<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Tow Center - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[The Tow Center for Digital Journalism at the Columbia Graduate School for Journalism - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/tow-center?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 22:44:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/tow-center" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scorched Earth Litigation: the call for Anti-SLAPP may save you]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/scorched-earth-litigation-the-call-for-anti-slapp-may-save-you-5ab50447d07b?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ab50447d07b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tow Center]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Nov 2022 21:43:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-18T18:14:29.304Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*j7Be-VxO4ySFEG7HDQAP2g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>By Victoria Baranetsky and Robert Rosenthal</em></p><p>Six years ago, an attempt to silence and destroy our nonprofit investigative reporting news organization, The Center for Investigative Reporting, began. That attempt, in the form of libel litigation, ended last month when the subject of our investigation agreed to one of the largest settlements in a defamation case.</p><p>In 2016, Planet Aid, a nonprofit charity and its employee Lisbeth Thomsen sued CIR after our newsroom published a series of articles and podcasts about them. The stories followed an 18-month investigation during which CIR’s reporters traveled to multiple continents and reported that Planet Aid diverted funds from their intended recipients, falsified invoices, failed to provide livestock and agricultural inputs to local farmers, and extracted kickbacks from the salaries. Plaintiffs alleged all this reporting was false. We fiercely objected and ultimately won.</p><p>The case turned on whether Planet Aid and Ms. Thomsen were public figures and whether CIR acted with actual malice so as to have knowingly published false information about them. A federal district found in our favor on both points. This was affirmed by the Ninth Circuit’s decision that had even broader ramifications for the First Amendment and the freedom of the press.</p><p>The Circuit Court stated, “The Supreme Court has long enshrined ‘a profound national commitment to the principle that debate on public issues should be uninhibited, robust, and wide-open.’” It further stated that this protected speech “may well include vehement, caustic, and sometimes unpleasantly sharp attacks on government and public officials,” solidifying the already stalwart rule that the press must be uninhibited in its ability to report on matters of public concern.</p><p>Despite having won, the lawsuit had significant costs.</p><p>This case which took six years to conclude could have easily bankrupted us. In its complaint listed 80 statements that were inaccurate and sought an estimated $25 million in damages. But with more than 4 million dollars in pro bono legal support from Covington &amp; Burling and Davis Wright Tremaine — and California’s strong anti-SLAPP statute protecting freedom of press — CIR has been saved, for the time being.</p><p>Anti-SLAPPs are state laws that provide for the early dismissal of cases, known as Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPPs), that masquerade as ordinary lawsuits but are intended to deter or punish people from exercising their right to speech.</p><p>Journalism and journalists are under assault around the world and without Congressional support for anti-SLAPPs, investigative reporting and newsrooms, especially nonprofits, may well be eliminated by often frivolous and vexatious lawsuits. While some states have anti-SLAPP statutes, not all states do, and some have weak statutes that don’t include attorney’s fees reimbursement clauses. And a federal anti-SLAPP statute — protecting freedom of speech nationwide — does not yet exist.</p><p>In CIR’s case, the final issue, attorney’s fees, was recently settled, with $1.925 million being paid to insurers and pro bono counsel. So even with CA’s strong anti-SLAPP law, our battle took six years, including two years of discovery.</p><p>The future of journalism, freedom of the press, and an informed citizenry cannot depend on the benevolence of pro bono lawyers and the benefit of your state having a strong anti-SLAPP. Many journalists and newsrooms who face litigation scares daily may not have that privilege.</p><p>“Anti-SLAPP statutes are intended to discourage defamation claims against good faith reporting on matter of public concern — to prevent well-heeled targets of commentary and news reporting from silencing critics,” said Simon Frankel, CIR’s lead attorney at Covington &amp; Burling, which led discovery in our case. “This case is Exhibit A for why we should have robust anti-SLAPP statutes.”</p><p>The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the press states, “SLAPPs have become an all-too-common tool for intimidating and silencing criticism through expensive, baseless legal proceedings. Anti-SLAPP laws are intended to prevent people from using courts, and potential threats of a lawsuit, to intimidate people who are exercising their First Amendment rights.” With uneven state anti-SLAPP protections, plaintiffs can manipulate state laws to their benefit. For instance, Planet Aid initially tried to file their lawsuit in Maryland, a state with a weak anti-SLAPP law; although we succeeded in having the case moved to California, as was legally appropriate, over two years Plaintiffs tried three more times to move it back to Maryland. This battle over jurisdiction clearly demonstrates the need for federal anti-SLAPP protection.</p><p>This is especially the case as the <a href="https://inn.org/research/inn-index/inn-index-2022/executive-summary/">number of nonprofit newsrooms</a> has <a href="https://www.poynter.org/reporting-editing/2021/more-than-50-local-newsrooms-launched-during-the-pandemic/">shot up in the past three years</a> to respond to the dearth of local news and investigative reporting. CIR and other nonprofit newsrooms are especially vulnerable, as plaintiffs often <a href="https://en.unesco.org/sites/default/files/the-chilling_chapter4.pdf">attack individuals</a> or defendants with fewer resources. Larger newsrooms — including the British Broadcasting Corporation, The Boston Globe, The Washington Post and The Los Angeles Times — have all reported on Planet Aid, but plaintiffs chose to single out CIR in the lawsuit — the newsroom with the fewest resources. However, it is precisely these vulnerable institutions, like ours, that often tell local stories or conduct more obscure investigations, holding accountable powerful organizations in society that would otherwise go unchecked.</p><p>In 2015, Mother Jones faced a similar lawsuit. And this past year, investigative reporter Carole Cadwalladr survived a <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/commentisfree/2022/jun/19/arron-banks-set-out-to-crush-me-in-court-instead-my-quest-for-the-facts-was-vindicated">defamation suit</a> brought against her by British businessman and political donor Arron Banks for her reporting. The lawsuit targeted Cadwalladr as an individual — not the <em>Observer</em>, the paper that published her work — forcing her to rely on crowdfunding to support her legal defense.</p><p>A federal anti-SLAPP statute, like the kind recently introduced by Rep. Jamie Raskin in Congress, is the only path to ensuring that the rights of smaller newsrooms, nonprofits, and individuals who hold power to account are able to survive.</p><p>Planet Aid’s case against CIR could have easily ended differently, says Thomas R. Burke, a first amendment attorney with DWT and the author of “Anti-SLAPP Litigation,” who led our defense. He devoted thousands of hours over six years to the case. He describes the case as the most complicated of his life. Why did he do it?</p><p>“I could not stand by and watch this plaintiff put CIR, which has done so much over five decades, reporting on things that are essential for the public, be put out of business. If it was the last thing I ever did, CIR was not going to fall on my watch,” Burke said.</p><p>The passage of an anti-SLAPP statute would let smaller newsrooms rest easy, knowing they are protected. This is particularly important given the growing numbers of wealthy individuals and institutions that can use their power to attack less powerful outlets trying to tell important and otherwise unseen news stories.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ab50447d07b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/scorched-earth-litigation-the-call-for-anti-slapp-may-save-you-5ab50447d07b">Scorched Earth Litigation: the call for Anti-SLAPP may save you</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Growing Strength of Public Media Local Journalism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/the-growing-strength-of-public-media-local-journalism-7f17864d9682?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f17864d9682</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solutions-journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tow Center]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Oct 2022 17:28:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-04T17:28:57.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>By Elizabeth Hansen Shapiro, Mark Fuerst, Caroline Porter</em></p><p>We live in an era of shrinking local journalism capacity. By now we all know the statistics: Since 2005 more than one in four newspapers — 2,500 total — have shuttered in the U.S. Overall employment in the newspaper industry has decreased 70% as total newspaper revenues have dropped 60%. Two out of three counties in the U.S. do not have a daily newspaper, and four million Americans do not have access to any local newspaper.</p><p>At the same time, we live in an era of expanding local news experimentation. The number of local journalism collaborations, digital start-ups, and nonprofit newsrooms has grown over the last decade. For instance, between 2018 and 2020, 33 local news organizations in the Institute for Nonprofit News (INN) network launched, and according to a July 2022 report, the total number of local nonprofit organizations in the INN network has doubled since 2017.</p><p>Yet perhaps the biggest development in local journalism expansion and policy has been hiding in plain sight.</p><p>In many places around the country, strong public media stations are stepping in to fill the holes left by shrinking daily metro newsrooms by building up their staffs and leaning into new products and platforms. Other stations are partnering with newsrooms in their communities in new and innovative ways that support the overall growth of local news capacity in their regions. And National Public Radio remains a dynamic national news organization with opportunities to deepen collaboration with its local member stations.</p><p>But what is the scale of this growth? With this research, we aim to increase collective knowledge about one set of important institutions we have at the ready for rebuilding local news: The public media system, especially the stations associated with NPR. The evolution and increasing strength of some local public broadcasting institutions in providing local journalism deserve a close look, not just to understand the role public broadcasting can play in rebuilding local news, but to draw lessons from a robust and mature media ecosystem that can inform the development of fledgling local media enterprises everywhere.</p><p>This piece is an abridged version of our research and presents key findings and arguments. For a downloadable version of the full report, see <a href="https://www.nationaltrustforlocalnews.org/_files/ugd/9477fa_131834a47058436b9413a6348d9a2125.pdf">here</a>.</p><p><strong>Methodology and Approach</strong></p><p>We compiled the research for this report with three areas of focus: journalism capacity, sustainability, and reach.</p><p>Over the course of 2021 and 2022, we gathered data on journalism capacity from individuals at the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, GBH, and the Station Resource Group. We collected data about the number of journalism positions in public media across the country, the number of licensees with at least 15 full-time news positions, and the number of licensees providing local news stories for NPR broadcasts.</p><p>Over the course of 2021 and 2022, we gathered data on sustainability from individuals at Blackbaud, the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, Greater Public, National Public Radio, and Station Resource Group. We gathered data about total revenue for news-focused licensees, revenue streams, trends in individual giving and federal funding, the ownership type of broadcast licenses, and projections about the growth of the public radio donor base. We also produced our own analysis using Corporation for Public Broadcasting data from the largest 123 news-focused public radio licensees, collected and tracked since 2015 by one of our authors.</p><p>Over the course of 2021 and 2022, we gathered data on sustainability from individuals at Audience Research Analysis, the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, Greater Public, National Public Radio, Radio Research Consortium, and Station Resource Group. We compiled data about the total weekly audience for public media licensees, the growth of local and regional news collaborations, the percentage of the population reached by public media, total NPR digital weekly audience reach, website and podcast metrics, demographic breakdowns of listener metrics, station rankings, and listener trends before and during the pandemic. In March 2022, we also conducted an original analysis of 119 public radio licensees’ websites to count the number of original newsletters, original news programming, and online story updates.</p><p>From these sources, we compiled a unique and multi-faceted dataset which offers the most comprehensive view to date of the size, scale, and scope of public media local journalism.</p><p><strong>THE GROWING FINANCIAL STRENGTH OF LOCAL PUBLIC RADIO</strong></p><p>The growth of public media is best understood through examining the growing financial strength of the local organizations that own and run public radio signals. (We refer to these organizations as “licensees” and their broadcast signals as “stations.”) This section lays out the key indicators of growing financial strength among local public radio licensees.</p><p><strong>News-focused public radio licensees have enjoyed stable and growing revenue across the decade. </strong>According to an analysis performed by one of our authors, total direct revenue for the largest 123 news-focused public radio licensees has grown steadily, from roughly $678 million in FY2009 to just under $1 billion in FY2020. More than 40% of FY2020 revenue in this group came from individual giving (a term that combines small and major gifts), while underwriting (the public media form of advertising) accounted for about 23% of revenue that year. These two categories represent the largest streams of revenue for public stations in FY2020.</p><p><strong>Americans have been giving to public radio in greater numbers across the past decade.</strong> If we look more broadly at the entire system of public radio stations (including all news, music, and eclectic formatted stations), the donor base and individual giving capacity for public radio stations continues to grow, even in the face of increasing competition for media donations. In FY2020, according to CPB annual financial reports analyzed by the Station Resource Group, individual giving came to nearly $600 million across the entire set of public radio stations, from a donor base of about 3.5 million. By comparison, in FY2009, the entire set of public radio stations had a base of just 2.5 million donors who provided just under $400 million.</p><p><strong>The last five years has seen an increase in giving levels in the public radio donor base. </strong>Available data suggest that small-level, mid-level, and major-level givers have all increased their support to public radio in the last five years, according to a detailed analysis of giving patterns in 54 public radio stations by Greater Public. Small-level givers are those who donate up to $249 per year. Mid-level givers are those who donate $250 to $999; and, major-level givers are those who give $1,000 to $9,999. Greater Public found that the size of each cohort of small-level, mid-level, and major-level givers increased from 2016 to 2020, and the amount that the individuals were giving in each cohort also increased. Relatedly, a 2021 report prepared by Blackbaud’s Target Analytics of 63 stations found that the revenue per donor increased from $150 in 2016 to $175 in 2020.</p><p><strong>Public radio has enjoyed an increase in both sustainers (those who give monthly) and major donors over the last five years.</strong> According to the same detailed analysis of giving patterns in 54 public radio stations performed by Greater Public, the percentage of public radio donors who are sustaining members grew from approximately 500,000 in 2016 to approximately 700,000 in 2020. In 2016, about 20 stations surveyed by Greater Public reported that at least half of their donors were providing support through sustainer programs. By 2020, nearly 40 stations reported that at least half of their givers were sustainers.</p><p>These two reports documenting the expansion of sustainer-donors provide additional evidence of increased financial capacity in public media. Sustaining donors renew at much higher rates than single-gift annual donors, and often contribute at higher levels of annual giving. So the growth of sustainers tells us the donor files of public radio licensees are likely to be strong, durable financial assets in the near and medium term.</p><p><strong>Major giving and planned giving are poised for expansion in public radio. </strong>The public media support organization Greater Public has been leading an initiative to encourage public radio licensees to expand their major giving and planned giving programs. Amongst the licensee members in their initiative, Greater Public found in April 2021 that medium-performing licensees in the cohort were receiving around $2 million per year in major gifts, high-performing licensees were receiving $7.6 million and very high-performing licensees, $8.4 million. Based on projections of giving capacity in the donor base, Greater Public set expansion expectations of more than double those amounts in the next five years: $4.7 million for medium-performing licensees and $19 million for high-performing and very high-performing licensees.</p><p><strong>More growth potential remains across the public radio system.</strong> While there is a top tier of very successful news-focused public media licensees, we see an opportunity for more licensees to capitalize on their strong positions in their local markets. For example, of the 123 news-focused public radio licensees analyzed by one of our authors, seven earned revenue of more than $25 million each in FY2020, with another 15 licensees earning more than $10 million each. These midsize news-focused licensees have room to grow. Beyond the set of news-focused licensees, there is a long tail of smaller licensees with revenue earnings of less than $10 million. Most CPB-funded radio licensees fall into this third category, and there is room for growth here too.</p><p><strong>News-focused public radio licensees are supported by a declining share of public funding. </strong>According to an analysis performed by one of our authors of the largest 123 news-focused public radio licensees, the share of public dollars supporting these licensees (in the form of CPB funding, state funding, and public institutional funds) has declined as their other revenue streams have expanded. This trend among the largest news-focused licensees, however, does not shed light on the inequalities between station owners. Smaller stations, typically those serving sparsely populated rural areas, are supported by a much larger share of federal dollars than large stations serving populous areas.</p><p><strong>News-focused public radio licensees are spending more on content than fundraising.</strong> As revenue has grown in the sector, the data we collected suggest news-focused public radio licensees are spending more resources on producing content and expanding news capacity than on fundraising. In our analysis of 123 news-focused public radio licensees, we found that these licensees spent $640.2 million directly on content production in FY2020. If we account for the full cost of content production, including promotion and delivery, that figure rises to $712.4 million or 69% of total revenues. By comparison, the combined cost of fundraising for licensees’ “generated income” was $202.4 million in 2020, representing 19% of total FY2020 revenues. In other words, as revenues in the system have expanded, public radio stations are spending 3.52 times more on content and its delivery than they are spending on fundraising.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iidhxvtZYb4N84gJ" /></figure><p><strong>Public radio is spending more on content than fundraising.</strong> As revenue has grown in the sector, the data we collected suggest public radio station licensees are spending more resources on producing content and expanding news capacity than on fundraising. In our analysis of 123 public radio licensees, we found that these licensees spent $640.2 million directly on content production in FY2020. If we account for the full cost of content production, including promotion and delivery, that figure rises to $712.4 million or 69% of total revenues. By comparison, the combined cost of fundraising for licensees’ “generated income” was $202.4 million in 2020, representing 19% of total FY2020 revenues. In other words, as revenues in the system have expanded, public radio stations are spending 3.52 times more on content and its delivery than they are spending on fundraising.</p><p><strong>GROWING NEWS CAPACITY: MORE REPORTERS AND MORE LOCAL NEWS CONTENT</strong></p><p>We gathered data from across the public radio system to paint a picture of growing news capacity. The data clearly show that the number of journalists working in public radio has increased, along with investments in new news formats.</p><p><strong>Increasing numbers of journalists work at a local public broadcasting station. </strong>Despite the significant headwinds facing local journalism in recent years, the number of journalists working in both local public radio and local public television has grown. Drawing from data from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, our research found that between 2016 and 2021, the number of local journalists in public media grew from 3,694 positions in 2016 to 4,148 positions in 2021. By comparison, between 2016 and 2020, newspaper newsroom employment dropped from 42,450 to 30,820.</p><p><strong>A few public radio stations are growing newsrooms that rival the size of metro daily newspapers. </strong>More than 40 public radio licensees supported at least 15 full-time local reporting positions in FY2020. Of those licensees, more than 10 stations supported at least 40 full-time local reporting positions each. One licensee, WBUR in Boston, was nearing 100 full-time local news positions as of 2020. And in a remarkable advance for the public media industry, Chicago Public Media in Chicago announced in January 2022 that it was acquiring the Chicago Sun-Times (and its newsroom of about 100 people) as part of a local journalism strategy that attracted $61 million in philanthropic funding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*okUnyRGn0_2GDA2D" /></figure><p><strong>Increasing and maturing local journalism content</strong></p><p>As local public media newsrooms have expanded, they have also become innovation hubs for local media, often hiring editorial talent from shrinking newspapers and expanding their public-service mandate to include text-based local news.</p><p>The most sophisticated public radio stations (and a few sophisticated public television stations) now have large multi-platform newsrooms with an array of local media products. These media organizations, like WFAE in Charlotte and WBUR in Boston, are building on a foundation of local news broadcast formats which are, in some cases, decades old. In this section, we review the types of local journalism content being produced in public radio and televisions.</p><p><strong>Local News Call-In Shows.</strong> Perhaps the most basic public radio local news format is the local news talk show. Often produced with listener call-in opportunities, these types of local shows create forums for live dialogue and debate on local issues and the local implications of national and international news. WNYC’s <em>The Brian Lehrer Show</em>, WGBH’s <em>Boston Public Radio with Jim Braude and Margery Eagan</em>, and <em>Detroit Today</em> with Stephen Henderson are examples of local talk shows which have reached local institution status with loyal followings and longtime hosts. Of 119 NPR member stations program schedules we analyzed in March 2022, we found 53% had at least one local news magazine (discussed below) or a news/talk call-in program running each weekday, Monday through Friday.</p><p><strong>Local Newscasts. </strong>The NPR newscast format itself is a blend of local and national news. The NPR newsmagazine “<a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/publiceditor/2018/08/16/639209921/morning-edition-resets-its-clock-again">clock</a>,” which structures and coordinates the on-air time of its member stations in the popular commuting hours, leaves segments open for local stations to produce and air their own local news content. According to the NPR audience insights team, the local segments in the NPR One app consistently perform well, and listeners to local newscasts within the app return to the app at a higher rate than those who listen only to national news segments. Additionally, an October 2021 NPR audience insights listener survey found that 40% of listeners using the app “feel more connected to their local station and informed about local issues.”</p><p><strong>Local News Magazines</strong>. In addition to call-in shows and hourly newscasts, some public radio and television stations also produce daily or weekly local news magazines. These formats, which are meant to mirror popular national offerings like the <em>The PBS Newshour </em>and NPR’s <em>All Things Considered</em>, are usually hour-long shows featuring a handful of local news stories. NJ PBS’s nightly news magazine <a href="https://www.njspotlightnews.org/about/"><em>NJ Spotlight News</em></a> (rebranded and strengthened with the acquisition of the digital news website NJ Spotlight), WBUR’s <a href="https://www.wbur.org/radio/programs/radioboston/about"><em>Radio Boston</em></a>, and <a href="https://www.texasstandard.org/about-the-team/"><em>Texas Standard</em></a>, a statewide news program produced in collaboration primarily by four stations in Texas are three examples.</p><p><strong>Local News Digital Sites. </strong>The shift to public media digital news has been many years in the making, particularly amongst NPR member stations. NPR maintains a digital team focused on providing a low-cost centralized digital platform support to stations of all sizes. The stations using the NPR-provided content management system are able to publish both national NPR News and local news content. The largest stations in the NPR member ecosystem maintain their own sophisticated digital news platforms, many with the ability to target content and messaging, recruit and convert new members, and deliver an array of sponsorship and advertising products. All of these sites host both listening and text-based local news products. Of 119 stations the authors accessed online in March 2022, we found that 98% had published original local news content in the previous 24 hours. We also found that 50% were publishing an email newsletter focused on local news sent Monday through Friday.