<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Wonk Bridge - Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Where Tech Worlds Collide - Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 09:59:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/feed/wonk-bridge" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It is time to talk about Technology differently]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/it-is-time-to-talk-about-technology-differently-2085909f866?source=rss----252b18208b92---4"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1968/1*0q5iIUdezH0MhweuvU5x4Q.png" width="1968"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Technology discourse is dominated by Silicon Valley and Information Technologies. It is time for publishers to focus on broader narratives.</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/it-is-time-to-talk-about-technology-differently-2085909f866?source=rss----252b18208b92---4">Continue reading on Wonk Bridge »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/it-is-time-to-talk-about-technology-differently-2085909f866?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2085909f866</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wonk-bridge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[silicon-valley]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yuji Develle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 Jan 2021 16:10:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-26T15:45:33.515Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Very Online Insurrection]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/a-very-online-insurrection-583f686b38c1?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/583f686b38c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[washington-dc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitol-riot]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jackson Oliver Webster]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Jan 2021 14:03:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-11T16:45:52.724Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zRCRAXwqkzo7emVM.jpg" /><figcaption>Credit: Mike Theiler — Reuters</figcaption></figure><p>Wednesday, as I took a break from the joys of my tenth straight month of remote work to eat lunch, I witnessed something I never thought I’d see. For only the second time in the history of the United States, the flag of an enemy army entered the nation’s capitol. However, <a href="https://www.senate.gov/artandhistory/history/common/generic/August_Burning_Washington.htm#:~:text=On%20August%2024%2C%201814%2C%20as,Mansion%2C%20and%20other%20local%20landmarks.&amp;text=Not%20until%201819%2C%20after%20a,Chamber%20in%20the%20U.S.%20Capitol">unlike in 1814</a>, this was not the result of a military defeat, but was instead a self-inflicted wound. We watched, in real time, as a unique form of political violence was unleashed the likes of which America had not seen since the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Shirts_(United_States)">Redemption era</a>. As much as January 6th was a disaster of disingenuous politics, it was, perhaps more importantly, a failure of our information space.</p><p>Before I continue, let’s pause to appreciate the gravity of what <em>could</em> <em>have</em> happened. The rioters were not allowed to remain in the Capitol long enough to do more serious property damage. Photos show some rioters came <a href="https://twitter.com/samdman95/status/1347292870487625729">equipped with zip-ties</a>, clearly hoping to take hostages. The Secret Service stopped that from happening. Despite the presence of multiple firearms, only one person was shot and killed, while four others died during the riot. This was potentially one of the most <a href="https://twitter.com/Reuters/status/1347231552472805383?s=20">serious breaches </a>of the security of confidential documents in recent US history. With unauthorized personnel inside the Capitol, any documents or systems stored in Representatives’ offices that were breached, including the Speaker’s, must be assumed to be compromised. <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/06/fbi-says-it-is-investigating-suspicious-devices-in-washington.html">Reports indicate</a> that two or more bombs were planted in Washington, one at the Republican National Committee, and a possible second at the headquarters of their Democratic counterparts. It’s unclear who did this, but without the intervention of the FBI and ATF, January 6th, 2021 could have been made even more infamous than it is now <a href="https://youtu.be/hHhf3v95lqU?t=20">destined to become</a>.</p><h3></h3><p>For me, the striking thing about so many of these images of rioters in the Capitol is that what they&#39;re doing - all of them - is creating content for social media. At least in their minds, the true seat of power is not actually in that building. It&#39;s online.</p><p>The first thing I noticed about the crowd or rioters was how ‘online’ its members were. <a href="https://twitter.com/kevinroose/status/1346920498387566592?s=20">I wasn’t the only one</a>. Pepe masks, Q banners, Punisher skulls, “Kekistan” flags…all the chatroom oddities that friends and colleagues in the information security space have joked about for years were suddenly manifesting in real life, in the Capitol, alongside dismaying <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2021/01/07/us/capitol-confederate-flag-fort-stevens/index.html">symbols</a> from the darkest days of our history. A <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/CJwCIMihh1X/?igshid=17aq1123l3swx">group of men</a> wore sweatshirts with an antisemitic logo whose implication is so heinous I won’t explain it here. Interspersed among campaign banners and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gadsden_flag#/media/File:Gadsden_flag.svg">Gadsden flags</a> were signs referencing “The Storm”, the great purge QAnon cultists believe will usher in a new age of religious enlightenment. The banner of the Shah’s Persia was carried down the National Mall. A video surfaced of a Delta flight from Salt Lake City to Washington where passengers chanted “traitor” upon recognizing Senator Mitt Romney was onboard, an internet comment section mob manifesting in kinetic space. Rioters interviewed were confused their “revolution” was not met with jubilation from DC security personnel, as they instead faced tear gas and mace. Columnist <a href="https://twitter.com/cwarzel/status/1346886184350347264">Charlie Warzel described</a> it as a “crash of brain-poisoned conspiracies against the rocks of human reality”. Mushy brain worms IRL.</p><h3></h3><p>Who could ever have predicted such a horrible thing would happen, said no one who had been remotely paying attention</p><p>Beyond my initial disgust, my feeling was, sadly, one of vindication. <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/satanic-panic-2-facebook-boogaloo-2e40e8c2c9e7">On</a> <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/turf-wars-astroturfing-the-birth-of-americas-covid-19-protests-1465ef532ec0">this</a> <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/https-medium-com-wonk-bridge-cesspool-of-hate-cf0dc2d6b1af">site</a> and <a href="https://rusi.org/publication/rusi-defence-systems/far-right-radicalisation-pipeline-and-state-war-fighting-capacity">others</a> I’ve argued that online conspiracy theories aren’t just bizarre entertainment: they’re a threat to the physical security of citizens and to the integrity of our institutions. I cannot think of a more poignant example than what happened in Washington on Wednesday.</p><h4>What is to be done?</h4><p>The short answer, of course, is I Don’t Know. It seems to me posing that question would be a bit like asking a man whose house is about to be engulfed by a tsunami whether the city should’ve build a seawall. <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-us-2020-54910344">Truth decay</a> is well under way, and divisiveness is here to stay. But I do think a productive thing we can collectively do would be to shift our discourse around social media, free speech, and disinformation to better ground it in the realities we face today.</p><p>In the information space, we do not apply our principles equally. Free speech reigns supreme for some ideologies, while others are the targets of armies of <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/16/21021005/google-youtube-moderators-ptsd-accenture-violent-disturbing-content-interviews-video">overworked content moderators</a>. Certain types of dangerous radicalism, namely Islamist jihadism, are, rightfully, suppressed in order to make the information space a safer place. Social media companies work effectively with governments and law enforcement agencies to remove extremist propaganda from some sources, but <a href="https://theconversation.com/qanon-and-the-storm-of-the-u-s-capitol-the-offline-effect-of-online-conspiracy-theories-152815">drag their heals</a> in combatting <a href="https://www.bellingcat.com/news/americas/2021/01/07/the-making-of-qanon-a-crowdsourced-conspiracy/">others</a>. The online movements that created the chaos on Capitol Hill Wednesday <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/how-social-media-made-the-trump-insurrection-a-reality">were not taken seriously early enough</a> to prevent us from reaching this unfortunate result.</p><p>Wednesday’s violence was <a href="https://twitter.com/ncri_io/status/1347275150736183296">coordinated in the open on Facebook</a>, and the escalation and entrenchment of extremist rhetoric in right-wing social media spaces has been obvious to even casual observers for years. Due to Facebook and Twitter’s willful inaction over the last three years, QAnon and related conspiracies have spread like wildfire on social media, as “normies” come into increasing contact with die-hards on these popular platforms.</p><p>The mainstream has become exposed to more and more extremist rhetoric. This can be seen in <em>New York Times</em> journalist Kevin Roose’s <a href="https://twitter.com/facebookstop10?lang=en">“Facebook’s Top 10” project</a>, which uses Facebook’s own data to determine the ten posts each day with the most reach. Even a cursory review of the listings reveals a trend. Over the past year, the site has not only become more right-leaning — unsurprising, as its average user age increases — it has also embraced a more conspiracy-laden segment of the right-wing media ecosystem. Whereas the list of popular posts used to be dominated by mainstream news outlets, <em>Fox News</em>’s posts are now regularly outdone by grifters and conspiracy theorists like Dan Bongino, Newsmax, Dinesh D’Souza, and various extremist-adjacent grassroots accounts. In other words, the Overton Window of the online base has shifted under the mainstream conservative media’s feet. This radicalization has increased since the November 2020 election, with viewers shifting from Fox News to more radical sources like OAN and Newsmax. The normies are moving further up the conspiracy supply chain, approaching farm-to-table wackadoodlery.</p><p>This spiralling online discourse didn’t happen on <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/fake-news-spread-whatsapp-indian-americans-plays-stealth-role-us-elect-rcna166">encrypted group chats</a>, as many disinformation experts feared would become the new norm. It happened in public, on Facebook groups whose content was perfectly visible to moderators and safety teams. Action was eventually taken against the most extreme of these groups, but <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/18/technology/qanon-is-still-spreading-on-facebook-despite-a-ban.html">only in December 2020</a>, after the damage to the information space had already been done.</p><h4>Leaving Freedomism Behind</h4><p>The issue at stake here is not “freedom of speech”, nor any of the other freedoms afforded citizens under the First Amendment. The issue is freedom of <em>virality</em>. The Bill of Rights does not explicitly permit the unfettered projection of information of any kind whatsoever. It does not force social media companies to treat <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/23/mark-zuckerberg-alexandria-ocasio-cortez-facebook-cambridge-analytica">all political advertising</a> as equally good-faith. It does not prevent private companies from enforcing their trust and safety policies however they see fit, as I’m sure libertarians intent on defending the freedom of private enterprise would agree.</p><p>There is a definitional distinction between the ability to express an idea and the ability to broadcast it to millions. In the <a href="https://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/titles/peter-pomerantsev/this-is-not-propaganda/9781541762138/">20th century</a>, the enemy of democratic societies was totalitarian suppression: information wanted to be free. Today, however, most meaningful barriers to accessing and consuming information have been <a href="https://theconversation.com/too-much-information-how-a-data-deluge-leaves-us-struggling-to-make-up-our-minds-44674">obliterated</a>. Legally-speaking, thought and speech have likely never been freer, and access to knowledge has never been so democratized. Instead of an anachronistic debate about the merits of free speech, we need to come to terms with our new reality.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/the-russians-manipulated-our-elections-we-helped/2020/04/23/e44e9e76-5742-11ea-9000-f3cffee23036_story.html">battle-lines</a> have been redrawn. The unregulated dissemination of information on viral, engagement-based platforms can in fact be the <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/11/23/how-to-stop-a-power-grab">enemy</a> of <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/how-pro-trump-islamophobe-laura-loomer-got-famous-on-the-internet">free expression</a> and self-government when bad actors game the algorithms to spread violent and hateful ideology. The incentive structures of our information space are spurring on the worst impulses in our society, <a href="https://www.journalism.org/2020/07/30/americans-who-mainly-get-their-news-on-social-media-are-less-engaged-less-knowledgeable/">not keeping us better informed</a>. We are <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-twitter-echo-chamber-confirmation-bias/">suffocating</a> <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/136272/what-were-blogs-death-gawker-blogging">informed debate</a>, not encouraging it. Something needs to change.</p><h3></h3><p>I can&#39;t tell you how surreal it is to watch these platforms completely reverse themselves in the span of 24 hours, after years of insisting that their inaction was rooted in principles rather than convenience.</p><p>As companies have belatedly <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/technology/capitol-twitter-facebook-trump.html">begun taking stronger measures</a>, we have to ask ourselves if the discussion we’ve had over the last four years about free speech online was even genuine at all? Did tech moguls mean what they said when <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MTpd7YOnyU">waxing poetic</a> about protecting free expression? In light of Wednesday’s reversals, it certainly seems to have been more strategic than philosophical. The Platforms have finally drawn a line in the sand, but somehow they only managed to draw that line in the aftermath of the sack of the US Capitol.</p><p>We must abandon our rhetorical “freedomism” and return to a more complex understanding of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Freedoms">what “freedom” really means</a>. Preserving liberty and justice for all in our modern society does not mean simply allowing anyone to do anything at any time. As we’ve seen vividly illustrated in Washington, words are not without consequence: they can drive people to take extreme actions. Once an individual has bought into an alternate version of reality, fact checking, flagging, and counter-messaging become ineffective. By that point in the cycle of radicalization, the “marketplace of ideas” is useless, at least certainly as it has been constructed in the age of the viral social internet. Radicalism will always be in demand.</p><h4>An Eternal Pessimist’s Attempt at a Silver Lining</h4><p>Wednesday’s events profoundly effected me, both as an American and as a proponent of liberal democracy. When I was an intern in the Library of Congress, I walked through those same halls that were desecrated by a mob. As Americans, we’re raised to remember the men, like my great uncles, sons of working class immigrants, who died fighting tyranny “over there”. It is painful, though not surprising, that the <a href="https://twitter.com/BGrueskin/status/1346973464910028805?s=20">same ugly politics</a> they gave their lives to defeat has a <a href="https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/capitol-trump-insurrection-explosions/">receptive audience</a> at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herrenvolk_democracy">home</a>.</p><p>For many in my generation, the last four years have profoundly shaken our confidence in the strength of our political system. However, I believe that’s a good thing. The first step in solving a problem is recognizing there is one. We’re not going to make it through this crisis wearing rose-tinted glasses. If we don’t draw the right conclusions from this difficult period, I worry we will slide further into a place none of us want to contemplate. It’s unclear where we go from here. All that I know is that the vitriol unleashed on Capitol Hill isn’t going anywhere.</p><p><strong><em>Jackson Oliver Webster</em></strong><em> is a politics and security researcher based in Los Angeles. He is, unfortunately, on Twitter @joliverwebster</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=583f686b38c1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/a-very-online-insurrection-583f686b38c1">A Very Online Insurrection</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Kindness Game: A Review of “Kind Words”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/the-kindness-game-a-review-of-kind-words-db367c66c0?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db367c66c0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kindness-of-strangers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pc-gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kindness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oliver Meredith Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Dec 2020 12:04:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-24T12:04:50.959Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>Kind Words is not a meditation game, but a kindness game for which meditation is the optimal strategy.</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1jg2qe37-B2uO6Mr" /></figure><p><em>Kind Words </em>is a game without winners and a social network without identities. The only objective is to show kindness to strangers, and its social functions and gameplay are the opposite of the most insidious features of modern social networks that make them simultaneously anti-social, depressing <em>and </em>impossible to quit. For this reason, I consider it a prototype for a type of system that we might build to foster broader, more profound and more positive-sum interactions between people.</p><h3>Opening: Highs without Subsequent Lows</h3><p>The thinker Naval Ravikant identified a pleasing set, “highs that don’t lead to subsequent lows”:</p><h3></h3><p>Highs that don&#39;t lead to subsequent lows:* Meditation, gratitude, prayer, journaling, unconditional love.* Yoga, exercise, play, nature walks.* Creating art, reading for fun, singing, poetry.* Practicing a craft, pursuing curiosity, work done for its own sake, flow.</p><p>This, I compare to social media, which contains many of the facets that ought to make it <em>a high without a subsequent low</em>: community, conversation, information, reading; but, I argue, these media in their current configuration deliver sorbet highs and pudding lows. They encourage us to misunderstand difficult people, ignore neutral people, flatter those we’re fond of, and hate ourselves.</p><p>And they make us come back for more. One might ask, can we create social media that would be less insidious? This, of course, raises the follow-up question: would such media gain any ground or, like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXyS-74sRTE">Louis Theroux said of Scientology</a>, are the insidious parts what we actually like?</p><p><em>Kind Words</em> appears to have created something akin to a social network, but which is also a high without a subsequent low. This, I theorize, it does through a combination of thoughtful mood and emotional queues, careful user interface choices, alongside a social design that lends itself to unimpeded generosity. I believe that Kind Words, thus, has prototyped some of the features that we need to implement in our networks to promote better relations among individual people and as a society.</p><p>Further, the philosopher <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_b4qKv1Ctv8&amp;t=7826s">Daniel Schmachtenberger observed</a> how a great many of our conflicts as a species result from our having differential degrees of affinity with different groups of people: we care for our family more than we do others, we find it easier to go to war with people from different countries, we smear those far from us on the political <em>spectrum.</em></p><p>Schmachtenberger suggests that Buddhism may hold something of a solution to this: Metta meditation, the act of directing good will first to those for which it is easy to do so, then steadily increasing the circle to more and more challenging people, possibly even to a whole city or the whole world. My thesis is that <em>Kind Words </em>offers this sort of training, through its gameplay. This is, firstly, why it is HAL and, secondly, why social structures like this show us how we might build new systems (on-line and off-line) that foster more collaboration and interactions of a more positive-sum nature.</p><h3>Explanation of Gameplay</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*niHRApR6vswx5OCD" /></figure><p><em>Kind Words</em> is a platform for sending kindness to real people, via writing. In this respect, it shares a great deal with social networks, such as Facebook. However, the available actions are fewer, but more direct and personal.</p><p>There are three main actions:</p><p>Public posts:</p><ul><li>One can write messages of kindness, which everyone on the platform can see.</li><li>One can write about one’s uncertainties and struggles via posts in the same format, which, again, everyone can see.</li></ul><p>Private responses:</p><ul><li>One can respond to other people’s problems and challenges by writing them kind messages, which only they can see.</li></ul><p>Stickers:</p><ul><li>One can send a choice from a selection of odd, charming stickers, either alongside one’s response or as a sort of “thank you” for the kindness one receives.