<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Strictly Business - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Conversations exploring the  role of the artist in technology and entrepreneurship. Project of @FabricatorzFoundation. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/strictly-business?source=rss----2bd6dcfc8768---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 07:38:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/strictly-business" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The role of physical media is to document]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/strictly-business/if-i-could-write-or-not-be-afraid-to-write-i-would-have-written-natasha-staggs-berlin-biennale-8c45210bd70e?source=rss----2bd6dcfc8768---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c45210bd70e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trends]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tyler Mathews]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Feb 2018 15:09:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-26T15:07:36.676Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Tyler Mathews on Twitter</h3><p>The role of physical media is to document. A magazine is a capsule, cassettes are proof of support http://bb9.berlinbiennale.de/trends-and-their-discontents ...</p><h3>The role of physical media is to document</h3><p><em>A magazine is a capsule, cassettes (or vinyl) are proof of support</em></p><p>If I could write (or not be afraid to write) I would have written Natasha Stagg’s Berlin Biennale article “<a href="http://bb9.berlinbiennale.de/trends-and-their-discontents/">Trends and their Discontents</a>” back in 2012 after the Dis Magazine “slimepunk” mix came out (a joke response to a post-ironic trend). At the time it seemed like the nano-trend to end them all for those in the know. But then #normcore somehow crossed over into the public consciousness and micro-fashion — whether a joke, serious or a joke-turned serious—became a scaled, decentralized, unstoppable force. I recommend reading “Trends and their Discontents” to get a better idea of how micro-trends start and gain traction. But some interesting ideas in the article that, for obvious reasons are not written more extensively, are around micro-trends and labor and the role of physical media.</p><h3>The purpose of physical media</h3><blockquote>But it is the job of the magazine not only to understand these developments but to represent and report on them in artistic ways. As a periodical, a magazine becomes a capsule of cultural climate.</blockquote><p>I feel like I could quit writing after this quote (also from the Biennale’s article) but I believe there is lots to be gleaned when thinking about the how artists, musicians, individuals i.e., media companies i.e., everyone in business, should market themselves.</p><p><em>(This is the part where I apologize to artists and savvy writers on twitter who are thinking, “Oh God, another discussion about content!” #sorrynotsorry ← #sorrynotsorry.)</em></p><p>I get an email from <em>Offscreen Magazine</em> and I wonder why I have the urge to buy it. It’s beautifully made but the idea of holding it and then filing it away seems desirable. It’s also easy to empathize with the founder because he’s so open about his personal labor to make this for us. His story, combined with quality, combined with the desire to add this to my capsule of the current cultural climate all play into my desire to own a physical copy. This same desire is what has driven me to purchase albums in physical form whether it’s vinyl, cassettes, CD-Rs or a USB drive. I hadn’t purchased music for years until Anamanaguchi’s <em>Endless Fantasy</em> came out via Kickstarter. I bought the album to support them. I already liked their music but was moved by their story. The baseline is that the product has to be good but what separates noise from signal is the personal connection through story. I find myself no longer buying albums of artists I can’t relate to on a personal level. If their story is absent, not personally identifiable or not part of an idea I want to move forward I don’t buy their albums, but I will attend their show. My purchasing habits continue to trend toward local musicians or artists participating in communities with which I strongly identify.</p><p>I think this is why <a href="https://drip.com/">Drip.fm</a> shut down (only then to be acquired by Kickstarter). Not because the idea is bad but because subscribing to labels is a bad model. I certainly don’t want to buy subscriptions for each label. I’d rather pay Drip.fm a recurring fee to have access to all the labels and musicians and pick which tapes or vinyl + zips I want. Kinda like the <a href="http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/12-for-one-cd-deals-no-more-bmg-music-service-ends-in-june-20090310">mail-order CD scheme</a> from way back in the day.</p><h4>But back to artists and their content.</h4><p>The question of how do artists support themselves can be broken up into a couple options:</p><ol><li>Don’t play the content game. Instead do what you want and hope it works out for you. Make your “milestone piece,” (e.g., album, artwork) and sell it through a gallery or on iTunes. (How it “works for you” is largely dependent on how you define your own success.)</li><li><a href="https://youtu.be/wUAgfy-fILk?t=9m23s">Leverage the</a> <a href="http://techcrunch.com/2015/08/22/the-future-for-artists-and-celebrities-and-youtubers-is-direct-intimacy/">media company model</a> by making quality, free content for your supporters but in a way that is personal and engaging. But remembering “<a href="https://medium.com/@joshuatopolsky/your-media-business-will-not-be-saved-1b0716b5010c#.1ojjs2aaf">that you can’t think about making it great for <em>everyone</em>. You have to make it great for <em>someone</em>. A lot of people, but not <em>every person</em>.</a>”</li></ol><p>The second option allows artists to increase engagement, which makes them top of mind, which then makes it easier to make money when they’re ready to sell something. The frequent giving away of content allows artists to charge a premium for physical media and IRL activities like shows, talks, etc.</p><h3>Micro-trends and labor</h3><p>This will be short since you’re well into <a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/how-users-read-on-the-web/">skim mode</a>. Anyway, I’m just pointing out that Natasha Stagg’s concerns over poor labor practices to keep up with fashion demand will soon be outdated once 3D printing brings mass customized fashion into the home.</p><p><em>For more commentary and links on how the status of the artist is changing check out my </em><a href="https://www.are.na/tyler-mathews/artup"><em>Are.na channel</em></a><em> (or my straightforward </em><a href="http://news.absolutnet.work/"><em>list of links</em></a><em>) and follow </em><a href="http://twitter.com/net_dot_work"><em>@net_dot_work</em></a><em> on twitter.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c45210bd70e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business/if-i-could-write-or-not-be-afraid-to-write-i-would-have-written-natasha-staggs-berlin-biennale-8c45210bd70e">The role of physical media is to document</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business">Strictly Business</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Flood The Channels: On Marketing, Art, and Taking Up Space]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/strictly-business/flood-the-channels-on-marketing-art-and-taking-up-space-d0c7cd5c1015?source=rss----2bd6dcfc8768---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0c7cd5c1015</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women-in-tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alyce Currier]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Apr 2017 13:53:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-27T14:34:02.097Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Originally written as notes for a </em><a href="https://www.eventbrite.com/e/wimintechboston-voices-of-the-community-tickets-33344523367"><em>talk</em></a><em> for </em><a href="http://www.womeninmusic.org/boston"><em>Women In Music Boston</em></a><em>. Some slides included as screenshots.</em></p><p>I am a marketer by profession, although I’m the kind of marketer who will forever rail against a society where one’s professional affiliation is the first thing we respond with when someone asks “what do you do?”. It’s not that I don’t find my work satisfying; it’s that I don’t really believe that our employment status should be the core thing that defines any of us.</p><p>It’s easy to market a product when you’re fairly divorced from it, when you’re not self-conscious about what you’re doing. Marketing for a company is about learning as much as you can about a product, the audiences you’re trying to reach, and what they need.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*735F8WwKdkuEpxgZhHUC7w.png" /></figure><p>At my day job, I work best when I’m collaborating closely with a team. Sure, some of the work ends up being mine, and I often challenge myself and feel proud of the results, but it rarely feels <em>personal</em>.</p><p>While I have my own personal feelings about capitalism and advertising, most humans have been dispossessed of the ability to survive without participating in this system which normalizes not only the selling of our labor but the omnipresence of corporations in all realms of our lives.</p><p>We live with a tacit understanding that products and brands are going to take up a certain amount of space, and there’s a safety to expression under the umbrella of a brand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5TK_ZoAh3hyNjLc4x8THXQ.png" /></figure><p>However, as a woman, there are repercussions involved with occupying the spotlight or asking for attention for anything besides being pretty. In past romantic relationships with straight men, I’ve been accused of “self-centeredness” for my ambition, for voicing my own needs, needs which in retrospect were pretty basic. Early in my DJ career, before I would have called it a “career” at all, a man told me it seemed like I was on my way to becoming an “it girl,” and he didn’t mean that as a compliment.</p><p>“Manspreading” became a term for a reason. There’s still a lot of taboo around women taking up space, women having appetites for anything from food to sex to attention (see: <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/312518.Appetites"><em>Appetites</em></a> by Caroline Knapp).</p><p>As a DJ, it’s not effective to simply market my music: I would argue that the most successful DJs also market a persona, and as someone who’s not much of a performer, that persona is inextricably tied to my real self. For some musicians, their alias is a costume; for a band, there’s a group involved, there’s collective accountability, much like there is for a brand.