Sitemap

Value Defined

2 min readDec 21, 2016

--

Reading through this story about a McDonald’s franchise customer who has filed a class-action lawsuit claiming that the two-cheeseburger “value meal” is actually 41 cents more than buying the individual items separately, and therefore, these franchises were deceiving their customers.

My gut reaction to this is that he’s right, the customers are being screwed! But are they? First of all, where in McDonald’s (or the franchise’s) promotional material do they offer the guarantee that a “value meal” will be cheaper than buying the items individually, and do people have a reasonable expectation for this to be the case?

Get Leiterfluid’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

So what defines “value?” One might argue, in this case, that the value comes from the time saved by ordering the meal as a unit, rather than as an itemized list. After all, time is money.

Secondly, if the prices are clearly listed on the menu board, for both individual items, as well as the value meals, doesn’t the customer have a responsibility to know the terms of the deal as they go into it, as this gentleman did? Why wouldn’t this be the case of “buyer beware?”

It seems to me that the correct remedy would be for the customer to go back to the store manager, with his receipts, and say “hey, I noticed you charged me $5.90, but if I bought everything individually, it should have only been $5.49, can you credit me the difference?” I don’t know, though, if there was ever an attempt do this, or if he thought this would be a cash cow by going straight to a lawyer, and paying almost $600 to have this filed as a class-action lawsuit.

If I were the judge, I’d probably deny the class-action status, rule that he had been overcharged, and refund him the $2.05 (assuming he had the receipts for the other purchases), and probably issue a warning to the franchise that they should put up a notice that the value menu may not necessarily be priced cheaper than the individual items.

--

--

Leiterfluid
Leiterfluid

Written by Leiterfluid

Experienced IT professional, published author, and pompous jerk. Tweets posted are my own, and in no way reflect the opinions of my employer, family, or cat.