<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Together in Dignity - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[“Together in Dignity” brings together bloggers from four continents to reflect on a world without poverty and respectful of human rights and dignity. Inspired by the daily struggles of people living in poverty, we work to change perspectives on the world. - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 11:21:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/together-in-dignity" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mobile School Stolipinovo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/mobile-stolipinovo-school-e903cbc6c266?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e903cbc6c266</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bulgaria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stolipinovo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Jun 2024 11:36:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-20T14:14:46.478Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*IJ8sp8aB7XCZ46bswDhIFQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>In 2015, ATD Fourth World sent two Volunteer Corps members to settle in Southeast Europe. This was in an effort to better understand the countries there and learn more about the experiences of the people living in poverty and those who work alongside them. It was here that we, Véronique and Benoît, took steps that let us discover the impressive commitment and solidarity that exists among those living in the most difficult situations in Bulgaria.</p><p><strong>The Success</strong></p><p>In Stolipinovo, a very segregated neighbourhood in Plovdiv, Bulgaria, we became part of the development of an educational and knowledge-sharing initiative, in the street, named the “Mobile School Stolipinovo”. Established in 2015, the mobile school ran until the end of 2023. During that time, the Mobile school successfully formed an inclusive educational community.. It benefited not just the children but the neighbourhood as a whole, bringing together school teachers, families, other members of the community, and other supportive persons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/1*oWQZ-MIdxxV8AuS5EBlobA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Context</strong></p><p><strong>Joining those committed to the cause (Spring 2015)</strong></p><p>On arriving in Bulgaria, we decided to join those who were already involved in work to overcome poverty. We lived and worked alongside them, learning from their initiatives. It was through them that we were able to connect with those living in the most difficult situations in Bulgaria. This was knowledge we wanted to share with the rest of Europe as the experiences of those in Southeast Europe are largely unknown.</p><p>We went at the pace of those committed to overcoming extreme poverty. We travelled by bus and were housed by them, which also gave us the time to get to know them better. We met many of their friends. Together we had long discussions which helped them gain a deeper understanding of what we were hoping to achieve. It was during one of these discussions that one of our hosts spoke to us about Genika Baycheva, a young woman whom she had once met, who was looking at access to culture as a means to overcoming prejudices and poverty.</p><p>Genika immediately agreed to meet us. After training in cultural mediation, she settled in Plovdiv and worked in the “Plovdiv 2019 Foundation” team, which led the city to be selected as one of two European capitals of culture in 2019. The motto of this ambitious program was “Together”, aimed at involving the largest possible number of residents from all the neighbourhoods of Plovdiv in the events to come. To signify their determination, the choice was made to develop the initiative in the largest segregated neighbourhood in the city of Plovdiv, in all of Bulgaria and the Balkan region: Stolipinovo.</p><p>Eventually, Genika chose to leave the team, not seeing how this initial intention to involve the residents of discriminated neighbourhoods would be put into practice. However, she continued to personally invest herself in the participation of all the inhabitants of Plovdiv, and in particular, Stolipinovo.</p><p>With a few young friends, who, like her, continued living and involving themselves in their country</p><p>(Nikola, with a doctorate in anthropology; Rossi, a young law graduate; and Dimitar, with a doctorate in sociology), she wanted to create ties with the residents of Stolipinovo. They would give themselves as much time as they needed to understand the community without the pressure of a deadline for presenting conclusive results.</p><p>Very quickly after our installation in Bulgaria in 2015, we began accompanying Genika and her friends on their explorations of Stolipinovo.</p><p><strong>The Neighbourhood</strong></p><p>Plovdiv is the second largest city in the country. At the beginning of the 20th century, a village was created north-east of Plovdiv to forcefully settle the Turkophone population, who had been driven out of the city centre, along with the Romani-speaking population. During the period of communism, 8-story buildings were built to house the poor populations of all origins. Though, after the fall of communism in 1991, certain mayors authorised families arriving from villages to settle in the informal housings or shacks, at the base of buildings, or in shared gardens. It’s Stoliponovo!</p><p>The history of this neighbourhood is reflected in its current diversity. Today, it is a large neighbourhood with 50,000 residents or more (no one knows precisely), composed of many sub-neighbourhoods. At least 80% of the inhabitants identify as Turkish-speaking gypsies, and around 15% identify as Roma and speak Romani. Others are originally from the Bulgarian majority or from other minorities. Their common ground is living in poverty — extreme poverty for some — but above all having experienced discrimination. Stolipinovo is an outlying district, segregated since its creation and neglected since the fall of communism.</p><p>The buildings are all severely run-down. Beyond the fourth floor, there is very little running tap water, a dribble at best. The sewers don’t always work. In some buildings, the cellars are flooded, and the structure of the building threatened. Some flats are very well maintained, others less so.</p><p>At the base of some buildings, small houses have been added, sometimes made from bricks and scraps. These are often used as spaces for small businesses, such as coffee kiosks.</p><p>There are also two improvised barracks areas (the correct term for slums) at the northern district, Kanal, and western district, Shumen. Some shacks in these housing zones are built of stone or brick, while others are made with wood, plastic, or cardboard. These shacks are often made up of one or two rooms for an entire family.</p><p>Generally speaking, the neighbourhood has been completely politically and administratively abandoned for the past 30 years. Small repairs have been made here and there, but no vision of urban development has been established. Consequently, the area has become increasingly run-down. The most blatant example of this is how the rubbish is handled. While the population in Stolipinovo is much larger than in the city centre, there are far fewer rubbish bins, and they are collected half as often. As a result, waste accumulates and remains on the ground.</p><p>As Bérul, a local carpenter, explained to us: “Politicians are purposefully leaving this neighbourhood in this state so that we are singled out.”</p><p>In Bulgaria, there are many negative prejudices towards minorities, even more so towards the residents of Stolipinovo, so much so that the media refers to the area as a “jungle”. It is unusual for young people from the city centre to come to this neighbourhood. Certain young people hide their involvement in the neighbourhood from their friends and family.</p><p><strong>The Beginning: Taking the time to get to know the inhabitants (September 2015-December 2017)</strong></p><p>When the weather was nice, the neighbourhood was quite lively. Many inhabitants were out and about, engaged in activities, talking to their neighbours, and exchanging news. You could often find people sat together on plastic chairs in little groups. The inhabitants are used to bringing their own chairs out to sit with others and chat together.</p><p>At the International Architecture Festival, which takes place each summer in Plovdiv, a Dutch artist was surprised by how the locals engage in conversation. During the week of the festival, she invited the participants of her workshop to interact with the residents of Stolipinovo, by walking around with a plastic chair to sit and converse as they do in the neighbourhood.</p><p>Genika, Nikola, and Rossi participated in that workshop, sitting on their plastic chairs to meet and talk with the residents of the neighbourhood. At the end of each discussion, they were asked to write key words or phrases from the discussions on the chairs. As the meetings progressed, <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/a-total-change-of-perspective/">the chairs were covered by phrases</a> such as:</p><p>“<em>I didn’t have shoes, clothes to study.”</em></p><p>“<em>Education is everything. There are smart people around here.”</em></p><p>“<em>Our biggest problems are the electricity, the water and the registration, the documents.”</em></p><p>From all these phrases, a rap was born, written and performed by the youth of the area.</p><p>This first initiative of writing a song together helped us build trust with the residents and allowed us to team up with Genika, Nikola, and Rossi. As a team we agreed upon the objectives for our time together in Stolipinovo. We wanted to meet the residents of this neighbourhood, to get to know them, and to involve them in improving the image of the neighbourhood and life within it. One of our motivations was to allow the district to be integrated into the whole process of making ‘Plovdiv 2019 — European Capital of Culture: Plovdiv “Together”’ a success, with all its inhabitants around the cultural initiatives.</p><p>With these goals in mind, we decided to continue building relationships of trust with residents using the “chair method”. There were six of us “strangers in the neighbourhood”, travelling around in two groups, one day a week. Being the oldest members of the team, we (Benoît and Véronique) provided a certain degree of security. This also helped in building trust with all the generations in the neighbourhood. Genika, Nikola and Rossi translated what the residents were saying for us, which was no small feat! But, as far as the locals were concerned, we were all “strangers to the neighbourhood”, Bulgarian or French, it didn’t matter. We felt this particularly when we met children and young people who didn’t always speak Bulgarian, but a Turkish dialect. After all, Turkish is the mother tongue of 85% of the neighbourhood’s inhabitants.</p><p>Simply spending time walking through this big neighbourhood was disorientating. We discovered that this is an area full of life and activity. A wealthier part of the district is made up of artisans, particularly blacksmiths. There are also barbers and plenty of shops related to weddings and parties. Other trades are more informal, such as street cooking or selling various recovered items, sometimes transported with the help of an old stroller. Others cut wood pallets into small pieces and sell them for firewood. Some collect anything that can be burnt, and salvage anything useful from rubbish bins. Another activity consists of collecting copper wire, untwisting it and then burning the plastic covering releasing many odours.</p><p>Some people have entry-level salary jobs, either working as garbage collectors or cleaners for the town or in factories in the region. The wages are very low and are not enough to support a family, but do provide health insurance for the whole family.</p><p>After each period spent in the neighbourhood, we spent time debriefing, so that we could tell each other what we had learnt and reflect upon how to move forward. Genika counted on us to provide hindsight for the team.</p><p>We began to regularly meet Nadia and Kamelia, who were always present at the entrance of their building, Berul and Nasco, who were both in their wood and glass workshops, Chenere, the barber, Mitko known as “the Chinese”, Vasko and Artin, youths from the neighbourhood. Later, there was Mamik at Kanal and Assen, Elena, Yanka and Todor at Shumen. They were reference points for us and allowed us to meet even more people that they knew.</p><p>In the spring of 2016, Mitko “the Chinese”, a 20-year-old resident of the area, introduced us to what he considered to be the most impoverished part of the neighbourhood. There was no running water and often no electricity, just extension cords on wooden sticks running for several hundred metres around buildings. Homes often consisted of a single room for the family. When it rained, it was difficult to get around the alleyways because of the mud and the enormous puddles. These were the two improvised housing areas, Shumen and Kanal.</p><p>We couldn’t go into Shumen or Kanal with the plastic chairs. After all, the inhabitants of these areas didn’t have any. Instead, they often sat on the ground on stones. So, we asked Bérul, our carpenter friend, to make us wooden blocks. This was also a way of getting him involved in the activity with us. It was with these yellow cubes that we went to meet the inhabitants of these informal housing areas. We did not sit on the cubes but would write on them after our discussions. The children also came to draw on them. It was through these discussions that we met Assen and little by little, he eventually became our contact person.</p><p>Our presence in the neighbourhood allowed us to share happy and sad moments with the residents. We were invited to family celebrations such as engagements, weddings and circumcisions. It was quite impressive to see the neighbourhood transform and embellish itself during these celebrations. We also witnessed the difficulties of raising money to send someone to the hospital, or to buy medicine, or even housing problems leading to evictions.</p><p><strong>The question of access to school</strong></p><p>As our meetings with residents progressed, the question of access to school and education became increasingly central to our conversations.</p><p>In Shumen, a man told us <em>“My daughter is eleven years old, in year 6, and only knows how to write her name. But she passes from one year to the next. School is difficult for the children because they do not speak Bulgarian and the teachers don’t look after them. The teachers collect their salaries and that’s all. They are not interested in their work.”</em></p><p>We thought the matter might be more complicated than that. By meeting the teachers, we discovered that they were very poorly paid, with some having only having been trained with old schooling methods, and that they had to deal with lots of administrative and hierarchical constraints. On top of this, they have not been trained to teach students who do not speak Bulgarian when they start school.</p><p>Bulgaria’s education system is highly criticised. This concerns all children, but the consequences are magnified in neighbourhoods like Stolipinovo, where families face an accumulation of difficulties.</p><p>People spoke to us about the importance of education. Another father told us, <em>“I want all my children to learn at school, to stop living as we do now.”</em></p><p>Over time we also noticed that very few children went to school regularly. Some didn’t even have school bags, just a notepad in their pocket with almost nothing written in it. Several 8 and 9-year-old children barely knew their Cyrillic alphabet.</p><p>This did not necessarily mean the children received no education. On the contrary, during our time there we learnt about the many skills and values of solidarity that exist in the neighbourhood which are passed on to the children. Unfortunately, this tradition of knowledge transmission is often overlooked by the majority of Bulgarians, and the school system. For example, Assen used to be paid under the table for work on building sites. He took his 15-year-old son there for a day to learn about the work. But the teachers reproached him because his son had missed school. For Assen, it was important, but he couldn’t explain why.</p><p>Petar and Stefan were 11-year-old twin brothers. When we would pass them, they always said ‘I’m working!’. They were very proud of their ability to ride a neighbour’s horse. They often carried wheelbarrows with rubble or helped with building a brick wall. They were simply proud to contribute what they could to the work of their families. They never went to school, but Petar would take time off whenever he could to attend the “Mobile School Stolipinovo”.</p><p>We also observed that on birthdays all the children in the neighbourhood received a slice of cake with no visible difference between them. Similarly, some Muslim residents gave the children cakes or juice every Friday. While speaking with the adults, they told us that this was normal for them: ‘Fridays are for giving’.</p><p>These preliminary observations and reflections made us realise that we needed to continue working on the issue of education through a concrete initiative. Drawing on what we had learned with the parents, we hypothesised that a school that engaged with children as closely as possible through their living environment, seeking to recognise and build on their pride in their work and their values of solidarity and collaboration, could reconcile families and the neighbourhood with the school.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*m8XlaqPyLvduvm8TdRqSYQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>The basics of the Mobile School</strong></p><p>Genika, Nikola, Dimitar and ourselves had acquired a deep understanding and shared knowledge of the neighbourhood which was strengthened by the respect we earned from our interactions with the residents. The Plovdiv 2019 Foundation team then asked us to help run a week of workshops to prepare for future cultural events in the Stolipinovo district, in the run-up to ‘Plovdiv, European Capital of Culture’.</p><p>This week of workshops was a time for reflection and development of artistic projects for the ‘Plovdiv 2019’ project. We spent 6 days together, during which our team was responsible for presenting the results of the work to a group of around twenty architects and artists (Bulgarians, French, Germans, Belgians and Italians), and helping the participants discover Stolipinovo. This workshop gave us an opportunity to meet other people who wanted to get involved, even if they didn’t yet know how. This is how we met Magdalina Rajeva (Magi) and Anna Kalinova (Ani), both architects, who went on to become pillars of the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” and its initiatives.</p><p>Magi and Ani used to run an architectural workshop for children, making 3D constructions from various materials, or using paper and cardboard on small scale models. They primarily did this in wealthy schools in Sofia. Magi was the founder of an architectural workshop association for children in Bulgaria.</p><p>In the meantime, Genika, Dimitar, Rossi and Nikola also set up an association, as suggested by donors who told them it was the only way to gain recognition. The association was called Discovered Spaces.</p><p>After several weeks of dialogue, our three associations (‘Architectural Workshops for Children’, ‘Discovered Spaces’ and ATD Fourth World) submitted a project to the Plovdiv Foundation 2019 entitled ‘Mobile School Stolipinovo, discovering and releasing hidden potential’.</p><p>We were three associations, but one team.</p><p>We, Véronique and Benoît, gradually realised that Stolipinovo was exactly where we needed to be to truly understand and address the reality of poverty in Bulgaria. Through the team we had become a part of we got to learn about the action of other as well as contribute our own knowledge and experience. Eventually this is also what allowed us to become part of a major cultural project in the country: ‘Plovdiv 2019, Together’.