</p><p><strong>Local News Podcasts.</strong> Many stations were distributing their local news talk shows, newscasts, and newsmagazines as podcasts long before the podcast renaissance gained steam in 2014. The exponential growth in podcast listening has birthed another wave of audio-based local news products in public media. The strongest local public media stations are producing new local news podcasts such as <a href="https://www.kosu.org/podcast/the-kosu-daily"><em>The KOSU Daily</em></a> by KOSU in central and northeast Oklahoma, Vermont Public Radio’s <a href="https://www.vpr.org/podcast/the-frequency-daily-vermont-news"><em>The Frequency</em></a>, and KQED’s <a href="https://www.kqed.org/podcasts/thebay"><em>The Bay</em></a>. And the public media producer and distributor PRX now runs <a href="https://prx-training.squarespace.com/programs/prx-journalism-podcast-accelerator">a local news podcast incubator</a> to help local stations create new audio-based local news products.</p><p><strong>EXPLAINING PUBLIC MEDIA LOCAL JOURNALISM EVOLUTION AND EXPANSION</strong></p><p>What accounts for the growth of public media local journalism amongst public radio stations? This is a key question for policy makers, funders, and industry leaders looking to rebuild local news. We attribute the growth of public media local journalism to three fundamental related features of the public media system: organizational sophistication and maturity, the federated structure of public media, and the resulting financial strength of the system as a whole.</p><p><strong>Organizational sophistication and maturity. </strong>One key driver of the sustained expansion in local journalism capacity and local public service is the increasing sophistication and maturity of public media organizations, especially amongst the largest stations. Leading public media stations have invested in developing efficacy across key organizational components. Investment in strengthening editorial, formal human resources capacity, product development capability, marketing and sales expertise, development muscle, and editorial strength have each been critical to the local journalism growth of the strongest stations.</p><p>The organizational strength and sophistication of the largest licensees have also allowed them to pursue resource efficiencies and to be able to house multiple media services under one administrative apparatus. For example, Louisville Public Media has a classical music radio service, a news/talk service, and an adult alternative music service, as well as an investigative reporting center, all under a single operating organization. This kind of arrangement allows a public broadcaster to maximize revenues and service while sharing costs.</p><p>The culture and leadership of large public broadcasters has also undergone a growth spurt. As these organizations have matured, their leaders have come together to engage in more advanced, station-level and industry-level planning. This includes ambitious cross-industry coordinated audience growth efforts like the Station Resource Group’s 2010–2011 effort to <a href="https://www.srg.org/GTA/GTA_OrganizationReport.pdf">grow the public media audience</a>.</p><p><strong>The federated structure of public media. </strong>The U.S. public media system is structured as a federated network in which local licensees retain their own governance and decision rights but affiliate together through contracts and membership in national organizations. This means that while there are strong network actors (NPR and PRX, for example) that can share pools of resources, licensees operate independently of each other with their own governance and ultimate decision-making for products and services.</p><p>This federated structure has created an underlying buffer against organizational decay–allowing licensees to mature and embark on individual developmental paths. Licensee boards tend to be robust and well-developed with strong links to other community institutions. Licensees, as a result, have a remarkable longevity, despite many of them outgrowing their founding educational and cultural mandates. For example, NPR launched with 88 member licensees in 1970, and as of 2022 there are 250. These NPR members own and operate more than 1,000 station signals nationwide, as of fall 2021.</p><p><strong>Increased resources and business model sustainability.</strong> Our analysis leads us to conclude that the result of growing organizational sophistication, buttressed by the federated structure of public media, has been an increase in resources and sustainability for individual licensees and the public media system as a whole. Mature stations in major media markets in particular have grown dramatically over the last five decades, especially compared to other local media outlets. This is remarkable given the overall corporatization and digitization of media and shrinking of commercial local news media during the same time period.</p><p>All of these factors combine to explain the central observation that attracted our attention: Namely, news-focused licensees and the stations they control appear to be expanding their local journalism capacity during a period when other sectors of the local journalism industry were contracting. Especially among the larger public radio licensees, the maturity of their organizations, the increasing sophistication of their leadership and the strength of their revenues have provided a strong, stable foundation that these organizations are using to continue their role as NPR affiliates for national news and, now, to expand their role of providing original local news content within local markets.</p><p><strong>CAVEATS</strong></p><p>Having reviewed the sustainability, capacity, and reach of the public media system, as well as the insights generated through this assessment, we turn now to address the limitations of our analysis and weaknesses within the public media system.</p><p><strong>Public media professionals are having to define and refine what local news means.</strong></p><p>“Local news” means different things in different markets. In many public media organizations, local news means metro or regional news, rather than community or hyperlocal news. As public media seeks to exert more leadership in local journalism, we see public media professionals working to become more specific about the different needs of the audiences served. Defining “local news” includes examining what it means to “serve the public.” In broadcast formats, reaching the local public entails attracting people across wide geographic areas to tune into a radio or television signal. Embedded concepts of a general broadcast “public” do not translate well into other media, particularly digital media, where media consumers are used to more tailored content.</p><p><strong>Institutional change is slow.</strong></p><p>Public media institutions have many stakeholders; the most successful ones are deeply embedded in their communities and in the wider public media system networks. Some licensees are part of university systems, others operate as independent nonprofit organizations. Many are required by CPB to have community advisory boards. The multiple overlapping stakeholder groups lend a richness and heft to public media — they also can significantly slow the process of change. Investments in public media are not an “instant results” proposition. Change tends to be slow but long-lasting — and highly dependent on visionary leadership and strong upper management teams.</p><p>As we assess the pace of change we can expect in the public media system, one critically important organizational feature stands out: Whether the station’s public broadcasting license is held by an educational institution or a community-based nonprofit. Of the licensees supported by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, about 46%, or 184 public radio licensees, are owned by a university. Nearly 43%, or 171 public radio licensees, are community-owned. The remaining 11% of public radio licensees are state and local-authority owned.</p><p>Institutional ownership by a university, community college, or state entity provides financial resources and shared services, but can also create confusing and conflicting governance because other interests (in universities, for example) can dominate the agenda. Institutional licensees in universities or as part of state agencies can face constraints on content development, fundraising, hiring, policy, and human resources. Indeed, the most innovative stations have tended to be “community licensees,” that is, public broadcasters governed independently from any other institution. WNYC in New York and WBEZ in Chicago are two examples of stations that became more dynamic after they changed their local government ownership model and became independent community licensees.</p><p><strong>Growing audience and public service over the airwaves has often meant underserving already underserved audiences.</strong></p><p>The irony of public media’s secret to audience growth is that public media content often super-serves those most likely to listen often and contribute: educated, white, affluent audiences. The concerted and successful audience development efforts beginning in 1988 have produced a large, loyal, supportive audience of mainly educated, white listeners and viewers. Perhaps the most critical insight of those audience studies was that level of education is the variable that most closely predicts listening, loyalty, and ultimately giving.</p><p>Public media is being called to account for the audience it has created, and many efforts are underway to expand content and service to truly diverse audiences. Given the slow pace of institutional change, this will take time and leadership. But because the institutional mission of public media highlights the value of public service, change is happening.</p><p><strong>Gradual changes to broadcast listening and viewing habits will continue to put pressure on licensees to evolve or lose relevance.</strong></p><p>The pandemic led to a <a href="https://www.niemanlab.org/2020/08/radio-listening-has-plummeted-npr-is-reaching-a-bigger-audience-than-ever-what-gives/">dip in broadcasting listening</a> and surfaced questions about changing habits among consumers. Listening levels in closely-researched markets dropped from about 9 million listeners in winter 2020 to about 6.7 million listeners in spring 2020. By fall 2021, that number had returned to about 8.1 million listeners. The Radio Research Consortium, a nonprofit research group for non-commercial radio stations, attests in its report that “90% of listening (AQH) is back.” While in-home listening maintained roughly the same numbers of listeners throughout the pandemic, the out-of-home listening numbers have yet to fully return to their pre-pandemic numbers.</p><p>While over-the-air broadcast viewing and listening continues a gradual decline, that decline is far from evenly distributed over time and place. The push-and-pull of fluctuating viewing and listening habits is putting pressure on licensees to evolve even more quickly, and become even more sophisticated in the ways they develop news and information products and deliver those to audiences across platforms.</p><p><strong>Inequalities in the public broadcast system mirror inequalities in the country as a whole.</strong></p><p>Public media growth and evolution has been concentrated among licensees whose metro areas have tended to enjoy disproportionate population and economic growth. As shown above, amongst the roughly 120 public radio licensees one of our authors examined, seven earned more than $25 million each in FY2020 revenue, while another 15 stations earned more than $10 million each. There is a long tail of smaller stations with revenue earnings of less than $10 million, and most stations fall into this third category.</p><p>CPB, NPR, PBS, and other national organizations work hard to help mitigate these imbalances at a network level. But differences in resources and capacity remain. For licensees that have grown large enough to have specialized development staffing, the pace of growth increased, while others have stagnated.</p><p><strong>LESSONS LEARNED</strong></p><p>We hope our data and insights shed light on an area of strength and evolution in local journalism. We also hope that policymakers, industry leaders, and journalism funders will draw some lessons from the growth and expansion of public media that will contribute to the overall task of rebuilding local news. In this final section, we offer three key lessons learned from our public media research that should inform those working to rebuild local news.</p><p><strong><em>Lesson 1: The “network effect” of public media cannot be overstated.</em></strong></p><p>Our first lesson is that building and nurturing multi-faceted networks among news organizations is just as important as boosting direct support for newsgathering. Public media organizations and public media audiences have benefited hugely from the highly networked structure of the field. The networks supporting public media take many forms: content collaborations, shared services, professional associations. The most visible network is the formal local/national content sharing system, which is supported by shared distribution technologies. But the infrastructure backbone network is one of many supporting the growth and vitality of public media.</p><p>Other layers of shared infrastructure have evolved over time — including shared digital infrastructure built and maintained through network leaders like NPR and PBS. While these infrastructures have tended to support national sharing to local partners rather than vice versa (with the exception of PRX), active and robust conversations are taking place about how to build the next set of digital infrastructure that supports and enhances stations as local news organizations.</p><p>Policymakers, journalism funders, and industry leaders in other parts of media can learn from the successes of public media networks and invest in growing the layered, networked capacity of news organizations operating in other media.</p><p><strong><em>Lesson 2: Media organizations and media systems take time to mature.</em></strong></p><p>Our second lesson is that true change in local media takes time, because media organizations and media systems require time to mature. Most public media stations are at least 50 years old. Many digital news organizations in operation today, by contrast, are less than a decade old. For example, according to the INN Index published in July 2022, more than 135 member organizations launched within the past five years, about double the number over the prior five-year period.</p><p>But we have also learned from our research that smart investments can speed the maturation of organizations and the evolution of local media systems. From our analysis of the drivers of growth in public radio, we would agree with funders like the American Journalism Project that investing in the business-side capacity of new news organizations and supporting the growth of their development staff should yield positive results for sustainability. Our research shows that the pace of growth amongst the public radio stations that have become old enough and large enough to have specialized development staffing has increased relative to peers that have not made those investments.</p><p>The current strength and vitality of public media took decades to come to fruition. Because organizations and media systems take time to mature, funders and industry leaders should continue to take the long view in the task of rebuilding local news.</p><p><strong><em>Lesson 3: Many public media organizations are ready to serve as anchor institutions for their ecosystems.</em></strong></p><p>Our final lesson relates to the huge opportunity that public media presents for those looking to rebuild local news. The last decade has seen an explosion of experimentation in local news and new news organizations foundings as the newspaper-based local media system has atrophied. If the challenge is to sustain and grow these new experiments and new newsrooms, then local ecosystem-level leadership has to be in place in order to achieve greater impact with fewer resources, and to foster collaboration instead of competition.</p><p>We would argue that many public media organizations are now ready to step into the role as anchor institutions in their local news ecosystems — providing the platform services, governance, and coordination support that their national network counterparts provide for local stations. Strong public media organizations are absolutely ready to acquire other forms of news media, as has happened in Chicago, Dallas, Los Angeles, New York, and elsewhere. Public media acquisitions of news media providers are one of the most exciting developments in public media in recent years and show huge promise for rebuilding local journalism. We anticipate that licensees capable of anchoring local news ecosystems will become even more critical going forward as commercial print-based local media risks disappearing altogether.</p><p><em>This research was made possible through the generous support of the </em><a href="https://www.wyncotefoundation.org/"><em>Wyncote Foundation</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><strong>Citations:</strong></p><p>Penny Abernathy. “The State of Local News,” Medill Local News Initiative, Northwestern University, accessed 28 Sept. 2022 at: <a href="https://localnewsinitiative.northwestern.edu/projects/state-of-local-news/">https://localnewsinitiative.northwestern.edu/projects/state-of-local-news/</a></p><p>Michele McLellan, Jesse Holcomb, Emily Roseman. “Nonprofit News Fact Sheet: Local news,” Institute for Nonprofit News, accessed 28 Sept. 2022 at: <a href="https://inn.org/research-factsheet-local-news/">https://inn.org/research-factsheet-local-news/</a></p><p>Emily Roseman, Michele McLellan, Jesse Holcomb. “INN Index 2022: Enduring in crisis, surging in local communities,” Institute for Nonprofit News, accessed on 28 Sept. 2022 at: <a href="https://inn.org/research/inn-index/inn-index-2022/">https://inn.org/research/inn-index/inn-index-2022/</a></p><p>Our second author has published other findings from this data set in the Pew Research Center Public Broadcasting Fact Sheet. <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/public-broadcasting/">https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/public-broadcasting/</a></p><p>Analysis performed by Mark Fuerst in Jan. 2022 of 123 public radio licensees.</p><p>Data provided by Station Resource Group’s Public Radio Overview, Nov. 2021.</p><p>Data provided by Greater Public’s Benchmarks for Public Radio Fundraising, July 2021.</p><p>Data provided by Blackbaud’s Target Analytics, July 2021.</p><p>Data provided by Greater Public’s Building a Sustainable Major Giving Program, April 2021.</p><p>Analysis performed by Mark Fuerst in Jan. 2022 of 123 public radio licensees.</p><p>“Newsroom Investment,” Pew Research Center. Accessed 28 Sept. 2022: <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/newspapers/#newsroom-investment">https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/newspapers/#newsroom-investment</a></p><p>Station Resource Group analysis of data provided by Corporation for Public Broadcasting.</p><p>“Newsroom Diversity Report,” Chicago Sun-Times. Accessed 29 Sept. 2022: <a href="https://chicago.suntimes.com/pages/newsroom-diversity">https://chicago.suntimes.com/pages/newsroom-diversity</a></p><p>Betsy Berger, “Chicago Public Media Announces Its Acquisition of the Chicago Sun-Times,” WBEZ Chicago. Accessed 29 Sept. 2022: <a href="https://www.wbez.org/pressroom/chicago-public-media-announces-its-acquisition-of-the-chicago-suntimes">https://www.wbez.org/pressroom/chicago-public-media-announces-its-acquisition-of-the-chicago-suntimes</a></p><p>Data provided by NPR Audience Insights.</p><p>Data provided by Station Resource Group in November 2021.</p><p>Data provided by the Radio Research Consortium (RRC) in a fall 2021 report.</p><p>The bounce-back of listening following the pandemic slump varies by market. Persons ages 45–64 represent the largest cohort of listeners for public radio, followed by the persons 25–44 cohort.</p><p>Shared distribution technologies include Public Radio Satellite System and PRX in the case of public radio; and, for public television the Next Generation Interconnection System operated by PBS, the PBS Passport OTT broadband content distribution platform, and several independent interconnection services that provide centralized distribution functions including contracts and fees between producers and stations.</p><p>Emily Roseman, Michele McLellan, Jesse Holcomb. “INN Index 2022: Enduring in crisis, surging in local communities,” Institute for Nonprofit News, accessed on 29 Sept. 2022 at: <a href="https://inn.org/research/inn-index/inn-index-2022/">https://inn.org/research/inn-index/inn-index-2022/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f17864d9682" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/the-growing-strength-of-public-media-local-journalism-7f17864d9682">The Growing Strength of Public Media Local Journalism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Local Journalism and Media Policy — recordings from all five Tow Center events]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/local-journalism-and-media-policy-recordings-from-all-five-tow-center-events-b7b4f14add9c?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7b4f14add9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[local]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[local-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Damian Radcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Jun 2022 16:47:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-09T16:47:32.018Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Local Journalism and Media Policy — recordings from all five Tow Center events</h3><h4>COVID-19 has had a profound impact on the U.S. news industry, especially at the local level, accelerating trend lines evident since the early 2000s. What can be done to safeguard local news?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/560/0*O8ABDtg5zQ0b1mBa.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo <a href="https://twitter.com/draddy_sam/status/1471593417796952075">via</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/draddy_sam">Sam Draddy</a> on Twitter.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>“What role can (and should) media policy play in supporting a strong, sustainable, vibrant local media sector in the United States?”</strong></p><p>That’s the question I explored in late-2021 and early 2022 in a five part webinar series for the Tow Center for Digital Journalism.</p><p>Organized in partnership with the University of Minnesota’s <a href="https://twitter.com/Nick_Mathews">Nick Mathews</a>, the series was designed to introduce and debate the best ways for media policy to support local journalism in the USA.</p><p>The webinars examined topics such as the role that media policy has historically played in supporting — and shaping — local news, how it can be leveraged to ensure access to information (including tackling digital divides), it’s contribution to facilitating community media, and what role it can play in encouraging new ownership and revenue models.</p><p>Expert panels — from academia, industry and foundations supporting journalism — examined the instruments that policymakers at a state and federal level have in their arsenal, and which ones they should deploy.</p><p><em>Here’s the top-level details of each session and links to the materials from them.</em></p><ol><li><strong>An introduction to Media Policy and Local Journalism.</strong> <em>(Watch on </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDOpQMAaDIs"><em>YouTube</em></a><em>, listen on </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/towcenter/an-introduction-to-media-policy-and-local-journalism"><em>SoundCloud</em></a><em>, read the transcript on </em><a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/536731561/Transcript-An-Introduction-to-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism"><em>Scribd</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/emily-bell-victor-pickard-and-nikki-usher-kick-off-new-tow-webinar-series-on-local-journalism-and-f8d0bf13c58f"><em>write-up on Medium</em></a><em>), </em>21 October 2021.</li><li><strong>Lessons from Overseas. </strong><em>(Watch the full conversation on </em><a href="https://youtu.be/H7eDaYZhXf8"><em>YouTube</em></a><a href="https://youtu.be/BW8XcnfF6hM"><em>,</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/towcenter/local-journalism-and-media-policy-lessons-from-overseas"><em>listen on SoundCloud</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/541224923/Transcript-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism-Lessons-From-Overseas"><em>read the transcript on Scribd</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-kristy-hess-sameer-padania-and-matthew-powers-explore-811d3960a7a7"><em>write-up on Medium</em></a><em> and the </em><a href="https://mailchi.mp/d2b2c1c218d5/weekly-updates-on-covid-19s-impact-on-journalism-2083397?e=7e286a7aaf"><em>Tow weekly newsletter</em></a><em>), </em>18 November 2021.</li><li><strong>Giving a Voice to Grassroots Media.</strong> <em>(Watch the full conversation on </em><a href="https://youtu.be/cflSJrk9_3o"><em>YouTube</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/towcenter/giving-a-voice-to-grassroots-media"><em>listen on SoundCloud</em></a><em>, read the transcript on </em><a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/548657139/Giving-a-Voice-to-Grassroots-Media"><em>Scribd</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://us7.campaign-archive.com/?u=f92dc374de944af763a8fdf13&amp;id=4625111cc7"><em>write-up</em></a><em> in the Tow newsletter and </em><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-giving-a-voice-to-grassroots-media-bc0302e59452"><em>on Medium</em></a><em>), </em>16 December 2021.</li><li><strong>Emerging Issues and Fresh Ideas.</strong> <em>(W</em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSNg4INGBkA"><em>atch the full conversation on YouTube</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/towcenter/emerging-issues-and-fresh-ideas"><em>listen on SoundCloud</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/554978599/Transcript-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism-Fresh-Ideas-and-Emerging-Issues"><em>read the transcript on Scribd</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://mailchi.mp/7c818d49fb49/weekly-updates-on-covid-19s-impact-on-journalism-2083424?e=b9ab6352a2"><em>write-up in the Tow newsletter</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-christopher-ali-sue-cross-and-jessica-gonzalez-discuss-emerging-46fb4c7262ef?sk=c3df136978e680dcd1224b686c87dd95"><em>on Medium</em></a><em>), </em>20 January 2022</li><li><strong>Lessons learned and a look at what happens next.</strong> <em>(W</em><a href="https://youtu.be/JPOi7svtF7I"><em>atch the full conversation on YouTube</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/towcenter/lessons-learned-and-a-look-at-what-happens-next"><em>listen on SoundCloud</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/555571905/Transcript-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism-Lessons-learned-and-a-look-at-what-happens-next"><em>read the transcript on Scribd</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://us7.campaign-archive.com/?u=f92dc374de944af763a8fdf13&amp;id=c83e161f47"><em>write-up in the Tow newsletter</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-joy-jenkins-elizabeth-hansen-shapiro-and-phil-napoli-on-what-bdc9b226932b?source=user_profile---------11----------------------------"><em>on Medium</em></a><em>), </em>27 January 2022.