<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Opaque Renaissance - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Contemplations on and beyond Game B. If Game A is robotic nationalism, Game B is maybe these things: infinite game, antagonistic cooperation, rooted cosmopolitanism, elegant resilience, networked state, tribal rationality, dissentful consensus, a healthy digital food pyramid. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:05:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/opaque-renaissance" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[ESG means technology]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/esg-means-technology-f7750af6ae49?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7750af6ae49</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[starlink]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[balaji-srinivasan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ukraine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Mar 2022 19:57:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-21T19:57:35.454Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/1*jXqucx23mUL28cktGZWvHA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Russian invasion of Ukraine changed the world. Suddenly the winter came and we appeared in the desert of the Real. People and companies need to get real and creative. And this usually means embracing technology.</p><p>Ukraine’s vice prime minister, Mykhailo Fedorov asked Elon Musk for a Starlink connection and got it within hours. And the devices came within two days. He also published various crypto addresses of organizations supporting their army. Recently Ukrainian government contemplates regulating crypto so it can fundraise directly.</p><h4><strong>From Woke Capital to technological transcendence</strong></h4><p>Balaji Srinivasan <a href="https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1498589127071059970?s=20&amp;t=YQaQwIZYFthJzFOwnnZTJQ">tweeted</a> on an interesting discussion in the EU and Germany focused on ESG taxonomy. And if weapons could be included under investments meeting the environmental, social and governance criteria as non-financial factors for assessing the material risk and opportunities of doing business.</p><p>German weapons’ manufacturers saw a window of opportunity to include weapons in the ESG taxonomy and thus increase their access to financing. Balaji comments that Germans should get bullish on nuclear energy too.</p><p>At first, including weapons into ESG seems quite odd, even unholy to contemplate. How could someone come up with such an idea?</p><p>Well, there is this <a href="https://www.city-journal.org/raytheon-adopts-critical-race-theory">meme</a> of a woke Raytheon. And a woke CIA recruitment <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jpJDnyZqfLw">video</a> with language people outside US won’t comprehend much.</p><p>But Balaji Srinivasan explains why such Hegelian syntheses, like a priest/warrior combination, might be in fact effective. The Left provides a moral justification and the Right provides the effective execution.</p><p>Balaji Srinivasan <a href="https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1320014748717441025?s=20&amp;t=tcySMY9bXCe5FsCMrOO4FA">simplifies</a> the world into three major power attractors today — The Woke Capital (NYT), the Communist Capital (CCP) and the Crypto Capital (BTC). They all oppose each other. The CCP wants you to submit because they are powerful. The NYT wants you to sympathize (and submit) because you are powerful (and privileged on some axis). And BTC wants you to be sovereign.</p><p>And the key is to find the <em>decentralized center</em> between them or some kind of technological transcendence (a z-axis that would transcend the inherent conflict of these three attractors). A way out of <em>maximalism</em> into something he calls <em>optimalism</em>. Because the dose makes the poison. Too little of tolerance is not good. But too much focus on tolerance flips into a new kind of intolerance. Too much sovereignty becomes impractical and solipsistic. The key to resolve this tension is a new kind of technologically enabled tribalism. Call it building epistemic communities in the cloud first.</p><p>All noble ideals are with us since the dawn of humanity. What changes is the technology that enables progress. <strong>Technology moves the Pareto frontier</strong>. One doesn’t need to make a trade-off between eco-friendly car, fast car and safe car. Tesla moved the frontier on all three dimensions. This is all-win approach and the culture of WAGMI enabled by tech.</p><h4><strong>From window dressing to technological progressivism</strong></h4><p>Messari in their Crypto <a href="https://messari.io/pdf/messari-report-crypto-theses-for-2022.pdf">Theses</a> for 2022 mentions ESG as one of the attacks on web3 due to misconceptions about inherent energy scarcity and perceived energy intensity of bitcoin mining.</p><p>But I think ESG needs web3. The decentralized financial internet, together with <em>the ledger of record</em> concept by Balaji Srinivasan, can in fact disrupt ESG and 10x it.</p><p>But by and large, ESG (CSR, Sustainability) still remains a window dressing exercise for potential investors and regulators. The culture and social wars don’t help either and eroded its credibility in the recent years. Hence the stakeholder capitalism and Woke Capital memes.</p><p>But to give CSR community their deserved credit, they are often the true <em>protopians</em> — enthusiastic people believing in, and patiently working towards gradual progress of their companies in sustainability, equality and transparency, using technological innovations, long-term goals and measurable KPIs.</p><p>Maximalists are both dystopian when attacking their enemies, and utopian when presenting their solutions. Protopians are technological progressives and pragmatists.</p><p>Web3 in general and bitcoin in particular reduces violence. Why? Because “<a href="https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1409886769139552257?s=20&amp;t=HhP4rFs9iT9MCLrRc9Bwqw">fiat money is backed by men with guns</a>” and the digital gold is backed by math. No amount of violence will solve a math problem.</p><p>A practical and a directionally right example from Kenya: an unbanked person could have been robbed of cash. But mobile banking in 2007 changed the equation quite a bit.</p><h4><strong>CSR community helped to scale M-Pesa, it can help to rebuild the world with web3</strong></h4><p>Many things in life are Pareto-distributed, and it means that black swans and big disruptions for better or worse are scarce. One of the biggest successes of CSR and development cooperation was the scaling of M-Pesa and the rise of mobile banking innovation in Kenya. And from Kenya and Africa even to places like Albania.</p><p>The original Kenyan innovation of peer-to-peer transfers of mobile phone credit in the micro-finance context was scaled, thanks to a CSR team at Vodafone and a challenge fund grant from the British DFID, into the M-Pesa mobile banking revolution across Africa.</p><p>Some 15 years ago Africans leapfrogged the West not just with mobile telephony, where they skipped the landlines and went straight to mobile phones, but also in mobile banking. Instead of bank accounts and plastic debit cards, they went straight to mobile payments.</p><p>Similar world-changing innovations in web3 might come from places like India, Nigeria or Ukraine in the near future. The ESG community might be a catalyst that will help to scale these innovations or might lose, fighting them and wake up on the wrong side of history and capitalism.</p><h4><strong>If politics is the sublimation of war, alignment is the sublimation of politics</strong></h4><p>War with exponential technology is negative-sum, all sides lose. Politics is continuation of war with other means. Memetic tribes fight a social war on social media for the domination of a noosphere. But again social media being exponential tech, all sides lose and discourse suffers.</p><p>Balaji Srinivasan explains how good can be defined as <em>helping others without self-regard</em>. Evil is the obverse — <em>harming others while helping yourself</em>. Both are zero-sum. Smart means <em>helping others while benefiting yourself</em>. A positive-sum solution. And stupid is <em>harming others while harming yourself</em>.</p><p>Both war and politics in times of exponential technology means eventual destruction of biosphere, geosphere and noosphere. Our global commons. Only true alignment is the way forward.</p><p>Fiat money is backed by men with guns, as Paul Krugman says. And bitcoin is money backed by math. No amount of violence can solve a math problem. Web3 means smart contracts, DAOs, NFTs and crypto certificates.</p><p>Web3 enables <a href="https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1418309677163552770?s=20&amp;t=qYSWPlNLomf6eL2UF0i0GQ">pseudonymous economy</a>, what Balaji Srinivasan calls a new digital Peace of Westphalia, as well as truly reproducible and cryptographically verified research and news reporting — the Ledger of Record.</p><p>After this tragic and stupid invasion is over, and Ukraine defends itself kinetically and memetically, hopefully without the conflict spreading to more countries, we need a new Peace of Westphalia.</p><p>It will be a more deglobalized and decentralized world. With automation, neutral web3 protocols, national tech stacks and pseudonymous economy as some of the building blocks.</p><p>Providing hope for a new civilization and the aligned movement with the rule of code, where money backed by math brings more peaceful times, than fiat money backed by men with guns ever did.</p><p>ESG can help with that.</p><p>You can read a longer version of this article called <a href="https://www.wisdomenterprising.com/p/esg-needs-web3?s=w">ESG needs web3</a> on Substack and jump right into various shifts ESG can make if it adopts web3 and some of Balaji Srinivasan’s concepts. Here are the examples:</p><p>“From the materiality matrix to the DeFi matrix”</p><p>“From the triple bottom line to triple-entry accounting”</p><p>“From mostly talking to true alignment in collective impact initiatives”</p><p>“From skills-based volunteering to DAOfying vocational training”</p><p>“From sustainability reporting to crypto oracles and the ledger of record”</p><p>“From SDGs to tech trees and vector-based theory of change”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7750af6ae49" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/esg-means-technology-f7750af6ae49">ESG means technology</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance">Opaque Renaissance</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On simulacra, noopolitik and regenerative futures]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/on-simulacra-noopolitik-and-regenerative-futures-8a314dbc9b6e?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a314dbc9b6e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jean-baudrillard]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ontological-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[simulacra]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[robert-kegan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[noopolitik]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Jan 2021 21:14:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-02T08:14:57.818Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/657/1*kUdd-i0Dsbng2dTJyKWzRw.jpeg" /><figcaption>This is a very recent meme about a meme-based cryptocurrecy dogecoin that is supposed to go “to the moon”. It is also an example of memetic warfare occuring on the Level 4 simulacra related to the current #stonks story where millions of Redditors battled Wall Street hedgefunds through meme magic.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Noopolitik shouldn’t be only about “Whose story wins” in the short term. But more about whose story is the most regenerative to our global commons in the long term.</em></p><p>I noticed that the rationalist community around LessWrong got recently <a href="https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2020/06/15/simulacra-and-covid-19/">interested</a> in simulacra levels. They took the original concept from <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulacra_and_Simulation">Baudrillard</a> and discarded almost all the rest of his thinking and just playfully engaged with the simulacra model in their further explorations.</p><p>In other words, they managed <strong>to separate a weak signal from the noise</strong>, and find “a jewel among a pile of not so useful rubbish”. Seeing rationalists using a model developed by postmodern thinker is a good sign of a novel approach — of digesting something painful and synthesizing it into something beautiful or useful.</p><p>I call this <em>syngesting</em>, but it can be just called prosuming — a combination of producing and consuming. Stealing a concept of a natural opponent to use it in our own projects. A project of stealing culture. Instead of cultural wars, some engage in cultural <a href="https://medium.com/@davidcsofer/noophagy-and-noomachy-acefbc69b9f3">cannibalizing</a>, or I would suggest cultural <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67oL0ANDh5Y">prospecting for gold</a>, or cultural and conceptual cooking of poisonous Fugu fish — where one needs to delicately separate toxic parts from the delicious ones.</p><p>I think this is the difference between postmodern <a href="https://medium.com/s/world-wide-wtf/memetic-tribes-and-culture-war-2-0-14705c43f6bb">culture wars 2.0</a>, with tens or hundreds of memetic tribes, AI sects or autocults, warring in multipolar conflicts for the control of the <a href="https://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PEA237-1.html">noosphere</a> — and more metamodern or transmodern approaches.</p><p>The existence of rationality diaspora, that inspired also the effective altruism movement, and the interest of this community in a simulacra model developed by a postmodern thinker, is by itself a testimony to development of noosphere, the growing inter-connection of <em>grains of thought</em> as Pierre Teilhard de Chardin put it, when he coined the term noosphere.