<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[What Matter Feels - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[How Science can Explain Minds - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 01:02:02 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/what-matter-feels" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Method for Unifying Physical and Psychological Aspects of Nature]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/a-method-for-unifying-physical-and-psychological-aspects-of-nature-b8ee2e013849?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8ee2e013849</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychophysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theoretical-physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Jun 2026 11:16:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-10T12:54:38.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g65ZOtIDI-KI1aYLdBxEwg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mind is the inside view of matter. Ink on paper, 2012. © Robert Pepperell</figcaption></figure><p><em>Treat the physical and the psychological not as different parts of nature but as two aspects of one nature considered from parallel perspectives: extrinsically, as an observable state or process, and intrinsically, as an experiential state or process.</em></p><p>The proposed method of unifying the physical and psychological aspects of nature involves the following steps:</p><p>1. Consider a body that is in a state or undergoing a process. This could be any particle, object or system being studied scientifically from an extrinsic perspective. Let the observed state or process of the body be the detectable aspect of an <em>experience</em> that occurs from the body’s intrinsic perspective. The body’s observed state or process and its experience are one and the same state or process considered from parallel perspectives.</p><p>2. Define experience broadly as <em>how a body is, in itself, from its intrinsic perspective and how that changes during a process</em>. Hence, experience can be the inherent state of a body, like its rest mass, or the change in its inherent state when undergoing a process. Because it is intrinsic, experience cannot be observed from an extrinsic perspective. Like rest mass, its existence in an observed body can only be inferred.</p><p>3. This definition does not entail that all experience is <em>conscious</em> experience; the experience of an apple falling, for example, is not the same as the conscious experience of a person observing it fall. Hypothetically, conscious experience requires highly complex dynamical organisation of relevant processes.</p><p>4. Let the physical properties and quantities attributed to a body from an extrinsic perspective — such as mass, force and energy — be paralleled by experiential properties and quantities attributed to its intrinsic perspective — such as Will, Conflict and Experience.</p><p>5. Define these experiential properties and quantities with the same precision as their physical parallels so they can be applied with the same rigour and utility to the scientific study of nature. For example, let Experience (capitalised as a technical noun) be the intrinsic parallel of energy and quantitatively equivalent to it. Hence, 1 unit of Experience = 1 unit of energy.</p><p>6. Energy is used as the physical parallel of Experience for two reasons. First, a body’s rest mass-energy, given by <em>E</em> = <em>mc</em>², is an inherent or intrinsic frame-independent property of the body, just as Experience is proposed to be. Second, energy exchange processes, observed extrinsically, track changes in a body’s state and so can be used to infer changes in its intrinsic Experience.</p><p>7. The intrinsic properties and quantities describe the body’s <em>psychological</em> aspect — which includes experiential states or processes of any kind, such as feeling, sentience, sensation or cognition — and the extrinsic properties and quantities describe its <em>physical</em> aspect. Taken together, these parallel properties and quantities describe its <em>psychophysical</em> nature.</p><p>8. Treat each act of observation as an experience that occurs from the intrinsic perspective of the observer and is registered in the observer’s body when states or processes of the observed body are detected from an extrinsic perspective. This does not require that all acts of observation are conscious experiences as we can include detection devices as observers.</p><p>These steps provide a method for unifying<em> </em>the physical and psychological aspects of observed or observing bodies in one psychophysical nature. Using this method, nature can be studied scientifically from an extrinsic physical perspective, from an intrinsic psychological perspective, or as a psychophysical unity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Sy5i3-eCcNBw0p5luDBDyw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The psychophysical unification of the observer and the observed</figcaption></figure><p>This diagram illustrates how a body can be considered from an extrinsic perspective, which describes its physical aspect, and from an intrinsic perspective, which describes its psychological aspect. These are both aspects of the body’s one nature considered from parallel perspectives. The bisected discs at the top and bottom indicate the observed and observing bodies. Each has a physical aspect (black) and psychological aspect (white), depending on which perspective is considered. A state or process of the observed body is the detectable aspect of an experience that occurs to that body intrinsically. The act of observation is itself an experience that occurs to the observer from an intrinsic perspective when a state or process of the observed body is detected. Taken together, these parallel perspectives create a unified psychophysical account of nature and its scientific study.</p><p><strong>About the Book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">book</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8ee2e013849" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/a-method-for-unifying-physical-and-psychological-aspects-of-nature-b8ee2e013849">A Method for Unifying Physical and Psychological Aspects of Nature</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Can’t Eat Information!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/you-cant-eat-information-c350f04e1060?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c350f04e1060</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[information]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Nov 2025 10:58:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-27T11:02:21.948Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*njuNtW0h4BoHJ6UMPmHybg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>We cannot replace energy with information to explain life and mind</em></p><p>In a recent solo episode of <em>Mindscape</em> called <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWP2ktac34k">Complexity and the Universe</a>, the physicist Sean Carroll claims that living systems survive by feeding off ‘available information’ from their environment. This is a puzzling and potentially misleading claim.</p><p>Carroll says that living systems maintain relatively low entropy or high complexity by seeking out and sucking in low entropy resources from the world. And low entropy resources — according to Carroll — have high amounts of information.</p><p>This makes scientific sense if we understand ‘low entropy’ as equivalent to high ‘free energy’, where free energy is the energy available to do useful work. That living creatures need to exploit environmental free energy was the essence of Erwin Schrödinger’s argument in <em>What is Life?</em> Carroll recognises this but then goes astray, I think, when he proceeds to conflate free energy with information, and then to substitute the former with the latter.</p><p>Energy is not information.</p><p><strong>So, What is Information?</strong></p><p>Information, according to one definition offered by Carroll, is how much we can “learn” about a system; it is a measure of knowledge gained: the more we learn about a system, the more information we have acquired. This refers to the so-called Shannon information or entropy, named after the communication theorist Claude Shannon, which is used in information theory to statistically measure the organisation of binary data.</p><p>Carroll also provides another definition of information — what he calls the ‘available information’ — as the difference between the maximum entropy of a system and its actual entropy. This refers to the so-called Boltzmann entropy, which is used in physics and chemistry to measure the way the energy in a system is distributed or spread out.</p><p>The fact that there are several definitions of information and entropy in use in science is a source of great confusion — as Carroll acknowledges — especially since the two forms of entropy referred to give entirely opposite results when used to measure information content. One can applaud Carroll for trying to clarify or unify these definitions in pursuit of a general theory of complexity. But conflating information with energy is unlikely to achieve either.</p><p><strong>Information is no Free Lunch</strong></p><p>Complex systems of all kinds — including living, thinking systems like us — can only move and cogitate if they find and consume <em>energy</em>, or more specifically <em>free energy</em>, because energy is needed to perform the biophysical work that all living processes depend on, including mental processes. The amount of energy transferred from one portion of matter to another is a measure of the work done, and work entails moving matter against resistance over distance.</p><p>Work is actual physical change that occurs through space and time.</p><p>Information, on the other hand, does not move and cannot move anything. We don’t fill our cars with information to drive engines or put information on the fire to accelerate air molecules to keep warm. We can’t eat information. The tools of information theory are useful, even indispensable, for measuring the <em>arrangements</em> of physical systems — how orderly or random they are or appear to be. But physical systems, and dynamical physical systems in particular, are in themselves arrangements of matter and energy endowed with the causal agency that information lacks.</p><p>Bits don’t bite!</p><p><strong>What is Fundamental?</strong></p><p>This is why it is puzzling for Carroll to say during his talk that “information is more general than energy”, if by this he means that information is more <em>fundamental</em> as a physical property. It seems odd because you can have energy without information, but not the other way around. We can be informed about how energy is distributed, but that distribution is not a form of energy. Moreover, energy is a conserved quantity in nature, information is not. Making information <em>the</em> determining property of nature risks privileging the measure over what is measured.</p><p>The belief in the fundamentality of information is now widespread in science. But this is a relatively recent development, a legacy of the computer science revolution of the late twentieth century. Prior to this, energy was widely thought of as the most fundamental and determinate actor in nature. The nineteenth century was a period of intense inquiry into what energy is, where it comes from and how it relates to other physical properties. For a fascinating history of this period, I’d recommend <a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/S/bo3628434.html"><em>The Science of Energy</em> </a>by Crosbie Smith.