DeSci’s Impact on Research in Underserved Fields
There is growing recognition of the inadequacies of the traditional funding mechanisms for research. The process of using peer review to make funding allocations is increasingly seen to be riddled with problems. This is a problem that impacts all fields, of course. However, the effects of this one-size-fits-all procedure fall hardest on so-called high-risk and neglected research carried out in underserved or understudied fields and populations. One of the unfortunate effects of the neglect of such research and the researchers that carry it out is that commonly acknowledged problems in research practice will simply not be researched because funding will not be forthcoming.
These are incredibly pertinent questions at the current juncture, with research funding under extreme pressure and more scientists diagnosed with a lack of funding or the dread of running out of it. There is a dearth of funding available, and researchers are operating in an increasingly unappealing environment of austerity and increasing precarization. But the broader point is this: what kind of scientific innovation could our uninformed funding be preventing in the diverse research ecosystems we have left untouched? In order to attempt to answer these questions — or to at least outline a path forward by which we can answer them — the logic, potential, and practice of decentralized science will be explored.
1.1. Background and Context
Decentralized science, often abbreviated as DeSci or “desci,” has received increasing attention in recent years. This interest is part of a wave of enthusiasm for new models and technologies supporting scientific research. This area of work in cloud computing and cryptocurrency, social computing, and recommender systems aims to connect the needs of society — for scientific answers — with those best able to provide this knowledge — researchers and those with dormant expertise.
This is a project that doesvetails with other conversations, such as that about the virtues of using alternatives to traditional models to fund research. In current systems, large sums of money are shunted from governments and private industry to large and increasingly global institutions, without regard for the value of many fields and without concern for long-term sustainability. The impact of these funding strategies on historically underfunded disciplines, especially those that have concrete benefits for interpersonal, communal, or health needs, is serious.
Many of the most exciting scholarly communities working on underfunded needs and questions are hidden from view because they lack the resources to participate. In other cases, the most liminal zones of study, those where researchers are prototyping future projects from fields that do not yet exist or using novel methods, are also the most in need of diverse expertise and feedback. These are the fields that are often crowded out by traditional approaches. Recent work on decentralized science has sought to illustrate these barriers by offering history, ideas of critique, and a manifesto to sustain and advance a discussion on equity.
At the start of the 20th century, the majority of academic research was funded directly by communities, patrons, and governments. That has shifted dramatically. However, flourishing is different from thriving, and experimentation is different from success. Today, we have a chance for a reset — especially in an era of global disruption and innovation. We are familiar with problems, but we also know about innovation. We have what we need. It’s time to adapt and to collectively do better by funding all.
1.2. Research Problems and Objectives
The specific problems under investigation in this study concern the funding and funding practices in underserved research fields. Traditionally, funding in important topics follows a practical, selective logic based on the ambitions of donors and governing governments. It is designed to allocate resources, not according to need but according to the best or, similarly, the most promising return on the investment, which limits capacities for equity. An additional problem is concerned with the overriding reliance on the peer review process, which promotes work in developed countries instead of those aligned with global health priorities. The objectives of the study are, first, to establish the limitations inherent to present practices and studies in some parts of the world, such as those that are systemic. These intentions will be investigated through a decentralized science lens to try to offer an alternative model.
Not much work has investigated the practicalities around decentralized science initiatives in a conventional research setting. As decentralized institutions, it is reasonable to expect universities would be involved in working non-decisions, and university research accelerates the understanding of achieving research and health system goals. Investigating the aims and tendencies of such practice, as well as the limitations and problems they face, is valuable as it furthers our understanding of how decentralized science can be used to advance research and health.
The use of qualitative methodologies is suggested for researching non-decision models, as documents tend to be scarce and secrecy surrounding policy hampers research into official meetings, agendas, important issues discussed, quantifiable indicators, and outcomes. Semi-structured interviews with recipients of outsider research funding, as well as authors of decentralized science-cited work, should be conducted, allowing the conduct of cross-organizational and multi-level governance analyses.
