<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Sprout Stories - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Reflections from Sprouters on learning, innovation, and community. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 01:03:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/sprout-stories" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Learning Tech To-Do List]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories/learning-tech-to-do-list-41409e3bb491?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41409e3bb491</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[open-badges]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[connected-learning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Freeman Cook]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2015 21:39:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-12T03:20:07.919Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A lot of us are working on projects that support the idea that <strong>learning is everywhere </strong>and want to empower learners to access high-quality experiences that match their interests. We work because we know our lives as learners are bigger than any single institution, or location, or subject, or age. We work because we know that learning is the formation of a life, not merely the acquisition of knowledge. Long before me, Henry David Thoreau talked about this idea in better terms:</p><blockquote>“We are all schoolmasters and our schoolhouse is the universe.”</blockquote><p>Some exciting visions for the future of learning have been cast, but there is still so <strong>much foundational work to do</strong>. In order for connected learning to connect in technical practice as well as in theory — in order to build the universal schoolhouse and empower all learners as their own schoolmasters — there are 10 technological challenges we need to work on.</p><p>We are committed to working on this list for the foreseeable future and would love to work with anyone else who is doing the same. It is time to move beyond our aspirational rhetoric and <a href="https://vimeo.com/127258571">inspiring videos</a> and do the hard work to build a technical foundation that actually <em>connects</em> learning.</p><p>Below are the <strong>10 things we need to do</strong>, with accompanying visuals and examples of those projects that have made some progress.</p><h3>#1: Distributed Knowledge Creation</h3><p>At the beginning of the learning cycle, we need tools that enable us to conduct distributed but <em>networked</em> knowledge creation. Generally speaking, we currently either have large silos of internally connected learning resources (e.g. Coursera, Lynda.com) or <a href="https://hackdesign.org/">individual resources</a> or topical platforms disconnected from any system.</p><p>Ideally, a new sort of platform would bring together ideation, publishing, sharing, remixing, and collecting into a single interoperable framework, distributed but connected across the web. This type of technology would enable knowledge creators — creators of ideas and learning resources — to work outside the confines of a monolithic LMS (Learning Management System), but still distribute their work at scale and connect with a larger community of practice.</p><p>We need something like the <a href="https://wardcunningham.github.io/">Federated Wiki</a>, except prettier.</p><p>In a <a href="http://www.wired.com/2012/07/wiki-inventor/">Wired article from 2012</a>, the inventor of the <a href="http://c2.com/cgi/wiki">original Wiki</a>, Ward Cunningham, notes that he “feels bad” about his creation and its inefficient, anti-creative centralization. The traditional Wiki, the article notes, “forces you to give up your own perspective” … “There are issues that no one will agree on, but with the federated wiki model, everyone can have their own version of controversial pages. ‘And they’re all linked together, so you can still explore them like a wiki.’ ”</p><p>With this new infrastructure spearheaded by Ward and others, ideas can be developed independently and then forked, shared, merged, and built upon by others. This platform for distributed knowledge creation combines the scalability and impact of a central platform with the freeing creativity of independent publishing.</p><p>The FedWiki project is still in its nascency and, as the Wired author questions is maybe “too nerdy to catch on?” There’s <a href="https://github.com/WardCunningham/Smallest-Federated-Wiki/issues">a lot of work</a> to be done to push the idea further, improve the visual design, and make it <a href="https://github.com/WardCunningham/Smallest-Federated-Wiki/issues/447">easier to create your own</a> instance. If FedWiki married Medium.com and was then improved and employed for the creation of learning resources, we’d be on our way to something really amazing.</p><h3>#2: Learning Resource Clearinghouse</h3><p>While networked creation tools will help to connect some of millions of great digital resources, we must build tools that help aggregate all resources across both local and digital environments. Of first importance is the creation of regional data-stores that operate local learning opportunity clearinghouses. The entire “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8btSVA-3SsE">socialstructure</a>” of learning is difficult to capture and make machine-readable, but offers us a wealth of resources that are not currently organized.</p><p>These local collections could publish APIs that allow any publisher to re-share a subsection of the collection based on their audience or area of interest. For example, instead of working alone a project like the <a href="http://stemisphere.org/">Stemisphere</a> here in Pittsburgh could aggregate STEM-related resources, add them to the clearinghouse, and then pull out an even broader collection to showcase to their constituents. Stemisphere benefits from having a more comprehensive and consistent collection (due to the other parties collaborating on the collection) and the Clearinghouse benefits from Stemisphere’s topical expertise and regional relationships.</p><p>If we have one open data store to rule them all, learning providers would save a tremendous amount of resources just by the reduction of the administrative time currently required to post their events across numerous disparate platforms.</p><p>As part of our current learning laboratory portfolio at the Sprout Fund, we are prototyping one <a href="http://cityasacampus.org/">open-source tool</a> that tries to solve these data collection problems with a specific focus on lifelong learning resources for adults.</p><h3>#3: Resource Curation Tools</h3><p>Once we aggregate the masses of resources, we will need increasingly powerful tools for the sorting and highlighting of learning resources. Most importantly, this curation must engage not just with digital resources, but the complicated wealth of all local, in-person opportunities. In order to make the scope of resources manageable, the best resources need to rise above the rest to eliminate the <a href="http://archive.wired.com/entertainment/theweb/magazine/17-09/ff_craigslist?currentPage=all">Craigslist problem</a>. To do this we need to raise up the ancient role of librarians by developing curative tools that help us build lighthouses amidst the flood of information.</p><p>One current project in this vein is <a href="http://bento.io/">Bento.io</a>, a volunteer part-time endeavor by Stack Overflow developer Jon Chan. Built on a custom layout by developed by Jon, Bento represents quite possibly the best learning resource curation for web development resources on the entire web. Remember, this is one person volunteering in his spare time. Imagine if we invested in great tools and more comprehensive curation across all subjects!</p><h3>#4 Learning Resource Visualizations</h3><p>Once the resources are all collected and curated, we need to share them with learners. Beyond the obvious formats for search and hierarchical browsing, we need a user-interface that promotes unintentional knowledge. One foundational problem of learning technologies is that you cannot search for what you do not know or have never considered. You do not have the words and do not even fully know what you do not know.</p><p>History is rife with examples of knowledge maps and our best video games have intricate skill trees to highlight progress and opportunity. It is time that we had a user-interface that enables an immersive visual exploration of learning. We need to see where we have been and chart a course for where we want to go. <em>Let’s make something better than a list.</em></p><p>To begin this effort, we have started another project as part of our learning laboratory portfolio: an early prototype of dynamically generated learning maps that can showcase connections and topical affinities. It’s been a <a href="https://github.com/saxifrage/caac-map/issues/31">very incremental progress</a>, but we are headed somewhere interesting.