</p><p>This was a tremendous asset in our first years in Bulgaria and something we could not have come to on our own.</p><p><strong>Mobile School Stolipinovo (January 2018 — July 2023)</strong></p><p>We chose to get involved in one of the two improvised housing areas, Shumen. From January to March, Genika and Nikola and us took time to visit all the parts of Shumen. We brainstormed with the parents we knew there on ways to get the mobile school initiative off the ground. They told us about their children, their concerns and school. We told them about our proposal to organise an outdoor activity for the children. We soon realised that until we started our program the parents could only see it as a vague concept.</p><p>In March 2018, the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” began with Magi, Ani, Genika, Nikola, Dimitar and us. Others became involved as we went on: Maria Dacheva, a photographer, students from Sofia or Plovdiv, friends of friends (Hannah, Maria…), and others after 2020.</p><p>From the beginning, we relied on Assen. While he didn’t take on a leadership role, or impose himself too greatly into the program, he became a friend of the team. That’s how he described himself. He worked intermittently, though when he was around, he’d come say hello or we’d go and talk to him. We often asked him for advice, and he also introduced us to others.</p><p><strong>The activities</strong></p><p>Once a week, we would begin by picking up the children from different parts of the area, while Magi and Ani set up the tables and equipment. We offered the children various individual and group activites. The activities encouraged them to create 3D models by exploring and playing with all kinds of materials: paper, cardboard, wood, clay, thread, crayons, etc.</p><p>Over the years, the children created a variety of geometric figures with wooden sticks, built castles out of cardboard, created a 3D map of the city, built Gaudi-style mud constructions and Leonardo da Vinci’s bridge at full scale, constructed sculptures using long bamboo sticks, cloth or large pieces of wood, and made wooden stools with the help of Berul.</p><p>As a result of the manual work they did in the architecture workshop, the children learnt how to communicate and work with each other, while also learning new manual and problem-solving skills. Some of the parents came to watch what was happening, and some young people too. They were interested and even participated from time to time.</p><p>The number of children who took part varied between 20 and 40, and on some occasions, there were as many as 60 children, and adults.</p><p><strong>Adjustments and readjustments to the framework</strong></p><p>Since the ages of the children ranged from 2 to 18, we initially thought that we should offer activities for all ages. In reality, what was most interesting was to propose two activities, without determining in advance who was going to do what. Older children sometimes took activities that had been designed for younger children very seriously. The fact that more than half the children didn’t go to school made them extremely curious, but also meant that there was no age limit to the activities.</p><p>We tried to create structure, but it wasn’t always easy. We also very quickly realised that we needed to offer time for sports for children who needed to move around. For some children, it was difficult to concentrate for more than 15 minutes on a manual activity. The best thing was to have a large skipping rope (5 metres) that 1 to 8 children could jump on at the same time. Afterwards, they returned to their manual activities or books.</p><p>We also realised that the most important thing was what happened during the activity, not so much the “finished product” the children could go home with at the end. In fact, the children had nowhere to put their work at home. More often than not, the models were destroyed at the end of the workshop.</p><p><strong>Going inside in winter</strong></p><p>Plovdiv is a city in southern Bulgaria, with a rather mild winter. But on two occasions, we had snow for 3 weeks. Unheard of!</p><p>The first winter, we looked for a place to set up without having to cross a street. It was a request from the parents with whom we had spoken. The owner of a restaurant behind the Shumen</p><p>district agreed to let us use his room every week. It was a modest room with 3 large tables which suited us very well. To obtain permission to bring the children to the ‘restaurant’, we had to be in</p><p>much closer contact with the parents. After the first session, the owner told us that he was going to look for other children to join: the ones who had come were barefoot! We explained to him that it was precisely the children who didn’t go to school that we wanted to work with.</p><p>Being in a room slightly changed the dynamics of the group. The activity was generally calmer than when it took place outside, and the children could sit down. After this experience, we needed to reflect with the whole “Mobile School Stolipinovo” team on the benefits we gained from setting up the school outside, in the middle of neighbourhood life. Eventually we found a middle ground between both options.</p><p>After the first winter, in March 2019, when we returned to the street, Magi had the idea of buying</p><p>a second folding table and 4 folding benches to allow the children to be calmer with what they were doing. This was also an opportunity to involve a local craftsman, who let us store the tables and benches that we used.</p><p><strong>Building a team together</strong></p><p>A few months after the start of the “Mobile School Stolipinovo”, a blanket with books was added. We had wanted to do this for a while, but we stuck to our strategy of moving at the pace of our friends. Genika felt that the reading activities should complement, not compete with, the hands-on artistic activities. So it was a good idea to bring out the books once we had launched the initial artistic activities. From then we ran both activities together. The big blanket, where the reading activity took place, became a quiet space, respected by the children, who took off their shoes before sitting on it. There, they discovered whole new worlds in the pages of the books.</p><p><strong>Finding our rightful place</strong></p><p>At the beginning, Ani and Magi wanted the living conditions in the neighbourhood to change quickly. This was the subject of many discussions between us. In particular, they confronted the local council to find solutions for collecting the rubbish, which was invading the whole area.</p><p>They were turned down by the local council, owing to a lack of political will. Tackling the waste problem in Stolipinovo would have been a completely different project. We had to realise that we were not here to change people, but to work with them, to offer opportunities that may or may not be seized. This is how Kalin, a health mediator from another extremely impoverished district of Bulgaria, put it to us. Realising was frustrating, but it also allowed us to stay focused on what we set out to accomplish. Nevertheless, the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” brought about many changes.</p><p>Ani often told us that we taught her patience and also the taste and ways of working with others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*qGcgX--19D01F1_tvtfoeA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Involvement of the local teachers in the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” (October 2019)</h3><p><strong>The International Workshop: a snapshot</strong></p><p>To share our experience of the “Mobile School Stolipinovo”, and to discover what others thought of it, <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/workshop-2019-in-plovdiv-inclusive-education-for-all/">we organised an international workshop in Plovdiv</a>. Over the course of several days in 2019, the event brought members of ATD Fourth World from France and Belgium together with people involved in education from Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary and Serbia.</p><p>Workshop participants shared information about how to improve relationships between parents and teachers based on their own practical experience (e.g. from the Alternative Education Club in Bucharest in Romania, or from the project to improve links between school and home in the Fives area of Lille in France).</p><p>These exchanges again convinced us that it was essential to create an environment in which teachers and parents trusted one another, and that to do so, would require mediators. From the experiences we shared it was clear that meeting the challenge of education for all has to be a joint effort which takes advantage of the knowledge of parents, grandparents and neighbourhood residents; the expertise of the teachers; and the involvement of other partners. Taking part in the workshop made everyone involved in running the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” realise that we had to put effort into developing a good relationship with the local teachers. So that was our next move.</p><p>We made contact with Rossi Zlateva via ‘Teach for Bulgaria’, an NGO which offers trainees a two-year programme of support to become teachers, with a number of them going on to work in mainstream education. We had been in touch with them at the national level for three years but without making any local contacts. But after the workshop we finally did so by meeting Rossi. She taught maths at the Pencho Slaveykov school, which was the closest one to the shacks in Shumen. We told her all about the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” that we had been running for 18 months. We explained that we were looking for teachers to get involved by taking part in our weekly open-air sessions.</p><p>Rossi came on board and introduced us to four other teachers from her school. We first took them on a visit to the informal settlements which was not easy for them or for us. It showed the teachers first hand just what it is like to live there. Their initial response was to reprimand the parents for not sending their children to school and so we had to make certain things clear. We explained that if they were going to work with us, they would have to ignore the usual rule that a teacher had to report to the authorities any parent who ignored three consecutive requests to send a child to school. They accepted. We also asked them to think carefully about the ways in which they spoke to the parents and showed them how we did it. This initial interaction helped us understand why parent-teacher relations could be difficult and why it was not so easy to change them.</p><p>For the teachers to able to work with us we needed the consent of the school principal, as well as of the education authorities in Plovdiv. This was granted, which was a big step forward for us.</p><p>An important consideration for the school principal was the fact that Magi and Ani were involved in running the mobile school, as they were also facilitators of a workshop at her school. Another factor was that the project was built on the experience of an international movement. It was agreed that the teachers could, with the approval of their superiors, work in the informal settlements after school hours, that Rossi would report back on progress, and that the teachers would be paid a small supplement (as they are for any extra-curricular activities in which they take part at the school).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*Ku3AMFQU9aYiKHZRknTHBQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Mobile school twice a week</h3><p>Rossi wanted to offer open-air maths classes to children in the streets. Stefan, an art teacher at the school, was also keen to offer classes. So we decided to run the mobile school twice a week — once with Magi, and a second time with the teachers and Genika, who acted as a link to the local community, with Rossi taking part in both sessions. The emphasis of the classes was not on theory but instead on knowledge transfer and exchange through practice.</p><p>The teachers typically organised a practical activity, involving drawing, colouring, and cutting out, around a chosen theme (like “spring” or “space” or “letters of the alphabet”). The results were then combined by the older children into a big mural representing the collective effort of all the participants.</p><p>The teachers made a successful request to be allowed to use the school premises for the mobile school during the wet days of winter. The principal even agreed to let children who were not on the school roll into the classrooms — something which is not usually permitted for insurance reasons.</p><p>Luckily the winter of 2019 was quite mild, and we only had to use the school premises a few times. On the first occasion we were just about to go in with about 15 children from the informal settlements when two of the least privileged, Vasko and Ivo, suddenly froze. They could not bring themselves to cross the threshold. Instead, they turned tail and ran off. They were too scared to go in. Another time a mother agreed to let her son attend a workshop despite the fact that he did not usually go to school. But only for an hour, and only after a lot of hesitation.</p><h3>One team but with multiple personalities</h3><ul><li>One of our challenges was navigating the fact that we were one team, with members who had differing personalities and played a variety of roles. We moved forward together, but we reacted differently. We could not expect the teachers to behave as the rest of the team did. This much was clear when they showed up prepped in their city shows ready to venture into the squalor of the most deprived areas and engage with parents in a respectful way — even if they did sometimes end up raising their voice at them!</li></ul><p>On one occasion Benoit went with Rossi and Raflin (a new member of the team) to meet a mother and her daughter Maya who had expressed interest in going to school, only for Maya to say that she had changed her mind. Rossi told her in no uncertain terms, almost aggressively, that to go to school was her only way out of the mire. Benoit and Raflin were surprised by the strength of this reaction and had to step in to calm things down. We had a long chat about it afterwards, concluding that her status as a teacher allows Rossi to have such strong reactions, but that our different approach is a useful complement.</p><p>What we took from this is that the attitude of a teacher must not be allowed to stifle dialogue with parents and children.</p><p>We each had our own role. Magi and Ani provided a stable environment in which creativity could flourish. Their experience of architectural workshops for children meant they were excellent facilitators. Magi was the main point of contact for the children. For a long time, Magi was what they called any female member of the team!</p><p>Through Genika and Dimitar we were able to connect with Maria’s mother, with Assen, Yanka and Todor, and with many others.</p><p>As for us, Benoit and Véronique, we brought to the table our experience of ATD Fourth World programs and campaigns, together with a willingness to engage with parents and to allow ourselves to be guided by the children towards others with whom we had yet to reach out to. Something else that we advocated for was the importance of working together as a team, and we spent a lot of time on planning and debriefing.</p><p>We started debriefing sessions every week in which everyone took part in order to share problems and successes, to identify children that we needed to seek out at home, and so on. Nikola was instrumental in ensuring that the sessions were productive. Held in a local café in one of the more distant corners of the informal settlement they lasted an hour and a half each. When the teachers first got involved, we reviewed progress with them once a month.</p><h3>Festival of Talent-Sharing: a joint initiative with parents</h3><p>We organised a Festival of Talent-Sharing on three occasions, in October 2020, June 2021 and June 2022, inviting local parents, young people and artisans to take part by running workshops. Preparation took several weeks, in order to give facilitators time to specify what they needed, and for materials to be made ready, but it was time well spent.</p><p>We spread the word about the festivals widely. It was, amongst other things, an opportunity to engage with inhabitants who we knew less well, and to visit areas well off the beaten track. In so doing we discovered that a number of young people were living in the wastelands beyond the informal settlements: couples who did not speak Bulgarian well, if at all. We already knew one of them, a young man called Mitko. He now had a one-year-old child and had been living there since getting together with the mother.</p><p><strong>Successes</strong></p><p><strong>The creation of an inclusive educational community</strong></p><p>Looking at all the progress made with “Mobile School Stolipinovo”, we can say that we succeeded in creating an educational community for the children of Stolipinovo. The Mobile school not only brought together the teachers and families but also individuals from all walks of life, all involved in bettering the community. With our aim to reach all children, and all families, especially those most hidden, it was important to not be discouraged by the initial difficulties we encountered. Ultimately, this was an initiative that thrived because of the skills and aspirations of the neighbourhood residents. By recognizing the efforts of the parents and acknowledging the part they play in their community, we also allowed the children to be proud of their parents, and their environment. This self-esteem, this self-confidence, was necessary for learning.</p><p>It was at the 2019 international workshop in Plovdiv, during the sharing of initiatives, where this approach was formalized under the title of an ‘Inclusive Educational Community’.</p><p>When speaking about the mobile school to partners and other citizens in Bulgaria, people were impressed that it was possible to involve teachers in conducting outdoor workshops in the neighbourhood. This was the main success of this initiative.</p><p>Even though Genika eventually stopped being regularly involved, she said that the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” exceeded her expectations. She could never have imagined such a success: <em>“We managed to build a bridge between families and the school, for children who were not able to go to school. Conducting regular workshops is important for them. The connection we have built with parents, teachers, and the team is also important. Maybe one day we will have architects in Stolipinovo…”</em></p><p>For us, Benoît and Véronique, it was the journey we made together with all the participants that ensured the long-term success of this initiative. It changed us individually and collectively. Of course, the fact that teachers were involved was very impressive along with the other team members’ involvement. Seeing us regularly, even when it snowed, left a lasting impression on the parents. “You came when it was snowing!” One child also once exclaimed, “But why do you keep coming here? Sometimes, children don’t behave well, but you keep coming to us… No one does that.”</p><p><strong>The journey with the children</strong></p><p>Did the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” improved access to education for a large number of children? It’s not possible to define the significance of the initiative in these terms.</p><p>The mobile school sparked a desire to learn. Over time, several children and adolescents began to ask members of the team for support in learning. Sonia was 12–13 years old. She was shy and did not speak Bulgarian well. She asked Ani to teach her how to read and write. Ani tried to give her more attention. She wanted to meet Sonia’s mother and see what was possible after the workshop, but this proved difficult to achieve. Eventually, her parents separated and Sonia went to live with her mother in a village for over a year. When we saw her again, her life was different.