</p><p><strong>Atomism versus Energeticism</strong></p><p>Inquiry into energy and its nature began to wane in the early twentieth century as more atomistic and statistically based explanations of physics came to the fore. The origins of this shift can be pinpointed to a famous debate in 1895 between Ludwig Boltzmann — one of the founders of statistical mechanics and a proponent of atomism — and the energeticist and anti-atomist Wilhelm Ostwald, as discussed in a recent paper by <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.12692">Horvath and Martins</a>.</p><p>These authors suggest that subsequent developments in relativity and quantum theory meant that we were perhaps premature to dismiss energy as the fundamental entity of nature and its foundational status should now be reconsidered:</p><blockquote>While atoms were eventually accepted (even by Ostwald himself), the emergence of Quantum Mechanics and Relativity were crucial to suggest that the dismissal of energy in favour of atoms was perhaps premature and should be revisited.</blockquote><p>Horvath &amp; Martins, 2025</p><p>This is not to say that refocusing on energy and its nature should be at the expense of information theory. Rather, we may need a more inclusive approach that recognises the rightful place of both in our explanatory frameworks. Carroll’s argument, arguably, could be strengthened by promoting conciliation rather than conflation.</p><p><strong>Why it Matters Now</strong></p><p>Trying to better understand what energy is and what role it plays in physics and biology is a central theme of <em>What Matter Feels</em>. In the book I set out an argument about why we now need to take energy seriously as a fundamental property of nature, and how doing so can yield immense explanatory potential when applied to the problems of explaining mind and life.</p><p>Energy, I propose, can be treated <em>for experimental purposes</em> as the extrinsic aspect of a proposed property called ‘experience’. In this framework, energy exchange is what we observe from the outside of physical systems while experience is what a system ‘feels’ from its own point of view when it is changed during work.</p><p><strong>“To think, we must eat”</strong></p><p>This energy–based approach helps to explain why complex structures tend or ‘prefer’ to develop from less complex ones, and ultimately how life and mind can emerge from processes governed by the laws of physics. It helps to explain why, for example, thought is an energy–consuming process.</p><p>This whole approach can be encapsulated in a phrase from the philosopher Pierre Teilhard de Chardin’s book <em>The Phenomenon of Man</em>: “To think, we must eat” — a statement that inspired the artwork below. Eating transfers free energy from the world to our bodies and brains; brains perform work using energy, the intrinsic aspect of which is experienced as thought.</p><p>It is a radical proposal, of course. But it is one that is grounded in established principles of physics and biology and — crucially — can be experimentally tested.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/850/1*LoxLfF76ylqgHnvtAb_xxg.jpeg" /><figcaption>“To think, we must eat” by Robert Pepperell, 2025</figcaption></figure><p><strong>About the Book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">https://mybook.to/mk6s</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c350f04e1060" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/you-cant-eat-information-c350f04e1060">You Can’t Eat Information!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Nature Wants: Does the Universe Have Mind and Purpose?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/what-nature-wants-does-the-universe-have-mind-and-purpose-69975e9315c7?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69975e9315c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sentience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phyiscs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Sep 2025 17:41:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-05T17:41:59.459Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A picture of a scientist observing a falling apple" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JeaRNgcsmUuHbVE_nZ6Pig.jpeg" /><figcaption>Does the falling apple fall for a purpose? Is it driven by some sentient goal or aim, or is it just subject to mindless, purposeless forces? (© Robert Pepperell, 2025)</figcaption></figure><p><em>New experiments may tell us whether the universe is sentient and goal–directed.</em></p><p>Is the universe driven by purpose? Is it a sentient agent with goals or aims? Are all natural processes directed towards some end?</p><p>These questions, which have deep historical and philosophical roots, tend to be answered in the negative by scientists today. General opinion is that natural processes have purely mechanistic causes and that the behaviour of matter can be fully explained by the physical laws of motion.</p><p>Physicists will say that these laws do not contain extra-physical properties such as preference, purpose or agency. Even the goal–directed behaviours of organisms can — according to this opinion — be explained at more basic levels by mindless, directionless actions.</p><p><strong>Atoms With Souls</strong></p><p>Scientific opinion at the turn of the twentieth century was very different. Leading cosmologists, physicists and biologists were then treating the universe as a sentient being and talking freely of “atoms with souls”. Take, for example, this statement from Ernst Haeckel — one of the most prominent biologists of the time — in his wildly successful book <em>The Riddle of the Universe</em>:</p><blockquote>“The two fundamental forms of substance, ponderable matter and ether, are not dead, and only moved by extrinsic force, but they are endowed with sensation and will (though naturally of the lowest grade); they experience an inclination for condensation [a form of mutual attraction], a dislike of strain; they strive after the one and struggle against the other.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>Ernst Haeckel,</em> The Riddle of the Universe, <em>1901</em></blockquote><p>Few, if any, today would endorse such bold claims about the feelings, aims and desires of matter. But there is a noticeable shift in that direction. Respected scientists and commentators are again asking questions about the place of mind and purpose in nature and coming up with more positive answers.</p><p>These include Jonathan Birch, whose book<em> </em><a href="https://www.edgeofsentience.com/"><em>The Edge of Sentience</em></a> tackles current uncertainties about the extent to which mind permeates reality, Terrence Deacon, who proposed a new form of end-directed ‘teleodynamics’ in his book <a href="https://anthropology.berkeley.edu/incomplete-nature-how-mind-emerged-matter"><em>Incomplete Nature</em></a>, and Michael Levin, a biologist who argues for a “mind everywhere” approach that treats organic systems as driven by basic forms of agency. Although he does not go so far as to talk of “atoms with souls”, Levin is at least open to the idea that sentience and purpose permeate all matter:</p><blockquote>“…as the minimal degree of internal self-determination and goal-directedness is apparently present even in particles there may be no true ‘0’ on the scale of consciousness in the universe.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>Michael Levin</em>, Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere: An Experimentally-Grounded Framework for Understanding Diverse Bodies and Minds, <em>2022</em></blockquote><p>To date, claims about universal sentience and goal–directedness have been largely speculative and very difficult to study experimentally. Now, for the first time, we have a scientific framework that allows us to test whether there is indeed a ‘hidden purpose’ that drives the behaviour of matter towards certain goals, not just in biological systems but in nature as a whole.</p><p><strong>The New Framework</strong></p><p>The framework, which is set out in a book called <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s"><em>What Matter Feels</em></a><em>,</em> provides a set of measurable quantities — most of which are new to physics — and optimisation principles that may govern how systems behave at all scales, from the fundamental to the cosmological. These principles, unlike those used in standard physics, suggest that matter (i.e., anything that has mass and occupies space) may indeed have inbuilt preferences that affect its behaviour.</p><p>Put briefly, the framework proposes that we treat all matter as having an intrinsic ‘experiential’ perspective that ‘feels’ different depending on how it interacts with other matter, much as Haeckel proposed earlier. If the interactions go one way, then the matter has a negative feeling called ‘distress’; if the interactions go the opposite way, then the matter has a positive feeling called ‘relief’.</p><p>The aim of the game — from matter’s point of view — is to optimise its experiential state during any interaction such that it:</p><p>A. Minimises its negative feelings of distress</p><p>B. Maximises its positive feelings of relief</p><p>The ultimate goal of matter, however, is to neutralise all its experiential states during interactions with other matter as far as possible; it aims to reach a state called ‘repose’, which is effectively the nearest it can get to equilibrium, where it feels nothing at all.</p><p>Details on how these proposed properties are derived, defined and measured are given in the book.</p><p><strong>Why the Framework is Different</strong></p><p>The common reaction to these proposals (which are no more than a starting point for experimentation) is that they over–anthropomorphise nature. In other words, they groundlessly attribute human states of mind to numb, dumb matter.</p><p>This reaction is understandable and scepticism here is not only healthy but essential for good science. Healthy scepticism, however, should be distinguished from premature dismissal, especially when the framework is readily testable — as this one is.</p><p>For what distinguishes this framework from other scientific approaches to explaining the nature of sentience is that it makes novel, precise and testable predictions about:</p><p>a. The behaviour we should observe in systems if they are optimising sentient goals rather than just reacting to external forces,</p><p>b. The quality of a system’s internal experience when undergoing certain observable behaviours.</p><p>The predictions that follow from the framework could not be made using standard physics because they depend on newly proposed quantities and principles. We now have an opportunity to conduct the experiments that could detect the influence of these new properties and verify these principles.</p><p>If experiments were to detect the predicted behaviour and verify the principles — or something like them — it would lend support to claims that nature is governed by factors that lie beyond the standard laws of motion. This would be important to science and our wider understanding of nature.</p><p><strong>Example Experiments</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels</em> sets out the basic methods and tools needed to experimentally verify, or falsify, the framework. These methods involve measuring energy exchanges between and within material systems, and in particular tracking the changes in the <em>direction</em> of energy exchange, which are not usually factored into scientific experiments.</p><p>Because energy exchange plays a role in most natural processes, the scope of applicability of the methods is very wide, from particle physics and cosmology to biochemistry and neuropsychology. Where the framework seems to offer most promise, however, is in complex systems where many interacting particles lead to nonlinear or emergent behaviours, such as in neuroscience, or where subtle effects occur in physical systems that cannot readily be explained by standard mechanics.