Sitemap
Foxfan52

Foxfan52

Solana?

8 min readJun 30, 2022

--

Why am I writing this article? Well, thanks to the response from a tweet thread I wrote, I realised that I wasn’t the only person concerned with So many different things on Solana. Every month there seems to be something else that comes out of the woodwork and the SolanaMobile announcement seemed very forced…

I wanted to try and understand at a broader level how many wallets/users there actually are on Solana and how SOL is distributed. I have spent many hours trying to research on sites like Messari etc. to figure this out, but to no avail. It was extremely hard and frustrating to try and find any usable on chain data and the things I did find didn’t stack up. How does Solana, with a market Cap based on circulating supply of 342m SOL have a total Staked value of 391m? How is DEFI marketplaces reaching TVL of 71.5m SOL and NFT Volumes hitting 6M Sol in May when the Liquidity of SOL on chain is already -51m??

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Solanabeach Dashboard

This time I felt I might get some where as I was able to find some decent sites that have popped up and solanabeach wallet information seemed to be back up and running. It hasn’t been easy to extract the information by any means, but I carved out some time, opened up an excel spreadsheet and started populating data. I Also had some help from Twitter user Halaprix to understand more about how wallets work on Solana.

Circulating vs Total Supply

So firstly I tried to understand the difference here between circulating and total supply, because on this distribution chart the SOL Total is the “Total supply” of 524m SOL.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Solana Wallet Distribution on solanabeach

This is important because it is what Solanas Marketcap is based on… According to the vesting schedules, only the Founders allocation is left to completely “release” and there is 15.6m SOL left to unlock at time of writing. Assuming the Unlock is linear, it is 2.65mSOL per month up until Jan2023.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Vesting release schedule for Solana from Messari

Solana Rich list

Whilst trying to figure out where to start, I came across a site called coincarp which shows the Top 100 wealthiest Wallets and thought this would probably be the place to start my digging..

Press enter or click to view image in full size
coincarp richlist

I was quickly able to export the data and start tracking the wallets. What I soon learned was that on Solana, when you stake your SOL, your wallet creates a “Staking account” which has its own address. The SOL sits in that address and not your “Standard” address. As I started to go through the list, it turned out only 17 of the Wallets were “Standard” the rest were “Staking” wallets, and this is where the rabbit hole began..

I was able to link back to the “Standard” Wallet for the Staking addresses. As it turns out, you can have as many staking wallets as you want from just one standard wallet. (In fact I found 1 Standard wallet with 3,150 Staking wallets, (mpa4abUkjQoAvPzREkh5Mo75hZhPFQ2FSH6w7dWKuQ5) this wallet nor any of its staking wallets are even in this richlist, so we will come back to this wallet and many others later..

Press enter or click to view image in full size
the top 100 rich list “True Wealth” the far left column is the original list, the middle one shows the “Standard wallet associated to the left column entry and the true total wealth and number of wallets.

Do your eyes hurt yet? Here is a summary, the coincarp rich list shows 100 wallets totalling 162m SOL (33%) but when you track back the 80+ “Staking addresses, you find 84 “Standard” Wallets associated to that rich list, the total wealth is 210mSOL (40%) but interestingly the wealthiest account is not 6.6mSOL, but 23.3m Sol:

( DYG1ooTxkLS5iHDkte2XK4QBrpHziDR6EEZg5VsqNpVo)

second on the “True” Rich list is 18m SOL

(9WzDXwBbmkg8ZTbNMqUxvQRAyrZzDsGYdLVL9zYtAWWM)

Which also happens to have 1.6bn USDC in it. Yes I guess these are serum and or another DEX, but still, it paints a different picture to the coincarp one. Even though I called this the “True Richlist” this is just purely those 85 Wallets that are directly linked to the coincarp richlist.. There are bigger yet.

Where to Look next?

Whilst I was looking into the above, I came across alot of other large accounts (>100kSOL) that were staking. So I decided to look at all the stake pools in the top 25 and track back the wallets to the standard wallets. Pretty deep into the rabbit hole, I then looked for any other accounts >100k within the top 50. Just when I thought I had enough and was ready to call it a day, I came across what I can only assume is Solana Labs Standard wallet.