</li></ul><p>Visually, one’s avatar sits in a room, writing, while the messages and stickers are delivered by a charming deer, who also introduces new tracks from the game’s lovely soundtrack. There is a little more to it, but those are the broad strokes.</p><p>Hereafter I will describe what to me seems the heart of the game: the subtle interactions and design choices that make <em>Kind Words work,</em> and which earn each one of its creators the title assumed by Buckminster Fuller and Ted Nelson: <em>systems humanist.</em></p><h3>Emotional Valence</h3><p>The emotional valence of the whole game is, perhaps, the first thing that the player will notice. The colors are warm, slightly muted, the resolution and detail is a little low-fi: this gives the game a natural, reassuring feel, like a combination of autumn leaves and candle-light.</p><p>The presence of the deer is particularly calming: your first mission, upon entering the game, is to write the postmaster deer a letter of encouragement: the creature encourages benign action on the part of the user. To be anything less than cordial, encouraging and magnanimous, and thus to implicate the deer in delivery feels like swearing in front of some combination of a child and a sweet elderly relative.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-cnz1lDabvF1LBZG" /></figure><p>Of course, then there’s the music: as I mentioned in the introduction, I can’t do it justice. The score (available on <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPDsC2suXsI&amp;list=OLAK5uy_ktw-lfEdYU2D37_aJhxSlKvhCC3ThL0dM">YouTube</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPDsC2suXsI&amp;list=OLAK5uy_ktw-lfEdYU2D37_aJhxSlKvhCC3ThL0dM">BandCamp</a> for those that want to give it a listen) has a similar character to the deer: it is fairly uncomplicated, sweet, a little nostalgic. It is, however, never mawkish, never boring or derivative. These factors: the deer, the colors and the music, make for a synthesis that almost immediately puts one in a benign and creative mindset: so much so that my wife and I sometimes activate the game in our shared office to enjoy these aspects of it while doing other things.</p><h3>The True Social Medium</h3><p>As I mentioned above, <em>Kind Words </em>is a social network, but contains features in precise opposition to the most insidious aspects of social media.</p><h4>Infinite Scroll</h4><p>Firstly, there’s no infinite scroll. This is one of the most depressing aspects of Facebook, Twitter and YouTube: one scrolls and scrolls, looking for that one <em>thing </em>that will provide the entertainment or interest that one is seeking. The problem isn’t that the available content is functionally infinite: the scope and variety of material online and on social media means that there’s more to challenge us in ways that we didn’t expect.</p><p>Rather, the problem is that with no end to the content, no pagination, or no need to go somewhere else to find other things, one easily slips into a passive mode of engagement, driven by fear of missing out on something of value below the fold. Like a debased currency, the content that one witnesses plummets in value the more you scroll, as the ratio of real effort and engagement to content gets more <em>off. </em>Eventually, you get to the equivalent of having an unnecessary serving of food at the all-you-can-eat buffet, <em>because it’s free.</em></p><p>As we do so, most of us are barely conscious, instead we’re in an odd state of disengagement (not really reading, not really watching or remembering) combined with overstimulation (in just a few minutes on Facebook, say, one might see more human faces than one of your ancestors might see in a year).</p><p>We browse, we never find what we’re looking for, and when we finally tear ourselves away, we’re <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2013/08/19/213568763/researchers-facebook-makes-us-sadder-and-less-satisfied">sadder than when we started</a>.</p><p>I think I’m right in saying that <em>Kind Words</em> has no scrolling. There are many lists that the user will need to access: of requests for help from other users, one’s own requests, the messages in one’s inbox, one’s stickers, all of which are navigated with <em>next </em>and <em>previous </em>buttons. The grass isn’t greener below the fold, because there is no below the fold. Meanwhile, there are no images: no images in messages or requests, or profile images, so no Facebook-style overstimulation.</p><h4>Notifications</h4><p>Meanwhile, there are no read receipts on messages, and no notifications when you’re in the middle of something. Facebook, of course, is famous for its little red integers on the <em>message </em>button, say, that give you a little dopamine hit and make it almost impossible to carry on what you’re doing until you’ve seen who had what to say. There was a time, say, two years ago, when I and others confirmed that the notification system on Facebook was reliably faulty: phantom notifications would come up, only to reveal that there was nothing new. This only made the platform more addictive, in responding to a given notification, one was actually gambling on whether it was real or not.</p><p><em>Kind Words </em>has nothing of this. You write your messages asking for help: you don’t know who read them, how many people read them, and what they think. You write your responses and are as kind as you can be, but you don’t know whether the recipient read them, what they thought, and they can’t reply. There’s no Facebook-style waiting while holding your breath for the read-receipt that tells you that they’ve read the message, or, worse, once they’re read the message, for their reply. Nor is there the tantalizing plunge of Twitter, when, after tweeting, one waits to see how many likes and retweets one earns.</p><p><em>Kind Words </em>pegs the satisfaction that one gets against the work that you do to spread kindness, rather than recognition. I derive my enjoyment of the game from the creativity of responding to people’s requests through writing, and of the feeling that I may have done something to help or bring someone happiness.</p><p>The closest thing that <em>Kind Words</em> has to anything like a trophy is the stickers, which users can send as thanks for kind words. Because they are trophy-like, I enjoy the stickers less than the other functions, but they <em>are</em> charming. Meanwhile, unless you only answer one request, you don’t know who sent them. Thus, game makes it very hard to keep score, so there’s never the feeling of “where’s my sticker?”</p><p>This imbues the game with a sense of selfless virtue for its own sake, best expressed by the Tao Te Ching:</p><blockquote><em>When success is achieved, he seeks no recognition.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Because he does not claim for the credit, hence shall not lose it.</em></blockquote><h4>No Conversation</h4><p>I am, of course, pro conversation: my point, however, is that <em>Kind Words</em> has created a well-functioning, socially engaged community, but with no chat, public posts, comments, or any back and forth at all. Thus, one can’t write a message and hope for a reward in the form of a reply, nor can a seemingly benign social post turn ugly when an unwanted connection shows up: again, the highest reward in <em>Kind Words </em>is the satisfaction one gets from doing one’s best.</p><p>Obviously, it’s neither possible nor desirable for all social media to be structured like this, <em>but </em>the fact that <em>Kind Words</em> made this structure <em>work</em> raises the question of what other highly social but non-reciprocal structures we could create: Twitter but if you didn’t know who liked your tweets or who follows whom; Instagram but when you like a photo, the user whose photo you liked doesn’t know which photo it was and who liked it.</p><h4>The Algorithm</h4><p>Of course, <em>Kind Words </em>must have some automated systems to ensure the game’s proper function. <em>Algorithm, </em>is used both as a trashcan for all manner of things we don’t understand, and as a scapegoat onto which to cast our fears about tech. Algorithms need not be scary or recondite, however: they can be simple, complex, and seek any purpose a human might seek. With that in mind, the <em>Kind Words</em> algorithm <em>appears</em> to be benign and equitable in its design: I’ve never had a request for kindness go unanswered, nor has any one request received an unreadably large volume of responses.</p><p>It would <em>appear </em>that the system modulates the visibility of requests so as to smooth out the volume of responses we get. Compare this to the Facebook and Google algorithms, which further promote material that is already successful, leading to power-law distributed success, often called the Matthew Principle. As with wealth, networks, success, the more you have, the greater your ability to get more: this is not inherently unethical but there are some undesirable features.</p><p>One is the fact that a <em>random</em> event can confer a small advantage which, compounded, results in huge profits. Another is that a large incumbent is hard to unseat by a worthy newcomer. Finally, effects like this can incentivize lowest-common-denominator behaviour: on Twitter, say, one will generate orders of magnitude greater attention by <a href="https://time.com/5390750/twitter-follower-counts/">appealing to tribal loyalties</a> and with clickbait language, through the resulting retweets.</p><p><em>Kind Words </em>saves us from the lowest-common-denominator effect because no matter how hard you try, any public post will likely get no more than four replies. Furthermore, on <em>Kind Words, </em>your reply will be seen by <em>one </em>person, and other people will only come into contact with it if the recipient copies it somewhere else or shows someone their screen: so you don’t have to optimize it for sharing, you can make it as complex, challenging and as ecumenical as you will.</p><p>Fundamentally, I’m not saying that <em>everything </em>should be redistributive like <em>Kind Words</em>, only,</p><ol><li>That this game seems to have created a redistribution algorithm that actually works</li><li>It seems worth experimenting with this sort of structure so as to raise the tenor of our conversations.</li></ol><h4>Moderation</h4><p>I feel as though I have to apologize for this part: <em>Kind Words </em>is moderated. Perhaps it is as though any problem insoluble by design and systems, leaving us to fall back on human intervention, represents something of a failure. Perhaps. That said, without popping the hood, it’s impossible to tell the extent to which <em>Kind Words </em>is held together by an army of moderators, or whether this measure is a minor corrective. One can say, however, that as a user the experience <em>is</em> unsullied by trolls and abusers.</p><h3>The True Video Game</h3><p>I’m not really a video game guy; they’re fun, but I <em>fear </em>them for the extent to which they so perfectly stimulate and manipulate the mind. <em>Kind Words</em> subverts this and other patterns that I dislike about games, but which I thought were essentially part of what video games <em>are.</em></p><h4>Underwhelming Dopamine Quests</h4><p>Video games are compelling for a number of reasons, one could divide these features into <em>cheap</em> and <em>expensive</em>: expensive reasons are intrigue, puzzles, action, plot; cheap reasons are those features that have the player do things that take longer or more effort than they assumed, and which deliver a reward, but less than anticipated, keeping you reaching for satisfaction. This is the underwhelming dopamine quest: it’s instrumental in keeping one in front of the computer or console, until one finds that it’s dark outside and, to return to Naval’s aphorism, that one feels a sense of shame for how long one played. Games figured out how to do this first, of course, then social media caught on and gave us their dopamine quest in the form of the infinite scrolling news feed, as mentioned earlier.</p><p><em>Kind Words </em>offers no cheap rewards, the only objective is to project kindness to others. You do so by sending writing and stickers. One walks away from the game, therefore, with a sense of fulfillment, not shame.</p><h4>Real Objectives</h4><p>Another of the reasons that I rarely play games is that the rewards themselves are, usually, virtual: to complete a level, defeat a boss, etc. This was always unsatisfactory to me, in that I wanted to walk a way having actually created something new and lasting, and feel guilty otherwise. This is a personal foible<em>, </em>not a value judgement. That said, if you feel something similar,<em> Kind Words </em>is for you.</p><h4>Positive-Sum-Games</h4><p>Finally, <em>Kind Words </em>is profound because it is a rare example of a <em>positive-sum</em> game. Some background: <em>positive-sum, zero-sum, </em>etc. are terms of game theory. Zero-sum games are those that have only one winner and to the extent that someone wins, someone else must lose: football (either sort), snap, <em>Mario Kart</em>, etc. are examples of <em>zero sum</em> games.</p><p>While diverting, I find this sort of game miserable precisely because one wins at the expense of others, and because all the most interesting and stimulating interactions that our species has developed exist in the <em>positive-sum </em>realm, wherein all parties can benefit: <strong>capitalism</strong> (wherein the seller benefits in that they prefer the money and the buyer because they want the goods, and where ecosystems of companies [sometimes in competition] profit more than if there were fewer of them) or <strong>the arts</strong> (wherein, say, two musicians play together for the first time and bring forth new ideas, benefiting both and at the expense of none).</p><p>This is why I’m so confused that most societies induct school children into competitive sports, which seems to get people into the zero-sum mindset that has more in common with<em> war</em> than it does with the fantastically generative civil societies that emerge when people learn that they have more to gain by collaborating.</p><p>Clearly, two players enjoying a winner-takes-all video game match are engaged in a positive-sum dynamic, to the extent that they’re both enjoying themselves. I, perhaps quite idiosyncratically, just prefer things when they are positive-sum on all levels.</p><p>Suffice it to say that I love <em>Kind Words </em>for the fact that you benefit to the extent that you show kindness and request kindness honestly: it is a microcosm of the pattern without which our species would not have moved an iota beyond the predator-prey-nature-struggle in which one lives but goes nowhere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*O-Jl6Usf7As83fsM.jpg" /><figcaption>Image from Games for Change, derived from Kind Words</figcaption></figure><h3>Metta</h3><p>These facets, in combination, allow <em>Kind Words</em> to do something very interesting: increase a person’s affinity for strangers.</p><p>At risk of oversimplifying, perhaps the next frontier in interpersonal relationships will be humanity gaining the ability to feel an sense of kinship towards an arbitrarily large group of people. Put it this way, if you’re a normal person, you probably feel a very strong bond with your family, a powerful yet less intense one with your friends, still less towards casual acquaintances or perhaps your colleagues at work, and so on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ptbJfCyxtkxM401S" /></figure><p>Ultimately, it’s possible to go so far away from you that you either don’t care about a given person, perhaps even to the extent that you would kill them or sanction their death. This state of affairs, which is of course quite natural, makes it possible for us, psychologically, to ignore the homeless person in the street, to do business with warlords, even to flatten cities during war: these actions would be impossible if we could project the level of affinity that we normally feel toward those closest to us, around the world.</p><p>I couldn’t claim that some <em>universal </em>brotherhood would solve all our issues; just looking at the beastly way in which some siblings treat each other is enough to eliminate that possibility. However, the ability to broaden our circle of whom we ought to <em>wish well </em>ought to improve the way we relate to each other, at lest a little.</p><p>I heard this idea first expressed by Daniel Schmachtenberger in conversation with Eric Weinstein on <em>The Portal </em>podcast. His recommendation is that we use the tradition of Metta meditation to do so.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F_b4qKv1Ctv8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D_b4qKv1Ctv8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F_b4qKv1Ctv8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d6a24cf971c367a28585f8245900e653/href">https://medium.com/media/d6a24cf971c367a28585f8245900e653/href</a></iframe><p>There are variations, but generally Metta works thus: you begin by sending good wishes to someone whom it is easy to do so (some versions begin with the self, some begin with some other individual whom it is easy to love), then to someone about whom one feels neutral, then to a person for whom it is difficult, then even to large groups of people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OmW4b16u05Wk3wH-" /></figure><p>This is the practice of developing the ability to send kindness and well-wishes to <em>anyone </em>one chooses, not just those for whom it is easy due to accidents of birth, political affiliation, nationality and so on. There’s nothing wrong with loving one’s friends, but there are more novel benefits to be gained from loving those one has never met, or those who one is tempted to hate: this includes the fact that one is much less likely to be unkind or boorish by accident if one is practices wishing difficult people well.</p><p>In essence, the claim here is that it is difficult to act with a global ethic because our affections are provincial, and that we can broaden our affections by practicing the art of showing kindness to those <em>who are not close to us.</em></p><p>Does that remind you of something? <em>Kind Words,</em> hopefully. This game is the practice of sending kindness specifically to people we do not know: if we met them they might be our friends, forgettable, or they might repulse us, but on <em>Kind Words </em>we know only that they’re human and that they write; it is Metta meditation, except taken a step further, with the kindness actually expressed to the relevant people. It strips away all temptations to make it about <em>us</em>: personal aggrandisement and popularity are impossible, the available actions in the game and the rewards are practically the same, the value of each interaction is prevented from being debased by oversupply.</p><p>Meditation, especially as expressed through practices like Metta, is an old patch on our ancient operating system. Computers, as Ted Nelson taught us, have no innate character, they scale whatever particular aspects of ourselves, intentionally or otherwise; created cynically or naively, games and social media scale those traits which give us tribal thinking and egoism. Created intelligently and in a spirit of humanism, games and social media can scale the kindness, simplicity and humbleness required to solve the civilisation-level problems that face us.</p><blockquote><em>But I have three precious things which I prize and hold fast. The first is gentleness; the second is economy; and the third is shrinking from taking precedence of others.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>With that gentleness I can be bold; with that economy I can be liberal; shrinking from taking precedence of others, I can become a vessel of the highest honour. Now-a-days they give up gentleness and are all for being bold; economy, and are all for being liberal; the hindmost place, and seek only to be foremost; — (of all which the end is) death.</em></blockquote><p><a href="http://www.gutenberg.org/files/216/216-h/216-h.htm"><em>— Tao Te Ching</em></a></p><ol><li>I mention the lovely <em>Kind Words Soundtrack</em> by Clark Aboud briefly but do not do it justice.</li><li>Being on Steam, Linux users like me aren’t well-catered for: Steam supports only Ubuntu Linux, so I (using Fedora Linux alongside 1.2 million others) have to run an Ubuntu virtual machine. Kind Words is good enough to justify the trouble, but the trouble is <em>totally avoidable.</em></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db367c66c0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/the-kindness-game-a-review-of-kind-words-db367c66c0">The Kindness Game: A Review of “Kind Words”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Some Thoughts on “The Mechanics Bad Faith”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/some-thoughts-on-the-mechanics-bad-faith-de59e89a4d00?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de59e89a4d00</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sartre]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bad-faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[discourse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ruoji Tang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Dec 2020 15:33:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-11T18:28:51.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Some Thoughts on “The Mechanics of Bad Faith”</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*W0muT_r3HUN7Qatp.jpg" /><figcaption>Wim Botha, <em>Bitis gabonica &amp; Ophiophagus</em>, 2008. Courtesy of Stevenson, Cape Town / Johannesburg, South Africa. © 2008.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>This piece was written as a response to the article </strong><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/a-short-introduction-to-the-mechanics-of-bad-faith-6b66fa6f3ba7"><strong><em>A Short Introduction to the Mechanics of Bad Faith</em></strong></a><strong> on Wonk Bridge.</strong></p><p>In my colleague Oliver Cox’s thought-provoking essay, <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/a-short-introduction-to-the-mechanics-of-bad-faith-6b66fa6f3ba7">“A Short Introduction to the Mechanics of Bad Faith”</a>, he describes bad faith as a rogue element in a communication system and proposes a set of new ways for dealing with bad faith. While I take his essay to be an ambitious, serious proposal for better, more civilized forms of online discourse, I rather think he’s shortchanging the concept of “bad faith.” In what follows, by drawing loosely on a few thinkers, I will outline an understanding of “bad faith” that treats the concept as a social structure of discursive engagement and not a quality belonging to individual expressions or actors. Along the way, I will layer example on example to draw out some of the payoffs of this understanding.</p><p>In defining “bad faith,” Oliver writes: “What is a bad-faith actor? What is bad faith, for that matter? Bad faith is to act in ways that spoof the normal modes of interaction, such as in debate, conversation, commerce, while actually pursuing hidden, selfish motives or even hoping to disrupt the operation of the system in which they operate.”