</p><p>But as a solo DJ, I am me. Sometimes I play with different facets of myself: more feminine, more masculine, heavier sounds, lighter sounds, relief, aggression, sentimentality. But these are all, at their core, parts of myself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*58bFIZd8oqw4_nQ8OrpulA.png" /></figure><p>Because DJing is an improvisation synced with the energy of an audience, a time, and a space, it often feels very raw. I listen to my old mixes and I can feel where they missed the mark. I can hear what I was reaching toward, and I think I’m closer to that indescribable thing now, but I don’t know if I’ll ever get there. And yet I try, again and again. It often feels ridiculous to ask other people to come and be a part of that strange experiment.</p><p>Marketing is a bit of a taboo in the art world. By marketing yourself, you’re suddenly perceived as inauthentic, commercial, as having some sort of ulterior motive for creating. It’s not just music: friends involved with other types of art, gender aside, have faced chiding remarks for their efforts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OHMpxjUN_ZSocN63-ZKOEQ.png" /></figure><p>But marketing is how we get booked. Marketing is how we expand our reach to collaborate with the people we’ve always dreamed about collaborating with. Marketing is how we expose ourselves to new experiences that help us grow as artists.</p><p>DJing, in particular, is an art form that’s collaborative by nature. If you DJ a set without an audience to communicate with, did that DJ set even happen? For me, the “purity” of a DJ set isn’t about me holing up and avoiding outside influence — it’s about how fluidly I’m able to communicate with a room and find the sweet spot where what I’m trying to express connects with something the audience, too, is striving to feel. I am happiest DJing when I feel like I’m part of the space itself, when I’ve dissolved into the atmosphere and become the music I’m playing. But how do I get those gigs?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UgEOjMPpttSHD2i_nwABkw.png" /></figure><p>I intended for this talk to be a bit more tactical: how do you market yourself as a musician? But I think most of us probably understand those tactics, and if we don’t, it’s easy to find them on a million marketing blogs. I think a lot of artists struggle with something entirely different: the idea of marketing themselves at all.</p><p>Are there ways of promoting your art that don’t fit under the umbrella of marketing? Maybe. How do we even define “marketing”? Social media is so central to how we communicate that sometimes real interpersonal relationships end up being instrumental in our development as artists, or our ability to get booked. Sometimes, it feels like everything we do is a performance. Some might say that’s particularly true in the age of the internet; Erving Goffman’s been saying it <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dramaturgy_(sociology)">since the ‘50s</a>.</p><p>Is “marketing” about intent? If you’re not promoting your art to make money but to achieve another end, does it even count as marketing? Should it be taboo to ask for money in exchange for art? In what situations do artists deserve to be paid for their labor? Is art that’s been paid for, within a pre-existing capitalist system, somehow less “pure”?</p><p>I don’t have the answers to these questions — I think we all need to answer these questions for ourselves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pmlD95noGb46oK4A01Mp5A.png" /></figure><p>Marketing yourself as a musician or performer or artist isn’t about tricking people to get them where you are: it’s about putting yourself out there, taking up space, and ignoring the voices that will tell you that you’re not entitled to the attention.</p><p>It’s about building the communities we’re a part of so there’s more space for everyone. In areas where support for the arts isn’t the default, all we have is each other and the community infrastructure we can only build together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O1_01DBgjFWrXUhDYJocHQ.png" /></figure><p>Don’t resent other women (or other musicians in general) for making noise. Help boost each other’s voices. Don’t be afraid to share your work, even when it’s not perfect.</p><p>The more we can flood the channels, the more we’ll all benefit from normalizing women’s voices, and queer voices, and voices of color, and nonbinary voices, and trans voices, and all of the other voices that have conveniently been left out of history.</p><p>It’s up to us to decide who’s allowed to take up space and speak for themselves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z7Zo-a_ThIXFAlehrfwAVQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0c7cd5c1015" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business/flood-the-channels-on-marketing-art-and-taking-up-space-d0c7cd5c1015">Flood The Channels: On Marketing, Art, and Taking Up Space</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business">Strictly Business</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Esc Artist]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/strictly-business/esc-artist-99a74c9e23b4?source=rss----2bd6dcfc8768---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/99a74c9e23b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[post-internet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[net.work]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Dec 2016 14:57:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-08T18:01:02.117Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Mat Dryhurst on the artist’s need to forge into new territory without compromise.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/416/1*Ub4E7erhph6R32dmRKw8HQ.png" /></figure><p><em>Mid-summer 2016, Mat Dryhurst and I talked about the tension between art and capital, funding non-traditional art projects and artists as advisors among other topics. </em><a href="http://www.mathewdryhurst.com/"><em>Mat Dryhurst</em></a><em> is an independent artist and musician releasing music on the PAN label. Mat co-runs a studio with </em><a href="http://hollyherndon.com/"><em>Holly Herndon</em></a><em>, is the creator of the self-hosting video and performance platform, </em><a href="https://github.com/matdryhurst/Saga#saga"><em>SAGA</em></a><em>, lecturer at NYU’s Clive Davis Institute, </em><a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/electronicmusic/comments/3h1odr/this_photo_is_going_viral_on_facebook_right_now"><em>meme-maker</em></a><em> and advisor to the music co-op, </em><a href="https://resonate.is/"><em>Resonate.is</em></a><em>. Despite hearing his own voice from mic echo for nearly an hour, Mat provides some great insight for entrepreneurial-minded artists dabbling in the post-contemporary. This conversation has been edited for length and clarity.</em></p><p><strong>Hey Mat, thanks a lot for joining me. Actually, thank you for letting me join you on your recording equipment since mine failed out.</strong></p><p>[Sound of vape pen]</p><p>I do sound a bit like God in a theater production.</p><p><strong>To start off, 2016 has been really busy for you and I’d love to hear what’s been going on.</strong></p><p>Yeah, so my partner, Holly [Herndon] and I have been touring pretty much. We released <a href="https://hollyherndon.bandcamp.com/album/platform">a record</a> last year that went pretty well. The nature of our business is you put that out and then you have to go, you know, play it to people. That’s kinda how we make our money. It’s been really fun [opening for Radiohead during their Moon Shaped Pool tour]. We’ve been touring all over the spot. We saw you in St. Louis with Colin [Self]. It’s been amazing to be touring with Colin. We’re just coming off that right now and trying to settle into some kind of domesticity or normal work schedule. I can imagine it was far harder 30 years ago. Now you’re still on email and there’s this conceit that you’re still participating in regular life but you’re not really. So it’s quite nice to come back and start thinking of other projects and you know, talk to people, cook food, go to bed at a reasonable time. Before we have to do it all over again. We’re structuring our lives around these kind of album cycles which is a very idiosyncratic thing.</p><p><strong>You also did some speaking this summer.</strong></p><p>Yeah totally. I’ve done quite a bit of speaking when I can go to festivals to talk specifically about decentralized publishing and a few other things that we’re interested in. And in many cases it’s become this kind of thing where we’ll often play a festival that also has a discursive angle to it and so you can kind of kill two birds with stone. You play a show and then you can go and nerd out with someone.</p><p><strong>Like </strong><a href="http://www.3hd-festival.com/"><strong>3HD</strong></a><strong>? Is that what you’re talking about?</strong></p><p>Actually, I’m not involved with that. It’s a really cool festival and is definitely and example of that discursive, performative platform and that’s happening in Berlin in a month or two time. But that’s definitely an example of a trend that’s been emergent in the past five years or so where you kind of get your meat and vegetables in the same place.</p><p><strong>In addition to that you’ve also become an advisor to Resonate.is.</strong></p><p>In the past couple of years, there’s another artist, <a href="http://www.larsholdhus.com/">Lars [Holdhus]</a>, who presents work as TCF. He and I have been nerding out, agreeing and arguing, on wanting to build some kind of a decentralized alternative for independent musicians. And we’re coming at it from different angles. [It] kind of came together through a shared interest in the topic and kinda also came to this conclusion that we’re really in such a fringe minority for active musicians that care about this stuff that it’s useful to work together and share perspectives. Lars met Peter Harris, who started Resonate, and recommended him to me. Peter’s vision, which I think is really quite great, is to build a blockchain-based platform cooperative for music streaming. The idea being that it provides a better deal for the artists and labels than Spotify or any of these major competitors who largely — unless you come from a really strong bargaining position — don’t really offer negotiation on the rates that you receive. With Resonate the idea is that it’s a really sweet deal and, also being a platform co-op model, stakeholders who are promoting their music through there or pushing their label have some say in the future of the platform. For both Lars and I, independently it made a lot of sense to try and get involved. Peter asked us to be involved on an advisory level. For us the interest is that one — none of us individually are going to solve this problem. The scale of the problem is huge and there’s a lot of money there and we’re really on the margins to even be thinking about this. And so it helps to work together. And two — Peter and a lot of the team that are working on Resonate have a level of technical aptitude available to them to really do some exciting things. It’s very useful to be able to talk to him about some of the ideas that we’ve been incubating and think of ways to take them to scale quicker through that infrastructure rather than just trying to work on projects separately.