<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[The Spouter Magazine - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[A nascent leviathan arising slowly; For action and free of reaction; A place to share a blanket with a headhunting harpooner. Whale image © Roslyn Rose 1975, used with permission - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 06:39:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/the-spouter-magazine" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Capitalism was here even before human existence, waiting for a host.”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/capitalism-was-here-even-before-human-existence-waiting-for-a-host-f46e2d556a4f?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f46e2d556a4f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collapse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Dec 2024 18:15:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-13T18:15:55.573Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>a system whose only aim is to violate the Cycle</h3><p>Although they are different types of ideas, <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/fuel-is">petromarxism</a> and <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/08/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-one/">sentient oil</a> both have the same point: that hydrocarbon energy moves the social and economic processes that we are used to thinking of as human. Specifically, it moves those processes towards extinction.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/capitalism-was-here-even-before-human#footnote-1-152202524">1</a></p><p>We are used to thinking of the consequences of these processes — breakdown of earth systems, pollution, catastrophic weather — as well as their achievements and benefits — as human phenomena. Technological progress. Civilization. Commodity production and exchange. Which feel so immutable and inescapable, but are today very different than they would have appeared in the mid-19th century, that is to say 175 years ago. (For scale, the period we call The Renaissance unfolded around three hundred years; the Mughal empire lasted in the Indian subcontinent for 336 years; the Babylonian Empire lasted 1,355 years; the Holocene has lasted nearly 12,000 years; and the Carboniferous age lasted 60 million years.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/350/0*VPNbIz6jefYlgCBC.jpeg" /><figcaption>“[Capital] constructs and erects itself on a contempt for life and from this foundation: the body, the time of living. Which does not cease to amaze: that a society, a <em>civilization</em>, a culture is able to construct itself from such disdain.” — Lefebvre, <em>Rhythmanalaysis</em>, 62</figcaption></figure><p>“[Capital] constructs and erects itself on a contempt for life and from this foundation: the body, the time of living. Which does not cease to amaze: that a society, a <em>civilization</em>, a culture is able to construct itself from such disdain.” — Lefebvre, <em>Rhythmanalaysis</em>, 62</p><p>But these — industrialization, capitalism, and catastrophe — are not actions that we, mere animals, could have taken alone. They are tied up at every step in complicity with a much older entity — or rhizomatic collection of entities — that we found beneath the surface of the earth. Real but more than real, larger than us in every measurable sense, vastly older than us. The anaerobically decomposed remains of the mass of life from the vastly more fecund ages that preceded our own by millions of years. Composed of molecules that could only be made by life and yet are dead; the material of death, the full realization of decomposition; the entities at metabolism’s end. If that entity taken a as a whole or in parts, does not contain spiritual power, than nothing does — certainly not we mortal animals. Power, taken in any meaning of the word: energy, control of labor, creative capacity: power to bring into being new regimes, new eras and aeons, to perpetrate the mass extinctions that mark the end of a geologic epoch; new regimes including this brief flare of industrial capitalism as well as the long silence it will leave behind, while life slowly metabolizes the novel synthetic substances and landscapes of the petrocapitalist frenzy, while new adaptations take hold in a Ballardian drowned and parched world. There will probably be people there, but they might not anymore see themselves as the dominant species, the apex predators of the living world. Because there will also be new entities that grow with the young jungles that will cover the ruins of our infrastructure, to be shaped by the contours of the catastrophe that is our coming collective death, the dramatic conflagration of the mid-21st century that ended it all, when the steady assault of climate catastrophes became indistinguishable from war: The Conflict.</p><p>I think I’m not supposed to be thinking of that future. So that I can function today, get through my days, and support my son through his childhood, it only hurts me to think of what’s coming for us on a collective level. Futile, also, because I will not be able to imagine or describe it better than JG Ballard could. And because, like all Americans, I truly believe that me and my family may remain exempt from the Catastrophe; that we will be able to live in our little house and work our little jobs to buy ever-more-expensive groceries while we watch others sacrificed in their millions to the Conflict, exactly the same way I now witness the hundreds of thousands of sacrifices in Palestine.</p><p>My son doesn’t know what’s going on. He hasn’t developed to the point where he can perceive the world around him, not truly, and he is entitled to his innocence. He is in his period of naivete enforced by a still developing brain, a recursively and slowly developing brain forced to find constant workarounds to accommodate an overly reactive nervous system. The least we can do, the minimum that we owe him as parents, is to keep him safe while this unfolds in its own time. But then, when he does inevitably awaken from his period of exclusive self-focus, will he be able to be adequately horrified by the world I’ve brought him into? Perhaps not at first, but the horror will catch up to him one day; I can only hope that I’ll still be there to help. Because Gaza is but a microcosm of the world that is being created around us all; The Conflict will turn vast swathes of territory into such sacrifice zones. But as I said, it will — it must — continue to miss us here in our little house in middle-California, the region considered by most to be precarious because of earthquakes; well, earthquakes aren’t made worse by climate change, at least in its early stages.</p><blockquote><em>“Kekulé dreams the Great Serpent holding its own tail in its mouth, the dreaming serpent which surrounds the World. But in the meanness, the cynicism with which this dream is to be used. The Serpent that announces, ‘The World is a closed thing, cyclical, resonant, eternally-returning,’ is to be delivered into a system whose only aim is to </em>violate<em> the Cycle. Taking and not giving back, demanding that ‘productivity’ and ‘earnings’ keep on increasing with time, the System removing from the rest of the World these vast quantities of energy to keep its own tiny desperate fraction showing a profit: and not only most of humanity — most of the World, animal, vegetable and mineral, is laid waste in the process. The System may or may not understand that it’s only buying time. And that time is an artificial resource to begin with, of no value to anyone or anything but the System, which sooner or later must crash to its death, when its addiction to energy has become more than the rest of the World can supply, dragging with it innocent souls all along the chain of life.” — </em>Gravity’s Rainbow.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f46e2d556a4f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/capitalism-was-here-even-before-human-existence-waiting-for-a-host-f46e2d556a4f">“Capitalism was here even before human existence, waiting for a host.”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Petromarxism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/petromarxism-111c5d7a9dc0?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/111c5d7a9dc0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oil]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Oct 2024 17:13:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-31T00:28:03.623Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Full Text of Standalone Essay</p><p>For reasons apparent in the context of the <a href="http://thespouter.substack.com/">rest of my work</a>, my key question has been, <strong>How does fuel fit into the Marxist framework?</strong> Strictly speaking, Marx treats it as an <em>ancillary substance</em>, ancillary, that is, to the means of production, and therefore a part of the means of production. But that only became clear and consistently applied in the third volume; throughout the first, substances like coal and oil seem to shift between categories. And so the answer to my question emerged in stages as I read along, and I believe that evolution in understanding has led to a revision of Marx that makes it most relevant in an age to be defined by fueled and catastrophic heat. Petrocommunism.</p><p>That question rests on a more basic question: <strong>What is fuel?</strong> <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/08/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-one/">Whether or not it is sentient</a>, that is surely not its defining characteristic. Rather, I will argue, fuel should be understood as a commodity sold with a particular use value: to do <strong>work</strong> by combustion. Compare this to the definition of <strong>labour</strong>: a commodity sold to do work by metabolism.</p><p>Some words are confusing because they have multiple meanings, but <strong>work </strong>is confusing because it only has one meaning: the force applied to an object in order to move it through space. “The use of labour-power is labour itself. The purchaser of labour-power consumes it by setting the seller of it to work” (vol. 1, 283 — the first lines of Chapter 7). The specific definition of work as the force necessary to move an object had already been well established by the physical sciences by Marx’s time. He cites a figure from 1861 (Chapter 15, footnote 11), who measures labour across modes (somatic, steam, hydro) in the force required to lift 33,000 lbs in one minute.</p><p>Perhaps today there would be workers (readers) who feel that their work is not reducible to the simple moving of objects — there is something more cognitive, creative in your vocation. If that is you, I challenge you to produce any value without moving something, even the inputs on a machine. The truth is, we ‘creative workers’ do work, just very little of it, applied in highly particularized ways. Work is always pushing something, pulling something, manipulating something.</p><p>Nonetheless, Marx exclusively attributes labour to humans in a passage I find challenging and philosophically problematic: “We presuppose labour in a form in which it is an exclusively human characteristic. A spider conducts operations which resemble those of the weaver, and a bee would put many a human architect to shame by the construction of its honeycomb cells. But what distinguishes the worst architect from the best of bees is that the architect builds the cell in his mind before he constructs it in wax. At the end of every labour process, a result emerges which had already been conceived by the worker at the beginning, hence already existed ideally.” (Vol. 1, 284). That seems wrong, and it’s not at all clear that the beehive as a collective consciousness has no awareness of its own creation as an ideal form.</p><p>Marxism is not a religion and Marx is not a prophet; here, as in other places, I will argue that Marx is wrong. Within a cooperative production process, a single worker does not need to have any conception of the end product in order to do his labour; imagine a worker on an assembly line who screws in a single screw. He is a part of a larger cooperative hive-mind that is very similar to that of the beehive, which is actually a good model for human labour. No substantial part of his theory rests on the intention behind the work; except for in this passage, he is concerned with work itself. Therefore, my argument is that human workers sell labour harvested from metabolism, and fuel sells labour harvested from combustion, does not compromise his larger theory. His assertion that only humans do labour is not a weight-bearing part of his argument, and it can be discarded without consequence. Which is important, because:</p><p>Marxism is right, and all other modes of analysis are wrong. This is proven by history, and by the repeated failures of bourgeoise economics to reflect reality or guide policy in an effective direction. Marxism is the only science of capitalism that doesn’t twist itself into knots trying to justify or hide the inequities and injustices of the capitalist system.</p><p>Therefore, if my revisions to his thought result in different answers, at the end of the day, different bottom lines, I’d be wrong. My revisions enhance rather than reverse Marxism’s ultimate conclusions. Think of “show your work” in math class: I’m revising the work, but we both get the same answers, except in the ways in which petromarxism shows how the dynamics at play in classical Marxism have accelerated greatly.</p><p>In the end, I hope we arrive at a political philosophy that can oppose oil and its influences — thereby staging a meaningful fight to claw back every tenth of degree of warming we can — without falling into the <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-dialectics-of-liberal-environmentalism">ideological traps of liberal environmentalism.</a></p><p><strong>How does fuel fit into the Marxist framework?</strong></p><p>Not exactly (or exclusively) where Marx thought it did. That fuel was not a major point of emphasis for him makes complete sense given the historical moment at which he wrote, and given the enormity of his main and only topic, Capitalism. It cannot be a surprise to you that fuel is fluid. And so it appears in the following (overlapping) forms.</p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/db32857c-47eb-4633-b444-46c87dc4e135">A. Land</a></p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/da2cb546-b545-45c7-a8ff-b0f1ce5681c3">B. i. Raw Material</a></p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/da2cb546-b545-45c7-a8ff-b0f1ce5681c3">B. ii. Commodity</a></p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/37a89213-3969-4121-9919-05ce385b55ae">C. Money</a></p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/24f127d1-6394-4163-959a-39d76912d809">D. A Part of the Means of Production</a></p><blockquote><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/24f127d1-6394-4163-959a-39d76912d809"><em>i) Ground rent</em></a></blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/24f127d1-6394-4163-959a-39d76912d809"><em>ii) An Auxiliary or Ancillary Substance</em></a></blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/07b6228b-20e0-4f3a-bfd1-e053cc9abeee"><em>iii) A Part of the Machine (of Productivity)</em></a></blockquote><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/33337181-08d1-49e5-81b9-f49113573761">E. Labour</a></p><h3>A. Fuel Is Land</h3><p>In Marxism, land is a metonym for everything we inherit from the earth and its systems, which are vastly older and of a much larger scope than what mere human minds can comprehend. The first act of capitalism, the “original sin” or rather primitive accumulation, is the enclosure of land, which though it was a precondition for commodity production, today continues in different forms that can be grouped under the term “Imperialism.” These words describe the process of appropriating land into the world capitalist system. As land is appropriated for use by capital, human beings are forcibly removed from the land, severing their connection with their traditional means of subsistence and forcing them onto the labour market. Whatever form it takes, this is open theft perpetrated by overwhelming violence.</p><p>This precondition of capitalism, this original sin, is why capitalism is fundamentally incompatible with an ecological or sustainable approach to natural resources. Before it can begin exploiting workers, capital must ensure total control over the land that freely yields its benefits.</p><blockquote><em>“The land (and this, economically speaking, includes water) in its original state in which it supplies man with necessaries or means of subsistence ready to hand is available without any effort on his part as the universal material for human labour. All those things which labour merely separates from immediate connection with their environment are objects of labour spontaneously provided by nature, such as fish caught and separated from their natural element, namely water, timber felled in virgin forests, and ores extracted from their veins. On the other hand, the object of labour counts as raw material when it has already undergone some alteration by means of labour.” (Vol. 1, 284)</em></blockquote><p>When it remains in the depths of a mountain or in a reservoir, raw crude, coal, and biogenic methane are gifts the earth gives to corporations, who pay workers to gather or extract it. This labour turns it into a raw material, the first form of any natural commodity. Crude oil is the raw material of the oil refinery, which is a manufacturing concern. If the extracted product comes out of the ground ready to burn — like biogenic methane and coal — then it becomes the raw material for the transportation industry that is set in motion to deliver the fuel to its consumer. Fuels remain commodities as they run up the value chain, until the moment they are burned, which is when their use-value is realized in work.</p><blockquote><em>“Labour is, first of all, a process between man and nature, a process by which man, through his own actions, mediates, regulates, and controls the metabolism between himself and nature. He confronts the materials of nature as a force of nature. He sets in motion the natural forces which belong to his own body, his arms, legs, head and hands, in order to appropriate the materials of nature in a form adapted to his own needs.” (Vol 1 283).</em></blockquote><p>Here, “first of all” means that this is what labor is <em>in the first instance</em>, at the beginning of the process of extracting something from land and turning it into a commodity. In my reading, it doesn’t mean that labour is <em>exclusively</em> a process between man and nature — it can be a process between two parts of nature, as indeed is reflected in Marx’s understanding of “man” as a <em>part of nature</em>.</p><p>Oil’s kinship with the land was realized in the early legal regime of rule of capture, which had to be reversed for the oil industry to grow into absolute domination. As you may know, this was a precept of English common law that stated that a lord could keep whatever game he killed on his own land, even if the animal made its home on a rival’s land. This was a part of the feudal legal regime that had to be overthrown as a precondition for the development of early capitalism; future petrocapitalists fought instead for their right to own the oil <em>when it was still in the ground</em>. This allows the industry to use the oil still underground as a collateral for advanced capital, among other financializations of proven reservoirs. The prorating system that replaced the rule of capture allowed capitalists, a small group of them in close coordination, to autocratically control the rate of the flow of the oil out of the ground and into the economy. This was a necessary precondition because, as was proven time and again in the early 20th century, when competition demands that each firm pull oil out of the ground as quickly as possible, the market floods and what was supposed to become a font of new wealth becomes a massive financial liability.</p><p>Marx’s recognition that capitalist accumulation begins by stealing from the land makes the term “ecosocialist” redundant. Protecting the land starts with socialism. Marx gives us an analysis that ties capitalist production to the exploitation of the earth’s systems as much as to the exploitation of labour. “For all its stinginess, capitalist production is thoroughly wasteful with human material, just as its way of distributing its products through trade, and its manner of competition, make it very wasteful of material resources, so that it loses for society what it gains for the individual capitalist” (vol 3, 180).</p><h3><strong>B. Fuel Is A Raw Material &amp; A Commodity</strong></h3><h3>i. Raw Material</h3><p>A raw material is a commodity, but it is specifically the commodity to be transformed by the labour process. It is reproduced and transformed in the finished commodity. Crude oil is the raw material of the refinery. However, gasoline is not the raw material to a lawn mower: the fuel is combusted, not reproduced bodily in the cut grass, which is the objectification of labour. Therefore, fuel, after its initial gathering, refining, and sale to its end user, is not and never will be a raw material. The same substances (chemicals) that are sold for use as fuel can also be elsewhere sold as a raw material (plastics, industrial chemicals). But fuel sold to be fuel is no longer a raw material, which makes it less obvious that fuel is clearly a part of the means of production as a whole.