2. Traditional Funding Models in Research
The way scientists are funded in their work, to a significant extent, determines the research problems they address with public resources. Funding can happen in a decentralized fashion, when scientists in a given field present their respective projects and compete for pre-allocated resources, or in a formula mechanism through which an agency disseminates calls to a few scientific disciplines. In both cases, the concentration of research in the specific fields of funded researchers is evident, and we can see how investment policies shape the operations in each discipline where the economy of science occurs. In the Netherlands, for instance, the funding policy packages go through predominantly traditional scientific fields that are concentrated in one of the Nine Missions, further reducing the diversity of their funding blocs.
Funding schemes in scientific exploratory research have evolved into complex policy packages with multiple schemes. In addition, the current centralized funding policy is based on the evaluation of projects by individual researchers with the help of a system that facilitates the selection of projects characterized by academic quality. Such a funding policy faces criticism, largely aimed at accessibility to these funds awarded by the Scientific Council. Recent research shows how the allocation of public resources in this way reproduces the academic culture and biases at work in other areas. The traditional funding model in science fields has limits, and these limits should not be neglected. Traditional funding is insufficiently able to recognize and represent the future and inadequately rewards research patterns that require persistence and a timescale to develop.
Agencies operating from this administration do so using outdated criteria based on peer-review judgments and h-indices, mostly generated by non-diverse gatekeeper characteristics, increasing the risk of rewarding researchers who are not qualified enough to receive basic funding and reducing the relative portion of the funding pool in the hands of capable researchers. But agencies find it difficult to shift the allocation of resources to a new, fairer approach due to their long-standing existence and lack of the capacity to change their distribution locations to the actual needs of modern science. Currently addressed at fixing the mechanics of a traditional system, progressive academics are increasingly advocating a complete overhaul of the traditional science system.
2.1. Overview of Traditional Funding Models
2.1.1. Types of Funding Sources
Research is often supported by public funding agencies and, in certain instances, by private foundations or companies. These funding sources are usually geared either towards public goods that private capital will not support or towards the specific research needs of the government or philanthropy.
2.1.2. Grant Applications
Investigators have to submit grant applications to these funding agencies in order to receive support. The size of the award varies widely, from a small grant to pilot a new idea to multi-million-dollar center awards. Applicants are generally rated on criteria such as their academic track record, the proposal’s “intellectual merit” and “broader impacts,” the subfield of research they are in (some are more competitive than others), and the funding agency providing the support. As a result, competitiveness for research dollars is part of the academic ecosystem and institutional reward system. It might be harder for a small state university system to compete with larger institutions for funding in an area for which the latter is best known. There are, of course, some areas that tend to be mentioned as particularly hard or easy in general.
2.1.3. Review Processes
These funding applications undergo rigorous peer review processes in return for the funds that they receive. Sometimes this review is double-blind between applicants and reviewers, and sometimes it is single-blind, but in most cases, the reviewers know the identity of the principal investigator applying for funds. The funding agency also knows the identity of the principal investigator. In the funding process, uncertainty about what might be optimal science to fund is resolved by having scientists with similar expertise judge the merits of the application.
2.2. Challenges and Limitations
Undoubtedly, several inherent limitations to the traditional system of research funding are common knowledge to researchers. There are the basic challenges brought about by the increasing competition for money. Resources are limited, and the ratio of proposals to awards continues to spiral; thus, a large proportion of research proposals incur wasting valuable time and energy on their development. Undervaluing innovative research is one of the primary consequences of resource limitations. A competition-based system also underestimates groundbreaking ideas. Although valuable, many innovative ideas are regarded as extremely risky. Many programs are funded on a guardedly experimental basis because of beliefs about how factors can operate. Such profound biases exist on the part of both reviewers and administrators: many funding agencies are predisposed to those scholars and disciplines with which they are already familiar and comfortable. Major responsibility also lies with programs that institutionalize favored fields. When judgments are being made, it is not enough for a scholar to just be talented; he or she must also have the required pedigree. There are those groups that head up certain fields, and as a consequence, other areas are overlooked.
Long-term results of research investigations tend to be neglected. Economics and regulatory processes exert an abundance of caution because they are predicated on public policy; failure can be detected. The dilemma with scientific research is that it is several years before results are observed, results that may deny endpoints that funders and reviewers want. In addition, fiscal constraints for many funding agencies tie them to annual congressional and executive turnovers. Grants are given on a strict accountability procedure; funds are received periodically with renewal based on demonstrated results often substantiated on quantitative outputs alone. Extremely risky research can be best achieved through an arm’s-length process.
