The Value of Redemption
Women’s Indian Captivity Narratives & the Development of the Frontier Myth
‘Nature and the Universe do not tell stories, we do’ William Cronan, 1992.
When the first female Euro-American captive was taken by a Native American tribe, the settlers killed over 200 Pequot tribes people in a month long period of retribution.
Over time the violence of the reaction may have decreased, but the intensity of feeling generated in Euro-American society from captivity certainly did not lessen. The anxieties surrounding interactions between the two cultures, and their political, cultural, and sexual consequences went straight to the heart of the experiment of the New World, and America’s confidence in claiming superiority over the native population. The focus of this paper will be on three main captivity narratives detailing experiences in captivity in the eighteenth century and nineteenth century in order to investigate the role that Euro-American women’s experience played in the developing discourse of the American frontier. This paper will argue that female Indian captivity narratives were used to reinforce stereotypes of female frailty in order to assure the dominant male position in society, and prevent women from accessing the opportunities of the West.
The frontier thesis developed by Frederick Jackson Turner is the defining tenet of Western history: ‘The existence of an area of free land, its continuous recession, and the advance of American settlement westward explain American development.’
This paper will take Turner’s founding idea and turn it on its head, arguing that it is the perception of westward expansion and the frontier which play a role in shaping, rather than explaining American development. Using the literary form of captivity narratives, the white male created the wilderness as an area where women were not safe, reinforcing the subordinate position of women in society and extending it into the frontier. The shift from the Puritan conception of the frontier as an undesirable dangerous space to a proving ground for masculine achievement was an important step in creating the myth of American West. It confined women to the Eastern city, and to the stereotype of western female experience.
The stereotype of western female experience was analysed in an article by Susan Armitage in the seminal text The Women’s West. Armitage criticises traditional frontier based western history as a Hisland where women are simply incidental to the male story.
Brigit Georgi-Findlay describes women ‘colonised as captives within the story of the male on the frontier’ due to the ‘androcentric bias underlying the pastoralisation of America’.
Women were held captive by the stereotypes that were created for them: as ‘the helpmate, the refined lady and the bad girl.’
Amongst the most overeaching stereotype was that women only went West at the behest of men, thus neutralising all female achievement in the frontier. Dawn Lander summed up the position of a woman who succeeds in the West aptly: she was ‘celebrated because she transcends a situation she would never have freely chosen’.
The process of removing women from the historical presentation of the frontier can be seen taking place in captivity narratives.
There are three ways in which female Indian captivity narratives were used to constrict female access to the frontier: the representation of female reactions to the wilderness itself, the stereotyping of the behaviour of women and Native Americans, and finally the way that a captive’s return was represented as a redemption. Of course, women were not passive in the propagation of the frontier myth: they were scared of the wilderness beyond the frontier, and of the marauding savage and prayed for the redemption of captives as much as anyone else. This paper combines an interest in the way that the female captive supported frontier discourse and the manipulations of the story of female captives by the male voice.
Glenda Riley argues in Women and Indians on the Frontier 1825-1915: that the negative stereotypes of women and Native American men were perpetuated to control both groups, even after the perspective of those in the West started to change.
The development of stereotypes dictating the behaviour of both women and Native Americans were co-dependent. Women were represented as physically weaker, and more vulnerable to the violent and inhumane attacks of Native American tribes. This positioned white men as protectors and controllers of female behaviour, and the only group capable of dealing with the savage threat from the Native Americans.
The concept of redemption is a central concern in this paper, and needs a little more explanation. A study of redemption allows the opportunity to analyse the way that power was taken away from captive women and placed in male hands. Redemption or restoration is the process of how a captive was accepted back into Euro-American society. The role of redeemers was given to the white men who bargain, fight and plot for a captives’ freedom. A women is not in control of their own body at any point in the traditional arc of captivity narratives: they are taken away in the wilderness, and then they are returned.
John Almack labelled the concept of the frontier as a ‘hangover from the Puritans’.
If we accept this to be true, then it makes sense to start my analysis with a woman’s Indian captivity narrative from that period. Beginning with the first captivity narrative published A True History of the Captivity and the Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson, in order to examine the ways in which it shaped the form, and became an archetype for American culture. The Narrative of the Life of Mary Jemison by James Seaver is an important narrative because its numerous publications demonstrate the way that texts were manipulated to help reinforce racial and gender roles that in turn supported imperialistic expansion. In addition, it is the first literary example of a white woman surviving and thriving in the western wilderness. The final text examined — Sarah Wakefield’s Six Weeks in the Sioux Teepees: A Narrative of Indian Captivity — is an example of how later captivity narratives emphasised the redemption of captive women, and an example of the development in the stereotypes of Indian behaviour.
The Institution of Captivity
The practice of captive taking pre-dated the arrival of Europeans on continental American shores, and was rooted in ‘economic and social life of a tribe, as well as the diplomatic and psychological aspects of Indian life.’