</p><p>Speaking of the refinery, it is clear that some forms of oil can skip these intermediate processing steps, but even those must still be transported. For the railroads, the pipelines, the tankers, fuel is a raw material, as it is for the refineries. Until recently, pipelines bought the fuel at the origin, sold it at the destination, and owned it between, and so were able to act not only as transporters but as brokers, playing the margins for advantage. For these businesses–for the oil business as a whole (in parallel with the gas and coal businesses–fuel is a raw material commodity. But not for the rest of the economy.</p><p>For Marx, a raw material does not by itself create value — its value is reproduced in the finished product, but no more. This is why it is common even for capitalists doing their accounting to subtract the cost of their raw materials from their revenue along with the other costs of the means of production to calculate their net profit.</p><p>Oil — petroleum derived chemicals — does act as a raw material for the <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/plastication">plastics industry. As we know</a>, such materials were originally unavoidable waste products that got incorporated into capitalism. Marx analyzes this situation:</p><blockquote><em>“As the capitalist mode of production extends, so also does the utilization of the refuse left behind by production and consumption. Under the heading of production we have the waste products of industry and agriculture, under that of consumption we have both the excrement produced by man’s natural metabolism and the form in which useful articles survive after their use has been made of them. Refuse of production is, therefore, in the chemical industry, the by-product which gets lost if production is only on a small scale…But there is a colossal wastage in the capitalist economy in proportion to their actual use.” (Vol 3, pg 195)</em></blockquote><p>However, in this situation, these petrochemicals cannot be considered “fuel,” a word which connotes its combustible use-value.</p><h3>ii. Commodity</h3><p>The entire archive of this substack is about fuel as a commodity. This is the domain of the Industry proper. It is obviously not the only branch of Industry that exists, but it is the one upon whom all the others depend. Therefore anyone invested in anything has an interest in maintaining an oil industry that can produce at all cost, at any cost. This is why the energy sector commands the fierce loyalty of capitalists everywhere in the economy. The guys in energy need to get rich in order for anyone else to get rich. This is the basic tenet of petrocaptialism. Timothy Mitchell, building on <a href="https://www.versobooks.com/products/2222-carbon-democracy?srsltid=AfmBOookxpSksc_zFr6DqSF7UFvWMaADWfcPynBrBHqenkJJnIboB8o9">Michel Serres</a>, theorizes the relationship between the corporation and the oil itself as one of parasitism; the economic entity that sucks value out of the flow of coal, oil, and gas. This helpfully gives conceptual primacy and agency to the flow of materials itself. But we must also consider that the oilmen see themselves as the masters of their substance. It’s much less clear to the rest of us.</p><p>At a minimum, it is clear that fuel’s specific attributes determine the character of its industry and thereby its relationship to capital and to the working class. Take, for instance, its state of matter: solid (coal), liquid (oil) and gas (gas). One of Mitchell’s key contributions to energy history is to show how the solid nature of coal gave workers a key point of leverage in their ongoing and accelerating conflict with Capital. As the century progressed, this became a key incentive to move the economy from coal onto oil. Mitchell says that with</p><blockquote><em>“the concentration of energy supplies in large amounts at specific sites led to the creation of an apparatus of energy supply with which the democratic politics of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries would be built. Large stores of high-quality coal were discovered and developed in relatively few areas: in central and northern England and south Wales, along the belt running from northern France through Belgium to the Ruhr Valley and Upper Silesia, and in the Appalachian coal belt in North America…Great volumes of energy now flowed along narrow, purpose-built channels. Specialised bodies of workers were concentrated at the end-points and main junctions of these conduits, operating the cutting equipment, lifting machinery, switches, locomotives and other devices that allowed stores of energy to move along them. Their position and concentration gave them opportunities, at certain moments, to forge a new kind of political power. The power derived not just from the organisations they formed, the ideas they began to share or the political alliances they built, but from the extraordinary quantities of carbon energy that could be used to assemble political agency, by employing the ability to slow, disrupt or cut off its supply.” (</em>Carbon Democracy<em>, 18)</em></blockquote><p>Somatic labour was firmly bound up in the sale and use of coal, and this is why “coal miners played a leading role in contesting work regimes and the private powers of employers” from the 1880s onward. Think of Ludlow and <em>Matewan</em>. Crucially, Stalin was an organizer in the coalfields of Georgia, which was a key contributor to the victory of 1917. Marx wrote during the buildup to the dramatic confrontations of the coal age, and he saw how coal-fired industrialism gathered workers together in key points, from whence they could challenge Capital. Since the machinery itself was in an early stage of technological development, coal’s use or function as a competitor to human labour appeared less salient than its material alignment with proletarian power. Nonetheless, I think Marx saw both sides, and we can, as well.</p><p>The second–or third, etc., — Industrial Revolution was the unfolding replacement of coal with oil over the course of the first half of the 20th century. As a liquid, oil does not require shoveling; engines don’t require stoking; it only needs to be pumped, not mined. It requires much less human labour per unit of energy than coal, to produce and to ship. The payroll–variable capital–is greatly streamlined, profits increased, and the working class has lost one of its key points of leverage over the entire structure of capitalism. It’s not clear that Marx could have or should have seen that coming.</p><p>In the world of coal, carbon consumption, total payroll, and surplus value were tightly positively correlated within any industrial concern. As technology became more efficient and as the hydrocarbons moved into liquid and gas forms, payroll fell out of that relationship, to stagnate far below the embiggening fuel consumption, which was overwhelming the complex system of the atmosphere above us with new carbon, pushing it towards tipping points to be realized decades (but not centuries) hence.</p><p>With the labour intensity of its production largely (but never absolutely) stripped away, today fuel provides a low-cost alternative to human labour, and so an increased fuel purchase generates more surplus value per dollar than the purchase of more costly somatic labour. So fuel, as it moves into its liquid and gas forms, decouples the proportional relationship that says the more variable capital you put in, the more surplus value comes out. Instead, energy consumption becomes correlated with surplus value. Compare Google’s workforce to its energy consumption (or “carbon footprint” as the environmentalists would like me to call it).</p><h3>C. Fuel Is Money</h3><p>Fuels, and particularly liquid fuels both in their raw material and finished states, have become key money-commodities in use by the financial system today, famously attached to the dollar to make the combined Petrodollar the universal world currency. Marx essentially predicted that eventually currencies would become unmoored from their representational relationship with specific quantities of mineral value. He recognized that money is not required to be gold, or gold-equivalent. This implicit prophecy only came true well into the oil energy regime in the 2nd half of the 20th century. Already, when the dollar finally left gold, oil had become deeply intertwined with the very centers of finance globally. In fact, the American oil interests ran on financed debt from its earliest days, which is why Patillo Higgens owned none of the oil that was produced from “his” Spindletop well. Even in those earliest days, oil was owned by the banks even before it came out of the ground.</p><p>This is because the physical properties of oil predetermined its alignment with financial capital. The fact that oil, at least by the geologic understanding of the day, was heavily concentrated in remote and rare underground reservoirs that could be quite immense, meant that exploring for oil a very risky gamble that attracted a noticeably lumpen group of men who were comfortable living on the knife’s edge between abject poverty and striking it rich: Wildcatters. These men depended on finance capital to loan them the funds to buy a lease, often on nothing more than a hunch or a dream, and to finance the drilling. Most of the time–data aren’t reliably preserved–the only result was a very deep dry hole. Most of them found it more profitable to sell the prospect of oil drilling to investors and then keep the money. One archetypical such man was Dad Joiner, born Columbus Joiner, but known as Dad of the East Texas oil industry. Before he struck big, “Dad Joiner was virtually invisible, just another of the thousands of threadbare promoters, each with an idea, the promise of riches, and the gift of gab. For three years, beginning in 1927, while the industry’s leaders carried on their furious debate about shortage and glut and regulation, Joiner–the poorest of the poor boys–and his motley crew were drilling mid the dense pine trees of East Texas with rusted, third-hand equipment, constantly tormented by breakdowns and accidents, always short of even the barest cash.” (Yergin 246) “He had been very cavalier in his promotion, to put it generously. He had sold more “interests” than there were interests to sell. Some leases had been sold several times over, and in at least one lease eleven separate times.” The lawyers and the bankers owned the oil he discovered, from the first gurgle heard from the Daisy Bradford Well Number 3. He got nothing, and neither did his motley crew of drillers. This allowed HL Hunt to take over the whole enterprise on the cheap. As the capital flows centralized, Houston grew as a center of American finance, and oil was forever bound up with the industry of money itself. The truly big oilmen are bankers, and very few exploration companies turn a profit, even today when fracking has ended the risk of drilling a dry hole. You want to own the debt, not owe it.</p><p>During the age of the American empire–which we’re still in, but set to leave soon–the dominant currency was the petrodollar, which was guaranteed not only by the American government, but also by the Texan company, Aramco, which, along with the other oil majors, agreed to only sell oil around the world in dollars. Most of this story should be told within the actual petrohistorical narrative that comprises the bulk of this project. What we must keep an eye on is the fact that though oil sells labour, it is intimately tied to capital itself, to the point where it functions as capital and can replace currency itself. Therefore its own interests lie aligned with the Western ruling class.</p><h3>D. i. Fuel is a Part of the Means of Production</h3><p>Here we must take the time to make sure everyone is on the same page. Marx teaches that for money capital to become productive, and thereby to ‘valorize itself.’ it must buy the two types of commodities used in any system of production: the means of production, and the labour. The total capital © invested equals the sum of the cost of the means of production (constant capital, c) and the cost of labour (variable capital, v). C=c+v.</p><p>The means of production itself is of (at least) two types: raw material, and the conditions of production. We’ve already discussed the former. For the most part, the conditions of production are the necessary upfront capital investments that must be paid in full, and therefore are beyond the reach of private citizens: factories, machines. Trucks. These things depreciate over time: that is, they reproduce a tiny part of their own value in the value of the final commodity. In Volume II, Marx explains that these things embody “fixed capital,” as opposed to “circulating capital” which are ongoing costs that must be paid out month after month, like wages and the purchase of raw materials. This is the only separation in the type of capital recognized by the capitalist himself, but Marx points to a more fundamental differentiation between “constant capital” which is what is invested into the means of production, and “variable capital” which buys labour.</p><p>Since the means of production reproduces its value as an ‘aliquot part’ of the value of the produced commodity, either all at once as in the case of raw materials, or slowly over time, as in the case of the conditions of production, all of the extra value that makes up the rest of the value of the finished commodity, arises from variable capital, which always pays less for labour than the work it actually receives, since workers always produce more value than the cost of their wages. This is why it is consequential to ascertain whether oil falls into the category of means of production or labour. This essay is here to argue, both: but it should be <em>counted</em> on the variable capital side of the ledger. Which is perhaps contrary to what Marx himself thought.</p><p>If we continue with the traditional practice of considering fuel as an element of the means of production, then this passage applies to it: “means of production never transfer more value to the product than they themselves lose during the labour process by the destruction of their own use-value. If an instrument of production has no value to lose, i.e., if it is not the product of human labour, it transfers no value to the product. It helps to create a use-value without contributing to the formation of exchange-value. This is true of all those means of production supplied by nature without human assistance, such as land, wind, water, metals in the form of ore, and timber in virgin forests.” Oil only has value insofar as human labour is required to extract it, refine it, and ship it. If that value is $4/gallon and ¼ gallon is used in the production of one widget, the oil contributes $1 to the exchange value of the finished product, and the capitalist who burned that oil in his own production process makes no surplus on that dollar. “If we look at the creation and the alteration of value for themselves, i.e. in their pure form, then the means of production, this physical shape taken on by constant capital, provides only the material in which fluid, value-creating labour power has to be incorporated” (vol. 1, 323).</p><p>Marx wrote around the question of fuel without ever addressing it directly (had he, there would be little need for this essay). In a <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-solution-to-petrocapitalism-is?r=3916x">previous post</a>, I referred to fuel as a part of the means of production. This is clearly the category into which it belongs in the text of Capital. At different points in the text, he lists both coal and oil as overhead costs, like ground rent, and, elsewhere, as a component part of the machinery that drives industrial capitalism, and elsewhere as an auxiliary substance. So within the text of <em>Capital</em>, fuel is:</p><h3>a) Ground Rent</h3><p>When fuel, coal specifically, is referred to as ground rent, Marx has in mind the context of the pre-industrial manufacturing period, when coal was primarily used to heat buildings, including workshops. This first practice, where energy (especially in the form of heat for climate control) is a utility that comes with a piece of property, maintains dominance today. We often think of utilities as a part of our rent. This makes sense, but is obviously not an exhaustive treatment of the issue.</p><h3>b) An Auxiliary or Ancillary Substance</h3><p>When the dust settles by volume 3 of <em>Capital</em>, coal gets most consistently categorized along with lubricating oils and other substances that get consumed by the production process, for example, flour which was used in weaving textiles, as substances that are auxiliary or ancillary to the means of production.</p><p>“Both in the case of the machine and of the tool, we find that after allowing for their average daily cost, that is, for the value they transmit to the product by their average daily wear and tear, and for their consumption of auxiliary substances like oil, coal, and so on, they do their work for nothing, like the natural forces which are already available without the intervention of human labour” vol 1, 510. Tellingly, this category here appears as a second exception to a rule that would otherwise be true: that machines work for nothing. But they don’t do their work for nothing,they cost money in at least these two different ways. The auxiliary costs may be considered as costs of the machine itself, it would seem. Elsewhere, these substances are referred to as “accessories to be consumed by the instruments of labour” vol 1, 288.</p><p>After Marx clarifies the difference between fixed and circulating constant capital, it is clear that ancillary materials are paid out of circulating capital. From the point of view of the capitalist, the difference between fixed and circulating capital is of daily importance, but to Marxist economists who can see the big picture, the meaningful difference is between variable and constant capital. Nonetheless, I find it significant that fuel (and other ancillary substances) appear to the capitalist to be of the same category as wages: circulating capital.</p><p>My only comment on the categorization of fuel as an ancillary substance is that it erases the differences in the use values of ancillary substances.</p><h3>c) A Part of the Machine</h3><p>At times Marx understands coal to be a part of a machine, and therefore quite clearly a part of the conditions of production, and therefore clearly constant capital. Marx takes the example of an industrial steam-hammer: “Since its daily wear and tear, its coal consumption, &amp;tc., are spread over the stupendous masses of iron hammered by it in a day, only a small value is added to a hundredweight of iron.” vol 1, 511. (I think the wear and tear counts differently from its coal consumption. The cost of its coal consumption is passed on in full to the commodity in whose production it was expended, but that cost is so tiny that it barely registers in the value it adds to a hundredweight of cotton. It is a very small cost, even in comparison to the depreciation of the machinery, which is spread over the stupendous masses of iron. But this argument will be taken up in a later section.)</p><p>He explains that a machine is an apparatus for turning motive power into specialized forms of labour. Machines have three parts: the motive power itself, the transmitting mechanism, and the tool. Marx has historical memory of both the great waterwheel factories of English industrialism, but also firsthand experience with industrial machines who used somatic motive power, especially in handloom weaving. As Andreas Malm documents in <em>Fossil Capital</em>, although the power loom was invented in 1784, economic conditions conspired to make handloom weaving much more prevalent in the English textile industry through the 1830s. Handloom weavers were distributed throughout the countryside as a “domestic industry” where work was done in households that owned their own looms. “In 1829 there were roughly 240,000 handloom weavers [in England] (each presumably equipped with at least one loom) as opposed to 55,000 power looms… the hand-loom weavers were the largest group of workers connected to <em>any </em>British industry, their lifestyle and experience far more typical than those of the mule-spinners.” And yet it is the story of the mule-spinners that Marx writes about, as he is able to document the transition from foot-powered spinning wheels to steam-powered mills:</p><blockquote><em>“In many manual implements the distinction between man as mere motive power and man as worker or operator properly so called is very striking indeed. For instance, the foot is merely the prime mover of the spinning-wheel, while the hand, working with the spindle, and drawing and twisting, performs the real operation of spinning. It is the second part of the handicraftman’s implement, in this case the spindle, which is first seized on by the industrial revolution, leaving to the worker, in addition to his new labour of watching the machine with his eyes and correcting its mistakes with its hands, the merely mechanical role of acting as the motive power. On the other hand, in cases where man has always acted as a simple motive power, as for instance by turning the crank of a mill, by pumping, by moving the arm of a bellows up and down, by ounding with a mortar, etc., there is soon a call for the application of animals, water and wind as motive powers. Here and there, long before the period of manufacture, and also to some extent during that period, these implements attain the stature of machines, but without creating any revolution in the mode of production.” vol. 1, 496</em></blockquote><p>It is only with the application of steam (coal) that it does rise to the level of a revolution in a mode of production. So although Marx sees that motive power originates outside the machine itself, he nonetheless sees it as a part of the machine, at least at the moment of its combustion or expenditure. And this is why, for Marx, fuel appears a part of the technological apparatus for increasing productivity. Machines increase productivity, and so its component, motive power, must be merely a part of that project.