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tO9zqPcbzfzDrNNn.png" /><figcaption>Here’s how <a href="https://resonate.is/">Resonate.is</a>&#39; stream to own works.</figcaption></figure><p>The big opportunity is when it comes specifically to decentralized hosting platforms or these kind of platform co-op models. I see this as a huge opportunity for a new kind of independent music. A new kind of independence in how much control you have over the releases, how much discrete control you have over pricing, how much control you have over releasing work atypically online. Resonate is taking on the challenge of streaming first, which is already a considerable challenge. But what also gets me excited is that once these labels and artists are somewhat familiar with participating with the blockchain all kind of applications can be built on top of that. And in a fair way that doesn’t feel exploitative. It’s a group of sympathetic and smart people at this point and the spirit of that is really wonderful.</p><p><strong>It’s cool to see you and Lars on the advising side. Are other musicians or artists advising tech companies like this?</strong></p><p>In the case of Resonate it perhaps makes more sense given the scope of what they do. Their reason for being is to provide a fairer deal for artists. Years ago I put on a hack in Stockholm. There was a festival called Visions of the Now, a recreation of the original <a href="http://www.visionsofthenow.com/">Visions of the Now</a> festival in Stockholm in the 60s that predated EAT — <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experiments_in_Art_and_Technology">the Experiments in Art and Technology </a>— and actually it was very closely related to it even though they had their disagreements. Part of the idea of that hack was simply to say, “Why is it when exorbitant amounts of money are being spent on these platforms that are reportedly in the interest of artists; that are determining the terms of how artists are viewed, experienced, whatever; Why is it that so few artists are involved in that ideation or creation process?” And I think that the blame falls on both sides, right? In many cases you want engineers behind those projects because they kind of know what is possible and are in a better position to raise money and all this kind of stuff. But on the other side it’s also the challenge of encouraging artists to see these platforms as something they have a vested interest in. And remove yourself from this kind of role of simply participating in platforms as a user and [instead] seeing them as something that’s fundamentally important to your practice and also to your financial future. Perhaps it’s easier in the case of someone like Lars or I. We’re coming from a doggedly independent music infrastructure. Particularly myself, every job I’ve ever had, or in music at least, has been dyed in the wool, kind of indie. Like OG indie, puritan kind of approach.</p><blockquote>For me it makes a lot of sense to look at these things and be like, “Where is the Discord for streaming?” It’s a rough analogy but I think it’s a really, really relevant analogy.</blockquote><p><strong>Is there apprehension to bring artists on as advisors because they may not want to be involved in the business or capitalistic side to running and launching a startup? I’m trying to figure out what the general attitude is for artists now. What you’re seeing in Berlin versus here in the States?</strong></p><p>Totally. I mean you’re always up against it in some ways. We’re weirdos in a way. We’re predominantly involved in music but we deal with people and characters and subjects in the contemporary art world, or the design world or the tech world in some ways. In doing so, or having this breadth of practice we’re kinda ****** whichever way we go. There’s this special corner for these inter-sectional practices. They’re not considered as pure or authentic as the artist who practices with no consideration for the means by which they push the work or fund the work. This is the mythology of the great artist, right? I think in some cases without having a really strong passion for these topics as an artist you’re disincentivized to really pursue that stuff because it’s not considered very sexy. But, I think that is shifting more and more.</p><p>And on top of that you have a scenario where you used to be able to be oblivious or naive to these topics because the system was working, right? That system, at least if you were invited into that very rarefied system, that worked and you were getting paid. It wasn’t lucrative for everyone, but there was a degree of investment or faith put into that system. Of course that system has changed so radically and those protections have depleted so radically in the past 10, 15 years that [it] behooves you as someone looking to have an artistic practice to start looking into infrastructure and to start taking the reigns on your own career. If I look at the people who are thriving, whether they would concede it or whether this is something that is happening subconsciously, people are organizing themselves into business entities. They may not describe it as such, but art studios, musicians, touring musicians, you look at the ones who are operating on a level and they’re companies. I mean they really are. The way they work, the way they share resources, the way they interact with their agents or their labels. These are negotiations that are occurring between business entities and you do lose something in that.</p><blockquote>But my argument would be that your only choice is to be creative with it, pragmatic with it and find ways to participate in that without making ethical compromises.</blockquote><p>Which is why for example, with Resonate, a lot of people, most people don’t know what a platform co-op is. And if they were to approach it with a degree of cynicism because it seems like a business entity… the reason for platform co-ops to exist is exactly to combat that kind of cynical engagement with capital and with business. It behooves artists to look into this stuff more. There’s a lot there and you can feel ethically and creatively sound.</p><p><strong>The pathways that are coming out are: Engage and experiment with this new model for artists in a way that works for you or pursue what has traditionally been happening i.e., isolate yourself from that industry or go headlong into the hyper-professionalization of the art world. Is that what you’re thinking it looks like? Are all artists tech companies/publishers?</strong></p><p>I mean, I wouldn’t say all, but, well actually, in some ways yes. Perhaps they all are but I don’t think people perhaps realize it. If I talk about visual arts I’m far less experienced with it so I’ll stick to music but I think it probably applies across the spectrum. If you have a young musician…the way in which they approach their practice — and this is not necessarily by choice and I don’t know if it’s necessarily conscious — is you have access to such research and such knowledge of who is who, who’s doing what, where’s the place you need to be, what’s the fashionable thing at this point in time, where your place may be in relation to that. You join Twitter and you see the journalists, the curator, the editor. You can follow these people and there’s ways to enter that conversation. Unfortunately, it’s heavily weighted to Western, English-speaking countries but generally there are ways to participate in that conversation so much more. It’s important to consider…when you create something now you’re doing it with access to so much more information than this kind of fantasy or mythology of the autonomous artist, you know? And yeah, there are opportunities in that and there are huge potholes you can step into. But whether you like it or not the approach has shifted and now it’s really a matter of trying to distinguish between a good approach and a bad approach.</p><p><strong>This particular space that you, Holly, Lars and all these other people that are operating in is a really weird space in general. It kind of came piggybacking off the early new media or post-media art world. Music got involved alongside of it and with the integration of tech and startups becoming more of a mainstream concept it’s just a weird community with a lot of overlap with different communities. It seems like a very new concept to the outside world, and surprisingly to me, even the art world. I’ve never been that involved in the traditional art world and I guess I’m shocked by how surprised they are. Something that was interesting, I think it was a Red Bull interview last year, you talked about the art world in general having trouble with art doing something. Did you discover that in response to what you were doing with SAGA?</strong></p><p>Yeah, we’ve had criticisms in the past, like you know, in the art world the bogeyman is the concept of didacticism. If you go through any art school program there’s this concern that you’re too concerned with educating people about things. And we run into it quite a lot. The issue for me is, yes, I’m often incredibly shocked by how discrete or siloed these worlds are. In music we run into this all the time where the vast majority of music is people who just listen to music and they don’t really check out much else. There’s this kind of curiosity gap about what’s happening in the world currently. As a result you find yourself in this kind of frustrating position where if you’re trying to talk about an issue — decentralized tech in a musical context — there’s very little ground you can break. And that’s happened a little bit with Holly. It’s like, “Holly makes music on a laptop.” And that’s like the coloring book story of what Holly does. But there’s a lot of ground to cover to open up the discussion within each field. And again you also get into this hairy scenario because of how reviled the concept of educating people is or the concept of functionality or something being designed to actually live in the world in a certain way. You get into a position where you either have to educate people or have to contextualize your work yourself in order to make your point. Or [else] participate in the more pop economy of things and just accept that the nuances of the points you want to make aren’t going to be communicated. I think for some people a lot of their practice is in that universe of playing with those themes and I think that’s great and there’s really smart things you can do in that context. But for us it would be just quite boring.