</p><h3>#5 Learning Pathway Technology</h3><p>While visuals will help us begin to express the <strong>structure of learning</strong>, both what we have done and what we hope to do, we still lack the basic foundations of that structure. In order to construct pathways — and relationships between resources in general — we need an interoperable, machine-and-human-readable specification. What do connections between learning resources mean? What do they look like? What are the lower and upper bounds of this expression?</p><p>While learning <em>is</em> non-linear and dynamic, there are useful non-obligatory pre-requisite structures that answer the question “What should I do next?” These kinds of relational models will help to build a network of resources that can express both predefined and emergent learning pathways. Pathway technology will empower learners and educators alike by providing powerful way-finding amongst the wealth of opportunities.</p><p>A small group of us (in one remote circle of the learning-tech world) are just <a href="https://github.com/openbadges/openbadges-discussion/issues/24">beginning to define</a> a linked data structure that can provide this definition and usability for learning pathways. While the “learning pathways” idea has been in full force over the last two years, it still lacks any technical reality. We still have difficult questions to answer. For instance, what are the nodes or steps along the pathway? Are they competencies? Credentials? Experiences? Resources? And how do we account for difficulty variabilities?</p><h3>#6 Digital Credentials</h3><p>To show our accomplishments along these pathways, we need robust digital credentials. Given the amount of recent attention projects like Open Badges have received, one might think this “to-do” was <em>done. </em>Far from it. We are still on <a href="https://openbadgespec.org/">version 1.1</a>. Open Badges exist, but the standard is still very much in its nascency and has yet to fully support the visions that are often discussed in relation to their use.</p><p>The anatomy of badges (and the work of digital credentials more generally) has a lot of evolution left to do in order to: make them truly stackable; enable remixing, sharing, and endorsement; map them to standards and competencies; embed them with evidence for use in a portfolio; provide version control; etc.</p><p>A powerful digital credential standard is inevitable, but will we build one that empowers learners and distributed learning networks or one that only meets the needs of institutions and existing Learning Management Systems?</p><h3>#7 Learner Identities</h3><p>Credentials, and learning data in general, are only valuable if they are verified and organized around your identity, not scattered about the internet. Right now I have details about my progress scattered about the world: college transcripts, high school grades and diplomas, portfolios of work, awards, workshop certificates, DuoLingo stats, Khan Academy achievements, Coursera work, professional development experience, a Degreed profile, etc.</p><p>In the Open Badges world we have the “Badge Backpack”, but the reality of learning technologies is that everyone has 100 “backpacks” strewn about in isolation. In the past, we talked about ideas like <a href="http://chrismcavoy.org/2014/06/23/simplifying-open-badges-federation/">Federation</a> in which all the backpacks would connect. The reality is that we need a single service that empowers learners to have a common identity and data-store across learning environments.</p><p>We need an infrastructure that can represent a single learner identity across 100s of local and digital environments. A single identity controlled by the learner that they take with them to each and every learning experience.</p><p>Though not directly related to learning, projects like <a href="https://onename.com/">OneName</a> and <a href="http://openid.net/">OpenID</a> are working on things in this vein. As was the now de-prioritized <a href="http://identity.mozilla.com/post/78873831485/transitioning-persona-to-community-ownership">Mozilla Persona</a> initiative. Local endeavors, like the the Municipal ID project being undertaken here in Pittsburgh have relevance to this work as well and will have an important role in how we bridge the local and digital contexts.</p><h3>#8 Seamless Interoperability</h3><p>Once my identity is sorted out and we can be <em>ourselves </em>across learning places, we must work to ensure that all these places can share information. By asking for properly scoped permissions when you sign in, platforms should be able to read out and translate your learning data to customize your experience.</p><p>If we are pursuing a distributed learning program (maybe part of a pathway), we need to go from Khan Academy to Coursera to a Mobile App to a local workshop and back again and have each place understand our progress.</p><p>The folks behind the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experience_API_%28Tin_Can_API%29">TinCanAPI or xAPI</a> projects have been working on a simple “Noun, Verb, Object” data structure that could work to capture any type of learning experience. While still maturing, it represents a beginning towards a <em>very</em> difficult problem.</p><h3>#9 Lifelong Learning Archives</h3><p>The end result of all this should be a comprehensive portfolio. An archive of everything you have ever learned. This <a href="https://medium.com/@timothyfcook/the-learner-archive-1c33e8aa1492">archive</a> would provide permanent storage for your learning data and an API service that allows you to control and use it across the web.</p><p>User settings on your dashboard could include a default option to “share data for research” to allow for important meta-analysis of learning so that future learners can <em>see </em>the successful pathways taken before them. Your archive, or parts of it, could be shared or displayed at your discretion on other platforms.</p><p>As a good example of a powerful experience archive, Github does an amazing job of archiving your accomplishments. In their <a href="https://help.github.com/enterprise/11.10.340/user/articles/viewing-your-feeds/">profile view</a>, you can see all of your recent accomplishments at a high-level and drill down to see the exact detail of each contribution.</p><h3>#10 Personal Learning Analytics</h3><p>Utilizing the data from these extensive archives, we can then work on providing powerful personal analytics for learners. Things like goal-setting, progress metrics, and personal dashboards will help us be intentional about the past, present, and future of our learning.</p><p>This kinds of learning dashboards would help us be intentional about our “<a href="http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/178/transcript">super hero lists</a>” (read/listen to Act 2: Wonder Woman). This everyday “super hero” created a list when she was young of everything she wanted to learn:</p><p>“The list included martial arts, electronics, chemistry, metaphysics, hang gliding, helicopter and airplane flying, parachuting, mountain climbing, survival … weaponry, rafting, scuba diving, herbology — yes, I, studied that — CPR, first aid and mountain emergency kind of medicine…”</p><p>Due to the 9 other things that are prerequisites for the full realization of this, little exemplary work exists. The Degreed platform is the best example of this so far, but suffers from its manual nature, it’s lack of accurate accounting, and exclusion of local resources.</p><p>In a way you would be able to <em>see</em> the development of your brain. We can see how far we have progressed towards our masteries in video games, why not in real life?</p><h3>Does any of this matter?</h3><p>Will any of this empower the most struggling students? Will it improve access to quality programs? Is it, in Dewey’s words, serving the primary criterion for a successful student: “a desire for continued growth” and a “capacity for further education?”</p><p>I believe that, <em>if done right</em>, learner-centered execution of the above list would result in a set of tools that would empower learners, foster a culture of “yearning for the sea”, reduce costs, and help us to once again see the pursuit of learning as something paired with the pursuit of life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41409e3bb491" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/learning-tech-to-do-list-41409e3bb491">Learning Tech To-Do List</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories">Sprout Stories</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Quantum Mechanics of Learning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories/quantum-mechanics-of-learning-742f9ba70cc2?