<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Meta-Theology Quarterly - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Toward a theology of theology, posting at least every quarter. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 05:58:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/meta-theology" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do Not Quench the Spirit]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/do-not-quench-the-spirit-9a415bc6768d?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9a415bc6768d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sermons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Feb 2020 05:38:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-09T05:38:44.700Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*54Q_Sgos2LOThenD" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@matfelipe?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Mateus Campos Felipe</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>A sermon, or hot-take if you prefer</h4><p>I think it is safe to say that in Paul’s letter to the Galatians, and especially in chapter 3, we find Paul at his grumpiest. Paul writes,</p><blockquote><em>You foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you? It was before your eyes that Jesus Christ was publicly exhibited as crucified!</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>The only thing I want to learn from you is this: Did you receive the Spirit by doing the works of the law or by believing what you heard?</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>Are you so foolish? Having started with the Spirit, are you now ending with the flesh?</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>Did you experience so much for nothing? — if it really was for nothing. Well then, does God supply you with the Spirit and work miracles among you by your doing the works of the law, or by your believing what you heard? (Gal 3:1–5)</em></blockquote><p>Its safe to say that Paul thinks that this ancient community of believers has lost its way, and Paul is willing to speak plainly about it. This suggests that — no surprise — it is possible for Christians to lose their way, even in community. Christian communities can and do lose their way. It happens all the time. The problem is understanding what it looked like to lose the way in ancient Galatia, and to imagine what it might look like to lose our own way today.</p><p>We also have here a famous example of open conflict and disagreement between Christians. Note that Paul opposes the influence of other Christian leaders on the community in Galatia. He is up against insiders, not outsiders, even insiders in the form of an angel, or Peter, or James. Paul is deeply vexed by something important in this letter, something so important that he isn’t willing to let it go. For some reason Paul can’t agree to disagree here. He must speak.</p><p>At first glance it may seem like Paul is vexed by the question of the Jewish law, and the role that it should play in the lives of non-Jewish Christians. That is certainly the context for this particular letter. But I am convinced that there is something deeper going on, something that hits much closer to home today. If I could choose one sentence from Paul to summarize the entire letter of Galatians it would be his own phrase from First Thessalonians. When I read Galatians, all I hear is this — “Do not quench the Spirit<strong>” </strong>(1 Thess 5:19).</p><p>Let’s begin by taking stock of Paul’s posture toward the Jewish law, the law of his own people. There’s no escaping the fact that in this letter Paul marginalizes the law in a bold way. If that doesn’t bother you, it helps to realize that Paul is marginalizing the only Scriptures available to him at the time. What we call the Old Testament other people call the Hebrew Bible, and Paul calls the Law and the Prophets. This was the only Bible Paul had, and he is going to criticize it without holding much back. Because Paul’s writing is in our own Bible (as Christians), we can easily imagine that Paul would be a big supporter of the authority of Scripture, and the importance making sure that our Christianity is biblical, in some sense. But just look at how Paul treats his own Scripture.</p><p>In Paul’s day, many people thought that the law was given to Moses by God indirectly, through the mediation of angels. You won’t find this idea by reading the Old Testament, but it was in the air for Paul and he makes use of it. In this letter Paul repeats this idea that the law “was ordained through angels by a mediator,” namely Moses. “Now a mediator involves more than one party; but God is one” (Gal 3:19–20). In other words, Paul tells us that it was necessary for Moses to mediate the law to Israel because he was receiving it from multiple parties, from multiple angels. Moses would have been an unnecessary mediator if the law was given by God directly, since God is one. Make what you will of this, but this is strong evidence that Paul is putting the law under strict limits, without dismissing it. The author of Hebrews makes a similar but more gentle contrast, writing instead, “Long ago God spoke to our ancestors in many and various ways by the prophets, but in these last days he has spoken to us by a Son” (Heb 1:1–2).</p><p>Paul also undercuts the law by putting strict time limits on it. On the one side, he appeals to Abraham at great length, a patriarch of impeccable stature who walked with God before the law existed. Paul makes Abraham, not Moses, the archetype of faith. He insists over two chapters in Galatians that Abraham received the promise of God before there was any law, and that he received it by faith. So there once existed a mode of being in relation to God apart from the law, and indeed apart from the mediation of the angel powers behind the law. On the other end, Paul bounds the law by insisting that it is undermined by the death and resurrection of Jesus. This is in contrast to other biblical writers, such as the author of Hebrews, who insists that in the Kingdom of Heaven the law is written upon the hearts of the people of God. Hebrews 8:10–12 specifically quotes and comments on Jeremiah 31:31–34: “I will put my laws in their mind, and write them on their hearts.” This is certainly a big difference from knowledge of God mediated by angel powers through a written law! In Hebrews, the law will finally come home in the hearts of the people of God. For Paul, in contrast, the law is undone by the death of Jesus. The law can only curse, not bless. It is a curse upon those who fail to obey it. As Paul writes, “for it is written, ‘Cursed is everyone who does not observe and obey all the things written in the book of the law’.” (Gal 3:10)</p><p>But the law also curses Jesus Christ himself: “for it is written ‘Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree’.” (3:14). If I understand Paul’s logic correctly, this cursing of Christ is the undoing of the law that curses him. As Paul writes to the Corinthians, “But we speak God’s wisdom, secret and hidden, which God decreed before the ages for our glory. None of the rulers of this age understood this; for if they had, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory” (1 Cor 2:7–8). Since Jesus Christ came under the curse of the law, in virtue of being crucified, the law and the angel powers behind it are undone. To worship the crucified one is to part ways with the law that calls him cursed by God. In Paul’s worldview, Christ defeats the powers of the world, including the angel powers behind the law — who serve at God’s pleasure — by scorning the shame of the cross (Heb 12:2), to use a phrase from Hebrews. The law and the powers behind it, which claim to speak for God, abdicate their authority in the act of cursing God’s chosen one.</p><p>Hopefully this makes us a bit uncomfortable. That’s what a polemic like Galatians 3 is meant to do. Paul provokes us by attacking something we might consider sacred. That doesn’t mean he isn’t genuine, but there is always a risk of misunderstanding the polemic. When the stakes are high enough, as they are for Paul, he’s willing to take that risk. Even so, a few verses later he anticipates a misunderstanding. That’s why he writes, “Is the law then opposed to the promises of God? Certainly not!” (Gal 3:21).</p><p>In Paul’s worldview the law, even a law mediated by defeated angel powers, is part of God’s plan and not a mistake or obstacle. In Romans he writes, paradoxically, “it is not those who hear the law who are righteous in God’s sight, but it is those who obey the law who will be declared righteous” (Rom 2:13). This is very surprising, given his stance in Galatians. Let’s keep reading in Romans: “When [the nations], who do not possess the law, do instinctively what the law requires, these, though not having the law, are a law to themselves. They show that what the law requires is written on their hearts, to which their own conscience also bears witness” (Rom 2:14–16). So there is a sense in which the law reveals the will of God to a person, but the law does not constrain or contain or exclusively mediate that will. There are other ways to encounter God’s will in experience. What matters most is the conscience, the law written upon the heart, like the one described in Hebrews. It doesn’t matter that people outside the nation of ancient Israel lack access to the Hebrew Scriptures and Jewish traditions.</p><p>At the end of Galatians Paul writes “For the whole law is summed up in a single commandment, “You shall love your neighbor as yourself’.” (Gal 5:14). How does this fit what what we’ve heard from Paul so far? When Christ defeats the powers through the cross, and their authority over humans through the law, does Christ defeat the command to love your neighbour? That wouldn’t make any sense. What is going on with Paul’s hot-then-cold posture toward the law of his people? I think that the answer is simple: a good thing can become bad for a person, depending on their posture toward it.</p><p>Paul develops a type of Christian relativism twice in his writings, that I know of — in Romans 14–15 and in First Corinthians 8–10. In First Corinthians, Paul is answering some questions about whether or not it is appropriate for Christians in Corinth to eat meat sold in the market that was previously offered to idols as part of the religious life of the city. Paul can eat meat with a clean conscience, if it were only his conscience at stake. He doesn’t care that it was prepared for idol worship and then sold at a discount in the market. That doesn’t bother him. As far as he is concerned, the idols in the temples are of no account since “for us there is one God, the Father, from whom are all things and for whom we exist, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things and through whom we exist” (1 Cor 8:6). Idol meat is a matter of indifference for Paul. He isn’t for it or against it.</p><p>However, there are others in the community who recently worshiped in these temples and for whom idol meat takes on a different meaning. If they were to partake, to them it would mean a return to their old gods. The principle here is captured by a verse in Romans where Paul writes, “I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean in itself; but it is unclean for anyone who thinks it unclean” (Rom 14:13). The subjective is just as real as the objective in matters of the conscience. A good thing can become bad depending on a person’s posture toward it, or rather toward God concerning it. “All things are lawful”, the Corinthians write to Paul. “But not all things are beneficial,” he replies, “not all things build up” (1 Cor 10:23).</p><p>When we use a good thing in a way that goes against our conscience, we damage our posture toward God and quench the Spirit. I think this makes sense of Paul’s concern about the law in Galatia alongside his willingness to give it a larger yet limited role in the theology he describes in Romans. For the Galatians, the law has become a stumbling block. When they became convinced by rival Christian leaders that their experience of the Spirit of God still lacked something — a proper submission to the law of the Jewish people — they began to quench the Spirit in their midst. Something that is not actually objectively dangerous, the Jewish law, becomes subjectively dangerous, dangerous for the non-Jewish Christians in Galatia.</p><p>If the non-Jewish Christians in Galatia were to agree with Paul’s rivals, and attempt as non-Jewish people to conform to the way of life of Jewish Christians, they would then ignore the fact that the Spirit of God was present among before they began to submit to the law. God poured out the Spirit of Jesus upon the community in Galatia long before they ever considered submitting to Jewish customs and norms. For Paul it is completely appropriate and understandable for Jewish people upon whom the Spirit has fallen to continue with many of their customs and norms. Remember that Acts tells us that Paul was arrested in Jerusalem while worshiping at the temple precisely for the sake of reassuring the Jewish Christians that he did not oppose their traditions. But not everything traditional is sacred for Paul — he insists that those who share the Spirit of Jesus be free to eat together, no matter what the law or tradition say. Paul is so sure of this that he’s willing to challenge Peter in public on this question.</p><p>In contrast, Paul finds it completely inappropriate for non-Jewish people upon whom the Spirit has fallen to seek the approval of Jewish Christians by mimicking their law-keeping. This Spirit of Jesus has been given without any regard to whether or not a person obeys the Jewish law. That has to mean something. In Acts, the Spirit falls upon the household of Cornelius, a Roman centurion. That fact alone is enough to convince Peter that the gospel is for the nations, and not just for the people of Israel. In Galatians when the Spirit falls upon people who have never before considered obeying the Jewish law, that means for Paul that the law is not eternal or sacred, however appropriate it remains for Jewish Christians. The Spirit is evidently no respecter of law-keeping — God has given the Spirit to both those who keep and to those who ignore the Jewish law. For non-Jewish Christians in Galatia to seek the approval of Jewish Christians by keeping foreign traditions is to ignore the incongruous gift of the Spirit, to regard themselves as second-class Christians, which is to quench the Spirit among them.</p><p>I suspect that very few of us are tempted to think that we are not real Christians because we do not observe ancient Jewish customs and traditions as we find them in our Old Testament. We know where to begin, to love your neighbour, but where does it end? Living biblically is a slippery-slope. Even so, I am convinced that we face the same threat that Paul addresses. We as a community — and Christians in Canada, North America, and around the world — are constantly being tempted to quench the Spirit. Usually this temptation comes by way of taking some gift of God and treating it as normative or necessary for all Christians. It is all too easy to come up with examples.</p><p>Suppose you are healthy, and thankful to God for your good health. What do you make of people who are sick? Do you look at the sick as those who lack the Lord’s favour? Could it be instead that those who have experienced physical hardship may have received strength and encouragement from the Spirit that the healthy among us have yet to experience?</p><p>Suppose you are wealthy, or just thankful that God has met your needs. What do you make of people who lack resources, opportunities, and connections? Do they lack the Lord’s favour? Or could it be that the Spirit of the one who said, “Foxes have holes, and birds of the air have nests; but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head” (Matt 8:20) — could it be that this Spirit is with those in need?</p><p>Suppose that you are married, or belong to a nuclear family that many would describe as traditional. What do you make of those for whom family has been a disappointment, and marriage a hardship? Could it be that the Spirit of the one who declared, “whoever does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother” (Matt 12:50) — could it be that this Spirit is present among those for whom family has become a stumbling block and a hardship? Or what do you make of those who have healthy and loving relationships and marriages that happen to look much different from your own? Is not the Spirit of Jesus present wherever two or three are gathered in his name, even when it looks much different than you might expect or feel comfortable with?</p><p>Suppose that you are thankful for the church, taken very broadly, and the progress of Christianity in the world over the past two millennia. You take comfort in the fact that your faith is a global religion, perhaps even the dominant one in the society in which you were raised. Maybe you even enjoy listening to Christian music and give thanks to the Lord for the local Christian bookstore and megachurch podcasts. Maybe you yearn for the day when a Christian worldview regains some level of dominance and plausibility in our culture, where you can believe whatever you happen to believe without embarrassment or shame. Could it be that the Spirit of the one who said, “You see all these, do you not? Truly I tell you, not one stone will be left here upon another; all will be thrown down” (Matt 24:2) — could it be that this Spirit is also among those who work against the influence of the organized church and its legions of ministries and networks of power-aggregation?</p><p>Suppose, last of all, that you are thankful for the Bible. Perhaps you take it to be the very word of God to us. You join in the worship of the saints throughout the ages as you read about what the Lord has done in salvation history, a grand narrative to which you now belong. What comfort to know that God can be known by simply reading. Not that the reading is an easy task, but this book is clearly different from all others. The importance of the topic — eternal life and salvation — makes the reading all the more critical. The special character of this book suggests that it might answer all manner of questions, perhaps even any question whatsoever that we put to it, provided that we pay careful attention to the context, pray carefully, and cultivate the needed worldview. Perhaps taking the Bible seriously, more seriously than other Christians, is the distinctive feature of your spiritual life. Perhaps your confidence in your own interpretation is in proportion to you zeal for searching the scriptures. Could it be that the Spirit of the one who said, “You search the scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that testify on my behalf” (John 5:39) — could it be that this Spirit is also with those who interpret and use the Bible in different ways than you do? Perhaps the Spirit of Jesus is among those for whom the Bible plays a much different role and meets much different standards than those you take comfort in.</p><p>Maybe you noticed that this last one bothers me a bit more than it should. I was taught growing up that the Holy Spirit would never contradict the Bible, but of course that isn’t true. The Spirit of Jesus does not defer to the experts in the law, or the experts on the Bible. If anything, the Spirit of Jesus interprets us as we interpret the Bible. As we read or hear we are provoked to interpret our world and our scriptures with the same audacity that Jesus and Paul interpreted their own world and scriptures. We interpret both by the power of the Spirit. It is more true to say, as Paul does, that we are <em>known by God </em>than that we know biblical facts about God, even when we do. We must not — as many do and have always done — use the Bible to quench the Spirit.