</li></ol><p><strong><em>Full links, detailed of panelists + other materials embedded below.</em></strong></p><h4>Session 1: An introduction to Media Policy and Local Journalism</h4><p><em>Panel:</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://twitter.com/VWPickard"><strong>Dr. Victor Pickard</strong></a>, C. Edwin Baker Professor of Media Policy and Political Economy at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/nikkiusher"><strong>Dr. Nikki Usher</strong></a>, Professor at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Fellow at the Open Markets Institute.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/emilybell"><strong>Professor Emily Bell</strong></a>, Founding Director of the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia Journalism School, Leonard Tow professor of Journalism.</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FaDOpQMAaDIs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DaDOpQMAaDIs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FaDOpQMAaDIs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f620014bd32be6080bc75b2f73cd85b8/href">https://medium.com/media/f620014bd32be6080bc75b2f73cd85b8/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1147798000%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Ftowcenter%2Fan-introduction-to-media-policy-and-local-journalism&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-i0bVaSG4b30h6zXG-PGIRdA-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/436e6448531e095ddb8c6eaf46f6e502/href">https://medium.com/media/436e6448531e095ddb8c6eaf46f6e502/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fembeds%2F536731561%2Fcontent&amp;display_name=Scribd&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fdocument%2F536731561%2FTranscript-An-Introduction-to-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimgv2-1-f.scribdassets.com%2Fimg%2Fdocument%2F536731561%2F111x142%2F22f365580f%2F1654523579%3Fv%3D1&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=scribd" width="600" height="800" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/50bb1be81fdc3b635dd128a4a2f949e1/href">https://medium.com/media/50bb1be81fdc3b635dd128a4a2f949e1/href</a></iframe><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/emily-bell-victor-pickard-and-nikki-usher-kick-off-new-tow-webinar-series-on-local-journalism-and-f8d0bf13c58f">Emily Bell, Victor Pickard and Nikki Usher kick off new Tow webinar series on local journalism and…</a></p><h4>Session 2: Lessons from Overseas</h4><p><em>Panel:</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://www.deakin.edu.au/about-deakin/people/kristy-hess"><strong>Dr. Kristy Hess</strong></a>, Associate Professor of Communication at Deakin University, Australia; Associate Editor, Digital Journalism.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/mj_powers"><strong>Dr. Matthew Powers</strong></a>, Associate Professor, Dept. of Communication, University of Washington. Co-Director of Center for Journalism, Media and Democracy at University of Washington.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/sdp"><strong>Sameer Padania</strong></a> is the Founder and Advisor at Macroscope, Lead Author Journalism Funders Forum.</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FH7eDaYZhXf8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DH7eDaYZhXf8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FH7eDaYZhXf8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/beb854df2c1f742401afb0384c3830d6/href">https://medium.com/media/beb854df2c1f742401afb0384c3830d6/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1163184217%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Ftowcenter%2Flocal-journalism-and-media-policy-lessons-from-overseas&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-pyOjwOcfcyYOrjFd-tB5bzA-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/322bfdbdc6dcc5da4f704c06cbe5e025/href">https://medium.com/media/322bfdbdc6dcc5da4f704c06cbe5e025/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fembeds%2F541224923%2Fcontent&amp;display_name=Scribd&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fdocument%2F541224923%2FTranscript-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism-Lessons-From-Overseas&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimgv2-1-f.scribdassets.com%2Fimg%2Fdocument%2F541224923%2F111x142%2Fda4ad82397%2F1654523576%3Fv%3D1&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=scribd" width="600" height="800" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b687e55ab690b12b40a1a09f1752bc97/href">https://medium.com/media/b687e55ab690b12b40a1a09f1752bc97/href</a></iframe><p><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-kristy-hess-sameer-padania-and-matthew-powers-explore-811d3960a7a7">Local journalism and media policy: Kristy Hess, Sameer Padania and Matthew Powers explore…</a></p><h4>Session 3: Giving a Voice to Grassroots Media</h4><p><em>Panel:</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://twitter.com/gmochkofsky"><strong>Graciela Mochkofsky</strong></a>, Director of the Bilingual Journalism Program, Executive Director, Center for Community Media at Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/TMPowell"><strong>Tracie Powell</strong></a>, Founder at The Pivot Fund and a Fall 2021 Shorenstein Center Research Fellow at Harvard Kennedy School.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/thensim0nsaid"><strong>Simon Galperin</strong></a>, Founding Director of the Bloomfield Information Project and the Community Info Coop.</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FcflSJrk9_3o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DcflSJrk9_3o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FcflSJrk9_3o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/19480b5fcca797b8680bf4d497ce4a27/href">https://medium.com/media/19480b5fcca797b8680bf4d497ce4a27/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1181417323%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Ftowcenter%2Fgiving-a-voice-to-grassroots-media&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-wbTq1nVjFaEdwzZO-gazjAA-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/cffc0ee5c30c597daa37ba5a4d5432fd/href">https://medium.com/media/cffc0ee5c30c597daa37ba5a4d5432fd/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fembeds%2F548657139%2Fcontent&amp;display_name=Scribd&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fdocument%2F548657139%2FGiving-a-Voice-to-Grassroots-Media&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimgv2-2-f.scribdassets.com%2Fimg%2Fdocument%2F548657139%2F111x142%2F98383ac4d8%2F1654523575%3Fv%3D1&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=scribd" width="600" height="800" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c5a4de489ca93d5b96ff949ce6e5e310/href">https://medium.com/media/c5a4de489ca93d5b96ff949ce6e5e310/href</a></iframe><p><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-giving-a-voice-to-grassroots-media-bc0302e59452">Local journalism and media policy: giving a voice to grassroots media</a></p><h4>Session 4: Emerging Issues and Fresh Ideas</h4><p><em>Panel:</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://twitter.com/JGo4Justice"><strong>Jessica Gonzalez</strong></a>, Co-CEO, Free Press</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/suecross"><strong>Sue Cross</strong></a>, Executive Director and CEO at Institute for Nonprofit News</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/Ali_Christopher"><strong>Dr. Christopher Ali</strong></a>, Associate Professor, University of Virginia, Knight News Innovation Fellow, Tow Center for Digital Journalism, Columbia University</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FGSNg4INGBkA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DGSNg4INGBkA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FGSNg4INGBkA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8aa740e266f370349d220230ceba4518/href">https://medium.com/media/8aa740e266f370349d220230ceba4518/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1201068052%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Ftowcenter%2Femerging-issues-and-fresh-ideas&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-NvhB6dLnZ9BAMoyt-gXSHPA-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4749f648d66c2b45181008793edfed1e/href">https://medium.com/media/4749f648d66c2b45181008793edfed1e/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fembeds%2F554978599%2Fcontent&amp;display_name=Scribd&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fdocument%2F554978599%2FTranscript-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism-Fresh-Ideas-and-Emerging-Issues&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimgv2-2-f.scribdassets.com%2Fimg%2Fdocument%2F554978599%2F111x142%2Ff8096358a6%2F1654523576%3Fv%3D1&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=scribd" width="600" height="800" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/2ff9849596f7d159a78b8e3eed73e3af/href">https://medium.com/media/2ff9849596f7d159a78b8e3eed73e3af/href</a></iframe><p><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-christopher-ali-sue-cross-and-jessica-gonzalez-discuss-emerging-46fb4c7262ef">Local journalism and media policy: Christopher Ali, Sue Cross and Jessica Gonzalez discuss emerging…</a></p><h4>Session 5: Emerging Issues and Fresh Ideas</h4><p><em>Panel:</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://twitter.com/joyjenkins"><strong>Dr. Joy Jenkins</strong></a>, Assistant Professor at School of Journalism and Electronic Media at the University of Tennessee</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/ehansen02"><strong>Dr. Elizabeth Hansen</strong></a>, Senior Research Fellow at the Tow Center for Digital Journalism, co-founder of the National Trust for Local News.</li><li><a href="https://twitter.com/pmnapoli"><strong>Dr. Phil Napoli</strong></a>, James R. Shepley Distinguished Professor of Public Policy at Duke University.</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJPOi7svtF7I%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJPOi7svtF7I&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJPOi7svtF7I%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3f237aacbd4577cb46f65c6ba1b1dede/href">https://medium.com/media/3f237aacbd4577cb46f65c6ba1b1dede/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1205043838%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Ftowcenter%2Flessons-learned-and-a-look-at-what-happens-next&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-fBZfyXENxrTikms0-dzXSjg-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b4a9e4c15eee5f5eef328cc9f8b12d42/href">https://medium.com/media/b4a9e4c15eee5f5eef328cc9f8b12d42/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fembeds%2F555571905%2Fcontent&amp;display_name=Scribd&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fdocument%2F555571905%2FTranscript-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism-Lessons-learned-and-a-look-at-what-happens-next&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimgv2-1-f.scribdassets.com%2Fimg%2Fdocument%2F555571905%2F111x142%2F7c7bee7b4e%2F1654543675%3Fv%3D1&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=scribd" width="600" height="800" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c4a7a9a849c9ad1a851874228a943254/href">https://medium.com/media/c4a7a9a849c9ad1a851874228a943254/href</a></iframe><p><a href="https://medium.com/damian-radcliffe/local-journalism-and-media-policy-joy-jenkins-elizabeth-hansen-shapiro-and-phil-napoli-on-what-bdc9b226932b">Local Journalism and Media Policy: Joy Jenkins, Elizabeth Hansen Shapiro, and Phil Napoli on what…</a></p><p><strong>I hope you find these materials useful. I am currently working on a report pulling together some of the key ideas from this series, which will be published later in the year.</strong></p><p><a href="https://journalism.uoregon.edu/directory/faculty-and-staff/all/damianr">Damian Radcliffe</a> is the Carolyn S. Chambers Professor in Journalism, a Professor of Practice, an affiliate faculty member of the Department for Middle East and North Africa Studies (MENA) and the <a href="http://agora.uoregon.edu/">Agora Journalism Center</a>, and a Research Associate of the Center for Science Communication Research (SCR), at the University of Oregon.</p><p>Alongside holding the Chambers Chair at the School of Journalism and Communication (SOJC), he is also a three-time <a href="https://towcenter.columbia.edu/content/damian-radcliffe">Fellow</a> of the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia University, an <a href="https://www.cardiff.ac.uk/people/view/201298-radcliffe-damian">Honorary Research Fellow</a> at Cardiff University’s School of Journalism, Media and Culture Studies (JOMEC), and a life fellow of the Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce (RSA).</p><p>An experienced digital analyst, consultant, journalist, and researcher, Damian has worked in editorial, research, policy, and teaching positions for the past two and a half decades in the UK, Middle East, and USA. This includes roles in all media sectors (commercial, public, government, regulatory, academic, and nonprofit/civil society) and all platforms (print, digital, TV and radio).</p><p><em>Follow him on Twitter </em><a href="https://twitter.com/damianradcliffe"><em>@damianradcliffe</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7b4f14add9c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/local-journalism-and-media-policy-recordings-from-all-five-tow-center-events-b7b4f14add9c">Local Journalism and Media Policy — recordings from all five Tow Center events</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Collaborative Scaffolding: The Key to Successful Collaborative Journalism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/collaborative-scaffolding-the-key-to-successful-collaborative-journalism-cc045157a292?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc045157a292</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[solutions-journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[local-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tow-center]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[columbiajournalismschool]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tow Center]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 May 2022 13:21:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-18T13:21:55.238Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Caroline Porter and Elizabeth Hansen Shapiro, May 2022</p><p>In spring 2020 Steve Leone, a newspaper editor in Concord, New Hampshire, faced a problem. The news was both dire and critical; and yet, his newspaper’s advertising nearly halved overnight, his team was forced to quickly adjust to remote work, and reporters faced a massive learning curve to cover the pandemic.</p><p>Now Publisher of The Concord Monitor, Leone did something he’d never done in his decades as a journalist. He opened up his local media collaborative’s shared Google Doc and began to post stories reported by his competitors. Through the local collaborative, a group of local newsrooms and partners working together to produce and distribute local news stories, the Monitor also began alerting competitors when the paper had a hot story about to publish.</p><p>The following spring, nearly 900 miles south, the fall-out from the pandemic could be measured in eviction metrics, with thousands of renters behind on their payments in Charlotte. Three journalists from three different media outlets started meeting weekly to analyze more than 700 eviction cases, <a href="https://www.wcnc.com/article/money/markets/real-estate/affordable-housing-crisis/charlotte-renters-advocates-brace-end-of-eviction-moratorium-north-carolina/275-11daa024-98e7-401d-8e56-5b5ae8ebd747">producing a major feature story</a> with three bylines from three organizations.</p><p>Meanwhile, in Philadelphia, about 20 news organizations were meeting monthly to pitch stories that had one major requirement: the news organizations had to work together in order to receive funding from the collaborative. Each newsroom could not move forward on a story without partnering with another.</p><p>In an industry whose history is pockmarked by clickbait, hero worship, and competitive speed, these acts of collaboration cut against the grain of decades of business-as-usual. We’re more familiar with well-worn storylines about newsroom woes that include phases like “resource-strapped,” or “victim of recent lay-offs,” and stories that describe either the death of a news outlet or the crafty way one person circumnavigated such perils with singular ingenuity.</p><p>As a rallying cry for a new way of doing the news, collaboration is a flashy buzzword (often touted as a path to industry salvation) that pops up in nearly every discussion about where the industry <em>should</em> go. Yet anyone who has dared mount a collaborative project has quickly learned that productive and authentic collaboration remains exceptionally difficult to sustain. Personalities clash, incentives get easily misaligned, resources inevitably dry up, the news cycle moves on.</p><p>Given that sustained collaboration between newsrooms is so difficult, runs counter to so many deeply-held industry norms, and is also an idea on which so many future hopes are riding — we must figure out how to increase the chances of collaborative success. But to do that, we have to ask ourselves: Do we really know what successful collaboration looks like? And what does it take to sustain successful collaboration over time, beyond a single story?</p><p>We believe the answers to these questions are emerging from a set of local media collaboratives that have been hard at work together over the last few years, focusing a solutions frame on a single topic critical to the quality of life in their communities.</p><p>For the last year, we have studied the impact six collaboratives are creating for their members, their partner newsrooms, their media ecosystems, and their communities. Using interviews, surveys, and observations of meetings throughout a yearlong period that comprised the major news events of 2020–2021, we had a front-row seat to the ups and downs of these collaborative journalism efforts. This essay reviews the key findings of our research. The full results of our research, including a detailed description of our methodology, are available <a href="https://collaborativejournalism.org/soljourno/">here</a>.</p><p>Not all of the collaboratives we studied were fully mature. In fact, one lost its funding after failing to meet grant obligations during our course of observation and then re-started its efforts a few months later. But when we compared the collaboratives that were maturing and able to hang together and produce results, to those that were developing, we were able to uncover a set of elements driving sustained collaboration over time. The maturing groups in our study had developed strong collaborative scaffolding that helped them weather the inevitable difficulties of collaborative work and create change both within and outside their memberships.</p><p>The idea of collaborative scaffolding — what it is, how it works, and why it matters — is our contribution to the current conversation on the future of local journalism and how to get there.</p><p><strong>Our research approach</strong></p><p>Our insights derive from an impact study we developed and implemented examining the process and output of six local media collaboratives. The cohort of journalism collaboratives that we studied are part of the Local Media Project, a five-year program conceived and produced by the Solutions Journalism Network to launch and support solutions-journalism collaboratives around the U.S., with funding from the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation and the Ralph C. Wilson, Jr. Foundation. These collaboratives’ distinction lies in their commitment to reporting on both problems and their fixes and in their focus on a single subject of particular urgency within their community. The collaboratives’ areas of focus range from affordable housing to mental health. In their founding, the smallest collaborative had nine members and the largest collaborative had 22 members. Most collaboratives focused on the metro areas, though there are also two statewide collaboratives and one regional collaborative in the cohort. (For a detailed overview of each collaborative’s focus and members, see the full <a href="https://collaborativejournalism.org/soljourno/">report</a>.)</p><p>A “collaborative” refers to a group of newsrooms and non-news members from different organizations that come together to produce joint reporting, often related to a single topic. The newsrooms which were part of the collaboratives we studied generally designated one journalist per newsroom (one person per organization, in the case of non-news members) to participate in the collaborative. The journalist members of the collaborative would then work on behalf of the newsroom in the collaborative. Some collaboratives also held separate meetings for editorial leaders and for reporters. The collaboratives we studied met as a group with a cadence of their choosing, such as weekly or monthly, to review editorial projects in the works and to pitch and approve new projects. Across the collaboratives we studied, group decisions were generally made by majority rule, with members voting in-person in meetings or sometimes weighing in over email. Group policies such as voting methods, as well as editorial policies, such as how to edit, credit and share content, were decided at the collaborative-specific level.</p><p>The collaboratives in our cohort were each based in a geographic region and were given funding to become part of the Solutions Journalism Network’s Local Media Project. As a condition of funding, the collaboratives were required to choose a single topic and cover that topic using a solutions journalism approach. Once a collaborative had identified a subject, members often pitched stories that interested them, and then members would weigh how new story ideas fit within their broader collection of work. Other times, members identified a critical issue and broke down the story into separate areas to cover, assigning different members different stories. (For a detailed analysis of the developmental phases of these collaboratives, see the full report.)</p><p>We’ve found what works to sustain collaboration, and it’s collaborative scaffolding.</p><p>We found that the most mature collaboratives had a strong sense of shared values, operated with a high degree of trust, and had a commitment to the collaborative as an entity. The values, trust, and commitment operated like a scaffold to keep the groups moving forward on their projects, even when they encountered challenges. We call the critical ingredient to their success <em>collaborative scaffolding</em>. Collaborative scaffolding is a way of thinking and working together that any collaborative group can build, and that increases the chances of collaborative success. So what does collaborative scaffolding look like? And what can it accomplish?</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding looks like a community-first value system.</em></strong></p><p>Journalists often draw inspiration from general ideals about “serving the public,” a broad and opaque umbrella for industry values that can quickly become lip service. We found that strong collaborative scaffolding makes values explicit and brings members together in service of a common set of ideals.</p><p>The most powerful of those values is orienting around the needs of a collaborative’s communities first. We saw that in mature collaboratives, a shared orientation to not just provide information to an audience but to actually support a community with actionable information led to different editorial goals than we’ve seen in typical newsrooms.</p><p>In mature collaboratives, a shared orientation to community service had the power to bring together journalists from different backgrounds and different newsrooms into a sense of common purpose, motivation, and momentum.</p><p>What did this look like in practice? The most obvious examples we saw were in mature collaboratives’ responses to the the murder of George Floyd, the pandemic, and the 2020 election cycle. Before spring 2020, most of the collaboratives we studied were finding their way, choosing subject areas to focus on and building out their processes. The heavy news cycle of 2020 required unique responses from newsrooms of all kinds, and we observed that the mature collaboratives were able to move more swiftly to identify and address the information needs.</p><p>In all of our mature and maturing collaboratives, the members expanded and coordinated coverage that would not have been feasible from one newsroom alone, motivated by the desire to get their communities as much critical information as possible. At a mundane level, this often looked like members working together to compile questions for press conferences or hash out strategies to avoid duplicate stories. At a more complex level, this looked like, for example, <a href="https://digitalbranch.cmlibrary.org/cjc/graphic-novel/">the Charlotte Journalism Collaborative’s producing a multi-part graphic news series</a> that was freely distributed through the public library branches and online through social media. The series explains the pandemic at the local level, in both English and Spanish, in partnership with a local arts group and the public library.</p><p>The murder of George Floyd, the 2020 election cycle, and the covid-19 pandemic catalyzed a growth spurt in the collaborative scaffolding of the mature collaboratives we studied. Rather than drive these newsrooms apart, we saw how the shared community-service orientation encouraged closer coordination, sharing, strategizing, and led to a sense of pride and meaning in the quality of the group’s output.</p><p>For example, collaborative members in New Hampshire reflected that the the murder of George Floyd, the pandemic, and the 2020 election marked a new phase of development within their collaborative. Whereas before, members were tentative about sharing and coordinating plans, the urgency of community needs helped collaborative members begin to share and delegate coverage organically. “We all kind of saw this new opportunity to create a statewide collaborative reporting effort on Covid-19,” said one collaborative member. “We were able to collaboratively give readers a statewide view of Covid. It happened seamlessly.”</p><p>But the community orientation in mature and maturing collaboratives went many steps beyond coordinated coverage. Guided by the solutions framework, the Northeast Ohio collaborative, for example, approached the issue of residents’ utilities being turned off by preparing <a href="https://eyeonohio.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/rev-NEOSOJO-Eng-2022-utility-guide-1.pdf">a guide of how to get help to keep residents’ lights on</a>. The guide was distributed at places where residents were already, like a local health center.</p><p>Orienting together to meet community needs also helped mature collaboratives think concretely about how those needs might differ by community and by story. For example, one collaborative member in Charlotte explained how she evolved her thinking from the idea that one newspaper could meet all parts of her community and started leaning on smaller news partners:</p><p>“Everything can’t serve every audience. So we stop trying to do that and instead think about how multiple pieces of journalism serve more specific audiences. You tend to serve nobody if you try to say, ‘Well, this is for everybody,’ Because it can’t be! The collaborative really challenged my thinking about who cares about a story, and why are they going to read it.”