<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[The Gnoose - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[exploring the universe - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/the-gnoose?source=rss----8821cead2fba---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 05:42:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/the-gnoose" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Frozen, Frankisstein and the Cold, Cold Heart — The Gnoose]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-gnoose/frozen-frankisstein-and-the-cold-cold-heart-the-gnoose-f6076ff05f44?source=rss----8821cead2fba---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6076ff05f44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[frozen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeanette-winterson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[angela-carter]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyadarshini John]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Dec 2019 11:57:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-12T11:57:51.160Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Frozen, Frankisstein and the Cold, Cold Heart — The Gnoose</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xEE6nIARcim2y6Iq.jpg" /></figure><p>I can’t find a single review of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Frankissstein-Love-Story-Jeanette-Winterson/dp/1787331407">Jeanette Winterson’s Frankisstein</a> that isn’t roaring applause. The same goes for <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frozen_(2013_film)">Frozen</a>, the Disney-Snow Queen of some years ago, which has now arrived at its sequel. It’s because both ‘ <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/nov/17/how-frozen-melts-children-hearts">tick all the right boxes</a>,’ as they claim. They say this like it’s a good thing. It makes me wonder whether critics are just google bots, looking for the right keywords for optimal correctness to the current definition of politically correct, and assuming, then, that the thing is good, good to go.</p><p>I tried watching Frozen on a flight and couldn’t survive it beyond thirty minutes even in flight-zombie-intertia. The only good thing about it was that it put me to sleep — it seemed so dull that consciousness chose to escape. I hated Frankisstein — it ticked all the wrong boxes, the ones that gave me goosebumps of queasiness, fear and shame.</p><p>The story of Frozen is a kind of babble of re-writing. A stolen story, rewritten to make the right number of dolls, the right noisy songs. Enough to sell. And everyone applauds this transformation from the bad old days when fairy tales were about girls needing to be rescued. Because in this story, two girls get rescued by each other, sort of, with the help of a man and the hindrance of another man. Though in the original <a href="https://andersen.sdu.dk/vaerk/hersholt/TheSnowQueen_e.html">Snow Queen</a>, it was a girl rescued a boy, even though this was an archaic fairy tale, before the word empowerment became popular. There are a thousand similar <em>archaic </em>fairy tales, where princesses, poor girls, orphaned girls, abandoned girls, trekked through frozen landscapes, visited fearsome witches in dark forests, encountered wolves and humans and both together, though one must admit all their missions were unsuccessful (read unproductive) because they didn’t make salable secondary merchandise at the end.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ocBKhq1HrK56BTzp.jpg" /><figcaption>Forests, witches and the fearsome world of fairy tales. Image: Priyadarshini John</figcaption></figure><p>Anyway, by the standards of capitalist enterprise and profit-making venture, brand-value and marketability, Frozen was the mostest. The empowerment of the fairy tale. Thanks to Disney, womanhood has a hero and a damn shrieky anthem.</p><p><strong>The Snow Queen and The Demon’s Mirror</strong></p><p>Let’s get distracted, though, for a moment, by the original Snow Queen. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Christian_Andersen">Hans Christian Andersen</a> usually likes to tell punishing tales where eyes are sacrificed, little girls who are too attached to their shoes get their feet cut off, and other little girls who’re too poor die in the snow. However, the Snow Queen is surprisingly redemptive, from a man who seems to have believed that redemption should only happen after death.</p><p>The story starts with a mirror created by a demon. It morphs the reality it reflects, showing only the bad and the ugly. The demon insists that people could, now, <em>see what mankind and the world were really like. </em>The mirror sounds suspiciously familiar, especially for someone who read other Hans Christian Anderson stories as a child. That tendency to imagine that reality is the grey stuff. The demon and his troll-students take the mirror around the world, but when they try to bring it to the skies to see what angels look like in its distorted view, it shatters and all those mirror bits invade the earth. Small enough to be a speck of dust in someone’s eye, sometimes big enough to make a window pane, the mirror-shards multiply in their capacity for harm. Because from here on, we’re not dealing with a visible enemy anymore. Not a demon, a troll, a visible outside entity. Instead, we’re attacked by infinitesimal bits of devilry, a little speck of something that darkens your vision, a person who was once whole and warm who gets hit by an unseen thing and transforms before your eyes into something cold, a frozen heart.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ji185krRdGJUcNnu.jpg" /><figcaption>Cold heart. Image: Painting by Kristian Al Droubi</figcaption></figure><p>Imagine those shards of mirror as a thing, an incident, an event, something you heard, something someone did or said — which looks like a thousand other similar things or sayings, but for some reason, freezes your heart or makes the world look grey. It doesn’t seem so impossible. From the wild ride of the troll-mirror, we come down to earth to a village where two pious little children live, as they should, in the Anderson-world. A little boy, Kay, and a girl, Gerda, and they’re best friends. One day Kay sees a shimmering woman made of ice beckoning to him from a wintry landscape. This first vision of the Snow Queen, like a dream, is an intimation of things to come.</p><p>Soon after, Kay is struck in the eye by a bit of demon-mirror, and another shard pierces his heart. He is wounded, but no one knows, no one can see. He sees the worm in the heart of the rose ( <em>o rose, thou art sick!)</em>. He sees everything that is wrong in everyone. His loss of connection goes unrecognized. Like all people who are never really unhappy or happy, he’s assumed to be unusually clever. And in a way, he is. The demon’s mirror is a clever thing. It doesn’t tell lies, even. Just not the whole truth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Ha1TxxaskDi_Xy3C.jpg" /><figcaption>He sees the worm in the heart of the rose. Image: Painting by Kristian Al Droubi</figcaption></figure><p>Soon after <em>that</em>, Kay is kidnapped by the Snow Queen. She wraps him in a cloak and kisses him, a frozen kiss that vibes strangely with his frozen heart. <em>No more kisses</em>, after this one. <em>Or I should kiss you to death</em>. Because Kay did feel like he was dying, from that first kiss. Somehow, though, life re-asserted itself. You can live with a frozen heart. You can live in a frozen world. I’m not sure whether that’s because some tiny speck of soul that remains is waiting to be lit, revived and rescued, or because <em>human beings can get used to just about anything</em>.