</p><p>I don’t think fuel is a part of the machine. Perhaps only at the moment of its combustion, but prior to that it clearly had a life as a commodity outside the machine, and a natural one before that. Correspondingly, I think that machines can increase productivity, but fuel has the <em>ability to create value</em>, and therefore, surplus value. But we’ll get into what I think later — for now, we must first understand productivity as a consequence of machinery.</p><p>Both fuel and workers operate machinery, but are not parts of the machine itself, except as considered within the larger apparatuses in which all three are embedded.</p><h3>D) ii. Fuel Is a Part of the Technical Apparatus for Increasing Productivity</h3><p>On the level of appearances, fuel appears as a part of the technological apparatus for increasing productivity. It appears as a part of the machine, and machines increase productivity. Marx defines a machine as an apparatus consisting of three parts: motive power, means of transmitting power to a tool, and a tool. I argue that if motive power is a part of the machine, it’s source isn’t: it needs to be poured or shoveled into the machine continuously, so it is also its own thing: fuel.</p><p>In Marxism, productivity is the measure of how much product can be produced with a given amount of labour. Intensification of labour is the measure of how much labour can be expended within a given time. Productivity is therefore seen as the efficiency of labour. The two other variable here is the quantity of labour (in terms of length of the working day). In <em>Capital</em>, Marx explains each of these variables by holding the other two constant and determines that “A working day of a given length and intensity always creates the same amount of value no matter the productivity of labour.” (vol. 1, 656). This is why when an industry as a whole becomes more productive, the social value of the commodity it produces decreases, sometimes rapidly. The market becomes swamped and the price of the commodity can dip below the cost of its production; as we have seen, this is a chronic problem in the oil industry: the problem that most dictates the Industry’s behavior and history.</p><p>When the amount of labour, both in quantity and quality, remains constant, more raw material can be worked up in a working day by more efficient means: steam-driven spindles consume more cotton and produce more yarn than the earlier somatic machines. The absolute mass of stuff goes up in a day. However, since such conditions are independent of the labour market, increasing efficiency does not by itself affect the social value created in a day (or any other amount of time). That same value is simply spread over a larger quantity of saleable commodities, making each one cheaper, as each one represents a smaller amount of socially necessary labour. Efficiency makes for cheaper commodities, creating a supply that can be the impetus to find new demand, pushing the boundaries of the market as a whole ever outward.</p><p>Fuel, specifically oil during the second industrial revolution, added to the intensity of labour expended at sites of production. More labour is exerted per unit of the working day when fuel is burned during that time. It did set into motion machines that also increased productivity. But not just that. But, along with productivity, there ballooned a massive pile of surplus value, increasingly controlled by capitalists, as industrialization proceeded through its first and second phases. The existence of that surplus value can only be understood when we see fuel as labour.</p><p>Nonetheless there is the consequential question of whether fossil energy is replacing human labour or augmenting it. If the former it should be considered as labour, if the latter, it should be considered a means of production. Marx says, “what exclusively determines the magnitude of the value of any article is the amount of labour socially necessary, or the labour-time socially necessary for its production.” So in classical Marxism, the introduction of technology is said to merely reduce the amount of labour time necessary to produce a commodity and therefore decrease the commodity’s value. Indeed, we have seen a radical cheapening of everything since the introduction of industry. A machine does not really do labour itself, but rather just makes human labour more efficient.</p><p>But does technology actually save labour time? Extensive experience now shows, No, it increases production without decreasing socially necessary labour time. Thereby it is additive, not augmentative, with human labour. So it should be considered as labour, even while we also consider it a part of the means of production. We will again have to live with ambiguity.</p><p>Capitalists are always hoping to extract the most efficient or productive work that they can out of their workers. If they become the first in their sector to adopt more productive working methods, then they will likely be able to sell their commodities on the market at the old, higher prices, before one of their competitors adopts the new techniques and the competition between the two pushes the price down towards a commodity’s true value. The dynamics of this lie in the sphere of competitive markets and circulation, and not production, and is therefore left by Marx to Volume 2.</p><p>This competitive dynamic, along with the fact that increased productivity in the areas of industry that produce the working class’s means of subsistence can make labour cheaper, makes increased productivity highly sought-after by capitalists even though it does not produce extra surplus value, strictly speaking. As industrial petrocapitalism unfolded after WWII, it created a general cheapening of everything, which did increase the quality of life of the working middle class, which was racially segregated, and those benefits were very inequitably distributed through society.</p><p>But I have a problem with this. What I think I’ve seen in the last seventy years is a vast expansion in the mass of value that exists in our economy, Hoarded in almost all cases by the craven rich, who are richer as individuals than entire national public sectors. Productivity alone cannot explain this growth in the pile of wealth, not when it creates no real value. There must be more labour in the system, if the system is more profitable: human labour is added and added, of course, but there is a hidden font of cheap labour that has not been hitherto acknowledged: fuel. Machines do not create value but fuel does, because fuel does work.</p><p>It appears to me that the absolute amount of total value in our economy, along with the amount of surplus value, has rapidly grown in size especially during the age of full-blown petrocapitalism after the second world war. This is true however you want to measure value, but it is important for us to reconcile the numbers of the environmentalist historians with our account: people who track the mass of inputs, outputs, and waste products involved in our total economic project. Admittedly, comparing wealth across historical societies in different periods is not easy or straightforward; although we can adjust to inflation to some extent, much of the accounting is relative to the total wealth of a particular society, not absolute. For instance, people have said that John D Rockefeller was the richest man in history because he had the greatest proportion of the total wealth of his society. However, when we are concerned with the total material footprint of the Standard Oil of old and the oil majors today, it is the absolute scale of the enterprise that concerns us.</p><p>One such environmental historian, J.R. McNeill provides the following data for world GDP. I am not asserting that GDP represents the actual value of an economy, but one would expect the two to be positively correlated (Figures given in index numbers relative to A.D. 1500)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/823/0*L2Ze2G6kpcWZLIU_.png" /></figure><p>If anyone has better numbers, or can extend this data set beyond 1992, <a href="http://thespouter@substack.com/">email me</a>.</p><p>And so the world’s economy in the late twentieth century was about 120 times larger than that of 1500. Any historical plot you can make of this time period will have the same type of line: exponential asymptotic increase, taking off in 1950: coal production, oil production, timber production, carbon dioxide accumulation, global temperature. All these charts have that same signature asymptotic line. All of them show that the economy — the total value that it produces, along with the corresponding toll that production takes upon the earth and its natural systems–has rapidly accelerated since 1850, but much more so since 1945. To me, this can’t all be explained by increasing productivity, and we must note that it happened well after Marx wrote, and it makes sense we should have to evolve our thinking to acknowledge and account for it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lcDxqKBsaZOvQTVZ.png" /></figure><p>The counterargument is that value is the only thing we don’t have more of, but that the same total value is now distributed amongst more commodities, and so everything is cheaper. But although plastication does result in a general cheapening, things haven’t gotten <em>that </em>cheap–cost of living is high. Alternatively, one could argue that value is tied to money and therefore was only allowed to expand beyond the world’s stores of gold after it was taken off the gold standard. These explanations are unsatisfactory compared to mine: All of this excess wealth comes from the labour done by fuel. Now that the length of the working day cannot be materially increased in developed societies, the intensity of labour grows. This extra work done per hour is done by harnessing exosomatic energies, not by ‘increased efficiency.’</p><p>(People tend to look at <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/against-populationism">population growth as the cause</a> and not the effect of the great acceleration. In this they are wrong, population growth is just another effect of the exosomatic energy regime.)</p><p>In Marx’s account, increased productivity or efficiency does benefit the capitalist class as a whole, but it does not value the capitalist who makes his own production system more efficient. This benefit is always displaced one step on the value chain, as the increased productivity in a preceding industry results in a cheaper raw material for the next:</p><blockquote><em>“The increased profit that a capitalist [who has invested in textile spinning mills] obtains through a fall in the cost of cotton and spinning machinery, for example, is the result of an increase in labour productivity, and indeed not in the spinning mill, but rather in the production of machines and cotton. A smaller amount of expenditure on the conditions of labour is needed in order to objectify a given quantity of labour, and thus appropriate a given quantity of surplus labour. The costs of appropriating a certain quantity of surplus labour therefore fall.”</em></blockquote><p>Improved machinery then is seen as increasing profit not directly by driving production of a greater amount of commodity, but by saving money on constant capital. This raises the rate of surplus value and the rate of profit, and the fact that the value is realized by the company after you on the production chain provides powerful incentive for vertical integration. This type of savings on the means of production, economizing on constant capital, can affect the rate of surplus value, but not the absolute amount of surplus value, which can only be increased by adding labour. Nonetheless, the fact that savings on constant capital greatly improves the rate of surplus value and the rate of profit, capitalists will go to any length to economize on the means of production: “This economy extends to crowding workers into confined and unhealthy premises, a practice which in capitalist parlance is called saving on buildings; squeezing dangerous machines into the same premises and dispensing with any means of protection against these dangers; neglect of precautionary measures in those production processes whose very nature is harmful to health or involves risk, as in mining, etc. Not to speak of the absence of all provisions that would make the production process humane, comfortable or simply bearable for the worker. From the standpoint of the capitalist this would be a senseless and purposeless waste. Yet for all its stinginess, capitalist production is thoroughly wasteful with human material, just as its way of distributing its products through trade, and its manner of competition, make it very wasteful of material resources, so that it loses for society what it gains for the individual capitalist” (vol 3, 180). Marx goes on in the same passage:</p><blockquote><em>“If the value of commodities is determined by the necessary labour-time contained in them and not simply by labour-time as such, it is capital that first makes a reality of this mode of determination and immediately goes on to reduce continually the labour socially necessary for the production of a commodity. The price of the commodity is therefore reduced to a minimum through reducing to a minimum each part of the labour required to produce it.”</em></blockquote><p>In this reading then, fuel does not increase total value but is a part of the mechanism by which commodities are reduced to their cheapest possible prices. My problem is that there is more than cheapness to today’s economy — there is also great excess that needs to be wasted; a huge mountain of accumulation that is not explained merely by an increase of productivity.</p><p>E) i. Fuel Is Labor</p><p>Fuel is a commodity, but it is a commodity with a unique use-value: work. In this, it is the same as the human being who sells their labour for a wage. Both humans and fuel set the means of production into motion, are operators of machines. For most processes of production, both motive powers are needed, but this is not a universal law. Fuel, specifically oil during the second industrial revolution, added to the intensity of labour expended at sites of production, including the sites of the production of oil itself. More labour is exerted per unit of the working day when fuel is burned during that time.</p><p>Understanding work in the sense it is used in the physical sciences, and thereby asserting the fuel does work, <em>appears as </em>a semantic argument, but it is not. In his book <em>Fossil Capital</em>, Andreas Malm comments on the dual meaning of the word power — the political and the caloric. That is a linguistic coincidence that does not extend to other languages. But the singular meaning of the word work, a meaning that accommodates both somatic and exosomatic energy, is not a semantic or linguistic coincidence. When it can be measured, work is measured in units of horsepower, calories, watts. Joules.</p><p>The appearance of fuel as a component of a machine hides a key distinction: the machine increases productivity, but the fuel uses the machine to produce. Fuel operates the machine. Usually this process proceeds with the (for now) indispensable collaboration of human labour: a worker also operates a machine. But that very interdependence between fuel and worker is also the field of the intense and perpetual competition to reduce and eventually eliminate the human share.</p><p>Following the second industrial revolution, fuel has been in league with capital to decrease demand for human labour. Competition for what meager jobs are available allows them to discipline the workers that do have jobs, to further depress wages, and so on. This is why, in the West, the dead god has found a firm and unshakeable ally in capital. In the Communist world, when there was one, where the state was/is charged with defending the interests of workers, fuel as a massive source of cheap labour was used to materially equip the country with the means of subsistence necessary to first defeat Hitler and then eliminate poverty and suffering. With an empowered workers’ state, therefore, fossil energy can be used for good, but it is not under today’s political regime in the West.</p><p>You may not be prepared to accept that all your work can be measured in horsepower. Your work is highly specialised (due to the division of labour in society) and therefore requires knowledge of techniques you have inherited from past iterations of work. However, when you look at any one of those techniques, what it is doing is channelling a flow of power along a specific path. Pure horsepower must be exerted, things must be moved, but only at the right time and place, and so your time is spent managing and correcting the flow of horsepower.</p><p>This then gives us two dimensions along which work is performed: the main stream of motive power that is brought to bear in a productive capacity, and the secondary regulatory work that precisely directs the power where to go and what to do.</p><p>Marx: “In many manual implements the distinction between man as mere motive power and man as worker or operator properly soc called is very striking indeed. For instance, the foot is merely the prime mover of the spinning-wheel, while the hand, working with the spindle, and drawing and twisting, performs the real operation of spinning.” (vol 1 496)</p><p>All work has these two components: the foot and the hand. The power and its manipulation. Both of these types of work are, importantly, clearly work in the sense that they both require moving objects in space (and in some cases require moving movement, or moving energy, moving work itself).</p><p>It is clear that this is how a computer works: by channelling current through on/off gates. That then covers the vast portion of the economic sphere wherein we are all engaged with staring into a screen. In earlier technical regimes, for example in steam, the worker used their somatic energy to shovel fuel as well as to guide, direct, and regulate machines. The function of the foot was first and most easily assumed by exosomatic power, but as machines get more autonomous and self-correcting, they gradually take over the work of the hand as well; no type of somatic labour is safe from being replaced by technology. Rather than a firm division between worker and machine, we arrive at a spectrum in which the work is distributed between the two types of workers, somatic and combustive. We see again the reason for the constant antagonistic competition between the two for access to capital.</p><p>“A machine which is not active in the labour process is useless. In addition, it falls prey to the destructive power of natural processes. Iron rusts; wood rots. … Living labour must seize on these things, awaken them from the dead, change them from merely possible into real and effective use-values. Bathed in the fire of labour, appropriated as part of its organism, and infused with vital energy for the performance of functions appropriate to their concept and to their vocation in the process, they are indeed consumed, but to some purpose, as elements in the formation of new use-values, new products, which are capable of entering into individual consumption as means of subsistence or into a new labour process as means of production.”</p><p>Today, you could also say, a machine which is not plugged in is useless. Exosomatic power and labour power are equally necessary to the process of production. Without these two inputs, the means of production lie still. It may be that the lack of other ancillary materials would also grind the process to a halt, but fuel/electricity is universally necessary in the same way as human work is, for now. The foot and the hand is today the engine and the worker, but we know that capitalists hope for and are working to create a future where the engine can do both types of work in their entireties. Without socialism, such a future will unfold in the form of a series of miserable and ongoing catastrophes which will eventually significantly reduce the human population, along with taking a massive toll on nonhuman lives.</p><p>Therefore, it would be interesting to see what happens if we consider the cost of fuel a part of variable capital, rather than as a component of constant capital.</p><h3>i) Increasing Intensity of Labour</h3><p>Marx places the beginning of the process of intensification of the working day at the moment when legislation began to regulate the length of the working day — prior to the workers’-led movements that resulted in the Factory Acts, capitalists captured increasing quantities of surplus value mostly by forcing their workers to work increasingly long and grueling hours. At the moment in which the length of the working day could expand no further, it became necessary to increase the quantity of labour that could be expended within the limited working day — a quantity named by Marx the intensity of labour. It is this intensification of labour, not an increase in productivity, that results in the growing piles of surplus value that accelerates the valorization of capital.