<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Polytics - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[A publication by Bilkent University Political Thought Club. Leading forum for discussion of Turkish politics and global affairs. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/polytics?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 11:47:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/polytics" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[İnternetin Büyük Buhranı]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/i%CC%87nternetin-b%C3%BCy%C3%BCk-buhran%C4%B1-78592393c9f9?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78592393c9f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[türkçe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[siber-guvenlik]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[çin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Jan 2021 15:14:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-25T15:14:39.726Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C2V9gPUuoARPiPoMDt642w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kongre baskını sırasında Meclis Başkanı Nancy Pelosi’nin odasına bırakılan “Geri adım atmayacağız” notu. Fotoğraf: Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images</figcaption></figure><p>Hayatımızda özgürlük içeren çoğu konseptin devletle ilişkisi hep sancılı bir tartışma olageldi. Ekonomiyle devletin ilişkisi ekonomik faaliyetlerin tam özgürlüğüyle başlamıştı. Önce bir dünya savaşı, ardından buhran, sonra yine bir dünya savaşı bu algıyı altüst etti ve ekonominin tam özgürlüğüne inanan toplumların devleti sahneye çağırmasına vardı, ancak orada da sonuçlanmadı. Tartışmalar sürüp geldi ve yine bir kriz, ardından bugün yaşadığımız küresel salgın hastalık, bize normalde “paranın ağaçta yetişmediğini” öne sürüp devleti uzak tutmaya çalışacak kapitalistlerin bile kenara çekilişini an be an gösterdi. Hükümetler para harcadıkça piyasalar sinirlenmeyi bırakın, daha fazlasını istedi. Bu radikal değişim devimler, reformlar veya anlaşmalarla değil, tarihin akışıyla geldi ve bugün karar alma mekanizmasında rolü olan her fikir insanı şunu kabullendi: Her şey aslında daha farklı olabilirdi. Görüldü ki, “şey”leri öyle oldukları için öyle kabul etmemizi gerektirecek hiçbir sebep yoktu.</p><p>Dünyanın kendini “Demokrasi” olarak kabul ettirmiş en büyük ülkeleri büyük bir dönüşümün içinde. Bu dönüşümün öznelerinden biri yine devlet, ancak ikinci özne İkinci Dünya Savaşı öncesi ekonomik gelişmelerden bile daha hızlı işleyen bir varlık: İnternet. Henüz geçtiğimiz günlerde ABD’de kanıtlandı ki bu dönüşümün toplumsal boyutu, devletin ekonomiyle oynadığı köşe kapmaca oyunundan çok daha hızlı gelişerek çok daha somut tecrübelere yol açabilir. ABD’de yaşanan olaylar aslında uzun süredir büyüyen bir tartışmanın artık yalnızca tartışma olmaktan çıkıp karar alıcıların müdahalesine yol açması adına bir işaret fişeği.</p><p>Batı’da internetin özgür yapısı ilk ortaya çıktığı günden bugüne “Demokrasi adına bir başarı” olarak lanse edilmişti: Toplumun elinde artık her türlü baskıdan uzak kalabilecek bir iletişim aracı vardı. Amerika oldu bu projenin dünyadaki mimarı, demokrasiyle ilişkili çoğu konuda iddia ettiği diğer mimarlıklar gibi. Doğu ise, bunun tam zıddında yer aldı. Çin modeli, ABD modelinin yarattığı büyük özgürlük idealinin internette de tam karşısında durdu. Sansür ve kısıtlama, hatta gelinen noktada “gözetim” odaklı çalışan Çin Halk Cumhuriyeti’nin siber politikaları özgür dünya için elbette kabul edilemezdi.</p><p>Ancak özgür dünya, 6 Ocak günü yaşanan Kongre baskınını da “kabul edilemez” olarak nitelemekten geri durmadı. Bu hareket özgür internetin varlığıyla gerçek olabilmiş bir politik mobilizasyon sayesinde olsa bile… İnsanlar artık sosyal medya platformlarının kişisel verileri işleyerek yarattığı “yankı çemberleri”nin içinde radikalleşiyor, mobilize olup somut aksiyon alabiliyor, bu somut aksiyon ise daha fazla insanın radikalleşmesinin önünü açıyor. Batı’nın özgür interneti yıllardır uyuşturucu, pornografi, insan ticareti gibi karanlık konulara hız verirken son kertede yarattığı siyasi radikalleşme ve “demokrasinin kalbi”nde yaşanan ayaklanma girişimi, artık karanlık tarafın görmezden gelinemeyeceğini ve acilen aksiyon alınması gereken bir konu olduğunu yine Batı’nın gözlerinin önüne serdi.</p><p>Ve aksiyon alındı. Kim tarafından? ABD merkezli Twitter, Facebook, Apple ve Google gibi şirketler büyük bir kırmızı çizgiyi aşarak ABD Başkanı Donald Trump’ın kişisel hesaplarını erişime engelledi. Bu önemli olay ise bırakın tartışmaya son vermeyi, tıpkı ekonomi odaklı tartışmanın neredeyse bir asırdır aldığı farklı formlar gibi, kapitalizm ve internetin kaderi birleştiğinden beri büyüyen daha farklı bir tartışmayı gün yüzüne çıkardı: Demokrasiyi ve internetin yapısını koruma görevi birkaç kapitalist şirket yöneticisine mi bırakılacak? Bu şirket yöneticileri politik radikalleşme ve mobilizasyonun önünü kesmek istiyorlarsa 2011 yılında başlayan Arap Baharında bunu neden yapmadılar, ve yapmamaları için onları durduran neydi? Bu şirket yöneticilerinin ahlakî yetenekleri toplum adına karar almaya ne kadar muktedir, hele ki şirketlerinin bir numaralı kâr kapısı toplumun kişisel verilerini gözetleyip bunların satışı üzerinden para kazanmak iken? Pratik açıdan ise yine özgürlük, toplumun acil ihtiyaçlarına cevap vermekte yetersiz kalıyor: Çin’in COVID-19 sürecinde uyguladığı ve tamamı internet tabanlı olan temas takibi, kamusal alanda maske takma zorunlulukları ve aşı uygulaması gibi konular, Batı’da uygulanmadan önce büyük tartışmalar gerektiriyor ve toplumun tamamı tarafından kabul edilmesi zor bulunuyor: Halihazırda tüm bilgilerini şirket yöneticileriyle paylaşan ve bu şirket yöneticilerine demokrasinin korunması adına dahi güvenmek zorunda kalan toplum tarafından! Son yaşananlar, özgür dünyanın başından beri karşı çıktığı Çin modeliyle arasındaki kavgada Çin modeline teorik üstünlük kazandırmaktan başka bir işe yaramamış gibi görünüyor. Çin modelinin büyük bir baskı aracı olduğunu kabul ettiğimizde bile, karşısında pratik veya ahlakî açıdan savunabileceğimiz herhangi bir somut model bulunmuyor.</p><p>Dolayısıyla bu yazıda bahsedilen tartışma güvenlikçi modellerin üstünlüğüne yönelik bir argüman değil, ancak özgürlükçü modellerin yanlış yaptıklarıyla ahlakî ve pratik üstünlüğü kaybedişinin argümanı olabilir. Tıpkı Batı’nın ekonomik özgürlüğün maksimize edilmesini ve devletin uzak tutulmasını toplumun faydasına görmesi nasıl Büyük Buhran’la değiştiyse, bugün yaşananlar da büyük bir tartışmanın fitilini ateşlemesiyle <em>İnternetin Büyük Buhranının</em> başlangıcı olarak görülmeyi hak ediyor. Çözüm ise gerekirse özgürlük dahil olmak üzere değişmez kabul edilen her modelin sorgulanmasından ve hem birey, hem de toplum adına en makul orta yolun bulunmasından geçiyor, zira ekonomiyle ilgili tecrübe bize öğretti ki “şey”leri öyle oldukları için öyle kabul etmemizi gerektirecek hiçbir sebep kalmadı.</p><blockquote><strong>Onurcan Mısır</strong>, Bilkent Üniversitesi Uluslararası İlişkiler Öğrencisi</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78592393c9f9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/i%CC%87nternetin-b%C3%BCy%C3%BCk-buhran%C4%B1-78592393c9f9">İnternetin Büyük Buhranı</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Devletçi Ekonomi ve Bürokrasi Üzerine Bir İnceleme]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/devlet%C3%A7i-ekonomi-ve-b%C3%BCrokrasi-%C3%BCzerine-bir-i%CC%87nceleme-54b40fc0972d?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/54b40fc0972d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[devletçilik]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ekonomi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalizm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[türkçe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bürokrasi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 Jan 2021 21:34:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-23T09:11:53.824Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Ekonomi ve siyaset birbirlerinden asla ayrılamayan iki farklı olgudur. Birbirlerini etkiler ve değiştirirler. İkinci Dünya Savaşı’ndan sonra altın çağlarını yaşayan liberalizm, şüphesiz gücünü Nazilerin ve Sovyetlerin güçlü devletçi ekonomik modellerinin zıttı olmaktan almıştır ve modern dünyayı şekillendirmiştir. Nitekim Mises, Hayek ya da Friedman gibi liberal filozoflar siyasi fikirlerinin temelindeki kolektivizm düşmanlığını birinci elden tanık oldukları Nazilerden aldıklarını yazılarında dile getirmişlerdir (Bknz. Mises-Bürokrasi, Hayek- Kölelik Yolu). Bu düşünürler devletçi ekonominin insan hayatı üzerindeki etkilerini sadece ekonomik olarak değil, psikolojik ve toplumsal olarak da ele almışlardır. Ancak benim onlar kadar usta olmayan kalemim ne yazık ki bu konuyu daha dar bir alanda incelememi zorunlu kılıyor. Bu yazımda onların bu gözlemlerini ülkemiz özelinde daha güncel konularla okuyucunun zihninde canlandırmaya çalışacağım.</p><p><strong><em>Bürokrasi rejiminin ruhu</em></strong></p><p>Bürokrasi, şüphesiz devlet işlerinin ilerlemesi için gerekli bir iştir ancak onu serbest piyasa ekonomisinde başarısızlığa; başarısız olmasa bile dengesizliğe iten bazı özellikleri vardır. Bunları üç başlık altında işleyeceğiz:</p><ol><li>Bürokrat ve girişimci</li></ol><p>Serbest piyasa ekonomisi iki ana temel unsur üzerine kuruludur: Rekabet ve kâr. Ancak, bu iki temel unsur girişimcinin elinde olsa da serbest piyasa ekonomisinin tek bir patronu vardır, ki bu tüketicidir. Tüketici istediği işletmeyi büyütür ve zenginleştirir, istediğini ise batırır. Yani genel manada serbest piyasa ekonomisi tüketiciye sürekli daha iyi hizmet verip daha fazlasına ulaşmak isteyen rekabet halindeki işletmelerden doğar. Bu rekabet sürekli yenilik ve yaratıcılık gerektirir ancak bunlar bir bürokratta olmayan unsurlardır.</p><p>Bürokrat, bürokrasi mefhumu içinde bir emir eridir. Bürokrasi bir rekabet kurumu değil, hizmet kurumudur. Onun amacı hizmeti sağlamaktır; kâr etmesi beklenmez, beklense dahi bu kârın topluma bir yansıması olmaz. Bir girişimci daha fazla müşteriyi ürününe çekebilmek için sürekli analiz yapmak ve riskleri değerlendirmek mecburiyetindedir ancak bürokratın derdi amirini mutlu etmek ve mesuliyeti üzerinden atmaktır. Bürokrasi “daha iyi nasıl olur?’’ sorusunu sorma kabiliyetine sahip değildir. Bürokrat yapısı gereği yukarıdan gelen emri yerine getirir. THY bu durum için mükemmel bir örnek oluşturur. Bugün en çok noktaya uçan havayolu şirketi olma unvanı kâr amacıyla değil bürokratik bir emirle yerine getirir ve bu emirin getirdiği politik yıkım da yine kamunun üzerine kalır.</p><p>Bir bürokratta aranan özellikler girişimcilik ruhu değil emre itaattir. Bir bürokrat zaman içerisinde alt basamaklarda görevini yapar ve amirlerine itaatle üst basamaklara gelir fakat bir insanın bir alt kademede iyi iş çıkarmış olması yöneticilik pozisyonunda iyi iş yapacağının bir göstergesi olamaz. Girişimcinin amiri tüketicidir ve tüketici istekleri her an değişir ve dallanır. Bu dallanma en nihayetinde yenilik gerektirir ancak hem bürokrat hem de bürokrasi kurumu bu yeniliği tesis edebilecek kabiliyetlerden mahrumdur. Yenilikler mevcut düzenin değişmesi ya da yıkılması anlamına gelir ancak bürokrasi mevzuatlar üzerine kurulur, ayrıca bilinmezlik birçok yeni mesuliyet alanı oluşturur ki bu bilinmezliğin riskini alabilecek çok az insan vardır.</p><p>Anlaşılacağı üzere bir bürokrat içinde bulunduğu sistemin yapısı gereği yeniliklerden uzak duracak, olabildiğince garanti yolu tercih edecektir. Çünkü onun amacı hizmeti halka ulaştırmakken, bir girişimcinin amacı diğer rakiplerinden daha iyi bir hizmet sağlamaktır. Elbette kamu teşebbüsleri de yenilikleri takip edecektir ancak yenilik esas manasında patentleri kopya etmek değil onları direkt ortaya koymaktır. Bürokrasi mefhumu içinde ise direkt bir yenilik olmayacağı açıktır çünkü bürokratlar güçlerini durgunluktan alırlar, yeniliklerle değişen güç elbette bürokrasinin sert hiyerarşik yapısına tamamen terstir. Bürokrasi işleri olurunda tutmanın en mükemmel yoludur.</p><p>2. Kâr ile ölçülemeyecek olan işler</p><p>Bir bürokrata bunu düşünemediği için kızmamak gerekir çünkü sistemden o mesul tutulamaz. Bürokrasi sistemi genel manada kâr mefhumu ile hareket etmez. Onu bürokrasi yapan şey yaratmış olduğu katma değerin kâr ile ölçülemeyecek olmasıdır. Bir polis amirine bir fabrikayı koruması emredildiğinde yapacağı iş güvenliği sağlama almaktır. Amir kaç polis korursa en verimli şekilde bu işin altından kalkacağını ya da bu işin ona doğuracağı ekstra maliyeti düşünmez, o emri yerine getirir ve olabildiğince çok polisle fabrikayı emniyete alır. Burada bu polis amirinin yaptığı işi kar ile ölçemeyiz, genel manada bürokrasinin temel taşı budur. Vergi Dairesi’nin, Su ve Kanalizasyon İdaresi’nin yaptıkları işler kâr ile ölçülmez, hükümet kâr gayesi ile işletilen bir yapı değildir. Devlet işlerinin görülmesinde kâr veyahut zarar mefhumları rol oynamaz bu hizmetler de para olarak hesaplanamaz. Çünkü bu hizmetlerin bedeli halk tarafından bazı fedakârlıklarla ödenmiştir. Bu hizmetlerden bazıları, bizlere para, zaman ya da rahatlık sağlar ancak Polis teşkilatının sağladığı asayiş ya da yargının sağladığı adalet kâr ile ölçülemez.</p><p>Bürokrasi yaptığın işlerinin birer hizmet olmasıyla serbest piyasa ekonomisi içinde verimsizliğe mahkûmdur çünkü onun genel amacı hizmettir. Hizmet bir yol değil amacın kendisidir. Bir girişimci bir hizmeti nasıl en optimal şekilde sağlayacağını, ilerde bu hizmeti nasıl sağlaması gerektiğini düşünmelidir ancak bir bürokrat elindeki imkanlarla bir hizmeti nasıl sağlayacağını hesaplar ve ondan istenen de budur. Bürokrasi sağlamakla mükellef olduğu hizmeti genelde çok verimsiz bir şekilde yapar ama bu kötü bürokratların yarattığı geçici bir durum değildir zira o özü bakımından verimsizliğe mahkûmdur.</p><p>3. Verim ölçütü</p><p>Bürokratik hizmetler çoğu zaman en verimsiz yoldan halledilirler. Burada dikkate almamız gereken şey Friedman matrisidir. Genel manada bürokrasi bir başkasının parasını (vergi) bir başkası için (vatandaş) harcar. Bu harcamada bürokratın çok az kişisel çıkarı vardır bu yüzden detaylı bir analizden uzaktır. Böyle bir durumda israfın ve verimsizliğin hüküm süreceği aşikârdır. Bunu engellemek için iyi bir kamu ihale sistemine, şeffaf bir sisteme, hesap verebilir bürokrat ve siyasetçilere ihtiyaç vardır ancak her devlet bu saydığım özelliklere sahip değildir. Ayrıca hükümetler ve politikalar sürekli değişir, böyle bir ortamda verimli ve sürekli üretimden söz edilemez. Bir üretim tesisinin akıbeti her seçimde belirsizliğe düşer çünkü iktisadi (iktisadi olmasa bile bürokratik olarak farklı olması kaçınılmazdır) görüşler ayrıdır. Bu kadar kısa sürede tüm yönünü, istihdamını ya da amacını değiştirebilecek bir üretim şekli zannediyorum ki uzun vadede verimsiz bir üretimden başka hiçbir şey doğurmayacaktır. Kamulaştırma isteğine sahip siyasetçilerimizden aşina olduğumuz bir söylem tipi vardır. Bu söylem genel olarak “x kamu teşebbüsü satıldığından beri y kadar değerlendi. Eğer satmasaydık bu para kamunun parası olurdu.’’ Bu söylem en başından beri kamu teşebbüsünün verimsiz üretimini kanıtlamıyor mu?</p><p>Genel anlamda bu üç ana nedenden dolayı bürokratik işletmeler serbest piyasa ekonomisinde başarısız olurlar. Peki, başarısızlıklarının bedelini kim öder? Ya da başarılı olduklarında bu başarı kimin işine yarar?</p><p><strong>Piyasanın doğası ve bürokrasi kurumu</strong></p><p>Bir özel işletme piyasaya girmek için kamu malını kullanmaz onlar kendi parasıyla bir hizmet sunmak zorundadır. Battığında kendi parasını batırmış olacak ve piyasadan silinecektir, kazandıklarındaysa yine kendi parasını kazanmış olacaktır. Ancak kamu işletmelerinde bu durum hiç de böyle değildir: Onlar kamunun parasıyla üretim yaparlar, zarar ettiklerinde kamunun parası harcanmış olur ve devlet kendi kasasından( ki bu para yine halkın vergilerinden oluşur) o kamu işletmesini sübvanse eder. Yani halk hem işe girişte hem de işin sonunda parasının harcanmasına şahit olmuş, bu verimsiz üretim için ekstra vergi yükü altına girmiştir. Peki, kamu işletmesi kar ederse ne olur? Kar bedeli halka geri ödenmeyeceğine göre bu para devlet kasasında kalır. Yani halk kendi parasından üretir, kendi parasıyla tüketir; batarsa kendi parasıyla istemese dahi üretilir, batmazsa bunun olumlu sonuçlarından çok az yararlanır. Zannediyorum bu zamana kadar halka hiçbir kamu teşebbüsünün kârı geri ödenmemiştir.</p><p>Üretici içinse bu durum tamamıyla eziyettir. O üretip kendisine rakip olması için rakibine para ödemek zorundadır, Rakibi ondan daha ucuza üretebilir (kamu teşebbüsleri genelde “halka daha ucuz hizmet sunma” gibi bir amaçla yola çıkar )çünkü arkasındaki yatırım çok daha büyüktür ve amacı kar edip para kazanmak değil hizmet sunmaktır. Yanlışlar sonucu batarsa, başka üreticiler bu verimsiz bürokratik üretimi devam ettirsin diye onu beslemeye devam etmek zorundadır. Zarar etse dahi batmayan bir işletme rekabeti öldürecektir. Tüm zorluklara ve krizlere kamu parasıyla bağışıklık kazanmış bir işletme serbest piyasa ekonomisini değil bu ekonomi içerisindeki bir aristokrasiyi temsil edebilir.</p><p>Serbest piyasa ekonomisinde üreticiler tüketicilere bir hizmet sunar, bundan gönüllü bir şekilde yararlanmak isteyen tüketiciler de bu hizmetin ücretini öderlerse yararlanabilirler ancak kamu iktisadi teşebbüslerinde durum tam da böyle değildir. Kamu teşebbüslerinde yük tüketicilerde değil halkın tamamındadır. TRT dizilerini izlemeyen bir vatandaş da izleyen vatandaş kadar o kuruma para aktarır ancak hizmet almadan bedel ödemeye zorunlu tutulmak zannediyorum ki kamu teşebbüslerinin ahlaki olarak da sakıncalı olduğunu bizlere gösteren önemli bir noktadır.</p><p><strong>Kamu teşebbüslerinin politik gücü</strong></p><p>Kamu teşebbüsleri güçlerini hükümetten, yatırımlarını da vergi gelirlerinden alır. Bu kurumlar demokrasilerde uzun ve kısa vadede büyük problemler doğurmaya çok müsait durumlar ortaya çıkarırlar.</p><p>Kamu teşebbüsleri sadece işçi çalıştırmaz aynı zamanda çalıştırdıkları o teşebbüsün demokratik patronlarıdır da. Bir vatandaş demokrasilerde vergi ödediği devletten, seçtiği siyasetçiden ve atanan bürokrattan hesap sorma hakkına sahip olmalıdır ancak kamu teşebbüslerinde durum böyle olmaktan çok uzaktır. Bir bireyin siyasi özgürlüğü öncelikle ekonomik özgürlükten başlar, karnını doyurmak için kendi emeği ya da yatırımından başka bir şeye muhtaç olan biri politik olarak özgür olamaz. Kamu teşebbüsleri bu durumu yaratır çünkü patron ve siyaset birbirine karışmıştır. İşçi var olan mevcut durumu devam ettirmek adına var olan siyasi iktidarı destekleyecektir çünkü yeni gelecek yönetim işine son verebilir. Ayrıca hükümetin işveren olduğu durumda bir işçinin hükümeti rahatça eleştirebileceği ya da ondan hesap sorabileceğini düşünmek büyük bir yanılgı olacaktır. Bu durum işçilerin nazarında mevcut siyasi iktidarı korumak için büyük bir motivasyon sağlayacaktır. Bir seçmen kitlesinin hükümet parasıyla geçindiği bir memleket demokrasiden ödün veriyor demektir. Bu durum statükonun tiranlığını perçinleştirir.