</p><p>Anyway, this is Kay. Hurt, trapped, kidnapped. Waiting to be rescued. And Gerda does the rescuing. Gerda the traveler, the adventurer, the maker of relationships and friendships. Gerda the renegade soul that chooses its own path. That lives neither in the fantasy of Disney princesses nor in the heartless reflected world of the demon’s mirror (I can’t always see the difference between the two). And finally, even though this is a Hans Christian Anderson story, both get to live, without any limbs amputated. Gerda’s tears melt Kay’s heart, if you’re wondering. And that makes him cry, washing the mirror-shard out of his eye. Whole again, in the world again, he suddenly realizes that he’s been sleepwalking alone in an icy world all this time.</p><p>I’m relieved. I wish Anderson had been as kind to the little match girl. I’m not sure what kind of retelling Frozen has done — looking at the plot line, I’d say it’s not a lot of things. Not better, not modernized, not deconstructed, not decoded, not even connected. It feels a little like the story itself was kidnapped and stuffed into the devil-mirror.</p><p>I don’t remember a single frame of Frozen. However, the image of the mirror carried by a gang of trolls, that shook with laughter halfway to the heavens, fell down to the earth and broke into billions of pieces is manic, surreal, beautiful, unforgettable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8KUxULX0n7rhEZBS.jpg" /><figcaption>Shards of the demon’s mirror. Image: Priyadarshini John</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Reviews, retellings, fairy tales and the heart of things</strong></p><p>A hundred years ago, a <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/film/2011/apr/09/the-new-red-riding-hood-is-grim">review or not even of one more ‘new’ Red Riding Hood by John Patterson in The Guardian</a> made mention of the film-makers’ being unacquainted with the ‘late, great Angela Carter’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Company_of_Wolves">The Company of Wolves</a> ‘ and spoke about how that entire industry of child-tween-cleaned movies was in need of her subversive, galvanising presence.</p><p>A hundred years later, when nobody writes reviews like this anymore, because they don’t tick the right boxes, when <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frozen_II">Frozen 2</a> comes out and everyone pretends to like it, or at least not to hate it, I feel a mad yearning for Angela Carter’s subversive presence. Not just because it would make films and life more fun. (Or in this case resurrect what has become a series of clones of corpses.) But also because she actually researched fairy tales, dug down to their roots, even if that meant walking a long and winding road as the story repeated itself in a thousand different ways across the world. These days, I think that Angela Carter didn’t re-write fairy tales — she just cut them open at the heart, and let the colour red dazzle you.</p><p>I also thought about that other great decoder of fairy tales — <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A._S._Byatt">A S Byatt</a>, whose eldest princess (from <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Djinn-Nightingales-Eye-S-Byatt/dp/0679762221">The Djinn in the Nightingale’s Eye</a>) abandons her mission to save her country, wanders off into the forest, bypasses a few other stories, and finds an old woman, a weaver of webs of narratives, and chooses to live with her in a hut full of strange and not-so-pretty creatures. An unproductive version of Elsa? Much more. The eldest princess simply makes a different choice. She chooses story-making over storying. It’s not a hermitage she needs to be rescued from. No-one rescues anyone. Things don’t happen, one after the other, until one arrives at the heart of the forest, where stories are spun. Life is not a succession of happenings. Life is as much paths diverted as paths followed. If you’re going to remake a story, this is how you do it.</p><p><strong>Frankinstein Being Kissed to Death</strong></p><p>Frankisstein, on the other hand, lies in the place of paths crossed, rather than paths followed. Mary Shelley writes her story in the company of sort-of friends in the stillness of a lakeview. Ry Shelley, a trans-evolved-human-not-woman, meets a very traditional mad scientist called Victor Stein, who inhabits a post-Elon-Musk post-feminist post-human world but scans the brain by, well, scanning brain. Ron, a sort-of-evolved-incel, solves the problem of women by making female-bots. Or should you say the problem of men? Or just the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incel">collective problems of incels</a>?</p><p>I loved Jeanette Winterson’s lyrical writing about love, once upon a time. Also, her constantly-mutating descriptions of bodies. Now, she seems to have coalesced into a final-stage evolution description of one body, that of Ry Shelley.</p><p>If I were to collect the repeated keywords/keyphrases in Frankisstein, they’d be:</p><p>three holes (mouth, pussy, vagina)/two-inch clitoris/sex/penis/three holes/sexbots/women/trans/AI/trans/three holes/two-inch clitoris/flat chest/muscled chest/xx-inch breasts/flat muscled chest/trans/Shelley/Shelley/Mary/Ry/Victor/Stein/Frankinstein</p><p>These are the characters as I remember them:</p><ul><li>Mary Shelley, who is given the pat on the back of being a feminist in the dark times, and hence can be sympathized with as a potential trans person of the lit times who just hadn’t arrived at the light yet.</li><li>Victor Stein, who always talks like a TED talk.</li><li>Ry Shelley, of the flat muscled chest, two-inch clitoris, evolved-to-be-better-than woman</li><li>Hypocritical Female 1 — a church-feminist-capitalist/bitch (though we can’t really say that, just sort of imply it)</li><li>Hypocritical Female 2 — a stalker/journalist/abuser of boundaries</li><li>Numerous sex-bots who’re mostly demo-ed in the book. We don’t really see them in action.</li><li>Ron the sex-bot maker, who’s actually pretty funny.</li><li>Ron’s mother, who is unseen but very much a part of the sex-bot-making industry.</li><li>Irrelevancies like Byron/Shelley/other characters who don’t mean much.</li><li>The monster. A shapeless thing. A thing that sometimes looks like Frankinstein himself, at other times AI, sometimes like a sex-bot, sometimes like Ry Shelley. At one point like some sort of brain attached to nodes or wires or whatever it is mad scientists use.</li></ul><p><strong>Clits, dicks, breasts and vaginas</strong></p><p>I’ve got Ry Shelley’s two-inch clit on my mind. The inches maketh the man? And yet, Ry Shelley asks, is manhood dickhood? It seems to me that the two-inch clit is more about womanhood than manhood. The dickhood of womanhood. The two-inch clit separates Ry Shelley from the sexbots, who are, after all, just three holes and a head which is often bashed in. We’re not sure if the heads are bashed in because the bots are recipients of male aggression towards women, or because incels realized at the end of the event that they were sleeping with bots, and therefore still technically incels.</p><p>Ry Shelley, without <em>large</em> breasts, or breasts at all, with a repetitively mentioned flat-muscled chest, with a vagina that can be penetrated but might possibly disappear and be replaced with even more inches, stands taller/bigger/more inched, not among men, but among women. Ultimately, what seems to be communicated, through these repetitious statements about sex-bots and two-inch clits, is that there is an inherent physical problem with a body that is composed of three holes. This body, since there is no visible phallic element to it, seems to be viewed as inherently <em>passive</em>, by being structurally receptive. Ry Shelley, while open to penetration, does not orgasm through penetrative sex. Sex-bots do. And if women do? Does that make them sex-bots?