Competition Entry
Dear Stephanie,
Thank you for taking the time to read my short story ‘He Who Dares’. I am a dedicated reader of your magazine and of the Crime/Thriller showcase specifically. This will, in fact, be my third submission to the Crime/Thriller competition, and I hope that it will meet with greater success than my previous efforts.
The style and structure I have chosen is, I hope you’ll agree, an original take on the true crime genre. I’m sure you will recogise some of the names and events described, yet remain entertained by the narrative I have chosen to bring to them. With such things, of course, it is necessary to retain a delicacy of touch and sensitivity, so I have left out some of the more disturbing details of what actually happened without sacrificing some of the more nuanced aspects of the story. I hope also that it provides an exciting new angle on the unfortunate deaths of both James Swift and Fran McTavish.
Submission: He Who Dares
I arrived late to Fran McTavish’s funeral on purpose. Like many there, I only knew her in passing, as a fellow crime writer, and the thought of having to go through the rigmarole of saying who I was and why I was attending seemed undignified. It was just as the readings started that a young lady sat down next to me, likewise late, and smiled sympathetically.
In fact, I had only ever met Fran in person once, but there was something in her warm personality that reminded me of my mother. Unlike my mother she wasn’t particularly encouraging when it came to my writing. This was deeply unpleasant to me, as my mother had always supported me in my literary ambitions, and it was with the inheritance I recieved on her death that I had the opportunity to start taking writing a lot more seriously.
Two years ago, after my mothers affairs were wrapped up and I was in receipt of her estate, I suddenly had the means to engage with writing on a more determined basis. It was at this time that I became aware of James Swift’s much lauded Fiction Master Classes.
I should confess that these classes were not as I expected them. James was not, as I recall, a particularly organized teacher, and one felt that he had a rather mercanary approach to writing.
“There’s no money in writing,” he said, “Unless you are prepared to sacrifice your ego.”
He gave us plenty of exercises, held many writing discussions, and close-readings, and he would insist on us copying out vast sections of books and applying our own narratives to the texts. I found this more than a little disingenious.
During this time, I would write nothing more than glorified fairytales. These had always entertained my mother but seemed not to be quite what James had in mind for a serious writer. He said that though my stories were ‘quirky’ and ‘oddly delightful’, I would stand more of a chance of being taken seriously if my narratives were to ‘grow up a bit.’
At the end of our course, he invited us to all submit to a short crime fiction competition he would be judging. He cautioned us about assuming that we would be in with a better chance as his students, but that this particular competition would be good as it always offered feedback.
I set to work on a short story about a medieval intrigue, combining the tenets of crime fiction and my love of the romance. I honed and redrafted this piece, right up until the day of the deadline, and submitted it with my heart in my throat.
Get Shorn’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
As with many such competitions, I had to wait rather a while for the results to come out. To my dismay, I looked up and down the shortlist and couldn’t see my name anywhere. As promised, though, my submission did come back with some comments.
He said that my piece was ‘delightful’ and ‘quirky’ but did not yet show the authority of a great historical writer, but that I should keep plugging away nonetheless. He added, moreover, that I should concentrate on a subject I knew well.
Though I was downhearted at first, I realised soon that he was right. I hadn’t really the faintest idea about the middle ages, though I may enjoy historical literature. A period of deep reflection followed, and I wrote voraciously.
Sadly, I was never able to submit any of this work to him. In the autumn of that year, he died.
I decided, that if I were to be published, I would dedicate my first novel or collection to him, and the advice that I should ‘keep plugging away.’ By the middle of last year, I had built up a collection of short thrillers that I felt ready to submit. By chance, I saw that the same competition that James had judged was up again, this time to be judged by Fran McTavish.
I had a particularly gruesome thriller ready for her, and after ensuring it fitted in with the competition guidelines, I sent it in.
As before, I waited for the response. During this time I continued to write, mostly little autobiographies, or vignettes to pass the time. I knew that my style was improving, and at times I regretted submitting my horrible little thriller. Indeed, when the results came through, my name was absent from the shortlist, yet again.
Fran sent me an email, which, I confess, rather surprised me. The tone of it was very warm and gentle, saying I clearly had a ‘storm of emotions’ raging within me, but that perhaps this wasn’t suited to a nuanced crime thriller. She said that a good writer knows themselves first and the world second, and that, rather than ‘sub-let the subconscious to grim-faced demons’ that I should ‘seek some counselling.’ It really was quite a touching message, but did not really address any opportunity for me to improve as a writer.
For months afterwards, I was at pains to reconcile my efforts at autobiography and the crime fiction genre. I was tired of writing, tired of being knocked back, and somewhat put out at the suggestion that my writing was ‘unhinged’. I allowed a period of lethargy to wash over me. My pens lay drying out on my desk, papers yellowing in the sun.
I was engaged in a moment of such idleness when I found Fran’s obituary in the paper. I must confess I was rather excited at the opportunity to attend her funeral, meet fellow writers, and perhaps find some inspiration from the afternoon.
When the young lady approached me and asked how I knew Fran, I explained that I hadn’t ever met her, but she had offered me some kind and helpful words in the past. It turned out that the young lady had similar praise for Fran, that she too had known hardship as a fledgling writer, and it was with Fran’s help that she had overcome some of her foibles when writing. She was herself now a published author and said she looked forward to seeing some of my work in the future.
This conversation, as it turned out was just the thing I needed to get writing again. I took up my pens and paper and wrote frantically. I let it come forth in a flow, re-editing and redrafting when the action became too ‘overt’, expertly calming the ‘storm of emotions’ to produce something more ‘nuanced’.
When the time came, I was surprised and delighted to see the young lady I had met named as judge for the competition that both Fran and James had chaired before. I wrote a carefully worded submission letter to her and began a story which I hope she will enjoy and judge fairly.
Originally published at https://jphartshorn.wordpress.com on November 5, 2019.




