<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Product Hunt Book Club - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Here are some AMAs from the authors who have launched their books on Product Hunt. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 09:06:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/product-hunt-book-club" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lean Analytics — Ben Yoskovitz]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/lean-analytics-ben-yoskovitz-804069b78094?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/804069b78094</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 21:33:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-25T21:33:50.647Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Ben Yoskovitz, who some call one of the best product minds in the game. He’s going to introduce himself briefly, and then we’ll get right to the questions</strong></p><p>Hi folks — I’m currently VP Product @ VarageSale, previously @ GoInstant (which was acquired by Salesforce). I ran a startup accelerator for ~1 year (called Year One Labs). Been an entrepreneur for 16ish years now.</p><p>Blog at <a href="http://www.instigatorblog.com/">http://www.instigatorblog.com/</a></p><p>And the book of course, which I co-wrote with Alistair is at:</p><p><a href="http://leananalyticsbook.com/">Lean Analytics Book - Use data to build a better startup faster</a></p><p><strong>Q. How did you develop your product chops? What are some of the biggest pieces of advice you give to aspiring PM’s? </strong>— Erik Torenberg</p><p>Lots of trial and error. ☺ I started a company back in 1996, learned a lot there. Then another one in 2007. So early stage CEO is also the product person (usually).</p><p>PMs can come from anywhere, which makes it interesting. I started as a startup founder and then slotted myself into the PM role. But PMs have a broad set of skills. They have to be both strategic and very tactical.</p><p>If you want to be a PM, I’d encourage you to go build something. Anything. On the side. Learn to code and hack away. Learn design.</p><p>Learn marketing. You’ll need all those skills in various degrees to be a successful PM.</p><p><strong>Q. What would you say is one of the most important nuggets of wisdom regarding product you wish you could tell your 1996 self? </strong>— Jennifer Fox</p><p>Oh crap. Pretty much everything :simple_smile: First thing that comes to mind is Lean-based I think — don’t just build and build and build for the sake of building (or because customers want it all). Have a hypothesis, validate it with a minimal product, and then go from there.</p><p><strong>Q. How important is the “ One Metric That Matters” to the entire lean process? Can you tell us a bit more about that? —</strong> Eric Willis</p><p>Sure — the One Metric That Matters is both theory and practice. By that I mean it’s meant to get people thinking about simplifying the number of metrics and the complexity of the metrics they track. People get buried in the data and overwhelmed. So that’s the theory part if you will, in the sense that you’re not obligated to track a SINGLE metric!</p><p>The practice part though — you should really try and pick a single metric at a single point in time and use that as the barometer for how things are going. It creates really intense focus — which is often a huge failing of PMs and startups (a lack of focus). If you don’t know what metric matters how do you know if anything you do will make a difference?</p><p><strong>Q. What would you say is the most important thing in developing new metrics for new mediums? How are ideas best generated? </strong>— Jeff Needles</p><p>Great question. My first thought is this: What behaviors do you want to encourage? You have to understand those behaviors and the “loop of behavior” you’re trying to encourage (because you think it’ll create a real business) and that helps inform what metrics matter.</p><p>A good metric has to change your behavior as a company — so if you look at a metric and you don’t know what you’d do with it (as it changes) it’s not worth focusing on (at least too much)</p><p><strong>Q. Who are the best product minds in the game right now? Who do you most admire ?—</strong> Erik Torenberg</p><p>HHhhmmm…product minds. Evan @ Snapchat is one. I honestly don’t get Snapchat (I’m too old I think) but I read an article recently about it and loved it. There are some real instincts there about a target audience that are important. Paul Adams @ Intercom is great too.</p><p>I follow Laura Klein a lot b/c she’s awesome. Focused on Lean + customer development. Super funny. Straight to the point (some might describe her as rude <strong>haha</strong>)</p><p>Brandon Reti (@brandonr182) at Breather is solid too. (Disclosure: I’m an investor in Breather). He doesn’t have a big following or anything of the sort, but I think Breather is a very nice product.</p><p><strong>Q. What advice would you have for PH as we grow from your vantage point?</strong>— Erik Torenberg</p><p>PH is an interesting beast. It keeps growing, but I think many of us wonder where it will end up. I know we’ve had some private conversations around that. Scale + engagement are so tricky — you have to keep growing w/o sacrificing (too much) engagement. Then at some point you have to monetize.</p><p><strong>Q. What do you do when you hear a great product idea that’s not being implemented? —</strong> Jeff Needles</p><p>I think almost every idea is being implemented right now, but hundreds of people. So my first reaction is, “Who else is already doing this?” But I do get easily excited about a whole bunch of ideas.</p><p><strong>Q. What are the top 3 books you feel made you a better Product guru? </strong>— Jennifer Fox</p><p>4 Steps to the Epiphany blew my mind. I read it and said, “Holy fuck, I made every single one of the mistakes Steve Blank described.” Lean Startup by Eric was also huge for me, as was Running Lean. I think those are all pretty obvious choices though. Traction was a great book too.</p><p><strong>Q. Are you learning anything new these days or is history repeating itself? </strong>— Jonathan Ma</p><p>I’d like to think I’m learning all the time. I don’t think you can survive in a startup without that mindset. Like most people I also like to think I know what I know, but that gets challenged regularly too. Having said that it’s important to look at history also, because there’s plenty of context there.</p><p><strong>Q. I’m doing a bit of consulting and have been brought in to a couple larger 150+ people who throw the terms “lean” and “agile” around as buzz words, not really understanding what they are saying. What are your 2 favorite companies that have actually implemented successfully? — </strong>vbarnett323</p><p>I can’t really speak about companies I’ve worked with on the Lean front in terms of success stories (for disclosure reasons) but I think there are quite a few solid examples out there of companies genuinely putting efforts into place. There’s going to be a lot of “buzzword bingo” type nonsense in big companies re: Lean, there always is around pretty much everything in big companies.</p><p><strong>Q. Many talk about having a true north when it comes to metrics but for staring startups, that is not easy to find. Any tips on this? </strong>— abe238</p><p>Most early stage companies (depends on how early we’re talking) need to focus on engagement as their #1 thing. So the metric they have to focus on is around DAU, WAU, MAU…something in there; something that tells you “Yes in fact, people are using this product, and at a frequency that’s important/material.”</p><p><strong>Q. Favorite product idea that you think died too soon? —</strong> Jeff Needles</p><p>Oh man…I need more softball questions! ☺Honestly I find it more interesting how many ideas are now coming back that previously weren’t possible. Groceries online for example. Fact is, timing is so bloody important but almost impossible to manage. One of my startups that didn’t pan out (Standout Jobs) was in the recruitment space back in 2007–2010. Trying to build a recruiting company during a recession is a terrible idea.</p><p><strong>Q. What new product areas do you see being opened up with the new emerging platforms like Docker, Wearables, etc.? </strong>— Michael Buckbee</p><p>That’s a 20,000 foot view type question! Truth is I think we’re nearing a point where almost anything can be built at any time (short of really hard stuff like teleportation). And since that’s the case the real question is, what SHOULD be built?</p><p><strong>Q. What’s some advice around getting early traction that you think people should focus on? </strong>— Michael Buckbee</p><p>Focus on a tiny “string of behaviors” or “loop of behaviors” that you think matter; that you want to create, that you want to inject yourself into. So for example — I need people to do A, which leads to B, which results in them getting C, which encourages them to do A again. I know that sounds like it’s in the hypothetical, but if you can create that type of tiny loop in your product that’s what will get you early traction (or not; in which case you’re not solving an important enough problem)</p><p><a href="http://www.instigatorblog.com/tiny-addictive-new-behaviors/2013/07/02/">Tiny, New, Addictive Behaviors (or How to Build an Awesome Minimum Viable Product)</a></p><p>That’s a bit more expansive if you want to take a look.</p><p><strong>Q. What has been the book that has influenced you the most, not necessarily tech related? </strong>— vbarnett323</p><p>I’ve read a lot of Roald Dahl books to my kids. I don’t know if they’ve influenced me specifically, but it’s amazing when you read to your kids what they ask, how you see them think about it, the discussions it creates. That’s been extremely meaningful to me, if not influential.</p><p><strong>Q. A product manager has to rally the entire company around their vision and ensure that other departments execute on their end to get there. Do you have any advice as to how to foster the type of leadership skills to accomplish this? —</strong> jenhau</p><p>I’m loud. Loud helps. I’m not sure you can really have quiet PMs. But I think it comes by leading from example (so doing as much as you are talking/planning) and also being extremely good at communicating high level vision and how that relates to the tactical. Everyone has to understand how the little thing they’re doing actually has an impact/is relevant to the vision.</p><p>Actually, @jenhau “loud” is a bit facetious; really it’s about being an excellent communicator. Over-communicating. I also think PMs have to be hyper responsive so everyone feels like they’re receiving the attention they need. A PM is there to un-block people.</p><p><strong>haha yes, although the loud thing does help too, I find. ☺ Amen on the hyper-responsiveness. Sometimes I feel like the only person in the company that does not get to have a “Do Not Disturb” sign to get things done, but its essential for me to be available.</strong></p><p>Agreed. I’m hyper-responsive, but I also force myself to block calendar time to actually build product. You can’t be exclusively in responsive mode to people’s inquiries.</p><p><strong>Q. What product captures your attention the most these days? —</strong> Jonathan Ma</p><p>Interestingly, Timehop is one of them. After many years of posting on Facebook (and elsewhere), the stuff it’s surfacing starts to be really meaningful. I never shared anything out of Timehop until a few months ago.</p><p>I posted NewsGIF recently on PH too, which is news via animated GIFs. Silly, but there’s something there.</p><p><strong>Q. Do you have a different approach to Enterprise vs Consumer product developments? </strong>— Michael Buckbee</p><p>There are some differences; I think that question warrants a lot more thought + a blog post (I’m writing notes for myself…hold on…)</p><p>I don’t think there are HUGE differences between the two. But in enterprise you have to be much more responsive to customers (assuming they’re paying), whereas with a consumer product you just can’t respond attentively to every single inquiry/comment. Now, that doesn’t mean you should build every single request from enterprise customers either, but it’s a different way of bringing in and interpreting feedback.</p><p>I think for consumer apps the “problem” is also harder to understand. It’s more nuanced b/c often consumer apps are solving “how should I spend the next 5 minutes while I’m sitting on the toilet”, whereas Enterprise apps are solving “real” problems around business processes, etc.</p><p><strong>Q. is there’s anything as a PM that you purposely don’t balance? — </strong>Jonathan Ma</p><p>I think you always have to ask yourself when you’re building something what you are comfortable sacrificing/balancing and what you are not. Can you assume a bit more tech debt this go around? Can you refine the copy a bit later? Those are regular questions a PM has to ask. Same goes for whether you include a feature or not in a release. One thing I try very hard not to sacrifice/balance is whether something we’re doing fits within the brand / values / vision of the company.</p><p><strong>Q. What’s your thoughts on whitelabeling a product? </strong>— Michael Buckbee</p><p>If you’re asking about whether I think it’s OK to sell a whitelabeled product, I think the answer is, “It depends.” It’s not my go-to strategy, because you lose a lot of control (potentially) of customers. You want to, particularly early on, have insanely close access to your customers/users. Anything that takes you away from that is a risk.</p><p>Whitelabeling could be a reasonable Scaling strategy though; it just wouldn’t be my first go-to market play if I could avoid it.</p><p>It also tends to lead towards losing product roadmap control; because feedback will come from a customer to your partner and your partner will instinctively say “Build X immediately!” And since you don’t have any data one way or another to tell you otherwise, you build X.