</p><p>If we are going to let the Spirit of Jesus be our guide, we must test the voices that we encounter in our world against the character of Jesus of Nazareth. No voice is safe or trustworthy — not even an angel from heaven, not even Paul — unless it yields to the authority and character of the Spirit of the crucified and risen Jesus. And none led by the Spirit of Jesus are to be rejected, no matter how strange it seems to us that Jesus is also present with them, perhaps without them even acknowledging him. In spite of our reservations, we must learn to recognize the same power at work in others that we find at work in ourselves, the same power made manifest in the person and actions of Jesus. The gift of God in Christ is a gift of power to act in this world in the interests of the Spirit of Jesus. We must not quench this Spirit.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9a415bc6768d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/do-not-quench-the-spirit-9a415bc6768d">Do Not Quench the Spirit</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Godforsaken and the Spirit of Jesus]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/godforsakenness-and-the-spirit-of-jesus-cebd2081b5bc?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cebd2081b5bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sermons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Aug 2019 12:53:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-18T13:03:20.425Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sRCYmfvQe4rsvU3olgoJ4w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@unitasphotography?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Charles “Duck” Unitas</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>A Sermon</h4><blockquote><em>“Hope does not disappoint us, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit that has been given to us” (Rom 5:5).</em></blockquote><p>We are looking at passages from the lectionary this summer, and this week the lectionary includes one of my favourite passages in the New Testament, Romans 5:5. Apparently today is also Trinity Sunday in the church calendar, and I hope to say something helpful about that too in relation to this passage (but probably not too helpful).</p><p>As some of you may have gathered by now, I’m very interested in theology for some reason or another. As with any interest, it can be a bit lonely if you don’t have friends to share it with. Thankfully, I do have a couple <em>theology friends</em> (though I wouldn’t say a few). These are friends with whom I mostly talk about theology. By they way, I’m always looking for more theology friends, so let me know if you’re interested. Anyway, I have a friend in California who shares my love of theology and he once shared something with me that I consider fairly profound. He said, I want to live in the dialectical tension between Mark 15:34 and Luke 23:46. That is, he wants to live in the tension between a Jesus who’s final words from the cross are “<em>My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?</em>” and a Jesus whose final words are “<em>Father, into your hands I commend my spirit.</em>” Do you notice a tension between these two phrases? I’m convinced that <strong>we need to do justice to both sayings if we are ever going to understand the Christian faith or make it our own.</strong></p><p>But how can we make sense of both? To make sense of both we need to ask questions like, Is there hope for the godforsaken? Can we find hope in a godforsaken place? Can we find a hope that is stronger than all that assaults it? Can we have a clear-sighted sober view of the world, with all its injustices and catastrophes and still cling to a hope that is neither naive or overconfident? Is hope at bottom self-deception or can it rest on truth and power? I think that our passage today in Romans points us in the right direction. Paul writes,</p><blockquote><em>hope does not disappoint us, because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit that has been given to us.</em></blockquote><p>A philosopher who I appreciate (and consider a theology friend), named <a href="https://pmoser.sites.luc.edu/">Paul Moser</a>, has called this verse the most significant statement in Christian literature pertaining to knowledge of God. In this passage, we find the firm foundation for Christian hoping against hope. And that foundation is an act of God that reaches each of us in the present. This verse describes a basis for hope that actually impinges upon our individual and collective experience. It is the love of God poured into our hearts, today, through the Spirit of God. Elsewhere, Paul names this Spirit the Spirit of Jesus, without hesitation or distinction. So we could instead say that Christian hope does not disappoint us because God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Spirit of Jesus that has been given to us. Our experience of the love of God comes by way of the Spirit of Jesus, and this is the Spirit of someone who felt godforsaken and yet who also entrusted himself into the hands of his Father.</p><p>Today I want to try to explain what I’ve just said in a little bit more detail. That is, I want to describe my basis for Christian hope, or at least what I take to be Paul’s basis, and try to explain what I think it might mean to live in the tension between Mark 15:34 and Luke 23:46.</p><p>What does it mean to feel godforsaken? I’m sure that many of us have felt this, and I fear that those of us who have not yet tasted godforsakenness may yet encounter it. In fact, we often do all that we can to avoid this experience. We put it out of our minds. We even avert our gaze when we encounter those struck by it. But the central image and source of power in the Christian faith is the cross of Jesus Christ, and Jesus found himself — we might even say placed himself — among the godforsaken. So <em>as Christians we can’t look away from the godforsaken experience without compromising something central to our faith</em>.</p><p>Let me suggest that the feeling of being godforsaken is, perhaps among other things, a feeling of deep disappointment and even confusion that comes when God does not meet our expectations. We expect something from God and it doesn’t happen. God will protect us, and yet we are harmed. God will provide, and yet we go hungry. God will vindicate us, and yet we are ridiculed. God will heal us, and yet we weaken. God will bless our plans, and yet they fail. God will favour his people, and yet the wicked prosper.</p><p>Perhaps you’ve noticed that <em>this experience of godforsakenness inspires a large portion of the writing that we have come to call scripture</em>. Consider the long story of the people of Israel, as we find it in our Bible. Jacob’s descendants, the people of Israel, are delivered from slavery in Egypt. After a long journey through the wilderness followed by generations of turmoil, they eventually form a kingdom of their own. This kingdom reaches an apparent zenith during the reigns of David and Solomon. But then it immediately divides into two kingdoms. Several generations later it comes to shipwreck at the hands of godless Babylon. The people are sent into exile and the temple of Israel’s God is destroyed. A major portion of our Old Testament is dedicated to exploring this national experience of being godforsaken. What could it possibly mean for God’s special people to face such a national catastrophe? Out of this painful collective experience an expectation forms that God will send Israel a saviour, that is, a Messiah or a Christ. The New Testament authors and the early Christian movement embodied the conviction that Jesus of Nazareth was in fact this long awaited Messiah. Jesus somehow was the one who would rectify the national experience of godforsakenness. And yet this Jesus is himself crucified and finds himself godforsaken! So in many ways, at least from a certain perspective, the cure seems worse than the disease.</p><p>A common scriptural thread, as I see it, is that those who wrestle with God — notice that this is the biblical meaning of the name Israel — do not simply ascend from one victory to another. Instead, God leads those who follow on a surprising path to places that are paradoxically best described as <em>godforsaken</em>, at least from the perspective of what we might have previously expected God to do. There is always a temptation in Christianity to embrace what some have called a <strong><em>theology of triumph</em></strong>, a theology on which we now live in the golden age where God is no longer dangerous and the path forward is assuredly peace and prosperity. However, I am convinced that the truth and the future belong to a<strong> <em>theology of the cross</em></strong>, a theology that does not hide or obscure the godforsaken experience of Jesus.</p><p>I believe that the evidence we have in the New Testament suggests that<em> Jesus himself was in fact surprised by God </em>and allowed his expectations of God to change with time. Jesus was not born with all the answers, obviously. And he didn’t die with all the answers either. Jesus began by preaching pretty much the same message as John the Baptist: “Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand!” He began his work with a genuine offer of reconciliation from his God to the people of Israel, and especially to the leaders of his people. Jesus believed that Israel is God’s vineyard, and its leaders the tenants assigned to care for that vineyard and to produce fruit for the owner. In the past, Jesus believed, God had sent messengers (the prophets) to the tenants of the vineyard but the leaders had always rejected and mistreated them. As Jesus proclaimed his message, he was truly surprised that those with the greatest faith were not even members of how own people of Israel. Recall his surprise at both the Roman centurion and the Syrophoenician woman. Before long Israel’s leaders attributed his miracles to the power of Satan and not to the God of Israel. As in the parable of the vineyard, Jesus began to understand that God’s love for Israel required one final climactic offer of reconciliation. God was sending a son and not just a servant, and Jesus was this very son. Whatever Israel and its leaders did to Jesus, the son, would count as being done to God, the Father.</p><p>Remember that Jesus wept over Jerusalem. He wept knowing that, because of the hardness of heart of the people and its leaders, even God’s best offer of a son would be rejected. Jesus shared God’s deep love for Israel and wanted nothing more than that they would embrace his Father by embracing him. And yet, Jesus believed that God’s love for Israel would require him to provoke the leaders and inevitably die at their hands. Luke describes Jesus telling some people in the crowd to not weep for him but to weep for themselves. The death of Jesus would be the judgment of God upon a world at war with God, a world that hates God often without even knowing it. <em>God’s judgment upon the world was to permit the world to destroy its own saviour, to bring human sin to the point of a moral apocalypse, or decisive unveiling</em>. And so Jesus finds himself godforsaken, having truly wondered up to the very last moment whether God would protect him and find another way. Awaiting a rescue that never came, Jesus resolved at great cost to obey his Father until the end, no matter the outcome, out of a shared love for Israel and concern for the holy name of is Father. In the end his God and Father withdrew all protection and the worst became actual. <em>By obediently sharing in God’s love for God’s beloved enemies, Jesus finds himself paradoxically godforsaken</em>.</p><p>This all seems very bleak, and so it should. I’ve mentioned already that the cross of Christ can be described as the day of God’s judgment upon the world. It is an unveiling of our proclivity to oppose the love of God manifest in the person of Jesus. Jesus died because we prefer to cling to our ways of being and living and thinking and organizing when confronted by the righteous love of God manifest in a living breathing person. He died because he challenged the authority of those who claim to mediate knowledge of God to others by way of their elite interpretation of tradition, scripture, and priesthood. He died because even though the crowds enjoyed when he humiliated and embarrassed their leaders, Jesus nevertheless refused to give the crowds the prosperity and victory that they demanded in the form they expected. Remember that they wanted to crown him king by force, if only they could appropriate his power and influence for their own purposes. Jesus died because Pilate feared being brought low in the eyes of Caesar more than having the blood of innocent people on his hands. Jesus died alone because, at the crucial moment, the men who he called disciples didn’t share <em>his experience of the Father as an ever-loving divine imperative</em>. Remember how he implored them to pray with him in the garden of Gethsemane. Sadly, they couldn’t truly conceive of a future in which God would require the life of God’s chosen one. They were a stumbling block first to him and then also to themselves. Only a few of his women followers remained with him to the end.</p><p>What then does it mean that Luke describes Jesus as saying “<em>Father, into your hands I commend my spirit</em>,” especially against the backdrop of godforsakenness? It was obedience to the love of God that led Jesus to die among the godforsaken, and it wasn’t simply in his last moment that he entrusted himself to his Father. <em>His whole life is spent enacting this phrase</em>. His mission to Israel is a mission driven by the love of God for Israel, a mission of costly reconciliation. As it becomes clear that his mission would cost him his life, Luke tells us that Jesus “set his face toward Jerusalem”. The whole process of coming to realize that obedience to God would cost Jesus his life was a process of entrusting himself to God. And this process led Jesus from the height of popularity and potential to the actual depths of godforsakenness. We only find this phrase about commending his spirit to his Father in Luke’s Gospel. But the actions to match it are found in all four Gospels. The whole trajectory of the life of Jesus is perhaps best summarized by “Father, into your hands I commend my spirit.”</p><p>Put another way, Jesus demonstrated with his actions, even more than with his words, that he considered his Father to be worthy of worship, that is, worthy of unqualified trust and obedience. Perhaps without fully understanding exactly why God would require his obedience unto death, <em>Jesus knew that his Father was worthy of that obedience</em>. Jesus knew better than anyone before or since the character of Israel’s God as the God of unqualified holy love. It was the love of God for Israel that drove Jesus to the cross, and <em>Jesus knew this love at first hand through his communion with his Father</em>. What could possibly possess a person to appropriating for himself these words of Isaiah, as Jesus does in Luke’s Gospel:</p><blockquote><em>“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me,<br> because he has anointed me<br> to bring good news to the poor.<br>He has sent me to proclaim release to the captives<br> and recovery of sight to the blind,<br> to let the oppressed go free,<br>to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.”</em></blockquote><p>Jesus knew God and knew the character of God first hand through the power of the Spirit of God. He knew the one who he obeyed. He embraced the character of his God including God’s concern for the those who most regard as godforsaken. <em>God was, to Jesus, a near and present will-to-love and the Spirit of God was the driving wind in the sail of his willing obedience</em>. That is, we can say that the love of God was poured out into the heart of the man Jesus of Nazareth by the power of the Holy Spirit given to him.</p><p>In the end, Jesus placed all his hope in his Father as the God of the living. There were certain religious leaders who came and debated with him about whether there was any hope beyond the grave. In three of the Gospels Jesus tells them that the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob is the God of the living. That is, <em>those who walk with God in this life enjoy a fellowship that is stronger than death, and that fellowship is the true basis for their hope</em>. Hope in a hopeless place stems from first hand knowledge of God’s character. Hope isn’t cheap or feeble. Christian hope is living hope because it is the hope that stems from fellowship with the living God and an experience of the character and power conveyed to us by the Spirit of this God.</p><p>Let’s return to Romans 5:5, which I consider a summary of the basis for Christian hope. Hope does not disappoint us, not because God behaves as expected or because we can see the end from the beginning and the beginning from the end. No, hope does not disappoint us because we know <em>at first hand </em>the character of the God of the living, the one upon and in whom all our hopes rest. We hope because we have knowledge at first hand — through our experience of the love of God in conscience and in encounter with one another — knowledge that the world is governed by a God who is actually worthy of our worship, a God who is trustworthy and who acts out of the utmost love and concern for all people, even and especially those we regard as godforsaken.</p><p>I’ll finish with three remarks. First, we need to be careful when we use the word “God”. Words mean, to us, whatever we decide they mean, to us. There’s nothing to stop me from redefining everything in my vocabulary, other than the fact that none of you would be able to understand what I’m talking about. That said, <em>the words we use can either illuminate or obscure certain crucial elements in our experience</em>, and that is true of the word God as well. With that said, I’d like to share the definition of God that I have found very helpful, and I learned it from the philosopher Paul Moser who I mentioned earlier.</p><p>God is whatever, or whoever, turns out to be worthy of worship, where worship is unqualified trust, obedience, and adoration. Put another way, someone or something <em>qualifies as God</em>, in my sense of the word, only if it is worthy of my unqualified trust, obedience, and adoration. God is God because God is worthy of worship, and the <em>worthiness </em>is key. All sorts of things receive worship without being worthy of worship. The biblical word for these is “idols” and the worship of them is “idolatry”, and that is true even when we spell the idol G-O-D. So we do well to ask ourselves, <em>is that which we worship, whatever or whoever it happens to be, actually worthy of that worship?</em> If not, then we should stop.</p><p>Once we talk about God in these terms, we need to ask ourselves, what does it take to be worthy of worship? The answer, it seems, is often described using the word “holiness” or “righteous love”. God, if God, is worthy of worship and therefore trustworthy. If there is a God, then there is something that we can and should trust without reservation, and if not then there isn’t. This means that if there is a God then that God is doing — right now in our actual world — all that can be done to extend and promote righteous love to and among all people, including and especially the so-called godforsaken. A God who hated God’s enemies or those at the margins would not be trustworthy <em>to them</em>, and therefore would not be worthy of worship and would not qualify as God after all.</p><p>Now for my second remark, this time about the Trinity. The good news, at least at a practical level, is that <em>the Spirit of God that conveyed the personal power and presence of God to Jesus, is the very same Spirit that Paul describes as conveying the personal power and presence of Jesus to us today</em>. That is, the same Spirit they make the righteous love of God a real presence and power in the life of Jesus comes to us today to pour out the love of God into our hearts. The Spirit of God and the Spirit of Jesus are one and the same — that is my doctrine of the Trinity in case anyone was wondering — and this Spirit reveals at the existential and experiential level that we live in the presence of and under the care of a God of righteous love, a God worthy of our worship.