A Dangerous Game of Semantics
Recently my news feed has been inundated with articles about Brittany Maynard who is choosing to die on her own terms. Plagued with a malignant tumor, she has only 6 months to live and is choosing to end her own life before the tumor kills her.
My friends have been in awe of her sacrifice, wondering why right to die laws aren’t in every state. Why can’t there be death with dignity for all? Isn’t that a basic human right?
Death with Dignity.
Get Emily Gulbransen’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
It sounds so empowering; someone is choosing his or her own destiny. They are choosing when and how they want to die. They are cheating death by dying before their sentence is up.
As a volunteer crisis counselor that works with people who also want to end their life on their own terms, the death with dignity movement is troubling. How could one person’s suicide be labeled death with dignity, while another’s is looked down upon and even mocked?
Groups like Compassion and Choices are taking the act of suicide and dressing it up with flowery language, claiming it’s honorable for people to make the decision to kill themselves as long as they are terminally ill or suffering from a painful disease. Suicide however, does not come with caveats. People who are not terminally ill, but are struggling with suicidal thoughts are in pain. They feel alone in a world surrounded by people. Their struggle might seem different, but it is just as painful and lonely as someone facing a terminal illness.
Making suicide out to be “compassionate” and “honorable” is dangerous. It further validates and encourages those with suicidal ideation to kill themselves instead of seeking the mental healthcare that could save their life. It builds on their fear that they have become a burden to their family and friends, and the only “honorable” way out is to sacrifice their life to save their family from a burden that is only perceived in their head. Allowing terminally ill patients to make the decision to die, directly contradicts the efforts of the suicide prevention movement, which has been advocating tirelessly that proper mental healthcare and a community that cares can save someone from dying at their own hand. Physician-assisted suicides put the community at odds with saving someone’s life.
Suicide is complicated. There are a myriad of factors that culminate in someone deciding to die prematurely and the same goes for terminally ill patients that choose to die before their natural death. Most right to die laws do not require the patient to first seek a mental health professional prior to ending their life. Even though, these individuals are fighting a terminal illness, choosing to die is at odds with human nature. The decision to end one’s life regardless of what the person is struggling with externally often develops from instability in their mental health. Instead of encouraging them to end their life, we should be helping them receive the proper mental healthcare they need, so they have the courage to keep fighting their external illness and their internal battles.
The right to die movement’s attempt to re-brand suicide puts lives at risk by playing a dangerous game of semantics. Suicide whether physician-assisted or at one’s own hand is preventable and should not be glorified. By remaining vigilant and recognizing the signs of someone struggling with suicidal thoughts regardless of their external struggles, our community can break down the stigma associated with seeking mental healthcare. We can make sure those struggling receive the proper care they need to persevere and to shed light on their story and purpose that hasn’t reached its ending yet.






