<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Smoking Cricket - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Cricket nuances, analysis and opinions - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:53:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/smoking-cricket" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The unbearable lightness of being the favourite]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/the-unbearable-lightness-of-being-the-favourite-52d9d7ab44a9?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52d9d7ab44a9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[icc-world-cup-2019]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-cup-2019]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[icc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cricket]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Mar 2019 16:52:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-07T09:40:38.702Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If I were to ask you who is the favourite to win the World cup — you could say England, India or whoever stirs your being. You could also go ahead and answer my “gut” says SA will spring a surprise. Is your prediction like the West Indies of 1983 or is it like the Pakistan of 1992! Is this all about guts and hunches?</p><p>Let’s do a short exercise, whoever is your favourite, If the same WC is played 5 times, how many times do you think your favourite would win. Take a few seconds, we will compare notes later. If you feel 4 then the team is a firm favourite in your books, and their chances are 80%.</p><p><em>This article is an exercise in thinking about incomplete information and trying to predict what will happen if the matches are repeated again and again.</em></p><p>On a given day, Bangladesh can beat Aus but is it a 1 in 3 event Or a 1 in 20? Yes, that one instance could be in this WC but anybody claiming this would be so without rationale is just shooting from his/her backside.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*KA_frr0DaVbRFnln.jpg" /><figcaption>The others weren’t supposed to have much fun?</figcaption></figure><p>The format for this WC is like that of ’92 — with teams playing all others once and then the top 4 would proceed to semis. This evens out the luck, the variance. Teams can start badly and pick up or lose momentum after winning. Pakistan didn’t start well at all — they were a few minutes of rain away from crashing out in fact, but they found their combination and form towards the end. England started like they are not going to lose any, but with a bit of complacency and with steady improvement in others they lost a couple towards the end. Come to the semis and finals, the teams became very evenly matched.</p><p>For this WC too I think the semi lineup could be predicted with high confidence — Ind, Eng nearly 90–98% certainty. <br>Next up — SA, NZ -80–90%. <br>Pak, Aus — 50–60%. <br>WI, Bang — 0–10%<br>Srl, Afg ~0<br>How could you come up with these numbers? A winning team will play 9 matches pre semifinals, One has to win about 6 matches with net run rate to qualify comfortably*. Winning against bottom 4 could be taken as a given scenario for the top-6 teams (Yes, WI have indeed beaten England in two games, we will come to it later). So that leaves winning 2 or more games against the remaining 5 teams. So one can do the heads-up stat and a simple back of paper calculation to get it. This is level 1.</p><p><em>## If you are interested in more rigorous analysis of this —it is there at the end of the article.</em></p><p>*Improved from earlier assumption of 7 outright wins.</p><p>The simplified approach and doesn’t take into consideration the latest form (say of WI), the planning of matches and venues.</p><p>Say, are few teams playing on the same venue? The nature of the pitches, grounds suiting the “home” team, if the tough matches are being played at the “home” venue? In the drier weather, summers when the 2017 Champions trophy was played, the pitches were fairly balanced. England’s batting was diminished with it and the better bowling attacks had more of a say. Also one shouldn’t expect seaming wickets in the later half, July onwards of the World cup, might even have tired wickets.</p><p>The scheduling — are the supposedly easy games right at the start or at the end or are they evenly distributed — playing 9 matches with your best 11 again and again, be it strong or weak opposition ain’t easy! In easy games, those players in the struggling middle orders don’t get game time, which then puts you at a disadvantage against tougher opponents.</p><p>It will take a good day to do all this, and I look forward to doing it just before the WC when the squads and the forms are more defined.</p><p>Then all 4 teams reaching the semis would have a similar probability of success. Eng, Ind though ahead of the pack, but not 2–3 sigma better than SA, NZ, Aus — say like how Australia was in 2003, 07. In such cases no matter how much better the 2nd team gets, Aus was too good, even on their mediocre day.</p><p>So at the moment (if you were to predict for the WC happening next month) <br>To win WC — odds — <br>Eng — 36% (~60% chance of winning semis, and finals so 60%x 60%) <br>Ind — 30% (~55–60% each match)<br>NZ — 15% (40–45% chance and making semis 85%)<br>SA — 13% (40% each and the chance of making the semis assuming 85%) <br>Aus — 10%<br>Pak — 8%<br>Rest — 1%<br>*We multiply the chances of reaching semis x odds of winning semis x odds of winning finals to arrive at these.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*c8SrFekK4coGUXnR" /></figure><p>I know the above add up to 113%. One can divide each by 1.13. This is how you can think about the favourites! Now let’s see how this stacks up against the science, the IMF of our world — the bookies.</p><p>Percentages are followed by odds to win in decimal format (to compare with odds of betting bookmakers). Here 3.12 means If you wager 1 you would get 3.12 (ie 2.12 profit). To get it just divide 100 by the percentage you arrived at.</p><p><em>In this format: Team : Chance predicted as per above methodology = Converted into odds || Odds by bookmakers</em></p><p>Eng : 32% = 3.12 || 3.5 *<br> Ind : 26% = 3.84 || 4<br> NZ : 13% = 7.7 || 9&quot;<br> SA : 11.5 = 8.7 || 9 <br> Aus : 9% = 11.1 || 6.5^<br> Pak : 7% = 14.3 || 10^</p><p>” Undervalued teams<br>^ Overvalued teams</p><p>Remaining teams : 1% → 100 || 40 ( Weighted mean )</p><p>* Eng were given odds of 2.5ish a year back. Since then better sense has prevailed among the bookies. They initially priced England as they did Aus in ’15 and India in ’11. The format has changed completely this time around.</p><p><strong>Interestingly the odds are directly correlated to how easily can you can select the 15 player squad. Ind, Eng are decided on 13–14 players. SA, NZ have 11 or so. Pak, Aus ~8 players. Of course, Bangladesh too has their 11–12 players but they ought to be good to win consistently also.</strong></p><p><strong>Disclaimer </strong>— I am not encouraging anyone to bet. No moral policing either. This is just a mental exercise, having fun with numbers. <br> <br>So how do you use this information if you are inclined to bet? If you see the odds at the betting sites there are no apparent leaks in their methods — like say NZ was in 2013 WC. Again a dark horse but I correctly predicted that they could even top their group (the odds given if I recall correctly were 4–5, I thought it was evens with Aus) because of their form leading up, and they were playing the crucial deciding match of the group with Aus in NZ.</p><p><strong>But the odds will change, and you can use this or other such methods to make a better judgement. More importantly one understands how despite Eng being a favourite — what a favourite sometimes means — a chance of winning at ~30% — So nobody should go around making friendly or otherwise costly bets.