</p><p>İnsanların ekonomik özgürlüklerini hür teşebbüslerden aldığı serbest piyasa ekonomisinde ise özgürlüğün temeli hükümete dayanmadığı için siyasal değişime çok daha açık bir toplum yapısı görmemiz daha olasıdır. İktidar oy kaygısıyla kamunun sırtına kambur gibi olacak işletmeler açabilir. Bu durum işsizliği azaltsa da uzun vadede refah getirmeyeceği aşikârdır. Devletin hiç yoktan zenginlik yaratması gibi bir durum söz konusu değildir. Onun gücü sadece aldığını dağıtmaktan gelir, böyle bir durumda sürekli zarar eden hükümet zararını kapatmak adına kimin parasına göz dikecektir? Böyle bir ülkede yüksek vergi yükleri, verimsiz üretim, değersiz para birimi ve en nihayetinde bir memur devleti görmemiz kaçınılmazdır. Halk yaşamak için devlete bağımlı olmuştur ve devlet bu bağımlılığın yarattığı muazzam güçten sonuna kadar faydalanacaktır.</p><p>Yapılan en büyük hatalardan bir tanesi kamunun herkesin ortak malı olduğu düşünmektir ancak devlet kurumu kendi çıkarları olan halktan çok ayrı bir kurumdur. Onun kendi istekleri ve kendi çıkarları vardır (Thomas Sowell, 2018) ve herkes gibi o da gücünün sınırlarını sürekli genişletme eğilimdedir. Devletin totaliterleşmesini engellemenin tek yolu halkın ona aşılamaz sınırlar çekmesidir. Unutulmamalıdır ki devlet haklarımızı korur ya da gasp eder ancak haklarımızı verebilme kabiliyetine sahip değildir. Haklar insanlar tarafından alınmak zorundadır. Üretim alanına giren bir devlet vatandaşına hem rakip hem de patron olacaktır. Devlet gibi (neredeyse) sınırsız güce sahip bir kurumla rekabet etmenin imkânsızlığı zannediyorum ki okuyucunun da zihninde canlanacaktır.</p><p><strong>Son sözler</strong></p><p>Sonuç olarak kamu teşebbüsleri üretim açısından yenilikten yoksun ve verimsizdir. Bu durum onların bürokratik özlerinden kaynaklanır ve rekabetçi bir pazarda neden uzun vadede yok edici tesirleri olduğunu gösterir. Asla batmazlar ve hizmetlerinden yararlanmasak bile onlara ücret öderiz. Ayrıca politik birer güç odağıdırlar. Vatandaşların ekonomik ve demokratik hürriyetlerini belirli bir oranda tahakküm altına alırlar ve dinledikleri tüketici (kamu teşebbüsleri için bu vatandaşın kendisi de olabilir) değil amirlerin ya da hükümetin (ki bu her zaman hizmet olmak zorunda değildir. Bazen politik ihtiraslar da bu işin içine girebilir) emirleridir. Ben bunları yazarken PTT’nin 2019 yılında bir milyar iki yüz milyon zarar ettiği haberi haber sayfalarında kendilerine yer bulmaya başladı. Sadece bu haber bile zannediyorum bu yazdıklarımın tamamından daha büyük bir tesir gücüne sahiptir.</p><p>Hükümet elbette zorunlu olduğu bazı konularda hizmet sağlayacaktır, (burada bir vatandaş neyin zorunlu neyin zorunlu olmadığını iyi muhakeme etmelidir. Ancak bana kalırsa devlet rekabetçi serbest piyasanın koşullarını belirlemek ki bunu yaparken en az müdahalede bulunmak, iç ve dış savunmayı yapmak ve en nihayetinde yargı ve yasama erklerine sahip olmak zorundadır.) ancak daha verimli, daha özgürlükçü ve daha az despotik olan serbest piyasanın neden tercih edilmesi gerektiğini zannediyorum ki gösterebildim.</p><p>Bu yazı Mises’in Bürokrasi kitabının en daraltılmış bir özeti mahiyetinde. Diliyorum ki onun kadar açıklayıcı olabilmişimdir ancak yine de eminim ki benim yazım kitabın yerini tutmayacaktır. Ancak ortaya koyduğum bazı noktalarıyla zannediyorum ki kamu teşebbüslerinin problemlerini ve uzun vadede kaçınılmaz başarısızlıklarını ortaya koyabildim.</p><blockquote>Kağan Mete Uzun, İzmir Ekonomi Üniversitesi Tıp Fakültesi Öğrencisi</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=54b40fc0972d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/devlet%C3%A7i-ekonomi-ve-b%C3%BCrokrasi-%C3%BCzerine-bir-i%CC%87nceleme-54b40fc0972d">Devletçi Ekonomi ve Bürokrasi Üzerine Bir İnceleme</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Brexit’i Kazanan Adam]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/brexiti-kazanan-adam-6e1b98bb4de5?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e1b98bb4de5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[türkçe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boris-johnson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dominic-cummings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Dec 2020 16:47:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-17T17:36:05.354Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bCBPFsoHmLqO40j2.jpg" /><figcaption>Boris Johnson’ın başdanışmanı Dominic Cummings başbakanlık konutundan ayrılırken [Görsel: Henry Nicholls/Reuters]</figcaption></figure><p>2015 yılında Birleşik Krallık’ın AB’den ayrılması için referandum kararı alındığında tüm anketler AB’de kalmayı savunanların bu referandumu kazanacağını işaret ediyordu. Brexit kampanyasını yürütmesi için işbaşı yapan ve daha sonra Başbakan Boris Johnson’un kişisel danışmanlığı görevini üstlenen Dominic Cummings’in 2017 yılında bir davranış bilimi konferansında verdiği “Why Leave Won the Referendum?” başlıklı konuşması, Brexit yanlılarının bu referandumu nasıl kazandığının imkansıza yakın öyküsü ve tüm dünyadaki halkla ilişkiler çalışmaları için bir mihenk taşı. Sizler için çevirdik.</p><p>2015 yazı… İşsizdim ama mutlu bir şekilde evimin bahçesinde biramı yudumluyordum. Ta ki iki gün önce gerçekleşen genel seçimle ilgili telefonlar almaya başlayana dek. David Cameron beklenmedik şekilde kazanmıştı ve birkaç ünlü milletvekili, kampanya sorumlusu ve muhafazakar milyoner beni aramaya başladı. David Cameron’un seçim vaadi olan AB’den ayrılma (Brexit) referandumu gerçekleşecekti ama kimse bu referandum için hazırlık yapmamıştı. Ortada bir kampanya yoktu ve bu insanlar beni arayıp sıfırdan bir kampanya başlatmamı teklif ediyorlardı.</p><p>Doğrusunu söylemek gerekirse, bu iş için çok da istekli değildim. Tam 15 yıl önce aynı pozisyonda, Britanya’nın AB’ye girmesini önlemek için bir kampanyanın başındaydım. Milletvekilleri ve milyonerlerle çalışmak zorunda kalmıştım ve hiç kolay bir iş değildi! Ama bilirsiniz: Böyle bir fırsat insanın eline hayatta birkaç kez ancak gelir. Britanya’daki sistem genel olarak düzgün işlemiyordu ve belki de bu sistemi kökünden değiştirecek işler başarabilirdim. İşi kabul ettim.</p><p>İşi kabul ettiğimde ortada ne bir organizasyon, ne belirli bir bütçe ne de insan gücü vardı. Yalnızca AB’den nefret eden, ama ilginç şekilde birbirinden de nefret eden bir siyasetçi grubuyla seçim çalışması yürütmem bekleniyordu. Ve elbette elimizdeki bir organizasyona en yakın şey olan UKIP’i kullanmalıydım: Genel Başkan Nigel Farage halkın küçük bir kısmında çok popülerken çoğunluk tarafından sevilmiyordu.</p><p>Kampanyaya başladım: Bisikletimle Londra’da dolaşıp uzun zamandır tanıdığım yetenekli dostlarımın kapısını çaldım. İstediğim şey büyük bir risk alıp işlerini bırakmaları ve benim yürüttüğüm seçim çalışmalarına katılmalarıydı. Neredeyse 8 ay boyunca kampanyam bundan ibaretti! Rakibimiz Başbakan David Cameron ise Downing Street’te oturuyor, elindeki büyük avantajların tadını çıkarıyordu. Whitehall arkasındaydı, medya gücü arkasındaydı, Muhafazakar Parti’nin tüm bütçesi ve insan gücü arkasındaydı. Anlayabileceğiniz üzere, başbakana karşı bir seçim çalışması yürüterek epey zor bir iş üstlendim.</p><p>Bisikletimle dolaşırken yaptığım bir başka kampanya çalışması vardı. Konuştuğum dostlarımla ve hayatımda tanıdığım tüm insanlarla Brexit konusunu tartışıyordum, böylece aklımda bu seçimin o anki gidişatıyla ilgili bir fikir netleşti. 15 yıl önce yürüttüğüm AB karşıtı kampanyadan bu yana ülkede çok da şeyin değişmediğini fark ettim: İnsanlar AB ile ilgili 15 yıl önce ne biliyorsa bugün de onu biliyordu. Ama 3 çok önemli faktör değişmişti.</p><p>Birincisi elbette, artık elimizde mülteci sorunu vardı. Mülteci sorunu Britanya çapında çok geniş sıkıntılara yol açtı. İnsanlar televizyonlarında mültecilerin zorlu yolculuklarını, denizlerde boğulup ölmelerini izlerken bir yandan da işlerini mültecilerin çaldığı ve ülkenin yapısını bozdukları algısına kapılmıştı: Halkın çoğu bu durumdan Avrupa Birliğini sorumlu tutuyordu, çünkü Avrupa Birliği bu durumla mücadele etmekte başarısız olmuştu.</p><p>İkinci önemli olay 2008 yılındaki büyük finansal kriz olarak gözüme çarptı. İnsanlar bu krizde çok büyük yara almıştı ve Whitehall’a, hükümete, başbakana, bankalara ve özellikle AB’ye büyük bir güvensizlik duymaya başladı.</p><p>Üçüncüsü ise Euro. 15 yıl önce Euro para birimi kullanıma girdiğinde ona karşı olan benim gibi insanların argümanları yalnızca teorikti. Tony Blair ve ekibi Euro’nun işe yarayacağını iddia ettiğinde onların argümanı da teorikti. Ama aradan 15 yıl geçti, ve bu 15 yılda insanlar ardı ardına gelen olaylar sonucunda Euro’nun zararlı bir konsept olduğunu pratikte görmeye başladı. Hepimiz televizyonlardan Yunanistan’ın başına gelenleri izledik: Koca ülke bir para biriminin ve AB’nin başarısızlığı yüzünden iflas bayrağını çekmişti.</p><p>Bu üç önemli olayın etkileri, tüm siyasetçilerin konuşmalarından ve tüm seçim kampanyalarından daha büyük oldu. Bütün bakanları, bütün propaganda makinelerini ve parlamentodaki tartışmaları yan yana koysanız yine de halkın gözünde canlı canlı izlediği bu üç olay kadar etki yaratamazsınız. Bu üç olay halkın önemli bir kısmının bizim safımıza geçmesine sebep olmuştu bile, ancak yeterli değildi. 2015 yazında AB’de kalmak isteyenler hala çoğunluktaydı ve bizim açımızdan korkutucu bir tablo vardı: Dünyadaki tüm referandumlara baktığınızda göreceksiniz ki statükonun devam etmesini savunan görüşler, değişim isteyen görüşleri her zaman yenmiş. Genel olarak dünyadaki diğer referandumlarda zaman geçip kampanyalar devam ettikçe statükoyu savunanlar daha da güçlenirken değişim isteyenler güç kaybediyor. Bu elbette bizim için kötü bir sinyaldi. Ama Britanya’daki tabloya baktığımızda şunu da görebiliyorduk: Halkın yaklaşık üçte biri AB’den nefret edip çıkmak istiyordu ve sonuçları umursamıyordu, yani bizim görüşümüzde oy verecekti. Diğer üçte biri AB’yi savunuyordu, AB’yi istediğini söylüyor ve o yönde oy vereceği açıktı. Ama asıl önemli olan üçte birlik kısım vardı ki bunlar AB’den nefret ediyor ama AB’den çıkmak için oy vermek istemiyordu, çünkü bu durumun yaratacağı belirsizlik ve kaostan korkuyordu. İşte bizim kampanya boyunca odaklanmamız ve kazanmamız gereken kısım bu sonuncu kısımdı.</p><p>Böylece kullanmamız gereken sloganlar üzerinde çalışmaya başladık. Halka vermek ve coşku yaratmak istediğimiz üç önemli mesaj vardı. Birincisi, “Kontrolü Geri Kazanmak” (Take Back Control) oldu. Buradaki “geri kazanmak” kelimelerine dikkat çekmek istiyorum, çünkü fark edeceksiniz ki bu kelimeleri kullandığımızda “kontrolü kaybettiğimiz” argümanını da tetikliyorduk. Bizden bir şeyler çalınmıştı ve onları geri kazanmamız gerekiyordu. Özellikle AB’ye ve AB’nin bizden çaldığı yetkilere yönelik bir tepki gibi görünse de gizlice tetiklediğimiz başka bir mesaj daha vardı. Sistemin kendisinden de kontrolü geri kazanmalıydık. Evet, David Cameron ve arkasındaki bankalar bizden paramızı çalmış ve bizi krizin ortasına koymuştu. Bu adamlara gününü göstermeliydik. Londra’daki Euro lobicilerinden de kontrolü geri almalıydık. Bu güçlü bir slogandı.</p><p>İkincisi, AB’ye her hafta gönderdiğimiz 350 milyon sterlin ve NHS sloganı oldu. AB’ye resmi faturamızın 350 milyon sterlin olduğunu ve AB’den ayrılırsak bu parayı kendi harcamalarımız için kullanacağımızı söyledik. Bilerek “göndermek” kelimesini kullandık çünkü AB’de kalmak için kampanya yürüten siyasetçileri kızdırıp provoke etmek istedik. Şanslıydık ki yemi yuttular, sadece bu slogana karşı mücadele edip bunun yalan olduğu iddiasını öne sürdüler. Bu da halkın gözünde bunun aslında doğru olduğuna dair izlenimi bıraktı. Hatta o kadar ileri gittiler ki, BBC’yi arayıp bizim bu sloganımız yalan olduğu için haberlerde yayınlanmamasını istediler. Bu önemli bir slogandı çünkü basitti: Tartışmayı kompleks ve kimsenin anlamadığı ekonomik terimlerden uzaklaştırdı. Tüm siyasetçiler Ortak Pazar gibi ekonomiyle ilgili konulardan bahsediyordu ama gelin görün ki hayatımda Ortak Pazar’ın ne olduğunu anlayabilen bir siyasetçi bile görmedim. David Cameron ve AB’de kalmayı savunanlar Ortak Pazar’ın ne olduğunu bile anlamadan bunu halka anlatmaya çalıştılar, halk ne dediklerini anlamıyordu. Bizim önerilerimiz ise basitti. AB’den çıkacak ve farklı ülkelerle serbest ticaret antlaşmaları yapacaktık, böylece ekonomik açıdan bir kaybımız olmayacaktı. Halk bizi anlayabiliyordu, çünkü basit konuşuyorduk.</p><p>Üçüncü sloganımız az önce bahsettiğim üçüncü gruba yönelikti: AB’den çıkmak isteyenler ama alacağımız riskten korkanlar. Bu gruba AB’de kalmanın çok daha riskli olduğu fikrini aşılamalıydık, bunun için Türkiye’yi kullandık. AB’de kalırsak gelecek mültecilerden ve Türkiye’ye vize serbestisi verilmesinin risklerinden bahsettik. Risk ve güvenlik konseptleri psikolojik açıdan büyük destek toplamamızı sağladı.</p><p>Bu üç sloganın tamamına baktığınızda görebilirsiniz ki, bu sloganları solcu veya sağcı olarak tanımlamak imkansız. Westminster’daki politikacılara baktığınızda gördüğünüz şey tamamının halkı merkezdekiler ve aşırı sol veya sağcılar olarak düşündüğüdür. Bu düşünce empirik açıdan yanlış. Biz halka baktığımızda merkezde olarak düşünülen herkesin ya daha solcu ya da daha sağcı olduğunu görebildik: Herkes daha radikaldi! Biz halkın bölündüğünü fark ettik ve bu sağ-sol kavgalarından kaçınmak istedik. Sağ politikalar solcuları, sol politikalar ise sağcıları korkutacaktı. Sağ veya sol olarak tanımlanamayacak, sadece halkın iyiliğini istiyor gibi görünen sloganlar ürettik ve bunun için her partiden tanınmış yüzleri topladık.</p><p>Ama mesajımızı halka iletmek neredeyse imkansızdı. David Cameron başbakandı, BBC ve diğer medya kanalları elbette onun seçim programını takip ediyordu. Medya arada bir bize döndüğünde de argümanlarımızla değil elimizdeki isimlerle ilgilenmek istiyordu, ve o noktada elimizde bizi destekleyen hiç önemli figür yoktu. Herkes çoktan bizim kaybedeceğimizi düşünmeye başlamıştı bile ve bu yüzden ihtiyacımız olan önemli figürler de bizimle çalışmak istemiyordu. Bir yumurta-tavuk probleminin içindeydik, yeni bir şeyler yapmamız gerekiyordu.</p><p>Risk aldım: Fizikçilerden bir ekip kurdum. Bu fizik ekibi seçim kampanyalarının en temel ilkelerini gözden geçirmeye başladı. Bugüne kadar seçime katılım ve ikna yollarıyla ilgili yapılmış çalışmaları ve arkalarındaki matematiği incelediler. Bu matematiği kullanarak hem saha çalışmalarında kaynağın nereye ayrılması gerektiğinin, hem de dijital çalışmaların nasıl bilimsel bir şekilde yapılabileceğinin modellerini kurdular. Sonuçta internet siteleri, mailler, sosyal medya, anketler ve saha çalışmaları gibi çeşitli kaynaklardan sürekli bir veri akışı fizik ve veri ekibimize geliyor, bu ekip operasyonun merkezinde bulunup gelen verileri inceleyerek vermek istediğimiz mesajları bu verilere göre yönlendiriyor, her mesaj ve kampanya çalışması için aldığımız geri dönüşlerle daha çok veriye sahip oluyorduk.</p><p>Bugün dünyanın çoğu yerinde kullanılan anket sistemi 1930&#39;lu yıllarda geliştirildiği haliyle duruyor. Ortalama 1000 kişilik bir grubu alırsınız ve bu grup yeterince rastgele seçildiyse tüm halkın ne düşündüğüyle ilgili size ortalama bir fikir verir. Fizik ekibimiz bu geleneksel anket yöntemine karşı çıktı: Bugün anketçiliği icat edecek olsanız bu şekilde icat etmezdiniz, dediler. Küçük bir grup yerine devasa boyutlarda gruplarla, belki milyonlarca insanla çalışmak bugün teknoloji sayesinde mümkün. Milyonlarca insan içeren bu grup üzerinde yapay zeka ve makine öğrenimini kullanarak daha ucuz, daha hızlı ve daha kesin sonuçlar elde edebilirsiniz ve elinizde devasa boyutta bir grup varsa bunu demografik alt gruplara ayırabilirsiniz. Diyelim ki bir reklam için hedef kitleniz 35–45 yaş arası belli bir şehirde yaşayan, üniversite diploması olmayan kadınlar; milyonlarca insanı içeren veri grupları elinizde olduğu sürece bu hedef kitleye yönelik reklamları vermekle kalmayıp bu reklamlara geri dönüşleri de tam olarak tespit edebilirsiniz. Tam olarak bunu yaptık, hatta kullandığımız demografik alt gruplar Facebook’un dijital reklamlarda kullandığının aynısıydı. Bize ulaşan verilere göre vermek istediğimiz mesajları çeşitlendirip, kurduğumuz alt gruplara göre bu mesajları dolaşıma soktuk. Bu deneyimiz için başlangıçta çok para harcamamışken, seçime günler kala deneyin dozunu arttırdık. Son üç günde yaklaşık 7 milyon insana bu şekilde çeşitlendirilmiş ve özel olarak hedeflenmiş reklamlarla ulaştık.</p><p>Bu dijital çalışmayla aynı anda devasa saha çalışmamız da yürürlükteydi. Saha çalışması yapan gönüllü arkadaşlarımız çoğu zaman benim gibi insanları, yani projeyi yönetenleri kaale almakta zorluk yaşarlar. “Bilmem nereden mezun olmuş, kuantum mekaniğinden bahseden bu herif yerel siyaseti nasıl anlayabilir?” Sosyal medyada kullandığımız verileri saha çalışmasına da yansıtmamızla kendi gönüllülerimizden aldığımız geri dönüşler muazzamdı. “Bu adamlar bizi tam olarak doğru yere göndermiş, inanılmaz!”</p><p>Tam bu anda seçime yalnızca birkaç hafta kala Johnson ve Gove işe dahil olup hükümete karşı sert çıkışlar yapmaya başladı. İşte medya gücünü kullanmamız için gereken fırsat önümüze çıkmıştı: İktidar partisindeki çatlak sesler medyanın dikkatini çekiyordu. Bu çatlak sesleri aldık ve Brexit’le ilgili tartışmayı hükümetin değişebileceğiyle ilgili tartışmaya karıştırdık. Yeni hükümet ve yeni başbakan olasılığı üzerine tartışma yarattıkça insanların bir şeylerin değişeceğine olan inancı da artmıştı. Kampanya mesajlarımızı artık yalnızca Brexit’i gerçekleştirmek üzerine değil, yeni bir hükümetin nasıl çalışacağı üzerine vaatlerle veriyorduk. Referanduma neredeyse 10 gün kala bu sayede medyada liderliği ele aldık. Bizden bağımsız TV haberleri tam olarak dijital reklamlarımız ve saha çalışmalarımızın amaçladığı hedeflere göre konuşmaya başlamıştı, onlarca uykusuz gecenin ardından ilk kez her alanda işleyen bir makine elde etmiştik. Bu yaklaşık 10 günlük sürecin sonunda, az önce bahsettiğim üç grubun durumu değişmeye başlamıştı. Üçüncü grup, yani AB’den ayrılmak isteyen fakat ayrılığı tehlikeli gören grup birkaç puan geri çekildi. AB’yi daha tehlikeli gören grup ise %44&#39;lere kadar yükseldi. İnsanları AB’de kalmanın AB’den çıkmaktan daha riskli olduğuna inandırmıştık.