</p><p>Some of the children who were not enrolled in school, came to the school premises for a workshop in the winter. Even Vasko and Ivo managed to overcome their apprehensions about entering the school. But this did not bring them closer to attending the school. The gap was still too large.</p><p>Rossi told us that some children would go to school the day after the workshop in the neighbourhood because, at the end of the workshop, she reminded them that there was school the next day. But on other days, it was not as straightforward.</p><p>Julia, another teacher, told us that she relied on Stefan, a 14-year-old who was still attending school. Stefan was like an ambassador to the younger children. He helped out during the workshop and helped the younger ones go to school. But we also knew that he only attended school occasionally, mainly the days after the workshop.</p><p>A child, thanks to Rossi, started school at the age of 9 with her grandmother’s permission. She entered the 1st grade when she should have been in the third grade. It was good and challenging at the same time. Will she be able to keep up?</p><p>The children and young people were very proud to see their teachers in the street. Young people aged 18–20 would pass by and greet them. However, others remained strangers. Gradually, contact between the teachers and parents was also established.</p><p>Elena, a mother, said:<em> “I don’t want to go to parent meetings. It’s not interesting, it’s useless. One of the problems is communication in Bulgarian. Every time, the teachers told me the same thing — that I have to speak Bulgarian with my children. When we go to parent meetings, we forget half of what the teachers said in Bulgarian before we even get home.”</em> But two years later, we saw her talking to the teachers during the workshops.</p><p>All the workshop facilitators had something to say about the progress made by some of the children.</p><p>For example Magi spoke about Vasko and Ivan, <em>“There is of course Vasko but also Ivan. I am proud of what he is doing today. Ivan, when he started, was very aggressive. Now, he likes to do everything we propose. When we suggest two activities, he wants to do both. For Vasko, it’s important to involve him, asking for his help with the younger ones. He needs to have real responsibility.”</em></p><p>Vasko drew out a lot of patience and ingenuity from all of us. It was always so beautiful to see him at 12–13 years old helping with the younger ones. He even advised us in the building of the workshops.</p><p><strong>The journey with adults</strong></p><p>Yanka, a mother of 8, often came to tell us that she appreciated everything we were doing. She often had a lot to do to provide for her family. But some days, she would stop and take time for herself to participate in the workshop.</p><p>It was also a moment of creation for her, and it was beautiful to see her apply herself. At times, she helped the younger ones with what they were doing. She also told us she wanted to help us, even though she did not have the time. We suggested that she should lead a workshop during the shared talent festivals. She chose what she wanted to do: manicures and hairstyles for girls. She was very conscientious in what she did and was able to lead her workshop well.</p><p>Edris’ grandmother was also often present. She came regularly with her grandson, finding him too young to leave on his own. Then she also started helping other children and found her place in the workshop. When her health prevented her from coming, her husband took over, even though he was more reserved.</p><p>One way of involving parents was by offering parent-child activities such as building stools. This, in particular, motivated everyone. These stools were prepared with Bérul, our carpenter friend from the neighbourhood. <em>“Some people say that our neighbourhood is the toughest, but that’s not true. I grew up in Stolipinovo, I work with wood there. I try to teach children how to work with wood.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*sLwlsrEtcGWAqyMpkjkZmQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Stepping back</strong></p><p>On several occasions, we decided to interview parents and teachers about what education meant to them. We hoped to gain some perspective on this initiative, and to especially prepare for the 2019 international workshop.</p><p>Among the responses, parents also told us that what we were doing was good and that we should continue. A mother, Elena, told us that her 6-year-old daughter had a successful start to first grade. By attending the workshop, she got used to speaking Bulgarian and learned to use markers and scissors, <em>“With the workshop, they learn something and they won’t forget what they do.”</em></p><p><em>“What you do with the children, how to play, how to do activities, even if it’s simple, it provides structure, discipline. We see that our children have made progress.”</em></p><p>A father told us<em>: “For me, everything children can learn, like practical skills during the workshops, is important.”</em></p><p>With these responses we felt firm in our conviction to not focus the workshops on teaching reading and writing but instead on providing the children with lifelong skills and tools they can always use.</p><p>Magi told us that with the “Mobile School Stolipinovo”, we were bringing normality into the lives of the children. It’s normal for children to have the opportunity to draw at home. She did that with her own children. But for the children of Stolipinovo drawing at home was not as common. <em>“I usually do architecture workshops, but we brought in other materials: earth, wooden sticks, not just paper and pencils. We allowed the children to play with them, and that’s important. We knew we didn’t have the opportunity to make them write. And even with the teachers. At one point, we had imagined that we could give individual lessons, but it was too difficult to organize.”</em></p><p>Rossi, who coordinated the teachers, evolved a lot in 2 years and gained a good understanding of what needed to be done. This became clear during one debriefing meeting when she said: <em>“The socialization of children is important. Our goal is not to be efficient. Yes, it’s good if children can learn something tangible, but above all, the goal is to enable them to connect with others, to give them the desire to learn. It’s an opportunity to tell them to go to school, to give them the desire to go to school. That’s our goal, and it only makes sense if we go into the neighbourhood and not just into the school.”</em></p><p><strong>The limitations, the shortcomings, the things to improve, the unresolved issues, the challenges.</strong></p><p><strong>How to enable children to access basic education?</strong></p><p>How can children aged 9 to 14 who express an interest in school have access to it? There is no second chance school for children. Either they start in first grade, or they have to wait until they are 16 to go to adult schools. So, what is possible for Sonia, Maria, Petar, and Maya who, at some point, showed an interest in learning to read and write? How can this interest be sustained over time? How can the school adapt to all these children who only attend occasionally, and who, despite this, cannot write their name in Cyrillic? We know that we have not been able to fully address these questions even though they are very real.</p><p>The experience of the “Mobile School Stolipinovo” aligns with a national effort for access to education for all. How can an inclusive educational community be created that leaves no one behind? This national effort stems from reflections made in the 2019 international workshop in Plovdiv and from the work made by committed individuals on this issue at the national level during the following two years. Magi and Benoît were the driving forces behind this work, which brought together various partners from across the country (Sofia, Plovdiv, Sliven, Varna). Together, we realized that the academic challenges faced by some children were not unique to families from segregated neighbourhoods.</p><p>From these efforts an idea emerged to propose the presence of school mediators in all schools nationwide. This was based on the experience of the “Mobile School Stolipinovo”, as well as the experience of health and school mediators in certain segregated neighbourhoods. The school mediators’ responsibility would be to support teachers in the academic success of all children, to reach out to children and parents whose lives are too precarious to come to school, and to support the possibility for teachers to go beyond the school walls to make themselves known and recognized. Historically, such off-school premises meetings were already taking place with children about to enrol in the first year of middle school as teachers needed to ensure that all children were enrolled. But this practice is far from being a regular presence, a practice valuing the skills of families and neighbourhood residents. We also know that it is not enough to hire people: there is a whole process to go through, week after week in the neighbourhood, with children, parents, teachers, and those involved… <strong>It is the challenge of being dedicated to an initiative based on commitments.</strong></p><p>Some names have been changed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e903cbc6c266" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/mobile-stolipinovo-school-e903cbc6c266">Mobile School Stolipinovo</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Reading Club: Nurturing Relationships in a Neighborhood Surrounded by Violence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/the-reading-club-nurturing-relationships-in-a-neighborhood-surrounded-by-violence-9dc2ceb16cce?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dc2ceb16cce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[guatemala-city]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guatemala]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Apr 2024 11:55:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-29T11:47:36.903Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/1*JvbLawDvdK_x7O2nVeHbwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This story was written as part of the seminar “<a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/everyone-can-learn-if/">Everyone can learn if…</a>“, held in June 2018 at the <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/">ATD Fourth World</a>’s international centre in Mery-sur-Oise, France. This seminar brought together teams from different countries, all involved in educational programmes in partnership with parents living in extreme poverty. <strong>This milestone seminar represented the culmination of several years of collaboration between </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/activists/"><strong>activists</strong></a><strong>, school professionals, </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/volunteer-corps/"><strong>Volunteer Corps members</strong></a><strong>, and </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/supporters-and-friends/"><strong>allies</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p><strong>The Reading Club</strong></p><p>The Reading Club is an initiative where participants borrow and exchange books. The project is carried out by ATD Fourth World Guatemala Volunteer Corps members in three neighborhoods in Guatemala: Lomas de Santa Faz (in Zone 18 of Guatemala City), and the Guatelinda and Línea Férrea neighborhoods of Escuintla, a city in the south of the country.</p><p>The Reading Club in Lomas de Santa Faz is located in what is known in Guatemala City as the “red zone” area because of the gangs, commonly referred to as “maras,” operating within them. The gangs’ presence makes it harder for residents to commute to their workplaces, especially in this isolated and marginalized neighborhood with limited job prospects.</p><p><strong>Staying present</strong></p><p>ATD Fourth World has been present in Lomas de Santa Faz since the 1980s. At that time, families living in poverty had been driven out of the city center by new developments, and so had settled there.</p><p>The Street Libraries were held regularly in the neighborhood but had to stop as confrontations between rival gangs made it dangerous to take children outside. However, relationships with the families were maintained, and they were able to participate in other initiatives, such as the Family Encounters program, the October 17 International Day for the Eradication of Poverty commemoration, or the “Working and Learning Together” workshop, which began years later.</p><p>This connection with the families made it possible to recognize that, although the neighborhood had gradually been developing, it had not improved in terms of access to cultural activities. This illustrated a need for spaces like Street Libraries, and so the development of one was proposed once again. Because of security concerns, adjustments had to be made to the Street Library, typically held outdoors. As a result, it was proposed that it would be hosted in an activist’s home.</p><p>Although the “Biblioteca de Casa” allowed us to continue our presence in the Lomas de Santa Faz neighborhood, and to be close to existing families, it did not allow us to meet new families and children. This was doubly problematic as the “Biblioteca de Casa” was designed for children aged 3 to 8 years of age, many of whom could no longer participate in the initiative when they started school.</p><p>The direct contact we had with some families helped us to better understand the situation in the community and to find better ways to continue supporting families in the area. From wider dialogues and shared reflections emerged the idea of creating a Reading Club in 2014. This approach was inspired by a previous initiative implemented a few years ago in Escuintla, another region in Guatemala where ATD Fourth World is present. It originated when Veronica (not her real name), then a young girl, shared that she wanted greater access to books.</p><p><strong>Developing initiatives</strong></p><p>Once a week, two volunteers come to the neighborhood with fifty to sixty books, each classified according to appropriate reading ages. Throughout the day, the two volunteers move from house to house, interacting with the community, meeting new families, and learning about parents’ concerns for the education of their children. At the same time, they can gain a better understanding of the reality of the neighborhood and the families who live there.</p><p><strong>Reaching families where they live</strong></p><p>Doña Raquel, who lives in the neighborhood, describes the team’s relationship with twins who are part of the Reading Club: “These girls are orphans. The grandmother has raised them since they were little, but she is very sick with diabetes and has to go to the hospital very often. The girls are about to finish high school and their grandmother has set up a tortilla bakery for them […]. They will make a living through that. They get their books delivered to the tortilla bakery, and at night they read.”</p><p>The books are displayed in baskets, and children and their families are invited to come and look at the books and select the ones they want to take.</p><p>The team keeps a record of loaned books for each person, which not only allows a reference of the books borrowed, but also keeps track of the reading level of each child, young person, or adult, as well as their reading tastes. This record also helps Volunteer Corps members make informed book suggestions for each child. But although the volunteers often make suggestions when greeting the families at their homes, it is ultimately the child’s decision, and often it is the parents who help the children decide which book to take. This can be a good opportunity for parents and children to bond over their choices. The chosen books are loaned out for a week at a time.</p><p><strong>Make children happy, building family bonds, and instilling a love for school</strong></p><p>The bonds that books and the Reading Club have helped to create in families in Lomas de Santa Faz are essential. Cindy, a mother from the neighborhood, tells us:</p><p>“The special bond I have with my children is when we read together. It’s a beautiful thing, and my daughters and I share special family moments. Books have helped me interact with my daughters and taught me how to coexist with them. I read them the books, and then ask them questions about what they saw in the book, and what the book means […]. My husband also reads to my daughters, but he does it on Sundays.”</p><p>When talking about the impact of books on one of her daughters, Priscila, Cindy said that “before Priscila started reading books, she didn’t talk much and was always angry. [But] when we started reading books to her, her mind started to open. Now she dances, she’s more sociable, and her progress is all thanks to the books.” Doña Raquel, a neighbor of the family, added: “Priscila took a liking to reading. From the moment her mother started reading to her, she started listening. Her mother looked for books about princesses and took the time to read to her.</p><p>According to Cindy’s mother, the process also impacted Cindy: “Now she has patience! I used to bring her books, but she didn’t enjoy reading. Now I see that she’s started reading with her children, telling them stories. I am proud of her and can see that the Reading Club has improved the relationship between her and [Priscila].” Eventually, Priscila not only wanted to read but also to go to school to learn more. As a result, she was enrolled in school the following year.</p><p><em>In Guatemala, learning to read and write can sometimes be very challenging, especially for families living in extreme poverty. Many children fail in their first year of school and gradually the motivation to stay and succeed is lost. Books are also inaccessible, and buying them is a luxury that many cannot afford. As a result, many children ultimately end up dropping out of school.</em></p><p>Many of the children we meet through the Reading Club do not know how to read at first or have difficulties reading. To overcome these issues, we start with picture books. These books help to motivate the children and develop their imagination. This allows the children to gain confidence and feel that the books are accessible. For some, these books are the first steps toward learning letters and numbers.</p><p>One girl in the Reading Club, aged 11, had difficulties learning to read at school. Now, the Reading Club has given her the motivation to continue learning. In her words: “You come to my house to leave me books, and you know what books I like. […] Before, I only looked at the pictures. Now I have learned to read, so nobody has to read to me. I want you to bring me more books.”</p><p><strong>Veronica shares how reading shaped her life</strong></p><p>Veronica whose thirst for reading prompted the creation of the Reading Club in Escuintla, discusses her relationship with books as a child, and how her imagination developed:</p><p>“One of my favorite pastimes is reading. Since learning to read, I have developed an interest in books. In my house and in the neighborhood, there was nothing to entertain us. So [when ATD set up a library on the street], I took advantage of the books given to us on weekends.</p><p>We don’t have a television at home and most of the time there are no activities to distract us. When I can, I read the books I have borrowed and sometimes my siblings sit with me. Occasionally I let out a laugh because I find something funny in the book, and those are the moments when I am most focused on the images in my head. My siblings will look at me with doubtful expressions because they also want to know what is making me laugh, and they say “read it again”. I read aloud for them, and we laugh together.</p><p>I don’t like small books because they don’t take me very long to read. Books remind me of candy: you start eating it and you know it’s going to be over soon. When I have a book, I start reading and reading, and I never want it to end.</p><p>Sometimes I think about other places and things I would like to discover, but I know I can’t travel. That’s why I like books about different countries […]. Through them, I can discover other places. I have rarely left my community, and I have not seen more of my own country, but I can say that I have discovered it through books. When I am asked which countries I know about, I answer: Mexico, France, Spain, Bolivia, and Haiti — through reading, of course!