</p><p>Industrialism produced more per day but not per joule. The source of the great acceleration was in the cheapness and availability of work, in the scientific sense of the word. The transition from coal to oil greatly reduced the dead god’s reliance on human labour; many more workers per joule were employed by the coal industry of Marx’s day than the lean, subcontracted workforce of the oil industry today. (which is not to imply that energy workers are not proletarian; <a href="https://www.youtube.com/shorts/CSgEkjrGlbs">they </a><a href="https://www.youtube.com/shorts/FE5FkEsn5as">certainly </a><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRXJ3Zx7a_Y">are</a>.)</p><p>In this way, along with thousands of parallel processes in motion, all of which tended towards using greater and greater quantities of exosomatic energy to augment and, at the ever-growing margins, replace human labour, or somatic energy. All of Marx’s analysis of machinery and large-scale industry (chapter 15) stands, but now we need to add to it an understanding of what drives the machines:</p><p>“Machinery produces relative surplus-value, not only by directly reducing the value of labour-power, and indirectly by cheapening the commodities that enter into its reproduction, but also, when it is first introduced sporadically into an industry, by converting the labour employed by the owner of that machinery into labour of a higher degree, by raising the social value of the article produced above its individual value, and thus enabling the capitalist to replace the value of a day’s labour-power by a smaller portion of the day’s product.” i.e. to reduce the necessary labour time, increasing the proportion of surplus labour in the working day. Also, replacing labour that is valued by the necessary means of subsistence with labour that is valued by pure commodities markets. This is why, as Marx notes, machinery and workers have always been in competition with each other. This advantage that the owner captures — Marx here says by raising the social value of the article, but what he means is by temporarily decreasing the individual value beneath the price, which represents the social value — exists only at the margins; as soon as all companies in an industry are equally mechanized, the capitalist must already be off trying to find a new way to increase profits through new schemes of mechanization and/or new ways to increase exploitation of their workers.</p><p>By simultaneously cheapening everything and increasing the intensity of labour within a capitalist enterprise, fuel hypercharges the dynamics and contradictions of capitalism that Marx identified. The necessary part of the working day is shrunk to miniscule proportions by the relative cheapness of the means of subsistence in the industrial age; leaving mountains of surplus value to be expropriated, placing capitalists ever higher in the stratospheres of Power and Influence, while workers become cheaper, more expendable, and more desperate. Add to this the lottery ideology of capitalism, its appeal to the fantasy of a gambler, its elusive promise that there is some way to Get Rich — to graduate from a worker to an owner — and you have created a working class willing to do anything and everything for a wage, and who are extremely hesitant to organize. All for the low price of $100/barrel. Out of all of this, you get a capitalist class even more powerful than what Marx could have envisioned, which strangles in its crib the possibility, sometimes even considered an inevitability, of Revolution. Now, late in the story, we find out that oil actually costs a good deal more than $100/barrel — it costs us the future, the liveability of our only home, the earth. Already, by the time this became clear to everyone, the capitalists had completely overrun global political systems, and there was never any other plan than to continue to socialize the costs and privatize the profits.</p><h3>ii) How Does Work Generate Surplus Value?</h3><p>In many ways, this is Marx’s core insight: workers are paid based on what they need to survive–the cost of their means of subsistence and reproduction–but they always generate more value than that. Marx divides up the working day (or any other period of waged labour) into two pieces of time: the time it takes them to produce enough value for the capitalist for the capitalist to recover the cost of the worker’s wages, and then the time he spends at work beyond that point. See this from the worker’s point of view: “Since his work forms part of a system based on the social division of labour, he does not directly produce his own means of subsistence. Instead of this, he produces a particular commodity, yarn for example, with a value equal to the value of his means of subsistence, or of the money for it….If the value of his daily means of subsistence represents an average of 6 hours’ objectified labour, the worker must work an average of 6 hours to reproduce that value….I call the portion of the working day during which this reproduction takes place necessary labour-time, and the labour expended during this time necessary labour….During the second period of the labour process, that in which his labour is no longer necessary labour, he does work, but his labour is no longer necessary labour, and he creates no value for himself. He creates surplus-value which, for the capitalist, has all the charms of something created out of nothing” (vol. 1 324–5).</p><p>The definition of the rate of surplus value, then, is expressed in the ratio between the value of the surplus labour and the total variable capital: <em>s/v</em>. In most of Marx’s examples, the rate of surplus value he chooses is 100%, which means that the total variable capital is split evenly into necessary and surplus labour. During a 12 hour day, this worker would perform 6 hours of necessary labour and 6 hours surplus. In the morning he works for himself, in the afternoon, for his boss. Not only is this arithmetically convenient, but it must be seen as a generally reasonable s/v ratio in the industries he observed (more specific numbers can be found in the appendix to Volume 1, “Results of the Immediate Process of Production,” in which he examines cases in which s/v ratios range from 100%-150%.</p><p>To distinguish it from the rate of surplus value, the rate of profit is the ratio of the surplus value to the total capital (variable and constant), whereas the rate of surplus value is the ratio of surplus value to variable capital. The rate of surplus value can expand even while the rate of profit falls if the amount of constant capital invested accelerates.</p><p>The rate of surplus value is grown by paying as little as possible for as much labour as possible, which has the effect of shrinking the necessary part of the day and expanding the surplus part. All other things (conditions of production) being absolutely equal, a capitalist can grow his surplus value by adding more workers, and correspondingly expanding their means of production to absorb the extra labour: more is more, bigger is better. But all other things aren’t equal, and they are constantly looking for ways to pay less for more work, which is the cause of their inherently antagonistic relationship with the working class.</p><p>In 2019, <a href="https://thetricontinental.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/190922_Notebook-2_EN.pdf">the Tricontinental found</a> that the s/v ratio of the iPhone production process was 2458%. So those workers are 25 times more exploited than the ones Marx studied. Did all this extra free work come only from making the existing somatic work that is bought with wages more efficient? At first this appears reasonable, but at some nebulous point, maybe between 10x-15x, all attributable to efficiency, it begins to look like we are saying that something has been created from nothing. Marx acknowledges and even emphasises that a quantitative change can become so great that we are left in a whole new qualitative environment; a new regime takes hold wherein technology is actively augmenting human and replacing labour with its own, rather than simply assisting humans in their labour. Classical capitalism has accelerated into petrocapitalism, which can only be fought with petrocommunism.</p><h3>iii) What changes if we consider fuel to be a part of variable capital?</h3><p>The average price for a unit of labour plummets. It is as if wages have decreased drastically: the owner gets more work for less money. Marx examined the scenario in which wages fall, but it did not mark a signature dynamic of the capitalism of his day. In this scenario, “there is a release of variable capital…the same quantity of labour is set in motion with less money than before, and in this way the unpaid portion of labour is increased at the cost of the paid portion.” The decrease in the cost of labour becomes an increase in surplus value. “Variable capital can also be set free if the development of productivity leads to a reduction in the number of workers required to set the same amount of constant capital in motion, with the rate of wages remaining the same” (vol. 3, pg 212).</p><p>The cost of human labour is determined by the worker’s needs of sustenance, his cost of reproducing his own labour. Similarly, the cost of oil is determined by the oil industry’s cost of reproducing itself, the cost required to replace the burned fuel with fresh fuel, to keep the flow constant. However, the amount of that cost is determined in this case by oil executives, a smaller cabal of people who are much more able to coordinate with each other than the working class is able to coordinate with itself. And so it is, that by trickery and politics, that they are sometimes able to nudge the price of oil into the upper pricing tiers where their companies not only subsist, but become fonts of wealth. And barely ever approach the cost of human labour, which almost always will be more expensive than fuel. Since the natural supply of crude is rarely if ever truly in shortage, the cartel can collectively decide the price of oil in cartel format, and there is a wide field on which they play.</p><p>Therefore, the decrease in the average cost of labour accelerates the capitalist’s accumulation at the cost of the workers’ livelihoods. This reflects the reality of the capitalist world in which we live. As industrialization proceeds, the part of capital that goes to workers has gotten smaller and smaller, while the constant capital portion has gotten larger. Marx, as the process of accumulation and centralization of capital proceeds, the relative amount of variable capital decreases relative to the amount of constant capital: that is, the bigger an industrial concern, the more it needs to invest in means of production.. This does, indeed, describe what has happened in the economy since Marx. My clarification of this is that this process is assisted by the accelerating dependence upon fuel. By powering the machines bought by constant capital, of course. But also by replacing expensive labour with cheap labour. The cost of fuel does come out of the variable portion of capital, but that cost is so small relative to the value of human labour that its use shrinks the payroll. This accelerates the accumulation of capital tremendously. And it holds as true within the oil industry as it does in all other industries. “The higher the productivity of labour, the greater is the pressure of the worker on the means of employment, the more precarious therefore becomes the condition for their existence, namely the sale of their own labour power for the increase of alien wealth.” (Vol. 1, 798).</p><p>Fuel accelerates the capitalists’ perpetual antagonism with their own employees and subcontractors by accelerating the process of accumulation. And it aggravates the enmity between businesses and society because society is forced to bear the true costs of catastrophic warming and ecosystem collapse. Just as the coalfields were the major battlefield of the organizers and revolutionaries of the 19th century, so today, control of the energy industry ought to be a key site of contestation by Marxist-Leninist revolutionaries. Of course, if we ever attain that power over the energy sector, we would radically shrink the industry to a trickle of what it is today, to allow economic energy (capital) be directed toward building a decentralized grid of opportunistic energy (wind and solar) over a base load provided by nuclear thorium reactors.</p><h3>E) ii. Fuel is Only Sometimes Socially Necessary Labor</h3><p>It is one thing to argue that fuel does labour; it is quite another to argue that it is socially necessary labour, or that it <em>counts as </em>socially necessary labor in any one circumstance. To review, for Marx, a commodity’s value represents the amount of socially necessary labor that it embodies. If one producer uses a less efficient process than the social standard at any one time, they do not get paid for the extra labor required by an inefficient process. When a commodity is sold at its market value (i.e., when market forces like supply and demand are in equilibrium), “the total quantity of social labour which is applied to produce the overall amount of this kind of commodity must correspond to the quantity of the social need for it, i.e., the social need with the money to back it up.” Volume 3, 294.</p><p>Social labour is determinative of value because it is dear to us. A human only has so many hours of work to give in their lives, and since we are human, we understand that. Fuel, by contrast, is cheap by any economic measure, and so it doesn’t contribute anything at all to the social value of a commodity except by way of expanding the size of the society as a whole, which it does, furiously, thereby increasing the social need for any one type of useful commodity.</p><p>Its’ cheapness is how fuel replaces socially necessary labor with socially unnecessary labor, which hurts the working class. We have known this back to the luddites; machines compete with workers for their means of subsistence, and they do it by changing the composition of capital so that constant or fixed capital is a greater and greater proportion of the whole. Automation takes our jobs because it’s cheaper to do something by machine than by hand.</p><p>Except. We know now — we’ve known for a long time — that fuel is not actually socially cheap. Its cheapness is only an appearance, both in the sense that it <em>looks</em> cheap and that it appears in the earth in massive quantities, allowing it to appear or arrive upon the economy cheaply. This appearance masks a deeper truth: fuel is socially costly, because each tank of gas burned contributes quantitatively to our collective doom, which, as of now, we are living through rather than merely predicting. It materially threatens millions of the processes which comprise social reproduction. In the language of political economy (here used as derisively as Marx did), capitalism’s biggest failure has been to “internalize its externalities.” That is to say, it does not properly value fuel — or any other environmentally harmful material — on the market, leading to the liberals’ argument that if only they could carbon-tax the cost of externalities into the energy sector, the contradiction would be resolved. If we could only make it more expensive, goes the thinking. However, in the real world, this would only accelerate the widening gulf of inequality between the owners and the rest of us: the rich would be able to burn fuel with abandon while poor people would have to cook over wood fires, trash fires, plastic fires.</p><p>It would require instead much more collective intervention into the economy, such as the seizure of the energy sector as a whole. The goal is not simply to make fuel cost more, but to make it more socially precious, to conserve the amount of fuel we use while still guaranteeing power to hospitals and refugee camps, which are the critical infrastructure of the 21st century. To limit its use even though there is no and likely will never be a shortage of the natural wealth that buried fuels represent.</p><p>So what I’m saying is that fuel, for the most part, is not counted to be socially necessary labour, but it should be. This should be a key objective of revolutionary movements. When we attain power (by any means necessary), we will treat fuel as a source of necessary labor, which if used improperly can compete against and devalue human labor, and which inherently can cause a great deal of harm to people and their surroundings. This would reflect the true nature of fuel, a nature that capitalism obscures and alienates. A parallel argument could then be developed for plastics and all the other petrochemicals.</p><p>Again it must be said that theory can only speak in general terms, and I must leave the specifics of that project to the revolutionaries who will make policy based on their own context — a context which will, from here on out, always include catastrophic climate regimes.</p><p>In that context, they will not be able to eliminate use of fossil fuels. There will be a growing need for emergency power. Hospitals need to stay on, and backup generators will become primary infrastructure as the grid fails. We’re going to have to build structures out of concrete in order to protect our cities. Nonetheless, the collective desire to mitigate carbon emissions will become stronger and stronger in our hearts, and in our political will — we will become disabled by the cognitive dissonance of continued reliance on fossil fuels for everything — and we will seek to finally limit our emissions by any means necessary. Only a government led by a communist party can realize that desire.</p><p>—</p><p>In political economy, there has been no conceptual division between the socially necessary use of fuel and the unnecessary or wasteful use of fuel, even while Twitter users track Elon’s private jet.</p><p>This has allowed our class enemies to point to the social usefulness of fuel to justify their whole project of energy extraction and sale. Take for example Alex Epstein, who has a substack and also a book, “The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels.” His whole argument is, “look at all the benefits we get from fossil fuels. Those outweigh the costs which I think are only small.” These “benefits” are the usefulness of fuel to society. Epstein cannot conceive of a world where both refugee camps and hospitals have access to reliable electric power, and yet at the same time, he doesn’t get to fly a private jet if he wants to, much less buy the profits of an oil company on the stock market. The logic of capitalism does not allow a poor person to have even a small quantity of something that a capitalist can’t have in bloated quantities.</p><p>They — as well as their liberal opponents — assume that access to fossil energy is universal or it is completely shut off and cannot imagine a regime for regulating access to fossil energy for everyone’s benefit. Meanwhile, they can imagine baroque and ornate structures to regulate speech and cultural production to stop people from criticizing the Zionist regime.</p><p>Under a petrosocialist regime, fuel would become the first major post-commodity: a thing that was once a commodity and is now recognized to be something more special and valuable than that. A thing that is <em>precious</em> but not <em>expensive</em>, and therefore that needs to be safeguarded by a public apparatus. Even if that apparatus requires certain “authoritarian” qualities, it will fundamentally be led by a more-democratic-democracy of the proletariat. Actual majority rule. It will allow us to use small amounts of fossil fuels where the need is greatest, while we simultaneously build <a href="https://www.iaea.org/newscenter/news/thoriums-long-term-potential-in-nuclear-energy-new-iaea-analysis">thousands of un-meltdownable, zero waste thorium reactors</a>.</p><h3><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/">https://thespouter.substack.com/</a></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/832/0*RtQ7aVnCSEVeLwYq" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=111c5d7a9dc0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/petromarxism-111c5d7a9dc0">Petromarxism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Vaseline]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/vaseline-dcfe367c1766?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dcfe367c1766</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dermatology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psoriasis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oil]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 May 2024 16:58:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-31T16:58:06.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A part of my ongoing </em><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/revised-hydrogen-corpse-juice"><em>Dead God project on sentient oil</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>My skin is falling off. A minor annoyance. My immune system has a quirk where it overreacts to certain common yeasts, and causes my skin cells to reproduce at an accelerated rate: psoriasis. Somehow, this condition could someday work its way into my body from its current perch on my surface, and cause arthritis.</p><p>Nonetheless a minor medical annoyance; I’d rather be alive with psoriasis than any other option available to me. I do courses of steroid creams and hair oils once an a while, but you can’t use that all the time. Due to conceptual and chemical innovations in rheumatology, there exist oral medications that would correct this condition, but they make you feel sick, and a course of them is at least a month. I’m far too busy to deal with that right now. I’m already struggling mightily (and failing) under the obligation to see a dentist once in a while.