Sitemap

Superlative Games Journalism

3 min readSep 7, 2014

In an attempt to learn more about games journalism, here I present two pieces, one I consider a superior piece of games journalism, and one I consider an inferior piece of games journalism.

Superior Games Journalism:

Get Alec Thomson’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

An example I consider to be superior games journalism is this Grantland piece by Eric Raskin titled “When We Held Kings”. The piece—an oral history of the 2003 World Series of Poker featuring the underdog champion Chris Moneymaker—is a high quality piece of journalism because it pools a massive amount of sources backed by a heavy amount of context and history to show the same event from multiple perspectives. By interviewing players, friends of players, organizers of the tournament, and broadcasters, Raskin tells multiple stories tied around a single narrative. Naturally, the piece provides facts about the precise series of events that led Moneymaker to become an underdog champion, but it also explores the role of new technology (such as the “hole cam”) in televising Poker, the role Poker played in America’s culture prior to the 2003 tournament, the history of the tournament itself, and the massive rise in popularity the game of Poker received after the event. Despite the fact that many of those interviewed might hold biases or grudges (for instance, Moneymaker’s final opponent blaming his loss on a fluke rather than Moneymaker’s skills), by pooling them together in a single place, Raskin gives readers the tools necessary to draw their own conclusions. Such a piece is both rare and powerful in its ability to both entertain and empower its readers.

Inferior Games Journalism:

One example I consider to be inferior games journalism is this Kotaku piece by Jason Schreier titled “Flappy Bird Is Making $50,000 A Day Off Ripped Art”. The reason I feel this piece is an inferior piece of journalism is because it’s a fairly serious accusation levied against a developer backed up by shoddy evidence and a lack of thoughtful context. Schreier makes it pretty clear that he dislikes Flappy Bird and believes it undeserving of its enormous success. Rather than probe the source of this dislike and attempt to provide thoughtful criticism of the game and its success, Schreier accuses the developer of stealing art from Nintendo. If anything, the comparison images Schreier provides to prove his accusation instead prove that the developer of Flappy Bird didn’t directly copy art from Nintendo. At worst, the developer was highly inspired by the style of Nintendo’s games and attempted to emulate this style while producing his own original art, an offense hardly worthy of Schreier’s intense condemnation. This kind of thoughtless attack piece has genuine consequences, including facilitating further threats and attacks made against the developer after the piece was published. A more responsible piece could have looked at the artistic similarities between Flappy Bird and Nintendo games, providing the context of copyright law and stylistic influences throughout the art world, all while asking important questions such as, “When does emulating an artistic influence cross the line and become unacceptable?” Schreier might still have maintained his negative opinion of Flappy Bird and its inspired art, but a more thoughtful piece would have explored a larger context without making a blunt accusation without adequate evidence.