</p><p>To give a few hypothetical examples of experimental domains in which the framework makes specific predictions that could be tested:</p><p>1. Pain perception. The fundamental cause of pain in humans and other creatures is still not understood, in spite of decades of intensive research across several disciplines that has massively increased our understanding of its neurobiological correlates. The framework makes specific predictions about how energy is exchanged and stored in the regions of the brain involved directly in pain processing. In short, accumulation of energy, or increases in energy gradients in particular neural structures should be markers of excessive distress in the system, and therefore of pain perception. Depletion of energy, or decreases in neural energy gradients, meanwhile, should be markers of decreasing distress in the system, and therefore a loss of pain. A number of accurate methods of measuring neural energy storage and exchange are available to neuroscientists and concrete neural mechanisms that might produce these states are detailed in the book.</p><p>2. Nonequilibrium thermodynamics: There are long-standing questions in physics and chemistry about how to the explain the emergence of complex patterns of behaviour in systems that are far from thermodynamic equilibrium — that is, systems that are being perturbed by an external energy source and reconfiguring themselves so that they can dissipate the energy as efficiently as possible. The framework predicts that some such systems, when considered from their intrinsic perspectives, will be maximising their relief to a greater extent than they are minimising their distress. In other words, there will be an imbalance, or asymmetry, in the way they are processing their energy flows — and specifically the directions of their energy flows — which favours relief over distress. Again, this prediction can be tested using existing tools and methods in fields of many kinds, such as active matter research and fluid mechanics, by measuring the directional flow of energy with great precision.</p><p>3. Path choices: The framework also predicts that for any particle in a position where two equivalent paths are available, it will take the one that best optimises its distress and relief. Newtonian physics would predict that the particle would take the path that minimises its energy most quickly. But in certain complex systems where particles may exert subtle influences on each other that are not accounted for by local forces, the choice of path may deviate from that predicted by Newtonian mechanics. Again, experimental tools and modelling techniques of sufficient power and accuracy may be able to detect such subtle departures from standard predictions in a range of domains.</p><p>Note that these examples are given for purposes of illustration only, and a lot more detailed work would need to be done before they could be operationalised. But nevertheless, they do provide concrete cases where experiments could either verify or falsify the proposals of the framework.</p><p><strong>Very Early Days</strong></p><p>Admittedly, what is provided here is no more than a basic outline. And even once experimentation has begun, it will take more than one positive or negative result to verify or falsify the framework. Nevertheless, the approach does at least provide a principled motive for conducting such experiments. If successful, they may herald a branch of science that incorporates sentience and purpose into its objects of study <em>ab initio </em>rather than trying to plug them in <em>ex post facto</em>, as many scientific approaches do today.</p><p>That we may only be at the very earliest stages of such a research programme is ironic given how long we have been speculating about the universe as having sentience and purpose — as noted at the outset. But perhaps it needed science to reach a certain stage of maturity, inter-disciplinary cooperation and technical power — as it may now have done — before it could tackle an idea with such profound implications. The framework outlined here is one way we can begin to find out.</p><p><strong>About the Book</strong></p><p><a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s"><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds</em></a><em>)</em> is a new book that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69975e9315c7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/what-nature-wants-does-the-universe-have-mind-and-purpose-69975e9315c7">What Nature Wants: Does the Universe Have Mind and Purpose?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Physics of Panpsychism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/the-physics-of-panpsychism-5dab95921aa3?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5dab95921aa3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychophysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[panpsychism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Jun 2025 17:41:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-27T17:41:42.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3tqs-wQLn2yOa-3aKQfxQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr Hossenfelder meets Dr Fechner. © Robert Pepperell, 2025.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Panpsychism has so far been a philosophical proposal; could it now become hard science?</em></p><p>Two interesting pieces have landed on Medium recently, both critical of Sabine Hossenfelder’s proclamations about the science of consciousness. For those who don’t know, Sabine Hossenfelder is a theoretical physicist and YouTuber who draws attention for her outspoken opinions on various scientific topics.</p><p>The pieces by <a href="https://medium.com/the-infinite-universe/physics-may-not-explain-the-human-mind-f183bd49969d">Tim Andersen</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/atlas-writes/this-is-why-scientists-cant-understand-consciousness-ec0c7a2db0b6">TRIBE</a> — both of which I recommend — take Hossenfelder to task for, among other things, her crude materialism and “woeful conflations”.</p><p>My main objection to Hossenfelder’s mechanistic view of consciousness is that it perpetuates a form of ignorance that pervades science in general and physics in particular. The ignorance in question is the lack of understanding of, or even interest in, what the physicist Arthur Eddington called the “intrinsic nature” of matter. By ‘ignorance’ I mean that this intrinsic nature is simply ignored.</p><p><strong>Matter has feelings too</strong></p><p>As discussed in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/why-science-cant-explain-consciousness-scientifically-acd5e79bc2f8">previous pieces</a>, scientists — including most physicists — tend to consider only the extrinsic, outwardly observable nature of material systems in their theories and experiments. They observe particles in motion and work out the rules that govern that motion. Hossenfelder’s <a href="https://youtu.be/fRssqttO9Hg">YouTube description </a>of the particles that make up material systems like us exemplifies this tendency.</p><p>Yet consciousness exists exclusively from the <em>intrinsic</em> perspective of conscious systems like us. And if we are just “big bags of particles”, as Hossenfelder claims, then we are living proof that such particles, when arranged and moving in certain ways, have an intrinsic sentient nature.</p><p><em>So, contrary to Hossenfelder’s assertion, there is more to matter than just the observable motions of particles.</em></p><p>Only when science addresses this intrinsic nature of matter theoretically and experimentally, rather than ignoring it, will significant progress be made on the problem of how material systems acquire minds. Until then the study of consciousness, as distinct from the study of the <em>observable correlates</em> of consciousness, will remain beyond the purview of ‘hard sciences’ like biology, chemistry and physics.</p><p>Importantly, this is not the same as saying that it is the job of physicists to explain how we feel pain or see red or fear snakes. The challenge of explaining the diverse flora and fauna of our mental lives — and of the many other beings that we now believe to be sentient — remains the concern of psychobiologists, neuroscientists and psychologists, as it ever did.</p><p>It <em>is</em> the job of physicists — I argue — to explain, or help to explain, how the undeniable existence of mental states is compatible with our understanding of the physical world. If it’s not compatible, then physics needs a fundamental rethink. And if they can’t help, then they should at least acknowledge the problem.</p><p><strong>The Solution from Panpsychism</strong></p><p>In his piece, Tim Andersen (a physicist who does acknowledge the problem) highlights one possible solution: panpsychism. If we could show scientifically that matter has an intrinsic mental nature of some kind, as panpsychism proposes, then the problem of explaining the place of mind in the physical world could be scientifically addressed.</p><p>However, the trouble with panpsychism — as physicists like <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/answering-sean-carrolls-question-for-panpsychists-may-require-new-laws-of-physics-f3cc0d2caf0a">Sean Carroll </a>often point out—is that it has no firm scientific grounding; it relies almost entirely on ‘soft’ philosophical argument for support. What we lack — Tim Andersen says — is a “physics of panpsychism”.</p><p>Well, we <em>do</em> have a physics of panpsychism.</p><p>In fact, the foundations of such a physics were laid in the latter half of the nineteenth century by figures like Gustav Fechner and Ernst Mach, drawing on earlier ideas from Baruch Spinoza and Gottfried Leibniz. This form of physics was known for many years as ‘psychophysics’ or ‘psychophysical parallelism’. And although largely overlooked today it was once the dominant model of mind–matter relations endorsed by leading intellectuals such as Albert Einstein.</p><p><strong>Psychophysical Parallelism</strong></p><p>Psychophysical parallelism is the simple idea that all matter has two kinds of properties that exist in parallel at the same time: physical properties that appear when we observe the matter extrinsically and psychological properties that exist for the matter from its own intrinsic perspective. In history of philosophy terms this is a form of ‘dual–aspect monism’, which is itself a form of panpsychism.</p><p>Psychophysical parallelism can rightly be called a ‘physics of panpsychism’ because it unifies the physical and psychological properties of material systems within the same experimental and explanatory framework. Gustav Fechner (1801–87), who was himself an influential panpsychist, must take most of the credit for establishing this framework.</p><p>What the founders of psychophysics didn’t do — as far as I know — was to define the psychological properties of matter in the same way we have its physical properties. So, for example, we have no definitions of the psychological parallels of things like force, charge, mass or energy. Nor can we accurately measure basic mental properties such as ‘will’ or qualities such as ‘pleasure’, let alone things as complex as consciousness. *</p><p>Having a set of such definitions and measures that we can operationalise for experimental purposes is an essential prerequisite for any physics of panpsychism.</p><p><strong>Psychological Properties of Matter</strong></p><p>Although I <em>do not</em> claim they are finalised or comprehensive, and while I <em>stress</em> that they are subject to experimental validation, I have provisionally defined a set of fundamental psychological properties of matter that parallel the established physical ones. These can now be used to design experiments, test predictions and falsify hypotheses when studying the sentient states of <em>any</em> material system.</p><p>A list of these properties, and the historical and scientific context from which they emerge, can be found in the book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s"><em>What Matter Feels</em></a>. An expanded list, which includes the psychological parallels of thermodynamic properties such heat, temperature, pressure and enthalpy is in development.