Sitemap
Alex Jacobs

Alex Jacobs

Technical mentor. Facilitator of music circles with seniors with Alzheimer’s and dementia. Writing about code and music.

“Self Taught” Musicians

3 min readAug 4, 2017

Actually, all education is self-education. A teacher is only a guide, to point out the way, and no school, no matter how excellent, can give you education.

— Louis l’Amour

I’ve always been curious about the label “self-taught” when applied to musicians. I was at a concert at Yoshi’s in Oakland last month*, watching the phenomenally creative guitar player Nguyen Lê and his ensemble SAIYUKI. It was highlighted on every promotional piece about the show that Lê is self-taught. I reflected on how that information affected my perception of his skills as a musician. At one point during the show, I contemplated yelling aloud “Take some lessons!” As a joke only. He is a performer of highly refined technical ability.

I am curious about the general perception of the “self-taught” label. Perhaps it leads people to believe that a musician who didn’t need a guide along the path of their musical development is a genius. I suppose it could backfire as well. If the musician delivers a mediocre performance, perhaps the “self-taught” label adds to the listener’s frustration, causing them to wish they had chosen to see a concert featuring a musician who had studied with a teacher, and had received sufficient instruction and criticism to refine their performance skills.

Get Alex Jacobs’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

As a performing guitarist, I’m no stranger to the question “are you self taught?” I usually find myself wondering what the person asking the question is actually trying to figure out about me. My literal answer is that I have taken lessons on and off from the very first days I started playing guitar. There have also been periods of many years where I did not formally engage in lessons in a teacher/student arrangement. I also believe that for a musician who continues to work on improving their craft with the educational opportunities that are available to them at any given time, having a teacher makes little difference. With the following exception: I think there are certain lessons for which having a “teacher” is invaluable, such as when starting out, to learn efficient fingerings and playing technique. I’m sure there are many examples of masterful players who never had anyone show them how to hold the instrument, and if you’re one of those people, disregard this statement. I would also like to add some more detail to my definition of a teacher, so one isn’t limited to visualizing an academic classroom with each person sitting across from each other in a chair. I think of a teacher as a more experienced musician who can observe and suggest corrections of technique, and assign practice regimens. This can occur informally, perhaps at a jam session, or a casual musical get together.

I believe there is no meaningful difference. It’s all about repetition/invitation/listening

I used the Freeplane open source mind mapping software to create this mind map of my thoughts on the difference between self-taught and classically instructed musicians. As you can see from my diagram, I have notated the most important set of activities that go into creating a musician as:

  • repetition
  • imitation
  • listening

The only difference between “self” and “teacher” taught in my model comes from who motivates the repetitions that comprise practice. Following my diagram, what the actual difference between “self taught” and “teacher taught” is comes down to marketing. In conclusion, I believe the marketing director at Yoshi’s was hoping the popular perception of “self-taught” = “genius” would draw more interest in the show.

*Originally published in 2011, on a now-defunct blogging platform.

--

--

Alex Jacobs
Alex Jacobs

Written by Alex Jacobs

Technical mentor. Facilitator of music circles with seniors with Alzheimer’s and dementia. Writing about code and music.