</p><p>So I live with it, and that entails smearing generic-brand petroleum jelly (brandname Vaseline) on psoriatic lesions, after thorough exfoliation. What I do is pour a quarter of the little bottle of Tea Tree Oil (which used to be expensive but now available at Trader Joes), right on top of that rod wax — as it used to be known — then stir up the container with my finger. The petrolatum (its scientific name) forms a moisture barrier that keeps the tea tree active on the skin for a longer time, since the tea tree only does anything while it is wet. I have to add more tea tree oil to the jar periodically, since it doesn’t penetrate the rod wax easily.</p><p>Throughout these rituals, I wonder what I don’t know about Robert Chesebrough.</p><p>What I do know is how to tell his story as it became Chesebrough Ponds (bought by Unilever 1986) corporate lore and marketing copy: He was a chemist who worked at a small-scale refinery that made lamp fuel out of vegetable oils, tallow, and whale oil. When Petrolia came online in 1859, he was quickly made redundant. He traveled out to the oilfields to see if he couldn’t find a way to make good. He started hanging around Oil Creek, watching the drilling process. He noticed a waxy, pale substance that coated the equipment, the drillbits, and that the oilmen rubbed on their many injuries. Rod wax, they called it.</p><p>He found Vaseline, he didn’t synthesize it. He just figured out a way to purify it and turn it into the first major petroleum byproduct commodity. The substance we now call Vaseline is naturally occurring; it comes out of the well along with the crude oil and the methane, depending on local conditions. Natural medicine by any definition, but you’ll never find that on a Vaseline label because it <em>feels</em> synthetic, doesn’t it? (by now all the Vaseline is synthetic, actually; cheaper to synthesize it than to filter the natural material.)</p><p>And then the kicker: He ate a spoonful of Vaseline every day. And he lived to age 96.</p><p>Chesebrough feeding himself a spoonful of white petrolatum every day until his death in 1933 presages the <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-church-of-the-dead-god">Dead God’s</a> conquest of the human body. This was a process that began even before oil drilling began; the oil from seepages in Appalachia, called Rock Oil, was marketed widely as a cure-all, including by this jingle which would be at home in <em>Gravity’s Rainbow</em> but is reproduced in <em>The Prize </em>(Yergin):</p><blockquote><em>There’s various kind of oil afloat, Cod liver, Castor, Sweet;</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Which tend to make a sick man </em>well<em>, and set him on his feet.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>But our’s a curious </em>feat <em>performs: We just a </em>well<em> obtain,</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>and set the people crazy with “Oil on the brain.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>There’s neighbor Smith, a poor young man, Who couldn’t raise a dime;</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Had clothes which boasted many rents. And too his “nip” on time.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>But now he’s clad in dandy style, Sports diamonds, kids, and cane;</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>And his success was owing to “Oil on the brain.”</em></blockquote><p>While Chesebrough’s daily nip of Vaseline likely didn’t keep him healthy, neither did it harm him; it did make him wealthy. The spoonful of Vaseline a day was a hyperstitional entity of the coming pharmaceutical sciences as an appendage of a larger medical apparatus, which would forever alter the human body, collective and individual, in yet another way creating a barrier of artificiality between the human and the animal/natural. As Donna Haraway would say, making cyborgs of ourselves. The general medical apparatus is fundamentally dependent on chemical inputs derived from petroleum. The small pills you take daily are carefully rearranged bundles of petrochemicals, different from plastics only in the specifics of the particular relationships between atoms — reduce the scale any more and you’ll enter the realm of the Void — usually high-energy bonds of various types.</p><p>At the level of medical practice, crude oil has been so abstracted as to be completely unrecognizable, especially to the scientists and doctors involved with the Industry. But you can’t make something out of nothing; if the ingredients in your pill aren’t petrochemicals themselves, they were only placed into the pill with the assistance of petrochemical solvents.</p><p>Pharmaceuticals are only a small part of the medical apparatus; sometime after Oil’s incorporation as the basis of human material production, there developed a new type of medicine, we call today Western Medicine, in contradistinction to the preexisting human medical practices. The medical apparatus is much more than its petrochemical inputs; industrialization was a necessary condition for western medicine, but not sufficient. The modern medical apparatus is built out of a lot of scientific work and capital investment. But of course, like every other facet of life in the twenty first century, it requires large energetic and chemical inputs.</p><p>The modern formation of health care was tremendously successful: lifespans were extended as it eliminated hundreds of causes of death, diseases, and yes also disabilities. And so it came to pass that bodies were integrated into the petrocapitalist structure, changing the very understanding of Life and rearranging the economy around medical institutions. It does not all boil down to oil; there is a lot of other stuff in there. But the medical apparatus would never be able to function without plastics, without disposability, without Vaseline, without pills, or without electricity. Oil is a precondition for cyborg life, just as it is a precondition for digital life.</p><p>My skin is still falling off.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*vtS4_NEuCVhr50rz.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dcfe367c1766" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/vaseline-dcfe367c1766">Vaseline</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Zionism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/on-zionism-855696fe52a7?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/855696fe52a7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Mar 2024 16:14:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-15T16:14:06.752Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“To be a good Zionist one must be somewhat of an antisemite” — Chaim Greenberg, 1942</h3><p><em>This is not a part of the Dead God project, just a quick aside. I’ve been wanting to write this piece for a long time, it’s something that I must say.</em></p><p>Zionism is one of the most profound forms of internalized oppression that have developed in a population. Certainly one of the most damaging to other people. Other nationalisms are movements of belonging: the people of a place asserting their identity tied to the place where they are, where their families have been for as long as memory. And so asserting that colonizers shouldn’t run the show in their own home places.</p><p>Zionism, by contrast, developed from an anxious attachment to the place of Jews in Europe. Right-wing Jews and Gentiles alike thought that Jews could never truly belong in Europe, even though their families had lived there, again, for as long as memory. <a href="https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/mideast/agedict/index.htm">Brenner</a>: “The Jews had been in Europe for millenniums, far longer than, say, the Magyars. No one would dream of referring to the Hungarians as Asiatics, yet, to [Martin] Buber [a German Zionist philosopher] the Jews of Europe were still Asians and presumably always would be.”</p><blockquote><em>“The fact is undeniable that the Jews collectively are unhealthy and neurotic. Those professional Jews who, wounded to the quick, indignantly deny this truth are the greatest enemies of their race, for they thereby lead them to search for false solutions, or at most palliatives.” — Ben Frommer, </em><a href="https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/mideast/agedict/ch02.htm"><em>a writer for the ultra-Right Zionist-Revisionists</em></a><em>, 1935</em></blockquote><p>This belief that the Jews could never really belong with the rest of Europeans came from a belief that Jews are not properly human, that they are fundamentally different from the Europeans they lived among. This is true self-hatred; not the joking self-hatred of the Jewish comic, but true internalized self-loathing formed by generations of oppression in, specifically, Europe.</p><blockquote><em>“We Jews, we the destroyers, will remain destroyers forever. </em>Nothing<em> that you will do will meet our needs and demands. We will forever destroy because we need a world of our own, a God-world, which is not your nature to build…those of us who fail to understand that truth will always be found in alliance with your rebellious factions, until disillusionment comes, the wretched fate which scattered us through your midst has thrust this unwelcome role upon us.” — </em><a href="https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/mideast/agedict/ch02.htm"><em>Maurice Samuel</em></a><em>, a British-American Zionist in 1927 [emphasis in original]</em></blockquote><p>Once it is said aloud, it is obvious that the Zionist project could be aligned with the Nazi project: both are premised on antisemitism, and have an investment in spreading antisemitism. It is impossible to be surprised at Nazis such as Baron von Mildenstein, who spent six months in Palestine before returning to become the head of the Jewish Department of the SS. It is impossible to be surprised at the many moments when leading Zionists reached out to Nazis to make common cause, to lend their support, and most of all to provide a convenient answer to the Jewish Question.</p><p>This “Jewish Question” was not a question at all for the majority of European Jews, who were termed by the Zionists to be “assimilationist” but actually just saw no reason not to continue to live where they already were, speaking Yiddish and taking care of their families.</p><blockquote><em>“Germany already has too many Jews” — Chaim Weizmann, President of the WZO, in 1912</em></blockquote><p>Zionists in Weimar Germany helped enable the rise of the Nazis by steadfastly <em>refusing</em> to fight the rise of antisemitism. Instead, the ZVfD was focused on fighting Communism. This provided a true boon to the Nazi propaganda machine, making the German Zionists enablers of Nazism, as <a href="http://xn--is%20it%20difficult%20to%20understand%20the%20gullible%20reader%20of%20a%20nazi%20newspaper,%20who%20concluded%20that%20what%20was%20said%20by%20the%20nazis,%20and%20agreed%20to%20by%20the%20zionists%20%20jews%20%20had%20to%20be%20right-i877mka/?%20%20There%20would%20be%20worse:%20any%20Jewish%20movement%20that%20prattled%20on%20about%20the%20naturalness%20of%20anti-Semitism%20would,%20just%20as%20%E2%80%9Cnaturally%E2%80%9D,%20seek%20to%20come%20to%20terms%20with%20the%20Nazis%20when%20they%20came%20to%20power.">Lenni Brenner explains,</a> “is it difficult to understand the gullible reader of a Nazi newspaper, who concluded that what was said by the Nazis, and agreed to by the Zionists — Jews — had to be right? There would be worse: any Jewish movement that prattled on about the naturalness of anti-Semitism would, just as ‘naturally’, seek to come to terms with the Nazis when they came to power.”</p><p>And so they did, repeatedly collaborating with the Nazis<a href="https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/mideast/agedict/ch06.htm"> including formally with the Ha’avara</a>, essentially a free trade agreement between Jewish settlements in Palestine and the Third Reich. Meanwhile, the rising antisemitism in Germany drove a steady and increasing stream of Jewish immigrants to Palestine, furthering the settler-colonial toehold in the region well before the Holocaust gained momentum.</p><blockquote><em>“If I were a Jew, I would have been a fanatical Zionist.” — Adolf Eichmann</em></blockquote><p>The uncomfortable fact is that the Holocaust was key in realizing the dreams of the Zionists. Does this not make the creation of Israel the final stage of the Holocaust?</p><blockquote><em>“Hitler will be forgotten in a few years, but he will have a beautiful monument in Palestine.” — Emil Ludwig, 1936</em></blockquote><p>We can feel compassion for the person who carried around such immense self-loathing cultivated by generations of violence and exclusion in Eastern and Western Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries up through the end of World War Two, before Jews became White after 1947 by becoming colonizers in their own right. But these generations of violence experienced in the North by pale-skinned Jews do not enter into the some moral equation with the Palestinian right to exist. Palestinians lived far away from these pogroms and smaller acts of communal violence that spawned Zionism. Had nothing to do with it. There were well-integrated, valued and respected Jewish communities in cities across the Levant; had been for as long as memory. (Please read <em>When We Were Arabs </em>by Massoud Hayoun). Their very existence was erased by the colonial Zionist project.</p><p>The Germans, the Poles, the Ukrainians, the French, the Italians all have a real historical debt because of their little fascist orgies beginning in the late 1930s. Not so much the Russians, despite their 19th century pogroms — they paid the price to defeat Hitler.</p><p>And <em>they </em>call <em>us</em> anti-Semites for opposing Israel. Every accusation a confession.</p><p><a href="https://chrishedges.substack.com/p/the-chris-hedges-report-with-rabbi">We Jews are a diasporic people.</a> The Jewish religion and tradition is built around a <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Necessity-Exile-Distance-Political-Imagination/dp/B0C9VWW7CQ#:~:text=%E2%80%9CMagid&#39;s%20concept%20of%20exile%20invites,avoiding%20a%20&#39;culture%20of%20domination.">“necessary exile,” </a>that has been torn from us by the Zionist project, another violence. Give Palestine back to the Palestinians.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0y1CK-YtJmEXfFMP.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=855696fe52a7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/on-zionism-855696fe52a7">On Zionism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FRACK 1: Fracking]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/frack-1-fracking-ab981887d501?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab981887d501</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lovecraft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fracking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lng]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jan 2024 17:13:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-26T17:13:06.470Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/press-the-money-button-get-a-book">Buy a paid subscription on SUBSTACK, get a free book in a few years</a></p><blockquote><em>“The nethermost caverns,” wrote the mad Arab, “are not for the fathoming of eyes that see; for their marvels are strange and terrific. Cursed the ground where dead thoughts live new and oddly bodied, and evil the mind that is held by no head. Wisely did Ibn Schacabac say, that happy is the tomb where no wizard hath lain, and happy the town at night whose wizards are all ashes. For it is of old rumour that the soul of the devil-bought hastes not from his charnel clay, but fats and instructs </em>the very worm that gnaws;<em> till out of corruption horrid life springs, and the dull scavengers of earth wax crafty to vex it and swell monstrous to plague it. Great holes secretly are digged where earth’s pores ought to suffice, and things have learnt to walk that ought to crawl.” — H.P. Lovecraft, </em>The Festival</blockquote><p>In 1985, Sun Oil, the company that had been formed from the sale of the Haymaker Well to Edward Octavius Emerson and Joeseph Pew in 1882, had acres on acres of old, exhausted oilfields. One of these was at Austin Chalk, where some enterprising employees decided to experiment with mud motors and explosives.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/frack-1#footnote-1-139895038">1</a> They figured out a new process: You drop a mud motor down one of those old holes out in the desert, drill sideways at the bottom of the wellbore and then again at 90° angles to the first tunnel, and you’ve got a holey network running under every foot of rock. You explode it and rinse out the methane, like squeezing a sponge. You could do it anywhere, like back home in Petrolia, Pennsylvania.</p><p>The results were profligate; overwhelming amounts of new gas. A new supply in old hands. Now Methane followed the path forged by coal: production emerging from within the Imperial Core to generate fresh, clean cashflows that followed familiar paths (Blackrock, and so on).</p><p>Energy commodities, <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/benzin-al-jinn">benzin al-jinn</a>, must work through human systems of power in order to gain dominance over us. To do so, in the current context, they can only directly influence supply and demand. Humans may have other mechanisms to influence and game the markets, from governments to options, but benzin al-jinn can only be unearthed at a given rate and burned (or transmuted) at another rate. Their position is similar to that of any worker: all we have to sell is our labor. The main difference is that the quantity of labor on offer by benzin al-jinn is transcendentally higher than what any flesh and blood animal can give their employer in forty hour weeks.</p><p>Of these two, supply and demand, benzin al-jinn can most directly and easily impact supply. They will suddenly manifest in reservoirs so big as to dazzle humans, to seem to promise much easy wealth. And then when they deliver, that wealth evaporates as the price crashes. And so I can say that gas wants to be cheap, at certain historical moments.</p><p>In the early 2000s gas was on track to get incrementally more expensive over time, making it an investment good enough that it would be fiduciarily irresponsible to miss out on investments like the Sabine Pass LNG <em>Import </em>terminal.</p><p>This prospect of rising prices pleased liberals, because the 2010s were set to be, as we said at the time, the last decade where we could have averted the worst of global warming. Higher carbon prices would have made other technologies more competitive in the open market. We didn’t dare to wish for a more direct state intervention to the problem.</p><p>In the 2000s, Aubrey McClendon, highly leveraged, started buying up land and drilling rights in Oklahoma and environs. By the twentyteens he had inundated markets with the floods of his fracks.</p><p>Think of shale rock as a loaf of good bread; the yeast has exhaled into every space, leaving solid membranes around alveoli of gas. Sometimes you’ll get a huge hole in your slice, and you’ll have to carefully engineer your sandwich around it. Those are the traditional reservoirs. Frack gas comes from the rest.</p><p>To be clear: fracking can produce oil, but mostly produces gas. You can frack an oil well, but you may only get gas. Shale oil is not fracked. That euphemism refers to boiling the rock to produce an oil. That was happening, too, at increasing rates. Sands, too. “Unconventional” supply hitting the market in earnest.</p><p>Do this for me: take a half of a sourdough boule, and stab it with a knife from the white down to the crust at the far end. Then soak the bread with water. Then take an air compressor and blast it at a minimum of 100 PSI. The delicate, rhizomatic network that the yeast has grown is destroyed, and whatever was contained within is forced out.</p><p>Fracking is the industrialization of the truth discussed in <em>Cyclonopedia</em> that all that is solid, like the Earth, is infected by the void. There are pockets of gas beneath our feet, coexisting with the rock and soil. The relevant passage is made all the more relevant because it is here that he has to deal with the filthy old racist Lovecraft as well as that accelerationist (no insult is grater) Nick Land:</p><blockquote><em>“According to Lovecraft, the realism of horror is built upon poromechanics…But how do holes emerge out of the interactions of solid and void? It is best to answer this question by paraphrasing Nick Land’s remarks (from </em>Thirst for Annihilation<em>)…:</em> <strong><em>void excludes solid but solid must include void to architectonically survive.</em></strong><em> Solid needs void to engineer its composition; even the most despotic and survivalist solids are compositional solids, infected by the void. Through these inter-collisions of void and solid, the Old Ones — according to Lovecraft — can revive their ‘Holocaust of Freedom’ (</em>Call of Cthulhu<em>), both by consuming solid and by pushing compositions towards the highest degrees of convolution (as a result of the ambiguity of solid and void: i.e. the fuzzy space of the hole and its surface dynamics). In terms of Earth, the Holocaust of Freedom can be attained by engineering the corpse of solidus through installing ungrounding machines at molecular levels that exhume (ex + </em>humus<em>: unground) the earth from within and without, turning it into a vermicular and holey composition whose strata (The Economy of Solidus) is not dismantled but convoluted at each level of its own formation and composition.”