</p><p><strong>Questions. </strong>What is womanhood? Clithood? Breasthood? If breasthood does not the woman maketh, then what does? Why is a two-inch protuberance of a clit more powerful, more relevant, more real than, say, the inches of its depths, because the visible clit is, after all, only the tip of the iceberg? What makes a woman? Three holes? Why is the modern woman (as we meet her in this book) so annoying, as opposed to the modern transman? Why does the transman’s body count as the transfiguration, the transformation, the making of the self?</p><p>What then does one make of that less surgical transformation that all of us have to go through, after each spell of suffering, after each spurt of growth, after each evolution of the soul, after each resurrection from the icy winter of self-destruction? What do our relentlessly mutating selves make of the idea that some of us were cast in stone at birth? Of course, I do wonder, do semi-visible or invisible transformations count? Does a non-surgical amputation count? Does a mutating lover who is male and female but doesn’t remove the necessary appendages count? Because, as Roy says, <em>only what counts, counts</em>.</p><p>Which brings me back to the bloody chamber of <a href="https://www.amazon.in/Bloody-Chamber-Other-Stories/dp/014017821X">Angela Carter’s Bloody Chamber</a>. All fairy tales, to me, are stories of transformation. That’s why they’re not stories of success, or successful production (until they became that). The colour red is dazzling. The Bloody Chamber is the red beating heart of the fairy tale.</p><p>When Red Riding Hood finds the wolf in her grandmother’s bed, this is the moment of transformation. The discovery of internal beasthood, the encountering of it. When Beast licks the skin off Beauty and finds glistening fur, tiger-striped, beneath. These are also transformations. They’re not surgically verified. They don’t hold trans-authenticity. They are, however, familiar. They make you feel like something more than three holes. They make a distinction between receptivity, responsiveness and passivity. They don’t shame your holes, your breasts, your lack of inches, or whether or not they protrude. They make you sense the movement beneath your skin, the terrible, gravitational pull of the bloody chamber, they walk you down the lonely path in the darkest part of the forest and find the part of you that runs with the wolves. That runs <em>like </em>a wolf. That <em>is</em> wolf.</p><p>This time, also, Jeanette Winterson’s lyrical writing about love is the thing that stays with me that is not measurable with a tape measure. This time, though, I say these words to myself, not to a real or imaginary other. To remove the shard of mirror that freezes the heart:</p><p><em>I wanted to know you — in the gnostic sense of close experience of what would otherwise be unknown.</em> <em>What are you?</em> <strong>What are you?</strong></p><p>Angela Carter writes intimately about a woman who is not a woman — Fevvers, of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Nights-at-Circus-Angela-Carter/dp/0140077030">Nights at the Circus</a>. The hole she is missing is the navel. The bit she has added is wings — not angel-wings so much as circus-wings that sweep the roof, uncomfortable wings that itch, tremble, make it hard to lie down and dress up, that are never really real nor a sham, that always bridge the in-between. Jack Walser, former clever-frozen-boy, newly hatched by a towering bird-woman into a new man, looks at the creature straddling him, and asks, <em>What is your name? Have you a soul? Can you love?</em></p><p>This is an ending and a beginning. <em>That’s how you start an interview, laughs Fevvers. </em>A laugh that spirals to the skies.</p><h4>Author: Priyadarshini John</h4><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://gnoose.com/2019/12/03/frozen-frankisstein-and-the-cold-cold-heart/"><em>https://gnoose.com</em></a><em> on December 3, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6076ff05f44" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose/frozen-frankisstein-and-the-cold-cold-heart-the-gnoose-f6076ff05f44">Frozen, Frankisstein and the Cold, Cold Heart — The Gnoose</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose">The Gnoose</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rituals and the Performance of Being — The Gnoose]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-gnoose/rituals-and-the-performance-of-being-the-gnoose-8ac2f3fec129?source=rss----8821cead2fba---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ac2f3fec129</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[weddings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ritual]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyadarshini John]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Oct 2019 12:35:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-22T12:35:24.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Rituals and the Performance of Being — The Gnoose</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_QwKEsTtD0m_QGiq.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>A wedding ritual</strong></p><p>I don’t often get to see the actual ritual of a wedding, in its entirety. One of the rare times that I did, I watched it in a rage, and towards the end I started to feel desperate for escape, almost like I was suffocating. The smoke, the chanting, the oppressive need to be there and to hear this and to watch it through to the end.</p><p><strong>A morning ritual</strong></p><p>I don’t hate rituals in themselves. I start to see the value of marking things. The way we do with tea and conversation in the morning, or when I am alone, tea and music. This denotes the beginning of the day, or moving into consciousness. I think about Pratchett, the Hogfather. <em>If you don’t save the Hogfather, the sun will not rise</em>. Which doesn’t mean that if you miss this ritual, say of tea in the morning, there will be no day. It just means, maybe, that I will be more confused, less aware, that I won’t register the change, that the previous day will extend itself through my consciousness, say if I am fighting with someone, the fight will continue, repeat itself, and no matter how hard I try or how much I want it, nothing will change, nothing will change until I start a new day, until I perform this ritual of awakening, of sitting back and thinking.</p><p>In the wedding ritual, the bride’s mother must tie the marriage knot, must give away her daughter. I get the feeling, looking at her, that she may have never registered this separation, this acceptance of cutting something away, if it wasn’t physically forced on her, this symbolic action. The enraging part was that in everything that was said, there was no understanding that the man also had to cut this umbilical cord. The bride and the groom were not untied, let loose. The bride was released into the husband’s family, and mainly he speaks to show his acceptance of her, and mainly she speaks to commit to him and his family.</p><p>And yet, I do think that it makes a strong impact to ritualise this moment when you leave — not your home, not your family, but this space where your energies are tied to that of your parents (though the leaving really should be mutual, to be real). It’s only in the past couple of years that I really start to see how houses, homes, lives are run by this connection. Once upon a time, alone after a fight with a partner, I found that I was thinking not about him, but about my parents. I had this crazy fear, this terrible rage, this desire for violence and self-violence, and it felt like something was cutting me open, and I realised that this was an inheritance, from my family and from my childhood. And I wanted at that moment not to call, not to go back home, not to deal with the relationship even, but just to cut this cord of connection, to find my way back to myself.</p><p><strong>An imagined ritual</strong></p><p>It would be nice, maybe, if we had some ritual for growing up that had nothing to do with marriage at all, that our mothers symbolically untied a knot instead of tying us up to someone else, if we took these seven steps to walk away first, and not commit ourselves to walking towards something.