</p><p>These newly defined properties, when taken together with the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_property">list of established physical properties</a>, furnish us with a more comprehensive psychophysical framework within which to study and explain the widespread existence of sentience in nature. Perhaps most importantly, it allows us to experimentally investigate whether sentience is a fundamental property of matter, as panpsychists have long proposed.</p><p><em>Psychophysics turns panpsychism from a branch of philosophy into a branch of physics.</em></p><p><strong>Putting the Framework to the Test</strong></p><p>Of course, it is one thing to propose such a framework and quite another to experimentally validate it. I expect the currently proposed properties will need significant modification, and perhaps complete revision, once subjected to the rigours of the lab. One thing I have learned from practicing science is that experiments do not always turn out as theory predicts.</p><p>For this reason, it would be more correct to describe the currently proposed framework as a <em>provisional</em> physics of panpsychism rather than a firm set of principles, let alone a hard science.</p><p>But even the fact that we can now outline a provisional panpsychic physics marks a significant step towards the study of subjective experience becoming a hard science, if only because it unifies physics and psychology within the same explanatory project — just as Gustav Fechner and his follower Ernst Mach originally intended.</p><p><strong>About the book</strong></p><p><a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s"><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em></a> is a new book that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><p>*It should be noted that only a small fraction of Fechner’s voluminous writings has been translated from German and his original texts, many of which are not even published in German, are not widely read. So it may be that he attempted such a definitional task, but it has not so far come to my attention. It should also be noted that, more recently, the philosopher David Chalmers proposed that defining psychophysical properties of the kind discussed here may be a key to resolving the hard problem of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5dab95921aa3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/the-physics-of-panpsychism-5dab95921aa3">The Physics of Panpsychism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Arrow of Time: A New Psychophysical Perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/the-arrow-of-time-a-new-psychophysical-perspective-8048580aaf7e?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8048580aaf7e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychophysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arrow-of-time]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entropy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 May 2025 18:55:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-23T18:55:58.066Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TJbGOGaeAFKjmcQMYnRoIA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Could the new science of psychophysics help to resolve one of the deepest mysteries in physics: why time seems to flow in one direction?</em></p><p>Most physical events in our everyday experience occur in a single direction of time. We see balloons burst but never un–burst; smoke curls away from fire but never into it; balls at rest can roll downhill but ever uphill. All these occurrences follow the ‘arrow of time’. This is a term used by physicists to describe the one-way flow of activity we observe at the macroscopic level of reality. Physical processes at this level tend to be composed of complex interactions between many particles.</p><p>Yet behind this seemingly obvious march of events lies a profound mystery that has long puzzled physicists. When interactions are considered at the microscopic scale, or among small groups of particles, the arrow of time ceases to flow in one way. The physics that describe a steel ball colliding with another steel ball has no inherent time directionality; a movie of the collision would look just as plausible when shown forwards or backwards, unlike a movie of a balloon bursting.</p><p>Fundamental physical laws are regarded as ‘time reversal symmetric’, meaning that any interaction between particles — such as a collision between two steel balls — can be described as occurring forwards or backwards in time with equal validity. Nothing in those laws tells us anything about the ‘time reversal asymmetry’ we experience in the everyday world. As things stand, the contradiction between these basic laws and the one-way direction of time’s arrow is unexplained. Or more accurately, the usual explanation is problematic.</p><p><strong>The Statistical Approach to Explanation</strong></p><p>The most widely offered explanation for this puzzle appeals to the Second Law of Thermodynamics and the related quantity known as entropy. According to the prevailing interpretation of this law, systems tend to change from an ‘orderly’ state, where entropy is low, to a more ‘disorderly’ state, where entropy is higher. A box containing gaseous particles that happen to be arranged in a regular pattern, for example, will tend to evolve such that the particles become arranged more irregularly.</p><p>This directional tendency — as claimed by this explanation — is a purely statistical effect. Take any system made of many particles, like a pack of cards, and randomly shuffle them. Because, statistically, there are vastly more ways for the particles, or cards, to end up in an unstructured arrangement than a structured one, the system will almost always end up being unstructured when we observe it.</p><p>It’s not uncommon to find entropy being likened to a tidy bedroom that becomes inexorably messier. Because there are vastly more ways a room can be in a ‘disorderly’ state than an ‘orderly’ one, the former state is more likely to occur than the latter. And by adding to this argument the claim that the early universe was in a very low entropy state (a state of relatively high ‘orderliness’) and has gradually increased in entropy ever since (becoming ever more ‘disorderly’) the statistical explanation for the arrow of time rests its case.</p><p>This explanation remains unsatisfying however for at least two reasons. First, the assumptions about the early state of the universe on which it relies cannot be empirically verified and, second, it leaves the underlying symmetry of the fundamental physical laws that govern the particle’s behaviour untouched. As some people have pointed out (to adapt the adage from computer science: “garbage in, garbage out”): “time reversal symmetry in, time reversal symmetry out.”</p><p><strong>The New Psychophysical Framework</strong></p><p>An entirely different and potentially simpler kind of explanation for time’s arrow is suggested by the psychophysical framework set out in <em>What Matter Feels</em>. Although this new approach is consistent with the Second Law of Thermodynamics and the tendency towards higher entropy, it relies on neither statistical concepts like ‘order’ or ‘disorder’ nor on untestable assumptions about the early state of the universe. Rather it attributes the tendency of matter to behave in one time-directional way to its intrinsic psychological preferences.</p><p>Let’s see how this kind of explanation works.</p><p><strong>Energy and Experience</strong></p><p>A central proposal of the psychophysical framework is that all material systems acquire a property called ‘Experience’ (with a capital ‘E’) when they acquire energy. Energy is a well-established property of matter that we measure from its extrinsic perspective by observing its behaviour. The newly defined property of Experience, however, exists only from the <em>intrinsic</em> perspective of the matter. We cannot observe the Experience of a system directly, but we can infer its existence, and indeed how much of it exists in any material system, based on extrinsic observations of its energy.</p><p>In this psychophysical framework, Experience and energy are considered as parallel or complementary properties of matter — one psychological and one physical — that are quantitatively equivalent and change in unison over time, as shown in the diagram below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2XdB2P_Vi2Stqwq4ui6w2Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Note that as presented in this diagram the model is time reversal symmetric. There would be no difference in the way the system evolves if we were to reverse the direction of the time arrow. As such, the model conforms to the same time reversal symmetry that applies to all fundamental physical processes.</p><p><strong>An Inherent Asymmetry</strong></p><p>But there is more to the psychophysical framework than this. It also posits an inherent <em>asymmetry</em> in the way the Experience of a material system changes over time. According to the framework, a system that is acquiring energy, and therefore Experience, is being pushed away from its equilibrium state, as shown in the diagram above. The framework proposes that matter <em>prefers</em> to be in this equilibrium state, from its psychological perspective, and <em>dislikes</em> being disturbed from it by an influx of energy, as considered from its physical perspective.</p><p>On the other hand, when a system loses its energy, and therefore its Experience, and returns to equilibrium it <em>likes</em> to do so from its psychological perspective. Hence, there is an inbuilt preference in the way a system responds to changes in its energy which favours energy loss and disfavours energy gain.</p><p>In the psychophysical framework, the property in which a system is acquiring Experience (and therefore the net flow of energy is positive) is called Distress, while the reverse property in which the system is losing Experience (where the net flow of energy is negative) is called Relief. The property in which the system has no Experience at all (where energy is zero) is called Repose.</p><p>Note that these psychological properties of Distress, Relief and Repose are not just quantitative in the way the physical property of energy is. They are also <em>qualitative</em> in the sense that each property <em>feels</em> different from the viewpoint of the system.</p><p>The relationship between these newly defined psychophysical properties is shown in the diagram below. The pink phases of the Experience wave represent the Distress of the system, and the blue phases represent its Relief.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8mR8GaoYsCbTNaqYc2DUyA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This model is clearly not time reversal symmetric. While the energy dimension of the graph would be indistinguishable whether the time arrow pointed to the left or the right, the Experience dimension contains distinct phases of Distress and Relief that are not interchangeable. From the perspective of the system concerned, they are quantitively and qualitatively distinct.</p><p><strong>The Preference for Direction</strong></p><p>One of the cornerstones of the psychophysical framework set out in <em>What Matter Feels </em>is that there is a motive driving the behaviour of matter, which is that it seeks to <em>minimise its Distress and maximise its Relief</em>. In energy terms, this means that matter always seeks the lowest energy state possible given its circumstances — which is in accord with well-established principles of physics.