</p><p>But specifically on the function thing we did run into that. And I did run into that with SAGA.</p><blockquote>I joke with people, like if I just made a film about hypothetically making SAGA I’d probably have a stronger response from the art world than building the ******* thing.</blockquote><p>I don’t think the art world knows how to deal with that. That’s not their universe. And I guess it’s fine, but it’s frustrating for me because in my experience, I mean part of the reason I’ve always gravitated toward creative universes, is that’s where you find the freaks. And in my mind the real freaks are characters like Lars. Lars is a very skilled artists, he’s a very skilled musician. He chooses to show work in a certain way because that satisfies his curiosity and his intellect. And it’s those freaks that I got involved in music. That’s the reason I’ve been interested in contemporary art. But they’re not really facilitated by the industry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*k041fUdbFkB3aroY.png" /></figure><p><strong>Are you seeing this kind of work happening elsewhere? Is there anything interesting happening in Berlin? Do you see a line drawn in the sand or a convergence?</strong></p><p>There’s kind of two parts to it. There’s an awesome theorist and curator, Suhail Malik, who did a long series of lectures on the <a href="http://artistsspace.org/programs/on-the-necessity-of-arts-exit-from-contemporary-art">Necessity of Art’s Escape from Contemporary Art.</a> He defines Contemporary Art as a period of time, a genre of art that you know. Some of his criticisms go into the idea that Contemporary Art exists on critique that circulates amongst itself but there’s never any exit from that. I was joking last night… it’s like, “Oh well, next year will be the year that digital arts has a breakthrough.” It’s like every year there’s a panel at some prestigious institution talking about how this is going to be the year… it kind of repeats on itself because it has a really hard time escaping or exiting that perennial, naval-gazing discourse. I mean, there’s so much benefit to reading things in a artistic, musical, philosophical, theoretical tradition. The most exciting thing is with access to money (that’s really one of the crucial things), talks and communities you can just build something that doesn’t try and appease that conversation. And what you’ll find over time is that if you’re successful in doing it the art world will acknowledge you. They kind of have a habit…once something’s a success they will appreciate it. And so if anything, in my mind, it need not necessarily be a negotiation with art history. People like Adam [Harvey], for example. He’s very skilled, he’s very thoughtful about what he does and he just started a business. I can’t say definitively if Jonah Peretti’s BuzzFeed was an art project, but you have someone who was working, or in concert with the Fat Lab community, which I think was an awesomely influential project. And you see BuzzFeed and the tone of it… I don’t even necessarily think it was a source of good in the world, but you have a quite clear thesis there that seems synonymous with a lot of the Fat Lab experiments. And I’m like, well that’s a remarkable art project. And the impact it’s had on the world is pretty undeniable at this point in time. So why would you — if you’re a smart person who cares about something, whether it be aesthetics or whatever — why would you not just disentangle yourself from some very stringent expectations and also a very stringent and also unethical art market? When people talk about capitalism and you know, “You don’t want to get involved in the startup world and venture capital,” and I’m like why are you participating in the gallery system? This is one of the most shady, opaque, capitalist environments you can talk about it. Where is this high ethical standard that people are hobbling themselves to?</p><p><strong>It’s like the art world version of venture capital.</strong></p><p>Yeah, totally, with less transparency. And again, I like a lot of people who exist in that world, but there’s this kind of strange false binary.</p><blockquote>For me, as well those same characters, would argue [that] art is a fundamental. Like an ether that exists in the world. [But that] it’s not tied to institutions or any particular legacy. And I’m like, absolutely it is.</blockquote><p>So many smart people are going to try and find ways to navigate their own way in the world and find their own audiences and exhibit their work or push their work through different creative means and that’s wonderful. And of course there’s going to be a lot of bad work but there’s going to be a lot of great work. I don’t personally think that the contemporary art infrastructure, the gallery world, the museum world, as venerable as aspects of it can be… I don’t think they have a monopoly on art whatsoever.</p><p><strong>Correct me if I’m wrong, but when you were doing the Artup project in San Francisco with </strong><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business/what-does-it-mean-to-make-work-92ee1522f0c6#.94rmoo79h"><strong>Barry Threw</strong></a><strong>, was that more related to the business aspect in the art world or more the art and tech angle? What was the goal there?</strong></p><p>At the time there was kind of this emergent politic in San Francisco specifically that was parsing or stretching our loyalties a little bit. You had this accelerated gentrification occurring and Holly and I were playing weird autonomous rave spaces and noise shows and felt huge loyalties to that community that was being pushed out by the influx of capital in the city. You saw a lot of tension occurring. At the same time I was going to work and was hanging out with people who were being characterized as the gentrifiers, the weird tech bros who were taking over the city. And our experience of them was not quite as simple as that. You had some very thoughtful people who were very smart and were also concerned about what was happening to the city. And so the opportunity with Artup was really to start super informal — that’s always been my style — like very informal hangouts. We definitely invited some cool people to speak and discuss issues. We kind of pretended it was a formal environment by announcing it as an event but the real function of it was to invite speakers and just anyone from the community to freely hash out some of the emergent problems in San Francisco. I think it was quite successful at times because we invited good people, we had it very open access and we did bring in a lot of people from a money/tech world and a DIY musical/artist background to just have a go at each other. In most cases what you end up finding is that the archetypes and the stereotypes that were purportedly dividing people don’t apply when you’re in the same room with people. Most people are quite nuanced and also just trying to take care of themselves. So from that there were opportunities that came up. At the time it felt like a very necessary intervention because this was the pre-monthly thinkpiece about what’s happening to the soul of San Francisco. At the time it did do some good to at least create some relationships and try and parse those issues.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NN37FNTQAQ_vtzEp.jpg" /><figcaption>SAGA custom text overlay</figcaption></figure><p><strong>We were talking about your project SAGA earlier and I’m curious if that’s a project you’re still working on. Or are you onto something new?</strong></p><p>Yeah, I mean, honestly, it’s tricky. I think we spoke about this a little bit in St. Louis. Initially, I put it out. I had a pretty good response to it. I still think a lot of people didn’t get it which is partly my bad. But for those people who got it they saw the opportunity and how cool this was. The challenge to pushing SAGA further is you’re really talking about a level of technical aptitude to build this network that can host people stably, quickly and adhere to the same philosophical principles. It requires funding. And so, initially I’d applied to a number of grants thinking that I’d be a pretty good shot. But a friend of mine who is used to writing these type of grants came back to me like, “Well it’s tricky because you’re kind of falling in between the cracks. It’s a functional project so it’s not really in this category and it involves video and performance and visual stuff but it’s not really in that category.” There aren’t really the resources available at least that I could find to fund that project in the spirit of how I wanted to work on it. There are potential opportunities to go through more traditional funding mechanisms for starting a business and crowdfunding [but] it’s that return on investment aspect that specifically around SAGA I didn’t want to push. First off because my first job is working here with Holly and it really would conflict with that on a day-to-day level for me. Trying to start a business is a really hard thing to do. I have lots of friends who do it and you’ve got to really be all in. And specifically in music there’s something like a 3% success [rate] for music, tech-based projects. So for me to best develop this was to facilitate my own experiments and my own work. You see people developing their own proprietary technologies more and more in the contemporary art world. SAGA of course wouldn’t be proprietary because everything’s open-source. But I have some projects in mind where I’d like to use SAGA and further illustrate some of the capabilities of it and develop the platform a bit more. It’s not dead yet. I think people still haven’t caught up to the logic of it. I still think it’s relevant and I think it might well be relevant in five years time so I’d like to continue working on it. Hopefully, maybe, there’ll be a point where I can find some support for it so I can focus on it a bit more. I imagine there’s hundreds of remarkable projects on Github now that maybe in 20 years time we’ll look back and be like, “Whoa that person was really onto something.” But without that funding source and support infrastructure it makes it very hard to pursue and I’m not about to be a martyr for that. It was basically either I found some way to do it feasibly or I take another path, which is to develop it as a personal project with the explicit purpose of producing more artwork with that logic.