The causes of Native American captive taking were various, but there were several motives which were common explanations for the captivity of women in captivity narratives. Captives were always taken as prisoners during wars, as either prisoners of war or hostages. Sarah Wakefield’s captivity during the Dakota War, and Mary Rowlandson’s during King Philip’s war are examples of this kind of captive taking. There has always been a mercenary motivation to captive taking but it came to the fore in the nineteenth century, and sometimes the important and wealthy were deliberated targeted for captivity, or held in captivity instead of killed.
Another cause for the taking of captives was tribal custom of adoption to replace family members killed through mourning wars. Originally part of the culture practised amongst tribes of the eastern seaboard such as the Iroquois, these attacks were planned to take captives from local tribes in the surrounding area to replace those in the tribe had been killed, in order to ensure a stable population.
The arrival of Europeans meant that they were included in these raids, taken captive, and adopted into tribes.
Mary Jemison was adopted into the Seneca tribe to replace a lost warrior.
The success of these adoptions depended on the age and gender of those taken, as acculturation was more successful when the captive was younger. The ideal age for a captive to be taken was been the age of nine and fifteen, and female children were more successful than those of their male counterparts.
Of course not every captive taken by tribes practicing adoption, especially when taken during periods of war, was welcomed into the tribe. Mary Jemison was adopted into the Seneca tribe but recounts many examples of seeing those taken captive by members of her tribe being tortured and killed.
The Nature of The Captive Narrative
Captivity narratives are defined by Kathryn Zabelle Derounian-Stodola as any story which involves a captive and a captor which can embody a great variety of literary styles and genres.
Therefore, before looking at individual captivity narratives, it is important to get an understanding of the nature of women’s Indian captivity narratives, the readership, any common features, and the development of the genre. In this paper when the term captivity narrative is used, it refers exclusively to the women’s Indian captivity narrative.
Male captivity narratives were also a popular form, but the different gender roles throughout American history make the construction and meaning of male captivity narratives very different to those of female captivity.
As this paper is arguing that the captivity narrative was used to influence the behaviour and the role of women, it is important to look at the reasons why captivity narratives were popular with women. Initially captivity narrative’s popularity was due to the uniqueness of the story, Mary Rowlandson’s narrative was a best seller in Britain and American in part because it was the first time such an account had been published, but there were other reasons beyond simple curiosity. Kolodny’s famous text: The Land Before Her argues that the popularity of captivity narratives was rooted in the isolation that many women felt in the frontier, and that identification with these women taken into the wilderness by force allowed women to relive the emotional trauma of their own experience. Kolodny says that ‘narratives offered models of the kind of passive forbearance that some readers were themselves practicing’.
Castiglia agrees, he views the high female readership of captivity narratives as due to a connection ‘between the plight of the literal captive and the less tangible forms of victimisation and restriction experienced by their white female readership’.
He takes this further and suggests that captivity became a symbolic situation for the cultural unnamable: ‘restriction to the home, economic dependence,rape,compulsory heterosexuality’.
The parallel between the social captivity of women’s role in society and the actual captivity experienced by those who wrote captivity narratives underlined the restriction of all female behaviour.
Each narrative featured in this paper embodies a different stage of the captivity narrative. The texts in this paper are chosen because they span the life of the form, and therefore allow a chance to explore the changes that took place over that time. A True History is valued for its authentic representation of captive experience and its use as a religious allegory. By the seventeenth century society was becoming increasingly secular, the control of printing presses was no longer just in the hands of Churches, and moved into the hands of those looking to make a profit. As America moved on from the Puritans into the eighteenth century, the nature of the form changes and becomes more literary. Fiction became more popular leaving the emphasis on the authenticity of early Puritan texts behind, as writers desired to develop the elements of the captivity narrative that had become so familiar to readers. Thus beginning the divergence of the form into factive and fictive narratives.
Seaver’s Narrative of Mary Jemison’s life embodies contemporary literary influences such as the rise of in the popularity of sentimental novels, and the numerous re-edits show that the truth within a narrative was becoming a more flexible concept. By the middle of the nineteenth century, the prime period of the American West, the trope of the captive woman would be utilised again and again, and it became a common feature of many forms of popular culture such as the dime novel and the western film.The publication of Sarah Wakefield’s Six Weeks with the Sioux was a part of this literary trend that saw that for a captivity narrative to be published it needed to have something extra. In Sarah Wakefield’s case her book was part of a literary trend of women publishing protests of the treatment of the Plains Indians.
Even though there were some changes in the form of the captivity narrative over time, there are several traditional features of captivity narratives which appear in the majority of the texts. The first is the return, or redemption to Euro-American society. This process encompasses all means by which a captive is reconciled with her home culture, as well as the simple process of leaving captive, it also involves the means by which a captive achieves social acceptance after their captivity. Throughout these narratives the emphasis on the redemption, usually in the titles of a narrative, was presented to reinforce female weakness, and the lack of female agency. The negation of female agency acts to prevent the narratives from being seen as an impressive feat of female survival in difficult circumstances. It left the captive women as nothing but pawns of male power, passed between powerful cultures across the frontier. Emphasising the male role in redemption was the best way of removing power from women as it showed that the responsibility for female freedom was placed squarely on the shoulders of white men.