</p><p><em>It is the demanding love of God poured out into our hearts by this Spirit that both attracts us to Christ and then also alarms us</em>. This same love is something we enjoy, something we trust, and yet something that leads us outside the city among the godforsaken. Because the God who is worthy of our worship loves those that the world has rejected, and we are rarely in a position to see clearly exactly where the love of God will lead us. What we do know, usually, is what the love of God requires of us in the present moment, and that the future is in the hands of a God worthy of worship, a God of righteous love.</p><p>And this leads me to my final remark. Our experience of the love of God is an experience of the Spirit of Jesus challenging us in our conscience, and this experiences grows richer as we obey and embrace the Spirit of Jesus in conscience, just as he embraced and obeyed the Spirit of his Father in his own conscience. We will quickly discover that <em>the Jesus we worship is a real and present danger to the status quo in our lives and communities</em>. A wonderful place to read more about this is in the epistle of First John. Time and again that short text connects love and obedience to knowing God and hope in God. For instance, in 1 John 3:14 we read,</p><blockquote><em>We know that we have passed from death to life because we love one another. Whoever does not love abides in death.</em></blockquote><p>The love of God poured into our hearts is then, to us, something very practical. As Albert Schweitzer wrote, “We can only bring so much of the Kingdom of God into the world as we possess within us,” and, “To be a Christian means to be possessed and dominated by a hope of the Kingdom of God, and a will to work for it, which bids defiance to external reality.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cebd2081b5bc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/godforsakenness-and-the-spirit-of-jesus-cebd2081b5bc">The Godforsaken and the Spirit of Jesus</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Spirit of Jesus the Basis for Unity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/the-spirit-of-jesus-337cd1ab75db?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/337cd1ab75db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Aug 2018 18:49:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-01T18:50:56.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iYG-ReVMS0TlQRpjJYUBSA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://pixabay.com/en/architecture-windmills-holland-1850214/">Pixabay</a></figcaption></figure><h4>A sermon</h4><p>When I read <a href="https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Ephesians+2%3A11-22&amp;version=NRSV">Ephesians 2:11–22</a> I ask myself, How did the cross of Christ and the Spirit that led Christ to that cross solve the problem of division between Jewish and non-Jewish Christians in the early church, and what does that mean for us today? The answer is found in verse 18:</p><blockquote>For through him both of us have access in one Spirit to the Father.</blockquote><p>I take this to mean — and this is my main point — that Christian unity, then and now, is something that requires the power of the Spirit of God, and not just any spirit, but the Spirit of God as the Spirit of Jesus — the Spirit that led Jesus to his cross and the Spirit by which Jesus confronts us today in our own experience.</p><p>I’ll start with a couple observations about unity and this passage.</p><p>First, unity between people isn’t automatic. This passage doesn’t take unity for granted. It speaks of a time when the reader was “without Christ, being aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world.” So the unity proclaimed here is not the type of unity that was there all along, but we were ignorant of it. There was once a “dividing wall, that is, the hostility between us.”</p><p>Second, unity always requires power. Sometimes this power is power to <em>impose</em> unity upon people who otherwise wouldn’t get along. But the power that unites in this passage is not that kind of power. We don’t have a forced unity here. Rather, we read of a power described in terms of “the blood of Christ,” a power at work “in his flesh” that “breaks down the dividing wall, that is, the hostility between us.” It is a power that reconciles “both groups to God in one body through the cross,” and <em>somehow</em> this puts “to death” this hostility between us, the dividing wall.</p><p>Third, the power that unifies is the power of the Spirit of Jesus. We read that Jesus “proclaimed peace to you who were far off and peace to those who were near; for <em>through him</em> both of us have access in one Spirit to the Father.” This shared Spirit of Jesus unites us today, just as that Spirit once united Jewish and non-Jewish Christians in the early church.</p><p>Finally, the Spirit of God is the Spirit of Jesus. We are speaking about the Spirit of God. But in the New Testament, and in Christian experience, the Spirit of God and the Spirit of Jesus are one and the same. By this I mean that the Spirit that led and empowered the man Jesus of Nazareth, conveying to him the presence and power of his God and Father, is the very same Spirit that the exalted Jesus pours out upon us today, conveying to us his presence and power. This means that if we want to recognize the Spirit of God in our lives and world today, we should look for the same Spirit <em>today</em> that empowered and guided Jesus, the Spirit that ultimately led him to his death. Today, in our own experience, we must distinguish the Spirit that empowered Jesus of Nazareth in the Gospels from the numerous forces that nudge us toward this action or that attitude.</p><p>All that said, in order to understand how the Spirit of Jesus unifies, we must return to the story of Jesus and the Spirit of God. I’ll try to tell this story to you, a story that explains why the gospel of the New Testament tolerates no partiality or human-made divisions.</p><p>The story begins in ancient Palestine, about 2000 years ago. A proud yet powerless people find themselves under foreign rule — a painful and embarrassing turn of events. The people of ancient Israel had a history, a national story that involved a <em>special relationship</em> with a God known to them as the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. They believed that this God had promised their forefather Abraham that through his descendants — this people — all the nations of the earth would be blessed. Abraham’s children were once slaves in Egypt, and they believed that their God had delivered them from slavery, and brought them into a land promised to Abraham. This God had once blessed them with a kingdom to be proud of, during the rules of David and Solomon. In fact, they believed that God had promised David a permanent royal line — a never-ending kingdom, and a permanent leading role on the world stage. The God who had redeemed them from slavery was not, in their eyes, a tribal deity confined to their land but rather the grand ruler over all nations, the cosmic creator and the unique being worthy of human worship. Their God was worthy of their worship because of God’s saving deeds and promises. The God of Israel had earned their loyalty.</p><p>The problem was that David’s kingdom had fractured rather than prospered, and within several generations the people of Israel found themselves diminished in power. As other kingdoms rose to prominence, Israel found itself in the cross-fire, located in a disputed patch of land between the great powers of Egypt and Assyria, and then Babylon. The national dream was shipwrecked as Jerusalem fell, the temple was destroyed, and the people deported into foreign exile.</p><p>After the exile, what could it possibly mean to be the people of God, a people promised an eternal kingdom ruled by an unending line of Kings descended from David? Everyone wondered. Perhaps it meant that God would restore their former fortunes, that the days of David and Solomon might return? In due course many of the people were able to return to Jerusalem and Palestine. They were able build a second temple. But things never quite returned to normal. In fact, this people still found themselves in the cross-fire of the rising and falling world powers, being first occupied by the Greeks as Alexander the Great swept through, then ruled by his unsavory successors, and then swept up into the Roman empire. So the question remained. What did it mean to be promised a kingdom? What of God’s promises to Israel? Why did Israel’s God, who is sovereign over the nations, permit Israel to languish in obscurity?</p><p>Amidst this new status quo, something remarkable happens. Albert Schweitzer described it beautifully. <a href="https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.114136/2015.114136.The-Quest-Of-The-Historical-Jesus-1906#page/n389/search/crushes">He writes</a>,</p><blockquote>There is silence all around. The Baptist appears, and cries: “Repent, for the Kingdom of Heaven is at hand.” Soon after that comes Jesus, and in the knowledge that He is the coming Son of Man lays hold of the wheel of the world to set it moving on that last revolution which is to bring all ordinary history to a close. It refuses to turn, and He throws Himself upon it. Then it does turn; and crushes Him.</blockquote><p>What does this mean? A man we know as John the Baptist begins preaching in Roman Palestine that God was about to fulfill God’s promises to Israel. And another man, who we know as Jesus of Nazareth, begins to echo that same message and preach it for himself. But unlike John, Jesus has a deep conviction that God has called him <em>personally</em> to “set in motion the machinery” that will usher in the long-awaited kingdom of God — to lay hold of the wheel of history and make it turn. Jesus does not spiritualize Israel’s expected kingdom (although he does make it inescapably ethical). Rather Jesus is convinced that through his own actions the God of Israel will inaugurate the promised kingdom at any moment.</p><p>What we now call his ministry, or career, began with a baptism. Like many others, Jesus went to John to be baptised as a sign of his commitment to the coming kingdom of God. This baptism is a crucial moment in his life: the moment when the Spirit of the God of Israel finally empowers Jesus to act. At his baptism Jesus relates to the God of Israel as his Father. Immediately the Spirit of his Father drives him out into the wilderness where his trust in God is tested. And the test is precisely this: Will the one to whom God has promised a kingdom take that kingdom by force from his enemies with his own two hands? Or will he, like King David before him, wait for God to deliver the promised kingdom to him?</p><p>Jesus begins teaching near his hometown, <a href="https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+4&amp;version=NRSV">declaring</a>,</p><blockquote>The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind to set the oppressed free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.</blockquote><p>Many in Israel feel abandoned by God and long for a tangible salvation from what they think ails them. The downtrodden will be lifted up and God will finally set things right.</p><p>But sooner or later people take offense at Jesus. Jesus is not the type people expected to be the proclaimer, and certainly not the vehicle, of Israel’s salvation. His message has parts that they like — what’s not to like about healing the sick? Also, in a twisted sort of way, they enjoy seeing Jesus knock religious leaders down a peg. The people love to see Jesus embarrass their leaders in debate, especially in the final week of his life. But Jesus can also infuriate. He consistently exposes deep rooted prejudice and corrupted expectations about <em>who</em> God finds worthy, <em>what</em> God finds pleasing, and <em>what</em> God ought to do about it.</p><p>Remember, the question at hand was this: Why does God permit his special people to languish in obscurity on the world stage? When will God specially favour God’s special people? Of course, God favours his people by sending them Jesus, but in those days that is small comfort. Nevertheless, Jesus is entirely focused on his own nation, on Israel. His efforts are all directed toward influencing Israel, both its people and its leaders. He makes no real effort to sway the Roman authorities, or the neighbouring non-Jewish peoples. His life’s work is the work of one sent by Israel’s God to Israel. But Jesus also believes that when Israel inevitably resists God’s messengers, the nations are blessed <em>all the same</em>. When he makes this conviction clear to others it always strikes a nerve. In Roman Palestine, politics and theology and history are all one and the same. Israel’s political fortunes hinge on Israel receiving special treatment from her God, the God who rules the nations. And any threat to that divine privilege is anathema. Remember that in Nazareth, when Jesus reminds his neighbours at the synagogue of God’s favour to those outside of Israel in the days of Elijah and Elisha, the people of his hometown immediately try to kill him by throwing him off a cliff. Somehow he escapes.</p><p>As <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Practice-Christianity-Kierkegaards-Writings-Vol/dp/0691020639">Soren Kierkegaard writes</a>, “In order to believe, the person who believes must have passed through the <em>possibility of offense</em>.” However, “The possibility of offense lies in the contradiction that <em>the remedy seems infinitely worse than the sickness</em>.” Indeed, if the problem is Israel’s obscurity on the world stage, a salvation that blesses <em>all</em> the nations does seem like a cure that is worse than the disease. But it gets worse. Israel is chosen by God <em>not for its own sake</em> but for the sake of those other nations. Israel is chosen by God, but <em>chosen to serve</em> rather than receive preferential treatment. Israel is God’s vineyard, Jesus insists, its leaders the tenants chosen to care for the vineyard so that Israel will bear the fruit that will bless all the nations. Jesus interprets his own mission to Israel as the mission of the son of the owner of the vineyard, sent to collect this fruit of the vineyard from the tenants.</p><p>The teaching of Jesus alone has not produced the fruit of the vineyard. National repentance and preparation for a kingdom made not by human hands; embracing of a law that sets love of God and love of neighbour before all else; welcoming the son of the father to whom great men matter little and little children, women, and lepers matter much — these things did not happened through the ministry of Jesus. Instead, the miracles of Jesus provoke greed in some, slander in others. His blatant disregard for human standards of worth, whether they be sexual norms, human riches, political power, gender, age, health, ethnicity, or political affiliation (remember the tax collectors) — these all offend rather than inspire.</p><p>Only a decisive confrontation remains. This is why <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Diary-Soren-Kierkegaard/dp/0806502517/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1533147857&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=diary+of+kierkegaard">Kierkegaard writes</a>, “Christ is not love, least of all in the human meaning; He is Truth, Absolute Truth; therefore He had to let men become guilty of his death: i.e. reveal Truth to the uttermost degree.” The truth is that all is not well between God and his people, between God and the world. To make this truth known — and known for all human history — Jesus will bring things to a head between God and Israel. Peter Forsyth <a href="https://experientialtheology.hcommons.org/archives/155">writes</a>, “As a great statesman, in full view of the situation and its crisis, might commit a people to war, so [Jesus] would force the whole nation into the valley of decision for Israel’s death or life.” If the exile had dashed Israel’s expectation of steadily increasing prosperity under divine privilege, the death of Israel’s anticipated Messiah and Son of Man — at the hands of Israel’s leaders, by the will of the people — would <em>forever discredit human expectations of who God loves, and with whom God is well pleased</em>. And so we read, that toward the end of his brief career, and after the so-called “mountain-top experience” described as the transfiguration, Jesus <em>sets his face toward Jerusalem</em>. He begins a long walk from the margins to the center, from safety to danger, from popularity to near universal hatred, from success to failure. Jesus takes action. The Spirit of his Father drives Jesus toward Jerusalem, where he will force the wheel of Israel’s history to turn, and it will crush him.</p><p>Jesus does indeed perish, totally discredited, his teaching misunderstood, and his kingdom defeated.</p><p>But what does God think of Jesus? Jesus was crucified precisely in order to prove once and for all that God was not with him, that he did not speak for God, that God could be expected to conform to human standards of worth and value, that God would deliver unto us the type of kingdom we’d prefer, including in it only the types of people we find worthy. And in the silence of the three days after his death, the matter seems settled.</p><p>Yet the Christian faith insists that God has raised and exalted this crucified Jesus of Nazareth. God does not return Jesus to the condition he had before his death. God does not do for Jesus merely what Jesus did for Lazarus. The Christian faith insists that God exalted Jesus and makes him Lord over all. The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, the God of the living and the living God — this God turns out to be precisely the God and Father of Jesus of Nazareth, the crucified one. The stone that the builders rejected has become the cornerstone. And through Abraham’s children, all the nations are blessed.</p><p>But how do we know that Jesus has been exalted? The truth is, we don’t know, at least not automatically. Its not the sort of thing that you can know by just being told about it. Knowledge that Jesus has been exalted comes by way of encountering the Spirit of God as the Spirit of Jesus. The same Spirit that drove Jesus into the wilderness; that reversed his cultural and even theological expectations about Israel’s God; that led him to scorn human standards of worth and value, success and failure — that same spirit challenges us today, in the present moment.</p><p>In my view, this is why the New Testament speaks of the Spirit of God as the Spirit of Jesus without any distinction. We know that Jesus is exalted — we know that whatever gods there may be are such that the same <em>living divine imperative</em> that provoked and empowered Jesus of Nazareth provokes and empowers us today in our own experience, on behalf of that same Jesus. We know this Spirit by its fruit. Just as we cannot see the wind, but we can see the evidence of the wind as it makes trees sway and waves form, we cannot see the Spirit of Jesus or the exalted Christ. But we can know the truth firsthand by welcoming the Spirit of Jesus at the painful and private level of our will.</p><p>The Spirit of Jesus is the same Spirit that set his face toward Jerusalem, by which Jesus provoked his people to a final crisis with their God, out of a love for his people and a zeal for God’s holy name. Not every influence in our lives bears the marks of this Spirit. Not every suggestion or piece of advice or demand made in Jesus’ name is worthy of his demonstrated obedience unto death. Not every thought or opinion that we attribute to Christian principles or Christian culture is worthy of the crucified one. We need to test the character of what we attribute to Jesus against his spirit-empowered life and his spirit-empowered death.