Sitemap
Colette Truman Dahl

Colette Truman Dahl

Dear Juror,

15 min readOct 23, 2014

--

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Just a few images portraying Conrad Truman’s relationship with his wife, Heidy, and his hopes for their future.

This. Is. Hell.

Of course this whole process has not been any picnic for anyone involved. But never, ever, in any scenario did I think that you would find, beyond reasonable doubt, that my brother was guilty. When I left the court room today sobbing and went into the little room I’ve practically lived in for the past few weeks, I yelled, “Oh God, oh God, I don’t understand” over and over. Nobody could have heard my words through the whimpering but that phrase, or variations of it, continued for about an hour.

As I’ve tried to actually understand I realize, you don’t know my brother. In fact, there are many, many details you don’t know for various reasons. And so I’m not angry at you. This really isn’t even a letter. Let’s call it personal therapy. Because for 2 years we’ve all been suffering. My brother is accused of killing his wife and my family knows in our heart of hearts that he is innocent. There is no question, for us, that he is innocent. But for you, well, you don’t know Conrad like we do. And you don’t know us.

Conrad was arrested in July 2013, 9 months after Heidy’s death. He has been in jail awaiting trial since that time. In 15 months I haven’t been able to visit my brother face to face or give him a hug for all this time. Every single communication, phone calls, letters, and emails were monitored. Our weekly “in person” chats were via pixelated computer screen. You, dear juror, weren’t supposed to know this. We weren’t allowed to mention it because apparently there is a presumption of innocence before conviction. When a one million dollar bail that isn’t bondable is set for someone who was a productive member of society for 9 months after his wife’s death, I struggle to find where he was presumed innocent. But I guess it is assumed that you would be prejudice against him for being in jail and that you would assume he must be guilty because why would they send him to jail if he wasn’t. But I thought, to myself, that if I were on the jury, I might wonder why the defendant seemed a little stoic. I might wonder why, as the prosecution pointed out, two years later the defendant remembered some things pretty clearly. But, as a member of this hypothetical jury, had I known the defendant had been doing little else but thinking about that night and coping with the harsh realities of jail, I might understand why more details have become clear and other more traumatizing details remain vague. I might understand that a person would learn to stifle emotional reaction. But I’m not the expert. Although retrospectively, I guess you knowing about this couldn’t have hurt. Particularly when you consider that 15 months of monitored communication did not produce one piece of evidence the prosecution admitted to court.

The night that Heidy died, my ex-husband and I were the first ones at the hospital. We heard the multiple stories; we witnessed a man in excruciating pain trying to make sense of a tragedy that made no sense. We heard the things that were said to various other people as they arrived at the hospital. Those things were not presented to you as we heard them. But we were not asked to share our side of the story with you. We were spoken to by a “victim’s advocate” as was my brother. Incidentally, this person is employed (paid) by the state, wore a badge all through the trial but not that night, and didn’t identify herself as anything other than an advocate. Not that it mattered, but it seems like someone who works for the state and wears a badge shouldn’t be allowed to question or interact with people and then turn around and become adversarial in trial.

My mother and I accompanied my brother, who went willingly to the police station to give what we thought would be a brief statement. To tie things up. A long time passed during which we did not know where my brother was being held. Officer Ruiz came to speak to us. He told us that they were just trying to figure out what happened, that it was either a suicide or a homicide and it wouldn’t be much longer. I immediately felt that something was wrong. Why wouldn’t there be a third possibility? Why wouldn’t they consider perhaps an accident had occurred? Handgun accidents are not entirely infrequent; why would that be taken off the table immediately following the incident? Hours passed. We were alone in the police office lobby. We tried to find my brother. We called for him. We called the police station from the lobby hoping someone would answer. Officer Ruiz had given me his card. I called him many times. I began to get a bad feeling. I started calling lawyers. I, Colette, started calling lawyers. Of course, even the as the sky grew lighter, there was nobody answering the phone. My dad arrived, he had driven several hours. He tried to find Conrad and could not. Finally, my brother reappeared. I took him to my house. He continued to try to make sense of things. We didn’t mention a lawyer; I didn’t probe him for details. I just let him say what he needed to say. He didn’t go into detail about it. Have you ever experienced a great sadness? A horrible gut wrenching tragedy where you can’t breathe but you also want to throw up? Well I have. More than once. And my brother’s demeanor that night was not that dissimilar to my own when faced with unspeakable grief. So I didn’t press him. And some time mid-morning, he finally got a few hours of sleep on my couch.

