Step 2
One common theme I have observed in Western media (think BBC, New York times, Economist, etc.) and in Western discourse (university lecture halls, libraries, and campuses) is the deep discomfort and insecurity that exists around the growth of India as an economy, the resurgence of India’s pride about its past, and the strengthening of the Hindu identity.
There seems to be discomfort about a Hindu leader (India’s Primer Minister, Narendra Modi) speaking with pride about being Hindu. Why is this perceived as “hurting the sentiments of minorities?” This was especially pronounced in the “Indian social elite” that I had the pleasure to observe in graduate school in the US. This post aims to unpack what’s going on…
Why isn’t there the same uneasiness when American politicians, both Republican and Democrat, speak with pride about being Christian? Why doesn’t the media take issue with the leading German political party (Angela Merkel’s party) of the modern-era being the “Christian Democratic Union” (same for most other European nations)? Why isn’t their uneasiness about all the Islamic theocracies across the middle east persecuting “kafirs” for not following Islam (or, for that matter, not having sense of respect for women… how messed up must a belief-system be to view women as property)? Why isn’t their uneasiness about the fact that the British parliament is presided over by Anglican priests? Seems like “Separation of Church and State” only applies when the Church, or Mosque, please. At some point double standards need to be called out.
It has become so ingrained in Hindu people to avoid standing up for Hindu identity. At the same time Western Media internalizes the view that the world is governed by Abrahamic religions and institutions and that any person or institution that refuses to abide by that world-lens is an enemy.
So, what drives the uneasiness? Let’s unpack it.
India went through a grotesque 400-year period of attacks from the Arab states and European colonial domination, all with the goal of wiping out these followers of Dharma, and any symbol that these people had existed. This will be a blip in the region’s many-thousand year old history, but it still has a lasting impact on the society of today.
Thousands of sites are being discovered across North India with temple ruins, many of which now have mosques on top of them. When the Mughals came to India, they destroyed any ancient temple they could see and sought to replace it with a mosque. Even the birthplaces of key Hindu figures like Rama and Krishna were destroyed and replaced with mosques. Can you imagine the reaction if Mecca was covered with churches? The last time Pakistan had a non-Muslim Minister of the Minorities, that person was assassinated.
Get Satya Kiraha’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
When Aurangzeb knocked down a temple in Mathura commemorating Krishna, he made a point to smash all the idols into pieces and put them under the stairs of a mosque. Why? So that people would figuratively and literally walk all over them. That is where Hindu people are coming from, and that is symbolic of the journey that the Hindu psyche has been on.
When the Mughals came, they also sought to rename every city with an Islamic reference. That’s how deep efforts went towards wiping out the existing civilization. Allahbad. Moradabad. Aligarh. Faridabad. These are recent names for ancient cities. Can you imagine the impact that has on a people’s identity and psyche?!
There was an ancient university called Nalanda that attracted tens of thousands of students from the far East to the far West, hosting 2,000+ teachers at any given time. It’s libraries stored over 9 Million manuscripts and books. There’s no library that exists today that has such a repository. When Turkish Mughals came in c.1,100AD to the university, what did they decide to do? They burned it, of course. In their own accounts of these attacks (they actually documented some of their conquests quite well), the libraries of Nalanda burnt for 3 months. 3 MONTHS?! That’s how vast the stores of knowledge were.
The modus operandi of the Mughals was: “Convert, give us your women, or die. And if you leave, then leave your women behind.” Very well established, even in recent history when the Hindu Kashmiri Pandits were cleansed from Kashmir under this same pretense. It’s shocking to think that this happened only in the 1990s. That said, media coverage of this was hopeless, to the extent that many Indians themselves aren’t even aware of what really took place. The media for a long time has sought to avoid the atrocities convicted against people of ancient cultures. We’ll see plenty of reports of Islamaphobia, while Islamic theocracies wreak violent havoc.
Now what’s intriguing is that through Colonial rule, governing Indian institutions were replaced by the British, to serve the British (incumbents having been destroyed). Schools, universities, laws, were all re-established on the pretense that Christian, European people were superior. That’s what allowed them to govern. How else could you get a vast population to abide by the rule of a small, extractive minority? Your Indian friends can tell you about how “convent schools” were considered the best.
The curriculum in these institutions eliminated any discussion of India’s past, refused to acknowledge the rich history of vedic dharma or the atrocities committed by the Mughals, and of course the extractive colonialism of the British. So-much-so that, by constitution, it is illegal to teach anything about Hinduism in Indian schools. Only Hinduism though. Not Christianity, Islam, or anything else. To progress in society, it helped to study and work at these institutions, so naturally the more educated strata of society were those who feasted on fabricated narratives, leaving a deep sense of insecurity about their Dharmic origins. They were fed lies that the Mughals were kind leaders who shaped society, and that became the prevailing narrative. Anything to the contrary was considered insensitive and to be avoided.
Other narratives were also fabricated: for example, caste. The European modus operandi in colonies was to create castes and use a senior caste to govern, manage the population, and facilitate theft of resources while utilizing a subordinate caste. From the Hutu’s and Tutsi’s of Rwanda to India. Even the word caste comes from the Portuguese word “Casto”. In no ancient culture was there the belief that some humans are inferior to others. That’s a purely European way of thinking (the land of Lord’s and royal bloodlines). The narrative of India being the home of caste was also fed to the Indian population, particularly the Convent-educated elites, and became the prevailing view that was particularly propagated by Western media. It skewed how Hindu people view themselves
After so many layers of abuse and misinformation, followers of Dharma have forgotten what it means to be proud, confident, and stand-up for themselves. However, dharma has persisted and the country now has leaders insistent on restoring Hindu pride and identity. This is uncomfortable, almost like a case of Stockholm Syndrome where someone has become so used to belittling and abuse that anything to the contrary seems wrong. Of course, coupled with a healthy dose of misinformation.
But alas, times are a changing! Dharma rakshite rakshitah. Dharma protects those who defend it. Given the way the wind is blowing, there’s more discomfort to come!