</p><p><strong>Q. Semi, related — any approaches you’d recommend for working in ecosystems? Like Varagesale works in ios/android etc. — </strong>Michael Buckbee</p><p>What do you consider an ecosystem? An AppStore? Something else?</p><p>Maybe Salesforce’s app store?</p><p><strong>Well, my product only lives in PaaS App Stores currently (like Heroku, Azure, etc.) but yes, more similar to SalesForces</strong></p><p>Got it. Generally I prefer products (if I’m thinking as an investor, for example) that have a direct to customer approach; again, because you have that direct link. You “own” the customer, which is extremely valuable. That can be true of things like Heroku too, but I think of those as distribution strategies, and in that case you have to measure the effort (to get into those distribution platforms) vs. the reward. So are you getting quality customers through X vs Y ecosystem? Some ecosystems have a fairly heavy price to get into, and may not lead to the results you want.</p><p><strong>Well, the typical take from selling through them (like Heroku) is 30% off the top</strong></p><p>Also, if they are in fact distribution channels, you should have already proven that your product is sticky and valuable to customers — then as you get into the later stages (in Lean Analytics parlance that would probably be “Virality”) you think about distribution, where these ecosystems are channels for you, just like any other.</p><p><strong>It’s the big version of the App Store, where Apple takes 30% of the price or IAP</strong></p><p>30% is fine, if the value of the customer is super high — LTV, etc.</p><p>So like any distribution channel you have to measure Cost vs. Reward.</p><p>In enterprise I would be looking at Lifetime Value, but also Time to Recoup Cost of Acquisition.</p><p>Some ecosystems are both a distribution / marketing channel and an ease-of-use play too of course. So if you can reach all of Heroku’s customers that’s marketing. If people come to you through other channels and then they can launch faster / get value from your product faster <strong>because</strong> you’re on Heroku that’s a different thing.</p><p>If you see a channel works well, the next step is to try and build a relationship with that channel. Network your way into Heroku for example and see if you can get some form of special treatment (distribution through email newsletters, etc.)</p><p>Disclosure: I used to work at Salesforce, which owns Heroku, but nothing I’m saying is specific to Heroku ☺</p><p><strong>It’s like you are reading my to do list</strong></p><p><strong>Q. Did you see the Heroku Salesforce Connector? It exposes SFDC data as a Postgres database in Heroku and it’s awesome </strong>— Michael Buckbee</p><p>I’ve been out of Salesforce for awhile, so I’ve been paying less attention, but they are getting better at connecting all the things over there.</p><p><strong>Q. Follow up question — any ideas what I could build with that since it’s now about a 100x easier to do integrations? —</strong> Michael Buckbee</p><p>Ha! I’ll have to leave the idea generation to you and others, I’m afraid. But if you love Heroku, then dig up Matt Creager (he’s an evangelist there) and tell him I said hi.</p><p>No matter how easy something is to build, you need to start with a problem; not a solution.</p><p>Hell, I can start asking questions too!</p><p>Has anyone read Lean Analytics? ☺ (I’m still surprised when people say YES)</p><p><strong>It’s definitely on my reading list. I just started a new company and so, I’m getting used to the new schedule. </strong>— Jennifer Fox</p><p>Anyone have a good recommendation for referral software (that helps you launch referral programs) in mobile/native apps?</p><p><strong>Sumo app I think is the name of it —</strong> vbarnett323</p><p><strong>Not referral, but I think VarageSale could use one of those “Enter your phone number and we’ll text you the install link” to boost Web -&gt; Mobile signups —</strong> Michael Buckbee</p><p>We’ve looked at it…we may do so again in the future. (Can’t really share too much on that front.)</p><p>What’s the 1 metric you’re tracking right now that you think is bogus and doesn’t matter?</p><p>How many metrics are on your main dashboard? (Go ahead, admit it…)</p><p><strong>Too funny, at Disney we had so many and now I track client acquisition cost and monthly revenue</strong> — vbarnett323</p><p><strong>You asked for metrics. Heres my redacted dashboard —</strong> Michael Buckbee</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*HsxqLAunuYU76ite.png" /></figure><p>That doesn’t look too bad. My suggestion would be to figure out what problem you have right now that’s paramount to your business and go solve that. Figure out what metric tells you if you are, and focus, focus, focus.</p><p>We have this concept in the book that a metric is like a squeeze toy — you focus on one area (squeeze) and it tells you where the next metric is / problem is to focus on</p><p><strong>Well, so my 1 true metric is number of platforms (like Heroku) that I’m on — as that has by far and away the biggest impact</strong></p><p>Hhhm…ok. I’m not sure that makes sense (I know very little about your business though) but that number just keeps going up. So if you’re on 5 platforms, that doesn’t tell me anything about the business. When you add the 6th, you’re just tracking that. And there’s no guarantee (I don’t think) that new platforms will perform like old ones.</p><p>My feeling is it would probably be a Number / Platform — i.e. # of signups / platform so yo could measure the efficacy of each platform. But even that’s an assumption that more platforms is better, whereas optimizing performance in 1 may give you more bang for your buck.</p><p>Good metrics (as I preach here…) are usually ratios or rates and they have to change your behavior. How does the # of platforms you’re on change your behavior?</p><p><strong>It’s </strong><a href="https://www.expeditedssl.com/"><strong>https://www.expeditedssl.com</strong></a><strong> — and you’re right. I can’t disclose numbers, but it’s just been outsize marketing return from being listed in platforms and deeply integrated than through any other form of marketing</strong></p><p><strong>I was looking at it from the risk side of things, if I’m just in one then it’s substantially more risk.</strong></p><p>OK. So platforms may prove to be the best marketing channel, and # of platforms may be impactful for the business, but it’s not a measure of success per se.</p><p>That’s fair. But really if you’re at the stage with your company where you’re focused on Revenue, then the One Metric That Matters has to be revenue-related. MRR for example.</p><p>In the book we talk a lot about knowing what Stage you’re at. And you take the Stage + the type of business you’re in and that’s how you find the OMTM</p><p><strong>I think that’s a fair recasting of it — and suspect that I may have tapped out how many signups I get from Heroku</strong></p><p>Signups is usually not a great metric either — because it doesn’t tell you if the people who sign up are doing what you want them to be doing</p><p>And it always goes up (albeit at different rates) — so early on if all you care about is getting people through the front door, then signups / time can be meaningful.</p><p><strong><em>I thought this was like my parents bookclub — we’d just show up and drink white wine and devolve into a Jenga tournament</em></strong></p><p><strong>I’m in a weird spot where 90%+ of my signups go from not knowing I existed to paying for ExpSSL monthly in a matter of a few minutes.</strong></p><p><strong>There’s no real trial other than setting it all up and then cancelling.</strong></p><p>I don’t know if that’s weird or a great f-cking business model ☺Nothing wrong with charging people money.</p><p><strong>“PH is an interesting beast. It keeps growing, but I think many of us wonder where it will end up. I know we’ve had some private conversations around that. Scale + engagement are so tricky — you have to keep growing w/o sacrificing (too much) engagement. Then at some point you have to monetize.” If you have a sec, talk more about that ☺ and what you’d think about if you were running PH —</strong> Erik Torenberg</p><p>Sure…so first you have an MVP and it’s super engaging (ideally — certainly PH was). But you need more users otherwise there’s no real business, so you start making efforts to scale. PH was invite only initially, then started opening up, then raised $$ and the PR hit. So now more people pile in. That’s awesome. But if engagement drops, or if new users don’t behave as well (engagement-wise) as old users then things can crumble.</p><p>So the challenge for social / consumer products is often how to grow (and grow quickly because you can’t monetize with small #s of users), without losing the engagement. Engagement will most certainly drop, it just has to. Churn will go up. But if engagement drops too much then the product loses its value to new users AND old users.</p><p>In a UCG (user generated content play) like PH as you grow you also have to worry about Quality — if quality tanks, engagement tanks, and who cares how many users you have.</p><p><strong>Q. I think Quora in many ways is a precursor to PH. What might you suggest Quora do (or should have done differently)? —</strong> Michael Buckbee</p><p>I don’t have any intimate knowledge of Quora, but it had a problem of moving from early adopters to later adopters. Engagement rocked early on when it was small, people knew each other, tech celebrities were answering questions — but they had to grow. And I think that’s been a struggle; emerging out of the “tech bubble”. I still see a lot of Quora activity (based on the emails I get), although I rarely use it.</p><p>PH will have a similar challenge.</p><p>One approach is to go into other verticals (which we see PH dabbling in, e.g. games) but then the question becomes whether or not those verticals/communities want to engage in the same way. That’s a tough question.</p><p><strong>I keep head nodding in agreement</strong> — Erik Torenberg</p><p>So for me, the big challenge is always GROWTH GROWTH GROWTH w/o killing engagement.</p><p>Turns out it’s freaking hard ☺</p><p>Btw, what this has made me realize is that there are multiple stages of Product/Market Fit. PH hit Product/Market fit very early on with a very small crowd. But as it grows there will be other Product/Market fits that it has to hit. It’s a continuum as opposed to a point in time.</p><p><strong>That’s a great point Ben, we are trying games, then books and these are new PH market fits (secretly , ha), new product market tests</strong></p><p>This has been a ton of fun — does anyone have any last questions before I call it a night? Plus I have a pile of requests from my team that I have to respond to! <strong>haha</strong></p><p><strong>That was awesome thank you for hanging out with us and thank you for you support throughout.</strong></p><p>Absolutely. PH is great. And glad I could participate.</p><blockquote>Lean Analytics is the missing piece of Lean Startup, with practical and detailed research, advice and guidance that can help you succeed faster in a startup or large organization.” <strong>Dan Martell, Founder Clarity.fm</strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>The lessons in Lean Analytics apply to organizations of all shapes and sizes, from small business to big government.” </em><strong><em>Jennifer Pahlka,Founder &amp; Exec. Director, Code for America</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>In Lean Analytics, Ben and Alistair have done a masterful job showing us how to use data and metrics to peer through the haze of uncertainty that surrounds creating new businesses and products. This book is a huge gift to our industry.” </em><strong><em>Zach Nies, Chief Technologist, Rally Software</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>The bad news is, there will always be people out there smarter than you. The good news is, Alistair and Ben are those guys. Using Lean Analytics will give you the edge you need.” </em><strong><em>Julien Smith, New York Times bestselling author of Trust Agents and The Flinch</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Lean Analytics will take you from Minimum Viable Product to Maximally Valuable Product. It’s as useful for product managers at today’s multi-billion dollar companies as it is for entrepreneurs who aspire to build those of tomorrow.” </em><strong><em>John Stormer, Senior Director of New Products, salesforce.com</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Entrepreneurs need their own reality distortion field to tilt at improbable windmills. But that delusion can be their undoing if they start lying to themselves. This book is the antidote. Alistair and Ben have written a much-needed dose of reality, and entrepreneurs who ignore this data-driven approach do so at their peril.” </em><strong><em>Brad Feld, Foundry Group Managing Director, TechStars co-founder</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*ygcD5SxePR5gyNXSP7FrQA.gif" /></figure><h3>Available on <a href="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1449335675/ref=as_li_tf_tl?ie=UTF8&amp;camp=1789&amp;creative=9325&amp;creativeASIN=1449335675&amp;linkCode=as2&amp;tag=leananalytics-20">Amazon</a></h3><blockquote>Marc Andreesen said “Markets that don’t exist don’t care how smart you are.” Whether you’re a startup founder trying to disrupt an industry, or an intrapreneur trying to provoke change from within, your biggest risk is building something nobody wants.</blockquote><blockquote>Lean Analytics can help. By measuring and analyzing as you grow, you can validate whether a problem is real, find the right customers, and decide what to build, how to monetize it, and how to spread the word. The core idea behind Lean Analytics is this: by knowing the kind of business you are, and the stage you’re at, you can track and optimize the One Metric That Matters to your startup right now.