An Unpleasant But Wonderful Reminder
This week, the team was reminded of why we are so passionate about Shout after a user attempted to purchase something on Craigslist to then sell on Shout. Before I begin, it is important for me to emphasize that I think Craigslist is incredible. It provides people with an unmatched level of freedom and has paved the way for many. But it needs to die.
On Shout, if someone wants something that currently is not for sale, they can make a request. We love when these requests are fulfilled. It is magical; someone makes a wish with their phone and it comes true. Yesterday, someone made a request for a ticket to a local lobster event. Another user attempted to buy it on Craigslist and then sell it on Shout—a potentially clever switch. It did not go well and everything we are trying to achieve and why it is important we succeed crystalized in a single exchange. When we reached out, the user sent us the interaction.
I have included it below.
On the surface, it is a relatively unpleasant interaction but one in which both parties were able to get what they wanted. But to the team, it was indicative of so much more. While reading through the exchange we asked ourselves several important questions that a buyer might ask.
Should I need to give a stranger my personal information?
How will payment be made?
Have others interacted with this seller before?
How do I know if they are going to show up?
If they do, will they end up in a re-enactment of Silence of the Lambs?
If they survive will they be able to warn others?
Get Shout’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Yet, it wouldn’t be fair simply to look at this situation from the buyer’s perspective. Imagine it from the seller’s perspective. A stranger emails and asks to purchase a ticket. The seller probably had similar concerns to those of the buyer; first and foremost, he might ask, “What if I send the buyer the ticket and they do not pay?”
It all comes down to trust, accountability, and providing all the necessary tools for the entire transaction. As counterintuitive as this might sound, we want to remove the question of whether or not you should trust a stranger…so that you are able to trust a stranger.
Compare the pleasant exchange below that our buyer from above had while selling on Shout. While selling the ticket on Shout, our users did not have to ask themselves the questions that tinged the Craigslist interaction. As a result, on Shout, an incredibly friendly conversation ensued:
Pretty nice huh? Now is everyone on Craigslist an ass, no. Is everyone on Shout as nice as this guy, it’s pretty close ☺. Why is that? I think it is because there is trust, accountability, and the process was defined.
- They never had to share their personal information.
2. They communicated via the real-time chat (soon to have VOIP so users can call one another without giving their phone number).
3. The buyer paid through the app.
4. We held his payment in escrow for 24 hours until after the Shout expired. This gave the purchaser the confidence to pay knowing there could be a refund, if needed; he had recourse. It gave the seller the confidence that payment would be made as long as the ticket was delivered.
5. Lastly, after the exchange, they were able to tell the Shout community about the exchange. And everyone with whom they interact in the future will be better off as a result.
Sadly, the interaction did not end there and last image put a pit in the team’s stomach.
Why are we sharing this?
The questions the team asked are important to any interpersonal interaction. At Shout, we think answering these questions can unlock a secondary economy and create a community more powerful and creative than we even fathom. We are committed to providing our users a level of anonymity so they can explore and voice their true desires. We balance this with features that provide trust: identity checks, payment processing, escrow accounts, and user-ratings. We are striving to create an environment that does not restrict an individual but one that provides the tools for vibrant and unfettered exploration.
Today was an unpleasant but wonderful reminder that we want what we are building. It is our hope that you do too.









