhfSxnGVWi1C3-mH-_wOyg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Ines Perez</figcaption></figure><p><em>by Ines Perez, E&amp;E correspondent, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/cw"><em>ClimateWire</em></a><em> — a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p>CALAMA, Chile — About 765 miles north of Santiago in the Atacama Desert, the Gabriela Mistral recreational center emerges as an unexpected touch of modernity among the sandy-colored mountains. Down a path of crushed stone leading to the cafeteria, the site is peppered with circle-shaped patterns made up of bluish-green rocks — a telltale sign of the presence of copper oxide.</p><p>Since opening in 2009, the striking installations at the Gabriela Mistral mine — or Minera Gaby — have been a source of praise for their innovative approach to mining and community development. More recently, Gaby has drawn the attention of scholars and government officials as an unconventional yet practical example of how climate-change-related measures are not only necessary, but also can be economically convenient.</p><p>In 2013, CODELCO inaugurated what was then the world’s largest thermosolar plant, Pampa Elvira Solar, to provide Minera Gaby renewable energy for its operations. With 2,620 glass and aluminum collectors arranged in the shape of CODELCO’s corporate logo — a large Venus symbol, the alchemical symbol for copper — the plant delivers 85 percent of the power needed for the hydrometallurgical process used to produce copper.</p><p>As a result, the mine not only cut back its diesel costs, but it started producing “greener,” premium-quality copper cathodes that are competitive in more aggressive carbon emission reduction-prone markets, such as Europe.</p><p>“We are at a crucial point in the division,” explained Alan Brell Salgado, representative of CODELCO’s Gabriela Mistral division. “Our carbon footprint is a very important topic for us, as we are taking the steps to obtain our certification and negotiating with the European market, which is stricter than the Chinese.”</p><p>In the wake of declining demand from China, the world’s largest copper market, the opportunities of a new market opening up send a strong signal to the mining sector. The industry has now found an unusual ally in nonconventional renewables. In Chile’s case, the economic benefits of going green have also been heightened by a recent push from the presidency to meet the country’s greenhouse gas emissions targets.</p><p>“This administration, [Michelle] Bachelet’s administration, is really prioritizing climate change in a way that no other previous administration has done, including her first administration,” said Amanda Maxwell, Latin America project director at the Natural Resources Defense Council, a nonprofit international environmental advocacy group based in New York City.</p><p>But the shift to a cleaner, more sustainable energy sector is easier said than done here.</p><blockquote>“A lot of people would agree that Chile doesn’t have an energy generation problem, they have an energy transmission problem going forward,” Maxwell said, referring to an aging and inefficient electric grid. “I think people are starting to think about the depth of the changes that will be needed in order to allow renewables to really participate on an even playing field.”</blockquote><p>Advocates say it’s slowly beginning to pay off.</p><h3>Developing a ‘third way’ of climate politics</h3><p>Chile may not be the kind of country that comes to mind when discussing the future of climate change. Its annual emissions are 40 times smaller than China’s and 30 times smaller than the output of India. Its economy, while long the strongest in Latin America, does not make the country a global powerhouse of political influence.</p><p>Still, <a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Chile is beginning to play a pivotal role on the global stage.</a></p><p>Chile’s share of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions amounts only to 0.28 percent. But per-capita emissions have been on the rise over the last two decades. According to the country’s latest emissions report, emissions have increased by 83.5 percent since 1990. That makes it the second-largest per-capita climate polluter in Latin America, behind Venezuela, with an average of 5.3 tons per person. As the country continues to develop, these numbers are expected to grow.</p><p>Chilean President Michelle Bachelet is “prioritizing climate change in a way that no other previous administration has done,” according to one activist. Photo courtesy of Wikipedia.</p><p>After a contentious 2009 climate summit in Copenhagen, Denmark — which ended without a binding treaty after bitter battles between nations — Chile put its eggs in a new basket. It participated in the formation of a group called the Cartagena Dialogue, an informal space for countries committed to a low-carbon economy to work on a legally binding regime in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. It also became a member of the National Alliance of Latin America and Caribbean Communities (AILAC), which promotes the need for nations to take part in climate mitigation actions.