</p><p>These <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/on-transculture-metaconcerts-and-hyperobjects-894a1e695012">transcultural</a> approaches try to create <em>meta-sanghas</em>, communities of practice in psycho-technologies, like <a href="https://www.thestoa.ca/">The Stoa</a>, inspired by golden nuggets present in many traditions. Or they can result in what Gregory Rawlins calls <em>metaconcerts</em> — distributed ad hoc groups focused on one immediate objective and project in novel, complex or chaotic, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cynefin_framework">domain</a>, that can dissolve in few hours or minutes after the project is completed.</p><p>These transcultural approaches are more nuanced and discerning and are more pluralistic in the sense of <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/the-talebian-and-thielian-moment-af14d7016adb">fractal localism</a> and less focused on fighting for universalism of their view with a missionary fervor.</p><h4><strong>Level zero simulacra: Flow versus insight</strong></h4><p>A blogger from rationalist diaspora, <a href="https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2020/06/15/simulacra-and-covid-19/">The Zvi</a> mentions a useful definition of various simulacra levels that uses an example with a lion:</p><p><em>“Level 1: “There’s a lion across the river.” = There’s a lion across the river.</em></p><p><em>Level 2: “There’s a lion across the river.” = I don’t want to go (or have other people go) across the river.</em></p><p><em>Level 3: “There’s a lion across the river.” = I’m with the popular kids who are too cool to go across the river.</em></p><p><em>Level 4: “There’s a lion across the river.” = A firm stance against trans-river expansionism focus grouped well with undecided voters in my constituency.”</em></p><p>Another rationalist blogger<a href="http://benjaminrosshoffman.com/simulacra-subjectivity/">, Ben Hoffman</a>, created this abstract definition:</p><p><em>“Simulacrum Level 1: Objectivity as Subject (objectivism, or epistemic consciousness)</em></p><p><em>Simulacrum Level 2: Objectivity as Object (lying)</em></p><p><em>Simulacrum Level 3: Relating as Subject (power relation, or ritual magic)</em></p><p><em>Simulacrum Level 4: Relating as Object (chaos magic, hedge magic, postmodernity)”</em></p><p>Jordan Hall uses a practical example of a leaking plumbing to illustrate levels of simulacra and connects it to his notion of individual sovereignty. I am paraphrasing it from a podcast I cannot quickly find:</p><p><em>L1 Simulacra: My plumbing is leaking (= I am going to fix my plumbing myself)</em></p><p><em>L2 Simulacra: My plumbing is leaking (= I am calling a plumber to fix it)</em></p><p><em>L3 Simulacra: My plumbing is leaking (= I am complaining at the homeowners’ association meeting as a part of a coalition of homeowners who want the HOA to finally call the plumber to fix it)</em></p><p><em>L4 Simulacra: My plumbing is leaking (= I am lobbying regulators to regulate plumbing or HOA)</em></p><p>The Zvi also <a href="https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2020/08/03/unifying-the-simulacra-definitions/">suggests</a>, there must be a <strong>Level zero of simulacra</strong> — when an actor gets an insight that there is a lion across river, but doesn’t share it with others using language. But as soon as you manifest this insight by your behavior of not crossing the river, you are signaling to others, and they are in Level 1. You would need to be a hermit without interaction with others to remain in Level 0.</p><p>We could explore Level 0 a lot using various concepts. Gregg Henriques came up with a <strong>justification hypothesis</strong> (language and lying) as a basis of the emergence of culture as separate from the animal mind. When we are asking how do our actions look to others and reflect on us, we come up with various justifications of why we did, what we did.</p><p>We could use John Vervaeke’s language of <em>agent-arena</em> relationship and focus on their <em>reciprocal closing </em>(addiction) or <em>reciprocal opening</em> (addition/regeneration). One’s ability to dynamically switch from <em>mindfulness</em> to active <em>open-mindedness</em> and be present and introspective, as well as connected with the base reality and perceiving weak signals that are vital for adaptive sensemaking.</p><p>Using Ben Hoffman’s definition from above, we could speculate what other combination could enrich the simulacra framework. One can think of Level 0 simulacra either as <em>Subjectivity as Subject</em> when one has mystical experiences of introspection and mindfulness. Or maybe better <em>Subjectivity as Void</em> (the <em>Barred Subject</em> in lacanese).</p><p>We could also call the active open-mindedness mode as pure relating — <em>Relating as Relating</em>. Together this skillful and dynamic interplay of mindfulness and active open-mindedness modes enhance sovereignty of an individual actor, their sensemaking and their action-taking capacity in the arena (local context, world).</p><p>The combination of mindfulness and active open-mindedness is also vital for <em>a flow state</em>, when one feels optimally present and also optimally effective and rich with affordances from the arena.</p><p>People can pursue various mental states, including flow, to gain some valuable insights, or they can pursue them for the sake of those states alone. While in the first case it helps to regenerate someone and sort his thought and make some lateral connection, in the second case people can get addicted.</p><p>Before leaving this tangent, I would like to make a point that a mental state is not a developmental stage. Flow (feeling of unity) is not insight (discernment). And similarly, pathos is not logos, or mortido is not libido. But according to Alexander Bard, a narrative — <strong>mythos is a skillful combination of both pathos and logos</strong>. A skillful combination of<strong> </strong>subjective and objective views meant to create<strong> an adaptive intersubjective reality</strong> of a tribe.</p><p>For a deep dive into relationships of the first-person (subjective) view, the third person (objective) view and the second-person (intersubjective) view I recommend Forrest Landry’s <a href="http://www.magic-flight.com/pub/uvsm_1/idm_foundations_01.pdf">book</a> An Immanent Metaphysics.</p><p>David Snowden often mentions how Chinese have an ability to scan twice as much from the environment compared to us, due to their character-based writing. So, when a Westerner sees a picture with a tiger, a Chinese sees the trees behind a tiger more than a tiger.</p><p>Dave Snowden also often mentions how visual language (cave drawings) existed well <em>before</em> the spoken language. <strong>Therefore, art, memes, maps can compress and carry much more information than spoken words</strong>. And one can speak much more than one can write. And one can write much more than one can comprehend. A map is not a territory, but a map is much more than a story.</p><h4><strong>Oscillating between L1 and L2 simulacra: Bootstrapping the desired future with counterfactuals</strong></h4><p>While a spoken language brought about systems of justification (~lying), it also brought an ability to create coherence and punish defection on band, clan and tribal levels. The written language enabled the creation of first settlements, and later city states, empires and nations. The printed language enabled the most recent and outdated paradigm of industrial revolution.</p><p>Alexander Bard talks how an interactive language has brought about a new paradigm of an informational age. The old Napoleon’s hierarchies enabled by the printed language give way to new distributed networks. Power is not in ownership of land anymore, as in the agrarian societies, nor in ownership of factories and luxury condos as in the industrial age. <strong>Power today is in the attention economy underpinned by skillful curation of data and narratives</strong>. Also, individualism and collectivism are out, and <a href="https://medium.com/s/world-wide-wtf/memetic-tribes-and-culture-war-2-0-14705c43f6bb">(digital) tribalism</a> is back with a vengeance.</p><p>A spoken language enabled the creation of counterfactuals. According to John Vervaeke, counterfactuals are central to our cognitive development as humans, and they are important for what Gregg Henriques calls systems of justification.</p><p>Counterfactuals involve time. Moreover, they involve a special kind of time, that Jean-Pierre Dupuy calls <strong>projected time</strong>. One projects from a fixed future point backwards towards the present:</p><p><em>“If we don’t cut GHG emissions now, planet will be inhabitable by 2100.”</em></p><p><em>“If we don’t act on the generator functions of existential risk, such as rivalry, excessive extraction/pollution and exponential tech, we will likely not survive as a humanity to see the 22nd century.”</em></p><p><strong>Counterfactuals are connected with projected time, and thus also with projects</strong> — tasks that have a finite amount of time, a deadline. As goes the saying: “Without a deadline nothing gets done”.</p><p>Above we mentioned, that one needs to create a skillful combination of pathos and logos to arrive at an effective mythos. These effective narratives serve <strong>to</strong> <strong>bootstrap a desired future</strong> and coordinate around avoiding some catastrophe.</p><p>Jean-Pierre Dupuy <a href="https://www.advojka.cz/archiv/2016/19/borrowed-robe-of-sacred">talks</a> about the importance of an <em>enlightened doomsaying</em> and puts <em>a prophet </em>in a technical sense in the middle of a triad: <strong>futurist-prophet-expert</strong>. A futurist has too little constrains (too much pathos and artistic license) and an expert has too many constraints (too much logos and technical language).</p><p>But the prophet is able to build an effective narrative that will cause people to coordinate around some fixed point in time and some project that will bootstrap a desired future through projected time that flows backwards — from the fixed point in future to our current present that needs to change.</p><p>(And a failed prophet often becomes a scapegoat and later a saint. This is a nod to René Girard and mimetic theory that illustrates how people reduce widespread rivalry and coordinate through scapegoating.)</p><p>So a prophet, in a technical sense, employs a well-crafted narrative, combining art and design (pathos) with engineering and science (logos), to inspire people to coordinate around a specific goal, like creating electric vehicles that are safer, cheaper, more ecological and durable than traditional gas powered cars by 2030. Or starting a cell agriculture industry to produce cultured meat that will be cheaper than normal meat by 2030.</p><p>Prophets manipulate, or maybe better seduce, people into <strong>bootstrapping the desired future</strong>, and if they succeeds in their <strong>project</strong> of creating a thriving cell agriculture industry and creating cheaper cultured meat alternatives, e.g. by 2030, <strong>prophets were counterfactually not lying back then</strong> in e.g. 2015 when they made a promise of cheap cultured meat <strong>while the first such burger cost more than a luxury vehicle</strong>.</p><p>So, the prophet employs counterfactuals and well-crafted mythos to seduce people on L2 simulacra to bootstrap a new base reality at L1 simulacra through projected time and backcasting from the fixed point in the future back to the present that needs to change.</p><h4><strong>Re/generating commons with L3 and L4 simulacra: Orthogonal approaches in noopolitik</strong></h4><p>We should avoid dualism of “physical is good and virtual is bad” or vice versa. Also, we should avoid dualism in a sense that repetition is good and difference is bad, or vice versa. Or that a basic research is good and product development is bad, or vice versa. In the same way we should avoid thinking that L1 simulacra is good and L2–4 is bad.</p><p>But we can say, that it is maladaptive to be mostly in L2-L4 simulacra when you are living in the metaphoric Winterfell, where natural forces are raging and you need to perceive the base reality sharply and act swiftly. And the opposite is true as well, if you live in the metaphoric King’s Landing of intrigue and power games, it is maladaptive to be mostly focused on L1 simulacra and just “speak the naked truth to power”.</p><p>Most people then engage in what Timur Kuran calls <em>preference falsification</em>. Not many people criticized socialism a week before the Velvet Revolution in Czechoslovakia, but a week after the event, western journalists couldn’t find an ardent socialist to speak to.</p><p>Alexander Bard, inspired by Deleuze’s Difference and Repetition, describes two ancient and fundamental modes of thinking as <em>eventology</em> and <em>nomadology</em>. For vast majority of our history, we lived in a nomadological universe — constantly being on the move, but experiencing a constant repetition and return of the same. Since the dawn of civilization and written language, we could expand information and knowledge storage and sharing over generations. And this allowed a possibility of permanent settlements and a slight improvement and progress every year — an eventological universe with events that represent progressive and linear, <em>protopian</em>, improvements.</p><p>And even with some rare and much bigger events that represent non-linear shifts, phase changes and emergences. Since the dawn of civilization, we live in a combination of eventology and nomadology — in a combination of <em>linear time</em> and <em>circular time</em>.</p><p>Peter Thiel in his book Zero to One describes something similar — an <em>event</em> of a radical innovation and a subsequent <em>process</em> of <em>commodification</em> of that innovation and a monopolistic power stemming from being early in the game and controlling the market. Alexander Bard in his forthcoming book called Process and Event focuses on these dynamics of eventology and nomadology that have a conceptual origin in Zoroastrianism some 4,000 years ago.</p><p>Dave Snowden in his Cynefin framework distinguishes five domains: chaotic, complex, complicated and obvious systems of order, and a domain of disorder, when you don’t know in which of the four domains you are.