</p><p>Not every collaborative we observed had been able to build the shared orientation to community needs necessary for strong collaborative scaffolding. For example, one member of a developing collaborative said this about how to define the collaborative’s audience: “I don’t know, if I know the answer to that,” said the member. “And that feels like something that we should know, more specifically who our audience is.”</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding looks like high degrees of trust among members.</em></strong></p><p>Trust is a bedrock ingredient of strong collaborative scaffolding because high-quality collaborative work is dependent on the quality of relationships among collaborators. In the mature collaboratives we studied, members had developed enough trust to share time, resources, and learning with each other. That trust took time to build, and we learned, could also be damaged.</p><p>In some cases the trust among members was built through the process of re-examining their reporting practices and assumptions in light of solutions journalism’s community-first orientation. For example, the members of the Charlotte collaborative reported to us that they appreciated the role of solutions journalism in forcing an explicit reassessment and re-dedication to the craft of reporting through the lens of community service. That reflective process required more communication, vulnerability, and sharing among the members than they usually shared with industry colleagues.</p><p>In addition to building trust among members, members felt the reflection and learning inherent solutions approach also was leading to an improvement in their reporting chops and in other collaborations blooming outside the collaborative. For example, one New Hampshire collaborative member shared, “Because both [my news organization] and the Granite State News Collaborative are engaged in SJN projects, the quality of our reporting has improved; I consider coaching and instruction in these methods important and game-changing.”</p><p>Collaborative scaffolding takes time to build in part because trust takes time to build. But we saw in the mature collaboratives we studied that building trust is possible, even when things start out rocky. For example, the New Hampshire collaborative, which had a high degree of trust amongst its members during our observation period, initially struggled to build this element of collaborative scaffolding. “The biggest hurdle in our first two years was that the members seemed to struggle to trust each other,” explained the New Hampshire collaborative director.</p><p>Some of the trust hurdles in news collaboration stem from competitive feelings among newsrooms and among reporters. Explained one New Hampshire member, “Certainly at the beginning, people were much more cautious, not knowing am I going to be giving up a competitive advantage?”</p><p>Working together with positive results helped collaborative members in New Hampshire moderate their fear and feelings of competition and build trust. The collaborative member continued: “Over time, I think that people have seen other people are sharing, and have seen that people are willing to contribute and contribute quality pieces. The collaborative itself was producing pieces, which I think also made it easier to see that this was a shared work product.”</p><p>The developing collaboratives, in contrast, were still on the road to developing strong trust amongst members. For example, one of the developing collaboratives we studied consistently struggled to build trust between larger and smaller outlets in the group. “We have not done much co-reporting with other members,” reported one collaborative member. “And I think part of it is because that’s a lot harder to do than just sharing stories and things like that. It’s a lot harder.”</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding looks like commitment to the collaborative as an entity.</em></strong></p><p>Strong collaborative scaffolding helps members rise above their organizational identity to identify with — and feel commitment to — the collaborative as whole. The members of the mature collaboratives we studied expressed deep commitment to and affiliation with the collaborative as a “thing.” This went beyond buy-in and enthusiasm to a true identification with the collaborative itself. Participation in the collaborative influenced how members thought about themselves as journalists and the service they provide to their community.</p><p>The best example of commitment to the collaborative as a stand-alone entity is the <a href="https://brokeinphilly.org/">Broke in Philly (BIP) collaborative</a>. This collaborative benefits from a unique sense of confidence among the cohort we studied, in part because it is the oldest and most experienced, but also because of its role as part of a larger operation, Resolve Philly. Resolve Philly grew out of the first solutions journalism collaborative supported by Solutions Journalism Network, The Reentry Project.</p><p>“There is a whole organization that is dedicated to making this collaboration work as well as it can,” shared an editor within the organization.</p><p>Resolve Philly’s stewardship of Broke in Philly means their members benefit from additional time and resources dedicated to making collaborative relationships successful. For example, in 2021 alone,109 BIP journalists participated in BIP-sponsored lunch and learns, intended to allow members to share skills with each other. The collaborative offered $15 Grubhub gift certificates to encourage members from different newsrooms to have lunch together. And each collaborative meeting started with an ice-breaker as an activity to prioritize relationship-building outside of the reporting work.</p><p>But not all the collaboratives we studied were yet able to elicit such commitment. For example, one of our developing collaboratives struggled to help its members understand and practice the solutions journalism approach. The lack of understanding and commitment led to a lack of joint-reporting projects, which further undermined learning and buy-in. The collaborative experience did not hold enough meaning or gain enough momentum for members to take risks in working together, and near the end of the first year, two members had left the collaborative and the collaborative did not receive its second-year funding. Since then, the collaborative has brought on a new project manager, established a new plan, and relaunched with new funding from SJN for six more months.</p><p>Another developing collaborative which struggled to build commitment was working to overcome the competitive distrust and self-interest of its member newsrooms. Another primarily focused its work together on improving coverage for individual member newsrooms rather than working toward a collaborative-first approach. We observed that the interactions of this collaborative were much more transactional, and some of its members agreed. One member put it this way: “What is the bare minimum? Oh, you want me to upload two stories that ran four months ago? Yep, I got you.”</p><p><strong>Collaborative scaffolding is the bridge from theory to practice.</strong></p><p>What impact does strong collaborative scaffolding have? Through supporting the shared values, trust, and commitment of a group of journalists working together, strong collaborative scaffolding becomes the engine of sustained change in a media ecosystem. We observed that where collaborative scaffolding was strong, collaboratives affected change not just in how individual journalists work, but in how their local information ecosystems evolved.</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding fosters sustained, productive connections among journalists and news organizations beyond the collaborative experience.</em></strong></p><p>The positive changes in individuals journalists’ relationship to each other and to the practice of journalism was the most obvious impact we observed of strong collaborative scaffolding. The mature collaboratives we studied knitted together and sustained new relationships among journalists from a wide spectrum of news organizations, many of whom otherwise would not have reason to meet, let alone work together over an extended period of time.</p><p>Some of the positive effects of strong collaborative scaffolding stem from group composition. For example, each collaborative in our study included a Spanish-language media outlet or a Spanish media advisory group, as well as a mix of community media, corporate-owned media, public media and non-news partners, such as a local public library. “Many of us were meeting each other for the first time and are much more inclined now to offer a hand or lend an ear,” wrote one respondent in the research survey of members. “We’re certainly all talking more frequently, which is a huge benefit, and learning more about how other folks work,” reported another.</p><p>In mature collaboratives with strong scaffolding, individual members connected not only around the core reporting topic, but found reasons to collaborate outside of the formal collaborative as well. For example, one member shared with us: “We just traded articles with a partner in the collaborative. The two articles were not part of what the collaborative shares, but we both decided it was mutually beneficial to trade.”</p><p>The effects of powerful collaborative scaffolding can even extend beyond the topic-focused work to foster new and deeper connections between newsrooms. For example, one member in Charlotte said the collaborative connected her directly with another news leader, and together they have built out separate collaborations, including the sharing of a Report for America reporter. “This partnership has allowed us to write stories that we were unable to write before for lack of resources and we are expanding our audiences,” she wrote.</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding promotes deeper engagement with communities.</em></strong></p><p>Stronger collaborative scaffolding also produces more outward-facing engagement between the collaboratives and their communities. We saw that compared with developing collaboratives, the mature collaboratives with strong scaffolding made notable strides in holding engagement events, which showed promise as ways to lift community voices into the public arena. For example, a maturing collaborative within the cohort participated in nine events throughout the year, ranging from panels to listening sessions.</p><p>We also saw that when collaborative scaffolding worked well, joint coverage reflected new sources, different languages and humanizing details that had the potential to widen the communities served. For example, one mature collaborative with strong scaffolding chose the subject of race and equity in their coverage area for their reporting subject, and developed community boards to offer feedback and ideas for each reporting vertical within the broader subject. “The collaborative is helping to broaden editorial viewpoints, which … would then also lead to different coverage, maybe more diverse coverage in more neighborhoods by [my news organization],” shared one member of another mature collaborative.</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding can lead to positive media funding and policy outcomes.</em></strong></p><p>Strong collaborative scaffolding can also have a direct impact on policy and funding. We saw how maturing and mature collaboratives’ focus on a single subject generated buzz could command the awareness, attention, and action of media funders and policymakers.</p><p>The policy impacts we observed were often directly related to the solutions covered by the collaboratives. For example, in Charlotte, after the collaborative covered solutions to <a href="https://www.wcnc.com/article/money/markets/real-estate/affordable-housing-crisis/housing-vouchers-expiring/275-91ed5da2-6b03-47c2-9c16-13db41c2a0c7">expiring housing vouchers</a>, the Charlotte Housing Authority voted to move forward with one of the solutions highlighted by the collaborative. In New Hampshire, as part of its solutions-focused series on race and equity, the collaborative heard from members of the Latino community about a controversial draft bill prohibiting certain types of diversity curricula in the state’s schools. Following the collaborative’s reporting on the legislation and the impacts it might have, the governor opposed the measure and ultimately a weaker version of the bill was included in the state budget. And in Cleveland, a collaborative member published <a href="https://www.ideastream.org/news/several-ne-ohio-cities-consider-pay-to-stay-eviction-prevention-laws">a solution-focused story</a> about housing legislation, and shortly thereafter, a nearby city replicated the idea, which was also introduced in two other communities.</p><p>In addition to direct policy impact, we also found that many collaboratives were able to amplify the successful work of community groups in ways that influenced local funding. For example, in 2021, a group focused on vaccine distribution called Chicagoland Vaccine Partnership was awarded $1 million through a pooled fund from different foundations. The group cited the Chicago collaborative’s coverage of their efforts as a reason for the funding. Another group, Increase the Peace, said it raised $400,000 through grants and donations after it was covered by a member of the Chicago collaborative. In Northeast Ohio, an anonymous donor gave $50,000 to a community group after a collaborative member produced a story about the group’s work to prevent evictions. The community group cited the collaborative and the story as the reason for the donation. In another Northeast Ohio example, an organization that hosted Covid-19 vaccination clinics in historically Black churches received $250,000 from the Cleveland Foundation after a collaborative story on the subject, and the organization’s leader pointed to the story as an impetus for the grant.</p><p>Collaboratives have also been able to raise additional funds to support their work on the strength of their reporting, and some have been able to recruit new funders into local media. For example, in New Hampshire, the Granite State News Collaborative has raised about $240,000 since 2019 from local and national funders as well as from individual donors on the strength of its work, outside of its Solutions Journalism Network funding. One donor, the New Hampshire Charitable Foundation, asked the collaborative to speak about the importance of journalism and civic engagement at their Funders Forum meeting. And in Philadelphia, Resolve Philly, which houses Broke in Philly, received an award as a top nonprofit in 2021 and was granted $1 million from the <a href="https://www.inquirer.com/news/philadelphia-covid-19-community-information-fund-resolve-philly-philadelphia-inquirer-whyy-wurd-20200408.html">Philadelphia COVID-19 Community Information Fund</a> to support member newsrooms’ Covid-19 coverage in 2020.</p><p><strong><em>Strong scaffolding can build pathways to community change, over time.</em></strong></p><p>Impact on communities is the ultimate, highest aim for collaborations. Creating impact at this level requires the kinds of long-term practice changes, attitude changes, news, and information ecosystem engagement, and systemic change we have been pointing towards.</p><p>Within the timeframe of our study, and given the relatively short life to date of most of the collaboratives we studied, we were not able to uncover robust indications of the long-term impact of the collaboratives on their local communities. This stands to reason: community members’ relationships with the media are typically older than the collaboratives’ efforts, and longstanding, sustained change in dialogue and trust requires more time.</p><p>That said, we believe the solutions journalism framework in particular helps lay out pathways for audience members to participate in community change, which is one possible pathway through which local collaboratives may be able to create systemic change. Though gathering widespread evidence will require more time to study, we do have indications of possible long-term outcomes.</p><p>As a result of the solutions journalism coverage our collaboratives produced, we saw a handful of action-oriented networks developing in local ecosystems through attendance at events, building email lists, a texting group and volunteer opportunities. We could also detect a small change in audience attitudes in some places.</p><p>In the audience surveys we conducted, respondents reported ways their general outlook on their communities had changed, largely focusing on more compassion, awareness, and understanding. For example, in our audience survey for Philadelphia’s collaborative, 75% of respondents said that after engaging with a news story about economic mobility in Philadelphia, they discussed it with a friend or family member. Nearly one in five respondents said they changed personal behaviors or beliefs, and 26% said they followed a local journalist or journalism organization on social media. Other examples that respondents provided include: “share with educators for classroom use,” “contacted my state representative,” “shared with colleagues, use to inform my work,” and “raising my consciousness.”</p><p>Our nascent community impact data suggest that collaborative scaffolding is the foundation on which collaboratives can create community impact. Creating impact at the community level requires the kinds of long-term practice changes, mindset shifts, and community engagement that collaborative scaffolding makes possible. This means strong collaborative scaffolding is <strong><em>a necessary but not sufficient ingredient</em></strong> for creating community impact. Collaboratives need more time and resources to continue the hard work of making community change.</p><p><strong>The special role of solutions journalism</strong></p><p>While we believe the idea of a collaborative lifecycle and the concept of collaborative scaffolding can be usefully applied to all types of collaborative journalism, we also wanted to explore the special role that solutions journalism might play in the creation and development of collaborative scaffolding. Our research suggests that solutions journalism can develop and strengthen collaborative scaffolding in three ways: through meeting collaborators’ needs beyond monetary resources, by providing a rigorous way to test assumptions, and through fostering a sense of community and belonging to a movement larger than the single collaborative.</p><p>Solutions journalism as a whole provides a ready-made values framework that is the core of collaborative scaffolding. The unique differentiator of solutions journalism as a basis for collaboration is that the specific values of the approach meet collaborators’ needs for meaningful participation, service, and learning — in addition to the Solutions Journalism Network providing resources for reporting. The mere existence of an explicit, shared set of values has the potential to get collaborators from very different backgrounds on the same page from the very beginning. The kind of strong, early, momentum that explicit values provide can carry a collaborative through the inevitable ups and downs of the early stages of work together.</p><p>The solutions journalism framework also provides explicit ways to test assumptions about usual ways of practicing journalism. The reporting style can be very exacting and rigorous, even as the reporting products can take a wide range of forms. When practiced in a collaborative context, solutions journalism’s focus on generating insight with rigor helps build the trust that is a key component of collaborative scaffolding because reporters are forced to question their assumptions and be transparent about their practices together.</p><p>Finally, the structure, resources, and network of the Solutions Journalism Network itself helped create a container for collaborative scaffolding to develop and foster community and belonging. Distinct from other funders and associations in the space, funding flows to collaboratives, not to specific media organizations, which helps tamp down competition. And from sharing internal planning documents, to disseminating revenue strategies and other tips for engaging group members, to organizing inter-collaborative happy hours, the Local Media Project central organizers created spaces for members to feel part of a movement bigger than themselves.</p><p><strong>Collaborative Scaffolding and New Theories of Change for Journalism</strong></p><p>Journalism’s systems and theory of change <a href="https://www.cjr.org/special_report/journalism-power-public-good-community-infrastructure.php">need an update</a>. We believe that collaborative scaffolding, built with explicit values and goals that work alongside and for community needs, is one path to new structures that truly produce positive change. This is especially the case when collaboratives include member organizations that are not news organizations.</p><p>We have seen firsthand the incredible capacity of journalists to work together, across differences and divides, in pursuit of community service. Collaborations, especially when they grow more expansive in their ideas and less beholden to industry culture, can better partner with community members to share information and stories to pave the way for better outcomes, faster and with more buy-in. Strong collaborative scaffolding is the key to that success.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc045157a292" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/collaborative-scaffolding-the-key-to-successful-collaborative-journalism-cc045157a292">Collaborative Scaffolding: The Key to Successful Collaborative Journalism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Emily Bell, Victor Pickard and Nikki Usher kick off new Tow webinar series on local journalism and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/emily-bell-victor-pickard-and-nikki-usher-kick-off-new-tow-webinar-series-on-local-journalism-and-f8d0bf13c58f?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8d0bf13c58f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[local-journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[local-news]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Damian Radcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Nov 2021 20:42:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-11T20:42:48.953Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Emily Bell, Victor Pickard and Nikki Usher kick off new Tow webinar series on local journalism and media policy</strong></h3><h4><strong>“What role can (and should) media policy play in supporting a strong, sustainable, vibrant local media sector in the United States?”</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*70V0jde4LAwJr0k43N5ulg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>By Nick Mathews</em></strong></p><p>A powerhouse panel provided a simple, yet thorough primer to a new five-part series on the complex intersection of media policy and local journalism. The series kicked off in October and was hosted by the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia Journalism School. and will explore how media policy can support local journalism.</p><p>The first discussion, which provided an overview of this complex issue and many of the facets which accompany it, featured three expert panellists: <a href="https://twitter.com/VWPickard">Victor Pickard</a> (University of Pennsylvania), <a href="https://twitter.com/nikkiusher">Nikki Usher</a> (University of Illinois), and <a href="https://twitter.com/emilybell">Emily Bell</a> (Director of the Tow Center for Digital Journalism) and was moderated by <a href="https://towcenter.columbia.edu/content/damian-radcliffe">Tow fellow</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/damianradcliffe">Damian Radcliffe</a> from the University of Oregon.</p><h4><strong>Why are we having this conversation?</strong></h4><p>At the heart of the matter lies a crumbling legacy news media sector and an emerging dialogue about the concerns, and possibilities, of government support for local news. Publicly funded support for journalism is not an alien concept in many parts of the world, but the US market enjoys a number of unique characteristics that make this concept less embedded in the United States. <strong>“</strong> If all of these democratic countries around the world have been able to figure it out, I think we can, too,” Pickard said. “And I think we have to.” That is because, he believes, local journalism cannot survive financially on its own.</p><blockquote><strong>“</strong>The market won’t fix itself,” Pickard said plainly.</blockquote><blockquote>“I think the evidence is that, at least for particular kinds of journalism, there really is no commercial future. The market will continue to drive local journalism in particular into the ground. … If we don’t find non-market means of support, we know what’s going to happen.”</blockquote><p>Added Bell: “Small news organizations don’t really have a sustainable future in a market which works on the basis of advertising dollars and which is controlled by a couple of really enormous companies.”</p><h4><strong>What role might media policy play?</strong></h4><p>Perhaps the most talked about area of media policy right now is focused on the notion of an increase in government subsidies to help support local journalism. Some <a href="https://www.freepress.net/issues/future-journalism/local-journalism/where-were-working/news-voices-new-jersey">initiatives</a> are already in action, with the state of New Jersey, for instance, allocating between $1 million and $2 million to help rehabilitate local journalism. (Of note, the total is down from the original $100 million proposal). Other subsidy ideas being discussed include enabling residents to purchase local news subscriptions, or support non-profit providers <a href="https://www.cantwell.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Local%20Journalism%20Sustainability%20Act%20One%20Page%20Summary%20July%2023%202021.pdf">through</a> a “local news credit” and tax breaks for businesses to purchase advertising with local news organizations.</p><p>Usher, for one, is “very wary” of such government intervention.</p><blockquote>“The concern some people have, including myself, is not so much about government support, but about dependency on government support and what happens when the government pulls the rug out under you,” Usher said. “And so, I think that that’s actually when my hesitation comes in against relying too much on public subsidies.”</blockquote><p>Usher also identified “soft subsidies” that already exist. For instance, at the University of Illinois, student programming fees support subscriptions to the New York Times, not the regional Chicago Tribune or the local News-Gazette.</p><h4><strong>Who should get support?</strong></h4><p>Overall, Usher argued media policy’s support of local journalism “requires thinking big and bold.” At the same time, Usher said, it also “requires starting at the very basics.”</p><p><strong>“</strong>There are things that exist that we can do that don’t have to be created from the ground up. And it’s about thinking creatively within the potential that’s already present,” Usher said.</p><p>One of the primary questions regarding possible subsidies for local news organizations is, which organizations will benefit from the subsidies? For instance, would Gannett, which includes many small news organizations in its portfolio — but also is the largest newspaper publisher in the United States- be eligible?</p><blockquote>“For the first time, I think America is facing this idea that somehow you’re going to have to define this … which at least identifies who might or might not be suitable for subsidy,” Bell said. “This should be for as broad and imaginative group as we can possibly include.”</blockquote><h4><strong>Why is this a difficult conversation in the US?