</em></blockquote><p>In Lovecraft’s diseased, racist mind, the Old Ones are Black, precolonial. But he was wrong. Very, disgustingly wrong. They are White, driven by monomaniacal pre-human “mind that is held by no head” into a frenzy of colonial violence: the Holocaust of Freedom. Sure, committing holocausts on places and peoples much more free than American capitalism could ever allow, but nonetheless acting in the name of Freedom, brand America. Theirs was the freedom of “free markets,” which are actually <em>open</em> markets; markets ripped open and exposed to the worldwide torrents of colonial expropriation, just as the fracked earth is ripped open to let the gas escape into the Day. Not just open markets, but <em>freshly</em> opened markets; these are the raw veins that capitalism needs to grow; everyone knows that capitalism requires a perpetual frontier.</p><blockquote><em>Negarestani: “Although the void devours the solid, the solid feasts on the void, i.e., its outsider. In compositions, the solid becomes hysterically gluttonous for the void. This is what intrigued the Cult of the Old Ones in their mission to perform their awakening ritual. If the Old Ones are to fly through holey space, bubbling up through the carrion black pit and turning their tentacles into interconnected borrows and lubricious warrens, then the only strategic technique is to mess with the ( )hole complex.”</em></blockquote><p>Fracking is a strategic mess. So are all other methods of hydrocarbon extraction. It is a messy business.</p><p>Fracking came along late in the day, after the Oil Wars had been going on for a century and it was already established that the American empire brought freedom only for its perpetrators, lords of finance and industry whose creatures became known as Intelligence after the War. But also too late to stop them.</p><p>And so they embarked upon a fresh Holocaust of Freedom, again conveniently against their old bogeyman, the Russians. For frozen Frack Gas (LNG) to escape domestic consumption and rule the old country, Russian gas must be denied entry into Europe. What was actually happening within Russia didn’t matter to the narrative that America needed to justify a new war.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*Jt4MTVyaq3yyymld.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/press-the-money-button-get-a-book"><strong>Subscribe to get a copy of the book in a few years.</strong></a></p><p>Subscribed</p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/frack-1#footnote-anchor-1-139895038">1</a></p><p>Charles Blanchard, <em>The Extraction State.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab981887d501" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/frack-1-fracking-ab981887d501">FRACK 1: Fracking</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Methane History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/methane-history-dc78bb287c3c?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc78bb287c3c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[natural-gas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-crisis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Dec 2023 17:02:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-08T17:02:17.881Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Things have been tough since October 7th, as we stand witness to a holocaust in Palestine. I’ve been processing the horror with my family and reading through </em><a href="https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/document/mideast/agedict/index.htm">Zionism in the Age of Dictators by Lenni Brenner</a>, <em>which I hope you will look at especially if, like me, you are Jewish or have previously fallen into the specious “anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism” trope. We must stay awake; we must demand a ceasefire, but when it comes, we must not rest a day before we demand urgently an end to the blockade and the right to return for all. As horrific as the last month has been, the movement for a free Palestine is stronger now than it has been in my lifetime; I hope this will be remembered as a turning point.</em></p><p><em>But I do want to get back to the Autonomous Corpse Juice Project, and I had this section typed in before the war. All facts that are uncited come from </em>The Extraction State <em>by </em>Charles Blanchard, <em>which is not as radical as its title implies; Blanchard is a financial analyst with expertise in gas. But a good overview nonetheless.</em></p><p>The first conquest of the dead god was of the night. Throughout the somatic energy regime, fire persisted alongside animals as a constant companion and survival tool. Heat and light. For light, people burned candles and oil, whatever vegetable oil was on hand. Then there was <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/endlessness-and-intolerableness">whale oil</a>, the fuel that was made obsolete by gas light.</p><p>The gas light was invented by David Melville in Newport, Rhode Island, in 1805. Specifically, Melville developed the process by which coked coal could be turned into a flammable gas that then could be fed into a lamp. He successfully lit his home and the tavern next-door with burners connected to a small network of gaslines. He formed a company and tried to get municipal contracts, then the whaling industry got wind of his activities in their own home territory of the Northeastern seaboard, and waged a bribery and propaganda campaign to shut him down.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-new-light#footnote-1-138023429">1</a> The Melville <a href="http://melvilles.org/">clan </a>is large and has a <a href="http://melvilles.org/melvilletree.html">well documented genealogy</a> <a href="https://digital.nls.uk/histories-of-scottish-families/archive/96667220?mode=transcription">that </a>says that Herman and David were not related. Yet it is impossible to say that they are entirely unrelated, if only by cultural circumstance and history’s sense of irony.</p><p>Nonetheless, ten years later the cities began to get gas light. People loved it, and at first paid admission to see gas lights burning, which is how Rembrandt Peale, a museum owner, started the first successful gas company which lit Baltimore first in 1816. Then the gas industry first hit the big time in New York, where “men of standing and means”<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-new-light#footnote-2-138023429">2</a> Samuel Leggett, president of Franklin Bank, and twelve associates owned the New York Gas Light Company, which built a gas grid in lower Manhattan that was ignited in 1823. Chicago got it 1850, San Francisco in 1854, and almost every American city had it by the early 1870s.</p><p>The methane burned in those gas lights was obtained by heating coal in the absence of oxygen, which produces <em>coke oven gas</em> that was about half and half, hydrogen and methane, along with plenty of contaminants. Coke oven gas was also called “manufactured gas,” to differentiate it from “natural gas.” That process of manufacturing coke oven gas was horribly unhealthy and done locally, and so it was a major contributor to the famous toxic fogs that plagued both American and English cities at the end of the 19th century. However, at its founding, The New York Gas Company faced a shortage of coal, since the coal deposits of Appalachia would not be tapped until the 1840s, and so they developed an apparatus for making flammable gas from crude oil.</p><p>The Haymaker boys, Obadiah and Michael, were out looking for oil (already a very popular commodity) when they popped their gas well on November 3, 1878. Almost immediate, an onlooker ignited it with a lantern, and it became a “flaming fire, issuing from the earth [that] could be seen at night at a distance of eight or ten miles, and its roaring sound was distinctly heard for five or six miles.” (Blanchard). The Haymaker burned millions of cubic feet every day. Eventually, the gas was brought under control, but its ownership was contested. In 1882, an unnamed “promoter from Chicago” tried to buy the well from the Haymaker boys for $20,000 cash. But at the same time, one of the boys’ investors, H.J. Brunot, made a deal to sell the whole operation to Joseph Pew and his partner, Edward Octavius Emerson, cousin of Ralph Waldo Emerson. The Promoter from Chicago arrived at the well with fifty armed men on November 26, 1883. The Haymaker boys showed up with a posse of ten. Obadiah Haymaker was bayonetted four times and died before reaching home. Absent that day were Pew and Edward Octavius, but they cleanly won in the courts and became the uncontested owners of the Haymaker well. They incorporated the Peoples Natural Gas Company and built a pipeline to send the gas to Pittsburgh, which was completed in January 1883. That city was famously polluted at the time. It lived under a constant haze emitted by the steel energy. But it got noticeably better when the city got Haymaker gas, for seven years. After that, the well was exhausted and the city back to manufactured gas. Pew and Edward Octavius Emerson renamed their company into the Sun Oil Company, which, by 1985 was still the 20th largest company in the United States. That was when it pioneered the use of horizontal drilling in the Austin Chalk field, ushering in the Fracking Age.</p><p>There began a century-long battle over the flammable gas regulatory regime. The logic of gas, especially of public gas lights, dictates action at the municipal level. Cities came to need a grid of pipelines, which were built at public expense and outside of the War economy. Therefore, gas needed to be controlled by a utility compact, rather than regulated as a pure commodity like oil. Gas companies needed to have some close relationship to the State, which proposed in exchange to grant them a monopoly in their market. However, when cities made the switch from manufactured gas to natural gas, there became three different types of gas companies — utilities, pipelines, and producers — where before there were only the utilities, who manufactured and distributed coke oven gas.</p><p>Before that could happen, someone had to build all the pipelines at a significant capital investment. You can move oil by many means, but you can only move gas through a pipeline. Pipeline companies were formed and they determined the shape of the natural gas cashflow. At first, before the War, it wasn’t a priority and, since it was a utility compact, there little exciting profit in it. But during World War II, a private company was founded with public money, War Emergency Pipelines, and they built two pipelines, Big Inch from the crude oilfields in East Texas, and Little Inch from the refineries in Beaumont, Texas, where the pedophile and race terrorist Patillo Higgins still lived, to the East Coast, from whence it was shipped to the War.</p><p>Immediately after the War the cities in the Northeastern part of the country were split evenly between consumers of natural gas and manufactured gas. Philadelphia, New York City, and Boston had no access to natural gas. Then, Big Inch and Little Inch were bought by E(lijah) Holley Poe’s company, TETCO, and converted into gaslines. Continuing with the theme, given that Edgar Allan Poe’s best friend’s middle name was <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Holley_Chivers">Holley </a>it seems likely that TETCO’s boss was related to Master of American Horror, or at least thought of himself as such.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-new-light#footnote-3-138023429">3</a> These transregional pipelines faced competition from the Tennessee Gas Pipeline, run by a “loudmouthed bully” ( Blanchard) named Gardiner Symonds, and from United Gas, run by <a href="https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/natural-gas-the-gulf-souths-symbol-of-progress-newcomen-society-of-england-american-branch-publications/37493651/#edition=17359108&amp;idiq=21520791">Norris McGowen</a>. These three inaugurated an age of public corruption as they bribed municipal utilities in cities like New York and Boston. Meanwhile, PG&amp;E in California contracted with <a href="https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,893243,00.html">Paul Kayser</a>’s El Paso Natural Gas out of Texas.</p><p>In 1954 the Supreme Court ruled that natural gas producers — not just municipal distributors — could be regulated by the Federal Power Commission (FPC) under the Natural Gas Act of 1938 as long as their pipelines crossed state lines. This created two potentially divergent streams of gas capital — intrastate regulated gas and interstate unregulated gas. Since the gas market was sleepy and uneventful, and since gas was so naturally abundant in the US, the two prices remained aligned until 1973, where we will pick up next time.</p><p>Subscribed</p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-new-light#footnote-anchor-1-138023429">1</a></p><p>Louis Stotz and Alexander Jamison, <em>History of the Gas Industry</em>, 1938.</p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-new-light#footnote-anchor-2-138023429">2</a></p><p>Stotz and Jamison.</p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-new-light#footnote-anchor-3-138023429">3</a></p><p>So to summarize, we’ve got Melville, Emerson, and Poe all involved in the gas industry. What does this say about American letters? That it arose exclusively from a white, aristocratic, capitalist class and therefore was dependent upon petrocaptialism for its very existence.</p><h3>The 1973</h3><h3>Methane Part 3</h3><p>Gas runs out in a way that oil just doesn’t. It comes rushing out of the ground of its own accord, and eventually the unfracked ground will just be deflated. Also, gas is geographically constrained in a way that oil isn’t: it can’t travel by ship (without first freezing it into a liquid), only by pipeline, and so the producer, pipeline, and consumer all need to be on the same continent. Even so, there is so much of the stuff in the ground that this didn’t begin to happen in North America until the early seventies, after eighty years of increasingly voracious methane consumption.</p><p>The shortage of gas forced the unregulated price of gas that did not cross state lines in a pipeline to increase, while the government continued to regulate the price of interstate gas. This caused a shortage in the national interstate gas network that serves the large, northeastern cities, as producers sold to the higher bidders. Eventually, this dynamic initiated the deregulation of the interstate gas market. Deregulation proceeded slowly, but the rest of methane history sits along an entropic slide from gas being a highly regulated public good to a radically privatized commodity that was still nonetheless used and billed to the consumer as a utility. In the old regime, pipelines acted as gas traders: they bought gas from producers and sold it at the other end of the line to utility compacts (themselves to be deregulated to their own degree). The pipelines prevented utilities from making deals with gas providers. In the new regime, the pipeline is a contracted transportation service, and the trading is done on Wall Street.</p><p>Gas lived on the margins of the great petrowars, conquests, and fortunes of the 20th century, but beginning in 1973, it moved on to the center stage, where it coexists today with oil, first by way of this great deregulation.</p><p>1973 can be considered a useful narrative pivot from oil to methane because of the value of its scarcity. Of course, throughout everything, oil continued to be the main player of American capitalism. 1973 can only mark the beginning of the methane narrative shift that is only now reaching its maturity.</p><p>The disciplining power of the seventies oil shock was so important to the development of austerity that it needed to be buttressed not only by a stage play orchestrated between American allies in the Middle East, but also a material shortage of oil’s offspring, gas. The bubbles of gas beneath America had long been popped. Before horizontal drilling, there wasn’t much that producers could get out of old gasholes. There was never an oil shortage, but there was a gas shortage.</p><p>The gas shortage was used as a tool to discipline the public, to generate justification for austerity. Where oil is the godfather of the international stage, gas is a domestic creature. It can only be transported by pipeline. Which means, it can only be transported over land. For this reason, and other reasons directly attributable to the nature of flammable gas, it was considered to be a public good, a utility. This was why the price of interstate gas was regulated until the 1980s. The price of intrastate gas, that was burned in the same state it was produced, was not regulated. This theoretically created two separate commodities markets, with two different prices. During the propulsive phase of market saturation, it was easy to keep those prices identical. As it began to run out in the 1970s, the prices diverged, as nobody would sell gas to the price-regulated municipal markets. School had to be canceled because the building had no heat in the middle of winter. This generated a public demand for gas to become ‘deregulated.’ This of course was tightly aligned with the market incentives of the oilmen. The price of a single-carbon molecule had to correlate to the cost of strings of liquid carbons bonded with hydrogen. Even though the molecules travel through the economy on separate tracks. So, deregulated and thus more profitable, gas began its financial journey from the backburner of petrocapitalism to the sexy desk on the commodities floor. By the 2000s, the gas trading game was high risk, high reward, overleveraged and volatile, despite the fact that it was still consumed as a utility.</p><p>The gambling culture that grew up around this market reached a first peak in Enron, which will always be a funny thought to someone of my generation. Biggest idiots in the room type of affair, Marx brothers. Because their core gas trading business was a healthy cashflow. They leveraged that, gambled and lost. Others gamble and win, like Charif Souki, and yet others gamble and win a lot and then lose it all quickly like gas traders John Arnold and Brian Hunter who made and lost $5 billion in the 2000s.</p><p>Charif Souki had been born into a wealthy, connected Lebanese family, and made millions investing in real estate in the 1970s. He retired to Aspen, Colorado, and invested in a few restaurants that lost money. By the 1980s, oil and gas assets were dirt cheap after a decade of collapsed prices and oversupply. And there they stayed until the 2000s, before they collapsed even further. But Charif could imagine a world in which gas would begin running low; the same wells had been in service for decades. He decided that demand was growing faster than supply, enough so that in a few years he’d be able to make money importing natural gas. The U.S. had started importing LNG during the energy crises of the 1970s, but the old LNG import terminals had been mothballed for decades. He convinced a bunch of investors to go in with him on building a new LNG import terminal on the Gulf Coast, a facility which was to be called Sabine Pass. He started importing by 2004 and within five years the market was utterly destroyed by a massive surge of frack gas, and Souki’s investors were threatened with total loss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*dmV_MAK09J55Hla1.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc78bb287c3c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/methane-history-dc78bb287c3c">Methane History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wondrous Extermination]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/wondrous-extermination-368d098b44d2?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/368d098b44d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[herman-melville]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[moby-dick]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Oct 2023 16:01:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-06T16:01:57.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Methane Prequel (-1.5)</h3><p>The manufactured gas of the cities and oil from Petrolia, Pennsylvania, consigned one specific commodity to obsolescence: whale oil, which had become popular among the set of Americans who might, say, make their <a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/files/30956/30956-h/30956-h.htm">fortunes</a> by selling slave-grown cotton to textile mills in England in the decades preceding the Civil War. It was said to cast a most pleasing flame. It was also used as an industrial and narrative lubricant.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/endlessness-and-intolerableness#footnote-1-137598796">1</a> The commodity sale of whale oil created a market that oil and gas poured into and exploded.</p><p>Jamie Jones’ book <a href="https://bookshop.org/a/93378/9781469674827"><em>Rendered Obsolete</em></a> argues that <em>Moby Dick </em>created the metaphorical, linguistic, and ideological shape that oil and gas filled: the concept of <em>energy</em>. The novel was published at the peak of American whaling culture, which means it was written during the heady ascent, and yet in the novel the business of whaling is already a receding object-aesthetic of nostalgia, the type of nostalgia that would mark a decline that was to begin in the 1860s, when the whales moved inland, along with whaling workers, who were a major constituency in the man-camps along the Oil river. Reporters at Petrolia in the 1860s wrote that “the oil wells ‘spouted…sounding like the “blowing” of a whale.’” “Oil was oil, and whalemen were oilmen.”