God & Gays:
Gagging the Faithful
Few topics capture the Christian imagination more readily than the changing values around same-sex marriage.
With worries in the world as serious as climate change, slavery in the sub-Sahara, Ebola spread across the whole of west Africa, the growth of radicalism in Islamic countries, the radical growth of the Islamic State in Syria and Iraq, prison reform, race relations, global poverty and decades of American military conflict, it is odd that much of the Christian Church in the U.S. is obsessed with all things gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender.
A quick check of the comment numbers in any faith-based Facebook community reveals that conversations about same-sex unions are the longest and most vigorously debated topic on those forums. Some folks support same-sex unions, many more are opposed to them, but either way, everyone has an opinion, and every opinion is seemingly intractable.
However, in light of the rapid, unparalleled successes that proponents of same-sex marriage are having in American courts, both sides of the debate are shifting the conversation from blocking or promoting same-sex marriage to the balance between free speech and equal access. Across the country, precedent-setting lawsuits have been filed against Christian caterers, florists, photographers, and printers, who are unwilling to provide LGBT consumers with wedding-related and promotional services. Indeed a case against a wedding photographer in New Mexico was ultimately argued before that State’s Supreme Court, which ruling in favor of the plaintiff, concluded Americans are:
…compelled by law to compromise the very religious beliefs that inspire their lives. At its heart, this case teaches that at some point all of us must compromise, if only a little, to accommodate the contrasting values of others…. That compromise is part of the glue that holds us together as a nation, the tolerance that lubricates the varied moving parts of us as a people…. In short, I would say with the utmost respect: it is the price of citizenship.
Since then lawsuits against Christian business refusing to serve same-sex weddings have been filed across the country. And, if the Willock v Elane Photography case becomes the legal precedent followed across the nation, Christians may be required to violate their religious convictions as the price of doing business in the public marketplace. As the New Mexico Supreme Court explained in their unanimous opinion:
Elane Photography has misunderstood this issue. It believes that because it is a photography business, it cannot be subject to public accommodation laws. The reality is that because it is a public accommodation, its provision of services can be regulated, even though those services include artistic and creative work. If Elane Photography took photographs on its own time and sold them at a gallery, or if it was hired by certain clients but did not offer its services to the general public, the law would not apply to Elane Photography’s choice of whom to photograph or not. The difference in the present case is that the photographs that are allegedly compelled by the New Mexico Human Rights Act are photographs that Elane Photography produces for hire in the ordinary course of its business as a public accommodation. This determination has no relation to the artistic merit of photographs produced by Elane Photography. If Annie Leibovitz or Peter Lindbergh worked as public accommodations in New Mexico, they would be subject to the provisions of the public accommodations law.
I think it’s wrong to deny a couple “wedding related goods or services” because of a same-sex union. I think it’s stupid. I think it’s uneducated. I think it’s un-Christlike; and if Jesus were around today, working as a photographer, I’m convinced he’d shoot the wedding, probably for free, and bless the couple (not to mention the wine). Even so, I also fully support the right of churches, religious institutions, and wedding vendors to exclude themselves from same-sex couples weddings. It’s not as if there is a lack of florists, caterers, photographers and printers around to take that business.
In many denominations marriage is a sacrament and in all denominations, marriage is sacred. If you are part of a religious community that believes same-sex unions are ‘unholy’, it’s outrageous that government is able to compel an individual to participate in something they believe is profane. That by definition puts the worst kind of zealot from each side of the debate into conflict with one another. Which is exactly what’s happening in the cases popping up around the country. What the New Mexico Supreme Court failed to understand is the sacred nature of the event conservative Christians are being compelled to partake in. It’s one thing to deny photographing an openly gay couple. Making a faith-based argument for that is untenable. But demanding a religious person serve a sacred event done profanely, that’s also untenable. The court might as well required the respondents photograph an abortion.
The Hobby Lobby Effect
In 2014, the Supreme Court ruled that for-profit corporations have religious rights and, as such, granted them religious exemptions previously reserved for private persons. Presently, those exemptions are limited to exempting closely-held religious corporations from being required to offer birth control to employees. It will take decades to discover if the Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby case will also exempt closely-held religious corporations from serving LGBT people in other scenarios. Until a test case winds its way through the legal system, we can only guess how the lower courts, and ultimately SCOTUS, will rule. But, whatever the ruling, it’s almost certain, the case that makes it to the court will have something to do with same-sex marriage. Until then, Christian businesses who refuse to offer LGBT customers wedding related services and goods are at risk of being hauled into court.
