Sitemap
3 min readOct 9, 2014

--

Look to other countries for lessons learned to Counter Violent Extremism

Let’s Talk about Violent Extremism in America and open the door to learning what other countries are doing to combat the treat

Violent extremism is a problem in our country and across the world. In particular we have seen instances where people, U.S. citizens and naturalized citizens have become radicalized and have sought to harm others during an attack. We need to do a better job of countering, deterring, preventing violent extremism. Individuals seek out radicalization messages and resources for whatever their belief is- religious, political, personal, economic, etc. Due to these varied reasons for becoming a violent extremist in America, there is no ‘one size fits all’ approach to combating the threat in America. It seems at though up to now, the U.S. government (namely, the FBI), have used agent provocateur and informant approaches to capturing would-be extremists. Those individuals who have radicalized or been recruited into a local violent extremist group continue to slip through the cracks, as in the Boston Marathon 2013 bombers.

Get AF Bonanno’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

There is no ‘one approach’ to the current problem and I am not necessarily advocating for one here. But we need to deter, stop, or combat domestic violent extremism. It seems as though we aren’t doing enough in the media realm or at the community level to try and stop violent extremism and radicalization. The Department of State harnesses twitter to respond on social media to help counter terrorist groups and individuals. The FBI uses sting operations and waits for informants to snitch on a would-be terrorist or bomber. The current methods the FBI uses of either baiting a potential terrorist attacker or of using an informant to tip the FBI off to individuals’ plans are what is most effective in deterring violent extremism now. There is not one, whole approach to countering violent in extremism in America yet. We can more effectively work within communities to stop people from radicalizing and conducting violent harm on others. Current methods to counter violent extremism are not systematic, or wholesome; they are disjointed, inconsistent, and focused on political correctness.

By researching several options and by looking at what other countries are doing to counter violent extremism, we should be able to help deter violent extremists; we can come up with new potential solutions and ideas. The possibility exists to create an effective program to stop, deter, counter extremists. We could influence extremists by nudging them in a certain direction or manipulating them to do or act a different way. We could pay former extremists money to stop their planning, recruiting, or conducting a potential attack. We could threaten to punish violent extremists or deny them something. We could reconcile with extremists. We could look at programs to educate or train extremists to do something new or different with their life. There are potentially more options to review to help counter or deter violent extremists in America. By reviewing the options and lessons learned from what other countries are doing, we could come up with a new set of policies to create an effective counter violent extremism approach in America.

These approaches aren’t being used or, in the case of the threat of punishment (perhaps), aren’t being utilized well as endeavors to help deter violent extremism in America. The problem may lie in the fact that we do not have one overarching countering violent extremism strategy for the US. By reviewing the lessons learned from other countries, perhaps we could glean new approaches from them for the US. By creating new options and policies, we will be forced to turn to a new direction, to one that has the potential to work.

It opens America up to better, fresh, new ideas since we are still seeing a rise in radicalism and the increase in individuals interested in jihadi, radical Islamist beliefs and its terrorist ideals. We need to act now, we need to do better, we need to help combat our never-ending threats. Sooner rather than later.

--

--

AF Bonanno
AF Bonanno

Written by AF Bonanno

New Yorker, Army Guardsman, Homeland Security professional, living abroad, loving life