</p><p>I find Simon Wardley and his <a href="https://medium.com/wardleymaps/on-being-lost-2ef5f05eb1ec">Wardley Mapping</a> very similar to above mentioned concepts: an event of radical innovation in chaotic and complex domains and a subsequent process of <em>commodification</em> in the complicated and obvious domains. And this commodification is good, because it allows to create an ever-higher stack of (psycho)technologies. For example, a company can dominate cloud technology, or what Amazon has done with their AWS, and then leverage it not just as a platform for others to produce their services, but also as a rich source of data on the overall market and the future of innovation.</p><p>Simon Wardley describes three distinct cultures present in every company: <em>pioneers</em>, <em>settlers</em> and <em>city planners</em>. Thus, a company or a team, if we apply fractal localism, shouldn’t aim at mono-culture at a cultural imperialism of let’s say pioneers, or city planners, but acknowledge that each of these three cultures is important for a different stage of research versus development — pioneers create new innovations and concepts, settlers scale them into products/services and compete for dominance, and city planners standardize the production for volume and cost and commoditize these products as commodities/utilities.</p><p>This division between three cultures is somewhat similar to Venkatesh Rao’s <a href="https://medium.com/bad-buddhism/the-gervais-principle-integrated-organizational-pathology-4614d10cf042">Gervais Principle</a> of office politics, where he divides employees into Losers, Clueless, and Sociopaths and states that Sociopaths promote over-performing Losers into the middle-management (Clueless) and the under-performing Losers into C-Suite (Sociopaths). And this is similar to what The Zvi describes in his <a href="https://thezvi.wordpress.com/category/moral-mazes/">articles</a> on moral mazes where he stressed the importance of slack as a concept vital to life, and how super-perfect competition of middle managers destroys all slack, all difference and uniqueness and competes away all energies and vitality in a dog-eat-dog and zero-sum finite game.</p><p>There is one obvious solution against mazedom of office politics or city (state) politics — just exit the King’s Landing, leave. And spend most of your time in Winterfell with base reality of nature, and deep tribal connection with your close friends around the Dunbar’s number.</p><p>Take a concept of a healthy food pyramid and apply it on noosphere and a healthy noospheric diet — <em>a healthy</em> <em>noofood pyramid </em>or a healthy information and knowledge food pyramid.</p><p>If you are in Winterfell your discourse analysis of power dynamics won’t work on a circular saw — you need to be mindful and present when working with such dangerous tools to cut wood without hurting yourself. But I guess the opposite is true when you are in King’s Landing — you cannot just proclaim some innovative and novel truth and expect people to take it at face value.</p><p>You need to sell your truth with an effective narrative, as we discussed in the futurist-prophet-expert distinction. Not too much pathos, and not too much logos either. But their proper combination creates and effective narrative.</p><p>So, this was quite a long way to make a non-dualistic (monist) argument against Gnosticism — against considering a body sinful and a soul beautiful or vice versa. They are intertwined and interconnected, and both body and soul need to be nurtured with a proper and healthy (noo)food pyramid.</p><p>The same is true for innovation versus commodities. They are in a loop and a circular process of commodification that enables new events, new emergencies and new innovations. Electricity as a commodity <a href="https://www.rethinkx.com/humanity">enabled</a> iPhone. The improvement of batteries in smartphones enabled the rise of electric vehicles.</p><p>Many innovations start as toys. It took millennia for a steam engine to develop from an ancient toy meant for amusement into an industrial tool. Incas had toys with wheels but didn’t use wheels for transporting things.</p><p>In 2009, Thomas Thwaites, a graduate of Royal College of Art <a href="https://www.dezeen.com/2009/06/27/the-toaster-project-by-thomas-thwaites/#:~:text=Royal%20College%20of%20Art%20graduate,for%20less%20than%20%C2%A35.00.">created</a> a toaster from scratch, it cost him over 1000 pounds to replicate a value toaster he bought for 5 pounds. And his toaster project burst into flames few seconds after operation. And the artist used many commodified products, such as microwave oven in his creation. Simon Wardley often mentions this example to illustrate the importance of commodities for further innovations and also the futility of trying to do your custom-made oven from scratch.</p><p>Many innovations follow S-Curves and so do also peak predators — successful companies that dominate a certain market. Thus Microsoft dominated software, after IBM that was preoccupied with hardware paradigm, and later Apple dominated an ecosystem of neat hardware and applications after Microsoft missed the bus. Peak predators have a huge influence on the whole ecosystem — <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysa5OBhXz-Q">reintroducing</a> grey wolves into Yellowstone created <em>trophic cascade</em> effects that made the rivers cleaner. <strong>But peak predators are also fragile — they create too much of a monoculture</strong>.</p><p>Over our history we turned complex systems into complicated ones. We took global commons, such as forests, cut down wood and turned them into two-by-fours to build a house. But recently we were experimenting with some novel approaches like circular economy, or using mycelium as building material that can repair itself once broken. Companies such as BioCarbon Engineering <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxMsIb8_bDE">develop</a> drones to plant trees 60x faster and cheaper.</p><p>Forrest Landry explains that we need to start building machines that will not serve us but that will serve nature to move into regenerative paradigm away from the extractive paradigm.</p><p>The authors at RethinkX thinktank published a <a href="https://www.rethinkx.com/humanity">report</a> in 2020 titled Rethinking Humanity, where they divide our big history into three ages: The Age of Survival, The Age of Extraction and The Age of Freedom based on unleashing creativity through exponential tech like digital fabrication and precision fermentation.</p><p>But I think the key idea is that <strong>we need to craft compelling stories that don’t just win in the short term, but that are the most regenerative to our global commons in the long term</strong>.</p><p><strong>Level 2 simulacra is about the ability to skillfully manipulate reality</strong>, to shape it and bootstrap it into a regenerative future where global commons and communing play a decisive role.</p><h4><strong>L3 Simulacra — Ontological capture versus ethical cults</strong></h4><p>We could combine Kegan’s five <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructive_developmental_framework">stages</a> of adult development with Baudrillard’s levels of simulacra:</p><p><strong><em>1. I can perceive reality</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>2. I can manipulate reality</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>3. I belong to a tribe</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>4. I can manipulate tribes</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>5. I can skillfully match my (mental) state to the task at hand</em></strong></p><p>Kegan’s stage 3 of adult development is about <strong>the socialized mind</strong> — about a need to belong to a subculture or a tribe and find a specific personal archetype.</p><p>Alexander Bard talks about the need to have two archetypes — similarly to picking subjects in college — one major and one minor archetype. The major archetype is what you do with ease and people respect you for that. The minor archetype is something that you are able to do well when you put enough effort into it.</p><p>The need to belong is a strong one. Once some innovation gets traction it attracts not just early <strong>pioneers </strong>who are good at creativity, but not so good at scaling their inventions. It also later attracts a different type of personalities that Simon Wardley calls <strong>settlers</strong> with their own culture and skills to scale and standardize innovations into reliable products and services. And these are followed by <strong>city planners</strong> that have a skill to produce big volume of commodified products at a low cost.</p><p>Jamie Wheal has a similar framework to describe the evolution of current psychedelic <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XRe3FlZCEg">renaissance</a>: from <strong>creators</strong> to <strong>curators and sociopaths</strong> that then sell tickets to the latecomers that he calls <strong>tourists</strong>.</p><p><strong>When we talk about L3 simulacra, we talk about belonging to a tribe or a subculture</strong>, and we talk about settlers and tourists. This subculture can be ontologically captured in their own symbols and virtualism.</p><p>But we talk also about the need for a collective intelligence and a collective wisdom, <strong>because humans are fundamentally tribal</strong>. A need to find your own community of practice. What Buddhists call <em>sangha</em>.</p><p>But these subcultures can turn into cults — often as a result that their products became after some time widely accepted commodities and thus these communities lost their original sense of purpose and providence.</p><p>Or these subcultures are manipulated by sociopaths who are good at power games. Evan McMullen has a great series on The Stoa called <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p6AW7eb34tM">The Bridge</a>, where he talks about Kegan stages, simulacra and sanghas, and t<strong>he need for developing good power literacy</strong> to inoculate ourselves against such sociopaths.</p><p>The problem of cultish tendencies is aggravated by algorithmic manipulation, filter bubbles, AI driven sects and autocults. Social networks that optimize time spent on site and advertising revenue thus drive polarization, extremism and cultish behavior.</p><p>Arquilla and Ronfeldt in their recent <a href="https://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PEA237-1.html">work</a> on noopolitik called Whose Story Wins explain that currently the problem is not so much brainwashing of people, as in the past, but <strong>brain-boxing </strong>and<strong> thought-scripting</strong> by memetic filter bubbles.</p><p>Brainwashing as an idea has dubious origins in the Cold War propaganda and was introduced in The Manchurian Candidate. But the <strong>imprint vulnerability</strong> (a concept I <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxRyTibydno">heard</a> from Evan McMullen at The Stoa) is in my opinion real and is often enhanced by sleep and food deprivation, psychedelics, spending time only with members of a certain cultish subculture.</p><p>Jamie Wheal and others talk about <strong>ethical cults</strong> as a theoretical alternative to abusive cults that mentally enslave people and deprive them of their sovereignty, and thus r<strong>educe their sensemaking, choice-making and actuation capacities</strong>. So, an ethical cult would be focused on increasing individual sovereignty and at the same time also increasing collective wisdom and a group sovereignty — as in a team of elite athletes or elite forces.</p><p>Another proposition coming from The Stoa community and discussed also by Evan McMullen is the idea of meta-sanghas. Communities similar to <strong>the metaphor of MMA</strong>, that serve as memetic mediators and combine various psychotechnologies and ancient arts and are able to select <strong>grains of wisdom</strong> from various ancient traditions and discard the rest.</p><p>One can participate in various <strong>meta-sanghas</strong> and thus help to create <strong>a mesh of meta-sanghas</strong> akin to the concept of the <strong>noosphere</strong>. The examples of such meta-sanghas are for example The Stoa, Intellectual Deep Web, Inter-Intellect and community around Rebel Wisdom.</p><h4><strong>L4 Simulacra — Ontological design and noopolitik</strong></h4><p>Ontological design or <strong>context engineering</strong> is a concept promoted by Daniel Fraga and Owen Cox and discussed with various guests at their <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMVjY2fNOkk">Technosocial</a> podcast.</p><p>The idea of ontological design is similar to L4 simulacra and the ability to manipulate memetic tribes, for example through <strong>chaos magic</strong> and <strong>meme magic</strong>. It is also related to Kegan’s stage 4 of self-authorship, being able to achieve such <strong>situational awareness</strong>, that one considers herself above various tribes that one is member of.</p><p>Both context engineering and magic focus on <strong>perception hacking</strong>, and an interesting fact is that they are <strong>culturally universal</strong>. As Tristan Harris says — magic tricks work on people with various personalities and cultural backgrounds.</p><p><strong>The saying is that today’s technology is yesterday’s magic</strong>. John Vervaeke <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/on-the-religion-of-no-religion-sovereignty-vs-meaning-183cc7b1432e">uses</a> a concept of <strong>psycho-technologies</strong> to describe an ecology of various practices that are derived from ancient traditions but can be recombined without using their outdated epistemologies.</p><p>This idea of ability to pick nuggets of wisdoms and discarding the rest is also central to noopolitik, as Arquilla and Ronfeldt describe it in their recent work. Noopolitik is derived from the concept of a noosphere, that originated with Pierre Teilhard de Chardin and Vladimir Vernadsky.</p><p>The idea of <strong>prospecting for the noospheric gold</strong> is related to the <strong>signal vs noise metaphor</strong> (no one is genius enough to produce pure signal or pure noise) and it is also a subject to Pareto distribution — the vast majority of places and dirt don’t have golden nuggets, but there are a few places where the most (conceptual) gold reserves are.</p><p>Similarly, also the global problems and their solutions are very unequally distributed, and thus this <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67oL0ANDh5Y&amp;t=1s">metaphor</a> of prospecting for gold is suitable, and we can apply it also to the noosphere.