</p><p>How does this bear on church unity? As our passage says, “through him both of us have access in one Spirit to the Father.” If I am led by the Spirit of Jesus, the Spirit that set his face toward Jerusalem, I will rejoice to see that same Spirit at work in other people. It ultimately doesn’t matter whether we agree about theology, or church governance, or whether the moon landings were real or fake. The one thing needful for my unity with others is a shared experience of the Spirit of Jesus, however imperfect and limited that experience may be.</p><p>But what if other people don’t demonstrate the presence of this Spirit in their lives? Then that same Spirit leads me to love them, to regard as rubbish any human standards that differentiate and divide me from them, to see in them a person loved by the God who seeks to reconcile and redeem at any cost.</p><p>On the other hand, a form of Christianity guided by human distinctions stands at the foot of the cross hurling insults at the crucified one. To Christ it says, “If God is with you, why don’t you save yourself and us?” The moral apocalypse of the cross is that <em>God is with the one we rejected</em>. Those we are inclined to set aside as useless, perhaps as threatening — people such as these are in the good company of our crucified Lord. Who would our crucified Lord despise? Who would the one we despised and rejected, in turn despise and reject? This is how the cross destroys the ancient and universal hostility between those divided by human standards of worth. Those led by the Spirit of Jesus love who he loves, and despise none. And they rejoice to see that same Spirit at work in others, holding human distinctions and divisions in contempt. The Spirit of Jesus is manifest in us as the power to crucify human distinctions that divide those loved by God.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=337cd1ab75db" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/the-spirit-of-jesus-337cd1ab75db">The Spirit of Jesus the Basis for Unity</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[David Congdon on Salvation and the Church]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdon-on-salvation-and-the-church-799184def483?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/799184def483</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-congdon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Mar 2017 01:17:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-19T01:27:00.864Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chapter 5 of The God Who Saves</h4><p>I’m reading David Congdon’s new book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/God-Who-Saves-Dogmatic-Sketch/dp/1608998274/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1487896067&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+god+who+saves%2C+congdon"><em>The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch</em></a><em> </em>and writing about it as I go. Today I look at the fifth chapter, in which Congdon challenges what he calls the <em>Cyprian axiom</em>, that “outside of the church there is no salvation” (160). Instead, Congdon argues, “outside of salvation there is no church” (189). That is, he recommends that we not take for granted what it is that we mean by “the church” but instead define the church in terms of what we mean by salvation.</p><figure><a href="http://wipfandstock.com/the-god-who-saves.html"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*KEAVfDdVwCTrOdQQupRJrg.jpeg" /></a><figcaption>Cascade Books (Wipf &amp; Stock)</figcaption></figure><p>Congdon begins by noting that the Protestant reformers rejected the idea that the church <em>mediates </em>salvation. Salvation depends, they argued, upon individual faith rather than the church’s sacraments. Even so, the reformers left the traditional notion of the church largely unchanged. Congdon wants to reinterpret the church in light of his own account of salvation. This is consistent with his own <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-soteriocentrism-pt-1-3c5d43f39dc6?source=---------4">soteriocentric approach</a> to theology.</p><p>Congdon observes that twentieth-century theology gave pride of place to the church in its theology. He argues that this “ecclesiocentrism” or “ecclesiasticization” is a mistake. It represents an ancient Christian error. That is, after the apostolic generation, “the abandonment of the eschatological consciousness of the apostles and the corresponding conflation of Christ with the church that constituted the true fall of Christianity” (166). When Christ did not return as expected, the “defining mark of the church shifted from the imminent expectation of Christ’s coming to the sacramental expectation of the priest’s consecrating action” (167). That is, Christianity replaced its expectation of Christ’s soon return with an expectation of grace bestowed via sacraments administered by church leaders.</p><p>Furthermore, “In order to articulate this new self-understanding, early Christian leaders turned to the one paradigm of an alternative culture they all knew best: the people of Israel” (168). Israel became the model for the church, and the mission of the church changed from an outward mission of spreading the Good News to the nations to an inward mission, that of bringing the nations <em>into </em>the church. This was a loss. “The nations are sanctified <em>as the nations</em>,” Congdon writes, “rather than receiving God’s blessing only insofar as they are incorporated into the people of Israel” (170).</p><p>If this is what “the church” has come to mean, what should it mean on Congdon’s account? He observes that the original church was “constituted by its eschatological consciousness. The church had no <em>raison d’être </em>apart from its anticipation of the Messiah’s appearance” (180). That is, the church existed to await the second coming of Christ. Both baptism and the Lord’s Supper were interpreted in light of eschatological expectation rather than in terms of their sacramental value. (I would add that Albert Schweitzer seems to interpret New Testament baptism and the Lord’s Supper as <em>both </em>eschatological <em>and </em>sacramental.) As it happened, “The eschaton was deferred indefinitely and so rendered practically irrelevant. The apocalyptic Christ became the sacramental Christ” (181). Now, in these the last (?) of days, Congdon wants to reinterpret the church, once again, in an eschatological manner.</p><p>Leaving behind a sacramental or institutional interpretation, Congdon aims to interpret the church according to his own modified eschatology. Of course, Congdon’s eschatology is distinct from the early church eschatology — as it <em>must be </em>for all people today since Christ <em>did not </em>return as expected within a generation or so. The apocalypse of Christ, Congdon tells us, is a person-relative and ongoing “existential interruption” rather than a global cataclysm at the close of history. This apocalypse is the event of being co-crucified with Christ, in which the Spirit of God repeats the God-abandoned experience of Jesus in the lives of people today. Being God-abandoned, people are placed outside of themselves and thereby saved, in Congdon’s sense. This event of existential interruption — of being co-crucified with Christ by the repetition of his being abandoned by God through the Spirit of Christ — is something that God brings about rather than humans. In fact, humans need not be aware of it in any conscious or reflective sense. One can be abandoned by God without interpreting that event in those terms. Congdon calls this “existential dislocation” a “prereflective act of faith,” although it is God who acts and not the person of whom we say that they have faith (192). Forgiveness, in turn, “belongs to each person insofar a he or she exists as the child who shares in God’s reign without being conscious of it.” That is, the act of faith on God’s part “constitutes the apostolate as an unconscious community of those who participate in Christ’s death in God-abandonment” (193).</p><p>With <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdon-on-salvation-as-apocalypse-e553c92b0a2?source=---------3">this account of eschatological salvation in view</a>, Congdon tends to speak of the <em>apostolate </em>rather than the <em>church</em>. Of course, the word “church” is too well-worn to for us to use it to describe the domain of salvation via existential interruption as unconscious co-crucifixion with Christ. The word “apostolate” serves this purpose instead. Indeed, since Congdon’s account of salvation gives it a universal scope, if there is no salvation outside the church — or rather no church outside salvation — then the church and the world become <em>one and the same</em>. “The apocalypse constitutes the apostolate,” Congdon writes, “by simultaneously dissolving the distinction between the apostolate and the world” (193).</p><p>Congdon further distinguishes the conscious from the unconscious apostolate. Those who are conscious of the source of the universal human existential interruption — that is, the present and existential repetition of the death of Christ by his Spirit — are the conscious apostolate. Even more broadly, Congdon allows the conscious apostolate to include those who merely “identify the source of our existential liberation as being ‘outside of ourselves.’ Extrinsicality of some kind is thus the bare minimum for the conscious apostolate” (195). Being conscious of the source, or rather of the externality of the sources, however, is no guarantee of participation. It the <em>unconscious </em>apostolate who participate — or perhaps rather are made to participate — in co-crucifixion with Christ.</p><p>What Congdon offers us then is “an apocalyptic theology that dissolves the boundary between church and world” (196). Specifically, any church construed as “a distinct social and cultural body” is annulled “as part of the passing age” (196). In its place, we have the apostolate as “nothing more or less than the site where the kerygma interrupts the world. This interruptive event does not generate an outward, visible separation between church and world but rather elicits an invisible, existential crisis between world and world” (196).</p><p>What then of the church’s mission? If the apostolate is “a constant dying to oneself that frees the community from attempting to secure its existence,” then, Congdon writes, it’s mission is “again and again, to become unconscious and invisible, to journey with Christ on the way of the cross into utter darkness” (197). Congdon summarizes this chapter as follows:</p><blockquote>The apostolate is the site of the apocalypse by existing purely as event. In correspondence to Christ it pursues fidelity, not permanency; credibility, not authority; vitality, not stability; justice, not legality; translatability, not universality. The apostolate may be here today and gone tomorrow, but in each today it arrives as the emancipatory sign of God’s eschatological grace (198).</blockquote><p>As he tends to do, the church is reduced to an event. Indeed, “The kerygma is to theology what the apostolate is to the church. The kerygma and apostolate are the divine events to which theology and the church are the creaturely correlates” (182). Just as theology speaks about and is governed by the kerygma, as existential interruption, so also the church must be defined in relation to the domain of existential interruption, the apostolate.</p><p>The key lesson is that we ought not to begin with our definition of the church as the given. Rather, “We must first discern what constitutes the ‘body of Christ’ and only then speak of public manifestations of this body” (192). Just as theology is a public account of the existential event of the kerygma, so also the church is a public manifestation of those who share in this existential and ultimately universal event, the apostolate.</p><p>It has been a few days since I tried to write about this book, and I must admit that when I come back to my notes and highlights, I find it tricky to remember what all the words mean. This confusion clarifies my reaction to Congdon’s book. Congdon writes clearly and I think I understand what he means for the most part, if I stay focused. Also, his dogmatic sketch is tightly constructed with a great deal of internal coherence. Yet I find myself regularly objecting to <em>how he uses the words he uses</em>. They fairly often don’t mean the same thing <em>to me </em>as they apparently mean <em>to him</em>. That’s fine, as far as it goes. But I am a long way, in many cases, from being convinced that <em>I </em>should adopt Congdon’s framework for myself. I fear that much of what I value in the Christian good news, as I understand it, is lost or buried by Congdon’s use of our common terms.</p><p>For instance, I can agree with Congdon that all people will be existentially interrupted by God in the course of their existence — if only at birth and death. And if salvation just is existential interruption — which I doubt — then if all people are existentially interrupted then all people are saved. This much is analytically true for a person who chooses to define salvation as existential interruption and existential interruption as a universal feature of human existence. That doesn’t mean that all people are saved in another more familiar (to some) sense of “saved.” Concerning other notions of salvation, Congdon seems to advise that we abandon hope. Existential interruption is all that we can have, and our final destination, he told us above, is “utter darkness.” I expect that the final couple chapters will shed more light on this front. Even so, the picture painted so far seems too bleak to do justice to the Christian good news as various people at various times and places have understood it. I see little cause for celebration or worship in Congdon’s good news so far. Maybe it’ll grow on me with time.</p><p>Continuing with Congdon’s definitions, if the apostolate/church is defined as the domain of salvation, and salvation is the universal event of existential interruption, then the distinction between the apostolate/church and the world collapses. They become one and the same, or at least coextensive. This is to be expected on a universalist dogmatic sketch. Yet if the terms we use leave us unable to speak of the Kingdom God over and against the world — the realm governed by God’s love from the realm opposed to it — then those terms risk losing contact with reality. I can grant, and even applaud, the idea that God is at work in the world as a whole, even challenging <em>all people </em>at the individual existential level during the course of their lives. At present I deny, however, that this challenge constitutes the salvation of each person. Such a salvation seems like no salvation at all. God’s challenge needs to bear fruit in some sense if I am going to be comfortable speaking of it as bringing salvation to those challenged.</p><p>Congdon speaks of the existential interruption of a person as an “act of faith.” Normally, the actor in an “act of faith” is the human who places their trust in God. But by “act of faith” Congdon means the act in which God existentially interrupts a human life via God-abandonment. God acts. Yet the act of faith applies to the human. So who has faith here? This strikes me as a very odd way to use the phrase “act of faith” since the human does not act but is rather <em>acted upon</em>. And the action in question is not faith — as many construe it — but God-abandonment. This strikes me as collapsing the distinction between an <em>opportunity </em>for faith, or a <em>test </em>of faith, and the faith itself. I see no reason to collapse this distinction, apart from supporting the coherence of Congdon’s dogmatic sketch, and have reason not to. I want to acknowledge that humans seem to have <em>a role to play </em>in responding to God’s challenge, to cooperating when existentially interrupted. I want to say, with the author of Hebrews, “Today, if you hear his voice, do not harden your hearts.” Such a command, which I doubt we should regard as culturally-bound, makes no sense to me when an act of faith is distinct from the actions of the faithful.</p><p>Likewise, by “forgiveness” Congdon means unconsciously sharing in God’s reign, which really means unconscious co-crucifixion with Christ. But what manner of forgiveness is it to be abandoned by God? And might forgiveness involve a role for the human who is forgiven, such as receiving and accepting an offer of forgiveness? In Congdon’s system, forgiveness is unilateral. It is something that <em>happens </em>to a person, like faith, perhaps without their knowing of it. Admittedly, some Christians do treat forgiveness as something that does not require prior repentance or even informing the forgiven person. I’m not sure such construals are helpful, but I admit they are fairly common. At the very least, forgiveness means different things to different people. For my part, being co-crucified with Christ seems distinct from being forgiven inasmuch as apart from resurrection “your faith is futile and you are still in your sins” (1 Cor 15:17). Crucifixion may lead to resurrection, but without resurrection we lack forgiveness and so I want to maintain a distinction between forgiveness and co-crucifixion.</p><p>Faced with Congdon’s account of the ecclesiasticization of Christianity, I largely agree that a turn away from eschatology to the sacraments is a turn for the worse. He truly brings home the need for an eschatological theology. For my part, I lack a well developed eschatology. I acknowledge that I can’t simply adopt the New Testament eschatology <em>as is</em>. But I’m not convinced that I have nowhere else to go other than Congdon’s present and existential eschatology. I thank him and his book for pushing me to think harder about this important area.</p><p>I also value Congdon’s distinction between the church’s original (and proper) <em>centrifugal </em>or outward mission to the nations and the subsequent <em>centripetal</em> mission of assimilating the nations and incorporating them <em>into </em>the church. Congdon is right to remind us that Christianity is not a culture and the church is trans-cultural. Too often we have confused our culture and social group with the church. Yet I wonder if Congdon’s collapse of the world and the (unconscious) church concedes too much. I expect that the people of God — that is, the people who respond to the good news and are empowered by the Spirit of Jesus to manifest his love for each other and outsiders — will be empirically distinct from world they inhabit. Indeed, they will be known by their love. This seems to be a sort of trans-cultural evidence that God is with them. Such evidence requires human cooperation, unlike various sacramental strategies for identifying the church.</p><p>I remain wary of how Congdon collapses various entities into events (so far this has happened to God, Christ, the Spirit, and people in general). In this chapter, Congdon speaks of the apostolate or church as an event. I don’t quite understand why personal terms and notions should be replaced with what strike me as impersonal event-talk. I wonder if it has something to do with a distinction between time and eternity. Maybe David can help me out on this. In any case, it reminds me of a letter that Albert Einstein wrote after <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michele_Besso">his friend Michele Besso</a> died. Einstein wrote:</p><blockquote>Now he has departed from this strange world a little ahead of me. That means nothing. People like us, who believe in physics, know that the distinction between past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion.</blockquote><p>Put another way, perhaps Besso’s life is just a series of events in four-dimensional space-time. Those events retain their coordinates and it matters little if — as a set of events — they include a so-called final event of death. But it <em>does </em>seem to matter when a life ends. And I am inclined to think that there is a <em>real distinction </em>between past, present, and future given our inescapable experience of the passage of time and of the apparent tragedy of death. I think along these lines for the same reason that I deny that an evil Cartesian demon is deceiving me about the external world. Anyway, I just mention this quote because Congdon’s reduction of persons to events reminds me of this Einstein quote. But I probably haven’t quite understood his reasons for this yet.</p><p>Finally, what about the Christian proclamation? Yes, Congdon rightly points to a non-verbal element of the Christian faith as foundational. The non-verbal features of Christianity are all too often ignored. Talk, of course, is cheap and Congdon rightly reminds us that an unconscious element lies deeper than conscious Christianity. Yet if the Christian proclamation is re-cast as an event of unconscious existential interruption, then it sounds to me like no proclamation at all. That is, Congdon’s kerygma seems utterly unlike a proclamation inasmuch as it is essentially non-verbal. I’d rather call Congdon’s kerygma the acts of God in Christ and Congdon’s theology the kerygma as he articulates now. I’d rather not use the term kerygma to denote a non-verbal thing.</p><p>Well, that’s chapter 5. I hope I haven’t said anything too naive in my reflections here. On to chapter 6.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=799184def483" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdon-on-salvation-and-the-church-799184def483">David Congdon on Salvation and the Church</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rich Davis Challenges Pacifists on the Atonement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/rich-davis-challenges-pacifists-on-the-atonement-c150ee695a0a?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c150ee695a0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rich-davis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[atonement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Mar 2017 16:06:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-01T00:54:04.306Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>My critique</h4><p><a href="https://tyndalephilosophy.com/2017/03/14/penal-substitution-and-the-pacifists/">Penal Substitution and the Pacifists</a></p><p>Today Dr. Richard Davis challenged pacifists who reject the doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement (PSA) to clarify their view. I’m not a pacifist, but I am a critic of penal substitution. Although I once held it, I now regard it as an inadequate atonement doctrine. That’s another story — an ongoing story. Here are some thoughts about Rich’s challenge.</p><p>The challenge begins with Rich translating Isaiah 53:5 into this proposition:</p><blockquote>(R1) Jesus was crushed <strong>as a punishment for</strong> our iniquities.</blockquote><p>This, in brief, is his doctrine of penal substitution. Based on how he clarifies in the follow paragraphs, I take it that Rich wants to say (and this is <em>my summary </em>of him):</p><blockquote>(R1a) God punished Jesus for the iniquities of all sinners.</blockquote><p>That is, Jesus was punished (took the punishment) for each person’s sins — past, present, and future. And it was <em>God </em>who punished Jesus. Rich then criticizes three pacifist Christian authors who reject his doctrine, for various reasons. He summarizes their alternative view in this proposition:</p><blockquote>(R2) Jesus was crushed by the Romans <strong>as a consequence of</strong> our iniquities.</blockquote><p>This alternative view differs from Rich’s PSA in two senses: (1) Jesus is not punished but merely crushed, and (2) it is the Romans who crush him rather than God.</p><p>Rich then criticizes (R2) for leading to “perplexity if not outright falsehood.” Why so? I’ve read a number of authors who articulate a non-PSA account of the atonement without leading to “perplexity or outright falsehood.” These include two authors who I strongly suspect Rich Davis respects and appreciates — Nicholas Wolterstorff in his book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Justice-Emory-University-Studies-Religion/dp/0802866158%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAILSHYYTFIVPWUY6Q%26tag%3Dduckduckgo-d-20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953%26creativeASIN%3D0802866158"><em>Justice in Love</em></a><em> </em>and Paul K. Moser in his book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Elusive-God-Reorienting-Religious-Epistemology/dp/052112008X/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1489502657&amp;sr=1-1&amp;keywords=Moser%2C+elusive+God"><em>The Elusive God</em></a>. Why not engage <em>these philosophers </em>on their rejection of PSA rather than pick on various “emergent” figures? The people Rich addresses are not likely to reason by the same rules of analytic philosophy to which Rich is accustomed. It would be a hollow victory if they simply gave up because they couldn’t speak his language. That’s not to say that Rich shouldn’t do both, but I think he’d have a formidable challenge on his hands if he engaged Wolterstorff and Moser on this. For my part, my doubts about PSA began when I read these two authors. These doubts have been confirmed as I’ve read more broadly. And I haven’t read any of the emergent leaders that Rich targets in this post.</p><p>Back to Rich’s challenge, he suggests that (R2) is <em>ambiguous — </em>which is to be expected since it is, after all, <em>his own summary</em> of the work of others. He then looks at two ways to construe “as a consequence of” in (R2) — namely, as a cause and as a sufficient condition. In the first case, (R2) becomes:</p><blockquote>(R2a) Our iniquities caused the crushing of Jesus by the Romans.</blockquote><p>Rich suggests that this construal would require <em>backwards causation </em>in time, since the iniquities of future sinners can only be the cause of a past event — that is, the crushing of Jesus by the Romans — if future events can be the cause of past events. He suggests that “this is quite a metaphysical pill to swallow to avoid penal substitution.” How then does Rich avoid taking this pill on his own view?</p><p>Just as Rich finds “as a consequence of” ambiguous in (R2), we can also find “for” ambiguous in (R1). What does Rich mean by Jesus being crushed as a punishment <em>for </em>future iniquities? If he means that “Our future iniquities are the cause of Jesus being punished in the past” then his own view would suffer from the same defect as the view he criticizes. What then does he mean?</p><p>He tells us. It is <em>God</em>, on his view, who lays our future sins upon the historical Jesus. “It’s divine imputation that’s in view here, not backward causation.” Presumably, God in his foreknowledge of future sins lays those sins upon Jesus. Or, without appeal to foreknowledge, perhaps God simply resolves to count all sins to come as laid upon Jesus — without counting the future cost, so to speak. Just as foreknowledge or resolving do not necessarily require retro causation, neither does Rich’s view. But if that is so, then <em>neither does the view that he criticizes</em>. It could be that God allows the Romans to crush Jesus on account of God’s foreknowledge or mere anticipation of future sins. This wouldn’t require interpreting the death of Jesus as God’s punishment upon Jesus. Or it could be that God chooses to accept the obedient death of Jesus as a sufficient response to all future sins, without any need for foreknowledge of all future sins. There are lots of options. My point: retro-causation is in no way the burden that PSA’s opponents must bear. Rich must bear it too, and I’m sure he can deal with it just fine — as can his opponents.</p><p>In the second case, Rich construes (R2) as:</p><blockquote>(R2b) Our iniquities are a sufficient condition for the Romans crushing Jesus.</blockquote><p>Rich rejects this as inadequate because it is possible, he thinks, that God <em>might not </em>have saved humans from their sins. Therefore, human sin is not a sufficient condition for the redemptive death of Jesus. Notice, however, this criticism threatens his own view.</p><p>Again, wondering what Rich means by “punishment for our iniquities,” we can construe his (R1) as “Our future iniquities are the sufficient condition of Jesus being punished in the past.” How would Rich amend his own view to avoid his own criticism? I think he would say that “punishment for our iniquities” does not mean that our sins are the sufficient condition for the redemptive death of Jesus. That death is a <em>gift</em>, not something we guarantee or bring about by sinning.</p><p>Likewise, a proponent of (R2) could say, that the death of Jesus is a consequence of our iniquities in the sense that our salvation somehow requires this death. Or they could say that given human sin — which happens to be a constant feature of human life in the past and in the future — a righteous man like Jesus was bound to be killed by sinful humans. Or they could say that God, knowing the sins of the world, has subjected this world to judgment such that even the righteous suffer. Jesus, being obedient to this Father unto death, was crushed by the Romans in this realm of judgement for which we all hold some degree of responsibility. I could go on. Needless to say, there are plenty of possible ways to reject PSA.</p><p>In conclusion, Rich’s criticism of those who object to penal substitution — or simply the idea that God punished Jesus — does not strike me as a very careful or sympathetic criticism. His challenge can easily be rejigged to attack his own view. Of course, Rich can then easily defend his view against his own challenge. But so can his opponents.</p><p>One might get the impression from Rich’s post that opponents of penal substitution are in a logical corner, struggling to articulate a coherent view. This impression would be a false one. With a little creativity, there are plenty of options for opponents of penal substitution — especially if they are truth-seekers. For starters, I’d recommend reading Wolterstorff and Moser on this. A healthy next step would be Peter Taylor Forsyth’s book chapter entitled “<a href="http://pmoser.sites.luc.edu/idolanon/ForsythAtonement.html">The Atonement</a>” (also <a href="https://archive.org/stream/atonementinmoder00londuoft#page/48/mode/2up/search/back+to+Christ">available free here</a>).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c150ee695a0a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/rich-davis-challenges-pacifists-on-the-atonement-c150ee695a0a">Rich Davis Challenges Pacifists on the Atonement</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[David Congdon’s account of Christ and the Holy Spirit]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-account-of-christ-and-the-holy-spirit-8e01e4c65245?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e01e4c65245</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-congdon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Mar 2017 02:44:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-08T03:08:58.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chap. 4 of his book, The God Who Saves</h4><p>I’m reading David Congdon’s new book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/God-Who-Saves-Dogmatic-Sketch/dp/1608998274/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1487896067&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+god+who+saves%2C+congdon"><em>The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch</em></a><em> </em>and writing about it as I go. <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-universal-salvation-94ff4f81cfa3#.ikbzw1ojw">Last time</a> I wrote about Congdon’s account of universal salvation. Today I’ll summarize and comment on his account of Jesus and the Holy Spirit as depicted in the fourth chapter.</p><figure><a href="http://wipfandstock.com/the-god-who-saves.html"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*KEAVfDdVwCTrOdQQupRJrg.jpeg" /></a><figcaption>Cascade Books (Wipf &amp; Stock)</figcaption></figure><p>Where should we begin when trying to give an account of Jesus and the Spirit in Christian theology? David Congdon aims to understand Jesus and the Spirit in light of the crucifixion of Jesus and our <em>cocrucifixion </em>with Christ. “The entire debate within the ancient church over christology,” Congdon surmises, “is one long attempt to figure out how to keep deity and humanity together in one person when deity and humanity have already been defined in opposition to each other” (109). Instead of starting with pre-conceived notions of the divinity and humanity of Jesus — and then attempting to reconcile them — Congdon suggests that we attempt to discern what divinity and humanity should mean in light of his account of salvation. At the close of the chapter, he offers this summary:</p><ol><li>Jesus is the one who dies in God-abandonment;</li><li>Jesus is the saving event (i.e., the Christ) insofar as other human beings participate in his death in God-abandonment;</li><li>other persons participate in his death insofar as their existence nonidentically repeats the existence of Jesus;</li><li>other persons repeat the existence of Jesus when they unconsciously share in his eccentricity, his being-outside-of-himself;</li><li>to be outside of oneself is to be interrupted;</li><li>the Spirit of Christ is the agent of interruption;</li><li>every person is, at some moment, interrupted by the Spirit (157).</li></ol><p>There are several features at work in this account, and I’ll try to discuss a few of them beginning with his tendency to describe persons as events.</p><p>One theme I’ve noticed in Congdon’s book so far is a tendency to describe persons as events or actions. “The person is an event,” he writes, “an action, a historical happening” (119). If I’m reading him right, God is “the event of existential interruption” and “this event happens ever anew in the context of a person’s particular existence” (158). Jesus, rather than traditionally being one person both divine and human, is one event in two modes. Specifically, “Christ is the event of God’s presence-in-absence . . . simultaneously the interrupting God and the interrupted human person” (129). The Spirit of Christ, in turn, “is the event of our participation in this death” (142). What of human persons other than Christ?</p><p>In the first chapter Congdon writes, “there is no human essence behind one’s concrete actions and decisions” (18). Humans are inseparable from their contingent actions. But are they reducible to these actions? I suspect that Congdon wants to move away from talk of the human soul, and this may come up later. What I do notice in this chapter is that God, Christ, the Spirit, and humans all seem to be treated as events rather than as persons, conceived some other way. This is especially prominent in Congdon’s treatment of Jesus, who plays the role of both “interrupting God” and “interrupted human person.” Of course, if you define persons as events then there’s nothing to worry about here. But I think that this shift from talk of <em>Christ </em>to talk of <em>Christ-as-event </em>is significant, and one that I am personally wary of. Even so, it fits well within the logic of this book.</p><p>Next, this chapter speaks a great deal about God-abandonment and the fact that Jesus dies forsaken by God. Recall that salvation for Congdon is all about being placed outside of ourselves, and this occurs as we are godforsaken. On the face of it, if salvation is being abandoned by God then it sounds like no salvation at all. To resolve this, Congdon introduces a paradox of sorts — God is present precisely in God’s absence. To be abandoned by God is to be cocrucified with Christ, and she “who finds herself without God simultaneously finds herself with Christ” (129). Yet inasmuch as Christ is absent today, his Spirit is present. Put succinctly, then, “Christ is the presence-in-absence of God, while the Spirit is the ongoing presence-in-absence of Christ” (142).</p><p>In this way, Congdon depicts the three members of the Trinity so that the absence of one means the presence of another. Its almost as if God, Christ, and the Spirit work together to give humans the <em>hot-cold treatment</em>, that is, to both abandon them and remain present at the same time. This is a striking alternative to the idea that the Spirit conveys the personal presence of Jesus, who in turn conveys the personal presence of his Father. As such, what Congdon’s portrait lacks is a sense of <em>fellowship </em>with the Father through the Son by the Spirit. I admit, the symmetry of Congdon’s construal is striking. When I read that “Christ is the presence-in-absence of God, while the Spirit is the ongoing presence-in-absence of Christ,” I was impressed! Yet I find it nevertheless very depressing inasmuch as the godforsaken experience of being placed outside oneself substitutes, on Congdon’s view, for both fellowship with God via Jesus and the Spirit as well as the New Testament hope of future glory. And yet there is something about Congdon’s presence-absence paradox that <em>resonates </em>with me even as I recoil from it. If we speak of this paradox in the context of fellowship with God, then a God-relationship can be strongest at the very point when it is tested most. But such fellowship plays little role in Congdon’s dogmatic sketch.</p><p>The presence of Jesus today, however we construe it, is mediated by his Spirit. Yet on Congdon’s view, this presence is the <em>repetition</em> <em>of an event</em> — that is, Jesus is “present with us as the event of salvation” — rather than fellowship with a living person. Congdon draws his notion of repetition from Kierkegaard. The idea being, as we are cocrucified with Christ — that is, when we are placed outside of ourselves by God — the crucifixion of Christ is <em>brought forward </em>from the past into the present moment. Christ isn’t crucified again. Rather his crucifixion is <em>repeated as it becomes present</em>. “Repetition,” Congdon writes, “is not the supplementation of new occurrences but the movement of the singular occurrence out of the past into new historical moments” (143). The Spirit of Christ is the Spirit of this repetition. To summarize,</p><blockquote>Instead of speaking of one Christ in two natures, we should speak of one saving event in two modes: the historical actuality of the event in the crucified Jesus and the existential repetition of the event in the agency of the Spirit (158).</blockquote><p>Were it not for the Spirit of Jesus, Congdon writes, Jesus would be “lost to history.” This is because Jesus is present today inasmuch as the Spirit repeats his being-abandoned-by-God in the lives of humans, whether consciously or not. And since Christ is understood as an <em>event</em>, this Christ-event can be present when repeated by the Spirit <em>even if </em>the living person of Christ is not present (providing we define <em>living person</em> in a manner that doesn’t reduce persons to events). I don’t think it is wrong to say, of Congdon’s construal, that Jesus is <em>made divine by the Spirit of God. </em>Several passages read this way to me:</p><blockquote>The deity of Jesus is the existential meaningfulness of his humanity, the significance of his singular history. He is divine in the sense that his historical existence has been taken up into eschatological unity with the eternity of God, so that whenever and wherever we encounter the reality of God we simultaneously encounter the history of Jesus (129).</blockquote><blockquote>And as the one who elects Jesus, the Spirit elects and interrupts others, thereby constituting Jesus’s deity at the same time she constitutes his universality (155).</blockquote><blockquote>Jesus is divine as the one who is no longer lost to history but is present with us as the event of salvation. Jesus is divine, therefore, in his unity with others — that is to say, in the pneumatic repetition of his existence within the manifold array of human history (157).