</p><p>“What I think is really great about Chile, and its partners in [AILAC], as well, is that they are saying, ‘Climate change is a problem, but we need to develop. We are willing to make a transformation to low-carbon economies, but we need support,’” said Guy Edwards, research fellow at the Institute at Brown for Environment and Society and co-director of the Climate and Development Lab at Brown University.</p><p>“And I think this line of discussion, especially in the U.N. climate talks, is seen as a third way,” he said.</p><p>At the U.N. climate summit in New York in September 2014, Bachelet reiterated the country’s commitment to reducing carbon emissions and set an international precedent by announcing public consultations for Chile’s contributions to a new climate agreement that is expected to be signed in Paris at the end of this year.</p><p>The final target submitted to the United Nations at the end of September ultimately was less ambitious than some of the draft options that the Chilean government had circulated. The goal aims for a 30 percent cut in carbon intensity by 2030 based on 2007 levels. That target is unconditional, but Chile said it could go even further with financial assistance. At the same time, it pledged to reforest 100,000 hectares of forest.</p><p>In a blog post, the NRDC called the unilateral goal a “safe, conservative bet which Chile can meet and certainly exceed,” and called on Chile to meet the more ambitious end of its target. Still, the group and others said the energy conversation happening in Chile, particularly its call for public consultations, is a big step.</p><p>“I think Chile’s efforts are blurring the lines between domestic and foreign policy, and how climate change is an issue for both arenas to tackle simultaneously,” said Edwards. “As we gear up for Paris, the [AILAC] countries are going to be potentially key partners to be pushing for a higher-ambition agreement.”</p><h3>Institutionalizing climate action at home</h3><p>Chile’s climate diplomacy spurs changes at home.</p><p>In 2008, Chile launched its first National Climate Change Action Plan, for the period from 2008 to 2014, to gather information on what was happening in the country, identify the baselines for emissions cuts and measure other key variables. But the biggest change came in 2010, when the Ministry of Environment was finally created, according to Paola Vasconi, a climate change specialist and coordinator of political affairs at Adapt-Chile.</p><p>“Chile was one of the last Latin American countries to create a ministry of environment,” Vasconi explained. “In a way, the creation of the ministry helped institutionalize climate change at a national level.”</p><p>Since then, the ministry has launched several projects, in collaboration with other ministries, to define and promote the government’s climate agenda. In 2011, it launched its Mitigation Action Plans and Scenarios program, or MAPS Chile, to determine the baseline for the country’s greenhouse gas emissions under business-as-usual conditions from 2007 to 2030. Those projections on how the Chilean economy would evolve without any efforts to reduce its greenhouse gases are expected to help define different mitigation measures and possible scenarios.</p><p>Officials have also been working on an update to the National Climate Change Action Plan, for the period from 2016 to 2021, oriented to the implementation and funding of mitigation and adaptation actions contemplated in Chile’s intended nationally determined contributions. The ministry also recently launched a project to determine how much the government has been indirectly spending on climate-change-related measures, as well as one to standardize the way companies calculate their carbon footprint.</p><p>Most importantly, because of the presidency’s explicit support, other ministries have also been taking on a more active role on climate change, Vasconi said. Progress began with the energy sector.</p><h3>Unlocking green investments in a free-market economy</h3><p>With the creation of the Ministry of Energy, also in 2010, the government launched an aggressive campaign to restructure the energy sector and define its agenda. The ministry recently submitted to the Chilean Congress legislation aimed at tackling energy efficiency.</p><p>Perhaps the most significant change occurred in 2014 with the modification of the bidding process for power generation projects. The reform split the hours of generation between day and night shifts, finally unlocking investments in solar. The country also introduced a carbon tax on generation and vehicle emissions, its top two emitting sectors.