Sitemap

How do we encourage ‘good’ feedback?

6 min readNov 24, 2014

--

As designers we want to do the best possible work for our clients and ensure that their projects get great results. Feedback from clients and stakeholders is an essential and valuable part of the design process, and when managed well can propel good design into great design.

On the flip side ‘poor’ feedback can result in mediocre work, projects going over-budget and missed deadlines, not to mention frustrated clients and designers!

So what is ‘good’ feedback and how do we ensure that we get it?

To clarify, ‘good’ feedback does not mean ‘positive’ feedback. It means a meaningful, qualified, actionable response to a piece of work, and can be positive, negative or anywhere in between!

Whilst I certainly don’t hold the holy grail on encouraging good feedback, I have learned a few things over the years about how to extract it (and of course how not to!)

A point of reference

First off, collecting feedback is completely pointless if you have no point of reference to measure work by. This means a brief. A solid brief.

A solid brief is often a rare luxury, but for the purposes of this article, let’s assume that we are afforded that luxury. One that defines the goals of the project, the unique selling proposition, the target audience, the competition, industry etc etc.

Present your rationale

So you’ve been working on your amazing idea for the last few days, you’ve been referring back to the brief and you think you have a really strong idea.

Great! It’s time to share it with your client.

Don’t just plonk a piece of work in front of them or chuck it over in an email and expect the clients feedback to be useful. Explain your reasoning and how you came to this point so that clients can understand your thought process and can evaluate it from an informed perspective.

Ensure your client knows what they are supposed to be evaluating

Sounds obvious right?

Perhaps you’re working on a website. You share the latest iteration of the home page with the client and want their thoughts. The client comes back with feedback on the logo another designer is working on, they don’t like a ‘placeholder’ image you’ve used, it doesn’t look as great on mobile, the twitter feed isn’t working and the postcode on the contact page isn’t right!!!

By not being explicit about what you wanted your client to focus on you’ve not got the feedback you need to do your job and more worryingly you’ve potentially caused the client some unnecessary concern.

Insist on a communication protocol

There’s likely to may voices in your clients team wanting to be heard. That’s great for an evaluation discussion, but outside of that scenario feedback should be carefully managed.

Make sure that one member of their team is assigned as project manager, or chief decision maker, whatever. This person should be the primary point of contact throughout the project through which all team communication passes. This is a key step in preventing confusion created through numerous feedback channels and opposing points of view!

Try to train clients to not drip-feed their feedback. This is potentially damaging to productivity and easily over-looked and. Encourage clients to collate feedback prior to delivering it. Personally I prefer clients to present their feedback face-to-face at set key stages along a project to avoid one-way feedback, promote discussion and prevents people hiding behind emails!

Avoid the perils of personal preference

It’s easy for both designers and clients to get hung up on personal preference. As conscientious designers we owe it to ourselves and our clients to do our best to avoid our own personal tastes clouding our judgements and to encourage our clients to do the same.

It is our responsibility to educate our clients and encourage them to think in terms of the needs of their audience, helping them to feedback accordingly. I’m not exaggerating when one of our clients requested that their logo be red because they supported Manchester United!

Get Design By Day’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Remind clients that the brand, product or website is not the goal in itself, it’s a means to an end. We’re certainly not producing a piece of art, we’re creating a business tool with specific goals in mind.

Encourage directness

Create an environment where clients feel they are able to be as open and honest as possible with their feedback. For many clients this isn’t an issue and they have no problem telling you exactly what they think. For others this can feel like an awkward task, especially when feeding back to the person responsible for the design.

Let clients know that being direct and not ‘fluffy’ with their feedback allows you as a designer to best understand them and to reach the right solution quicker.

Ensure that your client knows that you as a designer won’t take constructive criticism personally and that you value feedback as a means to creating an outstanding piece of work.

Account managers can provide a go between enabling clients to speak more candidly about design. Personally I see real value in designers and stakeholders engaging in valuable discourse and feedback discussions about a piece of work, as long clients know that the project manager or creative director is always available to fall back on.

Embrace collaboration

Let clients know that their opinion matters and your team is essentially an extension of theirs, sharing the same goals and objectives.

Listen to clients, explore their ideas and genuinely take on board what they are saying. There’s nothing worse than a design team that thinks they are the only ones capable of ideas because they’re the ‘creatives’! That attitude will only succeed in making clients feel stupid and go on the defensive when feeding back.

Collaboration encourages rich meaningful discussion rather than conflict, and you’ll notice the positive effect it has on feedback.

Qualification (Why? why? why?)

Always ask clients to qualify their feedback. Ask them why they feel that a particular direction does or does not meet objectives.

If feedback is vague or without reason, for example “a different font would work better…”, steer the conversation around to exploring the reasons why.

Meaningful feedback enables further relevant conversation about the project, pushing it forward in the right direction. For example “the font doesn’t feel sophisticated enough for our audience”.

Asking ‘why?’ is powerful! It allows you to understand the clients point of view and the client to rationalise their feedback. It also enables further design iterations to be implemented with that rationale in mind.

Challenge feedback!

If you disagree with a clients feedback challenge it! Make sure you can give a clear rationale as to why you disagree. If you feel an idea is working and meeting the brief it’s your duty to push that direction forward. After all your client hasn’t (or shouldn’t have) hired you to be a ‘yes’ man / woman!

Provide a feedback guide

Provide new clients with a feedback guide explaining how to get the most our of their projects through good meaningful feedback. Go through it with them, as let’s face it, it’s not likely to be read if sent via email!

Agree next steps

Finally, ensure that you and your client agree the next steps of the project. What feedback to implement, what elements of the work to drop, what to carry forward and what to explore further.

Overlooking this step often results in producing something that the client wasn’t expecting to see or not implementing what the client was expecting as a result of both parties relying on assumptions rather than an agreement. And you know what they say about assumption being the mother of all……….?!

www.designbyday.co.uk

Further reading for clients:

www.designbyday.co.uk/good-design-feedback-guide/

--

--

Design By Day
Design By Day

Written by Design By Day

We are a Manchester-based digital and design agency helping clients to inform & persuade through creativity and technology.