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/742f9ba70cc2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[open-badges]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[competency-based-learning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Freeman Cook]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Sep 2015 21:00:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-10-06T15:31:15.907Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Recently, as I have discussed the <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/the-atomic-elements-of-learning-18bd51c7884">atomic elements of learning</a>, it includes things like:</p><ul><li><strong>Competencies (Standards):</strong> Definition of learning one ought to acquire</li><li><strong>Pathways (Courses)</strong>: Relationships between learning objects</li><li><strong>Badges (Credentials)</strong>: Proof of a learning accomplishment</li><li><strong>Resources (Opportunities): </strong>Something one can use for a learning experience</li></ul><p>or more simply, from the learner’s perspectives:</p><ul><li><strong>Competencies</strong> define learning (What should I learn?)</li><li><strong>Badges</strong> offer proof of learning (Did I learn it?)</li><li><strong>Opportunities</strong> are used <em>for</em> learning (How can I learn it?)</li><li><strong>Pathways</strong> set relationships between learning (In what order should I learn?)</li></ul><p>I have struggled with which of the first 3 elements should be nodes on a learning pathway (the aspirational idea we’ve been talking about for a couple years). The more I sketch and dwell on it, the more I am convinced that the concept of the pathway is actually something that should apply, separately, to each of the 3 elements. And still, each of the 3 elements can <em>map to</em> a node on a different elements pathway. In fact, I would go so far as to nominate the word “pathway” to exclusively be used in reference to <strong>resources</strong> (a.k.a learning materials or in-person opportunities), because the word implies past use. A “pathway” is not a untravelled route one <em>might</em> take, but rather a route that <em>is and has been</em> taken. An untravelled route is getting <em>off</em> “the beaten path”.</p><p>To clarify this, another semantic iteration is necessary:</p><p>The 3 primary elements are:</p><ol><li>Competency</li><li>Credential</li><li>Resource</li></ol><p>and <strong><em>each</em> of these can be expressed on a <em>graph</em></strong><em> </em>with a linear or non-learner ordering or nested relationships.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/333/1*pUqlISG1wWRQw32r8kllbg.png" /><figcaption>public domain: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graph_theory#/media/File:6n-graf.svg">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graph_theory#/media/File:6n-graf.svg</a></figcaption></figure><p>The significance of the graph for each element is different:</p><p>A <strong>competency graph</strong> is a <strong>prerequisite structure</strong></p><p>In the open badges framework a <strong>credential graph</strong> is often utilized as either a <strong>prerequisite structure </strong>or an uber-credential (e.g. a <strong>meta-badge)</strong></p><p>A <strong>resource graph </strong>then, has a lot of names: a <strong>syllabus </strong>or <strong>course catalog</strong> or <strong>playlist </strong>or <strong>knowledge map, </strong>or, perhaps, <strong>pathway.</strong></p><p>An issue that has been persistent in this work arises here again:</p><p><strong>Are badges really that different from competencies?</strong></p><p>I think they are, but to maintain this distinction we need to differentiate the terms better between the <strong>competency graph</strong> and the <strong>credential graph.</strong></p><p>For this, let’s explore a poor metaphor:</p><p>I’m taking a trip to Vatican City…</p><ul><li>a <strong>competency</strong> is my destination on a map: Vatican City</li><li>a <strong>credential</strong> is proof of my arrival: the selfie I take in the Sistene Chapel as one part of a larger scrapbook documenting my journey and proving my arrival</li><li>a <strong>resource</strong> is means by which I arrive: perhaps, the taxi I used to get to the Sistene Chapel</li></ul><p>Each of these can be graphed:</p><ul><li>Where I want to go: before I arrived at my destination in Vatican City (my <strong>competency</strong>), I flew first to New York, then through Frankfurt, then took a train, then walked to the Sistene Chapel — a prerequisite structure!</li><li>Proof I have arrived: before I took my selfie (my <strong>credential) </strong>in the Sistene Chapel, I captured and proved my arrival in many other places in my scrapbook.</li><li>Means to facilitate arrival: before I took the taxi (my <strong>resource</strong>) I had to take 3 planes, 2 trains, another taxi, use a suitcase, etc.</li></ul><p>Here, the <strong>competency graph </strong>is a <strong>map; </strong>the <strong>credential graph </strong>is a <strong>set of proofs </strong>that are part of a scrapbook or <strong>registry</strong>; and the <strong>resource graph</strong> is a <strong>means of traversal </strong>or a <strong>collection</strong> of means.</p><p>In an attempt to choose some names:</p><ul><li>I like <strong>competency map </strong>as the unique name for the <strong>competency graph</strong>, it speaks to the aspirational nature of competencies, both for the learner — “Here is where I want to go” — and the educator — “Here is what I want to teach.”</li><li>I like <strong>credential registry </strong>or <strong>credential narrative </strong>as the unique name for the <strong>credential graph </strong>(this implies that there is a set of proof being acquired into a history or <em>archive</em>).</li><li>I like <strong>resource collection </strong>as the unique name for the <strong>resource graph </strong>(this implies ongoing curation of something that could consist of tools and things for <em>use</em>)</li></ul><p>Of course, it might just make sense to refer to these groups of elements in consistent terms, as the <strong>competency graph, credential graph, and resource graph</strong>. I think I like this better…</p><p>The final trick then, of course, is to fully understand the relationship between the elements and their graphs.</p><p>Can you have a 1:1:1 relationship between a competency, credential, and resource graph?</p><p>Can individual credentials and resources be mapped to nodes on a competency graph?</p><p>Most importantly, what is the data model that makes all of this clear and interoperable?</p><p>More soon on the ramifications of this and how it might affect the development of the nascent <a href="http://cityasacampus.org/map/">learning maps</a> project.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=742f9ba70cc2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/quantum-mechanics-of-learning-742f9ba70cc2">Quantum Mechanics of Learning</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories">Sprout Stories</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“A Badge Won’t Make Me Care.”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories/a-badge-wont-make-me-care-4200203c77de?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4200203c77de</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Freeman Cook]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jun 2015 18:28:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-26T13:01:52.103Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O0EFKjbLgGbdIP7Clf8toA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Throughout conversations around the nascent Open Badges concept, one crucial question has been echoed frequently:</p><blockquote>“Aren’t badges just another gold star?”</blockquote><p>At the recent <a href="https://medium.com/the-saxifrage-school/learning-pathways-e411d5aa126b">Learning Pathways</a> summit, two students gave some powerful feedback: “We don’t need a silly badge to tell us we learned something. We want to learn because we are interested, not because of some fake reward.” If a student told me “A Badge won’t make me care!” I would respond “Excellent!” A badge should <em>not</em> make you care; if it does, you might be caring about the wrong thing. The student’s response gets to the heart of the issue. If the ultimate goal of education is to create the self-driven learner, then the artificial motivation of badges is potentially problematic. How do we reconcile the concept of digital badges with authentic motivation as described here by Antoine de Saint Exupery?:</p><blockquote>“If you want to build a ship, don’t drum up the men to gather wood, divide the work and give orders. Instead, teach them to yearn for the vast and endless sea.”