</p><p>Bu sadece mülteciler sayesinde mi oldu? Elbette hayır. İşin sonunda insanlar yalnızca AB’den çıkmak için değil, ayrıca NHS’e yatırım yapmak için, ekonomiyi düzeltmek için ve ekonomiyi batıran hükümeti göndermek için oy veriyordu. David Cameron ve ekibinin ekonomiyle ilgili dertleri görmezden gelmesi ise onlar adına bir felaketti. Fildişi kulelerinde yaşıyorlardı ve söyledikleri şey bir noktada “Biz iyi insanlarız, onlar kötü insanlar”dan öteye gidemedi. AB’den çıkmak isteyenlerle ilgili belki kendi eşim, arkadaşlarımın %80&#39;i ve bu odadaki herkes bu şekilde düşünüyordu. Cameron ve ekibi Londra’daki bu havadan etkilendi ve ülkenin geri kalanının Londra’dan farksız olduğu sanrısına düştü. Halbuki M25 otoyolunun dışına çıkar çıkmaz göreceğiniz tepkiler Londra’daki iyi eğitimli, daha zengin insanların tepkilerinden çok farklıydı. Kampanyamız elbette bunu kullandı, yalnızca halka yönelik kampanyada değil kendi içinde de. Kampanyanın yönetim ekibinde en yaşlı bendim (49) ve en gencimiz 21 yaşındaydı. Johnson ve Gove da dahil olmak üzere Londra’da yaşayan hiçbir milletvekili kampanyanın idaresinde söz sahibi yapılmadı. Olabildiğince küçük bir ekiple çok çalıştık, çok fedakarlık yaptık. Medyada çıkanlara veya Londra’daki koridorlarda konuşulanlara değil, halka odaklanmak amacıyla yola çıktık. İş istemiyorduk, milletvekili olmak istemiyorduk, kaybedecek bir şeyimiz yoktu. Sadece bu sayede risk almaktan korkmadık.</p><p>Geleceğin önceki konuşmada anlatılan deneysel psikolojinin ve bizim başardığımız veri çalışmalarının bir ürünü olacağını düşünüyorum. Şu bir gerçek ki, bugün çoğu halkla ilişkiler şirketi kıçından laf uyduran şarlatanlarla dolu. Bana kalırsa hepsi kovulmalı ve açıkçası önümüzdeki 10 yılda çoğunun kovulacağını tahmin ediyorum. Silikon Vadisi’nden çıkacak teknolojiden anlayan insanlar diğer çoğu endüstriyi ele geçirdiği gibi bu endüstriyi de ele geçirmeye başlayacaktır. 10 yıl içinde dil, cinsiyet araştırmaları, toplumsal araştırmalar gibi alanlarda yeterli tecrübeniz yoksa büyük ihtimalle işinizden kovulacaksınız ve iletişim endüstrisi ciddi bir değişimin içine girecek.</p><p>Yaptığımız şey bir inovasyondu ve bugün neredeyse herkes bizim yaptıklarımızı öğrenmeye çalışıyor.</p><blockquote><strong>Dominic Cummings</strong>, “Why Leave Won the Referendum?”, Nudgestock 2017</blockquote><blockquote>Çeviri: <strong>Onurcan Mısır</strong>, Bilkent Üniversitesi Uluslararası İlişkiler Öğrencisi</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e1b98bb4de5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/brexiti-kazanan-adam-6e1b98bb4de5">Brexit’i Kazanan Adam</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Success” of Far Right: Germany]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/success-of-far-right-germany-5ae542ab0d27?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ae542ab0d27</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[english]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[far-right]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[germany]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Dec 2020 16:12:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-16T17:07:18.437Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*PEyIskhLrGj-9pa5UJZ15g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Alexander Gauland delivers a speech during the anti-immigration party Alternative for Germany (AfD) congress in Hanover, Germany, December 2, 2017. (Reuters)</figcaption></figure><p>“If we were to take 200 million African migrants, with all respect would Europe still be Europe?”</p><p>-Alexander Gauland, currently the Leader of Alternative für Deutschland in Bundestag</p><p>(BBC News, 2019)</p><p>Most often the far right of the political spectrum has been associated with certain countries, because of their history with it. The first one on the list is Germany where, to this day, government has to implement certain laws to prevent the ramifications of Hitler and his Nazi Party: Distributing or displaying symbols of the Nazi era, including but not limited to, swastikas and the Hitler salute; Holocaust denial, besmirching an individual or a group based on their ethnicity or religion, or promoting violence against them is illegal in the country (Sauerbrey, 2020). So, how does Alternative für Deutschland (AfD), a party that is strictly anti- immigrant, anti-EU and suggests that Germany is colonized by Islam, can become the largest opposition in Bundestag, German parliament, as a result of the 2017 elections (BBC News, 2019)?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*WeMYwf3f2rIO85VcPRz09Q.png" /><figcaption>The distribution of seats in the 19th German Bundestag based on the official results (CDU and CSU are sister parties and forming the coalition government with SPD)</figcaption></figure><p>What their success means for Germany and European Union, will it last and will the party and its supporters become more extreme as time progresses, remain as a mystery and topics of debate for now. What is certain is, the media attention they gained will have a negative impact on immigrants and refugees currently residing in Germany. In this essay, I will talk about what is the secret of AfD’s success, how this success may be fragile and how the party’s presence in the country has already fueled more racism and violence against minorities.</p><p>As you know, just like any other political party, AfD followed a certain campaigning style before the election of 2017. However, it cannot be denied that the history of Eastern Germany and Angela Merkel’s policies did not serve as a boost for the party. After the unification of the country the transition from centrally planned economy to a free market in the East meant mass unemployment, migration to the West, Eastern companies going bankrupt and Western companies taking over those businesses that survived the unification (Göldner, 2020). Following the unification West has developed more than the East and it happened faster. As a result, these citizens see themselves as the victim of neglect from their government for over thirty years while it should be noted that this gap can be explained with other factors in play (Göldner, 2020). AfD has managed to exploit this mindset by proposing themselves as the party of East German interests and as an alternative to the mainstream parties, the citizens of East feel abandoned by (Göldner, 2020). This also gives the party the advantage of being able to carry out its anti-immigration and anti-EU agenda, using the protection of East German interests and traditions as a cover. Another reason why AfD is clearly strong in the East is that while some voters do believe in their xenophobic and extremist views, many others choose to ignore these and cast their votes for AfD as way of protest against the current government, resulting from the years of frustration (Göldner, 2020).</p><p>What adds onto these historical factors is Angela Merkel’s “Willkommenpolitik”, which translates to welcoming policy, regarding the refugee crisis in 2015. This policy gave the grounds for AfD to showcase their conservative views and the idea that “Germany belongs to Germans”. This policy and AfD’s way of marketing it, pushed some non-voters to the ballot and some mainstream party voters to switch their vote (Mudde, 2017). This might have also created the thought in the Eastern part of the country that these refugees would get the attention they did not get from the government, which resulted in AfD having a stronger ground in the East.</p><p>In addition to these factors; the party’s internet presence, their ability to play the victim and to use provocation as a way to get media’s attention, certainly helped on their way to victory in 2017. While an internet presence surely helps to get the word out about their policies and actions, it may also help securing future victories for the party, since Internet and especially social media users are relatively younger and more susceptible to influence. To show how active AfD is, a study by the Oxford University can be referred to; where they found out AfD was by far the most active German political party on Twitter (Peters, 2018). And when it comes to playing the victim and gaining sympathy among the moderates within their party and non-voters, they do not have to try too much:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/1*7tw8zCQz_9sSkAzcRU5FIg.png" /><figcaption>Graffiti on the Headquarters of AfD</figcaption></figure><p>Their headquarters in Schwerin was attacked by protestors in 2018 (Hill, 2018) and Alice Weidel (Leader of AfD) walked out of a televised debate and later declared that the moderator had mistreated her (Peters, 2018). These are two examples of many which can give an insight regarding the kind of reaction they face from the population that does not agree with their stance. Using certain amounts of provocation in certain times and places is another weapon AfD wielded professionally: Party chairwoman Frauke Petry called for the use of firearms against refugees along the border in case of emergency and her deputy Beatrix von Storch wrote that women and children should be allowed to bear arms (Peters, 2018). These remarks by the members of the party, brought them significant media attention which helped them leave an impression in public.</p><p>On the other side of the discourse, people believe that this victory will not sustain itself, so in the long run it is no victory at all. Some experts believe that AfD is not a real people’s party and that it has a quite homogeneous community voting for them; this community being mostly males who are responsive to nationalistic ideas (Güllner, 2019). In addition to the possibility of being unable to gain additional voter support from outside this community, AfD faces a problem regarding the persistence of support: It was found that 60% of voters voted “against all parties” and only 34% voted out of conviction for AfD (Mudde, 2017). In addition to this, it may not be possible to gain support from outside the party because only 12% of all Germans were satisfied with the political work of Alexander Gauland, who was the co-leader of AfD from 2017 to 2019. This clearly means that simply if there is a better option as a political party for the voters, AfD may lose the wind behind them. Especially with the number of non-voters they encouraged to moving, any election’s tide can change.</p><p>In the beginning I mentioned that the media attention AfD is getting will affect refugees and immigrants’ lives. However, this may have become a reality already: The Leipzig authoritarianism study found that 44% of Germans surveyed wanted a ban on Muslim immigration in 2018, compared to 36,5% in 2014 and one-in-two Germans said Muslims make them feel like a stranger in 2018, again compared to 43% in 2014 (Nielsen, 2018). In addition to this, according to a government dataset compiled by Der Spiegel magazine, Germany hosted 289 far-right events in 2017 which is the highest number since 2005 (Nielsen, 2018). If or when these events become violent the moderate voters of AfD may choose a way out, taking AfD’s power with them, but along with these mentioned events AfD’s presence in the media and parliament may encourage those who agree with them but had to hide it away before.</p><p>AfD’s 2017 victory continues to add onto the uncertainty of the times we are living through. Even if we are not residents of Germany, we should be concerned about a country and a world where these kinds of ideas can win elections. Even though it can be predicted that Alternative für Deutschland cannot come to a position of power without softening any present or future radical sides of it and would continue to be only an opposition party; the ideas they fanned the flames of, will haunt Germany and anyone that is a target to their hate. Time will tell the rest of the story.</p><blockquote><strong>Beyzanur Gençer</strong> Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Political Science and Administration</blockquote><blockquote>REFERENCES</blockquote><blockquote>BBC News. (2019, May 7). <em>The Rise of the Right: Populism in Germany- BBC News </em>[Video]. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pP3EcdC1VU.">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pP3EcdC1VU.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Göldner, F. (2020, January 7). <em>GERMANY AND THE AFD 30 YEARS AFTER THE FALL OF THE BERLIN WALL: STILL A DIVIDED COUNTRY?</em> Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://www.eyes-on-europe.eu/germany-still-a-divided-country/">https://www.eyes-on-europe.eu/germany-still-a-divided-country/.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Güllner, M. (2019, November 11). <em>Myths and realities</em>. Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://www.deutschland.de/en/topic/politics/populism-in-germany-analysis-of-the-electoral-successes-of-the-afd.">https://www.deutschland.de/en/topic/politics/populism-in-germany-analysis-of-the-electoral-successes-of-the-afd.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Hill, J. (2017, September 26). <em>German election: Why so many voters in the east chose AfD</em>. Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-41398628.">https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-41398628.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Mudde, C. (2017, September 24). <em>What the stunning success of AfD means for Germany and Europe</em>. Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/sep/24/germany-elections-afd-europe-immigration-merkel-radical-right">https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/sep/24/germany-elections-afd-europe-immigration-merkel-radical-right</a></blockquote><blockquote>Nielsen, N. (2018, November 9). <em>Xenophobia on the rise in Germany, study finds</em>. Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://euobserver.com/migration/143336.">https://euobserver.com/migration/143336.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Peters, B. (2018, May 17). <em>5 Reasons For The Far Right Rising In Germany</em>. Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://projekte.sueddeutsche.de/artikel/politik/afd-5-reasons-for-the-far-right-rising-in-germany-e403522/">https://projekte.sueddeutsche.de/artikel/politik/afd-5-reasons-for-the-far-right-rising-in-germany-e403522/.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Sauerbrey, A. (2017, August 23). <em>How Germany Deals with Neo-nazis. </em>Retrieved June 29, 2020, from <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/23/opinion/germany-neo-nazis-charlottesville.html.">https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/23/opinion/germany-neo-nazis-charlottesville.html.</a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ae542ab0d27" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/success-of-far-right-germany-5ae542ab0d27">“Success” of Far Right: Germany</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kül Rengi Acıdır]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/k%C3%BCl-rengi-ac%C4%B1d%C4%B1r-38b4e659d1e4?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38b4e659d1e4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mülteci]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[siyaset]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[edebiyat]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[türkçe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tarih]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Dec 2020 16:14:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-13T16:14:19.707Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/826/1*MPbG7hZ8ocGHEg6f9caPew.jpeg" /></figure><p>Kül rengi ne acıdır. Yanmış organik hissiyatlardan geriye kalan kimyasal bir acı. Ressam da kül rengine batırır fırçayı, yazar da kül rengi ile boyar kelimelerini. Mutabık kalınan ortak payda ise acının evrensel yasında birleşen hüzünlü bakışlarıdır kömür gözlü çocuğun, yanık ağıtlarıdır köylünün, sert iklimidir savaş mağduru ülkelerin. Ortadoğu’nun gözü dönmüş siyasi aktörleri tarafından iç savaşa mahkûm edilen onlarca şehir, yüzlerce yerleşim yeri sabahları keder güneşi ile doğar geceleri ölüm kokusu ile kül rengine döner. İç savaşlar ülkenin yalnızca politik katmanını değil coğrafya mahkûmlarının içlerinde yaşadığı psikolojik katmanı da bombalar. Nizar Kabbani’nin <em>Kelimelere Benzemeyen Kelimeler </em>isimli şiir kitabında “hayalet kent” olarak tanımladığı Beyrut gibi diğer savaş meydanına dönüşmüş kentler de kimliklerini, bağımsızlıklarını ve iskeletlerini bir bir kaybediyor kaderin kederine düçar oluyorlardı.</p><p>Suriyeli bir babanın günlerdir susuz bebeği için verdiği savaş, <em>Kelimelere Benzemeyen Kelimeler </em>gibi savaşa benzemeyen bir savaş cinsinden. Sebebi ise savaşların uygulanmasa da uluslararası kurallar ile bağlanmış bir yönü mevcutken coğrafyanın esiri olan insanı temsil eden babanın maruz kaldığı insanlık dışı zulüm ve eziyetler hiçbir kural ve kaidenin sınırlandırıp çerçeveleyemeyeceği boyutlardaydı. Tek taraflı yıkım ve yakıma sürgün edilmiş nice anne ve baba figürü çocuklarının sorduğu sayısız sorular altında suskun bir şekilde boyunlarını büküyor ve coğrafyanın kaderini yaşamakla görevlendirildiklerini düşünüp kendilerini bu telkinle bilerek kandırmaya devam ediyorlardı. Kabbani’nin (2018) bir şiirinde kendisinden buğday başağı çizmesini isteyen çocuğunun talebine cevaben buğdaydan bağımsız bir geometrik şekil olan üçgeni çizen babanın çaresizliğini hissediyorum, keder güneşinin kanadığı bu coğrafyayı düşününce. Buğday başağının artık Ortadoğu’yu süslüyor olmamasına isyan etmek, buğdayın kimyasal silahlarla kül rengine dönüştürülüyor olmasına serzenişte bulunmak ve katıksız buğdayın silahlı adamlar tarafından silahlı başaklara çevriliyor oluşuna başkaldırmak istiyorum. Üçgen gibi köşeli, sınırlı ve katı bir geometrik şeklin çağrıştırdığı kara sınırlarının da üç bir yandan terörize edilmiş ve zorla sıkıştırılmış olduğunu gözümde canlandırıyorum. İç açıları toplamı sınırlı bir üçgenin buğday gibi sonsuzluğu, bolluğu, bereketi ve hürriyeti temsil eden ve yaşayan bir canlının yerini alması yaşananların ne denli boğucu ve kasvetli olduğunu bir kez daha gözler önüne seriyor.