</p><blockquote>“What Chile did was create an environment that enables green investments,” said Marcelo Mena-Carrasco, undersecretary of environment.</blockquote><p>Specifically, the tax on power generation includes a fixed cost of $5 per ton of carbon dioxide, plus a variable tax based on the pollution and environmental damage to the community where the plant is located.</p><p>“The second tax to power generation has a strong market signal effect, because you are adding the cost of negative externalities to the electricity generation,” he explained. This, according to Mena-Carrasco, levels the field between renewables and conventional generation in terms of operational costs.</p><p>From his office at the Ministry of Environment’s building, near the Palacio de La Moneda — the seat of the president — in Santiago, Mena-Carrasco has become a key advocate within the government for cross-ministry climate action. He has had to learn to navigate the murky waters of bureaucracy to sell the ministry’s mitigation and adaptation initiatives.</p><p>“In a free-market economy, it makes sense to a lot of people when you say that not having a green tax is a hidden subsidy, and that’s something that at least resonates among the more conservative economists,” Mena-Carrasco said.</p><p>As the agency works on its new energy policy, Energía 2050, there is growing evidence that climate actions can mesh with the country’s development goals. Targets like a 30 percent reduction in energy costs by the end of the current administration, 20 percent in savings on energy consumption through energy efficiency and a goal to achieve 20 percent generation from nonconventional renewables by 2025 are already being implemented to make Chile more competitive, Mena-Carrasco explained. They are also vital to Chile’s climate policy.</p><h3>Will Chile’s grid stand in the way of its own progress?</h3><p>After a timid start, the approval of the “Law 20/25” in 2013 — which set a target of 20 percent nonconventional renewable energy (NCRE) generation by 2025 — triggered a boom in NCRE, according to data from the Chilean Association of Renewable Energy (ACERA).</p><p>In 2014, NCRE practically doubled its installed capacity in December 2013, reaching 2,097 megawatts by December 2014. By May 2015, installed capacity reached 2,270 MW, with an additional 2,000 MW reported in construction. Experts say these statistics point to an estimated investment of $4 billion a year in NCRE, between 2014 and 2015 alone.</p><p>“Recent studies show that Chile has an estimated potential of more than 1.8 million MW in NCRE projects, including solar technology PV [photovoltaics], CSP [concentrated solar power], wind, mini-hydro, biogas/biomass, geothermal and marine,” said Carlos Finat, executive director at ACERA.</p><p>“This potential supports that in a reasonable time, by 2050, for example, the country could have an energy matrix based 100 percent on renewable energy, both conventional and unconventional,” he said. But that reinforces the need to update Chile’s electrical grid.</p><p>After the grid’s privatization in the 1980s, new transmission lines were built catering to specific projects — particularly energy-hungry mines in the north. Meanwhile, cities were electrified almost as an afterthought. This led to an inflexible energy matrix, with serious shortcomings in transmission and little consideration for renewables. These are expensive issues.</p><p>In April, the government approved an expansion plan that calls for the construction of a transmission line that would connect Chile’s Central Interconnected System grid and northern Interconnected System of Norte Grande grid, and bring the clean energy in the north to the rest of the country. According to the National Energy Commission, the interconnection project has an estimated cost of $1 billion. And this is just one of the projects under construction.</p><h3>A glassy economic oasis in the desert</h3><p>Despite the cost, the value of solar power remains a bargain. Chile produces about a third of the world’s copper, and mining is by far the sector with the biggest demand of energy, representing almost 30 percent of total energy consumption. That number is expected to double by 2025, according to recent reports.</p><p>“The mining process itself uses a lot of electricity, but it also uses a lot of heat,” explained Cesar Belaunde, project manager at Energía Llaima, the company that owns and operates the Pampa Elvira thermosolar plant for Minera Gaby.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*LoQeiKvfQ1R8YVLr.jpg" /><figcaption>Photo courtesy of AP images</figcaption></figure><p>Covering almost 970,000 square feet of dry, rough terrain, Pampa Elvira stands out as a glassy oasis at the driest place on Earth. With the highest solar radiation in the world concentrated in the Atacama Desert, its collectors feed the mine more than enough heat necessary for the copper extraction process known as electrowinning.