</blockquote><p>Or, as Calvin says:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*4vLB6pwS559YWHfruguOpg.gif" /><figcaption>You can present the material, but you can’t make me care.</figcaption></figure><p>Calvin’s comment may seem obnoxious, but it is profound and simple: we cannot <em>make</em> someone care. Caring requires an intrinsic motivation that comes from agency, not instruction. There is a careful distinction that must be made when designing and issuing badges: a badge is not a goal in itself, but a representation of what we have learned. This needs to be held out in front of every badge design process.</p><p>The badge is neither a means nor an end. Let us not use badges as a tool for motivation, but as a tool for way-finding and archiving. They may look pretty, but their real power lies in their ability to visualize opportunities and capture learning. Badges should not make us care, but they can help us <em>see</em> what to care for and hold on to it for the future. While badges are motivating to some people, that should not be <em>our</em> motivation for creating them; motivational trinkets have been around for a long time; badges have been around for a long time. In our pursuit of digital and open badges we must focus on what is unique. What new capacity do digital badges give us? If we are just creating badges as gold stars, we are doing it wrong.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DCjKFLw9tKEdYdhdBX_TTA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Skill tree for the MMORPG <a href="http://www.pathofexile.com/passive-skill-tree/">Path of Exile</a>. In games we require these visuals to help us “know” we have gained sword-fighting abilities and to plan our characters as we level up.</figcaption></figure><h4>Way-finding</h4><p>Badges are the right tool to organize possible learning goals and find our way from opportunity to opportunity. The world of learning is a diverse network of opportunities. Badges help us track our progress through the points along the network and decide our next steps. We need something like badges to make personalized <a href="https://medium.com/the-saxifrage-school/learning-pathways-e411d5aa126b">learning pathways</a> commonplace for students. These pathways happen all the time without badges, but the intentionality of badges helps to increase the access to these pathways and improve their quality and breadth. Badges help us to be intentional about our learning by marking and mapping everything we can learn. If a city-wide badge system were to mature, learners could use it to visualize their possible futures as a learner. As in so many games, this kind of visualization lets us see how our experiences have equipped us for future opportunities and who we are becoming as a result.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FS9KbEgb6yMUZeDIh6FoXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Imagine each of these nodes as badges within a learning archive; imagine that the colored clusters are different skill areas, and the lines represent relationships or pathways between badges.</figcaption></figure><h4>Archiving</h4><p>Badges are the right tool to capture our accomplishments into a lifelong portfolio that includes proof-of-work, data, multimedia evidence, and a scope and sequence of accomplishments. Badges offer a new level of detail that goes beyond grades and majors to capture the nuance of a learner’s work. Imagine something like the image above, or these personal “<a href="http://feltron.com/">annual reports</a>” to help us understand the development or our minds and abilities.</p><p>The archives provided by badges have both personal and public use. Badges enable learners to track the details of their learning over time and let them share a rich portfolio of endorsed experiences with potential employers.</p><p>More than a simple portfolio, a layer of badges gives that portfolio the data it needs to be sorted, understood and viewed quickly, both by humans and machines. A portfolio with badges is a portfolio that is both qualitative <em>and</em> quantitatively detailed. The learner can present their work in two ways: “Here is the website that I built” and “I am a CSS expert”. A badge provides proof of that expertise from a trusted third-party. That proof is supported by evidence from their portfolio: a link to the website they built and its documentation.</p><h4>What do I do?</h4><p>Badges are a tool for communication and data. They help us to create learning pathways that span digital and local environments and employ the entire city as the campus. Learning pathways are crucial to the future of education: they enable students to pursue learning that is driven by their interests, not limited by their access to resources. If you want to help make Badges and Pathways a reality—and to ensure that Badges are <em>not</em> just another gold star—get involved on the international level with the <a href="http://www.badgealliance.org/">Badge Alliance</a> working groups, or on a local level with the <a href="http://pghcityoflearning.org/join/">Pittsburgh City of Learning</a> working groups.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4200203c77de" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/a-badge-wont-make-me-care-4200203c77de">“A Badge Won’t Make Me Care.”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories">Sprout Stories</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Cities of Learning?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories/why-cities-of-learning-9f737bd841d3?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f737bd841d3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Freeman Cook]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jun 2015 18:27:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-30T14:53:06.457Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SNHYdgxuxGw_VmQI7P1S_A.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://medium.com/@timothyfcook/why-cities-of-learning-tl-dr-version-b576ce0cd883">tl;dr</a></p><p>In all of my work for the last 8 years I have operated with a simple design principle: <a href="https://medium.com/the-saxifrage-school/the-saxifrage-school-part-i-90b2f701e712">the <em>how</em> must come from the <em>why</em>.</a> As we embark on year two of the Cities of Learning initiative it seems necessary to step back and consider <em>why. How </em>we do this work must be inspired by that answer.</p><p>We are already busy working to create a functional and beautiful technology platform, to connect organizations to the effort, to train educators, and—most importantly—connect with learners. It is easy to lose the purpose amidst the jargon and the road maps.</p><p>So, <em>why</em>?</p><h3>Learning Happens Everywhere</h3><p>More than anything, the purpose of Cities of Learning is to reclaim and recognize the value of learning experiences outside of school. The very fact that we have to argue for “learning everywhere” highlights a failure. Of course we learn everywhere! Of course we learn both in and outside of schools. The work to validate and showcase the breadth of our learned experiences is basic and imperative.</p><p>In addition to an unfortunate discounting of non-school learning, we have reared generations who often equate “learning” with “boring.” The branding agency helping City of Learning to appeal to youth has mentioned that it might be best to remove the word “Learning” from the name. “Learning” has an image problem. We wouldn’t name it “City of Boring,” would we?</p><p>Our work, it seems, is not only to validate <em>all</em> of learning, but to redeem learning itself. Our work is to give learning a context throughout life: in our schools, in our play, in our friendship, and in the woods. This requires much more than the re-branding of “Learning.” It requires an authentic shift to experiences that let learners pose problems and find solutions for the issues of their lives, rather than the issues of school. We must let learners engage with the actual work of building the world they live in, rather than 18 years of mere preparation.</p><p>The “City” context for City of Learning, of course, is completely arbitrary. The place in which we live<em> </em>is necessarily the place where we learn. If we reclaim the meaning of “Learning,” I think, we arrive at something like “the act of improving our ability to live in a place.” For an increasing number of people, this place—the context for learning to live better—is a city, but also the country, or the suburbs, or the corners of the internet.</p><p>As mentioned, this problem is not a new one. Thoreau’s journals observe the following:</p><blockquote>“As some give to Harvard College or another institution, why might not another give a forest or huckleberry-field to Concord? A town is an institution which deserves to be remembered. We boast of our system of education, but why stop at schoolmasters and schoolhouses? <strong>We are all schoolmasters, and our schoolhouse is the universe. </strong>To attend chiefly to the desk or schoolhouse while we neglect the scenery in which it is placed is absurd.”