</strong></p><p>Here are my <a href="https://www.theroar.com.au/2015/03/14/forget-the-kiwis-and-proteas-this-world-cup-is-all-about-australia-and-india/">old predictions during the last WC</a>. Got the Srl — SA wrong but otherwise worked to the tee. Also predicted Starc being Man of the tournament before the start. All this and more helped getting blocked on the biggest betting site pretty quickly :)</p><p>Now let’s do a short qualitative analysis of different teams. Few things you can see changing over the next 90 days which could improve and degrade the odds of the team -</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*NqUUsd4xQpVclrTH.jpg" /></figure><p>England — Yes they lost two vs the “weak” WI, their bowling lineup is not flash but as they have shown time and again — as a collective, they have the measure of the pitches in England. They beat one and all there, and the bowlers also come to the party. Then there is the composed captain, the no-ego, the no-pretention team culture — they should be able to do it all at the big stage. One of the best ODI players, Butler comes at 6, no game is beyond England. The best (or slightly behind Ind, Afg) spin combination in the last 2 years. How good is their supposedly poor bowling lineup — look at match sheets for tours of India, Aus, SA to England.</p><p>Their record chasing is enviable but then it has come in generally low-pressure matches. They aren’t that good batting first. England would love to outgun everybody on pitches stacked in the favor of batsmen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/784/0*-QMfRC9gEZHUuee2.jpg" /></figure><p>India — World class, experienced players at the top and a few in the bowling. The nous of MS. A settled, experienced team. Wobby middle order, the liability of MS in batting friendly conditions, poor record over last 2/3 years in chasing 280+ (read: over-dependence on Kohli), a foolish board that prioritizes IPL over WC. You are less likely to see both the highs and the lows of England. India would love to play matches on pitches less stacked in favor of batsman.</p><p>New Zealand — Perennially underrated. Masterful tactics, excellent man management. Yes, Williamson is a great, Taylor is setting the record books on fire, Boult can bolt, but there are no in-the-face reasons like England, India for them being so good. Iffy openers, lower order, serviceable-only bowling. On paper should struggle against both on-song Eng, Ind but are arguably the best among the rest.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2c1KMp1f19J5WE0g.jpg" /></figure><p>Now the teams who don’t have settled 11’s, plagued by ill-defined roles, not the best of leadership and cohesiveness. Winning consistently in ODIs takes much more than flash performers. Unlike a T20, 100 overs also require certain nous, calculations, clarity over individual roles, well thought out collective plans.</p><p><strong>South Africa</strong> — A team in a muddle off late, debuts being handed out like candies. Making way too many changes to the batting order, all-rounders. Few good players who have impressed in patches but in the name of trying everybody, they have not been given a consistent run. Obvious weakness against spin, propensity to attack at the wrong time rather than taking the game deep. A pretty good bowling attack and a batting line up with Qdk, Amla, Faf, Miller. They are still 4th in the pecking order because I expect them to sort out the mess before the world-cup and because the league stage is so long.</p><p><strong>Australia </strong>— Should be one of the contenders but the directionless selection and man management aren’t helping. Langer doesn’t inspire much confidence. Captaincy issues with Smith, Warner not being the options. Have a few matches to sort it out and with Smith and Warner in, I can see them being a force but just get the feeling they would still be playing individually rather than as a team.</p><p><strong>Pakistan</strong> — With Arthur and Sarfaraz at the helm, lack of mercurial match winners of the past, the shenanigans and interferences of PCB, Pakistan should be a goner in theory. But the bowling and batting are both quite un-Pakistan — they don’t have significant ups and downs but are consistently OK. If the pitches are not stacked in favour of the batsmen, expect them to do reasonably well.</p><p><strong>West Indies </strong>— Their recent two wins against England notwithstanding, I can’t see a batting lineup of individuals, playing million dollar shots coming good consistently enough against a decent top-6 bowling attack. The fielding is weak, and the bowling — one or two mercurial performances aside, ordinary.</p><p><strong>Afghanistan</strong> — A pretty good bowling attack with a top 3 spin attack for sure that could stumble a top team or two. Batting has been improving for the last year — Think they should beat WI, Srl, Bang and trouble SA, Aus.</p><p><strong>Sri Lanka </strong>— copy paste all the problems and more of Pakistan, add leadership woes of Australia, multiply selection muddle of South Africa, divide by the obvious lack of world-class talent of Bangladesh and you get the present state of Sri Lanka. The spin-friendly pitches don’t breed good pacers, and the spinners struggle on better tracks against quality opposition. The young batsmen are made to bat in absurd positions, are jettisoned quickly without any regard for options. The captains, coaches and selectors are outpacing climate change. Given how bad it is, it is even an achievement that they are putting out decent 11s, let alone match-winning ones. Such great cricketing culture laid to waste by Trump level incompetence.</p><p><strong>Bangladesh</strong> — A nation struggling to balance the needs of the present day results vs investing and becoming a sub-continent force in long-term. The spinners aren’t good enough, the pace bowlers aren’t encouraged enough. The batsmen have the luxury of securing careers with one inning, the coaches come and go like coalition governments of tin-pot democracies, while a dictator is sitting on the top as the chief who can ban and recall players on his whim. The bowling is so weak that it is straightforward to say they have just about no chance of progressing.</p><p>That’s it for now. If you have made it this far, all the power to you. Look forward to doing a deep dive in predictions as we approach the warm-ups.</p><p>## How to calculate the chances of progression into knockouts-</p><p>Let’s take the case of West Indies. WI has to win at least 3 games against top 6 teams and 3 against bottom 3. Let’s say they will win 100% of the matches against bottom 3 (Afg might be 50–50 btw).</p><p>Now to win 3 games against top 6 — let’s say WI will be given percentage of 35% on average vs each team (for simplicity — it will be more like 25% chance vs top teams). Think of it like when WI play in a bilateral series they generally get beaten 3–1, 4–1, 5–0. The 2 wins in 4 could make a case for an uptrend or just an anomaly.</p><p>To win 3 matches out of 6 — .35*.35*.35*.65*.65*.65 = .011 . This event can happen in 20 ways — called permutations of events. So multiply by that to get the total probability of .22 ie 22%. <br>then to win 4 out of 6 — .0063. This can happen in 15 ways. <br>to win 5 — .0034 . This can happen in 6 ways. <br>to win 6 — .002 . This can happen only in 1 way. <br>The total of above 4 will give you 35% chance. Now multiply that by say 45% chance in each of the 2 knockouts — you get 7% chance of them going on to win the World cup.</p><p>So in seemingly the best case scenario they a 7% chance (with assured win against Afg and a 35% chance against top 6 teams). I would think that this best case would happen only 50% of the times.</p><p>So how can you use this information. Basically bet on the teams which you think are undervalued. Betting on overvalued or fair valued teams is going to be a negative expected value ie you wouldn’t gain or lose if you were to do it again and again. When say NZ, undervalued, becomes fairly valued during the tournament, you can then compensate and bet on other teams that were initially overvalued or have become undervalued.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52d9d7ab44a9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/the-unbearable-lightness-of-being-the-favourite-52d9d7ab44a9">The unbearable lightness of being the favourite</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What can Australia do to stem the rot in Asia?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/what-can-australia-do-to-stem-the-rot-in-asia-6bd593e4e8b?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6bd593e4e8b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cricket]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[australia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Aug 2016 18:45:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-09T09:29:06.795Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Tl, Dr — Keep calm, stick with the players, a reset in mindset, get coaches to help with that.