</p><p>Here, my colleague is working with a definition of bad faith that is more or less interchangeable with deception. The “bad faith actor,” for all intents and purposes, is a liar who aims to “spoof” or “disrupt” normal modes of communication. I do not think I’m being reductive when I say that his essay adopts a kind of diplomat’s (or even a forum manager’s) point of view. In Oliver’s account, what matters when dealing with bad faith is reducing the friction and keeping the channels of communication open at all costs. Bad faith actors trouble us not because of <em>what they are saying, </em>but because they disrupt the <em>system </em>of communication. As always, the goal is to ensure that the system<em> </em>works properly.</p><p>In response, I’d like to point out that we inherit the concept of “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_faith">bad faith</a>” not from systems thinking, but from a tradition of Christian messianism and its requisite, secular counterpart — an atheistic humanism defined by radical social responsibility. In this vein, the call to attend to “bad faith” has generally emanated from self-proclaimed <em>outsiders </em>who have ethical commitments that supersede the normative. As such distinctions between good or bad faith is often the province of the Marxist radical and the Christian zealot — much more so than the diplomat and the systems architect. If we are to take the concept of “bad faith” seriously, we should also be brave enough to examine it on these terms.</p><p>To offer a provocative metaphor — “good faith” and “bad faith” work in the Matrix, but they’re not native to the Matrix<em>. </em>That is why they’re interesting to us — <em>even if we’re secretly backing the Matrix. </em>If bad faith disrupts the communication system, the noise is certainly worth listening to.</p><p><strong>On Listening and Speaking</strong></p><p>To distinguish between our two perspectives, I’d like to begin by challenging some of the assumptions my colleague makes about what exactly happens<em> </em>in a conversation between two people. As I see it, Oliver subordinates the social dimension of discussion to the machine metaphor he deploys. Oliver writes: “in essence, one should only transmit well-formed data but, if one receives malformed data that is nonetheless decipherable, one should parse it anyway.”</p><p>He rephrases the imperative this way: “(what you transmit) you should maximize obedience to the standard; in the domain you do not control (what others transmit) you should maximize the total information that you decipher.” Under this imperative, Oliver prescribes these rules of conduct: “When speaking: be clear”; “When listening: be charitable.”</p><p>By “well-formed data,” I think my colleague means transparent data or rather, data that presents limited interpretative possibilities<em>. </em>While I think this is the case for receivers and transmitters — I submit that mutual understanding between humans is a more complex and open-ended game<em>. </em>The “data” that matters most in a conversation is rarely the what is explicitly said. Often, it’s what is surfaced in the conversation’s interpretive subtext. The silences, the omissions, the evasions and equivocations — in other words the “data” that require interpretive latitude<em> </em>matter as much, if not more, than the face-value exchange on offer.</p><p>But let’s back up. Why, we might ask, is it worth listening to someone in the first place? After all, not all data is helpful or even relevant. Here, I submit that we <em>listen because we</em> want to know <em>something in particular, even if we’re not sure what. </em>I was lately reminded of Roland Barthes’ description of the phenomenology of waiting. The lover by the phone, having received no signs from anyone,<em> </em>nevertheless waits and waits <em>as if</em> having received an order not to move. Far from <em>maximizing the information received, </em>the absence of a transmission can absorb our interpretive faculties while excessive responses from the wrong one is unlikely to be processed.</p><p>The salesman knows that a “no” can mean “never” or “yes with time” — not because anyone is being deceitful<em>, </em>but because the nature of every conversation pertains to an inquiry, regardless of whether it is made explicit. This interpretive latitude vis-à-vis the question at hand is key, not because it guarantees a specific point of arrival, but because it underpins the wealth of interpretive possibilities available.</p><p>With this in mind, while intended as a gesture of generosity, I rather think treating “bad faith” as the equivalent of “mal-formed data” reduces the question of good or bad faith to something that<em> </em>is incidental to the original inquiry. Often, when bad faith is at stake, its determination is essential to the conversation — <em>it is the exact thing that we want to know.</em></p><p>Being “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity">charitable</a>” while listening is admirable and good manners, but it’s helpful to remember that charity can easily reflect back as feigned naivety or willful denial, a refusal to address an important subject because of a cynical calculus. Far from an attire for all occasions as my colleague suggests, the imperative to be generous takes as much interpretive liberty with the other as anything els<em>e.</em></p><p><strong>Whose Bad Faith Is It Anyway?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9eWoXb7zC7-QmDRZ.jpg" /><figcaption>“Bad Faith”, Banksy</figcaption></figure><p>For my part, I am less interested in the rigorous task of rooting out bad apples from good ones than the kind of interpretive game “bad faith” describes. Against the insistence that bad faith is a practice by an individual, I hope to show that “bad faith” is a distinctly <em>social</em> game and not a game with a clear, third-person objective (ball in hoop). We might take dating as a model — <em>knowing what the other is thinking, even if it’s a mere guess, is the only way to “orient” ourselves.</em></p><p>Instead of rushing to “deal with” bad faith, let’s begin by<em> </em>amending our working definition of “bad faith.”</p><p>It might be evident already that I plan to route my understanding of “bad faith” through Jean-Paul Sartre. I realize that at a time when systemic and structural exploitation dominates critical discourse, Sartre and his emphasis on personal responsibility is a hard sell. When all we want is “better systems,” virtues like “authenticity” appear embarrassingly naïve at best and an exercise in <em>mere style </em>at worst. Yet Sartre still has something to say about the <em>social </em>structure of “bad faith” — or more precisely, about the interplay of “accuser” and “accused” when bad faith is in question.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FxxrmOHJQRSs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DxxrmOHJQRSs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FxxrmOHJQRSs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/858382af34d60d92be6e49d27a086bb6/href">https://medium.com/media/858382af34d60d92be6e49d27a086bb6/href</a></iframe><p>In <em>Being and Nothingness, </em>Sartre is clear about what bad faith is not. Unlike legal and quotidian definitions, Sartrean “mauvaise foi” is never mere deception. To act in bad faith is never to lie. The liar knows the truth — he deceives the other in order to secure an outcome (he sells someone a bad car knowingly, he negotiates peace terms when he’s planning a surprise attack, and so on.) Acting in bad faith is also never a mistake — an error based on bad information.</p><p>Bad faith is first and foremost a form of self-deception [<em>mensonge à soi</em>]. To the observer, it takes the form of: I <em>do not wish to know the truth of what I am. </em>Oliver is right to point out that “bad faith” always involves an accusation of bad faith<em>, </em>but such an accusation is not always direct and never unidirectional. It’s important to note that to accuse (to demand that the other “come clean”), and to look away and feign ignorance (don’t ask don’t tell), both draw us into the game of self-deception.</p><p>Sartre’s own work admits how much the demand to know can itself be in bad faith<em>. </em>This is particularly evident in his controversial example of the secretive homosexual who feigns interest in women to his impatient friend. Here, the epistemology of bad faith overlaps with the epistemology of the closet. The friend might think, “we both know what you are — you can at least tell me, between us.” Yet it’s not clear whether the demand to <em>own up </em>to one’s sexuality<em> </em>can legitimately be made to someone else (or even to ourselves) — how are we sure that we are reading the right signs? What is it for one’s sexuality to be definitive? In a different vein, what are we demanding when “coming out of the closet” — for much of the twentieth century at least — was to accept a diminished life?</p><p>Bad faith speaks to the split within social discourse between an insistent demand to “out” the truth and the game of plausible interpretations that evade affirmation — the “evidence” that will never be quite right or quite enough. Here, the tug and pull between plausible deniability and indiscrete inquiry does not disappear by “being generous,” by pretending not to know the question. After all, is it better to <em>pretend not to know? </em>Don’t ask don’t tell certainly doesn’t eliminate curiosity as much as encourage speculation. Turning round and round with evasive maneuvers regarding what we really want to know about someone else — is an unavoidable aspect of the interpretive work that underlies<em> bad faith.</em></p><p><strong>Pascal’s Wager</strong></p><p>Taking a step back from Sartre, let us look at an example where a question with more self-evident stakes. (Although I might point out that “publicly accepting one’s sexuality” has become, for better or worse, one of the more weighty political gestures of the past few decades.)</p><p>To do so — let’s go back to religious iterations of bad faith. In Christian tradition,“bad faith” describes the pilgrim who, before scripture, remains divided in mind. I have generally found Pascal’s Wager to be a helpful illustration of the problem<em>. </em>For the sake of brevity, I will take <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blaise_Pascal">Pascal</a> (perhaps a little too much) at face value. In his <em>Pensées, </em>Pascal muses that if one isn’t sure, it’s safer to bet on God’s existence. By choosing piety, you risk nothing, but what you stand to gain is infinite.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XkETagN2NLzSjeep" /><figcaption>Pascal’s Wager, from the Cambridge University Press</figcaption></figure><p>For critics of Pascal, the problem with the wager is that it enables a kind of “dodging of the question.”<em> </em>If one takes Pascal seriously, piety becomes, not so much a practice of belief, but more of an insurance policy for the soul. For the one who takes the wager, the <em>nature of piety </em>changes, opening up a pandora’s box of bad faith possibilities. As long as you behave as if you believe, keep the Sabbath, refrain from murder, etc. you can <em>act piously </em>without committing to the truth of what piety expresses — the truth of divine presence.</p><p>The problem with bad faith is that it both circumvents evidence (revelation) and ups its stakes — all evidence of divine presence becomes evidence of my wager (my clever choice)<em>.</em> Unlike the divine injunction to“see,” Pascal’s wager recasts “seeing” as <em>betting on one’s belief.</em> (Here, it’s helpful to remember that our early empirical methods of inquiry derive partly from the faith-based orthodoxy of “seeing is believing.” One converts, quite simply, because one has seen. Blood-hungry crusades aside, the Christian tradition sets a surprisingly low bar for conversion — one does not need incontrovertible proof — one simply needs enough proof to believe.<em> </em>After all, what the pilgrim witnesses is not always extraordinary. Visions in conversion narratives — if they aren’t elided entirely — can range from the banal, to the repetitive, to the cryptic. In theory at least, “good faith” seeing balances the affirmation of having received <em>enough </em>revelation, and the private, personal choice that no further proof is needed.)</p><p>In a modern vernacular, we might say that Pascal presents conversion as a question of risk. The pilgrim adjudicates between risk avoidance — hedge your bets and believe — and an absurd exposure to <em>risk — </em>continuing to doubt<em>. </em>Yet as anyone who deals with “risk management” can attest, avoiding risk is not a one-time deal but an endless commitment.<em> </em>For the pilgrim that takes Pascal’s wager seriously, practicing “piety” becomes a strenuous responsibility. Going to church, giving alms, praying at dinner, are part of a never-ending dance of<em> </em>demonstrating that one believes, all the while begging and dodging the <em>question of whether one really sees.</em></p><p><strong>The Public Wants to Know</strong></p><p>Here, I think it’s helpful to lay out the stakes of our disagreement. As I understand it, Oliver understands the game of discourse as more or less a marketplace of ideas. When players present their ideas to a forum, they can either play fair, thereby enabling the best idea to emerge, or play dirty, thereby undermining public trust in the marketplace.</p><p>According to Oliver, if we accuse someone of bad faith — we risk alienating our opponents and undermining our trust in the exchange of ideas: “the assumption of good faith is essentially the assumption that, despite our differences, we are all trying to seek the truth. It is, metaphorically, the phones in JFK and Khrushchev’s offices. It’s a fragile line of communication — and when one side introduces bad faith as a talking point, the other may be tempted to cut the cord.”</p><p>Let’s set aside for now whether a phone line in Khrushchev’s office is “good faith comms” or more likely as not, a piece of hardware that holds both parties hostage. By this logic, <a href="https://www.history.com/news/kennedy-krushchev-vienna-summit-meeting-1961">JFK and Khrushchev</a> are representatives of two opposing sides in a debate. (You can cut the cake however you’d like: communism vs democracy, communism vs free-market capitalism, etc. etc.) In order for any debate to take place, we need what my colleague calls an “interoperable” language.<em> </em>As I understand it, by this metaphor, he means a language that works like an universal adaptor — a peg for every hole. To participate in the conversation, everyone must come equipped to play — pegs and holes at attention.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*i3tRDywoZ1a27Li7.jpg" /></figure><p>For our purposes here, I will not go into detail on why I think language is not, in fact, interoperable. As decades of postcolonial and critical race studies have demonstrated, how well the adaptor works depends very much on who we think is wielding it, for whom, and against whom<em>. </em>For my part, I hope I have shown that language is a game of<em> </em>epistemic power, a medium that for better or worse, offers enough elasticity and latitude for evasion, defenses, and flipping the tables.</p><p>So far, I have also tried to show that <em>what something means </em>(praying, negotiating, displaying interest) depends very much on 1) the demand to know (the “call-out, if you will) — regardless of whether it’s spoken or implicit — and 2) the game of deferral, avoidance, and misinterpretation in play. We mistrust someone if they lie, but “bad faith” draws us into the<em> </em>game of self-deception. To take another Sartrean example, the woman flirting in a café has no intention of giving the game away. Here, expressing interest a way of dodging the question of whether she — or her suitor — is actually interested. Flirting can leave the door open to changing one’s mind — but crucially, it avoids “outing” what neither party truly wants to know. No gesture, no promise, no act, can clinch the game. Yet only the sourest of suitors would cry “deceit” in all seriousness — after all, who has not deceived themselves in<em> </em>pursuit of a lover?</p><p>Where the stakes of bad faith are raised, I put forth, depends on the urgency and legitimacy of the demand to know <em>publicly and to know together. </em>To take my colleague’s example, let us remember that the Cold War was not a clash of ideas, clever mind games, or JFK and Khrushchev talking. Less of a “string” of communications, it was a string of wars with real victims and casualties (millions of whom fall beneath the notice of our trusted leaders.) Again, it may seem obvious to note here, but none of the victims of “ideological” wars had phone lines to Kennedy, and none of them were consulted about the violence visited upon them.</p><p>No one needs me to recount the bad faith<em> </em>involved in the Johnson administration continuing to prop up “<a href="https://millercenter.org/president/lbjohnson/foreign-affairs">containment</a>” as a legitimate policy, or the decision to frame the Vietnam War as a “moral battle against communism” when the death tolls were climbing publicly everyday. Here, it’s not that capitalism is an inferior system or that communism is superior. It’s that at one point in the US, throwing your chips behind “free-market capitalism,” engaging in debates about capitalism versus communism as if they were the point — became less about “mere theorizing” but more a case of dodging the reality at hand.</p><p>I want to be clear that I am not trying to challenge the project of civilized discourse that my colleague proposes. Nor am I disparaging the democratizing potential of technology (about this I remain cautiously optimistic). I bring this up to re-focus why accusations of “bad faith” — even as they draw us into making indiscrete demands and abandoning politeness and propriety can be productive or even necessary. If nothing else, let us remember that “bad faith” is never about two parties discussing their ideas across a table — communism good / capitalism bad or vice versa. It is about the connection between the discursive games we rehearse and the questions they both pose and evade, the immensely costly self-deceptions in which our games can entrap us.</p><p>After all — to take another one of Oliver’s examples — the problem with cult leaders isn’t that their ideas are bad (let’s be honest, cultish ideas typically range from practical self-help to cheap messianism.) It’s that ideas are so often a form of doublespeak that conceals the all too predictable abuses that take place behind closed doors.</p><p><strong>Just Who Is Accusing Whom?</strong></p><p>Although Sartre does not reprise the concept explicitly in his later works, he returns to “bad faith” in a different form throughout the 1940s and 1950s through the questions of commitment and responsibility. In fact, the post-war popularity of existentialism owes much to its insistence on joining personal responsibility and historical realities at a time when so much of the world simply chose to “move on.” In the American and European imagination, the 1940s still persists as an unparalleled example of the abdication of responsibility by an entire people and civilization.</p><p>As our education teaches us, to be neutral in 1939 is to be guilty of a particularly unforgivable kind of cowardice. That such cowardice came, not through the violation of bourgeois, law-abiding behavior but through its embrace makes it a fertile testing ground for bad faith. To an extent, bourgeois life has always involved a degree of bad faith, of turning away from and talking over the uglier realities of poverty and prejudice. Yet the 1940s revealed just <em>how much</em> it was possible for people to deceive themselves.</p><p>I realize that no one wants to talk about Nazis, and it sounds like I’m making a moralizing digression. Yet it’s important to note the extent to which our narratives about the Second World War have served as the crucible through which we have developed our secular vernacular of bad faith — one that turns on “accusation,” “complicity,” and “collusion.”</p><p>In an oft quoted passage from Simone Weil’s “Reflections on War,” Weil reminds us that under extraordinary duress, we are still bound by forms of agency: “But the impotence one feels today — an impotence we should never consider permanent — does not excuse one from remaining true to one’s self, nor does it excuse capitulation to the enemy, whatever mask he may wear.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XTIZOErYJCqclhuz.jpg" /></figure><p>Weil’s diagnosis of “impotence” is often read as an empowering rallying cry for activists, but it’s helpful to note that the possibility of <em>agency </em>also implicates our own powerlessness. Feelings of “impotence,” Weil cautions, are not admissible in the court of divine or historical judgment. One can be <em>wrong </em>about feeling impotent, and often, such feelings enable the slippage from neutrality to “capitulation” — from not wishing to know because it makes no difference to refusing to act.</p><p>We need only to look to our cinematic love affair with “good Nazis” to see how the interplay between “needing to know what it’s like, to understand”<em> </em>and “mere excuse-making” renders the Nazi era such a fertile staging ground for embarrassingly uncomfortable narratives<em>. </em>Films and stories like <em>Jojo Rabbit, Good, The Reader </em>etc. etc. tell us again and again how many Nazis were merely average people going about their business, feeding their pets and buying their groceries in a manner indistinguishable from us.</p><p>Yet this very relatability and familiarity<em>, </em>even as it implies plausible deniability — the mere accident of having been born at the wrong place, the wrong time — can’t help but feel disingenuous in a new way. Is it that they were powerless or that we are culpable by <em>our intimate rehearsals of their powerlessness</em>?<em> </em>Claims of German victimhood — of having been swindled by a charismatic speaker and caught up in the torrent of history — begin to sound like an eerie denial of guilt and a counter-accusation to the tune of “Cell Block Tango”:</p><blockquote>“…if you’d’ve been there, if you’d’ve seen it — then you would have done the same.”</blockquote><p><strong>Living In Dark Times</strong></p><p>In his poem <a href="https://harpers.org/2008/01/brecht-to-those-who-follow-in-our-wake/">“To Those Who Follow in Our Wake,”</a> Bertolt Brecht reflects on how “bad faith” can become oddly environmental — something acutely <em>inflected</em> in every action, however banal or seemingly gentle:</p><p><em>Truly, I live in dark times!<br> An artless word is foolish. A smooth forehead<br> Points to insensitivity. He who laughs<br> Has not yet received<br> The terrible news.</em></p><p><em>What times are these, in which<br> A conversation about trees is almost a crime<br> For in doing so we maintain our silence about so much wrongdoing!<br> And he who walks quietly across the street,<br> Passes out of the reach of his friends<br> Who are in danger.