Sitemap

Catcalling Confuses Me

4 min readNov 5, 2014

I’ll admit up-front that what I’m about to say is probably going to be considered controversial and “anti-feminist” but I’m ok with that because I’m confused and I want to talk about it.

Catcalling has been all over the news and social media thanks to that video of the lady walking around New York video taping men who were “catcalling” her.

So, to start, I asked Google for the definition of catcalling and Google said:

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Google’s definition of catcall

That’s what I thought it was based on what I saw on TV shows/movies from New York in the 80's or 90's where a woman would pass a construction site and the men would whistle and say things that were sexual in nature to her.

But, in the video everyone is talking about, there are some men who say things like “God bless you” or “How you doing today?” or “Hey baby” or “Hey Mami” and it’s ALL considered catcalling her. Or the guy that walked beside her silently for 2 minutes, which although possibly weird or possibly coincidence, does not rise to the definition of catcalling.

The Pros and Cons

In my Google search for the definition of catcalling, I also encountered several articles with various positions on the topic. There’s one on Buzzfeed that explains 8 Reasons a Catcall is NOT a compliment. There’s another on NY Post that says Hey ladies — Catcalls are flattering deal with it!

The feminists want you to know that it’s unacceptable because apparently saying “hi” = harassment. The other side wants you to believe that if you don’t like being catcalled you’re sanctimonious and bitchy.

Some people want to put laws into place against it. Let’s let THAT sink in for a minute. They want LAWS to regulate what people say…in a country that PRIDES itself on the freedom of speech.

Everyone has an opinion about how women as an entire group should feel about something that we haven’t even fully defined.

What I do know is offense is a choice and every person is entitled to decide what is or isn’t offensive to them. This blanket statement about how all us women should rise in unity against The MAN who is trying to belittle us all by speaking to us on the street is crappy logic!

Then there’s the debate that if the guys who are doing the alleged catcalling were HOT Brad Pitt types, women wouldn’t be complaining, but instead blushing and giving out their phone number.

Get Nikki Johnson’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

So, is catcalling defined, in part, or in whole, by the attractiveness of the person making the comments?

This is exhausting!

My Confusion Gets Worse

Yesterday, social media was all a-flutter with the video of an interview on CNN where comedian/actress Amanda Diva and author Steve Santagati debate catcalling.

CNN debate on catcalling http://youtu.be/-HI4DC18wCg

Amanda says that a woman has the right to leave her house and walk in silence. Steve says if you don’t like what someone is saying to you, ask/tell them to stop. Amanda says that doing so could get you killed.

So NOW, I’m extra confused. If someone says something to me I don’t like, I’m not supposed to ask them to stop doing that because they could kill me? WTF!

Essentially, the argument, from what I can tell, is that women want to walk down the street without ANY man saying ANYTHING to them. Don’t speak to me. Don’t smile at me. Don’t say good morning. Don’t tell me I’m pretty/beautiful/sexy. DON’T SAY SHIT TO ME! Seriously? Is that how we’re doing things now?

I’m from the South. Old men say “hey baby” to women all the time. It’s not catcalling or a compliment, it’s just a greeting. People say “Good morning” and it doesn't mean that they want to sleep with you. I've been greeted by men in the grocery store who say “Hey beautiful” or “You’re beautiful” and it doesn't mean ANYTHING more than a greeting. But, this debate is turning it ALL into something sinister.

This is what I do understand — if a man is saying something obscene about how he wants to put his ___ in your ___ or how he’d like to mount you or even if he’s whistling at you, I can see how that’s inappropriate and/or rude. And a woman has every right to not respond to that.

Remember that episode of Sex & the City where Miranda got sick of the construction workers catcalling her and she went over and challenged the guy and he backed down and said he was married and it was just a joke? As Miranda put it, he was all talk and no action.

Miranda vs. Construction Worker SATC http://youtu.be/YEMM9N3cTP4

I just wish we didn't live in a time where EVERYONE wants to make EVERYTHING a big deal. If a person is harassing you in a way that makes you uncomfortable, then you have every right to ask them to stop doing it and not fear for your safety or your life in doing so.

That said, I also don’t think it would be pleasant to live in a time where people are afraid to speak to people of the opposite sex because it’s considered harassment just to say “Hello.”

--

--

Nikki Johnson
Nikki Johnson

Written by Nikki Johnson

Just a girl who is passionate. In pursuit of happiness — for myself and others. Trying to help people along the way — myself included.