</strong></h4><p>For decades, news organizations have traditionally balked at the idea of receiving government funding. And in many ways, the First Amendment, championed as journalism’s greatest arrow, has — in the eyes of some — also effectively impeded the implementation of media policy because of its seemingly interventionist stance; a stance some believe to be at odds with the very nature of a free press.</p><p>“So much of what we’re dealing with now are really discursive impediments, that you’ll start talking about these things and as a knee jerk reaction, people would just say, ‘First Amendment’ as a kind of conversation stopper,” Pickard said.</p><p>But, now, he said, is the time to counter-punch such arguments. “We all learn in school that democracy requires a free-and by implication functional-press system. And it is the affirmative duty of government to guarantee that we have that press system,” he said. “So I think, if we start using these kinds of discursive weapons…we can try to counteract both the market fundamentalism and the First Amendment fundamentalism that are often used to beat down these conversations, especially here in the U.S.”</p><h4><strong>Looking ahead</strong></h4><p>Ultimately, as the local journalism sector struggles mightily, the decision by any stakeholder to stand by quietly speaks volumes. “Policy inaction is as important, sometimes more important, than actual policy action,” Pickard said. “The bottom line is that government is always involved in our media. The real question is how the government should be involved, and that is a question for media policy.”</p><p>Nick Matthews is a PhD candidate at the University of Minnesota Hubbard School of Journalism &amp; Mass Communication and a Research Assistant at the Tow Center for Digital Journalism.</p><h4><strong>Missed this event?</strong></h4><p>You can <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDOpQMAaDIs">watch the full conversation on YouTube</a>, <a href="https://soundcloud.com/towcenter/an-introduction-to-media-policy-and-local-journalism">listen on SoundCloud</a> or <a href="https://www.scribd.com/document/536731561/Transcript-An-Introduction-to-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism">read the transcript</a> on Scribd.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FaDOpQMAaDIs%3Fstart%3D70%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D70&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DaDOpQMAaDIs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FaDOpQMAaDIs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ea8fe46fd0d7c1d8717e34b96d622ad0/href">https://medium.com/media/ea8fe46fd0d7c1d8717e34b96d622ad0/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1147798000%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Ftowcenter%2Fan-introduction-to-media-policy-and-local-journalism&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-i0bVaSG4b30h6zXG-PGIRdA-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/436e6448531e095ddb8c6eaf46f6e502/href">https://medium.com/media/436e6448531e095ddb8c6eaf46f6e502/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fembeds%2F536731561%2Fcontent&amp;display_name=Scribd&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.scribd.com%2Fdocument%2F536731561%2FTranscript-An-Introduction-to-Media-Policy-and-Local-Journalism&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fimgv2-1-f.scribdassets.com%2Fimg%2Fdocument%2F536731561%2F111x142%2F22f365580f%2F1654523579%3Fv%3D1&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=scribd" width="600" height="800" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/50bb1be81fdc3b635dd128a4a2f949e1/href">https://medium.com/media/50bb1be81fdc3b635dd128a4a2f949e1/href</a></iframe><h4><strong>Future Webinars</strong></h4><p>This conversation on media policy and local journalism will continue at 4 p.m. Eastern Time on Nov. 18. All future events are being hosted by the Tow Center at 4 p.m. Eastern Time on the third Thursday of every month (Oct ’21 — Jan ‘22).</p><p>The second panel of the five-part series is entitled, “Lessons from Oversees,” with panellists <a href="https://twitter.com/sdp">Sameer Padania</a> (Founder and Advisor, Macroscope Lead Author Journalism Funders Forum), <a href="https://twitter.com/mj_powers">Matthew Powers</a> (University of Washington) and <a href="https://www.deakin.edu.au/about-deakin/people/kristy-hess">Kristy Hess</a> (Deakin University, Australia) anchoring a discussion about media policy in local journalism outside of the United States, with a particular emphasis on Europe and Australia. <a href="https://www.eventbrite.com/e/local-journalism-and-media-policy-lessons-from-overseas-tickets-201065029917?aff=ebdsoporgprofile">Sign up to join us here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*pDAGVXPaSs14UnNCtEcexA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Looking ahead, the Dec. 15 panel will focus on issues unique to grassroots media, and the Jan. 19 panel will address emerging issues and fresh ideas in media policy. On Jan. 26, there will be a wrap-up panel, highlighting many of the lessons learned from the five-part series.</p><p>All panels are free and open to the public.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://us7.campaign-archive.com/?u=f92dc374de944af763a8fdf13&amp;id=2178a1abbe"><em>https://us7.campaign-archive.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8d0bf13c58f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/emily-bell-victor-pickard-and-nikki-usher-kick-off-new-tow-webinar-series-on-local-journalism-and-f8d0bf13c58f">Emily Bell, Victor Pickard and Nikki Usher kick off new Tow webinar series on local journalism and…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What do we mean by “quality news?”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/what-do-we-mean-by-quality-news-cec178704356?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cec178704356</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[credibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[misinformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metrics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[news]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Aviv Ovadya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Nov 2018 17:54:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-07T17:11:04.488Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Imagine this: You work at Facebook and you have been instructed by Zuck himself to “fix news on the platform” — to do “the right thing” for users, even if it cuts into Facebook’s profits. So what do you do? And how do you measure if you’ve succeeded?</p><p>This scenario gets at much of the purpose of journalism and news consumption. To help answer it and elucidate some the implicit complexity, we propose a conceptual framework for news and news ecosystem “quality,” which can then form a basis for news ecosystem health measurement. Without such a framework and measurement capability, it is difficult to even judge, either as an insider or outsider, if Facebook and its brethren are doing the “right thing” — or to meaningfully suggest substantive improvements.</p><p>Underpinning this framework are several elements for which it might be valuable to measure quality: the content, the source, and the effect on the receiver. These are defined as follows:</p><ul><li><strong>Content</strong>: The actual content and message of the news</li><li><strong>Source</strong>: The entity that creates or packages content for distribution, generally associating their identity with the content, e.g. a publisher, author, account, blog, etc.</li><li><strong>Reception</strong>: The effect the content has on individuals, their communities, etc.</li></ul><h3>News Source Quality</h3><p>In evaluating a news source, there are several related but distinct values that one might consider and evaluate.</p><ul><li><strong>Integrity</strong> — How well does this source adhere to a set of ideals and processes? These ideals might include not plagiarizing or slandering, while processes would include fact checking and correcting errors. This value speaks most directly to the element of source, exploring the methodology used as the source creates content.</li><li><strong>Accuracy</strong> — How closely do the articles published by the source match the true state of the world? This value is more content-focused, examining the output of the source.</li><li><strong>Reliability</strong> — What is the likelihood that any particular story from this source will be accurate? This value ties content and source together over time.</li><li><strong>Credibility</strong> — What is the likelihood that the source will inform recipients — or at least avoid misleading them? This value includes the direct impact of the source on recipients — which may be different for different contexts or recipients.</li><li><strong>Informativeness — </strong>How <em>much</em> does this source inform readers? This value captures the degree to which a source increases the recipient’s understanding (which is also usually context and recipient dependent).</li><li>(Net-positive) <strong>Impact </strong>— How much does this source improve its readers and the world? (This could include informing readers, fostering community, improving accountability, etc.). This value is focused entirely on reception to the content.</li></ul><p>These are all values which an ideal news source would attempt to maximize, and which are deeply correlated and build upon one another; e.g. a news source cannot be credible if it is not accurate, and is unlikely to be accurate without integrity. As a shorthand, we can say that the <strong>quality</strong> of a news source hinges on the extent to which it fulfills these properties. Each of these can also be the basis for a metric or classification scheme.</p><h3>News Consumption Quality Metrics</h3><p>How do we measure these different properties of news sources and the news ecosystem as a whole? One measure of news ecosystem health might simply be “relative news quality”<strong> — </strong>the<strong> </strong>degree to which a population’s news diet comes from sources that value the news properties that are indicators of overall quality.</p><p>However, there is some crucial nuance here when we place all the news sources consumed by an individual within their role in civic society. Quality is not necessarily enough — various <strong>civic categories</strong> of news need to provided and consumed in order to ensure a robust society. A 2012 report for the FCC, “<a href="https://www.fcc.gov/news-events/blog/2012/07/25/review-literature-regarding-critical-information-needs-american-public">Regarding Critical Information Needs of the American Public</a>”, proposed one version of these, suggesting 8 key categories of news: economic opportunities, transportation, health, emergencies, environment, civic information, and political information.</p><p>Keeping that in mind, there are several types of “<strong>news health</strong>” that an individual or population might aspire to:</p><ol><li><em>Significant quality news consumption</em>. Consuming a significant amount of high-quality news. This does not imply anything about simultaneous consumption of low-quality news, which may also be significant.</li><li><em>High relative news quality</em>. Consuming a significant proportion of quality news, without implying anything about the amount and comprehensiveness of the news consumed, which may be limited in number of articles, frequency of consumption, and variety of sources.</li><li><em>A complete civic news diet</em>. Consuming a sufficient proportion of each civic category of quality news, without implying anything about the quality of other news being consumed. As in (1), consumption of low-quality news may also be significant.</li><li><em>A complete and fulfilling civic news diet</em>. Consuming a sufficient proportion of each civic category of quality news and avoiding overconsumption of low-quality news — a combination of (1) and (2).</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*RhKk-u50t8H5Zu7ZVZepeA.png" /></figure><p>Evaluating if a news ecosystem fulfills these criteria requires a way to classify or score the quality of news and/or the completeness of a civic news diet. Being able to measure (4) is ideal, as it represents the highest possible level of “news health” for each person or community — but is also the mostly costly to classify.</p><p><em>If you believe there are important aspects not captured by these frameworks, please get in touch via email at </em><a href="/service/mailto:tow@aviv.me"><em>av@aviv.me</em></a><em> or on twitter at @metaviv. For updates on my work, follow me and subscribe at </em><a href="http://list.aviv.me/"><em>list.aviv.me</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cec178704356" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/what-do-we-mean-by-quality-news-cec178704356">What do we mean by “quality news?”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Web no.point.0: rise of the Splintr.net]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/web-no-point-0-rise-of-the-splintr-net-d45869aa1b8?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d45869aa1b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[platform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Albright]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Oct 2018 17:28:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-17T19:35:58.901Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QnzLlpQ8pu0UqVowvsoDOw.png" /><figcaption>“The M.I.N.D.”, a hemisphere projection of my November 2016 large-scale <a href="https://medium.com/@d1gi/left-right-the-combined-post-election2016-news-ecosystem-42fc358fbc96">political news network</a> analysis.</figcaption></figure><p>The “<a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/facebook-may-facing-era-accountability">era of accountability</a>” for American tech has begun. Though unsettling, the spate of disclosures from <a href="https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2018/10/update-on-security-issue/">Facebook</a>, <a href="https://blog.google/technology/safety-security/project-strobe/">Google</a>, and other technology companies has provided a much-needed win for public accountability. Not in the least, it has led to the <a href="https://transparencyreport.google.com/political-ads/overview">establishment of tools</a> that offer at least some degree of <a href="https://www.facebook.com/ads/archive/?active_status=all&amp;ad_type=political_and_issue_ads&amp;country=US">transparency into advertising</a> and digital politics. At the same time, it’s likely we are only around the midpoint in a longer pattern of undisclosed privacy violations, security breaches, and regulatory oversights.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gfw8xeS5wcyFRD3-bByKQQ.png" /><figcaption>“Facebook in Privacy Breach” The Wall Street Journal, October 2010.</figcaption></figure><p>The good news: we know more than we did six months ago, and the six months before that. Still, the larger questions remain: How did we get here? What brought us to this point? What details <em>haven’t</em> we been told yet? And why have these unfortunate developments, some involving issues that were pointed out years go by researchers, regulators, and activists, proven so difficult to anticipate by those responsible?</p><p>In our efforts to understand the <em>how</em> and <em>why</em>, we should continue advocating for access to the data that allows us to accurately reconstruct exactly what happened. Only then can we start preparing for the future. And while the pieces of the data puzzle still trickle in, ensuring independent researchers and policymakers have the right evidence is nevertheless essential, as it helps inform the actions that regulators take, the questions legislators ask, and the changes platforms ultimately make. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/10/12/facebook-takes-down-data-and-thousands-of-posts-obscuring-reach-of-russian-disinformation">Archives are key to this process</a>.</p><p><a href="https://blog.twitter.com/official/en_us/topics/company/2018/enabling-further-research-of-information-operations-on-twitter.html">Enabling further research of information operations on Twitter</a></p><p>It is tempting to relate recent happenings to occurrences of the past, and to lean on outdated theories and convenient analogies to explain the relative collapse of the information sphere. Yet there are no historical precedents, or set of precedents, that can adequately encapsulate the situation and challenges we currently face. This is important, because as we embark on our broader inquiry of “<strong>what’s happened to the internet,”</strong> and try to interpret its effects on our information ecosystem, media industry, and way of life, we need to think holistically.</p><p>I believe studying this requires a diverse palette of investigative tools, a multidisciplinary outlook, and a willingness to experiment in methodological approach. It demands both contextual and reflexive consideration. It involves <em>going back</em> and <em>asking</em> <em>more questions.</em> We must do our best to untether findings from any single disciplinary interpretation or established idea about the past.</p><h4><strong>The State of the Internet</strong></h4><p>The state of the modern information ecosystem — including our dilemma addressing misinformation, propaganda, security, and hate speech — are manifestations of <strong>intrinsic misalignments within an increasingly hybridized global information system</strong>. I believe we are just beginning to realize some of the consequences. The stakes are high.</p><p>Tech companies and regulators, as well as policymakers and the public, are tasked with grasping a hybrid information machine that is not only complex, but riddled with critical vulnerabilities. These involve technological vulnerabilities as well as social ones.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n-mvvNAPUy4i8WYa6CP-iQ.png" /><figcaption>&lt;<strong>4mysquad</strong>&gt; and &lt;<strong>lagonegirl</strong>&gt; reblog on Tumblr, author’s name redacted, January 2018</figcaption></figure><p>Outside of the installation of sentient, perfectly designed, self-coding machines, emerging technologies and their adoption and subsequent normalization pose problems that can<em> </em>never<em> be solved</em>. The vulnerabilities are inherent to the human-centered design of systems, which are, in essence, features embedded in our mathematics, biology and psychology.</p><p>⚠️ <strong>The exploits that haunt us are part of</strong> <strong>human nature</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/996/1*w0AwBdrWmg7o5ihVVN80Vw.png" /><figcaption>Post shared on Facebook, September 2016</figcaption></figure><p>⚠️ <strong>We can only anticipate, identify, and patch. We can </strong><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-hack-single-sign-on-data-exposed/"><strong>never control</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/454/1*LUj0gGg05pTe95pakMJR0A.png" /><figcaption>Pinterest autocomplete recommendations, November 2017</figcaption></figure><p>The reason I emphasize this is because the internet is not mature, nor should it ever be. It is not analogous to a human adolescent or a teenager; there is no human condition or developmental stage that sufficiently pinpoints its state.</p><p>It’s a network that’s <em>always</em> under construction. It’s both structured and chaotic — an amalgamation of power, culture, and politics. And the more who join this network, the more unpredictable it is likely to become.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*axcQ6otpQ6nL9T88oSDxEA.png" /><figcaption>Facebook timeline post, 31 October 2016</figcaption></figure><p>The <em>Internet</em>. With a capital I. It was once called the “virtual.” Or less problematic nowadays, “online.” It was deemed the space that opened up new possibilities for exploration and civilization. A heralded venue for identity experimentation, information sharing, and discovery. The dawn of a new digital age. It was <a href="https://cddrl.fsi.stanford.edu/libtech">liberation tech</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wjSp7pWnGcxthOBEQNOkVw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/original-wired-manifesto/">https://www.wired.com/story/original-wired-manifesto/</a></figcaption></figure><p>Early on, the impact on humanity was equated with the discovery of 🔥. In hindsight, maybe this was a fitting analogy.</p><h4>Start Making Sense</h4><p>How do we make sense of the unstable scaffolding of technology, culture — and begin to interpret the less desirable effects it has bestowed upon our society and way of life?</p><p>We could start, perhaps, by further reflecting on the many decades of technological innovations and engineering developments, or revisiting the contexts through which the internet has been constructed and framed. We could investigate its applications and uses. Of course, the answer is all of the above.</p><p>⚠️ <strong>The first thing we should do is lay out what the Internet <em>is</em> and what it is <em>not</em>.</strong></p><p>The construct known as the Internet — and its associated analogies, euphemisms, and anthropomorphisms — has come and gone.</p><p>Most of us don’t “get online” anymore, and younger generations will never truly be “offline.” Even when we are physically separated from data connectivity, whether by situation or by choice, our digitized remnants and data trails still flow and pulse through the veins of the network.</p><p>Through 1s and 0s, data representing fragments of our lives and those of our social connections and families will be stored, aggregated, and processed. Emails and DMs will arrive in our inboxes. Many of the most important, if not downright essential, parts our lives now exist indefinitely within the network, and our devices will buzz and beep to remind us of this <strong>the moment we connect</strong>.</p><p>Powered through the diffusion of innovations, capital investment, and ideologically fueled by the promise of connectivity, the “Internet” of yesteryear — I mean the one with the uppercase “I” — has undergone a complete and total metamorphosis.</p><p>There are, of course, artifacts which remain: We still use versions of the original protocols today, including TCP/IP and POP, and languages such as HTML, JavaScript, and .net. And while more efficient, the transmission of data across the network, allowing our all-important connections, is based on improvements to the same legacy technologies, including the ethernet, coaxial, and fiber optic networks, switches, and undersea cables.</p><p>It should also go without saying that, regardless of the amazing ways we obtain and store it, <strong><em>everything</em></strong> runs on electricity. Until our understanding of the laws of physics dramatically changes, this will continue to be the case.</p><p>⚠️ <strong>What’s changed in our relationship with the Internet</strong> <strong>is its supposed</strong> <strong><em>purpose</em></strong>.</p><p>This isn’t technological. It’s <em>cultural</em>. Facing this reality involves revisiting most of our expectations after decades of celebrated technological achievements, collaborations, and thought leaders who have told us what the internet was <em>supposed</em> to do for<em> us</em>.</p><p>To put it bluntly, we — and I primarily mean Americans and Western Europeans — must stop asking <em>what the internet</em> <em>can do for us</em>. And journalists need to stop fixating on <em>how the internet has done us wrong</em>. Instead,</p><p>⚠️ <strong>We should start asking what <em>we</em> can do for the internet.</strong></p><p>Western conceptions and idealistic notions about the Internet are no more. Its trajectory is now dictated in response to the <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/05/late-capitalism/524943/">demands of late capitalism</a>. This is not so much a response to economic market pressures or “e-commerce,” nor it is the end of capitalism. It’s the harnessing of the utility of the Internet as the engine for achieving unbridled wealth and power through the accumulation of data.</p><p>The consequences of this shift mean that <strong><em>we</em></strong> — the assumed denizens in our supposed liberal democratic states — have already lost control.</p><p>Once this fact is recognized, rather than presuming that the Internet is <em>supposed</em> <em>to</em><strong> </strong><em>evolve</em> in tandem with the needs of our society and its constituent global stakeholder communities, or molded by the creative vision of altruistic programmers and designers, we can see it’s <em>virtue</em> as a thing has already been lost — expropriated by a confluence of mostly American mega corporations and their shareholders.</p><p>The new rules of engagement are enforced by a deep network of vested lobbying interests and legal experts in the relentless pursuit of capital. There are upsides and downsides to this scenario.</p><p>⚠️ <strong>We shouldn’t — and can’t — expect the Internet to work for <em>us</em> anymore.</strong></p><p>Because it doesn’t. Despite that fact that it often feels this way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/1*B5OfLqQAgfO_qRRNZgLy8g.png" /><figcaption>Facebook UK Labour Party sponsored profile frame, November 2017</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/846/1*0BiGqp0CpRtxveJc605JkQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*FPRIbI-x92S4S8P-bU7LDA.png" /><figcaption>Facebook US sponsored post, usa.gov, November 2016.</figcaption></figure><p>Therein lies the acknowledgement of the existential threat the Internet poses to our supposed liberal democratic way of life.</p><p>The dangers of the internet that are circulated in news headlines, quoted in congressional hearings, and aired in parliamentary sessions have always existed. It’s just that they have only recently been realized as our <strong>loss of agency becomes more apparent</strong>, and as our <strong>perceived</strong> <strong>lack</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>control</strong> <strong>over what will happen in the future accelerates</strong>.</p><p>Our ability to connect with others, share information, engage in open dialogue, and to communicate<em> on our own terms </em>without outside interests, advertising, data siphoning, and algorithmic prejudice through the Internet has quickly deteriorated.</p><p>Today, the bulk of our interactions, identities, and informational exchanges are determined not by our <em>access</em> <em>to</em> the network, but by the convenient and free services that have slowly but surely become <em>de facto</em> standards for global communication.</p><p>Some might argue that the telegraph, telephone, and television networks were owned by private corporations. However,</p><p>⚠️ <strong>It’s not the <em>Internet</em> that poses a threat to democratic society. It’s that the technologies that make up what we call “the Internet” have become less democratic</strong>.</p><p>This, in turn, has relinquished the administration of our public archives, and most of our personal data — including comprehensive records of our lives, conversations, locations, activities, political preferences, purchasing habits, and emotional and health states — into the hands of a small group of private corporations, opening the potential for data extraction and reselling, oversight, and surveillance.</p><p>Today, there are few, if any, practical alternatives. If you don’t want to use the Internet in America, you might not be able to even submit an application for a job. The same will eventually be true for using cash and non-digital currency.</p><p><em>So, what are we supposed to do now that it’s become obvious that the Internet is neither public nor democratic?