</blockquote><blockquote>Repeating this process helps you to overcome many of the risks inherent in early-stage companies or projects, avoid premature growth, and build atop a solid foundation of true needs, well-defined solutions, and satisfied customers.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=804069b78094" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/lean-analytics-ben-yoskovitz-804069b78094">Lean Analytics — Ben Yoskovitz</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Obstacle Is The Way — Ryan Holiday]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-obstacle-is-the-way-ryan-holiday-c86f613415a1?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c86f613415a1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 21:33:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-25T21:33:37.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am excited that my book The Obstacle Is The Way has been selected as May’s selection for the Product Hunt Book Club! I’ve written a Medium post to give you a quick introduction to the book and to facilitate discussion and conversation. Please let me know what you all think!</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/p/94a2af9a2ec5"></a></p><p><strong>I was recommended this book a few months back by a mentor of mine, along side The War of Art. Read them both; War of Art felt like disjoint, macho bravado to me (all “grr, punch your resistance in the face”), whereas Obstacle actually made sense. Especially for someone with depression, any philosophy that allows you to accept things will be broken and still give hope is a huge deal. I’m actually incorporating it into a talk I’m giving later in the year, since the whole approach of “yea, shit sucks, let’s work with that fact” will probably resonate really well with my slightly cynical target audience.</strong></p><p><strong>So, yea. If I had a little “stamp of approval” it’d be on this book. ☺ — </strong>Zoe Landon</p><p>That’s very kind of you. Thank you. The War of Art is one of my favorite books — and was actually quite influential in the writing of Obstacle. I definitely urge you to give it a second chance. It’s worth it.</p><p><strong>Hey Ryan, thanks for the great book and introducing me to stoicism ☺. When it comes to practicing stoicism, how has it manifested in your daily routines? —</strong> Bryan Lee</p><p>My daily routine is a little bit different than it might be if I were something other than a writer (and indeed it was when I had a job I had to go to). For instance, I don’t have to make time to read in the middle of the day. Or go for a walk. When I am struggling with some moral issue or working something out, I don’t write a note to myself like the stoics would, I write and publish those things online. These are sort of part of my job.</p><p>BUT a couple things I think are important:</p><p>I write in a journal each morning.<br>-I get up early, when it’s quiet and reflection is easier and there is less distraction.<br>-I do intense physical exercise at least once a day — because this is what the human body is intended for<br>-I got to therapy approximately once per week where I rigorously review and work on myself<br>-I try to read something philosophical or stoic before bed most nights<br>-I have a 200+ year old bust of Marcus Aurelius next to my computer. I have two 3D printed ones too…They are helpful reminders.</p><p><a href="http://observer.com/2014/06/how-3d-printing-is-bringing-an-ancient-art-form-back-to-the-future/">How 3D Printing Is Bringing An Ancient Art Form Back to the Future</a></p><p><strong>Hi Ryan, thanks for the AMA! Funny to see your approach, as I was recently thinking about what cynicism from Diogenes could bring to entrepreneurship ☺ Mostly about self-sufficiency, and how to focus on reducing needs rather than expanding resources, which could be a prime for any startuper.</strong></p><p><strong>Despite stoicism inheriting from cynicism, its self-sufficiency concept is quite different, iirc — something more in the stance of detachment. Do you think this could apply as well to entrepreneurship, and if so, how? — </strong>Olivier El Mekki</p><p>Diogenes would probably be a little disruptive to entrepreneurship. From what I understand, he lived in a clay pot and loved to masturbate in public. He’s a genius for sure, and I love his one liners, but that’d still be hard to overcome.</p><p>There is a line in Juvenal where he says that “there’s only a shirt between” the Stoics and the Cynics. Essentially meaning that the philosophies are very similar but the Stoics did not have the same disdain for luxury and the trappings of society.</p><p>In any case, to answer your question perhaps a better word than detachment is indifference. In stoicism we see a lot of the ethics focusing on doing the right thing for the right reasons — with an indifference to the results. Help a friend because you want to help a friend, not because you want something out of it. Work hard to build your company because it’s fulfilling your potential and improving the world, not because you need to be famous, important or rich.</p><p><strong>&gt; Diogenes would probably be a little disruptive to entrepreneurship. From what I understand, he lived in a clay pot and loved to masturbate in public. He’s a genius for sure, and I love his one liners, but that’d still be hard to overcome.</strong></p><p><strong>Sure, it’s not the part we could focus on ☺ But then, there’s the whole “dropping everything that is not necessary” part and the cosmopolitanism, which is surprisingly close to the nomad trend among entrepreneurs.</strong></p><p><strong>The ethic perspective you develop is interesting. I’ve always wondered if true success as a person can actually happen if you’re looking for it. But past wanting to be personally successful, there is also the desire for our company to be successful. Do you think company success can be achieved as well without actively looking for it (that is, without pondering how to make the company successful, and only think about what it could bring to the world)?</strong></p><p>There is a line from Viktor Frankl that happiness cannot be pursued it must ENSUE. I think that’s a great way of looking at it.</p><p>Now to get really practical and blunt: It really is possible to will certain kinds of success into existence. Brute force and energy will get you there. The problem is that once you arrive you realize it’s never going to be what you thought it was going to be.</p><p><strong>Thank you so much Ryan for doing this AMA! I have 2 questions-<br>1) when evaluating your choices (ie. Where will I find the good or bad?) that lead you to action, how heavily do you weigh the good/bad for the society? 2) When applying Stoicism to entrepreneurs, who would you say is the best at leading by action today?<br>I know the 1st question is a source of endless debate, but is good/ bad the same as right/wrong? —</strong> Virginia Barnett</p><p>What the stoics try to remind us over and over against is this concept of “what injures the bee, injures the hive.” An example off the top of my head. You build a company that is immensely profitable for you, but externalizes a good deal of its costs onto the world (and thus making it worse). A lot of web publishers fall into the boat. They publish media that is cheap to produce but expense for society (it’s cheap, shitty, untrue, etc etc). All of this leads to a general decline in our culture — the culture that those same entrepreneurs live in. I guess I would ask then: What exactly is the point? You make a lot of money personally so you can afford to live in a bubble that blocks out the shittiness of the world that you helped create?</p><p>I suppose my point here is: Helping yourself at the expense of other people is very often a one step forward, two steps back scenario. In which case, it’s rather self-defeating.</p><p><strong>What has been most interesting/surprising thing you’ve learned since releasing the book? —</strong> Erik Torenberg</p><p>1) Writing a book about stoicism is a bit inconvenient if you’d ever like to complain about anything ever again. People are always trying to make me ‘live up to my own words’ which is a total pain.</p><p>2) Just how many people have followed the precepts in their life but didn’t know that there was a word or a philosophy for it. It’s been really cool to connect with those people and reintroduce them to a philosophy they already KNEW but couldn’t articulate.</p><p>3) Just last week I read a new passage in Marcus Aurelius’s Meditations — one I have read dozens and dozens of times — that I never realized better articulates my own thesis better than I could have hoped. Funny how that works.</p><p>“–But there are external obstacles…</p><p>Not to behaving with justice, self-control, and good sense.</p><p>–Well, but perhaps to some more concrete action.</p><p>–But if you accept the obstacle and work with what you’re given, an alternative will present itself–another piece of what you’re trying to assemble. Action by action.”</p><p><strong>Ryan how have you used these ideas in your work life? —</strong> Andrew Warner</p><p>I would say there is not a day that goes by that I do NOT use them. From beginning to end, there is something in stoicism to think about.</p><p>Starting with this line from Marcus: <a href="http://ryanholiday.net/motivation/">http://ryanholiday.net/motivation/</a></p><p>ending with this line from Epictetus:</p><p>“As you kiss your son good night whisper to yourself, ‘He may be dead in the morning.’ (the point being to practice and anticipate misfortune instead of pretending that it could never happen to you. To enjoy the things you have as you have them)</p><p><strong>Why are your hands covering your face in you profile photo? —</strong> Andrew Warner</p><p>One of my favorite musicians Jackie Greene did it in a photo once and I’ve always liked the photo. A photographer at American Apparel took a version of it for the back cover of my first book, Trust Me I’m Lying and I use it for a lot of stuff now. My wife and I did a version at our wedding too. It’s my favorite.</p><p><a href="https://instagram.com/p/zxIbemleQv/">Instagram photo by Ryan Holiday * Mar 3, 2015 at 1:44pm UTC</a></p><p><strong>Are you still working on a book with Cash Money? —</strong> Ross Simmonds</p><p>This is going to sound weird, but I don’t know. I’ve spent a lot of time with Birdman and Slim and I’ve written the intro but obviously their world has been in a bit of a state of flux recently. I’m basically just waiting for word from them (and some other minor contract details) and haven’t gotten any quite a while. I’m still excited about the book and their story. I think they are two of the most underrated entrepreneurs in the history of the music industry.</p><p><strong>Whoa. can you hint anymore about their story? Been a ton of music entrepreneurs — why them? —</strong> Erik Torenberg</p><p>In 1997, Birdman had offers from every major label to buy Cash Money (basically the same thing that Russell Simmons and Puffy both got offered). Instead of selling, he and his brother signed a distribution deal with Universal — a $30M advance with a 85/15 royalty split in his favor. Cash Money has since sold something like 500M songs. Just think about the acts that have graced their roster: Juvenile, Lil Wayne, Nicki Minaj, Drake, Kevin Rudolf, Big Tymers, Rich Gang, DJ Khaled, etc etc They are the most successful independent label in the history of music.</p><p>When Jay Z rapped “own your masters, slaves!” he was talking about something that Cash Money has done from day one. Every other hip hop mogul has gotten rich from all the ancillary products — clothing, clubs, headphones, beverages etc. Birdman and his brother Slim (who is the quiet one) are worth about $500M almost entirely from music. And that’s just what their worth now — Michael Jackson’s estate (which was comprised mostly of copyrights to famous songs) has made something like $700M since his death. Same growth will happen for Cash Money…except the guys are in their 40s.</p><p><strong>Wanted to first thank you for the books you’ve written. “Trust me, I’m Lying” has completely changed my outlook on media and made me much more aware of how to see how the media manipulates. That being said, if you could wave a magic wand and make any change to the way that media is done, what would you change and why?</strong> — Daniel Kao</p><p>I’d bring RSS back as a major consumption/delivery mechanism. Ideally, with some sort of paid subscription component too. I wrote a piece on the first part of that for Medium a while back:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/p/7b1a7ddb6ffe">Our Regressive Web</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c86f613415a1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-obstacle-is-the-way-ryan-holiday-c86f613415a1">The Obstacle Is The Way — Ryan Holiday</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Powerhouse — Steve Levine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-powerhouse-steve-levine-8b9c8c47d520?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b9c8c47d520</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 21:33:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-25T21:33:24.422Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Q. What is it like to have the weight of the world on your technical shoulders? And what is keeping us from getting a super-battery? To find out, Steve LeVine spent two years in a lab with a half-dozen battery geniuses. —</strong> Erik Torenberg<br>Probably not since Alessandro Volta himself has so much public attention been lavished on the battery. Like then (the first decade of the 19th century), that’s included big hopes, some inflated claims, and much hoopla. Inventing one that is much cheaper and far more powerful is truly a big deal. But it’s not the usual science or technology story — no one knows when or even whether we are going to get a great battery. Last night, however, I replenished my own sense of reality by catching up on the story of the light bulb. Humphrey Davy first invented a facsimile of an incandescent bulb in 1802. But it took almost eight decades for Edison to create the one that went commercial. We need to relax a bit.