</p><p>An important concept related to magic and alchemy is <strong>blackboxing</strong>. Just focusing on the inputs and outputs, even without the ability to fully explain how the magic trick is being done. This is related to the Cynefin Framework and the fact that <strong>in complex systems one needs to run small and safe-to-fail experiments in parallel to test opposite hypotheses</strong>.</p><p>The complex domain is characteristic of <strong>dark constrains</strong> and also the existence of competing theories and explanations. One way to get closer to the objective truth is to run experiments. This is how new technology is developed, and this is how magic is done.</p><p>In January 2021 we have witnessed events related to concepts like alternate reality games, deep play and kayfabe. Eric Weinstein has an important and counterintuitive point related to this pure virtuality and L4 simulacra — <strong>American Wresting with nested levels of deception saw much more deadly injuries than MMA.</strong></p><p>Similarly, we can see people being hurt and killed when the virtual reality of filter bubbles spills into physical world and people engage in LARPing and alternate reality games.</p><h4><strong>Level 5? Dynamic and efficient matching of mental states to the task at hand</strong></h4><p>Now the question is what is Kegan’s developmental stage number 5? A stage beyond self-authorship into self-transcendence. The Bridge <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxRyTibydno">sessions</a> by Evan McMullen at The Stoa focused on bridging these 4 to 5 stages (as well as bridging earlier stages, like 3 to 4). He focused on what he calls phenomenological self-inquiry and posits that <em>via negativa</em> — e.g. fasting is the way to hack the perception of what is possible and engage in ontological design.</p><p>Jamie Wheal, who co-wrote Stealing Fire and focuses on elite performance and founded The Flow Genome Project, says that t<strong>he key skill is to efficiently match (mental) state to the task at hand</strong>. In other words, to be fully present when doing something — and use various skills sets required for it. Daniel Schmachtenberger says similar thing quoting Ecclesiastes from the Old Testament: “There is a time to kill, and a time to heal”.</p><p>So there are times where one needs to be in fight or flight mode. And times where one needs to practice mindfulness and personal phenomenological self-inquiry, or PSI, as Evan McMullen calls it.</p><p>John Vervaeke distinguishes active open-mindedness from mindfulness. The first one focuses on external reality and various affordances, and the second one focuses on self-inquiry. We need to efficiently combine both.</p><p>This brings us back to what John Vervaeke and Jordan Hall call <em>the religion of no religion</em>. As I mentioned above, we definitely can and should find golden nuggets from various ancient traditions and subcultures — both in terms of conceptual ecology and ecology of practices. <strong>But we also need a bold vision</strong>. This is the critique that Alexander Bard has for this type of Californian thinking influenced by complexity and Game B. This subculture is full of brilliant minds, but they are often too much focused on talking and exploring various group flow practices.</p><p>I partly <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/on-the-religion-of-no-religion-sovereignty-vs-meaning-183cc7b1432e">share</a> this sentiment and think that meaning is derived from bold and higher visions — not just from communitas, peak performance and peak experiences.</p><p>Partly I <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/we-need-to-accelerate-game-b-while-game-a-decelerates-in-crisis-a715dc84ca5b">think</a> that there are already Game B adjacent startups and innovations that focus on holistic improvement and increasing individual and group sovereignty as opposed to increasing addiction. But there are only a few of them and <strong>we need orders of magnitude more startups in this problem space</strong> of X Risk, and generator functions of X Risk, ontological design and context engineering.</p><h4><strong>Opaque Renaissance</strong></h4><p>Game B is inherently liminal, full of local experimentation and testing of opposite hypotheses. Game B is played in the chaotic and complex domains of the Cynefin Framework, or in a Genesis/Conceptual stage of the Wardley Map. Where pioneers create some innovations, and later settlers scale them, and later city planners turn them into commodities — essential for building a yet higher stack of (psycho)technologies that were pure magic just a few years ago.</p><p>But I see it as a process not a thing — <strong>an ever refreshing renewal</strong>, as Alexander Bard would put it. Something starts as a concept, gets scaled and later commodified for volume production. Something starts like a Game B (infinite game of playful collaboration) and turns into Game A (finite game with winners and losers). <strong>But then the key is to never get stuck on one finite game and mistaking it for an infinite game</strong>.</p><p>This is similar to Peter Thiel’s <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/the-talebian-and-thielian-moment-af14d7016adb">concept</a>: <strong>from zero to one</strong> (where true innovation happens) versus <strong>from one to infinity</strong> (where copycats happen).</p><p>The practical example of startups from the Game B and adjacent spaces is Neurohacker Collective, founded by Daniel Schmachtenberger and Jordan Hall, and their Qualia products. Or the idea of planting trees 60x faster and cheaper using drones and AI, tested by companies such as BioCarbon Engineering.</p><p>Or plant-based meat and cultured meat based on novel technologies such as precision fermentation that represent according to Rethink Humanity a radical revolution of taming micro-organisms in cell agriculture, as opposed to traditional agriculture that started some 10,000 years ago by taming macro-organisms such as cows. This new paradigm is about disrupting the cow and can have profound and beneficial consequences to food security and climate change.</p><p>Another ambitious project is <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CH4mlDX-fc&amp;t=15s">Civium</a> — a global community/city that combines the best of virtual and physical worlds, created by Jordan Hall. He was inspired by Geoffrey West’s Scale and the idea of super-linear scaling, and focuses on building something like <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/jordan-halls-civium-hacking-the-deep-code-of-metaculture-82828f4b40fe">transculture</a> (related to the idea of transmedia). He also collaborates with John Vervaeke and Gregg Henriques and uses his Tree of Knowledge System.</p><p>Daniel Schmachtenberger did a great <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LqaotiGWjQ&amp;t=8s">series</a> of videos for Rebel Wisdom, titled The War on Sensemaking. He also founded <a href="https://www.civilizationresearchinstitute.org/our-projects">The Consilience Project</a> focused on repairing broken information ecology and “doing broadcast right”.</p><p>This is what Alexander Bard calls <strong>protopian</strong> approaches towards <strong>ecotopia</strong>. We also need to embrace dialectic and paradox, by using <strong>antagonistic collaboration</strong> we can get closer to ideas, such as Greg Thomas’ <strong>rooted cosmopolitanism</strong>.</p><p>But we need to nurture <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/orthogonal-approaches-of-balaji-srinivasan-231320080723">orthogonal approaches</a> and other ways of <a href="https://medium.com/meta-metta/a-summary-of-bonnita-roys-six-ways-to-go-meta-21fae29e9123">going meta</a>, that are inherently opaque to the majority of people who live in the increasingly outdated paradigm.</p><p>Some people call this move and movement <em>dark renaissance</em>, but I prefer calling it <em>opaque renaissance</em>. It relates to two ideas:</p><p>The first one is <strong>blackboxing</strong> — using practical parallel experiments in the complex domain akin to magic that later becomes (psycho)technology. The second idea is <strong>choosing only the opaque box B</strong> in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox">Newcomb’s Paradox</a>. Which is a meta-rational move of <em>bootstrapping a desired future</em> by a consistent and long-term good-faith engagement despite setbacks and painful experiences.</p><p>I think opaque renaissance can be characterized also by three key concepts I explored in my previous writings:</p><p>1. <strong>syngesting</strong> is my term similar to prosuming and being a prosumer, which means consuming and producing at the same time — digesting the painful experiences of everyday life and synthesizing them into something beautiful. This is a first-person/subjective view . And it should help reduce rivalry — one of three generator functions of X Risk as defined by Daniel Schmachtenberger.</p><p>2. <strong>imploitation</strong> is Alexander Bard’s term that is the opposite of exploitation and refers to a tantric practice of withholding, of saving up, delaying gratification, and repairing and renovating. It could be related to re/generation. This is the second-person/intersubjective view. And it should help reduce excessive extraction and pollution — another of the generator functions of X Risk.</p><p>3. <strong>exaptation</strong> — a term promoted by Dave Snowden that refers to radical repurposing and serendipity. This is in opposition to adaptation. This is the third-person/objective view as Forrest Landry would put it. And it should help reduce the impact of exponential technologies — the third generator function of X Risk. Exaptation can help to change paradigms more quickly and produce new peak predators — and thus turn the exponential functions into S-Curves quicker.</p><p>These three concepts and practices can shift the <strong>addictive behaviors</strong> that lead to, what John Vervaeke calls, <em>reciprocal narrowing</em> of agent and their arena, into <strong>regenerative behaviors</strong> or what he calls a <em>reciprocal opening</em> of agent and their arena.</p><p>We also need to have a well-grounded and healthy noospheric food pyramid. Most people engage too much time in virtual cocktail parties on social media and in the L4 simulacra and too little time in L1 simulacra of base reality. Too much time in the metaphoric King’s Landing and too little time in Winterfell.</p><p>But a food pyramid might not be the best concept — we need concepts from living and complex domain — such as <strong>a healthy noospheric tree</strong> — with deep roots in L1 simulacra and wide branches in L4 simulacra — reaching across all levels of simulacra and Kegan’s stages.</p><p>I think we need to do prospecting for noospheric gold and find nuggets of wisdom from ancient traditions and recombine them into new (psycho)technologies. We also need to have bold visions and build new companies with novel products such as nootropics, or plant-based burgers that taste better than normal meat and can become widely spread commodities. Building ethical cults and a mesh of meta-sanghas is very important, but not enough.</p><p>In this article I wanted to reflect on Baudrillard’s four levels of simulacra as one nugget of wisdom and a useful framework originating from postmodernism, and being recently discovered by the rationalist diaspora.</p><p>I was inspired by Evan McMullen’s lectures at The Stoa and combined it with Kegan’s five stages of adult development. So, the result is something like this:</p><p><em>1. I can perceive reality</em></p><p><em>2. I can manipulate reality</em></p><p><em>3. I belong to a tribe</em></p><p><em>4. I can manipulate tribes</em></p><p><em>5. I can skillfully match my (mental) state to the task at hand</em></p><p>And my second contribution on noopolitik is based on reading Whose Story Wins report by RAND is:</p><p><em>Noopolitik shouldn´t be only about “whose story wins” in the short term. But more about whose story is the most regenerative to our global commons in the long term.</em></p><p><em>You can support my </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek"><em>writing</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/jaksim/videos"><em>videos</em></a><em> on these topics and my small podcasting project </em><a href="https://anchor.fm/jakub-simek"><em>Between Ideas &amp; Subcultures</em></a><em> through </em><a href="https://www.patreon.com/user?u=32652896&amp;fan_landing=true"><em>Patreon</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://paypal.me/jakubsimek?locale.x=sk_SK"><em>PayPal</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a314dbc9b6e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/on-simulacra-noopolitik-and-regenerative-futures-8a314dbc9b6e">On simulacra, noopolitik and regenerative futures</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance">Opaque Renaissance</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On transculture, metaconcerts and hyperobjects]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/on-transculture-metaconcerts-and-hyperobjects-894a1e695012?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/894a1e695012</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gregg-henriques]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jordan-hall]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gregory-rawlins]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-vervaeke]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Sep 2020 08:18:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-21T05:59:22.464Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*lkTN-Owdd4n3PTX9Gv7L2w.jpeg" /><figcaption>A map of the US made of slime mold and put through deep dream generator.</figcaption></figure><p>Recently I tried to capture some <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/jordan-halls-civium-hacking-the-deep-code-of-metaculture-82828f4b40fe">ideas</a> from ongoing <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ft_7n3eUytQ&amp;t=2s">dialogues</a> between Jordan Hall, John Vervaeke and Gregg Henriques that revolve around <strong>the idea of Civium and hacking the deep code of culture</strong> to allow for an emergence of a truly global collective intelligence, a global virtual city, with planetary consciousness and a brain.