</p><p>We can see this motive playing out in the everyday world of simple systems, like springs that resist being stretched or compressed and want to return to a relaxed state, or balls that roll downhill under their own volition but never spontaneously uphill. Conventional physical accounts of these processes consider only the extrinsic perspective of the system being studied and the way behaviour is motivated by forces acting on matter. The framework set out in <em>What Matter Feels </em>allows us to study matter’s intrinsic perspective as well, and the psychological motives driving its behaviour.</p><p>Thus, when we carry out an analysis of a system that undergoes some kind of change in its motion, we can calculate the accompanying change in its Distress or Relief. We can then predict, based on those measurements, how it will behave according to the preferences and motives outlined above. For simple systems, such as springs and balls, this process would be straightforward. For complex, multi-particle systems like gases or chemical reagents, calculating the psychophysical properties of all the particles and their interactions would be impossible.</p><p><strong>A New Psychophysical Thermodynamics: Psychodynamics</strong></p><p>The traditional way to study the energetic activity of complex systems like gases and chemical reactions is to treat them thermodynamically. Like all branches of physics, thermodynamics has hitherto been concerned only with the extrinsic perspective of material systems. A natural extension of the psychophysical approach introduced here with respect to simple systems is to apply the same methods to study the psychology of more complex systems. In <em>What Matter Feels</em>, I term this expanded version of thermodynamics ‘psychodynamics’.</p><p>If we were to apply psychodynamics to the study of, say, a gas in a box to understand why the gas tends to diffuse throughout the box over time — as it would be predicted by traditional thermodynamics — we would attribute the changes that each particle undergoes, and the changes the system as a whole undergoes, to the influence of the psychophysical preferences of the system. We would predict that the system, due to the combined motives of all its particles, would act in such a way that minimises its Distress and maximises its Relief. Outwardly, this internal psychological activity would manifest as a more ‘disorderly’ arrangement of its particles.</p><p><strong>Mathematical Modelling and Experimental Predictions</strong></p><p>Although the psychophysical framework discussed here might seem highly speculative to many people (and some might regard it as downright bizarre) it has three virtues that should incline us to take it seriously.</p><p>First, as with thermodynamics, psychodynamics can be mathematically formalised with rigour and precision. Second, it can be experimentally tested using conventional techniques and tools, as described in <em>What Matter Feels</em>. And finally, it makes novel yet testable predictions about what we should expect to find in systems that are behaving according to the psychophysical principles set out in the framework. For example, we should expect to see subtle differences in the way a system behaves when modelled by classical thermodynamics compared to psychodynamics.</p><p>The psychophysical framework, including its proposed field of psychodynamics, is not intended to supplant traditional approaches in physics but to enrich and expand them. By adding a quantifiable psychological dimension to the physical dimension of reality, we stand to gain greater explanatory power, not least in our understanding of the place of mind in nature.</p><p><strong>The Psychophysical Arrow of Time</strong></p><p>In sum, the possible explanation for the arrow of time introduced here does not conflict with the standard thermodynamic account but may provide a deeper and ultimately more satisfying understanding of how nature operates at its most fundamental levels. Rather than relying on purely statistical effects, which does nothing to dispel the contradiction between the time symmetry of physical laws and everyday experience, we can appeal to an intrinsic property of matter that causes systems to evolve in one way rather than another. This causal aspect of the psychophysical framework, which is discussed in more depth in <em>What Matter Feels, </em>is where much of the potential explanatory power of this new approach resides.</p><p><strong>About the book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">https://mybook.to/mk6s</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8048580aaf7e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/the-arrow-of-time-a-new-psychophysical-perspective-8048580aaf7e">The Arrow of Time: A New Psychophysical Perspective</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Answering Sean Carroll’s question for panpsychists may require new laws of physics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/answering-sean-carrolls-question-for-panpsychists-may-require-new-laws-of-physics-f3cc0d2caf0a?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3cc0d2caf0a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[panpsychism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Apr 2025 07:40:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-21T07:40:00.887Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FcoTumLC4zPYbd0mF68Z_A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Gustav Fechner confronts the problem of explaining the relationship between mind and matter. Robert Pepperell (© 2025).</figcaption></figure><p><em>Current laws of physics deal only with the outward behaviour of ‘stuff’; to explain the mind we may need to add new laws that deal with its inward mental behaviour.</em></p><p><strong>A challenge for panpsychists</strong></p><p>The physicist Sean Carroll is robustly sceptical about panpsychist–type views that propose consciousness is a fundamental part of physical reality. In a recent interview with author and documentary maker <a href="https://annakaharris.com/about/">Annaka Harris</a>, who broadly supports such views, Carroll raises a key question that has not yet been addressed by panpsychists:</p><blockquote>“To me, the very first question that has to be answered by anyone who wants to talk about the fundamentality of consciousness is: do they think that it will manifest in some change of what we understand as the fundamental laws of physics for the behaviour of stuff, or does it leave the behaviour of physical stuff completely as we currently understand it?”*</blockquote><p>It’s a fair and pertinent question.</p><p><strong>The answer from <em>What Matter Feels</em></strong></p><p>The central proposals made in the book <em>What Matter Feels</em> address this question directly. Yes — the book argues — we may have to modify our understanding of the fundamental laws that govern the behaviour of matter. But at the same time, we can do so without repealing the fundamental laws as we currently understand them.</p><p>This seemingly improbable solution is achieved through a simple expedient. We can <em>supplement</em> the standard laws and properties of physics — which are concerned with the outward or extrinsic aspects of a system’s behaviour — by adding further laws and properties that exactly parallel the standard ones but are concerned with its inward or intrinsic behaviour.</p><p><strong>Supplementing Newton’s laws</strong></p><p>To give an example, take Newton’s first law of motion — perhaps the most foundational law of physics — which states:</p><blockquote>“Every body perseveres in its state of being at rest or of moving uniformly straight forward, except insofar as it is compelled to change its state by forces impressed.”</blockquote><p>Note that this statement is concerned with the outwardly observable <em>motion</em> of the system and how it changes when it is acted on by a force. But if we are concerned with the unobservable inward nature of the system — what is referred to in <em>What Matter Feels</em> as its psychological state or its <em>emotion</em> — then we need to add a parallel law that accounts for how its nature changes when the system interacts with another system. The proposed way to express this new first law is:</p><blockquote>‘Every body perseveres in its state of Repose, except insofar as it is compelled to suffer Conflict.’</blockquote><p>The psychological properties of ‘Repose’ and ‘Conflict’ that appear in this statement are defined in detail in the book, and Repose is discussed below. But this first ‘law of Experience’ (or law of emotion) says, in essence, that a system will remain in its preferred psychological state unless it interacts with another system, whereupon it experiences an unpleasant state of ‘stress’ as it disturbed from its preferred state.</p><p>For convenience, let’s view these parallel first laws side by side:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mY6iFHLpGzob1nZFOJHtLg.jpeg" /><figcaption>An extract from Table 2 in <em>What Matter Feels showing the first laws of Motion and Experience</em>. The full table shows Newton’s three laws of motion, which consider the behaviour of systems from their extrinsic motional perspective, and three parallel laws of Experience, which consider the behaviour of systems from their intrinsic emotional perspective. By taking these two parallel sets of laws together, the book argues, we gain a fuller understanding of the psychophysical behaviour of the system.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The new field of psychophysics</strong></p><p>I will return to the proposed laws of Experience that parallel Newton’s laws of motion in a future post because they have some remarkable features and implications. But for the purposes of this post, the pairing of these parallel laws demonstrates the claim made above, namely that we can modify or supplement the standard laws of physics to accommodate psychological properties of nature without repealing the standard laws. The new field of physics that is described by this expanded set of laws is called ‘psychophysics’.</p><p>These psychophysical laws provide us with a more comprehensive description of natural processes (or the “behaviour of stuff”, as Carroll puts it) than standard physical laws provide alone. Psychophysics allows us to study both the intrinsic and extrinsic — or psychological and physical — perspectives of a system’s behaviour.</p><p><strong>The psychophysical relationship between energy and Experience</strong></p><p>This new and more comprehensive psychophysical picture of nature can be illustrated by considering the relationship between energy and Experience. Energy is a well-defined physical quantity in physics that can be measured precisely. Experience, with a capital E, is defined in <em>What Matter Feels</em> as the psychological parallel of energy, or more precisely the change of energy. Because they exist in parallel, we can think of energy and Experience as two distinct but integral dimensions of a system.</p><p>To visualise this relationship, consider a system that periodically gaining and losing energy, a graphical plot of which is shown in diagram A.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5wIMOOgpS8_v5bFmojRx4A.jpeg" /><figcaption>A diagram showing the periodic change in the energy of a system as it evolves over time.</figcaption></figure><p>Here the system fluctuates between a high energy state that is represented by the peak of each wave and a zero-energy state that is represented by the trough of each wave, where the system is momentarily at equilibrium.</p><p>In <em>What Matter Feels</em>, the proposal is made (for reasons grounded in the histories of physics and psychology) that when a system undergoes a change in its energy — as observed from an extrinsic perspective — it also undergoes a parallel change in its Experience from its intrinsic perspective.</p><p>It is further proposed (again for reasons grounded in the relevant histories) that there is a <em>quantitative equivalence</em>between energy change and Experience, such that 1 unit of energy change is equivalent in value — but not in nature — to 1 unit of Experience. These units are specified and explained in <em>What Matter Feels</em>.