</p><p><strong>Aus have been woeful in Asia — no other non-subcontinent side has been so consistently poor recently.</strong></p><p>Take the recent records of SA, Eng, NZ. <br>SA won in Srl, drew in UAE; and defended courageously even in heavy defeats in India. They have an excellent record overall in India. <br>Eng drew in Srl, won in India, fought very well in UAE, almost winning a test and being very close in others. <br>NZ drew in UAE, drew in Srl, defended bravely in defeat in India.</p><p>Even the legendary team of 2000s did well in subcontinent. But that team was one of the best three across generations.</p><p>And mind you all these tours had come against sub-continent teams at their full strength, when their legends were playing.</p><p><strong>So there is precedent by other teams. What differentiates the present Aussie team from the other three?</strong><br>1. The pitches in respective countries don’t take the spin out of the game entirely. Apart from a couple of pitches in Aus, rest just don’t get better for spinners even on day 4, 5.</p><p>2. While batting, the other teams don’t play with hubris that is so typical of Aus. They respect the conditions, play with patience. Even to a degree by erring on the side on the caution.</p><p>It would be easy to say that this is how traditionally Aussies have won so many matches. But this approach has provided poor results in Ashes lately along with sub-continent. And the batsmanship across generations is not the same, we don’t have Gilchrist at 7, the proven performers top to bottom or the 4 equally potent bowlers, no matter the conditions — the methods of the yore need not work at present.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*E9ZTp6AE4yglX-RVhU0qQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Where the hell is the ball?</figcaption></figure><p>Remember how the same cricketers were tonking ball after ball of spinners in Australia? Quite simple — come down the track, loft the ball over the in-field — even if one is a mis-hit the bats are good enough, and all the commentators were like — Oh! This is brilliant batting, not allowing the spinners to settle. He is a good player of spin. Cue Khawaja, Burns.</p><p>The conditions in Aus are so lopsided against spin that never would a spinner run through a side. At best take wickets every 12 or so overs.</p><p>On pitches assisting the spinners, the Aus still employ the same method — here just to get singles with in-out fields. When they play back — the risks are presumed to be higher, so why not be aggressive and “unsettle” the bowlers. Going down the pitch and playing a shot does look good when it comes off but is not a positive expected value play in these conditions. Sooner or later the good spinner would do you in flight with loop and variations in speed.</p><p>Of course, Aussies know all this. It is bloody textbook. Here is what Lehmann said ahead of the series — <br>“We know that Sri Lanka will defend a lot once batters are in, so it’s going to take a lot longer to get your runs if that makes sense. We’ve spoken about the need to bat long periods of time is going to be key, which we’ve done pretty well to be fair over the last little while, but the challenge is to do it here.” Patience is the new buzz word everywhere in test cricket in this era of T20s.</p><p>Here is what Smith said after the 2nd test -<br>“A couple of the guys went over the top, showed a bit of courage, got the field back, sweep shots, reverse sweeps, it unsettles the bowler a little bit.”<br>He also judged 200 per innings to be par on this wicket and that 180 in the 4th innings was thus OK.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*1M-Q2SV3SxyfEDeA4xzd2A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hand grenades are these!</figcaption></figure><p>The two comments have a big disconnect.</p><p>Either — The batters don’t trust their defence to play with patience and wait for the bad balls. The way Eng, SA, NZ play.</p><p>Or the mindset of scoring freely like they do in Aus is so ingrained that it has taken hold of their mind. An idea is like a virus! Freaking Inception.</p><p>Srl are well cognizant of Australia’s lack of patience and the mentality to attack and hence they have also taken unwarranted risks to score below par scores the whole series.</p><p>The pitches are no vicious turners and with patience, application — runs like 400s per innings are to be had — others have done this consistently in the past, and that too against better bowling attacks. There is no mystery spin either — there is no Mendis, who accounted for India on the maiden tour.</p><p>When the match was all but lost in the chase of 4th innings — no one tried to change their approach to patiently tire the bowlers down and wait for mistakes. Runs were never going to be enough to win it. Remember how it seemed all too easy when O’keefe and Nevill were defending against spin in the 1st test. They played out 20 odd overs with only a couple of genuine scares.</p><p>But isn’t the objective of batting is to score runs — Of course and runs do come with time. Against scoreboard pressure, thinking you would hit off the bowlers of their lengths with attack is a not a potent technique against an international side, in its backyard.</p><p>There were still 2 and a half days left in the match. Instead, the batters took it as an excuse to be even more reckless. All they got were tens of runs at healthy strike rates, and not a single 50!</p><p>To succeed in conditions one is not accustomed to, you need skill and also the attitude to stonewall till one feels comfortable / change one’s methods — like ABD, Amla, Cook, Willamson, Bell.</p><p>An anecdote here — Bell ran down the wicket to a spinner in India, was beaten, yet carried on with the shot and was bowled in the first innings in India on 2013–14 tour. Eng lost the test big-time. The very next test he corrected the mistake, went on to score plenty of runs, and helped Eng win the series. He was ready to be patient, scoring well below strike rates he was accustomed to and was OK with runs that didn’t look pretty.</p><p><strong>So what can this Aussie side do to stem the rot in Asia?</strong><br> <br>1. Smith has to understand that hitting the spinners off their lengths works in shorter formats and on true wickets. It is courageous only in the same vein as driving 100 miles per hour within a city. Mathews knows this, and he keeps his in-out fields — getting wickets, without conceding many runs. The risks are not just worth the reward. All one can hope for with present attitude is decent strike rate, pretty 30–40.</p><p>2. They should start looking at their process and not stats i.e., the runs scored. Yes, Warner has scored more than others, so has Marsh, Lyon has gotten most wickets behind Starc. But stats often hide more than they reveal. Warner took too many risks by premeditating balls. Marsh’s present technique of hard hands and premeditation is not expected to reap more than an occasional fifty. Lyon has to develop new skills to get wickets without getting them in a bargain for runs. He did own up to it and described his plans. A good sign for tour of India.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*jESSQ2yt6Gbk4vzxm5O_PQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ooh, this is not difficult enough! Let me try the reverse!</figcaption></figure><p>3. More application, ready to look ugly — Voges reverse sweeps are an anathema to good batsmanship — for a player who had an average rightly or wrongly near Brandman — his lack of application was just appalling.</p><p>4. Get Jaywardhane, Laxman for batters; and guys like Prasanna, Bedi, Saqlain to help the spinners. There are few months to go before the Ind tour. And if this is bad — it could be worse. Indians won’t be this reckless with their batting. The pitches would be actual dust bowls / would deteriorate big time.</p><p>5. Make room for complimentary ideas in the methods — yes, Aussies play with aggression, try to unsettle others, play to win first but there should be room for voices echoing alternatives. Say Gary Kirsten (not that is an option now)— who relies on process, grit, technical aspects would compliment the traditional play of Australia.</p><p><strong>Is there a Silver lining?</strong></p><p>Players like Voges, Burns, Khawaja have shown they have the temperament for test cricket, albeit in more friendly conditions. But even in friendly conditions, not many batters play long innings. These are clearly very good players of a very good side.