</p><p><strong>Do you think for projects like this there needs to be a new funding model?</strong></p><p>I think that would be cool. I totally understand that when it comes to investment, people want a return. I did explore some monetization ideas that I thought were pretty cool but it’s finding the right person to support and finding ways to charge people in a way that you think is feasible. In particular with music where people expect everything to be free. And SAGA is anti-advertising, which was one of the points of it. I’ve seen some cool foundation models where they will fund these kind of nascent, experimental projects. They’re not so much explicitly focused on art and technology, but naturally a lot of the projects that end up seeking that kind of alternate funding will come from that universe. But I do think it’s an opportunity, because as you know, you have people going through the school system or the arts school system, the design school system are thinking more and more about these issues. I’ve gone to a lot of MFA shows and pretty much every MFA show is concerned about platform politics or networked dynamics. You have generations of students coming through thinking about these things who perhaps don’t feel like their skillset would work jumping directly into a tech job but perhaps do have wonderful ideas. Having some ability to fund the best of those ideas and just see what happens seems in the best interest of everyone. Culture is not going anywhere; art and music isn’t going anywhere and there’s such a rush to try and solve problems within those worlds. There are people who are from those worlds who are thinking about it and it would be beneficial for everybody to have more support and visibility to those ideas and projects.</p><p><strong>So at this point it’s just a matter of time?</strong></p><p>I don’t know. I takes a special person. It appears to me to be a philosophical thing. I was watching Vinay Gupta [who] has just started a venture capital organization called <a href="https://hexayurt-capital.typeform.com/to/lV91Mv">Hexayurt</a>. He’s coming at it with a very particular philosophical stance which seemed to make some sense to me particularly for his outcomes. He was talking about Paul Graham and how Y Combinator has this particular philosophical stance about supporting a large number of projects and investing in the future of these very speculative ways that ultimately do produce a return but it’s a very peculiar return. It’s not like a 1:1 return. Y Combinator will accept that 90% of their projects aren’t going to return them money, but the few that do compensate handsomely for the ones that don’t. And so using that as a mechanism to push things forward. But in all those circumstances you have really visionary people. Visionary people who have access to money. Those are two very special things. And same with the art world. We’ve dabbled a bit [in] the field of sound art. And when you talk to people, friends of ours, who sell works in that world and are part of that conversation and that legacy I mean, there’s like five collectors in the world who keep that system running. But the point being that entire conversation and infrastructure and discussion is facilitated by a few visionary people who have access to money that are pushing in that direction. The good thing about the tech and art discussion is — you’d think — a lot of very smart of people with a lot of very new money who have interest in this stuff will begin to emerge to start supporting this kind of work. It seems like there’s a higher likelihood for that than supporting sound art honestly.</p><blockquote>I’m pretty hopeful, [but] I could spend 10 years trying to find that one person, you know? So, up until those opportunities exist you’ve gotta be pragmatic and [find] different ways to work.</blockquote><p>We are not necessarily concerned about finding investment from an angel. We work in the music industry. It’s actually a very kind of honest craft where [Holly and I] make music and try to put on a show and a bunch of people show up and they pay. I’m really grateful because that allows us the flexibility to work on these speculative projects on the side without fearing for our bottom line. That gives us a degree of conceptual freedom also.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*yMisMen2BLlGzt8n." /><figcaption><a href="http://sonarplusd.com/activity/introduction-decentralization-artists/">Introduction to Decentralization for Artists</a> talk led by Mat and Lars at Sónar+D</figcaption></figure><p><strong>What’s happening in this space we’ve been talking about that’s interesting to you?</strong></p><p>I’m particularly interested in crypto projects. It’s an easy answer because there’s just so much happening in that world and so much changing. And the politics and the machinations and the transferal of money occurring it’s such high drama that it’s wonderful to watch. Blockchain-based, crypto currency conversations are super interesting to me. There’s a friend of ours, Galen [Wolfe-Pauly], who works on a project called <a href="https://urbit.org/">urbit</a>. They’re basically trying to build a different operating system for the web. It’s one of these wonderful, but also incredibly convoluted concepts. They managed to raise $200K in a two-hour crowd sale. The ability in that world to find funding sources who are down and are open, and in many cases, highly intelligent, well-read people… that’s exciting to me. We’ve done a lot of work with the design group <a href="http://metahaven.net/">Metahaven</a> who are wonderful and they’re kind of emblematic of this shift that’s happening across the board.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Cw59eN-jIrSXj1mHu_FwfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from from Britta Thie’s <a href="http://brittathie.tv/ep01-pores-of-perception">“Translantics,”</a> a television-style web series which exists between the pop and art worlds.</figcaption></figure><p>Our friend <a href="http://brittathie.tv/">Britta Thie</a> [made a TV show] similar of it’s trajectory. I’m like, “God, I wish TV was more like the Otolith Group.” This idea of people who were participating or are participating in the art world, creating works that are looking for wider audiences and not being afraid of that. [Like] producing film with the intention of having [it] distributed like a film or producing television with the intention of that distributed like television. I think there’s a lot of people who are taking advantage or really trying to push for wider audiences for what previously would have been considered fringe or marginalized works. Whenever I see a project like that I punch the air a little bit. It gives me spirit to think that people are being ambitious. This goes back again to that conversation about exiting the contemporary art paradigm. There are limitations and I’m the first person to say that the mythology of the internet being this great equalizer is kind of bull****. But there are new opportunities and I think there’s a lot of room for people to be ambitious. When I see people being super ambitious in what they do, particularly in a way where philosophically I would agree with them, I get really excited and that’s happening at a greater frequency.</p><p>Follow <a href="http://twitter.com/matdryhurst">@matdryhurst</a> and <a href="http://twitter.com/net_dot_work">@net.work</a> on twitter</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=99a74c9e23b4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business/esc-artist-99a74c9e23b4">Esc Artist</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business">Strictly Business</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What does it mean to make work?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/strictly-business/what-does-it-mean-to-make-work-92ee1522f0c6?source=rss----2bd6dcfc8768---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92ee1522f0c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[techart]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[net.work]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Aug 2016 12:25:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-03T12:14:38.738Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Barry Threw on the intersection of art, tech and entreprenuership</h4><p><em>I spoke with #NEWPALMYRA director Barry Threw over a dubious Google Hangouts connection discussing his projects and unique insight into the communities overlapping art, tech and business. Barry is also a curator for Gray Area Foundation and has helped incubate organizations such as Recombinant Media Labs, Obscura Digital, Fabricatorz, the BEAM Foundation and worked on projects like Artup among others. This is a shortened and paraphrased transcript from our time talking.</em></p><p><em>TL;DR What does it mean to make work and what does it mean to be an entrepreneurial artist? We’re still figuring that out.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9s46PQBsYxOLyXNgJKHh8g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Barry Threw. <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/christopheradams/21438312381/in/photolist-yn4Pr3-yn4W53-Av4CqB-B1cEJb-B1cE9o-A9txbC-yZ9dRJ-yEqXnx-ygfiHo-ygfjqL-9fTQb9-BpL2r7-As6Z1D-AuwJn9-AuwHWE-Bs4ZCP-AuxbkG/">Photo by Christopher Adams</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>You’ve been involved with a lot of worthy projects but I actually want to start by asking why you and Mat Dryhurst decided to create Artup?</strong></p><p>San Francisco is this interesting epicenter of these huge cultural changes that have global impact and new forms of cultural expression but at the same time we surprisingly didn’t see any sort of connection with traditional fine art and [technology] which didn’t make a lot of sense to us. Artup was a kind of an exploration…why are these two communities so balkanized? Why isn’t there more natural overlap between them and can we do anything to catalyze some new relationships between both of the spaces that will produce some new works? You have these strong cultural and technological impulses so why aren’t there more organic collaborations? The hypothesis we were testing was, is it because these people aren’t even in the same room together? And what if anything will come out of that?</p><p>We did a series of events and brought in guest speakers and local artists from San Francisco. We brought in Julia Kaganskiy who’s the executive director of NEW INC in New York; they’re doing stuff that’s in line with with the kind of things we like to see. We did this in various formats to get this dialogue going and see if anyone could start speaking the same language.</p><p><strong>What did you discover from that?