</em></p><p>Especially for American citizens, it means there can be no true first amendment arguments, or reasonable claims to “free speech” online. Or right to organize and protest. Why? Because the majority of the time, we aren’t residing, engaging, or transacting in public. And by using these services, we’ve already agreed to their terms, which typically <a href="https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1032&amp;context=caselrev">exclude the possibility of suing</a> for any type of damages in a court of law.</p><p>This sets up a vastly different scenario than the rosy future heralded by early enthusiasts, academics, and tech adopters. The opportunities afforded by the internet were assumed to offset the disruption. We ignored and dismissed them, because back then, it was all about <strong><em>us</em></strong>, and the democratization of information.</p><h4><strong>Byproducts</strong></h4><p>Built from the ground up to be resilient to attack, and designed to circumvent destruction from the acts of adversaries, hostile powers, and acts of war, everything from the transmission protocols to the geographical footprint of the Internet was designed with one quality, <strong><em>autonomy, </em></strong>in mind. I’ll leave the details to the existing body of work on the history of the Internet, ARPANET, World Wide Web, and Silicon Valley.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b011k45f">BBC Two - All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace, Love and Power</a></p><p>The point is, the Internet was meant to be an autonomous defensive mechanism for information storage and exchange. It never was supposed to be equated with autonomy in the liberal democratic sense — even in John Perry Barlow’s <a href="http://I declare the global social space we are building to be naturally independent of the tyrannies you seek to impose on us. You have no moral right to rule us nor do you possess any methods of enforcement we have true reason to fear.">techno-libertarian interpretation</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QwAXwJZ0GtscyE7ulXsK4w.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence">A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace,</a> February 1996</figcaption></figure><p>The core architecture — its designers’ operational creed — was to establish a place for information, and not necessarily one for humans. It was built for military reasons. Only then came the ideas about it being a mosaic of connected outposts. The virtual community. The WELL.</p><blockquote>I declare the global social space we are building to be naturally independent of the tyrannies you seek to impose on us. You have no moral right to rule us nor do you possess any methods of enforcement we have true reason to fear.</blockquote><p>We have ended up in Barlow’s alternative reality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IhVTAC15XcOjB53huiH-ew.png" /><figcaption>Facebook Group — “White Lives Matter More,” November 2017</figcaption></figure><p>Not that any of these people were wrong by default. They just built a vision based on grand expectations that has been reinforced to this very day.</p><p>Therein lies the Internet’s first disconnect with the needs and expectations of modern liberal democracies; it’s one of the glitches in the fabric of the matrix. The network was meant to be an autonomous sphere, and its celebrated architects and innovators, funded by and employed at American tech corporations, have seen seemingly limitless success in showing its beneficial applications to society. Enabled by entrepreneurial culture, regulatory loopholes and financial incentives, they followed dreams of infinite connectivity and growth. The goal: to move civilization onto the Internet. From atoms to bits, digitize everything.</p><p><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/wired25-kevin-kelly-internet-superpowers-great-upwelling/?mbid=BottomRelatedStories_WIRED25">How the Internet Gave All of Us Superpowers</a></p><p>Ushering in a plethora of products to satisfy their users and attract advertisers, dominant tech companies now scout for — and mitigate— innovations, businesses, and acts of legislation that present threats to their established dominance. Due to the lack of domestic regulation and international tax and market enforcement mechanisms, American tech has carved out an unprecedented niche in the global financial marketplace.</p><p>Over the past three decades, the increasing reach of the Internet and adoption of applications, platforms, code, and information sharing formats have, for better or worse — and for richer or poorer — succeeded in connecting much of the known world.</p><p>⚠️ <strong>The difference is, until less than a decade ago, researchers, politicians, and media tended to fixate on the Internet’s <em>potential to do good.</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://www.wired.com/story/wired25-david-karpf-issues-tech-predictions/">25 Years of WIRED Predictions: Why the Future Never Arrives</a></p><p>Years of magazine covers, news headlines, research initiatives, think tank reports, industry awards, white papers, and billions of dollars in public and private funding have been devoted to <strong>reinforcing the rhetoric of the Internet’s utopian promise</strong>, proclaiming its potential. At one point in the late 2000s, the concept of “<a href="https://www.facebook.com/pages/Altrupreneurship-venture-altruism/275947492510775">venture altruism</a>” was even a thing.</p><p>What’s become apparent as of late are the Internet’s<em> less prized </em>qualities. It’s <strong><em>anti-virtues</em></strong>, if you will. Things don’t add up quite like they used to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/892/1*SoW9hSvtiZ2ztaB_LWqGkQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/730/1*EnTindIQhYIg3htGtNpbTg.png" /><figcaption>Left, Facebook’s Instagram IRA response app; Right Facebook’s IRA Response App. 31 January 2017.</figcaption></figure><p>These constitute what I view as the <strong><em>byproducts</em></strong> — the unintended, ignored, and unrecognized effects of the rapid evolution and adoption of this hybrid information network on our society. We are starting to see the accumulation of our own cultural information smog.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/554/1*4SryQ_rLShy6KjTX-RkUAg.png" /><figcaption>Twitter Government, 26 September 2016.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>↕️ Splintrnet</strong></h4><p>Five years ago, I view the Internet as less <em>supervised</em>. Specifically, I mean that the online spaces, platforms, and connected applications — while owned by private interests — tended to be less subject to the encroachment of corporate profit models, algorithmic oversight, and the aggressive reprioritization of users’ content and shared information.</p><p>The ways in which we exchanged news, and the management and determination of acceptable activities weren’t nearly as formalized. Nor were we as valuable as users. And tech companies didn’t need to finance and maintain the infrastructure, data centers, and server farms required to support anywhere near their current levels of users.</p><p>It’s not that the Internet was objectively a <strong>better</strong> place. And though it was mostly a facade, it did feel more <em>public</em>. There existed unsupervised spaces, and events, hashtags, and interests that could — in theory — still be “occupied” by committed actors, change agents, and independent activists.</p><p>Now these same communities can easily be targeted, excluded, and harassed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DEeK8oyuOxYE8t9tw-jMRQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0r8UE2iBdAYaflm2HZTIcg.png" /></figure><p>The potential of the network for coordination to produce positive, if preconceived, outcomes was deemed by most of the Western world at the time as beneficial to society. No less than five years ago, we saw the Internet as the shining manifestation of self-organization and emerging technology working together for the greater good.</p><p>Through this American and Eurocentric framing, companies like Facebook and Twitter helped install what was perceived at the time as positive change. Revolutions came. People in countries even named their children “Facebook.”</p><p><a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/02/22/133959319/little-egyptian-girl-named-facebook-to-honor-sites-role-in-revolution">Little Egyptian Girl Named &#39;Facebook&#39; To Honor Site&#39;s Role In Revolution</a></p><p>The Internet of the past decade boosted coordination in the wake of catastrophic disaster events; helped to mobilize on-the-ground political activists; and invoke — you guessed it, “<strong><em>democratic</em></strong>” — change (these “positive” effects tended to take place in countries outside of America). And just a few years prior, Yahoo and Google formed part of the Web’s liberation of information, attributed with freeing access to knowledge from its institutional gatekeepers, which at the time involved public (i.e., state) agencies and mass media.</p><p>The problems with this framing are many: For one, these interpretations are always subjective — conditional upon dominant paradigms, time and place. The revolutions of the 2000s and 2010s have come and gone, but the resulting wars and long-term destabilization of the regions where they occurred linger on. Second, these mostly American technology companies were the enablers for the “positive” outcomes to happen on the Internet in the first place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lfFUpiGHG7w0RTTrUdP2kg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Facebook Elections official sticker (2016)</figcaption></figure><p>The underlying basis of the uses of the Internet for coordination and <em>to </em>produce outcomes — the Tahrir Squares, the Occupys, the election(s) of Obama, came at the cost of being built and subsidized by private technology companies and their internal talent.</p><p><strong>Subsidized</strong> is a key term here: by this, I mean that while the revolutions of “Arab Spring” and social responses to Fukushima and other crisis events took place, the potential threats to Western democratic ways of life were overlooked in favor of the Internet’s <em>potential</em> to do good.</p><p>To change the rest of the world for the <em>better</em>.</p><p>These things aren’t necessarily all <em>bad</em>. In fact, I’d argue many were good. Over the past decade, we might have seen the subjective realization of the Internet’s “audacity of hope.” Yet, it was private tech companies that provided the tools that allowed us to “occupy” their platforms and services.</p><p>These uses of the Internet were perceived as democratic and reviled as changing things for the better. It was also common-sense public relations for the companies involved, and happened to strategically align with American geopolitical interests at the time. Back then, tech companies weren’t nearly as far along in their quests to become multi-billion-dollar empires. They were, however, valued based on their potential to expand the size of their services and grow their user bases.</p><p>What’s become clear is that these companies’ <em>missions</em> in changing the world — and in ensuring their users can coordinate to produce “good” outcomes — is nowhere near the value that can be derived by expanding the overall size and reach of the network.</p><p><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/03/data-misuse-bigger-than-facebook/556310/">This Is So Much Bigger Than Facebook</a></p><p>More users, more value. But the activities of users and the designs of these services and platforms should be factors in helping us determine their social impact and consequences. While connectivity and potential for coordination are neither bad nor good, they are not neutral, as today they <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2018/07/27/twitters-monthly-users-fell-by-million-second-quarter-following-purge-fake-suspicious-accounts/">form the basis of corporate valuation and capital investment</a>.</p><p>Times have surely changed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d45869aa1b8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/web-no-point-0-rise-of-the-splintr-net-d45869aa1b8">Web no.point.0: rise of the Splintr.net</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tow Center Research Methods Workshop]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/tow-center-research-methods-workshop-b9cf7d4ed337?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9cf7d4ed337</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[columbia-university]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tow-center]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tow Center]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Jun 2018 19:01:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-10T15:17:23.301Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hKza7gkmjEN6PAQzaP1psg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tow Center Research Methods Workshop at Columbia Journalism School (June 2018)</figcaption></figure><p>On June 15–16, 2018, the Tow Center for Digital Journalism, in collaboration the University of Leeds, held its inaugural workshop on research methods. Programmed by Chris Anderson, this workshop convened scholars and practitioners from a diverse range of expertise for discussions on multi-method research, field work and ethnography, misinformation, computational journalism, scraping and network analysis, and issues in race, gender and power. Additionally, breakout sessions gave participants a chance to refine their research projects with the speakers, as well as Tow staff and fellows.</p><p>See below for the full agenda, with links to available presentations. The second Research Methods Workshop will be held in June 2019 at Columbia Journalism School; please reach out at towcenter@columbia.edu if you’d like to learn more.</p><p><strong>Tow Center Research Methods Workshop</strong></p><p><strong>June 15–16, 2018</strong></p><p><strong>Columbia Journalism School</strong></p><p><strong>2950 Broadway, New York, NY 10027</strong></p><p>9:30am Welcome (Emily Bell, Tow Center)</p><p>9:35am Plan of the weekend and introduction (C.W. Anderson, University of Leeds)</p><p>9:45am <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/hg2a80aunqoovht/180615%20Tow%20presentation.pdf?dl=0">Overview of Tow Center and research programs</a> (Kathy Zhang, Tow Center)</p><p>10:15am Keynote: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/fpt6ffh4dndq5h5/180615%20DK%20Designing%20Multi-method%20Research.pdf?dl=0">Designing Multi-Method Research</a> (Daniel Kreiss, University of North Carolina)</p><p><em>overview of methodological work and best practices for conducting research that draws on a variety of different methods in order to answer specific public problems</em></p><p>11:15am Method Talk One: The Fundamentals of Media and Journalism Research (Jenny Stromer-Galley, Syracuse University [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/5ehsv2saa97dsv7/180615%20JSG%20Illuminating%202016.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; Ros Donald, Columbia University [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/mgrmvbz9oz13wau/180615%20RM%20Interviewing.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; MODERATOR: Sam Ford, Rural Journalism Innovation Lab &amp; Tow Center)</p><p><em>basics of communication and media industries research: computational content analysis, interviews, and archival work</em></p><p>12:15pm-1:15pm Method Talk Two: Understanding Misinformation and Trust (Bernat Ivancsics, Columbia University [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/n1bwr8kky00wtii/ivancsics_facts_artifacts_pres_tow.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; Andrea Wenzel, Temple University &amp; Tow Center [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/g1fiscksitg9jz2/180615%20AW.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; MODERATOR: Pri Bengani, Tow Center)</p><p><em>examination of how and why misinformation spreads and the methods one can use in order to tease misinformation diffusion apart</em></p><p>2:00pm Method Talk Three: Ethnography and Journalism (Elizabeth Hansen, Harvard University [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/4mlbalqwdmubvny/180615%20TowMethodsWorkshopEHShare.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; Carlos Martinez de la Serna, Committee to Protect Journalists [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/2ojyzlakkm888qg/180615%20CMS.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; MODERATOR: C.W. Anderson, University of Leeds)</p><p><em>qualitative researchers who have studied journalism and the news as well as journalists who have used ethnographic methods discuss the similarities and differences between their two approaches</em></p><p>3:00pm Method Talk Four: Scraping and Network Analysis (Matt Weber, University of Minnesota [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/1jc1jil54jrdz40/180615%20MW%20Scaping.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; Kris Erickson, University of Leeds [<a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/bysree5v1su050t/180615%20KE%20Scrapping.pdf?dl=0">presentation</a>]; Victoria Baranetsky, Center for Investigative Reporting; MODERATOR: Jon Keegan, Tow Center)</p><p><em>analysis of how specific research projects have used website scraping and network analysis to conduct media and communication research</em></p><h3>Saturday, June 16</h3><p>9:00am Keynote: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/erxs0s8kgfsaykx/180616%20SS%20Public%20Research.pptx?dl=0">The Craft of Public Research</a> (Sarah Stonbely, Montclair State)</p><p><em>how to generate scholarship that speaks to a wide variety of communities, from activists to politicians to the general public</em></p><p>9:30am Keynote: <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/6c2tstjjnwzguug/180616%20The%20Master%27s%20Methods.pdf?dl=0">Research Design, Race, Gender and Power</a> (Racquel Gates, City University of New York)</p><p><em>how issues of power, race, and gender play out in communication and journalism studies research, and are inevitably implicated in the methods we use to answer our research topics</em></p><p>10:30am Reading the room: research interests and topics</p><p>1:00pm Breakouts</p><p><em>discussions and troubleshooting of research project among participants and presenters, grouped around overlapping methodological interests</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9cf7d4ed337" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/tow-center-research-methods-workshop-b9cf7d4ed337">Tow Center Research Methods Workshop</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Graph API: Key Points in the Facebook and Cambridge Analytica Debacle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/the-graph-api-key-points-in-the-facebook-and-cambridge-analytica-debacle-b69fe692d747?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b69fe692d747</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[api]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[facebook]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cambridge-analytica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Albright]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Mar 2018 00:07:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-21T14:14:06.366Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>That ain’t workin ‘, that’s the way you do it — data for nothin’ through the Graph API for free</h4><p>Due to the number of questions, I’ve decided to outline the key points, privacy implications, and technical features related to Facebook’s Graph API. The <strong>Graph API</strong> is the underlying issue in the <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/mar/17/facebook-cambridge-analytica-kogan-data-algorithm?CMP=twt_a-media_b-gdnmedia">Cambridge Analytica data-sharing voter “micro-targeting” debacle</a>. (This post is an expanded version of the Twitter thread linked below)</p><h3>J0nathan A1bright on Twitter</h3><p>Getting lots of questions, so I&#39;m posting a thread with an outline of key points to focus on in stories re: privacy implications and questions of Facebook&#39;s Graph API. The Graph API is the underlying issue in Cambridge Analytica &amp;amp; FB data-sharing &amp;amp; voter micro-targeting debacle.</p><p>The problematic collection of Facebook users’ <strong>personal</strong> <strong>info</strong> — and the ability to obtain unusually rich info about <strong>users</strong>’ <strong>friends</strong> — is due to the design and functionality of <a href="https://developers.facebook.com/docs/graph-api/changelog/archive">Facebook’s Graph API</a>. Importantly, the vast majority of problems that have arisen as a result of this integration were meant to be “<strong>features</strong>, <strong>not bugs</strong>,” as many have rightly pointed out.</p><h4>People = Objects</h4><p>Facebook’s Graph API is a developer, or app-level, interface that followed an earlier “REST” version of Facebook’s API. The introduction of the Graph API was heralded by Facebook as a revolutionary way to understand and access people’s social lives. Or, “We are Building A Web Where the Default Is [Sharing].”</p><p><a href="https://techcrunch.com/2010/04/21/zuckerbergs-buildin-web-default-social/">Zuckerberg: &quot;We Are Building A Web Where The Default Is Social&quot;</a></p><p>Marketers, businesses, researchers, and law enforcement were provided with <strong>industrial-level personal information access</strong> and advanced search functionality into Facebook users’ activities, connections, and emotional states far beyond what they simply “posted” and talked about on the platform and apps. As of 2017, Instagram has a similar Graph API functionality:</p><p><a href="https://business.instagram.com/blog/new-instagram-api-features">Introducing New Features to the Instagram Graph API</a></p><p>Facebook’s Graph API was a <em>revolution</em> in large-scale data provision. It converted people and their likes, connections, locations, updates, networks, histories, and extended social networks into — quite literally — “<strong>objects</strong>.” It made the company’s offerings and the data its users generated<em> more economically viable.</em></p><p>There are even “front end” Graph API interfaces still around, such as <strong>StalkScan</strong>, which is meant to show users the dangers of background (meta)data availability and teach about possible misuse:</p><p><a href="https://stalkscan.com/">Facebook Scanner - All &#39;public&#39; info Facebook doesn&#39;t show you</a></p><h4><strong>v1.0</strong></h4><p>Version 1.0 of the Graph API launched on <strong>April 21, 2010. </strong>It<strong> </strong>was deprecated in <strong>April 2014 </strong>and closed completely to legacy apps (ie, existing apps that used the API before April 2014) on <strong>April 30, 2015</strong>.</p><p>That’s <strong>five</strong> full years — a lot of time for apps and quizzes to extract vast quantities of users’ personal data and the information from across their entire social networks. It was the beginning of “<a href="https://medium.com/@d1gi/all-your-are-belong-to-us-f93fce123907">All Your Face Are Belong To Us.</a>”</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@d1gi/all-your-are-belong-to-us-f93fce123907">All Your 😳 Are Belong To Us.</a></p><p>Facebook saw problems with the amount of personal information available in the first implementation of their Graph API. But they didn’t want to cut off marketing channel and business partners from the huge <strong>revenue stream</strong>. So, on April 30, 2014, the company announced at f8 that v1.0 would be wound down in favor of a<a href="https://stackoverflow.com/questions/23417356/facebook-graph-api-v2-0-me-friends-returns-empty-or-only-friends-who-also-u"> much more restrictive v2.0 API</a>.</p><p><a href="https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2014/04/f8-2014-stability-for-developers-and-more-control-for-people-in-apps/">f8 2014: Stability for Developers &amp;amp; More Control for People</a></p><p>Zuckerberg and Facebook’s<strong> April 2014</strong> news release refer to the company’s change of heart about their industrial PII access feature that exposed users’ sensitive personal info and that of their extended friend and family network as a move towards “<strong>putting people first.”</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Dezv2Ck3efzPam5z.jpg" /><figcaption><a href="https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2014/04/f8-2014-stability-for-developers-and-more-control-for-people-in-apps/">https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2014/04/f8-2014-stability-for-developers-and-more-control-for-people-in-apps/</a></figcaption></figure><p>The exact same day in April, in bullet points underneath, the company announced their <strong>biggest tracking and ad targeting initiative to date</strong>: the <a href="https://www.facebook.com/business/news/audience-network"><strong>Facebook Audience Network</strong></a>. In simple terms, this extended the company’s data profiling and ad-targeting juggernaut from its own apps and services to <strong>the rest of the internet</strong>.</p><p><a href="https://www.facebook.com/business/news/audience-network">Facebook for Business</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ctfezpYNige8saHp.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Facebook for Business: </strong>Say hello to Facebook’s Audience Network — a new way for advertisers to extend their campaigns beyond Facebook and into other mobile apps.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Main v1.0 Problem: Extended Permissions</strong></h4><p>What made the Facebook Graph API’s v1.0 highly problematic was its <strong>extended permissions</strong>. Apps could request a huge range of users’ friends info without much friction or communicating the reason(s) for providing consent.</p><p>Once authorized with a single prompt, v1.0 app could potentially remain in the background collecting and processing people’s data — and that of their entire friend network — for years. Additionally, v1.0 apps could also request users’ <strong>private</strong> <strong>messages</strong> (ie, their Facebook DM inbox) via the “<strong>read_mailbox</strong>” API<strong> </strong>request.</p><p><a href="https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/456.pdf"><strong>Users’ FRIENDS info available</strong></a><strong>:</strong> <em>About me, actions, activities, b-day, check-ins, education, events, games, groups, hometown, interests, likes, location, notes, online status, tags, photos, questions, relationships, religion/politics, status, subscriptions, website, work history</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/674/0*daCS1Ll6Qc5td78A.jpg" /><figcaption>Symeonidis, Tsormpatzoudi &amp; Preneel (2017): <a href="https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/456.pdf">https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/456.pdf</a></figcaption></figure><p>Also, developers could operate <em>multiple</em> v1.0 apps. Since the v1.0 API returned users’ <strong><em>real</em> Facebook user_IDs</strong>, app developers and their partners could instantly <strong>recombine</strong> mass quantities of personal identifying info collected across <em>dozens</em> <em>of different Facebook apps and quizzes</em>.</p><p><a href="https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/456.pdf">Symeonidis, Tsormpatzoudi and Preneel’s excellent paper</a> (2017, see table above) argues that while the company’s v1.0 API allowed third party apps to obtain consent for <strong>originating</strong> users’ personal information, no consent was obtained for the rest of the “data subjects” — meaning people’s friends on Facebook, which were often the main reason this data was being collected and processed in the first place.