</p><p>Maybe then we could have some more mature ritual for marriage itself, because before we were married we were already somehow individuated, we were complete, and then we could be much more curious and prepared and interested in newness, in forming connections.</p><p>Even if this marriage ritual was more balanced, even if the mother of the groom and the mother of the bride had this symbolic action of cutting their own cords and making new ties, it still would happen too quickly. You cannot, I think, cut something and tie it up in the same action. You don’t have time to register, to understand and find yourself as a separate human being, before you start locating yourself in someone else.</p><p><strong>A Fool</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RMiBid92WzIvWLCO.jpg" /></figure><p>A hundred years ago, my girlfriend and I made ourselves a marriage ritual. We both read about the Fool, she from St Francis and I from Tom Robbins, and I remember this Tarot card, which I have seen again many times, of the Fool, walking in the wilderness, carrying his belongings, about to step off a cliff. In some peculiar way, even though a couple of years later we had a divorce ritual, even though we broke up, we kept these words, this image, endlessly walking off cliffs, committed to some idea of movement. And in so far as a wanderer meets up and speaks and shares travel stories with another wanderer, in so far as you can make connections on the road, we’ve always kept this commitment to each other. Maybe both of us would have been helped, though, by this other ritual I have imagined, of releasing yourself from family, from these two things, belonging and inheriting.</p><p><strong>Love</strong></p><p>And I also thought, last night, about two other rituals. One was manufactured for my brother and his wife when they came home after getting married. They sat in hard chairs, and we all fed them bananas in milk and threw rice on them. The other happened on the day my niece was named. We all fed her with milk in a silver spoon, and whispered her name in her ear.</p><p>I didn’t try to analyse these rituals too much, because I felt them, inside, differently. These are rituals of love. In the way that when someone is doing something which is important to them, in the sense that you all gather and wave when someone sets off on a journey, in the sense that you are full of good wishes and some of us pick and choose carefully, find the right words, and some of us can’t, we find this thing, this action, feed them and toss something on them, that does all of this. It’s a participative thing, it’s a shared thing, it’s neither masculine nor feminine, it’s very simple. You feed them, you bless them. Blessing not in the sense of the <em>blessings of the elder</em>. We all did it — adults, children. Friends, family. Blessings of love. Everyone in the room.</p><p>With my niece, she was a very small baby — she didn’t have words yet. So we give her something she recognises — milk, and something she doesn’t — her name. and again, it’s all of us — everyone in the room. And I guess you hope that you make some organic connection between these two things — the milk and the word, you feed them to her, together, so that, maybe, there is some mysterious awakening, the body remembering the word, the name.</p><p>Maybe the thing I remember most from these two rituals, is the wide, overwhelming sense of affection floating through the room, collected in the actions.</p><p><strong>Colours</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HJnuLeHgu8fB-b11.jpg" /></figure><p>The things I remember most from my brother’s wedding, are the two of them standing next to each other in the beginning, the strength of the colours — white and red. Somehow, by simply standing there alone, they seemed to be at a great distance. The moment when he misunderstood about this red thing that he was putting on her, and drew a strong red line on her forehead instead, how it seemed to glow before the fire. The registrar’s office where they got their marriage certificate — the white sari and flowers fluttering among the cows, goats, dogs, vegetables, and my brother bringing us a flask of tea.</p><p>And I remembered then and now, when I went to the same office to register an NGO, a bride walking in. She was tall and broad, a strong woman, she was so <em>present</em>, she seemed to turn us all into shadows or ghosts. She wore this long braid, down her back, loaded with flowers. She wore a silk sari, shiningly, fiercely. She wore gold chains and a gold belt, and seemed to radiate this light, and in this office, in this dust, among these papers, she shone like a warrior, proud, powerful, ready to ride off across two worlds.</p><h4>Author: Priyadarshini John</h4><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://gnoose.com/2019/08/30/rituals-and-the-performance-of-being/"><em>https://gnoose.com</em></a><em> on August 30, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ac2f3fec129" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose/rituals-and-the-performance-of-being-the-gnoose-8ac2f3fec129">Rituals and the Performance of Being — The Gnoose</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose">The Gnoose</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Travels with the Serbian Circus — The Gnoose]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-gnoose/travels-with-the-serbian-circus-the-gnoose-40dff6f17736?source=rss----8821cead2fba---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40dff6f17736</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[circus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[serbia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[balkans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyadarshini John]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Oct 2019 13:36:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-04T13:35:59.180Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Travels with the Serbian Circus — The Gnoose</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eWXyRWi_n2fbH9hr.jpg" /></figure><p>The one full of laughing, lovable characters, their biggest crime a little ‘untidiness,’ their caravans so colourful, their lives so pleasantly (not threateningly) exciting.</p><p><strong>The questions you ask yourself</strong></p><ul><li>Where do they go to the toilet?</li><li>How does sex work?</li><li>What if they don’t make any money in a town?</li><li>Do people ever get bored with their shows?</li></ul><p><strong>The thing that makes you want to run away with them</strong></p><p>That they wake up in a field, ride through the countryside, that they don’t go to school, that they wander through day and night in an unregulated, idiosyncratic rhythm.</p><p><strong>The circus you read about as an adult</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*IEDjqVjMMUs5gsZ1.jpg" /><figcaption><em>The very edge of reality<br>Performer: Kristian Al Droubi<br>Image: Priyadarshini John</em></figcaption></figure><p>Of course, the first thing that comes to mind is Angela Carter’s Nights at the Circus. The misery of the clowns that culminates in a sociopathic breakdown in the ring, the abusive Ape-man, the abused Ape-man’s wife, the anthropomorphic animals, the weeping tiger. The common thread in adult-circus-novel representation is tawdry glitter, unwashed charm and behind-the-curtains horror. But there’s also a playing on the edge of wilderness, of becoming a creature or a thing, of tightrope-dancing on the very borderline of reality and fantasy.</p><p><strong>The circus you visit</strong></p><p>It looks a lot like the adult circus literature, but worse.