</strong></p><p>It spurred a lot of discussions but what became very clear is that there are a lot of strong opinions and entrenched interests that made these conversations difficult. One of the things was the discussion of what art even is, is changing. There are a lot of entrenched economic and cultural norms adhered to in both of these communities, particularly in the art world. The whole conceit around contemporary art is open to indeterminacy and viewer interpretation. They exist in this transcendental space and ambiguous art language and this is the way they maintain this cultural cachet and expect art to be in this separate space. And on the other side you have this technology community that’s — and I’m generalizing about all of this — very solution-oriented and creating work that by its very nature is to have impact in society in a very direct way. There’s also a language barrier there with what’s spoken in startups and technical culture that’s also esoteric in its own ways. So we’re built on these two different pillars of what it even means to make work.</p><p><strong>There are a lot of similarities between the two worlds but in my oversimplified view it’s that in business you have to make something people want, but not necessarily with art… unless you want to be a sustainable, working artist.</strong></p><p>You’re testing your art and whether it’s good or not and how can you really measure that? Whereas with technology, either your code works, your business survives or you get users. There are a lot more metrics to test. It’s a lot harder for artists to say well, actually, my whole series of work failed because there’s a lot more personal expression involved in that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KuYgZOltozKONVDi.jpg" /><figcaption>Mat Dryhurst’s <a href="https://accessions.org/article/saga-v1-0/">Saga</a>, a publishing framework allowing full control over your video embeds</figcaption></figure><p><strong>It’s still early, but there seem to be more artists who are successfully navigating this new environment like Adam Harvey’s Privacy Shop, which leverages the familiarity of ecommerce to convey complex concepts around privacy.</strong></p><p>Right and Mat Dryhurst is kind of a master of this functional creative inquiry. He makes these sorts of projects that have strong conceptual, philosophical mooring, are definitely presented as art projects, but also are functional tools that other people can use that create dialogues.</p><p>There also people who make different types of tools that bleed into becoming an art project like creative coding tools and practices, data-driven civic projects and visualizing data.</p><blockquote>The role of this art isn’t just transcendental anymore it also has function so we end up having to reconceptualize what art even is in a manner that gets us away from a purely aesthetic experience without utility.</blockquote><p>There’s one conversation which is, I’m an artist and I make art; the economic models are changing and we have to be entrepreneurial pragmatically. But the other is that there are these creative practices now where you find the entire role of art is changing. It’s function is changing.</p><p><strong>Regarding entrepreneurial approaches. Something interesting I noticed is that the failure rates of MFAs and startups are very similar. Nine out of ten MFAs fail to go on as working artists just as nine out of ten startups fail.</strong></p><p>The interesting thing about that point of both having the same sort of success rate… I don’t feel like both of those cultures present accurate pictures of succeeding in a big way. What does it mean to have a viable career in art? What it does it mean to not work inside art anymore? One of the interesting things is if you put artists inside technology development processes. And I’m not talking as designers necessarily either, I’m talking about as people who are looking at technology, making work and providing speculative prototyping that explores pathways that no one could have figured out otherwise. That’s valuable to a technology development project. Also having it be ok for artists participating without feeling like they’ve sold out and that they’re not really artists, that they didn’t make it in the gallery world. There’s a cultural gap that we need to overcome.</p><p><strong>Like you mentioned earlier there’s this language barrier on both sides that prevents understanding but from the technology standpoint I think it’s difficult to communicate the value add of an artist in a tech company.</strong></p><p>There’s enough partition to go around on both sides but at the same time the technology community has to learn that art is important and that the cultural milieu in general is important. This is one of the problems we have in San Francisco right now. I think what people forget is that there’s a reason why this technology community is here. It’s not just because the weather’s good — although that is one reason. No one is talking about creativity, everyone talks about innovation (and disruption but mostly innovation). But all that means is incremental improvement on the last thing that was here. Let’s make the next better chair.</p><blockquote>But when the Apple computer, when it was in a garage, and all the early technologies explorations were made by people who were here and went through the Summer of Love and had a whole different idea of what technology could mean to society, of what globalization could mean to the human experience and people.</blockquote><p>And the reason why all these companies like Google or Stanford were started out here is because of a certain cultural setting that valued creativity and entrepreneurialism in a certain way. And what you have now is a bunch of companies that are much more concerned with building their internal culture than building the culture of the San Francisco Bay Area. You’ll find companies like Facebook have an artist-in-residence program but what that means is you have an artist that comes in and they make art that lives in the Facebook campus or projects that get branded and rolled back into the company and not engaging with the community as a whole.</p><p><strong>I think maybe it’s easier for a company that’s raising a Series C to invest in artist-in-residence programs but it’s difficult for an early stage startup to spend money in this area. It comes back to the value added. Plus, to people not involved in the art world, artists appear naval gazing and not providing immediate value or solving problems. When the reality is that good artists, like good engineers, are excellent at asking the questions you didn’t know you needed to ask and provide new ways to at look problems and outcomes that have internal and external application.</strong></p><p>It’s a different mode of thinking, which is valuable to a process and a whole team.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*KN63EFF0yNmftBQU." /><figcaption>Gray Area Foundation + Research at Google’s <a href="http://grayarea.org/event/deepdream-the-art-of-neural-networks/">Deep Dream: The Art of Neural Networks</a> gallery show and benefit auction</figcaption></figure><p><strong>But it’s difficult to figure out how that person fits in a company unless you’re a major company. And then it ends up becoming a novelty like, let’s just have someone come in and do streetart in our building. They know art is important but don’t necessarily know how.</strong></p><p>I don’t know if you followed anything about the Deep Dream art auction we did with Google at Gray Area Foundation for the Arts, but that ended up being a super interesting project. We had the R&amp;D department of a major technology company — Google — that came up with a this process for generating creative works based directly on its research development technology process that wound up gaining traction. And a lot of artists started exploring it in different ways and it created a body of work that directly spoke to a number of interesting cultural issues that are happening right now. What does artificial intelligence mean? What’s the line between a human generating art and a computer generating art? Where do we place value in computer assisted art? What sorts of affordances do these creative tools enable? So anyway, what ended up happening is that we entered into a collaboration with Google that took about six months to a year of pre-planning where a bunch of this stuff was printed out, framed and we did an auction of this work and it all sold and we ended up making about $100,000 for Gray Area Foundation. And it was a really interesting case of creativity and art exploration pushing forward technology development, artificial intelligence research and generating creative artifacts out of the process that had fairly significant cultural value for the place and time at where we’re at. And it’s also one instance of a company that worked with us at Gray Area that had wildly successful results by bringing their stuff outside of the walls and into a public event.</p><p><strong>How can we duplicate the success of this event?</strong></p><p>I think there were a couple of things that went right there. One you had a group of people who knew enough about the communities and what’s going on that they knew how to do outreach. What’s valuable about this work is that it’s using the tools and techniques of the 21st Century to make work that actually speaks culturally to the time we’re in. The hard part about individuals is that there is no one answer and that’s where this whole entrepreneurial things comes in.</p><p>Everything is fractured so much that there’s no one model now that people can follow and replicate to make this stuff happen. I think it’s all about people creating opportunities for collaboration. And that was another one of the big takeaways for me of the Artup project. One of the things that was sort of clear was the anxiety about how the art world doesn’t care about our work and the technology community isn’t buying our work, not coming to our events and don’t care about what we’re doing. And on the tech side they’re saying, the art world doesn’t care about the creative work we’re doing. What was apparent from that is if you really want collaboration and that’s important to you the onus is on everyone to create the opportunities for collaboration, to invite people into their process and to take that experimental risk upon themselves. That’s the only way these walls will be broken down. It’s about creating community and opportunities for other people to plug into that winds up being a successful strategy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LwtFYZLqrHqj4r5j1KEE0Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="http://grayarea.org/">Gray Area Foundation for the Arts</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>So more Artup-like events then?