</p><p><strong>Q. What was one awesome thing (or several) that you learned while writing the book that isn’t included in the book? —</strong> Ben Tossell</p><p>Toward the end of the research, I found out — and Elon Musk hints at this — that the answer to getting to the goals of the super battery can be otherwise reached. That is, you might not have to make the big leap in the discovery lab — you might achieve at least the cost goals by getting a lot better at manufacturing batteries.</p><p>I am looking at that now — at entrepreneurs who are trying to reinvent how batteries are made.</p><p><strong>Q. Is there anything that surprised you about John Goodenough? I think it’s remarkable that he’s still grinding it out at 92 years old. Did you come away from this with the feeling that he’s close to solving the problem of making an anode out of pure lithium or sodium metal? —</strong> Eric Willis</p><p>Ah, John Goodenough.<br>Renaissance man and decent person besides.</p><p>I did have the sense that at least he thinks he is onto an answer to the anode side of the battery.</p><p>At 92, he is focused entirely on lithium metal, and — though he is careful now about his secrets so he did not tell me precisely his approach — he thinks he has a decent shot at figuring out how to fashion lithium metal into an anode without it turning into an explosion while a car is rumbling down a freeway.</p><p><strong>Q. What was the most surprising thing you learned while writing this book Steve? — </strong>Erik Torenberg<br>The most surprising aspect of batteries, in my opinion, is how careful we have to be about what we hear. It turns out that many or most of the “breakthroughs” that we read about are not quite what they are implying; there is an invisible “yes, but … “ embedded — or should be embedded — into these announcements. Some of them are simply narrow — one aspect of the battery is improved, but a host of complications are left unattended to. But others are outright whoppers — they are exaggerations or deceit. That was a surprise and a lesson I carry with me.</p><p><strong>Q.</strong> <strong>I’m sure you had an exciting journey writing this, but if you had to pick a favorite quote or passage, what would it be and is there a hidden or more I depth story behind it? —</strong> Virginia Barnett</p><p>The story is character-driven, and so I am driven to reply from that space. The most interesting character from the vantage of a writer — the hardest to write about because of the strong emotions he elicits in others — was Khalil Amine, one of the two battery geniuses at Argonne. I heard no end of gripes about him, most or all of them deeply and sincerely felt. Ultimately, I concluded that Amine’s critics had him wrong. The gripes that is were problems not with him, but with the gripers themselves. Those passages weave through the book.</p><p>Amine is an immigrant from Morocco. His wife is Chinese. But his style is learned from years working in Japan. As I say, a fascinating window into invention that I did not expect.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b9c8c47d520" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-powerhouse-steve-levine-8b9c8c47d520">The Powerhouse — Steve Levine</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lean Enterprise — Trevor Owens]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-lean-enterprise-trevor-owens-8f9e55f88ce1?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8f9e55f88ce1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 21:33:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-25T21:33:13.487Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Trevor Owens is an author and entrepreneur. He’s the CEO &amp; Founder of Javelin, creators of the global Lean Startup Machine workshop series that has trained tens of thousands of startup founders and innovators from Google, GE, News Corp, Intuit, and others, start new businesses around the world.</strong></p><p><strong>In his bestselling book, The Lean Enterprise (published by Wiley), Owens details new approaches for corporations to structure innovation teams and bring new products to market. Owens’s work has been featured in national media outlets including Forbes, Bloomberg, Fast Company, Business Insider, Mashable, and others. Trevor will give a short intro and then we’ll get right into the Q+A</strong></p><p>Ready. Thanks for having me</p><p><strong>Q. Trevor, can you give some backstory behind Javelin —</strong> Erik Torenberg</p><p>Well, I fell into the Lean Startup community a bit by accident. I tried to start several businesses and was in business school. I was looking for a technical co-founder and so I started organizing lot’s of events in the NY Tech community, this was in 2010, actually, more like 2009. I hosted the largest hackathon in NYC at the time and I found that hackathons were very bad at helping people get an idea off the ground mainly because 90% of the projects didn’t have the customer in mind. Dave McClure introduced me to Eric Ries, this was a year before the book. Basically, I hosted the first LSM for fun, and it ended up blowing my mind at how much faster and better it was for going from idea to startup than either hackathons or business plan competitions. In 2012 I decided to do it full time but my goal was never to build a consulting company</p><p><strong>So in theory you could have written the lean startup!</strong></p><p>Ha no</p><p><strong>As in you were thinking about this before it came cult lore</strong></p><p>Definitely not. Actually I learned a lot from Eric Ries and others in the community.</p><p>So Javelin is a software company as one person mentioned. We went through Techstars NYC in 2013, have raised $2M to date from Mark Suster of Upfront Ventures, Dave McClure, and a bunch of other great people. Our main product today is QuickMVP: <a href="http://quickmvp.com/">quickmvp.com</a> which we’re about to release some big improvements to. So it’s going to change a lot but we also built a project management software and had to pivot away from that.</p><p>I can talk a lot about entrepreneurship as much as I can about how to do entrepreneurship in a large company. We were the first people to do serious work with corporations at bringing Lean methods inside the org and helping employees be more entrepreneurial it was fascinating to me how different the perspective is in the corporate world and how the reference point is way different than what we know being in the startup community and the whole idea behind The Lean Enterprise is that process is not enough that you need to rethink strategy, compensation, and legal structures.</p><p>For example, the typical way innovation happens in a large org. First of all, it’s a very incremental focus — Corporations don’t realize that startups grow so quickly because they make products that are 10x better and they rethink the industries paradigm. Most executives think their brilliant by coming up with a new product that is 10% better than what their company already does and in fact that’s the pressure inside a large organization. Second, most corporations try to innovate by preventing failure by any means neccessary ie. hiring 100 people and investing $30M in a single app like News Corp did in 2010 with The Daily. The Lean Enterprise advocates for a much more bottoms-up approach where you fund lots of employee projects as experiments through a structure we call an Innovation Colony and spin-out promising projects to protect them from corporate anti-bodies. In addition, this approach allows you to compensate employees like entrepreneurs with real equity and they can bring in outside investors who bring connections, expertise, and help value the companies, this is what Hulu did. It was a spin-out of NBC and partnered with NewsCorp they also sold 10% of the equity to outside investors. The venture investors helped make sure things were run like a startup, that it had the right talent and that talent was compensated like a startup. I think that’s it for the first question.</p><p><strong>Q. How does the lean startup methodology fit within traditional big businesses? —</strong>Jeff Needles</p><p>At a high level there are two types of innovation: sustaining and disruptive innovation. Sustaining focuses on incremental product improvements and cutting costs through process improvements. LS can help with that but most companies do it well enough. It’s not too different from what they teach in business school. Almost no companies can successfully do disruptive innovation and be at the front of the next major wave of technology and societal changes. IMO LS helps the most there because LS is a process for managing uncertainty.</p><p><strong>Q. In reference to the lean process and innovation what is more important speed or thoroughness — </strong>Jim Payne</p><p>I wouldn’t say one is more important than the other, but it depends how you define thoroughness. Obviously you need a certain amount of both, I’d give a slight edge to speed. You only need enough thoroughness to convince yourself something won’t work — it’s hard. Logical thinking and the scientific method help with this a lot. For most people, they could probably be 10x less thorough and have the evidence to prove something won’t work</p><p>For example, I once started a scooter company and I spent 6 months and $10k working on this company and I didn’t think I was thorough enough. I thought, “Wow I am a bad sales person and my partners are slackers” lol. But when I took the LS approach I targeted the riskiest assumption of the business and I said “If people don’t work this way, this business could not be successful”, and by framing it that way, in 1 day I was able to prove the business wouldn’t work — which is what we do at LSM workshops to help entrepreneurs frame their thinking so that they can logically conclude a business won’t work. Human beings have infinite capacity to rationalize and entrepreneurship is an art in insignificant data</p><p><strong>Makes sense I guess that is what quickmvp helps with</strong></p><p>Yeah, quickmvp is one part of the puzzle ☺</p><p><strong>I’ve seen the scooter company story somewhere else, and noticed it on your quickmvp sales page. Can’t remember which book it was in though.</strong></p><p>Yeah it’s here: <a href="http://validationboard.com/">validationboard.com</a>. Our new tool is here though: <a href="http://javelin.com/experiment-board.html">javelin.com/experiment-board.html</a> — X board is easier to use than the V Board but we keep the website up incase you prefer it.</p><p><strong>Q. What was your experience going through Tech Stars? Do you think it played a critical role in your success? — </strong>Eric Willis</p><p>So with Techstars — it’s an amazing program. I highly recommend accelerators if you are trying to raise money, makes your life a lot easier. The challenge with raising money is always that few investors tell you what they really think about your business, they just lead you on forever because you are basically an option call for them and fundraising is all about convincing investors you have a good business, in the earliest stages most people are raising off of an idea. Very few people have viral growth like PH did ☺</p><p>So Techstars helps you get the right feedback to improve your pitch, and Demo Day is a forcing function to get people to invest. So TS is really awesome. It’s different from YC in that; #1 it’s in NYC which was important to us at the time and #2 it’s a small cohort, 10 companies vs 50.</p><p>Erik, how many were in your cohort at YC?</p><p><strong>90, or 85, or 95. somewhere in there lol. The next class was over 100</strong></p><p><strong>Q. Have you ever had an experience where a slowly rolled out business model trumped someone trying to do something similar, sloppier and faster?? —</strong> Jeff Umbro</p><p>IDK… honestly I can’t think of THAT many situations where two startups actually competed w each other in a meaningful way. Most startups never make it to product market fit. I can’t imagine being slow or sloppy is a good thing in either case</p><p><strong>I’m thinking of situations (and I know these are exceptional) like SpaceX vs. Boeing</strong></p><p>Ah, you mean corp vs startup?</p><p><strong>Sure</strong></p><p>I think there are very few corp innovation success stories that would impress anyone in the startup world. I’ve never seen a slowly rolled out business model succeed let alone beat a startup. I think the reason is because the most valuable commodity in disruptive innovation is a community of early adopters. If you’re sloppy but fast and can earn the loyalty of the early adopters in a new market. There’s no go-to-market path for a slow and steady team instead of competing with nothing you’re forcing people to have to decide to switch.</p><p>So being fast to market allows you to also iterate and pivot to the right answer first. The most fascinating counter-example may be Slack bc there was already Hip Chat, Flowdock, etc. Part of it could be that team communication is such a large market that it didn’t matter, there’s also myspace and facebook etc. but I’m not sure it’s a corollary to a slow corp approach vs. fast sloppy startup approach.