</p><p>We can see this relationship represented graphically in diagram B, where a further dimension is added to the graph on which is plotted the change in the value of the Experience of the system as its energy fluctuates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z3jjN2bvKP-Sy-DKRxCHjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A diagram showing the relationship between the energy dimension (grey wave) and the Experience dimension (mauve wave).</figcaption></figure><p>This diagram shows energy and Experience as distinct but related dimensions or aspects of a system that change in parallel to each other as the system evolves. Each property exists from a different perspective — energy from the extrinsic and Experience from the intrinsic — and so both cannot be observed, or experienced, from the same point of view. Nevertheless, they are both integral properties of the system taken as a whole.</p><p><strong>Specific properties of Experience</strong></p><p>While the property of Experience is the most general property a system acquires when it interacts with another system, <em>What Matter Feels</em> also defines several specific properties of Experience that give a richer and more fine-grained picture of what a material system feels when we observe it.</p><p>For example, the unpleasantness that is felt when a system is disturbed from its preferred state of Repose (or equilibrium state) is defined as Distress (measured by a positive change in energy). Conversely, when a system gives up the energy it has acquired and returns to its preferred state of Repose it experiences a pleasant property defined as Relief (measured by a negative change in energy).</p><p>These specific properties are shown in diagram C, where Distress is represented by the pink phase of the Experience fluctuation and Relied by the blue.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3V-KemIECAju8B3erTYSEw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A diagram showing two specific properties of the general property of Experience, namely Distress (represented by the pink phase of the wave) and Relief (represented by the blue phase of the wave). These are experienced by the system, according to the proposals made in <em>What Matter Feels, </em>as unpleasant and pleasant respectively.</figcaption></figure><p><em>What Matter Feels</em> provides definitions of several more specific properties of Experience, including the derivatives of Distress and Relief with respect to time, and shows how they might be applied to real world systems so that we can more fully understand their psychophysical behaviour.</p><p><strong>Expanding the field of physics</strong></p><p>As noted above, psychophysics entails an expansion of the field of physics as it is currently understood. Diagram D shows how psychophysics incorporates physics and psychology within the same experimental and explanatory framework.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/892/1*RT-LhZUEd56Ltx6GmT2gDQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Physics and psychology have traditionally been regarded as opposite ends of the scientific spectrum, where physics deals with the ‘hard’ fabric of inanimate reality and psychology with the ‘soft’ world of feelings and thoughts in living creatures. Physics — some might argue — has nothing to say about the fundamental nature of mind and psychology has nothing to say about the fundamental nature of matter.</p><p>This position holds true, I would say, only while we avoid the problem of explaining the nature of mind and its relationship to the physical world. Once we confront that problem seriously and deeply then we are compelled, I would also argue, to adopt some form of psychophysical framework. This was the conclusion reached by the physicist and psychologist Gustav Fechner, who originally developed the framework of psychophysics in the mid-nineteenth century, when he confronted the same problem.</p><p>Physics and psychology, according to Fechner, are just two different perspectives on the same reality. In <em>What Matter Feels</em>, Fechner’s original psychophysical framework is extended and updated in the light of modern knowledge from physics and neuroscience and applied to the problem of explaining the relationship between the mind and the world.</p><p><strong>All proposals are provisional — but testable</strong></p><p>As is emphasised throughout the book, all these proposals are provisional and subject to experimental verification. They will only have scientific value if they can be shown to offer explanatory and predictive power. Fortunately, they can be experimentally tested using modern tools and methods — as the book also demonstrates — and the non-obvious predictions about the behaviour of “stuff” that follow from the proposals can be confirmed or disconfirmed.</p><p>I’m pleased to report that this experimental programme, which will address Carroll’s question directly and empirically, is now underway.</p><p>*From Sean Carroll’s Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas: <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/sean-carrolls-mindscape-science-society-philosophy/id1406534739?i=1000703460940&amp;r=3183">Annaka Harris on Whether Consciousness is Fundamental</a>, 14 Apr 2025</p><p><strong>About the book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">https://mybook.to/mk6s</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3cc0d2caf0a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/answering-sean-carrolls-question-for-panpsychists-may-require-new-laws-of-physics-f3cc0d2caf0a">Answering Sean Carroll’s question for panpsychists may require new laws of physics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Physics has a huge problem: it can’t account for experience]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/physics-has-a-huge-problem-it-cant-account-for-experience-57ae1ee589e4?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57ae1ee589e4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mind-body-connection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Mar 2025 18:37:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-21T11:06:37.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FtN5oY9AqUtoeYfkjgPqqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Observer — observed/experiencer — experienced</em>. Robert Pepperell (© 2025).</figcaption></figure><p><em>Either minds are part of physical reality, in which case they should be explicable using physical principles, or they are not, in which case they can’t be explained scientifically.</em></p><p>Physics is the scientific discipline charged with describing and explaining reality at its most basic levels. Physicists gain knowledge about reality by studying the organisation and behaviour of material systems. They propose principles and laws that govern that organisation and behaviour and which, in turn, allow them to predict how systems will behave as they act in accordance with those principles and laws.</p><p>None of this is controversial. Rather, it is stating the obvious. But there is a fact that is so obvious about the discipline of physics that it has been almost entirely overlooked. Physics has nothing to say about the fundamental nature of sentience or minds.*</p><p>Minds are part of reality, part of the world, part of the universe. Some people might argue that they are the <em>most fundamental</em> part of the world because our minds are the only things we can know or directly experience. All we observe in nature, or learn about its organisation or behaviour, we do as part of our experience.</p><p>Physics itself is often regarded as an ‘empirical’ science because it depends on observation to verify its claims. But empirical is just another way of saying experiential; physical facts, according to physics, must be directly experienced to be taken as true. So, consider these two observations:</p><ol><li>Minds exist and are part of the world.</li><li>Physics presumes experiencers.</li></ol><p>Given these two observations, why then does physics have nothing to say about the fundamental nature of experience or mind? There is no physical theory of mentality in the same way there are physical theories of motion or electromagnetism. The standard model of particle physics, often cited as the most complete and successful model of reality, contains no terms that refer to sentience. The equations of fluid dynamics or relativity theory contain no terms for mental states.</p><p>Experience—this most foundational aspect of nature—has been excluded from our models of physical reality, even though, according to the assumptions physics makes about itself, it is the very bedrock on which we build our knowledge of that reality.</p><p>This leaves a huge hole at the centre of physics that is nicely illustrated by the image below. Remarkably, there are no papers about consciousness in Nature Physics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5CjBWzB0l47o2ZAcK-U1eA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Error page from Nature Physics web site.</figcaption></figure><p>One way out of the problem is to say that physics is not, and never was, concerned with explaining the mind. Physics, people might argue, deals only with the mechanical, inanimate world and leaves the animate mental world to disciplines like biology and psychology.</p><p>But I am not arguing here that the discipline of physics should explain the mind. Rather, I am suggesting that the mind should be explicable in terms that are consistent with the principles of physics. To deny this is to sidestep awkward questions about the nature of mind and its place in the physical world. This makes physics complicit in denying the mind is part of the physical world, which encourages troublesome philosophical positions such as dualism, illusionism, idealism or eliminative materialism.</p><p>Another — and I would argue better — way out of the problem is to adopt the approach outlined in the book <em>What Matter Feels</em>. This is simply to extend the existing list of physical properties by adding a new set of psychological ones. In doing so we integrate the mental into the material, or if you prefer, the psychological into the physical. Having taken this simple step, we can carry on doing physics just as we always have done, but now with an expanded vocabulary that we can use to study the psychological aspects of nature alongside the physical.</p><p>I call this new, expanded form of physics ‘psychophysics’, although it is not actually that new. It was first proposed by Gustav Fechner in the mid-nineteenth century and was supported by figures like Ernst Mach and Albert Einstein, as also discussed in <em>What Matter Feels</em>.</p><p>* Of note here is the work done by Karl Friston and colleagues on the ‘physics of sentience’. However, this work is primarily aimed at developing a comprehensive theory of perception and action in organisms using tools and concepts from existing physics rather than, as is done in <em>What Matter Feels</em>, proposing a modified form of physics itself.</p><p><strong>About the book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">https://mybook.to/mk6s</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57ae1ee589e4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/physics-has-a-huge-problem-it-cant-account-for-experience-57ae1ee589e4">Physics has a huge problem: it can’t account for experience</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A simple solution to the mind-body problem]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/a-simple-solution-to-the-mind-body-problem-ef98b73cdc6c?