In this system, results can be judged on an equal level with high-level science as opposed to politics, fiscal constraints, and traditional funding. Alternatives to refine this process are in great demand. Financing change should not be based on individual arguments but on broad experiences and principles representing sound research and public policy. Schemes to attract scientists mandated to work within their disciplines in areas that show promise and opportunity should be appealing if for no other reason than those currently in place have not worked well.
3. Decentralized Science (DeSci)
In recent years, researchers, research organizations, and funders have called for science to be more open, more collaborative, widely accessible, and deeply connected to society. Decentralized Science (DeSci) can be defined as the collective effects and practices of these aspirations. DeSci is based on the belief that the new technologies we have today should enable us to go beyond traditional approaches to broaden the base of those who can contribute new ideas and data to research and be full participants. Indeed, however, to exploit the opportunities, researchers, administrators, funders, and policymakers must ensure that they understand the novel mechanisms, challenges, and strategies for turning aspirations into practice. DeSci focuses on removing the artificial barriers to entry that have crept into the scientific process over the years.
This is a fundamentally different model from the typical process. The traditional model can be thought of as a funnel for ideas and pearls in the class of swine. The DeSci model lets those pearls form where they may. It leverages all of the clams to make enough successful candidates happen in time to matter despite the failures that our current system produces. The scale and diversity that a more open system enables are stunning. Although the system is smaller and more focused than many large communities, rarely are they as open or inclusive about what matters to them or of interest to the field. Rather than trying to convince investors, they gather stakeholders and then engage them from the beginning in every research cost.
3.1. Definition and Principles
“Decentralized science,” or “DeSci,” refers to research that is democratized, transparent, open-source, community-driven, ethical in its composition and exploitation, and targets a broad inclusion of the population as researchers. The ultimate aim of DeSci is to mitigate issues of knowledge extraction and reduce exploitation in underserved fields by leveling the power differential found in traditional, often centralized, research paradigms. We employ the codesign approach to determine DeSci principles and best practices as defined by the DeSci working group, implementing participatory ranking to determine a final set of DeSci characteristics. To that end, we provide expanded operationalizations of each principle and explore one collaborative DeSci project that reflects the criteria established in this study.
Democratized Method
DeSci should continue to widen access to researcher roles across a variety of axes, including age, education, knowledge, access to resources and opportunities, and any other barriers that deny or impede access. Researchers are encouraged to have transparency around how community feedback (or the decision not to act on feedback) and the project are reported. The team should work to ensure it is reflective of the communities they are engaging with and work for the community rather than look at the community as a resource.
Transparent Method
A core principle in DeSci is ensuring research findings are made openly available, with options for access that are cost-free, shareable, and of the community. Researchers should put effort into ensuring that their methods are publicly available in the form of protocols. They are also recommended to keep the community informed about their research, with lay summary updates of standard lengths provided in newsletters, via social media, and/or through other appropriate outlets.
Get MetforminSol’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Open-source Method
DeSci research pursuits are collaborative and should encourage other researchers and community members to engage with and contribute to their work. The research team should encourage other researchers and community members. Community-driven Method: DeSci research is driven by community input, with the community having an equal and accurate understanding of the problem and more than a consultative role in the research process.
3.2. Examples of DeSci Initiatives
The Community-Led Open-Source Cancer Genome Biology Project is a project involving the development, nano-documentation and application of a massive in silico workflow to extend the reach of a previously published study. This community-led effort, which involves local groups in the choice of computational environment, has been shown to increase the number of potential cancer targets by 24%, more than doubling the output of the original grant study, with 29 groups from 11 countries and 4 decades of age participating. The emerging community-led, open-source HDR-seq pipeline is already being used by these groups.
Mothur is an open-source software package for bioinformatics data cleaning and analysis that can be used to run a very wide range of studies. While there are web service-based alternatives to Mothur, they are limited in the scale of the work they can perform. The Mothur project was initiated in 2009 and has grown to involve approximately 20 leading laboratory and computational scientists from around the world. As of July 2021, the website has accumulated over 6,000 registered users with up to 13,000 distinct site visits a week. The Mothur website has over 200 pages of tutorials, protocols, and other educational material to help computationally non-savvy scientists learn how to use Mothur and has had several million distinct hits. The key to Mothur’s enthusiastic uptake and impact on the field has been its accessibility to scientists who would have otherwise been limited by funding constraints. The Mothur website and software are built and sustained as an entirely volunteer-driven effort.