</p><p>Kederli ve kanlı coğrafya, bütün renkleriyle âdeta sanatkârın elindeki fırçaya hükmederek fırça darbelerini yönlendirip tablonun gidişatını biçimlendiriyordu. Yalnızca insanlar değil doğa da beraberinde yitiriyordu organikliğini. Kabbani’nin (2018) de kaleme aldığı gibi “Kuşlar silahlı, kültür silahlı, din silahlı” (s.19). İnsanlığın yaşama hakkına doğrultulan her silah, kültürel ve dinî değerlerden oluşan hüviyet mefhumunu da acımasızca baltalıyor. Bir türlü sulha kavuşamamış kızıllaşmış topraklar, bitmek bilmeyen bir erozyona kapılmışçasına metastaz yapmış habis bir urun yayılma hızını sollayan zalimlerin etki alanını genişletmeye devam ediyor. Güllerin yetişmesi için kül olmuş bütün değerlerin hercümerç edildiği bu coğrafyada her ne kadar korkulan olmuş insanlar yaşarken insanlık öldürülmüş olsa dahi denizden gelen rahmet esintileri güllerden oluşan gül bahçelerinin müjdesini veren tomurcukların yeşerdiğini haber veriyor. Şairler tüm dünyada olduğu gibi buradan barışın insanlığın evrensel dili olduğunu haykıran şiirlerle buğdayın, gülün, yaprağın, kelebeğin resmini çizecek mutluluğun nefes alırken bile hissedilmesini sağlayacaktır. Hiçbir çocuk koşarken, oynarken attığı kahkahanın kelebek etkisini bilmese bile, bu kahkahalardan kaynaklanarak kendisine yönelen şefkatli bakışlardaki güven ile Ortadoğu’nun kayan topraklarında saklı olan umutların kök salan ulu bir çınarın gölgesinde endişeden uzak huzurlu bir neslin yetişmesini umut ediyorum.</p><blockquote><strong>Mutlu Dilara Aydın</strong>, Bilkent Üniversitesi Siyaset Bilimi ve Kamu Yönetimi Öğrencisi</blockquote><p><strong>Bibliyografya</strong></p><blockquote>Kabbani, N. (2018). <em>Kelimelere Benzeyemeyen Kelimeler. </em>Hece Yayınları. İstanbul</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38b4e659d1e4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/k%C3%BCl-rengi-ac%C4%B1d%C4%B1r-38b4e659d1e4">Kül Rengi Acıdır</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Technology And Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/technology-and-politics-21b671ce9e18?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/21b671ce9e18</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-presidential-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[english]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 19 Aug 2020 11:55:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-19T11:55:40.259Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LsnFRgc2SwFL-3G5.jpg" /></figure><p>It is clear that our advancement in technology brings something new and unprecedented. Every new invention means a new choice that is offered to us and every new choice brings politics with it. So, politics is in every decision we make and every bit of our lives, starting from your birth certificate to your voting ballot, from the tax you pay to your marriage license, there is politics, even though we may not consider ourselves to be involved in politics. Therefore, considering both technology and politics are getting more and more important by the day, these two must coincide at some point. This is a very current topic and it has not been worked very much on before so, there are many things to explore in my research. In this sense, my topic is a trending topic among the scholars nowadays, it is a newly discovered gold mine for us to dig. Our question is: To what extent technology and specifically AI impacts the traditional perception of politics and is technology making our democracies stronger or weaker? We will examine the impacts of technological advancement in politics under 3 main points: Freedom and privacy, economic decentralization and elections and voting.</p><p>We will see that technology is a serious threat to people’s rights and freedoms, but it is also a threat to the existence of the states as well. Technology is a very powerful weapon that can be used to suppress and change people’s ideas, and to surveil people, but this weapon is not only used by the governments, ordinary people can master technology and use it against the rule of the state. We see that people began to free themselves from central governments’ control by switching their wealth to cryptocurrencies. This transition indicates a political freedom as well because economy and politics are inseparable. Finally, AI and technology directly impact our elections and people’s voting behavior. Our clicks, views, and likes are analyzed to determine our stance on political issues. By determining this, campaigns focus their propaganda on a narrower range of voters than they used to before the age of internet. In this research, we will not be viewing facts from a techno-optimist or from a techno-pessimist perspective, but rather have a realistic approach that relies on liberal values.</p><p><strong>Surveillance: Facial Recognition, Democracy, and Tech Empires</strong></p><p><em>Facial Recognition and Citizen Surveillance</em></p><p>Holding the power of data and surveillance makes states way more powerful than they ever were. Violation of citizens’ privacy and freedom might happen even without them knowing it is happening. This kind of accumulated power creates a Leviathan like image of states. States are now able to control and monitor their citizens thanks to smart cities and AI cameras. But how does it work? “Surveillance systems that include video analytics analyze video footage in real-time and detect abnormal activities that could pose a threat to an organization’s security. Essentially, video analytics technology helps security software “learn” what is normal so it can identify unusual, and potentially harmful, behavior that a human alone may miss.” (Saptharishi, 2) So the surveillance system is taught what is normal, unharmful behavior and what is a threat. And then AI simply learns to watch over citizens and inform the authorities whenever it spots a “criminal”. Although this technology is very beneficial for catching the actual criminals, it can be easily used for different purposes such as to track the location of people, or even their daily activities, where they visit, whom they meet and how often. This private data can be used for various purposes by governments. You might think that you and your privacy is safe because you think your government is not using AI surveillance, but this might not be the real case. Feldstein, in his The Global Expansion of AI Surveillance, illustrates this situation when he says “AI surveillance technology is spreading at a faster rate to a wider range of countries than experts have commonly understood. At least seventy-five out of 176 countries globally are actively using AI technologies for surveillance purposes. This includes: smart city/safe city platforms (fifty-six countries), facial recognition systems (sixty-four countries), and smart policing (fifty-two countries).” (Feldstein, 2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/824/1*9gcDBmTgIcjs7zF6O7tPyg.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1</figcaption></figure><p>As it is seen on figure 1, more than 50% of the nations in Asia, Middle East, and North Africa are adopting AI surveillance according to Feldstein’s report.</p><p><em>Democracy</em></p><p>Evidence shows that not only illiberal regimes, but also liberal Western democracies are using surveillance technology to monitor their citizens. In countries such as the United States and France, where there were revolutions occurred for freedom’s sake, there is now cameras around all corners monitoring the citizens. “Liberal democracies are major users of AI surveillance. The index shows that 51 percent of advanced democracies deploy AI surveillance systems. In contrast, 37 percent of closed autocratic states, 41 percent of electoral autocratic/competitive autocratic states, and 41 percent of electoral democracies/illiberal democracies deploy AI surveillance technology.” (Feldstein, 7) As it can be concluded by the evidence, advanced democracies tend to use AI surveillance systems more than illiberal or autocratic regimes. This situation might bring further problems in liberal democracies, since freedom and privacy have always been important values, and political institutions were challenged, or even overthrown for violations of such values.</p><p><em>Tech Empires</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/1*vi0xxynmxGDqAQj7xvtDmQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2</figcaption></figure><p>Technology-producing companies now have more influence than they ever had. They can reveal top secret state matters, private files of the citizens or data that can change the course of elections and political decisions. These tech giants are more powerful than most states and intelligence agencies in terms of holding the power of data. But what is more concerning is when these surveillance companies are controlled/owned or heavily influenced by states. For instance, although Huawei is owned by the labor union of the company, it is claimed by the Huawei official Mr.Jiang that the union has no control whatsoever over how the company’s business operations are conducted.(Zhong, 2) As long as these kinds of inconsistent announcements are made, it seems like the concerns about Huawei will be in our minds.</p><p><strong>Decentralization: Economy and Blockchain</strong></p><p><em>Cryptocurrencies</em></p><p>We have seen that as a result of suppression from the state, people tend to escape from centralization and form their own smaller communities in which they maintain a lifestyle. This natural reaction occurs faster as states puts more effort into monitoring their citizens. Blockchain is nothing but a reflection of this reaction in economy. As Comben states “Politics and cryptocurrency need to find some common ground. Regulators are increasingly expected to incorporate digital assets into the global economy, and as the general public becomes more aware of cryptocurrency, central authorities should accept it as part of the game.” (Comben, 1).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/734/1*NoF86AcGHu8I6sWAMU-zCA.png" /></figure><p>As we see in Donald Trump’s tweet, cryptocurrencies are highly undesirable for authoritarian administrators. It disables any kind of surveillance on economic activities ranging from 1$ transactions to the purchases worth millions of dollars. This did not use to be the case with the traditional economy. As Comben illustrates “Traditional financial systems empower governments and enable them to control the amount of money flowing in an economy.” (Comben, 3) So it is clear that cryptocurrency will keep being a safe haven and a safe exchange instrument in the years to come, for those who choose to be unregulated.</p><p><em>Decentralization</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/783/1*VWxz1BlcG1D74QgL2EL8Vg.png" /></figure><p>Cryptocurrencies take a very crucial role in this new decentralization, but their real values are underestimated by many politicians, and even by many political scientists. As Niyazov argues “Policymakers and politicians tend to disregard the importance of technology in defining the future of the socio-political system.” (Niyazov, 2) For instance, it is now possible to make big purchases from overseas by using cryptocurrencies and deep web, without any government regulation. Cryptocurrencies rely on nothing but the simple consensus of people. Thanks to this characteristic, cryptocurrencies are not easily affected by political decisions made by the government. It erases the borders in economics. In the near future, states as we know today might be redefined as people might be able to satisfy their economic activities without any state intervention, including currency. Role of state in people’s lives is likely to be challenged when it is left with a very few duties such as security and health. But these systems too might be revolutionized by the advancement of technology as well.</p><p><strong>Elections: Propaganda and Voting Behavior</strong></p><p><em>How?</em></p><p>Technology and AI can be used as a propaganda tool. Now that these tools have the power to reach to masses of voters with a single click, social media and voters’ data are the most important things politicians in order to pursue an effective campaign. Tech giants are important actors in this new form of politics. It is somewhat possible to determine people’s political tendencies by examining their clicks, their likes, or even the length of time they watch a politician speak or the sound volume they watch the politician in. There are various measurements and psychological factor that can be used to determine a person’s political tendency. But what is more interesting is that these data can now be examined by artificial intelligence. Online behavior of the people is processed within minutes. This opportunity can easily be abused by tech giants, politicians and campaign managers, as we will analyze in the next chapter.</p><p>These data are used by companies, such as Cambridge Analytica as we will examine later, to use in micro-targeted advertising. Relying on the collected data, user preferences are narrowed. So the micro-targeted advertisements contain personalized messages according to a person’s voter profile. This process of collecting data, analyzing preferences and using it to micro-target advertisements can result in a change of political tendencies, or even the color of your ballot.</p><p><em>Why?</em></p><p>As the gap between the governments and the new generations of people get wider, people tend to trust technology more than they trust governments. As a result of this tendency, politicians are now using technology for their campaigns more than ever. Tech giants like Facebook, Google and Twitter collect citizens’ data as much as they are allowed to, or we think. As much as we trust Facebook that they will ensure the safety our data, “The Times also found that tranches of raw data still existed beyond Facebook’s control.” (Confessore) In 2014, a political consultancy company called Cambridge Analytica collected millions of American people’s data from Facebook, without consent, to sell to political campaigns. The fact that this British political consultancy company had some ties with the Russian oil company Lukoil made an overwhelming impact on American politics. It is proved that Russians interfered in 2016 US Elections. (Confessore) This situation might be interpreted as a clash of civilizations, as it is also argued Brexit referendum was targeted by the Russians and the Chinese.</p><p><em>Another Result</em></p><p>Privacy is not the only concern when we think about surveillance and excessive use of data for political purposes. These kind of specialized advertisements and personalized content might push people into narrow communities that are closed to outside world. These are called information bubbles. In these bubbles, people are isolated from anything other than what is presented to them on social media contents like videos, podcasts, articles etc. “Information bubbles fuel political polarization by facilitating the formation of identity groups, resulting in an inability to undertake collective action and ultimately</p><p>fragmentation and even the total breakdown of society.” (Niyazov, 4) It can even be argued that most political conflicts in our modern world are caused by the information bubbles, narrow artificial environments that keeps people from expanding their knowledge, but instead reflect back what is thought in the bubble itself.</p><p><strong>Conclusion: How technology has been shaping today’s world?</strong></p><p>In conclusion, it is safe to say that technology, and spesifically AI, began to change our perception of politics from its foundation. Political terms like freedom, privacy, election, and propaganda are redefined. Governments today are able to supervise their citizens by holding the power of data. “Cookies, tracking tools and social logins allow the synchronization of data on users’ online behavior across platforms, websites and devices. These give constant information about our whereabouts, behavior, attitude, mood, preferences and social life.” (Körner, 8) Thanks to these data, politicians now can easily conduct campaigns that are more appealing and convincing for the people, thanks to the advancement in AI and technology. But these perks are not owned by the governments. Anyone who can put together a computer and connect to internet is within the reach of the power of data. So, not only governments, but also people can use technology as a political instrument. They can liberate themselves from government regulation in their economic decisions, and remove the borders drawn by the states.</p><p>In this paper, we did not view situations from a complete optimist or a pessimist perspective, but we tried to have a more realistic approach to how politics and its related fields like economics and social psychology are influenced by the rapid change in technology, especially with the advancement in AI and big data.</p><p><strong>Future: How technology might shape tomorrow’s world?</strong></p><p>In our rapidly growing world, it is very difficult to estimate tomorrow. But in light of the new evidence I shed light onto in this essay, it would not be a mistake to say that politics will be very different from what it was, not long, but 20 years ago from today. Those who can hold and process data might be the new elite of the next century, whereas the holders of money might be in pursuit of data to keep their social status. Politicians might seek new ways to convince people that they are necessary and worth to go to the ballot boxes for. Most bureaucrats are likely to be replaced by AI, excluding those who make policies that determine the lives of people: such as technocrats, diplomats, and economists. And the people might have more trust issues not only with the states, but also within the society. These trust issues might lead some of the people to create increasingly liberal communities, with minimal state or no state at all. Conflicts are not likely be physical, but economic. And finally, the limits of the sky will certainly be challenged, and who knows, an entirely new understanding of politics might emerge in space.</p><blockquote><strong>Onurcan Büyükkalkan</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Political Science and Public Administration</blockquote><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><blockquote>Comben, Christina. “What Happens When Politics and Cryptocurrency Meet?” Yahoo! Finance, Yahoo!, 15 July 2019, finance.yahoo.com/news/happens-politics-cryptocurrency-meet-180011520.html.</blockquote><blockquote>Confessore, Nicholas. “Cambridge Analytica and Facebook: The Scandal and the Fallout So Far.