Sitemap

Amplifying Voices

13 min readSep 3, 2016

--

This piece was first written in 2014, and though time has brought some change, much remains the same. I offer it up as a glimpse into the past as well as a continued hope for the future.

Collecting Autographs

I’ve collected a lot of autographs over the past four years. The reactions I’ve gotten, as I hold out my Sharpie, have ranged from shock to blasé acceptance, as though this is something that happens every day… Well, really, I’m pretty sure it doesn’t.

I do sketchnotes of conference talks, mainly ones in the tech industry, and while I’ve documented the insights and ramblings of some of the luminaries of our era, they’re still not exactly rock stars. Getting asked for an autograph is an outlier for all of them, no matter how many VC rounds their company has closed, or how many startups their accelerator has birthed. Yes, they’re up there on the big stage, & yes, the faces attending to their every word are usually rapt & adoring, regardless of how haphazard their presentation or stilted their speaking skills. But these aren’t frothing fans who rush the stage just to touch the hand of a god. If the attendees ask for autographs, they mean a John Hancock & are holding out a check.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

I’ve learned never to approach the stage directly. The main approach is cordoned off by glaring attendees, bent on getting their pitch into an open ear. Walking along that line I get the up-down assessment — a woman, in heels, wearing earrings, head shaved, carrying a sketchbook… a woman, in boots, wearing jeans, green spiked hair, carrying a sketchbook… a woman, in slacks, wearing a button down and tie, short brown hair, carrying a sketchbook… what the hell?

At a tech event, I’m a platypus, and the other attendees are biologists discovering a new unquantifiable creature. I am and am not something they’ve seen before, and what’s more, I’m cutting right past them in line as though I belong there.

Have I mentioned that 99% of the bodies in this line I speak of are male?

Up at the front, holding court, the speaker is usually male too… 99% of the time anyway.

Holding out my sketchbook & sharpie does catch attention. I don’t wait to be given my turn, but I also don’t interrupt. I just jump in when there’s a pause, before the next person can launch in. Sketchbook out, no badge in sight, nothing for the speaker to look at but what’s on the page. To me, it doesn’t really look like much at this point — penciled in roughly, awaiting ink&color, a map of words and images — but I always get my autograph. I hold out my sharpie, they sign, and usually just turn away.

What I always hope to get just a moment to explain, but I’ve cut the line for that autograph, and really there is no reason for this person, whose words I’ve just mapped to paper, to care that what I really do is UX. But I still want to explain.

I want to explain that sketchnoting is UX in another form. It is wire-framing and mind-mapping and storyboarding and card-sorting, all together. It is the visual documentation of the information architecture of a product that just happens to be a talk. My work modifies the user’s experience of a speaker’s presentation and of the conference as a whole. One page, providing a path through complex ideas, making thoughts sticky with humor and metaphor, all visible at a glance. Sketchnotes can transport you back to a talk far better than any slide deck can. They are feature rationalization embodied.

But I don’t get to say that too often.

The Connundrum

Doing sketchnotes is a job. I’m hired to document whatever the organizer considers to be the most important content at a conference, to create something that can be shared along through social media, that can convince folks to sit down and watch a video after the event is long over. I’m limited by who’s already been selected to speak, so in the end, I amplify the voices of those already privileged with amplification: men.

What does this do to the women vying a for space on the stage? Women who are already invisible in the tech scene, who are in the greatest need of a curated spotlight just to get their work noticed? What does this say to those working their way up through the ranks? The process of selecting speakers is always based in part on where they’ve spoken before. Big stages are reserved for seasoned speakers or names that will have “draw.” Names that have enough twitter followers. Names that have a company backing them. Names that have been handed up through the ranks of trusted connections.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

If there are no connections to hand your name along, you never get that first speaking opportunity. You never have a chance to step up on that first stage because there’s always someone else who’s a safer bet. I’ve asked men in the tech community repeatedly to take a look at their twitter lists. Do they follow any women in their industry? Can they name any? It’s not definitive, but it’s telling that the ones I have reason to ask come up empty. The women they’re listening to will be friends from school or that celebrity who says “funny stuff,” not peers.

How then would they know, when a call for speakers comes out, which woman would be appropriate for nomination?

Gauntlet Thrown

I’ve spoken to a number of event organizers about the “ocean of white men” conference lineup — it’s gotten better over the last few years, but it’s still not great. I’ve asked what challenges they’re facing in finding the right people. Not just for conferences either, but for hackathon judging panels, for mentors at accelerators, all of whom have the same problem: diversity.