The second is the negative stereotyping of Native Americans. Any narratives of female resistance to captivity reinforced the stereotype of Native Americans as ‘naked, dirty, mean, rapacious and hostile’ by highlighting the fact that they took vulnerable women captive. In turn reinforcing the subordinated position of which the captive had fought to escape.
The captive’s position within a tribe allowed the male editors to focus on the violence towards other whites. Underneath the representation of female weakness was the spectre of rape, and of inter racial sex in general, was a potent justification for keeping women out of the frontier. To maintain the image of the wilderness as a place not for women, narratives had to negate or control any representation of a women surviving in the wilderness alone, and both redemption and stereotyping Native Americans were both ways of doing so.
Captivity Narratives were not just a representation of female experience, they were used by male editors to assert control over women in general. Castiglia puts forward one reading of captivity narratives, he asserts that women were made just as powerless by the process of editing and framing their narratives as they were by captivity itself.
In the cases of these women’s narratives the bodily captivity was mirrored by the control exhibited over the editing and production of the narratives. It is the totalising discourse of power itself which is at stake in captivity narratives, and that is why such control is exhibited by the men involved in the publication of them. The fact men intervened in captivity narratives, by having their introduction or sermon published alongside the narrative awareness or recording a captive’s story, meant that the female voice was always heard with, or obscured by the male voice. Texts required framing, limiting and influencing to take the events of a captivity and make it fit in with the popular discourse. The story of Hannah Dustan is a good example of this: Cotton Mather cannot obscure the facts of her violent escape so instead he turns to religious dogma to reinforce it, and places her action within the biblical concept of judea capita.
Some consider the captivity narrative to be the foundation text of American culture, as it can function as an archetype of American culture itself.
Richard Slotkin agreed, and argued that looking at narrative literature is the best way to trace the process by which problems and concerns of early American life turned out into ‘visions which compel belief’, the most dominant of these ‘visions’ being the frontier.
Slotkin highlights the importance of captivity narratives in this transformation. They ‘express communities sense of meaning of its experiences, rationalise its actions and to move its people to new actions.’
From Mary Rowlandson’s captivity to Sarah Wakefield’s return, the need to understand the difficult experiences of settling a continent and to create meaning where there was only chaos has existed. Captivity narratives took that raw experience, gave it meaning and contributed to the creation of the frontier myth.
The Founding of the Form: Mary Rowlandson
Published in 1682, Mary Rowlandson’s account of her experiences in captivity became the founding text of the form: A true history of the captivity & restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson, a minister’s wife in New England: wherein is set forth the cruel and inhumane usage amongst the heathens for eleven weeks time and her deliverance from them. More commonly, it is referred to as A True History. The version used in this paper is from the fourth edition of her narrative again published in 1682, and reproduced in Penguin’s Women Indian Captivity Narratives.
Mary White Rowlandson, the wife of a prominent Puritan minister, was taken captive in February of 1675 as part of an attack on Lancaster on the Massachusetts frontier. During the attack she witnessed the murder of her sister and several other close family members. She and three of her children were taken captive, but almost immediately her captors separated Rowlandson from her family, and held her captive for eleven weeks.
The raid on Lancaster was a part of ongoing hostilities between European settlers and a coalition of tribes including the Narrangasett, Wampanoag and other tribes referred to as King Phillip’s War. Increasing anger at the attempted Anglicisation of the New England tribes, and efforts to convert them to Christianity caused the war.
It brought New England to the brink of destruction. Half of it’s towns were attacked, twelve were completely destroyed and the region’s economy and its population were devastated. It is estimated that between six to eight hundred people died, and if one considers the limited population of New England at the time, the death rate was nearly twice as large as that of the Civil War.
The psychological affect on the fledgling community cannot be overstated, as the fear of destruction was an emotion taken forward into the development of frontier ideology.
True History was the beginning of the literary impact on the frontier myth for women. Her text is the first chance for historians to look at how a woman reacted to the wilderness. As Mary Rowlandson was the ‘first women to engage with the frontier on public record.’
Rowlandson organises her journey through the wilderness as “removes” where she must ‘turn her back on the Town and travel with them (the Indians) in the vast and desolate wilderness.’
She is constantly in pain at the increasing distance between her and the ‘civilising light’ as she moves ‘into the Indian darkness.’
Nearly every remove is greeted with sadness: ‘I went along that day, mourning and lamenting, leaving farther my own Countrey (sic.)’ as it seems that is these journeys which force Rowlandson to keep confronting her own isolation and loss.
For Rowlandson the wilderness was a space which reflected her own emotional condition, her descriptions of what she sees and experiences are coloured by her misery. Upon the death of her child she laments at ‘leaving that child in the wilderness’, rather than specifically mourning the child’s death.
This suggests she views the wilderness as a place she will not return to, and in some ways she is abandoning the child by not burying it a place of God.
For Kolodny captivity functioned as pretext, first for religious teaching then as a pretext for the central drama of women suffering in the wilderness.
This characterisation fits with Mary Rowlandson’s experience in the wilderness, it is first of all a lesson in suffering, which brings her closer to God, but still depicts a women suffering in the uncivilised wilderness. The suffering of women on the frontier only had one aim, to use Slotkin’s phrase, to help develop these ‘new actions’, to claim the frontier, and to restrict women from it.
