Weekly Reflection #3
on the Pamplin College of Business’s MGT 1104 Alumni Roundtable
Last week, I had the opportunity to attend an alumni roundtable held by the Pamplin College of Business, as part of my Foundations of Business class. During the roundtable, recent Pamplin graduates fielded questions from students on the topic “success in business”. Listening to the roundtable brought up an interesting question, surely one that was intended to be mused over when the roundtable was assigned: what does it truly mean to be “successful” in business? On one hand, success in business can be defined numerically — who makes the most money the fastest — but, on the other hand, success in business can be defined by the achievement of a mission, the reaching of a goal, or the fulfillment of a cause. Which conclusion is correct? I believe, in different situations, that both methods of measuring success in business are correct, and yet both are wrong.
Get Troy Clark’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
If we define a business’s success merely through its quantifiable data, then we miss out on some of the important aspects of the business, such as its service to its community. Without these other actions taken by a business, the corporation becomes a faceless behemoth built only to collect money. Perhaps it will lose favor in the eyes of the consumer, and gain favor in the eyes of the stockholder. Perhaps neither will be true — we can only hope that stockholders care about more than just profits and revenue. However, the quantifiable goals of a business are very important as a success metric, when taken with other metrics. After all, if you help the community and do good in the world, yet make little revenue, those world-changing activities will not be sustainable for very long.
Success of a business cannot be defined solely through its community building either. Some businesses exist solely for charitable work and non-profit operation, so such community building would take favor in measuring the success of such a venture. For the vast majority of businesses, however, corporate social responsibility cannot be the sole reason the business exists. A business may exist to further a mission, like Facebook’s mission to “make the world more open and connected”. For Facebook and many other companies, their product is simply a means to an end: the achievement of their mission. These types of companies could do literally anything in pursuit of their mission. For them, profit is a lesser measure of success.
In conclusion, the measurement of a business’s success can be defined many different ways, none of which are entirely wrong or right. It takes a careful eye to determine what might be right for your business, and what might not be right. Reflecting on what values are important to you personally as well as what values are important to the entire organization are important steps in determining success metrics that will make you, the community, and the bottom line all feel great.
Weekly reflections are part of the Virginia Tech Honors College First-Year Seminar curriculum. Each week, one or more articles are presented for reading and reflection. The weekly reflection can be guided by these articles, but is generally an unrestricted writing exercise bounded only by an upper limit of 500 words. These reflections are presented on Medium exactly as they were written and submitted each week.