</em></p><p>Writing from his Danish exile in 1939, Brecht reflects on how his own precarious safety abandonment of his colleagues and friends. Here it is not that one’s actions — eating, going about one’s business, having a conversation — have changed in themselves, but they cannot but reflect that the world has fundamentally changed. Actions that seemed neutral and safe are now a form of “silence” about wrongdoing.</p><p>Brecht shows us the strange, conspiratorial knowledge that unwitting collaborators under fascism share. In 1939 Denmark, everyone knows that the world has changed. But having been spared (if by geography alone), some people can go on eating, drinking, and tending to their gardens just as before<em>. </em>But going on as before is also to deny the very knowledge that enables a kind of mutual recognition — the knowledge that <em>everything</em> has changed.</p><p>Even though small gestures of normality are gestures of denial, Brecht shows us “bad faith” is double-edged — that denial is also complicity, that going on as before is also to tacitly testify to the fact that things have changed. Staying “silent” is to <em>choose</em> to walk “quietly across the street” and “pass out of reach” of your friends in need (something we may be inadvertently doing now as more lockdown measures loom<em>)</em>. By behaving no differently as before, such actions reflect <em>a choice not to know, </em>and conspirators recognize each other through this theatre of dissembling. Gestures have lost their middle ground — as if to say, everything we now do, we do<em> </em>under the searing judgment of posterity.</p><p><strong>Telling a Story Everybody Knows</strong></p><p>What does this mean for communication? From our conversations in text and in person, I rather think that Oliver and I agree that there is something unproductive about public discourse as it stands. No doubt, we often talk at cross-purposes, and greater generosity is probably a good thing in our conduct toward others. Yet I rather disagree that a “falsifiability test” is what’s needed, and I am baffled by the assertion that machines are “faithful, diligent, and disinterested” teachers of good faith.</p><p>To repeat Sartre’s assertion — bad faith is not about lying to others. Like the “closeted” man who sends “signals,” all of them suggestive but none of them determining — the game is not quite one of “lies” and “facts,” but a game of mutual self-deception. Demanding to know — and to know together — is always a risk. We risk deceiving ourselves about the legitimacy of our demand and breaking the seal on the depth of our own culpability. Yet when the demand sticks, there is usually a story that needs to be told.</p><p>For instance — and I won’t linger on this because others have written about it with so much more eloquence — a simple message like “Black Lives Matter” tends to invite a myriad of bad faith responses in the manner of “all lives matter” or “blue lives matter.” Here, my colleague’s “falsifiability test” would, I venture, be useless if not insulting. In a case like this, it’s not about the <em>verifiability </em>of police brutality. As countless court cases have demonstrated, the nature of evidence has always been contingent on what the law chooses to know and not know<em>. </em>Yet, while statistics render visible sheer scale of police brutality and the prison industrial system, even setting them aside, if you live in the US, on some level, <em>you already know</em>. In its simplest formulation — this is what the charge of “bad faith” has to say: <em>there is no way for you not to know, and I know that you know.</em></p><p>To be honest, I don’t know well enough what it means for a machine to be “faithful” or “diligent.” But if a machine is “disinterested,” this would, in my mind, rule it out as a participant<em>. </em>As I have tried to show, the relation between “accuser” and “accused” is a tricky one, but being <em>interested </em>is an inherent part of the so-called mechanics of bad faith. “My” bad faith is always a game I’m playing with someone else — someone who can either <em>demand that I know what I do not wish to know </em>(try to kill the game), or who colludes with me <em>not to know </em>(play the game). Either way — they cannot avoid becoming an <em>interested</em> party.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UfAFc4EYTUyZxvfc.jpg" /><figcaption>Promotional image from the film Spotlight</figcaption></figure><p>I am not sure my lengthy response helps us deal with “bad faith,” but I hope it redirects us to the problems in discourse that to my mind, are unlikely to be solved by better rules of engagement<em>. </em>Finally, I’ll leave my reader with an example in the Tom McCarthy film <em>Spotlight </em>— an efficient portrayal of <em>The Boston Globe </em>journalists uncovering the story of child abuse hidden in plain sight. Yet the trope of uncovering — of getting liars to ‘fess up — gives way to another story of widespread culpability, plausible deniability, and indiscrete questions.</p><p>At one point, while explaining why he does what he does, Stanley Tucci as the lawyer Mitchell Garabedian practically turns to the camera to inform us: “If it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a village to abuse one.” After a confrontation with the administrators at Boston High, Rachel McAdams as Sacha Pfeiffer tells her editor — probably talking about the audience as much as everyone in the film — “It’s like everyone already knows the story.”</p><p>By the end, the righteous satisfaction of uncovering the truth is somewhat unsettled by the fact that, as it turns out, everyone already knew — including the <em>Globe </em>itself. In the final scene, instead of encountering outrage at what is uncovered, the <em>Globe </em>is flooded with testimonials of abuse. The story about the church coverup turns out to be the story of a community that <em>needed</em> to tell itself the story it always knew — the story that everyone, it turned out, had been telling in one form or another.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de59e89a4d00" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/some-thoughts-on-the-mechanics-bad-faith-de59e89a4d00">Some Thoughts on “The Mechanics Bad Faith”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Short Introduction to the Mechanics of Bad Faith]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/a-short-introduction-to-the-mechanics-of-bad-faith-6b66fa6f3ba7?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b66fa6f3ba7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politcs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bad-faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oliver Meredith Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Nov 2020 14:17:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-18T19:32:03.632Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Having Taught Computers Humanity, Perhaps They Can Teach Us Good Faith</h4><p>Winner of the <strong><em>Best Article from a New Contributor 2020 </em></strong>Award at Wonk Bridge’s 2020 Award Ceremony.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9lRNVtltpsXVUrS2oEGa1g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Degrain’s “<em>Otelo e Desdemona”, an image and scenario epitomising the quandary of our present focus — to risk good faith, or embrace the ease of bad faith?</em></figcaption></figure><p>Bad faith is corrosive and, as with the nuclear calculus, the only way to deal with it is invoke a deterrent that is just as (or more) dangerous: the accusation of bad faith, which has the potential to negate any conversation. This appears to be the case because the game theory is <em>off</em>: one might say that our public conversations are like public goods (fisheries, forests, waterways) in which those high in ambition and low in virtue can win big at everyone else’s expense.</p><p>What follows is an exploration of this dynamic, and some proposals for how we might find ways to converse better with people who are different to us.</p><h3>A Background to the Mechanics</h3><p>A little while ago I wrote an article called “<a href="https://olivermeredithcox.com/2020/06/26/conversational-interoperability/">Conversational Interoperability</a>,” which set out some ground rules designed to facilitate fruitful communication between people of different mindsets; this is in the context of how, quite frequently, people of different fields, philosophies or politics find their communication degrading for no other reason than they have different words for the same thing or different perspectives, when they really think quite similarly or at least don’t have differences that warrant getting angry.</p><p>That piece was based on Postel’s Law, or the Law of Robustness: “Be conservative in what you send, be liberal in what you accept.” John Postel, who was fundamental to the development of the Internet, expressed these words in the context of digital communications, meaning, in essence, that one should only transmit well-formed data but, if one receives malformed data that is nonetheless decipherable, one should parse it anyway.</p><p>Hopefully the reader can see how this provides for maximum communication, in theory: in the domain that you control (what you transmit) you should maximize obedience to the standard; in the domain you do not control (what others transmit) you should maximize the total information that you decipher. I extend the Law to my six rules of conversational interoperability, in three parts:</p><p><em>Clarity</em>:</p><ol><li>When speaking: be clear.</li><li>When listening: be charitable</li></ol><p><em>Offense</em>:</p><ol><li>When speaking: try not to cause offense.</li><li>When listening: don’t take offense.</li></ol><p><em>Errors</em>:</p><ol><li>When good-faith errors occur: be charitable.</li><li>When bad-faith errors occur: treat them like good-faith errors.</li></ol><p>One can see how each of these pairs follows the liberal/conservative duality that Postel originally outlined in his law, except for the last one. Upon first meeting with Yuji and Max from the Wonk Bridge team, Yuji asked me about the last point. Yuji’s background is in international relations, wherein one must <em>respond</em>: a nation not responding to border violations and other aggressive acts is irresponsible, given that it invites further foul play. How could I, he asked, possibly recommend treating bad-faith errors just as I would treat good-faith errors?</p><p>In this piece I hope to explore the nuance of bad faith and how it interacts with human nature, while proposing a system to incentivize good faith. It consists of six policies, expressed as three progressive steps, each using the former as foundation. For more on bad faith, game theory, and these recommendations in detail, read further.</p><h3>Six Policies to Encourage Good Faith</h3><p><em>Step one: being able to call out bad faith without getting confused by mere sloppy arguing.</em></p><p>1. All fora should publish lists of logical fallacies for people to avoid.</p><p>2. All fora should publish lists of <em>philosophy smells </em>or <em>philosophical anti-patterns</em>. A philosophy smell is a style of thinking that is not, itself, fallacious but is flawed in a way that makes it easy for fallacies to slip through.</p><p><em>Step two: avoiding the escalation that can often come when accusations of bad faith are thrown around.</em></p><p>1. Claims of bad faith should be recorded diligently, so as to discourage people from debasing the coin.</p><p>2. All claims of bad faith should be falsifiable. Falsifiable claims are stronger, and avoid trap accusations that one can’t get out of.</p><p><em>Step three: building a system with the right incentive structure to encourage good faith behaviour, identify bad faith, and discourage false accusations.</em></p><p>1. All claims of bad faith should be reciprocal: if you make an accusation, you should own up to a past infraction of your own.</p><p>2. Good Faith Bonds: an organizational structure that aims to promote good faith. It works thus: people join the organization by posting bond, agreeing that they will act in good faith and avoid baseless accusations of bad faith thereafter. Those found acting in bad faith or making bad faith accusations forfeit their bonds. See below for more detail.</p><h3>What Is Bad Faith?</h3><p>What is a bad-faith actor? What is bad faith, for that matter? Bad faith is to act in ways that spoof the normal modes of interaction, such as in debate, conversation, commerce, while actually pursuing hidden, selfish motives or even hoping to disrupt the operation of the system in which they operate.</p><p>The most clear and common example is trolling: trolls will often ask what appear normal questions of others, when in fact the real goal is to frustrate, annoy or waste time.</p><p>More sophisticated bad faithers use these techniques in debates. Creationists, for example, are notorious for pretending to think that Evolution is just a <em>theory </em>in the sense that “<em>in theory </em>the pub is still open” when they know that Evolution is a theory in that it is the best-evidenced model for the system it describes, having stood up to rigorous tests.</p><p>In my view, the most popular form of bad faith is the deliberate misunderstanding of phrases and wording, attributing to people views that they do not hold and clearly weren’t actually expressing. One Hitchens quote, if you’ll indulge me: Hitchens describes his opposition to the way in which particular religions categorize women as chattel, owned; the radio talk-show host responded by saying, “Well then are you against <em>ownership?</em>” Hitchens responded to say: “Of people: yes.”</p><p>Hopefully you can glimpse some of what we’re dealing with: bad faith, for our purposes, is when people will twist the universe around in their mind with as much effort as is necessary to avoid <em>understanding </em>a conflicting viewpoint to the extent that it might actually pose a challenge. All of these examples are shadows cast by the same desire: to frustrate, annoy, show off, posture in front of one’s followers, rather than to learn, exchange information and create connections.</p><h3>The Trouble with Calling out Bad Faith</h3><p>As such, one might ask, why don’t we just call out these bad actors, plainly and as often as possible? For example, in the case of the creationists, tell them that they have been corrected so many times on the point of the definition of “theory” that it is clear that they are not actually playing to win, but to foul?</p><p>The first reason not to do so is that telling someone that they’re in bad faith is the nuclear option, it is meta, it contains the statement that the accused is not actually interested in discourse or ideas, that they are, at bottom, a troll, or worse, a liar. This is something of a conversation stopper. Granted, it’s probably justified sometimes, but quite often people fall into sin by repeating arguments they hear elsewhere but don’t interrogate.</p><p>For example, have you ever heard someone say: “There’s no smoke without fire,” meaning that if there’s a fuss, there must be something to fuss about. Do you see how horrible it is? The phrase makes no allowance for lies or mistakes, and is cruelly wrong in that it damns the victims of false rumors. One might as well say, “There’s no map without territory.”</p><p>Meanwhile, and perhaps more importantly, there’s the problem of the proliferation of this nuclear option. Anyone can accuse anyone else of acting in bad faith, but proving that one <em>isn’t </em>is as hard as proving any other negative proposition. To the extent to which a given person is believed by their followers and readers, the accusation of bad faith against another threatens to cut that individual out completely (some people are more than happy to be given reason to ignore another person’s ideas).</p><p>This has also been miniaturized into the tactical bad faith insult: cheap character critiques like racist, socialist, anti-American. The accusation of bad faith could be said to lie above all of these, e.g. the person is <em>a social justice warrior </em>and what they say can’t, therefore, be trusted.</p><p>The assumption of good faith is essentially the assumption that, dispite our differences, we are all trying to seek truth. It is, metaphorically, the phones in JFK and Khrushchev’s offices. It’s a fragile line of communication — and when one side introduces bad faith as a talking point, the other may be tempted to cut the cord.</p><h3>Game Theory, Mutually Assured Destruction and Technology</h3><h3>Game Theory</h3><p>The answer to the question of how to deal with the bad actors, or at least the study of this question, starts with game theory. Game theory is the abstraction of strategic action, allowing us to simulate and theorize about the merits of particular strategies. Usually game theory comes down to simulated interactions between two or more “players” with different approaches to the “game.”</p><p>For example, Dawkins’ <em>The Selfish Gene </em>features games that simulate social interactions, with only two possible moves: cooperate or defect. These games have multiple rounds: during each round both players make their move, the outcome is decided, then they play the next round, and so on. In the Dawkins example, if both players cooperate, both get a payoff, if one player defects and the other cooperates, the defector gets a payoff, and the cooperator nothing. If they both defect, they both lose.</p><p>This allows the researcher to test out different strategies, “always cooperate,” “always defect,” “tit-for-tat” and so on — for American readers, who I am told don’t have the phrase <em>tit-for-tat</em>, this means to give it back as you get it, I’ll be nice if you’re nice, but if you hit me I’ll hit you back on the next move.</p><p>Imagine if two people were in oppositional conversation, in public, with their audiences watching. Imagine if each person had the option to press a “bad faith” button that would identify the other, categorically, as someone with sinister motives. Well, a large number would press the button instantly and on all occasions. Remember that to some people, all conservatives are oil-heads, to others, progressives don’t want to improve America, they want to destroy it.</p><p>As I mentioned above, each time someone presses the button, to the extent that they are believed, their audience is further encouraged to think that the only reason one would have to disagree would be dishonesty. Granted, some people would alienate their audience by acting in this way; others practically make a living from it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/331/1*gDEf6k4kXfjzADFbAyAOCw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://english.lem.pl/gallery/mroz-drawings/category/37-cyberiad-1972-wl">Daniel Mróz</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Mutually Assured Destruction</h3><p>Then, of course, one has the ultimate domain of game theory: nuclear deterrents. Essentially the well-worn theory goes like this: any nation launching a nuclear attack today would, often automatically, provoke a counter attack on the part of their adversary. Thus, mutually assured destruction.</p><p>Continuing the liberal draw on John Postel’s wisdom, one might call this the law of fragility: each nation must be totally permissive in what it accepts (technology that can fend off nuclear attacks ranges from non-existent to dubious) and as a defensive reaction to this weakness, each nation must be totally aggressive in what it sends (launch at any credible threat). It is bizarre that, perhaps as far from the balance of Postel’s law as one can go, we find something that is oddly stable.</p><p>In the game theory of a nuclear exchange, if either side defects, both are annihilated. Compare this to the typical behaviour of hatchet wielding journalists and social media agitators, who stand to gain in the short term by acting in bad faith, and even can gain if <em>both sides defect. </em>This appears to be because different people have different audiences with different takes on events. However the argument actually goes, people often uphold <em>their</em> champion as the winner.</p><p>But, of course, there are no free lunches, and I argue that the terminus of this path is mutually assured destruction, also. A society that lies this much will eventually degrade to the extent that collaboration across party lines becomes impossible. This is part of why Eric Weinstein is so fond of recommending that we <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/27-daniel-schmachtenberger-on-avoiding-apocalypses/id1469999563?i=1000469758815">return to above-ground nuclear testing</a>: a true perception of the risks is an excellent way to give people reason to coordinate their action effectively.</p><p>I kept a rather game theoretical horse tied nearby for just this sort of occasion: images on the Web. Do you remember when blog posts, articles,<em> etc.</em> didn’t <em>always </em>have an image accompanying them? Do you remember when Twitter consisted primarily of <em>text</em>? Well, what happened? It appears that the social networks, especially Twitter and Facebook, began offering fairly functional previews when users shared URLs, together with easy support for posting images themselves.</p><p>We know, to the embarrassment of our species, that people are more likely to click on something if it has an associated image; more so if the image features a human being. Thus, the incentive is for users to post images with <em>everything, all the time</em>: and if you don’t post an image to accompany your article you’ll lose clicks to someone who does.</p><p>In this example, online writers were playing a game of image versus no image, and image almost always wins (in the short term). This delivered us the sickening phenomenon of the mandatory blog featured image: teenagers on phones, a man reading a newspaper, a dreamy barista. This isn’t a lost cause, but it wasted a lot of time, energy and bandwidth along the way.</p><p>Fundamentally, the system of discourse appears to be configured such that it is very hard to win against bad faith actors and, like with the image battle, you can build a pocket of decency, but it’s much harder to stop the system as a whole from denaturing. To do that, we need better systems and better norms, the game theory itself must be different.</p><h3>Technological Esperanto</h3><p>You have probably heard of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Esperanto">Esperanto</a>, a constructed language, designed to be spoken universally and, thus, to foster international communication and collaboration. Esperanto, the most successful constructed language, spoken by millions, is dwarfed by another universal language, one which operates quite differently: TCP/IP.</p><p>TCP/IP describes the suite of protocols that facilitate the Internet; they are almost universally used and accepted, despite personal and global differences of language, creed and politics. Amusingly, when people are yelling at each other on Twitter, trolling, telling each other that we have <em>nothing </em>to offer, that we disagree on everything, they do so within a common framework about which there is total agreement: the protocols of the Internet that govern how we exchange data functionally, including John Postel’s contributions and his Law, which is where we started.