Sitemap
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Is a little e-learning a dangerous thing?

4 min readNov 24, 2014

--

I was reading an interesting article about junior developers when I run into this quote: “A little knowledge is a dangerous thing”. It’s “learning” variant, “A little learning is a dangerous thing”, is attributed to Alexander Pope. The origin of the quote itself is quite captivating (see here), but what got myself thinking at the moment was how it gave perspective about many efforts made today in the e-learning business. Here is a raw summary of how I digested this quote.

If you work in the e-learning industry, you are probably familiar with the idea of making short learning experiences, as learners either do not have the time or do not have the attention span for more than couple of minutes learning sessions. So basically, most of the time, you are just providing learners with “a little knowledge”. Hence, when I read the quote, I wondered if the e-learning industry was helping people or, well, if it was actually not just screwing things up with all the rapid/micro/just-in-time/your favorite flavor of e-learning.

So, could these forms of e-learning be a bad thing? With their content tailored for short timed experiences, their little knowledge units, are they dangerous things? At first I thought that in some cases it could be so. Being able to access little units of knowledge, specifically tailored for your needs, may give you a false impression of proficiency on fields were you still have much to learn before being called an expert. Even with the best prescriptive algorithm, you could be presented a knowledge unit which does not fit precisely the problem at hand but you may not be able to see it, because you do not have the experience to correctly assess the situation. So in worst case scenarios, I guess this could lend to poor life/business decisions, with costly consequences. And if you do e-learning truly aiming to improve people’s lives, that is something you are not ok with.

That thought brought me to an interesting question: if the user is not the expert, who is? I am tempted to say that, next to the obvious answer being the author(s) of the learning material, the system is the expert. Which brought up the image of lots of learners being just superficial technicians of topics directly impacting their lives and careers. And once again, being sensitive to other’s self development, this image was a little depressing.

So, was all my faith in e-learning lost? Are rapid/micro/just-in-time/your favorite flavor of e-learning just an easy and cheap patch to fix our societies’ lack of experts, maybe in spite of more efficient learning practices? Were we being too short-termist? I mean, like giving candy to a kid is a limited and short-termist strategy to get tranquility — in the mid/long run, you get dentist appointments and overweight… After some thinking on the matter, I (hopefully) convinced myself that it was quite the contrary!

Get Erik Gebers’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Indeed, these new forms of e-learning are only providing “a little knowledge” at a time. However, these little blocks of knowledge:

1) Are generally applied in a bigger plan, in which after experiencing meaningful sequences of these little blocks of knowledge, one would have sufficient ground to build up some real expertise.

2) Being little, they give sufficient space to have context, practice and socialisation intertwined between them. Which, I am convinced, will result in a much more durable learning experience.

Moreover, if I come back to the aforementioned potential bad consequences of learning through little knowledge units, they seem to me more linked to one’s behavior than to these forms of e-learning:

- If someone thinks he/she is proficient, or even worse an expert, after acquiring little knowledge, I would say the sooner they get sobbered up, the better. So confronting that knowledge with practice looks like a good call. The new forms of e-learning tend to be more practical, so in the end they give more chances to get a clear head.

- If systems are experts, sure there is a risk that people rely too much on them. But at the same time, e-learning systems are designed to transfer expertise. So what they really ought to achieve is making the equivalent of an expert accessible at any time and any place for reasonable fees (or even for free). And we are talking about a pedagogical expert here! People can take advantage of it and improve themselves, or just act like drones. Their choices. But with prices consideration, this kind of expert can “coach” more people than other solutions. And reach way farther than any human expert could do. One may still argue about the lack of adequacy of the expert pedagogy and users’ learning styles to undermine the efficiency of these systems, with good reason. Though I would say that this is just opportunity knocking at learning systems providers’ doors. And I would encourage anyone working in the field to read C. Christensen’s Disrupting Classroom, to get well acquainted with these opportunities.

So, to sum it up, I am no longer worried if a little e-learning is a dangerous thing because, anyway, a lot of knowledge does not make an expert, just a knowledgeable person! The issue here was really not about quantity. There are no such things as dangerous things, just dangerous behaviors, as projecting oneself as an expert on sole knowledge can be.

PS: Here is the article that got me on this trend of thoughts: http://norvig.com/21-days.html

--

--