</p><p>Assuming they won’t change their tactics on even friendlier track in Colombo, they will come back to Aus short on confidence with regards to spin. Then would score heavily at home. And go back to India with relatively the same team, only with mental scars?</p><p>CA has already spent hundreds of thousands of dollars if not more on pitches to resemble Asian conditions. But of course, you can not doctor good spin bowlers.</p><p>Hopefully, they would learn that suicidal intent to score runs with all the high risks shots is just dumb. Guys like Voges who bailed Aus out on debut in WI slow turner, Smith on previous India tour — have shown the application and patience before. Hopefully, they just need a reset.</p><p>Guys like Khawaja, Burns, Marsh have technical issues — premeditate the balls and shots; and play with hard hands. Plenty of time to work and correct them under able guidance.</p><p>The Indians were pretty accommodating on Aussies previous tour — providing pitches similar to those in Srl now. This time, the story could be different — Kohli likes to win at any cost, so rolled mud it could be!</p><p>On a secondary note, it is good to have more competitive test cricket. Be it Srilanka’s, WI’s home performance and Pakistan’s away. Test cricket is still lopsided towards the home team, but that has been the case for a long time now.</p><p>Images courtesy Espncricinfo.com.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6bd593e4e8b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/what-can-australia-do-to-stem-the-rot-in-asia-6bd593e4e8b">What can Australia do to stem the rot in Asia?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Don’t despair, Time is a flat circle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/don-t-despair-time-is-a-flat-circle-52233b0dcdf?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52233b0dcdf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cricket]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[australia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ash]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Aug 2015 17:25:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-08T15:18:38.576Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Yes, Eng have surged back to win the Ashes. The Aussies are hurt and are looking at wholesale changes. Clarke would be gone, call for sacking the selectors is on — quite legitimate, though. Lehmann would be called to mend his ways — always playing our natural game, going hard et al.</p><p>But is it all just part of Ashes cricket? Are things ever going to change? Is it legitimate to seek Australian dominance home and away like a couple of decades ago. Don’t think so!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*3a0dsKHQzdfee7E5QqeIYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The backlash is not unlike England. The personnel changed dramatically since their 5–0 drubbing. Then an upstart Australian group had ended the careers of many English cricketers. Calls were made to alter the pitches in England to better cope with pace and bounce in Australia. Similar calls would now be made in Australia to cope better with seam and swing. The roles have reversed. Australia went into the series as if entitled to win it. The new English team seemed more eager and expected little, always a good recipe. The bookies were giving lopsided odds just like 2013.</p><p>In last few years, both countries have traded turmoil following an Ashes campaign. This, of course, is because Ashes is the pinnacle of cricket for them. South Africa always make such noises after their world-cup campaigns — but bar the 2003 debacle, careers seldom end in a heap. South Africa are still winless. New Zealand changed their system of selection and management during the transition from Ross Taylor to Mccullum — the only time it seems the changes have provided long-lasting, proven results. India has had no such troubles — winning and whitewashes are just secondary to the money and the previous achievements.</p><p>Australia were just awful on the first days of the last two tests — the bowling was good but nowhere close to what we have seen in last few years. Steyn, Harris, Philander, Broad, Anderson have bowled, swung and seamed the bowl far better in last few years.</p><p>In the last decade, all teams, barring a few good years have struggled against the moving ball. It all comes down to the quality of the home team and that of the tourist. Current bowlers in England, South Africa, now New Zealand are just better equipped to bowl in the seaming-swinging conditions. Hell, even India beat England recently on a green Lords’ pitch. This Australian attack was just not good enough to exploit the conditions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*3PM0CO9wI3slopzNJTKVkw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Starc has taken a bucket load of wickets, but they have come with balls where the pitch was hardly in the equation. Hazlewood for all the talk of being McGrathesque has a long way to go. Pattinson like he was before the injury, Cummins would surely be more suited.</p><p>Aussie batters exasperate their problems with their technique and bravado. The same trade that makes them the best team in ODIs, by a distance. The same trade that makes whitewashes down under a formality.</p><p>Winning away from home has always been difficult. Australia needs better preparation for seaming conditions, but this has been the case for over a decade now. More settled Aus teams have struggled against SA, England, Pakistan over the decade. Change in personnel wouldn’t alter that. There is no quick fix. Pick younger cricketers, Invest for the long term, lose the cheap talk, and prepare a hell lot better. Smith was disappointing as captain vs. India and he would also take the time to learn the trade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*Ii62PB-cw9J1hCeC.jpg" /><figcaption>Long way to go, Smithy</figcaption></figure><p>Being on the wrong side of the 30s, this should be the end of S Marsh, Watson, Voges. Selectors have to take a call on Siddle — either play him at the Oval in place of Johnson or let it go. Cummins should come in for Hazlewood. Players like M Marsh should be given a longer rope. Getting your stumps knocked off looks uglier than groping outside off but patience is called for.</p><p>In familiar conditions, this younger group would go on to thrash West Indies, and would draw the series with New Zealand and be ready for their first stern test in South Africa.</p><p>Possibly the next Ashes would be a hard fought series between two matured teams. If Australia win, all will be right with the world again. They would still struggle to play in seaming conditions quite often and so would to play quality spin — but so would their opponents.</p><p>It is just the name of the game — compressed first class cricket seasons, the focus on different bowling skills for T20s, the patience expected in T20s, and no centralized agenda over domestic pitches. Case in the point — Root for being the leading run scorer could not just abstain from the drive on a seaming pitch, against Starc, who was finally bowling in a good channel on the second morning. He played and missed a couple within six balls, couldn’t resist and that was it.</p><p>In the words of a great philosopher of our time, Rust Cohle — Time is a flat circle. Everything we’ve ever done or will do — we would do all over again and again. Keep calm, lose the talk, prepare a hell lot better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52233b0dcdf" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/don-t-despair-time-is-a-flat-circle-52233b0dcdf">Don’t despair, Time is a flat circle</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Moment of truth for England or back to the Ashes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/moment-of-truth-for-england-or-back-to-the-ashes-9d7f155995ad?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d7f155995ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[australia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[england]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cricket]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 Jul 2015 09:24:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-18T09:51:43.421Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/628/1*N_h9JsBPbupNDxXcs_JJIw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Back to ashes?