</blockquote><p>My impression here is that Congdon interprets divinity as universality or something close. That is, to be divine is to be a universal or eternal event of some sort. Jesus is <em>made divine </em>inasmuch as Jesus is made the Christ-event, the event of being abandoned by God, and this event is repeated by the Spirit in the lives of all people. My impression: this is an account of Jesus being <em>adopted </em>by God and made divine in virtue of his death. Perhaps a better word would be <em>exalted </em>by God, rather than adopted. But Congdon admittedly defines divinity here differently than it is normally defined, which is fine. And as he defines it, and as I read his account, I can’t help but think that Jesus is made divine (in Congdon’s sense) by the Spirit.</p><p>Perhaps Congdon seeks to avoid this impression by depicting the Spirit <em>as </em>the risen Jesus. “Christ and Spirit,” he writes, “do not act in a sequence or order but as a single agent and event: the Christ-Spirit” (154). By denying any sequence, he may answer my concern that the Spirit makes Jesus divine. Yet the result of treating Christ and the Spirit as a single event (and defining persons as events) is that we have only one agent or person: the Christ-Spirit. Congdon suggests that “following the New Testament, we must speak of Christ and Spirit as a single divine agent in different historical modalities” (156). I <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Man-Attested-God-Synoptic-Gospels/dp/0802867952%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAILSHYYTFIVPWUY6Q%26tag%3Dduckduckgo-d-20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953%26creativeASIN%3D0802867952">don’t think the New Testament reads this way</a>, even if some passages do. The New Testament distinguishes Jesus and the Spirit God, only occasionally blurring this distinction. Before his death, at least, Jesus is largely led and empowered by the Holy Spirit, which serves as a separate character in the New Testament narrative. Indeed, we might even say that the Gethsemane struggle is between Jesus and the Holy Spirit. The Messiah, or anointed one, should not be confused with the one who anoints him or that with which he is anointed. Indeed, if Jesus and the Spirit (and perhaps God) are the same agent, then there can be no fellowship between them other than the I-myself relationship. I suspect that Karl Barth might object. Even so, these distinctions seem vulnerable to loss when persons are defined as closely related events.</p><p>This is a large and very rich chapter and I have respect for it as a piece of theological writing. It is well argued and seems internally coherent. My main concerns stem from my own set of theological presuppositions, although I do share many of Congdon’s criticisms of what we might call <em>theology-as-usual</em>. I’ll conclude with one last thought. Although I think Congdon’s use of Kierkegaard’s notion of repetition is very interesting and well placed within his dogmatic sketch, I’d rather (or at least also) appeal to something along the lines of Kierkegaard’s notion of <em>contemporeity with Christ</em>. On this notion (and I’m a bit fuzzy on it) the contemporary disciples of Jesus are at no real advantage when it comes to faith compared to those who live 2000 years later. This is because the condition of faith rests with God, rather than human observation. God must self-reveal, then and now. Another way to spin Kierkegaard’s notion of contemporeity is to say that Christ must become our contemporary, that is, must become a living presence for us today. This is distinct from Congdon’s notion that we find salvation in God abandonment today. Salvation as God’s presence-in-absence would make more sense to me if it involved fellowship with God that could be tested via presence-in-absence.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e01e4c65245" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-account-of-christ-and-the-holy-spirit-8e01e4c65245">David Congdon’s account of Christ and the Holy Spirit</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[David Congdon’s Universal Salvation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-universal-salvation-94ff4f81cfa3?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/94ff4f81cfa3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-congdon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Mar 2017 02:44:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-11T16:59:21.982Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reading his book, The God Who Saves, chap. 3</h4><p>I’m reading David Congdon’s new book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/God-Who-Saves-Dogmatic-Sketch/dp/1608998274/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1487896067&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+god+who+saves%2C+congdon"><em>The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch</em></a><em> </em>and writing about it as I go. <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdon-on-salvation-as-apocalypse-e553c92b0a2#.o8q1bdqbs">Last time</a> I tried to give an overview of what he calls the heart of his book, that is, his account of salvation in the third chapter. I stopped just short of explaining how Congdon argues for universal salvation and refrained from offering any critique. Today I’ll attend to those two tasks.</p><figure><a href="http://wipfandstock.com/the-god-who-saves.html"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*KEAVfDdVwCTrOdQQupRJrg.jpeg" /></a><figcaption>Cascade Books (Wipf &amp; Stock)</figcaption></figure><p>To review my summary from last time, Congdon wants theology to center around soteriology — that is, around salvation. The problem: We don’t have a single account of salvation in the Bible or the Christian church at large. Furthermore, accounts of salvation depend largely on what <em>we </em>identify as the problem from which God saves us. Congdon describes how early Christian adjusted their expectations for God so they differed from their prior Jewish expectations. That is, they left behind hope of political or national salvation and formed the expectation that salvation “could be actual and effective without any external or empirical evidence” (72). Nevertheless, they hoped that one day their hidden knowledge of salvation would be made manifest for the world to see and expected a return of Christ in glory. We still await that return, and Congdon advises that we reinterpret the second coming of Christ in an “existential and present” sense rather than a “cosmological and future” sense (70). At bottom, salvation for Congdon amounts to existential <em>cocrucifixion with Christ. </em>When we experience this cocrucifixion today, that experience is for us the return of Christ. Rather than having a portion of salvation now and awaiting a fuller measure at the close of history, salvation is “<em>wholly </em>past, <em>wholly </em>present, and <em>wholly </em>future” (85, emphasis original).</p><p>David Congdon’s book offers a universalist dogmatic sketch on which all people are saved (<a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/reading-the-god-who-saves-by-david-congden-9c4fd6c8b470#.lnm3s9a3a">I discussed univeralism in my first post</a>). How then does Congdon understand salvation as or via <em>cocrucifixion with Christ </em>to include all people? This is the burden of the remainder of chapter 3.</p><p>Axiomatic for Congdon is the notion that “salvation takes place where we are placed outside ourselves . . . being-outside-ourselves simply is what it means to have a saving faith” (90). In order to save all people, God simply needs to place all people outside themselves. But how can faith be construed as something that <em>happens </em>to a person, rather than a possession or activity or posture of a person? Congdon draws on infant baptism as discussed by Dietrich Bonhoeffer for the needed distinctions. Bonhoeffer distinguishes between “<em>fides directa</em> and <em>fides reflexa</em>. The former refers to an act of faith that takes place in the consciousness without being consciously reflected upon, while the latter is a conscious reflection upon this act of faith” (90). So we have an act of faith in the consciousness and conscious reflection upon the same. This is a legitimate distinction. No thing — other than reflection upon reflection — can be the same as reflection upon itself. A closely related distinction is between “<em>actus directus </em>and <em>actus reflexus</em>, that is, between a direct act of consciousness and the consciousness of subsequent reflection” (90).</p><p>With these distinctions in hand, Congdon contrasts infant baptism as <em>actus directus</em> and adult baptism as <em>actus reflexus</em>. One requires conscious reflection. The other does not. Yet Congdon still describes <em>actus directus </em>and <em>fides directa</em> respectively as “a direct act of consciousness” and “an act of faith that takes places in the consciousness.” Just because something lacks reflection, on these definitions, it doesn’t seem to follow that it is either <em>actus directus </em>and <em>fides directa. </em>These seem to require consciousness, as he defines them, even if they are not consciously reflected upon. Nevertheless, I think that Congdon wants to use these terms in a sense such that no awareness of the direct act or faith is required, and certainly they occur without any reflection.</p><p>Using these distinctions, Congdon essentially argues that a person can have saving faith in God and be saved without their consent or awareness, just as we may baptize and infant. In fact, he argues, all people are saved at this unconscious level, even if they then reflect upon it. Just as an infant is wholly outside of themselves, in terms of existing wholly dependent upon others, so also “whoever shares in the existential posture of the child is an unconscious Christian” (94). This, it turns out, includes <em>everyone</em> at some point in their existence, at least in birth and death:</p><blockquote>[W]e can be confident, based on the logic of the kerygma, that every person has been or will be an unconscious Christian. For some, unconscious faith might only occur in a moment of literal unconsciousness — at birth or at death, where we are placed wholly outside ourselves. Others will encounter eschatological existence in moments of pure being-for-others, such as at the birth of a child, in the ecstasy (<em>ek-stasis</em>, lit. “standing outside oneself”) of love, or in the ethical encounter with a neighbor in need. Still others will be placed outside themselves through the aesthetic experience of the beautiful, which constitutes “an elemental interruption of our framework of reality” that allows us to “see anew” our worldly context by giving it “a direction to the future, to a future that makes whole.” . . . In our estrangement from the world and our own existence, we gain a new understanding of ourselves and the other. However it occurs, each person will, at some moment, participate in the authentic existence promised by and actualized in the eschatological kerygma. Insofar as they are placed outside themselves, faith recognizes that it is Christ himself in whom they are placed (97–98).</blockquote><p>In this schema, truly we can say blessed are the poor, the marginalized and the godforsaken. For they, having been placed outside of themselves by the world in its cruelty, thereby experience cocrucifixion with Christ, which amounts to being saved. It seems as if, on Congdon’s account, any form of suffering or dependence upon others, whether it be chosen or imposed, amounts to cocrucifixion with Christ and serves as the place where the second coming of Christ happens anew.</p><blockquote>[T]he inbreaking of Christ’s reign is a reality for those excluded from every banquet and feast, and only because of this can we be confident that it is a reality also for each of us in the eccentricity of our unconscious self-understanding, our unreflective being-outside-ourselves. . . . [E]ven when our lives come to an end and the world seems to have lost all meaning, we can say in truth that, in him, the kingdom of God has come near (102).</blockquote><p>By way of my response and critique, I should say that although I have read this chapter closely I have not yet read the rest of the book. It could be that my concerns are addressed down the road, but I suspect that since Congdon describes this chapter as the heart of his account, what he says here will remain to the end.</p><p>I really enjoyed reading this chapter and appreciate a number of the problems that Congdon identifies. First, I agree that we lack a single biblical account of Christian salvation. I also agree that the early church revised their Jewish apocalyptic expectations to a large degree. In fact, after reading Albert Schweitzer, I’m inclined to think that Jesus even revised his expectations for God throughout the course of his ministry. Encounter with God is going to shake up prior expectations. I also agree that the Christian church needs to reckon carefully with the delayed return of Christ. The New Testament makes much better sense (again see Schweitzer) when we realize that its authors initially expected Christ to return in glory within their lifetimes. I also think that cocrucifixion with Christ, perhaps interpreted differently, is a powerful theme around which to articulate salvation. In fact, Schweitzer makes a similar point when he contrast’s Paul’s account of salvation via being crucified and raised with Christ to John’s account of salvation via being born again. I also think Congdon rightly distinguishes faith from reflection upon faith and I am open to the idea that God is pleased with people who lack reflective beliefs about God in virtue of a more direct acquaintance with God. And finally, I agree that all people are objects of God’s saving deeds. I could probably come up with even more that I value in this book so far. Nevertheless, I have some major reservations — even granting all that I value in this book. I can’t do justice to these points without writing my own book, but I’ll try to sketch my concerns here.</p><p>First, Congdon’s eschatological trajectory — from cosmic and future to existential and present — seems like a mistake in as much as it replaces the one with the other. I agree that “already but not yet” is an overused and trite summary of Christian existence. Even so, I think that Christian existence involves enjoying the <em>first-fruits </em>of that which is to come. These first-fruits consist of the presence and power of God’s Holy Spirit at work in willing humans, transforming them progressively into the image of Christ, empowering anyone and everyone who would cooperate with God’s Spirit to become like Jesus, the man in whom we finally see the image of God clearly. It is on the basis of this <em>experience</em> of cooperation and fruitful transformation that Christians can have hope for a future of even deeper union with God in Christ. Eschatological expectations well up within those who have tasted and seen that the Lord is good. The more we receive, the greater our hunger. These expectations do not rest upon a literal or otherwise hermeutically naive interpretation of apocalyptic passages within the New or Old Testament. Instead these expectations rest upon a present fellowship with God in Christ, a fellowship whose quality leads us to expect that it will outlast our own death. As such, eschatology in my view should be existential and present <em>yet also </em>cosmic and future, although I recommend a very generous dose of agnosticism concerning the details of our future expectation. What we should expect is that nothing can separate us from the love of God in Christ, not even a seemingly godforsaken death.</p><p>Second, I agree that cocrucifixion with Christ is important but in a different sense than Congdon depicts it. I agree that human selfishness (or self-centered existence or striving for absolute personal autonomy) are close to the heart of that which ails us as humans. But a related (and perhaps deeper) problem is that we fail to love as God loves, that is, with a self-sacrificial love that seeks the moral best for all others, even our enemies. The human predicament, as I see it, comes down to a conflict between the morally perfect will of God — a will to love — and human opposition and resistance to that will. If anyone, anywhere finds themselves (perhaps unconsciously) <em>challenged </em>to love as God loves and if they venture to do so, perhaps even being unwittingly empowered to do so by God’s Spirit — then that person is known by God whether or not they explicitly know God or know about God. This is because inasmuch as humans love as God loves, they truly embrace the character of God for themselves and demonstrate love for God and God’s ways. In this sense, humans can be “unconscious Christians.” One can love God’s ways without reflective knowledge <em>about </em>God.</p><p>God may challenge humans and even allow hardship and experiences of absolute dependence. But such challenges, as we all face them, are meant to foster <em>trust </em>in the loving character of God, not necessarily to directly place a person outside of themselves as the <em>end in itself</em>. Being placed outside of oneself, in Congdon’s sense, should be seen as an instrumental <em>means </em>toward a distinct redemptive <em>end</em>: that is, adopting a posture of trust toward God. This trust is inseparable from welcoming God’s will of perfect love as authoritative for a person’s own life and relationships toward others. But being placed outside oneself is <em>distinct </em>from embracing God’s will. Even in a moment of absolute dependence, objectively speaking, it seems to me that a person can nevertheless revolt against dependence upon God. I fear that this happens often. Perhaps you can baptize an infant, but an adult cannot be baptized against their will in any meaningful way — even if you dunk them.</p><p>Third, as I understand faith and salvation, they simply don’t make sense in a <em>fully </em>theo-actualized sense. As I use the term, faith isn’t something that <em>happens </em>to a person, it is rather a <em>posture </em>of one person toward another person, even if that other person is God. As such, I think faith is best characterized by something like personal trust, or self-entrustment to another. But faith as being placed outside oneself, perhaps by being godforsaken, seems to confuse the universal <em>opportunity </em>for faith as trust in God with faith <em>itself</em>. Congdon wants to use the word “faith” in a sense foreign to the way I use it. That’s fine, and may just amount to a semantic dispute. Indeed, if salvation just means what he says it means, then I can certainly see why it is a <em>universal </em>salvation. I see no reason to argue against the view that we all have or will have an experience of being placed outside of ourselves. But I deny that this experience is the experience of salvation, at least as I use the word. Rather, it is represents an <em>opportunity </em>for salvation. I maintain that salvation involves person-to-person reconciliation with God and with other humans.</p><p>One last point, which isn’t a criticism but rather a concession. Congdon’s account of salvation seems very bleak to me, in that he seems to be saying that our experience of cocrucifixion with Christ is all there is to expect of God. Given his emphasis on coocrucifixion via godforsakenness, it seems as if an eschatology of hope reduces to an eschatology of expecting to be forsaken by God. This may not be his intent, but it reads that way to me. Is this necessarily a problem for his view? I don’t think so. I’m reminded of the Book of Job and Job’s experience of being godforsaken (an experience that I think parallels the death of Christ in many ways). In that book, we lack clarity about what to expect from God. Job and his friends argue about expectations as they all interpret Job’s suffering and God’s role in various ways. The problem seems to stem from the incompatibility of Job’s (self attested) righteous moral experience, the traditional wisdom of divine-human <em>quid pro quo</em>, and the axiom that God will do no wrong. In a sense, the Book of Job offers an account of shattered eschatological expectations and a reduction of relations with God to the present yet godforsaken moment.