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 4 Apr. 2018, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/04/us/politics/cambridge-analytica-scandal-fallout.html.">www.nytimes.com/2018/04/04/us/politics/cambridge-analytica-scandal-fallout.html.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Dr. Mahesh Saptharishi, Avigilon. “The New Eyes of Surveillance: Artificial Intelligence and Humanizing Technology.” Wired, Conde Nast, 7 Aug. 2015, <a href="http://www.wired.com/insights/2014/08/the-new-eyes-of-surveillance-artificial-intelligence-and-humanizing-technology/">www.wired.com/insights/2014/08/the-new-eyes-of-surveillance-artificial-intelligence-and-humanizing-technology/.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Feldstein, Steven. “The Global Expansion of AI Surveillance.” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, carnegieendowment.org/2019/09/17/global-expansion-of-ai-surveillance-pub-79847.</blockquote><blockquote>Körner, Kevin. “Digital Politics, AI, Big Data and the Future of Democracy.” EU Monitor Digital Economy and Structural Change, 22 Aug. 2019, pp. 1–16., <a href="https://www.dbresearch.com/PROD/RPS_EN-PROD/PROD0000000000497768/Digital_politics:_AI,_big_data_and_the_future_of_d.pdf.">https://www.dbresearch.com/PROD/RPS_EN-PROD/PROD0000000000497768/Digital_politics:_AI,_big_data_and_the_future_of_d.pdf.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Niyazov, Sukhayl. “The Real AI Threat to Democracy.” Medium, Towards Data Science, 17 Nov. 2019, towardsdatascience.com/democracys-unsettling-future-in-the-age-of-ai-c47b1096746e.</blockquote><blockquote>Selimi, Sabin. “Can Artificial Intelligence Change the Future of Politics?” TRT World/News/Opinion, TRT World, 29 July 2019,</blockquote><blockquote>Zhong, Raymond. “Who Owns Huawei? The Company Tried to Explain. It Got Complicated.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 25 Apr. 2019, <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/25/technology/who-owns-huawei.html.">www.nytimes.com/2019/04/25/technology/who-owns-huawei.html.</a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=21b671ce9e18" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/technology-and-politics-21b671ce9e18">Technology And Politics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Bernie Sanders Was Bound to Lose?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/why-bernie-sanders-was-bound-to-lose-ce8d04eeb03f?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce8d04eeb03f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[english]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-presidential-race]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Jul 2020 15:47:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-01T15:47:38.524Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uZuHaZHfVT-pIRtv" /><figcaption>Bernie Sanders Rally on March 3 2020, Salt Lake City</figcaption></figure><p>While a few months remain until the 2020 presidential election in America and the presumptive candidates are debated among parties and public, I would like to talk about someone else entirely: Bernie Sanders. Sanders announced his campaign on February 19 2019, and during the first part of it seemed like he had a solid chance this time. This can be seen in his victories in the New Hampshire, Iowa and Nevada primaries but after a string of losses in South Carolina, Michigan, and Florida he had to drop out from the race as there was no evidence that he was going to be the candidate from Democrat Party (Ember, 2020). It is certain that Sanders did not drop out from the race for president candidacy because he was an incompetent politician: He has an abundance of experience in politics in various positions such as mayor, congressman and senator; working on amendments and bills enough to be called “amendment king”. From my point of view, he is a great speaker and everything he stands and fights for is worth standing and fighting for. The reason he dropped out of the race has more to do with the relationship between socialism and American people rather than his relationship with citizens. This relationship makes green deals for the environment, basic human rights such as free education and healthcare for all, housing for all seem like they are the beginning of a “communist tyranny” in America and overall restrictions on personal freedoms. In this essay, I will try to defend that the political culture in America and citizens’ relationship with socialism, created the downfall of Sanders and because of this he was bound to fail from the start.</p><p>The first thing that must be discussed is what kind of reaction does the word “socialist” create in America. The propaganda made during the Cold War about Soviet Union and communism in general, left ever-lasting negativity on the words “communist” and “socialist”. Even without knowing what socialism stands for, people accept it as a synonym for “enemy” or dismiss people as soon as they find out they are socialists. These statements can be proved by statistics from multiple poll results from different sources: According to Gallup 57% and Pew Research 55% of Americans view socialism negatively and Monmouth University found that 57% of Americans think socialism is incompatible with American values (Newport, 2020). As a result, when he described himself as a “democratic socialist” Bernie Sanders’ chance of a successful run for candidacy automatically decreased.</p><p>Another factor that certainly influence the relationship between socialism and American citizens is, the culture they have which is based on liberalism. While this culture is based on the basis of their rebellious nature right from the foundation of their country (Collinson&amp;Hu, 2020), it also comes from their competitiveness. America is famous for its competitiveness in almost all fields: Space, economy and trade, military, science, international relations and many more. This competitive psychology produces a deep-seated need for freedom of movement (Beilharz, p. 190, 2009) and that leads to an almost unhealthy obsession with freedom. What does an unhealthy obsession mean, can be seen in many examples but the one that appalled the world most was in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*1T_WN6k09INAS9p1au-_Zg.png" /><figcaption>A demonstrator holds a placard with a face mask stating “THE NEW SYMBOL OF TYRANNY MUZZLE” rallying outside the Pennsylvania Capitol Building to protest the continued closure of businesses due to the coronavirus pandemic on May 15, 2020 in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. (Collinson&amp;Hu, 2020)</figcaption></figure><p>Knowing that without wearing masks hundreds and thousands of people could die, people still refused to wear them because, at the bottom of it, it was something the government stated people should do. Thus, some citizens took it as an attack to their personal freedom. Since socialism depends on partial or full government control through an extensive tax system or centralized planning, in a country where government suggestions are not listened even if it is a medical emergency, socialism is seen as the greatest evil and cannot function in full capacity. Thus, by following the chain of events mentioned above, it is not difficult to predict that Sanders would have had to drop out of the race at one point or another because his ideas were not popular and would not gain support from voters in the near future.</p><p>Other than the value they give to their freedom, American citizens’ belief in capitalism adds onto the reasons why they view socialism negatively and would not support a socialist candidate. This is obvious because of the fact that in a country with such an advanced capitalism, working class is not nearly active or revolutionary as logic would suggest (Beilharz, p.190, 2009). The reason for the working class’ indifference to their exploitation is that they have a façade of reality taught as the “American dream”: Equality of opportunity for prosperity and upward social mobility. While there are famous cases of worker families’ children becoming rich and prosperous, those stories are only one side of the coin. According to a research Americans estimated that 12% of the poorest kids would move to the top tier, while the reality was around 8%; and children born in Denmark and Canada were more likely to move from bottom to up, than the ones born in United States (Kwok, 2018). As long as voters refuse to see the facts and live in their fantasy of limitless social mobility, they will continue to believe capitalism thus refusing any alternatives to it. And as long as Bernie Sanders offers socialism as an alternative, he will continue to fail.</p><p>How culture affected Sanders’ chances has another facet, in which the voting system itself failed Sanders. From the beginning of United States history, they primarily had two political parties: First these two were federalists and democratic republicans and then to this day it has been democrats and republicans. The single member district plurality system that is in place, has prevented minor parties from ever having the chance to win elections. In my opinion if Bernie Sanders had the luck of working among like-minded individuals in a socialist political party, he and his views could have become mainstream over the course of his political career and he could have continued his campaign in 2020. This is because while trying to fight republican ideals, Sanders also has to fight other democrats in certain topics like healthcare because even in the same political party, different approaches are debated almost constantly. Infighting decreases Sanders and democrat party’s credibility within voters, ultimately causing a catastrophe for him. Because at the end of the day, he still has to run as the democrat candidate.</p><p>If this essay proves anything, I would want it to prove that you can advocate for everything that is right; equality, human rights, being green, welfare within the state, and you might still fail because of the political climate in your country. You can defend everything that is right and still masses have the choice to ignore you. But that does not mean what you defend is meaningless and you have to keep on fighting. Just like Bernie Sanders did, relentlessly, for almost two decades.</p><blockquote><strong>Beyzanur Gençer</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Political Science and Public Administration</blockquote><h4>Bibliography</h4><blockquote>Beilharz, P. (2009). Socialism and America. In <em>Socialism and Modernity</em> (pp. 189–200). University of Minnesota Press. Retrieved June 27, 2020, from <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctttt8hb.18">www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctttt8hb.18</a></blockquote><blockquote>Collinson, S., &amp; Hu, C. (2020, June 23). <em>America’s mask resistance is just the latest example of a perennial struggle</em>. Retrieved June 27, 2020, from <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2020/06/23/world/meanwhile-in-america-june-23-intl/index.html.">https://edition.cnn.com/2020/06/23/world/meanwhile-in-america-june-23-intl/index.html.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Ember, S. (2020, April 08). <em>Bernie Sanders Drops Out of 2020 Democratic Race for President</em>. Retrieved June 27, 2020, from <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/08/us/politics/bernie-sanders-drops-out.html.">https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/08/us/politics/bernie-sanders-drops-out.html.</a></blockquote><blockquote>Kwok, R. (2018, November 6). <em>How Closely Do Our Beliefs About Social Mobility Match Reality?</em> Retrieved June 27, 2020, from <a href="https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/how-closely-do-our-beliefs-about-social-mobility-match-reality">https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/how-closely-do-our-beliefs-about-social-mobility-match-reality</a></blockquote><blockquote>Newport, F. (2020, April 13). <em>Public Opinion Review: Americans’ Reactions to the Word ‘Socialism’. </em>Retrieved June 27, 2020, from <a href="https://news.gallup.com/opinion/polling-matters/287459/public-opinion-review-americans-word-socialism.aspx.">https://news.gallup.com/opinion/polling-matters/287459/public-opinion-review-americans-word-socialism.aspx.</a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce8d04eeb03f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/why-bernie-sanders-was-bound-to-lose-ce8d04eeb03f">Why Bernie Sanders Was Bound to Lose?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Globalization, Modernization and Education]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/globalization-modernization-and-education-be46cb52984e?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/be46cb52984e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[english]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[globalization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jun 2020 15:09:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-29T15:08:59.985Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The theme of globalization means that there are an increasing number of social processes that are indifferent to national boundaries (Beck, U. 2000: 80). In other words, globalization is the spread of worldwide practices, consciousness and organization of social life (Ritzer, G. 2010: 574). There are multiple loyalties and identities which is strengthened by globalization such as work-internationally, love-internationally, marry-internationally, research internationally and so forth (p. 80). When it comes to examining globalization theory, it is seen that the theory in question focuses on becoming cross-national and it has emerged as a reaction to early social perspectives, such as modernization theory (p. 574). Although modernization theory has an inclusive and developmental model, as Dino Heiskala criticises in his article (2010) “From Modernity Through Post-modernity to Reflexive Modernization. Did We Learn Anything?”, evolution-based modernization theories have some blinds spots <a href="#_ftn1"><em>[1]</em></a>. Due to having a need of closing the gaps, globalization theory has evolved. Accordingly, in first step, the aim of this study is to examine what is globalization and its theoretical interpretations in economy. Then, the role of globalization in modernization process, in the terms of “second modernity” will be discussed. Finally, globalization’s effects in education and training in schools will be examined by giving some unique examples.</p><p>Globalization is one of the most debated issues of the present era (Kellner, D. 2002: 286). Accordingly, there are many different definitions: Douglas Kellner (2002) underlines this situation by saying that <em>“…a wide and diverse range of social theorists are arguing that today’s world is organized by accelerating globalization…”</em> (p. 285). He lists some social theorists who made some definitions such as “network society” based on communication and information technology; others underline the increasing power of consumerism within globalization and there are others who took attention on the importance of cultural changes in this process (p. 285–286). Although there are many different definitions, from various theorists, one of them is comprehensive and very suitable for a wide range of discussions. David Pick takes attention to the topic of globalization in his article (2004) “The Reflexive Modernization of Australian Universities” and he underlines this comprehensive and suitable perspective of Held et. al.’s three interpretations for globalization theory (pp. 100–103): According to Held et. al, there are three asserted theses that engage with the globalizing issue as the followings; the hyperglobalist thesis, the sceptical thesis and the transformationalist thesis <a href="#_ftn2"><em>[2]</em></a> (p. 100). According to the hyperglobalist thesis, globalization marks the dawn of a new epoch, characterized by the inevitable and positive consequences of the worldwide triumph of free-market and Western liberalism (p. 101). This is why, the hyperglobalist thesis is grounded in neo-liberalism even though it presents itself as being non-political. Globalization is meant as a new form of imperialism: The application of world market laws that must be implemented and obeyed according to neo-liberal interpretations (p. 101). Held et. al also underline the importance of free market’s role in economic ground of globalization and its positive effects in the society (p. 101). However, the sceptical thesis stands in opposition to the hyperglobalist position. From this point of view, the sceptical thesis points to a lack of empirical evidence regarding the impacts of globalization on the day-to-day practices of national economies (p. 101). The nation-states are placed at the centre of economic development (p. 102). However, both the hyperglobalist and sceptical theses are limited in their analytical usefulness. They rely on similar narrow economic approaches to support their claims. Because of lacking deep-analytic understandings of both, Held et. al. have also developed the transformationalist thesis as a response to the need for an alternative approach. According to the transformationalist thesis, globalization is composed of a complex set of processes (p. 102). Globalization is a central driving force behind rapid social, economic, political changes that are re-shaping modern societies (p. 102). In other words, globalization is more than just trade and commerce, it is a process of deep social, cultural and economic change (p. 103). The third one, the transformationalist thesis, that Held et. al have emphasized is also very important for the establishment of bridge between globalization and modernization processes. Therefore, the last thesis is based on the solid foundations that empower evolutionary-modern social theories such as Reflexive Modernization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mSMjxf02hzSfaxDC.jpg" /></figure><p>Globalization is also used in a positive sense to describe a process of integration into the world economy and a normative sense to prescribe a strategy of development, based on rapid integration with the world economy (Nayyar, D. 2006: 137). Globalization in economy refers to the expansion of economic transactions and the organization of economic activities across political boundaries of nation states<strong> </strong>(Nayyar, D. 2015: 389). Increasing economic openness, growing interdependence and deepening economic integration are a part of globalization process and they have a great deal of importance of shaping globalization theory. When it comes to examining them, it is seen that economic openness is not simply confined to trade flows, investments, financial flows; but it also extends to flows of services, technology, information and ideas across national boundaries (Nayyar, D. 2006: 138). To support this idea, D. Nayyar draws attention to the multidimensional characteristic of globalization that, its implications and consequences are not confined to the economy alone but extend to polity and society (Nayyar, D. 2015: 389). Although it happens, the cross-border movements of people are closely regulated and restricted. This is why, economic interdependence is asymmetrical (p. 138). It is closely related with industrialization, in which there is high degree of interdependence among countries in the industrialized world (p. 138). Finally, the integration process emerges with two previous characteristics in globalization theory.