</p><p>This means that the debate stemming from use of the term “<strong>breach</strong>,” while not accurate from a systems-level computer security standpoint, is arguably <strong><em>legally correct </em></strong>in regards to the lack of informed consent by the “data subjects.” Meaning before the mass collection, processing, and re-sharing of users <em>friends</em>’ personal information. (see users’ FRIENDS info table above)</p><h4>My Recommendation</h4><p>The UK MP Damian Collins, the UK’s ICO office, the United States Senate and Congressional committees, and other important regulatory actors such as the Federal Trade Commission should require Facebook to <em>immediately</em> share with the public the “quizzes” used by Cambridge Analytica — with <strong>all</strong> the questions, any versions if relevant, and the <strong>entire</strong> list of v1.0 Graph API “<strong>friend</strong> <strong>permissions” </strong>used to effectively steal personal information from up to 50 million people.</p><p>There’s no reason to withhold as there are no privacy implications. We should also know if <strong>users’ private Facebook messages</strong> were collected at any point.</p><p>While clearly more problematic than useful overall, Facebook’s Graph API v1.0 tools were <strong>amazing for teaching</strong>. I used several apps — including Bernie Hogan’s (<a href="https://twitter.com/blurky">@blurky</a>) app at the Oxford Internet Institute in my own classes between 2013 and 2015. My students in journalism, communication, public relations, and media analytics could extract their own Facebook networks to understand nature and quality of links, friend clustering, communities, and learn about anthropology concepts <a href="https://www.npr.org/2011/06/04/136723316/dont-believe-facebook-you-only-have-150-friends">such as the <strong>Dunbar</strong> <strong>number</strong> firsthand</a>.</p><h4><strong>Publicity Settings versus Privacy Settings</strong></h4><p>Facebook’s interface has been built around the false pretense of giving users <strong>control</strong> <strong>over what is shared</strong>. But the focus is on “posting,” or <strong>outward sharing</strong>; what we <em>actively</em> CHOOSE to share. In reality, Facebook users have the exact opposite ability to control what is <em>passively</em> shared ABOUT THEM — meaning the information and metadata others can <em>extract</em>.</p><p>In this sense, Facebook’s “privacy settings” are a grand illusion. Control over <em>post-sharing</em>— people we share TO — should really be called “<strong>Publicity Settings.</strong>” Likewise, control over <em>passive sharing</em>— the information people can take info FROM us — should be called “<strong>Privacy Settings.</strong>”</p><p><strong>Politics has become the most important kind of tech reporting.</strong></p><p>Recent political news, especially stories about social platforms, foreign manipulation, and misuse of data and public data tools <strong>demand a technical baseline</strong>. While journalists don’t need deep expertise, they should understand the <em>essential</em> mechanisms — such as the Graph API’s problematic history and its direct relevance to the Cambridge Analytica story.</p><p>Reporters should be able to convey in broad terms how users’ personal data was obtained with the Graph API v1.0, and explain to readers <strong>why</strong> their data was open to mass collection purposes. This will help provoke questions and scenarios about how it was used and where it might have ended up. This technological literacy is a <strong>prerequisite to informed reporting</strong> on what Cambridge Analytica, Facebook and other political propaganda and media manipulation events mean for society, elections, and the future of technology and democracy.</p><p>This is a <strong>complex</strong> topic. Even for experts it’s easy to get things wrong. But for journalists, this leads to getting called out by defensive execs, PR teams, politicians, and otherwise important stories getting branded as “fake news.” It’s easy to <strong>overstate</strong> certain pieces of the puzzle. Or lose sight of the bigger picture in side arguments about whether Cambridge Analytica’s tools and methods were effective or not.</p><p>None of these are productive at this stage. I suggest <a href="https://medium.com/@d1gi/election2016-propaganda-lytics-weaponized-shadow-trackers-a6c9281f5ef9">we have much bigger issues to confront</a>, like revisiting current business models and rethinking data privacy rules. I hope this outline of key issues (and the questions that might arise as a result of more accurate and technically informed reporting on this topic) is helpful!</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@d1gi/election2016-fakenews-compilation-455870d04bb">📌#Election2016 #F*keNews Compilation</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b69fe692d747" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/the-graph-api-key-points-in-the-facebook-and-cambridge-analytica-debacle-b69fe692d747">The Graph API: Key Points in the Facebook and Cambridge Analytica Debacle</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reality Jamming: The Future of Information Online]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/tow-center/reality-jamming-the-future-of-information-online-3ad5cb0d932e?source=rss----832b0fa760ff---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ad5cb0d932e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[platform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tow Center]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Dec 2017 22:23:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-11T22:23:54.127Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aG-886ym4sx59S9d1YpjdQ.png" /></figure><p>As open communication platforms online become trusted sources of reality, we anticipate a future dominated not only by targeted digital battles for attention, but for beliefs—unconstrained by consensus or veracity. In a panel hosted on September 29 at the New School, co-organizers Susan McGregor of the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism and Chris Wiggins from Columbia’s School of Engineering and Data Science Institute were joined by four others to discuss the future of information online: Joan Donovan, Data &amp; Society; Matt Jones, Columbia’s Department of History; Jonathan Albright, Columbia Graduate School of Journalism; and Sam Thielman, a journalist at Talking Points Memo.</p><p>The panel attempted to look ahead; rather than sharing illustrative prior case studies of propaganda, coordinated trolling, or fake news, we tried to focus on dynamics and impact such as:</p><ul><li>the new scale or capability afforded by technology; why is this the same as or different from the prior century’s marketing and propaganda?</li><li>the role of solutions: what if anything can be done to defend, innoculate against, or otherwise counter “reality jamming”?</li><li>what communities or groups are disparately impacted?</li></ul><p>To best frame the discussion, consider a definition: “Culture jamming” is defined as playful attempts, often in satire, to combine media, or to communicate digitally, in ways that amuse, delight, shock, or inform. Reality jamming, meanwhile, differs both in scale (which is easier to attain now that communications are largely software-based, e.g., social media marketing tools) and intent. Rather than attempting hoax or satire, actors are using a trusted channel to try to convince targets into believing something false, fabricated, misattributed, or otherwise unreal. That is, the goal is to saturate, disinform, or jam what would otherwise be reliable sources of truth that people encounter digitally.</p><p>Below is a transcript of the Sept. 29 event, edited for clarity.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>This event started from an email from Justin in August, which was, “Hey, community, we should organize some workshops on interesting topics.” At the time I was interested in fake news and how it might expand; what I was calling reality jamming, meaning overwhelming the set of things that we use to define our reality. Not just in the format of news, but, as you get more and more reality from the palm of your hand, then the palm of your hand is now the attack surface, open to anybody who has user-generated content or any other signals that define your reality. That is going to be a scary way for all of us to define our views of reality.</p><p>One way to slice to the problem is in terms of past, present, and future. The present is changing by the hour. I’m sure by the time my phone goes off airplane mode, I will have three tweets, possibly from Justin, about how the state of fake news and computational propaganda has changed in the last fifty minutes. So instead, I want to focus on past and future.</p><p>The future: What is to be done? In the short term, and in the long term, is there any hope whatsoever? Is there one solution? Is there a spectrum of solutions we should be arguing for?</p><p>And the past: To what extent is this new or is this not new? Is this like dropping leaflets on Japan as we discussed on the phone call from yesterday? Or is this really qualitatively different? Is there a way we can say: “more is different” here?</p><p>Matt and Jonathan, could I ask y’all to kick it off with the past?</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>There’s been data-driven campaigning for years, but the targeting that is happening now is quite a bit different. If we think of the older kind of micro targeting as <em>push</em> — you could customize messages going out — the newer kind of system of targeting is something more akin to a <em>pull</em>, a pull system. It pulls you in. It’s emotional.</p><p>The difference is the real-time aspect. I read a statistic that between the 2012 and 2016 election, smartphone use, or the smartphone ownership in the U.S., has increased seventy percent. Those statistics are huge. And just the sheer amount of data that platforms, especially Facebook, have been collecting over time makes it a different kind of targeting than the kind of targeting you could use in 2012.</p><p>So there are similar methods, but the scale is completely different. And the ability to use tools, I would call them list matching tools. So, you know, you can essentially upload a voter roll, with email addresses or zip codes and it’s processed through <a href="https://mobile.nytimes.com/2012/06/17/technology/acxiom-the-quiet-giant-of-consumer-database-marketing.html">Acxiom</a>. And you can use that to find those real people. So, I mean, that can be done at scale. You can upload an Excel file, and find if a person has that email address as their Facebook account. That will instantly identify them as a real person. The power of that is not to be understated. It sounds simple, but after that all you’re doing is working to refine your data sets. So there’s a huge difference in scaling, there’s a huge difference in sharing. So we have no idea what data is being shared in the background.</p><p>There’s all sorts of ad tech firms and second-party data now. Second-party data is when your phone provider is actually selling your data and you don’t know. There’s no third party involved, it’s actually like AT&amp;T, or Verizon, or your ISP turning over and selling your, say, location data even if you have location services turned off on your phone.</p><p>The quantity of data we have now is different, as are the kinds of tools we have to target at scale, to find real identities through digital traces.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>Wonderful. We already have a unit — “baud” — for bits per second of information, and we need to recognize that if you’re going to have information per second, you’ll also have lots of disinformation per second.</p><p>Jonathan, Susan has put up <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/who-hacked-the-election-43d4019f705f">one of your posts</a>. Anything you want to say to talk us through some of your research on this topic?</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>I go to a lot of panels and events, and people argue about framing and about the content aspect, or the delivery of the messaging aspect, the strategic communication element. And people will spend hours arguing about the types of framing used, the terms being used to influence. But I would argue that a lot of these fake news sites, quote unquote, are as much about collecting data as they are about trying to persuade.</p><p>We already know that disinformation or misinformation is, you know, it’s not necessarily always to persuade, right? It’s mostly to inject noise. It’s much easier to inject noise into something to kind of confuse and distract, than it is to persuade someone. It takes a lot more effort.</p><p>But I think that a lot of these sites, and you can look and see by the content, with the kinds of tracking especially. ABCnews.com.co, which was one of the go-to examples of fake news sites, has about 160 pieces of ad tech on it—that one site. I mean, there’s just these kind of bare bones minimalist WordPress sites rolled out at scale, and I would say that their content is a bait and it’s a bait used to kind of A/B test people. And it’s … I think that the arguments about content are great, but I think that there needs to be a move back towards… Content is often … These types of hoaxes, and viral hoaxes and things, are actually just a means to an end as bait for data collection. Using [Facebook] custom audiences, you can refer back to that website and see how much of a video someone watches, if they watch five percent or ten percent, if they’re in a certain zip code. The kinds of refining you can do after someone gets angry and shares an anti-jihad video, is quite insightful; you can kind of track that person or track those individuals from that point onward and just watch where they go.</p><p>Just from that point they leave a trail, like a magic Harry Potter map.</p><p><strong>Matt:</strong></p><p>I’m a history professor, and I wanted to talk about a moment in which there were large amounts of text circulating from strange sources that were not verifiable. They were reprinted over and over again, and some of them may have been pushed by state actors to upset the policy of the United States. This concern was echoed by John Adams, who you all know because of <em>Hamilton</em>, <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=-rfPAAAAMAAJ&amp;lpg=PA504">who wrote</a>, “The gazettes of Europe,” gazettes being newspapers, “still continue to be employed as the great engines of fraud and impostor to the good people of America.” Engine is a technical term meaning a machine that produces energy at the time. “Stock jobbers are not the only people, so there’s financial gain who employ a set of scribblers to invent and publish falsehood for their own peculiar purposes. I verily believe,” he continued, “there are persons in every state employed to select out these things and get them reprinted.”</p><p>He’s referring to the circulation of paragraphs that are unverifiable, full of news that could have caused potential political and religious implications at a moment of strife. Why this is interesting—because he’s writing at a moment of the creation of new media and total lack of resolution of how that fits within democratic organization. How is it that the verification of sources is going to happen when you have at once a celebration of new media in a democracy and the questioning of all standard sources of credibility, combined with a lack of technical means of verification?</p><p>Fake news is old news. Now, I don’t want to discount anything that Jonathan just said. Why might this be interesting? Because many of the same questions about radical democratizing new media, and the way that it can be leveraged by state actors, by financial actors, and others, to lead one into a position of uncertainty is indeed something that we are living in very much today.</p><p>Fact production and verification, something that in some sense we had some certainty around in the United States in the middle of the twentieth century, are incredibly rare and fragile. They’re precarious. The default position, I want to say, is to be in the situation of fake news. The question then has to be, what are the kinds of solutions that one needs to have, technical as well as social? I think it’s important to know that the solution in the nineteenth century, which I’m not going to go into, was not the blockchain of the nineteenth century. The creation of the new forms of newspapers that comported with a democratic polity by the twentieth century involved both the constitution of new social organizations of credibility, something like <em>The New York Times</em> or the solidity of academic institutions, which came to fit into democratic organizations, but also new technologies of the potential of verification. Whether it’s the byline in the newspaper or other forms of verification.</p><p>That is, it was about a moment of technologies and institutions of credibility that comport with the radical democratic order. Because what we’re living through is the way in which the possibilities of the massively decentralized web have been exploited by people who want to take advantage of it. The celebration that you would find in, say, <a href="https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence">John Perry Barlow on cyberspace</a> in the late nineties was something that state actors recognized, feared, and have used as the grounds for an overinflation of sovereignty. The fearfulness about sovereignty being destroyed by cyberspace meant room for its exploitation. And that’s very much what Adams was getting at when he said that persons in every state are employed.</p><p>The U.S. Government used to define this in the DOD definition as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perception_management">perception management</a>. And I won’t read this whole thing, but this is U.S. Government doctrine from 2001 about doing this. “Actions to convey or deny selected information to influence their emotions, motive, and objective reasons.” The U.S. is famously bad at this Russian doctrine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s6GY7-FkUcF1CYpg1bFYMA.png" /></figure><p>It’s now been obliterated by new euphemisms. But clearly what’s novel here is that there’s a particular toxicity that has happened when that kind of state operation is combined with massively decentralized democratic organs and the new analytic technologies that Jonathan was talking about.</p><p>Now, Chris wanted us very much to talk about what we can do, so I want to go back to an even greater moment of epistemic uncertainty. At the end of the nineteenth century, there was massive uncertainty about who owned anything, whether it was the church, or the state, or individuals. There’d been a discovery of a vast number of forgeries of medieval documents, forgeries from the fourth century onward, and everything was called into question.</p><p>Now, out of this came an incredibly sleepy and dull discipline called “diplomatics,” which is the study of, essentially, the metadata of documents: what paper they’re made of, the kind of ink, the spelling of the words. It was a highly technical discipline and it’s the heart of the development of what we think of as forensics. And it turns out, if you study the history of this, the people you most want to talk to if you want to learn how to authenticate or de-authenticate a document are the forgers themselves.</p><p>Tony Grafton, a professor at Princeton, <a href="https://books.google.com/books/about/Forgers_and_Critics.html?id=9R6PQAAACAAJ">has written wonderfully</a> on this. But the entire set of technologies, both social technologies and technologies themselves, of the working against forgeries were something that were developed in alliance with the forgers. I think there’s a lot to that. So for every story about how AI is going to make it impossible for us not to, say, see that this video is fake, that’s an opportunity to leverage that, to counterexploit the exploit.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>There’s so much to work with there! Two great takeaways from what you said include the fact that the rate of production and verification of facts has increased. What’s interesting there is that I think the rate of production of facts has increased, but the rate of verification of facts has not. So we get to a point where it’s just so easy to just make crap facts, but it’s really slow for people to verify. We were talking about this earlier this morning, how much work it takes to actually track down where that Photoshopped source is from. If you’re a technosolutionist like me, that’s one thing where I’m like, “OK, I can write code to [whatever].”</p><p>And the second takeaway is this idea that we need white hat fake news people. Nobody better to combat fake news than fake newsers, so how do we create and incent people to create a federation of white hat fake newsers?</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>I wanted to <em>amen</em> Jonathan’s point, that there’s this gigantic scale that is, with greatest respect, historically unprecedented. I wanted to ask you how malicious actors use that scale.</p><p><strong>Joan</strong>:</p><p>Maybe I’ll just come out with a really contentious point: everything written and published online is fake news. Right? Because what you get is citizen-run media, and even though you have these large news organizations that are publishing things online, once they’re filtered through digital intermediaries like Google News, like Facebook, like Twitter, what you end up seeing is these cards where all content looks the same.</p><p>So the link that gets shared from <em>The</em> <em>Guardian</em> looks like the link that gets shared from <em>The New York Times</em>, looks like the link that gets shared from altright.com, looks like the link that gets shared from the Daily Stormer, looks like the link that gets shared from the WordPress blog. And as a result, you end up in a situation where people don’t really even reference the media institutions anymore. They say things like, “I read it on Facebook.” “I read it on Twitter.” And when you hear someone say that, you don’t instantly think, but where did you read it though? Right? And in that too, even these WordPress blogs, then you’re in this moment also of citizen journalism, where we are getting up alongside these articles and these hot takes and some of these more measured cold takes, which I appreciate. You know, maybe they’re a few days late to the party, but the cold take is something that I read.</p><p>In our research about the political opportunities posed by the change in infrastructure to news, we think about groups of people that are actually very good social engineers. They know how to make content look good. And then, what ends up happening is two forms of legitimation are built into the card itself, or the content card. One is repetition, you can see how many people share it. You can see how many people like it. And then, when these things hit into the hundreds, specifically like on YouTube videos when you see 80,000 people have watched something, it looks like it’s probably a big deal. And so maybe the YouTube video is of an event last week, like in Berkeley where the Milo Yiannopoulos fiasco played out. Where there are about maybe 300 people protesting overall, but 80, 90,000 people were watching online supposedly. But we know that people game these metrics. But they game these metrics to make other people believe that it’s more important than it is.</p><p>And then when we have this massive repetition where you start seeing the same links across platforms. So maybe you see it on Facebook, then you see it on Twitter, and you start to have a sense of it being a story and match with the metrics. You see lots of other people are sharing it, retweeting it. You then become part of the process of amplification at scale because then you think this is a big deal.</p><p>So, for instance, yesterday … Was it even yesterday? It’s like I know we’re not supposed to talk about the present but I got a hair across my ass about <a href="http://money.cnn.com/2017/09/27/media/facebook-black-lives-matter-targeting/index.html">the Black Lives Matter Russia thing right now</a>, and I’m very, very angry about the fact that you can purchase an ad and place it in people’s timelines in such a way to sow dissent and rage. And nobody can verify that that thing is officially from that organization. I can’t make an ad that defames Pepsi and put it on cable, right? There are gatekeepers for that. But when we have few gatekeepers and we’ve meshed all of the different ways in which we consume reality, right? You know, from the things our grandma says to us, to our first-person accounts, to our advertising, to our blogs. We end up being in on the … I don’t want to call it a game because the Black Lives Matter Facebook scandal, I think, had real-life consequences. I mean, people were … People are still serving court time for thing … jail time for things that happened in Ferguson and things that happened in Baltimore.</p><p>And so the Russian paying of ads that sow dissent, you know, makes it more and more difficult for people in those areas, community organizers, to argue for rethinking the narrative of what happened, and also getting their friends out of jail. Right?</p><p>And so that’s all to say that there’s things that are happening that are political opportunities that are part of the infrastructure itself, and that if we don’t hold these platform companies accountable for that, then it will imperil democracy. Of course, we know this. But it’s also coming for the economy, right? And this is another thing that we don’t really think about. When we don’t think about separating, parsing, legitimating, verifying, and also distributing information, we become beholden to systems that we have no control over.</p><p><strong>Sam</strong>:</p><p>I’ve been a reporter for, I guess, twelve years and that twelve years has seen the collapse of the news infrastructure, basically. I’ve seen everybody who’s my senior at these publications laid off. That’s all the institutional knowledge.</p><p>And Joan, I don’t want to spoil your research, but Joan was telling me there are things that the older reporters know that are conventions that younger reporters don’t know, even if they’re very smart, know how to do what they’re doing, and went to the best journalism schools. So that’s a real loss. Seeing these places atomize so that all the work is being done by freelancers who are writing for twenty-five dollars an article, and thus trying to pound out five, ten articles a day, creates a systemic effect where nobody’s verifying anything except through other news organizations. In the best case, that’s going to trickle up to four or five newspapers that have the resources to actually go out and do original reporting. In the worst case, which is much more likely, it’s going to trickle down to jerks and assholes who are creating their own news and pretending it comes from places that are reputable. Excuse me.</p><p>So I think the problem here, is that we have these gigantic things that operate at this incredible scale. Facebook has one employee for every 77,000 users. Twitter, I’m not sure what the ratio is, but I’m sure it’s not better and it may be worse. And that’s daily active users, that’s not accounts. That’s people who are on Facebook every day.</p><p>These platforms are created explicitly to avoid human intervention, and that’s an important thing to understand because they’re not domain registrars. They’re not just allowing people to speak whenever they want about whatever they want. They’re already carefully controlling what it is you can and can’t say, and putting things into your newsfeed based on the way you respond to them. There’s a suggestion that regulating Facebook would stifle free speech, which I think is a worthy thing to be concerned about, but also does not quite understand the purpose of Facebook, which is to part you from your money. That’s the only reason Facebook exists. The problem comes when you have people interacting with Facebook in a sophisticated way who don’t want money, who want something different from money. Who want to amplify perspectives, like Nazism, that have been kept out of responsible news organizations because those news organizations understand that amplification increases the viability of that movement. There are people who want to mess with political campaigns, as we’ve seen from Russia.