</figcaption></figure><p>For all the talk of this being a new England, new setup, learnings from previous series of giving up a lead nothing has changed. The second test of Ashes is going ahead on the lines predicted before the start of the test series. As if the first test never happened. Is this is really a new England? One which in English conditions is on par with Australia? The article is written from a perspective of England — because they are the underdog. I like to say I am a neutral.</p><p>There is a palpable change in England which reflects on the lower-mid order of their batting. But the culprit of this hole like it has been for few consecutive series is the top order. Not only attack is not in their nature, but their defense also doesn’t pose a challenge to the world number 1 team.</p><p>An average of 50 for Ballance just puts in perspective how stats have evolved over the years in Cricket. Is it too early to call time on Ballance? Greats also do go out of form! Yes, but the way Ballance handles the short ball, the low backlift that results in the minimal scoring range, the defensive mindset just doesn’t make a recipe for long time success. One can play with the patience of an average bowling attack (Ind, Srilanka, WI) but against sustained attacking bowling — a scratchy 50 is the best one can expect.</p><p>150 overs in the field makes you do funny things. Yes, but being three down for a handful has been second nature to England. And there was no drop for Root to redeem the innings this time around. He did play and miss quite a few times in the early part of his innings in the first test too. The redemption song of Bell in the second innings in the previous test seems to be premature too. A sixty, when one’s team is at a top, is very different from grinding out of a hole. And Bell’s career has been a story of scoring when the going is good, bar the magic in 2013 Ashes. The way he attempted to play the delivery from Hazlewood was just awful.</p><p>The form of Ballance and Bell has been no secret. But one tried to find solace in their fifties in the first test. If Eng do prepare wickets more conducive for fast bowling or Aus find good overhead conditions — things are going to go only downhill. For all the talk of attacking England, they should make a call now and drop Ballance and give one last chance to Bell. Not because Bell has a longer track record, but because attacking is more aligned with his nature. Lyth is young and should be given another shot. Also, there is no viable replacement from county cricket. The most reliable among the options- Compton was dropped because he was as insiders reported not fitting the old setup.</p><p>Root should move to one down and Bairstow (who is in terrific form, is attacking cricket by nature) should come in for Ballance at 4. Bell should go down to 5. If Eng go back to saying Root only averages 33 in top 3 but a 60+ in 5 or 6 would mean, the new England in tests is just a hoax. He is the man in form, has opened before in tests, and has rebuilt the innings, like a one-down already a plenty of times in his short career.</p><p>Apart from Batting the obvious predicament this time was their bowling. Although touching high 80s mph few times, on a slow, low pitch England don’t have the consistent pace to force a mistake. Few people seem to compare Anderson with Steyn — an artist and what not. But here on a pitch with not much to offer, clear overhead conditions, Anderson had no second plan, no other skill to fall back on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*XtCyondhw_v59XRoalnTqQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Should then Eng prepare more lively tracks? I think yes. I think it is a fallacy to assume the slow-low tracks would negate Australia. Yes, they would become less threatening but more so would England. In the first test — Aus played attacking cricket, bordering on recklessness sometimes. But the same can’t be always expected. And Eng has to win the toss to gain that advantage or otherwise we would see this sorry story repeat.</p><p>The keys to series, yes it a cliche but bear with me were<br>1. How much of an advantage England have over Aus in the middle-lower order?<br>With Nevile and Marsh the English advantage, I presume has reduced.</p><p>2. How much of a disadvantage England have when it comes to top 3.<br>To negate this England has to go back to livelier pitches where attacking mindset of Warner and Smith can be brought into question. Anyhow, the top 3 of England are no good no matter the conditions.</p><p>3. In which conditions can Anderson+Broad+Wood match Starc+Haz+Johnson?<br>Again livelier pitches.</p><p>4. When can Ali+Stokes+Root combine gain an advantage over Lyon+Marsh?<br>Only if there is scoreboard pressure.</p><p>Hopefully, we will see more evenly balanced pitches and England walking the talk when it comes to their team composition in the top 4.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d7f155995ad" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/moment-of-truth-for-england-or-back-to-the-ashes-9d7f155995ad">Moment of truth for England or back to the Ashes</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE GAME OF FEW INCHES]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/the-game-of-inches-and-pain-4d525af7701e?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4d525af7701e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Mar 2015 19:31:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-20T13:52:32.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>The game of few inches</h2><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*p5C0uY8K_JQDSqBOdNVizg.jpeg" /></figure><p>This world-cup had cried for closer contests, for ebbs and flows, just to invigorate another lifeline into a sport which is threatening to become a money-spinner for the bigwigs, turning into a complicated display which might never capture the imagination beyond the erstwhile British empire. Bangladesh, Zimbabwe and to an extent Pakistan helped us with some hope. The associates gave unarguably their best performances in the history to remind us what a sport this could be. The semifinal between New Zealand and South Africa has provided another much-needed shot in the arm.</p><p>I hate entitlements, I hate when journalists throw the word deserve around so loosely but gosh New Zealand just deserve to go all the way, just to add another chapter in history where a humble yet bold, aggressive team won both on the field and in the hearts of the fans. Let me make a case for this entitlement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*wNTgFS8tBBBfQgmHrzNWVA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The spirit in which NZ play is a eulogy in itself. But this transition is not just for the world-cup as a co-host. For over a year now, under the leadership of BMac they have been this good both on and off the field.</p><p>A particularly poignant incident to indicate this was that after the tragic death of Philip Hughes, New Zealand playing an ongoing test match with Pakistan at Sharjah didn’t even bowl a bouncer out of respect. They didn’t even have a close-in fielder for the entirety of the test match. They just went about the motions, didn’t celebrate a famous come-from-behind win, and were aptly lead by a McCullum who hit a double century at a strike rate of over a hundred. It is a testimony to this spirit that in such a close contest today we had no verbals and slurs. Can you expect the same in the other semi-final — I would not get my hopes up.</p><p>I could go on further about New Zealand, but there was another team which wanted this as much, possibly more dearly and, at any cost. It is always painful to see someone lose such close contests but it is this pain that reminds us to cherish these individuals, to cherish such contests and to remind us how at the elite level it is a game of moments, few inches, and could-have-beens. We could discuss further this pain, the emotions that are filling us up but I am more inclined to discuss the cricket nuances, the hits, and misses and I hope they are taken in the spirit of analysis, just to bring closure to possible outcomes in parallel universes.