</strong></p><p>I think that helps.</p><blockquote>I mean, what is entrepreneurialism really? What it means in a sense is that there’s not inherent established structure that’s going to give you a path forward. So if there’s things you want to see happen in the world you just gotta do it.</blockquote><p>Get people together, provide opportunities for people to plug in and a lot of times these projects will work out. You’ll find a lot more interest than you would think. But if you’re just waiting around looking for opportunities you’re not necessarily going to find the kinds of things you want without being the point of creation for these things. And that’s the kind of stuff artists are good at. Creating whole worlds, systems of thought, modalities, voices, visions and creative practices for themselves, which makes them potentially very good entrepreneurs.</p><p><strong>Did you see things progress in this way through Gray Area and Artup?</strong></p><p>Yeah, one of the things that clearly has been happening for a few years now is this cultural incubator concept. We’ve been doing it at Gray Area for a long time. NEW INC was one of the most high profile ones. There’s also creativity lab space in a lot of companies like Google Creative Labs and lab space in museums like the Met. This is a good foundation for a lot of artists to plugin.</p><p><strong>There’s been some criticism of art incubators. Do you agree with any of it?</strong></p><p>I think most of the criticism comes down to some sort of role of art and capital. I think it’s a valuable critique but not one I actually agree with. I don’t think these things are mutually exclusive. It’s ok that cultural incubators are a potential funding model that catalyzes work and makes it possible and that there’s public funding for the arts and a robust gallery scene. All these things can coexist and it’s not like we’re in a zero-sum game in terms of what the cultural landscape is going to look like. It will be a mix of all these models that will providing multiple opportunities.</p><p>I think the cultural incubator concept is an experiment that still hasn’t been fully vetted out. I’ve seen a lot of great things come out of it that otherwise wouldn’t have. Nobody’s forced to be involved so when I hear critique of them it makes me wonder if there’s some other argument that’s going on there that’s not really about the incubator itself. It’s more about what isn’t there than what is there. It’s like, “don’t do this because I want to see this other thing” and it’s like, then go do that other thing.</p><p><strong>Right, that’s what I like most about these incubators is that it creates alternative pathways.</strong></p><p>I think there are more options than there ever have been in the history of the world for someone to actually be successful doing a creative practice. There are opportunities that people through individual entrepreneurial activities can make for themselves. And when I say “entrepreneurial” that doesn’t necessarily mean creating a business.</p><blockquote>What it means is creating a model and situation for yourself that works.</blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/daee4d9996b2"><em>Net.Work</em></a><em> is helping formalize a community of entrepreneurial artists and what it means to make work. </em><a href="https://medium.com/@net_dot_work/introducing-net-work-a0ce41b02554#.mhm57lsg6"><em>Find out more here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Say hi, send comments and feedback to </em><a href="http://twitter.com/net_dot_work"><em>@net_dot_work</em></a><em> or tyler@absolutnet.work.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92ee1522f0c6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business/what-does-it-mean-to-make-work-92ee1522f0c6">What does it mean to make work?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business">Strictly Business</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Earnestness is not enough]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/strictly-business/earnestness-is-not-enough-274b89a7f688?source=rss----2bd6dcfc8768---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/274b89a7f688</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interview]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[side-project]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tyler Mathews]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Aug 2016 04:40:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-14T12:58:38.180Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Rachel Binx on turning her interests into companies.</h4><p><em>Earlier this year I had the pleasure of talking with data visualist, artist and entrepreneur, </em><a href="https://twitter.com/rachelbinx"><em>Rachel Binx</em></a><em>. Rachel has founded several companies including </em><a href="https://meshu.io/"><em>Meshu</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://gifpop.io/"><em>Gifpop!</em></a><em> and </em><a href="http://monochome.com/"><em>Monochōme</em></a><em>. She’s </em><a href="http://rachelbinx.com/"><em>currently working on</em></a><em> mapping technology for Mapzen, has done dataviz for NASA’s Jet Propulsion Lab, MTV and curated </em><a href="http://giflocal.net/"><em>gif.local</em></a><em>, a wonderful little art exhibit for Eyebeam’s LittleNets exhibition.</em> <em>This conversation has been edited for length and clarity.</em></p><h4>TL;DR turning your passion into a business doesn’t mean anyone wants what you’re making.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ou3pZttEaIg1EqJb1EWB3Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>This is Rachel. Photo by <a href="http://theblight.net/">Neil Girling</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Can you give us a rundown of the projects you’ve been involved in… are they side projects, startups? How do you view these?</strong></p><p>Good question. Sometimes I call them recreational ecommerce, sometimes I call them “the companies” sort of tongue-in-cheek. But there’s no VC so I think they’re technically not startups. But maybe some combination of both?</p><p><strong>What was the first project and what made you jump in?</strong></p><p>Meshu [which maps your travels and turns them into jewelry] was first. It was this nights-and-weekends, fun project we were building out. The response to it was way more than we thought it would be. It was this hobby thing that people got really interested in and placing orders. Then we had to reconsider how to turn this into a business that we could sustain.</p><p>It’s interesting because all of the issues about fulfillment and making pieces and all those lessons got rolled into the next project. Like with Gifpop! we found a printer that took care of fulfillment, which was just this amazing thing. We were like, wait, we can send you data and you do everything else?</p><p>For Monochōme it was kinda the same way. Meshu was built on Django and was all handmade, a little bit janky, but both Monochōme and Gifpop! were built on Shopify. I didn’t have to deal with the backend. I could just worry about the part that I care about. You learn how to make your life easier. That’s why I’ve been able to continue working on this kind of stuff because I’m just rolling the lessons from one to the next. It gets easier and easier and less time to do.</p><p><strong>Back in 2014 at XOXO you were giving a brief background on what you’ve worked on up until that point and something you said really stuck out to me. It was “earnestness is not enough.” What’s interesting to me is that in business you have to make something people want but in art you don’t. If you’re OK with that, that’s fine but if you want to be a working artist that can be difficult. I think that’s on the same page with what you were talking about, but can you explain more?</strong></p><p>That story comes out of when I was in Albuquerque and I was making jewelry. I was working with materials that I thought were interesting and making pieces I thought were interesting. At some point I thought I’ll go sell them. I’ll go around to stores and just make this work. As I’m going through this process of trying to sell samples and trying to get things put in stores I realized the chasm between what I was trying to sell and what the general finished product looks like. It taught me that just because I love something doesn’t mean the rest of the world will love something. It’s fine to make your own pieces, your own personal art if that’s the limit of what you’re hoping your adoption to be. But if you’re hoping people will go out and want to buy your pieces and to have a sustainable practice around it there’s a certain level of polish that exists in the world that you can’t just ignore because you really like the work for yourself.</p><p>The more recent projects I’ve worked on there’s a fair amount of market research that goes into it…polished photographs and sites that feel professional. Even it’s just something I’m doing on nights and weekends.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*RYd03WHEfnaX4FhCttQ8Qg.jpeg" /><figcaption>From the Meshu website</figcaption></figure><p><strong>I’m assuming you approached Meshu and Gifpop! with this mentality?</strong></p><p>Definitely. Something that was very important for us on Meshu was to get a professional photoshoot done before we launched. This actually delayed the launch by about a month because there were so many people that were involved in the shoot and we had to get availability for everyone. I was joking around with [my cofounder] Sha [Hwang] about this and he’d be like, “We can just take photos ourselves.” But for me it was really important to have that full studio experience and to have professional lighting, professional photographers, hair, makeup, models. I wanted there to be a certain level of polish and presentation on the photos that we use on the site. This was a huge expenditure. Sha and I are both web developers and so we just built the site basically for free on nights and weekends. But then we did this shoot and we wanted to pay people. We didn’t have a ton of money because we were paying out-of-pocket, but it was important to us to have professionals there and pay them for their time to get that level of polish.</p><p>I did all the photography for Monochōme, for Gipop!, for <a href="https://treknotes.co/">TrekNotes</a>. Sometimes there’s not quite the same level, but for jewelry shoots I think there’s something really nice to have that high fashion studio look. Certainly for things like Monochōme I was envisioning things like a streetwear kind of company so it was OK to be out on the street or in front of a mural.</p><p><strong>Did you view all three of those as real companies or side projects that make money?