</p><p>The question of whether such integration can be achieved enables us to focus on the homogeneous-heterogeneous structure of globalization as George Ritzer did (2010). According to G. Ritzer, globalization can be analysed culturally, economically, politically and institutionally (p. 575). For each type of analysis, a key difference is whether one sees increasing homogeneity and heterogeneity. In that sense, it is discussed that globalization can be seen either as the transnational expansion of common codes and practices, or as a process in which many global and local cultural inputs interact to create a kind of pastiche, or a blend that leads to a variety of cultural hybrids (p. 575). George Ritzer argues that while theorists who focus on economic factors tend to emphasize their growing importance and homogenizing effects, the other theorists focus on some differentiations to continue to exist, at least, on the margins of the global economy (p. 575). As it is seen from the homogeneity-heterogeneity debates, why globalization needs so much definitions can be easily understood.</p><p>While discussing homogeneity and heterogeneity within the characteristics and definitions of globalization, negative effects of globalization are another topic of discussion that should be underlined. According to Deepak Nayyar, there is life always, before and after globalization; that it is not the end of geography when globalization is restricted or terminated (Nayyar, D. 2015: 392). Touching a hard issue, Douglas Kellner underlines the contradictions of globalization (2002: 290–295). According to him, the experience of September 11 points to the objective ambiguity of globalization that positive and negative sides are interconnected. That, institutions of the open society unlock the possibilities of destruction and violence as well as those of democracy, free trade and cultural-social exchanges (p. 291). So, it may be said that the globalization process may open the doors for terrorist attacks in “modern”, “industrialized” and “global” cities. In this context, D. Kellner says that after September 11 attacks, a fury of reflection, theoretical debates and political conflicts have been promoted (p. 291) and the globalization have generated new conflicts in new areas throughout the world (p. 292). I think, the subject needs further generalization. In this context, two examples can be given. Whereas the first one <a href="#_ftn3"><em>[3]</em></a> refers to China’s role in globalization and emphasises China’s development in education (it will be discussed later), L. Yongbing and F. Yanping also express the problems that emerged with the development of China by saying:</p><p><em>“In the recent decade, however, China has opted for a globalized and market-oriented strategy to achieve its economic goals…The rapid economic growth is characterized by increasing industrialization, privatization of means of production, commodification of labour, the rising of a new rich class, and so on… In spite of people’s improved material life, the government and its cultural elites recently publicly acknowledged that these rapid changes have been achieved at the expense of widespread and severe environmental degradation in both rural and urban areas; accelerated loss of farmland to industrialization, widened income gaps between the rich and poor…” </em>(p. 407).</p><p>Another perspective about this issue can be found in D. Neubauer’s study (2007). His focus is different from the previous authors. However, underlying foundations are actually the same.: According to him, globalization creates widespread poverty (p. 39). Throughout the world globalization is associated with increasing inequalities of income and wealth <a href="#_ftn4"><em>[4]</em></a>. By arguing that he underlines:</p><p><em>“Globalization has brought vast numbers throughout the world into the cash economy — the world of goods — without effective minimal resources for them to obtain the threshold levels of these goods to assure basic human security. Sachs and McArthur (2005) for example, estimate that more that 20,000 persons a day (eight million a year) perish because they are too poor to stay alive…A widening body of scholars is concluding that the whirlwind of contemporary globalization has resulted in lessened human security for significant of the world.” </em>(p. 40).</p><p>Based on this, D. Neubauer criticizes that contemporary globalization is producing the largest migration in the history of the planet. As a result of this, the largest cities of the world are massive in their size (p. 50). That’s why, much of this rapid growth has confronted national governments totally unprepared to deal with it (p. 51). From this fact, he connects his sentences by saying that devastating diseases such as malaria, tuberculosis and cholera are making comebacks, a consequence of public health deficits brought about, in part by insufficient funding for basic public health measures which emerges from uncontrolled migration in globalization (p. 51).</p><h4>Second Modernity and Globalization</h4><p>The hypothesis of “Reflexive Modernization” of modern societies examines a fundamental societal transformation within modernity (Beck, U. Bonss, W. &amp; Lau, C. 2003: 2). According to it, modernity hasn’t vanished but it is becoming increasingly problematic (p. 2). A transformation has taken place from the logic of the production and distribution of wealth to the new logic of the production and distribution of risks between social groups (Heiskala, R. 2011: 9). It can be said that the structures of industrial society get more complex as it develops in the modernization process. It is not unreasonable to call each of society as a risk society, with the emergence of this situation. In this context, U. Beck’s response to fulling to need of clarifying what modernization process is that two phases of society which are named as industrial society and risk society (p. 9), may be associated with globalization, but especially associated with second modernity which is closely related to more-modern states.</p><p>According to Beck, in the birth of modern world “estate-like” formations emerged to bind people’s identities. Such formations included class, gender and religious identities. In the process of emergence of modernity, these formations replaced more traditional determinants of cultural identities but they were exposed to the disruptive forces of modern differentiation (pp. 9–10). Second phase of modernization disrupts the very same formations in the gradual process of individualization brought by differentiation (p. 10) and it replaces the traditions of the traditional societies with distinctively modern traditions (p. 11). In other words, in the first age of modernity, for example, the non-Western societies were defined by their foreignness and otherness, their “traditional”, “extra-modern” or “pre-modern” character but in the second age of modernity, everyone has to locate himself in the same global space and is confronted with similar challenges (Beck, U. 2000: 88). So, where is globalization included in this process? During transition which occurs from the second stage of modernization to the third stage of modernity which named as post-traditional society (Heiskala, R. 2011: 11), globalization can be clearly seen. In the paradigm of the first modernity, world society is thought in terms of nation-state and nation-state society. Accordingly, globalization is seen as additive and not substitutive. In other words, globalization appears as a process coming from outside (Beck, U. 2000: 87). Within the paradigm of the second modernity, on the other hand, globalization not only alters the interconnectedness of nation-states and national societies, but the internal quality of the social. The societies, the nations and all the borders (it doesn’t matter whether they are physical or not) become questionable due to the disappearance of principles of regional, social and personal (p. 87). To support this idea, David Pick (2004) also argues that globalization is a process driving this transformation in that it is “changing the foundations of living together in all spheres of social action” (p. 99). Thus, individualization becomes more important and boundaries begin to disappear.</p><p>Finally, while it has been emphasizing that globalization is effective in various fields in the transition from industrial to modern societies in economic, social and political fields (Beck, U. Bonss, W. &amp; Lau, C. 2003: 6), technology has a great deal of importance in constantly developing societies. The transmutations of technology and capital work together to create a new globalized and interconnected world. A technological revolution involving the creation of computerized network of communication and transportation (Kellner, D. 2002: 287). The spread of the railways has brought the hinterland of countries into the world economy; the arrival of the telegraph has revolutionized communication; the second half of the 20th century witnessed the advent of jets, computers and satellites… (Nayyar, D. 2006: 145). It is seen that these technological developments have had deep impacts on reducing geographical barriers. Accordingly, it may be argued that globalization cannot be understood without comprehending the scientific and technological revolutions or modernization, as a long-run process, cannot be understood without comprehending globalization itself.</p><h4>An Example: Globalization in Schools</h4><p>Globalization changes our lives. Global media and communication systems allow us to discuss them across national boundaries (Merryfield M. M. &amp; Kasai M. 2004: 354). As a consequence of globalization, communication technology has enabled the flow of information, ideas and value. Thanks to internet and growing interconnected systems, people everywhere come to see that no single culture, country or people is at the center of the universe (Merriam, S. B. 2010: 403). Thus, global interconnectivity and markets are increasing in their scope, intensity, speed and impact in all areas of social life.</p><p>While societies are getting more modernized, the convergence of each fields within globalization obviously manifests itself in the field of education too. This situation has become such a pervasive feature of society that, education can no longer have the idea of a sovereign nation as a centre of economic, cultural, social, political and moral gravity as its starting point (Rönnström, N. 2013: 196). As a consequence of these processes, global doctrines have emerged in education. Standards, testing and alternative forms of financing have come to challenge conventional public education in many countries (Sahlberg, P. 2004: 66). Globalization has become an influence to nation-state’s social reforms, as education has to adjust to the new global environments that are characterized by flexibility, diversity, increased competition and unpredictable changes (p. 67). From this point, when the impact of globalization on education is focused, these factors are encountered: Decentralization, privatization and increasing<strong> </strong>efficiency (p. 68). It has been thought that leaving the central system in education will provide an advantage both in practical and theoretical areas and to facilitate the adaptation process, but decentralization can neither improve the quality of education nor increase the productivity of schooling that school autonomy alone, as a form of decentralized education management, has produced no significant gains in achievement (p. 68). In another research which interests the impacts of globalization in the education , J. Spring identifies three fallouts are the followings: The role of global migration of workers, moving of brain circulation and increasing of multicultural population, from the knowledge economy in globalization and each of which has implications for education (Merriam, S. B. 2010: 402).</p><p>Although there are negative examples <a href="#_ftn5"><em>[5]</em></a> that examine the relationship between globalization and education, there is the other side of the coin. For example, a clear impact of globalization increased competition, not only in economy and trade, but also in other sectors, including education (Sahlberg, P. 2004: 74). As a response to the economic, political and cultural globalization process, education systems are seeking governance and operational models from the business world and this search is causing higher productive and successful inputs to be applied in schools (p. 75). In other words, education systems are trying to keep pace with the globalizing world by both embracing and developing globalization to deliver the next generations with a certain standard.</p><p>In this context, the primary goal of global education is to prepare students to be effective and responsible citizens in a global society (Merryfield M. M. &amp; Kasai M. 2004: 355). Children don’t have the same opportunities and abilities as adults to protect their own needs and interests (Rönnström, N. 2013: 195). Therefore, there is a need of adaptation of children according to what the society has and will have. Giving historical examples, what happened in the past while the societies had been becoming more complex and differentiated, the process may be made easier. Strengthening children’s position as subjects in a changing social world which is characterized by individualization and marketization, is essential to what modern education has. In order to meet these needs of students and ensure continuity of modern and global education in schools, teachers have begun to use multiple perspectives to teach important historical events, contemporary events and modern concepts such as democracy. Teachers also use role-plays, simulations, or work in the local community to help students experience diverse points of view and events that are historically, politically or culturally significant within social studies (Merryfield M. M. &amp; Kasai M. 2004: 355).</p><p>Teaching global interconnectedness helps students to understand how people, ideas and events are related across different eras and world regions. They can identify the connections of multinational corporations which generate cosmopolitan-respect-based view of world and will comprehend respect-based education while globalizing. In this context, even if there are some problems mentioned in this study, China can be given as a very suitable example. It is argued that China’s basis education has changed as rapidly as its politics, economy, culture and society (Yongbing, L. &amp; Yanping, F. 2009: 407). To be in accordance with global-modern- education systems, the substantial changes in China’s educational policy, governance and curriculum has attempted to (1) diversify the school governance with a clear shift from central control towards local decision makers, (2) reorient the system from traditional curricular orientations towards a focus on knowledge, (3) shift the emphasis of teacher-centered pedagogy to student autonomy and from knowledge transmission to knowledge construction and finally, (4) re-establish a free teacher education programme (p. 407–408). This process is seen as quite long, difficult and tiring, however, in the study, it is also seen that to find solutions to the problems, the question of “how” has been asked by policy-makers many times. For example, to find a solution to the biggest challenge for China which is to make sure that all of the children receive a nine-year compulsory education with improving the overall quality of education, China has closed down smaller schools and constructed new larger “central” schools while existing conditions have been improved (p. 410). Another is dealt with the adolescents’ stance towards sexuality. In this study, it is argued that although the Chinese adolescents have a low incidence of engaging in sexual behaviours compared to their Western counterparts, their attitudes towards sexuality are becoming increasingly liberal (p. 410). In the study, there are also examples of various articles on the activities of China in the field of education and it is emphasized that although China is more successful than before in globalization but it still has some deficiencies (p. 411) that should be fixed or empowered. However, it is quite normal for any country other than European countries <a href="#_ftn6"><em>[6]</em></a> to have difficulty. At this point, globalization is seen an important in order to catch up with the speed of the era and it is an inevitable end to the societies during the process of modernization.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>In this paper, the term of globalization has been explained with its characteristics. Then, its theoretical background in economy has been detailed by giving some examples. Here it has been understood that globalization is multidimensional and it has own characteristics in various fields. The concepts, which are related to globalization theory that put forward by various authors, have been expressed and the position of globalization in reflexive modernization has been studied in detail within the importance of technological developments. As a result of this examination, it can be argued that globalization and modernization are intertwined and the societies, that act reflexively, will eventually become global when the necessary conditions arise. Finally, globalization’s reflections have been elaborated in the field of education. Here it is seen that education is a part of globalization and it plays an active role in the shaping of societies. From this point of view, the role of education in the globalizing societies as well as teachers’ roles on the students have been examined too. The case of China has been given to ensure better understanding on the topic. Thanks to these examples, it can be argued that change is a very difficult process for every society and nation. There may be shortcomings or difficulties in the process which aims to become an integrated part of globalization. However, it shouldn’t be forgotten that the benefits of globalization are essential to catch the needs of the era just like emphasized before by other researchers (Ching, H. S. et. al. 2011; Thompson, R. L. 2007; Johnson, D. G. 2002).