</p><p>So there is a way to interact with a billion people, even if that interaction is necessarily delimited by the platform, that will get you not money but power. And Facebook has not accounted for that, and Twitter has not accounted for that. And the news media is collapsing at a rate that is proportional to the rise of Facebook and Twitter in a way that is preventing it from countering it effectively. Not to spread despair.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>Now, we’re nearly at the midpoint, so I wanted to switch from the past to the future. I want to talk about people’s ideas for solutions, long term and short term.</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>You know, I get this question a lot. So when some reporters call me, they’re like, “What can we do?” And I think that I’d hate to do it, but, I mean, we need to define the problem. We need to understand the scale and scope of the problem. There’s going to be a lot of money thrown around. People are looking to throw money at these foundations, even the State Department, the government. But we really have to understand what’s going on before we can move forward with initiatives to try to stop this. Otherwise, I think there’s going to be a lot of effort wasted.</p><p>We need to continue to wait and analyze and see what is going on and what’s happening right now. Just the past few days have given us more information than probably we’ve had in almost a year. And this is a legal process. This is based on subpoenas, or likely subpoenas. More information is going to come to light. Every day, or every week maybe, there’ll be revelations and maybe, possibly, other people will get pulled into this. I mean, you know, it’s not unlikely that Google will get embroiled in this somehow.</p><p>In my own research, I found that YouTube was one of the centers of all this. It’s an emotional training ground, so you can kind of recruit people through Facebook into a YouTube video. It’s like a propaganda education system. I don’t see it unlikely that Google will get embroiled in this, especially as they own Double Click and other organizations.</p><p>But I think that defining the problem is very, very important to move towards solutions, and safeguarding the open web, and safeguarding privacy. If we can reframe this as a personal information and data issue, we get past the tropes of, “Oh, how do we regulate Facebook? Can Facebook self-regulate?” I think that the fact that personal information and personal data in the United States is kind of more or less managed by the Federal Trade Commission, which suggests right there that people’s information is treated like commerce, it’s treated like a product.</p><p>Even if we ask companies for our data and they give us a table of our categories, the information they use to target us we’ll never know. We’ll never know who and how we’re being targeted. Regardless, if we get our kind of demographics list from whatever company, the methods and how we’re being influenced are not known because they’re proprietary.</p><p>So I think that, yeah, maybe a privacy commission. I don’t know. Maybe an arm of the FTC that deals specifically with election data. Maybe a Department of Homeland Security online because we’re strengthening our physical borders, right? It’s not really the physical borders that we need to worry about. So maybe there needs to be a department of … I don’t know what it would be. The Department of Online Homeland Security, DOHS.</p><p><strong>Joan:</strong></p><p>I’m gonna go ahead and just say “no, thanks” to the government regulation being involved in that aspect.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>Exactly. I have to wonder: Jonathan’s solutions all involve government. Depending on what city you’re in, you can imagine people being like, “OK, well we’re going to disrupt fake news” or something like that. There’s probably a broad spectrum of possible solutions.</p><p><strong>Joan:</strong></p><p>I … yeah. We’re in this situation because of the government. For years under Obama we had Occupy, Black Lives Matter, Justice for Trayvon Martin, just to name a few movements that were antagonistic to the government. But not all movements can be distrustful of the government and fight for social change in this way. The dreamers did register en masse in these government forms because they needed a legal path to citizenship and you cannot win that without cooperating with the government. Right after the election, the paranoia around “how do I make my phone more secure?” “How do I stop leaking data constantly?” Like, why is this thing [the smartphone] a faucet? Right? This was the fear that the government was going to use my information and my participation to track me.</p><p>Maybe handing over power to the government puts us in this position too, where we’re giving them information. Right? Amelia Acker and I were talking about this. Why don’t we think about creating standards for our telephones, and our computers, so that they aren’t so leaky? Right? So that we know what’s coming in and what’s going out, and that there are more controls over that.</p><p>The other thing that I’ve done for years is that I don’t register things in my own name—when I sign up for things on my telephone, and my computer and things—but I know that the ISP is the big problem. There’s only so much obfuscation you can do with digital tools; eventually you need to connect into the tubes and wires. And it’s at that place that they capture your identity and then link things up. You can have fifty different email accounts, but it’s not really going to make a huge difference.</p><p>How do you instill better standards? Can you bring Silicon Valley to the table and say, no more? At the same time, <a href="https://slate.com/technology/2017/08/the-alt-right-wants-to-build-its-own-internet.html">we’re watching a burgeoning alt-tech movement </a>that has outpaced the left right after Charlottesville during this moment of corporate denial of service, emerged an entire disaffected tech class that is now aligned with white supremacists, now aligned with men’s right activists, now aligned with trolls that have been part of the fake news problem that are trying to build an alternative internet based on the values of, quote unquote, free speech. And they are going to argue very strongly and persuasively for legislating silicon value …</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>That’s a high-quality Freudian slip.</p><p><strong>Joan:</strong></p><p>I know, right?<strong> </strong>Silicon Valley. But we’re going to see some of the leftists dragged along this path of what we need online is free speech instead of polices against hate speech and hate symbols<strong>.</strong> The legislation that the far right wants is basically to make everything work like the telephone, and they want to ignore the new possibilities of amplification because that’s their infrastructural opportunity, the political opportunity of amplification.</p><p>In the coming year we’re going to see a big push for net neutrality from all sides. People are going to be really like, yeah, it seems like a good idea. Twitter’s a lot like the phone, you know? Everybody should have a right. We have to then think about what it means: the right to an audience? And what kind of world do we get when everyone is acting, or playing, or ambivalent, or acting like a reality star?</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>Right. You can’t treat these platforms like they’re neutral. You often hear people who slept through everything except day one of microeconomics say that there’s a free market. Of course, there is no free market. There are many markets, and they’re all established by the first person who goes into the market. That person says, “I have something to sell, here it is. Also, I’m establishing rules for this market and all of my competitors have to abide by those rules.” That’s the way most markets work in this country.</p><p>Twitter has pre-established zones of speech. Facebook is a different proposition, actually. But they both create these questions about what kind of speech you privilege and whether or not these things are platforms or publishers. I contend that you’re a publisher if you’re policing speech in any way.</p><p>I do think it’s important, though, to have some kind of regulation. I am very sympathetic to Jonathan’s point, having spent two years covering ad technology with the notion that there’s too much data out there. There was, at one point, an interesting article in <em>The</em> <em>Times </em>about what the moral obligation was at these companies when they figured out they could fairly accurately predict whether or not somebody was about to commit suicide. They’ve definitely figured out how to tell you whether or not you’re pregnant, and occasionally inform people’s parents before …</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>Yeah.<strong> </strong>The <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habits.html">Duhigg Target story</a>.</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>Yeah, exactly, which I don’t think I have time to tell.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>OK, but solutions, Sam, solutions.</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>Yeah. Solutions, I think, are purgative. I think you have to go through and purge all of this data every few years. And it doesn’t have to be everything, but at some point, there’s no reason the OPM hack contained people’s biometrics from 1980. That’s nonsense. You don’t need people’s biometrics from 1980. You need to dump all that stuff after a certain period of time. But it is monetizable into infinity, and those companies are never going to do anything that interferes with their profit motive. They have to be forced by society.</p><p>That was one of the most disturbing things Zuckerberg said the other day, that he didn’t want to police, he didn’t want to have people check whether or not it was OK to say something, and he didn’t think society should want him to. Those are very disturbing words.</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>I’m going to go old-school and take it back to the open web idea. As things move further and deeper into apps, the less we’re going to know. The kind of data we can extract from apps is extremely complicated. We have to catch traffic packets. The open web is being systematically targeted. Over the years Facebook and Twitter have systematically deprioritized the URL, especially with things like embeds.</p><p>Platforms have also kind of co-opted the URL in terms of converting it to a short link. The URL is not a platform’s friend, because it takes you outside of that platform. In most cases, a URL will take you outside of the property. We also lose signals when we have embeds. This goes back to what Joan was saying. Even in iMessage now, there are embeds. When we see a domain, there is some trust involved. We can see there’s signaling involved that we can make some kind of decision about whether this source is reputable, whether it’s dangerous.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>Those are all good problems. Solutions?</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>Showing your source, like the links. It’s very simple. A second solution would be removing or adding non-emotional sharing mechanisms. Everything on Facebook is based on a loaded emotion, and they’ve now, I’m not sure exactly how much, but now a like is less than the reaction emojis in terms of the weighting algorithm. So the reaction emojis actually have more impact in the news feed than a regular like.</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>Wow<strong>.</strong></p><p><strong>Joan</strong>:</p><p>I remember when bit.ly came on the scene and it was really confusing. The history of the web is really tied to a bunch of librarians wanting us to have formatting information and knowledge so that you can share things consistently. Right? And so the hyperlink was an address, right? And somewhere along the way, they started to acquire becoming verification, and then they became brands and signals towards corporations and things. We used to believe the URL would help us organize knowledge, help us with our universities, help us archive knowledge over time.</p><p>Some of us still feel that way about the URL. But at the same time, I just watch, and watch, and watch domain squatting, fishing attempts. There’s got to be another system of verification layered into the URL. Recently reporters were talking about wanting to have blue check marks on Google to say this is a verified company, corporation, a verified news source, whatever. It seems like that blue check mark thing, as weird as it is, does help us think about things as gatekeepers, as sources of verification and legitimation.</p><p><strong>Sam</strong>:</p><p>Another solution: it’s something all you can go out and do, which is lose trust in Facebook and Twitter. If the public loses trust in Facebook and Twitter, and you all go home and delete your accounts and throw your phones into the sea, the world will be a much better place.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>There’s a big space of what it might mean to “solve fake news.” Jonathan is pointing out first of all that we should define the problem. That’s hard. So let me do something cowardly and not try to do that. Instead, let’s focus on parsing possible ways that you can think about solutions. One way to parse the solution is: Who’s going to do the solving? Sam is bringing out that one set of people that could do the solving is us, the consumers. Jonathan started out by thinking about the government should be doing the solving. Nobody here brought up disrupting the market. Maybe if we were in a different peninsula somewhere elsewhere in America some of you would say we should disrupt and disintermediate the platform companies.</p><p>In general, this gets back to a conversation Matt and I have been having for years about the three-party game that shapes the innovation economy. In <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/business/books/2013/02/william_janeway_s_doing_capitalism_in_the_innovation_economy_reviewed.html">Janeway’s book on doing capitalism in the innovation economy</a> there’s a three-party game among the government that regulates things and, to some extent, sets the guardrails for the market. First, the private companies that shape what the products are. And then the individuals. The individuals play three roles out there. The individuals are the consumers, right? They’re giving money to these companies. They are the users, which, if the users flee then there is no product there for these particular sets of products. And they’re also the engineers, that is, they are the people that actually populate these companies.</p><p>One set of solutions that we haven’t really talked about is the fact that these companies have employees. You can imagine situations in history in which scientists or technologists have created a technology and afterwards realized that there were negative consequences, and taken a role of moral leadership in public to shape the way those technologies are used. I have not seen an abundance of that, personally, in the last couple of years of engineers building AI tools that have taken moral leadership. Maybe there will be in the future.</p><p>Joan was pointing out that, actually, it’s worse than that. In addition to an absence of people looking to correct the ways that these capabilities are being used for mal intent, Joan’s pointing out that there actually is an alt-tech movement and that there are plenty of engineers who are like, “Yeah, we like it this way.” And “let’s build out more technology to pour kerosene on the fire.”</p><p><strong>Joan</strong>:</p><p>Can I just add one other actor? So if y’all haven’t heard of two organizations, one is called the <a href="http://centerformediajustice.org/">Center for Media Justice</a>, which does a lot of wrangling around tech and policy and has a different kind of perspective as a civil society organization that is really trying to intervene in the policy realm, but also is trying to understand what a people’s terms of service would look like. If we were to define our relationship to these companies, what would that look like? What could we push for? What is possible?</p><p>They recognize that why we end up needing a black press, for instance, is that none of these companies, corporations, newsrooms always act with the best of intentions. Center for Media Justice is a really important resource for myself when I’m trying to think through, well, what are the complications of doing it this way, and who do we silence when we decide that this is where legislation needs to go.</p><p>The other organization is called <a href="https://www.colorofchange.org/">Color of Change</a>, which was running a blood money campaign right as Charlottesville happened where they were trying to get payers, MasterCard, Visa, Discover, and PayPal to stop funneling money to white nationalist companies online. There’s a huge crowdsourcing issue as well around this, where these white nationalists do make and use each other’s products. And they’re investing heavily in new infrastructure right now, and so cutting off the servicers was Color of Change’s move in the game, right? So while the media’s covering the battle between white nationalists and anarchists, what’s really happening, in terms of the social movement fight, are strategic about stopping the money. And you stop the flow of money, we know they can’t build the infrastructure.</p><p><strong>Jonathan</strong>:</p><p>One of the things I proposed to Facebook, months ago, was, what if there was a trust emoji? And I have no idea if it would work, but it would be interesting to test out what a trust emoji would do.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>It would be a <a href="https://support.twitter.com/articles/119135">blue check </a>at the level of the individual post.</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>The blue check is not meant, technically, to imply authority or influence. It does, unfortunately. The only thing that it’s supposed to do is authenticate identity. This is a platform argument. Over time, the blue check mark has come to kind of symbolize or represent kind of influence, authority, weight in the network.</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>Well, it literally does that on Twitter.</p><p><strong>Jonathan:</strong></p><p>Yeah. So it gives you different options. The fact that we have people like Richard Spencer who have blue check marks. And there’s arguments that say, well, if he didn’t have a blue checkmark, it would be even worse because people would pose as Richard Spencer and insight riots or even more violence. You get into these arguments.</p><p><strong>Matt:</strong></p><p>I think the blue check mark is a way of informing authority through trust in who is an authority, and that’s one of part of a whole range of things that you would want in verification. It’s a very thin reed to rest upon when you aren’t able to go beyond the flat plane of the news story, as Joan was saying.</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>But it is also the expression of an internal editorial voice.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>Yet another indication that these are not neutral platforms.</p><p>You democratize the production of information by allowing anybody to contribute content. There’s no way for anybody to consume all that content. Therefore you have aggregator companies. Those aggregator companies are not neutral, despite what they say, they assume all sorts of editorial functions. And the way that they scale the editorial function is to use user signals in order to do that editorial function. That opens up the possibility of mal actors to shape the way it’s curated, in addition to the mal actors that are generating lots of content.</p><p><strong>Question from the audience:</strong></p><p>Most of the solutions that you guys talked about had some iota of regulation in it, right? One of the things that we didn’t talk about, the cost of producing content is effectively zero. The amount of content is effectively infinite at this point, so it’s arguably impossible to regulate.</p><p>Shouldn’t we be talking about more how we, as individual consumers of information, alter how we do that? How do we change how we look at things through an editorial lens? Do you guys have any opinions on that?</p><p><strong>Sam:</strong></p><p>I mean, I really hope that happens. It’s not just individual jerks on YouTube, although there are a surprisingly increasing number of people who are producing incredibly influential work. It’s also the kind of alt-right news infrastructure that goes back to the first Clinton administration, I would say. And you can trace it all the way back to William F. Buckley at the <em>National Review</em>. There’s all kinds of dogwhistles and overt white supremacy in a lot of this material going back seventy years. But there was a period during the Clinton administration where up to that point staid outlets like the <em>American Spectator </em>started publishing insane things that didn’t comport with reality on any level. That has metastasized into a bunch of outlets that employ people who call themselves reporters and even sometimes go on to work for other news organizations who just traffic mendacious nonsense.</p><p>The Daily Caller, Breitbart, and so on are not quite on the same level as those kinds of zero cost content aggregators, but I would say morally and in terms of the amount of truth in their writing, they often are exactly equal. I hope people will learn who to trust, but I fear that people want to see sort of their biases reinforced. And I’m no different. I try to be different, but it’s hard. I fear that that will end up sort of precluding any change in that.</p><p><strong>Joan:</strong></p><p>I’ll just say really quickly that what we find is that media literacy doesn’t work. And it doesn’t work because when people do try, what they do is self-investigate, and then you end up with Pizzagate, where people are like, “I’m just going to go drive by a pizza parlor and see if there’s<strong> </strong>a child sex dungeon or not.” Right? And so when we find that when they start self-investigating online things that are conspiratorial, they end up getting pulled into these conspiracy theories and these conspiracy message boards. Especially when it comes to things that could be real, or seem outlandish, but once you get into a community of people that are ready to validate that worldview, or that story, it’s like fast downhill.</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>In the future, if we create a sustainable business model for local news, we would have this sort of thing where you experience them digitally, but you also run into them at the store or see them at local events, and that multi-channel engagement with a source gives it a type of veracity that a graphically denuded card that strips out all branding, or you don’t even bother to read the source, doesn’t convey that source of truth and would return us to having some sense of veracity in source.</p><p><strong>Question from audience:</strong></p><p>Yes, thank you. I wanted to problematize kind of the frame of the conversation for a second, because we’re talking about something that is a problem that has solutions. That implies this is a bug that can be worked out, whereas isn’t this actually, as Matt was saying, like a future of Western civilization? Like Plato famously said—I’m going to butcher the quote but—that writing is the enemy of truth. Fifty percent of peer-reviewed results can’t be replicated.We talked about this is a difference in kind and a difference in scale, but are we actually just witnessing civilization becoming woke to the tenuous and precarious nature of an objective reality?</p><p><strong>Chris:</strong></p><p>There are, I think, qualitative differences of intent of the source. Sometimes the source is actually intending to mislead. Sometimes the source thinks that it’s true. Sometimes the source is purveying bullshit, to use the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Bullshit">Frankfurtian</a> technical definition of bullshit, meaning somebody says something, they don’t care whether or not it’s true. Other comments?</p><p><strong>Joan:</strong></p><p>I’m always sympathetic to the idea that early versions of blogs and citizen journalism were where I started to travel into getting my news when I was younger, and I felt very connected to local events because people were reporting on the scene. I’m trying to say that while we understand, and I think the broad public understands, that media is constructed and that it’s not always going to know everything about a situation. That you do appreciate the gloss, at least so that you have a sense of an event, what happened. You know, like a forest fire or a hurricane, things like that. And it brings us into a common sense of reality where at least we all know the event happened.</p><p>But we’re tracking disinformation campaigns where people are faking chemical explosions, right? And that is just different in terms of jamming reality than it is about the details of an event being possibly wrong. When the event doesn’t happen, but it appears online as if it did, those are the kinds of things that I’m thinking about as the problem.</p><p><strong>Question from the audience</strong>:</p><p>What’s the difference of what you’re talking about between the start of the Iraq war and when Hearst got us into Cuba? Same thing. No difference.</p><p><strong>Matt</strong>:</p><p>Those are, of course, explicit and well-organized campaigns to change public opinion and emotion. One of the things that’s very different, and a lot of people have struggled with understanding this in the Russian situation, is the extent to which this is explicit stated doctrinal policy of the Russian Federation coming out of the Soviet Union, and yet it’s amplified both by people in Russia and then by whole series of social phenomena that has made it remarkably stronger than anyone could expect.</p><p>There are definitely people in our government who are upset they can’t do more of this because the legal infrastructure of the United States is very restrictive. When we get more about what happened in the Russia hack of our election, a lot of it is not going to be directed centrally, and yet it’s going to have the effects that people like all of you have tracked so well that we’re going to understand that this is sort of qualitatively different.</p><p>Another thing that I think is quite important, is this relativism. One of the largest goals of disinformation is simply a suspension of belief, a disbelief that there could be any possibility of verification on media or this sort of thing. That even any potential solutions, that, I think, is different from what you saw with The Main and what you saw with Iraq. Because those were supposed to be facts, about which they were propaganda, rather than a world in which you are constantly suspended in the inability to know anything with certainty except for what is immediately around you.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ad5cb0d932e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/tow-center/reality-jamming-the-future-of-information-online-3ad5cb0d932e">Reality Jamming: The Future of Information Online</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/tow-center">Tow Center</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>