</p><p>Where did it go wrong for South Africa or where did New Zealand really win it? Did the rain and hence D/L calculation botch SA’s chances? Did ABD cost SA the match? Did they choke? I expect all of these 4 questions from an uninitiated fan and from even some reporter looking for a story. I think SA’s true fans, fans of cricket who have lived these circumstances in different matches would go beyond this. This is what I want to make the case for.</p><p>Like SA, New Zealand uncharacteristically also grassed few half chances, missed hitting the stumps — they are arguably the best fielding side after all and one expects them to bucket all. For the entirety of the match it seemed that neither team actually took the match by the scruff. It seemed that both potentially first-time finalists were on their nerves and were playing too polite — you first; oh no, you go ahead; it is ok, I insist.</p><p>But I think the biggest moments came well before even the toss. Philander for Abbott, the humble yet aggressive approach for NZ and the biggest bet of all — SA’s selection for choice of the 5th bowler. In the space of 9 months from the World-cup, SA’s plan for all-rounders went from Kallis and McLaren to polite dibly-dobly pies offered by Behardien, ABD and Duminy. Kallis withdrew for the lack of runs and age, and for the impact Mclaren was having with the ball. Then McLaren was inexplicably dropped for just one bad series against the best ODI side on their home turf. But for what? With Behardien, Phangasio and Parnell in the squad SA played this world-cup with effectively a 12 men team. And add to that the fact that Steyn and Philander didn’t live up to their billing. Compare that to New Zealand who have the fastest to 100 wickets, the all experienced Mills, a very promising Gilespiesque Henry sitting on the bench.</p><p>In all matches, ABD took calls on when to sneak the 5th bowler, arguably he chose the worst moments to do so. Against India and Pakistan, he chose when both teams had gotten off to decent but not run-away starts, at the end of 10 overs; setting a platform for the two teams to launch from. India took full toll, Pakistan not so much. In the semi-final, he bowled Duminy to new at the crease Taylor, who is regarded as very vulnerable at the start and who till this match had always started very slowly. He took Tahir off in favor of Duminy when Guptill was not picking him and when 300 was a long way to go. He brought on Duminy when he could have taken the game by the scruff. Would McCullum, Dhoni or Clarke done the same — there is no way. Was it an unplanned move — No! He had followed the same script earlier as I stated. But this is the match when you have to weigh your decisions with the anxiety the opposition is facing — I am not arguing for a gamble, it was the only way to go.</p><p>The moments after the all-important toss ( a lucky break for South Africa) were filled with nerves. Russow looked assured but played a Rohit Sharmaeque innings, he could be one to look out for though. South Africa accelerated well ahead of what I had expected, mostly to account for the fifth bowler and for the first time in the tournament McCullum was befuddled, the fielders were under the pump. Did untimely and unexpected rain impact the result — who can say? But SA had made up for the blip with Miller and the acceleration prior to the break. 298 was a fair approximation (310 would have been no complaints whatsoever) by DL I would argue. SA had to get at 12 rpo to reach 350 and the key to that was ABD — he could have also got out and SA could have ended with 320–330.</p><p>But one thing is for certain New Zealand have always found a way to come from behind in the last 12 months — be it the epic draw against India, come from behind wins with many players rested in T20s, ODIs, Tests against Pakistan in the middle-east, in home-series against SRL, in the world-cup against Aus, Bangladesh. With the diversity of the individuals who have stepped up, it is fair to say they were always in the game, no matter the score. But one should be able to defend 300 in a knock-out and with SA boasting a top test-bowling attack. It could be owed to equal parts of luck, form, tactics by ABD, injury issues but most significantly the selection of the fifth bowler.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*NPmQUOPvhaoKjUwO0YDGSg.jpeg" /></figure><p>One would think no article on South Africa’s performance would be termed complete if one doesn’t include a discussion on whether they choked?</p><p>A popular definition of choking in sports is “fail to perform at a crucial point in a game or contest as a result of nervousness”. Were they nervous? I think they wouldn’t be human if not. Was ABD, in particular, nervous with those 2 half chances? His super-human abilities belie such arguments but for my faith in humanity I want to believe that all of us, even the super-humans among us are actually not infallible, nerves or otherwise. I would hate to say ABD lost SA the world-cup — he put them there in the first place.</p><p>So did the choke?</p><p>Yes, If you mean they didn’t perform to their highest potential in the field but they are not playing against dummies and such things are part of the sport and they were not that way off.</p><p>No, if you can just feel the heaps of expectations upon their shoulders and as evidence we have the performance of NZ in the field earlier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/792/1*8JKkuE8sf5kEePZibmgfqA.jpeg" /></figure><p>That does it, I hope these 1400 odd words bring some closure as they have done to me. Could we expect such a nail-biter in the other semi-final. My money is on No. Both Australia and India are hardened campaigners and whoever catches a sniff of advantage would in all likelihood drive it through. For the finals, NZ’s bowling form apart from Boult, the lesser likelihood of swing, bigger grounds and their lack of matches in Australia could work against them. But one thing is certain — they believe and they are having fun — a very potent cocktail indeed.</p><p>Images copyright of Espncicinfo.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4d525af7701e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/the-game-of-inches-and-pain-4d525af7701e">THE GAME OF FEW INCHES</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Against the odds, Srilanka is favorites in their match against South Africa]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/against-the-odds-srilanka-is-favorites-in-their-match-against-south-africa-541b647493fe?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/541b647493fe</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Mar 2015 12:45:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-18T09:27:29.903Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Against the odds, Srilanka is favorites in the QFs — But it didn’t work!</h2><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*rHaNOv8vhLpPyjXB6a1VwQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Domingo to enjoy a laugh?</figcaption></figure><p>South-Africa is a bookie favorite for this match and is 70% favored to win. Frankly, I can’t digest such a big discrepancy in match between two top 5 ODI sides at a venue which doesn’t favor anyone, in particular. But this is also as per the bookies the closest match in QFs, so much for close contests.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/365/1*l8RPSEY3cXWfBjDNfBztGw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Or are we looking at this?</figcaption></figure><h4>Teams’ Preview -</h4><p>Herath and Mathews are both expected to be fit. Herath is especially key despite a good balance of left-handers in the SA lineup. Sydney didn’t spin as expected in their match against Australia, but that may be down to the quality of spin than anything else.</p><p>This is very much the weakest Srilankan attack in recent times — Malinga is not what he used to be and if Herath doesn’t recover it would be only up to the SAfrican ineptitude to lose this one.</p><p>Would SA drop Quinton? Would AB actually keep wickets? AB has so far rejected this but this is a crunch situation and their options are limited with Parnell, Quinton both not firing yet.</p><p>Can one expect Duminy to bowl 10 overs of spin at Sydney? Would they include Bahardien over de Kock? Only if AB decides to keep. Duminy along with Bahardien for the 5th bowler is something I can live with at Sydney.