ASReml-R is a package that fits mixed models, very similar to its predecessor ASReml, while also having the added functionality of being able to fit large genetic models and genomic selection objectives. ASReml-R is built on the R programming environment, with the best from ASReml at its core, hence its name. A special license agreement is required to use ASReml, while ASReml-R is open-source software, licensed under the GNU General Public License, which also means that it can be used for teaching and by breeders with no licensing fees, as well as researchers. All consultations, time, and effort from the Biometrics team at DPIRD were provided without cost under the DeSci paradigm.
4. Funding Gaps in Underserved Fields
Consider underserved research fields. Subfields, technical planks, and other research components in these broader underserved fields are often propped up by funding from the fields at large. Narrow in further and the funding picture gets even murkier: laboratories are the primary sector of science that funds any sort of tool development or methodological research, which is why women of color and white women are so significantly overrepresented in the sector. They are the ones doing the data collection and analysis to contribute to this pan-field, pan-disciplinary research enterprise of academic journals. Without this broad field as a whole, it can be difficult to focus on the research detailing women of color and white women’s lived experiences in physics and the minoritizing attitudes that sometimes accompany ‘difference,’ or growth as physicists throughout the student lifecycle.
Research that is not in these traditionally valued fields frequently finds itself underfunded compared to research that is in the traditionally valued fields. An absurd amount of this valued research is completed solely by computer scientists and natural scientists, and yet many calls for proposals from engineering, sociology, women’s studies, or gender and physics will still get submissions! Research that is neither computing nor (bio, chem, phy) science — or research in computing that is not artificial intelligence, biologically inspired computation, or software — is far less likely to be science.
A significant percentage of funding goes to (bio, chem, phy) science. A significant percentage of newly funded projects go to (bio, chem, phy) science. This indicates a very small initial distribution to engineering, social science, and economics. This has nothing to do with grants: the stereotype threat publication was a grant-funded study, after all. Instead, this stands as an example of disparity in funding on the basis of research subfield. A specific percentage of funds were distributed to research projects explicitly focusing on a science discipline.
4.1. Identification of Funding Gaps
In order to advocate for additional funding in fields considered to be underfunded, we must first define where the funding gaps exist. Unfortunately, little collaboration exists between academia, industry, and governmental funding agencies owing to different ideas about what constitutes basic versus applied research, as well as underlying differences in the cross-disciplinary impact of research. Thus, to identify gaps in funding resulting from research that falls into the DeSci, we conducted a literature search across low-bibliometric publication output areas such as the arts and humanities. To provide signals that would indicate a lack of funding and promote reforms in these areas, a significant part of the analysis consisted of tracking federal funding amounts. In order to make our argument for funding based on potentially profitable research, this paper takes a quantitative perspective with a strong focus on funding awards.
While the papers explicitly focus on identifying subject areas that receive persistent funding gaps, the data also show that a history of persistently low funding trends for topics can be fairly estimated using data on individual institutes’ annual award levels. Rather than publishing attendance and non-attendance metrics, a similar attendance means scoring report includes variables such as research area awardee mean and score distributions. Interestingly, attendance patterns range between 6% and 85% across 228 disciplines when normalized between 0 and 1. Of the 20 lowest attendance disciplines, 12 of 20 are in the sciences, and together these 12 disciplines have published over 68,000 articles. In an example of underfunding of certain attended subjects, Computing Systems and Devices is supported by the CPU budget at the 10th percentile.
4.2. Consequences of Limited Support
An array of critical and systemic barriers combine to create limited funding for initial project development in many of these fields. When research programs are awarded insufficient financial resources, the project fails. Often detailed in paragraphs with euphemistic calls to “innovate” and “reframe our approach,” the descriptions of stalled research push ill-designed and unmodifiable planned agendas as grounds for new and innovative research to ensure recruitment into positivistic human biology. However, often little, if any, innovation actually occurs, and the “state-of-the-art methods” and “exploratory overview” are generic, underdeveloped if supported sufficiently as preliminary, canned research design teams’ goals, divorced from the objects of research.