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eZQONTxgaPyQV_VIjhu_PQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>John Postel/<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Postel#/media/File:Jon_Postel_sitting_in_office.jpg">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Online, at least on the very basic level, there is almost total interoperability. For those who aren’t familiar, the Network Centric Operations Industry Consortium <a href="https://www.ncoic.org/minimum-level-of-interoperability/">provides nice primer</a> on interoperability:</p><blockquote>To claim interoperability, you must:</blockquote><blockquote>1) be able to communicate with others;</blockquote><blockquote>2) be able to digitize the data/information to be shared; and</blockquote><blockquote>3) be recognizable/registered (i.e., you must have some form of credentials verifying both senders and receivers on the network as authorized participants with specific roles).</blockquote><p>For example, the USB standard provides for interoperability: all compliant devices fit into the hole correctly and can transmit data. Conversely, some Windows and Mac disk formats are still non-interoperable, throwing errors or even doing damage when one crosses the streams.</p><p>To the extent that interoperability is reduced, I see no instances wherein the community benefits: we benefit where there is more scope for communication, only those who want fawning, captive audiences would want people to use technology, or adopt mindsets, that cannot interact properly with others.</p><p>Another aside: if you want to build a cult, or at least make it difficult for your adherents to leave whatever organization you are building, it’s in your interest to give them an incompatible philosophy or mindset and especially to <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/like-a-demagogue-wework-the-doublespeak-advertising-philosophy-of-silicon-valley-89efe0300a05">denature language</a>, such that adherents can’t communicate properly with people using common parlance.</p><p>It’s worth noting the domain of operation of TCP/IP and the Law of Robustness and why it works there. Its domain, of course, is computers and their communication, and it works at least partly because there are few grey areas: either the packets are well-formed or they are not, my father would have said: “That’s one of the convenient things about computing: it either works or it doesn’t.” Things are much more difficult to judge in the domain of people and culture.</p><p>Amusingly, it seems that when left to our own devices, we find bad faith action irresistible; we have been astonishingly successful in maintaining good faith by offloading this responsibility to dependable machines. In order to build a less divisive discourse, we might want to be a little more like our devices — at least how they communicate.</p><h3>Six Proposals for the Promotion of Good Faith</h3><h3>Reducing False Positives</h3><h4>1. All fora should publish lists of logical fallacies for people to avoid.</h4><p>Fora, communities, social networks and particularly <em>schools, </em>should publish lists of logical fallacies: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem"><em>argumentum ad hominem</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc"><em>post hoc ergo propter hoc</em></a><em>, etc. </em>It’s a travesty that school children don’t emerge knowing logic and it’s fallacious use: one has to admit that those not versed make better votaries and consumers.</p><p>Fundamentally, dealing with points that are logically unsound is frequently the source of friction in conversations: truly, if you use a fallacious argument, you either forgot yourself, are ignorant, or really are acting in bad faith. Usually it’s the first two, but with better norms, it seems that we could reduce them to practically nothing.</p><p>The most common fallacy, I find, and one that is perhaps less well known, is <em>touquoque</em>: meaning “also you.” It describes the act of trying to absolve one’s own side of something by identifying that the other side did it, too, or perhaps did something just as bad. This may, like a child realizing that they are not the only one in trouble, lessen the feeling of guilt, but it certainly doesn’t change the ethical implications of what one actually did.</p><p>The <em>tu quoque, </em>this style of argument, is supremely popular, perhaps one of the most popular rhetorical devices: yet it wastes our time and our patience with each other, during conversations that require every ounce of grace that we can afford.</p><h4>2. All fora should publish lists of philosophy smells or philosophical anti-patterns.</h4><p>Along with the list of fallacies, I would have people publish lists of “philosophy smells.” This, I believe, is a concept original to me.[1] A philosophy smell borrows from the <em>code smell</em> idea in programming: code smells don’t describe bugs or errors, necessarily; rather, they are evidence of poor practices and thinking, which are themselves likely to throw up bugs in the future. These smells, rewardingly, have the fruity names common to programmers: <em>object orgy, feature envy, boolean blindness.</em></p><p>Philosophy smells are equivalent: they aren’t the same as logical fallacies, but are evidence of a style of philosophizing that is likely to produce errors and mistakes in future. My favorite, so far, is <em>drive-by syllogism, </em>which is when someone submits rapid-fire premises and demands an immediate yes/no answer to the conclusion; this doesn’t mean that the logic is wrong, only that you’re much more likely to get a case of <em>l’espirit de escalier. </em>It’s not a particularly fruitful discussion if your means of winning is baffling people with speed and, in the process, <em>missing out </em>on their best counter-arguments. (If you are intellectually honest, you would want to hear the best they have.)</p><p>One more: <em>astrolophizing, </em>which is a blend of the style of astrology and philosophy, exemplified when people deploy logic and especially critiques that are so generic that they can be applied wholesale to more or less anything and are, thus, not necessarily wrong but are unlikely to be right. Christopher Hitchens gives a lovely example in <em>Hitch 22</em>:</p><blockquote>The last time I heard an orthodox Marxist statement that was music to my ears was from a member of the Rwanda Patriotic Front, during the mass slaughter in the country. ‘The terms Hutu and Tutsi,’ he said severely, ‘are merely ideological constructs, describing different relationships to the means and mode of production.’ But of course!</blockquote><p>I hope that establishing these two norms would eliminate many of the false positives: people who look like they’re acting in bad faith, but by accident. If <em>philosophy smell </em>is too weird a phrase, <em>philosophical anti-pattern </em>might be more palatable, to borrow from <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-pattern">Andrew Koning’s work in software</a>.</p><h3>Making It Easier and More Productive to Handle Bad Faith</h3><p>Additionally, I have two proposals for moderating and softening accusations of bad faith, and to disincentivize people from making frivolous accusations a habit.</p><h4>3. Claims of bad faith should be recorded diligently.</h4><p>We should record accusations of bad faith. We could do with this feature in other domains, but we may as well start here. It is as common as dirt for commentators, the general public, etc. to make strong accusations against their fellows, but that essentially get black holed or forgotten: it had an impact at the time, but eventually people forget and move on. Few people check on these claims to see if they turn out to be true or false.</p><p>The accuser gets to pack some punch at the time, and perhaps do so repeatedly, with no tally of their accuracy. To be clear, I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with being wrong — it’s a beautiful thing — but we should be wrong in public and embrace it. More apologies, more admitting that we were wrong, less forgetting.</p><h4>4. All claims of bad faith should be falsifiable.</h4><p>For that matter, all non-metaphysical claims should be falsifiable too, but that’s a fight for another day. The reason for this injunction is that it’s easier than spitting to make an accusation against someone: most of the time, they’re so woolly as to be impossible to prove or disprove. If the accusation is well-formed, then there ought to be something that the accused can do, or even prove that they have already done, to convince you that they are in good faith.</p><p>My editor asked that I give an example of an unfalsifiable accusations. I don’t like to make a habit of public criticisms like this, so instead I will draw on a historical example: the Hamilton-Burr duel. In 1804, Vice President Aaron Burr shot and killed fellow Founding Father Alexander Hamilton, during a duel. Burr challenged Hamilton because the latter had refused to deny insulting the former during a dinner in upstate New York. Putting aside whether this sort of thing is worth a duel, how could Hamilton possibly have falsified an account of a dinner held in private? Of course, Burr did not say that Hamilton acted in bad faith, but hopefully this incident illustrates the danger of any and all unfalsifiable accusations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/1*ltB7cAk3nVAW5looCnFCYg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hamilton and Burr dueling/<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Hamilton#/media/File:Hamilton-burr-duel.jpg">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Remember: claims of bad faith cannot be metaphysical. If your accusation is not falsifiable, it is non-admissible. There are of course grey claims, like saying that there are 5 sextillion grains of sand on our planet: this is falsifiable, but impossible to prove. We should avoid such grey accusations for this reason, their greyness is a potential get-out-of-jail-free card.</p><p>Finally, the means of falsifying the accusation should be part of the accusation; this is to say that if I accuse you of something, I should also state what I would accept as proof to the contrary. For example, if one accuses a politician of being an oil shill, one should state also which oil companies or lobbyists are involved, thereby making it possible to see if that person had been paid.</p><p>This gives some liberty to the accuser, but there’s no incentive to softball, and we can all tell, conversely, when an accuser demands evidence that makes acquittal impossible (which is obvious bad form). This is not perfect, but ought never to be worse and usually to be better than the norm today.</p><h3>Incentivizing Good Faith and Disincentivizing Frivolous Accusations</h3><h4>5. All claims of bad faith should be reciprocal.</h4><p>There should be a cost associated with making such bold claims. Just as in the legal system, wherein court fees disincentivize frivolous action, we ought to make it mean something to make accusations of this magnitude. We know from game theory studies that people will happily pay, often more than the value of the infraction, for justice.</p><p>A non-monetary system would work on reciprocation: if you accuse someone of bad faith, you ought to pair the accusation with an admission of a time that you acted in bad faith in the past. The extent to which people name only petty examples of their own bad faith, I expect, will speak for the quality of their accusation. This method ought to be advantageous not least because it demonstrates us reaching for a higher value: the game should not be one of <em>I’m right you’re wrong </em>but of <em>we are all trying to be better.</em></p><h4>6. Good Faith Bonds</h4><p>Finally, a monetary proposal: Good Faith Bonds. Here’s how it would work:</p><ol><li>Individuals active in the public sphere would post bond with a the <em>Good Faith Bonds </em>organization, on the promise that they act in good faith thereafter.</li><li>If a claimant comes with a falsifiable accusation, the accused can either submit evidence in their defence, apologize or (hopefully not) do nothing.</li><li>If they apologize they keep their bond, if they are proven wrong or ignore the accusation, they lose their bond.</li><li>If they are proven right, the accuser loses their bond.</li><li>We would need to find a means of disposing of the forfeited money in a way that doesn’t generate perverse incentives: for example, it would be a very bad idea for the forfeited money to go to the accuser, this would make it impossibly tempting to abuse the system. One might say that the funds should go to charity, but that isn’t unproblematic either.</li></ol><p>There’s obviously more to be ironed out here, but hopefully the idea is, at least, provocative. Questions around conflicts of interest and corruption within the organization are non-trivial, but new <em>trustless </em>modes of organization afforded by blockchain technology offer exciting possibilities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/321/1*6hJ1MVeWUF8_sjc8a9_7yA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://english.lem.pl/gallery/mroz-drawings/category/37-cyberiad-1972-wl">Daniel Mróz</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Finding the Best of Humanity Expressed by Computers</h3><p>As I mentioned at the start, it seems as though our <em>games </em>of communication incentivize bad faith. Bad faith, one might say, is worse than lying, in that it breaks down the mechanisms of communication and our ability to coordinate, especially among people who are different from one another.</p><p>That said, technology and computers in particular can give us tools to reflect some light back onto our species. To talk in such terms, bad faith breaks interoperability, and offers the cultural and conversational equivalent of VHS v.s. Betamax; building interoperability offers whatever the cultural and conversational equivalent of the Internet is: imperfect, confusing, but game-changing enough that any self-respecting tyrant would want to censor it.</p><p>Some complain at the inhumanity of computers and systems. This is usually fallacious: all such systems are created in the images of humans, and usually what people lament inhuman isn’t so in the sense that it is unlike people (say, lacking emotion) but in actually in the sense that it lacks empathy and ethics: if you spend any time with humans, you will learn just how fond some people are of creating <em>inhuman</em> systems; the only difference, in the realm of computers, is that the machines give people a place to hide.</p><p>So, Postel’s Law of Robustness, which computers find it much easier to obey than we do, is actually very <em>human, </em>and Postel, a man very fond of machines, a great humanist. Thus, when I recommended, above, being a little bit more like our machines, I meant only the extent to which they are faithful, diligent, and disinterested; characteristics which, combined with very human traits like public-spiritedness and a sense of community, we might call <em>virtue</em>. With this as our guiding principle, we might find conversation a little easier.</p><p>Notes:</p><ol><li>I have not found reference to the <em>philosophy smell</em> idea anywhere, so believe it to be original. I will of course hand it to its rightful owner, if corrected.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b66fa6f3ba7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/a-short-introduction-to-the-mechanics-of-bad-faith-6b66fa6f3ba7">A Short Introduction to the Mechanics of Bad Faith</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Accidental Tyranny of User Interfaces]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/the-accidental-tyranny-of-user-interfaces-7ce8dbaa51ba?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7ce8dbaa51ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tyranny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ui]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oliver Meredith Cox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Oct 2020 20:59:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-29T12:26:02.338Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>The potential of technology to empower is being subverted by tyrannical user interface design, enabled by our data and attention.</em></h4><p>My thesis here is that an obsession with easy, “intuitive” and perhaps even efficient user interfaces is creating a layer of soft tyranny. This layer is not unlike what I might create were I a dictator, seeking to soften up the public prior to an immense abuse of liberty in the future, by getting them so used to comical restrictions on their use of things that such bullying becomes normalised.</p><p>A note of clarification: I am not a trained user interface designer. I am just a user with opinions. I don’t write the following from the perspective of someone who thinks that they could do better; my father, a talented programmer, taught me early on that<em> everyone</em> thinks that they could build a good user interface, but very few actually have the talent and the attitude to do so.</p><p>As such, all the examples that I shall discuss are systems where the current user interface is much worse than a previous one. I’m not saying that <em>I</em> could do it better; <em>they</em> did it better, just in the past.</p><p>This is not new. Ted Nelson identifies how in Xerox’s much lauded Palo Alto Research Center (the birthplace of personal computing), the user was given a graphical user interface, but in return gave up the ability to form their own connections between programs, which were thereafter trapped inside “windows” — the immense potential of computing for abstraction and connection was dumbed down to “simulated paper.” If you’d like to learn more about his ideas on how computing could and should have developed, see his YouTube series, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KdnGPQaICjk&amp;list=PLlTLLSskDvc9IbD2_CZDE7C2Ffb8dvpSz">Computing for Cynics</a>.</p><p>Moore’s law describes that computers are becoming exponentially more powerful as time passes, meanwhile our user interfaces — to the extent that they make ourselves act stupidly and humiliate ourselves — are making us more and more powerless.</p><h3>YouTube</h3><p>YouTube’s Android app features perhaps the most egregious set of insulting user interface decisions. The first relates to individual entries for search results, subscriptions or other lists. Such a list contains a series of video previews that contain (today) an image still from the video, the title, the name of the channel, a view count, and the publishing date.</p><p>What if I want to go straight to the channel? This was possible, once. What if I want to highlight and select some of the text from the preview? I can’t. Instead, the entire preview, rather than acting like an integrated combination of graphics, text and hypertext, is just one big, pretty, stupid, button.</p><p>This is reminiscent of one of my favorite Dilbert cartoons. A computer salesperson presents Dilbert with their latest model, explaining that their latest user interface is so simple, friendly and intuitive that it only has one button, which they press for you when it’s shipped from the factory. We used to have choices. Now we are railroaded.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jQ4lWEr3cQLg0l5z" /></figure><p>Do you remember when you could lock your phone or use another app, and listen to YouTube in the background? Not any more. YouTube took away this — my fingers hovered over the keyboard there for a moment, and I nearly typed “feature” — YouTube continuing to play in the background is not a feature, it should be the normal operation of an app of that type; the fact that it closes when you switch apps is a devious <em>anti-feature</em>.</p><p>YouTube, combining Soviet-Style absurdity and high-capitalist banality, offers to give you back a properly functioning app, in return for upgrading to Premium. I’m not arguing against companies making available additional features in return for an upgrade. Moreover, my father explained how certain models of IBM computers came with advanced hardware built-in — upgrading would get you a visit from an engineer to activate hardware you already had.</p><p>IBM sells you a car, you pay for the upgrade, but realize that you already had the upgraded hardware, they just suppressed it; YouTube sells you a car, then years later turns it into a clown-car, and offers you the privilege of paying extra to make it into a normal car. Imagine a custard pie hitting a human face, forever.</p><p>Obviously this simile breaks down in that the commercial relationship between YouTube and me is very different to the one between a paying customer and IBM. If you use the free version of YouTube, you pay the company in eyeballs and data — this sort of relationship lacks the clarity of a conventional transaction, and the recipient of a product or service that is supposedly <em>free </em>leaves themselves open to all manner of abuses and slights, being without the indignation of a <em>paying customer</em>.</p><h3>WhatsApp</h3><p>WhatsApp used to have a simple, logical UI; this is fast degrading. As with YouTube, WhatsApp thwarts the user’s ability to engage with the contents of the program other than in railroaded ways.</p><p>Specifically, one used to be able to select and copy any amount of text from messages. Now, when one tries to select something from an individual message, the whole thing gets selected, and the standard operations are offered: delete, copy, share, etc.</p><p>What if I want to select part of a message because I only want to copy that part, or merely to highlight so as to show someone? Not any more. WhatsApp puts a barrier between you and the actual textual content of the messages you send and receive, letting you engage with them only in the ways for which it provides.</p><p>On this point I worry that I sound extreme — today I tried this point on a friend who didn’t see why this matters so much to me. Granted, in isolation, this issue is small, but it is one of a genre of such insults that are collectively degrading our tools.</p><p>That is is to say that WhatsApp pretends that the messages one the screen belong some special category, subject only to limited operations. No. It’s <em>text. </em>It is one of the fundamental substrates of computing and any self-respecting software company ought to run on the philosophical axiom that users should be able to manipulate it, as text.</p><p>Another quasi-aphorism from my father. We were shopping for a card for a friend or relative, in the standard Library of Congress-sized card section in the store. Looking at the choices, comprehensively labelled <em>60th Birthday, 18th Birthday, Sister’s Wedding, Graduation, Bereavement, etc.</em>, he commented, <em>Why do they have to define every possible</em> <em>occasion?</em> <em>Can’t they just make a selection of cards and I write that it’s for someone’s 60th birthday?