</p><p>I like to read books about slavery, discrimination, and mistreatment of people. They help me to become a better person and change my attitude. Before reading, I didn’t realize that I sometimes treat my siblings and mother badly, and now I am more aware of that. There is a play that I like a lot, called One Thousand and One Nights. I like it because a girl, through a story she told the King, was able to save her sister’s life, and also the lives of other women.</p><p>Reading is important to me. Books help me develop my mind and imagination. They help me forget about my problems. I am the protagonist when I read, and I forget about everything else. It makes me happy, and I want my son to be happy too.</p><p>We learn with time and the people around us, but for me, books were important for learning.</p><p>1 Excerpt from the forthcoming book La Come Libros (, written by Elda Garcia and Veronica).</p><p><strong>Rebuilding community interaction</strong></p><p>When the Reading Club first started, families we did not know well were distrustful of us as a result of the insecurity in the neighborhood. Parents did not let the children approach us at first and were afraid to take the books. However, the regularity of our presence every Thursday, our perseverance in offering books by knocking on doors, and the fact that we were already trusted by other families gradually allowed us to gain trust. Eventually, new parents began allowing their children to come and borrow the books we were offering.</p><p>Before the Reading Club, there was no initiative in place to bring the families of the neighborhood together. In the beginning, we went from house to house with the books, but as we progressed, we identified several “strategic points” in the community where neighbors could gather. Today, we collect the children at their homes, bring them together, and set up a basket of books at these “strategic points.” This allows children to discuss their readings and swap books.</p><p>The Reading Club has enabled us to connect with over a hundred children and adults in the Lomas de Santa Faz community. Moreover, it has facilitated interactions among the most isolated families in the area. Books have now become a reason for not only children but also adults to meet and interact with each other.</p><p>Now, one Thursday a month, we visit the families and gather the children together for storytelling. First, we tell a story, and then the children share what they have read with each other. Though there are many children who don’t know how to read yet, they are still able to share their thoughts and tell stories based on pictures.</p><p>We feel that the trust we are building with the children goes beyond the Reading Club. It even reaches school, where the children lend the books to their friends. The initiative has also allowed us to reach outside the community. The relationships built with the families in the neighborhood have been strengthened through their participation in cultural activities, such as Book Fairs, or meetings where we invite artists and writers.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>The Reading Club has allowed us to create a space where members of the community have access to art and knowledge through books. Amid a community confronted with violence, children and adults have been able to familiarize themselves with books and develop a taste for reading. This has had a significant impact on the neighborhood, as families have spent quality time discovering books and stories with each other.</p><p>The fact that the books arrive every week also allows the children to adopt a reading routine. This allows them to enter gradually into the world of imagination and reading comprehension.</p><p>The importance of books in these communities refutes the belief that nothing is valued there. The Reading Club confirms that books are a treasure.</p><p><strong>Principles of Action</strong></p><p>In June 2018, more than fifty people involved in education from fifteen countries gathered at ATD Fourth World’s International Centre in France for a conference hosted in English, Spanish, and French. Participants included families living in poverty, education professionals, facilitators, and researchers. Together, they shared and analyzed the knowledge gained through their cumulative experiences, working to guarantee access to quality education for children.</p><p>Using the “<a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2023/11/2023-11-10-LEARNING-FROM-SUCCESS3.pdf">Learning from Success</a>” methodology, participants analyzed key moments or turning points in their experiences in order to derive principles of action and identify problems or unresolved issues. Participants applied this methodology to ATD Fourth World Guatemala’s story of the Reading Club. Below, several key initiatives taken by the team, highlighted in the story, have been grouped according to several principles of action.</p><p><strong>Creating initiatives with and for the community</strong></p><p>It is important to develop programs from the perspective of those most underrepresented. For example, the team drew inspiration for the Reading Club from Veronica, the young girl who, after participating in the street library, wanted to continue borrowing books.</p><p>It is also important to involve the community in all phases of the project, from conception to evaluation, and ensure the participation of the most vulnerable families at every stage. By drawing upon the insights of parents and activists and maintaining a steady and visible presence in the neighborhood, will enable us to reach out to new families and motivate their involvement in our programs.</p><p><strong>Using books as a tool</strong></p><p>Elda: “Once you start talking about “red zones”, you cannot expect anyone to seriously consider going there. One of the biggest challenges for […] ATD Fourth World, but also for families, is to make sure that books can get there. In the eyes of the team, providing quality books was a must. Books are expensive in Guatemala. Giving families the opportunity to borrow good books and ensuring that these quality books stay in the community is far from trivial. In fact, it’s a way of saying to them: “If we lend you […] these books, it’s because we have confidence in you and your abilities.” Of the hundred or so books that have been loaned out over the years, only one has ever been lost. This just goes to show that the local people take good care of them.”</p><p>Books can be used as a tool to build trust between ATD Fourth World team members and the community. For example, in the Reading Club, each book is lent out after careful selection. When a volunteer offers a book to a person, it shows that they have thought about them from one week to the next and that they have considered their tastes and taken them into account. The individual register is a record of this exploration of the person’s tastes and interests. It bears witness to the dialogue between the person and the volunteer through the medium of the book. In this way, the action built around the book encourages encounters and deep exchanges between the reader and the volunteer, helping to break the cycle of exclusion.</p><p>Christian Deligne, an educator who participated in the 2018 seminar, said to the Guatemalan team: “I think that by reading and sharing stories, each person’s story doesn’t stay alone. It meets other stories, and from these shared stories a third story is born: [the] story of the future.”</p><p><strong>Further thoughts</strong></p><p>The Book Club is still in development. As a result, there are still some challenges to be addressed to ensure its continuity. The team identifies the following challenges:</p><p>- We must constantly think about renewing our collection. This means finding sources of funding, building partnerships with public and private organizations, and promoting the initiative nationally and internationally.</p><p>- Reading is not just a matter of comprehension: it is also about developing the imagination and sharpening the mind, and the local school rarely considers this. How can we continue to promote the idea that reading is not just about asking children to understand, and how can we further our actions in helping children and parents understand that there’s more to reading?</p><p>- We know children who have read an enormous number of books — but their teachers are often not aware of it. Some of these children, despite being skilled readers, are still failing in school. What can we do to help break this cycle?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dc2ceb16cce" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/the-reading-club-nurturing-relationships-in-a-neighborhood-surrounded-by-violence-9dc2ceb16cce">The Reading Club: Nurturing Relationships in a Neighborhood Surrounded by Violence</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Story of The Giant]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/the-story-of-the-giant-d5bc496dbd40?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d5bc496dbd40</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[canada]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Mar 2024 10:56:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-12T07:07:56.680Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/1*JvbLawDvdK_x7O2nVeHbwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This story was written as part of the seminar “<a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/everyone-can-learn-if/">Everyone can learn if…</a>“, held in June 2018 at the <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/">ATD Fourth World</a>’s international centre in Mery-sur-Oise, France. This seminar brought together teams from different countries, all involved in educational programmes in partnership with parents living in extreme poverty. <strong>This milestone seminar represented the culmination of several years of collaboration between </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/activists/"><strong>activists</strong></a><strong>, school professionals, </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/volunteer-corps/"><strong>Volunteer Corps members</strong></a><strong>, and </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/supporters-and-friends/"><strong>allies</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p>—</p><p>By Caroline Moreau</p><p><em>To begin with, you have to be ashamed of yourself. Then live in this neighbourhood and go downhill, Then be proud of this neighbourhood and bounce back within yourself. Adore the chaos that brings forth the sun.<br></em>Hélène Monette</p><p>To begin with, you must cross the town and go right to the bottom. Dash headlong down Sherbrooke Hill until you reach the river contained behind the Port of Montreal. Go to the people who have lived there forever. Listen to the Suzannes, the Marcels, the Celines hanging out in the local greasy spoon or sitting on the steps of the convenience store. They are the ones who’ll tell you the history of the neighbourhood, its streets, and its inhabitants.</p><p>They’ll explain that the building, which today has been converted into trendy loft apartments and communal work spaces was once home to the Grover Textile Factory. Men and women who could barely read and write came to toil here, night and day, for starvation wages.</p><p>You must listen to the Rogers, the Francines, the Andrés. They’ll reminisce about their childhood with their twelve brothers and sisters, crammed into a cardboard box, a three-room flat impossible to heat, that was an absolute sieve in winter. You’ll hear, in their voices, the tremors that used to rattle the walls when the trains went by. The railroad that ran through the neighbourhood, now a pedestrian walkway, was used to transport goods from the port to the factories.</p><p>They’ll talk to you about the war, far away, on the Old Continent, the war whose horrors the people of Hochelaga had to thank for their livelihood and work. The Canadian Vickers shipyard alone made it one of North America’s largest industrial cities. You’ll hear, from afar, the voice of one of the greatest Canadian novelists, Gabrielle Roy: <em>“Because the poor are not half as necessary to peace as they are, and always have been, to war.”</em> (Roy, Gabrielle (1978), Fragiles lumières de la terre, Montréal, Éditions Quinze, p.164 (Coll. “Prose entière”).)</p><p>You’ll also hear the story of the economic crisis that followed. The factories were closing, one after another. Families that were already vulnerable found themselves leading an even more precarious existence. As if that weren’t enough, a few years later, two waves of expropriations left their mark on the neighborhood. First, for the refurbishment of the Port of Montreal, then for the construction of the Olympic Park that would host the 1976 Games.</p><p>Then imagine the years as they passed and turned into decades, turning the screws of a system of exclusion that increasingly tightened its grip on people. The violence of an obscene poverty perpetuated for generations, in spite of the country’s wealth, dragging in its wake emaciated, angular bodies, shaken by spasms, dizzy on too-high heels, struggling to retain some semblance of dignity, despite the sideways glances and insults: to the point, even, of erecting a camp amid a recent housing crisis. For weeks, tents and trailers formed a veritable village, with its networks of mutual aid and strife, on the edge of our awareness, in a non-place, along this highway that criss-crosses the river.</p><p>Everything is there. Yet something is missing. What’s missing are the bands of citizens who stand up against the bleakness of the times, faithful to the call whatever the era. These are the women and men who take action in the face of conflicts with employers, repeated housing crises, and the disintegration of public services.</p><p>Let’s remind ourselves, for example, of the <a href="https://www.rccq.org/en/about-us/">Hochelaga Community Kitchen</a>. Three women decided they wanted to make food choices with dignity, by doing more than just receiving free groceries. They set up a Community Kitchen, unaware that their idea would be adopted throughout Quebec and become an actual movement. During those same years, the Hochelaga Family Centre was set up on the initiative of parents who assessed their own situations and wanted to break the isolation they experienced. Without professionals or experts, ordinary citizens decided to take action, based on the strengths of each individual.</p><p>It was into this landscape that the ATD team established a presence with the <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/what-we-do/culture-and-education/street-library/">Street Library</a> and the <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/what-we-do/culture-and-education/festival-of-learning/">Festival of Learning</a>. Our focus was a housing development in a strategic area of the neighbourhood, where the issues of prostitution, homelessness, and drugs were widespread.</p><p>Twice a week, the street library offered an opportunity to gather with books and engage in practical or creative activities. It took place in two different ways, each with its advantages and disadvantages: outside, in public, in the small tension-filled park adjacent to the dwellings; or inside the buildings, in stairwells or on doorsteps, close to the families who didn’t manage to get out so easily. The street library had already existed a year when the tenants’ committee, chaired by Ginette, a resident of the seniors’ tower block, launched a scheme to provide breakfast in the community hall.</p><p>And so we decided to eat there, too. At first, one time just to experience it, and then on a more regular basis. We had become better acquainted with the older adults who lived in the tower. By insisting that everyone, without discrimination, was welcome and given equal attention while being served, Ginette allowed us to experience first-hand what living together really meant. Whether they were living in the housing development, in a room in a nearby house, or on the street; whether they were sex workers or night cashiers at the convenience store; whether they were intoxicated, semi-conscious, or asleep, Ginette would insist: “Everyone is hungry, so we must let everyone in. No other organization offers meals this early in the morning.”</p><p>Word quickly spread around the neighbourhood, and the community hall became a landmark. In 2014, Joëlle Tremblay, an artist and friend of ATD Fourth World came to eat with us. After she had joined us there for several weeks, the tenants’ committee was asked whether the community hall could be used to hold art workshops with Joëlle. Residents would have the opportunity to paint artwork to decorate the stairwell of the community hall. And so the decision was made to create four large panels depicting trees throughout the seasons.</p><p>At the inauguration party for this first community artwork entitled <em>A painting for the stairwell: Seasons of the Trees, </em>one mother expressed her amazement at what we could accomplish together. “At first, I didn’t believe that we could put an end to the squabbles and disagreements, but then I saw it could actually work. The street library and the Festival of Learning have already brought families and older people closer together. Over time, all the activities organized in the park have brought people closer together.”</p><p>Empowered by this first positive experience and with the artist Joëlle Tremblay still involved, we embarked on a second community project. This time, the idea was not to decorate a communal space but to create a work that expressed something about the neighborhood: a kind of collective self-portrait, composed by and with the people of the community.</p><p>This was when Tiago and his family moved into the housing development. It was said that they came from another tough neighbourhood in the north of the city, where racial tensions and conflicts with the police regularly flared up. Later, in conversation with Tiago’s father, we learned that the family had left Haiti in the aftermath of the earthquake.</p><p>Although they had been living in the housing development for barely a week, Tiago’s reputation was already established. “The police were prowling the park the other day. He pissed them all off and got a ticket.” “It’s the same at school. He made death threats to his teacher. He was suspended, and they are going to send him to a rehabilitation center.” “He spends his days roaming the streets. Gangs are circling around him, and he steals things from the discount store on behalf of others.” “He is in the process of being recruited. “He will end up in prison.”</p><p>It was clear that we had to see for ourselves. We went to his house on a street library day. We knocked on the door and Tiago opened it to let us in. We explained our activities to him: lending out books, reading in the park, and creative activities. He listened to us and then, unexpectedly, asked us if we had any novels.</p><p>Those few words were enough to change everything. We didn’t know it yet, but this question was the starting point of a slow process of transformation that was to involve the entire community. Already, the image we had built up of him, in spite of ourselves, was beginning to crack. The person whom the other children called “the thief” was <em>also</em> a reader of novels. We accepted his request and returned a few days later with a choice of several books. Little by little, a bond was forged that was strong enough for Tiago to agree to take part in the first stage of our new project: collecting stories. Because to create a work that speaks about the neighbourhood, you first have to meet the people who live there and hear their stories.</p><p>We came up with a strategy that allowed for easier interaction with the people involved in the housing development. We wrote questions on cards, such as, “What was your first work experience?” “Tell us about the worst thing you did at school?” ; or even “Do you remember a bad thing you did with your brothers and sisters?”