In addition to being the beginning of the frontier myth for women, King Phillip’s war also held the beginnings of the violent stereotype of Native Americans. The war was known for its extreme violence on both sides, however many of the written accounts solely focus on the violence of the attacks by the Native Americans, using the ‘literall advantage (sic.)’
of New Englanders played a key role in establishing this stereotype.
Cotton Mather described how they tortured an oxen and horse by putting them into ‘ a hovil and then let it on fire (sic.)’.
Jill Lepore traced the origin of a racially defined American identity to the events of King Phillip’s War, as Native Americans were increasingly associated with violence, and colonists began to define themselves in opposition to this emphasised cruelty.
Mary Rowlandson’s text supported this, she represented the Saggamores as hellish savages calling them: ‘inhuman creatures’ and ‘ravenous bears’.
By representing Native Americans as inhuman, it in turn reinforced colonist’s superiority, and led to a shifting of the emphasis on the justification of colonial settlement on to the frontier, to who deserved the land, and who would use it better.
In this shift, we can see the origins of the stereotype of Native American behaviour: inhuman, cruel, and incapable of using the wilderness “properly”.
Lepore herself emphasised the role of Rowlandson’s narrative in creating an American identity. She was the most prominent captive taken during King Phillip’s war, and the success of her return was a psychological boost for the New England population. This can be seen in how Rowlandson describes her return to Boston, she felt in ‘the midst of love’ and she details how the cost of her ransom was paid by ‘some Boston gentlewomen’.
Her redemption was significant during King Phillip’s War but the delay in publishing her narrative meant that it took on an even greater significance, as the text became America’s first best seller, it positioned the settlers in direct opposition to the New England tribes.
Her text was republished again during the American Revolution, where the British were represented as ‘more savage enemies than the Indians of King Philip’s war’, evoking the memory the early struggle to survive against an outsider enemy to help unify the country to prepare for another.
Mary Rowlandson became the single strongest cultural memory of King Phillip’s War, and would continue to play a crucial role in cementing the oppositional identity of Americans.
Mary Rowlandson’s narrative did not become such a culturally significant text on its own. Puritan ministers saw the potential for using Rowlandson’s narrative as a biblical allegory as well as to reinforce social and developing racial boundaries. Historians assume that it was Increase Mather who wrote the preface to the original text in 1682, framing Rowlandson’s story with a reminder of its connection to Puritan theology.
The preface urges readers to ‘read therefore, peruse and ponder…lay up something from the experience of another, against thine own turn comes’.
The expectation is that the reader will use Rowlandson’s text to help prepare for their own test of faith, and framing Rowlandson’s experience as biblical lesson.
Historical debate has raged over whether Mather or Rowlandson’s husband played a role in the writing of the text itself. It is likely that either or both played some role in editing the text, as it was highly unusual for a Puritan woman to have a voice in public. The original title includes a qualification that the text was ‘written by her own hand, for private use and now made public at the earnest desire of some friends and the benefit of the afflicted’, suggesting that there was a need to endorse the text’s authenticity, and justify its publication.
The narrative itself has many inconstancies of tone and argument, but one of the most jarring elements is the lack of description of a reunion with her family. Being a Puritan woman, her role as wife and mother was paramount, yet they are recounted as secondary to her own religious experience.
All these elements suggest that A True History was not just the work of Mary Rowlandson.
These interventions were needed because Mary Rowlandson’s story would not fit into the Puritan stereotype of female behaviour. Her text was presented to the Puritan population accompanied by a preface by Increase Mather, the most prominent thinker in the New World, and a sermon by Rowlandson’s husband. This bracketing of the text neutralised the controversial elements by reminding readers of the text’s theological importance. It also lent the text the respectability of their names.
Beyond this, some critics have detected two voices in A True History : a colloquial and a biblical voice. There has been much literary discussion of the two voices in Rowlandson’s text, some argue that these dual voices suggest that there was another author involved in the process of writing. Speculation about two authors aside, the two voices demonstrate the tensions inherent in the writing of a captivity narrative as Rowlandson tries to understand her experience using her Puritan beliefs. Rebecca Blevins Faery asserts that theology as an explanatory system failed to deal with much of her experience, leaving Rowlandson to use the second colloquial voice to recount the parts of her story which don’t support the biblical.
Get Josephine Shaddock’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The constriction of A True History created a central plot point for all captivity narratives: their return. It was the most crucial moment in the narrative, the way that captives returned was termed a redemption or in Rowlandson’s case ‘restoration’. By emphasising the captive’s return, it reinforced the superiority of Euro-American culture. The origins of redemption were religious, as to redeem shared much of the same meaning as to save and so was linked to the soul being restored to back to God’s grace. It is also suggests a sense of compensating for the bad aspects of something, or a restoration to honour and respectability. Both these interpretations show that a captive was somehow degraded by their experience. If contrasted with restore as defined by the Oxford English dictionary’s definition meaning to bring back or re-establish, it is clear that redemption is much more conditional on a woman’s behaviour. The terms would go on to support the secular removal of the role of women themselves in the process of their return, regardless of their own experience.