</em></p><p>This is about the shape of it. The Magnetic North to which UIs appear to be heading is one in which all the things people think you might want to do are defined and are given a button. To refer to the earlier automotive comparison, this would be like a car without a steering wheel or gas pedal. Instead there’s a button for each city to which people think you might want to visit.</p><p>There’s a button for Newark but not for New York City? Hit the Button for Newark then walk the rest of the way. What kind of deviant would want to go to New York City anyway, or for that matter what muddle-headed lunatic would desire to go for a drive without having first decided upon the destination?</p><h3>The Lifts in My Building</h3><p>I work in the Financial District in Manhattan. Our previous building had normal lifts: you call a lift and, inside, select your floor. This building has a newer system: you go to a panel in the lobby and select your floor, the system then tells you the number of the lift that <em>it has called for you.</em> Inside, you find that there <em>no buttons for floors</em>.</p><p>This is impractical. Firstly, there is no way to recover if you accidentally get in the wrong lift (more than once, the security guards on the ground floor have seen a colleague and me exit a lift with cups of coffee and laptops, call another, and head straight back upstairs). Meanwhile, one has to <em>remember </em>in order for the system to function. I don’t go to the office to memorize things, I go to the office to work. Who wants to try to hold in mind the number for your lift while trying to talk to a friend?</p><p>More importantly, and just like WhatsApp, it’s like getting into a car but finding the steering wheel immovable in the grip of another person, who asks, “Where would you like to go?” What if I get in the lift and change my mind? This says nothing for the atomizing effect this has on people. Before, we might get into a lift and I, being closest to the control panel, would ask “which floor?” Now we’re silent, and there’s one fewer interruption between the glint of your phone, the building, and the glass partitions of your coworking space.</p><h3>Any Non-Descriptive Loading Bar</h3><p>My father set up my first computer when I was 8 or 9 years old. Having successfully installed Red Hat GNU/Linux, we booted for the first time. What we saw was something not unlike this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*Ic61YnRjxwNQ5ExJ" /></figure><p>This is a list of the processes that the operating system has launched successfully. It runs through it every time you start up. I see more or less the same thing now, running the latest version of the same Linux. It’s a beautiful, ballsy thing, and if it ever changes I will be very sad.</p><p>Today, our software treats us to what you might call the Ambiguous Loading Icon. Instead of a loading bar, percentage progress, or list, we’re treated to a thing that moves, as if to say<em> we’re working on it, </em>without any indication that anything is happening in the background. This is why I like it when my computer boots and I see the processes launching: there’s no wondering what’s going on in the background, this <em>is the background</em>.</p><p>One of the most egregious examples of this is in the (otherwise functional and inexpensive) Google Docs suite, when you ask it to convert a spreadsheet into the Google Sheets format:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/659/0*Ca8fTruiSNdER-P6" /></figure><p>We’re treated to a screen with the Google Docs logo and a repeating pattern that goes through the four colors of Google’s brand. Is it doing something? Probably. Is it working properly? Maybe. Will it ever be done? Don’t know. Each time that ridiculous gimmick flips colors is a slap in the face for a self-respecting user. Every time I tolerate this, I acclimatize myself to the practice of hiding the actual function and operation of a system from the individual, or perhaps even to the idea that I <em>don’t deserve to know.</em> This the route of totalitarianism.</p><h3>Recommendations</h3><p>I’m not pretending that this is easy. I understand that software and user interface design is a compromise between multiple goals: feature richness (which often leads to difficult user interfaces), ease of use (which often involves compromising on features or hiding them), flexibility, and many others.</p><p>I might frame it like this:</p><ol><li>There exists an infinite set of well-formed logical operations (that is, there is no limit to the number of non-contradictory logical expressions (e.g. A ⊃ B (the set A contains B)) that one can define.</li><li>Particular programming languages allow a subset of such expressions, as limited by the capabilities and power of the hardware (even if a function is possible, it might take an impractical amount of time (or forever) to complete).</li><li>Systems architects, programmers and others provide for a subset of all possible operations as defined by 2. in their software.</li><li>Systems architects, programmers and others create user interfaces that allow us to access a subset of 3. according to their priorities.</li></ol><p>They have to draw the line somewhere. It <em>feels </em>like software creators have placed too much emphasis on prettiness and ease of use, very little on freedom, and sometimes almost no emphasis on<em> letting the user know what’s actually happening</em>. I’m not asking for software that provides for the totality of all practical logical operations, I’m asking for software that treats me like an adult.</p><p>Some recommendations:</p><ol><li>Especially for tools intended for non-experts, there seems to be a hidden assumption that the user should be able to figure it out without training, <em>and </em>figure it out by thrashing around randomly when the company changes the user interface for no reason. A version of this is laudable, but often leads to systems so simplistic that they makes us feckless and impressionable. Perhaps a little training is worth it.</li><li>No fig-leaves: hiding a progress message under an animated gimmick was never worth it.</li><li>Perhaps the ad-funded model is a mistake, at least in some cases. As in the case of YouTube, it’s challenging to complain about an app for I don’t pay conventionally. The programs for which I do pay, for example <a href="http://notion.so/">Notion</a>, are immensely less patronizing. Those for which I don’t pay conventionally, but aren’t run on ads, like GNU/Linux, Libre Office, Ardour, etc. are created by people who so value things like openness, accessibility, freedom (as in free), that they border on the fanatical. Perhaps we should pay for more stuff and be more exacting in our values. (Free / open source software is funded in myriad ways, too complex to explore.)</li></ol><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>All this matters because the interfaces in question do the job of the dictator and the censor, and we embrace it. More than being infuriating, they train us to accept gross restrictions in return for trifling or non-existent ease of use, or are a fig leaf covering what is actually going on.</p><p>Most people do what they think is possible, or what they think they are allowed to do. Do you think people wouldn’t use a Twitter-like “share” function on Instagram, if one existed? What about recursive undo/redo functions that form a tree of possible document versions? Real hyperlinks that don’t break when the URL for the destination changes?</p><p>We rely on innovators to expand our horizons, while in fact they are defining <em>limited </em>applications of almost unlimited possibilities. Programmers, systems architects, businesspeople and others make choices for us: in doing so they condition in us that which <em>feels possible.</em> When they do so well, they are liberators; when they do so poorly, we are stunted.</p><p>Some of these decisions appear to be getting worse over time, and they dominate some of the most popular (and useful) systems; the consciousness-expanding capabilities of technology are being steered into a humiliating pose in a cramped space, not by force, but because the space is superficially pretty, easy to access and because choices are painful.</p><p>This article was originally posted on <a href="https://olivermeredithcox.com/2020/02/27/the-accidental-tyranny-of-user-interfaces/">Oliver Meredith Cox</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7ce8dbaa51ba" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/the-accidental-tyranny-of-user-interfaces-7ce8dbaa51ba">The Accidental Tyranny of User Interfaces</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Satanic Panic 2: Facebook Boogaloo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/satanic-panic-2-facebook-boogaloo-2e40e8c2c9e7?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e40e8c2c9e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[facebook]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conspiracy-theories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jackson Oliver Webster]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Oct 2020 18:03:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-18T18:03:06.786Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Disinformation relied on large platforms’ complacency</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jsfhAKSRqicbwWgD" /><figcaption>Stranger Danger, the more palatable gateway drug to Satanic Panic // wikimedia commons</figcaption></figure><p>A couple of weeks ago, I was in the middle of what has now become the only reliably pandemic-proof part of my social life: BYOB on Sunday afternoons in my friend’s backyard. Through conversational circumstances that a few <a href="https://hpb.la/">hazies</a> prevent me from recalling in detail, we ended up talking about <strong><em>1980s Satanic Panic</em></strong>. My friend’s mom had dropped by, and began telling the story of the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/23/books/review/we-believe-the-children-by-richard-beck.html">McMartin Preschool</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/476/0*aLhvK2YdLDzFQQGD.jpeg" /><figcaption>McMartin Preschool in the early 1980s // Investigation Discovery</figcaption></figure><p>In 1983, a group of parents in Manhattan Beach began making allegations of pedophilia and assault against a teacher at McMartin Preschool, Ray Buckey. Buckey, who also happened to be the grandson of the school’s founder, was placed under investigation by the local police. After the initial allegations couldn’t be corroborated, detectives sent out a <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20070810165136/http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/mcmartin/lettertoparents.html">now-infamous letter</a> to parents disclosing the alleged behavior, and telling parents to ask their children to recount any <em>odd</em> <em>behavior</em> by preschool staff.</p><p>In a textbook example of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/10/us/the-trial-that-unleashed-hysteria-over-child-abuse.html">how leading questions compromise witness</a> testimony, police and social workers questioned hundreds of students who made increasingly fantastical accusations.</p><p>They had been touched, prodded, beat, abused. Not only that, but the McMartins had engaged in animal cruelty. In fact, they had a system of tunnels under Manhattan Beach where they hid animals. Elephants! Giraffes! They engaged in satanic rituals. Ray Buckley and his mother were witches who could levitate.</p><p>The original accuser, Judy Johnson, was later institutionalized for paranoid schizophrenia, and clinical psychiatrists dismissed the interrogations as “improper and coerced”, but many parents took the students’ testimonials at face value. My friend’s parents had lived here in Manhattan Beach during the McMartin affair, and told of droves of homes and cars sporting lawn signs and bumper stickers declaring that “We Believe The Children”. Panic consumed the community for months, and the city even went so far as to excavate the preschool’s lot in search of tunnels full of tortured zoo animals.</p><p>Given the media environment at the time, none of this should have come as a surprise. The country was gripped in the grips of an <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/28/us/religion-politics-evangelicals.html">evangelical revival</a>, Reagan’s <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2019/01/17/how-policy-decisions-spawned-todays-hyperpolarized-media/">deregulation of the media</a>, and, most importantly, <a href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/35P1EKbHfRh1bSsx1V2VhM">Satanic Panic</a>.</p><p>Somehow, I’d grown up only a few blocks away from the excavation sites, yet I’d never heard of the McMartin Preschool allegations, nor of its trial, one of the longest in American history. Unlike my friend’s parents, and unlike my own parents, I hadn’t been around during the height of 1980s satanic hysteria. But I had grown up in the 1990s, when Satanic Panic’s lite version, “<a href="https://www.jacobinmag.com/2020/05/stranger-danger-mass-incarceration-paul-renfro">Stranger Danger</a>”, was still alive and well. Local news stations frequently regaled viewers with tales of men in unmarked white vans tricking children into being abducted. Both phenomena are now understood to have been a wave of “<a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0011392119829511">moral panic</a>” in reaction to the cultural revolution of the 1960s and 70s.</p><p>The problem is that Americans’ popular conception of what child abduction and disappearance look like are far off from reality. For example, <a href="https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/michael-hobbes/youre-wrong-about/e/56984782">78% of missing minors </a>cases are actually a part of custody battles, where one spouse absconds with the couple’s child. 1.5m children run away every year, 99% of them return home, the majority of whom return the same week. Moreover, the majority of runaways are fleeing some kind of emotional or physical abuse. In most cases, law enforcement is notified, finds the child, and either returns them to the abusive home from they’d run away from, or funnels them into America’s broken and underfunded foster care system.</p><p>The sad truth belied by these statistics is that there are indeed many young Americans who are forced to endure horrible circumstances, and our system utterly fails them. However, because truly combatting these abuses would inherently require Americans to reconsider their own priors on family, gender, sexuality, religiosity, and the sanctity of marriage and the home, we tend to prefer simpler outlier narratives to hard truths. We want to believe that most “normal” people are essentially good, and that we can trust our families, communities, and law enforcement. We want to believe that the real threat to our loved ones’ safety comes from some evil outsider in a white murdervan. We Americans want the simplicity of a fight between light and dark. Of course, things are rarely that black and white; but truth is often hard to swallow.</p><p>What the McMartin case, Stranger Danger, and the statistics above tell us about American society is that it is particularly susceptible to moral panics when three criteria are present. Firstly, the <em>perceived</em> victims of the panic must be or at least potentially include <a href="https://www.vice.com/en/article/nnqkkm/the-makers-of-nightcrawler-want-to-shake-up-local-tv-news-122">white, suburban, affluent Americans</a>, usually wronged by some kind of “othered” group. Secondly, the narrative of the panic must align with conservative axioms about what kinds of behavior are and are not morally acceptable. Thirdly — and most importantly for the purposes of this article — the era’s predominant mass media must join in the frenzy by amplifying stories that fit the first two criteria.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*YbbhUSC0f_oedla0NPJsvA.png" /><figcaption>2004 study shows crime reporting dominates local TV coverage // Pew Research</figcaption></figure><p>Even if these stories are not statistically representative of the reality of the problem, the emotive quality of affecting Good Average Citizens and mapping onto existing conservative talking points will propel the panic onto the national policy agenda through the awesome political power of suburbia. American local TV coverage, a key trusted news source for millions of Americans, leans heavily on covering crime for content, leaving relatively little programming time for reporting on subjects that put that crime in context, like city government, the economy, or social issues.</p><p>In 1985 at the height of the Satanic Panic, the prominent mainstream news program <em>20/20</em> ran an “investigative piece” called “<a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2378615/">The Devil Worshipers</a>”. The episode presents a number of rumors as serious possibilities, notably the idea that a satanic cult “could be in your hometown”, and advancing the claim that targeted violence and sex crimes were being organized on a national scale by a satanic cabal. Despite presenting itself as a piece of Serious Journalism run by a Serious Journalism Show, the <em>20/20</em> episode repeated talking points of the satanic panic conspirators without providing the necessary context, namely the fact that the claims made are demonstrably false. When a large, mainstream media platform takes a fringe movement’s ideas seriously, it lends them an air of legitimacy, even if the media source does not explicitly endorse the movement. Throughout the 1980s and 90s, the supposed threats of satanism and stranger danger abduction were taken seriously as an extremist risk by communities and law enforcement.</p><p>The national conversation on online extremism has become focused on the QAnon movement, a bizarre set of interlocking conspiracy theories based on the claim that the world is ruled by a satanic cabal that abducts and abuses children. The movement is essentially an elaborate modern fan-fiction based on age-old medieval “<a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/159529/qanon-blood-libel-satanic-panic">blood libel</a>” conspiracies that regained traction with <a href="https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan-government/henry-ford-and-jews-story-dearborn-didnt-want-told">antisemitic reactionaries</a> in early-twentieth century Europe and America. Its alternate reality grew out of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/27/technology/pizzagate-justin-bieber-qanon-tiktok.html">Pizzagate</a>, and was built around the cryptic 4Chan posts of “Q”, supposedly a high-ranking intelligence analyst. The movement considers the entire government to be part of the “Deep State” and compromised by the global cabal, with the exception of law enforcement, the military, and President Donald Trump, who the movement venerates as the liberator of mankind from cosmopolitan oppression. Followers look to “The Storm”, a series of mass arrests of cabal members they claim is imminent, and which will bring about “The Great Awakening”, a sort of evangelical rebirth of humanity.</p><p>QAnon conspiracies have spun off into several communities, from the right-wing militia movement to anti-vaxxers, to wellness influencers. Tech platforms have come under pressure to act, with the movement’s violent rhetoric occasionally translating into real world violence. Incidents of <a href="https://ctc.usma.edu/the-qanon-conspiracy-theory-a-security-threat-in-the-making/">armed violence</a> and <a href="https://www.thedailybeast.com/qanon-incited-her-to-kidnap-her-son-and-then-hid-her-from-the-law">attempted kidnapping</a> have been <a href="https://www.tampabay.com/florida-politics/buzz/2020/08/26/politifact-qanon-hoax-has-been-linked-to-violence-fox-news-greg-gutfeld-falsely-claimed-it-hasnt/">linked</a> to the movement’s ideology as promoted across multiple social media sites.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PHFeuWW_DCJFzRBKOntTsw.png" /><figcaption>Not your typical fringe conspiracy aesthetic</figcaption></figure><p>As more platforms have begun banning explicitly Q-promoting accounts and pages, the movement has begun to obfuscate. The slate of pro-Q marches in July and August around the world pitched themselves as “<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/28/technology/save-the-children-qanon.html">Save the Children</a>”, claiming to be promoting awareness around child sex trafficking. Save the Children posts mainly originate on Instagram, where a series of accounts with a distinctly millennial beauty brand influencer aesthetic boosted #SaveTheChildren in July. Many of these influencers’ accounts <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/08/how-instagram-aesthetics-repackage-qanon/615364/">follow or comment on</a> QAnon or Pizzagate posts, and their awareness campaigns around child trafficking <a href="https://www.vox.com/21436671/save-our-children-hashtag-qanon-pizzagate">repeat many</a> of the Q movement’s inflated statistical claims.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/676/1*Cb6M2UB8L5dAiom8hFvBNQ.png" /><figcaption>Notice the QAnon hashtags #greatawakening, #maga, and #painiscoming</figcaption></figure><p>The claims on child trafficking made by these influencer accounts are often accompanied by other forms of misinformation. Though many are likely just concerned parents motivated by misleading statistics, several influential Save The Children promoters also have posts promoting “Plandemic” conspiracies about Covid-19, anti-vaccine claims, anti-government sentiment, 9/11 trutherism and a litany of other online theory tropes. The account @informedmothers, apparently run by a young African American mother, posts typical internet conspiracies around Covid response and vaccines, and on August 3rd posted a photo of Tom Hank’s Walk of Fame star defaced with the word “pedophile” following the LA Save the Children march on July 30th — Hanks is often a target of QAnon harassment along with other celebrities, notably model and outspoken Trump critic Chrissy Teigen. Experts on social media have pointed out that Save the Children’s claims about child trafficking act as a kind of <a href="https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2020/9/25/21453036/save-the-children-qanon-human-trafficking-satantic-panic">gateway drug</a> to the conspiracy movement, attracting new recruits by using moral panic to send them down an increasingly radical rabbit hole.</p><p>On October 6th, Facebook effectively <a href="https://twitter.com/oneunderscore__/status/1313584836624429057">banished QAnon</a> from its platform. It removed pages, groups, and profiles across Facebook and Instagram that promote the conspiracy movement. Other platforms followed Facebook’s lead, include merchandise marketplace <a href="https://www.insider.com/etsy-will-remove-all-qanon-related-items-from-its-marketplace-2020-10">Etsy</a>, which many <a href="https://www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/wellness-influencers-q-anon/">influential QAnon promoters</a> have used to financially support themselves.