Google Fi: Value Lost
I have been a Google Fi user for years. When it started, then ‘Project’ Fi was innovative. A flat rate $20 for text and voice, plus $10/gb. You could switch between multiple providers to expand coverage. But that is still what it is for their base plan. They do offer Simply Unlimited($50 a month for a single person), and Unlimited Plus($65 a person). But their unlimited plans only work if you have multiple people. You need 4 or more people to pay $25 a person. They do have a limited time promotion for new customers going on, but I’m only looking at what I’d ultimately end up paying.
Fi used to offer more, even with that plan. The occasional gift, a vending machine at the airport, good deals on hardware. But the deals only seem to be for new customers now. Long standing customers like me got nothing. You had full integration with Google Hangouts…which is An innovative little carrier has stagnated. Fi is also unique in that it has the top level of network prioritization on T-Mobile. It also offers extra data only SIMs on several plans. MVNOs usually, in congested areas, fall behind the provider’s service.
In the end, the price hasn’t gone done, and it is still $10 a GB when everyone else is reducing that cost.
So I started shopping around. I’m not including taxes by default below, so consider that on top of this. Also, unless I mention otherwise, unlimited text and voice and I’m not mentioning hotspotting at this time. For those of you outside the US, I’m only looking for myself. Apologies. For those Americans who travel outside the country, I did factor that in, but I’ll address that in a separate post.
Mint Mobile
Mint is very popular, however, its plans are most economical when bought in annual increments. So, we’re going to look at their annual plans. I’m willing to plop down 100% to start with.
- $15 a month for 5GB
- $20 a month for 15GB
- $25 a month for 20GB
- $30 a month for unlimited
Ting
I’m not sure I would have looked at Ting if they hadn’t been the first prepaid carrier I switched to when I left my parent’s family share plan. Ting isn’t who it once was. Ting was once the leader in ala carte pricing. Now their plans are more conventional and unimpressive.
- Set 5 – $25/month for 5GB
- Set 12 – $35/month for 12GB
- Unlimited – $45/month for 22GB
After you reach your limit, you’ll be slowed to a crawl. Any unused data carries over to the next month
MobileX
MobileX is the first MVNO I’ve mentioned that is running on Verizon, not T-Mobile. It has top priority on Verizon.
- Unlimited 10 – $14.88/month for 10GB
- Unlimited – $24.88 for unlimited
US Mobile
US Mobile offers a discount if you prepay annually. It is a bit more month to month
- Unlimited Flex – $17.50/month for annual, not available month to month
- Unlimited Started – $22.50/month for annual, $25 month to month
- Unlimited Premium – $32.50/month for annual, $35 month to month
The differences are in hotspot data, Starter includes International data, and Premium offers a free smartwatch plan and network transfers(which otherwise cost $2 each). Network transfers are interesting. They offer service on different major networks…without naming them. If you want to switch which one, you pay the $2 to change.
Either way, $210 for a year of unlimited isn’t bad.
Visible
Visible is actually a prepaid carrier owner by Verizon. But don’t call Verizon.
- Visible – $25/month for unlimited data on 5G/LTE, throttled video.
- Visible+ $45/month for unlimited at premium speed on their wideband network
Tello Mobile
I ended up giving Tello a chance. Tello offers ala carte plans like Ting once did, as well as unlimited.
- 1GB – $9/month
- 2GB – $10/month
- 5GB – $14/month
- 10GB – $25/month
- Unlimited Data(Really 35GB)/Minutes – $25 a month
You also don’t have to do unlimited phone/text, for example, $5/month gets you 1GB of data, and an extra $1 gets you 100 minutes and unlimited texts.
Conclusion
Picking a wireless carrier is extremely hard. There are a lot of good choices. And I only covered the ones that I considered because they fit my needs. I don’t stream video regularly. Since I got more data, I have been streaming music more, but I prefer my own music collection stored locally.
I was paying $20 a month for 2GB just to read and browse on my phone. That used to take less than 1GB…but all these sites are not concerned about data savings anymore. They are embedding autoplay videos, precaching resources, etc. So, without my behavior changing, I was using more data.
Ultimately, Tello won for the fact that I could justify the $25 a month(especially with a promo for 3 months at $15), but I could also switch down to 5GB a month which is still well above what I’m using on average. They made it extremely easy to set up and use an eSIM for a month in parallel with Fi as my phone supports that, then port my number over in 20 minutes. And even if I leave…I can still, thanks to the Pixel 9, try out anything for a month just to see what the experience is during my daily routine.
I did lose international included, but I’ll talk about that separately.