A Rising (black) Tide:
Voting is addictive.
Regardless of one’s age or education, considered by political scientists to be two of the best gauges for future voting habits, the best way to know if someone is going to vote in the next election is whether or not they voted in the last one. Those relatively few Americans who voted in last week’s midterm elections are, all things considered, more likely to have voted in 2012 or 2010, and they’re more likely to vote in 2016. Engaging in the political process not only helps create a more responsive, politically engaged electorate, it increases the likelihood that those newly engaged voters will participate in the future.
For Democrats, that news was supposed to be more comforting.
In the euphoria following 2008, it wasn’t unheard of to hear Democratic pundits talking about a new majority, echoing similarly ahistorical cries from some Republicans after the 2004 elections. This delusion — and it was a delusion — wasn’t completely unfounded given what the Party had experienced. Typically apathetic constituencies (minorities, millennials, and urban dwellers, for instance) voted in record numbers that year, and they voted overwhelmingly for the President. For instance, first-time voters made up 11% of the electorate in 2008, and President Obama won 69% of their votes. With this new coalition, atop their traditional base, Democrats won victories in places that had eluded the Party electorally for decades, like Colorado, North Carolina, and Virginia. Unsurprisingly, Democrats weren’t able to motivate their new coalition during the 2010 off-year elections, and were ultimately overwhelmed by a Republican wave.
As Pew Research noted, “57.1% of the voting-age population cast ballots [in 2008]….But two years later only 36.9% voted in the midterm election that put the House back in Republican hands.” Democrats may have turned out new or apathetic voters in 2008, but 2010 proved that one election wasn’t enough to break the long-term participation trends common in midterm elections. For the Obama Coalition, voting hadn’t quite become a habit yet. But after two years and more than $1 billion dollars, Democrats were rewarded when President Obama (and his digital team) were able to turn out their coalition in 2012 and secure re-election, proving false allegations that 2008 was an electoral fluke. Virginia and Colorado remained in the Democratic column, and North Carolina was close. Georgia, where the President hadn’t spent much time or money, suddenly appeared within striking distance for Democrats. Many in the Party were cautiously optimistic that changing demographics and their superior GOTV operations were now enough to mitigate anticipated losses in the 2014 midterm elections.
We know now that Democrats were wrong.
Democrats’ efforts to hook their new coalition on voting has hit a midterm snag. Despite millions of dollars spent in advertising and targeted GOTV operations, turnout in this year’s midterm elections was the lowest experienced since World War II. Even after two national elections to help solidify voting as a habit, most of the coalition that elected President Obama largely stayed home this year — leaving an electorate that was older, whiter, and more rural than expected. Democrats lost young voters, and the Latino share of the electorate declined as well, likely a result of delayed action on immigration. Five senators elected alongside President Obama in 2008 were also defeated last week. Republicans control both Houses of Congress, more State Legislatures, more Governorships, and have a 5–4 majority on the Supreme Court. In the political analysis conducted afterward, some are suggesting that Republicans are now America’s majority party. The electoral drubbing was so severe that the DNC plans to conduct an official autopsy to diagnose and propose solutions to their midterm problem.
Such self-reflection is no doubt an important part of righting the Party’s fortunes heading into 2016. But as Democrats craft a strategy for getting apathetic voters habituated to voting, they should perhaps look to the African-American community for guidance. After years of uneven participation rates, it seems as if Black voters are starting to pick up the habit.
When President Lyndon Johnson signed the Voting Rights Act in 1965, he hailed it as the final step in a centuries long journey:
“Millions of Americans are denied the right to vote because of their color. This law will ensure them the right to vote. The wrong is one which no American, in his heart, can justify. The right is one which no American, true to our principles, can deny.”
But the excitement over being able to enter the ballot box subsided, and African-American voter participation rates, while trending upwards since the 1990s, were largely uneven. That pattern changed in 2008, when Black voter participation reached a level not seen since 1964. That was also the first year that, “black citizens voted at a higher rate than the greater population, outpacing all Americans by 2.6%.” When asked to explain why, most commentators and specialists attributed the rise in black voters to “the presence of a black Democratic presidential nominee.”
Get S. Alexander Smith’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
But these voters, like the other components of the Obama coalition, weren’t necessarily hooked on voting after one election:
African-Americans made up just 11% of the 2010 midterm electorate, and only 40.7% of eligible African-American voters actually turned out, a 20 point decline from 2008. Heading into President Obama’s re-election in 2012, political pundits wondered whether African-Americans, disenchanted with politics in the Obama Era, had reverted to their previous participation rates. But in 2012, African-Americans proved the pundits wrong, and voted in higher proportions than any other race or ethnicity.