</p><p><strong>Maybe slow was the wrong ask. I meant more companies that are moving slower to make sure they get it right but your answer encompassed that</strong></p><p>IMO you only get it right by experimentation if you’re doing something innovative that is</p><p><strong>Q. How do you define a successful MVP? Especially when I imagine corporations must expect a lot — </strong>Maxime Pico</p><p>A successful MVP is one that gets you the most learning with the least effort. I don’t define it as a product but as an experiment. So, a good MVP helps you learn something that changes the game for your business / startup with as little effort as possible, so it depends on your context but you’re trying to change your own thinking ie. if you’re doing an A/B test and you’re testing the headline copy, try writing an alternative that you think should not work, under any circumstances because if it does work, or if there’s no change then you’ve invalidated yourself in a way</p><p>Here’s the best video I’ve found on it:</p><p>An MVP should test your riskiest assumption ie. do people really need this? or, do they need this more than something else?</p><p><strong>Q. How many products have validated through QuickMVP? —</strong> Jon Archer</p><p>I don’t have the exact number but a few hundred. we’re almost at 5,000 startup ideas tested on the platform since the fall.</p><p><strong>Q. How many ventures have you been involved in and how many “fails” aka learning opportunities versus revenue positive ventures? — </strong>V Barnett</p><p>I tried to start probably half a dozen companies over 5 years before starting LSM, doing things the non-lean way. LSM is my first successful revenue generating business and does almost $2M a year. QuickMVP we just launched and does over $250k a year</p><p><strong>Q. What are some of the most challenging issues you ran into trying to teach enterprises about innovating using lean tactics? — </strong>Eric Willis</p><p>There are more than I can count. I think the biggest is just how dramatically different the incentives are. and by different I mean bad. entrepreneurs do what they do because of the incentives and because of what they value. ie. having equity, changing the world, having autonomy, etc</p><p><strong>Q. One challenge I have seen with Lean Startup methods, especially “quick” ones is — is how do you reach actual, potential customers sufficient to test a key hypothesis (and related, how do you identify them well enough to know who they are/how to reach them) — </strong>Shannon Clark</p><p>It’s definitely hard. In my experience I’ve found the best way is your personal network. I never try to think idea → customers, I always think who am I → who’s around me → ideas → problems → solutions. It’s a more pragmatic approach but my point is that founder / market fit is more important than product /market fit, you can never conclusively invalidate an idea. You can only invalidate it in one way, namely, for yourself and for the set of customers you though were most likely to use it. For this reason it’s an art as much as it is a disciplined science some hacks you can use though are networking in a community that’s growing ie. like I did with Lean Startup and the tech community so you latch on to a growing thing. Other than that — google, facebook, and twitter are the best channels they are high volume and repeatable also cheap if you know what you’re doing but cheap is not a positive. Most of the time you get what you pay for, so an expensive keyword on google means people are making money from it, an inexpensive keyword on google means they are not because you know without a doubt what results your money is getting you when it comes to these channels. The caveat is that it may be inexpensive because you’re idea is so original there is no competition yet but everything is context specific. 99% of people at LSM find their first customers on the streets of a busy city or in a starbucks or from a referral because those methods take 10 minutes rather than days or weeks. Also, you’ll never get statistically significant in lean it’s also not the point bc you’re trying to predict the future if you actually got statistically significant data it would say DON’T DO THIS</p><p>You can identify early adopters in one specific way. Early adopters look like this:</p><p><a href="http://d.ibtimes.co.uk/en/full/1372597/cookie-monster.jpg">http://d.ibtimes.co.uk/en/full/1372597/cookie-monster.jpg</a></p><p>When they hear you’re idea they get emotionally excited so it’s never about what people say it’s about what they do.</p><p><strong>Q. What gave you the idea to write books? — </strong>Jim Payne</p><p>A couple reasons, firstly because I was always frustrated when working with large companies even after several days of coaching I couldn’t teach them everything they needed to know to be successful so I thought the only way was to write a book so in my coaching I could tell them, “Read this before we talk”. The other reason which I didn’t realize until later is because I’m probably the youngest person who does this and I felt I had to prove myself to show that I knew what I was talking about and let people evaluate me based on my ideas and my research.</p><p>Great. Well thanks everyone for the thoughtful questions.</p><p><strong>THANKS for taking the time today. This is one of my favorite AMA’s i’ve seen and way to set the tone for the book club one ☺</strong></p><blockquote><em>“Presents a framework for companies to create an environment that empowers the greatest entrepreneurial talent to thrive inside the organization, retaining the greatest innovative minds and reaping the benefits of their greatest inventions.”<br></em><strong><em>Brad Smith, Intuit President &amp; CEO</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>“Corporations who miss this book have their days numbered.”</em><strong><em><br>Dave McClure, 500 Startups</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>“Provides savvy insights on the organizational structures, systems, and processes that will maximize success odds with corporate entrepreneurship.”<br></em><strong><em>Professor Thomas Eisenmann, Harvard Business School</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>“New businesses aren’t willed into existence by executives with brilliant ideas and big budgets. Incentives are everything in innovation and </em>The Lean Enterprise<em> sets the record straight.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>David Cohen, CEO Techstars</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/241/1*H4uFap_fL1dY2WIebp6oNw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Available on <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Lean-Enterprise-Corporations-Innovate-Startups/dp/1118852176/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1431166519&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=the+lean+enterprise">Amazon</a></h3><p><a href="http://www.leanenterprisebook.com/">Lean Enterprise</a></p><blockquote><strong><em>#1 Best Seller in Lean Management</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>The first and most comprehensive book on bringing the startup mindset into large organizations. Forget vague notions of creating an “innovative culture.” This book reveals the methodologies, tools, and incentive structures guiding the world’s largest organizations to reclaim their innovation prowess.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>Even in a tough economic climate, small startups have found ways to create innovative products in shockingly short timeframes. So why should larger, more established companies take notice? Because they have everything to gain when they examine and adopt the process, strategies, and mentality of high-growth startups. The guidelines in this book will help companies shake the lethargy, bureaucracy, and power struggles that plague large organizations.</blockquote><blockquote>Respected thought leaders in lean startup methodologies, Owens and Fernandez cover successful enterprise product development, establishment of innovation labs, and acquisition and integration of startups.</blockquote><blockquote>Essential reading for product managers, directors, senior executives, and even board members of Fortune 2000 companies</blockquote><blockquote>Presents the tools and methodologies large businesses need to compete with a new generation of highly-empowered startups</blockquote><blockquote>Identifies the forces that stunt growth in large enterprises</blockquote><blockquote>Offers a comprehensive approach for developing exciting products and opening vast new markets</blockquote><blockquote>Don’t be mystified by the success of startups. Master the methods of this new era and compete on a level playing field.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8f9e55f88ce1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-lean-enterprise-trevor-owens-8f9e55f88ce1">The Lean Enterprise — Trevor Owens</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Most Good You Can Do — Peter Singer]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-most-good-you-can-do-peter-singer-6a51daf1745a?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6a51daf1745a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 21:33:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-25T21:33:01.967Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Q. What do you think will be the role of “social businesses” (American or otherwise) in creating solutions for issues like: water scarcity, poverty, or education in the world at large, and how important do you think they will be at creating positive changes in the lives of those affected? — </strong>Taimoor Bajwa</p><p>Social enterprises have a lot of potential, but we have to see if they are really going to reach the people in greatest need. So far, the verdict isn’t yet in.</p><p><strong>Q. In recent light of decisions made in New York regarding chimpanzees and habeas corpus, what do you think the future discussion of animal rights will conclude for the “captivity” of wild animals in zoos and research facilities, also what elements of “intelligence” will play a role in decisions regarding custodial authority? — </strong>Taimoor Bajwa</p><p>I’m hopeful that courts will eventually rule that they have legal standing. This is likely to come first with animals like chimps, but perhaps in the long run it will spread.</p><p>But the meat industry is so huge and influential, that first we have to undermine it, by developing plant-based alternatives that are healthier, more environmentally sustainable, and that eliminate the cruelty of factory farming.</p><p><strong>To add my unsolicited 2 cents to the point about the farming industry…</strong></p><p><strong>In addition to cultivating the vitally needed alternatives I feel the disconnect between the consumers’ awareness and the factory farms’ obligations to maximize profits plays a significant role on the demand for meat based on the fact that the agents are so far removed from what is required to get their steak on the shelves for under $10 a pound; this relationship can be continued with fruits and vegetables in that commercial farming has irreversibly harmed soil life and demand for fresh has lead to landfills of food waste.</strong></p><p><strong>I feel that one who is not prepared to take an animal’s life, should not be prepared to eat from it, much less create so much waste from the act, furthermore, corporate agriculture’s influence should be met by consumer education and awareness. —</strong> Taimoor Bajwa</p><p><strong>Q. Presuming that people who run charities / non-profits are Good People, what factors make so many of them ineffective? And how might we go about changing that? — </strong>Jonathan Archer</p><p>In contrast to the business sector, charities have not had to demonstrate their effectiveness. They can get away with emotional appeals and a few photos of smiling kids. The Effective Altruism movement is changing that. So supporting the EA movement, and donating to charities recommended on websites like GiveWell.org and thelifeyoucansave.org are good ways of changing things.</p><p><strong>Q. What do you think about competition between both non-profits and B corps and then for profit businesses in the same field? — </strong>Ross Rojek</p><p>Competition is good. But we need independent assessments of which organizations — whether non-profits or for-profits — are really doing the most good, eg to help people in extreme poverty.</p><p><strong>Q. You’d previously used an example (the details are off, but hopefully not important to the point) suggesting that if you were willing to ruin a pair of $200 shoes to jump in the water and save a drowning child, which most people would, you should be willing to forego a purchase of equal value in order to instead contribute $200 to a trustworthy charity that would save a child’s life. While I happen to agree with the conclusion, your reasoning in coming to that conclusion confuses me. One can easily use the same reasoning to argue that if you weren’t willing to forego a $200 purchase to contribute to the charity, you also shouldn’t jump in the water and ruin your shoes to save the drowning child? The thought experiment is focusing on the shared details of two scenarios (e.g., financial loss, and lives being saved), and suggesting that it is a mistake to let the other details (e.g., proximity to life-saving event) to affect our choices/preferences. As if to consign these latter details to some realm that is outside logic or rationality when, in fact, it makes all the difference to human beings in the real world; they’re part and parcel of how we decide what we should and shouldn’t value in the world. I’m not suggesting that there’s anything wrong with appealing to someone’s reason or intuitions to have them change their preferences to bring them in line with other, firmer preferences they may have or by making the distal effects of saving a child psychologically salient, but to suggest that they have to change their preferences to make them logically consistent in this very abstracted way, seems to take advantage of a confusion in order to get them to change their preferences. — </strong>Yaniv Eyny</p><p>The point of the example is just to get people to see that there is a problem with our intuitions that needs to be sorted out. I’ve given more argument, in several of my writings, as to why we should go in the direction of saving the child AND helping the global poor.