The conference organizers plead that it’s just too difficult to find qualified speakers while attempting to run a solid event. Thankfully, the claim has shifted somewhat in the last few years. When I first started sketchnoting & simultaneously rattling some chains, I heard too often that women just don’t want to speak. Wait. What? Women don’t want the opportunity to give their opinion? Isn’t the usual stereotype that women won’t shut up about what they think?

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Not so much that, it was explained to me, but experienced women are just too busy with their families, have different values than men do when it comes to their careers, and allocate their time such that the duties of a conference speaker just don’t fit.

The same argument was used to explain why women’s attendance at conferences was so low.

Luckily, that argument has been blown out of the water.

But it’s been replaced with one equally unfounded. Now, it’s just that women, even those with sufficient expertise & career clout [not going to touch the promotion/hiring issue here thank you] lack the speaking experience needed to take the main stage.

Have you ever seen a bad presentation given by a man up on the big stage? I have. I’ve seen innumerable ‘qualified’ men falter through boring talks with about as much stagecraft as a corpse.

Since arguments of perceived barriers go nowhere, my approach now is to offer up names. To have a list of them handy in fact. You can’t find a woman to speak on mobile design? Here are six whom I’ve already contacted, have submitted these topics, and who confirm that they have availability on the dates you provided. You don’t know of any C-level women in post-seed round startups to judge your hackathon? Here are five who are local & willing to cancel their weekend plans to be there not only to judge, but to do a keynote talk to kick off your event.

If you try to tell me there are no women qualified to speak on a subject I will tell you to kindly remove you head from your ass. It’s not healthy & you’re liable to suffer further brain damage due to continued suffocation.

Speaker Duties

Diversity is not just the responsibility of the organizers. Speakers have an equal obligation to the events they are involved in. Sure, just as I have bowed to the almighty dollar of the paid gig, not everyone can dismiss an opportunity without consequence. But they can speak up… after all, they’re being given a stage to speak from.

If you’re asked to speak, just as you might request that your travel expenses be paid, just as you’d ensure that you’ll have the right dongle for your laptop, you can make certain that the conference itself follows some rules.

I’d assume that any man would refuse to speak at a conference, no matter how beneficial to his career, if he was asked to present his talk while immersed in a tank of shark filled water, pantsless. I’ve suggested that men refuse to speak if the conference in question lacks a Code of Conduct or if organizers fail to show effort toward bringing a 50/50 split of men & women onto the stage. Notice I say ‘effort’ because in this case, there is a ‘try,’ one that shockingly does often end in success.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

The response is often incredulity. That it’s not their job to be telling organizers what to do. Somehow, they’re aok with telling an conference organizer how much they expect to be paid for the honor of speaking. So bunk to that.

More truthful is they’re afraid that they’d be off the list. If room was left open for women, naturally, some of the men would have to be stepping out of the way.

Who’s On First

So what if the speaker line-up isn’t just filled with the loudest tweeters or the most prolifically linked bloggers or the self-published book writers… who gets to claw their way to stage lit glory? How is it decided who will be up there speaking?

Every time I’ve asked women to nominate speakers I get back a solid list, but a list lacking one key person: themselves. Women nominate those adjacent to them. They nominate those they’d want the opportunity to sit & listen to speak for an hour. This works incredibly well actually, you get access to amazing undiscovered talent, so long as there’s not an equal population gladly accepting these nominations and then never returning them in kind.

Do women just need to organize a metric butt-ton of conferences, secretly changing the usual suspects over to one of predominantly women? A few have done just that.

At their annual summit, after voicing their commitment to women in STEM, GitHub got their arms twisted — all eight of them — when Julie Horvath proposed the now ongoing Passion Projects. Featuring one woman each month speaking about her — you guessed it — passion projects, the event also includes a fireside chat plus q&a on each speaker’s experience in the tech world. Oh, and guess what? It’s not just women who vie for tickets to attend.

Get AgentFin’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Apple tapped Kelly Hoey, co-founder of Women Innovate Mobile, after she packed the house for a one-off event. She now runs a monthly speaker series in their SoHo store &, recently added, in Chicago as well. She titled it “Meet the Innovators” and then proceeded to turn expectations upside down when “The Face of VC Investing” panel was a stage filled with women.

An exception in conferences is The Farmhouse. It’s almost shocking to run down the speaker lists and have it so evenly bounce between men & women. Yes, the event is small, but that makes it all the more notable. It proves that it doesn’t take a huge budget to find a few talented women.

So What

There are plenty of other examples out there of the good, the bad & the ugly. There area also plenty of statistics to back up why all this matters. We can see one end of the path we’ve been on, right here where we’re standing, with girls dropping out of STEM at earlier and earlier ages.