</p><blockquote><strong>Deniz Devrim Karabulut, </strong>Graduate at Yıldız Technical University Dept. of Humanities and Social Sciences</blockquote><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> As a more detailed criticism on this subject, we are encountered Ryan Kennedy’s study (2010). According to his neo-institutionalist perspective, modernization theory, that Lipset and later his followers argued, has difficulty explaining timing of transitions (p. 787) and the link between economic development and democratization, which varies within modernization process, carries an inherent contradiction (p. 797). That’s why, other related fields are also affected by this contradiction and some shortcomings what his study aims to explain.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> To see more comprehensive study on this issue: Luke Martin (2007). The Third Wave in Globalization Theory. International Studies Review, 9 (2). 173–196.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> L. Yongbing &amp; F. Yanping (2009) Basic education reform in China globalization with Chinese characteristics, <em>Asia Pacific Journal of Education</em>, 29(4), 407- 412</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Touching on the same problem, S. B. Merriam (2010) criticizes globalization with an emphasis on the process of marginalization of societies (pp. 403–404).</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> One of them is D. Neubauer’s criticism to global education (2007). According to him, the challenges of providing education in mega-cities environments are vast (due to migration and other problems what have been written above). Not the least is the absence of governance infrastructure created by uncontrolled growth in cities. Government’s inabilities to produce routine infrastructure are compounded by the frequent absence of capacity to establish the essential routines required for the rule of law administrative regularity. In absence of effective governmental authortity, corruption flourishes which further undercuts governmental authority. Then, education which is one of civic purpose cannot find a basis to easily develop in that country where there are mentioned absence (p. 51–52).</p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> To see another example on this issue, see: Amar K.J.R. Nayak, Kalyan Chakravarti &amp; Prabina Rajib (2005). Globalization Process in India: A Historical Perspective since Independence, 1947. South Asian Journal of Management, 12(1).</p><h4>Bibliography</h4><blockquote>Beck, U. (2000). The cosmopolitan perspective Sociology of the second age of modernity. <em>The British Journal of Sociology</em>, 51(1), 79–105</blockquote><blockquote>Beck, U, Bonss, W. &amp; Lau, C. (2003). The theory of Reflexive Modernization: Problematic, Hypotheses and Research Programme, <em>Theory, Culture and Society</em>, 20(1), 1–33</blockquote><blockquote>Cambridge, J. &amp; Thompson, J. (2004), Internationalism and Globalization, <em>International Education</em>, 34 (2), 161–175</blockquote><blockquote>Ching, H. S., Hsiao, C., Wan, S. K., &amp; Wang, T. (2011). Economic Benefits of Globalization: The Impact of Entry to the WTO On China’s Growth<em>. Pacific Economic Review, </em>16(3), 285–301.</blockquote><blockquote>Heiskala, R. (2011). From modernity through postmodernity to reflexive modernization: “Did we learn anything?”. <em>International Review of Sociology</em>, 21(1), 3–19</blockquote><blockquote>Johnson, D. G. (2002). Globalization what it is and who benefits. <em>Journal of Asian Economics</em>, 13, 427–439</blockquote><blockquote>Kellner, D. (2012). Theorizing Globalization. <em>Sociology Theory</em>, 20(3), 285–305</blockquote><blockquote>Martin, L. (2007). The Third wave in globalization theory. <em>International Studies Review</em>, 9 (2). 173–196</blockquote><blockquote>Merryfield, M. M. &amp; Kasal, M. (2004). How are teachers responding to Globalization?, <em>Social Education</em>, 68(5), 354–359</blockquote><blockquote>Merriam, S. B. (2010). Globalization and the role of adult and continuing education. <em>Handbook of adult and continuing education</em>, 401–409</blockquote><blockquote>Nayak, A. K., Chakravarti, K., &amp; Rajib, P. (2005). Globalization process in India A historical perspective since independence, 1947. <em>South Asian Journal of Management</em>, 12(1)</blockquote><blockquote>Nayyar, D. (2006). Globalisation, History and Development: A Tale of Two Centuries. <em>Cambridge Journal of Economics</em>, 30, 137–159</blockquote><blockquote>Nayyar, D. (2015), Globalization and Democracy. <em>Brazilian Journal of Political Economy</em>, 35(3), 388–402</blockquote><blockquote>Neubauer, D. (2007). Globalization and Education: Characteristics, Dynamics, Implications<em>. Changing Education,</em> 29–62</blockquote><blockquote>Ritzer, G. (2010), <em>Sociological Theory (8th edition), </em>New York: McGraw-Hill</blockquote><blockquote>Rönnström, N. (2013) From globalist to cosmopolitan learning: on the reflexive modernization of teacher education, <em>Ethics &amp; Global Politics</em>, 5:4, 193–216</blockquote><blockquote>Pick, D. (2004). The Reflexive Modernization of Australian Universities<em>. Globalisation, Societies and Education</em>, 2(1), 99–116</blockquote><blockquote>Thompson, R. L. (2007). Globalization and the benefits of trade. Chicago Fed Letter<em>, The Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago</em>, 236</blockquote><blockquote>Sahlberg, P. (2004). Teaching and Globalization, <em>Managing Global Transitions</em>. 2 (1), 65–83</blockquote><blockquote>Yongbing Liu &amp; Yanping Fang (2009) Basic education reform in China globalization with Chinese characteristics, <em>Asia Pacific Journal of Education</em>, 29(4), 407- 412</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=be46cb52984e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/globalization-modernization-and-education-be46cb52984e">Globalization, Modernization and Education</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fascism in the Interwar Period]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/fascism-in-the-interwar-period-dfc03c0a072b?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dfc03c0a072b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[english]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jun 2020 15:48:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-19T15:47:36.118Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A Case Study: Fascism in Italy and United Kingdom</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eR1453fb8U3MTOWJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler in Munich, Germany. National Archives Collection of Foreign Records Seized, 1675–1958</figcaption></figure><p>The term “fascism” has been used for almost over a century to identify a spectrum of different movements and governments. It was mostly used to describe the regimes of Italy, Germany and Japan during the pre-WWII years and the WWII years. Although it was first used for Italian nationalist movements, this term was also used to describe Salazar’s Portugal, Antonescu’s Romania, and Franco’s Spain. Even in an exemplary democracy, in Canada, Adrien Arcand, who claimed to be the ‘Canadian Führer’, established the Christian National Social Party and the National Unity Party of Canada. Nonetheless, fascism is not only used to describe the movements seen in western countries, but also in some of the African and Asian countries, such as Jingwei in China, Leibbrandt in South Africa, and the New Guard in Australia. Hence, the term “fascism” has been used for a variety of different regimes all over the world. When these regimes and movements are examined in detail, some significant similarities can be observed. The notions of nationalism and xenophobia are the common characteristics of these movements. The emergence of these characteristics usually corresponds to a context of national distress. Fear and suppression are other key elements that can be discerned. For example, in Nazi Germany, “Over 150,000 informants throughout the country would report any anti-Nazi feeling to the Gestapo. The Gestapo and informants did not wear uniforms so Germans did not know when they were being spied on. Many ordinary Germans also informed on one another for personal gain or out of jealousy. This created tension and fear throughout the country.”<em>[1]</em></p><p>Although “fascism” was first used to describe Italian nationalist movements, it is now widely accepted and used around the world to describe movements and regimes where there is oppression of the opposition, common state involvement in social and economic life, imposition of ideology, and militarism. It is a historical fact that fascism reached its peak during the interwar period (1918–1939). Several notions can be claimed to have impact on the rise of fascism. Expansionism is one of the features seen in fascist movements. “Fascism emphasized the need for the restoration of the Mazzinian Risorgimento tradition that pursued the unification of Italy, that the Fascists claimed had been left incomplete and abandoned in the Giolittian-era Italy.”<em>[2]</em> The desire to prove superiority of one race is another reason which emerges as a result of different experiences of a nation. The claim of Aryan race being superior to others and it being the creator of most of the civilization like the Persians, Greeks, Romans, and Celts⁴ can be given as an example. Economic desires, national perception of honor and the collective hate on a certain group can also be given as features observed during the rise of fascist movements. It can be claimed that the instability in the economic and social life has impact on all the features mentioned above. In the interwar period, the 1929 Economic Crises (The Great Depression) began in the US and spread relatively quickly to the US’s economic partner: Europe. It led to a drop in personal income, tax revenue, and profits. It was a huge devastation for many countries in Europe. Unemployment rates throughout the west hit %20–25, putting millions of people out of their jobs.</p><p>The financial crisis escalated out of control in mid-1931, starting with the collapse of the Credit Anstalt in Vienna in May. This put heavy pressure on Germany, which was already in political turmoil. With the rise in violence of Nazi and communist movements, as well as investor nervousness at harsh government financial policies. The crisis continued to get worse in Germany, bringing political upheaval that finally led to the coming to power of Hitler’s Nazi regime in January 1933 <em>[3]</em>. The people of Europe were already in economic misery considering the continuing negative effects of the WW1. The economic crisis and unemployment led to anger and exhaust.</p><p>The global process of recession and factionalism led to the creation of an environment in where fascism could cherish and find ground to expand its range of impact. The movements and regimes with the fascist ideology demonstrated key similarities as well as nuances. This paper examines two different states; Italy where fascism rose to power and United Kingdom where fascist movements occurred but evanesced without gaining rule. The sections focus on the conjuncture before the emergence of fascism and continuum of development of the fascist ideology. The purpose is to identify the relevant notions throughout the course of interwar years, to gain insight into the essence of fascism and to analyze its characteristics through comparison of the two mentioned states.</p><h4>Italy</h4><p>In 1871, Risorgimanto, the unification of the Italian peninsula gave birth to a nation which has been evolving for centuries, but still have been lacking economic progression to match with their sense of national pride. Italy’s role between great colonial and military powers of Europe was uninspiring. Newly formed kingdom, however, took the initiative and showed clear determination in its economic and its military progression to find its place in Europe, which to them had to be more eminent than it was. To that end, Italy was getting hungry for colonialism. All things considered, it is inevitable that Italy, pre-great war, fit the definition of a country that was lusting war for economical and territorial gains that disregarded any question of legitimacy and request for peace of other countries. In particular, the spirit which rose from the Italian unification and Third Italian War of Independence in 1866, made the intellectuals and politicians aware of more humble expansion policies which led to the rise of Irredentism. In 1877, the Italian politician Matteo Renato Imbriani invented the term terre irredente (unredeemed lands)<em>[4]</em>. It was aiming to expand Italian borders to the territories which were not part of the kingdom but ethnically and linguistically are Italian or considered Italian. Prior to the Great War, power of nationalism was alive in other countries as much as Italy, it shaped the Italian Parliament in great scales. However, the Italian decision to go to war was as late as May 1915. It is only understandable that the hesitation Italy had, can only be a by-product of indecision. Italy; being late to colonial practices with respect to European powers, most importantly Austria, France and Germany; was thriving for any gain it could get.</p><p>Colonial practices and Irredentism were dominating the foreign policy of Italy. The early relative success in Eritrea and Somali, encouraged and empowered any plan of expansion in Africa which Italy desperately needed for economic and political prestige gains. However, in Ethiopia, Italy suffered a great defeat. This absolute catastrophe for Italy meant that not only they failed to colonize Ethiopia but they also recognized it as an independent nation. This would arguably mean that Italy is not a European power that is able to operate in African soil successfully. The civil unrest came afterward at home due to this humiliating defeat, led the Prime Minister Francesco Crispi to resign. The self-doubt of Italian politics had after Ethiopia, did not disappear with the victory in Libya in 1913 because of budget deficits and unforeseen loss of manpower, hence Italian colonialism, was still on questioning. At home, the Irredentism did not suffer such theoretical blows. Italian nationalism was still dominant in the parliament. The Triple Alliance, Italy had with Germany and Austria was doomed to end because of these dominant characteristics of Italian politics. The historical French threat was at the end proved to be less important, since Austrian territories claimed by Italy was much more decisive and coherent with this new way of doing politics. The neutral Italy entered the war with guarantee from Allied powers, that Italy would receive Trieste, Southern Tyrol and Northern Dalmatia, all belonged Austro-Hungarian Empire. Opposition from the old guard politician, Giovanni Giolitti, did not change the mind of the parliament and Italy declared war on Central powers, having already refused to help their offensive war. At the end of the Great War, Italy was again displeased, with Allied powers, this time. Reason was again irredentist policies, causing to demand more territory than the new Allied countries have agreed. The narrative Italy established with this dissatisfaction, the Mutilated victory, was so popular that it would still find its place in Mussolini’s Italy.</p><p>In the aftermath of the First World War’s mutilated victory, Italy was dragged into the inevitable tough economic conditions just as the other belligerent states. This environment of crisis even got worse when the demobilized soldiers joined the work force while the factories were already being closed. Hence, the unemployment rates skyrocketed. This economic downturn of Post-World War I environment ineluctably led to difficulties and canalized people and ideologies into extreme ends of the political spectrum because extreme demands could be satisfied solely by extreme ideas and methods. One of these trending ideologies was socialism which included many significant political figures of 20th century such as Antonio Gramsci. This socialist movement caused an era called “Red Biennium”<em>[5]</em>. In this period popularization of radical socialism was observed. Just as in some other countries this ultra-leftist movement was balanced by ultra-rightists, the fascists led by Benito Mussolini who was a former socialist were in the stage and socialism was avoided.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*dJWmXdZTJizQG1py" /><figcaption>Benito Mussolini delivering a speech about the German Anschluss of Austria and German-Italian relations at the Piazza della Vittoria in Genoa, Italy. Photograph, 14 May 1938. CREDIT: KEYSTONE/GETTY IMAGES</figcaption></figure><p>Fascist period in the Italian history witnessed many extraordinary incidents such as the emergence of the Black Shirts which was the militia composed of soldiers who fought in the great war. They also perpetuated many violent incidents all around the Italian peninsula and assisted Mussolini to slowly acquire political power that he desired by marching to Rome and taking place in the further negotiations. Mussolini consolidated his power and renamed himself as “II Duce” after closing the opposition political parties by pleading the assassination attempts targeting him and gaining authority in the state.</p><p>The main motive of Italian fascist nationalism was reviving the Roman Empire. This factor determined the later policies of Mussolini. The education and the architecture were other areas which were influenced by the fascist regime’s incline to Roman Empire. The expansionist policies towards central Europe and the colonies were the outbreaks of these phenomena. The idealized Italy was an equivalent of the other western industrial colonial powers. Hence, in this period, Italy began industrializing and launched a campaign against what nowadays is Ethiopia.