</p><p><strong>The circus you ran away with</strong></p><p>It wasn’t a circus at all, really, because wherever they go these days, you’re nowhere near. I haven’t been to the circus since I was a child. Cirque du Soleil did some rebranding and re-invigorating of the genre, but they’re the posh cirque, not what the Serbs call Cirkus.</p><p>I’m talking about that collection of day/night/street/club entertainers that work in seasons. Tourist season, marriage season, corporate event season, Dubai carnival season. Work-time and idle-time are equally intense, in this world. A rollercoaster relationship with a Serbian performer brought this world to my doorstep, literally. A relentless hopper over the line between art and street, he introduced me to his family, their dog, and his little circus tribe, all in one big colourful bounce into a new playground. There was a mutual adoption.</p><p><strong>Somewhere in the era of the neo circus, as we call it</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*__pAJR4MNaSBq-6Y.jpg" /><figcaption><em>The carnival theme<br>Image: Priyadarshini John</em></figcaption></figure><p>You can be bored and cynical about events, party trends, theme-driven cliches, but eventually you can get bored with your own cynicism. You start craving honesty, ordinariness, awakening. You get pleasure out of watching a bunch of children chasing soap bubbles. An old woman hiking up her sari, vigorously joining in the race to be the first to kill the bubble. The one bubble that escapes, floats off into space, ridiculously beautiful, defiantly other-worldly, a tiny spaceship joining the stars.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Gi7B4_xmOqPGzAzP.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Soap bubbles<br>Image: Priyadarshini John</em></figcaption></figure><p>When there isn’t a wave of ostentation blocking your view, you can see the production of joy and wonder, which is a lot easier than you would imagine.</p><p><strong>Thinking back on the Serbian circus</strong></p><p>One of the greatest imports from my little microcosmic circus was the giant butterfly stilts. It’s a miracle that they came to India at all, that they were allowed into check-in luggage, that they transited half-way across the world without being battered or bruised.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TLh5b90Z42sD77kk.jpg" /><figcaption><em>The patient butterfly</em></figcaption></figure><p>One of the things I loved doing at events was watching Serbian stilt walkers setting up the butterflies. It involves taking a pair of pliers, hammering out the metal, attaching the wings together with tiny screws, finding the straps, laying everything out on the ground and then waiting. All done in methodical calm, in patience, in preparation for a few rounds of pure physical discomfort. These wings have been created out of so much recycled material that it would give goosebumps to green activists.</p><p>In Serbia, I rail about the passivity of Serbians. In India, I love their stoicism in the face of near-violent crowds, iPhone-touting kids and the complete non-availability of basic support, including changing rooms.</p><p><strong>The lonely, two-member circus</strong></p><p>When the rest of the Serbian tribe went back home to recover, there was just two of us left, alone. One Indian (F) and one Serbian (M). We continued to make scattered forays across the country, doing a thing here and another thing there. We did tons of gluing, pasting, cutting, painting and cursing the blazing hot sun as it beat down on us. We complained about hotel rooms, wedding party food, flights and the lack of help. Two people alone, hunting tailors, materials, making and fighting is the kind of company that’s desperate for a crowd.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pMgtsBRM_esTQjCP.jpg" /><figcaption><em>The missing tribe…<br>Performers: Nemanja Miric, Marko Drazic at Capillotractee workshop finale Novi Sad<br>Image: Priyadarshini John</em></figcaption></figure><p>I guess this is why so many things are done in communities. The dancing community, the ganesha-statue-making community, the wedding-banner community, the weaving communities. Because, firstly, some things cannot be done in ones or twos. Simply the scale of those things might force you to look for help. Secondly, people outside your community might not want to help you; they might think it’s dirty, or gross, or weird, or boring, or too painful. In India, community borderlines are fortressed. Moated. Landmined.</p><p>In the Serbian circus, informal communities form in a very simple, organic way. You don’t chat with your driver on the way to Croatia in a van full of equipment because you’re cool, forward-thinking and not into that whole caste thing. You do it because he’s sitting next to you. Work is interactive, wild, playful, uncensored and untainted by notions of purity.</p><p><strong>Serbian memories</strong></p><p>In this lonely period, I missed one Serbian (M), sitting and tooling into the night to make a couple of new pois and touring local hardware shops on his first trip to Bangalore. I missed another Serbian (M), who shot around on his unicycle through the Chennai bus stand, joining in the chorus of city-calling, earning himself some spontaneous friendships for that extra marketing effort.</p><p>Somewhere outside of Chennai, we worked on an event in a resort and one of our team hung the butterflies on the balcony of our cottage for easy access. I’ve always had trouble distinguishing hotel rooms and cottages (I guess you’re supposed to). This time, however, recognition was immediate, and from quite a distance away. And what a wonderful way to recognize a temporary home. The one with the butterflies.</p><p>One time when I was in Serbia, a movie crew that included a former Bond lead was auditioning for extras. I went for the audition not because I can act or have ever wanted to act in a movie. I just went along. Everybody went. The partner, his family, his neighbours, friends, the dog if they could just get him out of the gate. As we walked to the city center, I realized that we had collected enough people (everyone dressed weirdly because that’s how you get noticed) to make something like a parade. And I realized that this was the event. Not the Bond or his movie or his crew. Or even the audition.</p><p>I thought about all these things in India, when the two of us were alone, walking or flying or climbing ladders or trying to carry unreasonably large things.</p><p><strong>Indian memories</strong></p><p>Once, we stayed at a small and horrible hotel in Dwarka, a sort of suburb in New Delhi, with sticky floors and dark rooms and food made out of unrecognisable things — we entertained ourselves by coming up with possible ingredients — mud? Water and plaster? Sawdust? Stone?</p><p>On our way to the event, we stopped outside an apartment block — a part, the event manager tells us, of one of the biggest apartment colonies in — Asia? India? Something massive. A forest of buildings. Occupied and unoccupied. On the fringes of this dark grey mass, I looked across at an empty plot, bordered by a (grey) compound wall. I had this curious feeling of being on the edge of some wilderness. The only homely sight was the black-painted phone number of a key-maker who had found a strategic advertising space. Otherwise, the apartments looked distant, forbidding, and the landscape so strange, lost — the very edge of nothing, the place after the end of the world. I wondered whether this plot was so unwatched, so ignored, that it had almost become unreal.</p><p>And as we travelled on out of Delhi, into Noida, then into Greater Noida, we found more and more of them, apartments without people living in them, rising like trees out of empty landscapes, dark and ghostly in the night, with one single light in a thousand windows to really reinforce that shiver of solitude.</p><p>Travelling three hours across evening and night, cars come back and forth, carrying Very Rich People, Caterers, Event Managers and their Paraphernalia, which in our little cartel included us, The Russian Girls, and The Russian Musicians.