</p><p>Would they prefer Abbott over Philander or can they play both? Sydney proved to a batting beauty in the matches prior and relying on Bahardien or out-of-touch De Kock to adding batting depth doesn’t seem right over adding cover in the bowling department. I think the best 11 has to have AB as keeper and Abbott, with Rossouw opening with Amla. I would love to see the 6–5 combination with both Abbott and Philander playing along with Steyn, Morkel, and Tahir. Do I expect this to happen? Actually no but the lack of batting and bowling depth has left not much room. Phangasio, Parnell and to an extent Bahardien are true passengers in this squad; way too many for a 15 men team. In the earlier matches, it was the introduction of the 5th and 6th bowler which eased the pressure on the batting sides. So playing 5 bowlers could be a worth gamble on a batting strip.</p><h4>The key battles –</h4><p>1. Can Steyn deliver? So far a pretty he has had nothing better than a wicket per match. Do I expect him to — I am inclined to believe not, but the eternal optimist Domingo, SA coach believes so.</p><p>2. Can Amla deliver a platform in a crunch match? As much is made of ABDs ability and he being the bedrock of SA’s batting, I think it is Amla whose fortunes would decide their fate. Without a really solid start, I can’t possibly back them while chasing.</p><p>3. Can Srilanka put up a fairly decent bowling performance? In the present squad, even SA shouldn’t mind facing their spinners. If history is any indication Srilanka find a way and with this being the last world-cup of their stalwarts, I am expecting nothing less. Unlike the SA counterparts, they have a lot of big match experience.</p><p>4. SA’s off the boil bowling attack against Sanga, Dilshan, and Jaywardhane. This is their swan song, pretty eager to see how this turns out.</p><p>5. Herath vs ABD — Can the others build on the pressure from the other end?</p><p>Can anything be predicted with absolute certainty? Yes, Whoever wins the toss will bat first because SA has a 3–10 record chasing down targets in excess of 240 since last world-cup.</p><p>And Domingo has again called in Mike Horn to put things in perspective, this after they have Donald, Kirsten, Hussey already. Mike recently said — “I don’t just play, I play to win, I have to win. If you have that mindset where losing is no longer an option and the whole team believes in it and you can create the team that helps each other to move forward and everybody is willing to give more than what’s asked for.” We will see.</p><p>Is it a 70–30 game in favor of SA? I don’t think so, more like 55–45 in favor of Srilanka. The logic in my mind is, if Srilanka bat first it would be 70–30 in their favor; if SA bat first it would be 60–40 in their favor.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=541b647493fe" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/against-the-odds-srilanka-is-favorites-in-their-match-against-south-africa-541b647493fe">Against the odds, Srilanka is favorites in their match against South Africa</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is it Australia’s or India’s cup to lose?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/is-it-australia-s-or-india-s-cup-to-lose-this-world-cup-fed324f320d6?source=rss----8fa3f75a82a4---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fed324f320d6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gurlivleen Grewal]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Mar 2015 12:44:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-13T14:22:15.591Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There has been talk that it has been a boring world cup thus far — scarcity of close contests and for being true to predictions barring of course England’s early exit. But exciting times are ahead, potentially with Ind-Aus, Aus-Pak, Srl-SA, Srl-NZ and Ind-NZ. Have I given the predictions away? ☺I have tried to put a case where all except Austraia, New zealand and India are pretenders in the context of winning this world-cup. It if of course not as clear cut as that and we would explore further next.</p><p>Coming back to the start, a change in format could be the tonic for league games and for England, it was also on the cards given how they were performing since the tournament started. I was disappointed because England did show a lot of fight in the tri-nation series before and their bowling certainly fared unexpectedly poorly. It has been heartening to see associate nations put up a fight and reducing the number of teams has become a topic of debate once again. I agree with the decision by ICC but for different, non-commercial reasons, may be a topic for another post.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*zcgT7wQFr9BTjHW6q6fT3A.jpeg" /><figcaption>How did Bulter survive the English over-coaching?</figcaption></figure><p>As much has been made of England’s batting being from another era — it is their bowling, lack of individuality and the lack of creative captaincy that is hurting them the most. They play most of their cricket in England where bowlers enjoy an advantage even in shorter formats and haven’t developed the skills to outthink batsmen when the shoe is on the other foot. Their reluctance with Tredwell is a case in the point for lack of imagination — he is their premium spinner who has confounded India, Srilanka in the past but thou shall not play two spinners in an English one-day lineup. Individual talents are either cast aside or molded into something they are not — over coaching and emphasis on numbers over individuality has killed the innovation the shorter formats demand. But let’s get over the sad story and see what we have to look forward to in the business end.</p><p>I would go from pretenders to contenders, quarters to semis and then finalists, in that order.</p><p>Well Pakistan would beat Ireland, leaving even West Indies to qualify but they along with Bangladesh are just there to make up the numbers. NZ vs WI and India vs Bangladesh should be as one-way traffic as they come. Yes, Bangladesh did beat England but they were woeful in their warm-up against Ireland not long ago and were thrashed by Srilanka just a match prior, not very becoming of a test playing nation. WI as Holding said are doing a lot of batting but little of thinking. Their tactics and giving up with a fair bit to go against India just indicate their state of mind and ability. Even if Pak does lose to Ireland, the semifinal lineup should not change but I would hate to miss out on how Aus fare against Pak.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*H7mB-DXofZ2pad5l-abUYg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Just looks so yummy! But are we in for Pakistan bowlers to revive their campaign from being pretenders? Mostly not!</figcaption></figure><p>Pakistan are next — they have a match up against Australia at Adelaide. They bowl with a lot of spunk but as evidenced by statistics since the medieval times, like SA they don’t need much to trip them if they end up chasing. Lacking a real quality spinner (Afridi? nah!) and the lack of faith in a good leggie; they are not doubling down on their major strength. But their bowlers always find a way and give them a chance; it is their batting which always comes undone especially chasing. Can they bat first, make 260 and give themselves a chance? History in big tournaments has shown that Pakistan batsmen do find a method to post a decent score somehow if batting first, even when their ardent fans don’t expect them to. So it is not going to be a walk in the park for Australia but I would be just expecting too much for them to lose this one.</p><p>South Africa vs Srilanka at Sydney is tricky — especially if SL get over their injury concerns (Herath and Mathews). Losing Chandimal was a blow too but in all considerations won’t be fatal, but without Herath and Mathews it would be just up to some South-African ineptitude to stop them from winning their first knockout in world cups. Can we rule out the SA ineptitude — ABD thinks yes, he regularly chest thumps that they are the best team in the world; the only captain to do so and who have had a pretty average tournament thus far. He also indicates that his fellow players have to perform and that he can’t win the WC on his own — well, I can’t see how his blame on vibe, minor blimp etc is helping their campaign.