Before too long we were awake. I take care of things. Of people. It is my role in the family. When other people would break down, I am strong, I solve problems, I handle our business. I contacted Conrad’s employer, I told them there had been an accident. I, Colette, told them there was an accident. Did I know that it was an accident? No. Did my brother tell me that it was an accident? Among other possibilities he postulated. He simply did not know. But what was I going to say? What would you have said? One of Heidy’s sisters, (whom you didn’t meet for interesting reasons) started posting on Facebook about her sister being taken away from her. I didn’t think their friends and family should learn about her death via Facebook. I realized that Facebook needed to be monitored. People began messaging my brother, expressing sympathy, but mostly demanding details, probing him for more. Not understanding why he could not give them a deep and detailed explanation. I, Colette, began responding to questions. I made posts. I called it an accident. It seemed the gentle thing to do. I KNEW it wasn’t my brother but I didn’t know what happened. I couldn’t say it was or wasn’t suicide. I didn’t think it was and Conrad was almost certain it could not have been. Why do I keep emphasizing that I did things, you may wonder. Because sometimes they were attributed to my brother. And nobody ever asked if that was accurate.

The night that Heidy died, the cops had hung onto Conrad’s wallet. In the days that followed when he wanted to retrieve it, it became evident that they wanted to further question my brother. It was at MY insistence that we visited a lawyer. My brother wasn’t interested, he didn’t think it was necessary but I told him it was preventative, a just in case safety measure. We met with Mike Petro, a man who had a reputation in our county for being a good defense attorney. He spoke to my brother privately and then he spoke to us. I asked him if I could give him some money, retain him. He stated that it wasn’t necessary but that we should not under any circumstances speak to the police again unless they placed him under arrest. He reiterated this to my brother. Do not speak to them for any reason.

In the following months there was an investigation. Multiple search warrants were served and executed. They took several phones, computers, cameras, photos. He would get a new phone and they would come and take it away again. What you saw from these many search and seizures, dear juror, the details of a lifetime, was a blank voice message, a few loving texts and a couple of photographs. As you learned, the police showed up at his work, questioned his co-workers and managers. They actually contacted people I went to high school with to find out what, if anything, I had told them. But they never contacted me. And they made a huge deal about why he wouldn’t talk to them. As this was ongoing, my brother couldn’t grieve, my family couldn’t grieve. We made multiple calls to the lawyer to whom we had spoken, Mike Petro. I told him if he didn’t want to take the case just to please tell us so we could find someone to help stop the harassment of my brother. He reassured us that we were doing the right thing. Just don’t talk to them unless they arrest him. We got a warrant for Conrad’s DNA. We went to Petro’s office. He told us they had a right to conduct their investigation and there was nothing we could do to impede. He said I should go with my brother to give the DNA sample to make sure he didn’t say anything. He said I should tell them to contact him if I wanted.

Conrad just wanted them to stop. He would have spoken with them a million times over. I told him not to; told him to listen to the lawyer. I went with him to give his DNA sample. I was dressed professionally, in a suit, as I’d come from the office when I walked in to the police station. Detective Wallace met us in the lobby (this kind of stuff has to be on camera somewhere, right?). He visibly stiffened when he saw me. Once he learned I wasn’t a lawyer, he softened dramatically. I told him we had been speaking with a lawyer, as I had been instructed. He said, “Oh really, who? Maybe I know him.” “Mike Petro” I answered indignantly, trying to seem as though I knew anything about anything. “Oh yeah, I know him,” Wallace responded. “If you need to talk to someone, you can talk to him,” I relayed the message as I had been directed. Why didn’t you ever hear about a lawyer? Well the experts say that it will be assumed that you are guilty if you talked to a lawyer. I guess it couldn’t hurt for you to know now.