</p><p>After some weeks I think I get a bit better some parts of their intellectual jazz sessions so I want to update my thinking on Civium. The project is based on the deep insight from Geoffrey West’s Scale, that showed how some human built systems like <strong>cities are unique in their super-linear scaling</strong> as opposed to nature where we observe sub-linear scaling that put the upper bound on some big organisms, such as tall trees, whales and elephants. If the population of a city doubles, the rate of innovation, wealth, crime and pollution more than doubles. If you would get a global virtual city, with e.g. 6 billion minds connected online, you could in theory accelerate the rate of innovation many times over.</p><p>Another concept behind Civium is <strong>TAP, or</strong> “<strong>the adjacent possible</strong>” that states what is possible with the current levels of (psycho)technology and how to move towards increasing these possibilities and “create a recursive and synergistic or autopoietic machine” that would produce low-hanging fruits in some problem space of interest.</p><p>A practical example is Tesla that started at the top of the market, with Tesla Roadster that only a fraction of people can afford. But this small success opened adjacent possibilities to invest into research of cheaper batteries and open the possibility for purchasing EVs to orders of magnitude more people with the Tesla Model S. And then the same loop was closed yet again, and this allowed Model 3 to arrive. Next year even the most affordable car brand in Europe, Dacia, plans to launch their EV crossover.</p><p>Which means that the technology went through a cycle in a <a href="https://medium.com/wardleymaps/on-being-lost-2ef5f05eb1ec"><strong>Wardley Map</strong></a>, from <strong>Genesis</strong>, <strong>Custom-built</strong>, <strong>Product</strong> into a <strong>Commodity</strong>. In the language of Jean-Pierre Dupuy and Peter Thiel we could say that <strong>TAP helps us to bootstrap the desired future</strong>. This was recently done in other areas, such as cultured meat and plant-based meat.</p><p>Another idea is Gregg Henriques’ <strong>ToK System</strong>, or<strong> Three of Knowledge System</strong>. It describes four distinct <strong>emergencies</strong> that happened in big history. From Big Bang to matter. From matter to life. From life to mind. And from mind to culture. Life can be described by evolutionary synthesis. Mind can be described by <strong>behavioral investment theory</strong>. And the emergence of culture is connected with the emergence of <strong>language</strong> and <strong>the justification hypothesis</strong> that describes cultures as <strong>justification systems</strong>.</p><p>The Civium aims at arriving on the next emergence that can be, in my opinion, described as <strong>transculture</strong>. Culture can be viewed as a meta-behavior, or a set of acceptable behaviors for some niche. The question is what could be meta to culture? A good example in this problem space is, in my opinion, how an AI behind Google Translate created its own metalanguage with a meta-grammar to better translate particular languages.</p><p>I used the term <strong>metaculture</strong> before, but maybe transculture is better, because it refers to the concept of <strong>transmedia</strong> by Jeff Gomez. The idea is to create <strong>trans-narratives</strong> that work within ecologies with various heroes and stories. A trans-narrative is different from mata-narrative. Trans-narrative allows for diversity of cultures and memetic tribes and their collaboration. And captures their shared deep essence.</p><p>Meta-narrative is just a big narrative of a dominant culture as in the western modernism and imperialism. Trans-narrative allows for fractal localism and doesn’t aim at universalism. John Vervaeke and Jordan Hall describe how “<strong>narratives create heroes but dialogues create networks</strong>”. And they aim at arriving at this transculture with an ecology of psychotechnologies and practices that support better intercultural and inter-tribal communication and emergence of <strong>trans-paradigmatic mind</strong>. A mind that is able to shift between paradigms and find a higher synthesis between them.</p><p>Civium, a virtual city with its transculture will be something like a meta-protocol for global collaboration and acceleration of innovation. I think it will allow <strong>metaconcerts</strong> to proliferate. Metaconcert is a term introduced by Gregory J.E. Rawlins in his online <a href="https://homes.luddy.indiana.edu/rawlins/books/shoulders/ch02-labor.html">book</a> <strong>The Human Swarm</strong>. He compares our mental tools to our physical and institutional tools. And he says that our mental tools for effective collaboration are still in “the stone age” and the internet with a computer revolution could change that profoundly in the near future.</p><p>As Alexander Bard says, the printing press allowed for <strong>printed language</strong> and rapid spread of science and technology. And the internet brought an <strong>interactive language</strong> and a new topology of networks, with distributed hierarchies and attentionalism as opposed to top down hierarchies of the printing press and Napoleon’s army and capitalism.</p><p>Metaconcets can have a lifespan of a fly and allow for global and short collaborations in the human swarm. So a transculture is an infinite game, a sense that we are one united humanity, a super-organism, and metaconcerts are short or longer finite games, e.g. allowing for effective <strong>antagonistic cooperation</strong>, an elegant term by Albert Murray.</p><p>I also follow <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i26ifcjoqEs">dialogues</a> between Andrew Sweeny, Alexander Bard, and Thomas Hamelryck who explore similar topics, from deep history through Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, Daoism into digital shamanism and netocracy. And I see these two different ongoing dialogues as a useful dialectic between more continental philosophy approaches and more analytical approaches developed across the pond by Vervaeke, Hall and Henriques.</p><p>Vervaeke and Hall discuss how the “new Buddha is the sangha” (monastic community). Similar to how Žižek talks about God becoming Holy Spirit of the community. Alexander Bard <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/on-the-religion-of-no-religion-sovereignty-vs-meaning-183cc7b1432e">critiques</a> this approach of “religion that is no religion” and a fear of utopias, and says that religion is ever present and we need a religion proper, <strong>a religion for a digital and networked age</strong>.</p><p>Vervaeke and Hall also discuss how <strong>happiness can be divided into: subjective wellbeing, meaning and success</strong>. I think, these three modalities can be viewed through lenses of Forrest Landry and his three <a href="http://www.magic-flight.com/pub/uvsm_1/idm_foundations_01.pdf">modalities</a> popularized by Daniel Schmachtenberger — the first-person, the second person and the third-person view.</p><p>So, the meaning part of happiness is attained in a crew, in a collective unit, as We. John Vervaeke says how parents with young children experience both a decrease in subjective wellbeing and in success, but they experience an increase in meaning. Similarly, old people experience these decreases, but experience an increase of meaning. The question for Civium is if both three can be nurtured and increased in the long-term through what John Vervaeke calls <strong>reciprocal opening</strong> and contrasts with reciprocal closing.</p><p>I <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/utopias-are-hyperobjects-not-perfections-c89e6486d91f">see</a> <strong>utopias as hyperobjects</strong> and not perfections. Similarly, Alexander Bard refuses the idea of infinity and perfection, and embraces instead the idea of <strong>completion</strong> and <strong>wholeness</strong>, influenced by Zoroastrian monism. He presents three utopias — <strong>Syntheism</strong>, <strong>Cosmopolis</strong> and <strong>Ecotopia</strong>. These can be again viewed through Forrest Landry’s metaphysics and modalities, through lens of doing, becoming and being. <strong>I think Cosmopolis and Civium are quite similar ideas</strong>.</p><p>I think the ability to see hyperobjects is connected to <strong>trans-paradigmatic mind</strong> and this connection can be explored further. Daniel Schmachtenberger does that. But we could connect it to the idea of <strong>utopias as hyperobjects</strong>. Alexander Bard currently explores his two new terms <em>anoject</em> and <em>hyperject</em> that are connected to a term by Julia Kristeva — <em>abject</em> (something hated, a scapegoat). <em>Anoject</em> is an anonymous crowd that does the scapegoating, and <em>hyperject</em> is the heroic person who goes against the crowd to serve some higher value, such as truth and beauty.</p><p>Similarly, I <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/orthogonal-approaches-of-balaji-srinivasan-231320080723">wrote</a> how Balaji Srinivasan distinguishes between the ability to do <strong>social diligence</strong> (following the opinion of others) and <strong>technical diligence</strong> (individual or collective learning and due diligence based on facts).</p><p>How to arrive at these three utopias — <strong>Syntheism</strong>, <strong>Cosmopolis</strong> and <strong>Ecotopia</strong>? Through reversing the cycle of <strong>reciprocal closing</strong> (addiction) that can be described by: <strong>consuming, exploiting and adapting</strong>. And instead, to allow for <strong>reciprocal opening</strong> of the opportunities and capabilities, use different verbs: <strong>syngesting (prosuming), imploiting and exapting</strong>.</p><p>Syngesting is my verb, but it means something like prosuming — <strong>creatively digesting the pain of life and synthesizing it into something beautiful</strong>. Imploitation is a tantric concept and a term introduced by Alexander Bard as the opposite to exploitation, and it is something like regeneration and postponement of pleasure. Exapting is a term I heard first from Dave Snowden, but John Vervaeke uses it a lot and it means finding novel uses for some tools in different contexts through serendipity — using a lucky chance for innovation and rapid prototyping.</p><p>I am excited by such dialogues and ideas like Civium and the efforts to nurture various psychotechnologies to arrive at some novel emergence of something beyond culture and systems of justification to create a united human swarm.</p><p>And as both Gregory Rawlence and Daniel Schmachtenberger say — we as the human swarm <strong>need to transform from a caterpillar, through a liminal stage of a cocoon, into a butterfly</strong>.</p><p><em>You can support my </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek"><em>writing</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/jaksim/videos"><em>videos</em></a><em> on these topics and my small podcasting project </em><a href="https://anchor.fm/jakub-simek"><em>Between Ideas &amp; Subcultures</em></a><em> through </em><a href="https://www.patreon.com/user?u=32652896&amp;fan_landing=true"><em>Patreon</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://paypal.me/jakubsimek?locale.x=sk_SK"><em>PayPal</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=894a1e695012" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/on-transculture-metaconcerts-and-hyperobjects-894a1e695012">On transculture, metaconcerts and hyperobjects</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance">Opaque Renaissance</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jordan Hall’s Civium — Hacking the deep code of metaculture]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/jordan-halls-civium-hacking-the-deep-code-of-metaculture-82828f4b40fe?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82828f4b40fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gregg-henriques]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[john-vervaeke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-b]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jordan-hall]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Aug 2020 11:05:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-13T17:59:12.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Jordan Hall’s Civium — Hacking the deep code of metaculture</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/629/1*-Lql8NUBnUVPG_3iAfcyQA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I am quite excited by Civium, the new project of Jordan Hall, one of the thinkers that came up with the Game B idea.</p><p>Jordan Hall worked for and founded some deep tech startups behind innovations such as MP3 and DivX. He is also a co-founder of Neurohacker Collective, a producer of probably the most holistic nootropic stack on the market. He worked also on some blockchain projects and currently he is interested in “hacking the deep code of metaculture”.</p><p>I think he means finding underlying protocols for dynamic and seamless cooperation of very different people, and at scale. A quality of cooperation and coherence, not unlike a well-functioning crew sailing a boat at sea or a prehistoric tribe, but without knowing the people well.</p><p>This may sound too abstract and overambitious, but bear with me. Jordan Hall has a long-time interest in complexity science, and last year he got into some deep discussions with a cognitive scientist John Vervaeke who got famous for his lecture series Awakening from the Meaning Crisis. And this year he added to his explorations of psycho-technologies another interesting thinker, Gregg Henriques and his Tree of Knowledge (TOK) theory that explains culture as a kind of meta-behavior that differentiates people from animals through an ability to justify their behavior to others and themselves.</p><p>Now the quite ambitious mission is to arrive at metaculture. Or one could say a universal culture proper. Culture is a kind of acceptable range of behavior for some community — a fractally local subculture. But we don’t have a universal and global culture proper. This is obvious for anyone with just a bit of multi-cultural experience — some customs, behaviors and expressions are perfectly normal for one community or subculture, and repulsive for other.