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef98b73cdc6c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mind-body-connection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychophysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mind]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Mar 2025 20:31:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-21T20:36:50.037Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_4nNfeVkGSksQblXiBYgGA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The mind-body problem, or the mind-matter problem, is one of the deepest and most enduring in philosophy and science. No model of mind-matter relations proposed so far — including materialism, idealism, dualism, monism, illusionism or panpsychism — has provided an intuitively satisfying or experimentally testable solution.</p><p>Yet such a solution has been available in principle for at least 150 years. Originally developed in Germany in the 19th century and known as ‘psychophysics’, it has great explanatorily potential and is now scientifically testable ways that were not possible when it was first developed. What’s more it is very simple.</p><p>The psychophysical solution is this: Rather than assuming a fundamental separation between the physical and the psychological (or the material and the mental) and then struggling to understand how they are related, we simply <em>add some basic psychological properties to the current list of physical properties</em>. That is, we expand the list of physical properties we use to describe nature — such as mass, energy and charge — to include newly defined psychological properties such as Will, Experience and Volition.</p><p>These new psychological properties of nature can be defined, quantified and measured in the same way as the established physical properties and studied scientifically using the same tools and methods we ordinarily use to study material systems.</p><p>The difference between the new and the established properties, according to psychophysics, is that the former belong to the intrinsic perspective of the system while the latter belong to its extrinsic perspective. Put another way, the psychological properties are <em>subjectively experienced</em> by the system being studied while the physical properties are <em>objectively measured</em> by the observer of the system.</p><p>Once we become comfortable with this way of integrating psychological and physical properties within the same psychophysical framework, we will no longer struggle to understand how they are related.</p><p>This simple move is a major step in resolving the longstanding problem of how to incorporate the mind into our physical picture of the world. It also augurs a new branch of physics — psychophysics — that can sit alongside classical, relativistic and quantum physics and which we can use to study the nature of mind and its place in the world.</p><p>The book <em>What Matter Feels</em> outlines this psychophysical solution, puts it in its historical context, and shows how it can be tested and applied to many important scientific and philosophical questions.</p><p><strong>About the book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">https://mybook.to/mk6s</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef98b73cdc6c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/a-simple-solution-to-the-mind-body-problem-ef98b73cdc6c">A simple solution to the mind-body problem</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What do physicists mean by ‘experience’?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/what-do-physicists-mean-by-experience-d8df917ad053?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8df917ad053</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[matter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[experience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Feb 2025 13:11:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-23T13:11:15.277Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gMAfhm_w-ay0ILYYhMQLiw.png" /><figcaption>A scientist (right) observes a material system made of atoms (left) being subjected to an energy source (top left) during an experiment. Does the material system have any experience of being affected by the energy; does it feel anything? Many people assert that atoms have no capacity for experience. Yet we take it for granted that the scientist, who is also made of atoms, experiences the experiment. (Image credit: © Robert Pepperell, 2025).</figcaption></figure><p><em>Physicists frequently refer to the ‘experiences’ or ‘feelings’ of matter yet deny that matter experiences or feels anything at all. Is this a problem for science, or an opportunity?</em></p><p>Some readers of the book <em>What Matter Feels</em> have objected to the suggestion that matter can experience or feel anything. Matter — these objectors confidently assert — is entirely insentient. Attributing psychological states of pleasure or displeasure to atoms or molecules, they say, is a form of naive animism or scientifically impotent panpsychism.</p><p>This objection overlooks several things, not least the fact that we, along with many other creatures, are made of atoms and molecules yet are clearly sentient. It also sits uneasily with the way physicists habitually refer to the ‘experiences’ and ‘feelings’ of matter when explaining its behaviour — and surely we should take seriously what physicists say about matter!</p><p><strong>The Experiences of Matter</strong></p><p>An early example of a physicist referring to the ‘experience’ of a material object is James Clerk Maxwell in his book <em>Matter and Motion,</em> published in 1877, where he says “…the ball experiences a force in the direction opposite to its relative motion.”</p><p>In his <em>Lectures on Physics</em> published in 1964, Richard Feynman defines the quantities inherent in the electromagnetic field “…in terms of the forces that are felt by a [test] charge…” at any point in the field. Physicists assume these quantities exist at that point in the field, he says, whether the test charge is there to “feel” it or not.</p><p>It is not only physicists who use this kind of language about matter. The neuroscientist Dr Rachel Barr — in a recent video discussing the relativistic properties of charged particles on her hugely popular TikTok channel — is even more anthropomorphic about a particle’s ‘experience’ [See image below, left and middle].</p><p><strong>The Desires of Matter</strong></p><p>Saying that matter ‘experiences’ or ‘feels’ forces is one thing. But what about saying that it ‘wants’ or ‘desires’ or ‘prefers’ to be in one state rather than another? Is it not taking the anthropomorphising of matter to an absurd extreme to imply that a ball or a charged particle has wishes, volitional states or preferences?</p><p>We don’t have to look hard for examples of physicists, and indeed scientists from many fields, referring to the behaviour of matter in exactly this way. In the same video, Dr Rachel Barr refers to what the particles ‘want’ to do when subjected to the field of an opposing charge [See image below, right].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WORLbfO1nAwjmotYVsSvTw.png" /><figcaption>Three frames from a TikTok video by the neuroscientist Dr Rachel Barr in which she explains the relativistic behaviour of charged particles in the brain. In the left and middle frames she discusses how the experience of the particle varies depending on its relation to surrounding charges. In the right frame she attributes ‘wanting’ to the particle. This illustrates the widespread habit among scientists of describing matter in general as having sentience and volition (For full video see @drrachelbarr).</figcaption></figure><p><strong>An Awkward Problem for Science</strong></p><p>I’ve asked many physicists, chemists (who sometimes talk of ‘happy’ and ‘unhappy’ chemical reactions) and neuroscientists what they mean by using psychologically-laden terms such as ‘experience’ and ‘wants’ about electrons, atoms, ions and molecules. The answer is usually the same. They do not mean to attribute sentience to matter. Such terms, they say, are no more than convenient figures of speech, or loose analogies, that aid explanation and should not be taken literally or seriously.</p><p>But this is a cardinal case of having your cake and eating it. On one hand, scientists imply that matter is inherently sentient and volitional because doing so is explanatory convenient. On the other hand, they deny that matter is sentient or volitional because it invites the taint of animism or panpsychism.</p><p>This leaves physics — and the sciences more widely — with an awkward problem. How can we take the statements of scientists about the nature and behaviour of matter seriously when they themselves do not?</p><p><strong>An Opportunity not a Problem</strong></p><p>Fortunately I think this is a problem we can turn into an opportunity. Rather than affirming and then denying matter’s sentient nature we should use the tools of science to investigate whether matter is sentient or not.</p><p>If matter <em>seems</em> to act as if it experiences or wants things, and if describing it in that way is explanatorily useful, then it is perfectly reasonable use the scientific method to find out whether this appearance has any foundation in reality.</p><p>We have an opportunity to do this, I argue in <em>What Matter Feels</em>, by using newly defined psychological properties of matter such as ‘experience’, ‘will’, ‘pleasure’ and ‘displeasure’, giving them precisely measurable units, and studying them experimentally to try and better explain how matter behaves.</p><p><strong>Not a Metaphysical Claim</strong></p><p>Crucially, this is <em>not</em> the same as asserting that ‘matter has mind’; this is not a metaphysical claim that balls or particles <em>do</em> experience or feel. Some people who have read <em>What Matter Feels</em> have taken me to be asserting this, despite my consistent denials. No. As things stand, we cannot say definitively whether matter has sentient properties, and even if it does we have not yet agreed how to define and measure them.</p><p>What I <em>am</em> saying is that for scientific purposes,<em> and scientific purposes only</em>, we <em>hypothesise</em> that matter in general has certain psychological properties that exist in parallel to the well known physical ones and which can be provisionally defined. Moreover, we can hypothesise that both kinds of properties play a role in the matter’s ‘psychophysical’ behaviour. These are no more than rational and testable proposals.</p><p><strong>Testing the Experiences of Matter</strong></p><p>Equipped with this hypothesis and the newly proposed (and highly provisional) definitions, we can now carry out the relevant experiments and see from the results whether we have gained any explanatory purchase. If not, then we must go back and revise the hypothesis and definitions and try again.</p><p>If, however, the hypothesis were to be experimentally confirmed and explanatorily fruitful then the payoff would be substantial for many areas of science, and indeed for our understanding of nature more generally. We would have made significant progress in resolving one of the deepest and most intractable problems we know, namely how to explain the relationship between mind and matter, or psychology and physics. In my view, this alone is sufficient reason to conduct the experiments.</p><p>So, why not study the putative experiences of balls and the desires of charged particles using the tools and methods of science, albeit supplemented by some newly defined properties? We may discover that we already know more about the fundamental nature of mind than we realise, or are yet willing to admit.</p><p><strong>About the book</strong></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">https://mybook.to/mk6s</a> that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in eBook, paperback and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets. The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a> that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. Part of the proceeds from the book and poster sales will support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8df917ad053" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/what-do-physicists-mean-by-experience-d8df917ad053">What do physicists mean by ‘experience’?