</p><p><strong>Q. What advice do you have for high school/college students who want to be effectively altruistic but don’t have jobs yet and therefore lack the financial means available to many in your TED audience? —</strong> Hugh Jones</p><p>It’s going to depend on what the company does but everyone can give to an effective charity.</p><p>Form an EA group in your school or on your college campus. Help to educate yourselves and others about issues like global poverty, climate change, factory farming, etc, and about the different groups working on these issues. You can volunteer for some of the organizations working on these issues. And even if you don’t have much money, you can still start giving a small amount to an effective charity, to get into the habit of doing so. Then when later on you have more, it will come more easily to you.</p><p><strong>Q. What’s more ethical: taking a job you’re really passionate about but doesn’t make as much money vs. a job you don’t feel passionate about but that would earn you tons of money that you could then donate to someone else? —</strong> Erik Torenberg</p><p>People often advise “follow your passion” but I don’t think that’s always good advice. It might be better to take the high-paying job and do more good that way. You might develop a passion for doing good, and helping effective charities. Or it might depend on what each job does, apart from the money you earn. Anyway, people’s passions change. Think about your basic values, and I hope they will lead you to want to do the most good.</p><p>Ophelie Lechat Head of Content &amp; Community, SitePoint<br>Hi Peter, thanks for doing this AMA. What advice do you have for the workers and managers of for-profit companies (specifically technology workers), who may not be eligible for b-corp status, but want to integrate effective altruism into their work?</p><p><strong>Q. For people in SF who notice the stark contrasts in quality of life among its residents, how do you prioritize helping locally vs helping globally? — </strong>Erik Torenberg</p><p>It may sound tough, but you can do much more good per $ by helping people globally.</p><p><strong>Q. I have many inspired, passionate, and good friends who can’t find their niche in the job market. They’re non-technical. How would you advise folks to explore their passions without missing out on the big things in life that require moneys (buying a home, starting a family, etc)? —</strong> Narek Khachatryan</p><p>They need to keep trying. We still need non-technical people, with good human relations skills. And they may need to lower their material expectations, too. It’s possible to have a home and start a family without a great deal of money.</p><p><strong>Q. Some younger folks who are overqualified to help mentor youth and children don’t feel qualified to give back, like they haven’t earned their badges or credibility yet. Is this just doubt, or should younger folks wait until they’ve achieved some substantial accomplishments in life in order to “inspire” and help? — </strong>Narek Khachatryan</p><p>They should do what they can do now, and not wait.</p><p>I’m out of time, everyone, sorry.. Thanks for the questions, and I hope you found the answers helpful. For more info, please get hold of The Most Good You Can Do, or go to <a href="http://www.thelifeyoucansave.org/">www.thelifeyoucansave.org</a> or <a href="http://www.effectivealtruism.org/">www.effectivealtruism.org</a>.</p><blockquote><em>“An optimistic and compelling look at the positive impact that giving can have on the world.”<br></em><strong><em>Bill and Melinda Gates</em></strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*fdMO15B2qnpjjkvyiLkIFQ.png" /></figure><p><a href="http://www.alibris.com/booksearch?isbn=9780300180275"><strong>Alibris</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://www.amazon.com/Most-Good-You-Can-Effective/dp/0300180276/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1423189189&amp;sr=1-1&amp;keywords=9780300180275"><strong>Amazon</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://www.indiebound.org/book/9780300180275"><strong>IndieBound</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/books/search?keywords=9780300180275&amp;pageSize=10"><strong>Indigo</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://search.barnesandnoble.com/booksearch/isbnInquiry.asp?r=1&amp;afsrc=1&amp;ISBSRC=Y&amp;ISBN=9780300180275"><strong>Barnes &amp; Noble</strong></a><strong> |<br></strong><a href="http://www.overstock.com/search/?keywords=9780300180275&amp;searchtype=Header"><strong>Overstock.com</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://www.booksamillion.com/search?query=9780300180275&amp;where=All"><strong>Books-a-Million</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://www.powells.com/biblio?isbn=9780300180275"><strong>Powells</strong></a><strong> | </strong><a href="http://www.buy.com/retail/usersearchresults.asp?querytype=home&amp;qu=9780300180275&amp;qxt=home&amp;display=col"><strong>Buy.com</strong></a><strong> |<br></strong><a href="https://www.textpublishing.com.au/books/the-most-good-you-can-do"><strong>Text Publishing (Australia)</strong></a></p><p><a href="http://www.mostgoodyoucando.com/">The Most Good You Can Do: How Effective Altruism is Changing Ideas About Living Ethically</a></p><blockquote><em>Peter Singer’s books and ideas have been disturbing our complacency ever since the appearance of </em>Animal Liberation<em>. Now he directs our attention to a new movement in which his own ideas have played a crucial role: effective altruism. Effective altruism is built upon the simple but profound idea that living a fully ethical life involves doing the “most good you can do.” Such a life requires an unsentimental view of charitable giving: to be a worthy recipient of our support, an organization must be able to demonstrate that it will do more good with our money or our time than other options open to us. Singer introduces us to an array of remarkable people who are restructuring their lives in accordance with these ideas, and shows how living altruistically often leads to greater personal fulfillment than living for oneself.</em></blockquote><blockquote>The Most Good You Can Do <em>develops the challenges Singer has made, in the </em>New York Times <em>and </em>Washington Post<em>, to those who donate to the arts, and to charities focused on helping our fellow citizens, rather than those for whom we can do the most good. Effective altruists are extending our knowledge of the possibilities of living less selfishly, and of allowing reason, rather than emotion, to determine how we live. </em>The Most Good You Can Do <em>offers new hope for our ability to tackle the world’s most pressing problems.</em></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6a51daf1745a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-most-good-you-can-do-peter-singer-6a51daf1745a">The Most Good You Can Do — Peter Singer</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Leader’s Guide — Eric Ries]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-leader-s-guide-eric-ries-c964aa9b2596?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c964aa9b2596</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 21:32:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-25T21:32:48.468Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Eric Ries on his recent kickstarter campaign to release his new book The Leader’s Guide.</strong></p><p><strong>Q. So why release your book only on Kickstarter? —</strong> Jeremie</p><p>I wanted to do an MVP to test out if there was really demand for The Leader’s Guide. The nice thing about Kickstarter is, if people don’t want it, you don’t have to write it.</p><p><strong>Q. What do you think about launching an MVP for a media business? For instance, if you are launching a podcast network that is a paid-for network BUT you own and operate a bunch of free networks. Would you say those free networks serve as an MVP? Or would you still try to test the concept for the paid network? —</strong>Dain Miller</p><p>I would still try to test. My motto as your advisor would be “you’re probably right, but what could it hurt to double-check?”.</p><p><strong>Q. What’s your favorite book on the topic of agile methodology on 100% remote teams across timezones? — </strong>CE</p><p>I don’t have a lot of experience with remote teams + agile, although I hear it is do-able. I still think the best agile book is Kent Beck’s original XP Explained and the principles are the same no matter the physical setup.</p><p><strong>Q. What’s your favorite thing about the whole lean methodology? — </strong>Martin Bavio</p><p>TBH it kind of took me a whole book to explain that.</p><p><strong>Q. Any advice for people trying to start user generated content communities? Amassing the following and building a community around it? Any books you could point me towards ? — </strong>Bakzfuture</p><p>There aren’t that many UGC books that I can think of that are told from the POV of the person trying to create the community. I wonder if you’d find Play Money or Synthetic Worlds helpful, although they are very game-focused and a little dated now or Amy Jo Kim’s book on community.</p><p><strong>Q. What do you do if your customer feedback is, “I would use this if it had X”, where X is something you can’t knock off a quick/rough version of in a week or even a month? Are there times when your next learning opportunity is 1–3 months away? Feels like a long time to go in between iterations. — </strong>Jason Crawford</p><p>Hey Jason! “I would use this is if X” is one of the worst kinds of feedback, because it’s so often wrong. So let’s say you build X in three months, they may still not use it! That’s an awful feeling. Look, there are times when it takes &gt; 3 months to get feedback on something, and that’s not something to be scared of but I think a lot of us talk ourselves into that situation when it’s really not true (I was working with consumer appliance startup recently that got their speed of iteration — in metal, plastic, and electronics — down from years to weeks).</p><p>So I suggest two things: 1) can we get the customer to make a commitment that X is really important, as in a pre-order of some kind or 2) can we get some of the benefit of X sooner using a concierge MVP or other technique to measure their real reaction to it.</p><p><strong>Q. What company, in your opinion has most successfully adopted the principle concepts from lean startup? — </strong>Amino</p><p>I try not to take credit for any company’s success. Every year we have companies tell their own stories in their own words at the Lean Startup Conference, and I’d recommend you check out those videos (they are online for free). Incidentally, Product Hunt will be at this year’s conference.</p><p><strong>Q. I have a question about the small shift in tone in your books. In “The Lean Startup” you lay the groundwork for a scientific process that can be learned and replicated. You’ve caused a big ripple effect in SV and the world because of this. In “The Leader’s Guide”, I get the feeling that you are trying to learn from other people and learn about their diverse experiences. Are you starting to believe in the random magic of startups once again (as opposed to the formula approach) or why the shift? — </strong>Irving Torres</p><p>I’m not sure I know what you mean. The Lean Startup (the book) uses dozens of case studies to tell the story of how those ideas work. Most of those stories were based in my own personal network and clients. I’d like to have a more diverse set of case studies this time around.</p><p><strong>Q. My question would be around tailoring how polished an MVP should be depending on target market? Let’s say you’re building something for designers (overly critical ones) would you spend time polishing the UI and visuals so they feel you have paid attention to quality? Or should an MVP be bare bones feature wise and quality/design wise? — </strong>Creig Cranfield</p><p>If you don’t know who your customer is, you don’t know what “quality” means and the only way to learn what a customer thinks is quality is to put something in front of them that they can react to. You’d be surprised how many designers don’t care about the aesthetics of the products they use every day.</p><p><strong>Q. Quote from Zero to One: “The buzzwords of the moment call for building a ‘lean startup’ that can ‘adapt’ and ‘evolve’ to an ever-changing environment. Would-be entrepreneurs are told that nothing can be known in advance: we’re supposed to listen to what customers say they want, make nothing more than a ‘minimum viable product,’ and iterate our way to success. But leanness is a methodology, not a goal. Iteration without a bold plan won’t take you from zero to one.” — </strong>Jason Crawford</p><p>I get asked about that quote all the time. I couldn’t agree more with this: “But leanness is a methodology, not a goal. Iteration without a bold plan won’t take you from zero to one.” I don’t understand why some people think saying “Lean Startup is (just) a methodology” is a criticism or insult. Part one of my book is called Vision for a reason — you can’t do science without a good hypothesis. Now the idea that I advocate that “nothing can be known in advance” etc is a bit of a strawman but you know how Peter likes his rhetorical flourishes.</p><p><strong>Q. How do you recommend applying lean startup philosophies in hardware environments when chipset design has multiple month and high capital investments? — </strong>Sarkar</p><p>Same as as in software: try to learn as quickly as possible. In some businesses, the MVP can take years and millions of dollars.</p><p><strong>Q. Have you considered writing for companies that are beyond the lean startup point in their life cycle? when do you stop being lean? — </strong>Amino</p><p>Yes, that is a big part of the new book — what happens when you get post product/market fit.