</p><p>Perhaps we need to look at theology from this vantage point from time to time — lest our relation to God become one of religious manipulation. Can we embrace God’s love for others even when that love must serve as its own reward? Can we say with Paul that we wish “that I myself were accursed and cut off from Christ for the sake of my own people,” or does self-abandonment finally have no place in our religion? Is the pearl of great price found in the present and existential apocalypse of God through cocrucifixion or does it belong to the future cosmological unveiling in glory? I think David Congdon’s theology, so far, reminds us rightly that the pearl of great price is found in the godforsaken moments, rather than in expectations of future glory. I would add, this is because <em>God is himself the treasure</em>, and this treasure cannot be had as a means to any other end. It must become the end in itself. Congdon’s account points me back in this direction, and even though I don’t like it, I am better for the reminder.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=94ff4f81cfa3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-universal-salvation-94ff4f81cfa3">David Congdon’s Universal Salvation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[David Congdon on Salvation as Apocalypse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdon-on-salvation-as-apocalypse-e553c92b0a2?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e553c92b0a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-congdon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Mar 2017 02:02:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-04T00:31:53.863Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reading chap. 3 of <em>The God Who Saves</em></h4><p>I’ve been reading David Congdon’s new book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/God-Who-Saves-Dogmatic-Sketch/dp/1608998274/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1487896067&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+god+who+saves%2C+congdon"><em>The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch</em></a><em> </em>and writing about it as I go. Today I look at his third chapter, entitled “The Act of Salvation,” which Congdon describes as the heart of his book. I’ll hold my comments to the end in order to try to handle it with care.</p><figure><a href="http://wipfandstock.com/the-god-who-saves.html"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*KEAVfDdVwCTrOdQQupRJrg.jpeg" /></a><figcaption>Cascade Books (Wipf &amp; Stock)</figcaption></figure><p>Any attempt to articulate a Christian doctrine of salvation faces a number of problems. To begin, we lack a single agreed upon doctrine of salvation. Indeed, “the biblical texts do not know a single account of salvation, not even a single account of the cross” (60). So we can’t just re-state a so-called <em>biblical </em>doctrine of salvation since there are several. Even if we could, (and we can’t) we would still face the problem of <em>hermeneutics </em>or interpretation. That is, biblical descriptions of salvation are products of their time and place. They are the fruit of one particular culture as it sought to interpret Jesus. As such, biblical metaphors do not necessarily transfer to our present time, place, and culture. Perhaps “some metaphors are ‘dead to us’” and we must “discern new metaphors and concepts to make sense of the biblical text for the present moment” (62). Congdon advises that we “inquire after the kerygma that comes to contextual expression in the New Testament, and then reflect on how this kerygma may appropriately come to expression in our contemporary situation” (64). Put another way, just as the biblical authors sought to articulate something, we must try to articulate that same thing in our own words. Crucially, we are not simply translating their words into our own language. Rather, the thing needing articulation (the kerygma) must <em>itself </em>be present to us in order for us to articulate it. We cannot simply articulate that which was present to others in the past. We must articulate that which is present to us again today.</p><p>This leads us to Congdon’s account of salvation as <em>apocalypse</em>, or eschatological unveiling. Eschatology has to do with expectations for God, especially expectations concerning how God will save his people from what they think ails them. If, as Congdon argues, theology must focus on soteriology (that is, on salvation) then it must also focus on eschatology since this concerns <em>how and when </em>God will save. Congdon rightly observes that “salvation in the New Testament is fundamentally a matter of eschatology, wherein one is saved through the inbreaking apocalypse of God” (64). One’s perspective on the problem will shape one’s expectations for the solution. The early Jewish Christians came to <em>spiritualize</em> both the perceived problem and its solution. Rather than expecting concrete political salvation of their God, they came to expect a salvation that “could be actual and effective without any external or empirical evidence” (72). Against all appearances, the crucified man was their saviour. God was well pleased with the one who was hung upon a tree, an erstwhile guarantee of divine displeasure. Yet this difference between appearance and reality left early Christians hoping for a resolution, that is, a time when the reality that they perceived would be made manifest for all. A triumphant return of Christ in glory would do the trick, and they expected one very soon. Soon and very soon, the earliest Christians reckoned, all would behold what they knew to be true. Yet Christ did not return, and has yet to return in the sense expected. This delayed return of Christ required <em>yet another </em>round of revisions to Christian eschatological expectation, just as Christians once revised their Jewish expectations.</p><p>Regardless of how they <em>did </em>proceed, how <em>should </em>such revisions proceed? In a phrase, Congdon proposes that “the apocalypse is no longer cosmological and future but rather existential and present” (70). By this he means, I think, that we should no longer expect an apocalyptic end of history via a glorious return of Christ at some future moment. Instead, we should look for an existential apocalypse in the present, within history, modeled for each person on the apocalypse of Jesus as crucified saviour. This apocalypse, or unveiling, is hidden from all but those who receive it, as they are receiving it. As such, it cannot be a cosmic event for all to see, or for any to grasp and control. And since this unveiling is modeled on the death of Jesus as one forsaken by God, Congdon describes it as <em>cocrucifixion </em>with Christ. The crucifixion of Christ is God’s eschatological solution to what ails humans. The expected coming apocalypse of Christ is, Congdon suggests, our own existential <em>cocrucifixion</em> with Christ. The second coming becomes a personal, rather than a global, cataclysm — modeled upon Christ’s own godforsaken personal cataclysm.</p><p>Nevertheless, the delayed return of Christ ought to embarrass Christians in some sense. Congdon follows Eberhard Jüngel in <em>embracing </em>this embarrassment rather than resolving it:</p><blockquote>The certainty that comes with either denying or affirming the coming advent leads to the comfortable domestication of the kerygma. To prevent this, the embarrassment “must remain . . . a lively embarrassment,” so that we never experience ourselves as settled and secure (76).</blockquote><p>The delayed return of Christ is meant to unsettle us, and Congdon calls for an <em>eccentric eschatology</em> since the eschatological deed of God draws us <em>out of ourselves</em>:</p><blockquote>If Christ is near at hand in his very disruption of our propensity toward easy solutions and self-security, then his parousia occurs in the event of the word of justification that disturbs our illusions of peace and safety and thereby places us outside ourselves (<em>extra nos</em>). And this disturbing word from the eschatological beyond, this <em>verbum externum</em>, would indeed be the “new coming of the one who has already come,” since the essence of Christ’s initial presence was the proclamation of this same unsettling eschatological word. I call this existential account of the apocalypse an <em>eccentric eschatology</em>; it is a soteriology determined by the ex-centricity that defines the being of the person who belongs to the new age of faith, who is a justified creature before God (77).</blockquote><p>Cocrucifixion involves being unsettled or placed outside oneself, and the embarrassment of the delayed return of Christ serves this purpose. What does this have to do with the kerygma that we want to articulate today? On Condgon’s dogmatic sketch, “the proclamation of the kerygma in the present situation is the parousia of Christ, the expected future, the new coming of the one who has already come” (78). We might say that the second coming of Christ is replaced by the present preaching about him, but this preaching is not simply a translation of the New Testament. Rather, the second coming of Christ is God’s existential apocalypse in the lives of those being cocrucified with Christ today. This brings us to what I suspect is the rock bottom of this book. Congdon agrees with the apostle Paul’s view that salvation occurs through cocrucifixion:</p><blockquote>He [Paul] thus declares, in what I would identify as <strong>the kerygmatic norm<em> — the only potential “canon within the canon” — for all Christian soteriology</em></strong><em>: </em>Χριστῷ συνεσταύρωμαι, ζῶ δὲ οὐκέτι ἐγώ, ζῇ δὲ ἐν ἐμοὶ Χριστός — “I have been crucified with Christ; and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me” (Gal 2: 19– 20; [Congdon’s] translation) (81, emphasis added).</blockquote><p>Here we have it. Being crucified with Christ in the present is the saving eschatological act of God that we anticipate, rather than some future cosmic apocalypse. This being crucified with Christ is itself the saving apocalypse, or unveiling, of God. The crucifixion in question is existential, rather than necessarily literal or physical. So understood, we are saved <em>from ourselves</em>, rather than from various traditional threats, such as suffering, death, or hell. We are saved from “the illusion that we belong to ourselves, from the anxious attempt to secure ourselves, from the desire to possess our identity and thus our future, from the struggle to assert our freedom and authority” (80). As goes the problem, so goes the salvation — being placed outside of oneself via cocrucifixion. That is, “God eschatologically interrupts our existence and places us outside ourselves, thus making us wholly insecure in ourselves but wholly secure in God” (83).</p><p>If we reinterpret the second coming of Christ as our own cocrucifixion with Christ, then instead of speaking of salvation in terms of the common “already but not yet” tension, Congdon insists that we speak of salvation as “<em>wholly</em> past, <em>wholly </em>present, and <em>wholly </em>future” (85). That is, the same apocalyptic unveiling that occurred in at the death of Jesus is also happening today as we are crucified with Christ. And it will continue to happen in the future. It is already, is present, and is yet to come.</p><p>But what is it about the death of Christ that counts as God’s eschatological unveiling? In a phrase, the death is “apocalyptic and saving <em>because it is a death in God-abandonment</em>” (85, emphasis original). If humans need to be unsettled, then it would seem that there’s nothing that does the trick quite like being abandoned by God. Congdon wants to take Jesus at his word in his cry of abandonment from the cross and look to this godforsaken experience of Jesus as a template for cocrucifixion with Christ. He even draws an interesting comparison between the loud cry of Jesus on the cross and the two other exorcism-related loud cries in Mark’s Gospel. He almost speaks as if the crucifixion was the <em>exorcism </em>of the world from Jesus. Nevertheless, what does abandonment by God accomplish at the cross? What is gained by being forced out of ourselves (<em>extra nos</em> as Congdon puts it)? Briefly, Congdon addresses this question and writes, “Cocrucifixion is a movement <em>extra nos </em>for the sake of being <em>pro alio, </em>for another” (89). That is, “To be cocrucified is to be given eyes to see the old world in a thoroughly new way . . . to see each person as the neighbor in need” (89).</p><p>I promised to keep my comments to the end, but I think it would be best to save them for next time. My real aim in this post has been to understand what Congdon means, and I hope I’ve come close. Meditating upon this chapter the past couple days has provoked a great deal of thinking, and things might seem even clearer tomorrow. In any case, there’s a bit more of chapter 3 left to cover, in which Congdon explains with this account of salvation leads to or requires a doctrine of universalism (on which all people are ultimately saved in the manner described above). Until then.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e553c92b0a2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdon-on-salvation-as-apocalypse-e553c92b0a2">David Congdon on Salvation as Apocalypse</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[David Congdon’s Soteriocentrism: pt. 1]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-soteriocentrism-pt-1-3c5d43f39dc6?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c5d43f39dc6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-congdon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Feb 2017 22:38:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-27T02:36:04.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m reading David Congdon’s new book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/God-Who-Saves-Dogmatic-Sketch/dp/1608998274/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1487896067&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+god+who+saves%2C+congdon"><em>The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch</em></a><em> </em>and writing about it as I go. <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/reading-the-god-who-saves-by-david-congden-9c4fd6c8b470#.xlm6xlqny">Last time</a> I looked at his first chapter, in which he outlines the options for Christian universalism. The book reads very well and promises to provoke me to think more carefully about my own views. Already, I’ve noticed a fairly major difference between my own perspective and Congdon’s. That is, Congdon’s account doesn’t seem to have a place for genuine I-Thou encounter between God and humans, <a href="https://ia601507.us.archive.org/13/items/in.ernet.dli.2015.61530/2015.61530.I-And-Thou.pdf">as described for example by Martin Buber</a>. Any notion of a relationship with God is regarded as, at bottom, metaphorical or mythological in origin. As I keep reading, I expect to be further challenged on this point.</p><p>Previous post:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/reading-the-god-who-saves-by-david-congden-9c4fd6c8b470">Reading The God Who Saves by David Congdon</a></p><figure><a href="http://wipfandstock.com/the-god-who-saves.html"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*KEAVfDdVwCTrOdQQupRJrg.jpeg" /></a><figcaption>Cascade Books (Wipf &amp; Stock)</figcaption></figure><p>Given my own influences, this challenge is actually quite helpful. If asked, I’d have to admit that I am largely in agreement with <a href="http://pmoser.sites.luc.edu/">Paul K. Moser’s</a> philosophy and theological method (I’m writing an MA thesis on it). His method gives divine-human I-Thou encounter pride of place, and generally comports with theologians like <a href="https://archive.org/details/principleofautho00fors">Peter Taylor Forsyth</a> and <a href="https://archive.org/details/dogmatics01brun">Emil Brunner</a>. (I’m also just starting to put together <a href="https://medium.com/one-thing-needful">a website</a> where I’ll (re)post public domain writing from this tradition.) That said, I’m reading Congdon’s book more skeptical about his construal of divine-human I-Thou encounter than about his universalism. But I realize that we come from different corners of the theological world and I truly want to understand his dogmatic sketch. The better I understand his views, the better I’ll be able to understand my own. And what better way to understand than to read and write about it?</p><p>David Congdon entitles his second chapter “Soteriocentrism: Prolegomena to a Dogmatic Sketch.” This chapter sets out his view about what theology is, what it’s about, and roughly how to do it. To put his conclusion first,</p><blockquote><em>Christian theology reflects the saving action of God</em>. God’s saving action is the origin, object, and norm of theological discourse. The single divine act that elects, justifies, reconciles, redeems, and reveals makes theology <em>possible</em> by bringing human beings into an encounter with God, makes theology <em>meaningful</em> by providing the material context for scientific reflection, and makes theology <em>orderly</em> and <em>critical</em> by supplying the criteria for authentic God-talk (p. 50).</blockquote><p>This is basically what Congden means by <em>soteriocentric</em> theology — a theology that is about and because of God’s saving actions. Such theology has three major features (I’ll only get to the first two in this post).</p><p>First, <em>theology is a science</em> inasmuch as it is “a mode of rational inquiry appropriate to its object” (p. 25). So far so good. Congden distinguishes between faith as <em>doctrinal content </em>to be believed and the faith <em>by which </em>such content can be believed. He rightly identifies the historic and all-too-common error of exalting <em>faith that </em>over <em>faith in</em>, that is, belief that something is the case over “the faith of the human subject that relates to God” (p. 25). Christian faith ought not be be confused with intellectual assent.</p><p>Congdon credits a revival of this distinction between <em>faith in</em> and <em>faith that </em>to a “rise of historical consciousness” in the modern era (p. 25). That is, as people came to realize that their beliefs and language are largely contingent upon where and when they live, faith as mere correct belief was no longer a solid rock upon which to stand (and it never was by the way). We might call this realization the discovery of the <em>perspective-bound nature of human inquiry </em>(see Paul Moser’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-after-Objectivity-Making-Perspective/dp/0195130944"><em>Philosophy after Objectivity</em></a>, chap. 1). If all inquiry is inquiry in perspective, what access, if any, do we have to an objective picture of the way things actually are? Lacking any escape from such questions, theology must shift from allegedly objective inquiry to admittedly perspectival inquiry. This much seems correct to me.</p><p>Yet if inquiry is perspective-bound, some inquirers may deny the existence or importance of that which eludes their reach. This seems to be Congdon’s approach regarding God outside of God’s relations to humans. He writes,</p><blockquote>As we have argued above, theology has no access to a divine in-itself — a theological <em>Ding an sich</em> — apart from the human subject on whom God acts (p. 50).</blockquote><p>Put another way, “The wind/spirit blows where it chooses, and you hear the sound of it, but you do not know where it comes from or where it goes” (John 3:8 NRSV). It is only as God acts upon humans that we perceive God. This seems right. But Congdon takes it further.