For example, Rowlandson plays a key role in her own restoration, as she is trusted enough to name her own ransom fee. She also finds a level of economic freedom in the wilderness, as she sews items, and takes payment for them. Rowlandson is so successful she is even asked to sew a ‘shirt for his (King Phillip’s) boy’, and her connection to him undoubtedly helps her gain her freedom.
However, Rowlandson herself assigns her return to ‘providence’, one of the few ‘remarkable passages of providence’ which marked her captivity.
Like any good Puritan, she credits her redemption to God’s hand, not her own talent or strength.
The story of Hannah Dustin (sometimes referred to as Duston or Dustan) and Cotton Mather’s handling of it, shows that even the most extreme assertion of female agency can be framed in such a way to remove the power of her actions. Dustin was taken captive in 1769 shortly after the birth of her daughter, who she then saw brutally murdered, alongside several other members of her family. A few weeks into her captivity, she took a hatchet and killed 10 of the Abenaki tribe who had taken her captive, six of which were children, scalped them and returned to white society to claim the bounty that was paid for all Native American scalps.
The violence of her escape leads us to consider stretches the traditional construction of redemption. Even Mather cannot frame this as redemption, as her behaviour is far to masculine, and the savageness Indian, choosing rather to term it in ‘a notable exploit’.
In Cotton Mather’s narrative of her experience, he roots her behaviour in bible verse, and in Puritan ideology, using judea capita to fit her story into the image of ‘meek and frightened white women, suffering in the wilderness’.
The emphasis is placed on her motherhood, as ‘she was not forbidden by any Law to take the Life of Murderers, by whom her Child had been Butchered (Mather’s emphasis).’
Cotton Mather led the focus on female captivity narratives because women were ‘more perfectly accommodated the interpretative biblical type because female captives could be so easily identified with the shrinking passive vulnerability that is at its heart.’
The fact that a male preacher is the reason for the enduring popularity for female captivity narratives shows the importance of the male role in shaping the form.
Lost Daughters: Eunice Williams and Mary Jemison
‘You will have sons and daughters but you will not keep them, because they will go into captivity’ Deuteronomy 28:41
Eunice Williams and Mary Rowlandson shared a position as part of the Puritan elite, both were related to ministers who dominated the religious life of New England. Whilst Mary Rowlandson became a parable of successful redemption, Eunice would go to become a symbol of all the anxieties and fears of what would happen if a captive was lost to another culture.
These so called “lost daughters” of which Eunice Williams is the most famous represented a failure to the Euro-American community. They had chosen to remain in culture which was supposedly inferior to the one they had left behind. With every captive that chose to remain, that feeling of superiority was challenged and with it the mandate of American frontier settlement.
Cadawaller Calden writing in 1699 about an exchange of French and Iroquois prisoners stated that ‘few (English prisoners) could be persuaded to return’, and he noted that the reverse situation was never the same, Native American prisoners held by the English settlers were never easily assimilated.
The captivity of Eunice Williams was particularly painful for the Puritan community, as she was taken as part of the Deerfield raid in 1704 which Evan Haefeli termed as one of the ‘most devastating attacks on a colonial village’.
Over 50 were killed and 112 were taken captive. Among the captives included the family of John Williams a well connected Puritan minister, and his seven year old daughter Eunice. He went on to write a narrative of his experience The Redeemed Captive which became the main source we have for Eunice’s life. Over the next sixty years she would become a community obsession as stories about her visits spread across the whole community such as the rumour of her preferring to sleep outside when she visited her brother at his parish at Longmeadow in 1740.
Hopes continued for her to return home throughout her life as sermons were preached for her return until 1742.
Over time, due to her continued refusal to return Eunice became an enduring reminder of the pain of the Deerfield Massacre, and of the loss of face her captivity generated.
It might seem strange to include Eunice’s story in an analysis of captivity narratives, as she never wrote her own narrative, but her story became so well known in Puritan and later American society that she carried a cultural significance of her own.
It is difficult to analyse Eunice’s reaction to the wilderness as we have no captivity narrative from her perspective. Her main exposure to the frontier is in the march to Canada undertaken by majority of the Deerfield captives as Eunice ends up in the mission of St. Francois Xavier du Sault St.Loius, just outside Montreal, which can only be termed wilderness from the perspective of the Puritan community in New England. John Williams wrote that ‘she was carried all the journey and looked after with a great deal of tenderness’.
Nevertheless she had to experience the death of her mother, at the hands of her captor so her experience in the wilderness was marked in by emotional difficulty rather than extreme physical hardship. The tenderness shown to her by her captors may hold the root of the cause as to why she stayed.
Puritans had to justify why captives chose to remain with those who took them captive by relying on a patriarchal system of gender and racial stereotypes. The perception of women and Native Americans meant that they both shared a similar subordinate relationship to the male, both were considered inferior, and requiring of guidance to maintain a proper position with the civilised world. This was due to the belief that both were closer to “nature” than to “culture”, Native Americans were considered pre-civilised, whilst women’s menstrual cycles tied their minds to earth’s rhythms. This made women more vulnerable to acculturation by Native American culture.