</p><p>Ishmael anticipated fossil fuels’ power and function in the business of whaling:</p><blockquote><em>I freely assert, that the cosmopolite philosopher cannot, for his life, point out one single peaceful influence, which within the last sixty years has operated more potentially upon the whole broad world, taken in one aggregate, than the high and mighty business of whaling. One way and another, it has begotten events so remarkable in themselves, and so continuously momentous in their sequential issues, that whaling may well be regarded as that Egyptian mother, who bore offspring themselves pregnant from her womb.</em></blockquote><p>This image of “pure fertility, focused on the violent whaling industry, is ironic and even grotesque. The booming American whaling industry, its excessive power as an agent of vast historical change on a global scale: Is its fecundity itself unnatural, perhaps even cancerous? Consider the consequences of the Egyptian mother’s pregnant newborns.” (Jones 56)</p><p>The key component of the modern concept of energy is, according to Jones, the myth of “wealth without work.” In describing the mansions of New Bedford, Ishmael says “Yes; all these brave houses and flowery gardens came from the Atlantic, Pacific, and Indian oceans. One and all, they were harpooned and dragged up hither from the bottom of the sea.” Wealth without work continues to be a foundation of the energy industry today. It is a lie, of course, as Ishmael spends most of the novel showing that each cask of oil is earned at an intense animal cost (human and non-) and the drama and violence of extractive labor is the heart of the book.</p><p>When Ishmael arrives in Nantucket, he sees whale oil in commodity form before he even sees the ships:</p><blockquote><em>“Huge hills and mountains of casks on casks were piled upon her wharves, and side by side the world-wandering whale ships lay silent and safely moored at last, while from others came a sound of carpenters and coopers, with blended noises of fires and forges to melt the pitch, all betokening that new cruises were on the start; that one most perilous and long voyage ended only begins a second; and a second ended only begins a third, and so on, for ever and for aye. Such is the endlessness, yea, the intolerableness of all earthy effort.”</em></blockquote><p>The hills and mountains of casks on casks echo not only barrels of oil, but also the hills and mountains of bison carcasses that were being piled up out West as part of the genocide.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/endlessness-and-intolerableness#footnote-2-137598796">2</a></p><p>The proto-industrial aural backdrop supports Jones’ contention that this passage is about the capitalist ideal of perpetual growth, which Melville pairs with a constant anxiety about extinction, conceived of as a type of resource depletion. Jones writes, “Ishmael reveals the fatal fallacies of extractive capitalism by testing the landsman’s view of whaling against the direct experience of the industry he acquires as a laborer on the <em>Pequod</em>: <strong>endlessness is the mandate of capitalism, but intolerableness is its reality</strong>.” This test lies in many places, including the graphic violence of the whale hunt, a violence that is hidden out of sight from the landsman’s view.</p><p>What is it that is intolerable? Is it the violence, or is it “the specter of exhaustion and extinction that haunts the industry” (Jones)? This specter is raised in the name of the ship<em>,</em> as Ishmael says<em> </em>“<em>Pequod</em>, you will no doubt remember, was the name of a celebrated tribe of Massachusetts Indians, now extinct as the ancient Medes.” Here Ishmael commits the verbal violence that scholar <a href="https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/firsting-and-lasting">Jean O’Brien</a> calls “lasting,” which writes American Indians out of existence by declaring them extinct when they are still alive: the Mashantucket Pequot tribe is not extinct but is a federally recognized tribal nation in Connecticut. But for Ishmael, they are as utterly extinct as an ancient Persian dynasty that left no written records. But he also said that the whale was a fish (it is not).</p><p>Will the same fate be shared by whales? This is the concern of “Chapter 105: Does the Whale’s Magnitude Diminish? — Will He Perish?” Wherein Ishmael reminds us “Though so short a period ago — not a good lifetime — the census of the buffalo in Illinois exceeded the census of men now in London, and though at the present day not one horn or hoof of them remains in all that region; and though <strong>the cause of this wondrous extermination was the spear of man</strong>; yet the far different nature of the whale-hunt peremptorily forbids so inglorious an end to the Leviathan.” No; Ishmael knows that the buffalo were killed as part of a mass genocide, not for their value in commodities markets, and he believes that the labor expenditure required to harvest whales for these markets will save them. As if labor has ever been fairly valued. He concludes: “we account the whale immortal in his species, however perishable in his individuality.” Only familiar with somatic, 19th century methods of whaling, this error is forgivable: the whale didn’t become threatened with extinction until the mechanized harvesting began in the 20th century.</p><p>He then commits the same logical error that has since been popularized by the climate deniers: something has never happened before, and therefore it can never happen in the future, no matter the changed conditions. “He [the whale] once swam over the site of the Tuileries, and Windsor Castle, and the Kremlin. In Noah’s flood he despised Noah’s ark.”</p><p>But nonetheless wonderous extermination <em>is</em> upon the whaling business, at least as a living cultural and economic influence, not from resource depletion but from technological obsolescence.</p><p>For Jones, <em>Moby Dick </em>“offers a vision of the future, not by dreaming up new forms to come, but by imagining the structures of the present in ruins. <em>Moby Dick</em> narrates energy history in the future past tense, in <em>futur antérieur: </em>whaling will have declined.” Going out in the middle of the ocean and stabbing whales is best done in moderation, and America proved to be intolerant of moderation after the lights turned on. The slaughter escalated to a new level entirely in the twentieth century, but with none of the cultural power of Nantucket and New Bedford.</p><p>This is why we get so much nostalgia from Ishmael. He insists on shipping out of Nantucket when the bulk of the business had already moved to New Bedford, because he is looking not to work in a modernized commodity environment but rather for something a little more romantic. He chooses the most gnarled, small, haunted-looking ship.</p><p>Ahab’s unproductive obsession with vengeance upon a single white whale could only have been supported by a profitable extractive economy, but not one that had been fully ingested into capitalism. Before Ahab can be seen, we must meet the <em>Pequod’s </em>primary investors. The owners are not representatives of New York banks, but rather old Peleg and Bilal, “well-to-do, retired whalemen,” who came up in the trade and are romanticized at least as much as Ahab, if in different ways. Melville’s capitalism didn’t have room for outside investors; it gives us a romantic vision of a craftsman’s capitalism, of small-scale industry supported by the production of a luxury item. If this corner of the American economy did once exist, it proved to be brittle, and Melville knew it, or predicted it.</p><p>After the first whale is killed and taken aboard the <em>Pequod</em>, the ship transforms into a factory to render the oil. Turning it from an animal into a liquid fuel. It is during these scenes that we get the lovely homoeroticism of the men’s hands finding each other in the vats of spermaceti as they massage the fat into a liquid that can be poured into the kettles. This is how Melville makes the <em>Pequod</em> generalizable into America the Nation, as it becomes a butchery, a refinery, and other bits of infrastructure that Jones points out to us, including gas pipes and plumbing. Jones: “At the moment of the birth of the concept of energy, <em>Moby Dick’</em>s infrastructural metaphors model the way that an energy resource, the whale’s body, is put to use in terrestrial infrastructures: first in imagination and then, fatally, in practice.”</p><p>What <em>Moby Dick </em>does well is to show the violence at the heart of all extractive industry. The single-minded madness that drove Ahab was echoed by many oilmen as they drove their crews to drill deeper and deeper into dry holes, at the cost of worker’s lives. They used to hire “bean boys” who would literally be paid in beans, so the wildcatter’s lottery ticket could be punched. For whalers, casual violence toward workers and animals alike was a daily part of the job. Ahab was driven by a romantic or perhaps medieval idea of vengeance, rather than the quotidian profit motive that operates out here in the real world. Nonetheless, Melville reveals and reinforces the horror of the whaling industry upon both sailors (workers) and whales. Jones: “Commercial whaling as portrayed in <em>Moby Dick </em>is death-driven settler ideology that makes whale bodies into commodities and infrastructures that fuel capitalist expansion and settler colonialism.” But Melville cannot see anything outside of that, cannot imagine non-suicidal livelihoods. Ahab could always only die in the past, even a future past.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*LbOnZ5yAvgx9qaHE.jpeg" /></figure><p>This post was submitted to Amazon as a 5-star review for <a href="https://bookshop.org/a/93378/9781469674827"><em>Rendered Obsolete: Energy Culture and the Afterlife of Us Whaling</em></a><a href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/rendered-obsolete-energy-culture-and-the-afterlife-of-us-whaling-jamie-l-jones/19955707?ean=9781469674827"> by Jamie Jones</a>. Pick up a copy.</p><p>The Spouter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.</p><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/endlessness-and-intolerableness#footnote-anchor-1-137598796">1</a> <em>Cyclonopedia: Complicity with Anonymous Materials </em>by Reza Negarestani<em>:</em></p><blockquote><em>First Hyperstitional Entity of Oil: “Oil as lubricant or Tellurian lube, upon which everything moves forward, spreading smoothly and inevitably. Events are configured by the superconductivitiy of oil and global petrodynamic currents to such an extent that the progression and emergence of events may be influenced more than by time. If narrative development, the unfolding of events in a narration, implies the progression of chronological time, for contemporary planetary formations, history and its progression is determined by the influz and outflow of petroleum.” …</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“According to a blobjective point of view, petropolitical undercurrents function as narrative lubes: they interconnect inconsistencies, anomalies, or what we might simply call the ‘plot holes’ in narratives of planetary formations and activities.”</em></blockquote><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/endlessness-and-intolerableness#footnote-anchor-2-137598796">2</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*RyHDkzRdPteJQy_B.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://theconversation.com/historical-photo-of-mountain-of-bison-skulls-documents-animals-on-the-brink-of-extinction-148780">photo taken taken outside of Michigan Carbon Works in Rougeville, Mich., in 1892</a></p><p>Jones: “Melville renders the violence of whale slaughter in unflinching detail, but he does indeed flinch when it comes to representing violence against Indigenous people, whose existence is only implied.” Historian Nancy Shoemaker, shows that “in fact, most young men from Indigenous communities in Southern New England worked on commercial whaling ships in the eighteenth and nineteenth century.” But only in non-leadership positions, though their skill and knowledge comprised the core competency of every ship. Indigenous Americans are represented aboard the <em>Pequod</em> only by Tashtego, who is thrust to the frontlines of the extractive violence and is otherwise only mentioned as one of a trio of harpooners with Daggoo and Queequeg. When he is described, it is as non-human: “The parted mouth of Tashtego revealed his shark-white teeth, which strangely gleamed as if they too had been tipped by corposants…”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=368d098b44d2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/wondrous-extermination-368d098b44d2">Wondrous Extermination</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digestion’s End]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/digestions-end-31c9abf2d1b9?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31c9abf2d1b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[natural-gas]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Sep 2023 14:44:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-15T14:44:50.364Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Methane Part 1</p><blockquote><em>“Solid needs void to engineer its composition, even the most despotic and survivalist solids are compositional solids, infected by the void.” This ( ) hole complex “unfolds holes as ambiguous entities — oscillating between surface and depth — within solid matrices fundamentally corrupting the latter’s consolidation and wholeness through perforations and terminal porosities.” For Lovecraft,</em><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/digestions-end#footnote-1-136832274"><em>1</em></a><em> “( )hole complex is the zone through which the Outside gradually but persistently emerges, creeps in (or out?) from the Inside. A complex of hole agencies and obscure surfaces unground the earth and turn it to the ultimate zone of emergence and uprising against its own passive planetdom, a time when, according to the </em>Call of Cthulhu<em>, ‘mankind would have become as the Great Old Ones; greed and wild and beyond good and evil, with laws and morals thrown aside and all men shouting and killing and revelling in joy. Then the liberated Old Ones would teach them new ways to shout and kill and revel and enjoy themselves, and all the earth would flame with a holocaust of ecstasy and freedom.’” </em><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/revised-hydrogen-corpse-juice#details">Cyclonopedia</a>: <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon?utm_source=profile&amp;utm_medium=reader2#details">Complicity with Anonymous Materials</a> <em>by </em><a href="https://re-press.org/title/cyclonopedia-complicity-with-anonymous-materials/"><em>Reza Negarestani</em></a></blockquote><p>Put yourself, if you will, in the moment you’re turning on your gas stove: the confrontation with click click click click click click click click click whump. In that moment, you know everything you need to know about methane. It’s flammable, which is why you need it. The more clicks you hear, the bigger the explosion when the stove finally decides to yield its fire. Each click is a unit in an ongoing wager between your food, your subjectivity, and methane; at some point it will become too dangerous, and you’ll have to try another burner, even if it means rearranging heavy pots. The smell is the index of the wager, the cards on the table: you know you’re welcoming into your home not only methane but an unknown variety of contaminants and additives. You don’t want to be doing this; you want to be cooking. But instead you’re just standing there, clicking.</p><p>Don’t do it, by the way. Turn it off and jiggle the piece that sits on top of the burner. I learned that at thirty-seven years of age, having only ever used gas stoves.</p><p>And that’s how it is with methane. It’s the most unruly of the Fossil trinity, profoundly and by its very nature leaky. Once in a while, a building will explode. It’s a sign of decaying municipal infrastructure.</p><p>As coal lives at the beginning of the story of the dead god’s conquest of earth, so does methane live at the end. Coal never left, and gas was always here. But narratively, coal goes before oil and methane goes after. CH4 is the simplest hydrocarbon (with one carbon atom per molecule), is a gas at temperatures over -162ᵒC (your freezer hovers at around -15ᵒC).</p><p>If the function of a machine is what it does, then decomposition is a maker of methane. It’s the final product of complex trophic hierarchies, a final liberatory vaporization, and is not necessarily attained by all organic materials. Sometimes ecosystems emit methane, and sometimes they store the organic material as more complex hydrocarbons which then only break down into methane over impossibly long periods of time, or never if frozen. No wildcatter “discovered” natural gas; it’s always been around us. But the process of petrolocization, when it began, had no use for dispersed energy stores of ecosystems; it needs dense reservoirs that can be financialized. Methane is but one product of The Company.</p><p>All oil, if left in the ground long enough, will become methane gas. It is very rare deeper in the earth’s mantle, which is an oxidizing environment, like the atmosphere, and therefore breaks down methane within ten to thirty years of its emission.</p><p>Methane plays a starring role in the natural (prehuman) history of the Earth. For example, in the most dramatic mass extinction, the End Permian extinction 250 million years ago, something (perhaps an earthquake) caused the <a href="https://www.science.org/content/article/last-gasp-permian#:~:text=The%20idea%20that%20methane%20contributed,over%2010%2C000%20years%20or%20so.">oceans to release</a> a massive quantity of methane which then exploded in the atmosphere, literally setting the air on fire. Even scientists who don’t subscribe to the giant fireball story of the End Permian believe that enough methane was released to substantially decrease the concentration of oxygen, and organisms suffocated to death. More recently, the last 800,000 years have been punctuated by ice ages and their endings, periods of warming <a href="https://theconversation.com/rising-methane-could-be-a-sign-that-earths-climate-is-part-way-through-a-termination-level-transition-211211">called Terminations</a>, and numbered from “Termination IX, which happened about 800,000 years ago to Termination IA which initiated the modern climate less than 12,000 years ago.” In each case, something triggered the release of methane into the atmosphere — usually by expanding tropical wetlands, but also by massive wildfires, which led to a brief period of abrupt heating. In Termination IA, Greenland’s temperature rose by 10°C within a <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0277379104003245?via%3Dihub">few decades</a> . These events pushed methane from about 360 parts per billion (ppb) during the ice age to 700 ppb at the balmy peak of the interglacial period, which was, incidentally, where we were when the industrial revolution began. Today we’re at around <a href="https://www.noaa.gov/news-release/increase-in-atmospheric-methane-set-another-record-during-2021">1,900</a> ppb.</p><p>Imagine a bit of algae settling in a precambrian ocean into a bed of very fine clay sediment. As that sediment is buried by the Earth’s cycles, it is compacted by the growing weight above, squeezing the clay into shale rock. As it does so, the methane leaks out, forming tiny alveoli of gas, many just microns across. In most places, this methane gets trapped in these alveoli throughout the otherwise-impenetrable shale rock. This is why it is possible to recover an even larger quantity by fracking, once that was popularized in the 2010s.</p><p>In other places, decomposing liquids pool amidst a jumble of broken chunks of rock, in which case methane is free to bubble up to the surface as the forces of time break the oil down into lighter and lighter molecules. This is fairly rare, geographically speaking, but when conditions are right, the reservoirs can be vast, almost oceanic.</p><p>When the reservoir is capped by a layer of unbroken rock, the gas pools below the ceiling, exerting upward pressure as it gets more and more compressed by the weight of time. Eventually, all the oil in the reservoir will be entirely metabolized into gas. It remains a gas even under pressure of thousands of feet of earth.</p><p>Some of the <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/revised-hydrogen-corpse-juice#details">entities</a> of methane:</p><ul><li>natural gas that can be commodified as fuel and sold mostly to utility compacts</li><li>agricultural waste product, especially from the meatflesh industries (cow burps) and rice</li><li><a href="https://www.technologynetworks.com/applied-sciences/news/nitrogen-fixing-bacteria-are-unexpected-source-of-methane-296303#:~:text=Recent%20research%20reveals%20that%20this,methane%20is%20only%20a%20sideline.">byproduct</a> of nitrogen-fixing microorganisms</li><li>product of natural decomposition in ecosystems, whether in balance or not</li><li>thaw from previously frozen dead ecosystems.