</p><h4><strong>Three aspects of ontological design</strong></h4><p>I find the Civium project somehow adjacent to similar efforts, such as The Flow Genome project by Jamie Wheal. The experience of flow is central to success of new ventures such as building a startup, it is also related to high trust between co-founders. Civium has a similar objective, but extends this type of thinking and a focus on psycho-technologies, into three deeper domains, that can be together called <a href="https://medium.com/datadriveninvestor/the-manifesto-of-ontological-design-7fdb19169107"><em>ontological design</em></a>.</p><p>Jordan Hall and John Vervaeke in their discussions see three joint projects emerging: <strong>a meta-psychotechnology</strong>, <strong>a sociotechnology</strong> and “<strong>a religion that is not a religion</strong>”. Civium is mostly related to sociotechnology, which can be viewed as a third-person (objective) instance of this complex effort.</p><p>While meta-psychotechnology has a character of first-person view (subjective), and “a religion that is not a religion” has a character of <em>a transcendental operator</em> between the two, or a second-person perspective (intersubjective).</p><h4><strong>Religion that is not a religion and the will to wisdom</strong></h4><p>I have <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/on-the-religion-of-no-religion-sovereignty-vs-meaning-183cc7b1432e">written</a> about the effort of building “a religion that is not a religion” and contrasted it with Alexander Bard’s vision of Syntheism, or “creating god in the internet age”. He says that we need a bold vision, and innovative discussions (e.g. anti-debates, dialogos, circling and dialectic) are not enough for something novel to emerge.</p><p>I connect this type of reasoning to Peter Thiel who lacks bold moonshots in the current culture and wants “to get back to the future”, and Jean-Pierre Dupuy who explains the need to “bootstrap the desired future”. Mariana Mazzucato <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/on-mariana-mazzucatos-moonshot-ideas-b16563d31f94">explores</a> similar moonshot thinking.</p><p>More practically, I wanted to see how different is the effort to build “a religion that is not a religion” from the various DARPA efforts to build super-soldiers, and IARPA efforts e.g. around super-forcasters (collective intelligence) and hybrid human-AI collaboration (symbiotic intelligence).</p><p>Alexander Bard talks about the <em>will to intelligence</em> as a successor to Nietzsche’s <em>will to power</em>. I think another level could be the <em>will to wisdom</em>. I feel the difference is that the will to intelligence can be weaponized, but the will to wisdom shouldn’t be possible to weaponize. And the difference is in my opinion in the opaque and unpredictable character of wisdom, or what Alexander Bard with Andrew Sweeny, in their discussions, call “crazy wisdom” of tantra.</p><p>Here I see the abstraction of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox">Newcomb’s paradox</a> of “one-boxing” (taking the opaque box only) as central, which can be summed up by Žižekian example of “I would rather not to”. I based my idea of <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/opaque-renaissance-from-playing-game-b-to-taking-box-b-77211ab7fca8">Opaque Renaissance</a> on this example of choosing a meta-rational solution as opposed to a rational one. <a href="https://www.advojka.cz/archiv/2016/19/borrowed-robe-of-sacred">Dupuy</a> argues that this Newcomb’s paradox is just a more abstract version of Weber’s Calvinist paradox of predestination. It is also related to the story of Abraham and Isaac and the idea of succession of ever more abstract sacrifices.</p><p>Newcomb’s paradox also illustrates the ability to shift paradigms and say no to the current most salient paradigm and thus allow for what John Vervaeke calls <em>reciprocal opening</em> as opposed to the reciprocal closing and over-optimizing on a limited set of incentives and perspectives.</p><h4><strong>From meta-psychotechnology to metaculture</strong></h4><p>John Vervaeke in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ft_7n3eUytQ">discussion</a> with Jordan Hall and Gregg Henriques explores the notion of fellowship and agape as a basis of religion. Jordan Hall adds the importance of commons as opposed to both the markets and the state. The commons are almost absent nowadays and we rely too much on markets and the state to solve our problems. And many of those problems are caused by the deterioration of commons.</p><p>Commons are related more to the chaotic and complex domains where innovation happens, while markets and the state are related more to the complicated and obvious domains. But I see this four systems in the Cynefin Framework as parts of a circular process of building an ever growing stack of psycho- and socio- technologies. A precursor to steam engine is first created just as a toy and art, and thousand years later it is exapted to serve in mining as a custom-built product. Later it is standardized and mass produced as a commercial product, as it finally becomes an obvious commodity. Here I am using Wardley Mapping that distinguishes a circular process of innovation from genesis stage through custom-built, product and a commodity.</p><p>So I don’t see commons as an alternative to the markets or the state. I see them as an integral part of ever changing process and an engine for innovations that can be later exapted by markets and the state to serve as a stack for further process in this accelerating OODA loops.</p><h4><strong>Metaconcerts and ephemeral groups</strong></h4><p>Gregory J. E. Rawlins in his book The Human Swarm explains how we are possibly just at the beginning of novel forms cooperation between humans facilitated by digital technology and internet. He calls these events of global cooperation <a href="https://homes.luddy.indiana.edu/rawlins/books/shoulders/ch02-labor.html">metaconcerts</a> and argues that some will last only for a lifespan of a fly. Once the common objective is accomplished, the metaconcert dissolves. I think this idea can be connected to the Forrest Landry’s project of <em>ephemeral group process</em> and <a href="http://www.magic-flight.com/pub/uvsm_1/sgrp_small_group_2.pdf">dynamics of small groups</a>.</p><p>Gregg Henriques has his Tree of Knowledge System (TOK) that tries to provide a unified framework for psychology and position it in the other emergencies in big history — matter, life, behavior and culture. Psychology deals with human culture that is based on justification systems facilitated by language.</p><p>Agriculture and written language created the current Game A. Game B could be facilitated by an interactive language of internet and a new metaculture and consciousness of a super-organism, a human swarm.</p><p>So Jordan Hall together with John Vervaeke explore the TOK and ideas such as <em>the adjacent possible</em> (TAP) to contemplate the possibility of metaculture. They connect it with the infinite game idea of James Carse. They also use process philosophy and the spirit of American pragmatism and try to avoid utopian thinking.</p><p>I would argue that it is a mistake to avoid utopias, as I <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/utopias-are-hyperobjects-not-perfections-c89e6486d91f">see</a> them only as hyperobjects and not perfections. So, the emergence of metaculture could be in fact the rise of a culture proper — an underlying protocol for subcultures to collaborate on a new level as a super-organism.</p><p>Gregg Henriques argues that this metaculture should nurture values such as dignity, wellbeing and integrity.</p><p>I would add that to nurture reciprocal opening we need to reverse the cycle of consumption, exploitation, adaptation and to arrive at novel values, we need to use novel verbs such as <strong>prosuming, imploiting and exapting</strong>. Instead of interactive production and consumption (prosuming) I came up with a word syngesting that describes digesting pain and synthesizing it into something beautiful.</p><p>So I use it as syngesting, imploiting and exapting. Imploiting is Alexander Bard’s term, and it is the opposite of exploiting and it means repairing, regenerating, postponing pleasure and is connected with tantric practices. Exapting is the opposite of adapting, and it is using serendipity for novel uses and innovations (Dave Snowden explains how dinosaurs had wings with feathers for sexual display and only learnt to fly by falling off trees — the wings were exapted for flying by lucky accidents.)</p><h4><strong>Sociotechnology for regenerating trust</strong></h4><p>Bonnita Roy <a href="https://anchor.fm/emerge/episodes/Bonnitta-Roy---A-Source-Code-Analysis-of-Trust-e24ds3">talks</a> about her source code analysis of trust and sees trust as emerging thanks to complex feed loops. This means it doesn’t follow simpler positive or negative feedback loops, but is diminished when inequalities in outcomes and skill grow. And these show up when thresholds for action are lowered and people actually engage in collective action. And thresholds for action are lowered when there is high trust. So Bonnita Roy sees the process as valves going up and down, and trust as something that needs to be constantly replenished. Because trust decreases with naturally rising inequalities of outcome and skill as people engage in effective collective action.</p><p>Some time ago I <a href="https://medium.com/meta-metta/something-between-charter-cities-and-charter-schools-c18bc419c090">wrote</a> about a need to build <em>something between charter cities and charter schools</em> — charter communities. I meant intentional communities like our Sote Hub, the rural startup hub we cofounded in Kenya. And was motivated with the pressing and yet unresolved question how to increase trust between cofounders and their effectiveness.</p><p>I see Civium as a similar idea to create spaces for regeneration. It is connected to a quite recent ideas and movements such as rural <a href="https://craigberoch.org/">decelerators</a> and modern monasteries.</p><p>So meta-psychotechnology should serve as an operating system or a software, and Civium should serve as a hardware for creating regenerative communities that operate on metaculture.</p><p>Jordan Hall says that he is hopeful because we have eight billion minds and six billion people online. So the chances for inventing and exapting something on a trajectory to metaculture are increasing.</p><p>I <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/how-to-build-innovative-and-impactful-startups-for-1-ad738e0a8bf6">wrote</a> about the need to create radically cheaper ways to register startups e.g. for 1€, to build smartphones that cost 10€, laptops that cost 100€ and digital fabricators that cost 1000€ and smart homes that cost 10,000€. Also, we would need to reinvent home appliances to be much more energy friendly, use circular economy, and we would also need cheaper sources of energy and storage. This is just an illustration of magnitudes. For example, thanks to cheap “dumb phones” mobile banking (M-Pesa) was invented in Kenya in 2007. Our banks in Slovakia plan to start doing instant payments in 2022, so 15 years after Kenyan M-Pesa.</p><p>I find Civium very inspiring and feel that the problem of regenerating trust is central and can be tackled with environment more conducive to human development and flourishing. I just wanted to share some thoughts and ideas that I picked and connected with recent discussions between Jordan Hall, John Vervaeke and Gregg Henriques.</p><p><em>You can support my </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek"><em>writing</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/jaksim/videos"><em>videos</em></a><em> on these topics and my small podcasting project </em><a href="https://anchor.fm/jakub-simek"><em>Between Ideas &amp; Subcultures</em></a><em> through </em><a href="https://www.patreon.com/user?u=32652896&amp;fan_landing=true"><em>Patreon</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://paypal.me/jakubsimek?locale.x=sk_SK"><em>PayPal</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82828f4b40fe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/jordan-halls-civium-hacking-the-deep-code-of-metaculture-82828f4b40fe">Jordan Hall’s Civium — Hacking the deep code of metaculture</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance">Opaque Renaissance</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Orthogonal Approaches of Balaji Srinivasan]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/orthogonal-approaches-of-balaji-srinivasan-231320080723?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/231320080723</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-b]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[balaji-srinivasan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[effective-altruism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Aug 2020 13:55:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-04T14:42:30.632Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/950/1*pPfvpiSePFh0rgrFbAsvRA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Balaji Srinivasan is an accomplished inventor and investor who saw the COVID-19 pandemics very early and was tweeting about it fulltime since February 2020. He also received for it some backlash from media, such as Vox/Recode for being too alarmist in a clickbait <a href="https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/2/13/21128209/coronavirus-fears-contagion-how-infection-spreads">article</a> from 13 February 2020 titled “No handshakes, please”: The tech industry is terrified of the coronavirus”. He debunked that article thoroughly and <a href="https://medium.com/@balajis/citations-for-the-recode-handshake-debunking-b2751adc7e69">shred</a> it to bits.</p><p>I like his particular ways of thinking, and I think they are relevant for the broader discussion around Game B, existential risks and <strong>a broken information ecology</strong>, as Daniel Schmachtenberger would put it. Therefore, I want to describe some of his approaches and ideas.</p><p>According to Bonnita Roy, there are at least six different ways how to go meta, or how to play the metagame. I summarized them <a href="https://medium.com/meta-metta/a-summary-of-bonnita-roys-six-ways-to-go-meta-21fae29e9123">here</a>. One way is to use <strong>orthogonal approaches</strong> — to create kind of new metaphysics by tweaking some aspects of reality. For example, to view people as processes, and not as objects or instruments. Bonnita Roy gives an example of “coffee moves millions of people each day”.