They wouldn’t let me walk into the back room where I guessed they were drawing blood but I stood at the end of the hall and listened to their conversation. Wallace asked my brother questions which he answered. He mentioned some of Conrad’s guns, which he admired and told my brother that he “bet he couldn’t wait to get them back.” My brother said something to the effect that his wife had been killed with a gun and he couldn’t care less about getting them back. They came back into the lobby.

I actually apologized for being a bit abrasive to Wallace initially. I stated that I just wanted to make sure my brother was okay. He sympathized. I thought again, stupidly, that he cared about us.

Get Colette Truman Dahl’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

The last time they served a warrant on my brother’s home, they brought the swat team. After they had taken all his guns months previously. Conrad explained how they could access the home. They broke down the door. They needed him to leave and he came with me. He offered my number as contact. They called me when they were done and explained that they had to break the door, even though they knew they could get in, because it was an officer safety issue and that it was procedure. They said they tried to fix it as best they could.

I wanted this to stop. I went to Mike Petro’s office and hand delivered him a letter, begging him to help stop the harassment. He said again that we just had to wait.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Conrad Truman’s home where he left Heidy’s favorite hat on the banister and her coat on the hook. even 9 months after her death he could not bring himself to move her things out.

When Conrad was arrested he was still wearing his wedding ring. Every. Single. Day. I know this because when I went to the jail to pick up his property it was sealed in the evidence bag and I had noticed it every time we were together in the 9 months post Heidy’s death. He was arrested driving to work because it was safer for the officers. We changed nothing in his home and it still exists exactly as it was when he left that morning. 9 months after her death, Heidy’s clothes still hung in the closet. Her coat still on the wall rack. Her favorite hat still on the banister. Their wedding pictures still on the wall. Their love notes still on the fridge and in the bathroom and the pantry. His tear warped journals next to the bed. You couldn’t see this. I don’t know why. We had pictures, I could have told you. But the experts were sure the complete lack of physical evidence, lack of motive and pure fact would be more than enough to allow you to determine the truth.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Pictures from Conrad and Heidy Truman’s wedding still hung on every wall in their home 9 months after he supposedly killed her for money. Dear Juror, does that make sense to you?

For around 15 months, I’ve been managing Conrad’s finances, my dear husband and I have hosted his two dogs (all the hard stuff of caring for dogs the hubs thankfully has taken care of), my mom has watched over his house and my dear father has worked from dusk to dawn farming to pay all the considerable legal bills. My mom and dad and are very hard workers and I like to think that was passed down to my brother and me. My brother, 4 years younger than I, is someone I actually look up to. He worked his way through college, the first one in our family to complete his bachelor’s degree and inspired me to do the same. But unlike me, my brother gradated without any student loans due to his work at an auto parts store.

He was known as a guy who would go the extra mile for people. If you weren’t sure what was wrong with your car, he was likely to walk out to the parking lot with you and have a look. Or if you bought some wipers and weren’t quite sure how to put them on, he’d be happy to take care of that for you. You know when you see someone moving in your neighborhood, and you feel like you should help. Well I think there are two kinds of guys, the one who shuts the blinds and hopes it looks like nobody is home and the kind of guy who drops what he is doing, and walks over and grabs a heavy box and asks where you would like it. Conrad Truman is the latter.