</p><p>According to online radicalization researcher Marc-André Argentino, Facebook’s purge was <a href="https://soundcloud.com/qanonanonymous/episode-113-the-second-qanon-purge-mutation-feat-marc-andre-argentino#t=50:25">extremely effective</a>. All the major Q-promoting pages he had been tracking were removed within 24 hours of the announcement of the new policy, and the only pages remaining were groups or communities that may have members who engage in Q-type rhetoric, but that are not explicitly promoting the conspiracy theory. Of course it’s nearly impossible to remove radical elements from a platform entirely, especially a platform with over two billion members. But, as Argentino points out, by forcing hardcore members to hide their affiliations or leave, the movement becomes less able to advertise its views, and the <a href="https://journals.openedition.org/aad/3870">radicalization cycle</a> slows down.</p><p>Unlike its approach to disinformation campaigns like those around elections and Covid-19, Facebook’s response treats QAnon as a “<a href="https://twitter.com/oneunderscore__/status/1313585708838400002">militarized social movement</a>”, a new category with an entirely new set of associated policies. Facebook’s thinking was most influenced by <a href="https://twitter.com/brianfishman">Brian Fishman</a>, an expert on <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Master-Plan-al-Qaeda-Strategy-Victory/dp/0300221495?ie=UTF8&amp;*Version*=1&amp;*entries*=0">jihadist online radicalism</a> and the company’s Head of Counter Terrorism and Dangerous Organizations. The new “militarized social movement” category was created to address both the QAnon movement and the litany of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Terrorist-Next-Door-Militia-Movement/dp/0312320418">“militia” movements</a> across the <a href="https://www.npr.org/2020/10/09/922319136/michigan-domestic-terror-plot-sends-shockwaves-through-militia-world">United States</a> and <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53273154">Canada</a>. Despite relative dormancy in the 2000s, right-wing violent self-described militia groups were treated by the FBI as a serious domestic terror threat in the 1990s, and have seen a growing resurgence in recent years.</p><p>The success of save the children shows that the effects of de-platforming, at least as portrayed in the discourse, are poorly understood. When it was banned from Reddit in 2018, the Q community didn’t up and move to 8Kun or <a href="https://www.thedailybeast.com/parler-the-trumpy-alternative-to-twitter-is-already-falling-apart">Parler</a> or <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2019/7/12/20691957/mastodon-decentralized-social-network-gab-migration-fediverse-app-blocking">Gab</a>. It didn’t retreat to the dark extremities of the web. It stayed on large platforms where it could maintain contact with “the normies”. Mass movements need mass, and the masses are not on dark web forums — suburban moms and B-list influencers do not hang out on 8chan, they’re on Facebook and Instagram. Without large social networks’ tolerance of the expanding Q base on their platforms, the success of the broader Save the Children movement would have been impossible.</p><p>The irony is that, whereas episodes like the Today Show’s <em>Stranger Danger</em> obsession and the <em>Satanic Panic 20/20</em> piece were the result of conscious editorial decision-making, our new panic was not knowingly endorsed in the same way. Today’s social media companies may have been willfully ignorant of QAnon’s prominence on their platforms, but they never actively decided to promote it. Instead, we see the inherent weaknesses of engagement-based algorithmic content distribution that have become tropes of tech critiques: that they favor knee-jerk emotionalism, outrage, and conflict. That said, Facebook, Twitter, and others <em>did</em> get the moral panic ratings boost, wittingly or not. Negligence yielded the same result as complicity.</p><p>I would concede that Facebook has indeed done the right thing by blanket banning the movement very broadly, but at this point it’s too little too late. The barbarians are inside the gates and Facebook is doing damage control. Their nuclear option response is an acknowledgment of how ineffective their more tolerant approaches have been. The link between conspiracy theories and online radicalization has been out in the discourse for decades, and disinformation and extremism experts have been pointing to QAnon as a possible source of violence and radicalism for at least a year now. But action wasn’t taken until the movement had already gotten what it needed out of these platforms: recruits and exposure.</p><p>The QAnon movement has reached a fever pitch. We don’t have reliable estimates on the number of adherents, but the fact that <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/aug/24/wave-rightwing-republicans-run-office-trump-blessing-extremist">dozens of candidates</a> across the country have won Republican primaries while publicly endorsing QAnon means the movement’s conspiratorial ideas have become a part of the mainstream discourse. Major social platforms could have <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/06/26/facebook-hate-speech-policies/">enforced</a> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/08/opinion/twitter-alex-jones-jack-dorsey.html">their</a> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/14/opinion/facebook-holocaust-denial.html?action=click&amp;block=associated_collection_recirc&amp;impression_id=2d8d8780-0f37-11eb-a5a4-67a683d40acf&amp;index=0&amp;pgtype=Article&amp;region=footer">own</a> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/28/opinion/sunday/coronavirus-misinformation-faceboook.html?action=click&amp;module=RelatedLinks&amp;pgtype=Article">rules</a> in a stricter sense and forced the movement back from the shitposting boards from whence it came, but too many chose inaction over controversy.</p><p><strong><em>Jackson Oliver Webster </em></strong><em>is a security researcher and regular </em>Wonk Bridge<em> contributor based in Los Angeles. His work focuses on information security, disinformation campaigns, and European and American politics.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e40e8c2c9e7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/satanic-panic-2-facebook-boogaloo-2e40e8c2c9e7">Satanic Panic 2: Facebook Boogaloo</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Who Watches the Watchers?’ — The Internet and the Panopticon]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/who-watches-the-watchers-the-internet-and-the-panopticon-8e5bedf169a6?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e5bedf169a6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[panopticon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cybersecurity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-rights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sebastian Vogelpoel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Oct 2020 15:23:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-13T15:23:28.409Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>‘Who Watches the Watchers?’ — The Internet and the Panopticon</h3><h4>How the philosophical concept of the Panopticon can help us visualise the structure of the internet and our position in it.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CnGt6SYiBLfOPBg3VVW3Fg.png" /></figure><p>Recently, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Rl82OQDoOc&amp;t=6574s&amp;ab_channel=PowerfulJRE">watching the Joe Rogan show</a>, it struck me how Edward Snowden used a philosophical concept known as the Panopticon in order to frame abuses of online data and privacy protection.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F_Rl82OQDoOc%3Fstart%3D6574%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D6574&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D_Rl82OQDoOc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F_Rl82OQDoOc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bf4f3975ecc7c6967b0ce5d8066bc4ec/href">https://medium.com/media/bf4f3975ecc7c6967b0ce5d8066bc4ec/href</a></iframe><p>The concept of the Panopticon is fascinating; the name derives from the ‘many-eyed’ giant of Greek mythology Panoptes, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bentham/">although the concept itself refers to an architectural prison design by the 18th century utilitarian philosopher Jeremy Bentham. </a>What sets this specific design apart is a singular but important detail of an observation deck from which guards can secretly view all prisoners. The intention of the design is part of a grander utilitarian attempt to supplant God with human mechanisms which ensure good moral conduct. From its introduction, this idea received significant backlash from other philosophers. Edmund Burke wrote at the time that it was “the spider in the web”. More recently, Foucault latched onto the concept as an illustration, as he saw it, of how “capitalist, bourgeois values” are forced into the internal psyche of individuals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*g6d79hy5fM-RxNgX.jpg" /><figcaption>Panopticon according to Bentham’s original design</figcaption></figure><p>Nowadays, it can be heard used as a <a href="https://www.e-ir.info/2016/05/19/knowledge-is-power-the-internet-panopticon-as-a-weapon-against-terror/">symbol of the internet</a>; of how through our daily use of it, it is possible for larger systems to observe the individual better than ever before. This raises the question, assuming Edward Snowdon is correct to use the Panopticon in relation to the internet:</p><blockquote>What does the Panopticon concept offer us in terms of understanding the relationship between individual and society in today’s world and what future developments might result from this understanding?</blockquote><h3>The Internet-as-Panopticon</h3><p>Why can the online world be defined as a Panopticon? Well, extending the rationality of Bentham’s approach, the modern world gives greater means to view patterns of human behaviour than Bentham could ever dream of with his optical tower design. Governments attempt to track patterns of online behaviour to deem whether or not individuals have <a href="https://www.e-ir.info/2016/05/19/knowledge-is-power-the-internet-panopticon-as-a-weapon-against-terror/">criminal intent</a>. Social media and search platforms track our conversations and find patterns through cookies for commercial targeting. Judging by recent elections the internet is increasingly becoming the premier platform for how society and culture develops — one’s digital life, in the extent of the imprint and influence it leaves, is in many ways the most decisive area of one’s total life.</p><p>Even on a more individual level, everyone is aware that there is a digital footprint and that companies evaluate potential employees based on this. There is a generally understood rule that what is said online is more likely to have consequences in future compared to what is said face-to-face.</p><h4>The individual as a ‘prisoner’ of the Panopticon</h4><p>This present reality forces us to consider our own digital footprint and what can be done to uphold personal privacy. Individually if we examine our patterns of online activity as a ‘cell’ that can be observed, how do we lessen the degree to which we can be observed?</p><p>The first thought to mind is to decrease our online presence; however, to end one’s internet use would be to end one’s own personal development within much of modern culture. So, in addition, it’s worth using technology to aid your privacy. The use of VPNs and anti-virus software can help significantly in making your panopticon cell more private. Location information, search history, information online is captured through a wide spectrum of consent, which can be better guarded against. Even when on unrelated websites online, search platforms and social media websites still collect your data through cookies. This data does offer the user something in return for allowing their data to be monetized, namely a more personalised online advertisement environment which it may be advantageous to be engaged with, as long as users are aware of the fact that this process frames your online use, potentially guiding you as much as you guide yourself. [1]</p><p>In the near future, we are likely to see increased trends of data-guzzling devices from wearable health monitors, censor embedded equipment and better voice and face capturing technology. Personal sacrifices regarding data sharing appear a growing inevitability and consistent ‘prisoner’ challenge between engaging with tech trends and maintaining a private sphere. [2]</p><p>Today, more than ever before, we have an increased ability to connect by virtue of the same technology that also observes us. However, this wider sense of communication also means an increased caution as to what is communicated. Indeed, we internally decide not to post a particular opinion or picture which might haunt us in future. It is even indicated in the change of social media preferences away from <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/r-facebook-used-less-for-news-as-youngsters-turn-to-whatsapp-reuters-institute-2018-6?IR=T">Facebook to Whatsapp (more chat-based) and Instagram </a>being dominated by pictures decreasing the need to communicate an opinion. Thus we could theorise that there has been a shift in trends of social media use according to an awareness of how data is used.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5guAyYOCJiUKXlOs.jpg" /></figure><p><a href="https://www.georgefm.co.nz/home/our-news/news/2017/03/five-normal-people-whose-lives-got-rekt-by-a-meme-.html"><em>Pictures which become termed memes often have very real-world consequences for the people pictured and those involved.</em></a></p><p>Do we increasingly shy away from meaningfully making our own statements, compared to when Facebook <em>et al</em> was introduced? If we do voice opinions of our own it appears we increasingly do it in a chat which we view as more private.</p><h4>The role of the Panopticon ‘guard’ online</h4><p>The concept of the Panopticon appears not only to be an effective allegory for our use of the internet but intimately connected to how we treat technologies with suspicion, how we act simultaneously as willing and unwilling participants or ‘prisoners’ within the Panopticon framework. However, just focusing on the ‘prisoner’ would be to miss the other half of the concept which is fundamental to a fuller understanding. We need to consider the systemic design of the ‘cell’, but more importantly the human component — the prison ‘guard’.</p><p>With a system as complicated as the internet it’s impossible to pin down this ‘guard’ role as being the domain of a single individual or entity. For this reason it’s important to identify and look at the layers at which a ‘guard’ would make observations, and what the intent of such observations would be. The prison ‘guard’s role consists of them focusing not only on safety but also with making a moral impact on prisoners before their eventual release. Furthermore, they must also think about control and their own role within the rest of society.</p><p>The first layer and the most important would be the prison guard observing in order to ensure safety and preventing crime. Indeed, today this is the easiest reason especially for government to gain access to information. This is also the most important when considering Snowdon’s criticism of the government’s collecting of data, namely that they use fear to act beyond an appropriate scope of action. The ‘guard’ is required to decipher a vast amount of data, which needs not only to be compiled but value judged by a human being making it very difficult to identify individuals with criminal intent. This is especially true considering that such individuals are the most likely to be cautious in their online use. We can therefore challenge the necessity of capturing an entire population’s data if it is uncertain whether this is an effective means of investigation. Something that appears to be the case with regard to t<a href="https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/09/nsa-spying-exposed-by-snowden-was-illegal-and-not-very-useful-court-says/">he Patriot Act, which has had a 0% success rate at least as indicated by a US federal appeals court recently.</a></p><p>The second layer of observation concerns the power of the ‘guard’ and the social expectations that define their role. Namely, it concerns not preventing immediate harm, but rather evaluating intent and actions that affect the structure of the ‘cells’ and the interaction between prisoners. Unlike in the first observation, the ‘guard’ analogy is weaker because although government rules and regulations play a role in determining morality, private individuals, corporations and the nebulous term of culture play a potentially larger role. Moderating content is the online equivalent of placing unruly prisoners in isolation and the creating of routine and selection of activities that should be adhered to. In our world, online content can be moderated in terms of laws, especially those that concern ‘hate speech’, but it can also be moderated by online platforms themselves. However, this is a fraught process as what is deemed appropriate or not invites conflicting subjective appraisal. Indeed differences in platforms can be as wide as culture itself with sites like 4chan gaining a reputation for more extreme (especially right-wing) political expressions whereas other channels like the Guardian can anecdotally be observed as having a more left-of-centre bias.</p><p>Like in the Panopticon prison, behaviour defined as morally wrong is set according to rules, online this is codified by national laws and a website code of conduct. These rules contain a human component of deeming the seriousness of behaviour. Thus, the ‘guard’ also has the task of deciding on penalties. Giving no answer could lead to an escalation of behaviour, while too strong a response could be viewed as tyrannical. In reality, no response would satisfy website users to the same extent as fear-based responses defined in the first observation would. Moreover, the same problem of volumes of data is apparent in the first and second layers of observation. There is also a mental strain forced upon the ‘guard’ who has to go<a href="https://techcrunch.com/2020/05/12/facebook-moderators-ptsd-settlement/?guccounter=1&amp;guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&amp;guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAI9j5oF5NEI3BldshsaNjLTHSxmbn72-ByUgzbtNyYBq4gS1S9IuShVcLzGTKHBbZDBw8A4njW4TP1er-D7KVCA1-LBbtvKug639CWV4yAHN4yILLbBMTpRTmurP_bXphCH9n8XjhYGE5KbSBjsdGjiOCOJYPRqg7NiVuOQjz98l"> through tremendous amounts of shocking content</a>. People will tend to focus on extreme ends that prove their point:</p><ul><li>“The prison guard didn’t do enough; they’re weak; they didn’t take this [example of offensive content to left/right] down”</li><li>“The prison guard is excessive, they took this [example of offensive content to left/right, whichever was not used in prior example] down.”</li></ul><p>The identity of those involved in prison guarding will be endlessly examined by people from every political and cultural persuasion to work out the guard&#39;s personal position. Often leading to a projection of the image of the guard which doesn’t fit with reality but rather suits the narrative of the world that the observing ‘prisoner’ themselves has.</p><p>Thirdly and connected with the second point by what conduct is the guard governed, how far does that role get influenced by the outside? For governments, we hope even as political parties change there’s a coherent structure maintained in the form of a civil administration which upholds rules. In effect, it is necessary especially in a democracy to have an element of trust that officials are held accountable for their actions. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/sep/25/nsa-reform-fire-officials-lied">However, if as Edward Snowdon suggests, the NSA has so far been immune to prosecution, then this belief is under threat.</a></p><p>Furthermore, because data use isn’t limited to just governments the same question has to be asked of online platforms. Do they take a particular position, or do they try and remain as neutral as possible to ensure business longevity and success? The size of users on many online platforms outsizes the populations of many countries, with such a powerful position it becomes more difficult to perceive a ‘guard’ as neutral. Moreover, it may be more profitable to support certain causes, commercial demands mix uneasily with other social demands. Look for instance at the large number of companies which proclaim themselves as woke. Differences between cultures and national structures can also lead to even the most commercially minded firms to become slaves to demands from outside users or national structures. If, for instance, companies wish for access to certain markets, then this can come with moral demands which create mismatches with how they forward themselves in another part of the world. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/12/zoom-admits-cutting-off-activists-accounts-in-obedience-to-china">Zoom admitting that it caved to Chinese pressure to undermine communication between CCP dissidents being a very good recent example.</a></p><p>This taking of a moral stance of how the ‘guard’ structures the ‘cell’ in terms of what content is allowed, can have the consequence of the ‘prisoner’ disassociating more with his environment. Taking a particular moral stance can have the opposite effect of increasing adversity to the ‘guards’ role rather than acceptance or support. What is referred to as the <a href="https://www.aipc.net.au/articles/what-is-psychological-shadow/">shadow in psychology</a> is forced to be withheld encouraging people to not engage with social media in the same way as they did previously. If they do engage it is with a broader movement, idea of mass hashtags, changes in profile pictures. Is this in itself a kind of safety reaction, valve release and prison riot, groups being more likely to expand exponentially because of the nature of the online medium, but also this response factor indicating that people feel less able to respond for themselves?</p><p>Prisoners in a state of repression, like people in general living under tyrannical conditions, assert their self and spirit through seditious activity. In a similar vein of thought, the desire for individuals online to assert themselves doesn’t go away and potentially contributes to the mental strain inflicted on the ‘guard’, as people create fake accounts to release pent-up dark feelings upon the world. A trend towards undermining speech appears to create and encourage a more extreme form of counter expression. <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/cultivating-an-authentic-online-image-1b9f876a0d1b">It also means on those occasions when this environment is perceived to be broken, there is far more power to it.