</p><p>Even NZ &amp; Austalia have been cautious with respect to their favorites tags, I really don’t know what affords ABD this luxury of boasting. But it might be his personality and the team dynamic. The larger concerns are his below par captaincy and their poor batting aptitude. He doesn’t want to keep because then he can’t communicate with the bowlers but given the repertoire of the bowlers, they should be self-reliant (Even the “poor” Indian bowlers make their own plan and Dhoni interferes only when water is above the neck during the games). His tactics to bowl part-timers at crucial junctures against India and Pak cost them the match, his lack of input on sacking of Mclaren has led to them having the worst 5th bowling option among contenders.</p><p>SA’s bowling has been fairly below par and their batting while chasing has its own sad tale. Frankly I would go on to say they are actually pretenders and the bookies have been over-estimating their value right from the start when they were second favorites, quite ahead of NZ.</p><p>Do any poll and their bowling would be called as the best in the world, what people and fellow experts regularly mistake is their virtues in longer formats over shorter ones. Given enough time they will get all batters out and that too cheaply than most but shorter formats don’t afford this luxury. Steyn can’t have his regular off the boil first spell as he often does in test matches and then get back with his eyes flared up late in the day and turn the match on his head. Philander can’t choke the runs because of luxury of movement and risk involved for the batsman. Morkel can’t build on the pressure and force batters to play higher risk shots, afforded to him by Philander and Steyn. Their best bet in shorter formats is actually their weaker link in the long one — a quality spinner, Tahir. Man he is so consistent. They are again playing by reputation by benching Abbott who is far more skilled one-day bowler then Philander — both upfront and especially at the death.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/365/1*2tTzy0mPzk_A7sV03zu1qg.jpeg" /><figcaption>I want what he is smoking.</figcaption></figure><p>The dissection of SA is turning out to be quite long — one more round on their batsman to go. I guess the long analysis is just because of ABD chest thumps, lack of performance and overestimation by people, please bear with me. While all their batters have by memory the best record since 2013, their numbers are just dismal while chasing — they don’t even last 40 overs combined. Duminy made the right noises after loss of Pak — conceding that they deter from team plans and start individual games when chasing; something they just never do while batting first. But it is a vicious cycle — lack of experience in finishing off while chasing leads to lack of confidence — leading to further losses. Their bet on ABD over Amla as captain in shorter formats doesn’t sit right with me either. In a run-chase, Amla is the biggest wicket and while ABD always sizzles, he also fizzles in equal number via his high-risk shots. Given he is a middle order bat and spends most time at the crease in chases — he should be able to shepherd the chase tactically, inspiring and motivating fellow batters on what to do and when but he is just no Dhoni, Bevan. His high-risk play betrays his faith in the fellow batsman to stick around and his proclaimed claim ‘I can’t win this WC on my own’.</p><p>Coming to the actual match if injury concerns are not an issue for Srilanka, I can see them winning against SA. But this is the only close match I presume in the quarters.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*oOI9UYOD9avR_spXkgvM4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>BMac is architecting a quantum jump in evolution of cricket.</figcaption></figure><p>Now coming to semi-finals — India vs Australia should be close, and can go either way. I would go into more details in next para. But NZ getting knocked out in Semis would be big, I can’t see that, or I would hate to see that because I like their team so much. But their middle order is suspect and heavily reliant of high-risk gambles at the top order by BMac. Williamson who I thought would be lighting up the charts by now has shown quite a few nerves in the first inconsequential opener but then came back to seal it against Australia. But it is their bowling which is so good that it would be near upset for somebody to beat them in NZ, but then it would be prudent not to term it upset when a top nation beats another.</p><p>India vs Australia– I wouldn’t have considered it this close had they played Lyon and Harris. But apart from major threat from Starc, consistent 6.0 rpo for 1–2 wickets for Faulkner and hit and miss Johnson they have nothing as fourth and fifth bowler. If they gamble to include even Marsh at the expense of a bowler to further strengthen their batting — I think it could be curtains. In a knock-out you want clearly defined roles for the batters and not the luxury that there is still batting to come down the order.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*gGhrrEpVcUxvgHDtxSSiHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>It worked? This is crazy!</figcaption></figure><p>Sydney was termed as India’s best chance to pip Australian a test match by Ponting. Their off the boil bowling let go of a potent opportunity then but this bowling unit does seem to have some measure of what to do in Australian conditions now. Can they contain them especially if Australia bats first is a question mark but I think it is the closest contest in Australian conditions, far more than pundits are giving it credit for.</p><p>The other dynamic is India’s proud record in tournaments and their vigor to avenge defeats against Aus. India does seem to be only team which stays in Australia’s face all the time. I would have thought if Jadeja failed completely with the ball it would have further helped India’s cause — because Patel is a much better wicket taking option. Expecting batting from your number 7 is a worthy goal but should not come at the cost of potential wickets especially against Australia’s long batting order and with the new fielding rules.</p><p>So what could be the make-up for the finals — I can see NZ vs Australia or NZ vs India to be the most likely outcomes. Either way it should be the curtains for NZ, whom I must reiterate I admire so much. Three reasons –</p><p>1. Whoever wins the India-Australia match would be on such a high that they would go all the way.</p><p>2. NZ have played no matches in Australia and the conditions are world apart. In NZ, one bowls fuller and gives it a chance to swing and the smaller grounds anyway don’t help with bowling short. In Australia, especially on the flatter and drop-in pitches, the modus operandi is more back of the length. Case in the point Australia struggled against Srilanka bowling full and India nearly lost the plot bowling short against Ireland in their first match in NZ. The ground dimensions and size add another dynamic and reward trying to bounce opposition out. NZ bowlers are world class if it swings may be the best new-ball bowling pair in test matches (Yes, ahead of the SA counterparts!) and could adapt, but their major threats Boult and Southee rely on movement and fuller lengths. McClenaghan is ideally suited for Australian pitches but he has played only one match.</p><p>3. The middle order of NZ with Taylor, Elliot, Anderson doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence. Anderson was playing woefully when put in a pressure situation against Australia, not unlike SA — trying to hit out of trouble. And repeated this inaptitude against Bangladesh. And Taylor has just poor strike rate when it comes to winning performances. This along with their reliance on BMacs tactics of attack with both ball and bat work in smaller NZ grounds but should backfire in bouncier conditions and in crunch situations, against in-form, believing opposition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*cImL2iSb4SnXSznPb8qgtQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The MVP.</figcaption></figure><p>So who would win the cup — I am a betting man but I make sure that it doesn’t matter who wins it to help with my investment. I would have to side with Australia or India. It certainly would be worth a ride.</p><p><em>Pics courtesy espncricinfo.com.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fed324f320d6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket/is-it-australia-s-or-india-s-cup-to-lose-this-world-cup-fed324f320d6">Is it Australia’s or India’s cup to lose?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/smoking-cricket">Smoking Cricket</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>