</blockquote><p>In the end, the purpose of City of Learning and the digital badges it uses to mark learning experiences is to expand the schoolhouse further into the universe, beyond the walls of the school itself. Although learning happens everywhere, we struggle to <em>count</em> it everywhere. Open Badges fill this need by providing the mark of legitimizing data. With them, we can begin to count, and therefore value, learning experiences across our lives. Badges are a <a href="https://medium.com/the-saxifrage-school/a-badge-wont-make-me-care-4200203c77de">mechanism for exploration</a>.</p><h3>Learning Should be Personalized and Interest-driven</h3><p>In first grade, my father was reading at a fifth grade level. To make sure he wasn’t bored, his teachers moved him into the fifth grade reading class. He had great teachers, loved the challenge of it and enjoyed the books they read. Unfortunately, because his school only went up to the fifth grade (and he wasn’t ready to skip ahead in all grades) he had no option but to <em>stay</em> in that fifth grade reading class as he went through grades 2, 3, 4, and 5 in his other courses. He was stuck for 5 years in the <em>same </em>class, reading many books multiple times.</p><p>Like so many others, everyone really, my father needed the freedom to exercise his ability and interests by pursuing learning beyond what his school provided. Even the most excellent schools with the best teachers have these limitations. While his case is an extreme example, every teacher recognizes the limits of what they can offer, and every student, regardless of proficiency, can participate in learning beyond the walls the classroom. Where do we send the student who is inspired by their teacher to love robots but whose school just has one robotics course? What about the student who loves his science class, is fascinated by the water cycle and wants to explore the rivers? How can we empower teachers with local resources to help extend learning beyond the classroom for their students?</p><p>In the past, the work required to personalize learning for each student amidst the distributed sea of opportunities was overwhelming. The ability to personalize is directly related to each educator’s access to resources and the time and energy available to connect students with those resources.</p><p>Through collaborative, data-driven learning networks, more diverse and personalized learning pathways are now possible and accessible without such a heavy burden on individual educators. But first, we have to build the network.</p><p>Through the City of Learning and digital badges, the act of documenting learning wherever it happens is possible. Notably, this is not an attempt to control more of a student’s life, but less. In a sense it is an act of faith believing that, given a certain freedom, students will seek out that which interests them. Let us integrate the great resources of our schools with the opportunities in the world beyond: apprenticeships, videos, service work, mentors, digital courses, workshops, meetups, games, etc. Through this, we can enable learners to use their schools not as the alpha and omega of their educational options, but as a home base for their life as a learner.</p><p>While it is possible for schools to offer <em>a lot</em> for their students, it is wrong to assume they should offer <em>everything</em>. Even if resources were unlimited, the interests that a learner should pursue will often require a different context and a non-peer community.</p><h3>Access to Resources</h3><p>The City of Learning initiative is, in many ways, a technology project. Because of this, there has been a lot of thoughtful criticism around issues of access. If we build a tech platform for accessing learning resources, what about learners who lack the tech to make use of this?</p><p>Right now, Pittsburgh City of Learning does not have the resources to pursue a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_to_one_computing_%28education%29">one-to-one</a> initiative, but we are equipping partners with technology, working with the public libraries, and focusing on mobile design and sms integration so that anyone with a cell phone can utilize City of Learning resources.</p><p>The issues of access that we hope to address in this work go beyond the technical requirement of having a device to log-in. Rather, we hope to address issues of access and equity by creating new out-of-school-time <strong>data sets</strong>, expanding <strong>learning networks</strong>, and complementing school <strong>resources</strong>.</p><h4>New Data</h4><p>Current data in the out-of-school-time education space is extremely limited. Because of this, it is difficult to identify disparities between students and resources and issues of quality, outcomes, and breadth. By creating a distributed network for out-of-school learning resources, City of Learning will create a lot of powerful data that can start to answer questions like:</p><ul><li>Do the kids from this low-income north side neighborhood have immediate access to any robotics workshops? If not, are they making the trip across town to an affluent neighborhood that does offer these workshops?</li><li>Do the number of resources in neighborhoods adequately match up to the quantity of learners in those neighborhoods?</li><li>Are there areas of the city that are completely lacking certain categories of learning opportunities?</li><li>Which neighborhoods are not attending out-of-school time learning events with much frequency?</li></ul><p>We hope that, by creating data to answer these questions, funders and educators can begin to direct resources more appropriately.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0njm9PWSTN6LlZn6eQm6hw.png" /><figcaption>Example of some early City of Learning data from Chicago</figcaption></figure><h4>Expanding Learning Networks</h4><p>A basic fact about learning communities is that they are relational and, often, limited by who you know or where you live. This is great if you live in a wealthy neighborhood and have immediate relational connections to the organizers of good quality learning programs. Kids are often whisked off to whatever learning programs are easily <em>found</em> by themselves or their parents. This is bound by their network and, to some degree, whatever social capital that learner has. By capturing the entire network of learning resources within a city (and, hopefully, online) the City of Learning can empower learners (and their families) to identify and sign up for opportunities outside of their relational networks.</p><h4>Complementing Schools</h4><p>As mentioned above, schools can provide a great home base for learners, but often have limited resources. By networking learning opportunities city-wide, City of Learning can come alongside schools not just with one or two out-of-school-time partnerships, but with an expansive map of resources. And, by using data-rich open badges and the City of Learning tools, these learning experiences beyond school can matter and be <em>counted</em> in entirely new ways. Students who only have access to schools with very limited resources could complement those resources with resources from the City of learning network. This complementary network can even be driven by the school. The school, functioning as a home base can provide the structure and relational support needed for students to use the entire city as their campus.</p><h3><strong>So, why Cities of Learning?</strong></h3><p>Because education means learning to live better in <em>every</em> place we find ourselves.</p><p>Because learning should be driven by interests, not limitations.</p><p>Because access to great learning should not be limited by fragmentation, social capital, or isolation.</p><p>I earnestly hope that, through City of Learning, schools can become home-bases for us as we explore our cities and learn how to live better in all places. Our whole lives and our whole places must be contexts for learning. We are all schoolmasters and our schoolhouse is the universe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f737bd841d3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/why-cities-of-learning-9f737bd841d3">Why Cities of Learning?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories">Sprout Stories</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Reflections on the Q2 Mozilla Work Week: From the MoFo Learning Networks Side’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories/let-s-think-about-the-internet-8bc70ee635bd?