Popcorn Theatre
Digital Broadcast Cinema — A disruptive innovation?
The new media are not bridges between man and nature; they are nature.
Marshall McLuhan — The Medium is the Massage
This, my fifth blog, is a continuation of my thoughts from my last essay submission on Digital Broadcast Cinema. It’s quite hard to fit everything into one 4,000-word paper, so I’m going to blog a few hundred words extra (without the Harvard referencing, that is!)
So “Digital Broadcast Cinema”, is the term I adopted (originally coined by Paul Heyer) to describe the new (or not so new) phenomenon of broadcasting performances (such as ballet, opera, or theatre) into a cinema, live.
So you might be more acquainted with “the brand names” of Digital Broadcast Cinema, such as National Theatre Live; Live from the Met; and The Royal Opera House’s: Live Cinema Season. You also might have already experienced one of these live broadcasts (such as Benedict Cumberbatch, in Frankenstein, or Michael Morpurgo’s War Horse) — and if you did, did you love it, or hate it? — Or, if you haven’t experienced one yet, how do you think you’d feel about it?
Get Chris Butterworth’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Digital Broadcast Cinema seems to have many industry professionals and audiences divided — but why? Well fundamentally it seems to be about “the experience” — Does watching a live performance broadcast into a cinema create the same experience for the audience? Well no, it’s not going to create the same experience, but it will create an experience nonetheless. I mean, we go to watch concerts — we’re in the same location as the performance / performer, but lets say we’ve got crappy seats — bummer. BUT hang about… what do we see before us? — A massive LED video screen — perfect, we can use it to watch Miley swing about on her wrecking ball! — And that’s what happens, we watch the whole concert THROUGH a screen — And everyone does it.
Now ok, even if you watch a concert through a screen in the arena, you still get the experience of being there — that shared atmosphere of excitement with the 6,000 other audience members who are eagerly awaiting the girl who licks hammers to come on stage! — But I ask you the question: is this not the same as the Digital Broadcast Cinema experience (aside from the hammers and wrecking balls)? Think about it — you’re in a cinema FULL of other people who are there because they’re excited to watch the performance. There’s still that thrill in the air of anticipation for the curtain to rise (so to speak). You get “the best view in the house” — just like those who watch the concert video screens. — Fundamentally, you’re still going to see the same show as the audience in the London venue sees. So what is wrong with this? — Nothing really.
Well, ok — there are those who see Digital Broadcast Cinema as (hold your horses — buzzword approaching) a “Disruptive Innovation”, which by Clay Christensen’s definition is:
“Taking a product and making it simpler, more affordable, so many more people have access to it”
And yes, that is fundamentally what Digital Broadcast Cinema is doing, and some people are trying to claim that the phenomenon will pull audiences away from the theatres in favor of this easier option — but I disagree! Just think about the positive that this “disruptive” innovation is having for audiences across the UK:
Cost: Say you want to go and see a show at the National Theatre; you’re looking at an average ticket price in the region of £50! Now yes, the National does offer out some tickets at a more affordable rate, but they’re few and far between. Then think about the travel cost — say you live in the North West; a train down to London and a hotel will set you back a further £150 at least! Now that’s nearly £200; and lets be honest, money is tight at the moment, a lot of us can’t afford £200. But then you find out that the performance you wanted to see is being live broadcast to your local Vue cinema — for £11 — suddenly London isn’t that interesting is it?
Accessibility: Through writing my paper, many of my peers also highlighted the accessibility benefits of Digital Broadcast Cinema. One peer noted that her Nanna would love to still be able to visit the National and experience some of these productions, but to draw on my previous comment, the cost is just too high, and the travel is just too much for her… So again, you can see that the ability to access these performances in people’s local cinemas is a wonderful thing for some members of our society.
Finally, think about it this way — people must be happy with this “disruptive” innovation. Since its inception in 2009, 1.5 million people within the UK and across the world have experienced National Theatre Live broadcasts, and it has not decreased in-theatre audiences, in fact it has been seen to increase in-theatre audiences because they’ve been given a ‘taste’ for the real thing in the cinema and they want more. Surely this shows that it is a good thing?
But then again, these are just my thoughts… maybe I’m just wrong… maybe it really is a “Disruptive Innovation”… maybe in ten years we’ll all be popcorn-theatre viewers… or maybe, just maybe, we’ve found a happy medium to suit all theatre audiences…









