On Paper, Facebook, and social networks re-imagined
A day’s thoughts on Facebook’s latest mobile efforts
I joined Facebook towards the end of high school.
Facebook had just started expanding beyond college campuses and (if I recall correctly) gave a few current users—college kids—an access code or sign-up link to pass along to high school friends.
Quickly, use of the service skyrocketed.
Facebook became our digital contact list: an address and yearbook in one.
We shared photos—at first, scanning printed copies—but later directly uploading digital files.
We wrote on each others walls, sharing stories, jokes, flirting, wishing each other happy birthday, etc.
We hung out with one another—playing games and sharing links.
Facebook became an extension of the cafeteria or a friend’s basement.
It was a catalog of our lives and the central spot where our friends lived when we weren’t physically together.
But that’s not what Facebook is anymore
Two key items have shifted since my high school days and initial use of the social network:
- I (and many of my friends) now use Facebook primarily as a news feed
- The features that were core to Facebook’s initial engagement have splintered into a variety of platforms both on web and mobile
- A few web examples: Profile / job history? LinkedIn. Status updates and short thoughts? Twitter. Photos? Instagram. Long notes: Blog or Medium
- The most relevant and engaging feature remaining is the newsfeed—a live list of links and status relevant to my social network
- Many people post Facebook updates because that’s where the majority of their network is, it’s a feed that consolidates these pieces of information
2. I (and many others globally) access the internet through mobile devices
- Facebook’s initial strengths were driven by the fact that it owned your online contact list, photos, etc.
- Now those items are owned by the platform, they’re stored in the cloud and accessed across devices
- People access the internet from their phone where there’s enormous opportunity to rethink and reinvent web services
And Facebook hasn’t kept up with these changes
Take the following web-centric example…
Facebook believes that the newsfeed is important. It’s critical to their vision of the network, to advertising, and to the discover of content.
And users have shifted their engagement: for many people I know (a biased sample, to be sure) the newsfeed is the most actively checked section on Facebook.
Despite the fact that both parties seem to be aligned, Facebook’s homepage is currently a cluttered product, certainly not optimized for newsfeed usage.
Don’t believe me? Check out this photo of my feed yesterday:
I have no idea what the various lists and groups are on the left—I never use them. I have no idea what the updates and ads are on the right—my eye ignores them. And the newsfeed itself takes up (barely) a third of the page.
It’s certainly not perfect and it’s still the feature I most frequently engage with (aka habitually refresh when I’m completely bored).
And this example doesn’t even begin to address Facebook’s need to innovate on mobile, where mobile-first communication and social networking startups have routinely gained traction over the past few years.
Designing for mobile is incredibly different than the web. There are new constraints but, more importantly, new opportunities for innovation.
Fast forward to Monday, Feb. 3rd: Facebook releases Paper.
The app is beautiful—a reinvention of the core feature people use on Facebook (the newsfeed) for where they use it (their phones).
I downloaded it and played around throughout the day.
After a few brief stumbles and mis-swipes, the gestures and actions in the app became both intuitive and incredibly impressive.
The articles were interesting and the Facebook updates targeted.
Get Adam London’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
For the first time ever, an app built by Facebook—not including Instagram—sat on my phone. That’s a vote of confidence if there ever was one.
So, onto the good stuff, what is Paper and why is it interesting?
Paper is a Facebook re-imagined for mobile devices.
It brings stories, pictures, and articles front and center.
The app doesn’t waste a pixel on your iPhone screen—no menu bars or navigational tools—just the content.
Many people—including my friend Ellis—have remarked that this is the best application Facebook has ever built. That it could, in fact, replace Facebook.
I believe that Paper represents Facebook’s strongest attempt to get ahead of the curve and disrupt its own unbundling.
Specifically, I believe that Paper represents the mobile reinvention of: 1) The Newsfeed, and 2) The Profile
1) Paper as a re-imagined mobile newsfeed
There’s little doubt that the Facebook team has created a strong news app.
The key questions is: how will Paper stand out (or fit into) the cluttered landscape of news apps vying for users attention.
For me, Paper doesn’t look like it will be my go-to, first source of content discovery.
As Benedict Evans pointed out: I still Google when I know exactly what I want.
I go to Twitter for a curated feed of news.
I go to Instagram for a curated feed of photos.
I go to Buzzfeed or Grantland or Medium or NYTimes when I have a general sense of the type of content I want to read, but am exploring.
And those examples only speak to the type of content. There’s also the issue of form: I go to Twitter for quick reads and seek out longer form reads on vertical specific sites.
So where does Paper fit in?
Right now, it feels like a hybrid between all of the sites I mentioned. And that’s not a slight on the product. There’s room in between I-know-exactly-what-I-want and I-have-absolutely-no-clue-what-I’m-searching-for.
Paper is curated by subject but not handpicked by source (like your Twitter feed).
It’s news and article centric, but is longer than a quick synopsis and shorter than a long form.
It’s less a source of on-the-go, small bits of mobile content and more a place to browse stories that are somewhat relevant to your interests when you’re bored and sitting on the couch (sounds a bit like the current newsfeed, no?)
The true power of Paper is in its engineering. The gestures, interface, and design are mobile centric and take advantage of a the iPhone’s construct (and are a complete re-thinking of the current newsfeed).
2) Paper is also a re-imagined profile.
Hiding behind the discussion of Paper as a news app is the fact that it is also a re-invention of Facebook’s original product: the social network.
Profiles are now much easier to navigate and explore than on the web. You can flick between pictures, ‘wall’-posts, and personal information.
Profiles are mobile friendly. They’re bright, easy to explore and get lost in, filled with content and photos.
Profiles are also less cluttered. You can easily message something or like something. But interestingly, likes / comments are hidden—they blend seamlessly into the content.
When everyone is focused on the rise of apps featuring anonymity and secrecy—like Whisper and Snapchat—it’s interesting to see Paper bring the content and person front and center while shifting the focus of commends and likes to a less public view. It’s less about how many likes or comments you receive in the app and more about the notification to the user.
Leveraging Paper’s framework as a testing ground, it’s easy to believe that Facebook could re-inventing its profile / social features in a similar form.
This year, Facebook turns 10 years old.
On the web, Facebook went from a social network (profiles at its core) to a curated feed (articles, photos, videos, etc.) at the core of users’ engagement.
On mobile, the opposite phenomenon is occurring.
Paper is the re-invented newsfeed. And while there are definite questions about how users will engage with the content, it’s a great effort.
If Paper successful drives engagement with users, don’t be surprised to see the profile and social network features built out more extensively.
Your address book only goes so far. Facebook has enough information (posts, photos, etc.) to create a more impressive mobile profile.
Don’t count out Facebook’s ability to leverage this incredible design to pull in articles you’ve commented on, photos from Instagram and other streams, and more to create a re-imagined profile page for mobile.
And don’t count out that just like the original, web product, people will spend hours engaging and exploring with peoples’ profiles.
While today’s teens might not flock to Facebook like they once did, mobile represents opportunity.
It represents the opportunity to reinvent its products, to push the boundaries of what’s possible on phones (and what was never possible on computers), to leap forward with new products that delight and attract users who will spend hours exploring the profiles, pictures, and stories that populate Facebook.