. Tiago agreed to play along and came with us. Soon, other young people joined in, and a small group formed around him. The youngsters accompanied us on our door-to-door excursions and as we wandered around the park. They were the ones who held the cards, posed questions to the adults, and captured their answers on the tape recorder’s microphone, just like a TV interview.</p><p>Without expecting it, we were picking up a lot of injury stories. The people interviewed had dealt with life’s hard knocks in their own way. We heard about physical injuries, illnesses, accidents, hospitalizations; but also about life’s trials and tribulations, those wounds that don’t leave scars, but which leave their mark all the same. We heard of separations, relocations, toxic marriages, and plunges into depression.</p><p>In each of the stories, several predicaments appeared which, while never being resolved, ended up becoming the turning point in a learning process: a life lesson, a new perception of self, others, and the world. A strength emerged, quite unexpectedly, from the deepest of silences. Sometimes it was the support of a loved one, or the community rallying around the person in need. At other times, a difficult situation revealed hitherto unsuspected personal resources that lay dormant inside, thanks to which the person was able to resist the temptation to give up everything.</p><p>Every evening, we systematically transcribed the previous day’s recordings. Together with Joëlle, we re-read the transcripts and, through them, we saw the main subject of our future creation taking shape. The people of this neighbourhood had difficult histories, and we wanted to take them into account. But the richness of those life stories lay in the resilience with which people overcame their ordeals. Not only had they survived, but they had also learned important lessons. As the embodiment of those two aspects, we imagined a dual character, half-wounded, half-angel: a larger-than-life being who was greater than the sum of the individual stories. In other words, a giant.</p><p>We were now entering the second stage of our creative project. We needed to move forward towards transposing this idea into a visual language in partnership with the young people of the street library and their families, with the elders, and with all the people we met at breakfast. However, we still didn’t know what our future giant would look like. Joëlle’s expertise and experience enabled us to organize a dozen or so exploratory workshops that combined theater, drawing, and painting as opportunities to learn together. Each painting workshop was always preceded by a period of observational drawing. Paintings by well-known artists and photos on the theme of the workshop were hung on a clothesline that crossed the community hall. On occasions when we met outside, we hung them in the park, transforming public places into creative workshops. Parents and children were invited to choose an image. Everyone honed their sense of observation, first drawing a pencil sketch inspired by the image, before moving on to painting. This process enabled us to approach the creative process step by step so that everyone could slowly gain confidence in their own artistic abilities. Joëlle would give very specific instructions: a background of a particular color, a darker line to highlight the silhouette of the characters, etc. These guidelines established a kind of framework that ensured an interesting result so that the participants could be proud of their creations.</p><p>Week after week, we accumulated the visual elements that were going to be reassembled into a large <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triptych">triptych</a> during the 2016 Festival of Learning. Once again, Joëlle orchestrated everyone’s contributions to bring The Giant into being. At the end of the four-day festival, our Giant had appeared. At the centre was the blue silhouette of the large wounded man, his body turned away in withdrawal. Around him spread two vivid yellow angel wings decorated with symbols of inner strength and life lessons — pouring out “a cornucopia of solidarity,” as one participant put it,</p><p>Tiago remained on board throughout the entire process. He continued to take part in Joëlle’s exploration workshops. He improvised the costume of a severely wounded soldier, struck a pose, and embraced the ridiculousness of it. Tiago also disguised himself as an angel, sketched alongside the other young people, wore an apron, chose his colors, and was inspired by the works of famous artists like Niki de St-Phalle or Frida Kahlo. Over those weeks, the way people looked at him changed, as did the way parents and other young people interacted with him. A father asked Tiago to help set up the daily sports matches in the park. Another suggested that Tiago and his son could prepare a workshop together as part of the festival. The youngsters at the street library stopped calling him “the thief.” The benefits were even felt by Tiago’s mother, who joined other Haitian mothers to cook a traditional griot dish for the shared meal that marked the end of the Festival of Learning.</p><p>The painting also had a sound component. During the Festival of Learning, alongside the painting workshop coordinated by Joëlle, we offered a writing and audio recording workshop. With the support of a professional radio host, everyone was invited to create a short story and record it in a small temporary studio set up in a room near the housing development. Once the audio capsules had been edited, they were inserted across the back of the painting. If people leaned forward as if to give the Giant a hug, those stories became audible.</p><p>The workshop didn’t involve writing a story in the usual way. Participants were not asked to <em>invent</em> but rather to <em>assemble </em>a story by inserting sentence fragments and words they had selected from a word bank into a ready-made story structure. The narrative framework they were given sought to reproduce the same two-fold pattern present in the visual aspect of the work. In other words: to evoke the wounds dealt by life, but also to recognize the courage and resistance in the face of those wounds.</p><p>To create word banks before the Festival of Learning took place, we immersed ourselves in the stories, which were the raw material of our project. This time, we had to transform the same things that had already been translated into visual language into poetic language. To create our first bank of phrases, we extracted fragments from each of the transcripts:</p><p>“I had 7 stitches in my leg…”</p><p>“I was desperate for love…”</p><p>“I found myself with lots of bright lights at Saint-Jérôme hospital…”</p><p>Participants were then invited to choose one of the anonymized and decontextualized phrases and interweave it with other fragments. We highlighted all terms related to injuries: diagnoses, treatments, diseases, and medical personnel. Individual words were then extracted so that the participants could pair them with others. This gave rise to real linguistic inventions: such as <em>trauma-cardiogram</em> or <em>family embolism,</em> found in the following example:</p><p><em>“</em>I had 7 stitches in my leg. I had a trauma-cardiogram with a family embolism, a scar of happiness. I came very close to never being here with you all, and I’m talking to you about it.”</p><p>This text was written by a mother we knew well through the street library. So we knew how much her piece revealed about her own experience–although we hadn’t anticipated that one outcome of the workshop would be the creation of a self-portrait. But of course, composing a text from the words of others doesn’t mean you can’t talk about yourself. People reveal themselves through the words of others, perhaps even <em>thanks</em> to the words of others. Potentially, in the end, we need the words of others to talk about ourselves in a more distanced way. Perhaps the truth of our experience also becomes heightened when we hear its echo resonate for someone else.</p><p>We also found that the playful, humorous aspect of the workshop made it accessible to people who were far removed from the written word. As is often the case when we embark on a creative process, there’s something liberating about constraint. Because the words that were to be used to construct the text had already been provided, the participants experienced writing as an act of montage. Words became tangible, they took on the form of cardboard boxes to be moved and arranged. Joining words that refer to ideas from different fields, such as <em>embolism</em> and <em>family</em>, challenges our common sense, and gives rise to improbable images that are rich and symbolic. It means bringing a poetic dimension to our relationship with language.</p><p>One of the street library’s youngsters, for example, wrote a story that ended with: “The police came, they had a disease of judgment”. The texts are full of such associations: <em>breach of trust</em>, <em>bipolar funeral</em>, <em>ignited attention</em>, <em>childhood burn</em>, <em>cardiac event</em>, <em>difficulty concentrating</em>, <em>medical infection</em>, <em>language pill</em>, <em>deficit of abandonment</em>, <em>mental intervener</em>, <em>intoxication of consciousness</em>, and so on. It can be argued that the constraints of the workshop opened up a realm of freedom, allowing everyone to reclaim everyday language, to bring it closer to their personal experience, thus regaining power over it. This is particularly significant with terms referring to the medical or institutional world, which people may feel they have no power over in their everyday lives.</p><p><strong>Proud together</strong></p><p>After completing the collaborative art project, we went on to organize an exhibition in the community hall of the housing development, where it became a subject of dialogue, exchanges, and meetings between residents on the one hand and visitors to the neighbourhood on the other. The visual elements of the triptych and the audio recordings inserted there resonated with those who stopped by. Visitors recognized something about themselves, and the soundboard inspired them to tell their own stories.</p><p>The Giant was then exhibited on the premises of several local community organizations. Other people who didn’t live in the housing development could see it, too. On World Day for Overcoming Poverty, October 17, 2016, The Giant was displayed as part of a larger exhibition organized in an art gallery. Children, young people, and parents from Hochelaga came to explain the creative process to the crowd. It was an unforgettable day for the children who felt proud of their parents, and vice versa.</p><p>The Giant made its final appearance at the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts in autumn 2018, following several other exhibitions. It was part of a group exhibition featuring local associations from various Montreal neighbourhoods, each showcasing their community art projects.</p><p>The project entitled <em>“And if the walls could speak of us”</em> offered residents of the historically underprivileged, working-class Hochelaga neighbourhood the opportunity to proudly feature, like everyone else, in this highly symbolic cultural institution.</p><p><strong>Analysis and principles of action</strong></p><p><em>Discussion with seminar participants</em></p><p>Romy: In this extraordinary story I can see several successes. One is how art found its place in an underprivileged neighbourhood and became a means of collective expression. Another is how a rebellious young man, who was seen as a bad influence, found his place in the community.</p><p>Caroline: We wanted to create work that was collaborative and intergenerational, that allowed families to share their knowledge amongst themselves and with others. And we did everything that we could to ensure that everyone, young and old, could participate. During the story-gathering phase with the adults, the children engaged in various activities. They dressed up, acted out the stories, and sketched and painted scenes from them. Additionally, they participated in writing workshops. The children were captivated by the stories told by their elders, which they had never heard before, at least not in such detail. The workshops provided them with an opportunity to think about how they could convey those stories through their drawings, helping them internalize the narratives.</p><p>David (Guatemala): I’m wondering how it all started because every time you mentioned a new stage in your story you had to go back and explain something that had happened before.</p><p>Caroline: You’re right. In fact, over the years, thanks to home visits and activities such as the street library and the Festival of Learning, strong relationships have been developed with the children, their families, and some of the elderly people who live in Hochelaga. They had already carried out community art projects there. The families knew Joëlle because she had already created paintings with them representing the four seasons to beautify the stark stairwell in their building. This answered people’s deep desire for beauty.</p><p>The process of creating The Giant went a little further. Based on the principle that <strong>everyone has culture and knowledge to share</strong>, our main objective was not to teach everyone how to hold a brush or mix colours but to <strong>highlight the cultural expressions and unrecognized knowledge of the residents of this neighbourhood.</strong> By working on how to put their own and others’ experiences into words and paintings, people became aware of their strength and resilience in the face of adversity and difficulty. They got to know themselves in a new way.</p><p>Romy: Can we say that this is the situation after the project: the painting workshops gave the residents the ability to understand themselves and express who they are and what they know? Did the activities help them break their silence and isolation?</p><p>Caroline: Yes. Putting it simply: the Giant project has shown that collaborative art-making can strengthen a community, creating new kinds of bonds between people, so that they feel safer and more comfortable going out and participating in neighbourhood life. By taking part in these activities with their whole family–because some of the parents joined in the activities too– people regained confidence in their ability to act, and they felt proud of themselves.</p><p>Irène: I love the idea of collecting the stories of the Hochelaga residents. But how did you get them to tell you their stories?</p><p>Caroline: We diversified our way of doing things. For example, we <strong>seized opportunities</strong> such as community meals in the neighborhood where people normally engage in informal conversation. We listened to them very carefully and then said, “That’s interesting what you just said. Would you be willing to be interviewed and have us record your story? This will remain confidential, of course.” <strong>We took the time to explain to them </strong>what we were looking for. And we had another method, which we used more systematically. We went to the park, to the place where there were tables, and <strong>approached</strong> the people sitting there with the help of a little questionnaire, but <strong>in a lighthearted, fun way</strong>.</p><p>Bruno D (France): What kind of questions did you ask?</p><p>Caroline: <strong>Open questions that leave them free to answer what they want</strong>: “Can you tell us any story about your work?” Or: “What is the worst thing you have done at school?” Or: “Can you tell us something you did with your brothers and sisters?” We didn’t intrude on their private lives, but we <strong>invited them to recount moments in their lives that had been important to them</strong>.</p><p>At one point we also went from door to door using our map.</p><p>Romy: Your map?</p><p>Caroline: In fact, the city department in charge of social housing was unable to provide a housing map or a list of homes. We drew up a plan of the buildings ourselves, listing every apartment on every floor, and entering the names of the people who lived there. People helped us fill it in by telling us who lived on their floor. Even today, we keep track of changes and keep it up to date. The map helps us <strong>not to forget any of the families, simply because we don’t see them very often</strong>. In fact, it was through the map that we discovered where Tiago and his family lived.</p><p>Donald W. (USA): There are two elements in this story that I would like to understand better: Firstly, the art form that was chosen: street art with a multi-sensory component. And secondly, the concept of the wounded or broken person with the wings of an angel. Who had these ideas?</p><p>Caroline: The Wounded Giant character came from the stories people told us. Of course, we could have chosen another character, a mother, for example. But with all the stories of illnesses, accidents, and injuries, the street library team and Joëlle, the artist, opted for the Wounded Giant.</p><p>Donald: But where did this expression come from? I can’t imagine someone saying to you, “I’m a big, broken guy, half-hurt, half-angel….”</p><p>Caroline: It seemed important to the team to <strong>bring out all the dimensions of the stories, the difficulties but also the courage, resilience, and solidarity people showed</strong>. Those who only see poverty in this neighbourhood don’t expect all this. Yes, the Wounded Giant and the Angel are metaphors. They are a reflection of the neighbourhood. There is a lot of prejudice. You have to get closer to find out what’s going on. In the painting of the Wounded Giant, you can only hear voices if you place your ear against the openings. The entire work of art is a metaphor for the neighbourhood in more ways than one.</p><p>Hélène (France): And once you had chosen the character of the Wounded Giant, how did it take shape?</p><p>Caroline: During one of the workshops, some children dressed up as wounded people with lots of bandages and crutches and mimicked cries of pain. The other children had 35 seconds to make a sketch. One child’s drawing of a “wounded” girl caught the attention of the artist, who printed an enlarged copy of the outline of his sketch. Then we went back and asked people what thoughts came to mind when they saw it. <strong>There was a lot of communication between the team and the families, back and forth, </strong>as the painting evolved.</p><p>Alban (Central African Republic): You spoke about the change that has taken place within the community. I see it not only as the result of the collaborative art project, but also of what you undertook with Tiago. With all the criticism of him, some parents thought he should be avoided. But you do exactly the opposite: you go directly to his house to meet him. Without saying a word about his bad reputation, you introduce yourself, tell him about the street library, and ask him if he’s interested in borrowing a book. And you manage to get him to participate. I see a principle of action at work here: <strong>Go and find the one whose contribution is still missing</strong>.</p><p>Romy: Yes, that struck me too. It seems to me that this is a turning point in the story: you offer to lend Tiago a book, and you seem surprised when he asks if you have any novels. He was certainly just as surprised that someone showed up with <strong>an offer instead of coming to reproach him</strong>. You built up your relationship from then on, returning week after week with new books until you felt you could invite him to join the art project.</p><p>Reymond (Philippines): What did you say to the father who refused to allow his child to continue going to the street library?</p><p>Caroline: I don’t remember the exact words. We let him know that we could also come and do the street library on his doorstep. Or, if his children didn’t want to join the group, we could come and see them at their home, so they would have less chance of coming face to face with Tiago.</p><p>Reymond: I ask that because sometimes we experience similar situations in Manila, where <strong>we have to adapt our usual ways of doing things to make it possible for a child to participate</strong>. For example, we used to pick up a child and accompany him to the activity, then drive him home again. Because he was so excluded that the other children would get up and leave when he came alone.