</p><p>An acid solution rich in copper called an electrolyte is heated to 47 degrees Celsius and pumped to a tank with insoluble lead plates and stainless-steel sheets. A direct current is then applied between the lead plates and stainless steel, causing the copper ions in the electrolyte solution to attach themselves onto the sheets. Thus obtaining the copper cathodes.</p><p>“Electrolytic copper is one of the purest coppers that can be obtained with the processes we have in Chile,” said Belaunde. And now, with thermosolar, it’s also a bit greener.</p><p>The benefits of using thermosolar power in mining processes are many. In the case of Minera Gaby, for example, the 39,300-square-meter solar plant can substitute about 80 percent of the fossil fuel used to heat the electrolyte solution with thermosolar power, saving up to 6,500 tons of diesel a year. By burning less diesel, Minera Gaby has also cut back its CO2 emissions by nearly 15,000 tons a year.</p><p>More importantly, “you get premium copper,” Belaunde added.</p><h3>Can greening the copper mines green the country?</h3><p>China’s economic deceleration, and the consistent drop in international copper prices, has led private mining companies in Chile to reduce their investments in new projects. As the <em>Financial Times</em> pointed out in April, this has left CODELCO with the burden of keeping up Chile’s share of the world market.</p><p>Earlier this year, the corporation raised $4 billion to finance new structural projects, spanning through 2025. According to Brell Salgado, now is as good a time as any to innovate and look for alternatives that would make the business much more sustainable and more resilient to the fluctuations in China’s demand for copper.</p><p>“The vision at the division today is that we are looking at a completely different scenario than we had yesterday. Today, we are betting to play in another league with copper of better quality, more efficient and more cost effective that will allow us to be more competitive and environmentally friendly,” Brell Salgado said. But this change in attitude didn’t happen overnight.</p><p>“It took us 11 years to convince CODELCO of doing it,” said Roberto Roman, solar energy expert and associate professor at the University of Chile. “But it’s finally catching on.”</p><p>According to Belaunde, Energía Llaima recently closed a deal with Minera Zaldívar — an open-pit copper mine in the Antofagasta region owned and operated by Barrick Gold Corp. — to install and operate a large thermosolar plant. There are currently only three thermosolar plants in Chile operating in copper mines; the fourth one will be in Zaldívar.</p><p>“I think there is an opportunity to take leadership in the particular topic of solar energy and mining,” said Roman. The model being implemented at Minera Gaby is evidence that climate change initiatives, such as pushing for cleaner energy, can have multiple economic benefits beyond reducing emissions. Market-wise, it’s smart business.</p><p>Chile has a long road ahead to solidify its climate change policy beyond the walls of the Ministry of Environment. As many civil society groups and officials point out, without a proper climate change law, it will be hard to steer powerful ministries like Finance and Economy away from their “business as usual”-oriented ways to a low-carbon future. But the fact that a conservative sector such as mining, famously resistant to change, has found a way to make the green business work for it shows a promising start.</p><p>“I think there is a huge opportunity in this regard, and many people are beginning to see it that way,” Roman said. “They realize that it is not a business issue of one mine, two mines, but a change in how you are going to do things, and that opens up opportunities that would be a shame for the country to lose out on.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing, LLC</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=982d35b508a5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/in-chile-solar-power-lights-the-way-to-a-cleaner-more-competitive-economy-982d35b508a5">In Chile, solar power lights the way to a cleaner, more competitive economy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The pending Paris accord: not your father’s climate agreement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/greater-expectations/the-pending-paris-accord-not-your-father-s-climate-agreement-ba46c40841b4?source=rss----5e14601ce4d0---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ba46c40841b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cop21]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[E&E News]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Oct 2015 17:12:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-09T15:31:24.427Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K41dJ1zSBCNpmaIU6ZyQjw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>By </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/staff/Lisa_Friedman"><em>Lisa Friedman</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060025955"><em>ClimateWire </em></a><em>— a publication of </em><a href="http://www.eenews.net/"><em>E&amp;E Publishing</em></a></p><p>By the time Ambassador Karl Hood took the microphone on a warm South African evening in December 2011, many hours into a marathon overtime U.N. climate change negotiation, he had just about enough.