</p><p>There’s more of course — tent-builders, flower deliverers, camera persons — we even had vanity vans to keep our things, this time. Vanity-van-drivers parked their chairs outside their charges.</p><p>I watched the guests going in and out — it’s not really a stream, more like a trickle. What do they wear? Lurid shades and glimmers of chiffon, polyester, nylon, all creating a friction in the skin, bringing humidity from the air, burning a little, making a bright note of irritation in everyone’s smile. Men in suits that all look a little too tight at the crotch, armpit and shoulders. Hampering movement. Women in high-heeled shoes. Nobody gets to move freely.</p><p>We are in three-clawed metal stilts and hoods covered in leaves and flowers and we move the least; we only circuit between cigarette breaks and phone-checks, but we pile onto the buffet in the end and we realise that our social circuit is neither small nor big, but random, fragmented — we are tied by work and untied beyond it.</p><p><strong>What the neo-circus does when it’s on its break</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4rKraWE4xcKuGPgd.jpg" /><figcaption><em>A long time ago, in a country far far away<br>Performers: Capillotractee<br>Image: Priyadarshini John</em></figcaption></figure><p>There is a special face you make when you are traveling through people. You are not gazing in wonder at landscapes. The best English word for it is <em>gawping</em>. You catch yourself doing it when look, for example, through a bus window at a tiny collection of homes very close to the street. Intimate details of people’s lives are spread out in the open, before your face. Clothes hanging, kids bathing, cooking fires being lit, people resting.</p><p>You also gawp when you are a traveling entertainer at an event. You are not party to the activities and energies, and neither are you a distant observer. You are an official and accepted gawper.</p><p>Sometimes, when a grand birthday party is at its peak, a slide-show appears with photos photoshopped into backgrounds of lurid flowers awhile italics flow messages around them. I watched a full slide show once. It was pure, unadulterated gawping.</p><p><strong>The child and the adult</strong></p><p>When I was a child I read about the storybook circus and all I wanted then was this censored, circumcised and prettified circus life, with its bright caravans, but mainly for the way it went in and out of places, never stopping for long enough to get stuck, a neverending voyage.</p><p>Now, having made a tiny foray into the fringes of modern animation-entertainment, I find that it is not so much places that you see. In fact, you barely see them, only out of windows on the way from your hotel to the venue. It’s more like traveling through people, watching how hierarchies align themselves automatically wherever you go, and moving in and out of them, walking around the foundations, getting a worm’s eye view and a bird’s eye view of everything.</p><p>It makes me rethink my notion of the caravan itself. A S Byatt in The Djinn in the Nightingale’s Eye describes glass as a thing to be seen and to be seen with. This is something like what the neo-circus entertainer/performer is. An ephemeral, almost transparent and yet brightly-coloured entity. Something like a soap bubble.</p><h4>Author: Priyadarshini John</h4><h4>Travel partner, maker and performer: Kristian Al Droubi</h4><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://gnoose.com/2019/08/30/travels-with-the-serbian-circus/"><em>https://gnoose.com</em></a><em> on August 30, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40dff6f17736" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose/travels-with-the-serbian-circus-the-gnoose-40dff6f17736">Travels with the Serbian Circus — The Gnoose</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose">The Gnoose</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Personal and Mutable TimeLine of Ashtanga Yoga’s #Metoo ‘Crisis’ — The Gnoose]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-gnoose/a-personal-and-mutable-timeline-of-ashtanga-yogas-metoo-crisis-the-gnoose-82eea87c2873?source=rss----8821cead2fba---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82eea87c2873</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[yoga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pattabhi-jois]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metoo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ashtanga-yoga]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Priyadarshini John]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Oct 2019 13:43:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-03T13:13:48.165Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Personal and Mutable TimeLine of Ashtanga Yoga’s #Metoo ‘Crisis’ — The Gnoose</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Bfzr5zDJzKjmkDrq.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>A lot more than a year ago</strong></p><p>There is a term now for people who practice yoga alone at home. It’s ‘home practitioner.’ Sounds straightforward, if you forget that once upon a time, a large number of people who practiced yoga in India did this, and there wasn’t a term for it at all. It was called ‘doing yoga.’</p><p>However, after seven years of doing yoga/being a home practitioner, I decided to teach. Until this moment, I hadn’t even registered the debate around using the word ‘yoga’ for a personal practice. I followed online classes — anything that was free, accessible, usable, that taught me something new and healed me. I practiced wherever I could fit my mat at that moment — a room, a hotel room, someone else’s living room, public parks, backyards. I read up on all the things I was confused about. Let’s call this the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekalavya">Eklavya</a> period of learning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0tl5GZ-8SnDPIp8Q.jpg" /><figcaption>Learning by doing</figcaption></figure><p>Deciding to teach, however, meant deciding to learn in a more structured way. It meant institutionalizing myself, so to speak. I thought it was only fair, because that’s what people expect of teachers. A bargain. I learnt for free. I won’t be teaching for free, so this is the moment to spend.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xlAH0QlWM1EL9cn9.jpg" /><figcaption>Choosing a path</figcaption></figure><p>Learning how to teach yoga means choosing a path. There’s the path of the guru-apprentice, which I already knew I wouldn’t follow, having formed a general idea of guru basically being a euphemism for potential butt-grabber. There’s the teacher-training path — vaguely and badly regulated by something called <a href="https://www.yogaalliance.org/">Yoga Alliance</a> (whatever that is, it’s definitely not Indian) and generating this hybrid entity called a TTC — teacher training course of 200 or 400 hours — a finite period, unlike guru-following. Since path 2 seemed to involve less risk of butt-grabbing and looked less expensive, I took that one.</p><p>Then the second problem — what do you learn how to teach? Most of my online classes were in a style that was poetically called vinyasa flow. But there didn’t seem to be a vinyasa flow TTC within my vicinity. So I picked Ashtanga, because vinyasa flow seemed to have stemmed from it.</p><p><strong>A month later</strong></p><p>I was practicing Ashtanga to prepare for the TTC, also through online videos. I was struggling quite a bit, sweating a lot, not sleeping much, and getting drunk most evenings to bring my energy down. But I felt fine.