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Matter Feels: A New (Old) Way to Study Consciousness]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/what-matter-feels-a-new-old-way-to-study-consciousness-2a9eed15a7d7?source=rss----bf43da881f48---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a9eed15a7d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Pepperell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Jan 2025 12:16:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-19T12:16:18.357Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qo_b68Hf_9b39QLuURcInQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Can we open up a new scientific frontier in consciousness research by assuming that all matter feels from its own point of view? (Image © Robert Pepperell, Watercolour and ink on paper, 2012)</figcaption></figure><p><em>This essay is adapted from the preface to the book </em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics<em>.</em></p><p><em>What Matter Feels</em> is a newly published treatise that offers a bold conceptual framework with which to address one of the deepest intellectual problems: how to explain the relationship between matter and mind. Recent years have seen numerous attempts to solve this problem using existing frameworks from science and philosophy, whether they be computational, neurobiological, mathematical, phenomenological or quantum physical.</p><p>While all of these have made valuable contributions, it is widely accepted that none has fundamentally unified our knowledge about the nature of matter from physics with that we have about the nature of mind from psychology. None of these approaches allows us to experimentally study the mental states of physical systems using principles that might explain how those systems have mental states at all.</p><p>Had we solved what David Chalmers, 30 years ago, called “the hard problem of consciousness” we would not still be arguing about it.</p><h4>A New Framework (Based on Some Old Ideas)</h4><p>The framework outlined in <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s"><em>What Matter Feels</em></a> offers an opportunity to address these challenges experimentally. It sets out a model of mind and its place in nature that draws on a wide range of current scientific and philosophical knowledge but also on the history of that knowledge, and especially on certain ideas that were prominent in earlier centuries but are now largely overlooked.</p><p>At the core of the proposed framework is a conjecture that Isaac Newton hinted at in his foundational work, <em>Principia Mathematica,</em> in 1687. In Definition III of the <em>Principia</em>, Newton considered the inherent condition of a body that is being acted on by a force.</p><blockquote>A body, from the inactivity of matter, is not without difficulty put out of its state of rest or motion. Upon which account, this <em>vis insita</em> [inherent force], may, by a most significant name, be called <em>vis inertiæ</em>, or force of inactivity.</blockquote><blockquote>Isaac Newton, <em>Principia Mathematica,</em> 1687</blockquote><p>The conjecture I make in <em>What Matter Feels </em>is that—for the purposes of scientific study—we should consider matter to have, in addition to properties such as mass and charge, a general property called Experience. I follow Newton in thinking of this property of Experience as a state of “difficulty”, or stress, that the body undergoes from its own point of view when it is acted on, against its wishes, by a force.</p><h4>Experience: A New Property of Matter</h4><p>In the book I use the word ‘Experience’, capitalised, as a noun in a technical sense that is distinct from — but related to — the various senses in which we use it as a noun or verb colloquially.</p><p>Experience in this technical sense is a <em>psychological</em> property that belongs to a portion of matter from its own point of view. It cannot be observed from the ‘outside in’. Yet as I will show, it can be measured.</p><p>There is a precedent for an unobservable yet measurable property of nature, which is force. A force cannot be seen. But it can be measured by the changes in motion it produces in a system it acts upon. As will be explained, the psychological property of Experience is measured by the changes in energy a system undergoes when it is subjected to work (as defined in physics).</p><p>Besides the <em>general</em> psychological property of Experience, in the book I also define <em>specific</em> psychological properties that can be attributed to matter such as Will, Volition and Conflict and show how these can be measured.</p><h4><strong>Does Matter Have a Point of View?</strong></h4><p>The phrase “from its own point of view” above is of utmost importance and highlights one of most conceptually challenging aspects of <em>What Matter Feels</em>.</p><p>For the purposes of theoretical and experimental investigation, I ask us to entertain the possibility that <em>all</em> material systems can have an intrinsic perspective, i.e., there can be “something it is like” subjectively to be a material system (to use a phrase given prominence by the philosopher Thomas Nagel).</p><p>In saying this, I am following in the wake of earlier scientists such as Gustav Fechner and Ernst Mach in suggesting, as the biologist Ernst Haeckel put it, that matter may be “sensitive”; i.e., matter “feels”. I take this suggestion seriously and literally for the purposes of scientific study. It may, of course, prove to be wrong or require revision in light of experiment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LjRS1hR507HDQIJaJGNZfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>An extract from Ernst Haeckel’s ‘Riddle of the Universe’ , first published in 1900. Haeckel was an artist and biologist who argued for a form of monism in which all matter possesses mind, favourably quoting the poet and scientist Goethe in support. (Image of author’s annotated copy, © Robert Pepperell, 2024).</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>The Difference between ‘Experience’ and ‘Conscious Experience’</strong></h4><p>I stress that I am <em>not</em> saying — as some contemporary panpsychists do — that all matter is <em>conscious</em> at some fundamental level, consciousness being defined here as a condition in which a system is aware of itself and its environment. The question of how a given system might become conscious, or even self-conscious, rather than just having a capacity for Experience is addressed in <em>What Matter Feels</em>.</p><p>Using evidence from contemporary neuroscience, I describe how nervous systems and brains undergo <em>conscious</em> Experiences when they are organised and behave in certain ways. Conscious and self-conscious Experience, I try to show, are special cases of the general property of Experience.</p><h4><strong>“But Matter Does Not Experience!”</strong></h4><p>Many people will balk at the idea that matter can feel, have Experience or sentience of any kind. Yet generations of chemists and physicists have routinely referred to the feelings and preferences of the material systems they study. The earliest example I can find in the modern literature is the physicist James Clerk Maxwell in the 1880s talking about the “experience” of a cannon ball acted on by a force.</p><blockquote>Thus the motion of a cannon ball is retarded, but this arises from an action between the projectile and the air which surrounds it, whereby the ball <em>experiences</em> a force in the direction opposite to its relative motion, while the air, pushed forward by an equal force, is itself set in motion, and constitutes what is called the <em>wind </em>of the cannon ball.</blockquote><blockquote>James Clerk Maxwell, <em>Matter and Motion,</em> 1877</blockquote><p>Earlier natural philosophers such as René Descartes, Isaac Newton and Michael Faraday also talked about the way material bodies “suffer” or “endeavour” during interactions. Chemists still talk of ‘happy’ and ‘unhappy’ reactions and physicists of systems that ‘want’ to do some things and not others.</p><p>Whenever I have asked chemists or physicists what they mean by talking in this way, I invariably get the same response. They say that they are speaking metaphorically; they do not mean to impute psychological states to atoms, liquids or mechanical gears. Matter self-evidently does not feel, they claim. Thinking a bit more carefully, though, how secure is this claim? Has it been tested experimentally? I am not aware that it has. <em>What Matter Feels</em> aims to provide reasons why it should be tested and to suggest how it might be.</p><h4><em>Strengths and Weaknesses</em></h4><p><em>What Matter Feels</em> has some unusual features that are both strengths and weaknesses. For one thing it is promiscuously multidisciplinary, drawing on knowledge and methods from the arts, humanities and sciences. The strength here is that the resulting framework benefits from a broader range of perspectives than a monodisciplinary approach could provide.</p><p>In my view, the nature of mind and its place in the world are topics that do not respect academic boundaries, and they are certainly not the exclusive concern of philosophy or science. The weakness of the present approach is that the depth and subtlety of the ideas contributed by some disciplines may not be given their full due.</p><p>The treatise is also quite short, especially in relation to its scope, and this limits the space for detailed and sustained argument in support of its main claims. But its brevity is also a strength, not just because of the reduced demands it makes on the reader’s time and on the earth’s resources but also because it is only as long as it needs to be to fulfil its main purpose.</p><p>It is not intended to convince by argument but rather to outline and illustrate a conceptual framework within which experiments can be conducted to test hypotheses and make predictions. Judgement on the contents of this treatise, I ask, should be withheld pending the outcome of those experiments.</p><h4>It’s all provisional!</h4><p>Finally, although this treatise is published it is not finalised. Rather, it is a working document that is designed to encourage discussion and stimulate research.</p><p>One of the most valuable lessons I have learnt from my involvement in science is how often rational expectations are confounded by experimental results. When the experiments proposed in the book begin and data is collected, the most likely outcome — based on my previous experience — will be the need for profound revision of what in the absence of that data seemed to be reasonable conjectures.</p><p><em>— — — — — — —</em></p><p><em>What Matter Feels: Consciousness, Energy and Physics (How Science can Explain Minds)</em> is a new book that sets out a scientific framework for studying consciousness. It is available in <a href="https://mybook.to/mk6s">eBook</a>, <a href="https://mybook.to/sonk">paperback</a> and hardback formats from Amazon and other outlets.</p><p>The book is accompanied by a series of poster artworks that celebrate and promote the ideas discussed in the book. These are available at <a href="https://pepperell.art/">https://pepperell.art</a></p><p>A portion of the proceeds from the book and poster sales is used to support interdisciplinary research into the nature of consciousness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a9eed15a7d7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels/what-matter-feels-a-new-old-way-to-study-consciousness-2a9eed15a7d7">What Matter Feels: A New (Old) Way to Study Consciousness</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/what-matter-feels">What Matter Feels</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>