While many may be sceptical or dismiss this as hubristic self-aggrandisement, many of the senior early and mid-career scholars (and their mentors, students, and emerging scholars) served by institutional policies and positions here receive little encouragement or understanding when they are denied developmental opportunities for intellectual and academic growth. Development, innovation and impact are thwarted at Faculty Senate meetings as staff work to rush through more than 630 tenure and promotion cases.
Unwitting violations of public health have covert ethno-nationalist and neoliberal consequences, and inter-agency and interdisciplinary collaboration in the social, biological and physical sciences is hampered in part by limited access to funding. For example, when only a small fraction of government funding goes to environmental social science research, some of us cannot play. Underfunding and limited support for such research, in addition to other systemic and exogenous constraints, has a number of negative and self-perpetuating consequences.
5. The Potential of DeSci in Addressing Funding Gaps
The demands of conducting research have never been greater, yet funding has not kept pace, especially in non-Western or computationally intensive fields. DeSci allows for research in fields without traditional funding streams to flourish by attracting alternate sources of funding. Because it is decentralized, those funding mechanisms could theoretically offer supplementary funds to support research.
While the flaws in traditional funding methods could very well be transferred to a DeSci model, the increased ability to fundraise through research-specific advocacy groups is a helpful leap outside of the traditional paradigm. It is also telling that DeSci projects are funded much faster than traditional research avenues; this implies that not only is funding decentralized, it is also on demand. For these and many other reasons, the work group is excited by the possibilities DeSci offers and endorses its proposed future use. DeSci provides a number of solutions to research funding disparities, particularly for researchers in underserved fields.
Decentralized funding programs are more flexible and catered to the needs of the researchers and potential funders. They are informed by the communities and peer groups as a way to support local projects and foster collaborations. This is especially important in fields where total possible funding is limited. Additionally, they allow communities and peer groups to reward researchers for a variety of contributions outside traditional steps in a scientific pathway. While the methods of collections and platform layouts through the technologies of crowdfunding change, there is certainly potential for platform designers to iterate on methods in ways that more effectively foster collaboration and targeted funding. Modern global social networks could also more easily facilitate outreach and connection to broad and diverse global research communities. Finally, there are success stories, such as those from the communities.
5.1. Advantages of Decentralized Funding Models
DeSci operates in a decentralized model, which has specific advantages for funding within the context of decentralized science. Decentralized models use open participation, are inclusive to diverse stakeholders, transparent, and function with minimal bureaucracy and managerial intervention. One of the key advantages of decentralized research funding mechanisms is that they reduce or eliminate financial or institutional barriers, making funding available to more than just the traditional researchers or grantees. In this way, greater diversity, equity, and inclusion are possible with decentralized models because of the ease of access to and participation in the knowledge-making process. Grassroots and collaborative approaches require an abundance of diverse insights and contributions. Decentralized mechanisms make collaborations between interdisciplinary groups easier, and decentralized technologies can coordinate networks of researchers and other stakeholders in ways that are accessible and transparent, providing additional benefits.
In a decentralized research model, the incentive can be in the learning and contributing that comes with network interactions rather than in the ownership of the intellectual property. This forces the researcher to constantly bring valuable insights and contributions to the network on an ongoing basis. Decentralized funding models can also adapt to urgently needed interdisciplinary cross-boundary science, which is difficult for centralized funders and sponsors bound by long-term policy. Researchers propose a project and are funded rapidly with little or no bureaucracy. As a result, project starts and finishes can be much faster than those of traditional research projects.
Funder involvement remains quite low, and early tailoring of the project is easy due to reduced start-up times. As the push to adopt distributed ledger technologies around the globe grows, it is likely that the values of decentralization will be increasingly embraced and mirrored in the implementation of research funding strategies.
5.2. Case Studies and Success Stories
Below are case studies and success stories from researchers involved in highly successful projects that provide empirical support for the effectiveness of decentralized funding models. These compelling stories and descriptions resonate with potential grantees and underscore the opportunities made possible by these processes. Success Stories The following are compelling descriptions from projects that were recommended through these processes. Notably, these projects have realized an outstanding impact in their fields and have demonstrated the enormous potential for decentralized funding in research areas that have been historically underserved. It is important to emphasize these narratives not just for the stories they tell but for their potential to motivate future grantees and to inspire great leaps in enhancement of and access to research.