</p><p>For days, major emerging economies led by India had pushed back against efforts to launch a new deal that included all nations, insisting they should not be forced to cut greenhouse gas emissions. Wealthy countries have not done enough to fight climate change, they argued, and poorer nations must have the right to develop with unrestricted fossil fuel use.</p><p>Those representing the most vulnerable countries — like Hood’s tiny island of Grenada — disagreed, but were reluctant to rupture the united front developing nations presented to the world. The role of battling China, India and other advancing powers was usually left up to the United States and Europe. Hood decided something had to change.</p><p>“I was listening [and] thinking, ‘If only a country could pollute their own atmosphere, that’s fine. But if we’re all going to pay the price of it, somebody needs to be responsible here.’ I didn’t feel that I should keep my mouth shut. I felt somebody had to stand up,” Hood said from Beijing, where he now serves as Grenada’s ambassador to China.</p><p>Stand up he did, arguing that night that all countries have a responsibility to keep global temperatures at safe levels, and no one — even historically low emitters — should have a right to unchecked development.</p><blockquote>“While they develop, we die. And why should we accept this?” he asked a packed plenary hall of surprised diplomats.</blockquote><p>Hood’s intervention was the climax of a long-standing fight over whether developing nations should play a stronger hand in abating the greenhouse gas emissions that scientists say are warming the planet. As it set in motion a new international accord that could be completed in Paris in December, it also underscored a rupture that has only deepened within the Group of 77 and China, nominally representing the interests of all developing nations.</p><p>When leaders from 194 countries meet in Paris, they will find a starkly different landscape than the one under which the 1997 Kyoto Protocol was crafted, or even the messy and incomplete Copenhagen Accord of 2009.</p><p>In interviews with dozens of ministers, negotiators and longtime U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) observers over the past year, most agreed that the once neatly divided world of rich and poor countries is gone.</p><h3>‘It’s everybody together’</h3><p>In its place is a more complicated and dynamic system in which countries of all levels of wealth and development are figuring out not whether to shoulder responsibility but at what level and how to finance the transition to clean power.</p><p>“Yes, there used to be the poor guys and the rich guys, the polluters and the guys that are feeling the impact. That kind of division of blame and labor,” said Marshall Islands Foreign Minister Tony de Brum.</p><p>But, he said, “It’s not us and the big guys anymore. It’s everybody together.”</p><p>So far, 138 countries, including the members of the European Union, have come forward with plans to cut or ratchet down their emissions, and there will likely be a few more that will be wrapped into a final document to be signed in Paris.</p><p>That, de Brum and others said, would have been unthinkable just a few years ago. The list includes not just big players like the United States and China, but also war-torn countries like Rwanda, tiny islands like Tuvalu and poverty-stricken nations like Bangladesh.</p><p>“This framing that it’s rich versus poor makes it sound like it’s only the rich countries who have to act, who have to pay, or who are acting and paying. It’s a much more complex picture than that,” said Jennifer Morgan, global director of the World Resources Institute’s climate program.</p><p>Under the radar are the countries in the middle — those who are not yet making an emissions splash, but whose rapid economic and carbon growth guarantees they will be among the major climate players of the future.</p><h3>Most move toward ‘mutual dependency’</h3><p>They include countries like Turkey, which is putting coal-fired power plants online just as fast as neighboring Europe can shut them down; Mexico, where an ambitious plan to peak emissions may be hampered by a newly liberalized energy market; and Singapore, which boasts the world’s third-largest per-capita gross domestic product but remains reluctant to put its wealth at jeopardy in order to tackle domestic emissions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*LLTWIUosHAa9wBhb.png" /><figcaption>By 2030, developing countries’ emissions will exceed those of industrialized countries by 77 percent. Here’s what that growth will look like in six key countries. Data courtesy of the Climate Action Tracker.