Shots Fired… Why didn’t we think of that?
I've never been more thankful to have my ideas ripped apart; To have a plan in mind with the corresponding steps, and actions all set, completely shot down.
Well first off, I hope you all are doing well! It’s been what, a month!? Well needless to say a lot has happened these past few weeks, and a lot of progress has been made. When I last blogged, I talked about how we finished our benchmarking stage as well as our problem statement. If you would like to revisit my last blog click here -> https://medium.com/@JacobReks/draw-like-your-hairs-on-fire-e2ac42c5e69c. The two weeks following that blog I was on my fall break. Not going to lie, innovationally (Can I say that?), I didn’t do much. I enjoyed my fall break for what it was, and was focused on other items.
Get Jacob Reks’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Now when we got back in school on the 20th, my colleague and I, were on fire. The first thing we did was contact our two mentors, Steve Visser and Michael Elwell (Professors of Industrial design, Purdue and Notre Dame). They were just as excited as us to dive in again! So we sketched, and sketched, and sketched. We made fun of each other’s TERRIBLE drawings, but sketched nontheless. After we had had around 100 sketches, we sent our top 12 to each of our mentors, eagerly awaiting their responses. Now when we heard back from them, wasn’t really what we wanted to hear. We weren’t really on the same page.
So in Sonu and I’s mind we have everything planned out and can visualize it completely. It even took us a couple weeks to get on the same page. What we heard back from our mentors was that our problem statement, sketches, and emails to them didn’t exactly all line up. So of course we all needed to get on the same track! After several more emails and sketches and descriptions we finally all have the same vision in mind. A large reason we weren’t on the same page was because our mentors don’t use fitness powders (pre-workouts/proteins/post-workouts). That’s not a knock on them, but it made us realize that the issues we are trying to fix, as well as the process we are trying to smooth out, are not common knowledge. This realization directly impacted everything. We had to reevaluate and put in layman’s terms what our process and issue was, so the general public would understand what we are trying to accomplish. So we in the process of rewriting our problem statement to do just that.
So our mentors knew nothing of our field, really not a big deal. So this past Monday we traveled to the local Vitamin Shoppe (Similar to a GNC) and had the pleasure of talking with the manager there for an hour or so. This is where our project got split in half and completely reworked. We shared our idea, and she laughed. For all the hard work and dedication she had the audacity to laugh. No joke, she (while tears from laughing in her eyes) tells us, “If you put your idea in this market, it will never work.” You can only imagine the feelings we were having. Confusion. Frustration. Anger. She started to explain why this wouldn't work, what was wrong with that, and yadda, yadda, yadda… yeah. When we got back into Sonu’s car we closed the doors took a deep breathe, and before anything was said I knew we came to the same conclusion. She didn’t understand who we were making this product for, as well as what it accomplishes. Understand that that was the first time we had actually talked to anybody about our product, and it was rocky. Now the great thing we pulled out from that meeting is that she pointed out every single flaw with our product. Now granted she was pointing them out for different reasons, we were able to take note of a lot of potential issues with the intentions we have in mind. A meeting like that was necessary for this to become a reality.
We recently heard back from Michael Elwell (Notre Dame) and we are going to have the pleasure of travelling to Notre Dame this Wednesday! When we got the invitation to do so we were ecstatic! We plan to have a really thorough brainstorming session, and possibly draw up some schematics so we can transfer that data into our AutoCad program at our school. His one criteria for visiting him was that we had to sit in on one of his classes. Not a bad deal at all.
We have had a lot of progress with our project these past couple weeks and (knock on wood) this success will continue. It’s been a blessing to work with the people we have so far and I look forward to what is in store next! Getting our idea laughed at was the motivation we needed to be even more on fire for this project. Sometimes shots need to be fired at ideas and concepts. For us, its only going to create a better product.