Robotics in Construction The Robo Innovations in Construction project funds cultural programming and community outreach that serves to familiarize people with automatic construction equipment and the worldwide robotics applications related to it. By opening communication channels and engaging with communities of new end users, funded projects can develop entirely new or improved products and practices for a specific population. The accommodating industry need could involve innovative ways of furnishing this equipment to that population.
6. Conclusion
Research has shown consistently that traditional funding models have accentuated funding disparities, dramatically affecting research in underserved fields. Meanwhile, the centralized funding model has created a risk-averse scientific culture, with negative effects on innovation and research quality. Scholarship also shows DeSci as guaranteeing more equitable access to resources, diversifying what research gets funded, and more fairly distributing the level of resources that are accessed across the funded body. The challenges faced by underserved fields in attracting traditional support, as well as the potential solutions in a DeSci system, are equally multi-faceted, though there are promising therapeutic opportunities to be exploited.
Associates from racialized groups and women are underrepresented groups in precision health research. Such differential representation and subsequent inequities in the genomic, health data, and research models being produced relative to these groups favor the development of products and services optimised for individuals of European descent as opposed to all Canadians. Exacerbating these harms is that this unjust differential representation, particularly that of women, occurs across the research spectrum and in conjunction with the crises of insufficient funding support facing precision health and growing competition from other fields of research for the funding support that is available under the existing funding models. The two-tier federal funding era that Canadian researchers are entering is likely to exacerbate these inequities further. While a DeSci pilot initiative has been primarily concerned with enhancing funding support available to investigators in computer science transcending disciplinary boundaries, particularly junior investigators, ongoing iterations of this platform offer an excellent opportunity to rigorously study the effectiveness of DeSci initiatives for addressing these pressing funding issues and injustices.
One recommended area for future exploration is the measurement of the impact of a DeSci-like open call — specifically examining the volume, quality, and diversity of applications submitted — against a more traditional call for proposals. Finally, we note that none of the aforementioned suggested systemic changes to research funding practices can take place without collaboration among key stakeholders communicating and advancing policy, including funding agencies, not-for-profit organizations, and industry. We invite stakeholders interested in pursuing these conversations to reach out.
6.1. Recommendations for Future Research
Strategies for conducting high-quality research, open to all, that have yet to be reached and run in underserved areas of thinking or doing may need a fresh start. We propose a few such ideas worthy of further investigation. Though the potential of DeSci as a model for executing research is well covered, the pursuit of these and the accompanying impact upon funding have not yet been subject to widespread attention. Future research could dismantle these independent diligence activities or could explore the art of directly pursuing these ideas. Research funders worldwide could provide seed money to test innovative funding models specifically for underserved initiatives.
We argue that within the findings of that action research, a focus on more equitable conditions for the R&D community would be a priority. Priority topics involving novel funding models include Diversified funding mechanisms, which can multiply resources and facilitate the experimentation of research approaches, skills, and methodologies. Some research funds could be further accompanied by connectivity, networking, and mentorship grants. Mandating community-based and experiment-induction approaches, combining researcher-driven calls and initiatives, and community-driven reviews from stakeholders. Building stakeholder capacity by training activities and involvement throughout the design and decision-making processes. Liaison between research grants and topic-targeted research funds that seek outcomes from the pilot-funded programs.
Impose transparency, accountability, and responsibility for monitoring and evaluation. To undergo and streamline new approaches, funding agencies might form multi-funder partnerships. Encourage collaborative funding mechanisms to support proposals consisting of an entire group of collaborating and potentially interdisciplinary teams. Investment in a model and conduct to collect case studies and champions showcasing the success of initiatives, but also valuable information about stumbling blocks and setbacks. Encourage and seek out evaluations from ‘more than one perspective,’ including the exploration of ‘the sustainability and required adoption of shared resources and activities.’ Make use of lessons from the social sciences to document and innovate complex scenarios that are engaging and incorporate innovation with the interdisciplinary expertise in research and social science framework, including involvement studies of how different funding mechanisms are utilized and internalized by the community.