</strong></p><p>For me all of them are both an exploration of manufacturing techniques and building interfaces. So there’s more hobby perspective on that but it was important for me to present them as actual companies. Part of that was to make the customers feel comfortable to place an order. Because if it was just some side project website that was explicit in not being taken seriously, but I’m asking people to pay me money… I don’t people would want to do that. I tried to come off as a real place. Which sort of backfires sometimes when people email you and want to get a hold of you. I have this full-time job and so I’m coming home and only remember to look at my inbox every couple days. And so people are like, “Oh my gosh, your turnaround is terrible.” I’m like, well it’s just me and I have a job. I’m sorry.</p><p><strong>In one perspective you want to make it really personal because it’s your creation on a scale for everyone else to enjoy. But then there’s this idea of professionalism. People who are familiar with you or your company’s history may be more lenient. But then there are people who only see this as a company and want to order something. That seems like an interesting thing balance</strong>.</p><p>Sometimes people write in and they’re like, “Oh, I’ve seen your [other] work somewhere else” but a lot of people just hear about it word-of-mouth or saw an article about it somewhere and are just treating it like a real company. I think the fulfillment side of it is the most difficult side of it because people have gotten a little bit spoiled by stuff like Amazon and Amazon Prime. So I’m like, “I’m sorry, it takes four weeks to make this and I’m shipping it USPS because I don’t have a business license. I’m sorry, it’s slow, it’s expensive. It’s just two of us. We’re sorry!”</p><p><strong>Does responding candidly help?</strong></p><p>I don’t use any sort of Zendesk or ticketing system on the email. I know on some level that would help me but I feel like it comes off that much more personal if it’s just me writing the meat of each email each time. And I can really bring a personal voice to it and throw in some emoticons to basically say, “Hey, there’s only one person talking to you. Please act accordingly.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*0iNwzDpU-Amop3GHn7Ld8Q.gif" /><figcaption>A Gifpop! print</figcaption></figure><p><strong>You also have another project… actually, you have a lot of projects listed </strong><a href="http://rachelbinx.com/"><strong>on your site</strong></a><strong>, which is fun because it’s like digging through a tumblr. One I found was a site that helps small ecomm sites solve problems around production and other things. Are you still keeping up with this?</strong></p><p>Sort of. Originally I had this very ambitious goal to do a weekly release and it turns out that if everyone I’m contacting are also doing their own small business on top of a day job it turns out everyone is busy. But the reason why that started is because I found myself at conferences or parties and someone would mention a product company and I was immediately like, “Oh my gosh, can we talk about this? What do you do for fulfillment, what do you do for shipping, for customer service?” And they would be super excited to talk about this too.</p><blockquote>I remember a friend and I were [at a party] going back and forth asking, “What do you do for this? What about this?” and someone else asked what we’re talking about and we’re like, “Shipping!”</blockquote><p>I realized that everyone who was doing this has the same sorts of issues and we’re all trying to figure it out for ourselves. So I wanted there to be a place where people could come and talk about it and share the good and the bad side of the work they’re doing.</p><p><strong>Are you seeing artists where you’re at in Los Angeles experimenting with the startup model or using more business tactics in their practices?</strong></p><p>I don’t know if I’m aware of a large-scale trend but on an individual, anecdotal level I talk to a bunch of people about marketing plans and how to do photography, tips on dealing with inventory and, yeah, all these things that go into running a business.</p><p><strong>How do you define success for most of your projects?</strong></p><p>Much of it is me wanting to explore manufacturing techniques and web technology. Really just launching it is a success. Finishing it enough to put it out into the world and tell people about it is its own baseline success for me. And if other people are interested in it, get excited about it, place orders, and of course, money which is a good metric of success. But, I feel good that they got out there and completed the idea to show other people.</p><p><strong>What’s interesting to me is exploring how artists are finding ways to make money in a way that works for them. There are plenty of models and paths to take but thanks to the internet people can make it their own…</strong></p><p>And that’s something I’ve been thinking about a lot lately. How do you call it finished? Do you let it peter out and eventually turn off the lights or do you pick a certain date in the future that you want it to be over with? Like TrekNotes, the book project I worked on. It turns out printing one-off books is really expensive and that was my end of exploration. Like, maybe this doesn’t actually work out. I had to price them really high to even cover the cost to make it. There’s basically no profit margin. Eventually I was like, “OK, I put this out there and 20 or so people have bought one. They feel good about it, I feel good about it. I’m OK to let it go and turn off ordering.” And for me that was the first time I closed one of these. It felt really nice that the entire arc of the project concluded. I’ve been thinking a lot about how to end things in a way that you feel good about it. Not because you got frustrated and had to shut it down.</p><p>Sometimes you can get stuck in this middle ground where it’s not hugely successful that it can by your full-time job but it’s not nothing either. You have some number of orders or income coming through but at some point it’s like what’s the mental tax of keeping all the projects in your head?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dWwWn6tg9OT5ekjkdb-SAQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photoshoot for Monochōme. Photo by Steve Rude.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Do you have any advice for people looking to get started with ecommerce as the revenue model?</strong></p><p>I think the two biggest to look out for are inventory and shipping. There’s a reason that each one of my projects are one-offs. I don’t want inventory in my house. I don’t want boxes and boxes of something that I’m trying to sell off. Thankfully that’s a lesson I learned early on with my Albuquerque jewelry venture. I was making bottle cap earrings and at some point I had like 100 pairs of bottle cap earrings that no one wanted. But I put all this time and love into and it was like, “Oh God, what do I do with this?” I was like OK, I’ll never do this again. I hear that often from people who want to do this cool thing and then suddenly have boxes of t-shirts that they’re waiting to ship out one-by-one. I think that can be a little bit overwhelming. Yeah, the whole shipping part is the thing that everyone gets overwhelmed with because navigating the Postal Service and how to get good rates for postage and order boxes, ship things and stay protected and to make them look nice. There’s just all these things and finishing touches that make your product more professional and then the labor involved. It takes people by surprise by how much time it takes to start mailing things.</p><p><strong>I’m guessing this took you by surprise?</strong></p><p>Yeah, my first year at Meshu… I left my job in October. I was like, this is great I can focus on Meshu for the holiday season. I hear the holidays are a big thing and maybe I’ll get, fingers crossed, maybe twice as many orders. That number turned out to be ten times. I remember…[one night] I had to make chain for like eight hours. I was like, maybe I should figure out some way to make this easier for myself.</p><p><strong>What did you end up doing?</strong></p><p>Well, this is really dumb. At first I bought chain bulk because I was like, “I’ve made chain for years. I can make this and save a little bit of money. Look at me I’m so smart.” Turns out the time spent on making that chain… I should just buy pre-made chain. Once you’re not constructing each of these and I just attach the pendent to the chain, put it in the box, ship it out.</p><p>And hiring people. If I’m overwhelmed by work I hire someone instead of sit and stress like, “I’ll never get this done.” It was such a new thing for me.</p><blockquote>If there’s enough orders that I’m stressed out, there’s enough money for me to hire someone.</blockquote><p><strong>Was your cofounder part of the shipping process?</strong></p><p>Yeah, but he still had a full-time job though. So I would be making jewelry all day long and then he’d come home and we’d box everything up. For some reason we didn’t know you could schedule pickups for USPS so we would go and stuff every single blue box until it was full and it couldn’t open any more and then walk to the next one and put more boxes in. We did all these things you just shouldn’t do. Once you start doing this stuff you’re like, this is really dumb. I should just schedule a pickup and not worry about it.</p><blockquote>But at the time we’re like, well, I guess this is my life and I just have to suffer now.</blockquote><p>There are so many little tricks you wouldn’t know about until you just start doing it.</p><p><strong>Any other projects in the works?</strong></p><p>I’d really like to get back into more traditional jewelry design. I have a few ideas kicking around for that but it will be more me acting as designer and less about user-generated designed pieces. But, I don’t know, still kicking ideas around.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/daee4d9996b2"><em>Net.Work</em></a><em> is helping formalize a community of entrepreneurial artists and what it means to make work. </em><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business"><em>Read more of my conversations here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Say hi, send comments and feedback to </em><a href="http://twitter.com/net_dot_work"><em>@net_dot_work</em></a><em> or tyler@absolutnet.work.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=274b89a7f688" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business/earnestness-is-not-enough-274b89a7f688">Earnestness is not enough</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/strictly-business">Strictly Business</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>