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8bc70ee635bd</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ani Martinez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jun 2015 18:27:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-07-01T21:23:49.959Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>‘Reflections on the Q2 Mozilla Work Week: From the MoFo Learning Networks Side’</p><p>Let’s think about the internet.</p><p>Now let’s think about change.</p><p>These are both fluid yet giant concepts that (can when used as tools) build great products, empower people, and create value for those that embrace them, “the users”. With nearly 3 billions users online, and another 5 on the way (altogether around 100% of the world’s population), it’s time to add people to the equation.</p><p>internet + change + people = what?</p><p>Well, influence for one thing. That’s why, when a company like Mozilla with 350 million+ users wants to use its influence for good, it’s going to attract some attention. But we also know that when you’re looking at something as powerful as the internet, piloting change for the people isn’t easy. To quote Chris Beard, “Piloting change, moving forward… is hard.” Also, let’s face it, though impressive, 350 million boils down to around 5% of all the people.</p><p>What if only 5% of all the humans on Earth think that an open internet that keeps people, product, and values as the driving force to the future (Mitchell Baker) is the leading priority? SHIT.</p><p>It’s no surprise then that it’s been a “rocky path to unified leadership,” (Baker) to get a little internet company called Mozilla into its “New 3rd Age.” Since dominating the market, Cloud, Social, and Data has given the Mozillians a hefty chunk of frontier space to catch up on. But, according to Baker, if “Space (the new frontier) is different, so must be the product. And we are going to Space!” Aspirational, yes. An abused metaphor throughout the week, yes. A rallying cry for the Mozilla Foundation? Yes.</p><p>This thought was echoed by David Robertson (Norton School of Business for LEGO) that in business with huge diversity, but with only a few essential elements, that Mozilla can and must broaden its relationship with the market with 1) Story and 2) Product. He challenged all Mozillians to consider what the world would miss if they were gone. For LEGO, it was ‘the Brick.’</p><p>Coupled with Chris Beard’s comments that “we need to keep the internet open (for people),” and that “people are living increasingly mobile lives (so we have to build mobile products),” seemed to spark the entire Mozilla Foundation (MoFo) community into action.<strong> Remember, LEGO says think about 1) Story and 2)Product. </strong>Marc Surman further stirred the soup by adding, “Millions of Facebook users don’t know they’re using the internet.”</p><p>Now we see where MoFo comes in, which Jono Bacon slam dunks in a (later) talk:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eJOTWxQ5SG8vczMa." /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AjMnWpUhHBSxakGd." /></figure><p><strong>Stop, let’s review:</strong></p><ul><li>Values, Product, People = the Future</li><li>the New Frontier (Space) = Cloud, Social, and Data</li><li>First: Story; Second: Product</li><li>Find Your “Brick”</li></ul><p>Now then, in the last 18 months, MoFo has undergone some “tremendous change.” 30 people have left out of the 3 remaining teams across the organization and in that tumult they have somehow continued to create visibility in the public eye, but have (perhaps) lost sight of their own “North Star.”</p><p>Currently, MoFo is represented in the following focus areas:</p><ul><li>Fellows/Advocacy</li></ul><p>MoFo Leaders</p><p>Build in the Open</p><p>Mentors</p><ul><li>Inclusion</li></ul><p>Engage the 5 billion coming online</p><p>Find out what it is we don’t know</p><ul><li>Fundraising</li></ul><p>The Drumbeat for “One Mozilla”</p><p><strong>Unify products and learning to create social currency</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Relationships</strong></li></ul><p>The Public: support digital literacy basics</p><p>Leaders: Improve skills; give back to the community</p><p><strong>Partnerships/Allies: </strong>What is it that Mozilla provides? What does it need from others?</p><ul><li>Web Literacy 2.0 (An-Me)</li></ul><p>Web-Lit Map</p><p>21st C. Skills Map</p><p>helping diverse groups understand why this is important</p><ul><li>“Universal Web Literacy” (David Asher)</li></ul><p>how can marketing, brand, and tools build on “human universals” (eg- inclusion) to <strong>catalyze participation in the open?</strong></p><p>Mozilla-wide</p><p>How to implement ‘action at a distance’</p><p>no funding</p><p>consideration for diversity</p><p>From these 6 groups, each are driven by one question: “How can Universal Web Literacy empower people to participate?” So, from this we can assume a few things.</p><ul><li>That there is a space for opportunity</li><li>That there are individuals and groups ready to participate</li><li>That MoFo can help inform the work</li></ul><p>(values, people, product <em>kind of)</em></p><p>From these six groups emerge Work Week Teams: Product, Fellows, Fundraising, Strategic Planning, Participation, and Mozilla Learning Network. Think of it this way, if we can learn from the Environmental Movement that has mobilized people from all over the world to care about keeping the Earth healthy, then Mozilla is striving to do the same for the Open Web. (“Keep it wild and free!”) This can mean more than just Net Neutrality and Privacy, though MoCo/MoFo will utilize these themes and driving campaigns to sell product and ideology. For certain partners, this can act as a label of quality or ideals, like an “Organic Certification.” Are you working toward Universal Web/Digital Literacy? Do you practice in the Open? Is your learning Social? (Cloud, Data, Social) Then think about working with MoFo! <a href="http://gph.is/1PjulFR">Easy right?</a></p><p>So again, PAUSE. The Participation Team says, “MoFo, we must now start to solve problems in real time.” and asks us, “What will participation in the Mozilla 3rd Phase look like?”</p><p>PLAY</p><p><strong>Timeline to reaching the “3rd Phase Vision”</strong></p><ul><li>3 year process</li><li>take the next 9 months to figure out what to say to the board</li><li>consolidate the MoFo web presence</li><li>Build curriculum for Moz.Teach &amp; Fellows</li><li>Do some ‘market research’ around the MoFo constituency<a href="https://teach.etherpad.mozilla.org/peoplepathways"> (for example)</a></li><li>find out where the constituency stand on credentials?</li><li>does volunteering with MoFo get you a job (if you want one) or build skills (if you’re already a professional in the field)?</li></ul><p>(<em>…this isn’t really a timeline, they are GOALS for the next 3 years, </em><strong><em>but we can talk about that in a different conversation — </em></strong>)</p><p><strong>In logic, it looks like this: <em>If we</em>___________ + <em>then we will</em> __________ + <em>ultimate outcome</em> _________+ <em>key indicator of process</em>:__________________</strong></p><p>Take a look at this in action <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H-jB9DS_JARjldb5SlTOfnlHdT5VvR8NtTudzt_qMFY/edit">here.</a></p><p>Here’s what we were able to bring to the table to start answering the above prompt:</p><p>MoFo Is…</p><ul><li>able to catalyze participation</li><li>trying to build career pathways</li><li>create access</li><li>a brand</li><li>creates visibility</li><li>is an advocate for the Open Web</li><li>wants to build sustained engagement</li><li>made up of different groups (see the six above)</li></ul><p>In order to help reduce the “friction created by nuance”, the Learning Networks Team (or MLN) split up to examine the following and help write the MLN Story:</p><ol><li>Purpose</li><li>People</li><li>Programs</li><li>Presence</li></ol><p>And after 2 days, this is what we came up with:</p><p><strong>Purpose</strong></p><p>“The Mozilla Learning Network cultivates diverse communities of web literacy leaders who are connected globally but act locally to teach others how to read, write and participate on the web.”</p><p><strong>remix:</strong> Mozilla Learning Network cultivates web literacy leaders who advance reading, writing and participation on the web.</p><p><strong>Activities that support the Purpose statement:</strong></p><p>[READ]</p><p>Provide language, tools, experiences, and community to demystify the web</p><p>[WRITE]</p><p>Build skills and confidence that give people agency to write the web</p><p>[PARTICIPATE]</p><p>Grow a community of leaders through multiple entry points to participation</p><p><strong>Measures [rough]</strong></p><p>[READ]</p><p>Robust offerings and events at teach.mozilla.org</p><p>[WRITE]</p><p>More contributors to our open knowledge base and resources</p><p>[PARTICIPATE]</p><p>Our relationships with leaders result in life outcomes they say they value</p><p>Included with the Purpose Statement was a short description of An-Me’s work, underpinning 21st C. Skills to the <a href="https://teach.mozilla.org/teach-like-mozilla/web-literacy/">Web Literacy Map</a>; think of these as the primary tools to help teach digital literacy, a “step one” to the (eventual) greater participation map.