</p><p><strong>Q. Are there any books beyond “the inmates are running the asylum” you would recommend for understanding how to design better ux, mvp style? — </strong>Tasha</p><p>I love that book. There are now several “lean ux” books including “Lean UX” and “UX for Lean Startups” that are excellent on that questions.</p><p><strong>Q. Any advice on honing one’s long term vision for a startup company? And concentrating that into a high impact MVP? Balance between long and short term strategic thinking — </strong>Bakztfuture</p><p>Great question to end on. There’s a real paradox of startups, which is that having a long-term vision requires short-term action and experimentation without the long-term vision, all that experimentation leads to running around in circles and, ironically, having a short-term outlook leads to slow and plodding waterfall development — just ask (almost) any public company. So to me, the key thing for strategy to answer is: what are the key hypotheses that are required to make this long-term outcome happen. Once you can do that, you can target experiments to test those hypotheses. Too much strategizing happens at the whiteboard, IMO.</p><h4>From Product Hunt Directly on day of kickstarter launch:</h4><p><strong>Q. Why do you write and speak about lean startup principles? I realize this is a broad question but I’m curious to hear your answer? — </strong>Ryan Hoover</p><p>I ask myself that question on a pretty regular basis, tbh. Remember, I used to be an engineer and I still love writing code more than just about anything else (although I don’t get to do it very often anymore — after a while, Project Euler exercises just don’t cut it). Traveling and speaking as much as I do now is not something I ever thought I’d be doing professionally.</p><p>I remember two really clear moments in my career that come back to me whenever I think about this question. One is from when I was still at IMVU. Believe it or not, a lot of the Lean Startup ideas that are today considered obvious and maybe even a little dated were controversial back then. And there was no Lean Startup movement to get your back if you advocated for them. I was going into a board meeting with my cofounders and VCs during a time when our startup was not doing that well. It was kind of a tense situation, and a lot of the discussion was going to be about whether our “wacky” way of building the product was to blame.</p><p>The clear thing that everyone wanted me to do was to compromise and propose to the board that we back off the “lean” stuff just a little bit. Slow down, get more “professional,” be less experimental. So I agonized over that meeting. I knew there was a real chance that if I stuck to my guns it might be the end of my time as CTO. Certainly it meant a long series of challenging conversations.</p><p>So I asked myself: even if I get fired, what do I want to be remembered for? And I thought about all of my friends who were (even then) founders of companies. And all the talented people I had worked with who were trapped in waterfall product teams wasting their life building products nobody wanted. I really felt the waste of it all. And I felt like I had a chance to strike a tiny little blow for what was right.</p><p>It was no sure thing that it would work out, and to this day I am grateful to my cofounders and investors for sticking with me.</p><p>I tell this long story, because the same image popped into my mind years later. The first time I was invited to give a talk about Lean Startup, I was backstage a few minutes before the talk feeling sick to my stomach. I was really asking myself, “WTF are you doing here?” The room was packed with 10X more people than I expected, and I was super nervous.</p><p>And I was literally in the bathroom in the back of the Moscone center trying to breathe. And I asked myself Ryan’s question again: why are you really here? And I thought, what if even one person in this audience is a founder, and they hear what I have to say, and when they are going into that board meeting to stand for what’s right, they feel like they have an ally? That they are a little better prepared? Even one founder would be enough to make it worthwhile. And that’s when I calmed down and took the stage.</p><p><strong>Q. Aside from your books, what are your must reads? —</strong> Ben Halpern</p><p>I love books &amp; I love reading. I already listed a lot of my favorite business/startup books in the last section of The Lean Startup, so I won’t repeat myself here.</p><p>I’m recently obsessed with Ancillary Justice by <a href="http://twitter.com/annleckie">@annleckie</a>, very original sci-fi that will make you see the world in a new way. BTW, I think <a href="http://twitter.com/pmarca">@pmarca</a>’s sci-fi list has aged really well (I read through the whole thing a few years ago):</p><p><a href="http://pmarchive.com/top_sci-fi_novelists_of_the_00s_so_far.html">Pmarchive - Top 10 science fiction novelists of the &#39;00s -- so far</a></p><p>It’s hard to pick out anything as a “must” read, because books have the most impact when they come into your life at the right time. For me, a number of authors have steered my life onto a new path: Neal Stephenson, Clay Christentsen, Kent Beck, Taichii Ohno, even Ayn Rand. (Steve Blank, obviously, but I knew him personally before I read his book)</p><p><strong>Q. Why use Kickstarter and give up a percentage of sales? You already have a large audience that will buy anything you write so validating demand is less of a need, I assume. — </strong>Ryan Hoover</p><p><strong>I had a similar thoughts to Ryan Hoover. Surely a more straight forward “tim ferris” style book launch would have been just as effective/more effective. — </strong>Ben Aldred</p><p>Been there, done that: <a href="http://www.startuplessonslearned.com/2011/09/last-lean-startup-bundle-48-hours-to.html">http://www.startuplessonslearned...</a></p><p>I wanted to try something new, see what I could learn about launching a book in 2015. The Kickstarter % doesn’t bother me, since the campaign isn’t really about the money.</p><blockquote><em>“Eric Ries is running one of the most successful publishing campaigns in Kickstarter’s history.” </em><strong><em>— </em></strong><a href="http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-06/the-followup-to-the-lean-startup-is-available-only-on-kickstarter"><strong><em>Bloomberg Business</em></strong></a></blockquote><blockquote><em>“On Monday, Ries began work on his next book project. Fittingly, he started it off with a Kickstarter campaign. The campaign achieved its $135,000 fundraising goal on Tuesday, and by Thursday morning Ries had more than $170,000 in pledges.” </em><strong><em>— </em></strong><a href="http://www.vox.com/2015/3/19/8252787/eric-ries-lean-startup"><strong><em>Vox</em></strong></a></blockquote><blockquote><em>“Ries turned to Kickstarter as an experiment in research, writing, and marketing. He didn’t want to write in a vacuum.” </em><strong><em>— </em></strong><a href="http://www.fastcompany.com/3043745/most-creative-people/the-lean-startup-author-eric-ries-is-crowdsourcing-his-next-book-via-ki"><strong><em>Fast Company</em></strong></a></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mZbeQBOm1EKd1l9i5LcA8w.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Leader’s Guide is no longer available. The Kickstarter campaign has now expired: <a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/881308232/only-on-kickstarter-the-leaders-guide-by-eric-ries/description">https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/881308232/only-on-kickstarter-the-leaders-guide-by-eric-ries/description</a></p><blockquote>The Leader’s Guide<em> is aimed at entrepreneurs, executives, or anyone leading a project or team. It will be full of stories about how companies both large and small are adopting Lean Startup methods to scale successfully and operate in conditions of extreme uncertainy.</em></blockquote><blockquote>The Leader’s Guide<em> is for both those who are new to Lean Startup as well as those who love the methodology in principle, but want to know more about how to put it into practice. It will include lots of real-world examples about how entrepreneurs are tackling questions like:</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>How can I convince my team that testing our early ideas with customers does not mean they should sacrifice quality or forget about our vision?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>How can I convince senior leadership that innovation projects require a different system of accounting?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>How can I do Lean Startup-style experimentation in a highly-regulated industry?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>How can I incentivize and reward my team for working in a cross-functional way?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>How can we turn functional specialists in areas like IT, HR and finance into allies when it comes to supporting new ideas?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>I think of </em>The Leader’s Guide<em> as a kind of master class in applying the Lean Startup methodology. I can’t possibly work with all the companies who ask for help, but I can do my best to translate the work I do into book form. </em>The Leader’s Guide<em> will also answer some of the most frequently-asked questions and dispel the myths surrounding the Lean Startup, as well as include tips and tricks from people who’ve been using the method successfully.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>So if you’re just discovered </em>The Lean Startup<em>, you’re a practitioner who wants a deeper dive, or you’re at a company trying to incorporate it at scale, this is a great next step.</em></blockquote><blockquote>The Leader’s Guide<em> in both its hardcover and digital formats will ship to backers in late 2015.</em></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c964aa9b2596" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-leader-s-guide-eric-ries-c964aa9b2596">The Leader’s Guide — Eric Ries</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Product Hunt Effect — Eric Willis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-product-hunt-effect-eric-willis-281f19cd43e7?source=rss----217b8a907390---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/281f19cd43e7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Product Hunt Global]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2015 09:17:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-19T20:25:41.305Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Eric Willis is a serial entrepreneur and the #1 ranked hunter (and moderator) on Product Hunt. He’s currently writing a book called The Product Hunt Effect: How community driven startups are changing the way products are built, launched, and distributed.</strong></p><p><a href="http://www.producthunt.com/posts/the-product-hunt-effect">The Product Hunt Effect on Product Hunt</a></p><p><strong>He’s been building tech products for nearly 16 years and his projects have been featured in Mashable, The Next Web, TechCrunch, Pando Daily, and several other publications. He’s traveled to 30+ countries to inspect startup scenes and also work with founders (as an advisor) on building new web/mobile applications. We can discuss anything you would like to know about Product Hunt, building products (and teams), market trends, and anything else related to startups.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/425/1*e-n6LibDFhW_cvITjo9ESA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Shameless plug before we start the AMA. Please support the Kickstarter campaign for my book: The Product Hunt Effect.</p><p><a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1845561887/the-product-hunt-effect/">The Product Hunt Effect</a></p><p>Thanks! Bonus reward is a virtual hug!</p><p>So I’m a long-time entrepreneur, top hunter, and moderator at Product Hunt. I’m also writing a book called The Product Hunt Effect: How community driven startups are changing the way products are built, launched, and distributed. I’m sure many of you have lots of questions about Product Hunt and I’ll answer to the best of my ability. So ask me anything! Just a warning. I’m traveling at the moment and I’m on a really bad connection. I don’t type slowly..it might just seem that way</p><p><strong>Q. What was the inspiration for the book? Obviously you have the knowledge, since you’re a core part of the team, but was there a specific reason you decided to go this route? — </strong>Ray Hernandez</p><p>I’ve been working with makers in various channels for several months. I’ve been learning about their successes and failures and began to notice some trends. I’ve been sharing those in Maker Hunt and other places and began to run into some issues with all the requests. It just didn’t scale. So I thought the best way to scale would be to get these ideas in a book format. I wanted to share a framework on how to build communities and how to leverage them.</p><p>To the second part.. I’m just a moderator and hunters so I’m not really part of the core team so I think that makes it a bit easier for me to pursue this.</p><p><strong>Q. Will the ebooks be interactive for tablets (eg iBooks author)? — </strong>Jeff Needles</p><p>I don’t know if you know Nathan (who built the first version of Product Hunt). He’s working on a new mobile platform for ebooks. It’s very interactive and I’m hoping he will have the beta ready so that I can use it to launch the ebook. If not, I’ll still create interactive versions of the ebooks.