Sitemap

Shops and time

A day in London; reflections on value in different contexts.

9 min readJun 11, 2014

--

I return to London on a wet November morning, to salve my homesickness and to show the city to my children, who had never ridden the top deck of a bus, and only know the exotic creature scriwwel—a bit like a possum, I tell them—from pictures. We have barely a week before we must move on. I write a short list of places we must go. Some of that list is written by the native in me, to reprise my most vivid memories: freshly-baked sesame loaves outside the corner shop on Mount View Road; walking between the trees in Finsbury Park; fireworks over ‘Ally Pally’. Of the others, chosen as a tourist, the first two and most obviously iconic are the British Museum, and Harrods.

These two London institutions are alike only in size and in fame: one temple for Janus, the other for Mammon. In Harrods, everything is for sale, except the furniture, and the piano that plays itself. In the museum, not only can you not buy the artefacts, you must not even touch them—or leave jam-and-peanut-butter finger prints on the glass, as I find myself endlessly repeating to the children, in a hiss quiet enough, I hope, to minimise the annoyance to other visitors, yet loud enough to be heard by the security guard, whose baleful eye keeps turning our way. While in the department store, you are constantly invited to poke and prod, pick up the new Wii-U controller and shake it around, glide your fingers over the surface of the iPad’s latest incarnation. The museum’s broken pots and early farm implements have been dug out of huts and palaces buried by time and forgetfulness; its heirlooms have been treasured and passed down the generations. The latest creations of Versace and Prada, for all their diversity in style and function, share an obsessional hatred of their own past, their every line and colour tone engineered not only in competition with each other, but to deliver a vicious backward kick at last season’s version of themselves. They rush forward into a future in which they, in turn, will be obsolete, and spend a brief dotage on a sale rail before being cast out into the garbage.

In the museum’s collections, age is not a barrier but a requisite to inclusion. An exhibition of currency shows a silver dinar from the Umayyad Caliphate, an imperfect disc engraved with Arabic calligraphy, displayed alongside a coin of the Han Dynasty, green bronze around a square hole; a solid gold mancus, bearing the inscription REX COENVVLF in a halo over the king’s profile, with his large eyes and sharp nose; some cowrie shells; a decayed copper alloy coin, recovered from Mytilene on the island of Lesbos, depicting the head of the poet Sappho; and an HSBC visa card.

This last item, with its bold colours and streamlined logo, seems comically out-of-place. I point it out to the kids, and laugh, but it’s a nervous and startled reaction to the paraphernalia of our own lives joining the quaint and the ancient. Their presence in the museum is an exception, a deliberate rupture in the reverie that we enter when we look at old things and think of the past. It is a statement of the future obsolescence of any modernity. The credit card is stripped of its everyday function, and becomes an artefact whose use must be explained to future museum-goers with a description on the plaque beside it. It haunts us with our mortality and the transience of culture. Already, it is slightly dated—it doesn’t match the most recent version in my own wallet—but this no comfort. It suggests that we are already a step ahead of the present, looking back over our shoulder at ourselves. (Perhaps this is what that hackneyed and debased term ‘post-modern’ means—if it means anything at all.) Or that nothing, not even the ruthless presentism that infects even the grammatical tense of our historical novels, exempts us from the alienating and objectifying gaze of history. To live in the moment—that feeble cry of contemporary self-help culture—is a kind of nostalgia, not for the past, but, ominously, for the missing present; or rather, a present from which we are in some way absent.

To face that visa card exhibit is to miss oneself terribly. There is an urge to leave the exhibition and its unpalatable implications, to quit the museum altogether, and go back to the department store, where we can buy ourselves back, a self selected and assembled from a smorgasbord of choice: a self that may not last longer than this season, but at least comes with a receipt, and affords us a chance to prove that our credit cards have life in them yet, for a little while. It’s apt that the British Museum’s exhibition of currency is sponsored by a bank—it’s housed in the HSBC Money Gallery.

Get Joshua Mostafa’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

I content myself with a glossy, content-light book about Sutton Hoo, a purchase I regret almost before I’ve paid for it. The children are more enthused with a Horrible Histories board game and a Cleopatra costume. To my chagrin, they’re more keen on the shop than they were on the rest of the museum. I grumble something peevish about consumerism, to salve my conscience; but when they ask me what that means, I find it hard to define.

The pleasure of shopping is, of course, far older than modern consumer society. To shop provides the same sense of satisfaction that foraging for fruit and berries did for our neolithic ancestors, whose once-deadly flint arrowheads rest harmlessly behind glass in the museum. It predates the work ethic, which is only as old as the agricultural revolution. It is older than homo sapiens, part of our primate core. To step out of the house and to return with the thing one set out to find is one of the little rituals that validate a day. I don’t like to think of myself as a blind devotee of commodity fetishism, but I have to admit that I get far more pleasure from the act of browsing, considering and occasionally purchasing than is warranted by the bare of act of obtaining some lowly object—a lead pencil, or a coffee made better than one can oneself. Surely even Marx felt a little frisson of buyer’s delight, leaving a bookshop on a crisp winter evening with a copy of Hegel’s Science of Logic tucked under his arm.