(mpa4abUkjQoAvPzREkh5Mo75hZhPFQ2FSH6w7dWKuQ5)

Get Foxfan52’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

But, before I go into the detail of this particular wallet, here are the results of all the above: the TOP 85 Wallets account for 41% of Total SOL Supply…

Regarding the 122 wallets to make 207, This is where I had to call the research a day. I am sure if I kept digging I would find some more big wallets. This is not an extensive list, it is as far as I could go with my other time commitments. But from what I have found above I accounted for 367m SOL. 207 “Standard” wallets that I found and included above, accounted for 68% of Total Supply, 50m of which is not staked. They hold a total of 5,508 wallets.

mpa4abUkjQoAvPzREkh5Mo75hZhPFQ2FSH6w7dWKuQ5

So let’s talk about this Solana Foundation wallet. Key facts: 83.9m SOL, (16.8% of total supply) staked to 3,150 Stake pools. No stake is greater than 55k SOL, at least 1,610 stakes are above 25k SOL. Why is this important? Well, in itself it probably isn’t, after all, alot of chains foundations will stake their currency to help POS decentralisation. Assuming that this is the Solana Labs wallet which houses the Community governance and Growth fund, then it does raise a few questions, especially when you look at where these stakes sit and the fact it is supposed to be spent at some point to develop the network etc....

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Is this the Solana Labs Wallet?

The interesting thing here though is that quite often the stake pools that this wallet stakes to, have very little else in terms of stake within them, and those that do seem to have stakes from other wallets that are staking small amounts to dozens of other pools.

When you look at the top 26 Stake Pools it is a similiar situation. These 207 wallets contribute 109m of the 130m SOL staked (86%)

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Here is an example: Nautilus Node. Click on the Top Stake account and then click on the “Staking authority” address. We end back up at Wallet mpa4abUkjQoAvPzREkh5Mo75hZhPFQ2FSH6w7dWKuQ5

This wallet is providing 95% of the total stake to 239 Stake Pools, and more than 50% of the stake to over 1000 pools.

DYG1ooTxkLS5iHDkte2XK4QBrpHziDR6EEZg5VsqNpVo Has the following % of stake wrapped in in the following pools and it is not alone in this situation:

Press enter or click to view image in full size

9WzDXwBbmkg8ZTbNMqUxvQRAyrZzDsGYdLVL9zYtAWWM pretty much represents the full stake of 2 of the top 26 Pools. (The >100% is a strange one because the stake pool 3N7s9zXMZ4QqvHQR15t5GNHyqc89KduzMP7423eWiD5g clearly shows 6.092m SOL but the WALLET AWWM also clearly shows 6.431m SOL staked to the pool!?

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Summary:

It seems clear that a huge amount of Solanas staking and staking pools are relying heavily or even almost entirely on Solana Foundation’ staking accounts and a few select VC Wallets to even exist. Also, during the last 2 days I have seen alot of moving of SOL between these Pools for no reason that I can tell, other than increasing the “MAV” from 25 to 28 & possibly just to inflate “Total Transaction volume” on chain?

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Solanas Reported MAV is increasing.

Seeing as the 207 wallets I have found are controlling the majority of the Pools Stakes including the top 27, what does anything like MAV really matter anyway?

Now I would like to point out that I get it, I really do get that when you sell all but 1.8% of your Crypto in funding rounds to private VC investors, and your Crypto goes from $0.04- $0.22 at investment round to over $200 in a matter of 18mths after launching the network, you are going to struggle to gain any real “Decentralised” ownership of your Crypto. But it is what it is, and decentralised it is not. Neither is the vast majority of its wealth even distributed to retail. After looking at 207 wallets, I have found over 2/3s of the total supply (366m), 86% of it is being used to almost entirely prop up the staking pools on a Proof of Stake and Proof of history network. (Let’s not talk about how the protocol clock was running late for ages a few weeks ago)

In the past we have all found Solana lacking in transparency and even shook our heads in disbelief when we see some of the half truths and misdirection being spun by Solana labs and it’s influencers, but for me, the lack of a large community anywhere on social media seemed strange for a network claiming to be bigger than Cardano and the next Etheruem Killer.

In reality, It would seem that there is actually not a large retail community at the moment and Solanalabs is doing everything it can to keep up the facade and wrangle things around to make the metrics look better.

I really hope you enjoyed this article. It’s the first time I have written one and needed to do so as I couldn’t write this all in a tweet thread again.

Thanks for reading and who knows, maybe I shall write another article soon!

Edit — Thanks to some help from the Solana Community, the wallet ending KuQ5 has been identified as Solana Foundation wallet not Solana Labs.

--

--