</p><p>Romy: You have brought together both sides: the oppressors and the oppressed. You involved Tiago in the art project and imagined a way for the other children to participate in the street library, taking into account the father’s concern for their safety. You didn’t try to discuss it with him, you didn’t take sides. You <strong>allowed everyone the time they needed to make peace in their own way, when they were ready</strong>. I would also keep this as a principle of action.</p><p>Donald: I found it impressive that <strong>you adapted to the needs of the person </strong>in a wheelchair, making a very long brush so that she was able to participate in the art project.</p><p>David: It has to do with the principle of action: <strong>include everyone</strong>. Just like the map you made, which was a tool that enabled you to put this principle into practice.</p><p>Caroline: I wonder if I can add one more principle of action: <strong>be ambitious and demanding. We decorated the workshop venues with reproductions of works by famous artists</strong> to provide a context and inspire the participants. The quality of their output made people proud both of their creation and their collaborative work. It’s pride like this that allows us to defend our neighborhood, feel part of a community, and be open about where we come from.</p><p>Don: What I liked was your way of <strong>translating individual traumas and experiences into portraits of courage to represent the neighbourhood.</strong> I see a dynamic there where one thing leads to another. When individual experience is integrated into a more collective context, you create strength, you make the community stronger. It’s fascinating!</p><p>Orna: So three modes of expression were used: painting, speaking, and writing.</p><p>Caroline: And the dressing up. But does that count as expression?</p><p>Romy: I would say so, yes. An instructor at the cultural center in Noisy-le-Grand said that through a theatre workshop, children could play someone else and that it helped them express things they wouldn’t have dared to say in real life.</p><p>David: Generally speaking, <strong>making art and beauty accessible so that people not only enjoy it but also express themselves</strong>, allows people to share something very positive: not only within their community but also with the outside world.</p><p>Quyen: Harnessing people’s creative potential.</p><p>Caroline: Yes, exactly. But for that, we must be convinced that this potential is there inside them: that people are creative, and that they are cultural beings.</p><p>Donald: An action principle would be: <strong>initiate and support artistic creation as an integral part of the action</strong>. Artistic creation can be found everywhere.</p><p>Orna: I would like to ask Caroline: how do you feel after sharing your experience with us?</p><p>Caroline: You speak of my experience in your own words, and it echoes your own experience. The principles you have identified in this project are useful because when one has one’s nose to the grindstone, one isn’t always aware of the impact of one’s actions. Hearing them from your lips reminds me that it’s not just my subjective perception, but also yours, ours. I want to thank you for this.</p><p><strong>Principles of action mentioned during the conversation :</strong></p><ol><li>Create the conditions that make it possible for everyone to participate: young or old, healthy or challenged, entire families.</li><li>Include everyone.</li><li>Be convinced that everyone has culture and knowledge to share.</li><li>Highlight the cultural expressions and unrecognized knowledge of local residents.</li><li>Seize opportunities to have informal meetings (to gather stories).</li><li>Take the time to explain and discuss the proposed project with people.</li><li>Meet new people in a relaxed and fun way.</li><li>Ask open questions that allow people to respond as they wish. Encourage them to recount moments in their lives that were important to them.</li><li>Use tools (here, a map of the neighbourhood, for example) to make sure you don’t forget any family, even those you don’t see very often.</li><li>Include every dimension of the stories that people tell–the difficulties but also the courage, resilience, and solidarity that people have shown.</li><li>Throughout the project, communicate back and forth between the team and families.</li><li>Reach out to those whose contribution is still missing.</li><li>Come with proposals, not reproaches or lessons.</li><li>Seize the right moment as a turning point that can be built upon.</li><li>Break out of the usual patterns to make the participation of a child or adult possible.</li><li>Allow each party the time needed to make peace in their own way, when they are ready.</li><li>Find inventive ways of making the activity accessible to those with differences.</li><li>Be ambitious and demanding. Expect high-quality contributions.</li><li>Stimulate inspiration by creating inspiring spaces, decorating them, and displaying works of art.</li><li>Make the community stronger by translating individual experiences and traumas into portraits of courage that represent the neighborhood.</li><li>Use different modes of expression: painting, speaking, writing, dressing up.</li><li>Make art and beauty accessible so that people can not only enjoy it but also express themselves.</li><li>Initiate and support artistic creation as an integral part of the action.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d5bc496dbd40" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/the-story-of-the-giant-d5bc496dbd40">The Story of The Giant</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Find your roots to grow well]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/find-your-roots-to-grow-well-1680c0bceecd?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1680c0bceecd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[learn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[burkina-faso]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 10 Nov 2023 12:56:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-10T13:14:22.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*IJ8sp8aB7XCZ46bswDhIFQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>This series of education articles that will be published on our </strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/"><strong>website</strong></a><strong> and this blog. They were written as part of “</strong><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/everyone-can-learn-if/"><strong>Everyone can learn if…</strong></a><strong>” a seminar that took place in June 2018 at ATD Fourth World’s International Centre in France. These articles aim to support creativity and highlight the successes of our teams and all those working with children. Through this series, we will share the inspiring stories that emerged from the experiences of the seminar participants.</strong></p><p><strong>Story from Burkina Faso by Florent Bambara with Orna Shemer</strong><a href="#sdfootnote1sym"><strong>1</strong></a><strong> :</strong></p><p>Florent Bambara is an ATD Fourth World Volunteer Corps member. In 2018, he was part of ATD’s team in Ouagadougou (Burkina Faso), working with the “Family Reconnection” project. This is a project that ATD Fourth World has been developing for many years with children living on the streets.</p><p>Florent explains:</p><p><em>Since the 1980s, ATD Fourth World has reached out to the children living on the streets of Ouagadougou to get to know them and to help them have a better future. This work includes reconnecting these children with their families.</em></p><p><em>The first step is to meet the children in the places where they congregate and gain their trust.</em> <em>We go and see the children on Wednesday nights, with books, in the places where they gather to sleep. We call this activity “</em>Street Library under the Lampposts<em>”. We spend time with them reading books, then before we leave, we tell them, ‘We’ll be waiting for you tomorrow morning at the </em><a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/the-story-of-the-one-hundred-trades-courtyard-in-burkina-faso/"><em>One Hundred Trades Courtyard</em></a><em>!’</em></p><p><em>The following morning, we get ready at the One Hundred Trades Courtyard, close to the town centre, to welcome the children. Fifteen, twenty, thirty children who live on the streets can come here to wash their clothes, shower, play games with us, chat, draw…We call these mornings” Mo’ Cool” — “Cool Moments”.</em></p><p>One Wednesday evening, during a Street Library Under the Lamposts, Florent meets Moussa, a 13-year-old boy living on the street for two years. In an interview with Orna Shemer, professor at the School of Social Work at the University of Jerusalem, Florent recounts to the participants of the seminar “Everyone can Learn if…” the story of Moussa and the circumstances that led to his reunification with his family eight months after they met.</p><p><strong>Before</strong></p><p>Orna Shemer<strong><em>: What was the child’s situation before he had any relationship with you?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Florent Bambara: </strong><em>When I met Moussa, he was thirteen years old and had been living on the streets for two years. He didn’t go to school, and his mother was distraught. Unfortunately, Moussa had acquired some bad habits on the streets and had taken to glue sniffing — a drug children take to escape the feeling of being ashamed and to feel a little safer. Moussa was weakened, in pain, and always on guard. He had found some friends on the streets. I could say he had no education and was fending for himself.</em></p><p><strong>After</strong></p><p><strong><em>How is he today?</em></strong></p><p><em>Moussa is now with his grandfather’s family. He goes to school, and he’s learning about the cultural values in the village. He has learned to herd cattle and farm. His mother is now reassured because her child is safe and receiving an education. She is happy because she feels that her son has a future now.</em></p><p><em>Moussa’s maternal grandfather told us,</em> ‘<em>When the child wasn’t around, his mother couldn’t sleep, and in the evenings, she worried a lot, imagining all kinds of things. It made his mother suffer terribly to chase after him. She didn’t know what to do. Now that he’s back, she’s happy; she can sleep.’</em></p><p>Moussa is also happy with the change in his life.</p><p><strong>The costs</strong></p><p><strong><em>Do you think that Moussa, you, his mother or anyone else in his circle paid any costs for the process he went through to return home?</em></strong></p><p>Yes, the mother paid a price because traditionally, custody of the child falls to the father’s family or to the father himself, and it was out of the question for the child to move in with his mother. Moussa didn’t understand all this; it was very hard for him. The mother, seeing how much her child suffered, went beyond these traditions and asked her new husband to accept Moussa so that he could live with them after the birth of his half-brother. But Moussa did not feel like he fit in there and did not want to stay, so he ran away and found himself on the street again. That was a cost for the mother, and I would say it was also a cost for the aunt<a href="#sdfootnote2sym">2</a>, the mother’s sister, who took the risk to go with me to ask the maternal grandfather to accept the child at his home. Traditionally, the grandfather wouldn’t dare accept the child into his home because he knows that the child doesn’t belong with him; he belongs more with the father’s family.</p><p><strong><em>Did you pay any costs yourself to help him?</em></strong></p><p>Yes, because in our work to mend family ties, we usually first go to the child’s family to prepare for their return. That step was not taken with Moussa. Since the boy was eager to return to his family, we chose to be flexible and trust the child. The risk to the child would be that he would be rejected, or something harsh would be said in front of him, and he would be discouraged. Another difficulty: we didn’t know the grandfather’s address. The boy only knew the name of the village but not his grandfather’s last name. So we went on an ‘adventure trip’ of sorts, trusting that the child would lead us to the place. We drove around for a long time without success. It was disheartening for the boy; you could see in his eyes that he was disappointed and didn’t want to return to the street. So what were we to do? Finally, we went 40 kilometres further, at the boy’s request, to find his aunt whose name and place he recalled.</p><p><strong>Defining success</strong></p><p><strong><em>Orna, [turning to the group] We heard the ‘before’ and the ‘after’ and the adverse effects or costs of the success. It is essential to balance the outcome and the costs. So what do you think? Is it a success story?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Participant:</strong> It’s a tough transition for children who have lived on the streets for a while and then return to a family structure and a rural community. After the experience of independence, albeit coupled with great insecurity, they may feel that the duties and obligations towards the family and community are constraints to their freedom. In this child’s case, the outcome was positive. This indicates that he was ready to change his life and that the risks and costs were well justified.</p><p><strong>Participant</strong>: Except for some differences in culture and traditions, this story could have happened in my country. So, yes, I am eager to learn from this success.</p><p><strong>Orna</strong>: It’s essential also to ask others — team members, colleagues, partners, including the parents and the child — if what seems a success to us is success for them. This story is clearly very relevant for you and for ATD Fourth World.</p><p><strong>Actions that led to success</strong></p><p><strong><em>Where and when did you meet Moussa, and when you met him, how did you make a connection with him?</em></strong></p><p>We met Moussa during the <em>‘</em>Street Library under the Lampposts’ held once a week on Kwame nKrumah Avenue. Approximately twenty children who beg from the rich (those who frequent the luxury bars in the neighbourhood) meet on this avenue to sleep.</p><p>We saw that he was a newcomer, so we asked him, ‘What’s your name?’ he answered, ‘My name’s Moussa.’ And we invited him.</p><p>First, he participated in the activity, and at the end, we invited all the children, as usual, to the One Hundred Trades Courtyard the following day for the Mo’Cool, and Moussa accepted. But unfortunately, he didn’t show up.</p><p><strong><em>So what did you do?</em></strong></p><p>The Monday after, I went back to where the children slept to invite another child to spend the night in the courtyard so that I could take him home — early the following day — to his family. When I arrived at the place looking for this child, Moussa was there. He said ‘hello’ to me, and I said, ‘I didn’t see you Thursday; you didn’t come.’ And he answered, ‘I went to sleep late because in the street, well…’ In short, when he woke up, the others had already left.</p><p><strong><em>When Moussa told you that he was asleep and everyone went off to the Mo’cool, what did you tell him?</em></strong></p><p>Moussa asked what we do to help these children. I didn’t need to answer; an older man who lives on the street answered in my place. He told Moussa that we are escorting children back to their families and that he could trust us, that we are not going say negative things about him to his family. I told Moussa that if he is interested, he can come to us, and if he is ready to return to his family, we can accompany him. In our programme, we do not want to go too fast with the children; we try to support the children’s initiatives and follow their pace.</p><p><strong><em>How did you end that conversation with Moussa, and how did you continue the relationship?</em></strong></p><p>The following Wednesday, after Moussa asked if he could come on Thursday for the <em>Mo’cool</em>. ‘Yes, of course, you can come,’ I said, ‘no problem!’ Because he didn’t know ATD Fourth World’s location, one of his friends said he could bring Moussa the next day.</p><p>The next day, we saw Moussa coming with his friend, and he held a bag of glue to his mouth. I told him right away that here in the courtyard, there are rules; it’s not like on the street, you can’t sniff glue here. And the other kid, who is used to coming to the courtyard, explained the rest of the courtyard’s rules to him. Ever since then, Moussa participated in the <em>Mo’cool</em>. He particularly liked doing his laundry and washing up, but he also loved the puppet theatre and dancing. In the street, Moussa was shy, but at the <em>Mo’cool,</em> he was a different child; he opened up to the other kids.</p><p>Visiting him on the street was another important initiative. Every time I went to the crossroads, he was there to beg. If he didn’t beg, it was because he was not well. I usually stopped by to say hello and ask about his health and family. Had he heard from them? Moussa would only talk about himself, that he was fine, no word about his family.</p><p><strong><em>What did you do when he would not answer questions about his family?</em></strong></p><p>We would talk about something else, pretend everything in life is fine.… Actually, I used to talk about things that might interest him, either ask him about one of the other kids or speak to him about one of his friends that I had [ already] brought back home to his family, and I would give him some news about that child. Sometimes, I would talk about something that had happened in the city, ask if he knew a specific person, give a little bit of my point of view, listen to his point of view… But Moussa didn’t like talking too much; he would say two or three words, and then it was over; you were the only one talking.</p><p>So, I spoke about my life and how my day went. I told him about my children and my wife; it was a little like talking to a friend. For example, I would say to him that this morning I dropped my child off at school, and then I went to work, and on the road, I ran into this person, we talked about that… you see? And about my child, how every morning before getting her ready for school it’s always a hassle, she makes me run after her to take her to school… things like that.</p><p><strong><em>Is there anything else you did to build such a good relationship with him?</em></strong></p><p>Sometimes, when he was with the group, I invited him to talk to me on the side, in private. There, I found him more open. It gave him more confidence because he knew I would not repeat what he told me to others.</p><p>One day, Moussa told me he no longer wanted to stay on the street. He asked me to accompany him to his family, ‘But where do you want to stay?’ I asked. He said: ‘I want to stay with my maternal grandfather.’ ‘But what about your father and your mother?’ He didn’t say any more. So I said, ‘Okay, Moussa, I trust you. If you’ve really decided to go, we’ll leave next Tuesday.’</p><p>The following Monday, I picked him up and said, ‘If you still want to see your family, you can come and sleep at ATD so we can go together early in the morning, and he came. He slept in the courtyard, and in the morning, he showered and cleaned his clothes. Then we left. On the road, we stopped for breakfast. I also hoped to get his father and mother’s address. Accompanying a child without any information about the child’s family means taking a risk. But as usual, Moussa did not talk. We continued our ride and arrived at the grandfather’s village. Moussa didn’t remember where his grandfather lived. We looked around for over an hour but didn’t find the grandfather’s house. Finally, we sat down. ‘What do we do now?’ I could see in his eyes that Moussa was disappointed. But then he told me, ‘I have an aunt in another village; I can recognise her place.’ I said, ‘Will we be turning and turning there too?’ Moussa gave me some directions. It reassured me, and we continued. We actually found the aunt’s home. She welcomed us and then kindly accompanied us to the grandfather’s house, even though she said, ‘The grandfather is never going to accept to take him in.’ We went in and talked with the grandfather; the whole family was there and welcomed us warmly. I asked the family to trust Moussa. Indeed, he ran away several times, but now he has decided to stay with his grandfather. I also spoke about children who had had a more complicated life than Moussa and who stayed with their families because of the trust their families placed in them.</p><p>From then on, Moussa stayed with his family. They enrolled him in school. Moussa had previously been to school up to grade 3, but his mother couldn’t get the papers from his old school proving that he had completed the two years and was supposed to begin the 3rd year, so Moussa had to do the 1st year again. Moussa stayed during the winter; he helped his grandfather keep the herds and farmed. At one point, due to a misunderstanding, Moussa went back to town. But his mother called me this time, and I found Moussa in town that evening. I reassured the mother that I had seen Moussa and that we had to give him time because bringing him back by force was useless. I followed Moussa, who said he didn’t want to return but wanted to look for work in town and that a gentleman had offered him domestic work. I informed his mother, but she disagreed with this arrangement because Moussa could potentially be exploited and abused. The ATD team was also concerned, so I told this gentleman that the mother and the team disagreed with the situation and that he shouldn’t make Moussa work for him. Ultimately, Moussa stayed with the man for two weeks, and after that the gentleman brought him back to town. The following day, I took Moussa back to his grandfather’s. Since then, Moussa has stayed there. Occasionally, I visit him with other children I take in the same direction as Moussa’s village. Also, from time to time, I call the mother or the grandfather to ask for news; Moussa and I also talk.</p><p><strong><em>At the end of Florent’s account, Orna Shemer asks the participants what they had learned from the session.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Deriving the ‘Principles of Action’ that underlay successful actions.</strong></p><p>Orna: Now, each participant can try to formulate a Principle of Action — a sentence that regroups similar actions from this story. In other words, it includes initiatives that Florent carried out or discussions that determined that he acted in a particular manner. Find active sentences that gather four to five very close actions.</p><p>Magdalena: What I heard from the story is <strong>Trust the child</strong>.</p><p>Orna: Okay, and which actions make you recognise that he trusts the child?</p><p>Magdalena: Florent said that he told Moussa that he trusts him.</p><p>Mariana: He asked the child what he could do at different moments.</p><p>Caroline: To say to the child: ‘you didn’t come to the <em>Mo’cool</em>,’ makes the child aware that we expect something from him.</p><p>Orna: Can you say the principle of action behind that in one sentence?</p><p>Caroline:<strong> To be demanding, to have high expectations of the child.</strong></p><p>Prisca: <strong>To involve other children to support Moussa in his plan to return to the family</strong></p><p>Suzanna: When Florent asked the child about the family, he said nothing. But the conversation flowed when he talked about other things, his family and day-to-day issues. I would name it a principle of action:<strong> Keep talking to the child.</strong></p><p>David: He rang the mother, went with Moussa to look for his grandfather’s house, and returned several times.</p><p>Orna: Ah! This is important. Because if an action happens once, it’s usually not a principle of action. It’s just an action. We should be able to give more than one example of an action for a principle of action. So this principle of action would be…?</p><p>David: <strong>To be very thorough when trying to mend family ties.</strong></p><p>Bruno: I’m impressed that Florent decided to shortcut the usual procedure and go with the child without contacting the family first. He said this was a risk, but the team supported his decision. They didn’t even wait to find the proper address. Instead, they chose to be guided by the child’s strong desire to return to his family and understood that the child was ready for it. Even though there is a procedure based on solid experience, they are attentive to the child. When the child is ready, you don’t waste time. You decide: We’re going on Tuesday. I would call this principle of action: <strong>To seize the right moment.</strong></p><p>Orna: This is the method of Learning from Success. To sum up what we just did: We understood the story and decided that this was a success after we heard the “before”, the “after” and the “costs”. We listened to the story through the actions. We discovered the principles of action behind the actions, and if we had more time, I’m sure we could still find more principles of action.</p><p>Florent, you know how to apply these principles from your experiences, and now we can learn from you how to build a relationship in this context, take it into our own context, and learn what we need to know from your story. We understand that for ATD Fourth World in Ouagadougou, each successful re-connection of family ties confirms the importance of each person’s roots in their family and community, and the bonds that are formed.</p><p><a href="#sdfootnote1anc">1</a> <em>This story about Moussa, is an abridged version of the Learning from Success dialogue between Florent Bambara and the Learning Companion </em>Orna Shemer<em>. This dialogue demonstrates that through patient ‘digging’ with questions that ask to describe rather than to explain, reason or justify- tacit knowledge from practice can be ‘unearthed’. It demonstrates how principles of action is useful for further or similar action can be drawn from the successful experience without duplicating actions regardless of the context and circumstances. The subtitles in this chapter correspond to the steps from the Learning from Success Method (</em>For more information, download the methodology <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2023/11/2023-11-10-LEARNING-FROM-SUCCESS2.pdf">sheet here</a>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1680c0bceecd" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/find-your-roots-to-grow-well-1680c0bceecd">Find your roots to grow well</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Right to the City: Participatory approach to poverty reduction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/right-to-the-city-participatory-approach-to-poverty-reduction-5a877edc0768?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a877edc0768</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[slums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[urban]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[swabhimaan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Jul 2022 12:50:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-25T12:53:51.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/961/1*YvmvyOJ5sO7o4XQeeyTpKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sunset over Bengaluru. Photo </strong><a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:KshitizBathwal&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1"><strong>KshitizBathwal</strong></a><strong> / Skyscape Photography, CC BY-SA 4.0</strong></figcaption></figure><p>By Anshul Sharma</p><p>Anti-poverty programs and schemes have faced various issues in all stages of policy formulation. These are, policy-making, implementation and policy evaluation. One main reason behind this is the linear assumptions made in these policies. Such linear processes fail to account for the different ways in which policy practice fails to understand the urban poor. This article aims to highlight the lack of participation of slum residents with the rest of the city. In this sense, it aims to inform better policy making for urban policies with slums.</p><p><strong>Urban Slums of Bengaluru and its residents</strong></p><p>Indian cities, in the 21st century have become aspirational hubs. A key part of this aspiration is the notion of a World Class City (Ghertner 2015). However, it has also been identified as a site of deprivation and exclusion. More importantly, it seems to work on deprivation <em>through</em> exclusion. In Bangalore, as in other Indian cities, this happens at multiple levels, from material deprivation that would limit one’s ability to live a healthy and secure life to non-material deprivation that impacts how and in what ways we participate in the social world around us. The latter type of deprivation comes forth explicitly in various forms of institutionalized outcasting that continue to plague Indian cities (Yengde 2019). A key form of this deprivation is a form of puritanism that animates the idea of urban localities in Indian cities (Ghertner 2015). Such puritanism determines what is visible and what remains invisible in the city landscape, a question which is at the heart of Urban slums and how we place them inside our cities. However, invisibility of certain communities from the city’s cultural and economic landscape influences how these communities participate in these realms. Effectively, the cleanliness rhetoric and aversion towards informal settlements discourages engagement of residents from these settlements with the larger city and deprives them of the larger ‘Right to the city’.</p><p><strong>Exclusion in the Everyday: Curbing participation</strong></p><p>In slum areas of Rajendra Nagar, a slum of Bengaluru, several physical exclusionary forms are apparent. Area-wise, the slum is situated in the inner city. Residents interact with the outside world on a daily basis in the form of work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/0*tZD1zWYiGQV3Xuxx" /><figcaption><strong>Map of Rajendra Nagar</strong></figcaption></figure><p>During my fieldwork as a researcher in this settlement, I used a number of research tools to understand the spatial sense of the young people in the slum. I noticed a key characteristic among the young people in the slum. They would associate nearby localities as <em>distant</em>. When I told them that I have come from Koramangala, their likely response would be that I have come from ‘a place far away’ despite the fact that Koramangala is just a 20 minute walk from the slum. Such responses point out the differential view of distances that are imbibed by residents in the slum. Even though they stay within the inner city, the ‘right to the city’ has eluded them. An explicit expression of such exclusion was seen in another example when some young students reported that they weren’t allowed to play in the playground outside the slum area. Other examples surfaced from a number of young people in their interactions with the institutions outside the slum. Denied entry to a mall, chased away from the playground, questioned by police on the streets are some examples of how this exclusion happens on a daily basis. It is this practice that has led to the embeddedness of the slum, where more and more young people tend to stay within the slum limits with limited access to the city outside. Such trends are dangerous, as pointed out in context of a different Indian city, the proliferation of a puritan notion that marginalizes specific populations could lead to internalization of this aesthetic (Ghertner 2015). This happens to such an extent that some of the slum dwellers I interviewed themselves felt that they weren’t entitled to using the common spaces of the city.</p><p><strong>Economic exclusion in the everyday:</strong> Participation will mean many things, foremost being the ability to economically engage with the city. In this regard, the residents can be characterized as ‘citizens without the city’ (Appadurai 2013). Meaning that the main inner city jobs might provide stable jobs to residents are off-limits to them. Indeed, as one moves through the settlements of Rajendra nagar and LR Nagar, we encounter rag pickers, petty vendors, mechanic’s assistants, cart pullers and other similar forms of work constitute the predominant forms of jobs that the slum dwellers occupy. While men are largely involved in this type of work, a substantial part of the labour force is driven by women and children. I met several women who, having been denied formal credit from banks, have used various means to set up their own small businesses.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zoDGkz2BAQxyK0nc" /><figcaption><strong>Women entrepreneurs in Rajendra Nagar</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Empowerment through Self-respect:</strong> It must be noted that such processes have given birth to various solidarity practices that address such exclusions.</p><p><strong>Swabhimaan</strong>, a community led organization, which literally translates into ‘Self-respect’, has addressed some of these concerns in its intervention towards urban poor programs. Founded in 2000, this organization is based in various slums of Bengaluru which include Rajendra nagar, LR nagar, Karidsandra, Banashankari and others. It aims at improving the lives of urban poor in these neighborhoods by empowering them with health, education and finance services. Understanding Swabhimaan is useful in appreciating how grassroots movements have handled the issue of dignity in their welfare programs. A key part of this initiative is its participatory nature, where slum residents themselves come together and address community concerns. There are overarching concerns with youth empowerment and creating robust infrastructure in the slum, initiating almost an unslumming process (Jacobs 1961). The organization is committed to working with the slum dwellers already know and understand, mobilizing resources and providing relief. In this sense, it resonates with the <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/">ATD Fourth World</a>’s approach in using people’s self-knowledge as a key resource in poverty alleviation. Another key similarity is the focus on sustainability, Swabhimaan ensures that all forms of resource distribution, mobilization and capacity building happens in a sustainable manner without compromising delivery. ATD’s larger strategic ambitions and Swabhimaan’s rooted practices provide a critical perspective on the current anti-poverty policies that are preoccupied by patrental redistribution (Duflo 2012). It is clear that a more nuanced approach would focus on a more participatory approach to poverty issues where people can participate more fully in their own lives and the world around them. Slums are a part of the city and urban policies must attempt to accommodate them by enhancing participatory practices of the slum dwellers with the larger city. This calls for a major overhaul of the urban governance and how it views the urban slums’ role in the cities. Indeed, social interaction enriches communities and creates solidarity that is beyond the narrow communities in which most slum dwellers are systematically subjected to in the status quo of Bengaluru slums.</p><p><strong>References:</strong><br>Ghertner, D. Asher. <em>Rule by Aesthetics: World-Class City Making in Delhi</em>. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2015.<br>Yengde, Suraj. 2019. <em>Caste Matters</em>. Gurgaon: Penguin Viking.<br>Appadurai, Arjun, ed. 2013. <em>The Future as Cultural Fact: Essays on the Global Condition</em>. London: New York : Verso Books.<br>Jacobs, Jane. 1961. <em>The Death and Life of Great American Cities</em>.<br>Esther, Duflo. 2012. <em>Human Values and the design of fight against poverty</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a877edc0768" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/right-to-the-city-participatory-approach-to-poverty-reduction-5a877edc0768">Right to the City: Participatory approach to poverty reduction</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social Justice, Environmental Justice and Human Dignity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/social-justice-environmental-justice-and-human-dignity-83e848da0178?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/83e848da0178</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environmental-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-dignity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[central-african-republic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 May 2021 07:21:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-24T07:21:54.142Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/489/1*UmZqguEo_rN3SkDyoJzg7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Watercolor: Six months in Central African Republic, CAR, 2007 © Jaqueline Page / ATD Fourth World / AR0200901012.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Christian Rhugwasanye</strong> is an ATD Fourth World <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/who-we-are/members/supporters-and-friends/">ally</a> living in the Central African Republic. As a child in the Democratic Republic of Congo, he was a member of the <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/get-involved/tapori-children-network/">Tapori</a> group in his home town of Bukavu. When he grew older, Christian joined ATD’s <a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/what-we-do/participation/youth-activities/">youth movement</a>. There, he led solidarity workshops and support programs with families living in extreme poverty. Several years later, he coordinated a group called Friends of ATD Fourth World.</p><p>In June 2016, Christian moved to Burundi to study civil engineering. There he and some friends led Tapori children’s groups. In addition, he helped organise mutual support activities with families in Bujumbura and Bubanza province.</p><p>Christian feels strongly about how climate change impacts families who are powerless to protect themselves from floods and landslides. In December 2020, he left for India to get a master’s degree in environmental and geotechnical engineering.</p><p><em>By Christian Rhugwasanye</em></p><p>We chase money, industrial development, and scientific and economic progress. We constantly want to fill our bank accounts more and more. At the same time, wildlife and plant species are rapidly disappearing around us. In order to satisfy the desires and aspirations of modern life, technology, and the economy, lakes and seas are heavily polluted.</p><p>Climate and ecological disasters are becoming more common. Agribusiness and the use of industrial technologies severely degrade the environment. Our living conditions on this planet are in danger. What will be left for future generations?</p><p>We must realize that science will never create a substitute for fish, birds, lakes, rivers, and forests. Yet all of these are essential to the ecosystem. Moreover, those in poverty and indigenous peoples are often the first victims of these disastrous climate changes. And no one hears their voices. In fact, they have no role in decision-making on these issues.</p><p>To avoid the worst, here are some proposals:</p><p><strong>Let’s use technology to preserve the environment.</strong> Any technology that does not contribute to a world of solidarity and a protected environment is not helpful. Let’s move away from technology that destroys resources in order to enrich a few at the expense of many.</p><p><strong>We must act together and transform I into WE</strong>. We need a form of governance where everyone can participate. It is sad to see that the people making decisions have learned about the effects of climate change from books. At the same time, no one listens to people who have actually been affected by climate change. Sustainable development will only occur when all people are involved in the process.</p><p><strong>The people most affected by climate change are in the best position to propose fair solutions.</strong> They can make decisions that will not sacrifice future generations. Someday, these people might only be able to see animals in pictures!</p><p>Climate change is a matter of human dignity and social justice. We should keep in mind the extent of destruction that has occurred for years in the Amazon forest. Was everyone involved in the choices that led to this damage? Certainly not.