If the department store—clean, air-conditioned, peopled with smooth-faced mannequins—is the great ziggurat of the corporate world, there are shops that purvey a more subtle and homely form of shopping’s opiate. My vice is to graze on the rows of spines on the shelves of second-hand bookshops. These, and all shops that recycle—antique stores, charity shops, and honest-to-goodness junk shops—do not participate in the cult of the brand-new, or even of the brand. At the department store, you buy something once and once only; an item in a second-hand shop might in fact be third or fourth hand. It might, in time, return to the very same shelf in the same shop. The second-hand shop’s stock is sometimes old, but not ancient. It does not pretend to universalism, as the museum (everything that ever was) and the department store (everything you could ever want) do. While the contents of both the museum and the department store come from every corner of the world, nothing in Haringey Mencap comes from outside the N4 postcode. You cannot walk into a second-hand bookshop and expect to find some specific title; you have to walk in with an open mind, be prepared to rummage and to emerge an hour later with something that you didn’t know you wanted, but now that it has shown up, becomes the salient point of your afternoon’s outing: look what I found.

The charity shop inverts the logic of supply and demand. Things are not put up for sale there because people want them, but precisely because someone did not want them. The act of buying something second hand—a small coffee table, say—is accompanied, for me, by an innocent enjoyment that I would not feel buying the identical item for the same price on the high street. It’s not just a question of sustainability, although it’s certainly true that buying a table second hand requires no trees to be felled. The act of buying a new coffee table vindicates the calculus of a whole chain of crafty, manipulative intellects—designers, copywriters, marketing people—who have pre-empted my decision, anticipated my judgements, pegged my sensibility to a number of facets of taste and demographic data: how old I am, how much money I earn, where I live and so on. It might make me an egotist, an idealist (in the derogatory sense used by materialist philosophers, approximating ‘dick-head’ in ordinary English) or an obstinate fool, but I prefer to think that I like this coffee table, with its irregular grain and bulbous legs, for my own reasons, if not unique, then at least idiosyncratic.

So I wander for an hour between cramped, musty shelves in a shop on Stoke Newington Church Street, a bus ride from my childhood borough. There’s a roomful of kids’ books at the back, where my son plays with Transformers and my daughter skim-reads the better part of a dystopian satire of Harry Potter in which all the wizards are evil, and they have taken over the world. I find a few books—none that I knew I wanted, but some that, once discovered, exert a powerful attraction, for the fact they will make me think about things I would not have considered otherwise, such as a pale green little book on Lévi-Strauss. There’s also a novel by Amit Chaudhuri, with a gentle but undeniable magic in its sentences. The serendipitous discovery of these books gives them a special value to me. They presented themselves to me at this or that point in my life, and for all my pretence at shunning superstition, this seems significant, an omen to nudge me in a certain direction, to provide me auspicious material for bricolage: food, not for thought exactly but for rumination, for dreams and for those half-asleep moments in which the mind becomes a crucible for unexpected metaphors and new connections.

I am chewing over one of these books on the top deck of the bus heading back along Green Lanes, so engrossed that we miss the stop for Turnpike Lane. Walking back towards the tube, I turn up Lymington Avenue in search of juice boxes for the kids. There in front of me, seven huge block letters spell out MATALAN in pillar box red. It’s not a pretty sight.

Matalan uses the euphemism ‘value’ to refer, with horrible coyness, to its chief selling point: the low prices of its unlovely wares. But it is a perversion of the word, an act of shameless doublespeak, to use it without irony to describe its opposite. There is no value in its ugly synthetic cardigans, its fake Adidas tracksuits with four stripes on the sleeves; they are cheap in every sense. Matalan is the antithesis of several kinds of value at once: rarity, glamour, charm, cool. It is the department store’s evil twin: everything you need, nothing you want. Its function in the scheme of value is to supply the punchline to an insult that is itself also cheap: ‘Where’d you get that from—Matalan?’ The odium derives not so much from the poor quality of its goods but from snobbery. It is not the impugning of poor taste, or meanness, but of poverty, that gives the sneer an edge. The unfairness of the slur does not redeem the shop, however, but rather buries it deeper in layers of contempt and hatefulness: even the way in which it is judged to be bad, is itself bad.

Prestigious brands sell t-shirts, unremarkable except for their corporate logo, emblazoned prominently. Matalan doesn’t. If it did, only hipsters might wear them, as an ironic ‘statement’ (since these ‘statements’ have no content, it would be more honest to call them jokes; but fashion, an everyday form of disguise, has no use for honesty). It would need to be no more than one part of an outfit whose other parts would act as a counterpoint: to go out head-to-toe in Matalan would be an act of bravery indeed, of sartorial suicide. Matalan goods will never be valorised in the way that jazz or the novel have been, from low culture to mainstream. They are the shitty end of the value continuum, deplorable but necessary, like the Lumpenproletariat in a meritocracy, or untouchables in a caste system. There but for the grace of God (or by my good karma, or the pulling up of myself by the bootstraps, etc) shop I.

It is my son, five years old, who reminds me that the malevolent aura of the shop—which seems to me as inseparable from the building as the unsightly concrete slabs that form its walls—is an illusion of culture. He is waving a brightly-coloured toy from the Digimon franchise—a poor imitation of Pokémon, itself an outdated fad—and suggesting that I buy it for him as a souvenir of our trip to London. It’s only fair that I do so, he claims, since ‘you got those old books’. My daughter, twelve and worldly-wise, eyes it askance. ‘That crap? Get something decent.’ But he insists. Envying my son’s ignorance of the value of things, I buy him the toy, and we leave the shop.

--

--

Joshua Mostafa
Joshua Mostafa

Written by Joshua Mostafa

PhD candidate at WSU: prehistory in fiction, poetics, historiography & representation. Inna Riddim selector: dub, jazz, jungle.