It is statistically true that female captives especially younger ones were more like to remain with their adoptive tribes, but this has more to do with connections of family and religion than a common nature.
Of course, Eunice did not follow the Puritan advice of resisting the authority of her captors:-she remained unredeemed, and as such her story is a cautionary tale for those taken into captivity. Meldicott argues that ‘as she lived and died an Indian; she achieved an immortality she might never have received had she been just another captive’.
It is very telling that those who did not return were better known than those who were redeemed, it suggests that they had a large cultural impact. The immortality she received made Eunice Williams a powerful historical character in colonial discourse.
An example of the differing interpretations of her legacy can be seen in different representations of her conversion to Catholicism. The story passed down through Eunice’s family represents her conversion as a powerful spiritual experience.
Presumably based on his own experience, John Williams saw her loss of Puritan faith as a function of the power held over her by her captors.
In reality, we have no details of her conversion, or many of the aspects of her life at all, as the absence of a narrative leave Eunice open to historical reinterpretation. She became a touchstone for Puritan anxiety because her story is unable to fitted into any narrative of redemption.
The placing of the responsibility for redemption outside the role of women is undermined in Eunice’s story. Many attempts were made by her father, and other family members to try to get her to return. In fact her strength of character and her refusal to be moved one of the most notable trends in recorded conversations with her: ‘she looked bashful, but proved harder than steel in the breast’.
Mary Jemison refused the same pressure to return, both cases could suggest that it was possible for a captive woman to assert control of themselves, although it has be to be outside the boundaries of regular society.
The perception of the failure to redeem a captive is seen as a fall into temptation as it is inconceivable that they, as white Euro-Americans, would want to remain. They have been tempted into acculturation. Eunice Williams and Mary Jemison are no longer the white women who were taken out of Euro-American society.
Like Eunice Williams Mary Jemison’s story was recorded by another, although her life was the text’s sole focus. James E. Seaver, minister to small population of Genesee near where Jemison lived, wrote The Narrative of the Life of Mary Jemison after a set of interviews with the elderly Jemison in 1824. Her story began much earlier: when Jemison was twelve she was taken captive in an attack in which the majority of her family were captured, but she was the only one chosen to be adopted. Her mother, father and younger brothers were killed. She witnessed their scalps being cleaned and prepared and ‘could easily distinguish my father’s and the children’s from each other’.
She was then adopted by two sisters of the Seneca tribe to replace their dead brother.
Mary Jemison’s narrative is the first example of a female flourishing in the wilderness. Despite Seaver’s best intentions, Kolodny said that ‘at the heart of The narrative of the Life of Mary Jemison…(is) the world of a white woman contentedly adopted into Indian society and happily adapted to life in the wilderness.’
Her early life amongst the Indians bared none of the hardships that characterised Mary Rowlandson’s: Jemison describes her situation as ‘easy: I had no real hardship to endure.’
By the beginning of the nineteenth century, society needed to create a new stereotype of the woman on the frontier, as the journey west was being undertaken in a greater scale than ever before. Jemison’s story allowed this transition, and did much to redefine a woman’s role in the wilderness of the frontier: she ‘brought home and family into the cleared spaces of the wild’.
Women could no longer be kept scared out of the wilderness, they had to be given a role on the developing frontier. Mary Jemison’s story fulfilled this need for a new domestic role.
If stereotypes of female behaviour on the frontier were in flux, conversely those governing expectations of Native Americans continued much in the same vein as before. The central tension in the text is between Jemison’s experience, and Seaver’s desire to fit her experience into a traditional captivity narrative form highlighting the violence of Seneca behaviour. The main aim of Seaver’s manipulation of Jemison’s story is to reinforce the negative stereotypes of Native Americans. Upon reading, it seems Seaver left the integrity of much of Jemison’s words intact, for example there is a tension between her fear of ‘ardent spirits- a poison that will soon exterminate the Indian tribes in this part of the country’ and the gratuitous focus on Native American violence.
The main intervention is his emphasis on the military career of Jemison’s second husband- Hiokatoo, as well as moments of tribal violence scattered through her life story such as a description of the killing of Lieutenant Boyd whose stomach was cut and intestines drawn out and ‘tied to a sapling…and drove him round until he had drawn out the whole of his intestines’.
It is clear that Seaver’s main focus in text is the violence of the Senecas for which Jemison’s life is a convenient vehicle.
Jemison’s fake cousin George Jemison even has his voice heard in her narrative, as he talks about the fearsome and violent reputation of Hiokatoo whose ‘thirst for blood’ Seaver turns into an eight page postscript of Jemison’s story.
This section fulfils Seaver’s desire to paint the Seneca tribes as warlike savages. The use of George allows Seaver to distance his representation of Jemison with the violence of her husband, preserving her sense of purity, and refined female sentiment as fitting to a nineteenth century heroine.
It is not just Seaver who manipulates Jemison’s text, it went on to be edited and republished over twenty times between 1824 and 1918, as each editor sought to highlight and manipulate her story in a different way.