</p><blockquote>In other words, we only have <em>access</em> to a God who acts upon us, because God simply <em>is</em> the God who acts upon us. God’s being <em>is</em> the act of salvation. There is no theological <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noumenon"><em>Ding an sich</em></a><em>. </em>We will develop this claim and its implications throughout the course of this book (p. 50).</blockquote><p>Unless I’ve misunderstood, this strikes me as a reduction of the wind/spirit to merely its sound. But why not just say that our access to God is <em>limited access</em>, that we only have access to God inasmuch as God acts toward us? Why not instead say that God has made known God’s true self to us through God’s saving deeds? For my part, I feel quite uncomfortable saying that there is “no theological <em>Ding an sich</em>.” The crucial matter, I think, is the extent of our access to God as God is, rather than rejecting the notion of God as God actually is. Otherwise, I fear that we are stuck with some type of theological anti-realism (Randal Rauser has <a href="http://randalrauser.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/ijst_153.pdf">an interesting paper</a> analyzing Rahner’s Rule along these lines).</p><p>This leads to the second feature of Congdon’s construal of theology, namely, <em>theology as hermeneutics </em>(or interpretation). If we acknowledge the perspectival nature of inquiry, then all that remains is to interpret the world as we perceive it. Our conceptual frameworks are indeed our contribution to inquiry, they are not objective features of the world as such. This seems like a modern (and positive) development in theology. For much of theological history, the proper quarry was thought to be “a <em>theologia perennis</em>, a perennial or permanent theology safe from the hermeneutical queries of the present situation” (p. 37). However, since all theology is perspectival we have no access to a theology that transcends interpretation. The question is how, not whether, we will interpret the world as we perceive it. I’m broadly in agreement here.</p><p>My first question: What, precisely, are we interpreting? Congdon seems to be interpreting religious texts, like the Bible, or various traditions. A text, or tradition, is both “a past artifact and a present event” (p. 38). It involves distinguishing “what is said” from “what is meant,” then and now. My next question: Meant by whom? Following Paul Moser, I take linguistic meaning to be relative to the interpretive commitments of language users (see his <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-after-Objectivity-Making-Perspective/dp/0195130944"><em>Philosophy after Objectivity</em></a>, chap. 3). The author of a text means something by the words they use. Although the modern reader can find new meaning in those words, they cannot find new <em>authorial</em> meaning. That meaning is fixed by the interpretive choices of the author. Put this way, if a text means for us something other than what the author meant, then we are bringing our own meaning to that text. That’s fine, but I think it is important to pinpoint the source of meaning in such cases. If and when modern readers find meaning in an ancient text that differs from the authorial meaning, their act of re-interpretation (whether reflective or unreflective) is responsible for the new meaning. What standards, then, should guide how we interpret texts and tradition? In a word, the <em>kerygma </em>(a term that means preaching or proclamation in Greek).</p><blockquote>The kerygma is the divine word-event that unites past and present, there and here, then and now. It is an event pregnant with infinite possibilities of meaning, which presses us ever onward toward the open future, compelling the community of those who hear this word to understand its contemporary significance in surprising new ways (p. 39).</blockquote><p>I’m concerned with the phrase “infinite possibilities of meaning.” If something can be interpreted in infinite ways, then it lacks any meaning. A word of gibberish, for instance, has no standards for interpretation and is therefore meaningless (in virtue of infinite possibilities of meaning). But Congdon may instead be talking about the kerygma having a <em>variable </em>meaning capable of addressing <em>every possible human situation</em>. Crucial to his notion of the kerygma is that it speaks to each time and place, without exception. This much seems right to me. He insists, however, that we cannot distill the kerygma from any given time and place, and articulate it once and for all. This kerygma is not a minimal propositional content of the Bible, that is, it isn’t a canon within the canon. Congdon describes it, instead as an event. “Every genuine interpretation is an existential encounter with a reality that confronts and claims us in and through this text” (p. 41). I like this, although I don’t fully understand it and I suspect Congdon and I will differ over what we should mean by existential encounter.</p><p>Putting it all together, if I dare, Congdon seems to say that we hear the kerygma as we discern what texts and traditions should mean for us here and now, rather than merely what they meant then and there. But, if we bring new meaning to texts and traditions in light of the kerygma, how can those texts and traditions illuminate the kerygma itself? Which comes first, the kerygma by which we interpret texts or the texts that reveal to us the kerygma?</p><p>Well, that seems like enough for now. I’m sure that most of these questions are answered in the coming pages.</p><p>Next in this series:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BNasmith/david-congdons-soteriocentrism-pt-2-797a66553a37">David Congdon’s Soteriocentrism: pt. 2</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c5d43f39dc6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-soteriocentrism-pt-1-3c5d43f39dc6">David Congdon’s Soteriocentrism: pt. 1</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reading The God Who Saves by David Congdon]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/meta-theology/reading-the-god-who-saves-by-david-congden-9c4fd6c8b470?source=rss----86b87735e40---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c4fd6c8b470</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[david-congdon]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Nasmith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Feb 2017 03:17:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-04T00:51:02.882Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Chap. 1: Introduction</h4><p>A couple years ago <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heaven-hell/#ThrPriEscVie">I stumbled across a trilemma</a> that clarifies the options for Christian theology considerably. Word for word, it goes like this:</p><ol><li>All humans are <em>equal</em> objects of God’s unconditional love in the sense that God sincerely wills or desires to reconcile each one of them to himself and thus to prepare each one of them for the bliss of union with him.</li><li>Almighty God will triumph in the end and successfully reconcile to himself each person whose reconciliation he sincerely wills or desires.</li><li>Some humans will never be reconciled to God and will therefore remain separated from him forever.</li></ol><p>This set of statements is logically incompatible in the sense that any pair rules out the remaining statement. This means we can sort theologies by which statement they reject, or which pair of statements they embrace.</p><ul><li><em>Augustinian </em>or <em>Calvinist </em>theologies reject (1), embracing (2) and (3).</li><li><em>Arminian </em>theologies reject (2), embracing (1) and (3).</li><li><em>Universalist </em>theologies reject (3), embracing (1) and (2).</li></ul><figure><a href="http://wipfandstock.com/the-god-who-saves.html"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*KEAVfDdVwCTrOdQQupRJrg.jpeg" /></a><figcaption>Cascade Books (Wipf &amp; Stock)</figcaption></figure><p>David Congdon’s new book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/God-Who-Saves-Dogmatic-Sketch/dp/1608998274/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1487896067&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+god+who+saves%2C+congdon"><em>The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch</em></a><em> </em>explores the third option above, known as universalism. Being curious, and hearing good things about it on Twitter, I bought the Kindle version and began reading it this week. Having only read the first couple chapters, I can say that the book reads very well and has captured my attention and interest. Whether or not I agree with the dogmatic sketch in this book, I want to understand it. In fact, reading this books makes me want to write about it and discuss with others (but the only people I know who might chat about it live on Twitter). So here goes.</p><p>In my view, Christians ought to hope that universalism is true — namely they should hope that all people are ultimately reconciled to God. Knowing that universalism is true (or false) is another matter, since knowledge requires evidence. If we lack the evidence needed to discern whether universalism is true (or false), then we should <em>desire </em>that it is true, even if we remain agnostic. If our evidence largely counts against universalism, we should then <em>hope against hope </em>that it is true. Even a Christian who believes that universalism is false should hope and wish that they are wrong. In his opening chapter, David Congdon recasts hope that universalism is true as an instance of a more tenacious biblical notion of hope in God’s promises. “Christian faith is <em>confident hope</em> in the <em>effective promise </em>of God’’ (p. 2). Put this way, Congdon invites his readers to leave behind hope as wishing and explore hope as knowing. Whether we can know, I maintain, will nevertheless depend on our evidence. I’ll have to wait and see whether he identifies the needed evidence as I keep reading.</p><p>Universalism, like any -ism, comes in several flavours and Congdon outlines the main ones. First, he notes that most Christians agree with the idea that “God calls people from every nation or people group (in Greek, <em>ethnos</em>) to become followers of Jesus Christ and participants in the community of faith” (p. 4). This view is a species of universalism, namely <em>multiethnic universalism</em>. He then recasts the trilemma above as a choice between <em>actual nonuniversalism </em>(rejects statement 1), <em>potential universalism</em> (rejects statement 2), and <em>actual universalism</em> (rejects statement 3). This terminology works fine, since the root trilemma remains no matter what you call it.</p><p>Congdon then introduces two new divisions of actual universalism. Are all people saved (on universalism) <em>with</em> or <em>without </em>their cooperation? In both cases, God’s actions are <em>necessary </em>for salvation, but they may or may not be <em>sufficient</em>. Congdon calls these two species of actual universalism <em>anthropo-actualized</em> and <em>theo-actualized</em> universalism. The crucial matter is <em>who</em> takes the final step in human salvation (presuming that God initiates). Humans or God? (Reading this distinction, I wonder if we could also speak of an <em>internalist </em>account of salvation, on which salvation requires some action internal to the human, and an <em>externalist </em>account of salvation, on which salvation is possible without reference to the internal life of the person being saved.) Condgen then subdivides actual universalism a second time. The question now, When are all people saved? The two main options, he suggests, are <em>protological actualization</em>, on which salvation happens in the past, and <em>eschatological actualization</em>, on which salvation happens in the future. Taken together, actual universalism comes in four flavours:</p><ol><li><strong>Protological anthropo-actualized universalism</strong>. Congdon rejects this option since it doesn’t seem to make sense to say that humans make actual their salvation before they exist.</li><li><strong>Protological theo-actualized universalism</strong>. Congdon attributes this view to Karl Barth, the idea that God makes actual the salvation of all people prior to their existence. He also calls this view <em>Barthian universalism</em>.</li><li><strong>Eschatological anthropo-actualized universalism</strong>. This is the view that eventually, at the end of all things, all people will cooperate with God and be saved. Congdon calls this <em>evangelical universalism</em> since this requirement of human cooperation strikes him as evangelical.</li><li><strong>Eschatological theo-actualized universalism</strong>. This is Congdon’s own view and the one that he aims to expound in his book.</li></ol><p>This fourth view distinctively grants to God and not humans the task of making actual their salvation, and it requires that God do so in the present or future rather than having already done it in the past. Since this salvation is eschatological, it must address those being saved as a word to them, rather than a prior decree about them. Yet Congdon insists that humans cannot have “a conscious and constitutive role, or else we would have the evangelical account of universalism” (p. 12). I’m curious about how this works out. This following passage hints at Congdon’s approach.</p><blockquote>Once we recognize that divine agency operates on a qualitatively different ontological order, we no longer need to worry about a competition between God and the human person, and thus we no longer need to resort to a cooperative account of divine-human relation. Indeed, both cooperation and competition trade on a fundamentally mythological and metaphysical understanding of God as one causal agent among others within the cosmos. If divine agency does not conflict with any creaturely agency — being of a wholly different order — then a universal divine decision to elect all human beings in Jesus Christ need not compete with the free decision of individual persons. . . . I am only interested in demonstrating that a responsible account of divine being and agency makes it possible to hold together a strongly monergistic doctrine of divine sovereignty with an equally strong doctrine of human freedom (p. 17).</blockquote><p>It seems here that Congdon is going to appeal to some species of <em>compatibilism, </em>the view that a “strongly monergistic doctrine of divine sovereignty” is logically compatible with “an equally strong doctrine of human freedom.” For my part, I am very skeptical toward this approach. It seems to me that God’s will is <em>qualitatively similar</em> to the human will inasmuch as there can be an all-too-real <em>experienced conflict </em>between the will of God and the will of humans. Inasmuch as God confronts humans in experience, perhaps in conscience, we seem to face a genuine Thou to our I (as, for instance, <a href="https://ia601507.us.archive.org/13/items/in.ernet.dli.2015.61530/2015.61530.I-And-Thou.pdf">Martin Buber describes</a>). As such, unless I-Thou encounter with God is illusory, I have my doubts about compatibilism or placing divine agency in a separate category from human agency, as non-overlapping magisteria. The richest features of the Christian faith, in my view, are found in human I-Thou relation to God. In a footnote, Congdon presses the matter further:</p><blockquote>The assumption behind this way of thinking [about human vs divine wills] is the notion that God is a “personal” God. Evangelicals, in particular, are fond of speaking about faith as a “personal relationship” with Jesus. If by “personal” we mean the kind of relationship that I have with another human person, then such language is clearly being used metaphorically, all personal delusions to the contrary notwithstanding. God is not <em>a </em>person, as Paul Tillich rightly stressed in his writings. What then is the meaning of such talk? In the best sense, it affirms that God is not an impersonal thing, an object lying at our disposal, which we are free either to use or ignore. A “personal” God is a living <em>subject</em> that confronts us and unsettles us. To say that faith is a “personal” relationship with God is to say that faith is a personally transformative event wherein we encounter the active reality of God. That much we can and must affirm. But to go beyond this and construe God in anthropomorphic terms as a supernatural person is to leave the realm of faith and enter the world of mythology and fantasy (p.15).</blockquote><p>Congdon is quite emphatic here in discouraging thinking about the divine-human relationship on the template of how humans ought to (ideally) relate to one another. I’m very reluctant to follow him on this. Yes, biblical authors have cast God in the image of various human figures (like king, warrior, etc) and we ought not to understand God solely in terms of these metaphors. Yet if in these, the last of days, God has spoken by a son, and if this chosen human is God’s best self-manifestation, then what do we gain (or lose) by treating the personhood of God as a mere metaphor? Need anthropomorphism always be a dirty word in theology? Could it be that human personhood is a gift, a feature of being made in the likeness of God? (For a high view of humanity, see <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Man-Attested-God-Synoptic-Gospels/dp/0802867952"><em>A Man Attested by God</em></a>, by J.R. Daniel Kirk.) I know that Congdon is concerned about whether certain theological notions are mythological, in the sense of being inseparable from their original time and place. But I’m not sure that the personhood of God should be demythologized in the same way that, say, God as cosmic warrior, ought to be critiqued.</p><p>Anyway, I’m here to learn and enjoying this book so far. I suspect that the division between realist and metaphorical approaches to God as a person will come up again. Back to his argument, Congdon understands human persons to be inescapably historical, in the sense that they are inseparable from their time and place. He rejects any attempt (I think) to abstract a person from their historical existence, meaning their actual actions and choices in a lived historical life. “Salvation is meaningless if it ignores or bypasses a person’s historicity, since that would mean ignoring or bypassing the person altogether” (p. 18). So is a human essentially their historicity? This is an interesting twist on a more familiar (to me) notion that to quench the freedom of humans is to quench the people themselves. Hence, a salvation by coercion destroys that which it might otherwise save. But Congdon is committed to a monergistic salvation that is compatible with human freedom, so long as it saves the person in their historical setting. Again, the initial differences I have with Congdon seem to return to the matter of personhood, whether human or divine.</p><p><em>Stay tuned for more as I digest this interesting book. If you’ve already read it and/or would like to discuss, Medium.com seems like a great place to discuss theology thoughtfully, given the highlight/comment features, private comments, and treatment of comments as their own articles. I’d love to make some new theology friends (or just friends) by chatting about this book here on Medium. It’s like Twitter, but with more space to write.</em></p><p>Next in this series:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/david-congdons-soteriocentrism-pt-1-3c5d43f39dc6">David Congdon’s Soteriocentrism: pt. 1</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c4fd6c8b470" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology/reading-the-god-who-saves-by-david-congden-9c4fd6c8b470">Reading The God Who Saves by David Congdon</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/meta-theology">Meta-Theology Quarterly</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>