</p><h4>Citizen journalists versus corporate journalists</h4><p>Balaji Srinivasan tries to<strong> create a z-axis</strong>, to create a third orthogonal view. In Central Europe we have this saying: “Where two are fighting, the third wins”. For example, he reframed the debate around legacy media and internet upstarts as <strong>a corporate journalism versus citizen journalists</strong>. Before the narrative focused on legacy media fighting conspiracy media. Balaji finds the commonalities of those x and y — they both employ corporate journalists — and suggests a z-axis: citizen journalists.</p><p>He draws a parallel <strong>between professional army and a conscription-based citizen army</strong>. The professional army is more of a monocrop and a monoculture of similar people from similar class, that is more prone to groupthink and can be manipulated or infiltrated. As in the case of German professional army and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/03/world/europe/germany-military-neo-nazis-ksk.html">recent</a> worries of far-right infiltration.</p><p>Similarly, the corporate media seem to be more prone to group think and manipulation by online lynch mobs often composed of their own peers. This contributes to an auto-catalytic process of polarization. One could frame the problem, together with Peter Thiel, in Girardian terms as a problem of too much competition and resulting scapegoating mechanism that follows the mimetic conflict among peers — corporate journalists.</p><p>Balaji Srinivasan blames the decline of media also on a new digital tech frontier opening in the last 20 years that attracted a lot of talent. The result is falling readership and revenues and heightened competition among journalists and a need to create more clickbait to chase after the same advertisers as social media that are expanding.</p><p>The same auto-catalytic process explained differently: Former craftspeople with a professional honor are turning slowly or rather quickly into missionaries for various AI-sects or autocults.</p><p>I see an opposition between people interested in (psycho)technological progress with advanced collaboration across subcultures, and people interested in online lynch mobs and getting their daily dopamine hit. Here, my inspiration is Alexander Bard and his division between netocrats and consumtariat as two classes of the digital empire of internet.</p><p>Alexander Bard sees a clear difference between people who spend most of their days in deep study or deep work, some part in effective communication and collaboration between peers in closed groups and only a fraction of day in online narcistic cocktail parties of self-promotion on social media. And people who do the exact opposite and are addicted to social media and constantly distracted.</p><p>I see it as <strong>a healthy information food pyramid</strong> where there is a deep study at the base and only a fraction of social media on the top, with a mid-layer of good faith and deep conversation between peers in closed groups, where one can engage in <strong>antagonistic cooperation</strong>. The unhealthy information food pyramid would be the reverse.</p><p>I illustrate this healthy pyramid as: “From edge work to online saunas to cocktail parties”.</p><p>Balaji Srinivasan tries to provide ways how to slowly <a href="https://balajis.com/how-to-gradually-exit-twitter/">exit</a> Twitter and prepare for a more decentralized crypto future with better information ecology. <strong>Where a narrative will be a wrapper around verified and immutable facts</strong>. Balaji is also interested in art and sees a need for (not just crypto and tech) companies to move from “learn to code” into “learn to write”, and “learn to create videos and direct films”.</p><p>Here again Alexander Bard would see a distinction between <strong>pathos, mythos and logos</strong>. Pathos is art and intrusion of creative daemon, mythos is a shared narrative, and logos is an objective technology and science of what verifiably works (as in hunting and war). According to Bard, mythos is a combination of pathos and logos. As a metaphor, where half brain of warm art and half brain of cold science create a proper narrative balance.</p><p>I use Forrest Landry’s three modalities of first-person, second-person and third-person views. And also see a cyclic process of starting in pathos or art, moving into mythos or narrative and later to factual logos and back to pathos, in a <strong>OODA loop</strong> or a <strong>Wardley Map</strong>. From a chaotic innovative creation in the <strong>genesis </strong>stage, to a complex <strong>custom-built</strong> product, then later to a scaled complicated <strong>product</strong> and finally to an obvious <strong>commodity</strong>.</p><p>As in the <strong>Cynefin Framework</strong> with chaotic, complex, complicated and obvious domains of order. And then repeat the cycle of pathos-mythos-logos back to pathos to build <strong>an ever higher stack of (psycho)technologies</strong> and monopolize other sectors or industries. It is important to note that to be in chaos is energetically expensive and only temporary.</p><h4><strong>Social vs technical diligence</strong></h4><p>Balaji Srinivasan sees the problem with current information ecology also in the fact that most people can only do social (due) diligence and only few people can do technical (due) diligence. This means most people rely only on recommendations and sensemaking of their friends. And if they over-rely on social diligence they may fall into groupthink.</p><p>To do technical diligence better, would mean regularly getting into deep studies to grog some phenomena and parse various views and opinions deeply, and thus get closer to the ground truth.</p><h4><strong>Nationalism vs Rationality — Tribal rationality</strong></h4><p>Balaji Srinivasan uses this model to describe behavior of e.g. Apple fans versus some rational model person. He says that it is important to keep balance between what he calls nationalism and rationality — because too much nationalism and fandom and you are stuck with inferior or overpriced products, and not really critical of your heroes.</p><p>But too much rationality and you are too open to a takeover. You need both a strong community, but also a strong focus on rationality. I would reframe this balance as <strong>tribal rationality</strong>. So, combining both the good parts of tribalism and rationality.</p><p>Tribal rationality would mean combining the good parts of both <strong>believing</strong> in your team or subculture, and then also accepting objective <strong>facts</strong> of rationality.</p><p>This would <strong>reconcile belief with facts</strong> in a similar manner as George Soros does in his <strong>theory of reflexivity</strong>. It is also connected to the idea of <strong>projected time</strong> by Jean Pierre <a href="https://www.advojka.cz/archiv/2016/19/borrowed-robe-of-sacred">Dupuy</a>. Or what he calls <strong>bootstrapping the desired future</strong><em> </em>from a fixed point in the future. By projecting that future to our current present time.</p><p>A similar notion is Peter Thiel’s <strong>positive and definite future</strong> of the moonshot era of 1960s that we need to get back to, as I wrote in my recent <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/the-talebian-and-thielian-moment-af14d7016adb">article</a> The Talebian and Thielian Moment.</p><h4><strong>Experiencing both sides of the trade</strong></h4><p>I am not sure if Balaji Srinivasan uses this exact words, but the idea is that one shall ideally have an experience of both: a patient and a doctor, an entrepreneur and a regulator, a startup founder and a venture capital investor, a seller and a client… to see both perspectives and have a more nuanced, humble and balanced view.</p><h4><strong>Meiji Restoration, Moonshots and Estonia</strong></h4><p>We need leaders and citizens who are <strong>more like Deng Xiaoping and less like Mao Zedong</strong>. This maps to Jordan Hall’s idea of increasing personal sovereignty and bouncing off after hitting rock bottom. But here the idea is that it is rare and hard to do a turnaround of a big company and even harder to do a turnaround of a country. Balaji states a few examples, such as Meiji Restoration, Deng Xiaoping after Mao, and Estonia after the fall of Soviet Union.</p><p>He says that it is patriotic to be both critical and practical. And to see clearly that our company or country has fallen behind and to have some bold and definite vision to turn around and improve.</p><p>I would also maybe add another layer of <strong>subculture restoration</strong> or local community restoration, after the corporate turnaround and before the national restoration. Also I would like to connect the restoration to the idea of reflexivity as defined by George Soros, or the idea of bootstrapping the desired future as elaborated by Jean Pierre Dupuy. Or by Peter Thiel, when he says that we used to have a positive and definite vision of the future in the US in the 1960s when we had a moonshot vision of getting to the Moon.</p><p>I could call the need for a communal or national restoration <strong>a sunshot, as opposed to moonshot</strong>. First one needs a dose of sunlight and transparency to look at their real and sad state, and then aim for a moonshot — a big bold vision of a turnaround.</p><h4><strong>Networked state</strong></h4><p>Balaji Srinivasan calls a networked state the idea that companies are becoming more like states as they can issue their own currencies, and states are becoming more like decentralized social networks. Thanks to exponential digital tech. And thanks to the <strong>dynamical interplay between consensus and dissent</strong> on social networks as John Robb would say it. Balaji also points out that Twitter can now censor the US President, and also can censor legacy media.</p><p>So, <strong>Twitter is actually upstream of both media and politics</strong>. Therefore, Balaji has <a href="https://balajis.com/">a project</a> to help others to exit gradually Twitter and create a network of decentralized pseudo-anonymous citizen journalists aided by blockchain.</p><p>This idea seems rather obvious and not that exceptional at first, but I like the framing of the networked state, because it is more technical and bypasses some baggage associated with culture wars and concepts such as The Cathedral, Blue Church, and Deep State.</p><p>I recently brainstormed terms like “<strong>decentralized power pyramid</strong>” (Game A) versus “<strong>decentralized creativity pyramid</strong>” (Game B). Also, I came up with “<strong>dissentful consensus</strong>” as a playful name for the John Robb’s idea of interplay between consensus and dissent on social media as a current decision and governance mechanism.</p><h4>Green Zones vs. Red Zones — focus on robo, bio, agro, astro, crypto, and VR</h4><p>Balaji Srinivasan came up pretty early with now common distinction between Green Zones and Red Zones amid the COVID-19 pandemic.</p><p>Green Zones are (fractally local) places where commons are not tragic and people don’t need to wear masks all the time and can visit e.g. bars or each other, because the territory managed to put out the novel corona virus fire.</p><p>Red Zones are all other places where commons are still tragic and the COVID-19 fire is not yet put out and seems to be getting stronger.</p><p>Balaji Srinivasan believes that Green Zones will attract FDI and skilled migrants, and the Red Zones will experience the opposite.</p><p>He thinks that companies will get more geographically distributed with a workforce based also in rural areas, but with a good VR rooms. He believes that these industries will prosper: robo, bio, agro, astro, crypto, and VR.</p><p>Balaji talks about the need to invent new business models. That we are not experiencing an economic crisis, but it is metaphorically similar to an invasion — by a biological agent. And thus if commons are tragic and unsafe, people will change their behavior and businesses need to become <strong>digital-first </strong>businesses. So e.g. a brick and mortar restaurant needs to become <strong>a cloud kitchen</strong>.</p><p>I would add also a need to make clean meat and plant-based meat and their combination available and accessible to everyone maybe through digital fabrication and cloud kitchens for small households.</p><p>I see also a need for Game B to come up with similar big ideas, as planting trees with drones and AI (BioCarbon Engineering), or what another subculture — Effective Altruism promotes with plant-based meat that tastes like meat (Impossible Burger and others).</p><h4>Bitcoin as the leader of the free world</h4><p>The US perceived itself as the leader of the free world and the №1 country. Also we in Europe, and especially in Central and Eastern Europe, perceived US as the guarantor of our freedom and security and economic prosperity.</p><p>The COVID-19 pandemic exposed the need for a return to a moonshot era, where the future is both positive and definite, — a need for a Meiji Restoration of the US to catch up with China and other countries that managed to become and stay Green Zones.</p><p>Meanwhile the absence of US on the world stage is felt and sensed. And Balaji Srinivasan proposes that bitcoin has replaced the US and has become the leader of the free world. If China is focused on AI governance and represents an authoritarian and centralized alternative, the <strong>digital empire</strong> of internet and cryptoeconomics provides a democratic and decentralized alternative.</p><p>I see Balaji Srinivasan as an eclectic thinker that is able to hold various perspectives from different subcultures. He is also active in culture wars 2.0 and <a href="https://balajis.com/">proposes</a> decentralized alternatives to twitter. Well worth <a href="https://twitter.com/balajis?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor">following</a>.