One of the most radical editors of Mary’s story was William Pryor Letchworth who played an important role in creating an image of Mary Jemison in the popular mind. Most crucially, his renewed interest in her life turned up a death bed conversion to Christianity in a letter from a wife of minister who visited her in her dying days. However, rather than conclusive evidence of a conversion, the letter documents Jemison’s relief at hearing the Lord’s prayer.
Her representation in popular culture emphasised her attributes as American frontierswoman. Most notably this can be seen in the statue commissioned by Letchworth by Henry Kirke Bush-Brown called the ‘The White Women of Genesee’ (see image below). The statue’s depiction of her costume is accurate, nevertheless the role she is given is solitary white woman. June Namias says ‘by creating and dedicating this statue to the White Woman (although they placed an Indian name at her feet) Letchworth and Bush-Brown celebrated the white and Euro-American values they saw Jemison representing: individuality, perseverance and the need to go it alone.’
A tradition of emphasising her American nature is seen in Seaver’s narrative as well, he describes her accent as maintaining some of its Irish lilt.
However it was Letchworth who seared the image of the White Women of Genesse into the minds of Americans everywhere.
Photograph of H.K Bush Brown’s statue of Mary Jemison in Letchworth Park, NY. From ‘Pieces of the Past, Artefacts, Documents and Primary Sources from Letchworth Park History’.<http://www.letchworthparkhistory.com/statuedesc.html> (24 April 2013).
As mentioned earlier, Jemison’s story disrupts the traditional narrative of redemption in so much as she resists many attempts from others to “redeem” her, instead remaining her entire life as a beloved part of the Seneca community. It could be argued that rather than being returned to Euro-American society in her lifetime, Jemison’s redemption came with the development of her as a well known cultural figure who represented the frontier spirit. The admirable qualities of her life story were represented by the editors of the text as part of her inherent whiteness, and her identification as part of the Seneca people obscured by her own success in the wilderness.
Sarah Wakefield: Narrative as a Form of Redemption
If Mary Jemison’s posthumous redemption was in the hands of the editors of her text, then Sarah Wakefield looked to the readers of her text to redeem her. Her narrative breaks with many of the features of captivity narratives discussed in this paper, as it criticises the white patriarchy but subscribes to the majority of tenets of the frontier myth.
Sarah Wakefield and her family went west into Minnesota after her husband’s appointment as a doctor on a reservation in 1861. She was taken captive in attack on Yellow Medicine Indian agency, where over 500 white soldiers were killed at the beginning of the Dakota War of 1862. Over 200 captives were taken including Wakefield and her two young children, as the attack was an attempt to drive the whites out the of the area. The six weeks they spent in captivity were spent in constant fear for their lives, as there were rumours of killings of white captives continually during that time.
It was due to the protection of a Dakota called Chaska and his family that Wakefield and her children survived. Chaska decided when the tide of the war was turning to turn themselves into the Army. Chaska was arrested; accused of crimes relating to the Dakota War. Wakefield did her best to defend him using her testimony that was taken from all those who had captive, but he was ultimately executed.
The treatment of Wakefield in the army camp was poor, but it was the execution of Chaska which ruined her relationship with the army, and the male establishment who rescued her. Chaska’s execution was officially considered a mistake caused by a mistranslation of Native American names but Wakefield believed that he was killed intentionally, and the matter has sparked much historical debate.
For the purposes of this essay, though, the truth of the matter is less important than Wakefield’s perception of it, and she believed that Chaska’s execution was part of conspiracy to prevent the truth about her experience coming out, as he would have been able to vouch for her story.
Sarah Wakefield’s journey West was part of the huge move into the frontier which took place in the middle of the nineteenth century. Her perspective on the wilderness is the result of continued exposure to frontier ideology. Wakefield’s representation of her entering the wilderness has two threads: first her initial experience traveling to the reservation, and then her time in captivity, in particular hiding in a valley with her two children. Nature seems to unleash the full force of its fury onto Wakefield. There is a thunderstorm, mosquitos which cause ‘her children’s faces to run with blood from their bites’, and muskrats.
The fear which overcomes her when she left without any kind of male protector shows that she cannot survive on the frontier independently. Of course, in this case the frontier was full of Indians bent on the eradication of whites from the Plains, but it is telling that it is the threat of natural world that Wakefield describes vividly.
The second strand is her initial perception at arrival on the frontier, and her admiration of the beauty and the emptiness of the landscape. Describing the view as ‘too beautiful for nature’s picture’ seems to reinforce the image of the frontier as a garden created by God.
She also labels the area around the reservation as a ‘vacant space’, supporting the central idea of the frontier as empty and prime for the use of American nation.
This suggests that even though her text has not had any direct masculine intervention, in terms of her perspective on the wilderness she is still very under the influence of frontier discourse.
Unlike the rest of our texts, it is somewhat safe to assume that Wakefield’s text was unadulterated. By the middle of the nineteenth century, women writers were an accepted part of the literary scene, especially in terms of works of sentimental literature who tried to encourage social change. Therefore it was unlikely there was a male editor hanging over her shoulder, whilst she criticised male elites.
In addition there is not the same tension between the anecdotal evidence of the text and the male writer attempting to shape that experience within the text, that we have seen in other narratives. Instead, the force shaping Wakefield’s narrative is her concern of the perception of the reader, often she directly addresses them: ‘those who think I prefer Indian to civilised life, ought to travel like I did last summer’.