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ASRBgII7mYZ_HgP8." /></figure><p><strong>People</strong></p><p>Next, we thought about who the main audience and contributors would be in a Mozilla Learning Network. It’s of note that we are first looking at the <strong>Cultivation of Leaders, </strong>such as Fellows and members of other Networks whose work aligns with that of the MLN.</p><p>You can see here a few exemplars of what those personas look like:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AK9TT4tojWIUPDxM." /></figure><p><strong>Programs</strong></p><p>Then, we considered simplifying (or clarifying) some of the language we use to describe Network Stakeholders. For instance, Maker Party = the Campaign to promote Web Literacy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*N5-2AWotbIvbjGOO." /></figure><p>Then, <a href="http://gph.is/119bkLX">after many drafts </a>we landed on this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YlzGJZuAgZpmmIxK." /></figure><p><strong>Disclaimer</strong>: This is the simplest version! The task at hand was to create a story you could tell to a child. The movement implied is representative of Campaign Channels and Messages (Such as Maker Party, Privacy, and Product ((People, Values, Product…)) ), but does not currently visualize movement from outside MLN nor within the Network itself.</p><p>At the heart of this “most challenging” task, it became evident that the need for a strategic plan between MoFo and MoCo is not only necessary, but should be effective immediately. For example, MozFest may not be the most productive place for MoFo/MoCo teams to communicate for the first time. For instance, what a great <a href="https://beta.webmaker.org/#/">opportunity is being missed by not building in messages about MLN into the product itself?</a></p><p>We also hear echoes of an unmentioned theme, “Act Local, Impact Global.” An oldie that still has lessons to teach, right? It is clear that Mozilla is invested in cultivating leaders, but outside of Clubs and Fellows is a bit unclear how partners (generically lumped into “Networks” here) can act on their initiative <em>yet.</em></p><p>Moreover, it is difficult to visualize authentic participation without a means (or even real understanding) to communicate the serious time it takes to enable it. But again, different conversations for a different day.</p><p><strong>Presence</strong></p><p>What work is supposed to get done between now and MozFest (October)?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zi2maLHr7xwwVWX6." /></figure><p>My hope, after 3(ish) days of building a narrative map of this kind is that we, the Learning Networks Team, managed to build a story that is clear and gives Mozillians goals that are not just moonshots, but <em>tasks that will be delegated.</em></p><ul><li>Facilitate Feedback from Stakeholders</li></ul><p>find out what they need from us</p><p>find out what they want to give back</p><ul><li>Manage Partnerships &amp; Build New Ones</li></ul><p>“don’t fight your competition/funders, date them!”</p><ul><li>Fundraise through a unified Mozilla</li><li>Build Content &amp; Organize entry points for newcomers/outsiders</li></ul><p>sustain engagement</p><p>don’t lose momentum</p><ul><li>Advocate</li></ul><p>for learning</p><p>for privacy</p><p>for the open web</p><p>for science</p><p>for product (and product will advocate back)</p><p>And the Brick? Maybe it’s “Open.” That’s what I hope, because there’s plenty of room (not to mention a hefty learning curve) for learning and making and building and socializing and diversity within Open. But like LEGO, huge diversity does not mean an equal number of elements, and if MoCo/MoFo leadership can delegate the tasks at hand, facilitate truly participatory channels, and lift its products to lead by example (<a href="http://gph.is/14Jhbvn">while looking good and functioning properly</a>) then maybe we can catalyze participation in the open. Maybe we can make a place in the new frontier. #internet</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8bc70ee635bd" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/let-s-think-about-the-internet-8bc70ee635bd">‘Reflections on the Q2 Mozilla Work Week: From the MoFo Learning Networks Side’</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories">Sprout Stories</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Atomic Elements of Learning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/sprout-stories/the-atomic-elements-of-learning-18bd51c7884?source=rss----f0aaa4287381---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18bd51c7884</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Freeman Cook]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jun 2015 18:27:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-06-30T20:18:57.707Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*vgYfR0k6XE3Whg9c859xBA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/darrencullen/5197315166">https://www.flickr.com/photos/darrencullen/5197315166</a></figcaption></figure><p>In the early stages of designing the future <a href="http://pghcityoflearning.org/">Cities of Learning</a> platform, we have discussed the types of elements that live within learning systems. In the effort to create a fully interoperable digital learning framework, we struggle to create something that is both uniquely customizable and machine readable. How can we let humans express the nuances of learned subjects, while also codifying that learning in a way that is easily sorted, analyzed, and ordered? The answer lies somewhere in the middle and requires us to solve two simultaneous challenges that arise amidst the 3 atomic(ish) elements of learning.</p><p>Our initial work on Cities of Learning and Open Badges has been confused by a lack of definition between these three elements: credentials, competencies, and resources. How do these three elements relate? Which element is the smallest and least divisible? What do we need to build to properly represent them? What complicates this discussion is that, in certain cases, the three elements can look very similar and have a 1:1:1 relationship. For example, one could have a resource (a “Chisel-Sharpening Workshop”), a credential (the “Chisel-Sharpener” badge) and a competency (“Chisel Sharpening”) that were, essentially, identical. This, however, is a special case. The framework designed to express these elements must be something that has proper significance in <em>all</em> cases, even if it seems redudant in some. To design this framework, we must de-conflate these three elements and understand their unique role.</p><p><strong>Resource: </strong>Any opportunity that can be used for learning, including both local and digital resources, people and media.</p><p><strong>Credential</strong>: An artifact that proves you have learned or experienced something of value.</p><p><strong>Competency: </strong>A specific knowledge, skill, or disposition you have acquired as a result of your learning experience.</p><p>And don’t forget the wildcard modifier: <em>difficulty</em>.</p><h4>Credentials and Competencies</h4><p>To start, we need to reconcile the proof of learning (credentials) with the outcomes of learning (competencies). This requires a certain degree of humility and creativity. The easy but incorrect approach is to conflate the two. Can’t we just credential each competency and then bundle those proofs-of-competency into larger credentials?</p><p>As logical as this sounds, this does not account for the complexity of human development. Learning is <em>not </em>limited to the acquisition of orderly elements, it is the formation of an identity and the pursuit of better ways to<em> know</em> and <em>do </em>and <em>live</em>. Moreover, the primary focus on competencies as <em>the</em> atomic element is problematically reductionist. Learning experiences are at their best when they are creative, interdisciplinary, and formational. Designing strictly for competencies is antagonistic to good learning design where a more a holistic approach is required.