</li></ul><p>You strike oil, you get gas, too, every time. You’ll have to make a decision about it: flare it off, or build infrastructure to be able to commodify it. The reason for the well is oil, and gas, like plastic later down the chain of production, is an inevitable side product. If you’re watching your bottom line and the numbers add up, you’ll build the pipeline. If you’re a wildcatter, you’ll flare. It was said that in East Texas in the 1930s, you could read a book at midnight in the middle of nowhere by the light of the gas flares.</p><p>I think you’re familiar with the atmospheric physics of methane. When burned, it releases less CO2 per unit of energy than oil and coal. But it doesn’t always get burned, it just leaks into the atmosphere where it is said to be about 30x more <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/erathication-definition">enthalpic</a> than CO2. It barely matters that methane breaks down over the period of a few decades; a few decades is the time-frame on which the Termination is happening. They keep <a href="https://www.science.org/content/article/natural-gas-could-warm-planet-much-coal-short-term">re-discovering</a> and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/13/climate/natural-gas-leaks-coal-climate-change.html">re-reporting</a> on the fact that accounting for leaks, flammable natural gas is much worse for us than coal. The trouble is that no one really measures the leaks, and they certainly could be much bigger than what’s reported.</p><p>It is impossible to know how leaky all our gas infrastructure is. It could all very well be spewing vast amounts of methane into the air at every transition-point. We don’t know how much, and we don’t want to know. The gas leaks from every pore on its way into the factory or stove, and also it frequently explodes. We do know that methane levels suddenly surged in the 1990s, then plateaued for five years starting around 1999, a period when scientists hoped the methane cycle had reached a new equilibrium, before the growth suddenly started accelerating again in earnest, on a steepening curve, in 2006.</p><p>About 30% of that is attributable, via isotropic profile, to industrial leaks. Then there are the fumes of feedlots and other livestock operations, and also landfills and city dumps. But that greater part is from <a href="https://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/5054#">wetlands</a>, <a href="https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/abs/10.1139/z88-076">beaver</a> dams, <a href="https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/arctic-methane-situational-awareness-assessment-policy-directions?gad=1&amp;gclid=CjwKCAjwu4WoBhBkEiwAojNdXkfYvPTEPidSEcrYCro-2ZfSp2XXosHFbqsTA9kiG2VRION_K7hNKhoCEykQAvD_BwE">permafrost</a>, and other nonhuman sources. People in the disinformation business may find solace in the idea that the methane isn’t being released by humans — after all, it seems to exonerate their corporate masters. First of all, that thirty percent could be the difference between life and death. But more to the point, these facts only denote that we have triggered a cascade of positive feedback loops over which we may never be able to reassert control: it means that it is too late to avoid the most dramatic <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/erathication-definition">erathication</a> in the natural history of the planet. These are sources of methane we can’t turn off.</p><p>Methane oxidizes into CO2 and hydrogen over about ten years. That does not make methane less important to as an agent of global <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/erathication-definition">enthalpy</a>. All that means is that the methane we release right now matters the most right now. Makes right now a great time to go around <a href="https://www.npr.org/2022/10/04/1126562195/the-nord-stream-pipelines-have-stopped-leaking-but-the-methane-emitted-broke-rec">blowing up pipelines under the Baltic Sea</a>.</p><p>As we will see in later chapters that show the narrative thread between fracking, LNG, and the war in Ukraine, Methane will be the driving force of the 21st century as an object of and an occasion for war. Also, it will trigger the next big surge in erathication. The final bombogenesis of the storm will happen in a world where humanity no longer can effect it with its actions, because thawing ecosystems are belching out methane at an enormous rate. All will finally be forced to give up the dream of a decarbonized capitalism that was so virulently opposed at the time when it would have still made a difference.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/832/0*mD81Y-04gvSifMpg.png" /></figure><p><em>most sources linked, except:</em></p><p>Charles Blanchard, <em>The Extraction State: A History of Natural Gas in America</em>, University of Pittsburgh, 2020.</p><p>Daniel Yergin, <em>The Prize</em> (is where the thing about being able to read at midnight in East Texas came from)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31c9abf2d1b9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/digestions-end-31c9abf2d1b9">Digestion’s End</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Answer to Petrocapitalism is Petrocommunism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/the-answer-to-petrocapitalism-is-petrocommunism-2a6405ce1371?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a6405ce1371</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oil]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Sep 2023 17:57:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-06T17:57:02.550Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Everyone knows that the goal of the people’s revolution must be to seize the means of production. Energy is a key means of production. No one buys a gallon of gasoline because it smells good: fuel is combined with human labor to accelerate productive output. It must be seized.</p><p>So, the revolution will declare itself the sole owner of all the earth’s coal, oil, and flammable gas. It becomes illegal to sell fossil fuel energy except by the government monopoly, governed by a bureaucracy that is able to use the science of central planning to allocate the rest of our “carbon budget” to where it is needed the most. Companies, restructured to be employee owned and controlled, can provide the Oil Ministry with services and infrastructure, but they can’t own what’s inside the pipeline. That’s owned by all the people, the state. As a product of oil, all plastic. If it’s made out of plastic, then you can own its shape, intellectual property, and metadata, but the government owns the underlying material. And so on as necessary.</p><p>This is necessary because although there is no scarcity of these commodities, we need to be able to cap their use. The sooner and more drastically we can decrease energy combustion, the better. The market is unable to make fuel expensive enough to reflect its true costs. Only the people can. There will be hardships. Everyone and every employee-owned company will be allocated a daily energy minimum, and everyone will be subject to <a href="https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/01/how-much-energy-do-we-need/">energy maximums</a>.<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-solution-to-petrocapitalism-is?utm_source=profile&amp;utm_medium=reader2#footnote-1-136608268">1</a></p><p>People will have to re-shape their lives and will be forced to return to the <a href="https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/">wealth of technologies</a> developed over the two thousand somatic years of human history. Solarpunk can be curated, but energy scarcity will also result in true suffering: heat deaths and famines in the heart of the metropole, endured by all to give the rest of the world their share of a greatly-limited carbon budget. That kind of suffering may be coming no matter what, but still, people will only submit to energy rationing under threat of force. We will need a coherent and disciplined People’s Party backed by a low-tech but effective People’s Army. The first thing that means is resisting American imperialism, even if that means supporting <a href="https://rainershea.substack.com/p/the-class-struggle-can-only-be-won">post-Soviet Russia</a>, and embracing a multipolar world that allows <a href="https://rainershea.substack.com/p/ongoing-successes-of-the-russia-china">China</a> to lead.</p><p>It will be legal and perhaps even profitable to privately buy and sell electrons generated by other means, creating a hybrid energy market on the model of the New Economic Policy. This industry will be tightly regulated, supervised, and price controlled. Those regulations will limit use of chemical batteries, preferring compressed air storage. Individuals and collectives will still be subject to daily energy maximums, which can be modified according to need, with an awareness of historical injustice perpetrated by capitalist imperialism.</p><p>Don’t worry; it won’t happen. I see almost no points of vulnerability in petropower. The denial machine is <a href="https://cssn.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Brulle2021_Article_ObstructingActionFoundationFun.pdf">heavily funded</a> and surprisingly effective. They have now mobilized a magical psyop machine that has even infected the <a href="https://ohiobarbarian.substack.com/p/the-climate-defiance-disruption-of">Left</a> and seems to be <a href="https://michaelalewis.substack.com/p/poverty-war-and-climate-change/comment/39317241#comment-39367731?utm_source=activity_item">endemic </a>on this accursed <a href="https://envmental.substack.com/">platform</a>. If you don’t believe the world is warming, I am prepared to fight you in the comments.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*ej0YEZmKw_RNHwcq.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-solution-to-petrocapitalism-is?utm_source=profile&amp;utm_medium=reader2#footnote-anchor-1-136608268">1</a></p><p>Shout out to <a href="https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/">Low Tech Magazine</a>. Read it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a6405ce1371" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/the-answer-to-petrocapitalism-is-petrocommunism-2a6405ce1371">The Answer to Petrocapitalism is Petrocommunism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Global Warming is the Punchline to History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/global-warming-is-the-punchline-to-history-514f5cfe3a07?source=rss----32648684c27e---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/514f5cfe3a07</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[global-warming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[petrohistory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[petroleum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jed]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Aug 2023 14:50:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-16T14:50:21.187Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>so the setup is key.</h3><p>James Joyce was out with his brother on the streets of Dublin when he pointed out a man who had just dodged out of the way of an oncoming tram. Imagine, he said, if he had not moved, had just stood there and been run over and killed. Suddenly, his every action, every object he left behind in the world, would become imbued with a significance, a narrative: a slow build up to that moment of decision…or was it indecision?* Death brings meaning where before there were just facts. Death binds life into narrative. Especially if that it was a suicide. This is true of individuals and of collectives.</p><p>Collectively,<a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon#details"> our death will have been a suicide</a>. And that makes the story of just how it happened more interesting. More interesting than making observations and then debating those observations. Not because the climate broadly speaking is uninteresting — all complex systems are hypnotizing, once you begin looking closely — but because your observations or opinions about those observations don’t change the physical reality. I prefer to ground my study in the material. The <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/benzin-al-jinn"><em>things</em></a> caused it: coal, oil, and methane.</p><p>If global warming is our collective Death (as opposed to nuclear weapons), then the <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/10/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-two/">cause-of-death</a> will be the <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2023/04/22/nitrogen/">white men</a> about <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/plastication#details">whom</a> I <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/hydrocarbon-corpse-juice-main-part">write</a>. More specifically, their <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2023/04/22/nitrogen/">will to power</a>: what they did to achieve power, exactly what assets they commanded, and how they deployed those assets to kill and create and kill again the world we now live in. Most of these men were motivated entirely by their own personal greed, their pursuit of personal gain.</p><p><a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/08/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-one/">Despite</a> the <a href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/cyclonopedia-complicity-with-anonymous-materials-reza-negarestani/10470055?ean=9780980544008">Negarestani</a> quote, “Capitalism was here even before human existence, waiting for a host,” I do not think that all this was over-determined. Yes, the oil was waiting for us beneath the ground the whole time, and yes, capitalism is deeply entangled with oil. But it is not by an entropic settling into most-likely scenarios that form the narrative shapes of the 20th century, but rather massively destructive expenditures of energy and labor. The <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/hydrocarbon-corpse-juice-main-part">petrolocized</a> world could not have been afforded if left entirely up to private markets and economic logic: <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/10/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-two/">it required a nationalist orgy of violence</a> that lasted forty-odd years.</p><p>By that I mean, the flows of the industrialized world require massive initial investments in physical infrastructure. That initial cost could not have been borne by the private capital of the day. Before the War, neither the oil nor the gas men were willing to build the long pipelines needed to connect the supply of oil and gas in the southwest to the markets in the northeast. Those pipelines required public budgets, public money. They were called the Big Inch and the Little Inch, the latter terminating at <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/hydrocarbon-corpse-juice-main-part">Beaumont</a>(Patillo Higgens’ hometown). And so they required the World Wars. It was war, not free market capitalism, that brought Oil to the throne of history. The Invisible Hand turned out to be quite visible and extremely violent.</p><p>I believe that one of oil’s attributes is agency, or at least certainly <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/08/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-one/">actancy</a>. But people including <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/footnotes-to-apocon-article">Andreas Malm</a> want to believe that only humans can really have agency, or, when feeling charitable, animals. For them, the warming itself, the change of climate, is an “unintended consequence” of industrial <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/10/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-two/">history</a>. For them, the moral equation changed at the <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/benzin-al-jinn">moment the humans became aware</a> of this unintended consequence; at that point, we should have tried to <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/the-dialectics-of-liberal-environmentalism">stop burning oil to prevent</a> the worst of global warming. That would have been nice, had that happened. The intended consequence, that would imply, was maximally corrupted global capitalism.</p><p>The most <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/hydrocarbon-corpse-juice-main-part">direct actants upon the climate are the carbon-bearing molecules in the atmosphere, driving the planet towards a specific heat-death</a>. Whether by coincidence or intent — my argument is the latter, but it doesn’t matter — fuel <em>is</em> pushing the biosphere towards another iteration of the planetary regime of when the stuff was last actually alive 360 million years ago, when, as will always be mentioned first in this type of article, the sea levels were 120 meters above their current level. All of the water that constituted that pre-pangea ocean is still here on this earth, and the portion of it that is currently frozen will not be forever, now that the warming has taken hold in earnest. Much of the land that remains unflooded will become desert. The interface zone between these landscapes will be salt marshes, where the remaining terrestrial life will thrive, perhaps including recognizable humans, metabolizing the pollutants of our own century, so fecund that the vegetation could become thick enough to become, following its own eventual descent into the earth plus another 360 million years, petroleum again.</p><blockquote><em>“Archaic memories of the terrifying jungles of the Paleocene, when reptiles had gone down before the emergent mammals, and sense the implacable hatred one zoological class feels towards another that usurps it.” (J.G. Ballard, </em>The Drowned World<em>, 29)</em></blockquote><p>Is that what It is after, Its driving desire? A return to a paleozoic climate? Or is it, as Negarestani says, “the Tellurian Omega through which the Earth reaches utter immanence with the burning core of itself and the Sun” (104)? Scientifically speaking, that is the way the Earth will end — but does that eventual final heat death have anything to do with this current unnatural global heatwave?</p><p>Every single combustion from the 1860s onward has contributed to the accumulation of carbon dioxide, before and after awareness of that fact dawned upon human animals. A much greater portion of the carbon in the air dates from after the truth was known. The intended and unintended consequences cannot be differentiated, any more than a drug’s effects can be differentiated from its side effects.</p><p>The thing that ignited and fed oil’s endless flame has always been the military-industrial complex. This must be understood in historically specific terms, rather than taking a constant refuge in theory. The “deep state” has created a circumstance in which our interests, as humans, are firmly subordinate to those of oil and its <a href="https://thespouter.substack.com/p/plastication#details">creatures</a>.</p><p>As the billboard proclaims, “it’s not too late to do <em>something</em> about global warming, but later will be too late.” Perhaps it is already too late; I am not the arbiter of that decision. We urgently need to resubordinate oil to the needs of humans. We need the power to make global, collective, (communist) decisions about who gets to burn oil, and why. Only with that power can we pursue policies like climate reparations. The goal, therefore, must be to weaken the petrological agents that have seized control of our politics. The sad reality, though is that the revolution is more likely to come in retribution for the coming catastrophes; it will not arrive in time to be preventative.</p><p>This was not historically inevitable. That is why They had to kill Albert Parsons, <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2023/04/22/nitrogen/">Clara Immerwahr</a>, Joe Hill, Subhas Chandra Bose, Mohandas Gandhi, Ruben Um Nyobè, Barthélemy Boganda, Adriano Olivetti, Joseph Bamina, Patrice Lumumba, Rafael Trujillo, Dag Hammarskjöld, Ngô Đình Diệm, John F. Kennedy, Malcolm X, Mehdi Ben Barka, Ahmadu Ibrahim Bello, Richard Fariña, Che Guevara, Martin Luther King, Jr., Robert Kennedy, Eduardo Mondlane, Fred Hampton, Walter Reuther, Sukarno, Jimi Hendrix, Abdel Nasser, Salvador Allende, Aldo Moro, Ali Soilih M’Tsashiwa, Park Chung-hee, Hafizullah Amin, William Tolbert, Josip Tito, Anwar Sadat, Olof Palme, Thomas Sankara, Huey Newton, Agathe Uwilingiyimana, Ken Saro-Wiwa, Tupac Shakur, Mark Lombardi, Paul Wellstone, Benazir Bhutto, Muammar Gaddafi, Young Dolph, and millions of others.</p><p>As a punchline to all that, <em>Global Warming!</em> lacks a certain wit; perhaps in the hands of a <a href="https://gravitysrainbow.substack.com/">more capable writer</a>, it would be funnier. It does feel very stupid. It also feels very stupid, and immaterial, that there are still so many people in denial about it. There’s really not that much to say about it, but most of what is worth saying is <a href="https://apocalypse-confidential.com/2022/09/10/the-autonomous-chemical-weapon-how-sentient-oil-took-control-of-our-history-part-two/">history</a>.</p><p>*Richard Ellman, <em>James Joyce</em>, page 163. It is not made explicit that the hypothetical tram death was a suicide, but it could have been.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eh_8VnTT09F4xbV_.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=514f5cfe3a07" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine/global-warming-is-the-punchline-to-history-514f5cfe3a07">Global Warming is the Punchline to History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-spouter-magazine">The Spouter Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>