</a></p><p>The book/film <em>One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest</em> by Ken Kesey illustrates the Panopticon idea of a feedback loop between ‘guard’ and ‘prisoner’, and the negative spiral that this can cause. In this work of fiction the ‘guard,’ Nurse Ratched, who is in charge of patients in a mental asylum, uses an extensive system of rules and regulations. She does so not to help patients or ‘prisoners’ but in order to assert authority and sate her thirst for power. Her goal is to break patients down, establish proprietary control over them, and reinforce the notion that ‘prisoners’ must conform to social expectations if they wish to be cured. She relies on threats and acts of personal degradation such as withholding medicine or capitalising on ‘prisoner’ shame and fear to have her way. It is for this reason that the appearance of a new ‘prisoner’ Randle Mcmurphy, who isn’t really mentally ill and has the intention to cause havoc presents such a significant threat to Ratched. By virtue of the way she has designed mental asylum life, she has granted Mcmurphy maximum opportunity to be effective in his havoc-creating endeavours. The ‘prisoners’, seeing Randle’s activities, are able to take heart, and are ostensibly freed from the belief that they have to be subservient. Moreover, Randle himself finds greater purpose in his actions and is even more committed to continuing them. As a result, both figures in this panopticon become committed to the destruction of the other; to commit to any other course of action would be to voluntarily give up their worldview. It’s a very personal internal battle as well as an external one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/857/0*81pvvGtS9SQx9hrr.jpg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.slashfilm.com/the-quarantine-stream-justice-for-nurse-ratched-in-one-flew-over-the-cuckoos-nest/">https://www.slashfilm.com/the-quarantine-stream-justice-for-nurse-ratched-in-one-flew-over-the-cuckoos-nest/</a></figcaption></figure><p>Effectively the book and film illustrate how in a constricted social framework shock value can find more power than it otherwise would. This is something that is especially illustrated in our modern times with politics becoming more divisive with people aligning to ‘guard’ panopticon norms or completely opposing them, increasingly building tension and less of an in-between. In the book, this alignment leads to nurse Ratched to behave like more and more of a draconian martinet, which only adds to her loss of control. Likewise in terms of efforts to moderate content online, while it may dam opinions that could otherwise be expressed, it in fact only encourages movement elsewhere and incentivises ferocity and damaging behaviour. Increasingly, we see political figures across the world, but most memorably Donald Trump, using this to significant advantage. Like McMurphy, the power is less the individual themselves, but rather the fact that they are perceived as antagonising the right people, and offering a general breath of fresh air in doing so.</p><p>The model of the Panopticon comes with a huge note of caution attached to it when it is brought into real life. Bentham’s over-rational approach to society reinforces certainties concerning right and wrong, especially when the approach taken is very hierarchical top-down. It is notable for instance that the most famous example of the panopticon design put into practice the <em>Presidio Modelo</em> in Cuba was used by both the Batista and Castro regimes to imprison political prisoners. The prison serving as an allegory of the revolution in that country and while social views flipped an authoritarian structure didn’t and poets and many independent individuals continued to stay in the same prison cells.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*7jJV44Uv4n2ZpmNB.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Presidio Modelo today</em></figcaption></figure><p>Bentham’s panopticon deserves defending even if it is too rational a construction, encouraging the Foucaultian view that the design is necessarily top-down. As has been illustrated above, the position of the ‘guard’ can also be humanised, and therefore the interaction between ‘prisoner’ and ‘guard’ needn’t be one-sided. In fact, Bentham’s ideas have an interesting history used by both free-market libertarians and socialists. The idea that social utility could be calculated based on the aggregate of individual interests impressed left-wing economists like W. S. Jevons who used it in developing economic theories in the direction of modern welfare economics. On the other hand libertarians such as Herbert Spencer also deployed the utility principle in <em>Man versus the State</em> (1884) and other writings to underwrite the liberty of the individual, defend the existing social order, and attack the drift towards socialism and “slavery”. [3]</p><p>We can’t assume that Bentham was naïve in believing that his panopticon could on its own create an ideally happy society, although he was naïve in believing happiness could be rationally calculated. So Bentham tries to create the best argument possible for his critics with a system of self-checking balances. For instance, the prison guard would have to be a highly tested and trained technocrat such that he could make the best moral decisions. But more importantly, such efforts would have to be matched by a completely free press and the prison guard would have to be accountable for all his/her decisions. [4]</p><p>Edward Snowdon used the more libertarian framing of the Panopticon to look at the problem, his principle point being that officials in charge of efforts to gather data are not publically accountable. As a result, they act beyond legal mandate in many cases, and even where they have legal powers they are unable to offer sufficient proof of the need or effectiveness of having those powers in the first place.</p><p>In reality, the online environment does not have any single ‘guard’ or even a singular ‘cell’ design but has different layers and interactions between them. Opinions voiced online are first viewed by individuals, whether employers or friend groups and these reinforce what can be said online as saying the wrong thing can have damaging consequences within your close circle. Above this layer, we have online platforms themselves, specifically search engines and social media websites, which use our data to compress us into commercially viable products as well as increasingly asserting moral positions. At the final layer, we have law and legislature, and the power that these have over cyber-space. All of these different layers interact.</p><p>The idea of the Panopticon is worth taking seriously because most aspects of society already take it seriously as a form of risk management. For instance, if a company is involved heavily in business options with a country like China, and an individual applying for a job there promotes free Hong Kong, then that alone could be sufficient reason for that job not to be given to that candidate. The decision hasn’t been taken because of any existing laws or regulations, but rather a shadow of the future, a custom.</p><p>Online platforms have the choice to make between using their powerful company position to act as the prison guard, to play a role in social moral realignment, or to act more like a business. There is an argument to be made that, regardless of their position, companies of such vast size and influence will act in both roles by default. <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/facebook-employees-go-public-disagreement-over-zuckerberg-s-handling-trump-n1220961">However, the dichotomy takes form in the ongoing tumult surrounding the responsibility such platforms do or do not bear to police content on their sites.</a></p><p>The most important aspect of the online panopticon is the intersection between Government and Online Companies. If companies hand data over to one government it becomes more difficult to refuse to hand data over to others. As a result, these companies, wittingly or unwittingly, become fixtures of wider government and social policy. If they choose to align themselves to social norms then they will also face increased backlash and later overthrow from younger companies more able to align with the moral tenor of a later day. Online companies see this issue and want to encourage end-to-end encryption so that the task of managing data falls outside of their remit and increasingly is a requirement of states themselves. This raises an interesting question concerning the idea of the ‘guard’ and whether this would simplify the issue of responsibility, given that governments would be more responsible for moderating content and potentially, therefore, checks and balances would be easier to uphold.</p><p>The Panopticon is a fascinating rational model with which to observe society and therein lies the strengths and limitations of the concept. Bentham would be staggered by the Panopticon possibilities that the online world brings, allowing for observation and personal information as he could only have dreamed of. Therein lies the problem, with all this information and data comes also the increased desire to use it to a moral effect. What the Panopticon both as an idea and as a physical historical example suggests is moral enforcement never has one direction of travel, something also illustrated in the political divisions of today. Rationally the online realm like much of society needs feedback loops for it to function well. Problems arise if morality is treated as a data pattern. To think this way only makes the concepts of ‘guard’, ‘prisoner’ and ‘cell’ all the more real. We should encourage a simplification of what is and isn’t allowed in data gathering because if we don’t the lessons from the Panopticon as Foucault describes it namely a decrease in personal space and the fermenting of revolution within the structure become more likely realities. Finally, the online realm like any realm in your life is something that you have a say over how you relate to it, engage online and elsewhere accordingly.</p><p>[1] https://www.wired.com/story/wired-guide-personal-data-collection/</p><p>[2] <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/wired-guide-personal-data-collection/">https://www.wired.com/story/wired-guide-personal-data-collection/</a></p><p>[3] <a href="https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft638nb3db;chunk.id=d0e10520;doc.view=print">https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft638nb3db;chunk.id=d0e10520;doc.view=print</a></p><p>[4] <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bentham/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/bentham/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e5bedf169a6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/who-watches-the-watchers-the-internet-and-the-panopticon-8e5bedf169a6">‘Who Watches the Watchers?’ — The Internet and the Panopticon</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Are You? A Short history of Identity Online]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/social-media-and-identity-d92fa6939ee8?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d92fa6939ee8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hamish Pottinger]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Sep 2020 20:57:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-02T19:32:44.854Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>What social media does with us and what we do with it…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*DgUHepAHCJKjmrYlbaBMMQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Internet is a bit like gravity, immune systems, or verbal communication — a humble miracle which we abuse, and which becomes more improbable and complicated the more we try to comprehend it. And despite bookending our waking days and being the topic and medium of so much conversation, how much do we actually know about the effect of Mark Zuckerberg’s apps — through which a huge part of our contribution to and understanding of the world occurs — on our identities?</p><p>Social media is* an era-defining phenomenon because it has reinvented communication; up to the beginning of any adult’s lifetime, human interaction took place predominantly in a single time or place — mostly both. The TV news was shown at a specific time in your country, and if it made you want to call Tony Blair a liar you probably said it to your partner or cat. Now, anything can be viewed by anyone, anywhere if content is made accessible to the public. Private communication can also occur in any place and at any time. This turns out to be quite a big deal when you consider how much of our lives — work, music, politics, family, and religion — is mediated by apps. So, how exactly are our identities being reshaped?</p><p>An initial line of thinking might be this:</p><blockquote>globalisation (fact) = increased awareness of the lives of others (feeling)</blockquote><p>Or, in other words:</p><blockquote>visibility beyond borders (fact) = mutual understanding and cultural homogenisation (feeling)</blockquote><p>This is the idea that the Internet breaks down national barriers and gives the world a more singular identity. In some respects, it seems intuitive — there are plenty of examples of cultural practices spreading rapidly with the movement of people and things, from the ubiquitous consumption of <a href="https://yaleglobal.yale.edu/coffee-long-way-ethiopia">coffee </a>and <a href="https://yaleglobal.yale.edu/famine-fries-potato-has-come-long-way">potatoes</a> to the birth of such precious international music genres as <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QL1JzeAjAs">Turkish psychedelic rock</a> or <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7UgkNDAUYQ">Nigerian synth funk</a>. In fact, culture no longer has to spread across borders, but already exists in its own delocalised and often anonymous world online. This is why we see a kind of universal culture emerging synchronously through the likes of Instagram and TikTok, manifested in the form of dances, clothes, images (memes), interests (likes and follows), and crazes.</p><h3>Global village, global pillage, local knowledge</h3><p>Are we becoming <em>homogenised, </em>then?<em> </em>While it is tempting to assume so, the more we explore the idea of homogenisation, the less certain it seems. Yes, a given human being will likely have a Samsung or Apple device somewhere on her person. Yes, democracy more or less reigns in all continents (I’m counting the social dynamics of penguin huddles). But economies are one thing and culture another; in terms of our values and practices, <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/how-our-technological-culture-has-decimated-our-attention-spans-cd1c7b32fb48">while there are bound to be similarities emerging</a>, in many ways we are still different.</p><p>In the UK and the US we aren’t adopting foreign styles of dressing or dancing — and are mostly discouraged from doing so. It also seems obvious that nationalism and wilful ignorance of the experience of others is rife; on the morning of writing, the BBC headlines include two separate disputes over national waters in the Aegean and the Strait of Taiwan, and a MAGA rally that defied Covid-19 regulations — each of them backed by no small number of nationalists. Also in the news today is <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/stories-54191344">the emergence of ‘LGBT-free zones’, the result of a movement whose leader cites Western sexual ideology as a threat to Polish traditions</a>. The movement distributes stickers that show an ‘X’ running through the rainbow flag, placing itself in opposition to an image that is understood globally as a symbol of tolerance. So much for mutual understanding, then.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8h0nLkx_JXfaxWBCBSVOcg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Nevertheless, like with any complex phenomenon the natural human reaction is to latch onto a belief to make sense of it all — hence ‘globalisation’ is taken for granted as something that has happened over the last 20 or so years. Yet evidence that globalisation is not a straightforward process can be found in the collective belief that it is. In other words, the mere <em>perception </em>that Western culture is taking over leads to acts of resistance; anti-English language and anti-cultural appropriation sentiments express understandable fears that traditions which define identities are being broken down and/or illegitimately consumed. Naturally, people from minority cultures might therefore place more importance on their identities and practices, and use the global resource of social media to do so.</p><p>But, you might say, those interested in foreign cultural practices can engage with them on their phones. Absolutely — our window to the outside world has rapidly moved from collective mass media consumption to personalised feeds and if I’m into capoeira I will see Brazilians doing flips when I open up Instagram. My social media feeds are like no one else’s in the world — I define it and it defines me. But would this indicate that we are homogenised, or that we are <em>fragmented</em>? Are we now defined by our membership to microcultural groups, as gamers, korfball players, yoga practitioners, and horticulturalists? Rather than all being same, we could now be infinitely different. Given that we are now in control of our media, and it makes no difference whether our interlocutors are sitting in the house next door or in Paraguay, aren’t locality and nationality irrelevant to our identities?</p><p>Not quite — life online is still bound to geographical location. Our Facebook friends are still mostly made up of people physically close to us and our news consumption is probably national or local. Also, if social media can strengthen ties for those with niche cultural interests, it can do so for those with an interest in their nation as well. Moments of collective national experience — royal weddings and elections — are still published, consumed, and discussed with disgust, zeal, and venom on Twitter. We may process the world in a delocalised cyberspace, but that is still a place with frontiers.</p><p>What’s more, those frontiers may be policed by nation-states that (try to) ban certain apps and exploit the popularity of others. Cambridge Analytica certainly made a good go of harvesting our contributions to the world while manipulating the aforementioned personalised flow of information to push not-so-personalised nationalist rhetoric on the receiver. We are not in control of our feeds after all. Social media has not quite signalled the ‘death of the state’ as some claim. Rather, governments maintain the power to promote ideal values and identities from both above and below, at both macro-levels of communication (by manipulating advertising/posting content on official accounts) and micro-level ones (generating shares, comments, and discussion).</p><h3>The verdict</h3><p>So, which is it, <em>fragmentation </em>or <em>homogenisation</em>?</p><p>Hmm. It is probably impossible to measure at the level of academic research, though is seems that these two ideas, although contradictory, are not mutually exclusive. A curious and convincing answer from Prof. Stig Hjarvard suggests that various things are happening at once, and it cannot be said that new technologies move society in any single direction. Crudely summarised, he describes how, in two separate ways, our cultural identity flows freely across borders:</p><h4><em>Global identity:</em></h4><ul><li>Fortnite dances, dabbing, bottle flips, things generally done by adolescent boys that drink Monster.</li><li>Cardi B, <em>Despacito</em>, Kim Kardashian, and other phenomena that are the topic of conversation for millions (billions?) of people worldwide.</li></ul><h4><em>Individual identity:</em></h4><ul><li>The ability to be part of transnational ‘microcultures’ of your choosing — gamers, knitters, samba for Satanists, etc.</li><li>Your personal feed (when not violated by Dominic Cummings)</li><li>Uploading content of yourself for public consumption</li></ul><p>And in two ways, our identities are still connected to where we live:</p><h4><em>National identity:</em></h4><ul><li>Collective ripping of Prince Andrew on Twitter</li><li>Captain Tom’s fundraiser</li><li>(Possibly sneaky) social media activity of political parties</li></ul><h4><em>Local identity:</em></h4><ul><li>Neighbourhood Facebook groups</li><li>Political separatist media</li></ul><p>It would be extremely wanting to conclude that life is just the same as before, just online. A world where you can figuratively walk up to the global elite and call them dinguses is not the same as a world with one radio station and no television. I think we would all agree that social media has changed us in <em>some </em>way, and I would argue that it does so variably in these four ways, and sometimes simultaneously. Sometimes, social media allows us to extend our preexisting, physical lives, but it can also expose us to all manner of novelties and take us away from our surroundings. Where the balance is drawn is impossible to tell and will inevitably vary depending on the person. And perhaps that’s just it — which of these four identities predominates will depend on what we believe, who and what we’re influenced by, what we (dis)like, and who we want to be. In true spirit of the age of personalised content, it is tailor-made for each one of us.</p><ul><li>Yes, I shall be using ‘media’ in the singular — please don’t @ me.</li></ul><p><a href="https://content.sciendo.com/view/journals/nor/29/2/article-p102.xml">Hjarvard, S. (2008). The mediatization of society. <em>Nordicom review</em>, <em>29</em>(2), 102–131</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d92fa6939ee8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/social-media-and-identity-d92fa6939ee8">Who Are You? A Short history of Identity Online</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge">Wonk Bridge</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dear Applicant, your interview will be on VR]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/dear-applicant-your-interview-will-be-on-vr-7391e5d668a9?source=rss----252b18208b92---4"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1920/1*h1p7Gn3g2JUt4e4dYk85-w.jpeg" width="1920"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Or how we&#x2019;d all like to interact with candidates and employees in a remote-working environment.</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/dear-applicant-your-interview-will-be-on-vr-7391e5d668a9?source=rss----252b18208b92---4">Continue reading on Wonk Bridge »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/wonk-bridge/dear-applicant-your-interview-will-be-on-vr-7391e5d668a9?source=rss----252b18208b92---4</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7391e5d668a9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virtual-reality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interview]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-humanities]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vr]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yuji Develle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Sep 2020 15:31:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-24T09:52:00.844Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>