</p><p>Credentials cannot be divided exactly into a number of competencies. To support creative learning design, we need to support <em>both</em> credentials and competencies as related, but uniquely irreducible elements. Credentials provide a creative construct for creators to define and provide proof for the whole scope of the experience. A credential could include:</p><ul><li>a description of the overall experience</li><li>details of the activities</li><li>qualitative claims about the student by the instructor</li><li>evidence created by the student</li><li>specific criteria required to earn the credential</li></ul><p>Credentials provide proof, definition, and evidence on behalf of the overall learning experience. Competencies, then, provide an extra layer of definition by calling out specific non-unique outcomes that were part of the larger experience. The role of competencies is to call out improvements in abilities that are common to many experiences.</p><p>I’ve been watching <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/23/sports/soccer/womens-world-cup-us-wins-after-colombias-keeper-gets-red-card.html?_r=0">World Cup Soccer</a>, so I think a good sports example is in order. In the World Cup, each soccer player has a unique identity and a cumulative set of unique experiences. Yet, within their uniqueness, they have common traits: ball-handling, leadership, muscle-mass, etc. The players cannot be fully defined by their common traits, they are unique players and must be understood as a whole. Still, when we begin to compare them to other players, we begin to reference those commons traits. e.g. “Abby Wambach is so much taller than the Colombian goalie.” or “Meghan Klingenberg has better ball-handling skills than the other defenders”. To talk about soccer players, we need two kinds of elements: whole people and specific traits.</p><p>The whole is <em>not</em> the sum of its parts. When we are talking about human identities and lived experiences, the wholes are creative, complex, and not entirely reducible. Similarly, using credentials and competencies in combination allows learners and educators to be simultaneously complex and specific. Despite the limitations of credentials, they are a generic structure that allows the creative capturing of an entire learning experience. Competencies, then, can map onto credentials and point out specific common outcomes.</p><p>To summarize:</p><p><strong>Credentials: </strong>Provide a proven story of the learning experiences.</p><p><strong>Competencies:</strong> Reference specific transferable outcomes.</p><h4>Resources</h4><p>Adding the third element, <em>resources</em>, into the mix makes a crowd of three elements. As we build the future of Open Badges and learning resource platforms like City of Learning, how should <em>resources</em> signify their relationship to credentials and competencies?</p><p>Utilizing a <em>resource</em> (something you learn <em>from, </em>e.g. a workshop or a book or a game<em>) </em>can result in a learner acquiring a new competency or a credential, but there is not always a one-to-one relationship. You do not complete one resource and gain one credential or one competency. What confuses this issue is that, very often, there <em>is</em> a one-to-one ratio. Sometimes you do sign up for a single class (a <em>resource)</em> and earn a single credential. Sometimes a credential represents a single competency.</p><p>To best signify the three-fold relationships and the complexities that they need to represent, we need to consider resources as the foundational element, overlaid with credentials that are earned when one experiences certain combinations of resources. These credentials are then overlaid by their associated competencies. Credentials, however, can have a direct relationship with the resource. Even if a learner is not earning an entire credential from a particular course, that course may constitute a “level-up” in a specific competency.</p><p>This last pairing, of resources directly related to competencies, is something that the community has not yet pursued with any seriousness. The idea that one could receive “credit” but not a <em>credential</em> for improving a specific competency after engaging with a learning resource requires a serious level of data granularity that does not yet exist.</p><p>The way this type of progress has been recorded in other systems is through a point system. Each learning resource, when completed, provides the learner with a number of points for each associated competency. The number of points is weighted by the estimated level of improvement one might receive from completing that resource or, possibly, could be awarded by the educator on a case-by-case basis. One student’s work in a specific workshop might merit 10 competency points related to the improved leadership competency while another student might only deserve 5 leadership points.</p><p>Quantifying progress towards competencies with a specific number of points is simple in a game format, but incredibly difficult in the real world. Of course, so is grading. What would happen if, instead of picking a number to define the quality of a student’s work we, instead, spent time choosing a number that defined their progress towards specific competencies. Rather than a “B+”, a student could earn “4 out of 5 competency points” in a particular area.</p><p>So, there are two main possibilities here:</p><ol><li>When you are awarded a credential, you get credit for the competencies associated with it. — This credit <em>could</em> come in the form of points, decided by the credential issuer depending on the scope of the learning resources. Or, your archive of competencies could simply note all credentials you have earned that constitute each competency. e.g. a learner has 6 badges for <em>x</em> competency and 9 badges for <em>y.</em></li><li>When you complete a learning resource/experience, you earn points towards your competencies based on the quality of your work. If you earn a credential, you earn additional competency points based on the quality of your work towards the competencies associated with that credential (not counting those already earned from completing individual resources associated with the credential).</li></ol><p>What’s your pick? For now, due to the nascency and great difficulty of the work, the simpler first option may be the best path forward. As soon as you start relating competencies directly to resources you open up a hallway full of possibilities, point systems, and ranking systems that could start to look frustratingly similar to our existing grade-based systems.</p><p>The relationships then, could go like this:</p><p>Resources correspond to credentials and credentials have associated competencies.</p><p>Resources → Credentials → Competencies</p><h4>The Wrong Typology</h4><p>Throughout much of the early work on Open Badges, we have talked about a few major types of badges. In our work on Cities of Learning, we currently define these as: Skill, Knowledge, and Disposition. However, as we dig more into the relationship between competencies and badges, it becomes unclear whether this typology should be attached to badges or to competencies.</p><p>In fact, when we start to consider the unique roles of each element, <strong>this typology seems better suited to competencies.</strong> Badges, as a form of credentials, are a fairly generic structure and, in many cases, might contain all three types of learning outcomes. A credential, as proof of a learning experience, could represent skills, knowledge, <em>and</em>, dispositions gained within a single credential. In some cases there might be a 1:1 relationship, but that is not a rule of credentials, nor should it be. If we try to limit badges to a single competency, then we restrict the significance of the credentials and eliminate the need for having both competencies and badges.</p><p>Instead, badges and credentials more generally should be defined by a different typology, while competencies are organized into types such as skills, knowledge, and dispositions. This is a typology for learning outcomes, not for credentials. If we want to search by which badges have these types of outcomes, we can search relationally for any badges that have associated competencies that fall into a certain type. Having these types applied to competencies makes more sense in the logical framework and allows for a level of sorting that will be useful to educators and learners when browsing competencies.</p><p>That’s all for now. Moving forward, let’s be very careful to not conflate these atomic elements of learning and to more exactly define their relationship and divisibility. If connected learning technologies are to actually connect learning across local and digital spaces, we need to clarify these foundational questions and build technology that supports them throughout our learning platforms.</p><p>bonus question: Any thoughts on where <em>difficulty</em> fits into all of this?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18bd51c7884" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories/the-atomic-elements-of-learning-18bd51c7884">The Atomic Elements of Learning</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/sprout-stories">Sprout Stories</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>