</figcaption></figure><p>It’s countries like Chile, which is seeking a major expansion of its renewable energy capacity even as it struggles with an aging and inefficient transmission infrastructure. Or Ethiopia, which has grand designs to be a middle-income country by 2025 while remaining carbon neutral but is still grappling with more than 25 million people in poverty.</p><p>Whether those countries as well as major players like India — still wed to coal despite renewable energy ambitions — can meet their targets and continue decarbonizing will be the real determinant of whether Paris is a success.</p><p>Over the next seven days, <em>ClimateWire’s</em> “<a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations</a>” series will examine the very different positions those countries have taken in the U.N. climate negotiations and how their international strategies have affected their domestic efforts on climate change. We will also look beyond Paris to the on-the-ground realities of the political and structural challenges they face.</p><p>“The UNFCCC process has been a proxy for a difficult discussion of trying to move countries away from the old North-South paradigm and into a paradigm of mutual dependency,” said Connie Hedegaard, the former European commissioner for climate change who helped lead the charge for a new global agreement in Paris.</p><p>“If you look at it through a human development lens, you will see the world is not organized along old categories. It’s much more complex,” she said.</p><h3>The realities that upset the old order</h3><p>The shifts in alliances in the U.N. negotiations came slowly at first, and then seemingly all at once.</p><p>The Kyoto Protocol divided the world into categories, or annexes. Annex I, 15 rich nations and European Union, would be charged with mandatory obligations to cut emissions. Hundreds of others, non-Annex I countries, could act voluntarily but were not obligated. Developing countries were allied in their insistence that wealthy countries, which had spewed carbon dioxide into the atmosphere for a century, should clean up the global mess they alone made.</p><p>By Copenhagen, that architecture was already straining at the seams. The United States never ratified Kyoto because of it, and while environmental groups pilloried the Bush administration for that decision, when President Obama came into office they were no more willing than their predecessors to get into another deal that treated America differently from China.</p><p>But longtime observers said it wasn’t just the relentless assault on the system from the United States, Japan and Europe that caused its fissures. Emissions from developing countries zoomed — with China’s alone growing 80 percent between 1990 and 2007, according to the International Energy Agency, displacing America as the world’s largest climate polluter.</p><p>Meanwhile, the impacts on vulnerable nations were becoming real. Island leaders, who had for years been pressing quietly within their caucus for more action from everyone, started to get publicly vocal.</p><p>“The differences have become starker,” said Jake Schmidt, international program director at the Natural Resources Defense Council. “There is a clear sense among many developing countries that the ‘just say no’ position doesn’t serve their interests anymore. That it was fine 15 years ago to say the West has to act on this problem because it’s all their fault, but the math doesn’t work that way anymore. These lines have been blurred without anybody admitting it.”</p><p>Others said the shifts also happened because developing countries were forced to face the reality that industrialized countries were no longer willing to move forward alone.</p><h3>… And caused old alliances to crumble</h3><p>“It’s becoming less and less a confrontation between rich and poor and that I think is partly for a disappointing reason,” said Yvo de Boer, the United Nations’ former climate chief and now head of the Global Green Growth Institute in South Korea.</p><p>“Developing countries are beginning to realize that this process is highly unlikely to provide them what they need to green their economies and cope with the impacts of climate change,” he said. “They’re realizing they are on their own.”