</p><p><em>You can support my </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek"><em>writing</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/jaksim/videos"><em>videos</em></a><em> on these topics and my small podcasting project </em><a href="https://anchor.fm/jakub-simek"><em>Between Ideas &amp; Subcultures</em></a><em> through </em><a href="https://www.patreon.com/user?u=32652896&amp;fan_landing=true"><em>Patreon</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://paypal.me/jakubsimek?locale.x=sk_SK"><em>PayPal</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=231320080723" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/orthogonal-approaches-of-balaji-srinivasan-231320080723">Orthogonal Approaches of Balaji Srinivasan</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance">Opaque Renaissance</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Opaque Renaissance — From playing Game B to taking Box B]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/opaque-renaissance-from-playing-game-b-to-taking-box-b-77211ab7fca8?source=rss----40ebcfe239dc---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77211ab7fca8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[opaque-renaissance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intellectual-deep-web]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-stoa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alexander-bard]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-b]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jakub Simek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Jul 2020 14:59:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-09T14:09:52.058Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Opaque Renaissance — </strong>From playing Game B to taking Box B</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/641/1*pyF6j02EtzDjZ5qqClbbGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The participant sees two boxes. Box A is transparent and there is 1,000 dollars in it and the second Box B is opaque, and there either is, or isn’t a million dollars. If the participant chooses only the opaque box, there is a Predictor who sees this in advance, and will put the million dollars there.</figcaption></figure><p>Alchemy made a big comeback through the rise of AI governance. Suddenly black boxes are everywhere. They collect inputs, run them through opaque neural networks and return outputs that affect our lives deeply.</p><p>They fragment our information ecology, lock us not just into filter bubbles but increasingly into AI-sects, hack our dopamine pathways, drive epistemic conflict and even prevent some of us from flying or using speed trains. The COVID-19 pandemic only accelerated this trend.</p><p>At the beginning of 2020 nobody couldn’t imagine that a province will be locked down for weeks somewhere in China, and suddenly the whole world instantiated the same policy. The ideas of smart quarantines proliferated.</p><p>Recently, I <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/the-talebian-and-thielian-moment-af14d7016adb">wrote</a> that we live in the Talebian and Thielian moment. Suddenly, both a history with ancient black swans, and a future with existential risks became much more salient.</p><h4><strong>Circling from playing Game B to taking Box B</strong></h4><p>Game B is the idea of an infinite game, that allows for all the other finite competitive games to exist. It is also the idea that our current Game A civilization, since agriculture until today, is inherently self-terminating because of three generator functions that drive existential risks.</p><p>Daniel Schmachtenberger explains, how rivalry with ever potent weapons on a finite playing field is self-terminating. Ever-increasing extraction and pollution are also self-terminating. And exponential technology without equally powerful wisdom and love is also self-terminating.</p><p>I <a href="https://medium.com/collective-wisdom/on-the-religion-of-no-religion-sovereignty-vs-meaning-183cc7b1432e">wrote</a> previously, how we could address these three generator functions by three new verbs. Alexander Bard suggests <em>imploitation</em> instead of exploitation. Dave Snowden talks about <em>exaptation</em> as different from adaptation. And finally, we could address the pain of rivalry and living instead of consumption with <em>prosuming</em> (interactive producing and consuming). Before I learnt about prosuming, I suggested a new verb “<em>syngesting</em>” — digesting the pain and synthetizing it into something beautiful.</p><p>Alexander Bard talks about the need for pathos, mythos and logos. I see pathos as the first-person artistic process of turning pain into beauty and novelty through syngesting. Logos is the third-person objective description of reality and using exponential (psycho)technology to shape the reality through exaptation, or using lucky chance and serendipity.</p><p>And mythos is according to Alexander Bard, the interplay and creative combination of pathos and logos into effective narratives. I would add that this is the interactive second-person process and is connected to imploitation of relationships. Of cultivating and regenerating relationships of some specific and local community and subculture.</p><p>Alexander Bard distinguishes nomadology and a circular process of repetition where a community travels through places or ideas and arrives at the same or slightly different place. The difference is caused by eventology, a singular event that can cause emergence of something new.</p><p>According to Bard, eventology was invented by Zoroastrians and created the possibility of progress and linear thinking. Nomadology is pagan and circular — every new year is just a repetition of the same and nothing much changes. But we need both nomadology and eventology.</p><h4><strong>“I would rather not to”: Speeding up the OODA loops through retraction and Newcomb’s paradox</strong></h4><p>We could abstract this circular process with rare events of radical emergence and singularity into an OODA loop, a Wardley Map, or a Cynefin Framework.</p><p>The idea is that we first start as pioneers in a creative chaos and create something unique and novel and not well understood. Then we proceed as settlers into something custom-build and more useful and later make it scalable as an established product. And finally, we optimize and standardize this former innovation into something now considered not just a complicated product, but an obvious commodity.</p><p>And thus, we dominate that particular market segment in the “zero to one” fashion. And this dominance allows us to plunge again into chaos in search for something novel so we can leverage our technology stack and dominate yet another domain.</p><p>If Game A is the game of city planners, architects and power-hungry people who try to compete using established products and commodities, in the <em>complicated</em> and <em>obvious</em> systems, Game B is more about the pioneers in the <em>chaotic</em> systems or settlers in the <em>complex</em> systems. It is more about circular exploration than linear exploitation. Simon Wardley talks about three different subcultures — pioneers, settlers and city planners. Each has their own weaknesses and strengths.</p><p>Our planet, people and their partnerships are suffering because, these OODA loops, these circles of innovation are stalled, and our mighty city planners try to optimize and squeeze the last bits of efficiency from the last outdated paradigm.</p><p>We are stuck in logos of the old extractive paradigm that is not even sustainable. And what we need is to get even beyond sustainability into regeneration and resilience. And we can do it only by plunging back into the chaos of the unknown. Into the chaos of pathos and art. Only by retraction and whispering the Žižekian “I would rather not to”. I would rather not engage in the old paradigm and competitions.</p><p>Chaotic systems require mostly decisive action. Complex systems require rapid prototyping and parallel testing of opposite hypotheses. This is where black boxes, AIs and the opaque renaissance comes in.</p><p>But let’s first connect the opaque renaissance to the idea of “I would rather not to”, to the idea of retraction, to the idea of withdrawal and postponement of satisfaction as in the tantric practice, or the concept of imploitation.</p><p>We can do it through the Newcomb’s paradox, an old philosophical riddle, that illustrates both protestant ethics and also some kind of meta-rational thinking.</p><p><strong>Newcomb’s Paradox is the following:</strong></p><p><em>The participant sees two boxes. Box A is transparent and there is 1,000 dollars in it and the second Box B is opaque, and there either is, or isn’t a million dollars. If the participant chooses only the opaque box, there is a Predictor who sees this in advance, and will put the million dollars there.</em></p><p>It would be rational to take both boxes, because in any case the participant will at least end up with some cash. Even though three orders of magnitude less cash, but better than nothing.</p><p>But the idea of one-boxing, to take only the one opaque box, is according to <a href="https://www.advojka.cz/archiv/2016/19/borrowed-robe-of-sacred">Jean Pierre Dupuy</a>, a French philosopher and a friend of René Girard, the abstract expression of the origin of Weber’s paradox of the predestination and Protestant ethics.</p><h4><strong>Opaque Renaissance: </strong>If dark is like fire, opaque is like water</h4><p>Opaque Renaissance is the idea that black boxes are now everywhere to be explored in a playful manner. Black boxes in the sense of how AIs work, and black or opaque boxes in the sense of Newcomb’s paradox, which posits a difficult philosophical problem, but also illustrates a kind of meta-rational action. Taking only the one opaque box in Newcomb’s paradox is not optimal from the rational perspective, but it is this action that allows for the novelty of an event and an escape from the treadmill of optimization in some same old paradigm.</p><p>So, if we take Game B as an idea of an infinite game of civilization that is not self-terminating, next we need to proceed to taking (only) the Box B in the sense of the Newcomb’s paradox. This is the Žižekian “I would prefer not to” and it means retraction, refusal to participate in the mimetic competition in the old paradigm. So, for example, instead of rushing to buy property in the cities, it would mean retraction to digital monasteries in the countryside, as Alexander Bard would say it.</p><p>Simon Wardley distinguishes three different cultures in every company — the pioneers, settlers and city planners. So next, we would take some of the (psycho)technological innovations in the chaotic and complex domains of pioneering experimentation and scale them into complicated systems as settlers, and later optimize them and commoditize them (as city planners) for wide use. And thus, engage in this circular process of repetition and distinct events of emergence of novelty, as Alexander Bard says, also echoing Peter Thiel’s “zero to one”.</p><p>One could also add Sun Tzu’s five factors put by Simon Wardley onto an OODA loop. Thus, an ever higher and refreshed stack of psycho-technologies is built for an Opaque Renaissance.</p><p>If dark is like fire, opaque is like water. We need an Opaque Renaissance. Speeding up the OODA loops of regeneration and conviviality.</p><p>If Game A is robotic nationalism, Game B is maybe an infinite game presented by James P. Carse.</p><p>Or these three concepts by Greg Thomas — antagonistic cooperation, rooted cosmopolitanism, elegant resilience.</p><p>Or a networked state, tribal rationality, dissentful consensus, a healthy digital food pyramid.</p><p>Or bootstrapping a desired future through a bold and definite vision.</p><p>If Game A is a distributed power pyramid, Game B is a distributed creativity pyramid.</p><p>If the distributed bitcoin is a leader of the free world. Then the centralized AI social credit is the leader of the authoritarian world. Someone should merge them to cancel out the downsides.</p><p>Bitcoin is like a devouring mother that drains lots of energy. AI is like the despotic father that is impossible to please. Maybe they should work on their relationship to be less toxic and more regenerative.</p><p>We need a <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/the-decades-long-quest-for-a-digital-aristotle-3546464eccc">digital Aristotle</a>. We need these types of inventions. Like M-Pesa in Kenya 13 years ago. But now on a blockchain. Because we had enough of talking logos and being stuck in logos of an extractive and exploitative paradigm that is not even sustainable.</p><p>Today we need to go beyond sustainability into regeneration and conviviality.</p><p>We also had enough of Sokal and Sokal Squared. We need <a href="https://medium.com/giving-on-the-edge/sokal-cubed-e99d64f9340c">Sokal Cubed</a>. We need physical spaces and communities of constant learning. We need 3D.</p><p>We had enough of logos and armchairs. We need to start playing with an opaque philosophical Lego, and ideally in places like Lagos.</p><p><em>This article is inspired by podcast and subcultures adjacent to Game B space, including the Stoa, Technosocial and Intellectual Deep Web. An inspiration that we need a renaissance not a revolution came from </em><a href="https://medium.com/@andrewpgsweeny/we-need-a-renaissance-not-another-revolution-7ff2a74c2a91"><em>Andrew Sweeny</em></a><em>. And the inspiration on digital nomadology loops and AI eventology singularities came from his discussions with Alexander Bard and other collaborators and podcast guests. The inspiration on AI, blackboxes and alchemy came from a recent discussion between Alexander Bard and Patrick Ryan on </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4tTJR9vqWB4"><em>Technosocial</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>You can support my </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jakubsimek"><em>writing</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/jaksim/videos"><em>videos</em></a><em> on these topics and my small podcasting project </em><a href="https://anchor.fm/jakub-simek"><em>Between Ideas &amp; Subcultures</em></a><em> through </em><a href="https://www.patreon.com/user?u=32652896&amp;fan_landing=true"><em>Patreon</em></a><em> or </em><a href="https://paypal.me/jakubsimek?locale.x=sk_SK"><em>PayPal</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77211ab7fca8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance/opaque-renaissance-from-playing-game-b-to-taking-box-b-77211ab7fca8">Opaque Renaissance — From playing Game B to taking Box B</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/opaque-renaissance">Opaque Renaissance</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>