</p><p>I would love to see an indigenous person from the Amazon sing for two minutes before the start of international summits on climate and the environment.</p><p>It is important that states meet at the Conferences of the Parties (COP) on climate change to agree on how to address the devastating environmental situation. Without such agreement at all these meetings and conventions, pollution and natural disasters will only increase.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=83e848da0178" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/social-justice-environmental-justice-and-human-dignity-83e848da0178">Social Justice, Environmental Justice and Human Dignity</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[People in Poverty: Agents of Peace and Development]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/people-in-poverty-agents-of-peace-and-development-239b38996e52?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/239b38996e52</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rdc-congo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Jul 2019 06:04:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-29T06:04:50.021Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*8bTxn2JKt9I2cn3-5zkZfg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>By Saleh Kazige Abasi</strong></p><p><strong>Bukavu, Democratic Republic of the Congo — </strong>In everyday life, human beings seek happiness and a feeling of well-being through their actions and decisions. We all need to find food and be with other people regardless of our social status or position, our health, our living standards, or our origins. We all want to belong to a cohesive group and, little by little, we work to achieve that. And we work in a similar way to achieve peace and development, which are inseparable.</p><p>Peace and development can be understood in various ways. For some people, peace is “an answer to families living without shelter, to children who want to go to school but who always face obstacles in their way”. In its definition of peace, UMUSEKE, an organisation in Rwanda that promotes education for peace, defines peace as “the development of a country and its people. It is when the people are free in their activities and when the country produces enough to benefit all its citizens”.</p><p>The notion of peace is thus inextricably linked to development: all human beings must work for peace and all are encouraged to do so, says UMUSEKE. The word “all” includes people living in extreme poverty, victims of rejection and discrimination whose rights are disregarded.</p><p><strong><em>When it comes to peace, and development projects, the efforts of people living in poverty, although an integral part of their lives, are often unseen, unrecognised, or simply ignored.</em></strong></p><p>They are deprived of the means to take on their responsibilities and exercise their rights, to the extent that institutions and social structures are often of no help to them. Yet they must be placed at the centre of these projects since they also have the power to reflect and to act. The situation will change only if other people dare to risk their personal situation for the good of people crushed by the suffering of poverty.</p><p>The work to build peace and development must not be the prerogative of a select minority (such as politicians, officers of the law, academics, and national or international associations). Instead, we must recognise that everyone can contribute; we should not ignore the efforts of some people by considering only the efforts of others. Eugen Brand, former director general of ATD Fourth World, points out that people who have suffered the violence of extreme poverty don’t want a mere façade of peace, a surface peace; they want a peace that will lead to real change.</p><p><em>The first change is for all people to be able to live among others and to have access to their rights.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=239b38996e52" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/people-in-poverty-agents-of-peace-and-development-239b38996e52">People in Poverty: Agents of Peace and Development</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Overcoming Advocacy Fatigue]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/overcoming-advocacy-fatigue-1e473f49dfd0?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e473f49dfd0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philippines]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jul 2019 06:12:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-26T06:12:15.927Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*Z9DKWgyWYP2Wpoi7tBQvIw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Michelle Baena Ciriacruz</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>On July 2–5, 2019, Michelle Baena Ciriacruz, from the Philippines participated in ATD Fourth World’s international session on communication practices and training, “Comm’ON.” Participants came from Belgium, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, France, Guatemala, the Philippines, Poland, Tanzania, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Michelle says that getting to know face-to-face other members of ATD Fourth World’s international community and being able to learn from their experiences encourages her to continue on with her advocacy:</em></strong></p><p>“I have a confession. Lately, I have been feeling what they call ‘advocacy fatigue.’ In my country that is now experiencing a number of challenges, including an increase in human rights violations and environmental problems, it seems to me that what volunteers and allies are doing is not enough to make a lasting impact on society. As I’m involved not just with ATD Philippines but also with groups dedicated to animal welfare, environmental protection, heritage preservation, and community development, I see how everything is interconnected, and especially how poverty affects so many aspects of society. I have been asking myself, “How can my own contributions in communications and fundraising make a difference?” In the middle of this soul-searching came the invitation from ATD Fourth World to participate in the Comm’ON session.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*S1oyQR4sER6JSR_BrOGm6A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Comm’ON participants</figcaption></figure><p>“In my own country, communicating our commitment of ‘leaving no one behind’ remains a challenge. We do have success in social media to highlight the right of poor communities to actively participate in finding solutions to eradicate poverty, particularly on the United Nations International Day for the Eradication of Poverty and in attracting people to help facilitate our annual<a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/what-we-do/culture-and-education/festival-of-learning/"> <em>Festival of Learning</em></a> or to tutor children in our basic literacy program,<a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/you-are-awesome/"> <em>Ang Galing!</em></a> But I felt that our voice calling for social change may not be enough. Millions of families are still living in poverty. The current political climate has been very harsh on our partner communities.</p><p>“At Comm’ON, my world view became clearer. Being able to share knowledge and take part in experiences in person with the other teams allowed me to understand more clearly the big picture of ATD’s decades-long work across the globe. I came to appreciate better how our own community-based efforts impact the international initiatives (and vice versa). I think, perhaps, I may not have properly appreciated the dynamics between the international movement and our own local actions before the meeting. I am awed as I realize that, as an ATD friend, I am part of an ambitious international community that has achieved milestones such as the UN pledge to “leave no one behind” in its 2030 Agenda of Sustainable Development Goals in 2015. More recently, an<a href="https://www.atd-fourthworld.org/we-would-like-others-to-stop-making-decisions-for-us/?fbclid=IwAR04SEefg1-SoS7Nase4KGn8C8JWitOzpYR4WZ6jyg6yV0cicJSUt-Dlau4"> ATD Fourth World delegation was able to impress on a UN Council President</a> that world leaders should stop making decisions for poor communities but do things with them instead. She shared this message at the 2019 High-Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development on July 9, 2019.</p><p>“The power of communications has contributed much to this progress. I found all the discussions and workshop sessions very interesting, especially about the groundbreaking Dimensions of Poverty<em> </em>research conducted in partnership with Oxford University in six countries, and also the fact that respect for the earth’s resources is integral to ATD’s work of fostering an economic model that is respectful of all people. Now, I am about to go home with useful tools and knowledge for the Philippines. I feel refreshed and empowered because, after all, we’ve got friends from all over — and all together we are working in dignity.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e473f49dfd0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/overcoming-advocacy-fatigue-1e473f49dfd0">Overcoming Advocacy Fatigue</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“It’s difference that is pretty…”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/its-difference-that-is-pretty-d70bb21185b2?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d70bb21185b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[france]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Jul 2019 08:21:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-14T08:34:39.255Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/584/1*CNjEST650vkrM-RLqutfUQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>“It’s Difference That Is Pretty…”</h3><p><strong>By Pascal Percq<br>France</strong></p><p>As I was arriving at a meeting, a melody was swirling in my head that I had heard one evening on the banks of the Niger River, sung by the Malian Salif Keita in his song “The Difference.” That day was actually about “differences” and “tolerance” towards people who mostly had lived with intolerance from others from prejudgements, from not being taken into consideration, from having fallen victim to stigma linked to the fact that they had once in their life been seen as “different.” This is in a normatively intolerant society which celebrates “winners” and knocks down those whom it judges, according to its criteria, to be “losers”.</p><p>This meeting was part of a Fourth World People’s University, a place of mutual training, with a confrontation between words and ways of living, and this time the theme was: “Tolerance, or how to enrich ourselves from our differences”. A “sensitive” theme for those who have had experience of… intolerance.</p><p>“<em>I have been mocked since I’ve been in a wheelchair”</em>, says Fred. Catherine: <em>“My eldest child has been placed in care and I was told that I don’t know how to look after him. They should explain why.”</em></p><p>A small group has made a list of all the differences which may potentially lead to intolerant behaviour. A nearly endless list. “<em>Beliefs, origins, religion, particular qualities, being foreign, being French. From lived experiences from early school years, some children understand quickly, others take more time. Even in sports there are differences. Some are rich, some are poor. We are different in the organisation of our lives in sleep, in food. Also in family relationships, whether close or extended (some abandon their parents and others are abandoned). Romany families or “Rroms” (who are without solutions) and are treated as grubby people — there is no tolerance for them. Those who have a home, those who don’t. It can depend on legal status. On skin colour, and even on hair colour (poor redheads in school playgrounds!). Differences are also cultural: the French spend hours at the dinner table and it’s different in other cultures. The differences can be in regards to gender, sexual preference, age. If one has a handicap or is healthy. Even concerning behaviour around others: those who speak up, and those who are afraid or ashamed to speak…”.</em></p><p>Differences: we could conclude that each one of us is different, just from the colour of our eyes. And so? The group continues: <em>“We all have the same blood, of the same colour, which runs through us. We are all different but equal. In theory.”</em></p><p>This experience of being a victim of intolerance can lead to reactions from some people such as pushing others away, feeling despised and scorned, losing self-confidence. But one day, an encounter occurs. And everything changes. Being able to talk about it with others, “it changes lives”. <em>“It sometimes takes courage to overcome oneself and to dare to go towards others. I was an intolerant person, but now I tell myself that I mustn’t react as I used to. Because one day, in particular in my little group, somebody listened to me and I understood that this person whom I despised, this person deserved to be known better. I grew and evolved by being in contact with them”. “Knowledge is what makes us overcome rejection, and also being confronted with people different from you.”</em></p><p>You have to dare to make a “sidestep”. <em>“If there’s no respect, there is no tolerance”.</em> Somebody adds: “Tolerance can sometimes be negative; one says one is tolerant because one is indifferent.” “Being tolerant can also be cowardice, to submit and say nothing because the other person is more powerful.” “Tolerance starts with oneself. If one does not love oneself, how can be tolerant of others!”</p><p>If one has been a victim of intolerance, can that become a positive experience?</p><p>“<em>I know what it is to be judged. So, I refuse to judge others. On the contrary, I want to tell them to go above and beyond that”.</em></p><p>As expressed by Fatiha: <em>“Tolerance is the fact of accepting someone as they are, even if they react differently and have different preferences, as no one is perfect, including us. We are all different and we all have good qualities and flaws. Tolerance is something that’s learnt, and it has a calming effect: everything gets turned down a notch. Being curious to know, to learn about and understand the differences of others is also about learning to protect yourself and not letting yourself be pushed around…”.</em> Catherine comments: <em>“I listen to a lot of music. Even in another language, I understand what it means…”.</em> Music…</p><p>The evening of this encounter, I had a listen to Salif Keita, the Malian singer and his song “The Difference”. According to him: “Difference is precisely the wealth of life”. This African, an albino abused for that very reason since childhood — until he became an international celebrity — sings: <strong><em>“I am a black man, my skin is white. And I like that. Difference is what’s pretty. I long for us to get along together in love. For us to understand each other in love and in peace. Life will be beautiful. Yeah, life will be beautiful.”</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d70bb21185b2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/its-difference-that-is-pretty-d70bb21185b2">“It’s difference that is pretty…”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Education for Breaking Out of Poverty]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/education-for-breaking-out-of-poverty-d7cd2f548ffc?source=rss----6ced91b38424---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d7cd2f548ffc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[african]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[africa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ATD Fourth World]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jul 2019 11:26:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-09T11:24:52.111Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/584/1*0cTHGU_RB5tEQAKntEkLcw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>By Denise Nvomera Ntegeza</strong></p><p><strong>The Democratic Republic of the Congo — </strong>The objectives for sustainable development in education emphasize the importance of free primary schooling — something that has not been provided in the Democratic Republic of the Congo or in many African countries.</p><p>A seminar organized by ATD Fourth World focused on the theme “Everyone can learn if…”. The three suspension points represent the multiple obstacles that prevent all children from having equal access to education, including obstacles related to family poverty, increasing insecurity in many countries, wartime conditions, etc.</p><p>We need to think about how to change the way the public looks at people in the deepest poverty. We need to think about how to put people who live in extreme poverty topmost in our concerns.</p><p>As parents, we have to start in our own families by laying the groundwork for basic education to pave the way for what will come next. All guidelines and suggestions should help us in the process of finding peace and working for other long-lasting solutions. We’re not only calling on families to take on more responsibility, but also appealing to the government and its institutions to guarantee that justice is done on all levels, They should make sure that all children — including those who live in poverty — can enjoy their right to free and compulsory primary education and that schools are safely accessible with no illegal or hidden fees.</p><p>Being ambassadors of peace, we as parents have to start in our own families by first solidifying the education that we give to our children, because without basic education a whole life can be wasted. If we are successful, the results will speak for themselves. We shouldn’t leave all the responsibility to the state since, by itself, the state is powerless.</p><p>Right now, certain governments act as if the people didn’t exist, as if children didn’t have the right to education and protection. There will be justice once the existence of others is taken into account and starvation wages no longer exist. Three, four, five, or six months of unpaid work won’t support a person’s well-being.</p><p>Social classes exist in every society, but we have to show that inequality leads to atrocities and that some people are being brutally impacted by poverty.</p><p>With the help of ATD Fourth World, we must issue a plea for governments to apply the principles of equality and fairness, and then even children from a background of poverty will be able to sit in a classroom, and we will build responsible, viable nations.</p><p>Children experiencing grave poverty may suddenly stop going to school or never attend at all because they are obliged to earn money or take on domestic tasks at home. Worse still, some find themselves living in the streets, with a wretched future ahead of them.</p><p>Education is essential if children are to be allowed to develop their personality, skills, and talents.</p><p>Schooling provides children with opportunities to participate in an effective way in social life and thus escape poverty by becoming assets not only for themselves but for the whole community.</p><p>The failure to complete primary and secondary education has economic consequences that devastate families and prolong the cycle of poverty.</p><p>Listen to our brothers and sisters in Syria: Little 8-year-old Mouna said on Radio France International, “We have hidden schools; parents won’t allow children to go to school anymore because so many have died when the schools were bombarded.”</p><p>A Syrian teacher said that she and her colleagues volunteered to do what they could to contribute to the education of children.</p><p>School is life; it’s our children’s future; it’s the future of an entire people. Children who aren’t in school are a ticking time bomb.</p><p>“Everyone can learn if…”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d7cd2f548ffc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity/education-for-breaking-out-of-poverty-d7cd2f548ffc">Education for Breaking Out of Poverty</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/together-in-dignity">Together in Dignity</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>