As John McCormick at Bloomberg wrote:
Almost two in three eligible blacks cast ballots in the 2012 presidential election, marking the first time they had a higher voter turnout rate than non-Hispanic whites, a U.S. Census Bureau analysis shows….blacks were the only racial or ethnic group to show a significant increase in voting participation between the 2008 and 2012 elections, from 64.7 percent to 66.2 percent.
For African-Americans, the habit was starting to stick.
The first sign was in Virginia’s 2013 off-year gubernatorial race. The Democratic candidate, Terry McAuliffe, was buoyed by an African-American electorate now accustomed to turning out on Election Day.
Or, as The Daily Beast put it after the election:
African Americans were 16 percent were of the electorate [in 2009’s gubernatorial race], a significant drop from the 2008 election. This year, blacks were 20 percent of all voters, which means their turnout was exactly where it was in 2012. Put another way, for the second year in a row, African Americans turned out at a rate above their percentage of the population, and supported the Democrat by a 9-to–1 margin.
In Virginia, where African-Americans had been mobilized by two successful national elections (and where voting restrictions were not an issue), Black voters matched their Presidential year turnout rates in an off-year election. In the process, they helped Democrats break a 36 year electoral streak that saw the White House’s opposition party winning the Virginia Governor’s Mansion. African-Americans also helped Democrats sweep the races for Lieutenant Governor and Attorney General as well.
Nor has the Democratic Party been the only beneficiary of an increasingly engaged African-American electorate.
Earlier this year, Mississippi Republican Senator Thad Cochran, trailed in his primary runoff election against Tea Party conservative Chris McDaniel. Doing something that would have been unthinkable in Southern politics a few years ago, Cochran actively solicited votes from the African American community, most of whom were registered Democrats. And on Election Night, despite criticism from fellow Republicans, black voters responded to Cochran’s call. In county after county, as shown in a chart by FiveThirtyEight, African-American voters turned out in a run-off election for a Mississippi Republican primary, and provided Cochran with a narrow victory (essentially ensuring Cochran’s election in this Fall, given the state’s political realities). Like African-Americans around the nation, Black voters in Mississippi, inspired by President Obama, had started to pick up voting as a habit:
[E]ligible voter turnout swelled [in Mississippi] from 69.7 percent in 2008 to 74.5 percent last year – also the nation’s highest rate behind the District of Columbia. The state saw a similar jump in the percentage of eligible voters who were registered, up 7.2 percent from 2008. So how did Mississippi have such a significant increase while turnout plummeted elsewhere? The answer is indicative of a national trend that saw eligible black voters turn out in record numbers. The Census Bureau estimates 82.4 percent of eligible blacks voted in Mississippi, up nearly 10 percent from 2008.
It’s a trend that continued during this year’s midterm elections. Despite being abandoned at the polls by the young, urban, and female voters that had been central to the Obama coalition, African-Americans grew their percentage of the midterm electorate compared to 2010. In fact, African-Americans composed a higher share of this year’s midterm electorate than they did in 2004's presidential election. This growth is even more surprising (or not) when you take into account persistent attempts by Republican legislators to disenfranchise black voters, as well as recent decisions by the Supreme Court to gut the Voting Rights Act.
This year, for the first time, President Obama’s GOTV machinery turned it’s gaze on Louisiana, Arkansas, and Georgia. While Democrats lost all three races, the process gave national Democrats a reason to invest in registering thousands of new African-American voters in predominantly conservative states. Increased participation rates in Arkansas (+3.7%) and Louisiana (+5%), compared with 2010, suggests at least some modest success. In North Carolina, which, after flipping on its own in 2008, had been targeted by Obama’s registration efforts in 2012, African-American turnout in 2014 (21%) was higher than in 2010, and only 2% less than turnout in 2012. In Virginia, African-Americans were 19% of the electorate this cycle, nearly matching totals from both the 2012 Presidential Election and the 2013 gubernatorial contest. While these gains amongst African-Americans couldn’t compensate for Democrats’ collapsing support amongst rural whites, all the signs of a rising tide of black voters are there.
For the first time in generations, the Democratic Party doesn’t have a single white Congressman or Senator from the Deep South. African-Americans are increasingly packed into minority-majority districts, diluting their strength and making it harder for Democrats to make inroads electorally. The Party’s future in the South, at least for the foreseeable future, rests on the backs of African-American voters. While national Democrats fret over voter turnout in the coming post-Obama era, they would be wise to continue registering and targeting African-American voters, keeping them engaged and helping solidify the habit. Not only are they one of the few constituencies in the Obama coalition with a proven track record of turning out once engaged, but their votes, unless courted, are not promised to the Democratic Party.
And Democrats should also keep an eye on Republicans, who are not so quietly making moves to poach this newly engaged, traditionally Democratic constituency.