</p><p><strong>Q. Talking about kickstarter ☺. When it started, it was easy to boostrap projects there. Then it got more and more “professional”, requiring consequent resources to make appealing videos, most notably. Do you think something of the sort could happen to Product Hunt when it gets bigger (requiring consequent budget to reach home page), and if yes, how could it be prevented? — </strong>Olivier Mekki</p><p>I don’t think that’s the major issue. I think the biggest problem is that people are often not prepared to launch on PH. They don’t do the small things like create a custom landing page or create a form to extract an email address from the visitors. It’s a huge wasted opportunity. They then iterate and fix the early issues and two months later they feel the need to get featured on PH again. I think a lot more planning should go into being ready to launch on PH</p><p>At the the same time, I know people are just looking to get validation.</p><p><strong>Q. What gave you the idea? what does a success look like for you here? — </strong>Erik Torenberg</p><p>Helping on Product Hunt, Maker Hunt, Maker Success, and then other product-related communities puts me in contact with a lot of makers. Many face the same problems and also have lots of concerns about how to not only launch on Product Hunt but how to best leverage their launch so that they don’t have just a few days in the limelight and then flame out. So I’ve been helping many with their post-launch plans and had some success. I wanted to share what I’ve learned with others. I just want to share these case studies and insights. If I can get a good book written and people can learn something from it, I’ve succeeded.</p><p><strong>Q. In your years of making products and working in tech, what books have had the most influence on your approach, ideation to build to marketing, anything ☺ and also, what books have you seen have the most impact on other founders from the companies you’ve worked with/alongside? — </strong>Greig Cranfield</p><p>Blue Ocean Strategy is a great one that comes up often. It’s about opening up uncontested market space.</p><p>A lot of people are still taking about The Hard Thing about Hard Things because it’s so practical and not just theoretical jargon.</p><p>I think you should also look at Peter Drucker books or even pick up The Daily Drucker.</p><p><strong>Q. Since you do so much awesome stuff for free — why not keep this free (at least the digital versions)? — </strong>Jeff Needles</p><p>I’ve thought about that a lot actually. However, there is some validation that comes with knowing people will pay for something. I do hope to release something related to that for free (thinking of a possible course)</p><p><strong>Q. Obviously you’re all about helping people &amp; other’s products, but do you have any products of your own in the hopper? (other than the upcoming badass book) — </strong>Ray Hernandez</p><p>I did an interview today with Josh from The Daily Hunt and he asked the same question. I’ve had “ideas”, but I’m not working on anything into a find a problem that I feel uniquely qualified to solve and that I’m passionate about. I’ve done enough startups for the wrong reasons. So this requires a bit of patience.</p><p><strong>Q. Besides giving visibility and traffic to the products themselves, what do you see as the best side-effect of Product Hunt for makers, hunters, or regular users? Are there any interesting effects that happen when a product is launched, that exists outside of the expected traffic to products? whether that’s fundraising opportunities, job-related finds, etc. — </strong>Marc Rosa</p><p>Yes. I’ve known makers who have gotten VC inquiries and then gone on to get funded with just a few weeks. Some startups have had engineers submit their resumes solely based on seeing the product on PH.</p><p>So people are hiring immediately after being featured on PH and getting lots of inbound from that. I also think PH can be a huge validator for the press and that exposure can be the gift that keeps on giving.</p><p><strong>Q. To get all Tim Ferris on you…what is your daily routine? You seem to always be online…and you’re a big contributor to so many things…do you sleep? — </strong>Ray Hernandez</p><p>I spend a lot of time in Slack in a couple of communities I run. I’ve doing multiple interviews per day I spend a lot of time on Skype… hours per day now. And the rest of the time is in email and then reading books. It’s very basic right now because a lot of just research for the book</p><p><strong>Q. I know there will be a whole book on that but, what is the most important piece of advice you’d give to makers? The one thing we should keep in mind all the time? — </strong>Maxime Pico</p><p>Always try to get to root of the problem you’re trying to solve. Also be talking to your users to get a better understanding of why they use your problem. Try to find patterns between those users and solve the one or two major problems REALLY well.</p><p>You need to find one or two things to really nail. That’s your stake in the ground. Everything starts there</p><p><strong>Q. I’m currently writing an article about PH, one point being that PH is a social network, and not just a website directory like in the early days of the internet. Do you think PH has a post-launch community effect, like it could exist in incubators, past the networking opportunities with engineers and VCs you described? — </strong>Olivier Mekki</p><p>I think you can see that in the PH Meetups. That’s taking the community-feel of the site to the offline world. So yes, I think you can see that.</p><p><strong>Q: Is there a tool you could not live without? Like a productivity hack? Or and app? — </strong>Maxime Pico</p><p>Right now it’s definitely Slack. It’s a major part of my workflow now. A hack: I’m committed to inbox zero so that means I’ll generally respond to emails very quickly to keep it clean. That almost means I don’t give my email out as much too. So email isn’t a time killer for me.</p><p><strong>Q. Are you a podcast guy? You have any non-popular podcast that are great about products? —</strong> Ray Hernandez</p><p>I’m not a major podcast guy. Do you know about Mixergy? I’m not sure if it’s really “popular”.. it’s known though. It’s awesome.</p><p><strong>Q. What is the latest Hunt or Maker that really made an impression on you? How do you analyze how good a product is? —</strong> Maxime Pico</p><p>Can I give you one that’s not hunted yet? but will be soon?</p><p>So there is this app called Blab. Imagine Google Hangout done right or if Meerkat was built to work with Slack channels but you could stream multiple people at one time.</p><p>It’s so cool…so cool! We even held an AMA with it today… and people that are watching can comment or jump in and out of the stream… it’s really sweet</p><p>It’s so nice. I love the app. You’ll see it next week and I’m not a big user of livestreaming apps but it’s so personal, intimate that it just works</p><p><strong>Do you think community driven startups need a leader, and how would you “scale” leadership if so, given the fact there are human limits in communicating with others ? —</strong> Marwann</p><p>Yes. PH is a prime example of that. Ryan was the earlier driver. To grow and also keep the quality up, you need others to buy in and help you lead. It’s the only way to scale</p><p>So the entire PH team drives the community and then moderators and then other heavy users mimic them…</p><p><strong>Q. Why do you think meerkat, periscope and blab has success while livestream and ustream got only moderate traction? —</strong> Olivier Mekki</p><p>I think a lot that has to do with smartphone penetration and increased bandwidth. It’s just technically easier for everyone to have a great experience. Plus.. people are just more comfortable being on camera now.</p><p><strong>Q. Do you think the current state of the startup scene and the whole unicorn thing are healthy? Like are you seeing people building products for the right reasons still or just focusing too much on building something that will get funding and cash out? — </strong>Greig Cranfield</p><p>It’s a cycle. People are being a bit greedy now and there is a lot of money in the market. At the same time, people are building real businesses.</p><p>Slack’s revenue is growing at a fast clip… look at Zenefits.. maybe one of the fastest growing ever</p><p>So it’s not like the late 90s</p><p>All the wealth brings in people are chasing quick bucks but eventually the window always closes for pretenders.</p><p><strong>I’ve seen people passionately hacking away at awesome products just because they want to make something cool without much thought to getting rich quick. I like those people. too romantic of an idea maybe but being at collision recently and hearing some people say they just made something in the hope that it gets bought out before even hitting the market was an eye opener for me. It’s totally understandable but i just like the idea of people trying to solve problems and help people not just $$$ in their eyes. Product hunt gives a platform for people to launch those types of products to a community that (from what I’ve seen) feel the same which is awesome ☺ so good work. — </strong>Greig Cranfield</p><p><strong>Q. How do you “know” that something will work? What are the questions you ask yourself when you discover a new startup or a new product? — </strong>Maxime Pico</p><p>I don’t always know, but sometimes the signs are clear. Slack was IRC for everyone else and it was well-built. So it was solving a real problem and was extremely well-built. That’s going to succeed.</p><p>Let’s use an example like Meerkat. They have a competitor that’s right there with them and they have resource and distribution advantages so we don’t know if they will succeed. It’s all about the vision and execution of the team.</p><p><strong>Q. What do you think is the dumbest thing people do…when they are “trying” to start a community based product? — </strong>Ray Hernandez</p><p>Make out “personas” (imaginary users) and built based on that and not find early real possible users immediately.</p><p>So they’re just guessing.</p><p>The first thing you should do it talk to real people and try to get validation.</p><p><strong>Q. You seem to bring up “finding problems” and “talking to users” a lot, these things are directly linked to empathy. So my question is, how did you develop empathy in order to better understand the problems and ask the right questions? Was there something critical you understood on the way? —</strong> Maxime Pico</p><p>I’ve read a ton of business books (maybe 1000 ..lots of biographies) and been an entrepreneur for nearly 20 years. When you look at most startup stories… at the “genesis moment”, it’s almost always rooted in solving someone’s problem. And then intimately understanding it.</p><p>Look at Fred Smith (Fedex) or King Gillette(Gillette).. they literally lived the problems and worked on them for years before anyone took them seriously</p><p>So I think you have to CARE to really solve a difficult problem or you’ll give up before the breakthrough comes</p><p>You have to care about the problem or the people who have the problem.</p><p><strong>Q. Regarding having user feedback, I’ve heard a developer saying recently that launching invite only beta was fading and it was better to launch directly and iterate quickly. Beta seems so much important to me, what’s your vision about that? — </strong>Olivier Mekki</p><p>I agree with the developer who said that to you UNLESS you’re working on a mission-critical problem. You’re not going to launch early and often if your building switch software for data centers.</p><p>If it’s consumer-based and you’re not handling financial data, release it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/1*OEF4n9rsf8bHx_vqJcu_kg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/1*aEK8sB5fRYIAu1-KygspAw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/1*rDsl4Xr5VKhqk65cuT5iXQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/1*1NUOrHIQRrvQA0NMTI9dEQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>You can still order the book on Kickstarter:</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1845561887/the-product-hunt-effect/">The Product Hunt Effect</a></p><blockquote>After having spent 1000+ hours talking to makers, I began to notice a pattern in the type of information that makers were seeking to help them become better entrepreneurs. I began sharing this information individually, but that just didn’t scale. So I began talking to people in these communities about a better delivery method and the overwhelming response was “Please put this in a book!”.</blockquote><blockquote>It’s important for people to know about these success stories: How Flatbook launched on Product Hunt and <a href="http://makersuccess.com/stories/111">added 125k</a> to their funnel, how Book in a Box converted Product Hunt visitors into <a href="http://makersuccess.com/stories/107">75k in revenue</a> in one month, how Treeling had nearly <a href="http://makersuccess.com/stories/100">10,000 developers sign up</a>for their service in 48 hours, or how some makers are <a href="http://makersuccess.com/stories/92">turning side projects into startups</a> just because of being featured on Product Hunt. More crucially, it’s important to know how the techniques and methodology used to harness the community on Product Hunt and in other places so that you can have an awesome launch and grow your startup.</blockquote><blockquote>I’ll give you the behind the scene details and framework so that you can replicate some of this success. Makers have complained about the lack of in-depth case studies that will actually teach them key techniques, ideology, tools, and other tips. The Product Hunt Effect will fill that void. Finally, the community we’ll build together is equally important as you’ll hopefully be connected to 1000+ other makers, entrepreneurs, developers, marketers and other tech professionals so that you can learn together and support each other. This is a movement.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=281f19cd43e7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club/the-product-hunt-effect-eric-willis-281f19cd43e7">The Product Hunt Effect — Eric Willis</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/product-hunt-book-club">Product Hunt Book Club</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>