</p><p>Although Mussolini approached the Nazis with antipathy because of the German concept of “ubermenchen”. The two sides reached to compromise by diplomatic gestures and signed an alliance treaty. The second world war broke out Italy first lost its colonial territories and then following the fall of Sicily and southern Italy. After several attempts of resistance, the fascist period ended when Mussolini was captured and shot.</p><h4>United Kingdom</h4><p>With the turmoil the First World War brought with itself, the spread of radical ideologies became significantly easier. However, the spread of an ideology did not guarantee its success as it can be seen when United Kingdom is analyzed during the interwar period. In the decade that followed the publication of the Fascist Manifesto, Britain had its fair share of fascist movements: Political parties of British Fascists and British Union of Fascists and a political movement named Imperial Fascists League are a few of those that were the most influential. Though it is known that fascist movements in UK were not successful on a country scale, some scholars refuse to say they failed and prefer to say they were marginalized, because they did not succeed in the first place to fail. The reason for these movements’ marginalization lies within the cold political and social climate in Britain at the time, their own organizational problems and the fact that they were not politically well-established. Even though one can presume that fascism was an imported ideology for United Kingdom and there are doubts among scholars that there were any “true” fascist movements or parties that operated in UK before 1930s, it is hard to deny the traces of fascist elements in Edwardian era between 1901 and 1910 and, even further, in 1880 which was mainly fueled by the fear of imperial decline, working-class unrest and constitutional imbalance. Another aspect of fascism that is seen in UK is the anti-alienation and patriotism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FxyOgRYVKeTsE9c1.jpg" /><figcaption>Blackshirt followers of Oswald Mosley. CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES</figcaption></figure><p>The Britons Society that was founded in 1919 who described themselves as a patriotic organization dedicated to the eradication of aliens is an example in this aspect. While the rest of Europe was in turmoil in all prospects, it was rather easy for United Kingdom to get back on its feet. Post-war recession was fairly light on the British economy especially with the nonexistence of hyperinflation, they had left the war victorious which meant an addition to the British sense of superiority and no fear of impending doom for the country, mass immigration rate was low, sustainment of national identity from its unification to this day and non-existence of a duration of political paralysis which could have helped the fascists make a move- which was seen in Italy and Germany meant a relatively hard environment for fascism to foster and yield results <em>[6]</em>. One can argue that even if United Kingdom witnessed the same level of disorder as the rest of Europe, fascism still would have been marginalized because of their internal characteristics. The first and maybe most crucial deficiency of the fascist movements was their inability to find a political message that would weaken the Conservative majority party or make the Labor opposition look like a threat. While the political message they supported did not do neither of these it also did not create an alternative to the status-quo <em>[7]</em>. In addition to this, the propaganda they conducted received poor reaction from the middle class, which they needed the support of, because it “aimed at middle class worries about industrial unrest and aristocratic anxieties about industrial development, rather than working class fears about immigration”<em>[8].</em> Lack of charismatic leaders to carry the flag and the political arena being under the monopoly of the Conservative party were major factors which led to their marginalization in the 1920s.</p><p>At first, Conservative party thought that fascism would be better a better alternative for socialism. They wanted to prevent every attack of socialist ideas and movements in Britain. “For Conservatives, in some ultimate choice between communist dictatorship and fascist dictatorship, fascism could be the lesser evil — but nonetheless still an evil”<em>[9]</em>. In Britain, liberalism was so strong that both politicians and public did not want to destroy its effects in the country. Because of that, they were not particularly warm to the fascism in their country. Basically, they were satisfied with their ongoing system and one charismatic leader or a strong crisis would not be able to change that situation. However, Mosley gained a lot of attention in these years. Even Neville Chamberlain thought of an electoral alliance with him. One can say that fascism in Britain could not spread like it did in Germany or Italy but it affected political atmosphere of Britain in 1920–30s. To look from another perspective, Oswald Mosley’s ideas were not similar with Hitler’s ideas. He thought that Europe as a whole should establish a sovereign state and Europeans should not be under neither Americans’ nor Bolsheviks’ influence <em>[10]</em>. This perspective showed major differences with the general concept of fascism. “It is worth pointing out that the vital difference between Hitler and Mosley is the absence of a social Darwinist element in his thought”<em>[11]</em>. Hence, the fascism movement directed by Mosley lacked some essential notions of the fascism seen in Italy and Germany. Nevertheless, after World War II began, Britain Union of Fascists (BUF) was disbanded by the Parliament of United Kingdom because of their potential threat of supporting Nazis. Thus, with establishment of the new coalition, National Government, any fascist activation in Britain had ended.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>The process which led to emergence of fascist movements in Italy and United Kingdom differ in various ways. The conjuncture of the countries after the First World War were distinct. The notion of fascism itself was understood and practiced differently by the groups in these states as Britain Union of Fascists focused more on the consolidation of Europe in general whereas Mussolini and his fascist government followed a different course.</p><p>After the end of the Great War, Italy was highly integrated to colonial race to play a role with the great powers in the post-war system. During this period, irredentism was an influential ideology that shaped domestic and foreign policies of Italy. A prevailing aspect of the Italian politics was dissatisfaction derived both from its failure in colonial struggle in Africa and from its discontented gains from the World War I. The mutilated victory and dissatisfaction got even worse after the Great War, and this situation paved the way for extreme ideologies to arise. Thus, the fascists, under the leadership of Benito Mussolini gained power and eventually acquired the rule of the state. The concept of honor and glorified national identity together with the affects of the global economic crisis and the major negative results of the First World War resulted in a suitable environment for the rise of fascism.</p><p>The fascist movements in the United Kingdom during the interwar years were relatively minor when compared to the other movements across Europe. There can be different claims on why the fascist movement in United Kingdom did not succeed. Firstly, United Kingdom did not suffer from the economic casualties caused by the First World War similar to Italy although United Kingdom was also effected from the ’29 crisis. Moreover, the civic society and the political interest groups were integrated in liberalism in such a way that radical ideologies such as fascism did not provide an alternative to consider. The essence of the fascism seen in United Kingdom was different from the Italian and German fascism as it did not focus on the separation and amplification of a single nation/race.</p><blockquote><strong>Beyzanur Gençer</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Political Science and Public Administration</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Burak Can Gül</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Political Science and Public Administration</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Eda Aslan</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of International Relations</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Kemal Yeşilova</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Economics</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Utku Mert Metin</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of International Relations</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Ömer Özyuvalı</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of International Relations</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Onurcan Büyükkalkan</strong>, Undergraduate at Bilkent University Dept. of Political Science and Public Administration</blockquote><h4>Bibliography</h4><blockquote>Bagnall, R. et al. The Encyclopedia of Ancient History. (Wiley-Blackwell, 2012)</blockquote><blockquote>Baker D. (1996) The Extreme Right in the 1920s: Fascism in a Cold Climate, or ‘Conservatism with Knobs on’?. In: Cronin M. (eds) The Failure of British Fascism. Palgrave Macmillan, London.</blockquote><blockquote>George Lachmann Mosse. Nazi Culture: Intellectual, Cultural and Social Life in the Third Reich, p. 79.</blockquote><blockquote>Griffin, Roger. The Nature of Fascism. St. Martin’s Press, 1991. Pp.</blockquote><blockquote>Schnabel, Isabelan twin crisis of 1931&quot;. Journal of Economic History 64#3 (2004): 822–871. Kogan, Norman. “The Origins of Italian Fascism.” Polity, vol. 2, no. 1, 1969, pp. 100–105., doi:10.2307/3234092.</blockquote><blockquote>Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary Archived 2007–09–30 at the Wayback Machine: fasces</blockquote><blockquote>Poole, Anne. “Oswald Mosley and the Union Movement: Success or Failure?.” The Failure of British Fascism . Palgrave Macmillan, London, 1996. 53–80.</blockquote><blockquote>Sforza, Carlo. “Italy and Fascism.” Foreign Affairs, vol. 3, Apr. 1925, pp. 358–370. EBSCOhost,search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&amp;db=ssr&amp;AN=521247206&amp;site=edslive.</blockquote><blockquote>Vivarelli, R. “Interpretations of the Origins of Fascism.” Journal of Modern History, vol. 63, no. 1, Mar. 1991, p. 29. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1086/244257.</blockquote><blockquote>Williamson, Philip. “The Conservative Party, fascism and anti-fascism 1918–1939.” Varieties of Anti-Fascism . Palgrave Macmillan, London, 2010. 73–97.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dfc03c0a072b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/fascism-in-the-interwar-period-dfc03c0a072b">Fascism in the Interwar Period</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hegemonya]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/polytics/hegemonya-ae6fb8ea4d94?source=rss----707f3232f1d7---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae6fb8ea4d94</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[felsefe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[siyaset]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tarih]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[türkçe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politika]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bilkent PDK]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Apr 2020 16:26:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-05T16:26:57.677Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Hegemonya kavramı, toplumsal sınıflar ya da gruplar arasındaki, kendiliğinden rızaya dayalı ideolojik üstünlük, denetim ve yönlendirme ilişkilerini anlatır.”(1) Tanımdan da anlaşılacağı üzere esasen hegemonya kavramı bir toplumda belirli bir zümrenin diğer toplumsal sınıflar ve gruplar karşısında gösterdiği entelektüel,politik ve ahlaki üstünlüğü ifade eder. Kavramın tarihsel boyutuna baktığımızda ise karşımıza şöyle bir tablo çıkmaktadır: “Antik Yunan siyasal düşüncesindeki <em>hegemonia</em><strong> </strong>terimi, bir birey, toplumsal grup ya da devletin başka kesimler ya da devletler üzerinde uyguladığı yönlendirici üstünlük anlamına geliyordu; hegemon ise, böyle bir üstünlük konumunda bulunan özne için kullanılıyordu. Özellikle, değişik polis’ler arasındaki siyasal ittifaklar bağlamında bir kent-devletinin öbür polis’ler karşısında elde ettiği askeri ve siyasal egemenlik, önderlik ya da yöneticilik niteliği hegemonya terimiyle karşılanıyordu.”(2)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*67E8SwkiE4deIlxA.jpg" /></figure><p>Toplumsal manada hegemonya kavramının kullanımını inceleyecek olursak hegemonya kavramının Antonio Gramsci (1891–1937) ile kuramsal bir çerçeveye oturduğunu görürüz. Ona göre : “Hegemonya, kendiliğinden rıza süreçleriyle yaygınlık kazanan egemen sınıf ideolojisinin toplumda ‘ortak duyu’ haline gelmesini ifade eder. Bu nedenle, hegemonya, egemen sınıfın diğer sınıflar ve kesimler üzerindeki ahlaki-entelektüel önderlik yeteneğiyle yakından ilişkilidir.”(3) Gramsci’nin çizdiği çerçeveden bakıldığında hegemonik sınıfın salt kendi çıkarlarını düşünmeden, yani bir uzlaşma yaratarak toplumun büyük kısmını ortak paydada birleştirmesi hegemonik gücün oluşumunda son derece önemli hale gelmektedir. Gramsci’nin yaşadığı dönemi göz önünde bulundurursak Mussolini yönetimindeki faşist diktatörlüğün, Hitler yönetiminin (daha sonra yıkılacak olsalar da) tıpkı onun tarif ettiği şekilde toplumsal sınıflar üzerinde geniş bir mutabakat kurduğunu görürüz. Tam da bu noktada hegemonyanın sonsuza dek sürüp sürmeyeceği sorusu akla gelmektedir. Mussolini ve Hitler örneğinde olduğu gibi bu mutabakatın çoğu zaman siyasi, ekonomik ve askeri motivasyonlarla sağlandığını, ya da ortak bir düşman algısı üzerinde yaratıldığını görsek de çoğu zaman yaratılan bu uzlaşı oldukça kaygan bir zemin üzerinde inşa edilmiş durumdadır.</p><p>Dolayısıyla mevcut uzlaşı bozulduğunda, ya da kitleleri ortak paydada birleştiren değerler bütünü başarısızlığa uğradığında hegemonik güç yok olma tehlikesi yaşar ve kendisine yeni bir çıkış yolu aramaya başlar. Yani hegemonik gücün aynı biçimde ve hiç durmaksızın yeniden üretilmesi imkansız duruma gelmektedir. Tarihsel bakımdan incelendiğinde de egemen sınıf üstünlüğünü ifade eden hegemonya kavramının sonsuza kadar yeniden üretilmesinin mümkün olmadığı görülür. Hegemonik üstünlüğün farklı sebeplerden dolayı varlığını devam ettirememesi durumunda çeşitli krizler ortaya çıkar. Şekil bakımından ülkeden ülkeye farklılıklar göstermekle birlikte bu krizlerin sonucunda tek bir somut durum oluşur ki bu da egemen sınıfın üstünlüğüne dayanan hegemonyanın sona ermesidir. Gramsci de kuramsal açıdan hegemonya krizinin iki durumda ortaya çıktığını söyler.</p><p>“Birinci durum, egemen sınıf yönetilen kesimlerin yoğun desteğini elde ettiği büyük bir siyasal girişimde (örneğin, savaş) başarısızlığa uğradığında gündeme gelir. İkinci durum ise, geçmişte edilgenlik içinde bulunan geniş kitleler birdenbire hareketlenerek devrimci talepler ileri sürmeye başladığında söz konusu olur. Egemen sınıfın bu iki durum karşısında sergileyeceği yöneticilik yeteneği, tarihsel blokun yeniden yapılanması üzerinde kararlaştırıcı bir etki yaratır.” (4)</p><p>Daha sonra Gramsci olası bir başarısızlık durumunda hegemonik krizin nasıl çözümlenebileceği konusunda meseleyi ikiye ayırır. İlk durumda egemen sınıf toplumsal sınıflar üzerinde yeniden bir uzlaşı yaratarak,ortak hedefler etrafında tekrar buluşarak krizi aşar ki bu krizin organik çözümünü ifade eder; ikinci durumda ise oluşan hegemonik krizde çatışmakta olan güçlere baskın gelecek bir üçüncü güç ortaya çıkar. Bu durum Gramsci tarafından “Sezarizm” terimiyle adlandırılmıştır. “…daha önceden yeterince tanınmayan bir siyasal odak ( karizmatik bir kişi ya da kurum ) kendi iktidarının oluşturarak güç dengesini yeniden inşa eder. Bu nedenle, kimi kuramsal modellerde Bonapartizm ile ilişkilendirilen Sezarist çözüm, çatışmakta olan taraflar karşısındaki özgül konumuna bağlı olarak, ilerici ya da gerici biçimler altında açığa çıkabilir.Tarihsel deneyimler araştırıldığında, Julius Ceasar ve 1.Napoleon yönetimleri ilerici Sezarizme; 3.Napoleon ve Bismarck yönetimleri ise gerici Sezarizme örnek gösterilebilir.” (5)</p><p>Sonuç olarak şunu söyleyebiliriz ki, hegemonya kavramı ve ifade ettiği anlam kavramsal tanımını korumakla birlikte toplumdan topluma değişmekte, dinamikler sabit kalmamakta ve tıpkı liberal-kapital ekonomik sistemin sürekli kriz yaratıp daha sonra bu krizi çözmek için yeni fırsatlar ortaya koyması gibi hegemonya kavramı da karşılaştığı krizlerden farklı biçimlerde sonuçlar doğurarak kendini yeniler. “Hegemonya” kavramı günümüzde hem toplumsal anlamda hem de uluslararası ilişkiler bağlamında geçmişte olduğu gibi askeri, ekonomik ve siyasal açıdan etkisini her alanda göstermekte ve toplumların geleceğine yön vermeye devam etmektedir.</p><blockquote><strong>Gökalp Badak</strong>, Hacettepe Üniversitesi Uluslararası İlişkiler Bölümü Öğrencisi</blockquote><p>(1) Yetiş,Mehmet (2012) “Hegemonya”,Atılgan,Gökhan ve E.Attila Aytekin (Der) Siyaset Bilimi: Kavramlar,İdeolojiler,Disiplinlerarası İlişkiler İçinde s:87</p><p>(2) Yetiş,Mehmet (2012) “Hegemonya”,Atılgan,Gökhan ve E.Attila Aytekin (Der) Siyaset Bilimi: Kavramlar,İdeolojiler,Disiplinlerarası İlişkiler İçinde s:87</p><p>(3) Yetiş,Mehmet (2012) “Hegemonya”,Atılgan,Gökhan ve E.Attila Aytekin (Der) Siyaset Bilimi: Kavramlar,İdeolojiler,Disiplinlerarası İlişkiler İçinde s:89</p><p>(4) Yetiş,Mehmet (2012) “Hegemonya”,Atılgan,Gökhan ve E.Attila Aytekin (Der) Siyaset Bilimi: Kavramlar,İdeolojiler,Disiplinlerarası İlişkiler İçinde s:92</p><p>(5) Yetiş,Mehmet (2012) “Hegemonya”,Atılgan,Gökhan ve E.Attila Aytekin (Der) Siyaset Bilimi: Kavramlar,İdeolojiler,Disiplinlerarası İlişkiler İçinde s:93</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae6fb8ea4d94" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/polytics/hegemonya-ae6fb8ea4d94">Hegemonya</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/polytics">Polytics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>