</p><p><strong>A little more than a year ago</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*25uyQxvMwq5lQ6Uc.jpg" /><figcaption>Mysore, alone and in company</figcaption></figure><p>I made it to teacher training in Mysore, where we practiced the Ashtanga Primary series in a rooftop shala facing the hills at 6:30am every morning. Halfway through, I had a breakdown of sorts. One day, I woke up and went to class and couldn’t do a single forward bend (the Ashtanga Primary series is famous for being heavily invested in forward bends). I couldn’t do anything, to be more precise. My body had gone into resistance. More than that, I was miserable. I didn’t feel like talking, thinking, eating or listening. My mind had caved in. I spoke to one of my trainer-teachers about it and he told me to do a lot of deep backbends. Two days later, I was racing back to life. Problem solved. I continued to get drunk to sleep at night, but I was also happy. I watched Chamundi Hills light up every dawn. I was in company, but as alone as I needed to be. TTCs aren’t so bad after all.</p><p><strong>A year ago</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ULWsH3FlR-p6S8v-.jpg" /><figcaption>Because it was addictive</figcaption></figure><p>Fresh out of Mysore, I decided to continue practicing Ashtanga alone, because it was addictive. I’d like to think there was a better reason but there wasn’t. And going back to my old ways, I started looking it up online. It was a nice juicy rabbit hole, with old teachers poetically talking about knees and hamstrings, young teachers picking apart poses, a thousand how-to videos, anatomy geeks, rebels and traditionalists. I spent hours online, because anyway I couldn’t sleep.</p><p>I knew I wasn’t going to teach Ashtanga. I was very clear that if I did teach, my classes would be adapted to the students’ needs, bodies or even moods. Which meant vinyasa flow, the only term umbrella enough to cover more or less everything. I still wanted to practice it, though. <em>Because I’m a nutjob</em>, I told myself.</p><p>Somewhere in the middle of all these juicy meanderings was when I found Karen Rain’s post about<a href="https://medium.com/s/powertrip/yoga-guru-pattabhi-jois-sexually-assaulted-me-for-years-48b3d04c9456%22"> Pattabhi Jois having sexually abused her</a>. It was a speedbreaker on my Ashtanga road. Karen Rain, formerly Haberman, was one of six students in a very early-days video of Pattabhi Jois directing them through the Primary series, that I had watched repeatedly on mute. I watched it on mute because there was something vaguely military about Jois’ staccato Sanskrit counts. I watched it for the pleasure of watching a pre-digital video, and for the grace of the practitioners.</p><p>From Karen Rain, I navigated to <a href="https://www.yogacitynyc.com/single-post/2016/03/07/Why-The-Abused-Dont-Speak-Up">Anneke Lucas’ Pattabhi Jois abuse story</a>, though that was actually a precursor, published in 2012. This one had a resolution of a personal kind, but for me it was darkly shadowed by the abuse that Anneke Lucas had faced as a child. This was the point when I started feeling a mad obsession rising. I took up yoga to heal, to be alone, to integrate and, simply, for pure pleasure. I imagine that healing was the reason a lot of people chose to do yoga. To work towards healing (possibly from abuse) and then to face abuse seemed to me to be an almost unimaginable contradiction.</p><p><strong>A few months later</strong></p><p>I guess obsession peaked. I read every Ashtanga #metoo story. I followed every near-psychotic Facebook thread. I read everyone’s response, the way other people watch Youtube response videos. Kino McGregor, Ashtanga’s celebrity youtuber, says #ibelieveyou, impatiently followed up with a <a href="https://www.jbrownyoga.com/yoga-talks-podcast/2018/4/kino-macgregor"><em>what do you want</em></a>, in an interview (penitently followed up with an apology). Tim Feldman, Kino’s husband and less of a celebrity, says <a href="https://www.elephantjournal.com/2018/01/sexual-misconduct-pattabhi-jois-ashtanga-yoga-me/">something</a>. Mary Taylor of the delightfully idiosyncratic Freeman+Taylor <a href="https://www.richardfreemanyoga.com/musings/2017/12/8/imsgnih1igya0m8ajzmx4n6yxyp8z8">acknowledges the abuse</a>, muddles her way through her initial statement and then grows into a more complete response — where, a little like I was brought up to do, she tries to balance kindness and delicacy towards every aggrieved party. Who else, I ask myself. I look up every yoga teacher I used to follow on youtube. I stopped watching asana videos, practice videos, jumpback videos.</p><p>Instead, these were the questions I asked of the internet: Did David Garrigues <a href="https://vimeo.com/channels/100584/347991779">respond</a>? Has John Scott <a href="https://johnscottyoga.com/about/my-teacher/">said anything</a>? What about those <a href="https://www.yoganatomy.com/">anatomy</a> guys? Do they agree that Jois was fixing (or whatever) people’s mula bandhas?</p><p>I was still practicing Ashtanga at this time. I was sleeping about three hours a day, and I felt fine. I worked on three projects at the same time, slept at around 1am so that I could wake up at 4am and spend two hours pacing before dawn. I didn’t wake up to practice. I still did my practice late in the morning. I woke up because I didn’t have a choice.</p><p>I felt this terrible need for things to change, for everything to change, for everyone to change. I felt it like it was mine, my story, my pain. Why? I had never really interacted with yoga teachers, yoga gurus, yoga cults, not even with yoga mythologies. I found it hard to explain to my world why it mattered, though I kept them updated about each of my readings.</p><p><strong>Eventually</strong></p><p>At some point, a general consensus was evolving that Pattabhi Jois was indeed a sexual abuser/purveyor of ‘inappropriate adjustments’ — the terminology shifted depending on the identity/school of the speaker. There was a much more limited consensus that Sharath Jois, his grandson and the head of the family business, if you want to call it that (they called it KPJAYI), needed to speak up about the abuse. There were a few scattered calls for actual change.</p><p><a href="https://chintamaniyoga.com/my-initial-response-to-karen-rains-interview-about-sexual-abuse/">Gregor Maehle’s acknowledgement and response to Karen Rain’s statement</a> seemed to be a turning point in the Ashtanga story. It was a personal response, asking that floating question — <em>why didn’t I notice? Why didn’t I respond?</em> This question is so hard to answer that I wonder whether the silence from the majority of the Ashtanga community had something to do with their unwillingness to do it.</p><p>I stopped following almost every former Ashtanga resource, except for <a href="https://grimmly2007.blogspot.com/">Grimmly’s blog</a>, which faithfully kept track of the <a href="https://grimmly2007.blogspot.com/p/given-that-i-have-promoted-ashtanga-for.html">abuse narrative</a>, as it had once kept track of every Ashtanga publication, asana introspection, Krishnamacharya investigation and other needles in the Ashtanga haystack.</p><p>At this time, I had modified my practice. I kept the structure, but added more backbends, more twists, changed the form and the variation of poses and went at a slower pace. I was coming back from a month-long break which I spent sleeping, eating and being drunk. I had stopped following even Ashtanga news during that time. Complete internet shutdown, yoga shutdown, communication shutdown. Coming back, I had felt the need to make a change.</p><p><strong>In the more recent past</strong></p><p>I’m trying to figure out how personal this story actually is. This was supposed to be an Ashtanga #metoo timeline. <em>That </em>story was not about me. But my way of navigating it is, much more about me and my practice than anyone else. Obsessive people don’t turn into journalists. You can tell someone else’s story when you let go of yourself, if you follow the traditional standards of reporting. I don’t let go of anything. <em>I took it all personal</em>, in the words of Tony Hoagland. <em>the breeze and the river and the colour of the fields; the price of grapefruit and stamps</em>. The actions of Pattabhi Jois, the silence of Sharath Jois, the betrayals of feminist sisterhoods, the limitations of language, the lack of conversation between antagonistic forces.