Another way forward
Folks that follow Jesus are directed by the New Testament to treat all people with kindness, gentleness, deference, and respect. Actually, even more so with regard to people with whom they disagree. Considering that same-sex marriages sanctioned by the State, they are matters of law, not matters of theology, so none of this should matter to churches who do not support same-sex unions anyway. Besides, when faith-based groups, in a secular society, oppose civil rights for any group, in any society, they undermine their most valuable commodity; moral authority. There is another way forward.
First, a few assumptions:
- Throughout American history, religious objection to same-sex relationships have (largely) been the root cause of legalized discrimination, societal prejudice, family shaming, school yard cruelty, and the cultural criticism typically experienced by members of the LGBT community in the United States.
- Advocates for the LGBT community are increasingly aggressive about overturning persistent and previous limits to their civil rights.
- Because the denial of those benefits have been almost exclusively due to religious objections, laws against equal civil rights are being struck down nationwide as courts determine that those restrictions breach the “wall of separation between church and state.”
- The emerging, majority opinion of the American populace is that, in a secular society, LGBT singles and couples must be afforded the same rights and privileges that are afforded heterosexual couples and singles. This includes the right to civil marriage.
- Along side the shift in majority-opinion regarding LGBT access to equal rights and social privileges is a rapidly rising number of Americans that identify as agnostic or atheist.
Now — let’s ask and answer a few questions:
Question 1a: Is the growing number of Americans that identify as agnostic and atheist a result of:
(a) A growing influence of secular humanism (including “gay culture”)?
Get Michael J. Salerno’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
(b) Much of the American church being enmeshed in the politics of exclusion, taxation-philosophy, science-denial, and theologies of self-satisfaction instead of centering on the ethics of Jesus expressed in Sermon on the Mount and the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats?
(c) Both?
Question 1b: Assuming it is the church’s responsibility to stem the tide of atheism and agnosticism in America, does the solution to that problem vary regardless of the answer to Question 1a?
…and if the answer to ‘Question 1b’ is ‘no;’ then allow me to posit one final question:
Question 2: What should the Church do to stem the tide of atheism and agnosticism in America?
(a) Redouble the effort to demonize secular culture and draw an even brighter defining line between the church and non-churched society?
(b) Divorce itself from politics, tax-philosophy, science-denial, and theologies of self-satisfaction and return to preaching the ethics of Jesus expressed in The Sermon on the Mount and the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats?
If you answered (b), I agree with you.
But that answer leads me to wonder why same-sex marriage would matter to ‘straight’ Christians anyway? If a faith community doesn’t recognize same-sex unions, a change in governmental policy likely won’t affect you unless your work involves the wedding industry. If your work does involve marriage and weddings, it would appear safest convert that business into a closely held corporation.
History teaches us that deriding same-sex behavior only inspires discrimination and violence against LGBT people. This is self evident in American history, and despicably evident in the rise of hate crimes against gays and lesbians in Russia today. For that reason, instead of opposing civil rights of any kind, for anyone, Christians and churches alike should instead take the lead promoting a socially responsible faith-based agenda that features:
- Equal and easy access to high quality health care
- Responsible stewardship of water, land, and air resources
- Advocating and utilizing green energy sources such as solar, wind, geothermal, and ocean kinetics
- Opposing genetically modified organisms
- Adding exercise, nutrition, and psychological wellness, to temperance, chastity and monogamy as signs of holiness
- Supporting social services in the form of food stamps, healthcare and aid to families with dependent children
- Providing and supporting free child care for welfare recipients
- Reducing the influence of the super-wealthy in public policy
- Supporting and providing free and equal education for all
- Protecting the rights of women (like equal pay)
- Defending and supporting social justice for women, minority populations, the LGBT community, indigenous populations, physically challenged, the mentally challenged, and undocumented immigrants
- Opposing war
- Supporting self-sacrifice in the form of higher taxes for social programs
When believers in Jesus oppose such things, they give credence to arguments against religion, and a reasonable basis to believe in the moral superiority of secular humanism. However, when people of faith defend and support justice in health care, education, civil rights, and the environment we inspire a passion for justice, forgiveness, equality, peace and kindness throughout our society. Which in the end, is what Jesus would do.