Without a visible path to follow, without someone to relate to as a role model — yes, that’s usually someone who looks like you — few realize the opportunities available to them. How many boys dream of becoming baseball or basketball players? Girls, not so much. They realize early that that path is closed to them. How many other paths seem similarly cut off, particularly to those young enough that they don’t examine the complexities of gender but take the examples they see in the media as truth.

In psychology this phenomenon is well recognized. It’s called mirroring: the act of learning by mimicry, of modifying the self to resemble that of another. Mirroring is easiest when some initial commonalities can be found, some kind of baseline to work from, some assurance that the desired endpoint is within the parameters of achievability.

Fun Fact: you actually have specific mirroring neurons which allow you to ‘feel’ what you see someone else feeling.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Somehow, even while the academics have documented this phenomenon over and over, across multiple disciplines, the tech world is up in arms. After all, we’re a meritocracy, right?

But even Harper Reed, ex-CTO of the Obama campaign, was caught out in the ramifications of all this. He told me how at one event during Obama’s campaign, he kept hearing over and over about “Doctor Biden” was amazed that the Vice President to-be had found to fit in a PhD along with everything else he had achieved. It wasn’t until he shook the hand of Doctor Jill Biden, Second Lady of The United States, that he realized his mistake. Of course all doctors are men, and who on earth would think that the wife of a successful man might be successful in her own right. . .

Into the Light

I finally had the chance to attend a She’s Geeky unconference here in Silicon Valley. It was a shock I was ill prepared for. A gathering of nearly all women, and my god the diversity in that room. Diversity any way you sliced it.

The most impressive to me was something I hadn’t even noticed at other tech events. Suddenly, it wasn’t just a bunch of 20-30 somethings jostling for attention & trying to be heard or noticed. Women had brought their daughters. Women of my mother’s generation and older were having frank conversations with recent college graduates, not giving advice, but discussing everything from their most recent arduino hacks to the unsung merits of Kitty Pryde. This was a room full of talent & knowledge with little or no judgement attached.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

I was only at She’s Geeky for one day. One day, on a weekend, with over 250 attendees, all of them women. No, that doesn’t make all of them immediate candidates for the main stage. It does however prove that women are willing to show up — and pay for — events where they feel like they belong and where they can have a voice.

I only wished we did have a stage for a few of those women to speak from. Maybe I’ll do something about that.

Some Details

I’m ending with some sketchnotes I’ve done of women speakers I had the honor to document. They each had a part in inspiring me to believe I belonged up there too.

Jen Meyers

Geekfest

This sketchnote was done in just one phase, unlike the ones in full color shared below. In this case, I was just using a regular pen — well, not that regular… my favorite ballpoint, a Pilot G-2 07. It’s done in a Moleskin & I let myself just keep going after each page was full. This is a freeing thing to do when I’m just taking notes for myself, letting the thread of ideas run as far as they want to, on off one page and onwards.

Betsy Hoover

TEDx DePaul

Usually, at a full day event, I make sure I have a seat at the back of the audience, a table & a small lamp. Since this was pro-bono work, I wound up with just my lap to hold my sketchbook & my own iPhone to light my page. Halfway through the event my phone died leaving me in the dark. The last few talks, including Ms. Hoover’s, I sat in the front row, catching light from the stage.

Nell Taylor

SXSW

Doing sketchnotes at SXSW has become something of a thing. The big keynote talks have someone up there drawing out their every word, live. I contract myself out to individuals, then make it my business to catch any women I know who are speaking. Before I switched over to markers, I colored in all my notes with colored pencils. Safer on airplanes. Slower to work with.

Jessica Lawrence

TwilioCon

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Switching over to first Prismacolor & then Coptic markers sped up my work considerably. It also changed how I was thinking about colors. Arrows stayed red, but talk bubbles needed to be outlined rather than filled in. Overall, I was able to think more about the flow of the piece & less about which colors I was choosing for each element. Jessica is more than kinda my hero, so look her up.

Claire Evans

The Farmhouse

Some talks wind up with more images than words. Most of it is just how the speaker uses words, not so much the content as the way they describe their topic. Sometimes it’s the smallest excuse to draw something I just like to draw, like a mixing bowl, or a check list.

Brenda Chapman

Great Work MBA

I’ve done only a few talks from video. It seems like it would be easier, but it’s actually more difficult. The temptation to hit pause is always there, catching those last few words I missed, making sure I’m not missing anything. But that’s not the point of sketchnotes. The idea is to capture the big ideas, make them accessible and relatable, not document every word.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

--

--

AgentFin
AgentFin

Written by AgentFin

• Defenestration Expert • Applied Anthropologist | UX / Design Research + Product Management + Brand Strategy + Experience Design = http://agentfin.com