</p><p>I had stopped practicing yoga.</p><p>In this period of silence, both external and internal, I read Guy Donahaye’s blog — breaking an extended silence, he spoke about Pattabhi Jois, <a href="https://yogamindmedicine.blogspot.com/2018/10/">the abuse</a>, himself and yoga itself. Something Tim Feldman tried to do but only managed in the title of his article.</p><p>Guy Donahaye, one of Jois’ early students, edited a eulogizing book called <em>Guruji</em>, about his former — well, guru. It has been taken out of publication now.</p><p>I learnt some things from Guy Donahaye’s blog — or maybe some things came awake in me when I read it. They’re important enough to make a list, I think. Here’s what I’ve got so far:</p><ul><li>Pattabhi Jois didn’t just abuse women. His ‘appropriate’ adjustments, done to men, <a href="https://yogamindmedicine.blogspot.com/2019/01/ahimsa-practice-with-pattabhi-jois-pain.html">caused injury, hurt, humiliation, self-doubt and other forms of harm</a>.</li><li>Since the two men who’ve spoken most about the abuse scandal have both spoken extensively about the injuries they faced, it seems to me for empathy to form, one has to be able to express one’s own pain.</li><li>Pattabhi Jois was part of a <a href="https://yogamindmedicine.blogspot.com/2019/03/">cycle of violence</a> — that was perpetrated by his own family, the injuries his own teacher inflicted on him and those that he transferred to his progeny, including his grandson.</li><li>The cycle of violence continued. Sharath Jois, by general consensus, is not a sexual abuser. One can imagine that constantly witnessing abuse, while being traumatic, also gave him an absolute horror of it, a desire not to repeat that pattern. But Ashtanga stayed physically harmful, adjustments continued to be painful and unnecessary, injuries were sustained and a different kind of power structure formed.</li><li>Cycles of violence can mutate. The abused become abusers. History repeats itself with just enough alteration to confuse you into thinking that it’s not.</li></ul><p>These points were not necessarily made as such in Guy Donahaye’s writing. These are part-learnings, part-inferences. They came to me in a time when I was underwater, isolated, not practicing yoga, and trying to understand something about my own past.</p><p>I finally understood, after shutting down every practice in my life, why I had followed the Ashtanga story for one year. I also finally understood why I had practiced Ashtanga at all. The term ‘cycle of violence’ made it clear in a way that #metoo and #ibelieveyou never did.</p><p>There was a study quoted in this blog that I had seen a long time ago and not followed up on, about the <a href="https://www.theluminescent.org/2017/01/postural-punishment-in-indian-schools.html">connection between yoga and corporal punishment</a>. The truth is, the all-encompassing term ‘yoga’ is much more fluid than you could imagine. You could make it a physical practice, a breathing practice, a form of meditation, a prayer, a petition to the gods, a penance, a form of abuse, a punishment, a path to healing.</p><p>My healing practice had become a punishing practice. It did that because it had heard, in the Ashtanga narrative, a language my body had known and understood. My own participation in a cycle of violence had found its yoga mirror.</p><p><strong>The baby and the bathwater</strong></p><p>A much-repeated phrase, in the time of Ashtanga #metoo turmoil, has been <em>let’s not throw out the baby with the bathwater</em>. I never understood this one. What’s the baby? What’s the bathwater?</p><p>I tried to break it down for myself. The baby could be:</p><ul><li>A personal practice</li><li>Pattanjali’s Ashtanga</li><li>Jois’ Ashtanga i.e. the primary, secondary and following series sequences of asanas</li><li>Good stuff (whatever that may be — teaching, relationships, money, appropriate adjustments)</li><li>The Ashtanga industry</li></ul><p>None of these things look like babies to me, except maybe the personal practice, but to me at least it turned out to be more of a punishing parent than a baby.</p><p>The bathwater?</p><ul><li>Abuse</li><li>Sexual abuse</li><li>Pattabhi Jois’ abuse</li><li>Bad stuff (inappropriate adjustments, overextended silence, ignorant assertions, bad ‘yogis’)</li></ul><p>I can’t really understand the difference between the baby and the bathwater. Maybe I took it all too personal. Maybe the baby got wet in the bathwater. Maybe the baby’s not a baby at all. Maybe the bathwater is just dirty water. Maybe what’s inside is a two-headed beast. Who knows?</p><p><strong>A time of change</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gEQ3gHv4teTegJPl.jpg" /><figcaption>Trying</figcaption></figure><p>A few weeks back, in tandem with a moment of confrontation in my own life, Sharath Jois <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/BzuKYVRlUv9/">finally spoke up about the abuse</a>. He spoke about it like a child traumatised. His language did not belong to the world of #metoo, or even to the world of 2019. It belonged home, it belonged in childhood, it was a world of youth and fear and rage and shame.</p><p>A new collection of introspections starts making their way to the internet. A petition has been started that demands the foregrounding of the voices of the victims, but I’m uncomfortable with clause 3, which says the petitioner will ABSTAIN from writing or speaking about Pattabhi Jois and sexual violence in any way that takes an educational or leadership role. I ask myself — without the voices of the responders, would this story have come through to me, would I have understood why it connected, why I related?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qZZWHnEtHAYx0D1x.jpg" /><figcaption>Coming back to yoga</figcaption></figure><p>In the meantime, I have not been practicing Ashtanga at all. I make yoga up as I go along. I say the words vinyasa flow to myself — not as a brand name, not as an alternative, just because the word flow is freeing, because vinyasa is breath and movement — you can vinyasa your way through any practice in the world.</p><p>On days when I’m hurt, tired, angry or sad, on days when I’m in pain, I don’t practice. I tell myself that the era of practice as punishment is finally done with. But non-punishment, non-repetition of cycles of violence, this is as much a practice as yoga itself.</p><p>For some inexplicable reason, I keep thinking about The Girl’s Guide To Hunting and Fishing. The narrator ends by saying ‘we are both hunters and hunted.’ She means, we have found balance, we have found ourselves and each other, as partners. We have ended that destructive dynamic of hunter and prey.</p><p>I don’t know why, but somehow, in the past month, I felt that my yoga practice at least has tilted, been less of hunting, less demanding of me and of the world, more of movement itself.</p><p>I don’t say that I’ve found balance, just that my relationship with yoga has become more balanced.</p><h4>Author: Priyadarshini John</h4><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://gnoose.com/2019/08/30/a-personal-and-mutable-timeline-of-ashtanga-yogas-metoo-crisis/"><em>https://gnoose.com</em></a><em> on August 30, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82eea87c2873" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose/a-personal-and-mutable-timeline-of-ashtanga-yogas-metoo-crisis-the-gnoose-82eea87c2873">A Personal and Mutable TimeLine of Ashtanga Yoga’s #Metoo ‘Crisis’ — The Gnoose</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-gnoose">The Gnoose</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>