As a hard worker, a doer, and a helpful, all around great guy, you could say my brother is a great example of the American Dream. He put himself through school and has been working his way up through various positions in his professional career. He probably made (before incarceration robbed him of his position) around $80K. And his wife was somewhere around $45K so they weren’t struggling for money. At all. And I wouldn’t go as far as to say he was cheap, but he was frugal. And he wanted to prepare for the future. The future he planned for with his wife whom he loved deeply. The love part was confirmed in court by both sides, both families, neighbors, everyone seemed to agree about this. All the experts said there could be no question about whether or not Conrad loved his wife so we didn’t really need to focus on that. Both Heidy and Conrad had good 401Ks, particularly for their age. They had several savings accounts, were in the process of refinancing their house (which did not complete before her death) so they could get in a great position to buy a bigger, family home. After 15 months of incarceration and unemployment, I was still paying all his bills with HIS money in checking and savings accounts. You may run in different circles from me but I don’t know any other 31 year old who could be unemployed that long and not miss a beat on mortgage, and utilities and credit cards. He wasn’t a big spender but he bought Heidy flowers, he took her on vacations, surprised her with little presents of things she liked like shoes or coats. And they were looking into life insurance as an investment. But as discovered during trial, they canceled their required medical tests prior to getting the life insurance. Sure they had benefits. You probably do too. I do. But there is a difference between a million dollar policy you take out on your wife and a myriad of 401K benefits, social security, accidental death and dismemberment, etc. that a responsible couple shared. I saw them as a fine example of the American Dream. They were a young couple, hardworking, building a solid foundation for the future in their 20s and 30s. It is what we say here in the US that we believe in. Fiscal responsibility…Oh and guns.

I don’t really like guns. I don’t know how you feel about them, probably okay since you made it on the jury, but I recognize they are perfectly legal. I don’t judge people who have them. I’d prefer they be harder to get and also that people act a little more safely with them. Like always keep them locked up in a safe so they aren’t involved in accidents. Anyway, again, not my place to judge. My brother believes in protecting himself and the people he loves. When I got my first car, I basically drove the hell out of it and never changed the oil or took care of silly things like broken windshield wipers and tires. For years, my brother is the only one whom I trusted to take care of my car. He did the same for my mom. It kept us safe.

One time not too long ago, I was at my mom’s for some holiday or birthday dinner. Conrad was there and Heidy was at home because her work schedule differed from Conrad’s. They didn’t live in the greatest of neighborhoods, there were documented disturbances regularly there. Both Heidy and Conrad were concerned about safety and possible break ins. Well this night, Conrad received a call from Heidy. I was standing close enough to Conrad to hear both sides of their conversation. She told him that she thought somebody might be trying to get into the house. The first thing he said to her was, “get your gun.” Her response was, “I already have it.” Then he told her to call the police. I remember this so distinctly because I thought to myself, “This is crazy! Who tells their wife to get their gun before advising that the police be called? And who gets scared and gets their gun and then calls their husband before calling the police if they’re afraid of someone trying to break into their house?!?” But clearly they did. It was how they felt safe. And it was their pattern of behavior. My brother bought Heidy a gun because he loved her and wanted her to be protected. He bought my mother the same gun for the same reason. And me, well, he made sure my air filter was clean and my oil was changed and belts weren’t defective. Had I expressed any interest in self-protection, I might very well have been the recipient of a gun as well.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Photos of Conrad and Heidy Truman which were still present and displayed 9 months after Heidy’s death when Conrad was arrested.

I don’t know if any of this information would have made a difference. There is so much more and I could probably write all night. I think you’d be shocked about a lot of the truths that were deliberately kept from you. I can’t help but wonder if you had only seen the house, if you had understood the position and the dimensions and everything else that I understand…would I be hugging my brother and celebrating the end of a nightmare right now? But I’m destroyed. I don’t understand. But as our attorney, a man whom I hold in great esteem, said, “This is not a game.” He was right. It isn’t a TV show; it is real life. And sometimes, sadly, in real life, reality isn’t tied up neatly with a perfectly clear explanation that allows everyone to have a happy ending. I wish people could accept, as sad as it seems, that sometimes there are no bad guys, no villains and no easy place to direct blame in order to ease survivor pain. But I guess someone had to be blamed because we like when things definitively conclude. Uncertainly doesn’t comfort. But I will never understand why you decided as you did and still I think to myself, if you only knew us. And if you only knew the Conrad Truman that I know.

https://www.facebook.com/TruthforTruman

#TruthforTruman

--

--