There are many people who have a natural revulsion to the idea of privilege. Hell, to the very word privilege. If you’re one of those people, try to avoid that and come into this with an open mind. You’ll find that actually, you agree that it exists. Likely, you just find it unpalatable to be shown your own examples of it. Attractive people are treated better. Taller men have an easier time with women. People in power get away with more things even if they wouldn’t were everyone held to the same standard. You would be hard pressed to find people who think those things aren’t true. You may not use the word privilege to describe those things but that’s essentially what they are.
Privilege is any unearned advantage, typically given for inherent, immutable characteristics. At least that’s how I define it but I think that generally aligns with most people’s definitions. This can manifest itself in different ways but I believe it mostly shows up as “benefit of the doubt” or the lack thereof. How about some examples to help clarify what I mean.
Scenario 1
Imagine an employer with two employees. One employee is black and the other is white. They both have the same job within your business which is to make sure the store is kept well maintained and all the merchandise is in the correct place. One day one of the employees is found leaving with some items in his pocket. He claims it was an accident, that he’d put it there because a customer had left it in the wrong place and had just forgotten to put it back in the right place. The employer now has a choice. Does he believe his employee and give him another chance or does he assume his employee is lying and let him go? Neither choice is right or wrong. Privilege here would be giving one employee the benefit of the doubt but not the other.
Scenario 2
Change it up a bit. Say the employee actually did something wrong. But he pleads and begs and says he needs this job. He was desperate, he’ll never do it again. Any employer would be well within his rights to terminate at this point and no one would blame him in the slightest. But he doesn’t have to. He could forgive and move on. Sometimes they do. Care to take a guess as to who usually gets that benefit of the doubt?
Blacks are less than half as likely to receive consideration by employers, relative to their white counterparts, and black nonoffenders fall behind even whites with prior felony convictions.
Scenario 3
Let’s use one we can all relate to. There’s a lot of speeding drivers out there. Despite conventional wisdom, the speed limit is the speed limit. There’s no 5mph buffer. Take a look at a policeman’s citation sheet. They can definitely mark you for going 1–5mph over the limit. I can tell you that my experience from driving in Michigan, people are regularly going 80+ on those 70mph highways. So who gets pulled over when the police decide to pull someone over that day? Surprise, surprise. It’s true that in those circumstances someone was speeding. And it’s true that the police are well within their rights to ticket someone for breaking traffic laws. But justice unequally applied is no justice at all.
Fixing it?
The trickiest thing about this is that most of it isn’t done at the conscious level. I don’t believe that employers and policemen and judges and lawyers are conspiring together or alone to find ways to treat different groups of people unfairly. They, we, just aren’t giving people the benefit of the doubt.
Get Ad Astra’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Look back to scenario three. You couldn’t necessarily accuse the cop who pulls over the black driver for speeding for any wrongdoing as the driver was actually speeding. But if you had enough data and saw that despite black and white drivers speeding at the same rates, black drivers were pulled over disproportionately more that would clearly be an issue. The police may not even be aware they’re doing it. Maybe stereotypes of black people being connected with drugs and criminal behavior have them more keyed in on noticing black drivers who are speeding.
For me this is the biggest hurdle for tackling privilege and trying to enforce equal standards and equal justice for all. People are going to wholeheartedly resist the fact that they are being told they hold prejudices. Most people today would agree that being racist, sexist, is a bad thing. They don’t call people niggers or slap women around so they think “I’m not racist” and “I’m not sexist.” On a conscious level I believe them. I think they believe they’re treating people fairly. But when we look at the statistical evidence that clearly isn’t true. As I said in a previous post no one can blame you for subconscious prejudices, you’re not choosing them. But we can never move forward as a society until people admit that those prejudices exist.