</p><p>De Boer noted that the G-77, led by China, has been instrumental in keeping developing countries unified and bolstering their influence in U.N. arenas. But, he acknowledged, when it comes to climate negotiations, keeping together an alliance with countries as diverse as Saudi Arabia, “for whom every drop of oil not sold has an impact on the economy,” to Kiribati, where every ton of emissions into the atmosphere is a death knell, hasn’t been easy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/298/0*EfvQMS7PEj-WLaOt.png" /><figcaption>While India’s emissions have spiked most dramatically since 1997, other major developing countries have also seen major increases in their climate output in the last two decades. Data courtesy of the Climate Action Tracker.</figcaption></figure><p>“Finding a compromise in such a large group is very, very difficult. For a long time, it was worth it because the G-77 were not only standing shoulder to shoulder in the climate debate, but in every other U.N. forum, as well,” he said.</p><p>“If you stick with the group on the negotiations of fried eggs, they will stand with you on the negotiations over boiled eggs.”</p><p>But by the time a 2009 summit in Copenhagen, Denmark, dissolved into chaos with a group of hard-line nations led by Bolivia, Venezuela and Sudan blocking the formal adoption of a deal, some countries understood there must be change.</p><p>Costa Rica, Ethiopia, Switzerland and more than two dozen other countries that saw themselves as “constructive” players formed a coalition called the Cartagena Dialogue. Out of that, a group of Latin American nations that also included Chile, Peru and Colombia started making the case within the G-77 that developing countries should take mandatory cuts. The major emerging nations of Brazil, India, South Africa and China strengthened their alliance, and oil-producing countries like Saudi Arabia and Venezuela joined forces with China and India to beat back progressive efforts.</p><p>Each formed new formal blocs within the G-77, pulling the body in multiple directions at once.</p><p>“This is a really interesting process in which the former bloc in which the economies used to be organized, now in the climate debate is completely different,” said Peruvian Environment Minister Manuel Pulgar-Vidal.</p><h3>Will the resulting strategies be ambitious enough?</h3><p>“For those of us who work in the real world, it’s not about ideological point-scoring. It’s about getting the politics right and the pricing right,” said Malini Mehra, chief executive of the Global Legislators Organization for a Balanced Environment.</p><p>“The bloc system has been broken asunder. That’s where the new story is. It’s very multi-polar, and that’s why it’s so exciting,” she said.</p><p>The new alliances are having real-world implications. When countries meet in Paris, the discussion of how to divide responsibility for fighting climate change will still be simmering, but it will be starkly different from the one diplomats had in 1997.</p><p>Poor countries say they must see finance, including a promised $100 billion annually by 2020, to help their efforts. But only a few are still tying those dollars to the idea of reparations for the rich world’s historical emissions.</p><blockquote>India is perhaps the most powerful country still in that camp. “Historical responsibility cannot be wished away by any new parameters. It will always remain,” Environment Minister Prakash Javadekar told ClimateWire recently.</blockquote><p>And yet in a world where China is putting up $3.1 billion for climate change assistance — comparable to the United States — and even Mongolia is putting money toward the Green Climate Fund, the tables have already turned. The question now, activists say, is whether the Paris deal will be ambitious enough to avert dangerous levels of climate change.</p><p>Leaders have acknowledged that in their quest to get all countries on board to cutting carbon, the Paris architecture has a built-in downside: Commitments are voluntary and based not on science but on what countries feel they can reasonably offer. The collective targets won’t keep temperatures below the 2-degree-Celsius “guardrail,” but diplomats say they hope the deal will create a strong system that encourages a routine ratcheting up of ambition.</p><p>Hood, who is no longer part of the negotiations but is watching from afar, said he worries it’s not enough.</p><p>“If you have cancer and you know this cancer is going to kill you, you don’t want to do a little chemotherapy once a month. You want surgery or radical chemo,” he said. “I don’t think there’s a feeling of urgency.”</p><p><a href="http://www.eenews.net/special_reports/greater_expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change -- An E&amp;E Special Report</a></p><p>Copyright E&amp;E Publishing, LLC</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ba46c40841b4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations/the-pending-paris-accord-not-your-father-s-climate-agreement-ba46c40841b4">The pending Paris accord: not your father’s climate agreement</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/greater-expectations">Greater Expectations: The New Geopolitics of Climate Change</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>