She justifies her actions as acting to preserve her and her children’s life, and she blames white society for leaving her under threat for so long and forcing her to make that decision.
Six Weeks with the Sioux was written as a reaction to pervasive contemporary beliefs about Native Americans, but Wakefield cannot help subscribing to some stereotypical views of those Dakota and Sioux she encounters. As she first arrived in the reservation, she thought the councils she could hear were ‘death songs’.
Her main support of stereotyping is her clear division in what she sees as “good” and “bad” Indians. Her division of Native Americans into “good” and “bad” supports much of Glenda Riley’s work on the stereotypes of Indians held by women who went west. Riley argued that women looked for the simultaneously the best and the worst of Indians, and found both.
This is seen most potently in the representation of Chaska and Hapa. Hapa is described as a ‘horrible blood-thirsty wretch’ who wants to kill her, and tries to rape her confirming the male fear of the rape of female captives.
Those of mixed European and Native American heritage are definitely in the Wakefield’s perception “bad” Indians. Her text strongly suggests that the violence of the Dakota war can be blamed on these ‘half-breeds’ who have ‘too much art and duplicity in them’.
She then counteracts the violence of their behaviour with showing how the ‘half breeds’ pretended to be loyal and cared for the white captives when the tide of the war was turning.
Her condemnation of those she considers ‘half breeds’ links into the negative conceptions of miscegenation within American culture, and it distances her from the accusation of sexual relations with Chaska as she is so negative about product of such unions. It also gives her narrative a villain to blame for the extreme violence that did take place in the Dakota war allowing her to continue to defend the rest of the Native American population.
Wakefield’s narrative allows us to see that the process of framing her experience is simultaneous to her “redemption”. Castiligia said ‘she was only useful to the government as a victim’, but when she refused this limited depiction of her experience and defended those to whom she owed life, she was represented as a ‘Indian lover’.
The hint of sexual impropriety, which she always denied, was enough to discredit her reputation. The army pardoned those who saved men, but could not deal with a relationship (of any kind) between a Native American man and white women without assuming there was a sexual element.
Sarah Wakefield’s experience and her choice to write a narrative complicates the notion of redemption assumed in this paper. Her redemption came not with her return and her reconciliation with the American community as defined by the majority of the captivity narratives. Instead redemption came with the production of the text and the publication of her Six Weeks with the Sioux. We again see the text being used a parallel for the body by explaining her reason for her feelings of indebtedness to Chaska, she explains her defence of him and redeems her sexuality and her body. If redemption came for Wakefield with the publication of the narrative, it came from the predominantly female readers of her narrative and not from her white male rescuers. At no point during her story are white men needed, the exertion of their power exists when they cause Chaska’s death, after this Wakefield frees herself from the predetermined narrative of captivity, and gives the power of redemption to her female readers. We have seen narratives which seek some kind of social acceptance through their narratives, but none have relied on the perspective and support of their readers to the extent of Sarah Wakefield.
Conclusion
Historiography of the American West has been coloured by the same gendered assumptions that affect the rest of historical thought, that facts and figures are inescapably masculine, and that texts based on these are somehow more true than the emotive female nature of narrative.
However, even the most dull economic history cannot exist without a story, they create shape out of chaos, and meaning out of disarray. The history of the West is particularly dominated by stories of individuals, with the most enduring being the masculine orchestrated frontier myth.
The narratives discussed in this paper show how a literary form can play a role in influencing the path of history. America’s history is littered with myths, stereotypes and images which disrupt historical thought, as these images are produced through the process of myth-making, and embedded in the popular imagination. The development of a myth is somewhat of a self fulfilling prophecy, as a divergence from the central tenet is lost to the all encompassing plot.
This paper asserts that it is the perception of the frontier, not the frontier itself which effected American development. The precedent for keeping women out of the wilderness, of which the captivity narrative were an important strand, helped to create, and cement an image of the frontier as a masculine space. This image would go on to dominate public perception of the West.
This paper has surveyed examples that span the full history of the frontier, and that embody the variety of the form of the captivity narrative. There are three strands to how captivity narratives influenced perception of the frontier: the representation of the wilderness itself, stereotyping of both women and Native Americans and finally the construct of redemption. Despite all the variation over time, in terms of the values reinforced by the texts there was little change: they reinforce the image of a frontier where women are unsafe, unhappy, unwelcome and dependent on men for their protection.
Ultimately, captivity narratives were the story of how women came to terms with the difficulties of being uprooted and thrown into an entirely different culture. The frontier myth was another story told to help America come to terms with a genocide of the Native American people by making it seem like part of a God-given plan. Every big story like the frontier is composed of the obfuscation and manipulation of a million smaller stories, and a million smaller lives, of which captive narratives are the most public example. They offer us a crucial window in to the practicalities of creating the frontier myth, of how a text’s meaning is altered, and how personal experience is reorganised to reinforce a bigger narrative. As William Cronan says we are the ones who create the stories, and we are the ones who must deal with their complicated consequences when we come to look at again at history.







